Dissecting and Folding Stacked Geometric...

39
1 Dissecting and Folding Stacked Geometric Figures Greg N. Frederickson Purdue University Copyright notice: Permission is granted only to DIMACS to post this copy of Greg N. Frederickson’s talk, “Dissecting and Folding Stacked Geometric Figures”, on its website. No permission is granted for others to copy any portions of this talk for their own or anyone else’s use. If you have what you feel is a justifiable use of this talk, contact me ( [email protected] ) to ask permission. Because producing this material was a lot of work, I reserve the right to deny any particular request.

Transcript of Dissecting and Folding Stacked Geometric...

Page 1: Dissecting and Folding Stacked Geometric Figuresarchive.dimacs.rutgers.edu/Workshops/MathArt/Slides/frederickson.pdf* Nifty variation on piano-hinged dissections. * At least as challenging

1

Dissecting and Folding

Stacked Geometric Figures

Greg N. Frederickson

Purdue University

Copyright notice:

Permission is granted only to DIMACS to post this copy

of Greg N. Frederickson’s talk, “Dissecting and Folding

Stacked Geometric Figures”, on its website.

No permission is granted for others to copy any

portions of this talk for their own or anyone else’s use.

If you have what you feel is a justifiable use of this talk,

contact me ( [email protected] ) to ask permission.

Because producing this material was a lot of work,

I reserve the right to deny any particular request.

Page 2: Dissecting and Folding Stacked Geometric Figuresarchive.dimacs.rutgers.edu/Workshops/MathArt/Slides/frederickson.pdf* Nifty variation on piano-hinged dissections. * At least as challenging

2

A note about animations and videos

None of the animations and videos were included when

my powerpoint file was converted to a pdf file. Any slide

that contains a picture with color but no title is the first

frame of an animation or video. Selected animations are

available from my webpages:

http://www.cs.purdue.edu/homes/gnf/book3/stackfold.html

http://www.cs.purdue.edu/homes/gnf/book3/stackfold2.html

These animations were time-intensive to produce. Please

show your appreciation by respecting my copyright.

Dissection of one square to two squares[Plato, 4th century, BCE]

Page 3: Dissecting and Folding Stacked Geometric Figuresarchive.dimacs.rutgers.edu/Workshops/MathArt/Slides/frederickson.pdf* Nifty variation on piano-hinged dissections. * At least as challenging

3

Hinged dissection of one square to two squares(with 2 swing-hinged assemblages)

Piano-hinge (fold-hinge) brings a piece Afrom being next to a piece B to being on top of B

Page 4: Dissecting and Folding Stacked Geometric Figuresarchive.dimacs.rutgers.edu/Workshops/MathArt/Slides/frederickson.pdf* Nifty variation on piano-hinged dissections. * At least as challenging

4

Piano-hinged dissection of 1 square to 2 squares(with 2 assemblages)

Page 5: Dissecting and Folding Stacked Geometric Figuresarchive.dimacs.rutgers.edu/Workshops/MathArt/Slides/frederickson.pdf* Nifty variation on piano-hinged dissections. * At least as challenging

5

Juggling 2 (or more) assemblages is a pain!So let’s change the game:

Instead of having two smaller squares,

let’s have just one, but twice as high.

We want a folding dissection of

a 1-high square to a 2-high square,

the latter with smaller cross-section.

General goals

Eliminate multiple assemblages

by increasing the height of figures:

Dissect a m-high figure to a n-high figure.

Try to dissect, as always, into

the fewest possible number of pieces.

Create a nifty and lovely mathematical object.

Page 6: Dissecting and Folding Stacked Geometric Figuresarchive.dimacs.rutgers.edu/Workshops/MathArt/Slides/frederickson.pdf* Nifty variation on piano-hinged dissections. * At least as challenging

6

Folds for a 1-high square to a 2-high square

Page 7: Dissecting and Folding Stacked Geometric Figuresarchive.dimacs.rutgers.edu/Workshops/MathArt/Slides/frederickson.pdf* Nifty variation on piano-hinged dissections. * At least as challenging

7

Follow-up to material in:

(published by

A K Peters,

Dec. 2006)

Folds for a 2-high 10-pointed star to two 2-high 5-pointed stars

Page 8: Dissecting and Folding Stacked Geometric Figuresarchive.dimacs.rutgers.edu/Workshops/MathArt/Slides/frederickson.pdf* Nifty variation on piano-hinged dissections. * At least as challenging

8

Outline of the talk

* Introduction

* Squares

* Regular Hexagons

* Hexagrams

* Equilateral Triangles

* Well-formed polyominoes

* 5-pointed and 10-pointed stars

Page 9: Dissecting and Folding Stacked Geometric Figuresarchive.dimacs.rutgers.edu/Workshops/MathArt/Slides/frederickson.pdf* Nifty variation on piano-hinged dissections. * At least as challenging

9

Squares

Structure of 1 large and 8 small squares

Page 10: Dissecting and Folding Stacked Geometric Figuresarchive.dimacs.rutgers.edu/Workshops/MathArt/Slides/frederickson.pdf* Nifty variation on piano-hinged dissections. * At least as challenging

10

Folds for a 1-high square to an 8-high square

Page 11: Dissecting and Folding Stacked Geometric Figuresarchive.dimacs.rutgers.edu/Workshops/MathArt/Slides/frederickson.pdf* Nifty variation on piano-hinged dissections. * At least as challenging

11

Regular Hexagons

Structure of 1 large and 3 small hexagons

Page 12: Dissecting and Folding Stacked Geometric Figuresarchive.dimacs.rutgers.edu/Workshops/MathArt/Slides/frederickson.pdf* Nifty variation on piano-hinged dissections. * At least as challenging

12

Folds for a 1-high hexagon to a 3-high hexagon

Page 13: Dissecting and Folding Stacked Geometric Figuresarchive.dimacs.rutgers.edu/Workshops/MathArt/Slides/frederickson.pdf* Nifty variation on piano-hinged dissections. * At least as challenging

13

Dissection of 3 hexagons to 4 hexagons[Ernest Freese, 1957]

Folds for a 3-high hexagon to a 4-high hexagon

Page 14: Dissecting and Folding Stacked Geometric Figuresarchive.dimacs.rutgers.edu/Workshops/MathArt/Slides/frederickson.pdf* Nifty variation on piano-hinged dissections. * At least as challenging

14

Hexagrams

Page 15: Dissecting and Folding Stacked Geometric Figuresarchive.dimacs.rutgers.edu/Workshops/MathArt/Slides/frederickson.pdf* Nifty variation on piano-hinged dissections. * At least as challenging

15

Structure of 1 large and 3 small hexagrams

Folds for a 1-high hexagram to a 3-high hexagram

Page 16: Dissecting and Folding Stacked Geometric Figuresarchive.dimacs.rutgers.edu/Workshops/MathArt/Slides/frederickson.pdf* Nifty variation on piano-hinged dissections. * At least as challenging

16

Equilateral Triangles

Page 17: Dissecting and Folding Stacked Geometric Figuresarchive.dimacs.rutgers.edu/Workshops/MathArt/Slides/frederickson.pdf* Nifty variation on piano-hinged dissections. * At least as challenging

17

1-high triangle to n-high triangle

for n a perfect square:

1-high triangle to 4-high triangle

1-high triangle to 9-high triangle

1-high triangle to 16-high triangle

(not shown)

1-high triangle to 25-high triangle

Folds for a 1-high equilateral triangle to a 4-high equilateral triangle

Page 18: Dissecting and Folding Stacked Geometric Figuresarchive.dimacs.rutgers.edu/Workshops/MathArt/Slides/frederickson.pdf* Nifty variation on piano-hinged dissections. * At least as challenging

18

Folds for a 1-high equilateral triangle to a 9-high equilateral triangle

Page 19: Dissecting and Folding Stacked Geometric Figuresarchive.dimacs.rutgers.edu/Workshops/MathArt/Slides/frederickson.pdf* Nifty variation on piano-hinged dissections. * At least as challenging

19

Folds for a 1-high equilateral triangle to a 25-high equilateral triangle

Page 20: Dissecting and Folding Stacked Geometric Figuresarchive.dimacs.rutgers.edu/Workshops/MathArt/Slides/frederickson.pdf* Nifty variation on piano-hinged dissections. * At least as challenging

20

2-high triangle to n-high triangle

for n = 2 (p^2 + p + 1) :

2-high triangle to 6-high triangle (p = 1)

2-high triangle to 14-high triangle (p = 2)

2-high triangle to 26-high triangle (p = 3)

(Interior figure for each level of 2-high triangle

is a (p –1)-triangle.)

Folds for a 2-high equilateral triangle to a 6-high equilateral triangle

Page 21: Dissecting and Folding Stacked Geometric Figuresarchive.dimacs.rutgers.edu/Workshops/MathArt/Slides/frederickson.pdf* Nifty variation on piano-hinged dissections. * At least as challenging

21

Folds for a 2-high equilateral triangle to a 14-high equilateral triangle

Page 22: Dissecting and Folding Stacked Geometric Figuresarchive.dimacs.rutgers.edu/Workshops/MathArt/Slides/frederickson.pdf* Nifty variation on piano-hinged dissections. * At least as challenging

22

2-high triangle to 26-high triangle will includetwo 1-high to 4-high dissections in shaded area.

Folds for a 2-high equilateral triangle to a 26-high equilateral triangle

Page 23: Dissecting and Folding Stacked Geometric Figuresarchive.dimacs.rutgers.edu/Workshops/MathArt/Slides/frederickson.pdf* Nifty variation on piano-hinged dissections. * At least as challenging

23

2-high triangle to n-high triangle

for n = 2 (p^2 + pq + q^2) :

2-high triangle to 38-high triangle

(p = 3, q = 2)

2-high triangle to 74-high triangle

(p = 4, q = 3)

(Interior figure for each level of 2-high triangle

is no longer a (p –1)-triangle when q > 1 )

Folds for a 2-high equilateral triangle to a 38-high equilateral triangle

Page 24: Dissecting and Folding Stacked Geometric Figuresarchive.dimacs.rutgers.edu/Workshops/MathArt/Slides/frederickson.pdf* Nifty variation on piano-hinged dissections. * At least as challenging

24

Folds for a 2-high equilateral triangle to a 74-high equilateral triangle

m-high triangle to n-high triangle

Neither m nor n is 1 or 2:

Special case: m = 3 and n = 4

(Relatively easy!)

Many more combinations are possible.

Page 25: Dissecting and Folding Stacked Geometric Figuresarchive.dimacs.rutgers.edu/Workshops/MathArt/Slides/frederickson.pdf* Nifty variation on piano-hinged dissections. * At least as challenging

25

Folds for a 3-high equilateral triangle to a 4-high equilateral triangle

Page 26: Dissecting and Folding Stacked Geometric Figuresarchive.dimacs.rutgers.edu/Workshops/MathArt/Slides/frederickson.pdf* Nifty variation on piano-hinged dissections. * At least as challenging

26

Polyominoes

( not Polynomio ! )

Structure of 1 large and 2 small Latin Crosses

Page 27: Dissecting and Folding Stacked Geometric Figuresarchive.dimacs.rutgers.edu/Workshops/MathArt/Slides/frederickson.pdf* Nifty variation on piano-hinged dissections. * At least as challenging

27

Folds for a 1-high Latin Cross to a 2-high Latin Cross

Page 28: Dissecting and Folding Stacked Geometric Figuresarchive.dimacs.rutgers.edu/Workshops/MathArt/Slides/frederickson.pdf* Nifty variation on piano-hinged dissections. * At least as challenging

28

Well-formed Tree-Polyomino(with “Change-Direction” squares shown)

Well-formed polyominoes

Polyomino – a figure consisting of squares that are

glued together edge-to-edge.

Change-direction square – a square in a polyomino where

we switch direction between horizontal and vertical.

Well-formed polyomino – a polyomino in which no two

change-direction squares are directly adjacent.

Tree polyomino – a polyomino with no cycles.

Page 29: Dissecting and Folding Stacked Geometric Figuresarchive.dimacs.rutgers.edu/Workshops/MathArt/Slides/frederickson.pdf* Nifty variation on piano-hinged dissections. * At least as challenging

29

Properties of well-formed polyominoes

There is a dissection of such a 2-high figure to a 1-high

figure that uses pieces from a set of just 9 shapes.

The number of pieces in the dissection equals the

number of convex corners in the well-formed polyomino

plus the number of squares.

The pieces in the 1-high figure alternate between those

from the top level of the 2-high figure and those from

the bottom level.

Complete set of piece shapes for dissections of 2-high to 1-high well-formed polyominoes

Page 30: Dissecting and Folding Stacked Geometric Figuresarchive.dimacs.rutgers.edu/Workshops/MathArt/Slides/frederickson.pdf* Nifty variation on piano-hinged dissections. * At least as challenging

30

Algorithm to design the folding dissection:Step 1. Rotate the figure by 45 degrees.

Algorithm to design the folding dissection:Step 2. Cut isosceles right triangle at each corner.

Page 31: Dissecting and Folding Stacked Geometric Figuresarchive.dimacs.rutgers.edu/Workshops/MathArt/Slides/frederickson.pdf* Nifty variation on piano-hinged dissections. * At least as challenging

31

Algorithm to design the folding dissection:Step 3. For each CD-square use a “CD-piece”.

Algorithm to design the folding dissection:

Step 4. Divide up SW-to-NE arms by vertical cuts.

Page 32: Dissecting and Folding Stacked Geometric Figuresarchive.dimacs.rutgers.edu/Workshops/MathArt/Slides/frederickson.pdf* Nifty variation on piano-hinged dissections. * At least as challenging

32

Algorithm to design the folding dissection:Step 5. Divide up other arms by horizontal cuts.

Folds for 1-high tree-polyominoto a 2-high tree-polyomino (part 1)

Page 33: Dissecting and Folding Stacked Geometric Figuresarchive.dimacs.rutgers.edu/Workshops/MathArt/Slides/frederickson.pdf* Nifty variation on piano-hinged dissections. * At least as challenging

33

Folds for 1-high tree-polyominoto a 2-high tree-polyomino (part 2)

Page 34: Dissecting and Folding Stacked Geometric Figuresarchive.dimacs.rutgers.edu/Workshops/MathArt/Slides/frederickson.pdf* Nifty variation on piano-hinged dissections. * At least as challenging

34

Cross of Jerusalem(with “Change-Direction” squares shown)

Folds for 1-high Cross of Jerusalemto a 2-high Cross of Jerusalem (part 1)

Page 35: Dissecting and Folding Stacked Geometric Figuresarchive.dimacs.rutgers.edu/Workshops/MathArt/Slides/frederickson.pdf* Nifty variation on piano-hinged dissections. * At least as challenging

35

Folds for 1-high Cross of Jerusalemto a 2-high Cross of Jerusalem (part 2)

Page 36: Dissecting and Folding Stacked Geometric Figuresarchive.dimacs.rutgers.edu/Workshops/MathArt/Slides/frederickson.pdf* Nifty variation on piano-hinged dissections. * At least as challenging

36

Polyomino that has 2 holes(with “Change-Direction” squares shown)

Folds for a 1-high 2-holed polyominoto a 2-high 2-holed polyomino

Page 37: Dissecting and Folding Stacked Geometric Figuresarchive.dimacs.rutgers.edu/Workshops/MathArt/Slides/frederickson.pdf* Nifty variation on piano-hinged dissections. * At least as challenging

37

Stars

Page 38: Dissecting and Folding Stacked Geometric Figuresarchive.dimacs.rutgers.edu/Workshops/MathArt/Slides/frederickson.pdf* Nifty variation on piano-hinged dissections. * At least as challenging

38

Folds for a 2-high 10-pointed star to a 4-high 5-pointed star

Page 39: Dissecting and Folding Stacked Geometric Figuresarchive.dimacs.rutgers.edu/Workshops/MathArt/Slides/frederickson.pdf* Nifty variation on piano-hinged dissections. * At least as challenging

39

Conclusion

Folding a m-high figure to a n-high figure is:

* Nifty variation on piano-hinged dissections.

* At least as challenging than phd’s.

* Great basis for manipulation puzzles.

* Math/puzzle/art that is within reach.

* A lot of fun!

May the Folds be with you!