Dr. Frank M. Mitloehner - How Beef & Dairy Will Deal with the Precautionary Principle?

30
How shall Beef and Dairy Deal with the Precautionary Principle regarding Environmental Quality? NIAA, Omaha, NE, April 1, 2014 Frank Mitloehner, PhD Professor & Air Quality CE Specialist Dept Animal Science University of California, Davis

description

How Beef & Dairy Will Deal with the Precautionary Principle? - Frank M. Mitloehner, PhD, Professor and Air Quality Extension Specialist, Department of Animal Science, University of California Davis, from the 2014 NIAA Annual Conference titled 'The Precautionary Principle: How Agriculture Will Thrive', March 31 - April 2, 2014, Omaha, NE, USA. More presentations at http://www.trufflemedia.com/agmedia/conference/2014_niaa_how_animal_agriculture_will_thrive

Transcript of Dr. Frank M. Mitloehner - How Beef & Dairy Will Deal with the Precautionary Principle?

Page 1: Dr. Frank M. Mitloehner - How Beef & Dairy Will Deal with the Precautionary Principle?

How shall Beef and Dairy Deal with the Precautionary Principle regarding

Environmental Quality?NIAA, Omaha, NE, April 1, 2014

Frank Mitloehner, PhDProfessor & Air Quality CE SpecialistDept Animal ScienceUniversity of California, Davis

Page 2: Dr. Frank M. Mitloehner - How Beef & Dairy Will Deal with the Precautionary Principle?
Page 3: Dr. Frank M. Mitloehner - How Beef & Dairy Will Deal with the Precautionary Principle?
Page 4: Dr. Frank M. Mitloehner - How Beef & Dairy Will Deal with the Precautionary Principle?
Page 5: Dr. Frank M. Mitloehner - How Beef & Dairy Will Deal with the Precautionary Principle?
Page 6: Dr. Frank M. Mitloehner - How Beef & Dairy Will Deal with the Precautionary Principle?
Page 7: Dr. Frank M. Mitloehner - How Beef & Dairy Will Deal with the Precautionary Principle?

GHG & GWP

Global Warming Potential (GWP) of Main GHG

Carbon Dioxide, CO2 1

Methane, CH4 25

Nitrous Oxide, N2O 298

CO2 – Carbon Dioxide CH4 – Methane N2O – Nitrous Oxide

Page 8: Dr. Frank M. Mitloehner - How Beef & Dairy Will Deal with the Precautionary Principle?

Carbon Dioxide and Carbon Flux

Page 9: Dr. Frank M. Mitloehner - How Beef & Dairy Will Deal with the Precautionary Principle?

U.S. – the big GHG picture

Source: EPA (2009)

Page 10: Dr. Frank M. Mitloehner - How Beef & Dairy Will Deal with the Precautionary Principle?

“Livestock’s Long Shadow” (FAO, 2006)

• “The Livestock sector is a major player, responsible for 18% of GHG emissions measured in CO2e. This is a higher share than transport”

Page 11: Dr. Frank M. Mitloehner - How Beef & Dairy Will Deal with the Precautionary Principle?
Page 12: Dr. Frank M. Mitloehner - How Beef & Dairy Will Deal with the Precautionary Principle?
Page 13: Dr. Frank M. Mitloehner - How Beef & Dairy Will Deal with the Precautionary Principle?
Page 14: Dr. Frank M. Mitloehner - How Beef & Dairy Will Deal with the Precautionary Principle?
Page 15: Dr. Frank M. Mitloehner - How Beef & Dairy Will Deal with the Precautionary Principle?
Page 16: Dr. Frank M. Mitloehner - How Beef & Dairy Will Deal with the Precautionary Principle?

16

10

020

030

040

050

0In

dex

num

ber:

1961

=10

0

1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010

Roots and tubers CerealsMeat MilkEggs

Per caput consumption of major food items in developing countries – kg per caput per year (index numbers 1961=100)

Consumption is growing rapidly in

developing countries

Eggs

Meat

Milk

Page 17: Dr. Frank M. Mitloehner - How Beef & Dairy Will Deal with the Precautionary Principle?

17

Per capita GDP and meat consumption by country, 2005.

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

0 10000 20000 30000 40000 50000

Per capita GDP (US$ PPP)

Per

cap

ita

mea

t co

nsu

mp

ion

(kg

/yea

r)

USA

Japan

China

Brazil

Malaysia

Germany

Ghana

NorwayLithuania

... driven by incomes ...

Page 18: Dr. Frank M. Mitloehner - How Beef & Dairy Will Deal with the Precautionary Principle?

Global livestock distribution

FAO (2006)

Page 19: Dr. Frank M. Mitloehner - How Beef & Dairy Will Deal with the Precautionary Principle?

Distribution of cropland

FAO (2006)

Page 20: Dr. Frank M. Mitloehner - How Beef & Dairy Will Deal with the Precautionary Principle?

Mt

CO

2-eq

Time (years)

GHG by Regions

Page 21: Dr. Frank M. Mitloehner - How Beef & Dairy Will Deal with the Precautionary Principle?

Production efficiency and pollution is inversely related

0.00

2.00

4.00

6.00

8.00

10.00

12.00

0 1,000 2,000 3,000 4,000 5,000 6,000 7,000 8,000 9,000

Output per cow, kg FPCM per year

kg C

O2-

eq. p

er k

g FP

CM

Page 22: Dr. Frank M. Mitloehner - How Beef & Dairy Will Deal with the Precautionary Principle?

More Milk Produced per Cow – Less Methane & Waste

California Cow Mexican Cow

20,000

lbs/yr/cow

500 g 2000 g Methane

Production

4,000 lbs/yr/cow

Page 23: Dr. Frank M. Mitloehner - How Beef & Dairy Will Deal with the Precautionary Principle?

FAO (2010)

Page 24: Dr. Frank M. Mitloehner - How Beef & Dairy Will Deal with the Precautionary Principle?

Emission Intensities (direct emissions from livestock)

GTAP 2001 data base

Page 25: Dr. Frank M. Mitloehner - How Beef & Dairy Will Deal with the Precautionary Principle?

Mitigation: interventions to improve productivity

Gill et al. (2010)

Page 26: Dr. Frank M. Mitloehner - How Beef & Dairy Will Deal with the Precautionary Principle?

US Dairy trends

• Today, there are 9 million dairy cows in the US, 16 million fewer than existed in 1950.

• Even though cow number have decreased dramatically (1950 versus 2013), milk production nationally has increased 60 percent.

• The carbon footprint of a glass of milk is 2/3 smaller today than it was 70 years ago.

Page 27: Dr. Frank M. Mitloehner - How Beef & Dairy Will Deal with the Precautionary Principle?

China Swine Example

• China’s five year plan focuses on making farms larger and more efficient

• Half of the world’s pigs live in China• 50 million sows w/ 20 piglets born alive• Equals annual production of 1 Billion pigs• Pre-weaning mortality causes 400 Million

pigs to never make it to the market• One more pig per sow would mean

1 Million tons of feed saved

Page 28: Dr. Frank M. Mitloehner - How Beef & Dairy Will Deal with the Precautionary Principle?

Sustainable Intensification is key!

• Production intensity enhances biological efficiency

• Production intensity and emission intensity are inversely related

Page 29: Dr. Frank M. Mitloehner - How Beef & Dairy Will Deal with the Precautionary Principle?

Partnership on Livestock Environmental Assessment &

Performance (LEAP)

• Globally harmonized methodology for environmental footprints

• LEAP = national governments, livestock industry, non-governmental and civil society organizations, leading researchers

Page 30: Dr. Frank M. Mitloehner - How Beef & Dairy Will Deal with the Precautionary Principle?

Frank Mitloehner, PhDAir Quality CE SpecialistAnimal Science Department University of California, Davis(530) [email protected]