Does growing soy destroy Amazon rainforest?

27
The role of pasture and soybean in deforestation of the The role of pasture and soybean in deforestation of the Brazilian Amazon Brazilian Amazon Navin Ramankutty – McGill University. Oliver Coomes – McGill University Elizabeth Barona – CIAT Glenn Hyman - CIAT AAG - Annual meeting 2010 Washington D.C..

description

Elizabeth Baron's presentation at the 2010 annual meeting of the Association of American Geographers in Washington DC.

Transcript of Does growing soy destroy Amazon rainforest?

Page 1: Does growing soy destroy Amazon rainforest?

The role of pasture and soybean in deforestation of the The role of pasture and soybean in deforestation of the Brazilian AmazonBrazilian Amazon

Navin Ramankutty – McGill University. Oliver Coomes – McGill University

Elizabeth Barona – CIAT Glenn Hyman - CIAT

AAG - Annual meeting 2010 Washington D.C..

Page 2: Does growing soy destroy Amazon rainforest?

“the increasing role of large-scale agriculture and the vast remaining potential expansion of farming in Amazon is causing concern about deforestation and the loss of ecosystem goods and services “(Foley 2007; Fearnside 2005; Morton 2006).

Brazil’s territory ~ 850

Potential farmland 320

Cultivated land – all crops

60

Million hectares

Source: Ministry of Agriculture - Brazil

Page 3: Does growing soy destroy Amazon rainforest?

Deforestation in the AmazonDeforestation in the Amazon

FireFireFireFireLoggingLoggingLoggingLogging

AgricultureAgricultureAgricultureAgriculture

Cattle ranchingCattle ranchingCattle ranchingCattle ranchingRoadsRoadsRoadsRoads

Page 4: Does growing soy destroy Amazon rainforest?

International debateInternational debate

Deforestation is related to the expanding soybean sector

Cattle, not soy, drives Amazon deforestation: News Report http://www.reuters.com/article/idUSTRE53D65C20090414.

Deforestation is related to growth of the cattle industry

Expansion of cropland (mainly soy) into areas previously covered by forest has become one of the main causes of deforestation in southern Brazilian Amazon. (Morton et. al 2006)

Soybean is expanding into land previously under pasture, and not causing new deforestation (Mueller, 2003; Brandao et.al 2005)

Page 5: Does growing soy destroy Amazon rainforest?

Is soybean or pasture expansion the key driver of deforestation in the Brazilian Amazon?

• Agricultural expansion

•Soybean versus Pasture

• Data at municipality level for the entire Amazon for 2000-2006

• Census/Survey from IBGE

• Estimated annual pasture (based on livestock data)

• Deforestation from INPE

•Relationship between agricultural expansion and deforestation

•Spatial patterns, statistical relationship, and potential spatial shift in land use cover were analyzed over the period 2000-2006

Page 6: Does growing soy destroy Amazon rainforest?

Agricultural Expansion

Page 7: Does growing soy destroy Amazon rainforest?

Source: FAOSTAT 2006.

Main countries importing soybean products from BrazilMain countries importing soybean products from Brazil

SOYBEANSOYBEAN

Page 8: Does growing soy destroy Amazon rainforest?

Area under cultivation in Brazil in 2006Area under cultivation in Brazil in 2006SOYBEANSOYBEAN

Source: IBGE (2006).

CROPS% harvested area change

1990 1995 2000 2006 1990 to 2006

Soybean 11,487,303 11,675,005 13,656,771 22,047,349 93.46Maize 11,394,307 13,946,320 11,890,376 12,613,094 10.79Sugar Cane 4,272,602 4,559,062 4,804,511 6,144,286 16.57Beans 4,680,094 5,006,403 4,332,545 4,034,383 -5.71Rice 3,946,691 4,373,538 3,664,804 2,970,918 -8.64Cassava 1,937,567 1,946,163 1,708,875 1,896,509 -0.36Wheat 2,680,989 994,734 1,138,687 1,560,175 -9.92Cotton 1,391,884 1,103,536 801,618 898,008 -4.37Sorghum 137,758 153,961 528,061 722,200 5.17

Total harvested area (Ha)

Page 9: Does growing soy destroy Amazon rainforest?

Livestock productionLivestock production

Animal Total animal units Percentage

category 1990 1995 2000 2006 2006

Cattle 141,584,610 155,753,722 164,077,786 197,861,606 93.17%

Horses 5,787,045 6,054,538 5,547,335 5,452,630 2.57%

Buffalos 1,629,052 1,922,237 1,291,130 1,350,129 0.64%

Donkeys 1,129,280 1,131,824 1,044,912 1,000,488 0.47%

Mules 1,866,668 1,819,162 1,217,851 1,253,296 0.59%

Goats 2,325,782 2,207,304 1,808,175 2,018,878 0.95%

Sheep 4,534,176 4,153,792 3,219,687 3,427,127 1.61%

Total 158,856,614 173,042,578 178,206,876 212,364,154

         

Page 10: Does growing soy destroy Amazon rainforest?

Crop and pasture distribution- 2006 Crop and pasture distribution- 2006 in Legal Amazonin Legal Amazon

PASTUREPASTURE

Page 11: Does growing soy destroy Amazon rainforest?

Large-scale forest conversion for cattle ranching along the Large-scale forest conversion for cattle ranching along the arc of deforestationarc of deforestation

Page 12: Does growing soy destroy Amazon rainforest?

Data Source

Page 13: Does growing soy destroy Amazon rainforest?

Data ProcessingData Processing

Compiling census data on land use for 2000-2006:

- Total harvested Area (IBGE/SIDRA database)

- Estimated pastures (IBGE Livestock data)

DeforestationINPE (The National Institute for space research in Brazil) / PRODES (Amazon Deforestation Project): Annual deforested areas based on LANDSAT Images

Page 14: Does growing soy destroy Amazon rainforest?

Developing consistent administrative boundariesDeveloping consistent administrative boundaries

Page 15: Does growing soy destroy Amazon rainforest?

Estimated pasture area (from IBGE Livestock data):

1- Total Livestock unit

2- Livestock stocking density and linear interpolation

3- Estimated area under pasture for 2000-2006

TLU(i,t)= N(i,t,k) fAU(i,k)k

LSD(i,t)=TLU(i,t)/P(i,t), t=1996,2006

LSD(i,t)=LSD(i,1996)+LSD(i,2006)−LSD(i,1996)(2006 −1996)

(t−1996), t=2000,2001,...,2006

Pest(i,t)=TLU(i,t)LSD(i,t)

, t=2000,2001,...,2006

Page 16: Does growing soy destroy Amazon rainforest?

Spatial and Statistical Analysis

Page 17: Does growing soy destroy Amazon rainforest?

Statistical relationship between change in deforested area and change in agricultural area

Out

liers

Page 18: Does growing soy destroy Amazon rainforest?

Defo

res t

ati

on

Defo

res t

ati

on

Pasture change Soybean change

Soybean change

MATO GROSSO

Past

ure

ch

an

ge

Page 19: Does growing soy destroy Amazon rainforest?

Defo

res t

ati

on

Defo

res t

ati

on

Pasture change Soybean change

Soybean change

PARA

Past

ure

ch

an

ge

Page 20: Does growing soy destroy Amazon rainforest?

Defo

res t

ati

on

Defo

res t

ati

on

Pasture change Soybean change

Soybean change

RONDONIA

Past

ure

ch

an

ge

Page 21: Does growing soy destroy Amazon rainforest?

Def

ore

sta t

ion

Pas

ture

ch

ang

ePasture change soybean change soybean change

Mato Grosso

Para

Rondonia

Page 22: Does growing soy destroy Amazon rainforest?

Spatial Patterns: Spatial Patterns: Changes in area of different land uses in the Legal AmazonChanges in area of different land uses in the Legal Amazon

Deforestation Pasture

SoybeanTotal harvested crops area

Page 23: Does growing soy destroy Amazon rainforest?

Movement of the centroid of land use type

Page 24: Does growing soy destroy Amazon rainforest?

Land-use transitions between 2000 and 2006

Page 25: Does growing soy destroy Amazon rainforest?

Main findings

Consistent with other studies, soybean expansion is replacing pasture areas

However, soybeans may have displaced pasture further north into the forest areas, causing indirect deforestation there.

Even if the proximate cause of deforestation

were mainly ranching, it is likely that soy cultivation is a major underlying cause

Page 26: Does growing soy destroy Amazon rainforest?

CONCLUSION

Need for more large-scale studies and more field-based research to test the land-use displacement hypothesis.

Policy makers face important tradeoffs to satisfy the demands of the cattle and soybean industries vs conservation interests: policies that benefit one group, will likely work to the detriment of the others.

The dynamics of land-use changes are complex, and simple-minded policies to curb deforestation, without a full understanding of the underlying dynamics, will not work

Page 27: Does growing soy destroy Amazon rainforest?

THANK YOU!