Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering...

67
Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services Rail~Volution – September 10, 2019

Transcript of Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering...

Page 1: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services

Rail~Volution – September 10, 2019

Page 2: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

• Hi

Kelsey Singbeil Government of B.C.

Gordon Ross OXD

Tessa Forrest TransLink

Page 3: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

• Hi

What does ‘people-centred’ mean to you?

What do you hope to get out of this session?

Page 4: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

It’s About People

Kelsey Singbeil - Director, Service Design www.gov.bc.ca/servicedesign

Page 5: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

GOVERNMENT DIGITAL EXPERIENCE

What is design?

Page 6: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

GOVERNMENT DIGITAL EXPERIENCE

Design can be for… • Functionality • Usability • Experience

Page 7: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

GOVERNMENT DIGITAL EXPERIENCE

All artificial things are designed.

Page 8: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

GOVERNMENT DIGITAL EXPERIENCE

Can government services be designed?

Page 9: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

GOVERNMENT DIGITAL EXPERIENCE

Page 10: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

You ≠ User

Page 11: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

GOVERNMENT DIGITAL EXPERIENCE

The False-Consensus Effect

People’s tendency to assume that others share their

beliefs and will behave similarly in a given context.

https://www.nngroup.com/articles/false-consensus/

Page 12: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

GOVERNMENT DIGITAL EXPERIENCE

Even if you use the thing, you are still not the user.

Page 13: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

ActivityUncovering user needs

Page 14: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

GOVERNMENT DIGITAL EXPERIENCE

Making Toast

Page 15: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

GOVERNMENT DIGITAL EXPERIENCE

Sketch a diagram of how to make toast.(3 minutes)

Page 16: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

GOVERNMENT DIGITAL EXPERIENCE

Page 17: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

GOVERNMENT DIGITAL EXPERIENCE

Any reflections?

Page 18: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

GOVERNMENT DIGITAL EXPERIENCE

You understand user needs through human-centred research.

Page 19: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

GOVERNMENT DIGITAL EXPERIENCE

Page 20: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

Human-Centred Design in the Government of British Columbia

www.gov.bc.ca/servicedesign

Page 21: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

GOVERNMENT DIGITAL EXPERIENCE

Discovery – Do research to understand behaviours and motivations to define user needs.

Page 22: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,
Page 23: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

GOVERNMENT DIGITAL EXPERIENCE

Opportunity – Synthesize research findings into user needs to identify solutions to test.

Page 24: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,
Page 25: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

GOVERNMENT DIGITAL EXPERIENCE

Prototype – Test ideas to see if they meet the needs identified in your research.

Page 26: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,
Page 27: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

GOVERNMENT DIGITAL EXPERIENCE

Implement – Build your service and keep testing to make sure you are meeting user needs. You’ll discover new needs and the process repeats.

Page 28: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,
Page 29: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

Thank You!

Page 30: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

Make NewExperiencesPossible

ForByDate

Rail~Volution

Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services

oxd.com

Rail~Volution 2019, VancouverGordon Ross, Vice President, OXDSeptember 10, 2019

Page 31: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

OXD is an end-to-end design and technology consulting firm.We help organizations deliver new and better service experiences by putting people first.

Page 32: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

32

We’ve helped industry leaders design for—and with—their customers to build services that people love to use.

About OXD

Page 33: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

33

TReO / Port Mann Bridge

Page 34: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

TReO / Port Mann Bridge

$25M in-person & call centre savings

Page 35: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,
Page 36: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

36

TransLink Customer Experience

Page 37: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

37

Page 38: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,
Page 39: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,
Page 40: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

40

TransLink Fare Review

Page 41: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

41

The problemTransit Fare Review

Current fare structure largely unchanged since the mid 1980’s and was perceived as unfair, inflexible, and not reflective of how people travel.

Page 42: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

42

The opportunityTransit Fare Review

New possibilities to move towards a fare system that can work better for more people with Compass smartcard payment system.

Page 43: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

We wanted to review all the ways we price transit

43

Transit Fare Review

Distance Travelled The price you pay depending

on how far you travel

Fare Products The type of ticket or pass you purchase based on frequency

of travel

Service Type The price you pay depending on

what mode of transit you use

Time of Day The price you pay depending

on what time of day you travel

Discounts The reduced fares available to riders based on defined

eligibility criteria

Transfer Time How many minutes you

can travel on a single fare

Page 44: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,
Page 45: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

1. Different approaches to understanding the public’s problems2. Co-design and collaboration with stakeholders in policy options3. Devices that can give form to policy in practice

45

The value of Design for PolicyDesign for Policy

Page 46: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,
Page 47: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,
Page 48: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,
Page 49: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

49

Options for varying fares by distance travelled

Page 50: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,
Page 51: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,
Page 52: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,
Page 53: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

Make NewExperiencesPossible

Thank you

Gordon Ross, Vice President and Partner, OXD210-12 Water Street, Vancouver, BC V6B [email protected]+1 604 694 0554 x103oxd.com

Page 54: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

The TaxiSaver Automation ProjectTessa ForrestManager, Access Transit Planning

RailVolution ConferenceSeptember 10, 2019

Page 55: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

About TransLink

How did this conversation provide us with more meaningful data than a survey of hundreds of people?

Page 56: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

The TaxiSaver Automation Project

The ProblemCurrent paper TaxiSaver vouchers are:- Administratively onerous- Don’t allow for data collection- Subject to fraud

Page 57: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

The TaxiSaver Automation Project

The OpportunityTransLink is considering making changes to its existing TaxiSaver program by replacing the TaxiSaver vouchers with a pre-paid debit card. The objective this automation project is to:

Improvecustomer experience

Increase program security Improve performance measurement

Page 58: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

The TaxiSaver Automation Project

Project Approach - Quantitative

• Survey of 400 customers; 25% indicated they would prefer to stay with the existing paper vouchers instead of moving to a card solution.

Page 59: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

The TaxiSaver Automation Project

Project Approach - Qualitative

Understanding stakeholders and end

users.

Co-creating withstakeholders and

end users.

Prototyping and testing to de-risk innovation.

Planning for implementation and

impact.

Service design seeks to engage customers, employees and other stakeholders to co-design better, more customer-centric experiences.

Page 60: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

The TaxiSaver Automation Project

Project Approach - Qualitative

We took a sprint approach to the project, conducting research, developing concepts and validating with customers in just over six weeks.

14 Customers

12 Internal TransLink StakeholdersAcross 9 departments

11 Taxi drivers and General Managers Across 7 companies

Key stakeholder groups and transit agencies

…via

22 in-depth phone interviews

4 in-person workshops

Page 61: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

The TaxiSaver Automation Project Strategic insightsThese are high-level learnings about the project’s stakeholders that

form the foundation of all our work.

CORE NEEDS

SERVICE PRINCIPLES

SERVICE CONCEPTS

Tactical insightsThese are specific and actionable ideas that can be implemented to

meet stakeholders’ core needs.

At the strategic level, the project uncovered the core needs of customers and other key stakeholders that the new payment system must fulfill for customers and key stakeholders to be successful.At the tactical level, the project generated service concepts, or potential solutions, to meet those core needs.

Outcomes

Page 62: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

The TaxiSaver Automation Project

Help me feel confident when using my new card.

1/

Customers need assurance that they will be properly supported through the transition period.

Help me manage my card and be prepared.

2/

Customers need a means to manage their card balance that feels reliable and comfortable to them.

Give me a safety net in case I make a mistake.

3/

Customers need support systems to fall back on in the event of insufficient funds or card loss.

Customer Core Needs

Page 63: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

The TaxiSaver Automation Project

TaxiSaver Card Design Welcome Package Omnichannel Balance Checking Fare Payment Process Payment Confirmation Loading Balance

Tested Service Concepts

Page 64: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

The TaxiSaver Automation Project

What did we learn from user experience research and validation?

• Understood pain/stress points in ways we couldn’t through static surveys alone.

• Refined assumptions; what we thought customers needed wasn’t always accurate.

• Established customer needs allowed for simple solutions to make service work.

Page 65: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

Thank you!

Page 66: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

• Hi

To be discussed…

Page 67: Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services€¦ · Designing and Delivering People-Centred Transit Services oxd.com Rail~Volution 2019, Vancouver Gordon Ross, Vice President,

• Hi

Kelsey Singbeil [email protected]/servicedesign

Gordon Ross [email protected]

Tessa Forest [email protected]