DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG...

57
DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG ONLINE & ON-SITE Free and Hanseatic City of Hamburg Ministry of Urban Development and HousingDepartment of Urban and Regional Planning Claudius Lieven | Leiter der Stadtwerkstatt 19.06.2019

Transcript of DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG...

Page 1: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATIONIN HAMBURG

ONLINE & ON-SITE

Free and Hanseatic City of Hamburg

Ministry of Urban Development and

HousingDepartment of Urban and

Regional Planning

Claudius Lieven | Leiter der Stadtwerkstatt

19.06.2019

Page 2: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

1THE URBAN WORKSHOP

Page 3: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

Organizes information and participation on city-wide

topics ("Stadtwerkstätten").

Advises and supports BSW project groups, ministries,

districts and public agencies in participation procedures.

DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG

THE STADTWERKSTATT

(URBAN WORKSHOP)

Is a staff-unit in the Ministry of Urban Development and

Housing (BSW) of Hamburg.

Develops new methods and instruments for citizen participation.

Carries out R&D projects: DIPAS (FHH) Civitas Digitalis (BMBF)….

Page 4: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG

The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to:

intensify citizen participation on projects and topics around urban

development and housing, infrastructure and enviromnent,

develop new methods for digital participation,

seek to design more inclusive participation processes.

As a result since 2015 more then 100 participation processes have taken

place, organised by ministries, districts, public agencies and public

companies.

Meanwhile, what was an exeption ten years ago, has become the regular

practice in urban, mobility and environmental planning.

CITIZEN PARTIZIPATION IN HAMBURG

Page 5: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

INFORMATION AND CONSULTATION:

DIALOGUE WORKSHOPSDIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG

Quelle: BSW

Page 6: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

INVOLVEMENT: PLANNING WORKSHOPSDIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG

Quelle: BSW

Page 7: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

3 Online Participation

4 Planning Workshops

5 Recommendations

2 Outreaching Participation

Part

icip

ation

Pro

cess

1 Kick-Off Event

GOOD PRACTICE Hand over to district

authorities et al.

DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG

Page 8: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

2ONLINE CITIZEN

PARTICIPATION

Page 9: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

ANALOGUE COLLECTION OF IDEAS

DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURGQuelle: BSW

Page 10: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

ONLINE & OFFLINE PARTICIPATION

Problem: Media gap

Using Digital Tools in Participation Processes

Page 11: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

3

6

1

DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG

DIGITAL COLLECTION OF IDEAS

Page 12: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

Magistrale Nord Wohnen am Volkspark Ohlsdorf 2050

Spreehafenviertel Eimsbüttel 2040 Oberbillwerder

DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG

DIGITAL COLLECTION OF IDEAS

Page 13: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

2016 - 2019

35 Online Participation Processes

>500.000 Page views

13.500 Contributions

1.600 Comments

5.000 Survey Participants

DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG

Page 14: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

TOPICS

Participation Processes

Urban Planning Mobility Environment & Green

Climate/Energy Other

15

13

42

1

DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG

Page 15: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

SCALEDIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG

Participation Processes

Regional City wide District wide Quarter Plot

11

7

3

4

8

Page 16: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

INITIATORSDIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG

Participation Processes

Line Ministry District Authority Public Company

16

13

7

Page 17: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

DISTRIBUTION OVER HAMBURG

Elbinselquartier

Ohlsdorf 2050

Deine Geest

Oberbillwerder

MySmartLife

Eimsbüttel 2040

HolstenkampMagistrale Nord

StadtRad

Stadtklima Altona

Klimafreundliches

Lokstedt

Elbchaussee

Diebsteich

Lärmaktionsplan 2018

Grasbrook

Clever Cities

Bahndamm

Sternschanze

Entwicklungskonzept

Bergedorf

Radschnellwege

U Farmsen

Fußverkehr

Neustadt

Klein Borstel

Spreehafenviertel

Große Heide

Citywide topics:

DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG

Page 18: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

DATA EVALUATION

DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG

Page 19: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

DATA EVALUATION

DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG

Page 20: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

PARTICIPANTS

568494

71

8 5

20 - 34 Jahre 35 - 49 Jahre 50 - 64 Jahre < 20 Jahre > 65 Jahre

180

104

93

20

2

30-49 Jahre 18-29 Jahre 50-65 Jahre > 65 Jahre < 18 Jahre

Bahndamm

Sternschanze (2018)Grasbrook (2018/19)

DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG

Page 21: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

3DIPAS

DIGITAL PARTICIPATION

SYSTEMCURRENT DEVELOPMENT STAGE

Page 22: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

DIPAS | ELEMENTS

Open GeodataOnline-Participation Digital On-Site Tools

Quelle: BSWDIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG

Page 23: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

FINDING PLACES | CSL CITY-SCOPE

DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG

Page 24: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

DIPAS WORKSHOP SETTING

DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG

Page 25: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

Seite 26

DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG

DIPAS | TOUCH TABLE

Page 26: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

Selection and crossfading of

various background maps

DIPAS | TOUCH TABLE

DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG

Page 27: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

Display of multiple

data layers

DIPAS | TOUCH TABLE

DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG

Page 28: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

Integration of plan

graphics

DIPAS | TOUCH TABLE

DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG

Page 29: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

DIPAS | TOUCH TABLE

Retrieval of

database

information

DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG

Page 30: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

Retrieval of citizen

contributions

DIPAS | TOUCH TABLE

DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG

Page 31: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

3D View

(rotate, scale, tilt)

DIPAS | TOUCH TABLE

DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG

Page 32: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG

Adjustable

shadow

Page 33: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

04PARTICIPATION PROCESS

GRASBROOK

Page 34: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

PARTICIPATION PROCESS GRASBROOK

DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG

Page 35: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

PARTICIPATION PROCESS GRASBROOK

DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG

Page 36: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

Digitale Partizipation

PARTICIPATION PROCESS GRASBROOK

Page 37: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

Seite 39

KICK OFF FOR THE GRASBROOK

DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG

Page 38: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

Platzhalter für den Präsentationstitel

Seite 40

INFO BOX @ 250 YEARS VEDDEL FAIR

Page 39: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

PARTICIPATION PROCESS GRASBROOK

DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG

Page 40: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

INFO & WORKSHOP EVENTS

DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG

Page 41: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

PARTICIPATION PROCESS GRASBROOK

DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG

Page 42: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

COLLECTION

OF CITIZENS

INPUT

DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG

Page 43: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

RESULTS OF THE PARTICIPATION

PROCESS (at a glance)

Visions and values

- Island of Opportunities –

newly networked

- Heterogeneous mixture

- Living neighborhoods

- Transformation - Activate and

use stock

- Open spaces and access to

the water

- Local circuits and self-

sufficiency

- Strong mobility

- Cooperative development

General test orders

- Common offers for

Grasbrook and Veddel

- Diversity in urban

planning

- Free spaces as a multi-

talents

- Designing car-free

quarters

- Development in stages

- Climate adaptation -

embedding the flood

protection

Test orders located

- Crossing Grasbrook Veddel

- Reuse of historic warehouse

buildings

- Solutions for noise emissions

- Access to water and water

related uses

- Publicly accessible and

differentiated shore design

- Handling of existing facilities

- Veddel North as a hinge

+ „Idea-pool“

DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG

Page 44: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

GRASBROOK PARTICIPATION- AND

URBAN DESIGN COMPETITION PROCESS

DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG

Page 45: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

GRASBROOK PARTICIPATION,

COMPETITION AND PLANNING PROCESS

DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG

Page 46: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

5DIPAS

DIGITAL PARTICIPATION

SYSTEMPLANNED FURTHER DEVELOPMENTS

Page 47: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

3D CITY MODEL & URBAN DESIGN

DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG

Page 48: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

FEEDBACK ON 3D URBAN DESIGNS

DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG

Page 49: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

DIPAS | WIZARD FOR CONTRIBUTIONS

DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG

Page 50: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG

DIGITAL SUPPORTED PUBLIC DEBATES

Page 51: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

UPCOMING: INTEGRATION

X-PLANUNG

Quelle: BSWDIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG

Page 52: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

<40 dB

>50 dB

>60 dB

Noise Pollution

Quelle: LGV-HH

UPCOMING: URBAN SIMULATIONS

DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG

Page 53: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

BACKEND DATA ANALYSIS

Page 54: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

NLP - NATURAL LANGUAGE PROCESSING

DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG

Page 55: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

Seite 59

AUTOMATED REPORT GENERATION

DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG

Page 56: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

UPCOMING: CITY-COCKPIT

DIGITAL PARTICIPATION

Quelle: BSWDIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG

Page 57: DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG · 2020-01-15 · DIGITAL CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN HAMBURG The government program of the 2015 elected senate expressed the aim to: intensify

THANK YOU

DIGITAL PARTICIPATION

ONLINE & ON-SITE

Free and Hanseatic City of Hamburg

Ministry of Urban Development and Housing

Stadtwerkstatt

FOR YOUR ATTENTION