docs.cpuc.ca.govdocs.cpuc.ca.gov/word_pdf/RULINGS/36247.doc · Web viewAdministrative Law Judge...

KLM/hl2 4/30/2004

BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

Order Instituting Rulemaking to Examine the Commission’s Future Energy Efficiency Policies, Administration and Programs.

Rulemaking 01-08-028(Filed August 23,

2001)

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE’S RULING CLARIFYING PROCESS FOR THIRD PARTY ENERGY EFFICIENCY PROGRAM PROVIDERS TO SELECT

CONTRACTOR TO CARRY OUT EVALUATION, MEASUREMENT AND VERIFICATION OF 2004-05 LOCAL ENERGY EFFICIENCY PROGRAMS

Decision (D.) 03-12-060 delegated to the assigned Administrative Law Judge the authority to rule on the selection of Evaluation, Measurement and Verification (EM&V) contractors that would evaluate the performance of 2003-04 energy efficiency programs.

Table 1 attached to this ruling lists all EM&V contractors who are approved to perform EM&V work for each of the 2004-2005 Non-IOU, Local-IOU, and partnership programs. Energy Division staff must first approve the associated program’s proposed implementation plan and an executed contract with the administering utility. Contractors whose relationships to programs might compromise or appear to compromise an independent evaluation are not included on the list. Contractors not on the list may not assist listed contractors.

The objectives of EM&V are articulated in the Commission’s Energy Efficiency Policy Manual as follows:

“Measuring level of energy and peak demand savings achieved (except information-only);

“Measuring cost-effectiveness (except information-only);

171740 - 1 -

R.01-08-028 KLM/hl2

“Providing up-front market assessments and baseline analysis, especially for new programs;

“Providing ongoing feedback, and corrective and constructive guidance regarding the implementation of programs;

“Measuring indicators of the effectiveness of specific programs, including testing of the assumptions that underlie the program theory and approach;

“Assessing the overall levels of performance and success of programs;

“Informing decisions regarding compensation and final payments (except information-only);

“Helping to assess whether there is a continuing need for the program;

* * *

“Not all of the objectives may be applicable to all programs. Implementers1 are free to propose an EM&V approach that is logical for their program. . . . For the M&V portion of the plan, implementers should adhere to the guidelines in the International Performance Measurement and Verification Protocol (IPMVP), available on the Internet at http://www.ipmvp.org.”

In addition, the Policy Manual lists the following components for an adequate EM&V plan:

“Table 6.1. Components of an EM&V Plan

“Baseline Information

“Determine whether or not baseline data exist upon which to base energy savings measurement.

1 Because each program will hire a separate EM&V contractor to review its program, program implementers should ensure that their EM&V contractors perform the functions preceded by the term “Implementers” in the Policy Manual.

- 2 -

R.01-08-028 KLM/hl2

Existing baseline studies can be found on the California Measurement Advisory Committee website ( http://www.calmac.org/) and/or the California Energy Commission website (http://www.energy.ca.gov/). Detailed sources of baseline data should be cited.“If baseline data do not exist, the implementer will need to conduct a baseline study (gather baseline energy and operating data) on the operation(s) to be affected by the energy efficiency measures proposed.“If the baseline data do not exist and the implementer can show that a baseline study is too difficult, expensive or otherwise impossible to carry out prior to program implementation, the contractor should then provide evidence that baseline data can be produced or acquired during the program implementation. This process should then be detailed in the EM&V plan.

“Energy Efficiency Measure Information

“Full description of energy efficiency measures included in the program, including assumptions about important variables and unknowns, especially those affecting energy savings.“Full description of the intended results of the measures.

“Measurement and Verification Approach

“Reference to appropriate IPMVP option.“Description of any deviation from IPMVP approach.“Schedule for acquiring project-specific data.

“Evaluation Approach

“A list of questions to be answered through the program evaluation.“A list of evaluation tasks/activities to be undertaken during the course of program implementation.“A description of how evaluation will be used to meet all of the Commission objectives described above.”

Energy Efficiency Policy Manual at 31.

All EM&V contractors approved in this ruling and selected to conduct EM&V activities should perform the foregoing activities in a timely and thorough manner.

No later than June 30, 2004, each program implementer shall submit to the Commission’s Energy Division by e-mail to [email protected] and to the utility administering its program the name of the firm it has selected to perform EM&V work on its program. Unless Energy Division contacts the program implementer and objects to the selection on or before July 10, 2004, the program implementer may initiate work with the contractor on EM&V activities.

- 3 -

R.01-08-028 KLM/hl2

The selected EM&V contractor for each program shall submit its EM&V plan to the program implementer and to [email protected] no later than 30 days after EM&V contractor selection. On request, the program implementer shall forward the EM&V plan to the utility administering its program. The EM&V plan submitted to the Commission’s Energy Division will be reviewed and may be modified.

Parties should direct questions regarding the implementation of EM&V activities addressed in this ruling to the Energy Division’s Eli Kollman at (415) 703-5649 or [email protected].

IT IS ORDERED that:1. A program provider may use more than one contractor to perform Evaluation, Measurement and Verification (EM&V) if both contractors are on their approved list.2. A list of approved EM&V contractors for each program is attached as Table 1 of this ruling. No contractor or individual may provide any EM&V work, including subcontracted work, for any energy efficiency program unless it is listed as an approved contractor or it receives approval in writing from the Commission’s Energy Division staff. 3. No later than June 30, 2004, each program implementer shall submit the name of the selected EM&V contractor to the Commission’s Energy Division by e-mail to [email protected] and to the utility administering its program.4. Unless it receives a negative response from the Commission’s Energy Division to its selection on or before July 10, 2004, the energy efficiency program sponsor may initiate EM&V work with the approved contractor.

- 4 -

R.01-08-028 KLM/hl2

5. The selected EM&V contractor for each program shall submit its EM&V plan to the program implementer and to [email protected] no later than 30 days after EM&V contractor selection. On request, the program implementer shall forward the EM&V plan to the utility administering its program.6. Any program for which no EM&V contractor is approved in this ruling shall be assigned an EM&V contractor by Energy Division staff if its program implementer does not identify acceptable EM&V contractors to the Energy Division staff by May 5, 2004.

Dated April 30, 2004, at San Francisco, California.

/s/ KIM MALCOLMKim Malcolm

Administrative Law Judge

- 5 -

R.01-08-028 KLM/hl2

APPENDIX AEM&V CONTRACTORS

Page 1

Table 1a Non-IOU Programs

Proposal Sponsor Program Title Program Number Service Area Approved Contractor List

ADM Associates, Inc. (ADM)

Mobile Energy Clinic 1106-04 SCE 1. Robert Mowris and

Associates 2. Sisson and Associates 3. Ridge and Associates 4. Itron 5. Aloha Systems

ADM Associates, Inc.

Mobile Energy Clinic 1487-04 SCG

ADM Associates, Inc.

Mobile Energy Clinic 1105-04 SDGE

Alliance to Save Energy (ASE)

Green Campus Pilot Program 1427-04 PGE 1. Research Into Action

2. Skumatz Economic Research Associates

3. Vanward Consulting

Alliance to Save Energy

Green Campus Pilot Program 1426-04 SCE

Alliance to Save Energy

Green Campus Pilot Program 1425-04 SDGE

Alliance to Save Energy (ASE)

Green Schools Program 1435-04 PGE 1. Vanward Consulting

2. Ridge and Associates 3. Shel FeldmanAlliance to Save

EnergyGreen Schools Program 1430-04 SCE

American Synergy Corporation (ASC)

Comprehensive Hard-to-Reach Mobile Home Program

1275-04 SCE1. Robert Mowris and

Associates 2. Stellar Processes 3. Alternative Energy

Systems Consulting 4. Energy Analysis Technologies

American Synergy Corporation

Comprehensive Hard-to-Reach Mobile Home Program

1276-04 SCG

Association of Bay Area Governments (ABAG)

Northern California Local Government Energy Partnership

1112-04 PGE 1. Equipoise Consulting

ASW Engineering (ASW)

Energy Savers Program 1086-04 SCE 1. Sisson and Associates

2. SBW Consulting

Bo Enterprises (Bo)

Moderate Income Comprehensive Attic Program (MICAP)

1082-04 PGE1. Sisson and Associates 2. Robert Mowris and

Associates 3. Aloha Systems

Building Industry Institute (BII)

Building Energy Code Training 1101-04 PGE

1. Wirtshafter and AssociatesBuilding Industry Institute

Building Energy Code Training 1100-04 SCE

Building Industry Building Energy 1102-04 SDGE

R.01-08-028 KLM/hl2

APPENDIX APage 2



Institute Code Training

Building Industry Institute (BII)

Community Energy Efficiency Program

1099-04 PGE 1. Wirtshafter and Associates

California Building Performance Contractors Association (CBPCA)

California Retrofit Home Performance Program

1398-04 PGE 1. Lutzenhiser and Associates

California State University, Chico Research Foundation (CSU Chico)

Nonresidential Fenestration Certification Initiative (NFCI)

1227-04 PGE

1. Heshong Mahone Group 2. Robert Mowris and

Associates 3. Itron

California State University, Chico Research Foundation


1496-04 SCE



1497-04 SCG



1498-04 SDGE

California State University, Fresno Foundation (CSU Fresno)

Agricultural Pumping Efficiency Program

1418-04 PGE

1. Equipoise Consulting 2. Nexant

California State University, Fresno Foundation


1434-04 SCE

California State University, Fresno Foundation


1428-04 SCG

California Urban Water Conservation Council (CUWCC)

Pre-rinse Spray Head Installation Program

1198-04 PGE1. SBW Consulting

California Urban Water Conservation

Pre-rinse Spray Head Installation

1200-04 SCG

R.01-08-028 KLM/hl2

APPENDIX APage 3



Council Program

City of BerkeleyCalifornia Youth Energy Services (CYES)

1462-04 PGE

1. ADM Associates, Inc. 2. Aloha Systems 3. Bevilacqua-Knight Inc 4. Bottom Line Utility

Solutions, Inc. 5. Economic Consulting Inc. 6. Ecos Consulting 7. Energy Innovation Group,

LLC 8. Energy Market Innovations,

Inc. 9. Equipoise Consulting. 10. FCI Management

Consultants 11. Geopraxis 12. Global Energy Partners,

LLC 13. Heschong Mahone Group 14. ICF Consulting 15. Kema-Xenergy 16. National Resource

Management 17. Nexant 18. Occidental Analytical Group 19. Portland Energy

Conservation Inc. 20. Proctor Engineering Group 21. Quantum Consulting 22. Resource Management

Consulting 23. Ridge and Associates 24. RLW Analytics 25. Robert Mowris and

Associates 26. SBW Consulting, Inc. 27. Sisson and Associates 28. Summit Blue Consulting 29. VPI Strategies 30. BASE Energy Inc

City of DavisYolo Energy Efficiency Project (YEEP)

1079-04 PGE1. Heshong Mahone Group 2. Nexant 3. Frontier Associates

City of Davis/ (on behalf of

Yolo Energy Efficiency

1224-04 PGE

R.01-08-028 KLM/hl2

APPENDIX APage 4



partnership) Project (YEEP)County of Marin, Community Development Agency (Marin CDA)

Marin Public Facilities Energy Management Team

1433-04 PGE

1. Robert Mowris and Associates

2. Heshong Mahone Group 3. Equipoise Consulting 4. Quantum Consulting

D&R InternationalSchools Energy Efficiency Program

1190-04 PG&E1. Ridge & Associates2. Itron3. Power Logic

Ecology Action

RightLights Turnkey Commercial Lighting Retrofits

1445-04 PGE4. Quantec LLC 5. Summit Blue Consulting 6. Aloha Systems 4. Itron

Energy Analysis Technologies

Residential Duct Services 1311-04 SCE 1. Sisson and Associates

2. Quantum Consulting 1327-04 SCGEnergy Design Tools Group, UCLA, Department of Architecture (UCLA)

HEED, Home Energy Efficient Design

1068-04 PGE 1. Robert Mowris and Associates

Energy Design Tools Group, UCLA, Department of Architecture

HEED, Home Energy Efficient Design

1067-04 SDGE

Energy Solutions LightWash 1225-04 PGE 1. Equipoise Consulting

EnSave Energy Performance, Inc. (EnSave)

California Multi Measure Farm Program

1354-04 PGE 1. kW Engineering 2. SBW consulting 3. RLW AnalyticsEnSave Energy

Performance, Inc.California Multi Measure Farm Program

1360-04 SCE

FCI Management Consultants (FCI)

Emerging Communities Energy Efficiency Program

1396-04 SCE1. Robert Mowris and

Associates 2. Ridge and Associates

Frontier Associates (Frontier)

Green Building Technical Support Services program

1414-04 PGE1. Shel Feldman 2. Research Into Action 3. Quantec 4. Heshong Mahone Group

R.01-08-028 KLM/hl2

APPENDIX APage 5



Global Energy Partners and CCOF (GEP)

Certified Organic Farmers Energy Efficiency (COFEE) Program

1473-04 PGE 1. Quantec LLC 2. Aloha Systems

Global Energy Services, Inc. (GES)

Chinese Language Efficiency Outreach-Statewide (CLEOS)

1494-04 PGE

1. ASW EngineeringGlobal Energy Services, Inc.


1366-04 SCE

Global Energy Services, Inc.


1366-05 SCG

H&L Energy Savers (H&L) Performance 4 1066-04 SCE 1. Sisson and Associates

Heschong Mahone Group, Inc. (HMG)

Designed for Comfort, Efficient Affordable Housing

1146-04 PGE

1. Kema-Xenergy 2. Quantec LLP 3. Global Energy Partners 4. GDS Associates 5. Wirshafter Consulting 6. Summit Blue 7. Energy Market

Innovations 8. Aloha Systems 9. Robert Mowris and

Associates

Heschong Mahone Group, Inc.


1147-04 SCE



1148-04 SCG


Designed for Comfort, Efficient Affordable

1149-04 SDGE

R.01-08-028 KLM/hl2

APPENDIX APage 6



Housing

ICF Consulting (ICF)

Partnership for Energy Affordability in Multi-family Housing

1211-04 PGE1. Kema-Xenergy 2. Itron 3. Quantum Consulting

Insync/San Joaquin/ADM (InSync)

San Joaquin County Comprehensive Energy Efficiency Program

1423-04 PGE1. ASW Engineering 2. Quantec LLC 3. Aloha Systems

KEMA-XENERGY (Xenergy)

EEGOV - B.E.S.T. 1281-04 PGE 1. Quantec LLC

2. SBW ConsultingKEMA-XENERGY EEGOV -

B.E.S.T. 1333-04 SCE


Enhanced Automation Initiative

1287-04 PGE 1. Quantec LLC 2. SBW Consulting

KEMA-XENERGY Enhanced Automation 1289-04 SCE


Long Beach B.E.S.T. Program 1310-04 SCE 1. Quantec LLC

2. SBW ConsultingKEMA-XENERGY (Xenergy)

Positive Energy Loan Fund 1213-04 PGE 1. Shel Feldman

2. Research Into Action

Navigant Consulting, Inc. (Navigant)

Prototype Community Energy Efficiency Programs

1241-04 PGE1. Ridge and Associates 2. Brown, Vence, and

AssociatesNavigant Consulting, Inc.

Prototype Community Energy Efficiency Programs

1242-04 SCE

Portland Energy Conservation Inc. (PECI)

EnergySmart Grocer 1314-04 PGE

1. RLW Analytics

Portland Energy Conservation Inc. (PECI)

EnergySmart Grocer 1290-04 SCE

Portland Energy Conservation Inc.

EnergySmart Grocer

1291-04 SDGE

R.01-08-028 KLM/hl2

APPENDIX APage 7



(PECI)Portland Energy Conservation, Inc. (PECI)

Statewide Retrocommissioning Program

1381-04 SDGE1. RLW Analytics 2. SBW Consulting 3. Itron

Quantum Consulting (Quantum)

Building Tune-Up Program 1119-04 PGE 1. Itron

2. SBW ConsultingQuantum Consulting

Building Tune-Up Program 1117-04 SCE

Quantum Consulting (Quantum)

California Wastewater Process Optimization Program

1159-04 PGE

1. Itron 2. SBW Consulting

Quantum Consulting

California Wastewater Process Optimization Program

1165-04 SDGE

Redwood Coast Regional Energy Authority (RCEA)

Redwood Coast Regional Comprehensive Information and Education Program

1416-04 PGE1. Heshong Mahone Group 2. Summit Blue Consulting 3. Robert Mowris and

Associates

Richard Heath & Associates, Inc. (RHA)

Small Nonresidential Energy Fitness Program

1409-04 PGE1. Heshong Mahone 2. Itron 3. Robert Mowris and

AssociatesRLW Analytics (RLW)

Energy Savers Program 1085-04 PGE 1. Aloha Systems

2. Sisson and Associates

Robert Mowris & Associates (RMA)

RCA Verification Program for New Air Conditioners

1395-04 PGE

1. Ridge and Associates 2. Aloha Systems 3. Itron 4. Occidental Analytical Group

Robert Mowris & Associates


1385-04 SCE

Robert Mowris & Associates


1437-04 SDGE

San Diego Regional Energy Partnership (SDREP)

San Diego Energy Resource Center

1303-04 SDGE 1. Nexant 2. Zebedee and Associates

R.01-08-028 KLM/hl2

APPENDIX APage 8




Green Action 1300-04 SDGE 1. Nexant 2. Zebedee and Associates


San Diego Region B.E.S.T. 1285-04 SDGE 1. Nexant

2. Quantec LLC


San Diego Regional Cool Communities Shade Tree Program



San Diego Regional Green Building Education and Technical Assistance (GBETA)



Technical Assistance Program


San Francisco Community Power Cooperative (SFCPC)

Efficiency on Wheels 1083-04 PGE

1. ADM 2. Aspen Systems 3. Newcomb Anderson and

Associates

SBW Consulting, Inc. (SBW)

Compressed Air Management Program (CAMP)

1229-04 PGE 1. Ridge and Associates 2. Equipoise Consulting

SDREO

San Diego Local Government Energy Efficiency Program


SESCO, Inc. (SESCO)

Gas Only Multi-Family Program - South

1338-04 SCG

1. Occidental Analytical Group

2. Robert Mowris and Associates

3. Summit Blue Consulting

R.01-08-028 KLM/hl2

APPENDIX APage 9

Table 1b Local IOU Programs

Proposal Sponsor Program Title Program

Number Service Area Approved Contractor List

PG&ESchool Resources Program

1129-04 PGE

1. ADM Associates 2. Aloha Systems Aspen Systems 3. ASW Engineering Management

Consultants 4. Athens Research 5. ECONorthwest 6. Energy & Environmental

Economics 7. Energy Market Innovations 8. Equipoise Consulting 9. Flexo-Hiner 10. Frontier Associates 11. GDS Associates 12. Glacier Consulting 13. Global Energy Partners 14. H. Gil Peach & Associates 15. Heschong Mahone Group 16. Innovologie 17. Itron 18. KEMA-Xenergy 19. KVD Research Consulting 20. kW Engineering 21. Megdal & Associates 22. Nexant 23. Opinion Dynamics 24. PA Consulting 25. Population Research Systems

LLC 26. Quantec LLC 27. Quantum Consulting 28. Research Into Action 29. Ridge & associates 30. RLW Analytics 31. Robert Mowris & Associates 32. SBW Consulting 33. Sisson & Associates 34. Skumatz Economic Research

Associates 35. Summit Blue Consulting 36. Vanward Consulting 37. West Hill Energy & Computing 38. Wirtshafter Associates 39. Zebedee & Associates

PG&E Energenius 1132-04 PGE

SCELocal Small Non-Residential Hard to Reach

1313-04 SCE

SCELocal Government Initiative

1318-04 SCE

SCE Local Pump Test and Hydraulic

1317-04 SCE 1. ADM Associates 2. Aloha Systems

R.01-08-028 KLM/hl2

APPENDIX APage 10




Service

3. ASW Engineering 4. ECONorthwest 5. Energy Market Innovations 6. Equipoise Consulting 7. Flexo Hiner Partners, Inc. 8. Frontier Associates 9. GDS Associates 10. Glacier Consulting 11. H. Gil Peach & Associates 12. Innovologie 13. kW Engineering 14. Nexant 15. Opinion Dynamics 16. PA Consulting 17. Population Research Systems

LLC 18. Quantec LLC 19. Research Into Action 20. Ridge & associates 21. RLW Analytics 22. Robert Mowris & Associates 23. SBW Consulting 24. Wirtshafter Associates

SDG&E Local HTR Lighting Turn-In 1356-04 SDGE

1. Equipoise Consulting 2. Itron (RER) 3. Kema-Xenergy 4. Quantec 5. Quantum Consulting 6. RLW Analytics

SDG&E Small Business Energy Efficiency

1340-04 SDGE 1. ADM Associates 2. Aloha Systems 3. Aspen Systems Corporation 4. ASW Engineering Management 5. EcoNorthwest, Energy &

Environmental Economics 6. Energy Market Innovations 7. Equipoise Consulting 8. Frontier Associates 9. GDS Associates 10. Global Energy Partners 11. Heschong-Mahone Group 12. Itron-RER 13. KEMA-Xenergy, Inc.14. KVDR Consulting 15. Megdal & Associates

R.01-08-028 KLM/hl2

APPENDIX APage 11




16. Nexant 17. Opinion Dynamics 18. PA Consulting Group 19. Quantec LLC 20. Quantum Consulting 21. Research Into Action 22. Ridge and Associates 23. RLW Analytics 24. Robert Mowris & Associates 25. SBW Engineering 26. Skumatz Economic Research

Associates (SERA) 27. Summit Blue Consulting 28. Vanward Consulting 29. Wirtshafter Associates

SCG Non-Residential Financial Incentives

1260-04 1. ADM Associates 2. Aloha Systems 3. Aspen Systems Corporation 4. ASW Engineering Management 5. EcoNorthwest, Energy &

Environmental Economics 6. Energy Market Innovations 7. Equipoise Consulting 8. Frontier Associates 9. GDS Associates 10. Global Energy Partners 11. Heschong-Mahone Group 12. Itron-RER 13. KEMA-Xenergy, Inc.,14. KVDR Consulting 15. Megdal & Associates 16. Nexant 17. Opinion Dynamics 18. PA Consulting Group 19. Quantec LLC 20. Quantum Consulting 21. Research Into Action 22. Ridge and Associates 23. RLW Analytics 24. Robert Mowris & Associates 25. SBW Engineering 26. Sisson and Associates 27. Skumatz Economic Research

Associates (SERA) 28. Summit Blue Consulting

R.01-08-028 KLM/hl2

APPENDIX APage 12




29. Vanward Consulting 30. Wirtshafter Associates

R.01-08-028 KLM/hl2


Page 13

Table 1c Partnership Programs


Number Service AreaApproved Contractor List

PG&EWest Sacramento Partnership

1199-04 PGE



Economics7. Energy Market Innovations 8. Equipoise Consulting 9. Flexo-Hiner 10. Frontier Associates 11. GDS Associates 12. Glacier Consulting 13. Global Energy Partners 14. H. Gil Peach & Associates 15. Heschong Mahone Group 16. Innovologie 17. Itron 18. KEMA-Xenergy 19. KVD Research Consulting 20. kW Engineering 21. Megdal & Associates 22. Nexant 23. Opinion Dynamics 24. PA Consulting 25. Population Research Systems



PG&E City of Fresno Partnership 1205-04 PGE

PG&E Silicon Valley Partnership 1207-04 PGE

PG&EEl Dorado County Partnership

1214-04 PGE

PG&E City of Stockton Partnership 1215-04 PGE

R.01-08-028 KLM/hl2


Page 14




PG&E East Bay Partnership 1226-04 PGE



Economics 7. Energy Market Innovations 8. Equipoise Consulting 9. Flexo-Hiner 10. Frontier Associates 11. GDS Associates 12. Glacier Consulting 13. Global Energy Partners 14. H. Gil Peach & Associates 15. Heschong Mahone Group 16. Innovologie 17. Itron 18. KVD Research Consulting 19. Megdal & Associates 20. Nexant 21. Opinion Dynamics 22. PA Consulting 23. Population Research Systems

LLC 24. Quantec LLC 25. Research Into Action 26. Ridge & associates 27. RLW Analytics 28. Robert Mowris & Associates 29. SBW Consulting 30. Sisson & Associates 31. Skumatz Economic Research


PG&E, SCE, SCG IOU/UC/CSU Partnership 1461-04 PGE 1. ADM Associates

2. Aloha Systems Aspen Systems 3. ASW Engineering Management

Consultants 1324-04 SCE 1475-04 SCG

R.01-08-028 KLM/hl2


Page 15




4. Athens Research 5. ECONorthwest 6. Energy & Environmental

Economics 7. Energy Market Innovations 8. Equipoise Consulting 9. Flexo-Hiner 10. Frontier Associates 11. GDS Associates 12. Glacier Consulting 13. Global Energy Partners 14. H. Gil Peach & Associates 15. Heschong Mahone Group 16. Innovologie 17. Itron 18. KEMA-Xenergy 19. KVD Research Consulting 20. kW Engineering 21. Megdal & Associates 22. Nexant

1489-04 SDGE

PG&E, SCE, SCGBakersfield/ Kern Energy Watch

1350-04 PGE

1325-04 SCE 1230-04 SCG

SCE City of Pomona Partnership 1326-04 SCE

SCE, SCG The Energy Coalition 1196-04 SCE

1201-04 SCG

SCE, SCGSouth Bay Cities Energy Efficiency Center

1405-04 SCE

1404-04 SCG

SCE, SCG

Ventura County Regional Energy Efficiency Center and Comprehensive Public Sector Program

SCE 1403-04

SCG 1493-04

SCE, SCG LA County Partnership SCE 1321-04

SCG 1388-04

SDG&E San Diego City Schools Partnership

SDGE 1383-04 1. Equipoise Consulting 2. Itron 3. Kema-Xenergy 4. Quantec 5. Quantum Consulting

R.01-08-028 KLM/hl2

APPENDIX APage 16




6. RLW Analytics

R.01-08-028 KLM/hl2

APPENDIX APage 17

Table 1d Procurement Programs



PG&E Procurement Program PGE



Economics 7. Energy Market Innovations 8. Equipoise Consulting 9. Flexo-Hiner 10. Frontier Associates 11. GDS Associates 12. Glacier Consulting 13. Global Energy Partners 14. H. Gil Peach & Associates 15. Heschong Mahone Group 16. Innovologie 17. Itron 18. KEMA-Xenergy 19. KVD Research Consulting 20. Megdal & Associates 21. Nexant 22. Opinion Dynamics 23. PA Consulting 24. Population Research Systems



PG&E, SCE, SDG&E

Upstream HVAC and Motors PGE,SCE,

SDGE

SCE

Innovative Designs for Energy Efficiency Activities

SCE

SDG&E Limited Income Refrigerator and

SDGE 1. Equipoise Consulting 2. Itron

R.01-08-028 KLM/hl2

APPENDIX APage 18

Table 1d Procurement Programs



Lighting

3. Kema-Xenergy 4. Quantec 5. Quantum Consulting 6. RLW Analytics

SDG&ENonresidential Customer Energy Savings Bid

SDGE

SDG&E Nonresidential Energy Saver SDGE

SDG&ENonresidential Sustainable Communities

SDGE

(END OF APPENDIX A)

R.01-08-028 KLM/hl2

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

I certify that I have by mail, and by electronic mail to the parties to which an electronic mail address has been provided, this day served a true copy of the original attached Administrative Law Judge’s Ruling Clarifying Process For Third Party Energy Efficiency Program Providers to Select Contractor to Carry Out Evaluation, Measurement and Verification Of 2004-05 Local Energy Efficiency Programs on all parties of record in this proceeding or their attorneys of record.

Dated April 30, 2004, at San Francisco, California.

/s/ ELIZABETH LEWISElizabeth Lewis

N O T I C EParties should notify the Process Office, Public Utilities Commission, 505 Van Ness Avenue, Room 2000, San Francisco, CA 94102, of any change of address to insure that they continue to receive documents. You must indicate the proceeding number on the service list on which your name appears.

* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *The Commission’s policy is to schedule hearings (meetings, workshops, etc.) in locations that are accessible to people with disabilities. To verify that a particular location is accessible, call: Calendar Clerk (415) 703-1203.

If specialized accommodations for the disabled are needed, e.g., sign language interpreters, those making the arrangements must call the Public Advisor at (415) 703-2074, TTY 1-866-

R.01-08-028 KLM/hl2

APPENDIX APage 20

836-7825 or (415) 703-5282 at least three working days in advance of the event.

docs.cpuc.ca.govdocs.cpuc.ca.gov/word_pdf/RULINGS/36247.doc · Web viewAdministrative Law Judge...

Documents

Transcript of docs.cpuc.ca.govdocs.cpuc.ca.gov/word_pdf/RULINGS/36247.doc · Web viewAdministrative Law Judge...