DISCERNMENT NEWSLETTER - Discernment-Ministries Inc · DISCERNMENT PAGE 2 SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2016 PO...
7
PO B OX 520 – C ANTON , TX 75103-0520 D ISCERNMENT N EWSLETTER “…how is it that ye do not discern this time?” Luke 12:56 Volume 27, Number 4 September/October 2016 The Bethel Church Upgrade By Pastor Rod Page “I dedicate this book to my children’s children’s children’s children. Though we will not meet until we get to heaven, I wanted you to know that I had you in mind as I wrote every word of this book, and I continue to hold you in my heart. You will become the answer to my prayers and the fulfillment of my prophecies. By the time you read this book, I will be watching you from heaven (see Hebrews 12: 1).”[1] This quotation above is the opening dedication to Kris Vallotton's upgraded book called Heavy Rain. Its former title was How Heaven Invades Earth. At the outset it sounds like a way to soften, or even spiritualize, the more militant sounding “invade” language in his book from six years ago. I believe this change is part of a new effort to say the same thing in a more sophisticated, and yet more palatable, way in order to attract a wider audience. In this day and age where everything is seen from a marketing standpoint, as far as publishers and agents and business in general, it is no surprise that this would happen from within the headquarters of a now worldwide movement—Bethel Church in Redding, California. I am writing this from Redding as it is the closest city to where we live for groceries and doctors. It is also where I lived for several years. It's a pretty typical town in most aspects, with a Costco and an old converted theater downtown, and a mix of working people and retired folks looking for the sun.... It is even sunnier in Redding than Phoenix! But Redding is actually quite special in regard to what is happening in Christendom. A phenomenon has grown up here. There is something almost “magical” about the effect that Bethel has had on this community. The city has fallen in love with this “church”. Is this even possible in our day of hysteria over “separation of church and state”? It is not separate in Redding. Bethel bailed out the Civic Auditorium and is running it well from all indications. Bethel is also becoming a major property owner. They have bought and improved several commercial properties and hope to increase their School of Supernatural Ministry to 3000 students in the next few years. (It is currently around 1400.) They want to build a museum of revival in Americana and have spent around $40,000 to purchase one man's memorabilia collection of articles from major “moves of God” going back into the 1950s. Bethel is growing while the city of Redding has endured a decline in many facets. Crime is up. The housing market is flat at best. Homelessness is rampant. But Bethel is doing really well. I believe they know why. I think they have discovered a secret to moving forward at this time in their history. Before I get back to this subject let met tell you why I am writing this report. Why I Write Before becoming a full time pastor in 2011 I spent over 30 years being a regular Christian, with a regular secular job, raising a family with my wife of 37 years. Before we moved to Redding we attended a church for 10 years beginning in 1994 in Yuba City, California. We noticed after almost 7 years in that church that the teaching was changing. We heard things that shocked us, but because of intense loyalty to the leadership we tried to justify things we should have checked out immediately. We were told that spiritual warfare was calling out demons by name and defeating them in the atmosphere, and thus allowing our city to have a mass revival. We were told it was always God's will for us to be physically well. We were told our children were a chosen seed to bring in the great harvest of all time—that they would do miracles greater than Jesus or the Apostles. These things came in slowly, like a steady drip. We were told that Christians have demons that need to be cast out. We were to go on “prayer walks” that would run the devil out of neighborhoods and out of families as we took dominion over our city. The problem is it didn't work, and we could not find a good Biblical reason to swallow all of this new teaching. Young people would go to the church's new “discipleship” school and come out on the other end bewildered by a lack of power, not blaming the leaders who taught them but God, who they thought did not keep up His end of the bargain. We looked at our Bibles and saw texts that were clearly meant for the next world being brought into ours, with no concept for context or proper Biblical interpretation. It took us almost 3 years to realize we needed to get
Transcript of DISCERNMENT NEWSLETTER - Discernment-Ministries Inc · DISCERNMENT PAGE 2 SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2016 PO...
PO BOX 520 – CANTON, TX 75103-0520
DISCERNMENT NEWSLETTER “…how is it that ye do not discern this time?” Luke 12:56
Volume 27, Number 4 September/October 2016
TheBethelChurchUpgradeByPastorRodPage
“Idedicatethisbooktomychildren’schildren’schildren’schildren.Thoughwewillnotmeetuntilwegettoheaven,IwantedyoutoknowthatIhadyouinmindasIwroteeverywordofthisbook,andIcontinuetohold
youinmyheart.Youwillbecometheanswertomyprayersandthefulfillmentofmyprophecies.Bythetimeyoureadthisbook,Iwillbewatchingyoufromheaven
(seeHebrews12:1).”[1]
ThisquotationaboveistheopeningdedicationtoKrisVallotton'supgradedbookcalledHeavyRain.ItsformertitlewasHowHeavenInvadesEarth.Attheoutsetitsoundslikeawaytosoften,orevenspiritualize,themoremilitantsounding“invade”languageinhisbookfromsixyearsago.Ibelievethischangeispartofanewefforttosaythesamethinginamoresophisticated,andyetmorepalatable,wayinordertoattractawideraudience.
Inthisdayandagewhereeverythingisseenfromamarketingstandpoint,asfaraspublishersandagentsandbusinessingeneral,itisnosurprisethatthiswouldhappenfromwithintheheadquartersofanowworldwidemovement—BethelChurchinRedding,California.
IamwritingthisfromReddingasitistheclosestcitytowhereweliveforgroceriesanddoctors.ItisalsowhereIlivedforseveralyears.It'saprettytypicaltowninmostaspects,withaCostcoandanoldconvertedtheaterdowntown,andamixofworkingpeopleandretiredfolkslookingforthesun....ItisevensunnierinReddingthanPhoenix!
ButReddingisactuallyquitespecialinregardtowhatishappeninginChristendom.Aphenomenonhasgrownup
here.Thereissomethingalmost“magical”abouttheeffectthatBethelhashadonthiscommunity.Thecityhasfalleninlovewiththis“church”.Isthisevenpossibleinourdayofhysteriaover“separationofchurchandstate”?ItisnotseparateinRedding.BethelbailedouttheCivicAuditoriumandisrunningitwellfromallindications.Bethelisalso
becomingamajorpropertyowner.TheyhaveboughtandimprovedseveralcommercialpropertiesandhopetoincreasetheirSchoolofSupernaturalMinistryto3000studentsinthenextfewyears.(Itiscurrentlyaround1400.)TheywanttobuildamuseumofrevivalinAmericanaandhavespentaround$40,000topurchaseoneman'smemorabiliacollectionofarticlesfrommajor“movesofGod”goingbackintothe1950s.
BethelisgrowingwhilethecityofReddinghasenduredadeclineinmanyfacets.Crimeisup.Thehousingmarketisflatatbest.Homelessnessisrampant.ButBethelisdoingreallywell.Ibelievetheyknowwhy.Ithinktheyhavediscoveredasecrettomovingforwardatthistimeintheirhistory.BeforeIgetbacktothissubjectletmettellyouwhyIamwritingthisreport.
WhyIWriteBeforebecomingafulltimepastorin2011Ispentover30yearsbeingaregularChristian,witharegularsecularjob,raisingafamilywithmywifeof37years.BeforewemovedtoReddingweattendedachurchfor10yearsbeginningin1994inYubaCity,California.Wenoticedafteralmost7yearsinthatchurchthattheteachingwaschanging.Weheardthingsthatshockedus,butbecauseofintenseloyaltytotheleadershipwetriedtojustifythingsweshouldhavecheckedoutimmediately.Weweretoldthatspiritualwarfarewascallingoutdemonsbynameanddefeatingthemintheatmosphere,andthusallowingourcitytohaveamassrevival.WeweretolditwasalwaysGod'swillforustobephysicallywell.Weweretoldourchildrenwereachosenseedtobringinthegreatharvestofalltime—thattheywoulddomiraclesgreaterthanJesusortheApostles.Thesethingscameinslowly,likeasteadydrip.WeweretoldthatChristianshavedemonsthatneedtobecastout.Weweretogoon“prayerwalks”thatwouldrunthedeviloutofneighborhoodsandoutoffamiliesaswetookdominionoverourcity.
Theproblemisitdidn'twork,andwecouldnotfindagoodBiblicalreasontoswallowallofthisnewteaching.Youngpeoplewouldgotothechurch'snew“discipleship”schoolandcomeoutontheotherendbewilderedbyalackofpower,notblamingtheleaderswhotaughtthembutGod,whotheythoughtdidnotkeepupHisendofthebargain.WelookedatourBiblesandsawtextsthatwereclearlymeantforthenextworldbeingbroughtintoours,withnoconceptforcontextorproperBiblicalinterpretation.
Ittookusalmost3yearstorealizeweneededtoget
DISCERNMENT PAGE 2 SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2016
PO BOX 520 – CANTON, TX 75103-0520
backtotheBible.ThenwefoundtheDiscernmentMinistries’Herescopeblog(www.herescope.net).Godledustothissmallcadreoffolkswhohadbeenwritingforyearsaboutdifferentnewteachings,thatwerereallyoldthingswrappedupinnewandupgradedlingo.AsSolomonsays,thereisnothingnewunderthesun(Eccl.1:9).
Then,becauseofajob,andaministryopportunitytotakewhatwewerefindingaboutSatan'sschemesandwarnyoungerbelievers,wemovedtoReddingtostartanewjobandworkwithacouplewethoughttrulywerewantingtowarnothers.Sadly,withinayearwefoundoutwewerenotonthesamepagewiththeverypeopleweweresupposedtoservewith.ShortlyafterthiswebegantoattendachurchwheretheBiblewastaughtversebyverse.GodputusawayinHiswaitingroomwherewecouldgetourthoughtsandheartsinlinewithHispreciousWord.
WebegantoservetheLordinhumblebutusefulways.Wehelpedcleanthechurcheachweek,emptyingwastecansandvacuumingthecarpet.LaterwetaughtSundaySchool.Wetrulyhadmanyglorioustimeswithour4thgradeclassteachingthroughtheentireBiblelineuponline.EventuallyIwasaskedtoteachinplaceofthepastorwhenhewasoutoftown.Wewereaskedtoshepherdapartofthecongregationandhada“homegroup”ofover40peopleinourhomeeachmonth.WhatIfoundinthosedayswasthatGodisgracious.WhenweseekHimandHiswaysforHisglory,Heprovidesallweneed.HisWordhastheanswersweneedtocommunicate.Wedon'tneedtomakeupanythingfancytoattractattentiontoit.
IhadheardtheLordcallingmetoministrywhenIwas12yearsold.Ihad,becauseoffear,chosennottofollowHiscallformanyyears.Finallyat50yearsofageIansweredthatcall.IbegantoseektheLord,andaskedotherstopraywithmeaboutgoingintofulltimework.Iassumeditwouldbeinaministrytoyoungpeople,asthatwasthereasonImovedtoRedding.Iwantedtowarnthemofwhattheenemywastryingtodo,bothwithinthechurchandwithoutit.Afteranotheryearofwaiting,justwhenIbegantogiveup,anopportunitycameastheLordopenedupadoorforministry.IhavebeenservingaspastoratasmallcommunitychurchinLewiston,California,eversince.Ilivewithin35milesofReddinginthemountains.Godisgraciousindeed.Itisthehardest,andyetmostfulfillingjob,Ihaveeverhad.
ButBethelisstillathorn.IsupposeitremindsmeofwhathappenedtousinYubaCity.Butitisfarworse.Itisaleader,aworldwideanddominantleader,inamovementrifewitherror.Thisisgrievoustomepersonallybecauseitgoesafter,andactuallytargets,youngpeopleinahugeway.ThisiswhyIwrite.Theseyoungpeople(andoldpeople,too)areprecioustoourSavior.ThismovementisswallowingtheminwaysInevercouldhaveimaginedeven6yearsagowhenIlivedwithinamileofBethelChurch.This
churchismoresophisticatedandmore“excellent”inanalarmingway.
TheNewUpgradeAfewweeksagoIlistenedtoamessagebyKrisVallotton,whoisthenumbertwoleaderatBethel.Krisisknownforsayingthingsthatareedgyandevenshocking.Whatstruckmeabouthis“message”wasthenewangleofreasonabilityandnormalcythatitseemedtoemulate.Backwhenthe“TorontoBlessing”wasinundatingcongregationswithoutlandishbarkingandhowling,andpeoplefallingoutingatherings,where“holylaughter”wastaughtasanewthingthattheSpiritwasdoing,Bethelembraceditwholehog.(Punintended.)Atthattimeinearly1996therewasamassexodusfromBethelchurch.TheywentfromtwoservicesonSundaystoone.Butwithinacoupleofyearstheybegantogrowagain.Likeotherchurchestheydidn'tdivorcethemselvesfromtheteachingsbehindthemanifestations.Insteadtheychangedtheoutwardappearancestobemoresettled,morereasonable,moreattractive.(AlthoughIwouldsaythattherestillare,andalwayswillbe,outlandishworshipactivitiesthatarenothingbutsensualinnatureanddonotbringglorytoGodwithintheirmeetings,itisjustnotas“outthere”asitusedtobe.)
Thisnewupgradeseason,thatisindicatedbyKrisVallotton'srecentmessage,isjustoneinaseriesofattemptstobringlegitimacytoamovementthatIbelievewantstobebelievableandacceptable,notonlytotheirpeerswithinthecharismaticworld,butevenwiderintotheevangelicalworldaswell.Intheend,Ithinktheywanttoimpresstheworldaroundthem.Theybelievetheyalreadyarea“cityonahill”andthattheyaredefeatingthe“religiousspirit”oftheoldwayofdoingChristianity.IfyouwouldliketoseethedocumentationandhistoryofBethelChurch,andotherstheyareconnectedtointheNewApostolicReformation,thereismuchwrittenonthismovementonHerescope'swebsite.Bytheway,inKris'upgradedbooktitledHeavyRain,C.PeterWagner(NewApostolicReformation)givesahardyendorsement.FormoreinformationonWagnersearchHerescopeaswell.
LetmeillustratemypointwithsomequotesfromKris'message,“God,Government,andProsperity.”[2]
OnEarthNowUpgrade#1-BeingMore“Biblical”InhisopeningprayerKrissays,“Godmakeamessageoutofthismess.”Butinmixingtogether“God,GovernmentandProsperity”hebeginsinMatthew28:18whereJesussays,“AllauthorityhasbeengiventoMeinheavenandonearth.”WebelieveitisgiventoChristaloneinthatpassage.ButKrissays,“InHeavenandonearthwouldhavebeena
DISCERNMENT PAGE 3 SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2016
PO BOX 520 – CANTON, TX 75103-0520
revelationtotheHebrews,butnotjustinheaven,ifhehadleftoutonearth.”WhatKrisisimplyingisthatweinourdayhavebeenrestoredtosomekindofdominionovertheearthinaphysicalaspect.WearenowLordsoftheearth,andwemusttakecontrolofit,asifthisiswhyJesuscame—nottodealwithsin,buttorestoreourrulershipoverthisplanet.Theevangelicalchurchhasalwaysarguedthisistobeareality,butonlyduringthemillenniumafterJesusreturns.Kris,however,isadvocatingfor“KingdomNow”typetheology,butitseemskinderandmore“reasonable.”Inrealityitisthesameoldthing.
HethensayssinceweweremadeinGod'simagewearealready“likeGod.”InKris'seyeswewerelittlegods,butthroughourfailureinthegarden,welostourgodlikeness.Hebelieveswelostourauthorityovertheearth,sothatJesushadtogointohellsometimeduringthecrucifixionandtakebackthekeysofauthorityfromthedevil.Krisissayingthatwehavethosekeys,andthatthissomehowmeanswearenottomakedisciplesofthepeopleofthenationsbutwearetomakedisciplesof“thenations”(countries).Thisisanastronomicaljumpinlogic!
ThereisabigdifferenceherefromtheplainteachingoftheNewTestament.Jesussaidclearly,inJohn18:36,“Mykingdomisnotofthisworld.IfMykingdomwereofthisworld,Myservantswouldfight,sothatIshouldnotbedeliveredtotheJews;butnowMykingdomisnotfromhere.”HesaidthisstandinginfrontofPilate.Ifthekingdomwascominginaphysicalform,whydidn'tJesussay,“ButinafewhoursIwilltaketheelevatordowntohellandstealthosepeskykeysfromthedevilandthenyouwillseemydisciplesfightandwin!”Infact,wearenevertoldtofightinafleshlyorcarnalway.IntheGardenofGethsemanePeterwascommandedtoputawayhissword.NowtheonlyweaponwehaveistherevealedWordofGod,theSwordoftheSpirit.Evenwithourselveswedon'tsledgehammerthesinoutofourselveswithwhipsorchainsastheRomansCatholicsareobligedtodo.Wetakeeverythoughtcaptivewithtruth,makingitobeyChristwiththespiritualpowerandtrueauthoritywehave,basedontheWordandthefaithoncedeliveredtous,thesaints.Ourspiritualblessinginheavenisours,butthatleavesoffmanyphysicalblessingsthatwillbeoursinthekingdomtocome.
Krislovestospinthisoldideaofusbeinglittlegods,andthatbeingrestoredtodominionthroughthekeysorthetabernacleofDavidequalsusbeingrestoredtodominioninsomemysticalkindofway.Andthen,asaresultofbeingrestored,havingapowerministryaswespeakphysicalrealitiesintoexistence—allthewhilecallingthismethodology“faith”and“power.”Theycallanyonewhodoesnotgoalongwithitallan“anotherGospel”proponent.(Infact,BillJohnsonhasmadethesameallegationaboutallwhodon'tmajorinmiraclesandso-calledpowerevangelism.)
Krismakesanupgradeclaimrightawayinhistalk.HesaysthattheMuslimsarerunningfivenationsandChristiansaretakingdominionoverzeronations.AllofmyChristianfriendsandcolleaguesdeplorewhatISISiscurrentlydoing.Butwelookatthesituationfromatotallydifferentperspective.Jesussaidthattheworldwouldhateus.Infact,Hesaysthatevilmenwouldwaxworseandworse,uptotheverypointwhenHereturns.Thosethat“disciple”nationsareboundtofail.YetKrisdemands(andisnotbelowusingshamemanipulation)thatwecapturenationsandgovernmentsforGod,andthatifwedon'twearefailuresandGod'shandsaretied.
BrothersandsistersinChrist,thisisblasphemy!ThoughIfullybelieveinman'sfreewillandresponsibilityforhisactions,IbelievethatGod,too,hasaplanandisexecutingandusingourfreechoicestobringoutHisglory-filledendtotheexistenceofthisplanetanditsinhabitants.Weplayapart,butthatwillneverchangeGod'sultimateplantobringaboutthecompletionofHispropheticWord.
BethelChurchhasanoutwardformofpower.Theytalkaboutpower,writeaboutpowerandblogaboutitallday.Theirmeetingsare“powerful”intherealmofmusicandlighting,dramaandartisticcreativity.Allthesethingsareoutwardforms.Thisistherootmeaningbehindtheexactdescriptionoftheendtimesapostatechurchmovementdescribedin2Timothy3.Afterdescribingperiloustimeswherethecultureisindeepbondagetosin,andisdescribedasloversofthemselves(Krislovestosayabouthisownpreaching,“Thatisareallygoodword”),loversofmoney(Bethelisamoneymachine,asaremostconnectedministriesandchurchesintheirsphere),boasters,proud,blasphemers,etc.,theagingapostlePaulsaysinverse5,“havingaformofgodliness,butdenyingitspower.”Truegodlinesshasaspiritualpowerthatdefeatssinandbringsaboutholiness,sincerity,humility,andanabilitytopowerfullyproclaimtheGospelinwordanddeed.Aholylifeisapowerfullife,notalifethattwiststhepromisesofGodmeantforafuturetimeandholdsthechurchhostagewithacarrotofconstantlychangingnewthings,paradigms,methodologies,andnewsignsandwonders.
BethelissayingthesamethingstheyandothershavebeensayingsincetheLatterRainmovementwashatchedin1949,whichwassoundlyrefutedbyleadersoftheAssembliesofGodwhofoundittobespuriousandextra-biblicalinnature.No“wonder”thatBethelChurchbrokeawayfromtheAOGtenyearsagolastJanuary.Theywantednorealoversight.KrisVallottonisspeakingthesamemessagethatotherfalseteachershavebeenspeakingforatleast68years.Itisnuancednowandmadetosoundmore“biblical.”HequotesfromRomans4:17,saying,“AbrahamisnotthefatherofIsrael,butthefatherofnations.”Hesaysthismeanswearetobefatheringnations—thatifthechurchdoesnotfather,leadorcommandeer(Isuppose)
DISCERNMENT PAGE 4 SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2016
PO BOX 520 – CANTON, TX 75103-0520
thenations,wearenotfollowinginFatherAbe'ssteps,ashebelievestheNewTestamentteaches.(TheNewTestamentdoesnot,ofcourse,teachthis.)Missingthewholepointofthereality,thebeautyandthemajestyoftherevelationinRomansaboutthewonderofoursalvationandtherighteousnessimputedtousbyfaith,seeninitsrootformallthewaybacktoAbraham—havingmissedallthattruthforasillyandobtusevisionofamightyJoel'sarmynowtakingdominionby“fathering”nations,Krisdevolvesintoerror.Butheisattemptingan“upgrade”here.HeisattemptingtobeseenasmoreBiblicalsohecandragunsuspectingdenominationsandindividualchurchesandpreciouspeopleofGod,alongwithweak-willed,unskilledandstrugglingChristiansintohiscampoferror.UsingKris'perspectives,youwillnevercometoaknowledgeofthetruthbecauseyouarebeingtrickedbya“formofgodliness”thathasnopower.(See2Timothy3:5-9please!)
IrememberthefirsttimeIopenedabookbyaBethelleader,titledWhenHeavenInvadesEarthbyBillJohnson.Irememberthetremendousemphasis,notontheWordofGod,butonwordoffaith,onsignsandwondersandso-calledpowerministry.Now,itseems,theyarecounteringcriticismfortheirneglectoftheteachingofGod'sWordintheirchurch,andaretryingtogainacceptancebyquotingmoreversesofthesameBiblethattheyhaveseriouslydissedforyears.IhavebeentotheirmeetingsandseenfirsthandthatmostattendeesdonotevencarryaBiblewiththembecausetheydon'tneeditveryoften.Usuallythey“worship”foranhourorso.ThensomeonecomesandstartswiththeBible,andthenitistimetosharethe“newthingGodisdoing,”whichincludestestimoniesofso-called
miraclesandsignsandwonders.
IbelieveinthepresentworkoftheHolySpiritintheearth.Ibelieveinmiraclesandhaveexperiencedthem.IbelievesomehaveagiftoffaithandIhavewitnesseditbeingusedforthegloryofGod.ButIbelievethatanythingwehaveorknowcanbeturnedintoanidolor,attheleast,anobsession.Bethelobsesses
overmiracles.BillJohnsonforyearshasmodeledthisemphasis.Itisthemodusoperandiofhischurch.KrisVallottonandalltheotherleadersofthemovementhavetofallinlineortheyareout.NothinghaschangedatBethelbuttheyaretalkingslightlydifferentnow....tryingtheirbesttoputaBiblicalstampofapprovalontheirtiredtheoriesand“new”ideas,manyofwhichhavemoreroots
intheNewAgemovementthanintheGospelofJesus.Iknowthesearetoughwords.Theyarenotmeanttobe
toughbuttowakeupsome.OneoftheproblemswithBethelsayingthesamethingoverandoverandoveristhatpeoplegetusedtoit,andareworndown,andthenbegintoacceptit.ManyhaveinRedding—thenumbersdon'tlie—Bethelisgettingbiggerandtheirinfluenceisgrowingthroughouttheworld.Iamconcernedandmustwarntheflocktobeware.Donotlistentostrung-togetherversespulledoutoftheirproperinterpretationbythosewhodon'tcareifitisproperlypreached,butcaremorethattheiragendaisaccomplished.Don'tbemadecaptivetofalseteaching,nomatterhownormalitmaysound,bythosewhouseflatteryorsophisticatedbehavioraltechniquestodelivertheirmessage.
KrisVallottonsaysthatwearechildrenofAbrahamsothatallthepromisesgiventohimareours.Isthattrueinaphysicalsense?DoeseveryonewhocomestoChristbyfaithhaveababyofpromise?GodtoldAbrahamhewouldhaveason,butnoteveryonehasababy,andsomehaveonlygirls.Iknowthatsoundssilly,butisitsilliertomakesuchablanketstatementlikeKrisdoesateveryturninhismessage?Abrahamwasarichman.IseveryChristianblessedinthatway?Itsoundsgoodtothosewhoareanxiouslywantingphysicalblessingtobepouredoutontheirfailingbusiness,ortheiremptynursery,butitisfalseonitsface.Itisnotgooddoctrinalteachingthataccordsgodliness.Iamremindedofthistimelesstruthfrom1Timothy6:3-6:
“Ifanyoneteachesotherwiseanddoesnotconsenttowholesomewords,eventhewordsofourLordJesusChrist,and
tothedoctrinewhichaccordswithgodliness,heisproud,knowingnothing,butisobsessedwithdisputesandarguments
overwords,fromwhichcomeenvy,strife,reviling,evilsuspicions,uselesswranglingsofmenofcorruptmindsanddestituteofthetruth,whosupposethatgodlinessisameansofgain.Fromsuchwithdrawyourself.Nowgodlinesswith
contentmentisgreatgain.”
YearsagoBillJohnsonwasnotcontentwithhisfaith.HehadbeentoJohnWimber'splaceandsawsomemiraclesandrealizedallhehadwas“doctrine.”Hespentthenextseveralyearstryingtofindthepower.HeendedupatTorontoand“foundit.”Itsplithischurchintwoaspeoplebeganbarking,howlingandcrawlingonthefloor,andcallingitworship.Buthesaysitwasworthit.Idon'tthinkitwas.Ithinkitpossiblyshipwreckedhisfaith.Itcertainlyhasdonethatformany.Ihavepersonallywatchedmanyyoungpeoplebeinthismovementforafewyearsbutcomeoutsodisgusted,andsoletdown,andsoconfusedthattheygiveupandfallheadlongintotheworld.Ithasaffectedsomewhoareveryclosetomelikethat.ItisbecauseofthisthatIcryoutfordiscernmentintheselastdays.Iamnottheonlyone.Thereareafewothers,andthoughitisnot
DISCERNMENT PAGE 5 SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2016
PO BOX 520 – CANTON, TX 75103-0520
“costeffective”tospeakout,wemust.Somethinkwearejustmeanoroldorjealous.Thoseareunjustcharges.TheOldTestamentprophetshadsimilaropposition.Theyweretoldtoprophesy“smooththings,”buttheycouldnotbecauseGodhadnottoldthemto.Theyhadtosaythetruth.Itwasafireinthemthatboiledwithholyzeal.Thatsoundsexciting,butitisindeedaheavyburdentobear.God'sWordisbeingtamperedwith.Itisbeingusedtosaythingsitwasnevermeanttosay.Farfrombeingmorebiblical,thoughtheymayappearsototheirfollowing,BethelchurchcontinuestomoveawayfromtheBible.
InthemessagebyKrisVallotton,headmitsopenlythathedoesn'tlikethebookofLeviticus.Allthekillingsbotherhim.YetitisthedeathoftheLambofGodthatispointedtointhatbook.EverylambpointstoJesusandtheatonementforsin.ButthatisnotthepointofBethel.TheGospelofthepreciousbloodofJesusisnotthefocusoftheiroutreachesortheirexpansionsoroftheirschool.Theycallitrevival,butcanthereeverbetruerevivalwithoutconfession?IsredemptionpossiblewithoutteachingChrist’sbloodbeingspilled?No.Itisawasteoftime.AbiblicalchurchteachesthewholecounselofGod.BillJohnsonrefusestoanswerquestionsthatcomefromthebookofJob,asthoughsicknessisnotarealityinafallenworld,becauseheteachesitisalwaysGod'splantohealeverything.Thisisnotabiblicalchurchatall.God'sWorddealswithalloflife,andalloftheaffectsofsin,andstillpointsustoJesuswhodiedforusaviolentdeathsowemayhavelifeeternal.Therewillbeadaywhenallwillbemaderightbutitisnotthisday.
TheBoldEschatology-Upgrade#2KrisVallottonhasbeensayingforsometimethatherefusestoacceptaneschatologythatsaysthingshavetogetworseinorderforJesustoreturn.ToKris'credithelovesthestoryofJoseph.ButwhathelikessomuchisthatJoseph“profitedPotiphar'shouse.”“Ifyouputaprinceinaprisonitwillbecomeapalace,”hesays.Hethengoesontodreamsanddeclares,“Pharaohisdreamingagain.”HesaysJosephknewhowtointerpretdreamsbecause“Josephwasraisedinadreamingfamily,havingbeentaughtthe
supernaturalwaysofGod.”Thenhesaysagain,“Pharaohisdreamingagainandtheworldisdreamingagain.”Godisnotlifted
up,butthedreameris.Hesaysthatthelightisturnedoninaroom,butwedon'tcomeintheroomtolookatthelight,butyoucomeinto“see.”Friends,theLightiswhatwearetolookat.JesusistheLightoftheworld.Krisisteachingthatself-realizationisthegoal.Seeingwhatisaroundusisthemostimportantthingtohim—sowecan“see”thedreams.Hesays,“Ifwedon'tdreamthentheworlddies.”Inhiseschatology,then,itisalldependentonus.Wewillsavetheworldifwedream.YoumusthangwiththedreamershereatBethel,heisimplying.
HethenmovestothepropheciesofJesusbeingkinginIsaiah9.Thisiswherehebuildshis“eschatologynow”doctrine.HeripspartialversesfromthecontextoftheBibleanddeclaresthatGod'sgovernmentisonearthnow,inourtime.HealsodeclaresthatGodisnot“ashamedofhumanity”because“Hisshoulders”areus.Secondly,hesaysthatthegovernmentnowisincreasingandwemustadvocateforthisincrease.YoumightthinkhemeanstoadvocateforaspiritualincreaseofGod'skingdom.But,thereisabaitandswitchcoming.HeleapsfromGodrulinginHispeopletotalkingaboutgovernmentthat“actualizesyourpersonhood.”Thissoundsliketheliberalpoliticiansandpsychologiststoday,asthoughthegovernmentisresponsibleformakingusfullydevelopedpeople.ThatisnotwhatIsaiahteachesatall.ThatisnotevengoodAmericantalk.HeisemphasizingaNewAgeidea,rightinthemiddleofapreciouspartofGod'sWord.Hehasnotstudiedprophecyapparently.HedoesnotrealizethatGoddoesthingsindifferentperiodsoftime.Therearetwocomings,notjustone,Kris.Maybethatiswhy,inanotherbookoftheBiblethathedoesnotlike,hehasnottakenthistoheart:Ecclesiastes3:1-3says:
“Toeverythingthereisaseason,Atimeforeverypurposeunderheaven:Atimetobeborn,Andatimetodie;Atimetoplant,Andatimetopluckwhatisplanted;Atimetokill,Andatimetoheal”
FromhereKriscontinuesto“build”aneschatologywherehesimplyjustifiesthegovernmentaltakeover,albeitinanaltruisticsense,ofthe“spheres”ofthesociety(i.e.,dominion),bypeopleandmovementsandchurcheslikehimself.HiscaseinpointisthatBethelisrunningtheCivicAuditoriuminRedding.[3]Thissoundslikeitisjustthebeginningofmany“goodthings”tocome.“Greatgovernmentempowersyou,”hesays,asthoughanempoweredunsavedpersonisstillagoodthing.HethenpointstoKoreaasagreatillustrationofwhygovernmentistheanswer.Itisafalseargumentbecauseheholdsupdemocracyinthesouthassomekindofanendgameforthe
DISCERNMENT PAGE 6 SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2016
PO BOX 520 – CANTON, TX 75103-0520
church'smission.Theonlydifferenceis“government”hesays.Butmoregovernmentiswhathasdoomedthenorth,notless.IfSouthKoreaisbetteritisbecauseof“less”government,aswehaveprovedinourowncountry.Buthesays,“Governmentispowerfulandmeaningful.”
VallottonthengoesontotwisthisdominiontheologyintoamisplacedunderstandingofIsaiah61,goingbeyondwhatJesusreadasHebeganHisministrythereinNazareth.JesusstoppedreadingatexactlythepointwhereHeintendedtobecausetherestisforalatertime.ReadLuke4:18-20whereJesusclosedthebookexactlywhereitneededtobeclosedfornow.InKris'eschatology,thereisnoneedforheavenbecausethroughChristianstakingdominionoverthe“spheres”ofsocietywecanbringitdownnow.Lookattheirwebsite,www.ibethel.org.“YourKingdomcomeonearthasitisinheaven”istheirmotto.WhattheymeanisfortheKingdomtocomenow,exactlyinallofitsfulfillment,NOW!ItisnotaccordingtothetimingthatGodhassetforth,butaccordingtoBethel'sunderstanding—ALLFORNOW!
IsthisaplacewewanttosendourchildrenorgrandchildreninordertolearnthesupernaturalwaysofGod?No,thisisnatural,fleshly,andismancentered.[4]Krissays,“Idon'tknowwhatyoureschatologysays,butminesaysthat‘Godcaresaboutcities.’”DoesHe?Doesn'tHecareaboutindividualpeopleinthecities?Isn'titbettertobeaccuratewhenwemakeblanketstatements?DoesGodcareaboutsidewalksorpathspeopletaketoclassattheShastaCollege,likeKrisdeclaresinhisillustrationabouthowweshouldbesmartaswegoverneverypartofoursociety?Thisispragmatismand“kingdomnow”theologymarriedtogether!Itissillytalk.
ThereisnoGospelhereexceptthegospelofman.“Yourjobwhenyougetwellistohelpeveryoneelsegetwell,”Krisconfidentlyasserts.Thequestionis,“Well,fromwhat?”IfheweretalkingaboutgettingwellfromsinthroughtheshedbloodofthecrossofChrist,Iwouldbeallinforthat.Butheistalkingabouttheillsofsociety,andthatisjustnotdeepenoughtobecalledBible!Thatdoesnotgofarenough.Thatisonlyscrapingthesurfaceanddoesnothingforthesoulofmantobetrulywell.Thereisnocureforsocietyinthisage,butthereisacureforsinfoundonlyinthefinishedworkofChristatCalvarywhereHewillinglypouredoutHispreciousbloodforatonementforsin.GodisangrywithmanandhissinbutHeplacedthatwrathonJesusforoursakes.Butifwedon’treceivethatgiftweareundercondemnation.ThatisthesimpleGospel.Itisagoodnewsoflove,butitcostourSaviorHisverylifeasforetoldbyallthosesacrificesofold,inLeviticus.
1Timothy4isanexplicitwarningforourtimes.ItisopposedtothecozypicturethatBethelChurchpreachesthatiscouchedinhopeoftheir“kingdomnow”typeeschatology.Imustendsharethiswarninginhopesthat
somecaughtinthismovementwillhearitswords:
NowtheSpiritexpresslysaysthatinlattertimessomewilldepartfromthefaith,givingheedtodeceivingspiritsand
doctrinesofdemons,2speakingliesinhypocrisy,havingtheirownconsciencesearedwithahotiron.(1Timothy4:1-2)
Yearsagoafriendofminedevelopedthroatcancer.Hehadafamilyandawifeandwasintheprimeofhislife.Helovedtoservethechurchweattendedbydoingpracticalhelpforanyonewhowasinneed.Ifacarneededrepair,hewouldfindawaytofixit.Ifsomeoneneededaride,heprovidedit.HelovedtheLordandyethegotverysick.Ourchurchatthattimedeclaredthathewouldrecover—thatGodhadtoldthemhewouldbeatthecancer.Itdidnothappenthatway.Myfrienddiedfromthecancer,anagonizingdeathwitnessedbyhiskidsandwifeandbyallofus.Afewmonthsafterwardsweweretalkingwithsomefriendswhohappenedtoalsobeonthechurchstaff.Theytoldusthatmyfriendhadgivenupthebattleandhislackoffaithwasthereasonhedied.Thosewordsburnedinme.Theydisgustedme.Theymalignedmyfriend’smemoryandcharacter.Thechurchhadlied.
Likewise,Bethelislyingtodaywhenitsaysthesametypesofthings.Ifyoulookcloselyattheleadershipthere,theyarelivingalie.Theyarelivingalieinhypocrisybecausetheircurrentpastorneedsglassesandthesonofthepastorisstilldeaf.Sowhosefaultisthisintheirschemeofthings?PeopleinReddingandatBethelgetcancerandstillgetsick,soistheproblemwithGodorwiththeirfaith…orwithBethel’sdefectiveteaching?
In2016KrisVallottonrewroteabookfrom2010
becausehesaiditwasnowmorerelevantthanever.Inthisbookhetalksextensivelyabouthowthechurchhasfailedattransformingsociety,andhowhischurchhasbeguntosucceedatit.IwanttoconcludethisexposėofBethelChurch’s“upgrade”withadirectquotefromKris’bookandascreenshot(above)fromtheirwebsite.(Noticetheadvertisementforbeer!)UpcomingeventsattheReddingCivicAuditoriumarereferencedinthequotebelow.My
DISCERNMENT PAGE 7 SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2016
PO BOX 520 – CANTON, TX 75103-0520
questionforthereadertoaskisthis:whatdoesanyofthishavetodowiththeGospelmandatethatJesussoclearlygaveinMatthew28?Isthisthe“new”goalofChristianity?Whatgovernmentroleshouldthechurch“takeover”next?Whatfurthercompromisesincontentandmarketingwillthechurchmakeinordertowinthepraiseofthepublicandgovernmentofficials?
HereisthequotefromVallotton’sbook:
“WewantedtoruntheReddingConventionCenterthesamewayourstudentsbeautifiedourcity.Ourgoalwastomakeitanexcellentexperienceforeveryonewhocameintothebuilding.Wespent$500,000remodelingthebuildingandinstallingastate-of-the-artticketsystem.Wereplacedalltheseats,installedanewsoundsystemandremodeledtheentireinteriorofthebuilding.Wehiredanalmostentirelynewstaff,employingonlyfriendlypeoplewhohadaheartforexcellence.Ittookustwolongyearstolearntheentertainmentbusiness,butwewerepassionateaboutgettingitright.Atfirstwelostmoneyonmanyoftheshows.Tomakemattersworse,inourzealtomakesurethevenuestayedsecularandnot“Christian,”webookedsomeactsthatwerepurefilth...actuallynearlyporn.Attimesthingsweretough,butweknewwehadtoclimbordie.Forthefirsttwoyears,thecommunity(ledbythemedia)scrutinizedeverythingwedidandcutusnoslack.Butastimewenton,theirfearofa‘religioustakeover’evaporatedinlightoftheobviouslyimprovedexperienceourcommunitywashavingintheconventioncenter.Wewerehostingasmanyshowsandeventsasever,whilestillmeetingtheneedsofourschoolthere.Inourthirdyearofmanagingthebuilding,wefinallybegantowinthepraiseofourcommunity.Infact,manyofthepeoplewhohadprotestedagainstusthatnightatthecitycouncilmeetingcamebackandapologizedtoourteam.Andourcitymanagerandhisteamhavesincesaidopenly,‘Thisisthebesttheconventioncenterhasbeenrunin43years!’”
Whereisthetruthinallofthis?ItisfoundinGod'sWord.ItisfoundinthetrueGodoftheBibleandnotingodwemakeaccordingtoourowndreamsanddesires.It'sfoundintheOnewhohasgivenusHisSpiritthroughthenewbirthinChrist,whowillleadusintoalltruth.Itisfoundinchurchesthat,thoughtheymaybesmallandarecertainlynotperfect,arepreachingandlivingthewholecounselofGodinhumilityandbyHispower.ItisfoundintheholylivesofthepeopleofGodwhoseeknotthegloryofanearthlykingdombutwhoarewaitingforthisone:
Butnowtheydesireabetter,thatis,aheavenlycountry.ThereforeGodisnotashamedtobecalledtheirGod,forHe
haspreparedacityforthem.(Hebrews11:16)
MuchmorecanbesaidaboutthismovementthatisBethelChurch.Thoughitisconstantlyupgradingitsmessagetobringmoreandmorepeopleandchurchesinto
itsorbit,pleasebewareofthedangersinitsteaching.The“upgrade”isreallyadowngrade—asophisticatedandwell-marketedploytorepackagetheoldLatterRainheresyofthe1940sthathasrootsdeepinthedarknessoftheoldGnosticsthatwereplaguingthechurchatthetimetheNewTestamentwasbeingwritten.CertainlythepreacherofEcclesiasteswasright:“thereisnothingnewunderthesun.”
DonotletanyoneleadyouastraytoanythinglessthantheglorioustruthsfoundinGod'sWord,evenifitsoundsinnovativeandrelevant,andhasreallygoodmusichighupontheiTunescharts(Bethel’srockgroupJesusCulture).KeepyoureyesonJesus,theauthorandfinisherofourfaith!Keeplookingupforyourredemptiondrawsnigh!Beware,beware,bewareanddon’tsettleforanythingless!
BlessedbetheGodandFatherofourLordJesusChrist,whoaccordingtoHisabundantmercyhasbegottenusagaintoalivinghopethroughtheresurrectionofJesusChristfromthedead,toaninheritanceincorruptibleandundefiledandthatdoesnotfadeaway,reservedinheavenforyou,whoarekeptbythepowerofGodthroughfaithforsalvationreadytobe
revealedinthelasttime(1Peter1:3-5)
THEKINGDOMDOMINION(physically)WILLBELONGTOTHELORDatHisgloriousreturn!
Iwaswatchinginthenightvisions,Andbehold,OneliketheSonofMan,Comingwiththecloudsofheaven!HecametotheAncientofDays,
AndtheybroughtHimnearbeforeHim.ThentoHimwasgivendominionandgloryandakingdom,Thatallpeoples,nations,andlanguagesshouldserveHim.
Hisdominionisaneverlastingdominion,Whichshallnotpassaway,AndHiskingdomtheone
Whichshallnotbedestroyed.(Daniel7:13-14)
Thentheseventhangelsounded:Andtherewereloudvoicesinheaven,saying,“ThekingdomsofthisworldhavebecomethekingdomsofourLordandofHisChrist,andHeshallreign
foreverandever!”(Rev.11:15)
Endnotes:1. Vallotton,Kris,(2016-08-02),HeavyRain:HowtoFloodYourWorldwithGod'sTransformingPower,publishedbyChosenBooks-FromtheIntroductionoftheKindleEdition.Emphasisadded.2. Link is https://itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/bethel-church-sermon-week/id76583739?mt=2&i=374737430)3. ScreenshotofConventionCenterarticlephotoisfrom:http://www.redding.com/news/bethel-church-will-run-redding-convention-centerep-375592385-354729071.html4. HerescopearticlesaboutBethel,JesusCulture,itsyouthmovement,anditspopularityinevangelicaldomincludehttp://herescope.blogspot.com/2013/01/the-significance-of-youth-filled.html.Alsosee:theassociatedarticleat:http://apprising.org/2013/01/02/louie-giglio-passion-2013-and-jesus-culture/andthe6partseriesthatbeginshere:http://herescope.blogspot.com/2014/01/the-passion-of-presence.html
