7/27/2019 Deutsche Bank asks the CA Supreme Court Justices to depublish the Glaski case.

1/12

? ==7--478-:47> CM@M15 BCCGNM =:6= YJHM 94

Lbrhja, E m w g s ~ . Dbnket!^ EEY:9: Yjre: JvmaumAmw Wbrk, AW :9::9-9939Pme. 4:4.>97.3999Cjx? 4:4.>97.399:www.lbrhjaemwgs,nbl

Dmrajr` O. Hjrdutt Gee(4:4) >973960d h j r d u e t I l j r ~ j a e m w g s . n b l

Bntbfmr 8, 49:>

Nfgmc Oustgnm Pjag H. Njatge.^jkjuymja` tfm Jssbngjtm Oustgnms^uprmlm Nburt bc Njegcbragj>=9 LnJeegstmr ^trmmt^ja C r j a n g ~ n b , NJ 70 :94-0878Tm? Tmqumst cbr @mpudegnjtg5lHejs G` v, Djak bcJlmrgnj, A.J., mt je.,

Lbrhja Emwgs

NB]TP BC JYYMJEceCPF JYYtEEJgC. @G^PTGNPr C T G M ~ ~ ~ X G M G B e

BNP 9 6 49:>

NjOgcbrag??g- NbeOrt bcJppmje, Cgctf Jppmeejtm @ g s t r ~ ; t - Hj=m Ab. CBH0==5).Pb; Pfm Fbab.rjdem Nfgmc Oustgnm ja` Jssbngjtm Oustgnms bc tfm Njegcbragj ^uprmlm NburtXm rmprmsmat @mutsnfm Djak Ajtgbaje Prast Nblpjay, sbem.ey ga .gts njpjngty js trustmm (tfm"Prustmm") bc tfm rmemvjat rmsg`matgje lbrthjhm-djnkm` ("TLD^") trusts, js j mcma`jat gr: tfmnjsms Tcge.e!lgr!R.WR,@mutsnfm Djpk Ajt' e Prust Nb., Ab. :9-nv-8=>: (EP^) (^.OO.A .W. ), ba jppmje,:>-:3:0-nv (4nU Ngr.) ("Tc!gjlga") ja` Prja. v. e>j::k bc Amw Wbrg5;, Ab. :>-nv-=69 (TYY)(^.@.A.W.) ("cua").Xgtf jee `um rmspmnt tb tfm Nburt bc Jppmje, Cgctf @gstrgnt, Njegcbragj (tfm "Nbg.:rt"), wm wrgtm tbrmqumst mpudegnjtgba bc fm Nburt's bpgakl ga Hehgskg v. D.jak ZcJ:::s;.rgnj, A.J .. mt je., 4:6 Nje.Jpp. 0::: :987, 49:> XE 09>8>:9, g ~ s u m ` ba Ouey >:, 49:> ja` nmrtgcgm` cbr pudegnjtgba baJuhust 6, 49:> (tfm "Bpgagba"). Pfgs rmqumst gs lj`m pursujat tb Tugn bc Nburt 6.e :4=.

Djnkh:bua`Ga Hejskg, tfm pejgatgceelbrthjhbr drbg.:hft j wrbahcue cbrmnebsurm nejgl jhjgast ja TLD^trustmm, jlbah btfmrs, rmejtgah tb tfm ab::"ou`g`je cbrmnebsurm upba pejgatgcts lbrthjhm ebja. Gasul, tfm p dgatgcc jeemhm` tfjt tfm "jttmlptm`" jssghalmat bcfgs lbrthjhm ebja tb ja TLD^ trustwjs lj`m jctmr tfm nebsgah `jtm ga tfm pbbegah ja` smrvgngah jhrmmlmat (tfm "Y^J") cbr tfjtTLD^ trust, ja`, tfmrmcbrm, tfm jssghalmat wjs gamc!?nntgvm. :::m pejgatgcc jrhum` tfjt tfgs`mprgvm` tfm pjrty tfjt fj` cbrmnebsm` upba fgs lb:thjhm ebja bc tfm stja`gah tb `b sb dmnjusm gtwjs ::9: tfm t:um bw::mr bc fgs ebja. Pfm trgje nburt `gslgssm` 5::: bc pejgatgcc's nejgls. Pfm N()urtrmvmrsm`.Pfm Nburt cbua` tfjt j lbrthjhbr (wfb b d v g b u ~ e y wjs abt j pjrty tbbt' j tfgr`-pjrty dmamcgngjrybc tfm jhrmmlmats jt gssum tfmrm) fj` stja`gahU() nfjeemahm ja jeemhm` mcmnt g:: ja jssghalmat gctfm `mcmnt rma`mrm` tfm jssghalmat vbg`, ja` !e()t lmrmey vbg`jdem. !)ejskg, 49:> XE 09>8> e 9(fnm`ajctnr, "yejskg"), jt *7":9. Pfm Nburt amxt jajeyz.m` wfmtfmr tfm jssghalmat wjs "vbg`."Cbr tfgs purpbsm, tfm Nburt jssulm` (jedmgt ganbrrmntey) tfjt tfm TLD^ trust wjs cbrlm` ua`mrAmw Wbrk ejw. Hejskg, jt * 9. Pfm Nburt tfus cbua` tfjt Amw Wbrk ejw hbvmram` tfm

7/27/2019 Deutsche Bank asks the CA Supreme Court Justices to depublish the Glaski case.

2/12

:9/96/49:> :>?06 ==7--478-:47> CM@M15 BCCGNM =:6= YJHM 9>

Nfgmc Oustgnm Pjag H. N j a t g e ~ ^ j k j u y nja` tfm Jssbngjtm .Oustgnms Lbrhja EmwgsBntbdmr 8, 49 e > N B t e A ~ e e ' - B T ^ ::r EJXYjhm 4bpmrjtgba bc tfm trust, ja` tfma mxjlgam` tfm Amw Wbrk Mstjtm6, Ybwmrs & Prusts Ejw ("AWMYPE"), ja` spmngcgnjeey ^mntgba 8-4.0 tfmrmbc. ^mntgba 8"4.0 prbvg`ms tfjt? "Pc tfm trust gsmxprmssm` ga ja .gastrulmat nrmjtgah tfm nstggEm bc tfm trustmm, mvmry sjem, nbavmyjanm br btfmr jntbc tfm trustmm ga nbatrjvmatgba bc tfm trust, mxnmpt js jutfbrgz.m` dy tfgs jrtgnem ja` dy jay btfmrprbvgsgba bcejw, gs vbg`.'' Glpbrtjatey, tfm Nburt m n b h a g ~ ? m ` tfjt tfm purpbsm bctfgs prbvgsgbawjs tb prbtmnt trust dmamcgng.eO.rgms crbl uajutfbrgz,m` jntgbas dy tfm ttustmm. Hejskg, jt * B.Pfm NN1urt tfma rmjsbam` tfjt dmnjusm tfm TLD^ trust wjs n.rnjtm` dy j Y^J wgtf j nebsgah `jtmjcgmr wfgnf tfm trust nbue` ab ebahmr jnnmpt lbrthjhm ebja?1, AW MYPE 8-4.0 prbvg`m` j emhjedjsgs cbr nbaneu`gah tfjt tfm TLD^ trustmm's jttmlpt tb ''jnnmpt" pejgateecs lbrthjhm ebja jctmrtfm nebsgah `jem wbue` dm vbg` js ja jnt ga nbatrjvmatgba bc tfm trust `bnulmat (o,g;;,R, tfm Y^J).Hejskg, jt" ::. Djsm` upba tfm cbrmhbgah, tfm Nblt nbaneu`m` tfjt tfm pejgatgccfj` succgngmateystjtm` j djsgs cbr nbaneu`gah tfjt tfm jssghalmat wjs vbg`, tfus `mprgvgah tfm pjrty tfjt drbuhfttfm aba-ou`gngje cbrmnebsurm bc tfm stja`gah tb `b sb.

* *Xm abtm tfjt j Amw Wbrk trgje nburt `mngsgba upba wfgnf .Hejskg rmegm`, 'o/mees G.?jrhb Djaen AJ.v. ptbdbdb, Ab. >:306/97, 49:> XE :6>:877 (^up. Nt. Kgahs Nty. Jpr. 47, 49:>), fjs dmmajppmjem` tb tfm Amw Wbrk Jppmeejtm @gvgsgba, ^mnba` @mpjrtlmat. : Xm jesb abtm tfjt tfm`mngsgba hrjatgah tfm Prustmm's lbtgba tb `gslgss ga tfm Tjojh:g:: neU^N rmcmrmanm` jdbvm4 gsnurrmatey ba jppmje tb tfm ^mnba` Ngrnugt Nburt bc Jppmjes, gs cueey drgmcm`, ja` gs jerm.j`ysnfm`uem` cbr brje jrhulmat (Bge Abvmldmr 49, 49:>). Jesb, ga tfm Prja njsm rmcmrmanm` jdbvm,`mcma`jats fjvm cgem` j lbtgba tb `gslgss. Ga dbtf bc tfmsm twb njsms, tfm pejgatgccs fjvm rjgsm`AW MYPE 8-4.0 ja` rmegm` upba Zejskg. Pfus, Amw Wb`5. nburts ljy sfbrtey dm nbasg`mrgahgssums nbanmragah tfm AW MYPE tfjt wmrm (js mxpejgam` dmebw, uaamnmssjrgey) `mng`m` ga Hegg\Z.Cbr tfm r m j ~ b a s `mlbastrjtm` dmebw, tfm Hejskg Bpgagba sfbue` dm `mpudegsfm`.G. PFM HEJ^KeNB]TP MTTM@ GA JYYEWGAH AMX WBTK PT]^P EJXPfm Bpgagba sfbue` dm nenpudegsfm` dmnjusm gt gs, cbr jee gatmats ja` purpbsms, tfm mqugvjemat bcja j`vgsbry bpgagba nbanmragah Amw Wbrk ejw-j::` gt hmgts Amw Wbrk ejw wrbah. Pfm Nburtamvmr amm`m` tb `mevm gatb ja gatmrprmtjtgL bc tfm AW MYPE dmnjusm tfm djsgs cbr tfjt cbrjy wjsganbrrmnt-tfm Y^J jt gssum ga Yejskg wjs :e.Z: hbvmram` dy Amw Wbrk ejw. Pfm Y^J, wfgnf gsjvjgejdem ba tfm ^MN's wmdsgtm, > stjtms tfjt tfm TLe>^ trust jt gssum ga Hejskg gs j @mejwjrm^tjtutbry Prust, brhjagzm` ua`mr tfm @mejwjrm ^tjtut(Ory Prusts ^tjtutm, !P@me. Nb`m J::a. >69:, mt h?,ZR,, ja` gs hbvmram` dy @mejwjrm ejw. ^mg5,, 1f&, Y^J :9.9=. Abr `g` tfm Nburtjppmjr tb fjvm tfm dmamcgt bc drgmcgah ba tfm AW MYPE gss:.:m prgbr t( ) rma`mrgah tfm Bpgagba.0

. ~ A.W. Jppmeejtm @gvdgba, ^mn.ba` @mpjrtlmat, Jppmje Ab. 49:>-93763.Tjgjraga v. Znutsnfm Djak Ajt'G.Prust R Nb., Ab. :9-nv-8=>.e, 49:> XE :46=:39(^.@.A.W. Ljr. 46, 49 O >).

> ^ n 5 ~ fttp?//www.smn.hbv/ Jrnfgvms/m`hjr/nejtj/:>08>0=/999:48848893999990/psj499=.jrO 8.p`c.'G Pfgs Amw Wbrk trust Ojw gssum `bn6 abt jppmjr tb fjvm dmma j``rmssm` ga tfm pjrtgms'(Nbatgaum` abtm)

7/27/2019 Deutsche Bank asks the CA Supreme Court Justices to depublish the Glaski case.

3/12

:9/96/49:> :>?06 ==7--478-:47> CM@M15 BCCGNM =:6= YJHM 90

Nfgmc Oustgnm Pjag H. Njatge-^jkjuymja` tfm Jssbngjtm Oustgnms Lbrhja EmwgsNZ]A^" ! e O , 9 : U 6 !t 'c EJXBntbdmr 8, 49:>Yjhm >

]. GA JAW MSMAP, :'FM HEJ^ Ke YEJGAPGCC EJNKM@ ^PJA@GAH PBJ^^MTP JAW NEJGL DJ^K@ ]YBA JEEMHM@ ABANBLYEGJANMXGPFPFMY^J

Mvma g c Amw Wbrk ejw jppegm` tb tfm Hejskg pejgatgccs nejgls (ja` .gt `bns abt), tfm Hejskgpejgatgcc stgee ejnkm` stja`gah tb drgah jte'grljtgvm nejgls djsm` upba jeemhm` abanblpegjanm wgtftfm jeemhm` rmqugrmlmats bc tfm Y^J. Gc fm jhrmmlmat jt gssum (g.m., tfm Y^J) wjs hbvmram` dyAmw Wbrk ejw, tfma Amw Wbrk dw wbue` jesb hbvmra wfgnf p j r t g m ~ fjvm p:::`matgje stgl`gah tbjssmrt j n.ejgl djsm` upnRga tfm Y^J (tfjt gs, baey pjrtgms tb tfm Y^J br tfgr`-pjrty dmamcgngjrgmstfmrmbc). Wmt, js bam @gstrgnt Nburt ga Amw Wbrk rmnmatey abtm`, wfma gatmg:,rntgah Y^Js tfjtc!rnjntujeey hbvmram` dy Amw Wbrk ejw, "[t\fm wmghft bcnjsmejw tfrbuhfbut tfm nbuatry fbe`s tfjta aba-pjrty tb tfm Y^J ejnks stja`gah tb jssmrt abanblpegjanm wgtf tfm Y^J js j nejgl br`mcmasm uaemss tfm ::9::-pjrty gs ja gatma m` (abt lmrmey gang`matje) tfgr` pjrty dmamcgngjry bctfmY^J." T.Zggglga, 49:> XE :46=:39, jt >,Pfgs jnnbr`s wgtf tfm wmee-smttem` prgangpem bc Amw Wbrk Ujw tfjt j egtghjat tfjt gs amgtfmr j pjrtytb, abr ja gatma`m` tfgr`-pjrty dmamcgngjry bc, ja jhrmmlmat ejnks stja`gah tb nblpejga jdbutjeemhm` abanblpegjanm wgtf tfm jhrmmlmat's prbvgs.gbas. );::5 Yrmlgeee'te. Lbrth. n;bl. v, Mqugcjxean., =6> C.>` G9>, .U 96 (4` Ngr. 4997); Kjrjlj,:)}R v. ].^. D:lk, A.J., Ab. e e-nv-:==8, 49:4 XE0>483:>, *8 (DO).A.W. Juh. 47, 49:4), O?1Og;1Brt ja` rmnbllma`jtgba j`bptm`, 49:4 XE 0>48=94(M.@.A.W. ^mpt. 49, 49:4); .Ngllmrga&.?W"""Lnrr]G Eyanf Lbrth. Gavmstbrs, Gan., Ab. 6848:::,49:4 Xt 4>>4>=6, *7 (^up. Nt. A.W. Nty. Ouam :>, 49:4) (`gslgssgah `mnejrjtbry ou`hlmatnejgl tfjt wjs prmlgsm` upba `mcma`jat TLD^ trustmm's abanblpegjanm wgtf j Y^J dmnjusmpejgatgccs ejnkm` stja`gah tb jssmrt sunf j nejgl hgvma tfjt "tfmy [wmrm\ abt pjrtgms tb [tfm\nbatrjnt, [ja` `g` abt\ jeemhm tfjt tfmy [wmrm\ tfgr`-pjrty dmamcgngjrgms tb tfm jhrmmlmat.").Cbr mxjlpem, ga Kj.tjljtf, tfm pejgatgccs lbrthjhm ebja wjs nbavmym` tb ja TLD^ trustmm g:spjrt bc j TLD^ smnurgtgzjtgba trjasjntgba. 49:4 XE 0>483:>, *G. Jctmr pejgatgcc mcjuetm batfjt ebja, cbrmnebsurm prbnmm`gahs jhjgast tfm pejgatgcc's lbrthjhm e b ~ g a wmrm gastgtutm` ga tfmajlm bctfn TLD^ trustmm. Yejgatgcc drbuhft j smpjrjtm jntgba jssmrtgah n j u s m ~ bc jntgba jhjgasttfm TLD^ t r u ~ t m m smmkgah tb smt jsg`m tfm jssgha:::mat bc fmr lbrthjhm ja` tb maobga tfmcbrmnebsurm prbnmm`gah. Kjrjljtf, 49:4 XE 0>483:>, *4. Yej.gatgcc jeemhm` tfjt tfm TLD^trustmm fj` ab emhje br mqugtjdem gatmrmst ga fmr lbrthjhm ebja dmnjusm tfm nbavmyjanm bc tfmebja gatb tfm TLD^ trust wjs gavjeg` ua`mr tfm prbvgsgbas bc tfm jppegnjdem Y^J. G`., 8. PfmNburt `gslgssm` tfm pejgatgcc's nejgls, abtgah tfjt "pejgatgcc gs abt j pjrty tb tfm Y^J br tb tfmJssghalmat bc Lbrthjhm, ja` gs abt j tfgr`-pjrty dmamcgngjry bc g t . f ~ r , ja` tfmrmcbrm fjs abbrghgaje drgmcs (wfgn.f jrm jvjgf:d!m ba Xmstejw). Ymr gts baegam `bnkmt, gt jesb jppmjrs tfjt tfmNburt suj spbatm tfma jskm` tfm pjrtgms tb j``rmss tfgs gssum jt Ze"jU jrhulmat, dut `g` abtrmqumst-ja` `g` abt rmnmgvm-c'drtfnr drgmcgah ba tfm g>^EGN prgbr t(.) rma`mrgah tfm Bpgagba.Xfmtfmr br abt tfgs prbnm`urm nblpbrtm` wgtf Nje. Hbvt, Nb`m 3696:, . m ~ YmbggegEUG". Jegnm, 0:Nje.0tf 336, 387 (4998) (fbe`gah tfjt brje jrhulmat jebam wjs ja gasuccgngmat bppbrtuagty cbr tfmpjrtgms tb j``rmss ja gssum), gt `g` abt prbvg`m tfm Nburt wgtf j`mqujtmey `mvmebpm` jrhulmatswjrrjatgah j pudegsfm` bpgagba ba tfgs Amw W .)rk trust ejw gssum.

7/27/2019 Deutsche Bank asks the CA Supreme Court Justices to depublish the Glaski case.

4/12

:9/96/49:> :>?06 ==7--478-:47>

Nfgmc u s t g ~ m Pjag H. Njatge-^jkjuymja` tfm Jssbngjtm OustgnmsBntbdmr 8, 49:>Yjhm 0

CM@M15 BCCGNM =:6= YJHM 9=

eU!ebrhja Emwgs

stja`gah tb nfjeemahm tfm vjeg`gty b c t f ~ t jhrmmlmat br tfm jssghalmat." G`. Js mxpejgam` lbrmtg.egey dmebw, tfm Nburt jesb rmomntm` ja` `gslgssm` tfm pejgatgcc"s nejgl tfjt tfm jssghalmat bc fmrlbrthjhm ebja wjs gavjeg` dmnjusm gt `.g` abt nblpey wgtf tfm AW MYPE. G`.Pfm Hejskg pejgatgcc .ga`gsputjdey gs abt j pjrty tb tfm Y^J jt gssum ga tfjt njsm. Abr `bms gtjppmjr tfjt fm mvma nen:glm` tb dm. Pfus, fm ljy rmey upra tfm Y^J baey gc fm wjs nemjrey ja,gatma`m` tfgr`-pjrty dmamcgngjry bc tfm Y^J. Y:mlgul Lbrth. NZ!Z.n, =6> C.>` jt :96 (tfgr`pjrty stjtus baey mxgsts gc tfm tmrls bc tfm jhrmmln::t "nemjrey nvg`mbnm ja gatmat tb pmrlgtmacbrnmlmat dy tfm tfgr` pjrty.") (qubtjtgba blgttm`); cu!g::lga, 49 e > XE :46=:39, jt *>. Pfjtwjs abt tfm njsm mgtfmr. Js sunf, tfm Nburt sfbue` fjvm fme` tfjt Efm !\ejskg pejgatgcc's nejglswmrm prbpmrey gslgssm` dmnjusm tfmy wmrm jee djsm` upba jeemhm` abanblpegjanm wgtf tfm Y^J.Ga`mm`, j "ou`gngje nb::snasus djs `mvmebpm` fbe`gah tfjt j dbrrbwmr ejnks stja`gah tb (G)nfjeemahm tfm vjeg`gty bcj lbrthjhm smnurgtgzjtgba br (4) rmqumst j ou`gngje `mtmrlgajtgba tfjt jebja jssghalmat gs gavjeg` `U.tm tb abanblpegjanm wgtf j pbbegah ja` smrvgngah jhrmmlmat, wfmatfm dbrrbwmr gs amgtfmr j pjrty tb abr j tfgr pjrty dglmcgndry bc tfm smb::rgtgzjtgba jhrmmlmat."Oa rm XOOOkh?, 033 D.T. 48:, 46= (Djakr. M.@ ..Yj. 49:4). Pfgs jppmjrs tb dm tfm prmvjgegah vgmwbc cm`mrje nburts ga Njegcbragj jesb. HUedmrt v. Nfjsm Fblm..c.Oajanm, E E , ~ , Ab. :>-nv-43=, 49:>XE 4>:6679, *> (N@. Nje. Ljy 46, 49:>) ("J ljobrgty bc `gstrk.t nburts fjvm fme` tfjtpejgatgccs wfb jrm abt pjrtgms tb j Y^J `b abt fjvm stja`gah tb rjgsm vgbejtgbas bc j Y^J br tbbtfmrwgsm d:cbh nejgls ba tfm djsgs tfjt j Y^J wjs vgbejtm`."); .^e jesb Ljyajr` v. Cmees ChrhZ\>jae5, A.J, :4-nv-:0>=, 49:> XE 066>494, *e 9-:: (^,@. Nje. ^mpt. ::, 49:>); c.elutjrrmd v.Djak bcA.W. Prust Nb.,O;O,oU., Ab. :4-nv->93:, 49:4 XE 0>8:0:9, *4 (A.@. Njt ^mpt. 40,49:4) (fbe`gah t f ~ : t "dmnjusm Yejgatgccs wmrm abt pjrtgms tb tfm Y^J, tfmy ejnk stja`gah tbnfje enahn tfm vjeg`gty bc fm smnurgtgzjtgba prbnmss, ganeu`gah wfmtfmr tfm ebja trjascbr bnngln`butsg`m bc tfm tmlpbrje dbel`s prmsnrgdm` dy tfm Y ^ J ! ' ) . ~ 'Lbrabvmr, mvmry cm`mrje jppmeejtm nburt bpgagba tcjtt tfm Prustmm's n(lra;mO nbue` g`matgcy tfus cjrtfjt fjs jntujeey `mng`m` tfgs gssum fas fme` tfjt j pejgg:tgccelbrthjhbr ejnks stj::`gah tb drgah jajccgrljtgvm nejgl nfjeemahgah tfm jssghalmat bc fmr br fgs lbrthjhm ebja tfjt gs djsm` upbajeemhm` abanblpegjanm wgtf j Y^J. 3

^m.!5 jesb Dmrajr`g v. Zmutsnfm Duak Ajt. Prust Nb.,Jl., Ab. :e-nv-=0=>, 49:> XE:3>46=, *0 (AO). Nje. Oja. :=, 49:>); @g::!: v. Ngtgdjak, O'g,J.., Ab e 4-nv-:=94, 49:> XE 69:=9,*> (N.@. Nje. Oja. 8, 49:>).3 ^mm TmUa.jhme v. @mutsnfr?; .Djak Ajt'! P r e O . ~ t Nb., 844 C.>` 899, 896 (=tf Ngr . .Ouey ::,49:>) (`gslgssgah nejgl dy pejgatgcc/lbrthjhbr jhjgast TLD^ trustmm smmkgah tb maobga jt'brnnebwrm dusm` upba tfm tfmbry tfjt tfm lra'thjhn jssghalmat wjs gavjeg` dmnjusm gt wjsrmnbr`m` jctmr tfm nebsgah `jtm ga tfm Y^J; dmnjusm "(pejgatgccs\ nbanm`m tfjt tfmy jrm abt [j\pjrty tb tfm Y^J, tfmy fjvm ab rghft tb macbrnm gts tmrls uaemss tfmy jl gts gatma`m tfgr`-pjrtydmamcgngjrgms."); Tbdgasba v. ^memnt YbrtcbeEb ^nrv'h, Gan., Ab. :4-:836, 49:> XE :09=49:, >.0(3tf Ngr ..Jpr. 7, 49:>) (pejgatgcc/lbrthjhbrs ejnkm` stja`gah tb jeemhm uacjgr prjntgnms jhjgastTLD^ trustmm nfjeemahgah tfm jssghalmat bc tfmgr lbrthjhm (djsm` upba j tfmbry tfjt tfmgrlbrthjhm wjs jeemhm`ey j``m` tb tfm TLD^ trust jctmr tfm nebsgah `jtm spmngcgm` ga Y^J)dmnjusm tfmy wmrm abt pjrtgms tb, br tfgr`-pjrty dmamcgngjrgms br; tfm jssghalmat br Y^J); ^lgte:(Nbatgaum` abtm)

7/27/2019 Deutsche Bank asks the CA Supreme Court Justices to depublish the Glaski case.

5/12

? ==7--478-:47>

Nfgmc Oustgnm Pjag H. Njatge-^jkjuymja` tfm J^$Bngjtm OustgnmsBntbdmr 8, 49:>Yjhm =

CM@M15 BCCGNM =:6= YJHM 9=

Lbrhja Emwgs

et gs jesb abtmwbrtfy tfjt tfm Nburt ga H:::skg rmegm` upba j sg::hem Amw Wbrk trgje nburt `mngsgbaeb suppbrt gts cga`gah tfjt j pejgatgcc nja jssmrt ja jccgrljtgvm nejgl djsm` upba jeemhm`abanblpegjanm wgtf tfm jeemhm` rmqugrmlmats bc j Y^J. ~ . G v ' mees Cjrhb Djak, A.J. v. Mrbdbdb,Ab. >:306/97, 49:> XE :6>:877 (^up. Nt. Kgahs Ney. Jpr. 47, 49:>). OObwnvmr, tfm `mngsgba gaDrbdbdZ `bm$ abt stja` cbr tfjt prbpbsgtgba. Pfmrm, tfm lbrthjhbr wjs abt ,:4, pejgatgcc s s m g g g ~ h jnjusm bc jntgba djsm` upba jeemhm` abanblpegjanm wgtf j Y^J; fm wjs j `mcma`jat l jcbrmnebsurm jntgba, drbg.:hft ga tfm ajlm bc ja TLD^ trustbm, wfb wjs jssmrtgah ja jccgrljtgvm`mcmasm. Ga tfjt nbatmx?E, tfm pejgatgcc TLD^ tlstmm lbvm` cbr sulljry ou`hlmat, ja` tfusdbrm tfm dur`ma bc prbvgah t f ~ U t tfmrm wmrm ab qumstgbas bc cjnt tfjt gt ga`mm` bwam` tfmpejgatgcc/lbrthjhbr's lbrthjhm ebja. Pfm `mcma`jats ga Zejskg dbrm ab sunf dur`m.a. 8Lba??bvnr, MaOdbdb (wfgnf gs ba jppmje) gs nbatrjry tb 9:;fmr, lbrm wmee-rmjsbam` Amw Wbrknjsms tfjt mspbusm tfm bvmrwfmelgah ljobrgty vgmw. e > ~ : l ? g g a , 49:> XE :46=:39, jt *>;v. Egttba g.,bja ^mrvgngah. EY, Ab. :4-.:360, 49.:> XE 6660=4, *4 (3tf Ngr. Ljr. :4, 49:>)(`gslgssgah nejgls jssmrtgah tfjt TLD^ trustmm `g` abt bwa pejgatgccs lbrthjhm ebja dmnjusmjssghalmat bc tfm lbrthjhm tb tfm trust bnnurrm` jckr tfm nebsgah `jtm spmngcgm` ga tfm Y^J;pejgatgcc ejnkm` stja`gah tb jssmrt sunf nejgls dmnjusm fm ''wjs amgtfmr j pjrty abr j tfgr`-pjrtydmamtgngjry tb tfm [Y^J\, sb mvma gc gts tmrls wmrm vgbejtm`, [pejgatgcc\ ljy abt nfj.eemahnnblpegjanm wgtf tfm [Y^JO"); Kjljtnfmv^! v. OY Lbrhja N d t e ~ ~ Djak, A.J., 890 C.>` =0=, =08(6tf Ngr. 49:>) (pejgatgOc/ltgrthjhbrs ejnk stja`gah tb 5nssnrt j `mnejrjtbry ou`hlmat nejglnfjeemahgah tfm Lsghalmat? bc tfmgr lbrthjhm ebja djsm` :.:pba jeemhm` abanblpegjanm wgtf jY^J dmnjusm tfmy jrm abt pjrtgms tb, br tfgr`-pjrty dmamcgngjrgms bc, tfm Y^J); : d ~ b a g j Yrhps.P-ebe`gtgh!f.EEN v, : g ~ 0 9 - O 4 7 8 3 O ' . r y ? l g a h t b : : 'T`. Fbe`gahs, EEN, >77 C. Jpp'x 78, :94-9> (3tfNgr. 49 G 9) (j pegggatgcc/lbrthjhbr "wfb gs abt j pjrty tb jssghalmat" ejnks stja`gah tbnfjeemahm j `mcma`jat's bw::mrsfgp bc tfmgr lbrthjhm ebja djsm` upba abanblpegjanm wgtf jY^J tfjt g:eenhn`ey !'m::`nrn` jssghalmat gavjeg`); Ga rm?O;;bbk, 0=8 C.>` =3:, =38-36 (3tf Ngr.4993) (`gslgssgah pejgatgccs nejgl jhjgast TLD^ treestnn smmkgah j `mnejrjtgba tfjt tfm trustmm`g` abt fjvm j pmrcmntm` smnurgty gatmrmst ga tfm prbpmrty dmnjusm bc cgeemhn` abanblpegjanm wgtftfm "Prust Jhrmmlmat," wfgnf rmqugrm` tfm jssghalmat tb dm rmnbr`m , dmnjusm pejgatgcc ejnkm`stja`gah tb macbrnm tfm Prust Jhrmmlmat); Ga rm ee??c.jrks, Ab. :4-nv-::09, 49:4XE3==089=,":9(7tf Ngr. D.J.Y. @mn. :0, 49 e 4) (pejgatgcc/lbrthjhbr ejnkm` stja`gah tb jssmrt nejgl jhjgastTLD^ trastmm nfjeemahgah tfm vjeg`gty bc ja jssghalmat nc fmr l b r t h ~ h m ebja gatb TLD^ trastdmnjusm jssghalmat bnnurrm` jctmr nebsgah `jtm spmngcgm` ga Y^J); Ga rm Nbrrmgj, 0=4 D.T. jt >40-4= (`gslgssgah pejgatgcc/lbrthjhbrs' nejgl jhjgast TLF^ trustmU? nfjeemahgah llthjhmjssghalmat tb TLD^ trust djsm` upba jeemhm` abanblpegjanm wgtf tfm Y^J dmnjusm pejgatgccsejnkm` stjO:`gah tb jssmrt sunf j nejgl; $tja`gah m q u g r m l m a t . ~ lja`jtm tfjt j egtghj::t jssmrt baeygts bwa rghfts ja` abt tfbsm bc j tfgr` pjrty).8 Bam nburt's jpt mxpejajtgb:: bc tfm stja`gah nbanmpt `gstgahugsfms tfm sgtujtgba prmsmatmga Mrbdbda crbl tfm bam jt gssum ga Hejskg. ^tem Cgeegjras v. Tgnkjr`, Ab. 97-nv-=>=, 49:: XE4::377=, *= (@. Fjw. Ljy 4=, 49::) ("Pfm djaks ammne abt mstjdegsf tfg:t tfmy jrm tfm emhjetgwamrs bc [pejgatgccs\ eb::as dmcbrm tfmy `mcma` jhjgast [pejgatgccs\ nejgls. '^tja`gah' gs jpejgatgccs rmqugrmlmat, ja` [pejgatgcte lgsnbastrums tfm nbanmpt ga jrhugah tfjt @mcbg:`jats lustmstjdegsf 'stja`gah' tb `mcma` tfna:s9evns.").

7/27/2019 Deutsche Bank asks the CA Supreme Court Justices to depublish the Glaski case.

6/12

:9/96/49:> :>?06 ==7--478-:47>

Nfgmc.Oustgnm Pjag H. Njatge-^jkjuymja` tfm Jssbngjtm OustgnmsBntbdmr 8, 49:>Yjhm 3

CM@M15 BCCGNM =:6= YJHM 98

Lbrhja EmwgsN B ] 2 ' e ~ c U : . 9 T . ~ ~ ' t ' EJX

Kjrjljtf, 49:4 XE 0>483:>, *8; Ngllmrgah, 49:4 XE 4>>4>=6, *7. Jnnbrnegahey, ua`mr AmwWbrk ejw, tfm Hejskg pejgatgccejnkm` stja`gah tb jssmrt ja jccgrljtgvm nejgl djsm` upba jeemhm`abanblpegjanm wgtf tfm Y^J.GGG. PFM HEJ^K.e YEJGAPGCC JE^B EJNKM@ ^PJA@GAH PB

NFJEEMAHM PFM J^^GHALMAP BC FO^ @MM@ BC PT]^PDmnjusm tfm Hejskg pejgatgccwjs amgtfmr j pjrty tb abr j tfgx`-pjrty dmamcgngjry bc fm jssghalmatbc fgs `mm` bc trust ("@BP"), fm egkmwgsm ejnkm` stja`gah t:) nfjeemahm tfjt jssghalmat, js AmwWbrk n b u r t ~ fjvm fme`. ^mm,"'-&, RKjrjljtf, 49:4 XE 0>483:>, *8 ("pejgatgcc gs abt j pjrty tbtfm ... Jssghalmat bc Lbrthjhm, ja` gs abt u tfgr`-pjrty dma`gngjry ... mgtfmr, ja` tfmrmcbrm fjs abstja`gah tb nfjeemahm tfm vjeg`gty bc tfjt. .. jssghalmat."); smm j.Gsb ::Ornrjs v. Jmhgs Cup`ge:hNbrp., Ab. :>-nv-47:, 49:> XE 8673:0, *4 (M.@.A.W. Ljr. G, 49:>) (`gslgssgah nejgls jhjgastTLD^ tr:.:stnb; " gc bam pjrty puqO()t'tm` tb jssgha [j\ lbrthjhm tb jabtfmr pjrty, dut jntujeey cjgem`tb `b sb, tfmrm nbue` dm j hmaugam `gsputm dmtwmma tfm putjtgvm jssghamm ja` jssghabr ... dut[p\ejgatgcc [wfb gs abt j pjrty tb tfm jssghalmat\ wbue` fjvm ab stja`gah ga sunf 5: `gsputm.").OS. PFM AW MYPE @G@ ABP JEEBX PFM HEJ^KGYEJGAPGCC PB NGTN]LSMAP PFM ^PJA@GAH TMBeeeTML.MAPGa Bej.skg, tfm pejgatgcc jrhum` tfjt fm fj` stja`gah tb nfjekahn tfm jssghalmat bc fgs lbrthjhmebja js vbg` dmnjusm gt wjs sudlgttm` tb tfm TLD^ tlst jt gssum tfmrm jctmr tfm nebsgah `jtmspmngcgm` ga tfm Y^J, purpbrtm`ey ga nbatrjvmatgba bc tfm Y^J ja` AW MYPE 8-4.0. Pfjtjrhulmat, wfgnf tfm Hejse??;o Nburt jnnmptm`, gs wgtfbut emhje djsgs ua`mr Amw Wbrk ejw. 6Cgrst, ua`mr Amw Wbrk trust ejw, pmrsbas tfjt jrm abt dmamcgngjrgms bc j trust ejnk stja`gah tbnfjeemahm tfm jntgbas bc tfm trustmm. ^mnba`, mvma jssulgah, jrh!Ona`b, tfjt tfm jssghalmat ( e ctfm Hejskg pejgatgcc's lbrthjhm ebja wjs ga nbatrjvmatgba bc tfm Y^J ja` AW MYPE 8-4.0djsm` upba tfm tglgah bc tfm jssghalmat, tfm jssghalmat wbue` dm lmrmey "vbg`jdem," abt vbg`.

Aulmrbus nburts fjvm rmomntm` tfm jrhulmat tfjt j ?pejgatgccfjs stja`gah tb nfjeemahm tfmjssghalmat bc fmr br fgs lbrthjhm ebja js vbg` fmnjus,n sblm ebja-rmejtm` `bnulmat wjssudlgttm` tb tfm TLD^ tlst jctmr tfm Y^J's nebsgah `b::?m. cgee, m.h., Tbdg!eoe..Zee, 49:> XE:09=49:, *>-0 (pej.gatgcc/lbrthjhbrs ejnkm` stja`gah tb jeemhm uacjgr prjntgnms jhjgast TLD^trustmm nfjeemahgah tfm jssghalmat bc tfmgr lbrthjhm (djs5?` upba j tfmbry tfjt tfmgr lbrthjhmwjs jeemhm`ey j``m` tb tfm TLD^ trust jge?mr tfm nebsgah `jtm spmngcgm` ga Y^J) dmnjusm tfmywmrm abt pjrtgms tb, br tfgr`-p::rty dmamcgngjrgms bc, tfm jssghalmat br Y^J); ^lgtf, 49:> XE6660=4, *4 (`gslgssgah nejgls jssmrtgah tfjt TLD^ trustmm `g` abt bwa pejgatgOPs lbrthjhmebja dmnj:.:sm jssghalmat bc tfm lbrthjhm tb tfm trust bnnurrm` jct?mr tfm nebsgah `jtm spmngcgm` gatfm Y^J, pejg::tgccejnkm` stja`gah tb jssmrt sunf nejgls); Gr rm Ljrks, 49:4 XE 3==089=, :9(pejgatg cc/a'e()rthjhbr ejnkm` stjanegah tb jssmrt nejgl jhjgast TLD^ trustmm nfjeemahgah tfmvjeg`gty bc ja jssghalmat bc fmr lbrthjhm ebja gatb TL.D^ trust dmnjusm jssghalmat nennurrm`jctmr nebsgah `jtm spmngcgm` ga Y^J); Jelutjrrmd, 49:4 XE 0>8:0:9, *4 (fbe`gah tfjt "dmnjusmYejgatgccs wmrm abt pjrtgms tb tfm Y^J, tfmy ejnk stja`gah tb nfjeemahm tfm vjeg`gty bc tfmsmnurgtgzjtgba prbnmss, ganeu`gah wfmtfmr tdm ebja trjascbr bnnurrm` butsg`m bc tfm tmlpbrjedbua`s prm,=nrgdm` fy tfm Y^J.").

7/27/2019 Deutsche Bank asks the CA Supreme Court Justices to depublish the Glaski case.

7/12

? ==7--478-:47> CM@M15 BCCGNM =:6= YJHM 96

Nfgmc Oustgnm Pjag H. Njatge-^jkjuymja` tfm Jssbngjtm Oustgnms Lbrhja EmwgsBntbdmr 8, 49:>Yjhm 8Pfmrmcbrm, tfm hmamrje ruem tfjt j aba-pjrty tb ja jssghalmat ejnks stja`gah tb nfjeemahm tfmvjeg`gty bc j S()g`jdem (rjtfnt tfja vbg`) j s ~ g h a l m a t wbue` stgee jppey.

J. Aba-Dmamcgngjrgms Bc J Amw Wbrk Prust Ejnk^tja`gah Pb Nfjeemahm Pfm Jntgbas Bc Pfm Prustmmet fjs ebah dmma tfm ruem, ga Amw Wbrk l:` mesmwfmrm, tfjt baey j dmamcgngjry bc j trust fjsstja`gah tb sum cbr j drmjnf bc fjt trust. ^mm Tmstjtmlmat (Pfgr`) bcO?rusts, 70(49:4) (".J sugt;:hjgast j trustmm bc j prgvjtm trust tb maobga br rm`rmss j drmjnf bct:ust br btfnrwg.sm tb macbrnmtfm trast ljy dm ljgatjgam` baey dy j dmamcgngjry br dy j nb-trustmm, s u n n m ~ s b r trustmm, br (Otfnrpmrsba jntgah ba dmfjecbcbam br lbrm dmamcgngjrgms."); s m ~ , jesb 79J N.O.^., Prusts 8:7 (49:>)("J sugt tb mstjdegsf ja` macbrnm ja mxprmss trust, 9:: tfm trustmm's cjgeurm br rmcusje tb mxmnutm gtprbpmrey, br fgs br fmr drmjnf tfmrmbc, ljy ja` sfbue` dm d?nbuhft ja` ljgatjgam`, br`gaj`ey, dytfm trust dm:legngjry br tfbsm rmprmsmatgah br nejglgah ua`mr fgl br fmr.").Pfus, Amw Wbrk nburts, gan.eu`gah gts fghfmst NBeOrt, nbasg?1tmatey cga` tfjt egtghjats wfb jrm abtdmamcgngjrgms bcj trust ejnk $eja`gah tb macbrnm tfm trust's ~ a a s br tb nfjeemahm tfm jntgbas bctfmtrustmm. ^mm Ga rm Mstjtm bc )U.:nLjaus, 08 A.W.4` 8:8, 8:6, 0:8 A.W.^.4` ==, =3 ( e 787) ( t f b ~ m"abt dmamcgngjeey gatmrmstm`" ga j trust ejnk stja`gah tb nfjeemahm tfm jntgbas bc tfm trustmm);Njsfle!!EW Ymtrgm, :0 A.W.4` 043, 0>9-> O, 4=4 A.W.^.4` 008, 007-=9 (:730) (egtghjat wfb wjsanet j trust dmamcgngjry nbg.:e` abt sum tb macbrnm j trust); Ajvm:sna v. Z.jgeejr`, >6 J.@.>` =97,=97, 6>: A.W .^.4` 4=6, 4=7 (>r` @mpt. 4998) ("[^\ganm td5? `mcma`jats wmrm abt dmamcgngjrgms bctfm [trust\. tfmy Ojnkm` stja`gah tb nfj.eemahm tfm jntgbas ( g c tfm pej.gatgcc js gts trustmm,").Dmnjusm tfm H e j , ~ k g pejgatgcc wjs abt j dmamcgngjry bc tfm trust (br mvma j tfgr`-pjrty dmamcgngjrybc tfm Y^J), fm ejnkm` stja`g::h tb drgah jay nejgl mgtfmr mxpegngtey br glpegngtey nfjeemahgah tfmjntgbas bc tfm trustmm bc tfjt trust.

D. Mvma Gc Pfm Jssghalmat Bc Pfm Hejskgg Yejgatgcc'sLbrthjhm Ebja Pb Pfm Prust Xjs Ga Nbatrjvmatgba Bc PfmY^J Ja` AW MYPE, Fm ^tgee Ejnkm` ^tja`gah Pb Nfjeemahmet Dmnjusm Pfjt Jssghalmat Xbue` ek Lmrmey Sbg`jdem, Abt Sbg

AW MYPE 84.0 prbvg`ms tfjt, "[g\ctfm trust gs mxprmssm` ga tfm gg:strulmat nrmjtgah tfm mstjtmbc tew trustmm, mvmry sjem, nbavmyjanm br btfmr jnt bc tfm trustmm ga nbatrjvmatgba bc tfm trast,mxnmpt js jutfbrgzm` dy tfgs jrtgnem ja` dy jay btfmr prbvgsgba bc ejw, gs vbg`." AW MYPE 8-4.0. ^mvmrje nburts fjvm rmnbhagzm` tfjt, jetfbuhf j tfgr` pjrty hmamrjeey ejnks stja`gah tbnfjeemahm tfm vjeg`gty bc ja jssghalmat, j dbrrbwmr ljy rjgsm j `mcmas? tb 5l jssghalmat gctfjt`mcmasm rma`mrs tfm jssghalmat vbg . Pfm Hejskg Nburt cbua` tfjt tfm pejgatgcc tfmrm cmee ua`mrtfgs mxnmptgba tb tfm stja`gah rmqugrmlmat dmnjusm tfm jeemhm` abanblpegjanm wgtf tfm Y^Jrma`mrm` tfm jssghalmat vbg` ua`mr AW MYPE 8-4.0. Ga `bgah 69, tfm Nburt rmegm` upba jsgahem Amw Wbrk stjtm trgje nburt eepgagba, cjbdb);O.Z, 49:> XE :6>:877, wfgnf cbua`, wgtf vmryegttem jajeysgs, tfjt tfm trustmm's lmrm rmnmgpt bc tfm lbrthjhm ebja mxnmm` gts jutfbrgty ja` wjstfmrmcbrm "vbg`" ua`mr tfm AW M.YPE. Cgrs);, js `mlbastr?:tm` jdbvm, cer.bdbdb wjs j cbrmnebsurmnjsm drbuhft ga tfm ajlm bc tfm TLD^ trustmm ga wfgnf, ::s pejgatgcc, tfm TLD^ trustmm fj` tfmdur`ma bc jccgrljtgvmey prbvgah tfjt gt bwam` tfm `mcma`jat's lbrthjhm ebja. Ab sunfrmqugrmlmat wjs prmsmat ga Hejskg.

7/27/2019 Deutsche Bank asks the CA Supreme Court Justices to depublish the Glaski case.

8/12

:9/96/49:> :>?06 ==7--478-:47>

Nfgmc Oustgnm Pjag H. Njaege-^jkjuymja` tfm Jssbngjtm OustgnmsBntbdmr 8, 49 e >Yjhm 6

CM@M15 BCCGNM =:6= YJHM 97

Lbrhja Emwgs

^mnba`, mvma jssulgah tfjt sunf jnts wbue` nbatrjvmam tfm Y^J, nburts tfjt fjvm nba`untm` jaylmjagahcue jajeysgs bc tfm AW MYPE gssum rjgsm` g.a Hejs!.;e fjvm nbaneu`m` tfjt, ::9twgtfstja`gahtfm stjtutm's rmcmrmanm tb ja jnt dmgah "vbg`," j drmjnf bc tfm tmrls bc j Y^J wbue`, jt lbst,rma`mr ja jssghalmat vbg`jdem, abt vbg`, ja` tfjt lbrthjhbrs ejnk stja`gah tb drgah nejgls djsm`upba lmrmey vbg`jdem jssghalmats. J vbg` nbatrjnt gs "gavjeg` br uaejwcue crbl gts ganmptgba,"wfgem j vbg`jdem nbatrjnt "gs bam wfbrm bam 5)r lbrm bc tfm pjrtgms fjvm tfm pbwmr, dy tfmljagcmstjtgba bc ja memntgba tb `b sb, tb jvbg` tfm khje rmejtgbas nrmjtm` dy tfm nbattjnt." G 8JN.O.^., Nbatrjnt :37 (49:>); 44 A.W. Our. 4`, Nbatrjnt! 6 (49:>) ("J vbg` nbatrjnt gs abnbatrjnt jt je :; gt dga`s ab bam ja` gs j lmrm aueegty. J vbg` :?;batrjnt rmqugrms ab `gsjccgaajanm tbjvbg` gt .... ]sgah tfm tmrl ga gts mxjnt smasm ja` eglgtgah gt tb tdm pje'tgns tfmlsmevms, j vbg`nbatrjnt gs dga`gah upba amgtfmr ja` njaabt dm rjtgcgm`., .. Nbatrjnt=::rm fme` tb dm vbg`::dem wfmabam bc fm. pjrtgms fjs tfm pbwmr mgtfmr tb jvbg` br tb vjeg`jtm tfm jhrmmlmat."), Amw Wbrk nburtsfjvm tfus fme` tfjt uetrj vgrms jnts dy trustmms jrm lmrmey vbg`jdem dmnjusm tfmy nja dm rjtgcgm`dy tfm trust's dmamcgngjrgms. ;;O,nn, m.h., Lbbamx v. Lj``ma, :7> J@.4` 7>>, 7>>->0, =78A.W.^.4` 88=, 883 (>` @mpt :77>) (fbe`gah tfjt"[j\ trustm'm ljy dga` tfm trust tb ja btfmrwgsmgavjeg` jn.t br jhrmmlmat wfgnf gs butsg`m tfm snbpm bc fm trustmm's pbwmr wfma tfm dmamcgngjrybr dmamcgngjrgms nbasmat br rjtgcy tfm trustmm's uetrj vgrms jnt br jhrmmlmat"); Xjsfdu::: v. Tjga,7r.,:07 J.@. 699, 69>, :>0 A.W.^. >9:, >94 (4` @mpt. :7:4) {"Gcj trustmm ga nbatrjvmatgba bc fgste'ust `gspbsm bc fgs trast prbpmrty, tfm dmamcgngjry nja memnt tb rmhjr` tfm jnt js cbr br jhjgast fgsj`vjatjhm ... "); Fgam v. e-:.uatgahtba, ::6 J.@. =6=, =74, :9> A.W.^. =>=, =09 (0tf @mpt. :798)(trust dmamcgngjry "gs jt pmrcmnt egdmtty tb memnt tb jpprbvm ja uajutfbrgzm` gavmstlmat ja` maobyg.ts prbcgts, br tb rmomnt gt jt fgs bptgba."); :93 A.W . .Pur. 4`, Prusts 0>: (49:>) (j "[t\rustmm ljydga` trust tb ja btfmrwgsm gavj.Og` jnt br jhrmmlmat wfgnf gs butsg`m tfm snbpm bc tfm trustmm'spbwmr wfma dmamcgngjry nbasmats tb br rjtgcgms tfm trustmm's uetrj vgrms jnt br jhrmmlmat.").Ga`mm`, jctmr nba`untgah ja mxfjustgvm mxjlgajtgba bcAnw Wbrk ejw, ganeu`gah tfm AW MYPE,tfm eeegabgs Nburt bc Jppmjes ga D ~ a k bc Jl. Ajt'! Jss'a v. Djsslja CDP, E.E.N., 76: A.M.4neG, 6 (Gee. NE Jpp. 49:4), cbua` tfjt, dmnjusm j dmamcgngjry bcj trust nja rjtgcy j trustmm's uetrjvgrms jnt, tfjt jnt gs lmrmey vbg`jdem rjtdm,r tfja vbg`. Lbrmbvmr, tfm Djsslja nburt cbua`tfjt tfm dmamcgngjrgms bc tfm trust amm` abt ,gUNtujeey rjtg(y efm jnt tb prnnegg`m lbrthjhbrs crbldrgahgah j nejgl-tfm lbrthjhbrs "fjvm stja`gah tb jttjnk tfm trjasjntgba baey g c gt gs vbg`,rmhjr`emss bc wfmtfmr gt wjs ga cjnt rjtgcgm`." G`., jt 7. "[^\:mvmrje Amw Wbrk nburts fjvm jppegm`tfm ruem tfjt j dmamcgngjry nja rjtgcy j trustmm's uetrj vgrms jnt. Xfmrm ja jnt nja dm rjtgcgm` gt gsvbg`jdem rjtfmr tfja vbg`. Jnnbr`gahey, tfmsm njsms ga`gnjtm tfjt uetrj vgrms trjasjntgbas jrmvbg`jdem rjtfmr tfja vbg`."^mvmrje btfmr nburts fjvm rmnmatey ua`mrtjkma tfgs jajeysgs ja` fjvm fme` tfjt AW MYPE 8-4.0`bms abt prbvg`m pejgatgcc/lbrthjhbrs wgtf tfm stja`gah tfmy btfnrwg?gm ejnk tb jssmrt j nejgldjsm` upba jeemhm` abanblpegjanm wgtf j Y^J. Bam sunf njsm jajeyzm` Mrbdbdb ja` mxpegngteyrmomntm` gts jajeysgs. ^mn Kbucbs v. ].^. Djak, A.J., Ab, :4-nv-:980>, 49:> XE ::67=94, * >,a,4 (@. Ljss. Ouey e, 49:>) ("Pfm fmct? bc Mrbdbdb's stjtutbry jrhulmat wjs nbasg`mrm` ja`

r ~ o m n t m ` dy tfm `mtjgem` jajeysg.s bc tfgs gssum ga Djsslja"). ^mvmrje btfmr nburtr; mxjlgam` tfmAW MYPE ja` tfm ua`mrpgaagahs bc tfm Mrbd()db bpgagba ja` fjvm nbaneu`m` tfjt tfm AW MYPE`bms abt prbvg`m lbrthjhbrs wgtf tfm stja`gah tfjt tewy ejnk. ^m,; Kjrjlqtf, 49:4 XE0>483:>, *8 (rmomntgah pejgatgcc'6 nejgl djsm` upba tfm AW MYPE dmnjusm pejgatgcc ejnkm`stja`gah tb jssmrt? j nejgl djsm` upba abanblpegjanm wgtf tfm Y^J); Hrmma v. Djak bc Jl.

7/27/2019 Deutsche Bank asks the CA Supreme Court Justices to depublish the Glaski case.

9/12

:9/96/49:> :>?06 ==7--478-:47> CM@M15 BCCGNM =:6= YJHM :9

Nf g` Oustgnm Pjag H. Njatge-^jkjuynja` tfm Jssbngjtm .Oustgnms Lbrhja EmwgsN B ] A ^ c ! e , B T . ~ J c EJXBntbdmr 8, 49:>Yjhm 7A.cU,, Ab. :>-nv-O 974, 49:> XE 40:87:3, *4 (^.@. Pmx . .Ouam 0, 49:>) ("Nburts jppeygah AmwWbrk ejw fjvm trmjtm` jntgbas dy trustmms js vbg`jdem. [ngtgah LbZ.ZZ.)'.\ Dmnjusm jssghalmatslj`m jctmr tfm trust's nebsgah jtm jrm vbg`jdem, rjtfmr tfja vbg`, [pejgatgcc\ egkmey ejnks jutfbrgtytb nfjeemahm tfm jssghalmats bc fgs lbrthjhm."); ^ghjrja v. ].^. e>jak Ajt'! Jss'a, Ab.g4-nv->=>>, 49:> XE 4>36>>3, *> (^.@. Pmx. Ljy 47, 49:>) (jajeyzgah j :::brthjhbr's

~ . r h u l n a t s ua`mr tfm AW MYPE, ja` fbe`gah tdjt "jssghalmats lj`m jctmr tfm [TLD^\ Prust'snebsgah `jtm jrn vbg`jdem, rjtfmr tfja vbg`."); @mutsnfm Djak Ajt'! Prust Nb. v. ^tjcgmo, Ab.:B-nv-=9>O8, 49:> XE ::9>79>, *> (A.@. Gee. L ~ t r . :=, 49:>) ("Jctmr rmvgmwgah tfm pmrtgamatAmw Wbrk jutfbrgty ba smntgba 8-4.0, tfgs nburt jhrmms wgtf tfm jajeysgs ga D j ~ . s l j a ja` fbe`stfjt smntgba 8-4.0 baey ljkms ja jnt dy tfm [TLD^\ trustmm ga nbatrjvmatgba tb tfm trustgastrulmat vbg`jdem, abt vbg`."); Kmyms v. @mutsnfm e ~ j a k Ajt'! Prust Nb., 74: C. ^upp. 4` 807,8== (cj.@. Lgnf. 49:>).Tmnmatey, ga rmegjanm ba tfm Amw Wbrk jutfbrgtgms ngtm` jdbvm, ymt jatetfmr nburt fme` tfjt?

Amw Wbrk nburts fjvm lj`m nemru tfjt j dm.amcgngl)' nja rjtgcy j trustmm's uetrjvgrms jnt. ... Gcja jnt ljy dm rjtgcgm`, gt .gs W,!)g`jdem rjte:mr tfja v7g`. ^mm. Fjnkmtv. Fjn5kmtt, 7=9 A.W.^.4` 396, 49:4 XE 337=4=, !gt 49 (A.W. ^up. Nt. Cmd. 4:,49:4) ("J vbg` nbatrjnt njaabt dm rjtgcgm`; gt dga`s ab bam ja` gs j aueegty.Fbwmvmr, ja jhrmmllt tfjt gs lmrmey vbg`jdem dy bam pjrty emjvms dbtf pjrtgms jtegdmrty tb rjtgcy tfm trjasjntgba jg:` gasgst upba gt6 pmrcbrljanm.") (qubtgah 48Xgeegstba ba N5ltrjnts 89?:> [0tf m`.\) (gatmraje qu5Otjegba ljrks blgttm`). . . .Dmnjusm j trustmm's uajutfbrgzm` trjasjntgbas ljy dm rjtgcgm`, sunf trjasjntgbasjl vbg`jdem-abt vbg`. Pfus, mvma gcgt gs trum tfjt tfm Abtms wmrm trjascmrrm` tbtfm t r u ~ e ga vgbejtgba bc tfm trust's tmrls, tfjt traasjntgb:: nbue` dm rjtgcgm` dy tfmdmamcgngjrgms bc tfm trust ja` gs tfmrmcbrm lmrmey vbg`jdem. . . . Jnnbr`gahey, sganmbvma ja jctmr-tfm-`mj`egam trjascmr bc tfm Abtms tb tfm trast wbue` lmrmey dmvbg`jdem jt tfm bptgba bc tfm trust's dmamcgngjrgms, Yejgatgcc ::9 stja`gah tbnfjeemahm tfjt jssghalmat.

B l r j . ~ ~ W . W Jurbrj Djak. C^D, Ab. :4-nv-8>9, 49:> XE >404=49, *3-8 (X.@. Pmx. Ouam 4=,49:>).AW MYPE 8-4.0 `bms abt prbvg`m tfm H E ~ s k g pejgatgcc wgtf tfm stja`gah fm btfmrwgsm ejnkm`.S. PF.M BYGAgBA JNP]JEEW FJTL^ DMAMCGNGJTGM^ BC PF.Gt PT]^PPfm Nburt "dmegmvm[`\ jppeygah tfm stjtutm tb vbg` tfm j X ~ l p t m ` trjascmr gs oustgcgm` dmnjusm gtprbtmnts tfm dmamcgngjrgms bc tfm [trust\ crbl tfm pbtmatgje ?';`vmrsm tjx 5;basmqumanms bc tfm trustebsgah gts stjtus js j TMLGN trust ua`mr tfm Gatmraje Tmvmaum Nb`m." .Hejskg, *8. Js mxpejgam`dmebw, tfm. trust's TMLPN stjtus wjs amvmr ga ombpjr`y, ja`, nbatrjry tb tfm Nburt's dmegmc, tfmBpgagba erarls, ratfmr tfja prbtmnts, tfm tlst's dmamcgngjrgms.77 Pfm Nburt mvma rmnbhagzm` tfjt gts gatmrprmtjtgba )::jy fjvm tfm mccmnt bc fjrlgah, rjtfmrtfja prbtmn.tgah, tfm dmamcgngjrgms bc tfm TLD^ trust. Hejskg, *::. :::m Nburt's cbnus ba(Nbatgaum` abtm)

7/27/2019 Deutsche Bank asks the CA Supreme Court Justices to depublish the Glaski case.

10/12

? ==7--478-:47>

Nfgmc.Oustgnm Pjag H. Njatge-^jkjuymja` tdn Jssbngjtm OustgnmsBntbdmr 8, 49:>YjhmeB

CM@M15 BCCGNM =:6= YJHM ::

Lbrhja EmwgsN ( ) ] ) ' . c ~ T E Z O t ^ JP e ,1.X

C g r ~ : , tfm Nburt cbnusm` ba tfm sudsmqumat, smpjratn wrgttma jssghalmat bc fm Zejskg @BP (tfm"Jssghalmat") ja` ganbrrmntey dmegmvm` tfjt tfjt `bnulmat wjs amnmssjry tb nbavmy tfmpejgatgccs lbrthjhm ebja. Js j :msuet, tfm Nburt jssulm` tfjt dmnjusm tfm Jssghalmat wjsrmnbr`m` ga 4996 (tfrmm ymjrs jctmr tdm nebsgah `jtm bc tfm Y^J (499=)), tfm lbrthjhm ebja fj`abt dmma nLvmym` tb tfm trust uatge 4996, wfgnf nbue` nrmg:tm j`vmrsm tjx nbasnqumann= cbr tfmtrust ja` gts dnam.cgngjrgms. Pfgs gs ganbrrmnt. Yursujat tb ^mntgba 4.90 bctfm Hejskg Y^J, dyvgrtum bc tfm Y^J gtsmec ja` js bc gts nebsgah `jtm, tfm lbr';hjhm ebjas, abtms, ja` @BPs ga tfmtrust wmrm grrmvbnjdey "s(be`\, trjascmr[rm`\, jssgha[m`\, smt avmr ja` btfmrwgsm nbavmy[m`\ tb tfmPlst, wgtfbut rmnbursm . ,.." Pfus, js bc tfm nebsgah `jtm ga tfm Y^J (js bppbsm` tb tfm `jtm tfmJssghalmat w:Os rmnbr`m`), tfm trustmm bc tfm trust dmnjlm tfm emhje bwamr bc tfm Hejskgpejgargcc s lbrthjhm ebja, abtm, ja` @BP. Jay sudsmqumat, nbacgrljtbry jssghalmat bcfgs @BPwjs surpeusjhm ja` wbue` abt glpegnjtm tfm trust's TMLON stjtus dmnjusm ::9 amw jssmts wmrmnbavmym` tb tfm trust dy vgrtum bc tfm Jssghalmat. Ga rm RW/rghft, Ab. :Bnv->67>, 49:4 XE48=99, *> (@. Fjw. Oja. =, 49:4) (jctmr tfm jssghalmat bc ce lbrthjhm ga tfm TOv!D^ trustjhrmmlmat, tfm "cbrlje jTTghalmat bc tfm lbrthjhm jt j dtnr `jtm gs surpeusjhm!').^mnba`, tfm n,)urt's dmegmc tfjt gts Bpgagba prbtmnts :fm gatmrmsts bc tfm trust's dmamcgngjrgms gswrbah. Pb tfm nbatlry, tfm Bpgagba, wfgnf fjs jermj`y dmhua tb nrmjtm cjesm fbpm jlbah`mcjuetm` lbrthjhbrs tfjt j amw jvmaum bc jttjnk ba aba-ou`gngje cbrm`bsurms abw mxgsts, wgeeemj` tb !.eOZ!'..."e djsmemss nfjeemahms tb cbrmnebsurms ga Njegcbragj (ja` mesmwfmrm). Pfgs crastrjtmstfm p u r p b s m ~ bc tfm aba-ou`gngje prbnmss. :9 Pfm sudstjatgje nbsts ja` mxpmasms f:nurrm` ga`mcma`gah jhjgast wrbahcue cbrmnebsurm jntgbas uetgljtmey wgee dm dbram dy tfm dmamcgngjrgms bctfm TLD^ trusts. ^mm Y^J >.97. Cjr crbl "prbtmntgah" tfmgr gatmrmsts, tfm Bpgagba wgee egkmeyemj` tb j sudstjatgje `rjga ba trust jssmts tfjt, amt bc mxpmasms, dmebah tb tfm dmamcgngjrgms ..Tmspmntcbeey sudlgttm`,

pbtmatgje j`vmrsm tjx nbasmqumanms tb tfm dmamcgngjrgms lgssm` tfm ljrk. G c sunf nbasmqumanmsnbue`. dmcjee tfm. dmamcgngjrgms, tfjt lghft prbvg`m tfml wgtf ja gaoury tb sjtgscy Jrtgnem ]Ostja`lh, dut gt wbue` abt prbvg`m $]Nf stja`gah tb tfm Hegjskg pejgatgcc.:9 Jetfbuhf tfm Bpgagba ljy g l p ~ . n t tfbusja s bcetv!D^ smnurgtgzjtgba trjasjntgbas, ja`jesb cbrmnebsurms ga lj::y stjtms, tfm glpjnt ga Njegcbragj wgee dm pjrtgnuejrey jnutm. Cbrmxjlpem, tfm Z!jskg TLD^ trust nnltjgas l:Orm tfja 4,=99 lbrthjhm ebjas, 84% bcwfgnf rmejtmtb Njegcbragj prbpmrtgms.

7/27/2019 Deutsche Bank asks the CA Supreme Court Justices to depublish the Glaski case.

11/12

? ==7--478-:47> CM@M15 BCCGNM =:6= YJHM :4

Lbrhja Emwgs

NMTPGCGNJPM BC ^MTSGNMG jl mlpebym` ga tfm Ngty ja` Nbuaty bc ^ja Cara`snb, ^tjtm bc Njegcbragj. G jl bvmrtfm jhm bc :6 yn5:rs ja` abt j pjrty tb tfm wgtfga jntg(l. Ly dusgamss j``rmss gs Lbrhja, E m w g ~& Dbnkgus EEY, Bam Ljrkmt, ^pmjr Pbwmr, ^ja Clangsnb, Njegcbragj 70:9=.Ba Bntbdmr 8, 49:>, e smrvm` tfm jttjnfm` EMPPMT TMZ]M^PGAH@MY]FEGNJPeBA @JPM@ BNPBDMT 8, 49:>, ba tfm pjrtgms ga tfgs jntgba dy pejngah jtrum nbpy tfmrmbc ga smjem` mavmebpms, j``rmssm` js cbeebws?

^MM JPPJNFM@ ^MTSGNM EO^PTmhjr`gah tfbsm pjrtgms `msghajtm` js dmgah smrvm` dy "Cjx," G trjaslgttm` vgj. cjnsglgemtfm `bnwanat(s) egstm` jd5gvm tb tfm cjx auldmr(s) sfbwa cbr tfbsm pjrtgms ba tfgs `jtm dmcbrm=?99 p.l.Tmhjr`gah tfbsm pjrtgms `msghajtm` js dmgah smrvm` dy "Bvmraghft @megvmry," G `megvmrm`mjnf sunf smjem` mavmebpm ta j Cm`mrje Fxprmss bcegnm cbr ptbnnssgah ja` `megvmry tfm amxtdusgamss `jy.Tnhjr`gt:h tfbsm pjrtgms `msghajtm` js dmgah s n r v ~ ? ` dy "Fja` @megvmry," G njusm` tfmmavmebpm(s) tb dm `megvmrm` dy fja` tb tfm j``rmssmm(s) abtm` jdbvm dy `megvmrgah sjg` 9:wnebpmja jutf()rgzm` nburgmr br `rgvmr tb dm `megvmrm` ba tfm sjlm `jtm.G `mnejrm ua`mr pmajety bc pmroury ua`mr tfm Ojws bc tfm ^tjtm bc Njegcbragj tfjt tfmcbrmhbgah gs trum ja` bbl?lt, ja` tfjt tfgs `mnejrjtgba wjs mxmnutm` ba Bntbdmr 8, 49:>, jt ^jaCrjangsnb, N ~ : e g c b r a g j .

7/27/2019 Deutsche Bank asks the CA Supreme Court Justices to depublish the Glaski case.

12/12