Developing a stochastic simulation model for the generation of residential water end-use demand time...

22
Developing a stochastic simulation model for the generation of residential water end-use demand time series A. Cominola 1 , M. Giuliani 1 , A. Castelletti 1 , A.M. Abdallah 2 , D.E. Rosenberg 2 1 Dept. Electronics, Information, and Bioengineering - Hydroinformatics Lab, Politecnico di Milano 2 Dept. of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Utah State University

Transcript of Developing a stochastic simulation model for the generation of residential water end-use demand time...

Developing a stochastic simulation model for the generation of residential water end-use demand time series

A. Cominola1, M. Giuliani1, A. Castelletti1, A.M. Abdallah2, D.E. Rosenberg2 1 Dept. Electronics, Information, and Bioengineering - Hydroinformatics Lab, Politecnico di Milano 2 Dept. of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Utah State University

NRM

Urban population is growing

US246.2

Urban population in millions

81%Urban percentage

Mexico84.392

77%

Colombia34.373%

Brazil162.685%

Argentina35.690%

Ukraine30.968%

Russia103.673%

China559.2

Urban population in millions

42%Urban percentage

Turkey51.168%

India329.329%

Bangladesh38.226%

Philippines55.064%

Indonesia114.150%

S Korea39.081%

Japan84.766%

Egypt33.143%

S Africa28.660%

Canada26.3

Venezuela26.0

Poland23.9

Thailand21.5

Australia18.3

Netherlands13.3

Peru21.0

Saudi Arabia20.9

Iraq20.3 Vietnam

23.3

DR Congo20.2

Algeria22.0Morocco

19.4

Malaysia18.1

Burma16.5

Sudan16.3

Chile14.6

N Korea14.1

Ethiopia13.0

Uzbekistan10.1

Tanzania9.9

Romania11.6

Ghana11.3

Syria10.2

Belgium10.2

80%

94%

62%

33%

89%

81%

73%

81%

67%

27%

33%

65%60%

69%

32%

43%

88%

62%

16%

37%

25%

54%

49%

51%

97%

Nigeria68.650%

UK54.090%

France46.977%

Spain33.677%

Italy39.668%

Germany62.075%

Iran48.468%

Pakistan59.336%

Cameroon

AngolaEcuador

IvoryCoast

Kazakh-stan

Cuba

Afghan-istan

Sweden

Kenya

CzechRepublic

9.5

9.38.7

8.6

8.6

8.5

7.8

7.6

7.6

7.4

Mozam-bique

HongKong

Belarus

Tunisia

Hungary

Greece

Israel

Guate-mala

Portugal

Yemen

DominicanRepublic

Bolivia

Serbia &Mont

Switzer-land

Austria

Bulgaria

Mada-gascar

Libya

Senegal

Jordan

Zimbabwe

Nepal

Denmark

Mali

Azerbaijan

Singapore

ElSalvador

Zambia

Uganda

PuertoRico

Paraguay

UAE

Benin

Norway

NewZealand

Honduras

Haiti

Nicaragua

Guinea

Finland

Uruguay

Lebanon

Somalia

Sri Lanka

Cambodia

Slovakia

Costa Rica

Palestine

Kuwait

Togo

ChadBurkina

Ireland

Croatia

Congo

Niger

Sierra Leone

Malawi

Panama

Turkmenistan

Georgia

Lithuania

Liberia

Moldova

Rwanda

Kyrgyzstan

Oman

ArmeniaBosnia

Tajikistan

CAR

Melanesia

Latvia

Mongolia

Albania

Jamaica

Macedonia

Mauritania Laos

Gabon

Botswana

Slovenia

Eritrea

Estonia

Gambia

Burundi

Papua New Guinea

NamibiaMauritius

Guinea-Bissau

Lesotho E Timor

Bhutan

Swaziland

Trinidad & Tobago

The earth reaches a momentous milestone: by next year, for the first time in history, more than half its population will be living in cities. Those 3.3 billion people are expected to grow to 5 billion by 2030 — this unique map of the world shows where those people live now

At the beginning of the 20th century, the world's urban population was only 220 million, mainly in the west

By 2030, the towns and cities of the developing world will make up 80% of urban humanity

The new urban world

Urban growth, 2005—2010

Predominantly urban75% or over

Predominantly urban50—74%

Predominantly rural25—49% urban

Predominantly rural0—24% urban

Cities over 10 million people(greater urban area)

Key

Tokyo33.4

Osaka16.6

Seoul23.2

Manila15.4

Jakarta14.9

Dacca 13.8

Bombay21.3

Delhi21.1 Calcutta

15.5

Karachi14.8

Shanghai17.3

Canton14.5

Beijing12.7

Moscow13.4

Tehran12.1

Cairo15.9

Istanbul11.7

London12.0

Lagos10.0

MexicoCity22.1

New York21.8

Sao Paulo20.4

LA17.9

Rio deJaneiro

12.2

BuenosAires13.5 3,307,950,000

The world’s urban population — from a total of 6,615.9 million SOURCE: UNFPA GRAPHIC: PAUL SCRUTONAfrica Asia Oceania Europe0.1%

Eastern Europe-0.4%

Arab StatesLatin America& Caribbean North America

3.2%2.4%

1.3%

2.8%

1.7%1.3%

NRM

Residential water demand management

resolution depends on the installed meter, the logging time can beshortened without installation of smart meters but simplyincreasing the traditional reading frequency by the users. However,so far only ad-hoc studies systematically collected and analyzeddata at daily resolution (e.g., Olmstead et al., 2007; Wong et al.,2010) and few water companies (e.g., Water Corporation in West-ern Australia and ThamesWater in London) started increasing theirreading frequency by direct involvement of their customers, whoare invited to self-read their consumption and communicate itonline to the water company (e.g., Anda et al., 2013).

2.2. High resolution data

The advent of high resolution sensors, with their ability ofsampling water consumption on sub-daily basis, opened up a newpotential to better characterize domestic water consumption. Twodistinctive metering approaches can be distinguished: intrusivemetering, which ensures direct estimates of the residential waterend-uses by installing high resolution sensors on-device, namelyone sensor for each water consuming appliance (e.g., washingmachine, toilet flush, shower-head); non-intrusive metering, whichregisters the total water flow at the household level over one singledetection point for the whole house.

Intrusive metering (see Rowlands et al., 2014, and referencestherein) is generally considered inapplicable in real-world, large-scale analysis as the number of sensors to be installed makes thisapproach resource intensive, costly, and hardly accepted byhousehold occupants (Cordell et al., 2003; Kim et al., 2008). On thecontrary, non-intrusive metering represents a more acceptable,though less accurate, alternative (Mayer and DeOreo, 1999). How-ever, this approach requires disaggregation algorithms to break-down the total consumption data at the household level into thedifferent end-use categories (see Section 3).

Several types of sensors have been developed (Table 2) byexploiting different technologies and physical properties of thewater flow (for a review see Arregui et al., 2006, and referencestherein):

! Accelerometers (e.g., Evans et al., 2004), which analyze vibra-tions in a pipe induced by the turbulence of the water flow. Asampling frequency of 100 Hz of the pipe vibrations allows

reconstructing the average flow within the pipe with a resolu-tion of 0.015 L (Kim et al., 2008).

! Ultrasonic sensors (Mori et al., 2004), which estimate the flowvelocity, and then determine the flow rate knowing the pipesection, by measuring the difference in time between ultrasonicbeams generated by piezoelectric devices and transmittedwithin the water flow. The transducers are generally operated inthe range 0.5e2 MHz and allow attaining an average resolutionaround 0.0018 L (e.g., Sanderson and Yeung, 2002).

! Pressure sensors (Froehlich et al., 2009, 2011), which consist insteel devices, equipped with an analog-digital converter and amicro-controller, continuously sampling pressure with a theo-retical maximum resolution of 2 kHZ. Flow rate is related to thepressure change generated by the opening/close of the waterdevices valves via Poiseuille's Law.

! Flowmeters (Mayer and DeOreo, 1999), which exploit the waterflow to spin either pistons (mechanic flow meters) or magnets(magnetic meters) and correlate the number of revolutions orpulse to the water volume passing through the pipe. Sensingresolution spans between 34.2 and 72 pulses per liter (i.e., 1pulse every 0.029 and 0.014 L, respectively) associated to alogging frequency in the range of 1e10 s (Kowalski andMarshallsay, 2005; Heinrich, 2007; Willis et al., 2013).

So far, only flow meters and pressure sensors have beenemployed in smart meters applications because ultrasonic sensorsare too costly and the use of accelerometers requires an intrusivecalibration phase with the placement of multiple meters distrib-uted on the pipe network for each single device of interest (Kimet al., 2008). It is worth noting that the “smartness” of these sen-sors is related both to their high sampling resolution and to theirintegration in efficient systems combining data collection, transfer,storage, and analysis. Although sensors can be equipped with dataloggers requiring human intervention to retrieve the data directlyfrom the sensors (Mayer et al., 2004), bluetooth and wireless con-nections have been recently exploited for improving data man-agement. For example, Froehlich et al. (2009) installed a network ofpressure sensors communicating via bluetooth with a laptopdeployed at each household, which runs a custom data logger toreceive, compress, and archive data. These latter are then uploadedto a web server at 30-min intervals.

2.3. Research challenges and future directions

While smart meters are becoming easily available, we identifieda list of open research and technical challenges that need to beaddressed to promote the coherent use of this wide range oftechnologies:

1. The first open research question relates to the management ofthe metered high resolution flow data. In particular, the devel-opment of robust, automated processes to transfer the gener-ated big data requires further elaborations, both in terms ofhardware and software performance due to existing issues withrespect towireless network reliability, black spots, power sourceand battery life (Stewart et al., 2010; Little and Flynn, 2012). Allthese aspects appear key also because the possibility of inte-grating water and energy meters and using the same data log-gers and transmission systems is expected to enhance thediffusion of high resolution water sensors (Benzi et al., 2011;Froes Lima and Portillo Navas, 2012).

2. The second open challenge concerns the design of centralized ordistributed information systems to store the data collected bythe smart meters (Oracle, 2009). A centralized system wouldallow checking the accuracy of the collected data, which can

Fig. 2. Five-years count of the 134 publications reviewed in this study.

A. Cominola et al. / Environmental Modelling & Software 72 (2015) 198e214200

Benefits and challenges of using smart meters for advancingresidential water demand modeling and management: A review

A. Cominola a, M. Giuliani a, D. Piga b, A. Castelletti a, c, *, A.E. Rizzoli da Department of Electronics, Information, and Bioengineering, Politecnico di Milano, Milan, Italyb IMT Institute for Advanced Studies Lucca, Lucca, Italyc Institute of Environmental Engineering, ETH Zurich, Zurich, Switzerlandd Istituto Dalle Molle di Studi sull'Intelligenza Artificiale, SUPSI-USI, Lugano, Switzerland

a r t i c l e i n f o

Article history:Received 2 April 2015Received in revised form21 July 2015Accepted 21 July 2015Available online xxx

Keywords:Smart meterResidential water managementWater demand modelingWater conservation

a b s t r a c t

Over the last two decades, water smart metering programs have been launched in a number of mediumto large cities worldwide to nearly continuously monitor water consumption at the single householdlevel. The availability of data at such very high spatial and temporal resolution advanced the ability incharacterizing, modeling, and, ultimately, designing user-oriented residential water demand manage-ment strategies. Research to date has been focusing on one or more of these aspects but with limitedintegration between the specialized methodologies developed so far. This manuscript is the firstcomprehensive review of the literature in this quickly evolving water research domain. The papercontributes a general framework for the classification of residential water demand modeling studies,which allows revising consolidated approaches, describing emerging trends, and identifying potentialfuture developments. In particular, the future challenges posed by growing population demands, con-strained sources of water supply and climate change impacts are expected to require more and moreintegrated procedures for effectively supporting residential water demand modeling and management inseveral countries across the world.

© 2015 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

1. Introduction

World's urban population is expected to raise from current54%e66% in 2050 and to further increase as a consequence of theunlikely stabilization of human population by the end of the cen-tury (Gerland et al., 2014). By 2030 the number of mega-cities,namely cities with more than 10 million inhabitants, will growover 40 (UNDESA, 2010). This will boost residential water demand(Cosgrove and Cosgrove, 2012), which nowadays covers a largeportion of the public drinking water supply worldwide (e.g.,60e80% in Europe (Collins et al., 2009), 58% in the United States(Kenny et al., 2009)).

The concentration of the water demands of thousands or mil-lions of people into small areas will considerably raise the stress onfinite supplies of available freshwater (McDonald et al., 2011a).Besides, climate and land use change will further increase the

number of people facingwater shortage (McDonald et al., 2011b). Insuch context, water supply expansion through the construction ofnew infrastructures might be an option to escape water stress insome situations. Yet, geographical or financial limitations largelyrestrict such options in most countries (McDonald et al., 2014).Here, acting on the water demand management side through thepromotion of cost-effective water-saving technologies, revisedeconomic policies, appropriate national and local regulations, andeducation represents an alternative strategy for securing reliablewater supply and reduce water utilities' costs (Gleick et al., 2003).

In recent years, a variety of water demand management stra-tegies (WDMS) has been applied (for a review, see Inman andJeffrey, 2006, and references therein). However, the effectivenessof these WDMS is often context-specific and strongly depends onour understanding of the drivers inducing people to consume orsave water (Jorgensen et al., 2009). Models that quantitativelydescribe how water demand is influenced and varies in relation toexogenous uncontrolled drivers (e.g., seasonality, climatic condi-tions) and demand management actions (e.g., water restrictions,pricing schemes, education campaigns) are essential to explorewater users' response to alternative WDMS, ultimately supporting

* Corresponding author. Department of Electronics, Information, and Bioengi-neering, Politecnico di Milano, Milan, Italy.

E-mail address: [email protected] (A. Castelletti).

Contents lists available at ScienceDirect

Environmental Modelling & Software

journal homepage: www.elsevier .com/locate/envsoft

http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.envsoft.2015.07.0121364-8152/© 2015 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Environmental Modelling & Software 72 (2015) 198e214

Benefits and challenges of using smart meters for advancingresidential water demand modeling and management: A review

A. Cominola a, M. Giuliani a, D. Piga b, A. Castelletti a, c, *, A.E. Rizzoli da Department of Electronics, Information, and Bioengineering, Politecnico di Milano, Milan, Italyb IMT Institute for Advanced Studies Lucca, Lucca, Italyc Institute of Environmental Engineering, ETH Zurich, Zurich, Switzerlandd Istituto Dalle Molle di Studi sull'Intelligenza Artificiale, SUPSI-USI, Lugano, Switzerland

a r t i c l e i n f o

Article history:Received 2 April 2015Received in revised form21 July 2015Accepted 21 July 2015Available online xxx

Keywords:Smart meterResidential water managementWater demand modelingWater conservation

a b s t r a c t

Over the last two decades, water smart metering programs have been launched in a number of mediumto large cities worldwide to nearly continuously monitor water consumption at the single householdlevel. The availability of data at such very high spatial and temporal resolution advanced the ability incharacterizing, modeling, and, ultimately, designing user-oriented residential water demand manage-ment strategies. Research to date has been focusing on one or more of these aspects but with limitedintegration between the specialized methodologies developed so far. This manuscript is the firstcomprehensive review of the literature in this quickly evolving water research domain. The papercontributes a general framework for the classification of residential water demand modeling studies,which allows revising consolidated approaches, describing emerging trends, and identifying potentialfuture developments. In particular, the future challenges posed by growing population demands, con-strained sources of water supply and climate change impacts are expected to require more and moreintegrated procedures for effectively supporting residential water demand modeling and management inseveral countries across the world.

© 2015 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

1. Introduction

World's urban population is expected to raise from current54%e66% in 2050 and to further increase as a consequence of theunlikely stabilization of human population by the end of the cen-tury (Gerland et al., 2014). By 2030 the number of mega-cities,namely cities with more than 10 million inhabitants, will growover 40 (UNDESA, 2010). This will boost residential water demand(Cosgrove and Cosgrove, 2012), which nowadays covers a largeportion of the public drinking water supply worldwide (e.g.,60e80% in Europe (Collins et al., 2009), 58% in the United States(Kenny et al., 2009)).

The concentration of the water demands of thousands or mil-lions of people into small areas will considerably raise the stress onfinite supplies of available freshwater (McDonald et al., 2011a).Besides, climate and land use change will further increase the

number of people facingwater shortage (McDonald et al., 2011b). Insuch context, water supply expansion through the construction ofnew infrastructures might be an option to escape water stress insome situations. Yet, geographical or financial limitations largelyrestrict such options in most countries (McDonald et al., 2014).Here, acting on the water demand management side through thepromotion of cost-effective water-saving technologies, revisedeconomic policies, appropriate national and local regulations, andeducation represents an alternative strategy for securing reliablewater supply and reduce water utilities' costs (Gleick et al., 2003).

In recent years, a variety of water demand management stra-tegies (WDMS) has been applied (for a review, see Inman andJeffrey, 2006, and references therein). However, the effectivenessof these WDMS is often context-specific and strongly depends onour understanding of the drivers inducing people to consume orsave water (Jorgensen et al., 2009). Models that quantitativelydescribe how water demand is influenced and varies in relation toexogenous uncontrolled drivers (e.g., seasonality, climatic condi-tions) and demand management actions (e.g., water restrictions,pricing schemes, education campaigns) are essential to explorewater users' response to alternative WDMS, ultimately supporting

* Corresponding author. Department of Electronics, Information, and Bioengi-neering, Politecnico di Milano, Milan, Italy.

E-mail address: [email protected] (A. Castelletti).

Contents lists available at ScienceDirect

Environmental Modelling & Software

journal homepage: www.elsevier .com/locate/envsoft

http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.envsoft.2015.07.0121364-8152/© 2015 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Environmental Modelling & Software 72 (2015) 198e214

36%

43%

13%6%

<1%

Analysis of 134 studies over the last 25 years

NRM

Residential water demand management

resolution depends on the installed meter, the logging time can beshortened without installation of smart meters but simplyincreasing the traditional reading frequency by the users. However,so far only ad-hoc studies systematically collected and analyzeddata at daily resolution (e.g., Olmstead et al., 2007; Wong et al.,2010) and few water companies (e.g., Water Corporation in West-ern Australia and ThamesWater in London) started increasing theirreading frequency by direct involvement of their customers, whoare invited to self-read their consumption and communicate itonline to the water company (e.g., Anda et al., 2013).

2.2. High resolution data

The advent of high resolution sensors, with their ability ofsampling water consumption on sub-daily basis, opened up a newpotential to better characterize domestic water consumption. Twodistinctive metering approaches can be distinguished: intrusivemetering, which ensures direct estimates of the residential waterend-uses by installing high resolution sensors on-device, namelyone sensor for each water consuming appliance (e.g., washingmachine, toilet flush, shower-head); non-intrusive metering, whichregisters the total water flow at the household level over one singledetection point for the whole house.

Intrusive metering (see Rowlands et al., 2014, and referencestherein) is generally considered inapplicable in real-world, large-scale analysis as the number of sensors to be installed makes thisapproach resource intensive, costly, and hardly accepted byhousehold occupants (Cordell et al., 2003; Kim et al., 2008). On thecontrary, non-intrusive metering represents a more acceptable,though less accurate, alternative (Mayer and DeOreo, 1999). How-ever, this approach requires disaggregation algorithms to break-down the total consumption data at the household level into thedifferent end-use categories (see Section 3).

Several types of sensors have been developed (Table 2) byexploiting different technologies and physical properties of thewater flow (for a review see Arregui et al., 2006, and referencestherein):

! Accelerometers (e.g., Evans et al., 2004), which analyze vibra-tions in a pipe induced by the turbulence of the water flow. Asampling frequency of 100 Hz of the pipe vibrations allows

reconstructing the average flow within the pipe with a resolu-tion of 0.015 L (Kim et al., 2008).

! Ultrasonic sensors (Mori et al., 2004), which estimate the flowvelocity, and then determine the flow rate knowing the pipesection, by measuring the difference in time between ultrasonicbeams generated by piezoelectric devices and transmittedwithin the water flow. The transducers are generally operated inthe range 0.5e2 MHz and allow attaining an average resolutionaround 0.0018 L (e.g., Sanderson and Yeung, 2002).

! Pressure sensors (Froehlich et al., 2009, 2011), which consist insteel devices, equipped with an analog-digital converter and amicro-controller, continuously sampling pressure with a theo-retical maximum resolution of 2 kHZ. Flow rate is related to thepressure change generated by the opening/close of the waterdevices valves via Poiseuille's Law.

! Flowmeters (Mayer and DeOreo, 1999), which exploit the waterflow to spin either pistons (mechanic flow meters) or magnets(magnetic meters) and correlate the number of revolutions orpulse to the water volume passing through the pipe. Sensingresolution spans between 34.2 and 72 pulses per liter (i.e., 1pulse every 0.029 and 0.014 L, respectively) associated to alogging frequency in the range of 1e10 s (Kowalski andMarshallsay, 2005; Heinrich, 2007; Willis et al., 2013).

So far, only flow meters and pressure sensors have beenemployed in smart meters applications because ultrasonic sensorsare too costly and the use of accelerometers requires an intrusivecalibration phase with the placement of multiple meters distrib-uted on the pipe network for each single device of interest (Kimet al., 2008). It is worth noting that the “smartness” of these sen-sors is related both to their high sampling resolution and to theirintegration in efficient systems combining data collection, transfer,storage, and analysis. Although sensors can be equipped with dataloggers requiring human intervention to retrieve the data directlyfrom the sensors (Mayer et al., 2004), bluetooth and wireless con-nections have been recently exploited for improving data man-agement. For example, Froehlich et al. (2009) installed a network ofpressure sensors communicating via bluetooth with a laptopdeployed at each household, which runs a custom data logger toreceive, compress, and archive data. These latter are then uploadedto a web server at 30-min intervals.

2.3. Research challenges and future directions

While smart meters are becoming easily available, we identifieda list of open research and technical challenges that need to beaddressed to promote the coherent use of this wide range oftechnologies:

1. The first open research question relates to the management ofthe metered high resolution flow data. In particular, the devel-opment of robust, automated processes to transfer the gener-ated big data requires further elaborations, both in terms ofhardware and software performance due to existing issues withrespect towireless network reliability, black spots, power sourceand battery life (Stewart et al., 2010; Little and Flynn, 2012). Allthese aspects appear key also because the possibility of inte-grating water and energy meters and using the same data log-gers and transmission systems is expected to enhance thediffusion of high resolution water sensors (Benzi et al., 2011;Froes Lima and Portillo Navas, 2012).

2. The second open challenge concerns the design of centralized ordistributed information systems to store the data collected bythe smart meters (Oracle, 2009). A centralized system wouldallow checking the accuracy of the collected data, which can

Fig. 2. Five-years count of the 134 publications reviewed in this study.

A. Cominola et al. / Environmental Modelling & Software 72 (2015) 198e214200

Benefits and challenges of using smart meters for advancingresidential water demand modeling and management: A review

A. Cominola a, M. Giuliani a, D. Piga b, A. Castelletti a, c, *, A.E. Rizzoli da Department of Electronics, Information, and Bioengineering, Politecnico di Milano, Milan, Italyb IMT Institute for Advanced Studies Lucca, Lucca, Italyc Institute of Environmental Engineering, ETH Zurich, Zurich, Switzerlandd Istituto Dalle Molle di Studi sull'Intelligenza Artificiale, SUPSI-USI, Lugano, Switzerland

a r t i c l e i n f o

Article history:Received 2 April 2015Received in revised form21 July 2015Accepted 21 July 2015Available online xxx

Keywords:Smart meterResidential water managementWater demand modelingWater conservation

a b s t r a c t

Over the last two decades, water smart metering programs have been launched in a number of mediumto large cities worldwide to nearly continuously monitor water consumption at the single householdlevel. The availability of data at such very high spatial and temporal resolution advanced the ability incharacterizing, modeling, and, ultimately, designing user-oriented residential water demand manage-ment strategies. Research to date has been focusing on one or more of these aspects but with limitedintegration between the specialized methodologies developed so far. This manuscript is the firstcomprehensive review of the literature in this quickly evolving water research domain. The papercontributes a general framework for the classification of residential water demand modeling studies,which allows revising consolidated approaches, describing emerging trends, and identifying potentialfuture developments. In particular, the future challenges posed by growing population demands, con-strained sources of water supply and climate change impacts are expected to require more and moreintegrated procedures for effectively supporting residential water demand modeling and management inseveral countries across the world.

© 2015 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

1. Introduction

World's urban population is expected to raise from current54%e66% in 2050 and to further increase as a consequence of theunlikely stabilization of human population by the end of the cen-tury (Gerland et al., 2014). By 2030 the number of mega-cities,namely cities with more than 10 million inhabitants, will growover 40 (UNDESA, 2010). This will boost residential water demand(Cosgrove and Cosgrove, 2012), which nowadays covers a largeportion of the public drinking water supply worldwide (e.g.,60e80% in Europe (Collins et al., 2009), 58% in the United States(Kenny et al., 2009)).

The concentration of the water demands of thousands or mil-lions of people into small areas will considerably raise the stress onfinite supplies of available freshwater (McDonald et al., 2011a).Besides, climate and land use change will further increase the

number of people facingwater shortage (McDonald et al., 2011b). Insuch context, water supply expansion through the construction ofnew infrastructures might be an option to escape water stress insome situations. Yet, geographical or financial limitations largelyrestrict such options in most countries (McDonald et al., 2014).Here, acting on the water demand management side through thepromotion of cost-effective water-saving technologies, revisedeconomic policies, appropriate national and local regulations, andeducation represents an alternative strategy for securing reliablewater supply and reduce water utilities' costs (Gleick et al., 2003).

In recent years, a variety of water demand management stra-tegies (WDMS) has been applied (for a review, see Inman andJeffrey, 2006, and references therein). However, the effectivenessof these WDMS is often context-specific and strongly depends onour understanding of the drivers inducing people to consume orsave water (Jorgensen et al., 2009). Models that quantitativelydescribe how water demand is influenced and varies in relation toexogenous uncontrolled drivers (e.g., seasonality, climatic condi-tions) and demand management actions (e.g., water restrictions,pricing schemes, education campaigns) are essential to explorewater users' response to alternative WDMS, ultimately supporting

* Corresponding author. Department of Electronics, Information, and Bioengi-neering, Politecnico di Milano, Milan, Italy.

E-mail address: [email protected] (A. Castelletti).

Contents lists available at ScienceDirect

Environmental Modelling & Software

journal homepage: www.elsevier .com/locate/envsoft

http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.envsoft.2015.07.0121364-8152/© 2015 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Environmental Modelling & Software 72 (2015) 198e214

Benefits and challenges of using smart meters for advancingresidential water demand modeling and management: A review

A. Cominola a, M. Giuliani a, D. Piga b, A. Castelletti a, c, *, A.E. Rizzoli da Department of Electronics, Information, and Bioengineering, Politecnico di Milano, Milan, Italyb IMT Institute for Advanced Studies Lucca, Lucca, Italyc Institute of Environmental Engineering, ETH Zurich, Zurich, Switzerlandd Istituto Dalle Molle di Studi sull'Intelligenza Artificiale, SUPSI-USI, Lugano, Switzerland

a r t i c l e i n f o

Article history:Received 2 April 2015Received in revised form21 July 2015Accepted 21 July 2015Available online xxx

Keywords:Smart meterResidential water managementWater demand modelingWater conservation

a b s t r a c t

Over the last two decades, water smart metering programs have been launched in a number of mediumto large cities worldwide to nearly continuously monitor water consumption at the single householdlevel. The availability of data at such very high spatial and temporal resolution advanced the ability incharacterizing, modeling, and, ultimately, designing user-oriented residential water demand manage-ment strategies. Research to date has been focusing on one or more of these aspects but with limitedintegration between the specialized methodologies developed so far. This manuscript is the firstcomprehensive review of the literature in this quickly evolving water research domain. The papercontributes a general framework for the classification of residential water demand modeling studies,which allows revising consolidated approaches, describing emerging trends, and identifying potentialfuture developments. In particular, the future challenges posed by growing population demands, con-strained sources of water supply and climate change impacts are expected to require more and moreintegrated procedures for effectively supporting residential water demand modeling and management inseveral countries across the world.

© 2015 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

1. Introduction

World's urban population is expected to raise from current54%e66% in 2050 and to further increase as a consequence of theunlikely stabilization of human population by the end of the cen-tury (Gerland et al., 2014). By 2030 the number of mega-cities,namely cities with more than 10 million inhabitants, will growover 40 (UNDESA, 2010). This will boost residential water demand(Cosgrove and Cosgrove, 2012), which nowadays covers a largeportion of the public drinking water supply worldwide (e.g.,60e80% in Europe (Collins et al., 2009), 58% in the United States(Kenny et al., 2009)).

The concentration of the water demands of thousands or mil-lions of people into small areas will considerably raise the stress onfinite supplies of available freshwater (McDonald et al., 2011a).Besides, climate and land use change will further increase the

number of people facingwater shortage (McDonald et al., 2011b). Insuch context, water supply expansion through the construction ofnew infrastructures might be an option to escape water stress insome situations. Yet, geographical or financial limitations largelyrestrict such options in most countries (McDonald et al., 2014).Here, acting on the water demand management side through thepromotion of cost-effective water-saving technologies, revisedeconomic policies, appropriate national and local regulations, andeducation represents an alternative strategy for securing reliablewater supply and reduce water utilities' costs (Gleick et al., 2003).

In recent years, a variety of water demand management stra-tegies (WDMS) has been applied (for a review, see Inman andJeffrey, 2006, and references therein). However, the effectivenessof these WDMS is often context-specific and strongly depends onour understanding of the drivers inducing people to consume orsave water (Jorgensen et al., 2009). Models that quantitativelydescribe how water demand is influenced and varies in relation toexogenous uncontrolled drivers (e.g., seasonality, climatic condi-tions) and demand management actions (e.g., water restrictions,pricing schemes, education campaigns) are essential to explorewater users' response to alternative WDMS, ultimately supporting

* Corresponding author. Department of Electronics, Information, and Bioengi-neering, Politecnico di Milano, Milan, Italy.

E-mail address: [email protected] (A. Castelletti).

Contents lists available at ScienceDirect

Environmental Modelling & Software

journal homepage: www.elsevier .com/locate/envsoft

http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.envsoft.2015.07.0121364-8152/© 2015 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Environmental Modelling & Software 72 (2015) 198e214

36%

43%

13%6%

<1%

Analysis of 134 studies over the last 25 years

first smart meters

deployment

NRM

Traditional water meters

monthly to yearly readings

Oct Nov Dec

Wat

er c

onsu

mpt

ion

m3

?

1 cubic meter

NRM

Oct Nov Dec

Wat

er c

onsu

mpt

ion

m3

?

Smart water meters

Data logging at 5-10 sec72 pulses/L

Smart meters deployment: OPPORTUNITIES

• End-use characterization

• Advanced management strategies

• Projections of water demand

Smart meters deployment: CHALLENGES

• Deployment and maintenance costs

• Big data collection, processing and analysis

• Intrusiveness and privacy

NRM

Generation of end-use water demand

5 Devices (indoor): toilet, clothes washer, showers, dishwasher, faucet

753,076 water-use events over 4,036 monitoring days

across 9 US cities

Source: DeOreo [2011]

NRM

Generation of end-use water demand

The SmartH2O platform: advancing residential water management by smart metering and data intensive modeling of consumers’ behaviours A. Cominola1, M. Giuliani1, D. Piga2, A. Castelletti1, A.E. Rizzoli3

1.  Department of Electronics, Information and Bioengineering – Hydroinformatics lab |Politecnico di Milano| Milano (IT) 2.  IMT Institute for Advanced Studies Lucca | Lucca (IT) 3.  Dalle Molle Institute for Artificial Intelligence Research, SUPSI | Manno (CH)

THE PROJECT

THE FHMM-ISDTW END-USE DISAGGREGATION ALGORITHM

LONDON | UK Thames Water water supply utility

15 million customers served

2.6 Gl/day drinking water distributed

Development plan: 3 Million smart meters installed by 2030!

LOCARNO | CH Società Elettrica Sopracenerina

power supply utility, 80 thousand customers served

Interested in multi-utility smart metering (water, energy, gas)

Almost 400 smart water meters installed! VALENCIA | ES EMIVASA water supply utility 2 million customers served

490,000 water smart meters currently installed

Development plan: 650,000 water smart meters installed by end 015.!

MISSION The mission of the SmartH2O project is developing an ICT platform to improve the management of urban and peri-urban water demand.

CONCEPT The SmartH2O platform ICT infrastructure will enable water managers to close the loop between actual water consumption levels and desired targets, through:

_ understanding and modeling water consumers’ behaviour, based on historical and real-time water usage data

_ predicting how the consumer behaviour can be influenced by various Water Demand Management Strategies, such as customized feedbacks and different pricing schemes

_ raising users’ awareness to pursue water reduction in the residential sector

CORE ELEMENTS

high-resolution water consumption data interaction with customers for information sharing and socio-psychographic data gathering innovative water demand management strategies: dynamic pricing, customized feedbacks and rewards gamification

OUR USE CASES

The SmartH2O project receives funding from the European Union’s Seventh Framework Programme (FP7/2007-2013)!

THE ADVANCES ON END-USES CHARACTERIZATION

Simplified structure of the SmartH2O platform

smart meters and end use analysis

gamified bill online and board game

behavioral modeling

water consumption drivers identification

water consumption level forecast at the customer scale

administrator dashboard

dynamic water pricing tailored feedbacks prescriptive norms

gamified bill

Response to WDMS

DEVELOPMENT OF A SYNTHETIC WATER END-USE PATTERNS GENERATOR An algorithm to generate synthetic water end-use patterns has been developed within the SmartH2O project, with the double purpose of: •  building end-use water consumption datasets to feed disaggregation algorithms and to provide benchmark datasets for community

testing; •  allowing for the generation of end-use patterns under different demographic and technological scenarios.

DEVELOPMENT PLAN •  User-friendly interface •  Web portal to contribute with new

datasets from different case studies

CURRENT FEATURES •  Trained on high-resolutions (1 second) consumption data from 9 cities across USA •  Performance validated with a two-sample Kolmogorov-Smirnov test •  Flexible for synthetic generation at multi-scale resolutions.

user’s input end-use statistics extraction end-use traces generation •  house size •  time sampling

resolution •  device

presence

usage duration usage volume time-of-use frequency of use typical pattern (signature)

An new algorithm to perform household energy and water consumption trace disaggregation into end-uses (e.g., washing machine, toilet, tap, etc…) has been developed, with the purpose of profiling users’ consumption habits based on the total single-point smart metered consumption.

CHALLENGES •  Accurately reproducing the consumption trajectory of different

end-uses, not only their operating system (i.e., on/off status) •  Performing disaggregation for a number of appliances

simultaneously operating.

ALGORITHM TECHNOLOGIES •  Factorial Hidden Markov Models •  Iterative Subsequence Dynamic Time Warping

APPLICATION OUTCOMES

Experiments on POWER data (1 min resolution) show high accuracy in

reproducing the consumption trajectory of

many end-uses simultaneously working

Preliminary experiments on WATER data (1 min resolution) show suitability in reproducing the contribution of each operating appliance to the total measured household consumption.

36 %

34 %

30 % 25 %

30 % 31 %

DROP! The SmartH2O game

Andrea Cominola [email protected]

@smartH2Oproject

#SmartH2O

time

water

co

nsum

ptio

n

5 Devices (indoor): toilet, clothes washer, showers, dishwasher, faucet

753,076 water-use events over 4,036 monitoring days

across 9 US cities

Source: DeOreo [2011]

NRM

Generation of end-use water demand

The SmartH2O platform: advancing residential water management by smart metering and data intensive modeling of consumers’ behaviours A. Cominola1, M. Giuliani1, D. Piga2, A. Castelletti1, A.E. Rizzoli3

1.  Department of Electronics, Information and Bioengineering – Hydroinformatics lab |Politecnico di Milano| Milano (IT) 2.  IMT Institute for Advanced Studies Lucca | Lucca (IT) 3.  Dalle Molle Institute for Artificial Intelligence Research, SUPSI | Manno (CH)

THE PROJECT

THE FHMM-ISDTW END-USE DISAGGREGATION ALGORITHM

LONDON | UK Thames Water water supply utility

15 million customers served

2.6 Gl/day drinking water distributed

Development plan: 3 Million smart meters installed by 2030!

LOCARNO | CH Società Elettrica Sopracenerina

power supply utility, 80 thousand customers served

Interested in multi-utility smart metering (water, energy, gas)

Almost 400 smart water meters installed! VALENCIA | ES EMIVASA water supply utility 2 million customers served

490,000 water smart meters currently installed

Development plan: 650,000 water smart meters installed by end 015.!

MISSION The mission of the SmartH2O project is developing an ICT platform to improve the management of urban and peri-urban water demand.

CONCEPT The SmartH2O platform ICT infrastructure will enable water managers to close the loop between actual water consumption levels and desired targets, through:

_ understanding and modeling water consumers’ behaviour, based on historical and real-time water usage data

_ predicting how the consumer behaviour can be influenced by various Water Demand Management Strategies, such as customized feedbacks and different pricing schemes

_ raising users’ awareness to pursue water reduction in the residential sector

CORE ELEMENTS

high-resolution water consumption data interaction with customers for information sharing and socio-psychographic data gathering innovative water demand management strategies: dynamic pricing, customized feedbacks and rewards gamification

OUR USE CASES

The SmartH2O project receives funding from the European Union’s Seventh Framework Programme (FP7/2007-2013)!

THE ADVANCES ON END-USES CHARACTERIZATION

Simplified structure of the SmartH2O platform

smart meters and end use analysis

gamified bill online and board game

behavioral modeling

water consumption drivers identification

water consumption level forecast at the customer scale

administrator dashboard

dynamic water pricing tailored feedbacks prescriptive norms

gamified bill

Response to WDMS

DEVELOPMENT OF A SYNTHETIC WATER END-USE PATTERNS GENERATOR An algorithm to generate synthetic water end-use patterns has been developed within the SmartH2O project, with the double purpose of: •  building end-use water consumption datasets to feed disaggregation algorithms and to provide benchmark datasets for community

testing; •  allowing for the generation of end-use patterns under different demographic and technological scenarios.

DEVELOPMENT PLAN •  User-friendly interface •  Web portal to contribute with new

datasets from different case studies

CURRENT FEATURES •  Trained on high-resolutions (1 second) consumption data from 9 cities across USA •  Performance validated with a two-sample Kolmogorov-Smirnov test •  Flexible for synthetic generation at multi-scale resolutions.

user’s input end-use statistics extraction end-use traces generation •  house size •  time sampling

resolution •  device

presence

usage duration usage volume time-of-use frequency of use typical pattern (signature)

An new algorithm to perform household energy and water consumption trace disaggregation into end-uses (e.g., washing machine, toilet, tap, etc…) has been developed, with the purpose of profiling users’ consumption habits based on the total single-point smart metered consumption.

CHALLENGES •  Accurately reproducing the consumption trajectory of different

end-uses, not only their operating system (i.e., on/off status) •  Performing disaggregation for a number of appliances

simultaneously operating.

ALGORITHM TECHNOLOGIES •  Factorial Hidden Markov Models •  Iterative Subsequence Dynamic Time Warping

APPLICATION OUTCOMES

Experiments on POWER data (1 min resolution) show high accuracy in

reproducing the consumption trajectory of

many end-uses simultaneously working

Preliminary experiments on WATER data (1 min resolution) show suitability in reproducing the contribution of each operating appliance to the total measured household consumption.

36 %

34 %

30 % 25 %

30 % 31 %

DROP! The SmartH2O game

Andrea Cominola [email protected]

@smartH2Oproject

#SmartH2O

time

water

co

nsum

ptio

n

5 Devices (indoor): toilet, clothes washer, showers, dishwasher, faucet

Duration

Volume

Time of use

# daily uses

NRM

Generation of end-use water demand

The SmartH2O platform: advancing residential water management by smart metering and data intensive modeling of consumers’ behaviours A. Cominola1, M. Giuliani1, D. Piga2, A. Castelletti1, A.E. Rizzoli3

1.  Department of Electronics, Information and Bioengineering – Hydroinformatics lab |Politecnico di Milano| Milano (IT) 2.  IMT Institute for Advanced Studies Lucca | Lucca (IT) 3.  Dalle Molle Institute for Artificial Intelligence Research, SUPSI | Manno (CH)

THE PROJECT

THE FHMM-ISDTW END-USE DISAGGREGATION ALGORITHM

LONDON | UK Thames Water water supply utility

15 million customers served

2.6 Gl/day drinking water distributed

Development plan: 3 Million smart meters installed by 2030!

LOCARNO | CH Società Elettrica Sopracenerina

power supply utility, 80 thousand customers served

Interested in multi-utility smart metering (water, energy, gas)

Almost 400 smart water meters installed! VALENCIA | ES EMIVASA water supply utility 2 million customers served

490,000 water smart meters currently installed

Development plan: 650,000 water smart meters installed by end 015.!

MISSION The mission of the SmartH2O project is developing an ICT platform to improve the management of urban and peri-urban water demand.

CONCEPT The SmartH2O platform ICT infrastructure will enable water managers to close the loop between actual water consumption levels and desired targets, through:

_ understanding and modeling water consumers’ behaviour, based on historical and real-time water usage data

_ predicting how the consumer behaviour can be influenced by various Water Demand Management Strategies, such as customized feedbacks and different pricing schemes

_ raising users’ awareness to pursue water reduction in the residential sector

CORE ELEMENTS

high-resolution water consumption data interaction with customers for information sharing and socio-psychographic data gathering innovative water demand management strategies: dynamic pricing, customized feedbacks and rewards gamification

OUR USE CASES

The SmartH2O project receives funding from the European Union’s Seventh Framework Programme (FP7/2007-2013)!

THE ADVANCES ON END-USES CHARACTERIZATION

Simplified structure of the SmartH2O platform

smart meters and end use analysis

gamified bill online and board game

behavioral modeling

water consumption drivers identification

water consumption level forecast at the customer scale

administrator dashboard

dynamic water pricing tailored feedbacks prescriptive norms

gamified bill

Response to WDMS

DEVELOPMENT OF A SYNTHETIC WATER END-USE PATTERNS GENERATOR An algorithm to generate synthetic water end-use patterns has been developed within the SmartH2O project, with the double purpose of: •  building end-use water consumption datasets to feed disaggregation algorithms and to provide benchmark datasets for community

testing; •  allowing for the generation of end-use patterns under different demographic and technological scenarios.

DEVELOPMENT PLAN •  User-friendly interface •  Web portal to contribute with new

datasets from different case studies

CURRENT FEATURES •  Trained on high-resolutions (1 second) consumption data from 9 cities across USA •  Performance validated with a two-sample Kolmogorov-Smirnov test •  Flexible for synthetic generation at multi-scale resolutions.

user’s input end-use statistics extraction end-use traces generation •  house size •  time sampling

resolution •  device

presence

usage duration usage volume time-of-use frequency of use typical pattern (signature)

An new algorithm to perform household energy and water consumption trace disaggregation into end-uses (e.g., washing machine, toilet, tap, etc…) has been developed, with the purpose of profiling users’ consumption habits based on the total single-point smart metered consumption.

CHALLENGES •  Accurately reproducing the consumption trajectory of different

end-uses, not only their operating system (i.e., on/off status) •  Performing disaggregation for a number of appliances

simultaneously operating.

ALGORITHM TECHNOLOGIES •  Factorial Hidden Markov Models •  Iterative Subsequence Dynamic Time Warping

APPLICATION OUTCOMES

Experiments on POWER data (1 min resolution) show high accuracy in

reproducing the consumption trajectory of

many end-uses simultaneously working

Preliminary experiments on WATER data (1 min resolution) show suitability in reproducing the contribution of each operating appliance to the total measured household consumption.

36 %

34 %

30 % 25 %

30 % 31 %

DROP! The SmartH2O game

Andrea Cominola [email protected]

@smartH2Oproject

#SmartH2O

time

water

co

nsum

ptio

n

5 Devices (indoor): toilet, clothes washer, showers, dishwasher, faucet

Duration

Volume

Time of use

# daily uses

Typical pattern - signature

NRM

Generation of end-use water demand

The SmartH2O platform: advancing residential water management by smart metering and data intensive modeling of consumers’ behaviours A. Cominola1, M. Giuliani1, D. Piga2, A. Castelletti1, A.E. Rizzoli3

1.  Department of Electronics, Information and Bioengineering – Hydroinformatics lab |Politecnico di Milano| Milano (IT) 2.  IMT Institute for Advanced Studies Lucca | Lucca (IT) 3.  Dalle Molle Institute for Artificial Intelligence Research, SUPSI | Manno (CH)

THE PROJECT

THE FHMM-ISDTW END-USE DISAGGREGATION ALGORITHM

LONDON | UK Thames Water water supply utility

15 million customers served

2.6 Gl/day drinking water distributed

Development plan: 3 Million smart meters installed by 2030!

LOCARNO | CH Società Elettrica Sopracenerina

power supply utility, 80 thousand customers served

Interested in multi-utility smart metering (water, energy, gas)

Almost 400 smart water meters installed! VALENCIA | ES EMIVASA water supply utility 2 million customers served

490,000 water smart meters currently installed

Development plan: 650,000 water smart meters installed by end 015.!

MISSION The mission of the SmartH2O project is developing an ICT platform to improve the management of urban and peri-urban water demand.

CONCEPT The SmartH2O platform ICT infrastructure will enable water managers to close the loop between actual water consumption levels and desired targets, through:

_ understanding and modeling water consumers’ behaviour, based on historical and real-time water usage data

_ predicting how the consumer behaviour can be influenced by various Water Demand Management Strategies, such as customized feedbacks and different pricing schemes

_ raising users’ awareness to pursue water reduction in the residential sector

CORE ELEMENTS

high-resolution water consumption data interaction with customers for information sharing and socio-psychographic data gathering innovative water demand management strategies: dynamic pricing, customized feedbacks and rewards gamification

OUR USE CASES

The SmartH2O project receives funding from the European Union’s Seventh Framework Programme (FP7/2007-2013)!

THE ADVANCES ON END-USES CHARACTERIZATION

Simplified structure of the SmartH2O platform

smart meters and end use analysis

gamified bill online and board game

behavioral modeling

water consumption drivers identification

water consumption level forecast at the customer scale

administrator dashboard

dynamic water pricing tailored feedbacks prescriptive norms

gamified bill

Response to WDMS

DEVELOPMENT OF A SYNTHETIC WATER END-USE PATTERNS GENERATOR An algorithm to generate synthetic water end-use patterns has been developed within the SmartH2O project, with the double purpose of: •  building end-use water consumption datasets to feed disaggregation algorithms and to provide benchmark datasets for community

testing; •  allowing for the generation of end-use patterns under different demographic and technological scenarios.

DEVELOPMENT PLAN •  User-friendly interface •  Web portal to contribute with new

datasets from different case studies

CURRENT FEATURES •  Trained on high-resolutions (1 second) consumption data from 9 cities across USA •  Performance validated with a two-sample Kolmogorov-Smirnov test •  Flexible for synthetic generation at multi-scale resolutions.

user’s input end-use statistics extraction end-use traces generation •  house size •  time sampling

resolution •  device

presence

usage duration usage volume time-of-use frequency of use typical pattern (signature)

An new algorithm to perform household energy and water consumption trace disaggregation into end-uses (e.g., washing machine, toilet, tap, etc…) has been developed, with the purpose of profiling users’ consumption habits based on the total single-point smart metered consumption.

CHALLENGES •  Accurately reproducing the consumption trajectory of different

end-uses, not only their operating system (i.e., on/off status) •  Performing disaggregation for a number of appliances

simultaneously operating.

ALGORITHM TECHNOLOGIES •  Factorial Hidden Markov Models •  Iterative Subsequence Dynamic Time Warping

APPLICATION OUTCOMES

Experiments on POWER data (1 min resolution) show high accuracy in

reproducing the consumption trajectory of

many end-uses simultaneously working

Preliminary experiments on WATER data (1 min resolution) show suitability in reproducing the contribution of each operating appliance to the total measured household consumption.

36 %

34 %

30 % 25 %

30 % 31 %

DROP! The SmartH2O game

Andrea Cominola [email protected]

@smartH2Oproject

#SmartH2O

time

water

co

nsum

ptio

n

5 Devices (indoor): toilet, clothes washer, showers, dishwasher, faucet

NRM

Generation of end-use water demand

The SmartH2O platform: advancing residential water management by smart metering and data intensive modeling of consumers’ behaviours A. Cominola1, M. Giuliani1, D. Piga2, A. Castelletti1, A.E. Rizzoli3

1.  Department of Electronics, Information and Bioengineering – Hydroinformatics lab |Politecnico di Milano| Milano (IT) 2.  IMT Institute for Advanced Studies Lucca | Lucca (IT) 3.  Dalle Molle Institute for Artificial Intelligence Research, SUPSI | Manno (CH)

THE PROJECT

THE FHMM-ISDTW END-USE DISAGGREGATION ALGORITHM

LONDON | UK Thames Water water supply utility

15 million customers served

2.6 Gl/day drinking water distributed

Development plan: 3 Million smart meters installed by 2030!

LOCARNO | CH Società Elettrica Sopracenerina

power supply utility, 80 thousand customers served

Interested in multi-utility smart metering (water, energy, gas)

Almost 400 smart water meters installed! VALENCIA | ES EMIVASA water supply utility 2 million customers served

490,000 water smart meters currently installed

Development plan: 650,000 water smart meters installed by end 015.!

MISSION The mission of the SmartH2O project is developing an ICT platform to improve the management of urban and peri-urban water demand.

CONCEPT The SmartH2O platform ICT infrastructure will enable water managers to close the loop between actual water consumption levels and desired targets, through:

_ understanding and modeling water consumers’ behaviour, based on historical and real-time water usage data

_ predicting how the consumer behaviour can be influenced by various Water Demand Management Strategies, such as customized feedbacks and different pricing schemes

_ raising users’ awareness to pursue water reduction in the residential sector

CORE ELEMENTS

high-resolution water consumption data interaction with customers for information sharing and socio-psychographic data gathering innovative water demand management strategies: dynamic pricing, customized feedbacks and rewards gamification

OUR USE CASES

The SmartH2O project receives funding from the European Union’s Seventh Framework Programme (FP7/2007-2013)!

THE ADVANCES ON END-USES CHARACTERIZATION

Simplified structure of the SmartH2O platform

smart meters and end use analysis

gamified bill online and board game

behavioral modeling

water consumption drivers identification

water consumption level forecast at the customer scale

administrator dashboard

dynamic water pricing tailored feedbacks prescriptive norms

gamified bill

Response to WDMS

DEVELOPMENT OF A SYNTHETIC WATER END-USE PATTERNS GENERATOR An algorithm to generate synthetic water end-use patterns has been developed within the SmartH2O project, with the double purpose of: •  building end-use water consumption datasets to feed disaggregation algorithms and to provide benchmark datasets for community

testing; •  allowing for the generation of end-use patterns under different demographic and technological scenarios.

DEVELOPMENT PLAN •  User-friendly interface •  Web portal to contribute with new

datasets from different case studies

CURRENT FEATURES •  Trained on high-resolutions (1 second) consumption data from 9 cities across USA •  Performance validated with a two-sample Kolmogorov-Smirnov test •  Flexible for synthetic generation at multi-scale resolutions.

user’s input end-use statistics extraction end-use traces generation •  house size •  time sampling

resolution •  device

presence

usage duration usage volume time-of-use frequency of use typical pattern (signature)

An new algorithm to perform household energy and water consumption trace disaggregation into end-uses (e.g., washing machine, toilet, tap, etc…) has been developed, with the purpose of profiling users’ consumption habits based on the total single-point smart metered consumption.

CHALLENGES •  Accurately reproducing the consumption trajectory of different

end-uses, not only their operating system (i.e., on/off status) •  Performing disaggregation for a number of appliances

simultaneously operating.

ALGORITHM TECHNOLOGIES •  Factorial Hidden Markov Models •  Iterative Subsequence Dynamic Time Warping

APPLICATION OUTCOMES

Experiments on POWER data (1 min resolution) show high accuracy in

reproducing the consumption trajectory of

many end-uses simultaneously working

Preliminary experiments on WATER data (1 min resolution) show suitability in reproducing the contribution of each operating appliance to the total measured household consumption.

36 %

34 %

30 % 25 %

30 % 31 %

DROP! The SmartH2O game

Andrea Cominola [email protected]

@smartH2Oproject

#SmartH2O

time

water

co

nsum

ptio

n

5 Devices (indoor): toilet, clothes washer, showers, dishwasher, faucet

NRM

Generation of end-use water demand

The SmartH2O platform: advancing residential water management by smart metering and data intensive modeling of consumers’ behaviours A. Cominola1, M. Giuliani1, D. Piga2, A. Castelletti1, A.E. Rizzoli3

1.  Department of Electronics, Information and Bioengineering – Hydroinformatics lab |Politecnico di Milano| Milano (IT) 2.  IMT Institute for Advanced Studies Lucca | Lucca (IT) 3.  Dalle Molle Institute for Artificial Intelligence Research, SUPSI | Manno (CH)

THE PROJECT

THE FHMM-ISDTW END-USE DISAGGREGATION ALGORITHM

LONDON | UK Thames Water water supply utility

15 million customers served

2.6 Gl/day drinking water distributed

Development plan: 3 Million smart meters installed by 2030!

LOCARNO | CH Società Elettrica Sopracenerina

power supply utility, 80 thousand customers served

Interested in multi-utility smart metering (water, energy, gas)

Almost 400 smart water meters installed! VALENCIA | ES EMIVASA water supply utility 2 million customers served

490,000 water smart meters currently installed

Development plan: 650,000 water smart meters installed by end 015.!

MISSION The mission of the SmartH2O project is developing an ICT platform to improve the management of urban and peri-urban water demand.

CONCEPT The SmartH2O platform ICT infrastructure will enable water managers to close the loop between actual water consumption levels and desired targets, through:

_ understanding and modeling water consumers’ behaviour, based on historical and real-time water usage data

_ predicting how the consumer behaviour can be influenced by various Water Demand Management Strategies, such as customized feedbacks and different pricing schemes

_ raising users’ awareness to pursue water reduction in the residential sector

CORE ELEMENTS

high-resolution water consumption data interaction with customers for information sharing and socio-psychographic data gathering innovative water demand management strategies: dynamic pricing, customized feedbacks and rewards gamification

OUR USE CASES

The SmartH2O project receives funding from the European Union’s Seventh Framework Programme (FP7/2007-2013)!

THE ADVANCES ON END-USES CHARACTERIZATION

Simplified structure of the SmartH2O platform

smart meters and end use analysis

gamified bill online and board game

behavioral modeling

water consumption drivers identification

water consumption level forecast at the customer scale

administrator dashboard

dynamic water pricing tailored feedbacks prescriptive norms

gamified bill

Response to WDMS

DEVELOPMENT OF A SYNTHETIC WATER END-USE PATTERNS GENERATOR An algorithm to generate synthetic water end-use patterns has been developed within the SmartH2O project, with the double purpose of: •  building end-use water consumption datasets to feed disaggregation algorithms and to provide benchmark datasets for community

testing; •  allowing for the generation of end-use patterns under different demographic and technological scenarios.

DEVELOPMENT PLAN •  User-friendly interface •  Web portal to contribute with new

datasets from different case studies

CURRENT FEATURES •  Trained on high-resolutions (1 second) consumption data from 9 cities across USA •  Performance validated with a two-sample Kolmogorov-Smirnov test •  Flexible for synthetic generation at multi-scale resolutions.

user’s input end-use statistics extraction end-use traces generation •  house size •  time sampling

resolution •  device

presence

usage duration usage volume time-of-use frequency of use typical pattern (signature)

An new algorithm to perform household energy and water consumption trace disaggregation into end-uses (e.g., washing machine, toilet, tap, etc…) has been developed, with the purpose of profiling users’ consumption habits based on the total single-point smart metered consumption.

CHALLENGES •  Accurately reproducing the consumption trajectory of different

end-uses, not only their operating system (i.e., on/off status) •  Performing disaggregation for a number of appliances

simultaneously operating.

ALGORITHM TECHNOLOGIES •  Factorial Hidden Markov Models •  Iterative Subsequence Dynamic Time Warping

APPLICATION OUTCOMES

Experiments on POWER data (1 min resolution) show high accuracy in

reproducing the consumption trajectory of

many end-uses simultaneously working

Preliminary experiments on WATER data (1 min resolution) show suitability in reproducing the contribution of each operating appliance to the total measured household consumption.

36 %

34 %

30 % 25 %

30 % 31 %

DROP! The SmartH2O game

Andrea Cominola [email protected]

@smartH2Oproject

#SmartH2O

time

water

co

nsum

ptio

n

5 Devices: toilet, clothes washer, showers, dishwasher, faucet

Potential applications

NRM

End use characterization

NRM

Advanced management strategies

NRM

Projections of water demand: # inhabitants

NRM

Projections of water demand: device efficiency

- 40%

- 50%

- 2%

NRM

Conclusions

This preliminary results show great potential for supporting smart meters deployments and end-use water demand analysis.

Outlook:

1. Update of the database with new report by Aquacraft Inc.

2. Web service for community development

3. Creation of open database across countries

thank you

Matteo Giuliani [email protected]

http://giuliani.faculty.polimi.it