7/31/2019 DOFF Opposition to Appellees Motion to Strike Doc 50

1/34

Moifyo p AH@@ Hzzhroqohd qh Nhqohd qh rqyoef cda `hy Rcdbqohdr 3

Bcrf Dhr$ 33.60:;? cda 33.60301'Bhdrhmoacqfa hd @fiyvcy 2- 9:39/

OD QGF VDOQFA RQCQFR BHVYQ H@ CZZFCMR

@HY QGF DODQG BOYBVOQ

Morc Moifyo- fq cm$-

Zmcodqo``r(Czzfmmffr-

pr$

Hym Qcoq|- Af`fda Hvy @yffahnr@hvdacqohdr- Odb$- fq cm$-

Af`fdacdqr(Czzfmmcdqr$

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

HZZHROQOHD I_ CZZFMMCDQ-AH@@- QH CZZFMMFFR NHQOHD QH RQYOEF ZHYQOHDR H@

CZZFMMCDQR YFZM_ IYOF@ CDA RVZZMFNFDQCM FWBFYZQR H@

YFBHYA- CDA @HY RCDBQOHDR5 RVZZHYQODK AFBMCYCQOHDR

NHQOHD @HY YVMF 33 RCDBQOHDR CKCODRQ CZZFMMFFR @HY!3::-::: @HY FKYFKOHVR @YCVA HD QGF BHVYQ- QGYFF _FCYR H@

@OMODK PFWCQOHVR ZMFCAODKR- ICRFA HD @YCVAVMFDQ

RQCQFNFDQR CDA NCMOBF5 @HY POHMCQODK C BHVYQ HYAFYCDA DFPFY @OMODK [OQG QGF BHVYQ MOIFYO+R OAFDQO@OBCQOHDZCZFYR CR C ZYHH@ H@ GFY RQCQF BOQO\FDRGOZ @HY AOPFYROQ_

LVYORAOBQOHD$

Bcrf< 33.60:;? :6(:2(9:39 OA< 7301002 AeqFdqy< 6: Zckf< 3 h` 21

7/31/2019 DOFF Opposition to Appellees Motion to Strike Doc 50

2/34

Moifyo p AH@@ Hzzhroqohd qh Nhqohd qh rqyoef cda `hy Rcdbqohdr 9

Hym Qcoq| FRS9?72? Rcdqc Ncykcyoqc ze{- rqf 3::YRN- BC ?9077?1?.072.6133 ?1?.;00.;0:2hym$qcoq|Jkncom$bhn

bhvdrfm `hy AH@@

Af`fdacdq cda Czzfmmcdq- Af`fda Hvy @yffahnr @hvdacqohd lhodr Hym

Qcoq| od qgor iyof` od hzzhroqohd qh qgf Nhqohd h` Zmcodqo``r cda Czzfmmffr- MORC

MOIFYO- fq cm$ 'bhmmfbqopfm Zmcodqo``r/- qh rqyoef qgf iyof`- Rvzzmfnfdqcm Fwbfyzq

h` Yfbhya5 `hy Rcdbqohdr5 cda Cqqhydf @ffr 'Nhqohd/$

Caaoqohdcmm- AH@@ or rffeodk Yvmf 33 rcdbqohdr ckcodrq Czzfmmffr `hy `yophmhvr

`ommodk cda `hy fkyfkohvr `ycva hd qgf bhvyq cda {crqodk qgyff fcyr cda qghvrcdar

h` ghvyr h` qonf h` qgf Czzfmmcdqr hd cirhmvqfm `yophmhvr- pfwcqohvr bcvrf h`

cbqohd icrfa hd bhnzmfqf `ycva hd qgf bhvyq- {gobg {cr `vmm yfpfcmfa gfyfod od

cda bhdavbqodk qgor cbqohd od @fafycm Bhvyq- {gomf goaodk qgf `cbq qgcq qgfyf {cr

dfpfy cd lvyoraobqohd od @fafycm bhvyq$

O$ Odqyhavbqohd

Zmcodqo``r bhdqfda qgcq qgf cykvnfdqr h` Qcoq| cda Af`fdacdq cda Czzfmmcdq-

AF@FDA HVY @YFFAHNR @HVDACQOHDR- ODB$ 'AH@@/ 'bhmmfbqopfm

Af`fdacdqr/ hvqmodfa od Czzfmmcdqr Urob^ Yfzm Iyof` {fyf dhq ycorfa od qgf

Aorqyobq Bhvyq hy od qgfoy Czzfmmcdqr Urob^ Hzfdodk Iyof`$ Nhyfhpfy- Czzfmmcdqr cyf

Bcrf< 33.60:;? :6(:2(9:39 OA< 7301002 AeqFdqy< 6: Zckf< 9 h` 21

7/31/2019 DOFF Opposition to Appellees Motion to Strike Doc 50

3/34

Moifyo p AH@@ Hzzhroqohd qh Nhqohd qh rqyoef cda `hy Rcdbqohdr 2

dh{ creodk `hy Yfmof` `yhn qgor Bhvyq qgcq {cr dhq yfsvfrqfa od qgfoy Czzfmmcdq

Urob^ Hzfdodk Iyof`$ 'Nhqohd- z$ 95 fnzgcror od hyokodcm$/

Zmcodqo``r Nhqohd or icrfa hd c `cmrf zyfnorf . qgcq c yfzm iyof` bcddhq

bhdqcod cykvnfdqr yfrzhdaodk qh czzfmmffr cykvnfdqr od oqr cdr{fyodk iyof`- cda

qgcq czzfmmcdq or qgvr monoqfa qh cykvnfdqr ncaf od qgf mh{fy Bhvyq cda bhdqcodfa

od oqr zyodbozcm iyof`$

Zmcodqo``r cyf {yhdk$ Qgf boqf dh cvqghyoq `hy qgfoy cykvnfdq 'ifbcvrf dhdf

fworqr/$

@fafycmYvmfr h` Czzfmmcqf Zyhbfavyf'@YCZ/ Yvmf 97'b/ zyhpoafr