Discussion on Integrating a Child Rights Perspective in Poverty and Social Impact Analysis Event...

9
Discussion on Integrating a Child Rights Perspective in Poverty and Social Impact Analysis Even Dat United Nations Development Programme *The views expressed are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of the organization with which he/she is affiliated. Please send comments to [email protected] February 19 th , 2010, New York Namsuk Kim Office of Development Studies UNDP The views expressed in this presentation are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect those of UNDP.

Transcript of Discussion on Integrating a Child Rights Perspective in Poverty and Social Impact Analysis Event...

Page 1: Discussion on Integrating a Child Rights Perspective in Poverty and Social Impact Analysis Event Date United Nations Development Programme *The views expressed.

Discussion on Integrating a Child Rights Perspective in Poverty and Social Impact Analysis

EventDate

United Nations Development Programme

*The views expressed are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of the organization with which he/she is affiliated. Please send comments to [email protected]

February 19th, 2010, New York

Namsuk KimOffice of Development Studies

UNDP

The views expressed in this presentation are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect those of UNDP.

Page 2: Discussion on Integrating a Child Rights Perspective in Poverty and Social Impact Analysis Event Date United Nations Development Programme *The views expressed.

Contribution

•Comprehensive review of PSIAs

•Clear description of CRIA

•Concrete recommendations

Page 3: Discussion on Integrating a Child Rights Perspective in Poverty and Social Impact Analysis Event Date United Nations Development Programme *The views expressed.

Comments on the framework

•Short term vs Long term impacts

•Short term gains vs Long term losses

•Households’ response to policies

Page 4: Discussion on Integrating a Child Rights Perspective in Poverty and Social Impact Analysis Event Date United Nations Development Programme *The views expressed.

Comments on the data

•‘Child Lens’: Wider screen or higher resolution?

•Severe gap between data demand and supply

•Cost and benefit of extensive questions

Page 5: Discussion on Integrating a Child Rights Perspective in Poverty and Social Impact Analysis Event Date United Nations Development Programme *The views expressed.

Average lag in survey data availability for the latest reference year by region

Source: Chen and Ravallion (2008, Table 2).

Page 6: Discussion on Integrating a Child Rights Perspective in Poverty and Social Impact Analysis Event Date United Nations Development Programme *The views expressed.

Updating Frequency of Poverty Incidences and Counts in Selected Developing Countries

Frequency CountriesYearly China and IndonesiaEvery 2 years Thailand and IranEvery 3 years Jordan, Mongolia, and PhilippinesEvery 5 years India, Malaysia, Sri Lanka, and VietnamIrregular, depending on funds availability

Bangladesh, Cambodia, Laos, Fiji, and the Central Asian Republics

Not yet measuring poverty

16 of 79 countries that responded to the UNSD 2004 survey

Source: UN (2006, Chapter 4, p.106).

Page 7: Discussion on Integrating a Child Rights Perspective in Poverty and Social Impact Analysis Event Date United Nations Development Programme *The views expressed.

Data is more costly in developing countries

•The cost per sampling unit of LSMS

•$146 in Vietnam

•$698 in Brazil

•United States Population Census cost only $16 per person

Source: Grosh and Muñoz (1996, p.188) and Gauthier, 2002, p. A-1.

Page 8: Discussion on Integrating a Child Rights Perspective in Poverty and Social Impact Analysis Event Date United Nations Development Programme *The views expressed.

Comments on the suggestions

•Households’ adaptations

•Households’ response to policies/shocks

•World Bank’s incentive

Page 9: Discussion on Integrating a Child Rights Perspective in Poverty and Social Impact Analysis Event Date United Nations Development Programme *The views expressed.

Summary

•Framework: explicitly integrate Long term and short term impacts/behaviors

•Data: Systematic bias, cost/benefit consideration

•Suggestions: Mitigation and adaptations of households, Stakeholders’ response


No. 1/2013 Integrating Spatial Aspects of … Spatial Aspects of Poverty into Urban Spatial Planning: Solutions for Tackling Urban Poverty No. 1/2013 T he results of a 2011 SMERU study

No. 1/2013 Integrating Spatial Aspects of … Spatial Aspects of Poverty into Urban Spatial Planning: Solutions for Tackling Urban Poverty No. 1/2013 T he results of a 2011 SMERU study

Moving to a Supplemental Poverty Measure (SPM): Research ... · Views expressed in this presentation, including those related to statistical, methodological, technical, or operational

Moving to a Supplemental Poverty Measure (SPM): Research ... · Views expressed in this presentation, including those related to statistical, methodological, technical, or operational

WIDER Working Paper 2016/23 · harmful energy sources while tackling rural poverty. Integrating clean energy use in poverty alleviation discourse is increasingly gaining global attention,

WIDER Working Paper 2016/23 · harmful energy sources while tackling rural poverty. Integrating clean energy use in poverty alleviation discourse is increasingly gaining global attention,

Integrating Poverty and Gender into Health Programmes · Integrating Poverty and Gender into Health Programmes Module on Gender-Based Violence World Health Organization Regional Office

Integrating Poverty and Gender into Health Programmes · Integrating Poverty and Gender into Health Programmes Module on Gender-Based Violence World Health Organization Regional Office

The ‘Lisbon’ economic objective Focusing and Integrating ... › contents › meetings › 2005_Berlin › ENPM...b) Cancer c) Poverty-related diseases • HIV / AIDS • Malaria

The ‘Lisbon’ economic objective Focusing and Integrating ... › contents › meetings › 2005_Berlin › ENPM...b) Cancer c) Poverty-related diseases • HIV / AIDS • Malaria

Integrating Disaster Risk Reduction into the Fight Against Poverty · 2011-04-06 · Integrating Disaster Risk Reduction into the Fight Against Poverty 1 Foreword The nature and frequency

Integrating Disaster Risk Reduction into the Fight Against Poverty · 2011-04-06 · Integrating Disaster Risk Reduction into the Fight Against Poverty 1 Foreword The nature and frequency

Integrating climate change considerations into sustainable development and poverty alleviation Inger Andersen, Director Sustainable Development Department.

Integrating climate change considerations into sustainable development and poverty alleviation Inger Andersen, Director Sustainable Development Department.

INTEGRATING INDIGENOUS KNOWLEDGE (IK) INTO UGANDA’S POVERTY ERADICATION ACTION PLAN (PEAP) By Joyce N. Muwanga Assistant Executive Secretary Uganda National.

INTEGRATING INDIGENOUS KNOWLEDGE (IK) INTO UGANDA’S POVERTY ERADICATION ACTION PLAN (PEAP) By Joyce N. Muwanga Assistant Executive Secretary Uganda National.

Integrating a gender perspective into poverty statistics United Nations Statistics Division.

Integrating a gender perspective into poverty statistics United Nations Statistics Division.

Minding the Gaps Integrating Poverty Reduction Strategies and

Minding the Gaps Integrating Poverty Reduction Strategies and

Integrating Inter-Personal Inequality in Counting Poverty Indices: The Correlation Sensitive Poverty Index Nicole Rippin 24 June 2014.

Integrating Inter-Personal Inequality in Counting Poverty Indices: The Correlation Sensitive Poverty Index Nicole Rippin 24 June 2014.

SKILLS DEVELOPMENT AND POVERTY REDUCTION IN …€¦ · The views expressed in this document are those of the ... Poverty in Kazakhstan, ... and multilateral donor agencies like the

SKILLS DEVELOPMENT AND POVERTY REDUCTION IN …€¦ · The views expressed in this document are those of the ... Poverty in Kazakhstan, ... and multilateral donor agencies like the

Developing local fuel poverty alliances – integrating work on health and energy Chris Church Community Environment Associates.

Developing local fuel poverty alliances – integrating work on health and energy Chris Church Community Environment Associates.

Guidelines for Integrating Gender into AgShare...agricultural development outcomes of increases in agricultural productivity, agricultural sustainability, poverty reduction and better

Guidelines for Integrating Gender into AgShare...agricultural development outcomes of increases in agricultural productivity, agricultural sustainability, poverty reduction and better

Poverty Matters! October 2015 SHIFTING Our Perspective: Innovating, Integrating and Improving Children’s Service and Supports WI Office of Children’s Mental.

Poverty Matters! October 2015 SHIFTING Our Perspective: Innovating, Integrating and Improving Children’s Service and Supports WI Office of Children’s Mental.

Integrating the Environment into the Poverty Reduction ... · Integrating the Environment into the Poverty Reduction Strategy Papers 3 and the process dynamics. The PRSP is then evaluated

Integrating the Environment into the Poverty Reduction ... · Integrating the Environment into the Poverty Reduction Strategy Papers 3 and the process dynamics. The PRSP is then evaluated

MANUAL FOR THE IMPLEMENTATION OF USAID POVERTY ASSESSMENT ... USAI… · MANUAL FOR THE IMPLEMENTATION OF USAID POVERTY ASSESSMENT TOOLS 2 DISCLAIMER The author’s views expressed

MANUAL FOR THE IMPLEMENTATION OF USAID POVERTY ASSESSMENT ... USAI… · MANUAL FOR THE IMPLEMENTATION OF USAID POVERTY ASSESSMENT TOOLS 2 DISCLAIMER The author’s views expressed

Integrating Disaster Risk Reduction into the Fight Against ... · Integrating Disaster Risk Reduction into the Fight Against Poverty 1 Foreword The nature and frequency of disasters

Integrating Disaster Risk Reduction into the Fight Against ... · Integrating Disaster Risk Reduction into the Fight Against Poverty 1 Foreword The nature and frequency of disasters

Scoping Study on Integrating Poverty Reduction ... · Scoping Study on Integrating Poverty Reduction, Environmental and Economic Concerns into National Development Planning 3 Education

Scoping Study on Integrating Poverty Reduction ... · Scoping Study on Integrating Poverty Reduction, Environmental and Economic Concerns into National Development Planning 3 Education

Strategies for Integrating and Optimizing Livestock ... · problems of the world, including global warming, poverty, deforestation, contamination of water and desertification (Huss,

Strategies for Integrating and Optimizing Livestock ... · problems of the world, including global warming, poverty, deforestation, contamination of water and desertification (Huss,