Determining author Bias Online
description
Transcript of Determining author Bias Online
Navigating the Internet
Chris Kyauk, Masters Student in Library and Information ScienceSan Jose State
DETERMINING AUTHOR BIAS ONLINE
WHAT IS THE INTERNET TO YOU?
By flickr user violinha via Flickr CC license
“librarians used only one source to answer a question 75% of the time and used fewer than four sources 95.8% of the time. While this may indicate the lack of complexity in the questions, it may also reflect the power of the online sources to answer questions quickly and efficiently.” – Reference Transactions Analysis
WHY CARE?
In Vernor Vinge’s science fiction novel, A Fire Upon
the Deep, the internet is called “The Web of A Thousand Lies” because every one truth is immediately buried under a thousand lies.
THE INTERNET
IN MODERN DAY FRANCE…
By Flickr User – eko – via CC license
Although hyperbole, that image has some truth. It is not Google that is the liar, but the sites on Google that can lie. It is impossible to be absolutely sure about the veracity of any information- but there are ways to see if some pre-existing bias exists.
THE TRUTH IS OUT THERE?
Authority How to detect authorship in
Websites Wikipedia Articles
In past lessons, we had covered:Currency
Or “is the web page up to date?”Accuracy
Or “is the website accurate?”
TODAY’S LESSON
By 姒儿喵喵 via Flickr CC license
THE TRI-FORCE
Authority
Currency
Accuracy
THE AUTHORITY TRIFORCE
Websites
Wikipedia
Authority
Articles
THE AUTHORITY TRIFORCE
Websites
Authority
As you may know, websites have several suffixes (or domain names) that can hint at their purpose- .com for companies .org for organizations .net for internet administrative websites (although it has
become more of a catch-all today) .edu for educational websites .gov for governmental websites
WEBSITES OVERVIEW
The White House Try out these suffixes for The White House www.whitehouse.gov www.whitehouse.com
Several years ago, this link lead to an adult website; this is no longer the case.
www.whitehouse.org www.whitehouse.net
Please give me a smiley face when you’ve finished checking each of these websites out.
PARTICIPATION EXAMPLE
WWW.WHITEHOUSE.ORG
Every website has to be registered. Website registration ensures that you get to Google when you type in Google.com, and not Yahoo.com.
Real world analogy: when you ask for a Big Mac at the McDonalds drive-thru, you don’t get a McSkillet (hopefully). The person serving you knows what to get you something that looks like a Big Mac from the kitchen.
DIGITAL FOOTPRINTS
APPLICATION SHARING
Go to:
www.domaintools.com
Under Whois Lookup,Search for www.whitehouse.org
WHAT DO WE GET?
I’ll give you two minutes to look up a website on a controversial topic, and try to see if the author of the website is not who they seem to be. Feel free to share if you find something surprising! Raise your hand or type your answer or question in the chat box.
EXPLORATION TIME
Websites may have an author that is not who they may seem to be. You can identify authors via domain registry lookups, but
even though the information listed has to be valid, it can be through a “shell” or a front organization.
Nor are all respected resources always trustable. Sometimes they may be maliciously hijacked. Such as Comcast.net, when it was hacked & redirected to
another site. Thankfully, major websites are very rarely hijacked-
otherwise you would not know who is telling the truth!
MINI-RECAP
THE AUTHORITY TRIFORCE
Wikipedia
Authority
WIKIPEDIA AUTHORSHIP
WIKIPEDIA BIAS
http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?diff=prev&oldid=7321742
How do we know if this was a malicious edit?
The number there is a link to the “author” of the article. It is called an “IP address” – the equivalent of a mailing address on the internet.
INTERNET SLEUTHING
We put the “address,” 205.227.165.244 into an Internet Number Registry. Go to: http://whois.arin.net/ui/ This Registry is the equivalent of the Yellow Pages on the
Internet.
And the IP leads us to…
However, none of this is conclusive evidence. Someone could have “spoofed” or faked the address to try to frame the Church of Scientology.
THE END OF THE CHASE?
The Church of Scientology is not the only group to have edited themselves on Wikipedia. Wired Magazine compiled a large database of suspicious IP links making article edits at:
http://www.wired.com/threatlevel/2007/08/vote-on-the-top/
Although this happened three years ago, I doubt that such edits no longer occur.
SCIENTOLOGY ALONE?
All this does not mean that Wikipedia should not be wholly ignored. It is a great starting place, but it is not a source.
MINI-RECAP
THE AUTHORITY TRIFORCE
Authority
Articles
Even peer-reviewed articles are not immune to bias.
Sample Issue:Atrazine is one of the top weed-killing herbicides,
produced by Syngenta, used in the United States today. There are claims that it is responsible for frog hermaphroditism.
One article claims to have debunked such claims, as listed on Syngenta’s website.
ARTICLE AUTHORSHIP
Does Atrazine Influence Larval Development and Sexual Differentiation in Xenopus laevis?
By Werner Kloas, I lka Lutz, Timothy Springer, Henry Krueger, Jeff Wolf, Larry
Holden and Alan Hosmer
Yet a quick look at the biographies of the authors reveals that Hosmer is an employee of Syngenta, and the study was funded by Syngenta.
DEBUNKED?
Look for peer-reviewed articles, and try to find who funded them and their authors. This is the best way of determining if any bias exists.
MINI-RECAP
RECAP
Authority
Currency
Accuracy
WITHIN THE AUTHORITY TRIFORCE
Websites
Wikipedia
Authority
Articles
Authority is important Use only sources that you can trace to a well known entity
Through Domain Registry lookup or IP lookups, Be careful!
Cross check every source. Take nothing for granted. Tools to know what Websites to trust:
Web of Trust, a Firefox add-on.
Homework: Look up a Wikipedia article. Pick an IP address at random and
identify where it came from. Look up a website on a controversial topic. Look up its domain
registry and see if the author listed on the website matches the registry.
AUTHORITY