Digital Media Scholarship: Innovation or Insanity?

32
Digital Media Scholarship: Innovation or Insanity?

description

Presented by Dr. Cheryl E. Ball at the 2011 Modern Language Association, this presentation explains why digital media scholarship needs its own kind of content-management system and what one journal, Kairos, is doing to fix that.

Transcript of Digital Media Scholarship: Innovation or Insanity?

Page 1: Digital Media Scholarship: Innovation or Insanity?

Digital Media Scholarship:

Innovation or Insanity?

Page 2: Digital Media Scholarship: Innovation or Insanity?

Two Kinds of Scholarship

Page 3: Digital Media Scholarship: Innovation or Insanity?

Two Kinds of Scholarship

Page 4: Digital Media Scholarship: Innovation or Insanity?
Page 5: Digital Media Scholarship: Innovation or Insanity?

Kairos Peer-Review Process

Page 6: Digital Media Scholarship: Innovation or Insanity?

Collaboratively Reviewing Aesthetics

Page 7: Digital Media Scholarship: Innovation or Insanity?

Collaboratively Reviewing Aesthetics

Page 8: Digital Media Scholarship: Innovation or Insanity?

Collaboratively Reviewing Aesthetics

Page 9: Digital Media Scholarship: Innovation or Insanity?

Collaboratively Reviewing Aesthetics

Page 10: Digital Media Scholarship: Innovation or Insanity?

Snippet of Collaborative Review

Page 11: Digital Media Scholarship: Innovation or Insanity?

A Quick Review…

Page 12: Digital Media Scholarship: Innovation or Insanity?

A Quick Review…

Page 13: Digital Media Scholarship: Innovation or Insanity?

Head Count

Print Article• 1 word document• 2-3 figures (maybe)

Webtext (typical)• 20 image files in a folder• 15 HTML files (grouped by

folder)• 2 CSS files• 1 PDF• 1 video file• > 1 audio file

Page 14: Digital Media Scholarship: Innovation or Insanity?

History of Kairos

Map courtesy of Jeremy Tirrell’s Mapping Digital Technology in Rhet/Comp History

Page 15: Digital Media Scholarship: Innovation or Insanity?

Kairos design, circa 1996

Page 16: Digital Media Scholarship: Innovation or Insanity?

Kairos webtext, circa 1996

Page 17: Digital Media Scholarship: Innovation or Insanity?

Kairos webtext, circa 1996

Page 18: Digital Media Scholarship: Innovation or Insanity?

Kairos webtext, circa 1996

Page 19: Digital Media Scholarship: Innovation or Insanity?

Original Kairos Staff

Page 20: Digital Media Scholarship: Innovation or Insanity?

Kairos redesign, circa 1999

Page 21: Digital Media Scholarship: Innovation or Insanity?

Kairos redesign, circa 2008

Page 22: Digital Media Scholarship: Innovation or Insanity?

Open Journal Systems?

Features 1. OJS is installed locally and locally controlled. 2. Editors configure requirements, sections, review process. 3. Online submission and management of all content. 4. Subscription module with delayed open access options. 5. Comprehensive indexing of content part of global system. 6. Reading Tools for content, based on field and editors' choice. 7. Email notification and commenting ability for readers. 8. Complete context-sensitive online Help support.

http://pkp.sfu.ca/?q=ojs

Page 23: Digital Media Scholarship: Innovation or Insanity?

Open Journal System (Examples)

Page 24: Digital Media Scholarship: Innovation or Insanity?

Open Journal System (Examples)

Page 25: Digital Media Scholarship: Innovation or Insanity?

Open Journal System (Examples)

Page 26: Digital Media Scholarship: Innovation or Insanity?

Open Journal System (Examples)

Page 27: Digital Media Scholarship: Innovation or Insanity?

Open Journal System (Examples)

Page 28: Digital Media Scholarship: Innovation or Insanity?

Kairos redesign, circa 2008

Page 29: Digital Media Scholarship: Innovation or Insanity?

No Money In, No Money Out?

• free• no ads

• no affiliations

Page 30: Digital Media Scholarship: Innovation or Insanity?

No Money In, No Money Out?

Kairos + OJS + NEH = FTW!

Page 31: Digital Media Scholarship: Innovation or Insanity?

Kairos Plug-ins for OJS

Reviewer & Editor Features• synchronous and visual

review of webtexts• voting & gaming options for

reviewers• sticky notes for writing

directly on interface• moving all files together• archiving all versions• DOIs on all media elements• Compatibility with Zotero

Reader Features (Phase Two?)• Citation tools for media

elements• Robust search/index for

webtexts and media elements

• Remix & post capabilities• Creation of own journal

“issues” (for syllabi, research, etc.)

Page 32: Digital Media Scholarship: Innovation or Insanity?

Project Affiliates

Dr. Kathie GossettAssociate Editor of KairosOld Dominion University

Dr. Douglas EymanSenior Editor of KairosGeorge Mason University

Stephen PottsPHP Programmer ExtraordinaireNorfolk, VA

Dr. Cheryl E. Ball, PIEditor of KairosIllinois State [email protected]

http://kairos.technorhetoric.net