7/22/2019 Deutshce Bank National Trust Company v. Leigafoalii Tafue Williams

1/14

Bfsn 6

7/22/2019 Deutshce Bank National Trust Company v. Leigafoalii Tafue Williams

2/14

Bfsn 6

7/22/2019 Deutshce Bank National Trust Company v. Leigafoalii Tafue Williams

3/14

Bfsn 6-4.2

7/22/2019 Deutshce Bank National Trust Company v. Leigafoalii Tafue Williams

4/14

Bfsn 6, 6829 (9te Bir. 388;). I` f dfbtufj fttfbg Ww_enrn tenluriskibtim`fj issun is snpfrfcjn drmo ten onrits md ten bfsn, ten lukan ofy bm`siknrten nvikn`bn prnsn tnk wite rnspnbt tm ten luriskibtim`fj issun f`k rujn m` teftissun, rnsmjvi`a dfbtufj kisputns id`nbnssfry. [emr`eijj Xucj a Bm I`b. v An`

;

7/22/2019 Deutshce Bank National Trust Company v. Leigafoalii Tafue Williams

5/14

Bfsn 6 md 6; XfanjK 9; D.3k 128, 122 (9te Bir. 6919). I` sube bfsn, `mprnsuoptivn truteduj`nss fttfbens tm pjfi`tidds fjjnaftim`s, f`k ten nxistn`bn mdkisputnk oftnrifj dfbts wijj `mt prnbjukn ten trifj bmurt drmo nvfjufti`a dmr itsnjdten nxistn`bn md suclnbt ofttnr luriskibtim . Ik

Qenrn, emwnvnr,ten luriskibtim`fj issun f`k sucstf`tivn issuns frn smi`tnrtwi`nk teft ten qunstim` mdluriskibtim` is knpn`kn`tm` ten rnsmjutim` md dfbtufj issuns ami`a tm ten onrits, tenluriskibtim`fj kntnroi`ftim` semujk fwfit f kntnroi`ftim`md ten rnjnvf`t dfbts m` nitenr f omtim` ami`a tm tenonrits mr ft trifj.

Fuausti`n ^`itnk Rtftns 18; D.3k 681;, 6811 (9te Bir. 6952). Qenrn tenluriskibtim`fj issun f`k sucstf`tivn bjfios frn sm i`tnrtwi`nk teft rnsmjutim` md tenluriskibtim`fj qunstim` is knpn`kn`t m` dfbtufj issuns ami`a tm ten onrits, tenkistribt bmurt semujk nopjmy ten stf`kfrk fppjibfcjn tm f omtim` dmr suoofrylukaon`t. Futnry ^`itnk Rtftns ;3; D.2k 9;;,9>4 (9te Bir. 388>) (qumti`aSmsfjns ^`itnk Rtftns 53; D.3k 199, 582 (9te Bir. 6951))7 snn fjsm Fuausti`n18; D.3k ft 68117 Bfrnfu Arp ^`itnk Dfro Qmrgnrs 9;8 D.3k 6396, 6392 (9teBir. 6996). [en Bmurt oust tenrndmrn kntnroi n, vinwi`a ten nvikn`bn i` ten

jiaet omst dfvmrfcjn tm ten `m`omvi`a pfrty, wentenr tenrn frn f`y an`ui`n issunsmdoftnrifj dfbt Futnry ;3; D.2k ft 9>4 (qumti`a Ruzugi Omtmr BmrpBm`suonrs ^ im` us I`b 228 D.2k 6668, 6626 (9te Bir. 3882) (n` cf`n))7

>

7/22/2019 Deutshce Bank National Trust Company v. Leigafoalii Tafue Williams

6/14

Bfsn 6;3 ^.R. 6 66(388;). Bm`stitutim`fj stf`ki`a rnquirns ten pjfi`tidd tm semw teft ten bm`kubt mdweibe en bmopjfi`s efs bfusnk eio tm suddnr f` i`lury i` dfbt teft f dfvmrfcjnlukaon`t wijj rnkrnss. k ft 63. I` bmopfrism`, prukn`tifj stf`ki`an`bmopfssns ten an`nrfj prmeicitim` m` f jitiaf`t s rfisi`a f`mtenr pnrsm` s jnafjriaets. Ik. (bitftim` f`k qumtftim` sia`fjs moittnk)7 snn fjsm Mrnam` v. JnafjRnrvs. Bmrp., >>3 D.2k 94>, 916 (9te Bir. 3889).

[en Qijjifosns dfbtufjjy fttfbg Xjfi`tidd s prukn`tifj stf`ki`a tmdmrnbjmsn, fraui`a teft tenrn is `m nvikn`bn nstfcjisei`a teft Xjfi`tiddwfs vfjikjyfssia`nk ten Omrtafan f`k @mtn m` ten suclnbt prmpnrty. [en issun mdwentenrXjfi`tiddwfs vfjikjy fssia`nk ten Omrtafan f`k @mtn is i`nxtribfcjy i`tnrtwi`nk

4

7/22/2019 Deutshce Bank National Trust Company v. Leigafoalii Tafue Williams

7/14

Bfsn 6

wite ten onrits md ten Xjfi`tidds bjfios snngi`a tm dmrnbjmsn m` ten suclnbt prmpnrty-- teft is, Xjfi`tiddoust prmvn teft it wfs fssia`nk ten Omrtafan f`k @mtn cndmrn itefs ten fcijity tm dmrnbjmsn. Fs f rnsujt, ten bmurt kntnroi`ns wentenr ten nvikn`bnprnsn`tnk, vinwnk i` f jiaet omst dfvmrfcjn tm Xjfi`tidd, nstfcjisens f an`ui`n issunmdoftnrifj dfbt teft Xjfi`tiddwfs vfjikjy fssia`nk ten Omrtafan f`k @mtn. Rnn utnry ;3; D.2k ft 9>4.

[en cfsis md j i`tidds stf`ki`a tm dmrnbjmsn m` ten suclnbt prmpnrty(ft jnfst fs fjjnank i` ten Bmopjfi`t) is f Lf`ufry 62,3889 fssia`on`t md tenOmrtafan f`k @mtn drmoEmon 2 tm Xjfi`tidd. [en fssia`on`t, fttfbenk tm tenBmopjfi`t, prmvikns,enrni`fdtnr bfjjnk ten Fssia`nn.QI[@NRRN[E

7/22/2019 Deutshce Bank National Trust Company v. Leigafoalii Tafue Williams

8/14

Bfsn 619-58 (Cf`gr.K. Knj. 3889). Nddnbtivn Fuaust 6 3885, ten jiquikftim` pjf 5>-54 (bitftim`s moittnk). Aivn` teis jiquikftim , it fppnfrs teft Emon 632bmujk `mt efvn vfjikjy fssia`nk ten Omrtafan f`k @mtn tm Xjfi`tiddm` Lf`ufry 62,3889. F`k i` Mppmsitim , Xjfi`tiddprnsn ts `m nvikn`bn (mr nvn` frauon`t)nxpjfi`i`a emw teis Lf`ufry 62,3889 fssia`on`t is vfjik knspitn Emon 632 scf`gruptby f`k jiquikftim`. I` dfbt, Xjfi`tidd frauns -- witemut dfbtufj suppmrt teft @B Bfpitfj Bmrpmrftim` ( @B Bfpitfj ) dirst cmuaet ten @mtn drmo Emon 632f`k Xjfi`tiddsucsnqun`tjy rnbnivnk it termuae f snburitiznk trust. Rnn XI. sMpp ft 38. F`k ft ten enfri`a, Xjfi`tidd s bmu`snj i`nxpjibfcjy stftnk teft kisbmvnry is

5

7/22/2019 Deutshce Bank National Trust Company v. Leigafoalii Tafue Williams

9/14

Bfsn 6

7/22/2019 Deutshce Bank National Trust Company v. Leigafoalii Tafue Williams

10/14

Bfsn

7/22/2019 Deutshce Bank National Trust Company v. Leigafoalii Tafue Williams

11/14

Bfsn 6, ft > (K. Efw. Ofy 3>,3866), -- weibe i`vmjvnk ten sfon pfrtins i` teisfbtim` f`k i` weibe Jni Qijjifos fssnrtnk fddiroftivn bjfios fafi`st KnutsbenCf`g BeindLukan Rusf` Mgi Omjjwfy nxpjfi`nk ten kiddnrn`bn cntwnn` ten twm5, 4 (>te Bir. 3886) ( [en bmurt s kisoissfj mdf pjfi`tidd s bfsncnbfusn ten pjfi`tiddjfbgs suclnbt ofttnr luriskibtim` is `mt f kntnroi`ftim` md tenonrits f`k kmns `mt prnvn`t ten pjfi`tidddrmo pursui`a f bjfio i` f bmurt teft kmnsefvn prmpnr luriskibtim`. )7 Driafrk v ^`itnk Rtftns 543 D.3k 386 38; (9te Bir.6955) ( Mrki`frijy, f bfsn kisoissnk dmr jfbg md suclnbt ofttnr luriskibtim` semujkcn kisoissnk witemut prnlukibn sm teft f pjfi`tiddofy rnfssnrt eis bjfios i` f

3

7/22/2019 Deutshce Bank National Trust Company v. Leigafoalii Tafue Williams

13/14

Bfsn 6

7/22/2019 Deutshce Bank National Trust Company v. Leigafoalii Tafue Williams

14/14

Bfsn 6