Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … ·...

218
Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of the Draft Moreton Bay Regional Council Planning Scheme Residential Codes Draft Summary Report July 2013

Transcript of Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … ·...

Page 1: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of the

Draft Moreton Bay Regional Council Planning Scheme Residential Codes

Draft Summary Report July 2013

Page 2: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential Codes2

This publication has been prepared in accordance with the scope of services described in the contract or

agreement between PLACE Design Group Pty Ltd ACN 082 370063 (PDG) and the Moreton Bay Regional

Council (MBRC).

The report relies upon research, data, information and observations made or taken at or under at or prior

to the time of drafting. Any findings, conclusions or recommendations only apply to the aforementioned

circumstances and no greater reliance should be assumed or drawn by the MBRC or readers. Furthermore,

the report has been prepared solely for use by the MBRC and PDG accepts no responsibility for its use by

other parties.

Page 3: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential Codes 3

Table of Contents

1.0 - Introduction ������������������������������������������������� Page 4

2.0 - Scenarios ������������������������������������������������� Page 5

3.0 - Input Data ������������������������������������������������� Page 8

3.1-Building Construction Elements ������������������������������������������������� Page 8

3.2 -Land Purchase Data ������������������������������������������������� Page 10

3.3 -Product Sale Price Data ������������������������������������������������� Page 12

4.0 - Code Provision Commentary ������������������������������������������������� Page 14

5.0 - Feasibility Outcome Overview ������������������������������������������������� Page 21

6.0 - Feasibility Observations ������������������������������������������������� Page 23

Glossary

Term Definition

bd/du Bedrooms per dwelling unit

cp Car parking unit

du Dwelling unit

du/ha Dwelling units per hectare

GFA Gross floor area

NLA Net lettable area

ROC Return on cost (expressed as a percentage in feasibility testing)

SEQ South East Queensland

sqm Metres squared

Page 4: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential Codes4

1.0 -Introduction

The following methodology outlines in more detail the approach that was implemented by

the PLACE team in delivering this project.

1. Background Information Review of Draft Codes

2. Market Pricing Assessment (for serviced land prices and typologies)

3. Design Provisions Assessment / Design Development (for housing typologies)

4. Construction and Infrastructure Cost Review

5. Feasibility Analysis

6. Residential Code Review Report

In assessing the viability of a range of potential development scenarios the project team

undertook the following method:

Market Data Review

(Land sale and produce sale prices)

Design Interrogation

(Yield and Construction Area Schedules)

Feasibility Modelling

Feasibility Interogration

Reverse Engineering / Modified

Scenario Testing

Feasibility / Design Observations

Page 5: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential Codes 5

2.0 - Scenarios

The following scenarios were nominated by Council at the commencement of the project

and were tested by the team.

In additiona to the Primary 38 scenarios have been complemented with a number of

alternate scenarios in certain circumstances. The alternate scenarios are denotated with

an (a) or a (b).

Scenario Typology Location Precinct (provisions)Frontage / Lot

SizeParking Rate

DUAL OCCUPANCY / LOFT SCENARIOS

1 Dual Occupancy (Loft) Caboolture Next Gen Suburban7.5m frontage

(laneway)2/dwelling

1a Scenario Variation - increase in sale price

2 Dual Occupancy (Loft) Woody Point Next Gen Suburban 10m frontage 2/dwelling

2a Scenario Variation - larger development site with 3 x product rather than single site

3 Dual Occupancy (Loft) Caboolture Next Gen Suburban 18m frontage 2/dwelling

3a Scenario Variation - 2 x 360 sqm lots + 2 x larger attached houses

ROW HOUSE SCENARIOS

4Dwelling House (Row

Housing)Mango Hill Next Gen Suburban

7.5m frontage

(laneway)2/dwelling

4a Scenario Variation - 4 x smaller row house products

5Dwelling House (Row

Housing)Caboolture Next Gen Suburban 7.5m frontage 2/dwelling

6Dwelling House (Row

Housing)Caboolture Next Gen Suburban 10m frontage 2/dwelling

6a Scenario Variation - 4 x smaller row house products

MULTIPLE DWELLING (TERRACE) SCENARIOS

7 Multiple Dwelling (Terrace) Mango Hill Next Gen Suburban 25m frontage2/unit & no

visitor

8 Multiple Dwelling (Terrace) Lawnton Urban 25m frontage1/unit + 1/3

units (vis)

9 Multiple Dwelling (Terrace) Caboolture Urban 25m frontage2/unit + 1/3

units (vis)

Page 6: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential Codes6

MULTIPLE DWELLING (PLEX) SCENARIOS

10 Multiple Dwelling (Plex) Arana Hills Next Gen Suburban 25m frontage2/unit + 1/3

units (vis)

11 Multiple Dwelling (Plex) Arana Hills Next Gen Suburban20m frontage,

corner lot

2/unit + 1/3

units (vis)

12 Multiple Dwelling (Plex) Caboolture Next Gen Suburban 25m frontage2/unit + 1/3

units (vis)

12aScenario Variation - reduction in the number of car parks from 2 to 1 car park per dwelling, and also

reduces the product size to 120sqm

13 Multiple Dwelling (Plex) Caboolture Next Gen Suburban30m frontage,

corner lot

2/unit + 1/3

units (vis)

13a Scenario Variation - 5 x plex products reduced by 35sqm each + 1 car per dwelling

13b Scenario Variation - 6 x plex product + 1 car per dwelling +reduced communal open space

14 Multiple Dwelling (Plex) Kippa-Ring Next Gen Suburban 25m frontage2/unit + 1/3

units (vis)

14a Scenario Variation - 6 x plex product + 1 car per dwelling +reduced communal open space

15 Multiple Dwelling (Plex) Strathpine Next Gen Suburban20m frontage,

corner lot

2/unit + 1/3

units (vis)

15a Scenario Variation - 4 x plex product + 1 car per dwelling

LOW RISE APARTMENT SCENARIOS

16 Low Rise Apartments Caboolture Next Gen Suburban25m frontage,

1000sqm

2/unit + 1/3

units (vis)

16a Scenario Variation - 8 x units + 1 car per dwelling + reduced communal open space

16b Scenario Variation - 12 x units + 1 car per dwelling + reduced communal open space

17 Low Rise Apartments Kippa-Ring Next Gen Suburban25m frontage,

1000sqm

1/unit + 1/3

units (vis)

8 Low Rise Apartments Arana Hills Next Gen Suburban18m frontage,

600sqm

1/unit + 1/3

units (vis)

19 Low Rise Apartments Arana Hills Next Gen Suburban25m frontage,

1000sqm

2/unit + 1/3

units (vis)

20 Low Rise Apartments Strathpine Next Gen Suburban18m frontage,

600sqm

2/unit + 1/3

units (vis)

21 Low Rise Apartments Strathpine Next Gen Suburban25m frontage,

1000sqm

2/unit + 1/3

units (vis)

22 Low Rise Apartments Lawnton Urban18m frontage,

600sqm

1/unit + 1/3

units (vis)

23 Low Rise Apartments Lawnton Urban25m frontage,

1000sqm

2/unit + 1/3

units (vis)

23a Scenario Variation - increased site cover + 12 x unit product +reduced communal open space

24 Low Rise Apartments Margate Urban18m frontage,

600sqm

1/unit + 1/3

units (vis)

25 Low Rise Apartments Margate Urban25m frontage,

1000sqm

2/unit + 1/3

units (vis)

Page 7: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential Codes 7

MEDIUM RISE APARTMENT SCENARIOS

26 Medium Rise Apartments Redcliffe Urban20m frontage,

800sqm

2/unit + 1/3

units (vis)

27 Medium Rise Apartments Redcliffe Urban30m frontage,

1000sqm

2/unit + 1/3

units (vis)

27a Scenario Variation - 1 car per dwelling

28 Medium Rise Apartments Margate Urban25m frontage,

1000sqm

2/unit + 1/3

units (vis)

28a Scenario Variation - 2 bedroom product, deleting 3 bedroom product + 1 car per dwelling

29 Medium Rise Apartments Burpengary Urban25m frontage,

1000sqm

1/unit + 1/3

units (vis)

30 Medium Rise Apartments BurpengaryCentre (utilise urban

provisions)

25m frontage,

1000sqm

2/unit + 1/3

units (vis)

31 Medium Rise Apartments Arana HillsCentre (utilise urban

provisions)

20m frontage,

800sqm

1/unit + 1/3

units (vis)

2/unit + 1/3

units (vis)

32 Medium Rise Apartments CabooltureCentre (utilise urban

provisions)

25m frontage,

1000sqm

2/unit + 1/3

units (vis)

HIGH RISE APARTMENT SCENARIOS

33High Rise Apartments (8

storeys)Woody Point Urban

30m frontage,

1600sqm

2/unit + 1/3

units (vis)

34

High Rise Apartments (8

storeys)Redcliffe Urban

20m frontage,

1000sqm

2/unit + 1/3

units (vis)

35High Rise Apartments (6

storeys)Lawnton Urban

30m frontage,

1600sqm

2/unit + 1/3

units (vis)

36High Rise Apartments (12

storeysRedcliffe

Centre (can use urban

provisions)

35m frontage,

2400sqm

2/unit + 1/3

units (vis)

36a Scenario Variation - 1 car per dwelling

37High Rise Apartments (8

storeys)Strathpine

Centre (can use urban

provisions)

35m frontage,

2400sqm

2/unit + 1/3

units (vis)

38High Rise Apartments (8

storeys)Caboolture

Centre (can use urban

provisions)

35m frontage,

2400sqm

1/unit + 1/3

units (vis)

Page 8: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential Codes8

3.0 -Input Data

The following assumptions or figures and pricing have been used in the generation of the

project feasibilities.

3.1 - Building Construction Elements

Assumption / Exclusion Detail of Assumption

Return on Cost / Profit Project Likely to Proceed - 19% >

Project is Marginal - 15-19%

Project unlikely to Proceed < 15%

Soft Development Costs

(Consultants etc)

5% of total build price

Inbuilt Construction Contingency 7.5%of total build price

Selling Costs Nominal budgets of $35-45K for legal costs and $15-25K depending

upon the size of the project have been allowed for marketing and sales

costs.

Infrastructure Charges As per MBRC Cap Charge rates

$ 22,000 – 1 & 2 bedroom units

$ 28,000 – 3 bedroom units / lot

Development Application Fees Dwelling House (Code) - $690

Dwelling House (Impact) - $1280

Dual Occ/Duplex Dwelling (Code Assessment) - $2310

Dual Occ/Duplex (Impact Assessment) - $2890

Multi Dwelling (Code Assessment) - up to 10 units - $3480

Multi Dwelling (Code Assessment) - 31+ units – $11,550

Multi Dwelling (Code Assessment) - Medium (11-30 units) - $5780

Multi Dwelling (Impact) - up to 10 units - $5780

Multi Dwelling (Impact Assessment) - Medium (11-30 units) -$8090

Multi Dwelling (Impact Assessment) - 31+ units -$13,840

Construction Price per sqm Residential Row House (2 storey) Construction price - $ 1050 m2

Residential 3 storey MUD Construction price - $ 1500 m2

Residential 5 storey MUD Construction price - $ 1850 m2

Residential 8 storey MUD Construction price - $ 2000 per m2

Residential 15 storey MUD Construction price - $ 2200 per m2

Ground level / Undercroft $ 850 per m2

Level 1 Basement - $1515 per m2

Levels 2+ Basement - $2100 per m2

Page 9: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential Codes 9

Structure Costs Undercroft Structure $850 per m2

Basement 1 - $1515 per m2

Basement 2+ -$2100 per m2

Balcony (Unit balcony - reinforced concrete) - $500 per m2

Balcony (Timber Deck) -$250 per m2

Covered Car Park (metal car port) - $280 per m2

Ground Level Carpark - $100 per m2

Undercroft Structure - $850 per m2

Landscape Costs Landscape Buffers - $45 per m2

Deep Planting - $45 per m2

Open Space - deck/terrace/balcony (timber) - $250 per m2

Communal Open Space - $90 per m2

Open Space -soft landscaping - $70 per m2

Open Space – lawn - $25 per m2

Driveway and pavement - $140 per m2

Typical Dwelling Mix Dwelling House (Row Housing) – 3 bedrooms

Multiple Dwelling (Terrace) – 3 bedrooms

Multiple Dwelling (Plex) – 3 bedrooms

Low Rise Apartments – 75% 2 bedrooms + 25% 3 bedrooms

Medium Rise Apartments – 75% 2 bedrooms + 25% 3 bedrooms

High Rise Apartments – 75% 2 bedrooms + 25% 3 bedrooms

Carparking Assumptions Generally 2 carparks per dwelling + 1 visitor carpark per 3 dwellings,

unless specifically modified for the individual scenarios as noted

Financial Modelling All scenarios will be modelled in a static sense and assume 100% debt

financing across both land and total development costs. Assuming

100% debt finance funding is an approach typically adopted by

valuers enabling them to compare assets like for like. This approach is

adopted as the funding arrangements for most developments will vary.

GST Modelling has assumed development is undertaken by a ‘professional’

developer and as such GST is required to be paid on the sale of each

product.

Page 10: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential Codes10

Suburb Lot Size Purchase Price Suburb Profile

Vacant Land House on Land

Ara

na H

ills

600m2 - $275k - $380k Arana Hills is an established suburb with limited

vacant land. There are small pockets of land

available on the outskirts of the suburb although

the sites are generally constrained by topography.

New development in the area would be through infill

scenarios with house and land being purchased

and the existing dwelling demolished. Standard lot

sizes in the suburb are 40m depth by 15m wide.

800m2 $305k $365k - $445k

1000m2 - $460k - $499k

Greenfield

10,000m2

$2,000,000

Burp

engary

1000 m2 $220k - $280k Burpengary is an expanding suburb with tracts

of land still available for development. Lot sizes

in the area range significantly with standard lot

subdivision around the centre averaging 1000m2.

Large lots over 6000m2 are commonly being picked

up for smaller lot or community title subdivision.

Land parcels to the east of the Bruce Highway are

generally over 2000m2 containing single dwellings.

Large Lot

3000 m2 –

5000m2

Cab

oolture

600m2 $200k - $270k Caboolture is an expanding centre suburb with

large vacant parcels of land still available. The

600m2 and 800m2 land parcels are an established

standard allotment size in the locality. Higher

density development is occurring to the east of

Caboolture centre as large Greenfield development

sites between the centre and the Bruce Highway

become more appealing for development. The

surplus of land available in the area keeps land

prices low with financial efficiencies to be gained

when buying larger lots.

800m2 $212k - $270k

1000m2 $215k $230k - $290k

2400 m2

Kip

pa-R

ing

1000m2 $420k-$485k Kippa-Ring is an established suburb with limited

vacant urban land available for development.

New development in the area would be achieved

through consolidating land parcels for larger

developments or smaller lot infill development

typologies. Land achieves a higher sales rate

compared to inland suburbs due to close proximity

to the bayside suburbs of Redcliffe and Margate.

Law

nto

n

600m2 $220k $230k-$355k Lawnton is a relatively established suburb with new

development occurring as the larger rural lots are

purchased and subdivided. There is evidence of

urban consolidation and infill development with land

parcels around the rail station being redeveloped

for higher density product. Large parcels of land

exist between Francis Road and Todds Road with

development pressure likely to persuade a higher

density urban outcome. There is limited variance in

vacant land prices between the 600m2 and 800m2

allotments, with a similar sales price result also

achieved on the improved land of this size. Land

purchase prices increase on the larger 1000m2

allotment, particularly parcels within close proximity

to the rail station.

800m2 $220k $260k-$355k

1000m2 $265k - $480k

3.2 - Land Purchase Prices

Page 11: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential Codes 11

Suburb Lot Size Purchase Price Suburb Profile

Vacant Land House on Land

Mango

Hill

400 m2 $350k Mango Hill is a relatively new suburb with greenfield

development the predominant development type.

The greenfield development sites generally host a

mix of housing typologies -with examples of small

lot housing, terrace and townhouse product within

the locality. These lots generally achieve higher

subdivision efficiencies and therefore land price

per square meter and per dwelling is lower. Vacant

land in the area generally achieves $220k to $230k

for sites between 800sqm to 1000sqm. Improved

house and land product is new in the locality and

averages around a $440k sales price.

Large development sites are still available in

the locality and it is envisioned that greenfield

development will remain dominant.

600m2 $230k $450k

800 m2 $340k-$510k

1000m2 $225k $360k-$575k

Greenfield

10000 m2

$1mil –

$1.3mil

Greenfield

50000 m2

$4mil-$6.9mil

Marg

ate

600m2 $220k - $435k Land purchase prices are inflated in the suburb due

to proximity to Moreton Bay. Land to the east of

Oxley Ave can achieve higher sales rates with the

potential to develop a product that leverages off the

view over Moreton Bay. Margate is an established

suburb with vacant land relatively scarce. Urban

consolidation and infill development will be required

which can elevate project cost.

800 m2 $400k $340k-$399k

1000 m2 $495k $417k - $549k

1400 m2 $650k -

$750k

Red

clif

fe

800m2 $500k -

$700k

$300k-$495k Redcliffe is an established suburb which achieves

inflated sales prices for land and product due to

proximity to Moreton Bay. There is limited vacant

urban land in the area. Development would be

through urban consolidation and infill development.

1000m2 $840k

Str

ath

pin

e

600m2 - $285k-$310k Strathpine is a reasonably established suburb,

with new development occurring on the urban

fringe. Subdivision and Greenfield development is

predominantly situated to the east of Strathpine

Rail Station as development edges closer to South

Pine River. Standard lot dimensions are 15 meters

by 40 meters across the suburb. Opportunity to

develop Greenfield development to the east of

Gympie Road will most likely stifle significant infill

development unless larger land parcels around the

centre become available.

800m2 - $338k-$346k

1000m2 - $330k-$380k

Wood

y P

oin

t

400 m2 - $230k - $299k Woody Point is a small bayside suburb with limited

vacant land available, which results in inflated land

purchase prices. Deep narrow lots of 60 meters by

15 meters are the standard lot layout across the

suburb. Smaller lots have occurred through recent

land subdivisions, creating more manageable sizes

for single dwellings. The larger lots, although higher

in price, do create opportunity to consolidate and

develop higher density product.

1000m2 $415k - $470k

1800m2 $450k-850k

Page 12: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential Codes12

3.3 - Product Sale Prices

Market and Sales Research Elements:

Utilising real estate data and other information sourced from Price Finder, Realestate.com, RP Data and

Domain.com, market and sales data was collated across the various suburbs and typologies.

Where possible, actual projects were sourced with the actual land purchase price and sales data being

utilised, reflecting a true case scenario.

Where this was not possible, land purchase prices were averaged out for each site area to determine

a market realistic purchase price example. Average sales prices were provided assuming new and

contemporary product, relative to existing stock to determine the sales range to be applied to scenarios.

Generally, the higher end of the sale range was used in the feasibility testing to determine if a scenario

would be viable. If the scenario did produce a significantly feasible result, the sales price was reduced to

illustrate a more conservative outcome.

Please note, market and sales information collected for the purpose of the feasibility testing was

undertaken as high level, desktop research, and should not be considered an exact analysis. Accurate

feasibility testing should be undertaken on a site by site basis as results will vary significantly depending

on constraints and opportunities surrounding each site.

Suburb Typology Product Sales

Price

Studio 2 bedroom 3 bedroom

Arana Hills Plex $430k - $480k

Low Rise $340k -$360k $385k- $395k

Medium Rise $340k -$360k

Commentary: Arana Hills is primarily characterised by low density detached dwellings. This is a result of the

undulating topographic nature of the suburb and the market demand when it was established. There are very

few examples of new infill product in the locality and therefore product sale rates from surrounding suburbs

were also considered. The one example of new product in the locality was luxury townhouses selling between

$480,000 for 2 bedrooms up to $550,000 for 3 bedrooms and was therefore not considered to be a standard

product example.

Burpengary Townhouse $255k - $275k $300k – $330k

Medium Rise $240k-$260k

Commentary: There are currently no new examples of medium rise apartments in Burpengary. Burpengary

is largely characterised by single unit dwellings or plex and townhouse developments. Townhouse product in

Burpengary has been selling from $255-$275 thousand for a two bedroom product and $300 - $330 thousand

for a three bedroom product. As there are few examples of medium rise development in the locality, examples

from wider localities with similar market pricing were drawn upon to determine the apartment sales price.

Page 13: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential Codes 13

Suburb Typology Product Sales

Price

Studio 2 bedroom 3 bedroom

Caboolture DO (Loft &

Primary)

$180k-

$190k

$370k - $390k

Row House $260k - $299k $300k - $350k

Terrace $300k - $350k

Plex $300k - $350k

Low Rise $310k - $325k

Medium Rise $280k - $299k $310k - $325k

High Rise $290k - $310k $310k - $330k

Commentary: Caboolture caters for a wide demographic providing a diverse housing product to the market.

Product sales prices in the locality are fairly low which reduces the level of return that can be achieved through

developments. Dual occupancies have been delivered in the locality however generally in a traditional lot

format. The sales price for a loft (dual occupancies) was derived from standard studio apartment costs in

the locality. Plex product was assumed to achieve a similar return as a townhouse. Terrace housing in the

scenarios were of a significantly larger scale and were tested at an inflated sales price to reflect urban zone

and increased GFA. Apartment blocks are being achieved in the Caboolture area with evidence showing sales

prices matching townhouse prices in some instances.

Kippa-Ring Plex $315k - $350k

Low Rise $300k - $330k

Commentary: Kippa-Ring is a relatively small suburb with limited apartment development. Townhouse and

single unit dwellings are the primary development product on the market in the locality. In saying this however

there has been limited new development occurring in the suburb with no market evidence for new product.

Product sales rates for the scenarios were based on existing townhouse development prices in the locality,

however it must be noted that generally a new product would achieve a higher return on sale.

Lawnton Terrace $330k - $360K

Low Rise $275k - $300k $310k - $330k

High Rise $285k - $295k $310 - $330k

Commentary: Product sales rates in Lawnton are mid-range when comparing to the other suburbs

researched for this project. The primary multi-unit product on the market at present is townhouse product, with

limited market evidence for apartments. Sales rates suitable for apartments were derived by comparing market

rates in Lawnton to those of surrounding or similar areas. Terrace product was considered to be similar to

townhouse sales prices, although slightly larger and therefore capable of achieving higher premiums.

Mango Hill Row House $300k-$340k $350k- $380k

Terrace $300k-$340k $350k- $380k

Commentary: Mango Hill is a relatively new suburb with terrace and row house typologies already being

delivered through master plan communities. Sales prices were derived from project specific product sale and

also compared with standard product already released to the market.

Page 14: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential Codes14

Suburb Typology Product Sales

Price

Studio 2 bedroom 3 bedroom

Margate Low Rise $300k - $405k $390k - $480k

Medium Rise $300k - $425k $390k - $520k

Commentary: Margate is a bayside suburb with sale prices reflecting the prime locality. Low and medium

rise apartments are already being delivered in the locality with sale prices varying significantly depending on

proximity or views of the water. The sale range has been derived from new product entering the market and

averaging out price across the suburb. Medium rise product has assumed a higher sales rate considering extra

elevation could be achieved.

Redcliffe Low Rise $406-$423k

High Rise $405k - $485k $520k - $580k

Similar to Margate, Redcliffe is also a bayside suburb with sale prices leveraging off high amenity and proximity

to the water. Apartment product is already being delivered across the suburb with sale prices reflecting

actual projects. Of interest in Redcliffe were several blocks of land being sold with an approved DA however

the development was never built. This may suggest that there has been difficulty selling the higher priced

product or the realisation that the high sales prices may not be achieved in the current market. There are also

large supplies of apartments on the market at present in the locality which indicates market demand for the

apartment product is underperforming in the current economy.

Strathpine Plex $340k

Low Rise $280k - $330k $310k -$360k

High Rise $280k - $330k $310k -$360k

The Strathpine market is predominantly characterised by single unit dwellings with limited multi-unit dwelling

product available in the locality. For this reason product sales prices were compared with surrounding suburb

markets to derive likely sales rates.

Woody Point DO (Loft &

Primary)

$250k $490k - $580k

High Rise $380k-$520k $480k-$530k

Woody Point is also a bayside suburb with sale rates reflecting the opportunity to leverage off the scenic

amenity of the district. Product sale prices varied in the locality dependent on proximity to waterfront.

Page 15: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential Codes 15

Financial Feasibility Cost Estimations:

Using the output of the market analysis and architectural analysis, the team has undertaken a

detailed financial feasibility assessment of each site scenario. When undertaking the feasibility

assessment, the team looked at key construction and development feasibility parameters

which are outlined on the scenario summary pages. The feasibility testing made a number of

assumptions to create comparable yet realistic scenarios, although all testing was ‘static’ in

nature. Although notional allowances are made for financing and holding costs, it is assumed

that as projects are completed relatively quickly there is no need to allow for the time value of

money. This approach is considered reasonable for smaller projects however would need to be

considered in particular detail to the larger projects when specifically testing.

Ultimately, a project is gauged to be feasible on a 15%-20% return on cost. and realistically closer

to 20% for the larger projects, where bank funding is required.

Page 16: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential Codes16

4.0 -Code Provision Commentary

The following section provides specific commentary and observations from the process of

interpreting and implementing the provisions of the draft codes whilst developing up the mock

development scenarios.

Issue Impacts/ Recommendations Relevant

Scenarios/

Codes

1. Dwelling House (Row House)

1.1 Provision forces a mandatory dual built to

boundary alignment to the full 10m width. The

resultant house product is inefficient and therefore

expensive on lot widths of 10m.

Suggest that where on 10m lot, only

compulsory built to boundary on a

single wall or limit maximum width to

7.5m product

2, 6

1.2 On narrow lots, it proved difficult to fit all mandatory

landscaping elements at front of lot where driveway

is 5m as required by the code.

Suggest reviewing landscape

provisions where a 5m driveway is

required.

4, 5

1.3 On lots <7.5m wide it proved to be difficult to co-

locate double garage, 500mm2 landscape area,

rear entry, and garbage bin enclosure all within

the lot, whilst still accommating an efficient and

effective house design.

Consider reviewing the combined

or collective impact of all provisions

and see is all are necessary or

opportunities to reduce single

elements.

4

1.4 Provision forces a mandatory dual built to

boundary alignment to the full 10m width. 10m

wide lots test as too wide for built to boundary

both sides, and potentially will not optimise site

area. Excessive GFA will already be achieved in a

single storey, without building a second stroey with

extra and unncessary construction costs, affecting

feasibility.

Intensity of development may not

be reached through this product on

wider lots and expectations will be that

Dwelling House (Row House) are most

suitable for lots <10m wide.

6

2. Dual Occupancy (Loft)

2.1 Conflict with AO32.3 and Setback table:

Only single story can work on lots <7.5m where

built to boundary provisions of Table 1.4c require

maximum BTB wall height of 3.5m.

Any set back to upper loft level creates impractical

internal space (ie max width of 7.5m – 4m

setbacks = 3.5m internal space or loft).

�� No overlook of laneway where

relevant.

�� Suggest allow built to boundary

as mandatory on both sides of

narrow lots to height of 7.5m.

1, 4, 5

Page 17: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential Codes 17

Issue Impacts/ Recommendations Relevant

Scenarios/

Codes

2.2 Cannot achieve sufficient private open space

adjoining lane (AO32.6) on lots 7.5m wide in

ground plane; could be achieved with balcony in

first storey.

RE-word provision to be clear on

balcony solution as acceptable.

1, 2, 4

2.3 Similarly on lots <7.5m wide it is difficult to co-

locate double garage, 500mm2 landscape area,

rear entry, and garbage bin enclosure.

1

3. Multiple Dwelling (Terrace)

3.1 On narrow lots fit of landscaping elements at front

of lot is difficult where driveway is 5m.

Review provision AO8.1

3.2 Visitor parking requirements are in conflict with

typical configuration (each dwelling has own

entrances and driveways) – there is no communal

open space necessary for visitor parking to service

all units.

�� General rates of 1 per 3 dwellings

should be removed as a

requirement of terrace and plex

product.

�� Table 1.5 to read as per Table 1.4

for 5.4m setback to covered car

park for terrace and plex product

as well as detached housing.

Table 1.5

4. Multiple Dwelling (Plex)

4.1 Visitor parking requirements are in conflict with

typical configuration (each dwelling has own

entrances and driveways) – there is no communal

open space necessary for visitor parking to service

all units.

�� General rates of 1 per 3 dwellings

should be removed as a

requirement of terrace and plex

product.

�� Table 1.5 to read as per Table 1.4

for 5.4m setback to covered car

park for terrace and plex product

as well as detached housing.

Table 1.5

5. Multiple Dwelling (Low Rise)

5.1 Low rise apartments on lots <20m wide cannot

be parked @ 2 cp/ du. At lot widths less than

this there is no capacity for underground car

parking, and the ground plane cannot fit all

elements’ minimum requirements (most specifically

car parking, communal open space and deep

planting).

�� 1 car park per dwelling can work,

although may not give the best

outcome for the open space

areas/ amenity.

�� Also does not allow building

efficiency, in terms of optimising

building envelope and yields

(constrained by ground plane

elements).

18, 26

Page 18: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential Codes18

Issue Impacts/ Recommendations Relevant

Scenarios/

Codes

6. Multiple Dwelling (Medium Rise)

6.1 Difficulty in achieving ground floor private open

space as well as communal open space.

�� While scenario 27 is still a relatively wide lot,

the resolution of the ground plane elements

is only achieved with greater depth. Lot

size needs to be very particular to meet

compliance.

�� Consider rationalising the size

and spatial configuration of

ground floor private open space

and communal open space

requirements.

27

7. Multiple Dwelling (High Rise)

7.1 On lots <20m wide, the following minimum

requirements create conflicts and a non-compliant

built form:

�� Need for basement car parking

�� Setbacks to upper levels (which set any lift

shaft and servicing spaces too central within

the site to accommodate efficent basement

areas)

�� Communal open space and separate deep

planting requirements

�� Deep planting impacts on basement areas and

provision of car parking is tight.

33-38

7.2 Generally high rise development at (over six

storeys) requires 3 levels of basement car parking

where @ 2cp/dum, which is essentially unviable

in all instances, consider reviewing parking rates,

particularly for high rise developments in proximity

of public transport.

�� Prohibitive construction costs

beyond 1 level of basement.

�� While car parking is important

in high intensity development,

the parking reduction measures

should be well considered for

implementation and encouraged.

7.3 Podium car parking, in conjunction with basement

(to reduce basement construction costs) is unviable

given additional ramp and access requirements,

within the smaller footprint of the building as a

result of setback requirements.

�� Prohibitive construction costs

beyond 1 level of basement.

�� While car parking is important

in high intensity development,

the parking reduction measures

should be well considered for

implementation and encouraged.

33

Page 19: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential Codes 19

������������ ���

�����

Issue Impacts / Recommendations Relevant

Scenarios

AO1.1 Private Open Space is not allowed in both

primary and secondary setbacks which can be

restrictive in ground plane provision of 25m2

areas.

�� Consider allowing Private Open

Space in secondary setback.

10, 12, 13

AO2.1 Communal Open Space

�� Can be restrictive in the ground plane

(where provided solely as landscaped

area).

�� Requirement for 10m minimum dimension

is confusing in contrast to primary

provision for 5m minimum dimension;

potentially conflicting

�� Reference to solar orientation may be

useful for optimising quality of communal

open space.

�� Possibly remove – steering

committee to check

2, 6

AO5.1 Lesser of 30% or 10m: means 2.25m on 7.5m

lots which is not buildable outcome, which will

impact on terrace product.

7, 8, 9

AO5.1 “Lot frontage 10-12.5 & >10m (laneway)”:

should this be ”<10m (laneway)”?

AO5.1 Lot frontage 10-12.5 & >10m (laneway):

maximum covered car parking width for single

storey is 3m – forces tandem configuration.

AO8.1 Requirements for deep planting and 50%

landscaped frontage are hard fit on narrow lots

(<10m) with vehicle access/ crossovers.

AO8.1 Deep planting exclusion zones relative to

basement car parking restrict opportunities to

locate deep planting (usually to the front or rear

of lot).

Limits design solutions in the ground plane and

basement.

�� Deep planting zones alone can

be usually designed for basement

serviced lots, however the additional

inclusion of communal open space

and landscape areas along the site

front can be subsequently difficult to

resolve.

�� Consider purpose of communal

open space (large minimum

requirements), with potential to

incorporate deep planting zones.

34

Page 20: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential Codes20

Issue Impacts / Recommendations Relevant

Scenarios

AO8.2 Value of Communal open space for both

developers and residents is questionable where

not a large apartment

�� Deep planting in addition to

communal open space: can be

relaxed to better accommodate

all minimal elements. The function

of communal open space is not

necessarily compromised by

inclusion of deep planting zone (and

vice versa).

AO32.2 Interpretation can be confused to read “ensures

the loft is not annexed to..”

�� Re-word a) – “…ensures that the

loft: a) is not located in front of the

primary dwelling; is annexed to …”.

AO32.3 Conflicts with setback table for height >3.5m,

for lots down to 7.5m.

�� On 7.5m wide lots side setbacks of

2m above 3.5m are required to be

applied – creates impractical building

envelope.

�� Recommend change to setback

table for narrow lots.

1, 4, 5

Table heading states max and min

requirements but this is only relevant to front

(primary / secondary) setbacks.

�� Information technical consistency

(are all measures max and min

as per table heading?) can be

improved.

Built to Boundary for 12.5m-18m point b.

states 15m or 50% - needs clarification of

lesser of two values or otherwise.

�� Re-word: “The maximum length

of the built to boundary wall is

the lesser of 15m or 50% of the

boundary”

Built to only up to 3.5m height is restrictive for

narrow lots, seeking to go to double storey, as

is mandated for dual occupancy lots <450m2

(possible conflict).

�� Recommend change to setback

table for narrow lots.

AO32.3

Table 2 Visitor Car Parking: 1 per 3 needs clarification �� State if 1/3 or part thereof. 10

Building

Heights

Table

Check 3 storeys @ 12m in Urban, compared

with 3 storeys @ 9m in NGS

Page 21: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential Codes 21

5.0 Feasibility Outcomes - Overview

The following table provides a summary of the feasibility analysis undertaken, in terms

of the key feasibility indicators of the Return on Cost (ROC) as a % of the total costs of

development, along with an indication of where the project sites in terms of the feasibility

thresholds used for determining viability for the project

������� �� �� ������ ������������������� ROC %

Feasibility

Status

� ����������� ����� ���������� ����������������� -8.1% NO

�� ��������������� ���������� ����������������� 7.2% NO

� ����������� ����� �����!���� ����������������� -12.4% NO

�� ��������������� �����!���� ����������������� 21.6% YES

" ����������� ����� ���������� ����������������� -29.2% NO

"� ��������������� ���������� ����������������� -15.7% NO

# �$�����%�&��'�� (�$�&��'��%� ���%��&��� ����������������� -0.2% NO

#� ���%��&��� ����������������� 9.1% NO

) �$�����%�&��'�� (�$�&��'��%� ���������� ����������������� 18.7% MARGINAL

* �$�����%�&��'�� (�$�&��'��%� ���������� ����������������� -40.3% NO

*� ��������������� ���������� ����������������� -15.7% NO

+ ���������$�����%� ,������ ���%��&��� ����������������� -14.5% NO

- ���������$�����%� ,������ ��$���� .���� -36.7% NO

/ ���������$�����%� ,������ ���������� .���� -37% NO

�0 ���������$�����%� !���� 1�����&���' ����������������� 19.1% YES

�� ���������$�����%� !���� 1�����&���' ����������������� -16.0% NO

�� ���������$�����%� !���� ���������� ����������������� 8.0% NO

��� ��������������� ���������� ����������������� 19.3% YES

�" ���������$�����%� !���� ���������� ����������������� -10.8% NO

�"� ��������������� ���������� ����������������� 8.25% NO

�"� ��������������� ���������� ����������������� 13.1% NO

�# ���������$�����%� !���� 2��3(��% ����������������� -3.75 NO

�#� ��������������� 2��3(��% ����������������� 17.8% MARGINAL

�) ���������$�����%� !���� �����4��� ����������������� -28.5% NO

�)� ��������������� �����4��� ����������������� 4.15% NO

�* ��$�(�'��1���5���' ���������� ����������������� -8.5% NO

�*� ��������������� ���������� ����������������� 18.3% MARGINAL

�*� ��������������� ���������� ����������������� 18.3% MARGINAL

�+ ��$�(�'��1���5���' 2��3(��% ����������������� 21.1% YES

Page 22: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential Codes22

�- ��$�(�'��1���5���' 1�����&���' ����������������� 16.4% MARGINAL

�/ ��$�(�'��1���5���' 1�����&���' ����������������� 19.0% YES

�0 ��$�(�'��1���5���' �����4��� ����������������� 13.7% NO

�� ��$�(�'��1���5���' �����4��� ����������������� 1.4% NO

�� ��$�(�'��1���5���' ��$���� .���� 2.9% NO

�" ��$�(�'��1���5���' ��$���� .���� 10.6% NO

�"� ��������������� ��$���� .���� 20.45% YES

�# ��$�(�'��1���5���' ���%��� .���� 38.9% YES

�) ��$�(�'��1���5���' ���%��� .���� 28.4% YES

�* �����5�(�'��1���5���' (������� .���� 37.3% YES

�+ �����5�(�'��1���5���' (������� .���� -37.2% NO

�+� ��������������� (������� .���� -12.0% NO

�- �����5�(�'��1���5���' ���%��� .���� -27.6% NO

�� ��������������� ���%��� .���� 31% YES

�/ �����5�(�'��1���5���' 6����%��� .���� -18.2% NO

"0 �����5�(�'��1���5���' 6����%��� ������� �����'����������7�'���'� -11.1% NO

"� �����5�(�'��1���5���' 1�����&���' ������� �����'����������7�'���'� 15.2% MARGINAL

"� �����5�(�'��1���5���' ���������� ������� �����'����������7�'���'� -45.7% NO

"" &�%4�(�'��1���5���'� -�'�����'� �����!���� .���� 25% YES

"# &�%4�(�'��1���5���'� -�'�����'� (������� .���� Scenario Not Possible

") &�%4�(�'��1���5���'� *�'�����'� ��$���� .���� -8.5% NO

"* &�%4�(�'��1���5���'� ���'�����' (������� ������� ����'��

��������7�'���'� -45.7% NO

"*� ��������������� (������� ������� ����'����������7�'���'� 20.8% YES

"+ &�%4�(�'��1���5���'� -�'�����'� �����4��� ������� ����'��

��������7�'���'� -39.1% NO

"- &�%4�(�'��1���5���'� -�'�����'� ���������� ������� ����'��

��������7�'���'� -35.7% NO

Page 23: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential Codes 23

6.0 Feasibility Outcomes - Observations

Of the 38 primary scenarios tested, the vast majority failed to meet industry standard

feasibility levels with conflicts between design priorities and achievable density. Across the

inland suburbs, feasibility was largely hampered by the low product sale prices achievable

in the current market, with sales prices generally not offsetting the standardized industry

cost of construction. The bay side suburbs were capable of achieving a higher sales rate

and therefore feasibilities were generally more positive.

The following regular issues were also identified during the feasibility assessments:

• In multiple scenarios, the complexity of requirements to be accommodated within the

ground plane made it challenging to accommodate all elements compliantly.

• Communal open space provision and specifically the 10m minimum dimension,

effectively necessitates a 100 sqm communal open space area. Question the need,

costs and ongoing maintenance cost benefits of this space, at it dramatically affected

many scenario designs and feasibility as a result of restricting yield or further parking.

• Car parking rates of 2 per dwelling + 1 visitor space per 3 dwellings resulted in

significant spatial and cost impediments to project viability. With a carpark equating to

approximately 35 sqm, at an effective rate of 2.3 spaces per typical 2 bedroom unit,

with an area of 80sqm, the area of parking was equal to the size of the units. Put

another way, as big as the building is, the basement needs to be the same size. At

a cost premium of between $40-50K per carpark when in a basement configuration,

this either adds $50K to the cost of the unit if this can’t be recovered or affects

affordability negatively.

• Many of the alternate scenarios were run with 1 car park per dwelling, which

dramatically improved feasibilities in all instances, although some projects still did not

meet the feasibility threshold.

• The row house/ terrace products with overprescribed mandatory widths and

mandatory built to boundary, results in inefficient building designs and therefore extra

costs with no revenue benefit.

• The mandatory minimum height of 3 storeys in certain circumstances forces inefficient

building formats that are overly large and not suited to those markets, with associated

cost / viability impacts.

• The plan would seem to be promoting building typologies that are perhaps not suited

to markets at this time (or in the near future). MBRC has a number of regions with

significant price premiums, but also depressed prices, which makes the challenge of

delivering the same product across the region difficult or impossible without regional

variations to things like parking rates etc.

Page 24: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential Codes24

• Many of the scenarios were modelling in ‘infill’ contexts which effectively will

necessitate people purchasing an existing house and land to then demolish the

dwelling to construct the new products. This comes with significant extra costs over

and above vacant land. Where Greenfield development can still be achieved, this will

remain the industries preferred method of development as efficiencies can be found

when purchasing large land parcels.

• Townhouse development is the dominant multi-unit format across all suburbs which

is a reflection of the lower construction costs for the product and the established

market perspective of private living space. Townhouse development is predominantly

undertaken as Greenfield development however there is opportunity to achieve the

‘plex’ product if consolidated land parcels can be purchased at a lower market price

and be large enough to benefit from a higher yield outcome.

• The apartment product is not a dominant typology in the inland suburbs which is a

reflection of the high construction cost to build the product and the low sales prices

achievable in the current market for these suburbs. This disparity would be further

exasperated when basement parking is required.

• The smaller 18m and 20m wide frontage lots were unable to achieve a viable design

solution for the medium and high rise product as basements could not be achieved

and therefore yield was instead determined by the number of cars that could be

parked on the ground plane. This was made more challenging when also attempting

to accommodate all ground plane elements (communal open space and deep

planting) that further reduced number of parking spaces achievable. Podium car

parking was similarly constrained on these lots sizes.

• For the smaller product, land purchase price impacted feasibility as did low sales

rates for this product. Achievable yield is obviously more limited on smaller sites and

generally was not enough to offset costs of land purchase and construction. If product

market prices improve this product may become more viable.

Page 25: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Section 1 - Scenario Designs

Page 26: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 27: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 28: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 29: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 30: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 31: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 32: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 33: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 34: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 35: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 36: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 37: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 38: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 39: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 40: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 41: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 42: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 43: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 44: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 45: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 46: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 47: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 48: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 49: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 50: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 51: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 52: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 53: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 54: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 55: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 56: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 57: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 58: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 59: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 60: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 61: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 62: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 63: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 64: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 65: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 66: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 67: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 68: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 69: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 70: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 71: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 72: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 73: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 74: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 75: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 76: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 77: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 78: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 79: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 80: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 81: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 82: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 83: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 84: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 85: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 86: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 87: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 88: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 89: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 90: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential
Page 91: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Section 2 - Development Scenario Summaries

Page 92: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�1:�D

ual�O

ccup

ancy�(Loft)

Locatio

nCabo

olture

Zone

/Precinct

NextG

enerationSubu

rban

Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Site�Frontage

7.5

Site�Dep

th40

Land

�Area

300

Yield

2Ca

r�Parking�Rate

2cp/du

Dwellin

g�Co

nfiguration

Prim

aryDw

ellingandLoft

No.�Of�3

�bed

room

s1

No.�Of�1

�bed

room

s1

Infrastructure�Cha

rges�(C

umulative)

$22,000.00

(Credit�for�existing�dw

elling)

DA�Fee

$2,310.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(600�sq

m)

$238,000.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(300�sq

m)

$119,000.00

(600

sqm�lot�d

ivided�by�2)

Prod

uct�S

ale�Price�(1�bed

room

)$190,000.00

Prod

uct�S

ale�Price�(Prim

ary�Dw

ellin

g)$380,000.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

�(Prim

ary�Dw

ellin

g)223

$1,050

$234,150

GFA

�(Secon

dary�Dwellin

g)52

$1,050

$54,600

Balcon

y�(Secon

dary�Dwellin

g)23

$250

$5,750

Garage

36$850

$30,600

Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

27.5

$140

$3,850

Land

scap

ing

51.25

$45

$2,306

Private�Ope

n�Space�(Groun

d�flo

or)

33$160

$5,280

Total

445.75

$336,536.25

Feasibility�Outpu

tsLand

�Purchase�Price

$127,625.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

$340,133.00

Total�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

osts

$515,860.00

Gross�Realisation

$570,000.00

Developm

ent�P

rofit

�$41,994.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

�8.14%

Developm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

No

Scen

arioassum

esth

epu

rchaseofa600

sqmexistingho

useand

land

,rem

ovalofh

ouseand

creationof2x30

0lots.Scen

arioth

en

mod

elssingle300sqm

rede

velopm

ent.

Scen

arioisunviable,as a

resultofhighbaseland

cost.Inadd

ition

curren

tmarketp

ricesto

lowto

offsetcostsofcon

structionof2x

newdwellings.

Page 93: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�1a:�Dua

l�Occup

ancy���Sale�Pric

e�Va

riatio

nLocatio

nCabo

olture

Zone

/Precinct

NextG

enerationSubu

rban

Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Site�Frontage

7.5

Site�Dep

th40

Land

�Area

300

Yield

2Ca

r�Parking�Rate

2cp/du

Dwellin

g�Co

nfiguration

Prim

aryDw

ellingandLoft

No.�Of�3

�bed

room

s1

No.�Of�1

�bed

room

s1

Infrastructure�Cha

rges�Cum

ulative

$22,00

0.00

(Credit�for�existing�dw

elling)

DA�Fee

$2,310

.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(600

�sqm)

$238

,000

.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(300

�sqm)

$119

,000

.00

(600

sqm�lot�d

ivided�by�2)

Prod

uct�S

ale�Price�(1�bed

room

)$2

10,000

.00

Prod

uct�S

ale�Price�(Prim

ary�Dw

ellin

g)$4

50,000

.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

�(Prim

ary�Dw

ellin

g)22

3$1

,050

$234

,150

GFA

�(Secon

dary�Dwellin

g)52

$1,050

$54,60

0Ba

lcon

y�(Secon

dary�Dwellin

g )23

$250

$5,750

Garage

36$8

50$3

0,60

0Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

27.5

$140

$3,850

Land

scap

ing

51.25

$45

$2,306

Private�Ope

n�Space�(Groun

d�flo

or)

33$1

60$5

,280

Total

445.75

336,53

6$

Feasibility�Outpu

tsLand

�Purchase�Price

$127

,625

.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

$340

,133

.00

Total�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

ost s

$515

,860

.00

Gross�Realisation

$660

,000

.00

Developm

ent�P

rofit

$36,97

1.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

7.17

%De

velopm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

No

Varia

tiontobasescen

ario,w

hichincreasesa

ssum

edsa

lepricesto

$2

10kand$4

50K.Thisc

hangedidim

proveRO

C,alth

oughstillnot

toalevelw

hereth

eprojectw

ouldproceed

.Inadd

ition

,prices

used

wou

ldbeabsolutepremiumpricesatthistim

eandun

likelyto

reachtheselevelsforseveralyears.Ba

seland

pricestillth

emost

restrictiv

easpe

ctofthe

feasibility.

Page 94: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�2:�D

ual�O

ccup

ancy�(Loft)

Locatio

nWoo

dyPoint

Zone

/Precinct

NextG

enerationSubu

rban

Site�Frontage

10Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Site�Dep

th40

Land

�Area

400

Yield

2Ca

r�Parking�Rate

2cp/du

Dwellin

g�Co

nfiguration

Prim

aryDw

ellingandLoft

No.�Of�3

�bed

room

s1

No.�Of�1

�bed

room

s1

Infrastructure�Cha

rges�

$22,00

0.00

(Credited�for�e

xisting�dw

elling)

DA�Fee

$2,310

.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(400

�sqm)

$230

,000

.00

(Old�hou

se�on�land

)Prod

uct�S

ale�Price�(Loft)

$250

,000

.00

Prod

uct�S

ale�Price�(Prim

ary�Dw

ellin

g)$5

50,000

.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

�(Prim

ary�Dw

ellin

g)29

4$1

,050

$308

,700

GFA

�(Secon

dary�Dwellin

g)60

$1,050

$63,00

0Ba

lcon

y�(Secon

dary�Dwellin

g )26

$250

$6,500

Garage

56$8

50$4

7,60

0Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

27.5

$140

$3,850

Land

scap

ing

86$4

5$3

,870

Private�Ope

n�Space�(Groun

d�flo

or)

62$1

60$9

,920

Total

611.5

443,44

0$

Feasibility�Outpu

tsExpe

nse

Land

�Purchase�Price

$241

,475

.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

$465

,612

.00

Total�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

ost s

$762

,122

.00

Gross�Realisation

$800

,000

.00

Developm

ent�P

rofit

�$94

,382

.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

�12.38

%De

velopm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

No

Scen

arioassum

esth

epu

rchaseofa400

sqmexistingho

useand

land

,rem

ovalofh

ouseand

creationofanew

dwellingwith

rear

loftprodu

ctinclud

edand

thesaleoftho

seindividu

ally.

Scen

arioisunviableandinfactlosesm

oney.Itisconsidered

that

thebaseland

pricesareto

ohighto

produ

ceand

develop

inaninfill

manne

r.Forth

isscen

arioto

bemorefeasiblease

cond

ary

dwellingon

lycou

ldbemod

elledatth

erearofanexistingprim

ary

dwellinginsteadofanew

buildfo

rthe

hou

se.

Page 95: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�2a:�Dua

l�Occup

ancy���Site�Size�Va

riatio

nLocatio

nWoo

dyPoint

Zone

/Precinct

NextG

enerationSubu

rban

Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Site�Frontage�(per�produ

ct)

7.5

Site�Dep

th40

Land

�Area

1000

Yield

6Dw

ellin

g�Co

nfiguration

Prim

aryDw

ellingandLoftx3

No.�Of�3

�bed

room

s3

No.�Of�1

�bed

room

s3

Infrastructure�Cha

rges�(cum

ulative)

$122

,000

.00

(Credit�for�existing�dw

elling)

DA�Fee

$2,310

.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(100

0�sqm)

$450

,000

.00

(Old�hou

se�on�land

)Prod

uct�S

ale�Price�(Loft)

$250

,000

.00

Prim

ary�Dw

ellin

g�Sales�P

rice

$550

,000

.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

�(All�dw

ellin

gs)

789

$1,050

$828

,450

Balcon

ys69

$250

$17,25

0Garages

108

$850

$91,80

0Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

84$1

40$1

1,76

0Land

scap

ing

153

$45

$6,885

Private�Ope

n�Space�(Groun

d�flo

or)

99$1

60$1

5,84

0To

tal

1302

971,98

5$

Feasibility�Outpu

tsLand

�Purchase�Price

$469

,175

.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

$1,020

,584

.00

Total�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

osts

$1,675

,456

.00

Gross�Realisation

$2,400

,000

.00

Developm

ent�P

rofi t

$362

,478

.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

21.63%

Developm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

YES

Scen

ariovariatio

n,th

emod

elsa

similarscenario

,butinsteadofa

single40

0sqm

Lot,ithasb

eenmod

elledon

a100

0sqm

vacantlot,w

hichisth

en

develope

dinto3hou

sesa

nd3re

arloftprodu

cts,eachat7.5m

fron

tage

Scen

arioachievesv

iability,whichillustratesthatthistypeof

prod

ucta

rem

orelikelytooccuronvacantland

ratherth

an

replacingexistingstockandfurthe

rthanefficienciesfromm

ultip

le

prod

uctcanbegained

ratherth

anasingleprodu

ct.

Page 96: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�3:�D

ual�O

ccup

ancy�(Loft)

Locatio

nCabo

olture

Zone

/Precinct

NextG

enerationSubu

rban

Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Site�Frontage

18Site�Dep

th40

Land

�Area

720

Yield

2Ca

r�Parking�Rate

2cp/du

Dwellin

g�Co

nfiguration

Prim

aryDw

ellingandLoft

No.�Of�3

�bed

room

s1

No.�Of�1

�bed

room

s1

Infrastructure�Cha

rges�(loft)

$22,00

0.00

(Credit�for�existing�dw

elling)

DA�Fee

$2,310

.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(800

�sqm)

$230

,000

.00

(Old�hou

se�on�land

)Prod

uct�S

ale�Price�(1�bed

room

)$1

90,000

.00

Prod

uct�S

ale�Price�(Prim

ary�Dw

ellin

g)$3

80,000

.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

�(Prim

ary�Dw

ellin

g)184

$1,050

$193,200

GFA

�(Secon

dary�Dwellin

g)56

$1,050

$58,800

Balcon

y�45.5

$250

$11,375

Garage

56$850

$47,600

Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

30$140

$4,200

Land

scap

ing

293

$45

$13,185

Private�Ope

n�Space�(Groun

d�flo

or)

144

$160

$23,040

Total

808.5

351,400

$

Feasibility�Outpu

tsExpe

nse

Land

�Purchase�Price

$241

,475

.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

$350

,989

.00

Total�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

osts

$641

,166

.00

Gross�Realisation

$570

,000

.00

Developm

ent�P

rofit

�$18

6,98

3.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

�29.16

%De

velopm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

NO

Scen

arioassum

esth

epu

rchaseofa720

sqmexistingho

useand

land

,rem

ovalofh

ouseand

creationofanew

dwellingwith

rearloft

prod

uctinclude

dandthesaleoftho

seindividu

ally.

Scen

arioisunviableandinfactlosesm

oney,due

toth

ebaseland

pricesbeingto

ohighto

produ

ceand

develop

inaninfillm

anne

r.

Forthisscenario

tobemorefeasiblease

cond

arydw

ellingon

ly

couldbe

mod

elledatth

erearofanexistingprim

arydw

elling

insteadofanew

buildfo

rthe

hou

se.

Page 97: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�3a:�Dua

l�Occup

ancy��Site

�Con

figuration�Va

riatio

n�Locatio

nCabo

olture

Zone

/Precinct

NextG

enerationSubu

rban

Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Site�Frontage

18Site�Dep

th40

Land

�Area

720

Yield

2Ca

r�Parking�Rate

2cp/du

Dwellin

g�Co

nfiguration

Dualoccup

ancytradition

alNo.�Of�3

�bed

room

s2

Infrastructure�Cha

rges�(cum

ulative)

$28,000.00

(credit�for�existing�dw

elling)

DA�Fee

$2,310.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(800�sq

m)

$230,000.00

(Old�hou

se�on�land

)Prod

uct�S

ale�Price�(Prim

ary�Dw

ellin

g)$450,000.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

�(Prim

ary�Dw

ellin

g)446

$1,050

$468,300

Garage

72$850

$61,200

Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

55$140

$7,700

Land

scap

ing

102.5

$45

$4,613

Private�Ope

n�Space�(Groun

d�flo

or)

66$160

$10,560

Total

741.5

552,373

$

Feasibility�Outpu

t sLand

�Purchase�Price

$241,475.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

$579,968.00

Total�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

osts

$888,796.00

Gross�Realisation

$900,000.00

Developm

ent�P

rofit

�$140,034.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

�15.70%

Developm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

NO

Scen

ariom

odelsthe

same72

0sqm

lot,whichisth

ensu

bdivided

into3x360

sqmlots,w

ith2attache

ddw

ellingscon

structed

onthe

resulta

nt2allotm

ents.Theho

usesareth

enlarger, w

hichm

eans

thatyou

canachieveahighe

rsalepricesfo

rthe

hou

ses.The

combinatio

nofth

ehighersa

lepriceandlessoverallconstructio

ncostsimprovesviabilityalthou

ghstillwou

ldnotprodu

ceaviable

project,againtheun

derly

ingland

pricesarecurrentlyto

ohighto

facilitateinfillprojects.

Page 98: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�4:�R

ow�Hou

sing�(Freeh

old)

Locatio

nMangoHill

Zone

/Precinct

NextG

enerationSubu

rban

Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Yield�

4Ca

r�Parking�Rate

2cp/du

No.�Of�3

�bed

room

s4

Dwellin

g�Fron

tage

7.5

Site�Frontage

30Site�Dep

th35

Land

�Area

1050

Infrastructure�Cha

rges�(p

er�du)

$88,00

0.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(100

0�sqm)

$230

,000

.00

(Vacan

t�Lan

d)Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e�(3�bed

room

)$3

50,000

.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

568

$1,050

$596

,400

Garage

144

$850

$122

,400

Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

40$1

40$5

,600

Private�Ope

n�Space�(Groun

d�flo

or)

112

$160

$17,92

0Land

scap

ing

150

$45

$6,750

Total

870

$749

,070

Feasibility�Outpu

tsLand

�Purchase�Price

$234

,230

.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

$786

,524

.00

Total�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

osts

$1,183

,519

.00

Gross�Realisation

$1,400

,000

.00

Developm

ent�P

rofit

�$1,89

5.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

�0.16%

Developm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

NO

Scen

ariom

odelsa

100

0sqmvacantlot,w

hichisth

endevelop

ed

into4xte

rraceprod

ucts.Theterracesasp

ropo

sedwere2storey

andqu

iteexpansiv

e,with

theextraspaceinnon

�functio

nalareas,

whichcreated

highe

rcon

structionprices,butnone

cessarilygreater

revenu

e.The

scen

ariofailedtom

eetviabilitydu

etoacom

binatio

nofhighe

rcon

structionpricesand

mod

eratepo

tentialsaleprices.

Page 99: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�4a:�Row

�Hou

sing���Re

duced�Co

nstructio

n�Area

Locatio

nMangoHill

Zone

/Precinct

NextG

enerationSubu

rban

Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Yield�(no.�of�d

wellin

gs)

4Ca

r�Parking�Rate

2cp/du

No.�Of�3

�bed

room

s4

Dwellin

g�Fron

tage

7.5

Site�Frontage

30Site�Dep

th35

Land

�Area

1050

Infrastructure�Cha

rges�(p

er�du)

$88,000.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(1000�sqm)

$230,000.00

(Vacan

t�Lan

d)Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e�(2�bed

room

,�2�car)

$350,000.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

360

$1,050

$378,000

Garage

144

$850

$122,400

Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

40$140

$5,600

Private�Ope

n�Space�(Groun

d�flo

or)

112

$160

$17,920

Land

scap

ing

150

$45

$6,750

Total

662

$530,670

Feasibility�Outpu

tsLand

�Purchase�Price

$225,950.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

$557,204.00

Total�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

osts

$909,249.00

Gross�Realisation

$1,180,000.00

Developm

ent�P

rofit

$83,032.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

9.13%

Developm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

NO

Scen

ariovariatio

n,m

odelsthe

1000sqm

site,butdevelop

s4x

smallerterraceprodu

cts.The

redu

ctioninbuildingsiz

egene

rates

savingsinconstructio

ncosts,yetth

esalepricewasre

tained

atthe

samelevel.Projectachievesv

iabilitythreshold.

Page 100: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�5:�R

ow�Hou

sing�(Freeh

old)

Locatio

nCabo

olture

Zone

/Precinct

NextG

enerationSubu

rban

Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Yield�(no.�of�d

wellin

gs)

4Ca

r�Parking�Rate

2cp/du

No.�Of�3

�bed

room

s4

Dwellin

g�Fron

tage

7.5

Site�Frontage

30Site�Dep

th35

Land

�Area

1050

Infrastructure�Cha

rges�(p

er�du)

$88,000.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(1000�sqm)

$215,000.00

(Vacan

t�Lan

d)Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e�(2�bed

room

,�2�car)

$295,000.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

360

$1,050

$378,000

Garage

144

$850

$34,000

Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

40$140

$15,680

Private�Ope

n�Space�(Groun

d�flo

or)

112

$160

$24,000

Land

scap

ing

150

$45

$27,990

Total

622

$479,670

Feasibility�Outpu

tsLand

�Purchase�Price

$225,950.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

$557,204.00

Total�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

osts

$909,249.00

Gross�Realisation

$1,280,000.00

Developm

ent�P

rofit

$170,032.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

18.70%

Developm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

Marginal

Salesp

ricewou

ldneedtobearou

nd$32

0kto

be18

.7%and

more

feasible.Thisisn

otare

alisticpricefora

2bed

room

produ

ctin

Cabo

olture.

Page 101: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�6:�R

ow�Hou

sing�(Freeh

old)

Locatio

nCabo

olture

Zone

/Precinct

NextG

enerationSubu

rban

Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Yield�(no.�of�d

wellin

gs)

3Ca

r�Parking�Rate

2cp/du

No.�Of�3

�bed

room

s3

Dwellin

g�Fron

tage

10Site�Frontage

30Site�Dep

th40

Land

�Area

1200

Infrastructure�Cha

rges�(p

er�du)

$84,000.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(1200�sqm)

$220,000.00

(Vacan

t�Lan

d)Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e�(3�bed

room

,�2�car)

$310,000.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

645

$1,050

$677,250

Garage

108

$850

$70,125

Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

82.5

$140

$10,500

Private�Ope

n�Space�(Groun

d�flo

or)

75$160

$43,200

Land

scap

ing

270

$45

$44,550

Total

990

$845,625

Feasibility�Outpu

tsLand

�Purchase�Price

$231,125.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

$844,914.00

Total�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

osts

$1,214,030.00

Gross�Realisation

$930,000.00

Developm

ent�P

rofit

�$489,818.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

�40.30%

Developm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

NO

Scen

ariom

odelsa

120

0sqm

vacantlot,w

hichisth

endevelop

ed

into3x10m

wideterraceprod

ucts.Terraceprovision

sforcea

builtto

bothalignm

entsoutcome,whichre

sultsinan aw

kwardly

wideandinefficientbuilding.Projectlosessignificanta

mou

ntso

fmon

eyasa

result.

Itissuggestedthatm

andatedbu

iltto

bothalignm

entssh

ouldbe

reconsidered

.

Page 102: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�6a:�Row

�Hou

sing���Sm

aller�p

rodu

ct�

Locatio

nCabo

olture

Zone

/Precinct

NextG

enerationSubu

rban

Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Yield�(no.�of�d

wellin

gs)

3Ca

r�Parking�Rate

2cp/du

No.�Of�3

�bed

room

s3

Dwellin

g�Fron

tage

10Site�Frontage

30Site�Dep

th40

Land

�Area

1200

Infrastructure�Cha

rges�(p

er�du)

$84,000.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(1200�sqm)

$220,000.00

(Vacan

t�Lan

d)Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e�(3�bed

room

,�2�car)

$310,000.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

390

$1,050

$409,500

Garage

108

$850

$70,125

Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

82.5

$140

$10,500

Private�Ope

n�Space�(Groun

d�flo

or)

75$160

$43,200

Land

scap

ing

270

$45

$33,075

Total

735

$566,400

Feasibility�Outpu

tsLand

�Purchase�Price

$231,125.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

$563,777.00

Total�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

osts

$917,360.00

Gross�Realisation

$930,000.00

Developm

ent�P

rofit

�$144,266.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

�15.70%

Developm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

NO

Scen

ariovariatio

n,m

odelsthe

1200sqm

site,butdevelop

s3x10m

widesm

allerterraceprodu

cts.The

redu

ctioninbuildingsiz

egene

ratessavingsincon

structioncosts,yetth

esalepricewas

retained

atthe

samelevel.Projectstillfailsto

achieveviability

threshold.

Thealteratio

norre

movalofthe

10m

wideprovision

wou

ldallow

thecreatio

nofa4thprodu

ctand

thusth

efeasibilityben

efitsfrom

theadditio

nalreven

ueand

projectwou

ldachieveasimilarreturn

toth

atofscenario

5.

Page 103: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�7:�M

ultip

le�Dwellin

g�(Terrace)

Scen

ario

7Prod

uct

Multip

leDwelling(terrace)

Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Locatio

nMangoHill

Zone

/Precinct

NextG

enerationSubu

rban

Yield�(no.�of�d

wellin

gs)

3Ca

r�Parking�Rate

1cp/du

+vis

No.�Of�3

�bed

room

s3

Site�Frontage

25Site�Dep

th40

Land

�Area

1000

Infrastructure�Cha

rges�(p

er�du)

$84,00

0.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(100

0�sqm)

$230

,000

.00

(Vacan

t�Lan

d)Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e$3

60,000

.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

534

$1,050

$560

,700

Garage

54$8

50$4

5,90

0Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

65$1

40$9

,100

Private�Ope

n�Space�(Groun

d�flo

or)

115.5

$160

$18,48

0Land

scap

ing

244

$45

$10,98

0To

tal

958.5

$645

,160

Feasibility�Outpu

tsLand

�Purchase�Price

$241

,475

.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

$677

,334

.00

Total�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

osts

$1,047

,542

.00

Gross�Realisation

$1,080

,000

.00

Developm

ent�P

rofit

�$15

1,89

4.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

�14.50

%De

velopm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

NO

PleaseNote:

MangoHillisare

lativ

elyne

wsu

burbwith

green

fielddevelop

men

tthe

pred

ominantd

evelop

men

ttype.

Thegreenfielddevelop

men

tsite

sgen

erallyhosta

mixofh

ousin

gtypo

logies�

with

examplesofsmalllothou

sing,te

rraceandtownh

ouseprodu

ctwith

inth

elocality.The

selotsgen

erallyachievehighe

rsub

divisio

nefficienciesa

nd

thereforeland

pricepe

rsqu

aremeterand

perdwellingislower.V

acantlandin

theareagen

erallyachieves$

220kto

$23

0kfo

rsite

sbetween80

0sqm

to

1000

sqm.Improved

hou

seand

land

produ

ctisnew

inth

elocalityandaverages

arou

nda$44

0ksa

lesp

rice.

Largede

velopm

entsite

sarestillavailableinth

elocalityanditisen

visio

ned

thatgreen

fielddevelop

men

twillre

maindo

minant�avgvacantlandpu

rchase

priceofgreen

fieldsitesw

hendivide

dby800

sqmis$80

k.W

hendivide

dby

1000

sqmitis$10

0k.

Scen

ariom

odelsa

similarsitu

ationtoScenario

6,w

ithth

esame

outcom

e.A

doptionofsimilara

pproachtore

move10

mprovisio

nandallowa4thsm

allerp

rodu

ct@

7.5mfron

tagere

sultsinaviable

outcom

e.

Asm

entio

nedbe

low�greenfielddevelop

men

tisthe

prominen

tde

velopm

entforminth

eareaand

morerevenu

ecouldbe

foun

dthroughlargersitedevelop

men

tefficien

cies.

Page 104: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�8:�M

ultip

le�Dwellin

g�(Terrace)

Locatio

nLawnton

Zone

/Precinct

Urban

Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Yield�(no.�of�d

wellin

gs)

3Ca

r�Park�Ra

te1cp/du

+vi

No.�Of�3

�bed

room

s3

Site�Frontage

25Site�Dep

th40

Land

�Area

1000

Infrastructure�Cha

rges�(p

er�du)

$56,000.00

(Credit�for�existing�dw

elling )

DA�Fee

$3,480.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(1000�sqm)

$301,000.00

(Old�hou

se�and

�Lan

d)Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e$360,000.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

729

$1,050

$765,450

Balcon

y108

$250

$27,000

Garage

40$850

$34,000

Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

39$140

$5,460

Private�Ope

n�Space�(Groun

d�flo

or)

147

$160

$23,520

Land

scap

ing

262

$45

$11,790

Deep

�planting

54$45

$2,430

Total

1231

$869,650

Feasibility�Outpu

tsLand

�Purchase�Price

$313,925.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

$913,133.00

Total�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

osts

$1,341,988.00

Gross�Realisation

$1,080,000.00

Developm

ent�P

rofit

�$492,654.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

�36.70%

Developm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

NO

Scen

ariom

odelsa

1000sqm

siteth

atisdevelop

edfo

r3x3storey

terraceprod

ucts.Provision

smandateam

inim

umheighto

f3

storeys.

3storeycon

structioniscostprohibitiv

e,and

spatiallycreatesan

overlylargeandinefficientbuildingwhichsignificantlyincreases

constructio

ncostsa

ndintu

rndep

reciatesth

ereturnoncost.

Deletin

gthemandatory3storeyre

quire

men

tfromte

rraceprod

uct

wou

ldallowam

oresensible and

efficien

tprodu

ctto

be

Page 105: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�9:�M

ultip

le�Dwellin

g�(Terrace)

Locatio

nCabo

olture

Zone

/Precinct

Urban

Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Yield�(no.�of�d

wellin

gs)

3Ca

r�Parking�Rate

2du/cp+vi

No.�Of�3

�bed

room

s3

Site�Frontage

25Site�Dep

th40

Land

�Area

1000

Infrastructure�Cha

rges�(p

er�du)

$56,00

0.00

(Credit�for�existing�dw

elling)

DA�Fee

$3,480

.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(100

0�sqm)

$241

,000

.00

(Old�hou

se�on�land

)Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e�(3�bed

room

)$3

50,000

.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

729

$1,050

$765

,450

Balcon

y10

8$2

50$2

7,00

0Garage

79$8

50$6

7,15

0Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

39$1

40$5

,460

Private�Ope

n �Space�(Groun

d�flo

or)

147

$160

$23,52

0Land

scap

ing

222

$45

$9,990

Deep

�planting

54$4

5$2

,430

Total

1191

$901

,000

Expe

nse

Land

�Purchase�Price

$252

,860

.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

$946

,050

.00

Total�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

osts

$1,315

,659

.00

Gross�Realisation

$1,050

,000

.00

Developm

ent�P

rofit

�$48

6,81

1.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

�37.00

%De

velopm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

NO

Scen

ariom

odelsa

100

0sqm

siteth

atisdevelop

edfo

r3x3storey

terraceprod

ucts.Provision

smandateam

inim

umheighto

f3

storeys.

3storeycon

structioniscostprohibitiv

e,and

spatiallycreatesan

overlylargeandinefficientbuildingwhichsignificantlyincreases

constructio

ncostsa

ndintu

rndep

reciatesth

ereturnoncost.

Deletin

gthemandatory3storeyre

quire

men

tfromte

rraceprod

uct

wou

ldallowam

oresensibleand

efficien

tprodu

ctto

be

Page 106: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�10:�M

ultip

le�Dwellin

g�(Plex)

Locatio

nAranaHills

Zone

/Precinct

NextG

enerationSubu

rban

Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Yield�(no.�of�d

wellin

gs)

5Ca

r�Parking�Rate

2cp/du

+vi

No.�Of�3

�bed

room

s5

Site�Frontage

25Site�Dep

th40

Land

�Area

1000

Infrastructure�Cha

rges�(cum

ulative)

$112

,000

.00

(Credit�for�existing�dw

elling)

DA�Fee

$3,480

.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(100

0�sqm)

$478

,000

.00

(Old�hou

se�on�land

)Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e�(3�bed

)$4

30,000

.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

580

$1,050

6090

00Ba

lcon

y15

0$2

5037

500

Garage

165

$850

1402

50Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

218

$140

3052

0Land

scap

ing

110

$45

4950

Deep

�planting

70$4

531

50To

tal

978

8253

70

Feasibility�Outpu

tsLand

�Purchase�Price

$498

,155

.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

$866

,639

.00

Total�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

osts

$1,533

,155

.00

Gross�Realisation

$2,150

,000

.00

Developm

ent�P

rofit

$293

,346

.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

19.10%

Developm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

Marginal

Scen

ariom

odelsa

100

0sqm

siteth

atisdevelop

edfo

r5xte

rrace

prod

ucts.Thehighersa

lepricesbeingachievedinAranaHills

resultsinahighe

rrecoveryofcon

structioncostsa

ndth

ereforea

viableprojectre

turn.

Page 107: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�11:�M

ultip

le�Dwellin

g�(Plex���C

orne

r�Lot)

Locatio

nAranaHills

Zone

/Precinct

NextG

enerationSubu

rban

Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Yield�(no.�of�d

wellin

gs)

3Ca

r�Parking�Rate

2cp/du

+vi

No.�Of�3

�bed

room

s3

Site�Frontage

20Site�Dep

th40

Land

�Area

800

Infrastructure�Cha

rges�(p

er�du)

$56,00

0.00

(credit�for�existing�dw

elling)

DA�Fee

$3,480

.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(800

�sqm)

$416

,000

.00

(old�hou

se�on�land

)Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e$4

30,000

.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

492

$1,050

$516

,600

Balcon

y75

$250

$18,75

0Garage

99$8

50$8

4,15

0Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

193

$140

$27,02

0Land

scap

ing

110

$45

$4,950

Deep

�planting

160

$45

$7,200

Total

955

$658

,670

Feasibility�Outpu

tsLand

�Purchase�Price

$433

,985

.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

6916

04To

tal�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

osts

$1,284

,280

.00

Gross�Realisation

$1,290

,000

.00

Developm

ent�P

rofit

�$20

7,56

3.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

�16%

Developm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

No

Scen

ariom

odelsa

n80

0sqm

siteth

atisdevelop

edfo

r3xte

rrace

prod

ucts.

Land

salesp

ricepe

rdwellingisinflatedwhe

nsplitovero

nly3

prod

uct.Dw

ellingsat1

60sqmarealso

gen

erou

swhichadd

sto

constructio

ncost.The

rem

aybesomebe

nefitsinredu

cingsizeof

prod

ucth

owevernoen

oughto

makethefeasibilitie

sstackup.

Limite

dne

wplexprod

uctinAranaHills�EvertonHillssa

lesp

rices

forN

ewPlexprod

ucta

chieveso

ver$

430,00

0.New

townh

ouse

prod

uctinAranaHillsasksfor$48

0�$5

50k.Olderplexand

townh

ouseprodu

ctisachievingasa

lesp

riceaverageofover$

380k

Page 108: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�12:�M

ultip

le�Dwellin

g�(Plex)

Locatio

nCabo

olture

Zone

/Precinct

NextG

enerationSubu

rban

Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Yield�(no.�of�d

wellin

gs)

5Ca

r�Parking�Rate

2cp/du

+vis

No.�Of�3

�bed

room

s5

Site�Frontage

25Site�Dep

th40

Land

�Area

1000

Infrastructure�Cha

rges�(p

er�du)

$140,000.00

DA�Fee

$3,480.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(1000�sqm)

$215,000.00

(Vacan

t�Lan

d)Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e�(3�bed

,�2�cars)

$330,000.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

580

$1,050

$609,000

Balcon

y125

$250

$31,250

Garage

165

$850

$140,250

Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

218

$140

$30,520

Land

scap

ing

256

$45

$11,520

Deep

�planting

70$45

$3,150

Total

1124

$825,690.00

Feasibility�Outpu

tsLand

�Purchase�Price

$225,950.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

866975

Total�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

osts

$1,289,305.00

Gross�Realisation

$1,650,000.00

Developm

ent�P

rofit

$104,025.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

8.07%

Scen

ariom

odelsa

100

0sqm

siteth

atisdevelop

edfo

r5xplex

prod

ucts.Prod

uctisq

uiteefficien

t,yetfailstoachieveviability

thresholdasacom

bine

dim

pactofcom

mun

alre

quire

men

tsfo

rdrivew

ays,land

scapingetc.

Prod

uctw

ouldachieveth

reshold,if$35

5kperdwellingcouldbe

achieved

,whichis$25Kpe

rdwellingmorethanth

ecurren

tmarket

willsu

pport,ho

weverintimethisprod

uctcou

ldbeviable.

Page 109: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�12a:�P

lex���R

eductio

n�in�car�parks�and

�produ

ct�size

Locatio

nCabo

olture

Zone

/Precinct

NextG

enerationSubu

rban

Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Yield�(no.�of�d

wellin

gs)

5Ca

r�Park�Ra

te1cp/du

+vi

No.�Of�3

�bed

room

s5

Site�Frontage

25Site�Dep

th40

Land

�Area

1000

Infrastructure�Cha

rges�(p

er�du)

$140

,000

.00

DA�Fee

$3,480

.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(100

0�sqm)

$215

,000

.00

(Vacan

t�Lan

d)Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e�(3�bed

,�2�cars)

$330

,000

.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

540

$1,050

$567

,000

Balcon

y12

5$2

50$3

1,25

0Garage

82$8

50$6

9,70

0Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

218

$140

$30,52

0Land

scap

ing

336

$45

$15,12

0De

ep�planting

70$4

5$3

,150

Total

1164

$716

,740

.00

Feasibility�Outpu

tsLand

�Purchase�Price

$225

,950

.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

7525

77To

tal�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

ost s

$1,168

,587

.00

Gross�Realisation

$1,650

,000

.00

Developm

ent�P

rofit

$225

,649

.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

19.3%

Developm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

Marginal

Given$3

55kpe

rdwellingisno

tpossib

leatthistim

e,th

escen

ario

varia

tionmod

elsa

redu

ctioninth

enu

mbe

rofcarparksfrom

2to

1

carp

arkpe

rdwelling,and

also

redu

cesthe

produ

ctsizeto

120

sqm,

with

theextraareawasplacedintoth

eland

scaping.The

sechanges

seeasig

nificantly

improved

thereturnoncostand

essen

tially

meetsviabilitythreshold.

Page 110: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�13:�M

ultip

le�Dwellin

g�(Plex���C

orne

r�Lot)

Locatio

nCabo

olture

Zone

/Precinct

NextG

enerationSubu

rban

Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Yield�(no.�of�d

wellin

gs)

5Ca

r�Parking�Rate

2cp/du

+vi

No.�Of�3

�bed

room

s5

Site�Frontage

30Site�Dep

th40

Land

�Area

1200

Infrastructure�Cha

rges�(p

er�du)

$140

,000

.00

DA�Fee

$3,480

.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(120

0�sqm)

$220

,000

.00

(Vacan

t�Lan

d)Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e$3

30,000

.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

816

$1,050

$856

,800

.00

Garage

165

$850

$140

,250

.00

Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

193

$140

$27,02

0.00

Private�Ope

n�Space�(Groun

d�flo

or)

125

$160

$20,00

0.00

Land

scap

ing

340

$45

$15,30

0.00

Deep

�planting

58$4

5$2

,610

.00

Total

1532

$1,061

,980

.00

Feasibility�Outpu

tsLand

�Purchase�Price

$231

,125

.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

1115

079

Total�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

ost s

$1,556

,292

.00

Gross�Realisation

$1,650

,000

.00

Developm

ent�P

rofit

�$16

8,35

1.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

�10.80

%De

velopm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

NO

Scen

ariom

odelsa

120

0sqm

siteth

atisdevelop

edfo

r5

xplexprodu

cts.Produ

ctisquiteefficien

t,althou

ghstill

reason

ablysp

acious.Scen

ariofailsto

achieveviability

thresholdasacom

bine

dim

pactofcom

mun

al

requ

iremen

tsfo

rdriv

eways,land

scapingallonthe

grou

ndplane

,whichaffe

ctsa

bilitytoaccom

mod

ate

yield.Carparkingprovision

limitsth

eam

ountofyield

possibleonthesite.

Scen

ariolosesm

oneydue

toextracon

structioncosts

andlim

itedsiteyield.

Page 111: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�13a:�P

lex�(Corne

r�Lot)���re

duced�car�p

arking�and

�produ

ct�size

Locatio

nCabo

olture

Zone

/Precinct

NextG

enerationSubu

rban

Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Yield�(no.�of�d

wellin

gs)

5Ca

r�Parking�Rate

1cp/du

+vi

No.�Of�3

�bed

room

s5

Site�Frontage

30Site�Dep

th40

Land

�Area

1200

Infrastructure�Cha

rges�(p

er�du)

$140

,000

.00

DA�Fee

$3,480

.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(120

0�sqm)

$220

,000

.00

(Vacan

t�Lan

d)Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e$3

30,000

.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

650

$1,050

$682

,500

.00

Garage

80$8

50$6

8,00

0.00

Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

193

$140

$27,02

0.00

Private�Ope

n�Space�(Groun

d�flo

or)

125

$160

$20,00

0.00

Land

scap

ing

420

$45

$18,90

0.00

Deep

�planting

58$4

5$2

,610

.00

Total

1446

$819

,030

.00

Feasibility�Outpu

tsLand

�Purchase�Price

$231

,125

.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

$859

,982

.00

Total�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

osts

$1,287

,100

.00

Gross�Realisation

$1,650

,000

.00

Developm

ent�P

rofit

$106

,246

.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

8.25

%De

velopm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

NO

Mod

ified

Scenario

mod

elsa

120

0sqm

siteth

atisdevelop

edfo

r5x

plexprodu

cts,with

thesiz

eofth

edw

ellingsre

ducedbyapp

rox

35sqmperdwellingandon

lyprovidingone

carparkpe

rdwelling.

Mod

ified

scen

arioachievese

nhancedfeasibility,how

everstilldidn't

makescen

ariofe

asibleto

build.

Page 112: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�13b

:�Plex�(Corne

r�Lot)���add

�sixth�prod

uct

Locatio

nCabo

olture

Zone

/Precinct

NextG

enerationSubu

rban

Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Yield�(no.�of�d

wellin

gs)

6Ca

r�Park�Ra

te1cp/du

+vi

No.�Of�3

�bed

room

s6

Site�Frontage

30Site�Dep

th40

Land

�Area

1200

Infrastructure�Cha

rges�(p

er�du)

$168,000.00

DA�Fee

$3,480.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(1200�sqm)

$220,000.00

Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e$330,000.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

780

$1,050

$819,000.00

Garage

95$850

$80,750.00

Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

193

$140

$27,020.00

Private�Ope

n�Space�(Groun

d�flo

or)

150

$160

$24,000.00

Land

scap

ing

315

$45

$14,175.00

Deep

�planting

58$45

$2,610.00

Total

1496

$967,555.00

Feasibility�Outpu

t sLand

�Purchase�Price

$231,125.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

$1,015,933.00

Total�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

osts

$1,479,668.00

Gross�Realisation

$1,980,000.00

Developm

ent�P

rofit

$194,334.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

13.10%

Developm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

NO

Mod

ified

scen

ariopropo

seso

nly1carparkpe

rdwellinganda

redu

cedcommun

alope

nspacerequ

iremen

t,whichfacilitates

additio

nalcarso

nthegrou

ndand

thereforeallowsa

greateryield

tobeprovided

. Scen

ariom

odels6

dwellingsra

therth

an5.The

revenu

efrom

the6thdwellingsig

nificantly

improvesviability.

Lowrisefo

rmand

limite

dyieldaffectsp

rojectviability.

Page 113: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�14:�M

ultip

le�Dwellin

g�(Plex)

Locatio

nKipp

a�Ring

Zone

/Precinct

NextG

enerationSubu

rban

Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Yield�(no.�of�d

wellin

gs)

5Ca

r�Park�Ra

te2cp/du

+vi

No.�Of�3

�bed

room

s5

Site�Frontage

25Site�Dep

th40

Land

�Area

1000

Infrastructure�Cha

rges�(p

er�du)

$112

,000

.00

(Credit�for�existing�dw

elling)

DA�Fee

$3,480

.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(100

0�sqm)

$446

,000

.00

(Old�hou

se�on�land

)Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e$3

40,000

.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

580

$1,050

$609

,000

Private�Ope

n�Space

125

$160

$20,00

0Garage

165

$850

$140

,250

Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

243

$140

$34,02

0Land

scap

ing

190

$45

$8,550

Deep

�planting

46$4

5$2

,070

Total

1059

$813

,890

.00

Feasibility�Outpu

tsLand

�Purchase�Price

$465

,035

.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

$858

,270

.00

Total�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

osts

$1,491

,204

.00

Gross�Realisation

$1,700

,000

.00

Developm

ent�P

rofit

�$55

,888

.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

�3.75%

Developm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

NO

Scen

ariom

odelsa

100

0sqm

siteth

atisdevelop

edfo

r5xplex

prod

ucts.

Doub

legaragesand

excessiv

erequ

iremen

tforland

scaping,deep

plantin

gandprivateop

ensp

acemakesprojectunviable.

Page 114: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�14a:�P

lex���a

dd�sixth�prod

uct

Locatio

nKipp

a�Ring

Zone

/Precinct

NextG

enerationSubu

rban

Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Yield�(no.�of�d

wellin

gs)

6Dw

ellin

g�Co

nfiguration

1cp/du

+vi

No.�Of�3

�bed

room

s6

Site�Frontage

25Site�Dep

th40

Land

�Area

1000

Infrastructure�Cha

rges�(p

er�du)

$140,000.00

(Credit�for�existing�dw

elling )

DA�Fee

$3,480.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(1000�sqm)

$446,000.00

(Old�hou

se�on�land

)Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e$340,000.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

600

$1,050

$630,000

Private�Ope

n�Space

150

$160

$24,000

Garage

80$850

$68,000

Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

243

$140

$34,020

Land

scap

ing

240

$45

$10,800

Deep

�planting

46$45

$2,070

Total

1129

$768,890.00

Feasibility�Outpu

tsLand

�Purchase�Price

$465,035.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

$807,335.00

Total�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

osts

$1,465,455.00

Gross�Realisation

$2,040,000.00

Developm

ent�P

rofit

$260,854.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

17.80%

Developm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

Marginal

Mod

ified

scen

ariom

odelsa

6thprodu

ctonthesite,achievedby

dwellingbydecreasingGF

Aofeachdw

ellingandmakingminor

alteratio

nsto

theland

scapingspaceatgroun

dlevel,whilstalso

redu

cingcarparksfrom

2/duto1/duim

provesth

ereturnoncost.

Scen

arioviabilitysig

nificantly

improved

and

with

furthe

ram

endm

entsto

buildingefficiencyprojectviabilityprob

ablyableto

beachieved.

Page 115: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�15:�M

ultip

le�Dwellin

g�(Plex���C

orne

r�Lot)

Locatio

nStrathpine

Zone

/Precinct

NextG

enerationSubu

rban

Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Yield�(no.�of�d

wellin

gs)

3Ca

r�Parking�Rate

2cp/du

+vi

No.�Of�3

�bed

room

s3

Site�Frontage

20Site�Dep

th40

Land

�Area

800

Infrastructure�Cha

rges�(p

er�du)

$56,00

0.00

(Credit�for�existing�dw

elling)

DA�Fee

$3,480

.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(800

�sqm)

$350

,000

.00

(Old�hou

se�on�land

)Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e$3

40,000

.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

492

$1,050

$516

,600

Private�Ope

n�Space

75$1

60$1

2,00

0Garage

99$8

50$8

4,15

0Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

193

$140

$27,02

0Land

scap

ing

110

$45

$4,950

Deep

�planting

160

$45

$7,200

Total

955

$651

,920

Feasibility�Outpu

tsLand

�Purchase�Price

$365

,675

.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

$684

,516

.00

Total�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

osts

$1,152

,490

.00

Gross�Realisation

$1,020

,000

.00

Developm

ent�P

rofit

�$32

8,66

9.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

�28.5%

Developm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

NO

Scen

ariom

odelsa

n80

0sqm

siteth

atisdevelop

edfo

r3xplex

prod

ucts.Re

quire

men

tfordou

blegarageslim

itsamou

ntof

possibledevelop

men

tonsiteandresultsinanegativereturnon

theproject.Prod

uctsize

islargewith

anop

portun

ityre

ducesize

andsubseq

uentcon

structioncost.

Page 116: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�15a:�P

lex�(Corne

r�Lot)���add

�fourth�produ

ctLocatio

nStrathpine

Zone

/Precinct

NextG

enerationSubu

rban

Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Yield�(no.�of�d

wellin

gs)

4Ca

r�Parking�Rate

1cp/du

+vi

No.�Of�3

�bed

room

s4

Site�Frontage

20Site�Dep

th40

Land

�Area

800

Infrastructure�Cha

rges�(p

er�du)

$84,000.00

(Credit�for�existing�dw

elling)

DA�Fee

$3,480.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(800�sq

m)

$280,000.00

(Old�hou

se�on�land

)Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e$340,000.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

520

$1,050

$546,000

Private�Ope

n�Space

100

$160

$16,000

Garage

53$850

$45,050

Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

193

$140

$27,020

Land

scap

ing

110

$45

$4,950

Deep

�planting

160

$45

$7,200

Total

983

$646,220

Feasibility�Outpu

t sLand

�Purchase�Price

$293,225.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

$678,531.00

Total�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

osts

$1,101,725.00

Gross�Realisation

$1,360,000.00

Developm

ent�P

rofit

$45,712.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

4.15%

Developm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

NO

Mod

ified

scen

ario,red

ucesth

enu

mbe

rofcarparksperdwelling

from

2to

1,and

isabletoadd

anadditio

nalprodu

ct.Inadd

ition

a

redu

ctioninth

eland

purchaseprice wasund

ertaken,which

improvesth

efeasibilityhow

evernoteno

ughtom

aketheproject

viable.O

bservatio

nisthat800

sqmlotsareproblem

aticinth

atit

limitsth

eachievableyield,particularlycon

sideringthegrou

nd

plainisrequ

iredtoaccom

mod

atesom

anydiffe

rentprovisio

ns.

Page 117: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�16:�M

ultip

le�Dwellin

g�(Low

�Rise�Ap

artm

ent)

Locatio

nCabo

olture

Zone

/Precinct

NextG

enerationSubu

rban

Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Yield�(no.�of�d

wellin

gs)

6Ca

r�Parking�Rate

2cp/du

+vi

No.�Of�3

�bed

room

s6

Site�Frontage

25Site�Dep

th40

Land

�Area

1000

Infrastructure�Cha

rges�(p

er�du)

$168,000.00

DA�Fee

$3,480.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(1000�sqm)

$215,000.00

(Vacan

t�Lan

d)Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e�(2�bed

,�2�bath,�2�car)

$325,000.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

638

$1,500

$957,000

Balcon

y85

$500

$42,500

Und

ercover�C

ar�Parking

262

$850

$222,700

Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

209

$140

$29,260

Commun

al�Ope

n�Space

225

$90

$20,250

Private�Ope

n�Space�(Groun

d�flo

or)

25$160

$4,000

Land

scap

ing

88$45

$3,960

Deep

�planting

53$45

$2,385

Total

1238

$1,282,055

Feasibility�Outpu

tsLand

�Purchase�Price

$225,950.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

1323845

Total�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

osts

$1,799,418.00

Gross�Realisation

$1,950,000.00

Developm

ent�P

rofit

�$153,913.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

�8.50%

Developm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

NO

Thescen

ariom

odelsa

100

0sqm

sitedevelop

edinalow

riseapartm

entwith

6units.Im

med

iateincreasein

constructio

ncosts,yetnoincreaseinsa

lesp

rices

dram

aticallyaffe

ctsp

rojectviability.

Potentiallybyredu

cingth

ecarp

arkingra

teand

the

commun

alope

nspacerequ

iremen

tyou

cou

ld

accommod

atepo

tentiallyanadditio

nal1�2du

onthe

lot.Co

nstructio

ncostsw

ereraise

dto$15

00becauseit

hasb

eenassumed

buildingwou

ldbebu

ildwith

a

concreteslabasp

eratypical3storeywalk�up

structure

metho

d.

Page 118: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�16a:�Low

�Rise���red

uced

�parking�and

�com

mun

al�ope

n�space

Locatio

nCabo

olture

Zone

/Precinct

NextG

enerationSubu

rban

Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Yield�(no.�of�d

wellin

gs)

8Ca

r�Parking�Rate

1cp/du

+vi

No.�Of�3

�bed

room

s8

Site�Frontage

25Site�Dep

th40

Land

�Area

1000

Infrastructure�Cha

rges�(p

er�du)

$224,000.00

DA�Fee

$3,480.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(1000�sqm)

$215,000.00

(Vacan

t�Lan

d)Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e�(3�bed

)$325,000.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

800

$1,200

$960,000

Balcon

y85

$500

$42,500

Und

ercover�C

ar�Parking

262

$850

$222,700

Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

209

$140

$29,260

Commun

al�Ope

n�Space

160

$90

$14,400

Private�Ope

n�Space�(Groun

d�flo

or)

75$160

$12,000

Land

scap

ing

72$45

$3,240

Deep

�planting

53$45

$2,385

Total

1369

$1,286,485

Feasibility�Outpu

tsLand

�Purchase�Price

$225,950.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

1328639

Total�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

osts

$186,476.00

Gross�Realisation

$2,600,000.00

Developm

ent�P

rofit

$340,071.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

18.30%

Developm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

Marginal

Mod

ified

scen

arioinclud

esa2storeybuildingwith

8units.The

additio

nal2units,achieved

byloweringparkingratesa

ndre

duced

commun

alope

nspacerequ

iremen

ts.Co

nstructio

ncostsw

ere

redu

ced to$12

00ontheassumptionthatso

meefficienciesc

anbe

foun

dgivenitis2storeys,as$

1500wou

ldtypicallybea3storey

prod

uct

Page 119: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�16b

:�Low

�Rise���increase�nu

mbe

r�of�storeys

Locatio

nCabo

olture

Zone

/Precinct

NextG

enerationSubu

rban

Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Yield�(no.�of�d

wellin

gs)

11Ca

r�Parking�Rate

1cp/du

+vi

No.�Of�3

�bed

room

s11

Site�Frontage

25Site�Dep

th40

Land

�Area

1000

Infrastructure�Cha

rges�(p

er�du)

$308

,000

.00

DA�Fee

$3,480

.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(100

0�sqm)

$215

,000

.00

(Vacan

t�Lan

d)Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e�(3�bed

,�2�bath,�2�car)

$325

,000

.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

1036

$1,500

$1,554

,000

Balcon

y17

0$5

00$8

5,00

0Und

ercover�C

ar�Parking

262

$850

$222

,700

Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

222

$140

$31,08

0Co

mmun

al� Ope

n�Space

147

$90

$13,23

0Private�Ope

n�Space�(Groun

d�flo

or)

25$1

60$4

,000

Land

scap

ing

88$4

5$3

,960

Deep

�planting

53$4

5$2

,385

Total

1571

$1,916

,355

Feasibility�Outpu

tsLand

�Purchase�Price

$225

,950

.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

$1,912

,213

.00

Total�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

osts

$2,560

,292

.00

Gross�Realisation

$3,575

,000

.00

Developm

ent�P

rofit

$468

,255

.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

18.30%

Developm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

Marginal

Mod

ified

scen

arioisa3storeybuildingwith

12un

its.The

additio

nal6unitsfrom

thebasesc

enario areachievedbyre

ducing

carp

arkingra

te,com

mun

alope

nspaceprovision

(size

and

locatio

n)and

alte

ratio

nsto

buildinglayoutto

facilitategreater

parkingon

groun

d.Con

structioncostsw

ereliftedbackto

$15

00

consideringtheelevationup

toa3storeyprodu

ct.

Byincreasin

gnu

mbe

rofstoreysand

thereforeyieldandredu

cing

thecarp

arkingto

1cp/du�the

projectachievesv

iability.

Page 120: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�17:�M

ultip

le�Dwellin

g�(Low

�Rise�Ap

artm

ent)

Locatio

nKipp

a�Ring

Zone

/Precinct

NextG

enerationSubu

rban

Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Yield�(no.�of�d

wellin

gs)

11Ca

r�Parking�Rate

1cp/du

+vi

No.�Of�3

�bed

room

s11

Site�Frontage

25Site�Dep

th40

Land

�Area

1000

Infrastructure�Cha

rges�(p

er�du)

$280

,000

.00

(Credit�for�existing�dw

elling)

DA�Fee

$5,780

.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(100

0�sqm)

$446

,000

.00

(old�hou

se�on�land

)Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e�(3�bed

,�2�bath,�2�car)

$340

,000

.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

1036

$1,500

$1,554

,000

Balcon

y17

0$5

00$8

5,00

0Und

ercover�C

ar�Parking

262

$850

$222

,700

Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

222

$140

$31,08

0Co

mmun

al�Ope

n�Space

147

$90

$13,23

0Private�Ope

n�Space�(Groun

d�flo

or)

25$1

60$4

,000

Land

scap

ing

88$4

5$3

,960

Deep

�planting

53$4

5$2

,385

Total

1571

$1,916

,355

Feasibility�Outpu

tsLand

�Purchase�Price

$465

,035

.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

$1,967

,548

.00

Total�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

osts

$2,618

,615

.00

Gross�Realisation

$3,740

,000

.00

Developm

ent�P

rofit

$552

,975

.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

21.10%

Developm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

YES

Itwascon

sidered

unn

ecessaryto

testacom

pliantsc

enarioas

earlierte

stingofsc

enarios1

6and16

ashow

edsignificantnegative

returns.A

ccordinglyth

escen

ariohasbeenrunassumingano

n�compliant3storeydesignwith

increasedyieldandredu

ced

parkingratesa

sper16b

abo

ve.Projectviabilityismaintaine

dand

improved

due

toslightlyhighe

rsalespricesinkippa�ring.

Page 121: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�18:�M

ultip

le�Dwellin

g�(Low

�Rise�Ap

artm

ent)

Locatio

nAranaHills

Zone

/Precinct

NextG

enerationSubu

rban

Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Yield�(no.�of�d

wellin

gs)

6Ca

r�Parking�Rate

1cp/du

+vi

No.�Of�3

�bed

room

s4

No.�Of�2

�bed

room

s2

Site�Frontage

18Site�Dep

th33

Land

�Area

600

Infrastructure�Cha

rge�(cum

ulative)

$156

,000

.00

DA�Fee

$3,480

.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(600

�sqm)

$365

,000

.00

(Vacan

t�Lan

d)Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e�(2�bed

)$3

50,000

.00

Prod

uct�S

ale�Price�(3�bed

)$3

90,000

.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

534

$1,500

$801

,000

Balcon

y96

$500

$48,00

0Und

er�Cover�Parking

162

$850

$137

,700

Commun

al�Ope

n�Space

120

$90

$10,80

0Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

92$1

40$1

2,88

0Land

scap

ing

127

$45

$5,715

Deep

�planting

32$4

5$1

,440

Total

785

$1,017

,535

Feasibility�Outpu

tsLand

�Purchase�Price

$381

,200

.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

1043

212

Total�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

osts

$1,646

,529

.00

Gross�Realisation

$2,260

,000

.00

Developm

ent�P

rofit

$269

,822

.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

16.4%

Developm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

Marginal

Scen

ariom

odelsa

600

sqmsiteth

atisdevelop

edfo

ralow�rise

un

itswith

6dwellings.Thisscen

arioisbased

onon

ecarp

arkpe

rdw

elling.Projectiscurrentlym

arginaland

wou

ldbeun

viableat2

carsperdwelling.Itwou

ldneedtoincreaseGFA

againbythe

equivalentof1

bed

room

perdwelling(app

rox75

sqm)toachieve6

xthreebe

droo

msa

ndth

eassociated

highe

rsalepricesto

achieve

viability.

Page 122: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�19:�M

ultip

le�Dwellin

g�(Low

�Rise�Ap

artm

ent)

Locatio

nAranaHills

Zone

/Precinct

NextG

enerationSubu

rban

Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Yield�(no.�of�d

wellin

gs)

10Ca

r�Parking�Rate

2cp/du

+vi

No.�Of�3

�bed

room

s10

Site�Frontage

25Site�Dep

th40

Land

�Area

1000

Infrastructure�Cha

rges�(p

er�du)

$252,000.00

(Credit�for�existing�dw

elling)

DA�Fee

$3,480.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(1000�sqm)

$478,000.00

(old�hou

se�on�land

)Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e�(3�bed

,�2�bath,�2�car)

$380,000.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

946

$1,500

$1,419,000

Balcon

y170

$500

$85,000

Und

ercover�C

ar�Parking

290

$850

$246,500

Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

222

$140

$31,080

Commun

al�Ope

n�Space

147

$90

$13,230

Private�Ope

n�Space�(Groun

d�flo

or)

25$160

$4,000

Land

scap

ing

88$45

$3,960

Deep

�planting

53$45

$2,385

Total

1481

$1,805,155

Feasibility�Outpu

tsLand

�Purchase�Price

$498,155.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

$1,850,788.00

Total�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

osts

$2,711,679.00

Gross�Realisation

$3,800,000.00

Developm

ent�P

rofit

$516,484.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

19.00%

Developm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

Marginal

Scen

ariom

odelsa

100

0sqm

sitewhichisdevelop

edfo

ralowrise

unitprojectw

ith10dw

ellings.Scen

arioisfu

llycom

pliantoption

with

2carsp

erdwelling.Projectachievesv

iabilitydu

e toadd

ition

al

yieldassistin

gtoamortiseothe

rprojectcostssu

chaslandcosts.

Page 123: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�20:�M

ultip

le�Dwellin

g�(Low

�Rise�Ap

artm

ent)

Locatio

nStrathpine

Zone

/Precinct

NextG

enerationSubu

rban

Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Yield�(no.�of�d

wellin

gs)

6Ca

r�Parking�Rate

2cp/du+vi

No.�Of�3

�bed

room

s4

No.�Of�2

�bed

room

s2

No.�Of�1

�bed

room

s�

Site�Frontage

18Site�Dep

th33

Land

�Area

600

Infrastructure�Cha

rge�(cum

ulative)

$156

,000

.00

DA�Fee

$3,480

.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(600

�sqm)

$300

,000

.00

(Vacan

t�Lan

d)Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e�(2�bed

)$3

30,000

.00

Prod

uct�S

ale�Price�(3�bed

)$3

60,000

.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

534

$1,500

$801

,000

Balcon

y96

$500

$48,00

0Und

er�Cover�Parking

162

$850

$137

,700

Commun

al�Ope

n�Space

120

$90

$10,80

0Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

92$1

40$1

2,88

0Land

scap

ing

127

$45

$5,715

Deep

�planting

32$4

5$1

,440

Total

785

$1,017

,535

Feasibility�Outpu

tsLand

�Purchase�Price

$313

,925

.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

$1,043

,212

.00

Total�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

osts

$1,579

,254

.00

Gross�Realisation

$2,120

,000

.00

Developm

ent�P

rofit

$215

,801

.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

13.7%

Developm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

NO

Scen

ariom

odelsa

600

sqmsiteth

atisdevelop

edfo

ralow�rise

un

itswith

6dwellings.Lowersa

lesp

ricesinStrathp

ineim

pact

feasibilityre

sultsasthe

produ

ctcon

structioncostre

mainsth

esame.

Page 124: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�21:�M

ultip

le�Dwellin

g�(Low

�Rise�Ap

artm

ent)

Locatio

nStrathpine

Zone

/Precinct

NextG

enerationSubu

rban

Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Yield�(no.�of�d

wellin

gs)

10Ca

r�Parking�Rate

2cp/du

+vi

No.�Of�3

�bed

room

s10

Site�Frontage

25Site�Dep

th40

Land

�Area

1000

Infrastructure�Cha

rges�(cum

ulative)

$252

,000

.00

(credit�for�existing�ho

use)

DA�Fee

$3,480

.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(100

0�sqm)

$355

,000

.00

(Old�Hou

se�on�Land

)Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e�(3�bed

,�2�bath,�2�car)

$310

,000

.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

946

$1,500

$1,419

,000

Balcon

y17

0$5

00$8

5,00

0Und

ercover� C

ar�Parking

290

$850

$246

,500

Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

222

$140

$31,08

0Co

mmun

al�Ope

n�Space

147

$90

$13,23

0Private�Ope

n�Space�(Groun

d�flo

or)

25$1

60$4

,000

Land

scap

ing

88$4

5$3

,960

Deep

�planting

53$4

5$2

,385

Total

1481

$1,805

,155

Feasibility�Outpu

tsLand

�Purchase�Price

$370

,850

.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

$1,850

,788

.00

Total�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

osts

$2,584

,374

.00

Gross�Realisation

$3,100

,000

.00

Developm

ent�P

rofit

$35,74

3.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

1.40

%De

velopm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

NO

Scen

ariom

odelsa

100

0sqm

sitewhichisdevelop

edfo

ralowrise

unitproject w

ith10dw

ellings.Scen

arioisfu

llycom

pliantoption

with

2carsp

erdwelling.Exactlyth

esamebu

ildasthe

earlier

scen

ario19inAranaHills,how

everth

epricediffe

rentialbetween

Aranahillsand

Strathp

inedram

aticallyaffe

ctsv

iability.

Page 125: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�22:�M

ultip

le�Dwellin

g�(Low

�Rise�Ap

artm

ent)

Locatio

nLawnton

Zone

/Precinct

Urban

Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Yield�(no.�of�d

wellin

gs)

6Ca

r�Parking�Rate

1cp/du

+vi

No.�Of�3

�bed

room

s4

No.�Of�2

�bed

room

s2

No.�Of�1

�bed

room

s�

Site�Frontage

18Site�Dep

th33

Land

�Area

600

Infrastructure�Cha

rge�(cum

ulative)

$156

,000

.00

DA�Fee

$3,480

.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(600

�sqm)

$296

,000

.00

Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e�(2�bed

)$3

00,000

.00

Prod

uct�S

ale�Price�(3�bed

)$3

30,000

.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

534

$1,500

$801

,000

Balcon

y96

$500

$48,00

0Und

er�Cover�Parking

162

$850

$137

,700

Commun

al�Ope

n�Space

120

$90

$10,80

0Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

92$1

40$1

2,88

0Land

scap

ing

127

$45

$5,715

Deep

�planting

32$4

5$1

,440

Total

785

$1,017

,535

Feasibility�Outpu

tsLand

�Purchase�Price

$309

,785

.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

$1,043

,212

.00

Total�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

osts

$1,575

,114

.00

Gross�Realisation

$1,920

,000

.00

Developm

ent�P

rofit

$45,97

2.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

2.9%

Developm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

NO

Scen

ariom

odelsa

600

sqmsiteth

atisdevelop

edfo

ralow�rise

un

itswith

6dwellings.Lowersa

lesp

ricesinLaw

nton

impact

feasibilityre

sultsasthe

produ

ctcon

structioncostre

mainsth

esame.

Page 126: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�23:�M

ultip

le�Dwellin

g�(Low

�Rise�Ap

artm

ent)

Locatio

nLawnton

Zone

/Precinct

Urban

Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Yield�(no.�of�d

wellin

gs)

10Ca

r�Parking�Rate

2cp/du

+vi

No.�Of�3

�bed

room

s10

Site�Frontage

25Site�Dep

th40

Land

�Area

1000

Infrastructure�Cha

rges�(p

er�du)

$252

,000

.00

(credit�for�existing�dw

elling)

DA�Fee

$3,480

.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(100

0�sqm)

$301

,000

.00

(old�hou

se�on�land

)Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e�(3�bed

,�2�bath,�2�car)

$340

,000

.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

976

$1,500

$1,464

,000

Balcon

y17

0$5

00$8

5,00

0Und

ercover�C

ar�Parking

308

$850

$261

,800

Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

297

$140

$41,58

0Co

mmun

al�Ope

n�Space

200

$90

$18,00

0Land

scap

ing

45$4

5$2

,025

Deep

�planting

30$4

5$1

,350

Total

1548

$1,873

,755

Feasibility�Outpu

tsLand

�Purchase�Price

$314

,960

.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

$1,922

,818

.00

Total�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

osts

$2,604

,493

.00

Gross�Realisation

$3,400

,000

.00

Developm

ent�P

rofit

$276

,473

.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

10.60%

Developm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

NO

Scen

ariom

odelsa

100

0sqm

sitewhichisdevelop

edfo

ralowrise

unitprojectw

ith10dw

ellings.Inth

islocatio

n,th

esitecover

constrainsth

enu

mbe

rofd

wellingsth

atcanbeachieved

and

thereforethereturnoncost.Ifthe

marketa

llowed

thisprod

uctto

beso

ldfo

rmoretheprojectm

aybecom

eviable.

Page 127: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�23a:�Low

�Rise���Increase�site�cover,�red

uced

�com

mun

al�ope

n�space

Locatio

nLawnton

Zone

/Precinct

Urban

Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Yield�(no.�of�d

wellin

gs)

12Ca

r�Parking�Rate

~2cp/du

+vi

No.�Of�3

�bed

room

s12

Site�Frontage

25Site�Dep

th40

Land

�Area

1000

Infrastructure�Cha

rges�(p

er�du)

$308,000.00

(Credit�for�existing�dw

elling )

DA�Fee

$3,480.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(1000�sqm)

$301,000.00

(Old�hou

se�on�land

)Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e�(3�bed

,�2�bath,�2�car)

$340,000.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

1100

$1,500

$1,650,000

Balcon

y204

$500

$102,000

Und

ercover�C

ar�Parking

308

$850

$261,800

Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

360

$140

$50,400

Commun

al�Ope

n�Space

166

$90

$14,940

Land

scap

ing

45$45

$2,025

Deep

�planting

30$45

$1,350

Total

1701

$2,082,515

Feasibility�Outpu

tsLand

�Purchase�Price

$314,960.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

$2,124,166.00

Total�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

osts

$2,872,966.00

Gross�Realisation

$4,080,000.00

Developm

ent�P

rofit

$587,000.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

20.45%

Developm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

YES

Mod

ified

scen

ariom

odelsincreased

sitecoverto

60%

toenable2

extradw

ellings.Inadditio

nitinclud

esslightlyalte

redthecommun

al

open

spacedimen

sionsprodu

cing30sqm

lessth

anprovisio

ns.Car

parkingisstillgen

erallyat2

perdwelling.Scenario

meetsfe

asibility

threshold.

Page 128: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�24:�M

ultip

le�Dwellin

g�(Low

�Rise�Ap

artm

ent)

Locatio

nMargate

Zone

/Precinct

Urban

Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Yield�(no.�of�d

wellin

gs)

6Dw

ellin

g�Co

nfiguration

1cp/du

+vi

No.�Of�3

�bed

room

s4

No.�Of�2

�bed

room

s2

Site�Frontage

18Site�Dep

th33

Land

�Area

600

Infrastructure�Cha

rges�(cum

ulative)

$156

,000

.00

DA�Fee

$3,480

.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(600

�sqm)

$313

,000

.00

Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e�(2�bed

)$4

00,000

.00

Prod

uct�S

ale�Price�(3�bed

)$4

50,000

.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

534

$1,500

$801

,000

Balcon

y96

$500

$48,00

0Und

er�Cover�Parking

162

$850

$137

,700

Commun

al�Ope

n�Space

120

$90

$10,80

0Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

92$1

40$1

2,88

0Land

scap

ing

127

$45

$5,715

Deep

�planting

32$4

5$1

,440

Total

785

$1,017

,535

Feasibility�Outpu

tsLand

�Purchase�Price

$327

,380

.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

$1,043

,212

.00

Total�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

ost s

$1,592

,709

.00

Gross�Realisation

$2,600

,000

.00

Developm

ent�P

rofit

$619

,846

.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

38.9%

Developm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

YES

Scen

ariom

odelsa

600

sqmsiteth

atisdevelop

edfo

ralow�rise

un

itswith

6dwellings.Highersa

lesp

ricesinM

argateim

proves

feasibilityre

sultsasthe

produ

ctcon

structioncostre

mainsth

esame.

Page 129: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�25:�M

ultip

le�Dwellin

g�(Low

�Rise�Ap

artm

ent)

Locatio

nMargate

Zone

/Precinct

Urban

Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Yield�(no.�of�d

wellin

gs)

10Ca

r�Parking�Rate

2cp/du

+vi

No.�Of�3

�bed

room

s10

Site�Frontage

25Site�Dep

th40

Land

�Area

1000

Infrastructure�Cha

rges�(cum

ulative)

$252,000.00

(Credit�for�existing�dw

elling)

DA�Fee

$3,480.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(1000�sqm)

$540,000.00

(old�hou

se�on�land

)Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e�(3�bed

,�2�bath,�2�car)

$450,000.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

976

$1,500

$1,464,000

Balcon

y170

$500

$85,000

Und

ercover�C

ar�Parking

308

$850

$261,800

Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

297

$140

$41,580

Commun

al�Ope

n�Space

200

$90

$18,000

Land

scap

ing

45$45

$2,025

Deep

�planting

30$45

$1,350

Total

1548

$1,873,755

Feasibility�Outpu

t sLand

�Purchase�Price

$562,325.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

$1,922,818.00

Total�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

osts

$2,881,858.00

Gross�Realisation

$4,300,000.00

Developm

ent�P

rofit

$810,253.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

28.40%

Developm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

YES

Scen

ariom

odelsa

100

0sqm

sitewhichisdevelop

edfo

ralowrise

unitprojectw

ith10dw

ellings.

Thehighsa

lepriceachievableinM

argateenablesafu

llycom

pliant

prod

ucttobe

delivered

with

2carsp

erdwelling.

Page 130: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�26:�M

ultip

le�Dwellin

g�(M

edium�Rise�Ap

artm

ent)

Locatio

nRe

dcliffe

Zone

/Precinct

Urban

Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Yield�(no.�of�d

wellin

gs)

8Ca

r�Parking�Rate

2cp/du

+vi

No.�Of�3

�bed

room

s4

No.�Of�2

�bed

room

s4

Site�Frontage

20Site�Dep

th40

Land

�Area

800

Infrastructure�Cha

rges�(cum

ulative)

$172

,000

.00

(Credit�for�existing�dw

elling)

DA�Fee

$3,480

.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(800

�sqm)

$448

,000

.00

(Old�hou

se�on�land

)Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e�(2�bed

room

)$4

10,000

.00

Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e�(3�bed

room

)$4

30,000

.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

600

$1,500

$900

,000

Balcon

y12

8$5

00$6

4,00

0Und

ercover�C

ar�Parking

342

$850

$290

,700

Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

147

$140

$20,58

0Co

mmun

al�Ope

n�Space�(Groun

d�flo

or)

160

$90

$14,40

0Land

scap

ing

101

$45

$4,545

Deep

�planting

40$4

5$1

,800

Total

1048

$1,296

,025

Feasibility�Outpu

tsLand

�Purchase�Price

$467

,105

.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

$1,360

,826

.00

Total�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

osts

$2,083

,597

.00

Gross�Realisation

$3,360

,000

.00

Developm

ent�P

rofit

$776

,476

.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

37.30%

Developm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

YES

Scen

ariom

odelsa

800

sqmsiteth

atisdevelop

edfo

ralow�rise

un

itswith

8dwellingsin3storeycon

figurationwith

�grou

ndfloo

rparking2levelsof2and

3bed

room

mix.Projecte

xceedsviability

thresholdasare

sultofth

eprop

ortio

natelyhighe

rsalepricesable

tobeachieved

inRed

cliffe.

Page 131: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�27:�M

ultip

le�Dwellin

g�(M

edium�Rise�Ap

artm

ent)

Locatio

nRe

dcliffe

Zone

/Precinct

Urban

Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Yield�(no.�of�d

wellin

gs)

20Dw

ellin

g�Co

nfiguration

6storey

Car�P

arking�Rate

2cp/du

+vi

No.�Of�3

�bed

room

s14

No.�Of�2

�bed

room

s6

Site�Frontage

30Site�Dep

th33

Land

�Area

1000

Infrastructure�Cha

rges�(cum

ulative)

$496,000.00

(Credit�for�existing�dw

elling)

DA�Fee

$5,780.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(1000�sqm)

$445,000.00

(Old�hou

se�on�land

)Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e�(2�bed

room

)$410,000.00

Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e�(3�bed

room

)$430,000.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

2035

$1,850

$3,764,750

Balcon

y350

$500

$175,000

Basemen

t�1950

$1,515

$1,439,250

Basemen

t�2�and

�31900

$2,100

$3,990,000

Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

200

$140

$28,000

Private�Ope

n�Space�(Groun

d�Floo

r)100

$160

$16,000

Commun

al�Ope

n�Space�(Groun

d�flo

or)

200

$90

$18,000

Land

scap

ing

140

$45

$6,300

Deep

�planting

50$45

$2,250

Total

2725

$9,439,550

Feasibility�Outpu

tsLand

�Purchase�Price

$467,105.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

$9,918,143.00

Total�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

osts

$11,440,005.00

Gross�Realisation

$8,480,000.00

Developm

ent�P

rofit

�$4,255,705.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

�37.20%

Developm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

NO

Scen

ariom

odelsa

100

0sqm

sitewhichisdevelop

edfo

ralowrise

unitprojectw

ith20dw

ellings.

Sitecoverre

strictsnum

bero

fdwellingsth

atcanbeachieved

.The

higherpropo

rtional costsofcon

structingto6storeysa

ndcostsof

basemen

tforth

eun

itsincreasesc

ostsofcon

struction

prop

ortio

nately.

Observatio

nthatitm

aybeableto

sque

ezeinanextradw

ellingon

eachlevelifallprod

uctw

ere2be

droo

ms,how

everbecauseth

ebasemen

tsisth

emoste

xpen

sivecompo

nentofthe

projectto

construct,feasibilityislikelyto

remaininth

ene

gativ

es,evenwith

thischange.

Page 132: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

����

���

���

���

���

���

���

����

���

���

����

��

���

���

� ������

���

����

����

�����

����

���

��

���

����

��

� �

!�"

#�

$�

����

%��

����

����

���

���

������

���

&"

'#(

)��

��

���

&"

'#�

)��

��

��

����

*�

����

� �

����

+��

�,

����

-��

���

��.�

#���

����

����

�,�

����

!���

� ��

�/�%

!�"�

#���

&��

������������ ������

�������

+-*

��!*

#-��

&��

-/�

����

���

�,��

���

���

!011

1�2

�%

!��*

#���

&��

�������

�������

���

���

���

���

����

!�)

���

�%

!���

#���

&��

���

����

� ��

����

�!(

)��

��

%!�

�#���

&��

-���

���

���

�-�

����

����

��

��3*

-��

*!�

#�*�

! #-��

#-*�

4� �

��

*�

!*��

!�-*

#���

4���

���

�0�"

�!�

#*�*

!�#��*

# *�

4���

���

���"

�!�

#���

!�#��"

#���

+��/

�$��

���/

����

���

�!�

��!�

�#��

���

�/��

�'

���

����

�!3

���

�*

�%

���

!���

!��#��

��

��

���

'��

���

���

!3�

���

# �

%��

�!"

�!�

�#��

���

����

����

���

�!�

*!�

# ��

+���

� �

����

�*�

!�*

!�#�*�

5��

�-

�*!�

#*��

#�*�

*���

�)� �

��'

���

��

����

���

�,��

���

���

!��-

#��*

&��

���

����

���

���

�!�

#���

#�""

&��

5��

���

�+�

/�

����

���

� �!-

#���

#�""

&��

3��

����

����

��

!�#���

#���

&��

+�/�

��

����

�#��

�!"-

"#��

�&��

�'�

!�6"

*��

����

%���&��

;+�

/�

����

����

� �

��

���

����

�� �

��<=

<� �>

���

�>?=

>�J QX��X�>� � �<�

��<

��<Q��>

���J��<Z �JQ

�JX���Q

����[>#X<Q

� �<��\>��

[� ���

����J�

��>�J<�>&

� ��

�J�<����<�

>J���J�<��<>J><

�!�&*=

��=J����\�=

��<� >

������J\��J>J����

>��J>��� [J�� <�

J�<=

&

Page 133: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�28:�M

ultip

le�Dwellin

g�(M

edium�Rise�Ap

artm

ent)

Locatio

nMargate

Zone

/Precinct

Urban

Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Yield�(no.�of�d

wellin

gs)

15Ca

r�Parking�Rate

2cp/du

+vi

No.�Of�3

�bed

room

s5

No.�Of�2

�bed

room

s10

Site�Frontage

25Site�Dep

th40

Land

�Area

1000

Infrastructure�Cha

rges�(cum

ulative)

$332,000.00

(Credit�for�existing�dw

elling)

DA�Fee

$5,780.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(1000�sqm)

$551,000.00

(Old�hou

se�on�land

)Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e�(2bd

)$400,000.00

Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e�(3bd

)$450,000.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

1192

$1,850

$2,205,200

Balcon

y168

$500

$84,000

Basemen

t�1950

$1,515

$1,439,250

Basemen

t�2950

$2,100

$1,995,000

Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

94$140

$13,160

Private�Ope

n�Space�(Groun

d�Floo

r)139

$160

$22,240

Commun

al�Ope

n�Space�(Groun

d�flo

or)

200

$90

$18,000

Land

scap

ing

96$45

$4,320

Deep

�planting

50$45

$2,250

Total

1771

$5,783,420

Feasibility�Outpu

tsLand

�Purchase�Price

$573,820.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

$6,072,591.00

Total�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

osts

$7,324,702.00

Gross�Realisation

$6,250,000.00

Developm

ent�P

rofit

�$2,024,637.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

�27.60%

Developm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

NO

Scen

ariom

odelsa

100

0sqm

sitewhichisdevelop

edfo

ralowrise

unitprojectw

ith15dw

ellings.

Sitecoverre

strictsnum

bero

fdwellingsth

atcanbeachieved

.Observatio

nthatit m

aybeableto

sque

ezeinanextradw

ellingon

eachlevelifallprod

uctw

ere2be

droo

ms,how

everbecauseth

ebasemen

tsisth

emoste

xpen

sivecompo

nentofthe

projectto

construct,feasibilityislikelyto

remaininth

ene

gativ

es,evenwith

thischange.

Page 134: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�28a:�M

edium�Rise���a

ltered�prod

uct,�redu

ced�car�p

arking

Scen

ario

28a

Prod

uct

Med

iumRise

Apartmen

tsScen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Locatio

nMargate

Zone

/Precinct

Urban

Yield�(no.�of�d

wellin

gs)

20Ca

r�Parking�Rate

1cp/du

+vi

No.�Of�2

�bed

room

s20

Site�Frontage

25Site�Dep

th40

Land

�Area

1000

Infrastructure�Cha

rges�(cum

ulative)

$418,000.00

(Credit�for�existing�dw

elling)

DA�Fee

$5,780.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(1000�sqm)

$551,000.00

(old�hou

se�on�land

)Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e�(2bd

)$400,000.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

1192

$1,850

$2,205,200

Balcon

y168

$500

$84,000

Basemen

t�1950

$1,515

$1,439,250

Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

94$140

$13,160

Private�Ope

n�Space�(Groun

d�Floo

r)139

$160

$22,240

Commun

al�Ope

n�Space�(Groun

d�flo

or)

200

$90

$18,000

Land

scap

ing

96$45

$4,320

Deep

�planting

50$45

$2,250

Total

1771

$3,788,420

Feasibility�Outpu

t sLand

�Purchase�Price

$573,820.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

$3,977,841.00

Total�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

osts

$5,200,217.00

Gross�Realisation

$8,000,000.00

Developm

ent�P

rofit

$1,613,282.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

31.00%

Developm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

YES

Mod

ified

scen

ariom

odels2

0dw

ellings,achievedbydeleting3

bedroo

mprodu

ctand

replacingwith

more2be

droo

ms.Ith

as

been

assum

edth

atwecouldthen

fita

nextra5x2 be

droo

m

dwellingsinth

ebu

ildingwith

outsignificantly

increasin

gthesite

cover.Inadd

ition

scen

ariochangesth

eparkingrateto

1cp/du.

Additio

nalreven

uefrom

theextra5un

its,com

bine

dwith

$2m

savingbyredu

cingcarparkingra

tere

sultsinaviableproject.

Perhapsa

nop

portun

ityto

provide

carsa

tara

tecloser to1.5cars

perd

welling,given

mod

elled30%re

turn.

Page 135: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�29:�M

ultip

le�Dwellin

g�(M

edium�Rise�Ap

artm

ent)

Locatio

nBu

rpen

gary

Zone

/Precinct

Urban

Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Yield�(no.�of�d

wellin

gs)

20Ca

r�Parking�Rate

1cp/du+vi

No.�Of�2

�bed

room

s20

Site�Frontage

25Site�Dep

th40

Land

�Area

1000

Infrastructure�Cha

rges�(cum

ulative)

$440,000.00

DA�Fee

$5,780.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(1000�sqm)

$265,000.00

Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e�(2bd

)$240,000.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

1192

$1,850

$2,205,200

Balcon

y168

$500

$84,000

Basemen

t�1950

$1,515

$1,439,250

Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

94$140

$13,160

Private�Ope

n�Space�(Groun

d�Floo

r)139

$160

$22,240

Commun

al�Ope

n�Space�(Groun

d�flo

or)

200

$90

$18,000

Land

scap

ing

96$45

$4,320

Deep

�planting

50$45

$2,250

Total

1771

$3,788,420

Feasibility�Outpu

tsLand

�Purchase�Price

$277,700.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

$3,977,841.00

Total�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

osts

$4,926,097.00

Gross�Realisation

$4,800,000.00

Developm

ent�P

rofit

�$894,542.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

�18.20%

Developm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

NO

Scen

ariom

odelsa

100

0sqm

sitewhichisdevelop

edfo

ralowrise

unitprojectw

ith20dw

ellings.

Thelowpoten

tialsaleprices(n

early

$15

0pe

rdwllessthanviable

margatesc

enario)isthe

biggestdriv

erontheun

viableoutcome.

Page 136: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�30:�M

ultip

le�Dwellin

g�(M

edium�Rise�Ap

artm

ent)

Locatio

nBu

rpen

gary

Zone

/Precinct

Centre

Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Yield�(no.�of�d

wellin

gs)

20Ca

r�Parking�Rate

1cp/du

+vi

No.�Of�2

�bed

room

s20

Site�Frontage

25Site�Dep

th40

Land

�Area

1000

Infrastructure�Cha

rges�(cum

ulative)

$440

,000

.00

DA�Fee

$5,780

.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(100

0�sqm)

$265

,000

.00

Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e�(2bd

)$2

60,000

.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

1192

$1,850

$2,205

,200

Balcon

y16

8$5

00$8

4,00

0Ba

semen

t�195

0$1

,515

$1,439

,250

Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

94$1

40$1

3,16

0Private�Ope

n�Space�(Groun

d�Floo

r)13

9$1

60$2

2,24

0Co

mmun

al�Ope

n�Space�(Groun

d�flo

or)

200

$90

$18,00

0Land

scap

ing

96$4

5$4

,320

Deep

�planting

50$4

5$2

,250

Total

1771

$3,788

,420

Feasibility�Outcomes

Land

�Purchase�Price

$277

,700

.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

$3,977

,841

.00

Total�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

osts

$4,926

,097

.00

Gross�Realisation

$5,200

,000

.00

Developm

ent�P

rofit

�$54

6,54

2.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

�11.10

%De

velopm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

NO

Thescen

ariom

odelsa

100

0sqmsitewith

20un

itprod

ucts.the

scen

ariolostm

oneyasaresultofth

elowerattainablesaleprices

andtherelativ

elyhighcon

structioncosts.To

testth

ediffe

rence

betw

eenamed

iumriseurbanand

am

ediumrisecen

trescen

ario,

itwasassum

edth

esalesp

ricecouldbe

increased.Alth

oughth

efeasibilitydidim

prove,itwasnotto

astandardth

atwou

ldm

ake

theprojectviable.

Page 137: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�31:�M

ultip

le�Dwellin

g�(M

edium�Rise�Ap

artm

ent)

Locatio

nAranaHills

Zone

/Precinct

Centre

Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Yield�(no.�of�d

wellin

gs)

15Ca

r�Parking�Rate

1cp/du

+vi

No.�Of�2

�bed

room

s15

Site�Frontage

20Site�Dep

th40

Land

�Area

800

Infrastructure�Cha

rges�(cum

ulative)

$308

,000

.00

(credit�for�existing�dw

elling)

DA�Fee

$5,780

.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(800

�sqm)

$405

,000

.00

(old�hou

se�on�land

)Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e�(2�bed

)$3

50,000

.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

1275

$1,850

$2,358

,750

Balcon

y24

0$2

,100

$504

,000

Und

er�Cover�Parking

346

$850

$294

,100

Commun

al�Ope

n�Space

40$9

0$3

,600

Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

251

$140

$35,14

0Land

scap

ing

82$4

5$3

,690

Deep

�planting

52$4

5$2

,340

Total

1660

$3,201

,620

Feasibility�Outcome

Land

�Purchase�Price

$422

,600

.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

$2,962

,376

.00

Total�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

osts

$3,867

,427

.00

Gross�Realisation

$5,250

,000

.00

Developm

ent�P

rofit

$588

,568

.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

15.20%

Developm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

Marginal

Thescne

ariom

odelsa

n80

0sqmsitewith

15un

itprod

ucts.The

scen

arioattainsam

arginaloutcomelargelyasare

sultofth

esale

pricesbeingattaine

dinAranaHills.Thisscen

arioisnotanideal

desig

nsolutio

nwith

carparkingdom

inatingthegrou

ndleveland

commun

alope

nspaceon

anup

perstorey.Abasem

entcarpark

couldno

tbeachieved

asthe

limite

dland

areado

esnotallow

enou

ghro

omfo

rturningcircles.

Page 138: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�32:�M

ultip

le�Dwellin

g�(M

edium�Rise�Ap

artm

ent)

Locatio

nCabo

olture

Zone

/Precinct

Centre

Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Yield�(no.�of�d

wellin

gs)

24Ca

r�Parking�Rate

2cp/du

+vi

No.�Of�3

�bed

room

s8

No.�Of�2

�bed

room

s16

Site�Frontage

25Site�Dep

th40

Land

�Area

1000

Infrastructure�Cha

rges�(cum

ulative)

$548

,000

.00

DA�Fee

$5,780

.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(100

0�sqm)

$265

,000

.00

Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e�(2bd

)$2

90,000

.00

Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e�(3�bd)

$320

,000

.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

1792

$1,850

$3,315

,200

Balcon

y26

0$5

00$1

30,000

Basemen

t�195

0$1

,515

$1,439

,250

Basemen

t�2�&�3

1900

$2,100

$3,990

,000

Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

93$1

40$1

3,02

0Private�Ope

n�Space�(Groun

d�Floo

r)13

5$1

60$2

1,60

0Co

mmun

al�Ope

n�Space�(Groun

d�flo

or)

250

$90

$22,50

0Land

scap

ing

110

$45

$4,950

Deep

�planting

50$4

5$2

,250

Total

2430

$8,938

,770

Feasibility�Outpu

tsLand

�Purchase�Price

$277

,700

.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

$9,385

,709

.00

Total�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

osts

$11,14

0,32

4.00

Gross�Realisation

$7,200

,000

.00

Developm

ent�P

rofit

�$5,08

7,37

6.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

�45.70

%De

velopm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

NO

TheScen

ariom

odelsa

100

0sqm

sitewiht2

4un

itprod

ucts ina

med

iumrisecon

figuration.The

projectprovide

scom

pliantparking

andlosessub

stantia

lamou

ntso

fmon

eyasa

resultofth

ecostso

fconstructin

g3levelsofbasem

ent.

Page 139: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�33:�M

ultip

le�Dwellin

g�(High�Rise�Apa

rtmen

t���8�storey)

Scen

ario

33Prod

uct

HighRise

Apartmen

ts(8

storey)

Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Locatio

nWoo

dyPoint

Zone

/Precinct

Urban

Yield�(no.�of�d

wellin

gs)

47Ca

r�Parking�Rate

2cp/du

+vi

No.�Of�3

�bed

room

s32

No.�Of�2

�bed

room

s15

Site�Frontage

30Site�Dep

th53

Land

�Area

1600

Infrastructure�Cha

rges�(p

er�du)

$1,198

,000

.00

(Credit�for�existing�ho

use)

DA�Fee

$11,55

0.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(160

0�sqm)

$650

,000

.00

(Old�hou

se�on�land

)Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e�(2bd

)$5

00,000

.00

Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e�(3bd

)$5

30,000

.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

4302

$1,850

$7,958

,700

Balcon

y72

8$5

00$3

64,000

Basemen

t�113

78$1

,515

$2,087

,670

Basemen

t�213

78$2

,100

$2,893

,800

Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

212

$140

$29,68

0Private�Ope

n�Space�(Groun

d�flo

or)

130

$160

$20,80

0Co

mmun

al�Ope

n�Space

366

$90

$32,94

0Land

scap

ing

305

$45

$13,72

5De

ep�planting

80$4

5$3

,600

Total

5395

$13,40

4,91

5

Feasibility�Outpu

tsLand

�Purchase�Price

$677

,275

.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

$14,08

9,57

2.00

Total�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

osts

$16,73

1,84

6.00

Gross�Realisation

$24,46

0,00

0.00

Developm

ent�P

rofit

$4,152

,365

.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

25.00%

Developm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

YES

Thescen

ariom

odelsa

160

0sqm

sitewith

47un

itsinan8storey

configuration.The

scen

arioachievesa

mod

estreturnandwou

ld

beviable.Only2basemen

tsarere

quire

ddu

etositesizeand

ultim

atelysucceedsdue

toth

ehighsa

lepricespossib

leinW

oody

Point.

Page 140: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�34:�High�Rise�Apa

rtmen

t�(8�Storeys)

Locatio

nRe

dcliffe

Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Zone

/Precinct

Urban

Yield�(no.�of�d

wellin

gs)

Car�P

arking�Rate

2cp/du

+vi

Dwellin

g�Co

nfiguration

No.�Of�3

�bed

room

sNo.�Of�2

�bed

room

sNo.�Of�1

�bed

room

sSite�Frontage

20Site�Dep

th50

Land

�Area

1000

Infrastructure�Cha

rges�(p

er�du)

(Credit�for�existing�dw

elling)

DA�Fee

$11,55

0.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(100

0�sqm)

$575

,000

.00

Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e�(2�bed

,�2�bath,�2�car)

$410

,000

.00

Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e�(3�bed

,�2�bath,�2�car)

$440

,000

.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

0Ba

lcon

y0

Garage

0Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

0Private�Ope

n�Space�(Groun

d�flo

or)

0Land

scap

ing

0De

ep�planting

0To

tal

0

Feasibility�Outpu

tsLand

�Purchase�Price

Constructio

n�Co

sts

Total�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

osts

Gross�Realisation

Developm

ent�P

rofit

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

Developm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

Desig

ndo

esnotworkbe

causethereisno

t eno

ughroom

totu

rna

abasemen

tona20

mwidefron

tage.Carparkingwou

ldth

enneed

tobeplaced

onthegrou

ndleveland

thereforethecommun

al

open

space,deepplantin

gand

land

scapingrequ

iremen

tsdono

tfit.

Page 141: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�35:�M

ultip

le�Dwellin

g�(High�Rise�Apa

rtmen

t���6�storey)

Locatio

nLawnton

Zone

/Precinct

Urban

Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Yield�(no.�of�d

wellin

gs)

47Ca

r�Parking�Rate

2cp/du

+vi

No.�Of�3

�bed

room

s32

No.�Of�2

�bed

room

s15

Site�Frontage

30Site�Dep

th53

Land

�Area

1600

Infrastructure�Cha

rges�(p

er�du)

$1,170

,000

.00

(credit�for�2�existing�dw

ellings)

DA�Fee

$11,55

0.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(160

0�sqm)

$630

,000

.00

(con

solidate�2�prop

ertie

s)Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e�(2�bed

)$2

90,000

.00

Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e�(3�bed

)$3

20,000

.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

3218

$1,850

$5,953

,300

.00

Balcon

y52

0$5

00$2

60,000

.00

Basemen

t�114

93$1

,515

$2,261

,895

.00

Basemen

t�214

93$2

,100

$3,135

,300

.00

Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

212

$140

$29,68

0.00

Private�Ope

n�Space�(Groun

d�flo

or)

130

$160

$20,80

0.00

Commun

al�Ope

n�Space

366

$90

$32,94

0.00

Land

scap

ing

287

$45

$12,91

5.00

Deep

�planting

80$4

5$3

,600

.00

Total

4293

$11,71

0,43

0.00

Feasibility�Outpu

tsLand

�Purchase�Price

$656

,375

.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

$12,28

8,48

6.00

Total�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

osts

$14,81

0,35

0.00

Gross�Realisation

$14,59

0,00

0.00

Developm

ent�P

rofit

�$2,47

0,62

7.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

�16.7%

Developm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

NO

Thehighcon

structioncostand

lowprodu

ctsa

lesp

riceprod

ucesa

negativ

ereturnonfeasibility.The

rewou

ldbeanopp

ortunityto

redu

ceth

ecarp

arkingra

teto

1cp/duho

weverth

elowprodu

ct

salepricewou

ldstillre

sultinth

ede

velopm

entb

eingunviable.

Page 142: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�36:�High�Rise�Apa

rtmen

ts�(1

2�Storey)

Locatio

nRe

dcliffe

Zone

/Precinct

Centre

Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Yield�(no.�of�d

wellin

gs)

94Ca

r�Parking�Rate

2cp/du

+vi

No.�Of�3

�bed

room

s46

No.�Of�2

�bed

room

s48

Site�Frontage

35Site�Dep

th68

Land

�Area

2380

Infrastructure�Cha

rges�(cum

ulative)

$2,260,000.00

(credit�for�3�existing�dw

ellings)

DA�Fee

$11,550.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(2400�sqm)

$1,100,000.00

(Old�hom

es�on�land

)Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e�(2�bed

room

)$430,000.00

Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e�(3�bed

room

)$460,000.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

9296

$2,000

$18,592,000

Balcon

y1320

$500

$660,000

Basemen

t�12205

$1,515

$3,340,575

Basemen

t�24410

$2,100

$9,261,000

Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

356

$140

$49,840

Private�Ope

n�Space�(Groun

d�Floo

r)150

$160

$24,000

Commun

al�Ope

n�Space�(Groun

d�flo

or)

514

$90

$46,260

Land

scap

ing

468

$45

$21,060

Deep

�planting

153

$45

$6,885

Total

2605

$32,001,620

Feasibility�Outpu

tsLand

�Purchase�Price

$114,845.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

$33,623,956.00

Total�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

osts

$38,906,654.00

Gross�Realisation

$41,800,000.00

Developm

ent�P

rofit

�$3,309,954.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

�$8.50

Developm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

NO

Thescen

ariom

odelsa

12storeybuildingon

a240

0sqm

site,w

hich

hasb

eenassumed

tobea3x800sqm

amalgamation.The

extra

heightincreaseso

verallconstructio

nprices,and

thecompliant

parkingratese

esth

ene

edto

con

struct3levelsofbasem

ent,with

atotalcosto

fover$

12mfo

rthise

lemen

talone

.Thescen

ario

losesm

oney,asa

resultofth

eextracostso

fcon

structionandthe

significantb

asem

entcosts.

Page 143: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�36a:�H

igh�Rise���Re

duce�CP�rate�and

�Increase�Sale�Price

Locatio

nRe

dcliffe

Zone

/Precinct

Centre

Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Yield�(no.�of�d

wellin

gs)

94Ca

r�Parking�Rate

1/du

+vi

No.�Of�3

�bed

room

s46

No.�Of�2

�bed

room

s48

No.�Of�1

�bed

room

s0

Site�Frontage

35Site�Dep

th68

Land

�Area

2380

Infrastructure�Cha

rges�(cum

ulative)

$2,260

,000

.00

(credit�for�3�existing�dw

ellings)

DA�Fee

$11,55

0.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(240

0�sqm)

$1,100

,000

.00

Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e�(2�bed

room

)$4

50,000

.00

Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e�(3�bed

room

)$4

90,000

.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

9296

$2,000

$18,59

2,00

0Ba

lcon

y13

20$5

00$6

60,000

Basemen

t�122

05$1

,515

$3,340

,575

Basemen

t�211

00$2

,100

$2,310

,000

Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

356

$140

$49,84

0Private�Ope

n�Space�(Groun

d�Floo

r)15

0$1

60$2

4,00

0Co

mmun

al�Ope

n�Space�(Groun

d�flo

or)

514

$90

$46,26

0Land

scap

ing

468

$45

$21,06

0De

ep�planting

153

$45

$6,885

Total

2605

$25,05

0,62

0

Feasibility�Outpu

tsLand

�Purchase�Price

$114

,845

.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

$26,32

5,40

6.00

Total�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

osts

$31,20

4,85

9.00

Gross�Realisation

$44,14

0,00

0.00

Developm

ent�P

rofi t

$6,485

,405

.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

20.80%

Developm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

YES

Themod

ified

scen

ariodeletesth

e3rdbasemen

tleveland

assum

es

1cpperdwellingon

ly.Aviableprojectwasabletobe

demon

strated,butonlybyincreasin

gsalepricesto

$45

0and$4

90

cumulativelyup

from

$43

0and$4

60inth

ebasesc

enario.This

illustratesth

atth

isstyleofdevelop

men

twith

redu

cedparkingmay

occurinthene

xtfe

wyearsasthe

marketimproves,how

everis

perhapsn

otviableinth

ecurren

tmarket.

Page 144: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�37:�High�Rise�Apa

rtmen

ts�(8

�Storey)

Locatio

nStrathpine

Zone

/Precinct

Centre

Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Yield�(no.�of�d

wellin

gs)

62Ca

r�Parking�Rate

2cp/du

+vi

No.�Of�3

�bed

room

s32

No.�Of�2

�bed

room

s30

Site�Frontage

35Site�Dep

th68

Land

�Area

2380

Infrastructure�Cha

rges�(cum

ulative)

$1,472,000.00

(credit�for�3�existing�dw

ellings)

DA�Fee

$11,550.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(2400�sqm)

$1,030,000.00

Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e�(2�bed

room

)$290,000.00

Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e�(3�bed

room

)$320,000.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

6192

$2,000

$12,384,000

Balcon

y1008

$500

$504,000

Basemen

t�12204

$1,515

$3,339,060

Basemen

t�22204

$2,100

$4,628,400

Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

356

$140

$49,840

Private�Ope

n�Space�(Groun

d�Floo

r)150

$160

$24,000

Commun

al�Ope

n�Space�(Groun

d�flo

or)

514

$90

$46,260

Land

scap

ing

468

$45

$21,060

Deep

�planting

153

$45

$6,885

Total

2293

$21,003,505

Feasibility�Outpu

tsLand

�Purchase�Price

$1,074,750.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

$22,075,793.00

Total�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

osts

$25,858,781.00

Gross�Realisation

$18,940,000.00

Developm

ent�P

rofit

�$10,097,867.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

�39.1%

Developm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

NO

Thescen

ariom

odelsa

12storeybuildingon

a240

0sqm

site,w

hich

hasb

eenassumed

tobea3x800sqm

amalgamation.The

extra

heightincreaseso

verallconstructio

nprices,and

thecompliant

parkingratese

esth

ene

edto

con

struct2levelsofbasem

ent,with

atotalcosto

fover$

8mfo

rthise

lemen

talone

.Thescen

arioloses

mon

ey,asa

resultofth

eextracostso

fcon

structionandthe

significantb

asem

entcostsand

thelowsa

lepricesachievablein

Strathpine

.

Page 145: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Scen

ario�38:�High�Rise�Apa

rtmen

ts�(8

�Storey)

Locatio

nCabo

olture

Zone

/Precinct

Centre

Scen

ario�Com

men

tary:

Yield�(no.�of�d

wellin

gs)

62Ca

r�Parking�Rate

1cp/du

+vi

No.�Of�3

�bed

room

s32

No.�Of�2

�bed

room

s30

Site�Frontage

35Site�Dep

th68

Land

�Area

2380

Infrastructure�Cha

rges�(cum

ulative)

$1,472,000.00

(credit�for�1�existing�dw

ellings)

DA�Fee

$11,550.00

Avg�Land

�Purchase�price�(2400�sqm)

$725,000.00

Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e�(2�bed

room

)$300,000.00

Prod

uct�S

ales�Pric

e�(3�bed

room

)$330,000.00

Area�Category

Area

Rate/m

2Co

stGFA

6192

$2,000

$12,384,000

Balcon

y1008

$500

$504,000

Basemen

t�12204

$1,515

$3,339,060

Drivew

ay/Pavem

ent

356

$140

$49,840

Private�Ope

n�Space�(Groun

d�Floo

r)150

$160

$24,000

Commun

al�Ope

n�Space�(Groun

d�flo

or)

514

$90

$46,260

Land

scap

ing

468

$45

$21,060

Deep

�planting

153

$45

$6,885

Total

2293

$16,375,105

Feasibility�Outpu

t sLand

�Purchase�Price

$755,650.00

Constructio

n�Co

sts

$22,075,793.00

Total�Lan

d�De

velopm

ent�C

osts

$25,539,681.00

Gross�Realisation

$19,560,000.00

Developm

ent�P

rofit

�$9,109,626.00

ROC�(ex.�Finan

ce)

�35.70%

Developm

ent�Likely�to�Proceed

NO

Thescen

ariom

odelsa

12storeybuildingon

a240

0sqm

site,w

hich

hasb

eenassumed

tobea3x800sqm

amalgamation.The

extra

heightincreaseso

verallconstructio

nprices,and

thecompliant

parkingratese

esth

ene

edto

con

struct2levelsofbasem

ent,with

atotalcosto

fover$

8mfo

rthise

lemen

talone

.Thescen

arioloses

mon

ey,asa

resultofth

eextracostso

fcon

structionandthe

significantb

asem

entcostsand

thelowsa

lepricesachievablein

Cabo

olture.

Page 146: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Section 3 - Feasibility Summaries

Page 147: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - Scenario 1

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR 190,000�G/R�Residential�2BR ��G/R�Residential�3BR 380,000�G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 570,000

518,182 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 570,000�������������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 17,100�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 10,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 27,100

Less:GST 10.00% 57,000NET�REALISATION 485,900�������������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 120,000$�LAND�StampDuty 2,625$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 127,625$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 276,150$�CONST�driveway 3,850$�CONST�landscaping 2,306$�CONST�turf �$�CONST�fencing 5,280$�CONST�Balcony 5,750$�CONST�Garage 30,600$�CONST�Contingency 16,197$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 340,133$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 17,007$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 17,007$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 2,310$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 1,786$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 22,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 31,096$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 388,235$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 515,860$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 2,579$FINANCE�LineFee 1,290$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined 664$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 12,033$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 527,894$������������������������

DevelopmentProfit 41,994�$ROC(ExFinance) �8.1%ROC(InFinance) �8.0%

Page 148: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - Scenario 1a

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR 210,000�G/R�Residential�2BR ��G/R�Residential�3BR 450,000�G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 660,000

600,000 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 660,000�������������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 19,800�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 10,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 29,800

Less:GST 10.00% 66,000NET�REALISATION 564,200�������������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 120,000$�LAND�StampDuty 2,625$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 127,625$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 276,150$�CONST�driveway 3,850$�CONST�landscaping 2,306$�CONST�turf �$�CONST�fencing 5,280$�CONST�Balcony 5,750$�CONST�Garage 30,600$�CONST�Contingency 16,197$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 340,133$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 17,007$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 17,007$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 2,310$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 1,786$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 22,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 31,096$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 388,235$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 515,860$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 2,579$FINANCE�LineFee 1,290$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined �$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 11,369$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 527,229$������������������������

DevelopmentProfit 36,971$ROC(ExFinance) 7.2%ROC(InFinance) 7.0%

Page 149: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - Scenario 2

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR 250,000�G/R�Residential�2BR ��G/R�Residential�3BR 550,000�G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 800,000

727,273 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 800,000�������������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 24,000�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 10,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 34,000

Less:GST 10.00% 80,000NET�REALISATION 686,000�������������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 230,000$�LAND�StampDuty 6,475$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 241,475$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 371,700$�CONST�driveway 3,850$�CONST�landscaping 3,870$�CONST�turf �$�CONST�fencing 9,920$�CONST�Balcony 6,500$�CONST�Garage 47,600$�CONST�Contingency 22,172$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 465,612$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 23,281$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 23,281$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 2,310$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 2,444$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 22,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 31,754$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 520,647$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 762,122$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 3,811$FINANCE�LineFee 1,905$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined 5,044$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 18,260$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 780,382$������������������������

DevelopmentProfit 94,382�$ROC(ExFinance) �12.4%ROC(InFinance) �12.1%

Page 150: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - scenario 2a

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR 750,000�G/R�Residential�2BR ��G/R�Residential�3BR 1,650,000�G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 2,400,000

2,181,818 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 2,400,000����������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 72,000�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 30,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 102,000

Less:GST 10.00% 240,000NET�REALISATION 2,058,000����������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 450,000$�LAND�StampDuty 14,175$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 469,175$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 828,450$�CONST�driveway 11,760$�CONST�landscaping 6,885$�CONST�turf �$�CONST�fencing 15,840$�CONST�Balcony 17,250$�CONST�Garage 91,800$�CONST�Contingency 48,599$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 1,020,584$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 51,029$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 51,029$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 2,310$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 5,358$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 122,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 134,668$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 1,206,282$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 1,675,456$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 8,377$FINANCE�LineFee 4,189$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined �$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 20,066$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 1,695,522$��������������������

DevelopmentProfit 362,478$ROC(ExFinance) 21.6%ROC(InFinance) 21.4%

Page 151: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility -scenario 3

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR 190,000�G/R�Residential�2BR ��G/R�Residential�3BR 380,000�G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 570,000

518,182 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 570,000�������������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 17,100�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 10,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 27,100

Less:GST 10.00% 57,000NET�REALISATION 485,900�������������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 230,000$�LAND�StampDuty 6,475$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 241,475$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 252,000$�CONST�driveway 4,200$�CONST�landscaping 13,185$�CONST�turf �$�CONST�fencing 23,040$�CONST�Balcony 11,250$�CONST�Garage 30,600$�CONST�Contingency 16,714$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 350,989$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 17,549$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 17,549$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 2,310$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 1,843$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 22,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 31,153$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 399,691$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 641,166$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 3,206$FINANCE�LineFee 1,603$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined 19,408$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 31,717$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 672,883$������������������������

DevelopmentProfit 186,983�$ROC(ExFinance) �29.2%ROC(InFinance) �27.8%

Page 152: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - scenario 3a

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR ��G/R�Residential�2BR ��G/R�Residential�3BR 900,000�G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 900,000

818,182 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 900,000�������������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 27,000�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 10,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 37,000

Less:GST 10.00% 90,000NET�REALISATION 773,000�������������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 230,000$�LAND�StampDuty 6,475$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 241,475$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 468,300$�CONST�driveway 7,700$�CONST�landscaping 4,590$�CONST�turf �$�CONST�fencing 10,560$�CONST�Balcony �$�CONST�Garage 61,200$�CONST�Contingency 27,618$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 579,968$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 28,998$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 28,998$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 2,310$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 3,045$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 28,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 38,355$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 647,321$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 888,796$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 4,444$FINANCE�LineFee 2,222$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined 10,072$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 24,238$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 913,034$������������������������

DevelopmentProfit 140,034�$ROC(ExFinance) �15.8%ROC(InFinance) �15.3%

Page 153: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - scenario4

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR ��G/R�Residential�2BR ��G/R�Residential�3BR 1,400,000�G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 1,400,000

1,272,727 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 1,400,000����������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 42,000�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 20,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 62,000

Less:GST 10.00% 140,000NET�REALISATION 1,198,000����������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 223,000$�LAND�StampDuty 6,230$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 234,230$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 596,400$�CONST�driveway 5,600$�CONST�landscaping 6,750$�CONST�turf �$�CONST�fencing 17,920$�CONST�Balcony �$�CONST�Garage 122,400$�CONST�Contingency 37,454$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 786,524$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 39,326$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 39,326$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 2,310$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 4,129$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 112,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 123,439$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 949,289$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 1,183,519$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 5,918$FINANCE�LineFee 2,959$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined �$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 16,376$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 1,199,895$��������������������

DevelopmentProfit 1,895�$ROC(ExFinance) �0.2%ROC(InFinance) �0.2%

Page 154: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - scenario 5

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR ��G/R�Residential�2BR 1,280,000�G/R�Residential�3BR ��G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 1,280,000

1,163,636 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 1,280,000����������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 38,400�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 20,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 58,400

Less:GST 10.00% 128,000NET�REALISATION 1,093,600����������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 215,000$�LAND�StampDuty 5,950$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 225,950$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 378,000$�CONST�driveway 5,600$�CONST�landscaping 6,750$�CONST�turf �$�CONST�fencing 17,920$�CONST�Balcony �$�CONST�Garage 122,400$�CONST�Contingency 26,534$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 557,204$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 27,860$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 27,860$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 2,310$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 2,925$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 88,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 98,235$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 683,299$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 909,249$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 4,546$FINANCE�LineFee 2,273$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined �$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 14,319$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 923,568$������������������������

DevelopmentProfit 170,032$ROC(ExFinance) 18.7%ROC(InFinance) 18.4%

Page 155: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - Scenario 6

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR ��G/R�Residential�2BR ��G/R�Residential�3BR 930,000�G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 930,000

845,455 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 930,000�������������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 27,900�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 15,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 42,900

Less:GST 10.00% 93,000NET�REALISATION 794,100�������������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 220,000$�LAND�StampDuty 6,125$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 231,125$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 677,250$�CONST�driveway 11,480$�CONST�landscaping 12,150$�CONST�turf �$�CONST�fencing 12,000$�CONST�Balcony �$�CONST�Garage 91,800$�CONST�Contingency 40,234$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 844,914$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 42,246$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 42,246$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 2,310$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 4,436$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 84,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 95,746$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 982,905$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 1,214,030$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 6,070$FINANCE�LineFee 3,035$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined 53,282$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 69,887$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 1,283,918$��������������������

DevelopmentProfit 489,818�$ROC(ExFinance) �40.3%ROC(InFinance) �38.2%

Page 156: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - Scenario 6a

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR ��G/R�Residential�2BR ��G/R�Residential�3BR 930,000�G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 930,000

845,455 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 930,000�������������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 27,900�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 15,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 42,900

Less:GST 10.00% 93,000NET�REALISATION 794,100�������������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 220,000$�LAND�StampDuty 6,125$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 231,125$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 409,500$�CONST�driveway 11,480$�CONST�landscaping 12,150$�CONST�turf �$�CONST�fencing 12,000$�CONST�Balcony �$�CONST�Garage 91,800$�CONST�Contingency 26,847$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 563,777$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 28,189$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 28,189$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 2,310$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 2,960$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 84,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 94,270$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 686,235$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 917,360$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 4,587$FINANCE�LineFee 2,293$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined 6,626$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 21,006$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 938,366$������������������������

DevelopmentProfit 144,266�$ROC(ExFinance) �15.7%ROC(InFinance) �15.4%

Page 157: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - Scenario 7

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR ��G/R�Residential�2BR ��G/R�Residential�3BR 1,080,000�G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 1,080,000

981,818 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 1,080,000����������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 32,400�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 15,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 47,400

Less:GST 10.00% 108,000NET�REALISATION 924,600�������������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 230,000$�LAND�StampDuty 6,475$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 241,475$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 560,700$�CONST�driveway 9,100$�CONST�landscaping 10,980$�CONST�turf �$�CONST�fencing 18,400$�CONST�Balcony �$�CONST�Garage 45,900$�CONST�Contingency 32,254$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 677,334$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 33,867$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 33,867$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 2,310$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 3,556$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 84,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 94,866$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 806,067$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 1,047,542$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 5,238$FINANCE�LineFee 2,619$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined 13,596$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 28,953$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 1,076,494$��������������������

DevelopmentProfit 151,894�$ROC(ExFinance) �14.5%ROC(InFinance) �14.1%

Page 158: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility -Scenario 8

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR ��G/R�Residential�2BR ��G/R�Residential�3BR 1,080,000�G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 1,080,000

981,818 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 1,080,000����������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 32,400�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 15,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 47,400

Less:GST 10.00% 108,000NET�REALISATION 924,600�������������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 300,000$�LAND�StampDuty 8,925$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 313,925$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 765,450$�CONST�driveway 5,460$�CONST�landscaping 11,790$�CONST�turf 2,430$�CONST�fencing 23,520$�CONST�Balcony 27,000$�CONST�Garage 34,000$�CONST�Contingency 43,483$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 913,133$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 45,657$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 45,657$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 3,480$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 4,794$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 56,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 69,274$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 1,028,063$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 1,341,988$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 6,710$FINANCE�LineFee 3,355$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined 57,701$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 75,266$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 1,417,254$��������������������

DevelopmentProfit 492,654�$ROC(ExFinance) �36.7%ROC(InFinance) �34.8%

Page 159: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - Scenario 9

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR ��G/R�Residential�2BR ��G/R�Residential�3BR 1,050,000�G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 1,050,000

954,545 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 1,050,000����������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 31,500�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 15,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 46,500

Less:GST 10.00% 105,000NET�REALISATION 898,500�������������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 241,000$�LAND�StampDuty 6,860$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 252,860$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 765,450$�CONST�driveway 5,460$�CONST�landscaping 9,990$�CONST�turf 2,430$�CONST�fencing 23,520$�CONST�Balcony 27,000$�CONST�Garage 67,150$�CONST�Contingency 45,050$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 946,050$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 47,303$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 47,303$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 3,480$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 4,967$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 56,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 69,447$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 1,062,799$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 1,315,659$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 6,578$FINANCE�LineFee 3,289$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined 52,284$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 69,651$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 1,385,311$��������������������

DevelopmentProfit 486,811�$ROC(ExFinance) �37.0%ROC(InFinance) �35.1%

Page 160: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - Scenario 10

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR ��G/R�Residential�2BR ��G/R�Residential�3BR 2,150,000�G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 2,150,000

1,954,545 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 2,150,000����������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 64,500�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 25,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 89,500

Less:GST 10.00% 215,000NET�REALISATION 1,845,500����������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 478,000$�LAND�StampDuty 15,155$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 498,155$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 609,000$�CONST�driveway 30,520$�CONST�landscaping 4,950$�CONST�turf 3,150$�CONST�fencing �$�CONST�Balcony 37,500$�CONST�Garage 140,250$�CONST�Contingency 41,269$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 866,639$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 43,332$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 43,332$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 3,480$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 4,550$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 112,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 125,030$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 1,035,000$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 1,533,155$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 7,666$FINANCE�LineFee 3,833$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined �$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 18,999$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 1,552,154$��������������������

DevelopmentProfit 293,346$ROC(ExFinance) 19.1%ROC(InFinance) 18.9%

Page 161: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - Scenario 11

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR ��G/R�Residential�2BR ��G/R�Residential�3BR 1,290,000�G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 1,290,000

1,172,727 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 1,290,000����������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 38,700�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 15,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 53,700

Less:GST 10.00% 129,000NET�REALISATION 1,107,300����������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 416,000$�LAND�StampDuty 12,985$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 433,985$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 516,600$�CONST�driveway 27,020$�CONST�landscaping 4,950$�CONST�turf 7,200$�CONST�fencing �$�CONST�Balcony 18,750$�CONST�Garage 84,150$�CONST�Contingency 32,934$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 691,604$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 34,580$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 34,580$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 3,480$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 3,631$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 112,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 124,111$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 850,295$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 1,284,280$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 6,421$FINANCE�LineFee 3,211$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined 13,451$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 30,583$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 1,314,863$��������������������

DevelopmentProfit 207,563�$ROC(ExFinance) �16.2%ROC(InFinance) �15.8%

Page 162: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - Scenario 12

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR ��G/R�Residential�2BR ��G/R�Residential�3BR 1,650,000�G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 1,650,000

1,500,000 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 1,650,000����������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 49,500�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 25,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 74,500

Less:GST 10.00% 165,000NET�REALISATION 1,410,500����������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 215,000$�LAND�StampDuty 5,950$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 225,950$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 609,000$�CONST�driveway 30,520$�CONST�landscaping 11,520$�CONST�turf 3,150$�CONST�fencing �$�CONST�Balcony 31,250$�CONST�Garage 140,250$�CONST�Contingency 41,285$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 866,975$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 43,349$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 43,349$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 3,480$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 4,552$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 140,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 153,032$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 1,063,355$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 1,289,305$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 6,447$FINANCE�LineFee 3,223$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined �$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 17,170$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 1,306,475$��������������������

DevelopmentProfit 104,025$ROC(ExFinance) 8.1%ROC(InFinance) 8.0%

Page 163: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - Scenario 12a

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR ��G/R�Residential�2BR ��G/R�Residential�3BR 1,650,000�G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 1,650,000

1,500,000 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 1,650,000����������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 49,500�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 25,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 74,500

Less:GST 10.00% 165,000NET�REALISATION 1,410,500����������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 215,000$�LAND�StampDuty 5,950$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 225,950$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 567,000$�CONST�driveway 30,520$�CONST�landscaping 15,120$�CONST�turf 3,150$�CONST�fencing �$�CONST�Balcony 31,250$�CONST�Garage 69,700$�CONST�Contingency 35,837$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 752,577$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 37,629$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 37,629$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 3,480$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 3,951$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 140,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 152,431$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 942,637$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 1,168,587$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 5,843$FINANCE�LineFee 2,921$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined �$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 16,264$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 1,184,851$��������������������

DevelopmentProfit 225,649$ROC(ExFinance) 19.3%ROC(InFinance) 19.0%

Page 164: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - Scenario 13

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR ��G/R�Residential�2BR ��G/R�Residential�3BR 1,650,000�G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 1,650,000

1,500,000 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 1,650,000����������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 49,500�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 25,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 74,500

Less:GST 10.00% 165,000NET�REALISATION 1,410,500����������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 220,000$�LAND�StampDuty 6,125$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 231,125$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 856,800$�CONST�driveway 27,020$�CONST�landscaping 15,300$�CONST�turf 2,610$�CONST�fencing 20,000$�CONST�Balcony �$�CONST�Garage 140,250$�CONST�Contingency 53,099$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 1,115,079$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 55,754$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 55,754$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 3,480$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 5,854$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 140,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 154,334$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 1,325,167$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 1,556,292$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 7,781$FINANCE�LineFee 3,891$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined 3,387$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 22,559$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 1,578,851$��������������������

DevelopmentProfit 168,351�$ROC(ExFinance) �10.8%ROC(InFinance) �10.7%

Page 165: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - Scenario 13A

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR ��G/R�Residential�2BR ��G/R�Residential�3BR 1,650,000�G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 1,650,000

1,500,000 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 1,650,000����������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 49,500�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 25,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 74,500

Less:GST 10.00% 165,000NET�REALISATION 1,410,500����������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 220,000$�LAND�StampDuty 6,125$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 231,125$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 682,500$�CONST�driveway 27,020$�CONST�landscaping 18,900$�CONST�turf 2,610$�CONST�fencing 20,000$�CONST�Balcony �$�CONST�Garage 68,000$�CONST�Contingency 40,952$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 859,982$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 42,999$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 42,999$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 3,480$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 4,515$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 140,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 152,995$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 1,055,975$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 1,287,100$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 6,436$FINANCE�LineFee 3,218$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined �$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 17,153$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 1,304,254$��������������������

DevelopmentProfit 106,246$ROC(ExFinance) 8.3%ROC(InFinance) 8.1%

Page 166: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - Scenario 13b

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR ��G/R�Residential�2BR ��G/R�Residential�3BR 1,980,000�G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 1,980,000

1,800,000 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 1,980,000����������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 59,400�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 30,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 89,400

Less:GST 10.00% 198,000NET�REALISATION 1,692,600����������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 220,000$�LAND�StampDuty 6,125$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 231,125$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 819,000$�CONST�driveway 27,020$�CONST�landscaping 15,300$�CONST�turf 2,610$�CONST�fencing 20,000$�CONST�Balcony �$�CONST�Garage 80,750$�CONST�Contingency 48,234$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 1,012,914$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 50,646$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 50,646$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 3,480$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 5,318$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 140,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 153,798$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 1,217,357$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 1,448,482$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 7,242$FINANCE�LineFee 3,621$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined �$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 18,364$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 1,466,846$��������������������

DevelopmentProfit 225,754$ROC(ExFinance) 15.6%ROC(InFinance) 15.4%

Page 167: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - Scenario 14

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR ��G/R�Residential�2BR ��G/R�Residential�3BR 1,700,000�G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 1,700,000

1,545,455 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 1,700,000����������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 51,000�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 25,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 76,000

Less:GST 10.00% 170,000NET�REALISATION 1,454,000����������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 446,000$�LAND�StampDuty 14,035$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 465,035$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 609,000$�CONST�driveway 34,020$�CONST�landscaping 8,550$�CONST�turf 5,580$�CONST�fencing 20,000$�CONST�Balcony �$�CONST�Garage 140,250$�CONST�Contingency 40,870$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 858,270$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 42,914$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 42,914$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 3,480$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 4,506$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 112,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 124,986$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 1,026,169$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 1,491,204$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 7,456$FINANCE�LineFee 3,728$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined �$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 18,684$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 1,509,888$��������������������

DevelopmentProfit 55,888�$ROC(ExFinance) �3.7%ROC(InFinance) �3.7%

Page 168: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - Scenario 14a

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR ��G/R�Residential�2BR ��G/R�Residential�3BR 2,040,000�G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 2,040,000

1,854,545 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 2,040,000����������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 61,200�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 30,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 91,200

Less:GST 10.00% 204,000NET�REALISATION 1,744,800����������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 446,000$�LAND�StampDuty 14,035$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 465,035$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 630,000$�CONST�driveway 34,020$�CONST�landscaping 10,800$�CONST�turf 2,070$�CONST�fencing 24,000$�CONST�Balcony �$�CONST�Garage 68,000$�CONST�Contingency 38,445$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 807,335$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 40,367$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 40,367$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 3,480$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 4,239$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 140,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 152,719$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 1,000,420$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 1,465,455$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 7,327$FINANCE�LineFee 3,664$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined �$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 18,491$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 1,483,946$��������������������

DevelopmentProfit 260,854$ROC(ExFinance) 17.8%ROC(InFinance) 17.6%

Page 169: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - Scenario 15

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR ��G/R�Residential�2BR ��G/R�Residential�3BR 1,020,000�G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 1,020,000

927,273 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 1,020,000����������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 30,600�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 15,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 45,600

Less:GST 10.00% 102,000NET�REALISATION 872,400�������������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 350,000$�LAND�StampDuty 10,675$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 365,675$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 516,600$�CONST�driveway 27,020$�CONST�landscaping 4,950$�CONST�turf 7,200$�CONST�fencing 12,000$�CONST�Balcony �$�CONST�Garage 84,150$�CONST�Contingency 32,596$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 684,516$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 34,226$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 34,226$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 3,480$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 3,594$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 56,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 68,074$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 786,816$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 1,152,490$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 5,762$FINANCE�LineFee 2,881$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined 32,435$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 48,579$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 1,201,069$��������������������

DevelopmentProfit 328,669�$ROC(ExFinance) �28.5%ROC(InFinance) �27.4%

Page 170: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - Scenario 15a

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR ��G/R�Residential�2BR ��G/R�Residential�3BR 1,360,000�G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 1,360,000

1,236,364 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 1,360,000����������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 40,800�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 20,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 60,800

Less:GST 10.00% 136,000NET�REALISATION 1,163,200����������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 280,000$�LAND�StampDuty 8,225$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 293,225$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 546,000$�CONST�driveway 27,020$�CONST�landscaping 4,950$�CONST�turf 7,200$�CONST�fencing 16,000$�CONST�Balcony �$�CONST�Garage 45,050$�CONST�Contingency 32,311$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 678,531$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 33,927$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 33,927$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 3,480$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 3,562$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 84,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 96,042$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 808,500$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 1,101,725$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 5,509$FINANCE�LineFee 2,754$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined �$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 15,763$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 1,117,488$��������������������

DevelopmentProfit 45,712$ROC(ExFinance) 4.1%ROC(InFinance) 4.1%

Page 171: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - Scenario 16

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR ��G/R�Residential�2BR ��G/R�Residential�3BR 1,950,000�G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 1,950,000

1,772,727 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 1,950,000����������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 58,500�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 30,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 88,500

Less:GST 10.00% 195,000NET�REALISATION 1,666,500����������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 215,000$�LAND�StampDuty 5,950$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 225,950$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 957,000$�CONST�driveway 29,260$�CONST�landscaping 20,250$�CONST�turf 6,345$�CONST�fencing 4,000$�CONST�Balcony 21,250$�CONST�Garage 222,700$�CONST�Contingency 63,040$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 1,323,845$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 66,192$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 66,192$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 3,480$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 6,950$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 168,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 183,430$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 1,573,468$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 1,799,418$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 8,997$FINANCE�LineFee 4,499$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined �$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 20,996$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 1,820,413$��������������������

DevelopmentProfit 153,913�$ROC(ExFinance) �8.6%ROC(InFinance) �8.5%

Page 172: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - Scenario 16a

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR ��G/R�Residential�2BR ��G/R�Residential�3BR 2,600,000�G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 2,600,000

2,363,636 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 2,600,000����������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 78,000�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 40,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 118,000

Less:GST 10.00% 260,000NET�REALISATION 2,222,000����������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 215,000$�LAND�StampDuty 5,950$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 225,950$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 960,000$�CONST�driveway 29,260$�CONST�landscaping 14,400$�CONST�turf 5,760$�CONST�fencing 12,000$�CONST�Balcony 21,250$�CONST�Garage 222,700$�CONST�Contingency 63,269$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 1,328,639$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 66,432$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 66,432$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 3,480$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 6,975$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 224,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 239,455$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 1,634,526$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 1,860,476$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 9,302$FINANCE�LineFee 4,651$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined �$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 21,454$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 1,881,929$��������������������

DevelopmentProfit 340,071$ROC(ExFinance) 18.3%ROC(InFinance) 18.1%

Page 173: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - Scenario 16b

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR ��G/R�Residential�2BR ��G/R�Residential�3BR 3,575,000�G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 3,575,000

3,250,000 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 3,575,000����������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 107,250�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 55,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 162,250

Less:GST 10.00% 357,500NET�REALISATION 3,055,250����������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 215,000$�LAND�StampDuty 5,950$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 225,950$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 1,554,000$�CONST�driveway 31,080$�CONST�landscaping 13,230$�CONST�turf 6,345$�CONST�fencing 4,000$�CONST�Balcony 42,500$�CONST�Garage 170,000$�CONST�Contingency 91,058$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 1,912,213$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 95,611$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 95,611$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 3,480$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 10,039$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 308,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 326,519$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 2,334,343$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 2,560,292$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 12,801$FINANCE�LineFee 6,401$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined �$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 26,702$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 2,586,995$��������������������

DevelopmentProfit 468,255$ROC(ExFinance) 18.3%ROC(InFinance) 18.1%

Page 174: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - Scenario 17

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR ��G/R�Residential�2BR ��G/R�Residential�3BR 3,740,000�G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 3,740,000

3,400,000 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 3,740,000����������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 112,200�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 55,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 167,200

Less:GST 10.00% 374,000NET�REALISATION 3,198,800����������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 215,000$�LAND�StampDuty 5,950$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 225,950$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 1,554,000$�CONST�driveway 31,080$�CONST�landscaping 13,230$�CONST�turf 6,345$�CONST�fencing 4,000$�CONST�Balcony 42,500$�CONST�Garage 222,700$�CONST�Contingency 93,693$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 1,967,548$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 98,377$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 98,377$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 3,480$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 10,330$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 308,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 326,810$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 2,392,735$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 2,618,685$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 13,093$FINANCE�LineFee 6,547$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined �$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 27,140$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 2,645,825$��������������������

DevelopmentProfit 552,975$ROC(ExFinance) 21.1%ROC(InFinance) 20.9%

Page 175: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - Scenario 18

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR ��G/R�Residential�2BR 700,000�G/R�Residential�3BR 1,560,000�G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 2,260,000

2,054,545 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 2,260,000����������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 67,800�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 30,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 97,800

Less:GST 10.00% 226,000NET�REALISATION 1,936,200����������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 365,000$�LAND�StampDuty 11,200$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 381,200$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 801,000$�CONST�driveway 12,880$�CONST�landscaping 10,800$�CONST�turf 7,155$�CONST�fencing �$�CONST�Balcony 24,000$�CONST�Garage 137,700$�CONST�Contingency 49,677$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 1,043,212$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 52,161$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 52,161$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 3,480$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 5,477$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 156,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 169,957$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 1,265,329$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 1,646,529$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 8,233$FINANCE�LineFee 4,116$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined �$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 19,849$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 1,666,378$��������������������

DevelopmentProfit 269,822$ROC(ExFinance) 16.4%ROC(InFinance) 16.2%

Page 176: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - Scenario 19

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR ��G/R�Residential�2BR ��G/R�Residential�3BR 3,800,000�G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 3,800,000

3,454,545 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 3,800,000����������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 114,000�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 50,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 164,000

Less:GST 10.00% 380,000NET�REALISATION 3,256,000����������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 478,000$�LAND�StampDuty 15,155$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 498,155$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 1,419,000$�CONST�driveway 31,080$�CONST�landscaping 13,230$�CONST�turf 6,345$�CONST�fencing 4,000$�CONST�Balcony 42,500$�CONST�Garage 246,500$�CONST�Contingency 88,133$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 1,850,788$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 92,539$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 92,539$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 3,480$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 9,717$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 252,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 270,197$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 2,213,524$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 2,711,679$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 13,558$FINANCE�LineFee 6,779$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined �$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 27,838$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 2,739,516$��������������������

DevelopmentProfit 516,484$ROC(ExFinance) 19.0%ROC(InFinance) 18.9%

Page 177: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - Scenario 20

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR ��G/R�Residential�2BR 680,000�G/R�Residential�3BR 1,440,000�G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 2,120,000

1,927,273 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 2,120,000����������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 63,600�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 30,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 93,600

Less:GST 10.00% 212,000NET�REALISATION 1,814,400����������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 300,000$�LAND�StampDuty 8,925$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 313,925$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 801,000$�CONST�driveway 12,880$�CONST�landscaping 10,800$�CONST�turf 7,155$�CONST�fencing �$�CONST�Balcony 24,000$�CONST�Garage 137,700$�CONST�Contingency 49,677$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 1,043,212$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 52,161$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 52,161$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 3,480$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 5,477$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 156,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 169,957$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 1,265,329$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 1,579,254$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 7,896$FINANCE�LineFee 3,948$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined �$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 19,344$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 1,598,599$��������������������

DevelopmentProfit 215,801$ROC(ExFinance) 13.7%ROC(InFinance) 13.5%

Page 178: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - Scenario 21

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR ��G/R�Residential�2BR ��G/R�Residential�3BR 3,100,000�G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 3,100,000

2,818,182 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 3,100,000����������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 93,000�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 50,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 143,000

Less:GST 10.00% 310,000NET�REALISATION 2,647,000����������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 355,000$�LAND�StampDuty 10,850$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 370,850$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 1,419,000$�CONST�driveway 31,080$�CONST�landscaping 13,230$�CONST�turf 6,345$�CONST�fencing 4,000$�CONST�Balcony 42,500$�CONST�Garage 246,500$�CONST�Contingency 88,133$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 1,850,788$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 92,539$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 92,539$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 3,480$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 9,717$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 252,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 270,197$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 2,213,524$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 2,584,374$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 12,922$FINANCE�LineFee 6,461$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined �$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 26,883$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 2,611,257$��������������������

DevelopmentProfit 35,743$ROC(ExFinance) 1.4%ROC(InFinance) 1.4%

Page 179: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - Scenario 22

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR ��G/R�Residential�2BR 600,000�G/R�Residential�3BR 1,320,000�G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 1,920,000

1,745,455 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 1,920,000����������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 57,600�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 30,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 87,600

Less:GST 10.00% 192,000NET�REALISATION 1,640,400����������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 296,000$�LAND�StampDuty 8,785$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 309,785$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 801,000$�CONST�driveway 12,880$�CONST�landscaping 10,800$�CONST�turf 7,155$�CONST�fencing �$�CONST�Balcony 24,000$�CONST�Garage 137,700$�CONST�Contingency 49,677$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 1,043,212$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 52,161$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 52,161$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 3,480$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 5,477$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 156,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 169,957$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 1,265,329$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 1,575,114$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 7,876$FINANCE�LineFee 3,938$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined �$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 19,313$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 1,594,428$��������������������

DevelopmentProfit 45,972$ROC(ExFinance) 2.9%ROC(InFinance) 2.9%

Page 180: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - Scenario 23

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR ��G/R�Residential�2BR ��G/R�Residential�3BR 3,100,000�G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 3,100,000

2,818,182 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 3,100,000����������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 93,000�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 50,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 143,000

Less:GST 10.00% 310,000NET�REALISATION 2,647,000����������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 355,000$�LAND�StampDuty 10,850$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 370,850$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 1,419,000$�CONST�driveway 31,080$�CONST�landscaping 13,230$�CONST�turf 6,345$�CONST�fencing 4,000$�CONST�Balcony 42,500$�CONST�Garage 246,500$�CONST�Contingency 88,133$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 1,850,788$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 92,539$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 92,539$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 3,480$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 9,717$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 252,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 270,197$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 2,213,524$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 2,584,374$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 12,922$FINANCE�LineFee 6,461$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined �$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 26,883$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 2,611,257$��������������������

DevelopmentProfit 35,743$ROC(ExFinance) 1.4%ROC(InFinance) 1.4%

Page 181: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - Scenario 23a

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR ��G/R�Residential�2BR ��G/R�Residential�3BR 4,080,000�G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 4,080,000

3,709,091 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 4,080,000����������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 122,400�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 60,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 182,400

Less:GST 10.00% 408,000NET�REALISATION 3,489,600����������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 301,000$�LAND�StampDuty 8,960$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 314,960$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 1,650,000$�CONST�driveway 50,400$�CONST�landscaping 14,940$�CONST�turf 3,375$�CONST�fencing �$�CONST�Balcony 42,500$�CONST�Garage 261,800$�CONST�Contingency 101,151$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 2,124,166$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 106,208$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 106,208$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 3,480$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 11,152$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 308,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 327,632$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 2,558,006$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 2,872,966$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 14,365$FINANCE�LineFee 7,182$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined �$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 29,047$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 2,902,013$��������������������

DevelopmentProfit 587,587$ROC(ExFinance) 20.5%ROC(InFinance) 20.2%

Page 182: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - Scenario 24

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR ��G/R�Residential�2BR 800,000�G/R�Residential�3BR 1,800,000�G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 2,600,000

2,363,636 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 2,600,000����������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 78,000�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 30,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 108,000

Less:GST 10.00% 260,000NET�REALISATION 2,232,000����������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 313,000$�LAND�StampDuty 9,380$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 327,380$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 801,000$�CONST�driveway 12,880$�CONST�landscaping 10,800$�CONST�turf 7,155$�CONST�fencing �$�CONST�Balcony 24,000$�CONST�Garage 137,700$�CONST�Contingency 49,677$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 1,043,212$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 52,161$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 52,161$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 3,480$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 5,477$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 156,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 169,957$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 1,265,329$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 1,592,709$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 7,964$FINANCE�LineFee 3,982$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined �$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 19,445$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 1,612,154$��������������������

DevelopmentProfit 619,846$ROC(ExFinance) 38.9%ROC(InFinance) 38.4%

Page 183: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - Scenario 25

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR ��G/R�Residential�2BR ��G/R�Residential�3BR 4,300,000�G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 4,300,000

3,909,091 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 4,300,000����������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 129,000�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 50,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 179,000

Less:GST 10.00% 430,000NET�REALISATION 3,691,000����������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 540,000$�LAND�StampDuty 17,325$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 562,325$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 1,464,000$�CONST�driveway 41,580$�CONST�landscaping 18,000$�CONST�turf 3,375$�CONST�fencing �$�CONST�Balcony 42,500$�CONST�Garage 261,800$�CONST�Contingency 91,563$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 1,922,818$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 96,141$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 96,141$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 3,480$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 10,095$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 252,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 270,575$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 2,289,533$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 2,851,858$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 14,259$FINANCE�LineFee 7,130$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined �$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 28,889$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 2,880,747$��������������������

DevelopmentProfit 810,253$ROC(ExFinance) 28.4%ROC(InFinance) 28.1%

Page 184: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - Scenario 26

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR ��G/R�Residential�2BR 1,640,000�G/R�Residential�3BR 1,720,000�G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 3,360,000

3,054,545 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 3,360,000����������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 100,800�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 40,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 140,800

Less:GST 10.00% 336,000NET�REALISATION 2,883,200����������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 448,000$�LAND�StampDuty 14,105$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 467,105$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 900,000$�CONST�driveway 20,580$�CONST�landscaping 14,400$�CONST�turf 6,345$�CONST�fencing �$�CONST�Balcony 64,000$�CONST�Garage 290,700$�CONST�Contingency 64,801$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 1,360,826$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 68,041$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 68,041$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 3,480$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 7,144$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 172,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 187,624$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 1,616,492$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 2,083,597$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 10,418$FINANCE�LineFee 5,209$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined �$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 23,127$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 2,106,724$��������������������

DevelopmentProfit 776,476$ROC(ExFinance) 37.3%ROC(InFinance) 36.9%

Page 185: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - Scenario 27

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR ��G/R�Residential�2BR 2,460,000�G/R�Residential�3BR 6,020,000�G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 8,480,000

7,709,091 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 8,480,000����������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 254,400�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 100,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 354,400

Less:GST 10.00% 848,000NET�REALISATION 7,277,600����������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 448,000$�LAND�StampDuty 14,105$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 467,105$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 3,764,750$�CONST�driveway 28,000$�CONST�landscaping 30,600$�CONST�turf 2,250$�CONST�fencing 16,000$�CONST�Balcony 175,000$�CONST�Garage 5,429,250$�CONST�Contingency 472,293$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 9,918,143$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 495,907$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 495,907$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 5,780$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 52,070$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 496,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 558,850$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 10,972,900$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 11,440,005$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 57,200$FINANCE�LineFee 28,600$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined �$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 93,300$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 11,533,305$������������������

DevelopmentProfit 4,255,705�$ROC(ExFinance) �37.2%ROC(InFinance) �36.9%

Page 186: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - Scenario 27a

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR ��G/R�Residential�2BR 2,460,000�G/R�Residential�3BR 6,020,000�G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 8,480,000

7,709,091 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 8,480,000����������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 254,400�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 100,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 354,400

Less:GST 10.00% 848,000NET�REALISATION 7,277,600����������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 448,000$�LAND�StampDuty 14,105$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 467,105$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 3,764,750$�CONST�driveway 28,000$�CONST�landscaping 30,600$�CONST�turf 2,250$�CONST�fencing 16,000$�CONST�Balcony 175,000$�CONST�Garage 2,494,350$�CONST�Contingency 325,548$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 6,836,498$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 341,825$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 341,825$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 5,780$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 35,892$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 496,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 542,672$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 7,720,994$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 8,188,099$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 40,940$FINANCE�LineFee 20,470$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined �$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 68,911$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 8,257,010$��������������������

DevelopmentProfit 979,410�$ROC(ExFinance) �12.0%ROC(InFinance) �11.9%

Page 187: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - Scenario 28

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR ��G/R�Residential�2BR 4,000,000�G/R�Residential�3BR 2,250,000�G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 6,250,000

5,681,818 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 6,250,000����������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 187,500�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 75,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 262,500

Less:GST 10.00% 625,000NET�REALISATION 5,362,500����������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 551,000$�LAND�StampDuty 17,820$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 573,820$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 2,205,200$�CONST�driveway 13,160$�CONST�landscaping 18,000$�CONST�turf 6,570$�CONST�fencing 22,240$�CONST�Balcony 84,000$�CONST�Garage 3,434,250$�CONST�Contingency 289,171$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 6,072,591$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 303,630$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 303,630$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 5,780$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 31,881$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 332,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 374,661$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 6,750,882$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 7,324,702$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 36,624$FINANCE�LineFee 18,312$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined �$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 62,435$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 7,387,137$��������������������

DevelopmentProfit 2,024,637�$ROC(ExFinance) �27.6%ROC(InFinance) �27.4%

Page 188: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - Scenario 28a

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR ��G/R�Residential�2BR 8,000,000�G/R�Residential�3BR ��G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 8,000,000

7,272,727 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 8,000,000����������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 240,000�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 100,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 340,000

Less:GST 10.00% 800,000NET�REALISATION 6,860,000����������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 551,000$�LAND�StampDuty 17,820$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 573,820$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 2,205,200$�CONST�driveway 13,160$�CONST�landscaping 18,000$�CONST�turf 6,570$�CONST�fencing 22,240$�CONST�Balcony 84,000$�CONST�Garage 1,439,250$�CONST�Contingency 189,421$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 3,977,841$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 198,892$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 198,892$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 5,780$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 20,884$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 418,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 449,664$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 4,626,397$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 5,200,217$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 26,001$FINANCE�LineFee 13,001$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined �$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 46,502$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 5,246,718$��������������������

DevelopmentProfit 1,613,282$ROC(ExFinance) 31.0%ROC(InFinance) 30.7%

Page 189: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - Scenario 29

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR ��G/R�Residential�2BR 4,000,000�G/R�Residential�3BR 2,250,000�G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 6,250,000

5,681,818 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 6,250,000����������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 187,500�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 75,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 262,500

Less:GST 10.00% 625,000NET�REALISATION 5,362,500����������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 551,000$�LAND�StampDuty 17,820$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 573,820$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 2,205,200$�CONST�driveway 13,160$�CONST�landscaping 18,000$�CONST�turf 6,570$�CONST�fencing 22,240$�CONST�Balcony 84,000$�CONST�Garage 3,434,250$�CONST�Contingency 289,171$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 6,072,591$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 303,630$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 303,630$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 5,780$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 31,881$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 332,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 374,661$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 6,750,882$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 7,324,702$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 36,624$FINANCE�LineFee 18,312$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined �$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 62,435$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 7,387,137$��������������������

DevelopmentProfit 2,024,637�$ROC(ExFinance) �27.6%ROC(InFinance) �27.4%

Page 190: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - Scenario 30

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR ��G/R�Residential�2BR 5,200,000�G/R�Residential�3BR ��G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 5,200,000

4,727,273 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 5,200,000����������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 156,000�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 100,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 256,000

Less:GST 10.00% 520,000NET�REALISATION 4,424,000����������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 265,000$�LAND�StampDuty 7,700$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 277,700$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 2,205,200$�CONST�driveway 13,160$�CONST�landscaping 18,000$�CONST�turf 6,570$�CONST�fencing 22,400$�CONST�Balcony 84,000$�CONST�Garage 1,439,250$�CONST�Contingency 189,429$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 3,978,009$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 198,900$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 198,900$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 5,780$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 20,885$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 440,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 471,665$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 4,648,574$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 4,926,274$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 24,631$FINANCE�LineFee 12,316$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined �$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 44,447$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 4,970,721$��������������������

DevelopmentProfit 546,721�$ROC(ExFinance) �11.1%ROC(InFinance) �11.0%

Page 191: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - Scenario 31

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR ��G/R�Residential�2BR 5,250,000�G/R�Residential�3BR ��G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 5,250,000

4,772,727 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 5,250,000����������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 157,500�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 75,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 232,500

Less:GST 10.00% 525,000NET�REALISATION 4,492,500����������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 405,000$�LAND�StampDuty 12,600$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 422,600$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 2,358,750$�CONST�driveway 35,140$�CONST�landscaping 10,980$�CONST�turf 2,340$�CONST�fencing �$�CONST�Balcony 120,000$�CONST�Garage 294,100$�CONST�Contingency 141,066$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 2,962,376$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 148,119$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 148,119$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 5,780$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 15,552$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 308,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 334,332$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 3,444,827$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 3,867,427$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 19,337$FINANCE�LineFee 9,669$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined �$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 36,506$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 3,903,932$��������������������

DevelopmentProfit 588,568$ROC(ExFinance) 15.2%ROC(InFinance) 15.1%

Page 192: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - Scenario 32

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR ��G/R�Residential�2BR 4,640,000�G/R�Residential�3BR 2,560,000�G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 7,200,000

6,545,455 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 7,200,000����������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 216,000�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 120,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 336,000

Less:GST 10.00% 720,000NET�REALISATION 6,144,000����������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 265,000$�LAND�StampDuty 7,700$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 277,700$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 3,315,200$�CONST�driveway 13,020$�CONST�landscaping 22,500$�CONST�turf 7,200$�CONST�fencing 21,600$�CONST�Balcony 130,000$�CONST�Garage 5,429,250$�CONST�Contingency 446,939$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 9,385,709$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 469,285$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 469,285$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 5,780$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 49,275$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 548,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 608,055$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE 5,429,250$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 15,892,299$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 16,169,999$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 80,850$FINANCE�LineFee 40,425$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined �$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 128,775$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 16,298,774$������������������

DevelopmentProfit 10,154,774�$ROC(ExFinance) �62.8%ROC(InFinance) �62.3%

Page 193: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - Scenario 33

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR ��G/R�Residential�2BR 7,500,000�G/R�Residential�3BR 16,960,000�G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 24,460,000

22,236,364 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 24,460,000�������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 733,800�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 235,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 968,800

Less:GST 10.00% 2,446,000NET�REALISATION 21,045,200�������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 650,000$�LAND�StampDuty 22,275$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 677,275$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 7,958,700$�CONST�driveway 29,680$�CONST�landscaping 60,390$�CONST�turf 3,600$�CONST�fencing 20,800$�CONST�Balcony 364,000$�CONST�Garage 4,981,470$�CONST�Contingency 670,932$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 14,089,572$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 704,479$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 704,479$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 11,550$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 73,970$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 1,170,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 1,260,520$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 16,054,571$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 16,731,846$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 83,659$FINANCE�LineFee 41,830$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined �$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 132,989$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 16,864,835$������������������

DevelopmentProfit 4,180,365$ROC(ExFinance) 25.0%ROC(InFinance) 24.8%

Page 194: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - Scenario 35

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR ��G/R�Residential�2BR 4,350,000�G/R�Residential�3BR 10,240,000�G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 14,590,000

13,263,636 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 14,590,000�������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 437,700�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 235,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 672,700

Less:GST 10.00% 1,459,000NET�REALISATION 12,458,300�������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 630,000$�LAND�StampDuty 21,375$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 656,375$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 5,953,300$�CONST�driveway 29,680$�CONST�landscaping 25,830$�CONST�turf 16,515$�CONST�fencing 20,800$�CONST�Balcony 260,000$�CONST�Garage 5,397,195$�CONST�Contingency 585,166$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 12,288,486$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 614,424$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 614,424$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 11,550$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 64,515$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 1,170,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 1,251,065$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 14,153,975$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 14,810,350$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 74,052$FINANCE�LineFee 37,026$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined �$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 118,578$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 14,928,927$������������������

DevelopmentProfit 2,470,627�$ROC(ExFinance) �16.7%ROC(InFinance) �16.5%

Page 195: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - Scenario 36

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR ��G/R�Residential�2BR 20,640,000�G/R�Residential�3BR 21,160,000�G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 41,800,000

38,000,000 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 41,800,000�������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 1,254,000�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 470,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 1,724,000

Less:GST 10.00% 4,180,000NET�REALISATION 35,896,000�������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 1,100,000$�LAND�StampDuty 43,425$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 1,148,425$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 18,592,000$�CONST�driveway 49,840$�CONST�landscaping 88,470$�CONST�turf 6,930$�CONST�fencing 24,000$�CONST�Balcony 660,000$�CONST�Garage 12,601,575$�CONST�Contingency 1,601,141$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 33,623,956$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 1,681,198$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 1,681,198$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 11,550$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 176,526$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 2,260,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 2,453,076$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 37,758,229$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 38,906,654$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 194,533$FINANCE�LineFee 97,267$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined �$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 299,300$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 39,205,954$������������������

DevelopmentProfit 3,309,954�$ROC(ExFinance) �8.5%ROC(InFinance) �8.4%

Page 196: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - Scenario 36a

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR ��G/R�Residential�2BR 21,600,000�G/R�Residential�3BR 22,540,000�G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 44,140,000

40,127,273 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 44,140,000�������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 1,324,200�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 470,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 1,794,200

Less:GST 10.00% 4,414,000NET�REALISATION 37,931,800�������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 1,100,000$�LAND�StampDuty 43,425$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 1,148,425$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 18,592,000$�CONST�driveway 49,840$�CONST�landscaping 88,470$�CONST�turf 6,930$�CONST�fencing 24,000$�CONST�Balcony 660,000$�CONST�Garage 5,650,575$�CONST�Contingency 1,253,591$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 26,325,406$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 1,316,270$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 1,316,270$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 11,550$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 138,208$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 2,260,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 2,414,758$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 30,056,434$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 31,204,859$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 156,024$FINANCE�LineFee 78,012$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined �$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 241,536$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 31,446,396$������������������

DevelopmentProfit 6,485,404$ROC(ExFinance) 20.8%ROC(InFinance) 20.6%

Page 197: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - Scenario 37

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR ��G/R�Residential�2BR 8,700,000�G/R�Residential�3BR 10,240,000�G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 18,940,000

17,218,182 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 18,940,000�������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 568,200�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 310,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 878,200

Less:GST 10.00% 1,894,000NET�REALISATION 16,167,800�������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 1,030,000$�LAND�StampDuty 39,750$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 1,074,750$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 12,384,000$�CONST�driveway 49,840$�CONST�landscaping 88,380$�CONST�turf 6,885$�CONST�fencing 24,000$�CONST�Balcony 504,000$�CONST�Garage 7,967,460$�CONST�Contingency 1,051,228$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 22,075,793$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 1,103,790$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 1,103,790$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 11,550$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 115,898$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 1,472,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 1,604,448$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 24,784,031$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 25,858,781$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 129,294$FINANCE�LineFee 64,647$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined 205,445$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 406,886$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 26,265,667$������������������

DevelopmentProfit 10,097,867�$ROC(ExFinance) �39.1%ROC(InFinance) �38.4%

Page 198: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - Scenario 37a

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR ��G/R�Residential�2BR 8,700,000�G/R�Residential�3BR 10,240,000�G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 18,940,000

17,218,182 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 18,940,000�������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 568,200�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 310,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 878,200

Less:GST 10.00% 1,894,000NET�REALISATION 16,167,800�������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 1,030,000$�LAND�StampDuty 39,750$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 1,074,750$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 12,384,000$�CONST�driveway 49,840$�CONST�landscaping 88,380$�CONST�turf 6,885$�CONST�fencing 24,000$�CONST�Balcony 504,000$�CONST�Garage 7,967,460$�CONST�Contingency 1,051,228$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 22,075,793$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 1,103,790$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 1,103,790$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 11,550$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 115,898$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 1,472,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 1,604,448$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 24,784,031$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 25,858,781$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 129,294$FINANCE�LineFee 64,647$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined 205,445$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 406,886$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 26,265,667$������������������

DevelopmentProfit 10,097,867�$ROC(ExFinance) �39.1%ROC(InFinance) �38.4%

Page 199: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - Scenario 38

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR ��G/R�Residential�2BR 9,000,000�G/R�Residential�3BR 10,560,000�G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 19,560,000

17,781,818 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 19,560,000�������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 586,800�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 310,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 896,800

Less:GST 10.00% 1,956,000NET�REALISATION 16,707,200�������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 725,000$�LAND�StampDuty 25,650$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 755,650$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 12,384,000$�CONST�driveway 49,840$�CONST�landscaping 88,380$�CONST�turf 6,885$�CONST�fencing 24,000$�CONST�Balcony 504,000$�CONST�Garage 7,967,460$�CONST�Contingency 1,051,228$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 22,075,793$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 1,103,790$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 1,103,790$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 11,550$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 115,898$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 1,472,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 1,604,448$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 24,784,031$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 25,539,681$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 127,698$FINANCE�LineFee 63,849$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined 78,098$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 277,145$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 25,816,826$������������������

DevelopmentProfit 9,109,626�$ROC(ExFinance) �35.7%ROC(InFinance) �35.3%

Page 200: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Project Feasibility - Scenario 38a

REVENUEGross�Realisation���Resi�Sales�(In.�GST)�G/R�Residential�1BR ��G/R�Residential�2BR 10,500,000�G/R�Residential�3BR 12,160,000�G/R�Residential�HOUSE ��G/R�Residential�OTHER �SubTotal(Residentials) TRUE 22,660,000

20,600,000 <<<�Exc�GSTGross�Realisation���Non�Resi�Sales�(Ex.�GST)G/R�Commercial �G/R�Industrial �G/R�Retail �G/R�Other �SubTotal(NonResidentials) TRUE �

GROSS�REALISATION 22,660,000�������������������

Less:Selling/LeasingCosts�COMMS�Residential 679,800�COMMS�NonResidential ��LEASING�NonResidential ��SELLING�Residential 310,000�SELLING�NonResidential �SubTotal(Selling/LeasingCosts) 989,800

Less:GST 10.00% 2,266,000NET�REALISATION 19,404,200�������������������

DEVELOPMENT�COSTS�(Exc�of�GST)Land�Purchase�LAND�PurchasePrice 725,000$�LAND�StampDuty 25,650$�LAND�Legals 5,000$

0 �$SubTotal�(LandPurchase) TRUE 755,650$

Construction�Costs�CONST�Residential 12,384,000$�CONST�driveway 49,840$�CONST�landscaping 88,380$�CONST�turf 6,885$�CONST�fencing 24,000$�CONST�Balcony 504,000$�CONST�Garage 3,339,060$�CONST�Contingency 819,808$SubTotal�(ConstructionCosts) TRUE 17,215,973$

Professional�Fees�PROFFEE�(alldisciplines) 860,799$�PROFFEE�DM �$�PROFFEE�PM �$�PROFFEE�Architect �$�PROFFEE�Surveyor �$�PROFFEE�TownPlanner �$�PROFFEE�CivilEngineer �$�PROFFEE�StructuralEngineer �$�PROFFEE�TrafficEngineer �$�PROFFEE�GeotechnicalEngineer �$�PROFFEE�EconomicsConsultant �$�PROFFEE�OtherConsultants �$SubTotal�(ProfessionalFees) TRUE 860,799$

Statutory�Fees�STATFEE�Applicationfee 11,550$�STATFEE�QLeave/PLSL 90,384$�STATFEE�Certifier 2,500$�STATFEE�BA(QFRS) 2,500$�STATFEE�InfrustructureCharges 1,472,000$SubTotal�(StatutoryFees) TRUE 1,578,934$

Miscellaneous�CostsSubTotal�(MiscellaneousCosts) TRUE �$

DevelopmentCosts(excl.Land&Finance) 19,655,706$DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land) 20,411,356$

FinanceCostsFINANCE�ValuationFee 7,500$FINANCE�EstablishmentFee 102,057$FINANCE�LineFee 51,028$FINANCE�Interest�LandLoan }FINANCE�Interest�ConstLoan }combined �$SubTotal�(DevelopmentCosts(incl.Land)) 160,585$

TOTAL�DEVELOPMENT�COSTS 20,571,941$������������������

DevelopmentProfit 1,167,741�$ROC(ExFinance) �5.7%ROC(InFinance) �5.7%

Page 201: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Section 4 - Real Estate Market Research Data

Page 202: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

-���

���

��)�

�)��

��-

���

!��%

���

���

����

���

�,��

���

���

����

���

�,��

�+�

��7

8��

����

��

���

�+8

���

����

� �

����

���

���

���

�+�

����

����

�&�

��

_�<� `�

��

`��{���>

���|

� ���J�

Q ����[X<

�> �

!�-*#���&��

���*����

| � ���J�

Q ����[X<

�> ��

<��

��<J

<��<

>�J >X<�

���[� �

J� �<

��<�J���J\�<

��� �<��<Q

��>

�J����>��

`��{���>

��-�>J<� \<��X<�

> � �

�#�

�JX#���

! �*#���&��

*�� ����

{<�J<�

�J� J

`��{���>

��-�>J<� \<��X<�

> � �

�#�

�JX

! *�#���&��

����������

�J����>��

`��{���>

��-�>J<� \<��X<�

> � �

�#�

�JX#���

! �*#���&��

�*�������

�� ����J

`��{���>

��-�>J<� \<��X<�

> � �

�#�

�JX#���

! --#���&��

�-�������

��<>�\`� ��

`��{���>

����>J<� \<��X<�

> � �

�#�

�JX#���

! ��#���&��

���� �����

�<� >�

J� J

`��{���>

����>J<� \<��X<�

> � �

�#�

�JX#���

! ��#���&��

���� ����

� J�[<�

|���

`��{���>

���>��

[� >J<� \�����X<

�> ��

� �

#��JX#���

!��*#���&��

���X

�J� J

`��{���>

��"|Q

����[X<

�> �

� �

#��JX#�

��#�<

<�!��*#���&��

����������

�<Q��> �Q ����[Z�>J�

=<J ��<=

X�[X

��

�>�J\

� >�[�J�<

������>�<�

`��{���>

��"�

��J���

! ��#���&��

�-��������

�� Q

>J<��J\

� >�� �J� J

`��{���>

��"�>J<� \<��X<�

> ���

�#�

�JX#���

! �*#���&��

���X

�J� J

`��{���>

��"�>J<� \<��X<�

> � �

�#�

�JX#���

!� �#���&��

�����>�<�

`��{���>

"� �

��J���

! �*#���&��

�� Q

>J<��J\

{��� ��� `�

`��X���>

����

�<Q>

J<�������X<

�> ��

� �

#��JX#���

!�-*#���&��

*�������

�J�����<J>��

��`��{���>�>

�<��

�����-��>?=

&��=

�J ��<J>��

><� ��

��>?=�

=�[=J�<�Q<�

��X� J<<����&

� >�� �J� J

`��{���>

����

>��[� >J<� \�����X<

= Q�JX

�<

<�J� �� � �

#��JX#���

!�""#���&��

�<��

� �Q<<

���

`��{���>

��-�

�>J<� \<��X<�

> ���

�#�

�JX# ��

!���#���&��

��-�����

�����>�<�

`��{���>

�� ��

�<Q�X

<�> � �

�#��JX�<<

=#

���

� ��� ��<�

��J� � �

�<<=

#�

�JX�<<=

#���

!�#���#���&��

���������"

!��#���&��

!���#����!**�#���

�����������

���

��=�J

��

Q�

>�� �

J��� � �<�

= �

J��

`��{���>

|����J� J

���� �

[�\

* �-

!"��#���&��

���-����-

��

`�>�����X>� >�[�

�JX `�

��

>��<�

��J<

���=Q�� ��<J=

�J>>

����[�<

�!��*#���J�

��

�&�X > � �� X<

��

��<�

��J

��� �<J<��<

�\�<��<

�J &

|����J� J

���� �

[�\

�*�

���J���

!�*�#���&��

�-�������"

!-"�#���&��

�<��

� �

��J���Q�JX

��

�<� �J<Q�X

<�> |`

|����J� J

���� �

[�\

* �-

�<Q�X

<�> � �

�#��JX#���

!"��#���&��

���-����-

��! �#*-�&�

! ��#����! #���

�<��

Page 203: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

-���

���

��)�

�)��

��-

���

!��%

���

���

����

���

�,��

���

���

����

���

�,��

�+�

��7

8��

����

��

���

�+8

���

����

� �

����

���

���

���

�+�

����

����

�&�

��

�<\� �J� J

���� �

[�\

* ��

���J���

!���#���&��

����������

!"��#���&��

�<��

� |

� �<�=

�J�

�=�J�<��

���

�J>��

�<� �

�<\� �J� J

���� �

[�\

* �*

�<Q�X

<�> � �

�#��JX#���

!-��#���&��

���������*

��!�"#���&�-

!�**#����! ��#���

�<��

�<��=

���\�

JQ �=�����-�=

������

|����J� J

���� �

[�\

����

�<Q�X

<�> � �

�#��JX#���

!-�*#���&��

���� ����"

�*!��# &

!�-*#���&��

�"��������

�<��

�JJ�<��<

���

�� �

[�\

�*-�

�<Q�X

<�> ���

�#��JX#���

!�-*#���&��

����������

"! �#***&*�

!�**#����!�-*#���

���

J<`�[�>J

����

`���<��

�JJ�<��<

���

�� �

[�\

����

{<�>

!���#���&��

�"�������

�JJ�<��<

���

�� �

[�\

���"

{<�> �>��[� >J<� \# � �

#�

�JX#���

!���#���&��

���������

��J�\`�

���� �

[�\

����

{<�> �>��[� >J<� \�

� �

#�

�JX#���

! �*#���&��

�-��������

�JJ�<��<

���

�� �

[�\

����

{<�> �>��[� >J<� \� �

�#�

�JX#���

!�-"#���&��

�<��

���J ��

J� J

��<

<�J��

������X<�

> �>��

[� >J<� \� �

�#

��JX#���

!�""#���&��

�"�������

����<JJ�J� J

��<

<�J��

������X<�

> ��>J<� \� �

�#�

�JX#���

!��*#���&��

���������

��=

<�\�� >

��<

<�J��

��*����>J<� \� � �

#��JX#�

��X

<�>

!�-�#���&��

*��������

�\��� ��|���

��<

<�J��

- ����{<�

> �>��

[� >J<� \� �

�#

��JX#���

!���#���&��

�*�������

� Q

=��J� J

��<

<�J��

��"���{<�

> �>��

[� >J<� \� �

�#

��JX#���

!� *#���&��

���������

�X��� \�J� J

��<

<�J��

��"���{<�

> �>��

[� >J<� \� �

�#

��JX#���

!� �#���&��

��������

�<�=��J� J

��<

<�J��

������{<�

> �>��

[� >J<� \� �

�#

��JX#���

!�-�#���&��

�*�������

��� \�J� J

��<

<�J��

������{<�

> �>��

[� >J<� \���

�#

��JX# ��

!���#���&��

���������

�<Q ����[�J� J

��<

<�J��

����

����Q ����[X<

�> ��

>J<� \

!���#���&��

���������

�>�J�J� J

��<

<�J��

����

���J���

!��*#���&��

-��������

���[�J� J

��<

<�J��

���"

����Q ����[X<

�>

!���#���&��

����������

���[�J� J

��<

<�J��

����

����Q ����[X<

�>

!�"�#���&��

��� �����

�����<�

��<

<�J��

����

���|Q ����[X<

�> �>��[�

>J<� \

!� �#���&��

����������

`�J<=<���

��<

<�J��

���*

���J���

!�"�#���&��

����������

�<Q ����[�J� J

��<

<�J��

����

�J<� \�

��J����J��� �

�<<=

#��JX#���

!��*#���&��

�*��"�����

��!�*#� &��

!�""#���&��

�<��� �<� �<=�� J �

����

��\�J� J

��<

<�J��

����

���J���

!��*#���&��

��������"

�<�J�=

��J� J

��<

<�J��

���-

�<Q�X

<�> ��� �

��<<

=#��

��

��<<

=!*-�#���&��

����������

��!*-#���&��

! ��#���&��

�<��� ����� Q

��Q���J� J

��<

<�J��

�-��

|``��

�<� ��>J<� \�

��J����J

!� �#���&��

��������"

��!�-#���&��

!*-�#���&��

�<��� |`

��

�<� �#�<J����J#>

����[

� � �<�=

�J

|���J� J

��<

<�J��

��"�

��<<

=�<Q

�X<�

> !���#���&��

�"��������

��!��#���&��

!�-"#���&��

�<��� ����� Q

���Q

\���

��<

<�J��

���

�<Q�X

<�> � �

�#��JX#���

!-*�#���&��

-�� �����

��!-*#���&��

���J��

���<�

��<�

�J\<Q

� �>X��

Page 204: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

-���

���

��)�

�)��

��-

���

!��%

���

���

����

���

�,��

���

���

����

���

�,��

�+�

��7

8��

����

��

���

�+8

���

����

� �

����

���

���

���

�+�

����

����

�&�

��

����<JJ�J� J#

��<

<�J��

����

���J����J�"�����=

��

����J

!-��#���&��

�������"

��!�-#*��&��

! ��#����! ��#���

����J

��\�J� J

��<

<�J��

�� �

�<Q�X

<�> ���

�#��JX#���

!��*#���&��

�-��������

�*! �#���&��

!���#����!��*#����

��Q���J� J

��<

<�J��

���*

���J�����J�*>J<� \������

��[

[�<�

����<<

�>�

�� ��<� �

�����[��

��<<

=#��JX#���

!�#�"�#���&��

���������*

� !�*#�- &��

��*������*���

�<��� ����J���<>J�\

�<��

��

�>�

<�

�� �J<�{���>

����

�� ���

���J����J

!�#���#���&��

���������

��!-�#*-�&�

!� *#���&��

�<��

� ����� Q

�� J|

���

����

����[

���"

�<Q�X

<�> ��<

==��

�J\��J� �

���

�JX����

! #���#���&��

��������-

**!*�#-*�& �

� JQ

�! �*#����

! ��#���

�J ��������\

���"

�� >X

� �

�� > �J<!���#����

! ��#���

����

� JX`� ��

� ����

����[

�*����<Q�X

<�> ��<

==��

�J\��J� �

���

�JX����

!�#���#���&��

���������

� *

!��#���&�"

� JQ

�! ��#����

! *�#���

�J ���"��

��\

����

�<��

�� J|

���

����

����[

� ����<Q�X

<�> ��<

==��

�J\��J� �

���

�JX����

!�#���#���&��

���������"

" !*�#--�&��

! ��#���&��

�J ���"��

��\

����

��<��Q\�J� J

����

����[

����

���[� �J<� \{<

�> �*

� �

�<<=

#��JX#���

! -�#���&��

��-�����

`� ���� >

����

����[

���

{<�> ��

>J<� \� �

�#��JX#

���

!�-*#���&��

����� �J

����

����[

���-

{<�>

!��*#���&��

�-��������

���[>�<���J

����

����[

����

{<�>

!���#���&��

����������

�<���>�<�

����

����[

����

{<�>

!�-*#���&��

�-��������

�Q�J<�

*�*�

��J���

!��*#���&��

���

��<�

J��J

�Q�J<�

����

��J���

!���#���&��

���

��<�

J��J

_\=�� ��

�Q�J<�

��-{<

�>

!��-#*��&��

�-��������

_\=�� ��

�Q�J<�

��-�>J<� \{<�

> � �

�#��JX#�

��

! �*#���&��

���� ����

{ �=

��J

�Q�J<�

��-{<

�>

! **#���&��

����������

�����>�

��Q�J<�

���{<

�>

!��*#���&��

���������

�����>�

��Q�J<�

��-{<

�> �<Q> J� � �

#��JX#

��

!���#���&��

����������

��JJ��J� J

�Q�J<�

� ��

��J���

!��*#���&��

�<��

�����>�

��Q�J<�

� *{<

�> � �

�#��JX#���

! ��#���&��

����������

�����>�

<�

�Q�J<�

� *{<

�>

! ��#���&��

����������

��J�X

���J� J

�Q�J<�

�"�{<

�> �

� �

#��JX#���

!�"-#���&��

��������

��J�X

�`�

�Q�J<�

-�-{<

�>

!���#���&��

����������

�Q�J<�

�<�� J�

<�

�Q�J<�

��"{<

�>

!���#���&��

���������

�Q�J<�

��*�

��J���

!���#���&��

���

��<�

J��J

�<����

�J

�Q�J<�

��-<���>J<� \X<�

> � �

�#�

�JX# ��

! ��#���&��

����"����

�\� >�J� J

�Q�J<�

�*�����<Q> JX

<�> � �

�#��JX#

���

!�--#���&��

����������

�\� >�J� J

�Q�J<�

�*��<Q> JX

<�> ���

�#��JX#�

��

! **#���&��

�-�������

��J �`�

�Q�J<�

����

�� �| � �<�

= �

J�?����

� �

!���#���&��

���������

*!"�#���&��

����� Q

��<

>� >X

�>J<�\

�Q�J<�

����

�� �| � �<�

= �

J��X<�

> ��

J���� �

! ��#���&��

��������

�!-*#���&��

! ��#����! ��#���

=��>� >�

��"�

����

Page 205: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

-���

���

��)�

�)��

��-

���

!��%

���

���

����

���

�,��

���

���

����

���

�,��

�+�

��7

8��

����

��

���

�+8

���

����

� �

����

���

���

���

�+�

����

����

�&�

��

��\�<�

�Q�J<�

����

���{<�

> ��>J<� \� �

�#�

�JX#���

! �*#���&��

"�� ����

��\�<�

�Q�J<�

����

��������X<

�> �>��[� >J<� \�

� �#��JX#���

! *#���&��

��������

��J �`�

�Q�J<�

����

���[� >J<� \<���<JJ[ ���

�#

��JX#���

!��*#���&��

�-��������

�� �

� ��

J� J

�Q�J<�

����

����<Q>

JJ�=

� �X

<�> � �

�#

��JX#���

!�-�#���&��

�*��������

�����`� ��

�Q�J<�

����

����<Q>

J! ��#���&��

�"��������

��J�X

�`�

�Q�J<�

����

�<Q�X

<�> �<=

�� �� �

�#�

�JX#���

!���#���&��

����������

"!��#���&�-

��J�X

�`�

�Q�J<�

���"

����J �<Q�X

<�> >��<J

��������\><

��\ J

!���#���&��

��� �����

"!��#***&*�

�<J><

��\ J

��[XJ��[� |���

�Q�J<�

�� �

�>J<� \� Q

J<Q�X

<�>

� � �<�=

�J

!*"�#���&��

�-��������

��!* #� �& �

!�-*#���

�JJ�<��<

��Q�J<�

��

�<Q�X

<�> ��� � �

#��JX#�

��

!���#���&��

���������

��!*�#���&��

!�"*#����

�<��

� �\ �><

��

�<��=��� ��

���[<{���

�"�

><�

��\� Q

X<�

> �>��

[�

>J<� \��

� �

#��JX#���

! "�#���&��

�*�������

�<> �J� J

��[<{���

������{<�

> �>��

[� >J<� \���

�#

��JX#���

! *�#���&��

�<��

���>J<�

���J

��[<{���

�"*�

><�

��\� Q

X<�

> �>��

[�

>J<� \��

� �

#��JX#���

!���#���&��

��������

��[<{���

*�����{<�

> �>��

[� >J<� \� �

�#

��JX# ��

!�-"#���&��

�<��

���>J<�

���J

��[<{���

����

><�

��\� Q

X<�

> �>��

[�

>J<� \��

� �

#��JX#���

!�*�#���&��

��������

���> ���<�� >J

��[<{���

���|�

�� �|Q ����[�

� �

#��JX#

���

���������

������-�� �|`

���> ��>�

<�� >J

��[<{���

����

��J���

!� �#���&��

�<��

���> ��>�

���[<{���

���|Q

����[{<

�>

!���#���&��

-�������

���> ����� >J�

��[<{���

��"|Q

����[{<

�>

! "#���&��

����*�����

�<�

J���� ��� >J= �

J>�J\�J�

��=<>�J

��[<{���

��*|Q

����[{<

�>

!*��#���&��

���������

����

\��[<{���

� |Q

����[{<

�>

!� *#���&��

���������

� �J���J

��[<{���

��-|Q

����[{<

�>

!���#���&��

�������

��>J�J

��[<{���

�� |Q

����[{<

�>

!���#���&��

�*�������

_<��<�

�� >

��[<{���

"���

��J���

!��"#���&��

����*�����

�X�=��J� J

��[<{���

����

���J���

!�� #���&��

����*�����

����J�

�<>

��[<{���

�� �

{<�>

!*-*#���&��

���������

�<�� �>�J ��<�J =

�<��\�Q ����[X<

�> �

<��[������

���� !��*#���><

�����J

����

�<�

�J�J� J

��[<{���

���*

{<�>

! ��#���&��

�"�� �����

����Q ����[X<

�> ��<�

J��[�<

� �J�J� J

�=��[J<�

�<�

��[<{���

"��*

���J���

!�#���#���&��

�X�����>X ��<�

>J���J�<�>�J\�J�

`���`�

��[<{���

������

��J���

!�# ��#���&��

��-����-

�_���<Z �J>�

J\�J�

Page 206: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

-���

���

��)�

�)��

��-

���

!��%

���

���

����

���

�,��

���

���

����

���

�,��

�+�

��7

8��

����

��

���

�+8

���

����

� �

����

���

���

���

�+�

����

����

�&�

��

`���`�

��[<{���

��� ��

��J���

!�#���#���&��

��� ����-

`�>�����X>� >�[�

�JX `�

��

>��<�

��J<

���=Q�� ��<J=

�J>>

����[�<

�!��*#���J�

��

�&�X > � �� X<

��

��<�

��J

��� �<J<��<

�\�<��<

�J &

�=

��[J<�

�<�

��[<{���

*�����

��J���

!�#���#���&��

�X�����>X ��<�

>J���J�<�>�J\�J�

���>XQ

<<��<

��J

��[<{���

*�����

��J���

!�#"��#���&��

���������

��!���#�"�& �

! *�#����! ��#���

�J ���"����\

����

| �=

��|

� �<�=

�J>

��[<{��������>J

��[<{���

�--"��

�<Q�X

<�> ���

�#��JX�<<

=#

���

!��#*��#���&��

�"��������

��!�-"#��-&*�

! ��#����! ��#���

���"�����

�<J ��� ��<�

��J<

�JX =�� J��

�<<

�\�<��J&�� �<

=���J�\

J<Q�X

<�>

��<�

��J

>JX

��<> >J��<��

�JJ\�

&����Q<<

�������J

��[<{���

|��� �|Q ����[

���������

������-��*�|`

���>XQ

<<��<

��J

��[<{���

���J��

� |Q ����[�����J>

�*��������

������*����|`

��[�<

�`�

��

��[J

*��

���>��[� >J<� \X<�

> <�

�<�� �>�J � �

�#��JX#����

=�[=J�<�<�

�<�J��

�J\! �*#���&��

�<��

�<> �X

�J� J

��[J

��-|Q

����[{<

�> �� �

� �<�

= �

J�<

J �J��

!�"*#���&��

���

��<�

J��J

|���

��J� J

��[J

��-���[� >J<� \<��X<=

��

� �

#�

�JX#���

! ��#���&��

���������

�<��J� J

��[J

��-���[� �<J� \�<

��X<�

Q� �

�#

��JX#���

!� *#���&��

��������

|���� ���<

���[J

��-{<

�>

!���#���&��

*��"�����

���J<��`� ��

��[J

����

��J��<�������*>?=

!���#���&��

�<��

|���

��J� J

��[J

�����=��<�

J[ ��Q

����[X<

�>

Q�JX

�<J �

J��J<�

� �<�

! ""#���&��

���

����

�\� >�J� J

��[J

������J�

�<����

� �<�=

�J

�<J �J��

!���#���&��

��������

��=

<� �J� J

��[J

����>J<� \=

��J���

�J��

� � �

#�

�JX#������

� ���<�������

!���#���&��

����������

�!�#���&�

�"�������*���

���������|`

����

����J����J�

���

�J>#�>J<� \>

� �

��J� J

��[J

���������[� �J<� \� �

�#��JX#

���

! ��#���&��

����"�����

�<\� �J� J

��[J

���{<

�> �

� �

#��JX#���

!�*�#���&��

�<��

�<\� �J� J

��[J

���������[� �J<� \���

�#��JX#

���

! �*#���&��

���������

� �<�

>�� ���J� J

��[J

�-��>J<� \��

Q=

��J����

�J��

� �#��JX#���

!* �#���&��

����*�����

��!��#���&�-

! �"����!**����

�J �����

��\

���

�����

Q��J= �

J�<=

�� �

�XJX=�J� J

��[J

����

�>J<� \X<�

> � �

�#��JX#�

��

!��-#*��&��

����*�����

�XJX=�J� J

��[J

����

���[� >J<� \�<��

�X<�

> �

� �#��JX#���

!��*#���&��

����"�����

|�>� ���J� J

��[J

����

|`��

�<� ���<Q

��> =

��J�

>J<� \�

>�� �

J����>J<� \>�

�*=��> = �

J�����[�

!�*�#���&��

�<��

��!--#�-�&-

*� �

��<<

=#��JX#���#���

� ��<<

=#��JX#��������>�

� >

Page 207: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

-���

���

��)�

�)��

��-

���

!��%

���

���

����

���

�,��

���

���

����

���

�,��

�+�

��7

8��

����

��

���

�+8

���

����

� �

����

���

���

���

�+�

����

����

�&�

��

������<�X`� ��

��[J

��

�<�� ���<��� � �<�

= �

J<��

����� �

J�\*��J>� �=

��

�-=

�<���<�

J[ >�QJ ���<�

J�

�<�

�=�� �

�> �

>�� �

J��

!�#"*�#���&��

�<��

�� ��� Q>

� �

��J� J

��[J

���

�>J<� \X<�

> �<

���

!*�"#���&��

�<��

�<Q �

�J� J

��[J

���

���J���

!�"*#���&��

�<��

�|`���<� �

�<�JX�>>�J

�� �<Q

�>

�<J

�<�><���J�<�

`��

�J�J� J

��[J

��-�

�>J<� \=

��J����

�J#�> =

�J��

���

!�"*#���&��

����"�����

�-!��#���& *

��<=

! ��#����<�

��<<

=�

���

��<�

>J���J�<���

#���

� �

�<<=

��J=

�J>��<=�� J `�

[�>J���

�\� >�J� J

��[J

���

���X<�

> ��

>J<� \� �

�#�

�JX#���

!*�"#���&��

���

��<�

J��J

�� ��� �J� J

��[J

� ��

|`�<

������J>��

��J���

!�*�#���&��

���������

��!��#���&*-

�<Q �

�J� J

��[J

�* �

|`�<

�����

�J>��<Q��>

>�� �

J��� >J<� \>������[

<�[�<��

�� � ��

!�*�#���&��

�<��

��!--#�-�&-

�X� ��>�

J� J

� ������

-�"�

��J���

!�� #���&��

���������

� � �

�JX�J� J

� ������

��"�

��J���

!*-*#���&��

�<��

��=��<�

J[ �>��J�� �<��

J<Q�X

<�> >#

X�[X��> � � �<�

= �

J�<�����

�J>��J<�

>J<� \>

����[ ��

��

������

��"���[� >J<� \� �

�#��JX#�

��

!���#���&��

����������

`>X=

<� ��

� ������

��"���[� >J<� \X<�

> � �

�#�

�JX#���

! � #���&��

���� ����

����[� ��<�

� ������

����

��J���

!�""#���&��

�<��

���� \�J� J

� ������

�������>J<� \X<�

> ���

�#�

�JX#���

!��*#���&��

�*��-�����

���

Q<<

��J

� ������

���{<

�>

! �#*��&��

����-�����

�JJ �J� J

� ������

�����[ <�������X<

= <�

�<��

��<J��� �

#��J# ��

!�"*#���&��

�<��

�<X�

�J� J

� ������

�� �

��J���

!*��#���&��

��� �����

�� ��J� J

� ������

�� �<Q��>

`��J= �

J��� �

��

�JX����

! -*#���&��

�<�JQ<<

��J� J

� ������

����

���J����

�J�

>J<� \���

�#�

�JX#���

!�**#���&��

���������-

��! -#"��&�-

! ��#���&��

����������

�<��

�<�JQ<<

��J� J

� ������

����

���J���

!���#���&��

�<��

���J��J<� \�*��

�J�

������

���J=

�J> ���>�� >

� ������

��"�

���J���Q�JX

|`�<��

-��

�J>! ��#���&��

��������"

�-!��#� *&�"

�<X�

�J� J

� ������

����

���J���

�J�-

>J<� \���

�#�

�JX#���

!"��#���&��

�"�������-

��!��#���&��

! "�����!� *���

�<��� JQ �

���"�����

�<X�

�J� J

� ������

��**

���J���

!�#���#���&��

�<��

|`��

�<� ��<�

*>J<� \���J�<=

�� ��

�"��J= �

J>��

*>X

<�>&

�<X�

�J� J

� ������

�* �

*>J<� \>������J>���

�#�

�JX#�[�[

�<��

� ��� \�J� J

� ������

�"��

���J���

�J�Q

����[��

� �

#�

�JX#���

!�#�*�#���&��

��������-

�!��#���&�-

!���#����!�� #���

�<��� JQ �

���������

Page 208: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

-���

���

��)�

�)��

��-

���

!��%

���

���

����

���

�,��

���

���

����

���

�,��

�+�

��7

8��

����

��

���

�+8

���

����

� �

����

���

���

���

�+�

����

����

�&�

��

��JJ<�

�J� J

� ������

���

���J���

�J�

� �

#��JX#���

!�#-*�#���&��

���� ����"

��!-"#���&�-

�[�<�

��!*��#���

�!���#���

��������

���� ���

� ������

���

{�[X��>

� �

�#��JX#���

�*�������

!*��#���&��

�J ���<�

J

���� ���

� ������

���*

JQ<{�[X��>

���>J<� \���

�#

��JX#���

!��*#���&��

��������

���� ���

� ������

���*

��

�#��JX#���

!���#���&��

�<��

���� ���

� ������

��>J<� \���

�#��JX#���

!��*#���&��

�"�������

�J�����J� J

�J�JX���

��-����>J<� \X<�

> � �

�#�

�JX#���

! ��#���&��

�*��������

� J ��

J� J

�J�JX���

��-����>J<� \X<�

> � �

�#�

�JX# ��

! �*#���&��

�"�� ����

�J�� \�J� J

�J�JX���

��*����>J<� \X<�

> � �

�#�

�JX#���

!��*#���&��

�-�������

�J�����J� J

�J�JX���

� �����>J<� \X<�

> ���

�#�

�JX#���

!�"�#���&��

���� ����

��X=>�

J�J�JX���

�������>J<� \X<�

> � �

�#�

�JX#���

! �"#���&��

���������

��[ �� Q�J� J

�J�JX���

���{<

�> ��

>J<� \ � �

#��JX#�

��

! ��#���&��

����-�����

�<<�����J� J

�J�JX���

��-{<

�>

! �#���&��

�*��"�����

��\���

�J�JX���

" <��>��

[� >J<� \� �

�#��JX#

��

! #���&��

� �� �����

��<Q���[�J

�J�JX���

����

�>J<� \<��X<�

> � �

�#�

�JX#���

! ��#���&��

���������

�� �J� J

�J�JX���

����

{<�>

! �#���&��

��������

� ��>�<�� J�

<�

�J�JX���

����

�� ��<��?�

��� �#� Q

! *�#���&��

�-��������

"! �#���&�"

!�""#���&��

� �����>X

��J=

�J>

�J�JX���

=<>J�\

�<=

���>

�<�>��[� ���J

�Q ����[>&��=

�J ��J����� <�

���

����X> ���� �<�J\�<�<[� >&

�=><��� ��

�J�JX���

���-�

!�# ��#���&��

���������

|<����J� J

�<<

�\�<��J

������{<�

> ���

�#��JX#���

!��*#���&��

���������

��� �

���J� J

�<<

�\�<��J

��*���X<�

> � �

�#��JX#���

!�""#*��&��

� �� ����

��[��>�J� J

�<<

�\�<��J

��*���{<�

> ���

�#��JX#���

!��*#���&��

�-�� ����

���[�J� J

�<<

�\�<��J

��*���{<�

> � �

�#��JX#���

!� �#���&��

��������

_ <�[���J� J

�<<

�\�<��J

�������

� ��

� �

#��JX#���

�!�&��

!�*������!���#���

���"�����

_ <�[���J� J

�<<

�\�<��J

"���<Q��> ��J= �

J�

!���#���&��

-��*����

-!��#���&��

! ��#�-*�!*"�#���

���*�����

��=

�� �J� J

�<<

�\�<��J

����

{<�>

!�-�#���&��

�-�� �����

_ <�[���� J

�<<

�\�<��J

����

{<�>

!��*#���&��

�-��������

�J �J� J

�<<

�\�<��J

����

{<�>

!���#���&��

����������

`��� �

�J� J

�<<

�\�<��J

����

=��J���

�J��

>J<� \����

� ��<<

=#��JX#���

!���#���

*��-����

�|�����

!���#����

���JX ���

��� \`� ��

�<<

�\�<��J

�-��

���J�����J� � �

#��JX#���

�|�����

!�**#���&��

�\ �><

���QJ ���<�

J

Page 209: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

-���

���

��)�

�)��

��-

���

!��%

���

���

����

���

�,��

���

���

����

���

�,��

�+�

��7

8��

����

��

���

�+8

���

����

� �

����

���

���

���

�+�

����

����

�&�

��

_ <�[���J� J

�<<

�\�<��J

���

�<Q�X

<�> ��<��

�J� �

�#

�JX#���

!�*�#���&��

����*����-

��!�*#���&��

!���#����!* *#���

���������

_ <�[���J� J

�<<

�\�<��J

���*

�<Q���>

��J= �

J>���

�#�

�JX#���

!�*�#���&��

-�������-

��!�-#���&��

! �*#����!��*#���

���������

��=

�� �J� J

�<<

�\�<��J

����

�<Q�X

<�> ���

�#��JX#���

�!�&��

! *�#����! ��#���

=��J<

��

���"

Page 210: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Section 5 - Scenario Design Provisions

Page 211: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Notes

Assumption

Applicab

le�Design�Provisions

T�A0

2.120%ofsite

,5m

mindim

Applicab

le�Site

�Provision

sPrivate�Ope

n�Sp

ace

Commun

al�Ope

n�Sp

ace

Setbacks

Table�1.4

Site�Cover

Z�SO

�Tab

le6.2.6.4.4

Sitin

g�an

d�De

sign

T�A0

1.1Accessedoffliving

space;

Grou

ndlevelPOSlocated

behind

mainbu

ildingline

5mm

indim

Includ

es1area,50%

of

requ

iremen

t,im

indim

10m,rationot>2:1

Additio

naltoDe

ep

Plantin

grequ

iremen

ts

Build

ing�He

ight�

Level�o

f�Assessmen

tPa

rking�Ra

te

Car�P

arking/G

arages

Land

scap

ing

Drivew

ays

Scen

�ario

Lot�S

ize�

(m²)

Fron

�tage

�Stree

t�/�Lot�

Type

Precinct�

Locatio

nTypo

logy

Minim

um�Site

�Area�(m

²)Minim

um�

Fron

tage

Min.�A

rea

Min.�

Dimen

sion

Min.�A

rea

Min.�D

im�

ension

Metres

Storeys

to�Lan

eway

�to�Pub

lic�

Ope

n�Sp

ace

to�Front�Setba

ckto�Side/Re

arBu

ilt�to

�Bou

ndary

BTB�

cond

ition

s1

Dual

Occup

ancy

(Loft)

Cabo

olture

NextG

en.

Subu

rban

Lane

way

7.5m

3001/dw

elling

2/dw

elling

Code

Assessable

GF25

Else1B8m

²GF

5m

Else1B2.5m

n/a

n/a

PO30

�Accessvialane

way

only

T�A0

8.1�M

inim

um50%

of

fron

tageisplanted

fora

min.w

idthof2

m.

T�A0

8.2�5

%ofthe

site

T�A0

5.1��Singlestorey

3.0m

wide;

�Dou

blestorey:6.0m

andrecessed

1.0m

Theloftis:

T�A0

32.2�Notlocatedinfron

tofthe

prim

arydw

elling;ann

exed

to(adjoining,

belowora

bove)

9m3�H

eight<

8.5m

�70%

�Height>

8.5m

0.5�1m

to

OMP

�2�4mto

wall,

�1mto

OMP

�3�5mto

Wall,

�2mto

OMP

�5.4mto

covered

vehiclespace

�<4.5m

�1.5m

to

OMP

�4.5mto

7.5m�2m

toOMP

<7.5mwide,BTB

on

bothside

smandatory

form

axlength70%

7.5m

�12.5m

wide,BTB

onlyto

he

ight3.5m

�abo

vegroun

ddw

ellingshaveredu

cedminim

um

privateop

ensp

acerequ

iremen

ts.

areawith

deepplaning

zone

swith

am

in.w

idthof

4m.

T�AO

31.1�Lane

ways�Bin

area1mx2m

T�AO

31.3�Lane

ways�

land

scaped

square

adjoininglane

way

500m

m

belowfron

twallor

balcon

yofupp

erlevel.

�Located

with

in20m

ofthe

prim

ary

dwelling

T�A0

32.3�O

nlywith

ina2storey

building

T�A0

32.4��Iden

tifiablefron

tdoo

rand

un

dercoverentry

T�A0

32.6�M

inim

umpriv

ateop

ensp

ace

area

adjoinslane

50%

�>7.5m

�2m

to

OMP,plus0

.5mfo

revery3m

inheight

above7.5m

�Rear:4m

onone

side

mandatory

form

axim

umlength

60%(bo

thside

sop

tional)

12.5m�18m

widelot,

singleBT

Bmaybe

provided

tom

axlength

50%/1

5mifadjoining

adjoininglane

way500

mm

x500m

mareaadjoinslane

�Atleastone

dwelling(preferably

prim

arydu

)facesth

eno

n�lane

way

fron

tage.

T�AO

25.1�6m

3storage/du

50%/15mifadjoining

lot<

18m

2Du

al

Occup

ancy

(Loft)

Woo

dyPoint

NextG

en.

Subu

rban

Lane

way

10m

4001/dw

elling

2/dw

elling

Code

Assessable

GF25

Else1B8m

²GF

5m

Else1B2.5m

n/a

n/a

PO30

�Accessvialane

way

only

T�A0

8.1�M

inim

um50%

of

fron

tageisplanted

fora

min.w

idthof2

m.

T�A0

5.1��Singlestorey

3.0m

wide;

�Dou

blestore y:6.0m

Theloftis:

T�A0

32.2�Notlocatedinfron

tofthe

prim

arydw

elling;ann

exed

to(adjoining,

9m3�H

eight<

8.5m

�60%

�Height>

8.5m

0.5�1m

to

OMP

�2�4mto

wall,

�1mto

OMP

�3�5mto

Wall,

�2mto

OMP

�5.4mto

covered

�<4.5m

�1.5m

to

OMP

�4.5mto

7.5m�2m

<7.5mwide,BTB

on

bothside

smandatory

form

axlen gth70%

onlyto

he

ight3.5m

�abo

vegroun

ddw

ellingshaveredu

cedminim

um

privateop

ensp

acerequ

iremen

ts.

()

T�A0

8.2�5

%ofthe

site

areawith

deepplaning

zone

swith

am

in.w

idthof

4m.

T�AO

31.1�Lane

ways�Bin

area1mx2m

T�AO

31.3�Lane

ways�

ld

d

yandrecessed

1.0m

belowfron

twallor

balcon

yofupp

erlevel.

py

g;(

jg,

belowora

bove)

�Located

with

in20m

ofthe

prim

ary

dwelling

T�A0

32.3�O

nlywith

ina2storey

building

T�A0

32.4��Iden

tifiablefron

tdoo

rand

un

dercoverentry

TA0

326

Mii

i

g50

%vehiclespace

toOMP

�>7.5m

�2m

to

OMP,plus0

.5mfo

revery3m

inheight

above7.5m

�Rear:4m

g7.5m

�12.5m

wide,BTB

on

one

side

mandatory

form

axim

umlength

60%(bo

thside

sop

tional)

12.5m�18m

widelot,

singleBT

Bmaybe

idd

lh

land

scaped

square

adjoininglane

way500

mm

x500m

m

T�A0

32.6�M

inim

umpriv

ateop

ensp

ace

areaadjoinslane

�Atleastone

dwelling(preferably

prim

arydu

)facesth

eno

n�lane

way

fron

tage.

T�AO

25.1�6m

3storage/du

provided

tom

axlength

50%/15mifadjoining

lot<

18m

3Du

al

Occup

ancy

Cabo

olture

NextG

en.

Subu

rban

18m

1/dw

elling

2/dw

elling

Code

Assessable

GF25

Else

1B8m

²GF

5m

Else

1B2.5m

n/a

n/a

T�AO

7.1�M

ax.crossover

width

of4m

or5m

(shared),

T�A0

8.1�M

inim

um50%

of

fron

tage

isplantedfora

T�A0

5.1�4

0%ofstreet

fron

tage;o

r6.0m

Theloftis:

TA0

32.2�N

otlocatedinfron

tofthe

9m3�H

eight<

8.5m

�60%

n/a

n/a

�3�5mto

Wall,

� 2m

toOMP

�<4.5m

�1.5m

to

OMP

<7.5mwide,BTB

on

both

sides

mandatory

onlyto

he

ight

3.5m

�abo

vegroun

ddw

ellingshaveredu

cedminim

um

privateop

enspacerequ

iremen

ts.

Occup

ancy

(Loft)

Subu

rban

2/dw

elling

Else1B8m

Else1B2.5m

widthof4

mor5

m(shared),

�Max.one

driv

ewayper

streetfron

tage;o

rseparatio

nbe

tween

drivew

aysisa

minim

umof

6m.

fron

tageisplanted

fora

min.w

idthof2

m.

T�A0

8.2�5

%ofthe

site

areawith

deepplaning

zone

swith

am

in.w

idthof

4m.

fron

tage;o

r6.0m

(whicheverisgreater);

�Noop

eninggreater

than6mwith

outm

in.

1msp

acebe

tween.

T�A0

32.2

Notlocatedinfron

tofthe

prim

arydw

elling;ann

exed

to(adjoining,

belowora

bove)

�Located

with

in20m

ofthe

prim

ary

dwelling

T�A0

32.3�O

nlywith

ina2storey

building

T�A0

32.4��Iden

tifiablefron

tdoo

rand

60%

�Height>

8.5m

�50%

2mto

OMP

�5.4mto

covered

vehiclespace

OMP

�4.5mto

7.5m�2m

toOMP

�>7.5m

�2m

to

OMP,plus0

.5mfo

revery3m

inheight

above7.5m

�Rear:4m

bothside

smandatory

form

axlength70%

7.5m

�12.5m

wide,BTB

on

one

side

mandatory

form

axim

umlength

60%(bo

thside

sop

tional)

12.5m�18m

widelot,

height3.5m

privateop

ensp

acerequ

iremen

ts.

unde

rcoverentry

T�AO

25.1�6m

3storage/du

singleBT

Bmaybe

provided

tom

axlength

50%/15mifadjoining

lot<

18m

Page 212: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Notes

Assumption

Applicab

le�Design�Provisions

T�A0

2.120%ofsite

,5m

mindim

Applicab

le�Site

�Provision

sPrivate�Ope

n�Sp

ace

Commun

al�Ope

n�Sp

ace

Setbacks

Table�1.4

Site�Cover

Z�SO

�Tab

le6.2.6.4.4

Sitin

g�an

d�De

sign

T�A0

1.1Accessedoffliving

space;

Grou

ndlevelPOSlocated

behind

mainbu

ildingline

5mm

indim

Includ

es1area,50%

of

requ

iremen

t,im

indim

10m,rationot>2:1

Additio

naltoDe

ep

Plantin

grequ

iremen

ts

Build

ing�He

ight�

Level�o

f�Assessmen

tPa

rking�Ra

te

Car�P

arking/G

arages

Land

scap

ing

Drivew

ays

Scen

�ario

Lot�S

ize�

(m²)

Fron

�tage

�Stree

t�/�Lot�

Type

Precinct�

Locatio

nTypo

logy

Minim

um�Site

�Area�(m

²)Minim

um�

Fron

tage

Min.�A

rea

Min.�

Dimen

sion

Min.�A

rea

Min.�D

im�

ension

Metres

Storeys

to�Lan

eway

�to�Pub

lic�

Ope

n�Sp

ace

to�Front�Setba

ckto�Side/Re

arBu

ilt�to

�Bou

ndary

BTB�

cond

ition

s

4Dw

elling

House(Row

Ho

using)

MangoHill

NextG

en.

Subu

rban

Lane

way

7.5m

2/dw

elling

SelfAssessable

GF25

GF5m

n/a

n/a

PO30

�Accessvialane

way

only

T�A0

8.1�M

inim

um50%

of

fron

tageisplanted

fora

min.w

idthof2

m.

T�A0

8.2�5

%ofthe

site

T�A0

5.1��Singlestorey

3.0m

wide;

�Dou

blestorey:6.0m

andrecessed

1.0m

T�AO

1.1Groun

dLevelPriv

ateOpe

nSpaceislocatedbe

hind

themain

buildingline,notwith

instreetse

tbacks.

T�AO

25.1�6

m3storage/du

9m3He

ight<8.5m

�70%

Height>8.5m

�50%

0.5m

�1.0

OMP

n/a

�3�5mto

Wall,

�2mto

OMP

�<4.5m

�1.5m

to

OMP

�4.5mto

7.5m�2m

toOMP

<7.5mwide,BTB

on

bothside

smandatory

form

axlength70%

7.5m

�12.5m

wide,BTB

onlyto

he

ight3.5m

Common

shared

wallswith

easem

entsor

builtto

bou

ndarywall.

BuildingEn

velope

planrequ

ired�stand

ard

builtto

bou

ndaryassumed

.areawith

deepplaning

zone

swith

am

in.w

idthof

4m.

T�AO

31.1�Lane

ways�Bin

area1mx2m

T�AO

31.3�Lane

ways�

land

scaped

square

djii

l500

belowfron

twallor

balcon

yofupp

erlevel.

�>7.5m

�2m

to

OMP,plus0

.5mfo

revery3m

inheight

above7.5m

�Rear:4m

onone

side

mandatory

form

axim

umlength

60%(bo

thside

sop

tional)

adjoininglane

way500mm

x500m

m

5Dw

elling

House(Row

Ho

using)

Cabo

olture

NextG

en.

Subu

rban

7.5m

2/dw

elling

SelfAssessable

GF25

GF5m

n/a

n/a

T�A0

8.1�M

inim

um50%

of

fron

tageisplanted

fora

min

width

of2m

T�A0

5.1��Singlestorey

3.0m

wide;

Doub

lestorey:6

0m

T�AO

1.1Grou

ndLevelPriv

ateOpe

nSpaceislocatedbe

hind

themain

buildinglineno

twith

instreet

setbacks

9m3He

ight<8.5m

�70%

Height

>85m

50%

n/a

n/a

�3�5mto

Wall,

�2mto

OMP

54m

tocovered

�<4.5m

�1.5m

to

OMP

45m

to75m

2m

<7.5mwide,BTB

on

bothside

smandatory

form

axlength

70%

onlyto

he

ight3.5m

Common

shared

wallswith

easem

entsor

builtto

bou

ndarywall.

BuildingEn

velope

plan

requ

ired

standard

Housing)

min.w

idthof2

m.

T�A0

8.2�5

%ofthe

site

areawith

deepplaning

zone

swith

am

in.w

idthof

4m.

� Dou

blestorey:6.0m

andrecessed

1.0m

belowfron

twallor

balcon

yofupp

erlevel.

buildingline,notwith

instreetse

tbacks.

T�AO

25.1�6m

3storage/du

Height>8.5m

�50%

�5.4mto

covered

vehiclespace

�4.5mto

7.5m�2m

toOMP

�>7.5m

�2m

to

OMP,plus0

.5mfo

revery3m

inheight

above7.5m

�Rear:4m

form

axlength70%

7.5m

�12.5m

wide,BTB

on

one

side

mandatory

form

axim

umlength

60%(bo

thside

sop

tional)

BuildingEn

velope

planrequ

ired�stand

ard

builtto

bou

ndaryassumed

.

6Dw

elling

Cabo

olture

NextG

en.

10m

2/dw

elling

SelfAssessable

GF25

GF5m

n/a

n/a

T�A0

8.1�M

inim

um50%

ofT�A0

5.1��Singlestorey

T�AO

1.1Grou

ndLevelPriv

ateOpe

n9m

3�H

eight<

8.5m

�n/a

n/a

�3�5mto

Wall,

�<4.5m

�1.5m

to

7.5m

�12.5m

wide,BTB

on

lyto

Co

mmon

shared

wallswith

easem

entsor

House(Row

Ho

using)

Subu

rban

fron

tageisplanted

fora

min.w

idthof2

m.

T�A0

8.2�5

%ofthe

site

areawith

deepplaning

zone

swith

am

in.w

idthof

4m.

3.0m

wide;

�Dou

blestorey:6.0m

andrecessed

1.0m

belowfron

twallor

balcon

yofupp

erlevel.

Spaceislocatedbe

hind

themain

buildingline,notwith

instreetse

tbacks.

T�AO

25.1�6m

3storage/du

60%

�Height>

8.5m

�50%

�2mto

OMP

�5.4mto

covered

vehiclespace

OMP

�4.5mto

7.5m�2m

toOMP

�>7.5m

�2m

to

OMP,plus0

.5mfo

revery3m

inheight

above7.5m

R4

onone

side

mandatory

form

axim

umlength

60%(bo

thside

sop

tional)

height3.5m

builtto

bou

ndarywall.

BuildingEn

velope

planrequ

ired�stand

ard

builtto

bou

ndaryassumed

.

Page 213: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Notes

Assumption

Applicab

le�Design�Provisions

T�A0

2.120%ofsite

,5m

mindim

Applicab

le�Site

�Provision

sPrivate�Ope

n�Sp

ace

Commun

al�Ope

n�Sp

ace

Setbacks

Table�1.4

Site�Cover

Z�SO

�Tab

le6.2.6.4.4

Sitin

g�an

d�De

sign

T�A0

1.1Accessedoffliving

space;

Grou

ndlevelPOSlocated

behind

mainbu

ildingline

5mm

indim

Includ

es1area,50%

of

requ

iremen

t,im

indim

10m,rationot>2:1

Additio

naltoDe

ep

Plantin

grequ

iremen

ts

Build

ing�He

ight�

Level�o

f�Assessmen

tPa

rking�Ra

te

Car�P

arking/G

arages

Land

scap

ing

Drivew

ays

Scen

�ario

Lot�S

ize�

(m²)

Fron

�tage

�Stree

t�/�Lot�

Type

Precinct�

Locatio

nTypo

logy

Minim

um�Site

�Area�(m

²)Minim

um�

Fron

tage

Min.�A

rea

Min.�

Dimen

sion

Min.�A

rea

Min.�D

im�

ension

Metres

Storeys

to�Lan

eway

�to�Pub

lic�

Ope

n�Sp

ace

to�Front�Setba

ckto�Side/Re

arBu

ilt�to

�Bou

ndary

BTB�

cond

ition

s

7Multip

le

Dwelling

(Terrace)�2

Bedroo

m

MangoHill

NextG

en.

Subu

rban

25m

2/un

it&no

visitor

Code

Assessable

22m

GF25

GF5m

n/a

n/a

T�AO

7.1�M

ax.crossover

widthof4

mor5

m(shared),

�Max.one

driv

ewayper

streetfron

tage;o

r

T�A0

8.1�M

inim

um50%

of

fron

tageisplanted

fora

min.w

idthof2

m.

T�A0

8.2�5

%of the

site

T�AO

5.1��The

lesserof

30%ofstreetfrontage;

or10m

widepe

rstreet

fron

tage;and

setback

T�AO

5.3�V

isitorp

arkingprovide

dwith

in

thefron

tsetbackhasaland

scaped

area

with

am

in.W

idthof2

mbetweenthe

carp

arkareaand

streetfron

tage.

9m3�H

eight<

8.5m

�60%

�Height >

8.5m

�50%

n/a

n/a

�3�5mto

Wall,

�2mto

OMP

�<4.5m

�1.5m

to

OMP

�4.5mto

7.5m�2m

toOMP

noprovisio

nsfo

rlots

with

afron

tage>18m

15m

�Cod

eAssessabledue

tonon

�com

pliantstreet

fron

tagewidth.(30

metresforSelf�a

ssessable)

�Landscapingat2

mfo

r50%

based

onno

n�self

assessable.Provision

scanno

tbeachieved

with

Heightbased

onsitebe

ingwith

in400

m2of

railw

aystation.

separatio

nbe

tween

drivew

aysisa

minim

umof

6m.

areawith

deepplaning

zone

swith

am

in.w

idthof

4m.

behind

mainbu

ilding

T�AO

25.1�6m

3storage/du

�>7.5m

�2m

to

OMP,plus0

.5mfo

revery3m

inheight

above7.5m

�Rear:4m

provision

ofd

rivew

aysa

ndped

estrianaccess.

8Multip

le

Dlli

Lawnton

Urban

25m

1/dw

elling

1i/3

Code

Assessable

4�6st�

1000

²1�3st�22m

46t25

GF25m

²GF

5m

n/a

n/a

T�AO

7.1�M

ax.crossover

idth

f45

(h

d)T�A0

8.1�M

inim

um50%

of

ft

il

tdf

T�AO

5.1��The

lesserof

30%

ft

tft

T�AO

5.3�V

isitorp

arkingprovide

dwith

in

thf

ttb

kh

ld

dmin.9m,

17min.

3t

Height<8.5m

�60%

n/a

n/a

�1�3mto

Wall,

0t

OMP

�<4.5m

�1.5m

to

OMP

noprovisio

nsfo

rlots

ithf

t>18

15m

�Cod

eAssessabledue

tonon

�com

pliantstreet

ft

idth

(30

tf

Slf

bl)

Heightbased

onsitebe

ingwith

in400

m2of

iltti

Dwelling

(Terrace)

1vis/3

dwelling

1000m²

4�6st�25m

widthof4

mor5

m(shared),

�Max.one

driv

ewayper

streetfron

tage;o

rseparatio

nbe

tween

drivew

aysisa

minim

umof

6m.

fron

tageisplanted

fora

min.w

idthof2

m.

T�A0

8.2�5

%ofthe

site

areawith

deepplaning

zone

swith

am

in.w

idthof

4m.

30%ofstreetfrontage;

or10m

widepe

rstreet

fron

tage;and

setback

behind

mainbu

ilding

thefron

tsetbackhasaland

scaped

area

with

am

in.W

idthof2

mbetweenthe

carp

arkareaand

streetfron

tage.

T�AO

25.1�6m

3storage/du

max. 17m

3storeys,

max.6

storeys

Height>8.5m

�12m �

50%

Height>12m�40%

�0mto

OMP

OMP

�4.5mto

7.5m�2m

toOMP

�>7.5m

�2m

to

OMP,plus0

.5mfo

revery3m

inheight

above7.5m

�Rear:4m

with

afron

tage>18m

fron

tagewidth.(30m

etresforSelf�a

ssessable)

�Landscapingat2

mfo

r50%

based

onno

n�self

assessable.Provision

scanno

tbeachieved

with

provision

ofd

rivew

aysa

ndped

estrianaccess.

railw

aystation.

1visitorcarpark/d

udo

esnotworkfor

Multip

leDwelling(Terrace).

9Multip

le

Dwelling

(Terrace)�3

Bedroo

m

Cabo

olture

Urban

25m

2/dw

elling

1vis/3

dwelling

Code

Assessable

4�6st�

1000

1�3st�22m

4�6st�25

mGF

25m

²GF

5m

n/a

n/a

T�AO

7.1�M

ax.crossover

widthof4

mor5

m(shared),

�Max.one

driv

ewayper

streetfron

tage;o

rseparatio

nbe

tween

drivew

aysisa

minim

umof

6

T�A0

8.1�M

inim

um50%

of

fron

tageisplanted

fora

min.w

idthof2

m.

T�A0

8.2�5

%ofthe

site

areawith

deepplaning

zone

swith

am

in.w

idthof

4

T�AO

5.1��The

lesserof

30%ofstreetfrontage;

or10m

widepe

rstreet

fron

tage;and

setback

behind

mainbu

ilding

T�AO

5.3�V

isitorp

arkingprovide

dwith

in

thefron

tsetbackhasaland

scaped

area

with

am

in.W

idthof2

mbetweenthe

carp

arkareaand

streetfron

tage.

T�AO

25.1�6m

3storage/du

min.9m,

max.17m

min.

3storeys,

max.6

storeys

Height<8.5m

�60%

Height>8.5m

�12m �

50%

Height>12m�40%

n/a

n/a

�1�3mto

Wall,

�0mto

OMP

�<4.5m

�1.5m

to

OMP

�4.5mto

7.5m�2m

toOMP

�>7.5m

�2m

to

OMP,plus0

.5mfo

r3

ih

iht

noprovisio

nsfo

rlots

with

afron

tage>18m

15m

�Cod

eAssessabledue

tonon

�com

pliantstreet

fron

tagewidth.(30

metresforSelf�a

ssessable)

�Landscapingat2

mfo

r50%

based

onno

n�self

assessable.Provision

scanno

tbeachieved

with

provision

ofd

rivew

aysa

ndped

estrianaccess.

Heightbased

onsitebe

ingwith

in400

m2of

railw

aystation.

1visitorcarpark/d

udo

esnotworkfor

Multip

leDwelling(Terrace).

6m.

4m.

every3m

inheight

above7.5m

�Rear:4m

Page 214: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Notes

Assumption

Applicab

le�Design�Provisions

T�A0

2.120%ofsite

,5m

mindim

Applicab

le�Site

�Provision

sPrivate�Ope

n�Sp

ace

Commun

al�Ope

n�Sp

ace

Setbacks

Table�1.4

Site�Cover

Z�SO

�Tab

le6.2.6.4.4

Sitin

g�an

d�De

sign

T�A0

1.1Accessedoffliving

space;

Grou

ndlevelPOSlocated

behind

mainbu

ildingline

5mm

indim

Includ

es1area,50%

of

requ

iremen

t,im

indim

10m,rationot>2:1

Additio

naltoDe

ep

Plantin

grequ

iremen

ts

Build

ing�He

ight�

Level�o

f�Assessmen

tPa

rking�Ra

te

Car�P

arking/G

arages

Land

scap

ing

Drivew

ays

Scen

�ario

Lot�S

ize�

(m²)

Fron

�tage

�Stree

t�/�Lot�

Type

Precinct�

Locatio

nTypo

logy

Minim

um�Site

�Area�(m

²)Minim

um�

Fron

tage

Min.�A

rea

Min.�

Dimen

sion

Min.�A

rea

Min.�D

im�

ension

Metres

Storeys

to�Lan

eway

�to�Pub

lic�

Ope

n�Sp

ace

to�Front�Setba

ckto�Side/Re

arBu

ilt�to

�Bou

ndary

BTB�

cond

ition

s

10Multip

le

Dwelling

(Plex)

AranaHills

NextG

en

Subu

rban

25m

1/dw

elling

2/dw

elling

1vis/3

dwelling

Code

Assessable

22m

GF25

GF5m

n/a

n/a

T�AO

7.1�M

ax.crossover

widthof4

mor5

m(shared),

�Max.one

driv

ewayper

streetfron

tage;o

r

T�A0

8.1�M

inim

um50%

of

fron

tageisplanted

fora

min.w

idthof2

m.

T�A0

8.2�5

%ofthe

site

AO5.1 ��The

lesserof

30%ofstreetfrontage;

or10m

widepe

rstreet

fron

tage;and

setback

T�AO

5.3�V

isitorp

arkingprovide

dwith

in

thefron

tsetbackhasaland

scaped

area

with

am

in.W

idthof2

mbetweenthe

carp

arkareaand

streetfron

tage.

9m3�H

eight<

8.5m

�60%

�Height>

8.5m

�50%

n/a

n/a

�3� 5mto

Wall,

�2mto

OMP

�<4.5m

�1.5m

to

OMP

�4.5mto

7.5m�2m

toOMP

noprovisio

nsfo

rlots

with

afron

tage>18m

15m

�Cod

eAssessabledue

tonon

�com

pliantstreet

fron

tagewidth.(30

metresforSelf�a

ssessable)

separatio

nbe

tween

drivew

aysisa

minim

umof

6m.

areawith

deepplaning

zone

swith

am

in.w

idthof

4m.

behind

mainbu

ilding

T�AO

25.1�6m

3storage/du

�>7.5m

�2m

to

OMP,plus0

.5mfo

revery3m

inheight

above7.5m

�Rear:4m

11Multip

le

Dlli

AranaHills

NextG

en

Sb

bCo

rnerLot

20m

1/dw

elling

2/d

lliCo

deAssessable

22m

GF25

GF5m

n/a

n/a

T�AO

7.1�M

ax.crossover

idth

f45

(h

d)T�A0

8.1�M

inim

um50%

of

ft

il

tdf

AO5.1�40%

ofstreet

ft

60

T�AO

5.3�V

isitorp

arkingprovide

dwith

in

thf

ttb

kh

ld

d9m

3�H

eight<

8.5m

�60%

n/a

n/a

�3�5mto

Wall,

2t

OMP

�<4.5m

�1.5m

to

OMP

noprovisio

nsfo

rlots

ithf

t>18

15m

�Cod

eAssessabledue

tonon

�com

pliantstreet

ft

idth

(30

tf

Slf

bl)

Dwelling

(Plex)

Subu

rban

2/dw

elling

1vis/3

dwelling

widthof4

mor5

m(shared),

�Max.one

driv

ewayper

streetfron

tage;o

rseparatio

nbe

tween

drivew

aysisa

minim

umof

6m.

fron

tageisplanted

fora

min.w

idthof2

m.

T�A0

8.2�5

%ofthe

site

areawith

deepplaning

zone

swith

am

in.w

idthof

4m.

fron

tage;o

r6.0m

(whicheverisgreater);

�Noop

eninggreater

than6mwith

outm

in.

1msp

acebe

tween.

thefron

tsetbackhasaland

scaped

area

with

am

in.W

idthof2

mbetweenthe

carp

arkareaand

streetfron

tage.

T�AO

25.1�6m

3storage/du

60%

�Height>

8.5m

�50%

� 2mto

OMP

�Secon

dary

Fron

tage:2mto

wall,1m

toOMP

OMP

�4.5mto

7.5m�2m

toOMP

�>7.5m

�2m

to

OMP,plus0

.5mfo

revery3m

inheight

above7.5m

�Rear:4m

with

afron

tage>18m

fron

tagewidth.(30m

etresforSelf�a

ssessable)

12Multip

le

Dwelling

(Plex)

Cabo

olture

NextG

en

Subu

rban

25m

1/dw

elling

2/dw

elling

1vis/3

dwelling

Code

Assessable

22m

GF25

GF5m

n/a

n/a

T�AO

7.1�M

ax.crossover

widthof4

mor5

m(shared),

�Max.one

driv

ewayper

streetfron

tage;o

rseparatio

nbe

tween

drivew

aysisa

minim

umof

6

T�A0

8.1�M

inim

um50%

of

fron

tageisplanted

fora

min.w

idthof2

m.

T�A0

8.2�5

%ofthe

site

areawith

deepplaning

zone

swith

am

in.w

idthof

4

AO5.1��The

lesserof

30%ofstreetfrontage;

or10m

widepe

rstreet

fron

tage;and

setback

behind

mainbu

ilding

T�AO

5.3�V

isitorp

arkingprovide

dwith

in

thefron

tsetbackhasaland

scaped

area

with

am

in.W

idthof2

mbetweenthe

carp

arkareaand

streetfron

tage.

T�AO

25.1�6m

3storage/du

9m3� H

eight<

8.5m

�60%

�Height>

8.5m

�50%

n/a

n/a

�3�5mto

Wall,

�2mto

OMP

�<4.5m

�1.5m

to

OMP

�4.5mto

7.5m�2m

toOMP

�>7.5m

�2m

to

OMP,plus0

.5mfo

r3

ih

iht

noprovisio

nsfo

rlots

with

afron

tage>18m

15m

�Cod

eAssessabledue

tonon

�com

pliantstreet

fron

tagewidth.(30

metresforSelf�a

ssessable)

6m.

4m.

every3m

inheight

above7.5m

�Rear:4m

13Multip

le

Dwelling

(Plex)

Cabo

olture

NextG

en

Subu

rban

CornerLot

30m

1/dw

elling

2/dw

elling

1vis/3

dwelling

SelfAssessable

30m

GF25

GF5m

n/a

n/a

T�AO

7.1�M

ax.crossover

widthof4

mor5

m(shared),

�Max.one

driv

ewayper

streetfron

tage;o

r

�Landscape

strip

with

an

averagede

pthof3m

alon

gfthe

fullwidthfo

all

streetfron

tages.

AO5.1��The

lesserof

30%ofstreetfrontage;

or10m

widepe

rstreet

fron

tage;and

setback

�Minim

umof1

dwellingisorientated

towardseachstreetfron

tage.

9m3�H

eight<

8.5m

�60%

�Height>

8.5m

�50%

n/a

n/a

�3�5mto

Wall,

�2mto

OMP

�Secon

dary

Fron

tage:2mto

�<4.5m

�1.5m

to

OMP

�4.5mto

7.5m�2m

toOMP

noprovisio

nsfo

rlots

with

afron

tage>18m

15m

gg;

separatio

nbe

tween

drivew

aysisa

minim

umof

6m.

gg;

behind

mainbu

ilding

gwall,1m

toOMP

�>7.5m

�2m

to

OMP,plus0

.5mfo

revery3m

inheight

above7.5m

�Rear:4m

14Multip

le

Dwelling

(Plex)

Kipp

a�Ring

NextG

en

Subu

rban

25m

1/dw

elling

2/dw

elling

1vis/3

dwelling

Code

Assessable

22m

GF25

GF5m

n/a

n/a

T�AO

7.1�M

ax.crossover

widthof4

mor5

m(shared),

�Max.one

driv

ewayper

streetfron

tage;o

rseparatio

nbe

tween

T�A0

8.1�M

inim

um50%

of

fron

tageisplanted

fora

min.w

idthof2

m.

T�A0

8.2�5

%ofthe

site

areawith

deepplaning

AO5.1��The

lesserof

30%ofstreetfrontage;

or10m

widepe

rstreet

fron

tage;and

setback

behind

mainbu

ilding

T�AO

5.3�V

isitorp

arkingprovide

dwith

in

thefron

tsetbackhasaland

scaped

area

with

am

in.W

idthof2

mbetweenthe

carp

arkareaand

streetfron

tage.

T�AO

25.1�6m

3storage/du

9m3�H

eight<

8.5m

�60%

�Height>

8.5m

�50%

n/a

n/a

�3�5mto

Wall,

�2mto

OMP

�<4.5m

�1.5m

to

OMP

�4.5mto

7.5m�2m

toOMP

�>7.5m

�2m

to

noprovisio

nsfo

rlots

with

afron

tage>18m

15m

�Cod

eAssessabledue

tonon

�com

pliantstreet

fron

tagewidth.(30m

etres forSelf�a

ssessable)

drivew

aysisa

minim

umof

6m.

zone

swith

am

in.w

idthof

4m.

OMP,plus0

.5mfo

revery3m

inheight

above7.5m

�Rear:4m

15Multip

le

Dwelling

(Plex)

Strathpine

NextG

en

Subu

rban

CornerLot

20m

1/dw

elling

2/dw

elling

1vis/3

Code

Assessable

22m

GF25

GF5m

n/a

n/a

T�AO

7.1�M

ax.crossover

widthof4

mor5

m(shared),

�Max

onedrivew

aype

r

T�A0

8.1�M

inim

um50%

of

fron

tageisplanted

fora

min

width

of2m

AO5.1�40%

ofstreet

fron

tage;o

r6.0m

(whichever

isgreater);

T�AO

5.3�V

isitorp

arkingprovide

dwith

in

thefron

tsetbackhasaland

scaped

area

with

amin

Width

of2m

betw

eenthe

9m3�H

eight<

8.5m

�60%

�Height>

85m

n/a

n/a

�3�5mto

Wall,

�2mto

OMP

�<4.5m

�1.5m

to

OMP

� 45m

to75m

�2m

noprovisio

nsfo

rlots

with

afron

tage>18m

15m

�Cod

eAssessabledue

tonon

�com

pliantstreet

fron

tagewidth.(30

metresforSelf�a

ssessable)

(Plex)

1vis/3

dwelling

Max.one

driv

ewayper

streetfron

tage;o

rseparatio

nbe

tween

drivew

aysisa

minim

umof

6m.

min.w

idthof2

m.

T�A0

8.2�5

%ofthe

site

areawith

deepplaning

zone

swith

am

in.w

idthof

4m.

(whicheverisgreater);

�Noop

eninggreater

than6mwith

outm

in.

1msp

acebe

tween.

with

am

in.W

idthof2

mbetweenthe

carp

arkareaand

streetfron

tage.

T�AO

25.1�6m

3storage/du

Height>

8.5m

50%

4.5mto

7.5m2m

toOMP

�>7.5m

�2m

to

OMP,plus0

.5mfo

revery3m

inheight

above7.5m

�Rear:4m

Page 215: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Notes

Assumption

Applicab

le�Design�Provisions

T�A0

2.120%ofsite

,5m

mindim

Applicab

le�Site

�Provision

sPrivate�Ope

n�Sp

ace

Commun

al�Ope

n�Sp

ace

Setbacks

Table�1.4

Site�Cover

Z�SO

�Tab

le6.2.6.4.4

Sitin

g�an

d�De

sign

T�A0

1.1Accessedoffliving

space;

Grou

ndlevelPOSlocated

behind

mainbu

ildingline

5mm

indim

Includ

es1area,50%

of

requ

iremen

t,im

indim

10m,rationot>2:1

Additio

naltoDe

ep

Plantin

grequ

iremen

ts

Build

ing�He

ight�

Level�o

f�Assessmen

tPa

rking�Ra

te

Car�P

arking/G

arages

Land

scap

ing

Drivew

ays

Scen

�ario

Lot�S

ize�

(m²)

Fron

�tage

�Stree

t�/�Lot�

Type

Precinct�

Locatio

nTypo

logy

Minim

um�Site

�Area�(m

²)Minim

um�

Fron

tage

Min.�A

rea

Min.�

Dimen

sion

Min.�A

rea

Min.�D

im�

ension

Metres

Storeys

to�Lan

eway

�to�Pub

lic�

Ope

n�Sp

ace

to�Front�Setba

ckto�Side/Re

arBu

ilt�to

�Bou

ndary

BTB�

cond

ition

s

16LowRise

Ap

artm

ents(3

be

droo

m)

Cabo

olture

NextG

en

Subu

rban

25m

1000

1/dw

elling

2/dw

elling

1vis/3

dwelling

Code

Assessable

4�6st�

1000

1�3st�22m

4�6st�25

mGF

25m

²Else1B8m

²2B

12m

²3B

16m

²

GF5m

Else1B2.5m

2B3m

3B3m

200

5mT�AO

7.1�M

ax.crossover

widthof4

mor5

m(shared),

�Max.one

driv

ewayper

streetfron

tage;o

r

T�A0

8.1�M

inim

um50%

of

fron

tageisplanted

fora

min.w

idthof2

m.

T�A0

8.2�5

%ofthe

site

AO5.1��The

lesserof

30%ofstreetfrontage;

or10m

widepe

rstreet

fron

tage;and

setback

T�AO

5.2��P

arkingareasfaceinternal

drivew

aysO

Rlocatedbe

hind

building

line

T�AO

5.3���V

isitor p

arkingprovide

dwith

in

9m3�H

eight<

8.5m

�60%

�Height>

8.5m

�50%

n/a

n/a

�3�5mto

Wall,

�2mto

OMP

�<4.5m

�1.5m

to

OMP

�4.5mto

7.5m�2m

toOMP

noprovisio

nsfo

rlots

with

afron

tage>18m

15m

�SelfA

ssessableform

inim

umlotfrontages30m

�com

mun

alope

nspacebasedon

20%

ofsite

area.

separatio

nbe

tween

drivew

aysisa

minim

umof

6m.

areawith

deepplaning

zone

swith

am

in.w

idthof

4m.

behind

mainbu

ilding

thefron

tsetbackhasaland

scaped

area

with

am

in.W

idthof2

mbetweenthe

carp

arkareaand

streetfron

tage.

T�AO

25.1�6m

3storage/du

�>7.5m

�2m

to

OMP,plus 0

.5mfo

revery3m

inheight

above7.5m

�Rear:4m

17LowRise

A

tt

Kipp

a�Ring

NextG

en

Sb

b25

m10

001/dw

elling

2/d

lliCo

deAssessable

4�6st�

1000

²1�3st�22m

46t25

GF25m

²El

1B8

²GF

5m

El1B

25

200

5mT�AO

7.1�M

ax.crossover

idth

f45

(h

d)T�A0

8.1�M

inim

um50%

of

ft

il

tdf

AO5.1��The

lesserof

30%

ft

tft

T�AO

5.2��P

arkingareasfaceinternal

di

ORl

tdb

hidb

ildi

9m3�H

eight<

8.5m

�60%

n/a

n/a

�3�5mto

Wall,

2t

OMP

�<4.5m

�1.5m

to

OMP

noprovisio

nsfo

rlots

ithf

t>18

15m

�SelfA

ssessableform

inim

umlotfrontages30m

lb

d20%

fit

Apartm

ents

Subu

rban

2/dw

elling

1vis/3

dwelling

1000m²

4�6st�25m

Else1B8m

²2B

12m

²3B

16m

²

Else1B2.5m

2B3m

3B3m

widthof4

mor5

m(shared),

�Max.one

driv

ewayper

streetfron

tage;o

rseparatio

nbe

tween

drivew

aysisa

minim

umof

6m.

fron

tageisplanted

fora

min.w

idthof2

m.

T�A0

8.2�5

%ofthe

site

areawith

deepplaning

zone

swith

am

in.w

idthof

4m.

30%ofstreetfrontage;

or10m

widepe

rstreet

fron

tage;and

setback

behind

mainbu

ilding

drivew

aysO

Rlocatedbe

hind

building

line

T�AO

5.3���V

isitorp

arkingprovide

dwith

in

thefron

tsetbackhasaland

scaped

area

with

am

in.W

idthof2

mbetweenthe

carp

arkareaand

streetfron

tage.

T�AO

25.1�6m

3storage/du

60%

�Height>

8.5m

�50%

� 2mto

OMP

OMP

�4.5mto

7.5m�2m

toOMP

�>7.5m

�2m

to

OMP,plus0

.5mfo

revery3m

inheight

above7.5m

�Rear:4m

with

afron

tage>18m

�com

mun

alope

nspacebasedon

20%

ofsite

area.

18LowRise

Ap

artm

ents(3

be

droo

m)

AranaHills

NextG

en

Subu

rban

18m

6001/dw

elling

2/dw

elling

1vis/3

dwelling

Code

Assessable

1�3st�22m

GF25

Else1B8m

²2B

12m

²3B

16m

²

GF5m

Else1B2.5m

2B3m

3B3m

120

5mT�AO

7.1�M

ax.crossover

widthof4

mor5

m(shared),

�Max.one

driv

ewayper

streetfron

tage;o

rseparatio

nbe

tween

drivew

aysis a

minim

umof

6

T�A0

8.1�M

inim

um50%

of

fron

tageisplanted

fora

min.w

idthof2

m.

T�A0

8.2�5

%ofthe

site

areawith

deepplaning

zone

swith

am

in.w

idthof

4

AO5.1�40%

ofstreet

fron

tage;o

r6.0m

(whicheverisgreater);

�Noop

eninggreater

than6mwith

outm

in.

1msp

acebe

tween.

T�AO

5.2��P

arkingareasfaceinternal

drivew

aysO

Rlocatedbe

hind

building

line

T�AO

5.3���V

isitorp

arkingprovide

dwith

in

thefron

tsetbackhasaland

scaped

area

with

am

in.W

idthof2

mbetween the

kd

ttf

t

9m3�H

eight<

8.5m

�60%

�Height>

8.5m

�50%

n/a

n/a

�3�5mto

Wall,

�2mto

OMP

�<4.5m

�1.5m

to

OMP

�4.5mto

7.5m�2m

toOMP

�>7.5m

�2m

to

OMP,plus0

.5mfo

r3

ih

iht

Asin

glebu

iltto

bo

udnarywallm

aybe

provided

whe

reth

ebu

iltto

bou

ndarywall

adjoinsa

nallotm

ent

with

afron

tage<18

m.

50%

�SelfA

ssessableform

inim

umlotfrontages30m

�com

mun

alope

nspacebasedon

20%

ofsite

area.

�develop

men

tlim

itedto3storeysd

ueto

minim

umsiteareaof100

0m²

6m.

4m.

carp

arkareaand

streetfron

tage.

T�AO

25.1�6m

3storage/du

every3m

inheight

above7.5m

�Rear:4m

19LowRise

Ap

artm

ents

AranaHills

NextG

en

Subu

rban

25m

1000

1/dw

elling

2/dw

elling

1vis/3

dwelling

Code

Assessable

4�6st�

1000

1�3st�22m

4�6st�25

mGF

25m

²Else1B8m

²2B

12m

²3B

16m

²

GF5m

Else1B2.5m

2B3m

3B3m

200

5mT�AO

7.1�M

ax.crossover

widthof4

mor5

m(shared),

�Max.one

driv

ewayper

streetfron

tage;o

r

T�A0

8.1�M

inim

um50%

of

fron

tageisplanted

fora

min.w

idthof2

m.

T�A0

8.2�5

%ofthe

site

�Ope

ningofn

omore

than30%

ofstreet

fron

tage;o

r10m

wide

perstreetfrontage;and

T�AO

5.2��P

arkingareasfaceinternal

drivew

aysO

Rlocatedbe

hind

building

line

T�AO

5.3���V

isitor p

arkingprovide

dwith

in

9m3�H

eight<

8.5m

�60%

�Height>

8.5m

�50%

n/a

n/a

�3�5mto

Wall,

�2mto

OMP

�<4.5m

�1.5m

to

OMP

�4.5mto

7.5m�2m

toOMP

noprovisio

nsfo

rlots

with

afron

tage>18m

15m

�SelfA

ssessableform

inim

umlotfrontages30m

�com

mun

alope

nspacebasedon

20%

ofsite

area.

gg;

separatio

nbe

tween

drivew

aysisa

minim

umof

6m.

areawith

deepplaning

zone

swith

am

in.w

idthof

4m.

pg;

setbackbe

hind

main

building

pgp

thefron

tsetbackhasaland

scaped

area

with

am

in.W

idthof2

mbetweenthe

carp

arkareaand

streetfron

tage.

T�AO

25.1�6m

3storage/du

�>7.5m

�2m

to

OMP,plus0

.5mfo

revery3m

inheight

above7.5m

�Rear:4m

20LowRise

A

Strathpine

NextG

en

Sb

b18m

6001/dw

elling

2/d

lliCo

deAssessable

1�3st�22m

GF25

El1B

GF5m

El1B

25

120

5mT�AO

7.1�M

ax.crossover

idh

f45

(h

d)T�A0

8.1�M

inim

um50%

of

fi

ldf

AO5.1�40%

ofstreet

f60

T�AO

5.2��P

arkingareasfaceinternal

di

ORl

db

hidb

ildi

9m3�H

eight<

8.5m

�60%

n/a

n/a

�3�5mto

Wall,

2OMP

�<4.5m

�1.5m

to

OMP

Asin

glebu

iltto

b

dll

b50

%�SelfA

ssessableform

inim

umlotfrontages30m

lb

d20%

fi

Apartm

ents

Subu

rban

2/dw

elling

1vis/3

dwelling

Else1B8m

²2B

12m

²3B

16m

²

Else1B2.5m

2B3m

3B3m

widthof4

mor5

m(shared),

�Max.one

driv

ewayper

streetfron

tage;o

rseparatio

nbe

tween

drivew

aysisa

minim

umof

6m.

fron

tageisplanted

fora

min.w

idthof2

m.

T�A0

8.2�5

%ofthe

site

areawith

deepplaning

zone

swith

am

in.w

idthof

4m.

fron

tage;o

r6.0m

(whicheverisgreater);

�Noop

eninggreater

than6mwith

outm

in.

1msp

acebe

tween.

drivew

aysO

Rlocatedbe

hind

building

line

T�AO

5.3���V

isitorp

arkingprovide

dwith

in

thefron

tsetbackhasaland

scaped

area

with

am

in.W

idthof2

mbetweenthe

carp

arkareaand

streetfron

tage.

T�AO

25.1�6m

3storage/du

60%

�Height>

8.5m

�50%

� 2mto

OMP

OMP

�4.5mto

7.5m�2m

toOMP

�>7.5m

�2m

to

OMP,plus0

.5mfo

revery3m

inheight

above7.5m

� Rear:4m

boud

narywallm

aybe

provided

whe

reth

ebu

iltto

bou

ndarywall

adjoinsa

nallotm

ent

with

afron

tage<18

m.

�com

mun

a lope

nspacebasedon

20%

ofsite

area.

�develop

men

tlim

itedto3storeysd

ueto

minim

umsiteareaof100

0m²

Rear:4m

21LowRise

Ap

artm

ents

Strathpine

NextG

en

Subu

rban

25m

1000

1/dw

elling

2/dw

elling

1vis/3

dwelling

Code

Assessable

4�6st�

1000

1�3st�22m

4�6st�25

mGF

25m

²Else1B8m

²2B

12m

²3B

16m

²

GF5m

Else1B2.5m

2B3m

3B3m

200

5mT�AO

7.1�M

ax.crossover

widthof4

mor5

m(shared),

�Max.one

driv

ewayper

streetfron

tage;o

rseparatio

nbe

tween

drivew

aysisa

minim

umof

T�A0

8.1�M

inim

um50%

of

fron

tageisplanted

fora

min.w

idthof2

m.

T�A0

8.2�5

%ofthe

site

areawith

deepplaning

zone

swith

am

in.w

idthof

�Ope

ningofn

omore

than30%

ofstreet

fron

tage;o

r10m

wide

perstreetfrontage; and

setbackbe

hind

main

building

T�AO

5.2��P

arkingareasfaceinternal

drivew

aysO

Rlocatedbe

hind

building

line

T�AO

5.3���V

isitorp

arkingprovide

dwith

in

thefron

tsetbackhasaland

scaped

area

with

am

in.W

idthof2

mbetweenthe

9m3�H

eight<

8.5m

�60%

�Height>

8.5m

�50%

n/a

n/a

�3�5mto

Wall,

�2mto

OMP

�<4.5m

�1.5m

to

OMP

�4.5mto

7.5m�2m

toOMP

�>7.5m

�2m

to

OMP,plus0

.5mfo

r

noprovisio

nsfo

rlots

with

afron

tage>18m

15m

�SelfA

ssessableform

inim

umlotfrontages30m

�com

mun

alope

nspacebasedon

20%

ofsite

area.

6m.

4m.

carp

arkareaand

streetfron

tage.

T�AO

25.1�6m

3storage/du

every3m

inheight

above7.5m

�Rear:4m

22LowRise

Lawnton

Urban

18m

6001/dw

elling

Code

Assessable

1�3st�22m

GF25

GF5m

120

5mT�AO

7.1�M

ax.crossover

T�A0

8.1�M

inim

um50%

ofAO

5.1�40%

ofstreet

T�AO

5.2��P

arkingareasfaceinternal

�min.9m,

�min.

�Height<

8.5m

�n/a

n/a

�<10.5m=1.0m�

�<4.5m

�1.5m

to

Asin

glebu

iltto

50

%�SelfA

ssessableform

inim

umlotfrontages30m

Apartm

ents(3

be

droo

m)

2/dw

elling

1vis/3

dwelling

Else1B8m

²2B

12m

²3B

16m

²

Else1B2.5m

2B3m

3B3m

widthof4

mor5

m(shared),

�Max.one

driv

ewayper

streetfron

tage;o

rseparatio

nbe

tween

drivew

aysisa

minim

umof

6m.

fron

tageisplanted

fora

min.w

idthof2

m.

T�A0

8.2�5

%ofthe

site

areawith

deepplaning

zone

swith

am

in.w

idthof

4m.

fron

tage;o

r6.0m

(whicheverisgreater);

�Noop

eninggreater

than6mwith

outm

in.

1msp

acebe

tween.

drivew

aysO

Rlocatedbe

hind

building

line

T�AO

5.3���V

isitorp

arkingprovide

dwith

in

thefron

tsetbackhasaland

scaped

area

with

am

in.W

idthof 2

mbetweenthe

carp

arkareaand

streetfron

tage.

T�AO

25.1�6m

3storage/du

�max.17m

3storeys,

�max.6

storeys

60%

�Height<

12m�50%

�Height

>12.1�4

0%

3.0m

toOMP.

�>10.5m=5mto

wall,3m

toOMP

OMP

�4.5mto

7.5m�2m

toOMP

�>7.5m

�2m

to

OMP,plus0

.5mfo

revery3m

inheight

above7.5m

�Rear:4m

boun

darywllmaybe

provided

whe

reth

ebu

iltto

bou

ndarywall

adjoinsa

nallotm

ent

with

afron

tage<18

m.

�com

mun

alope

nspacebasedon

20%

ofsite

area.

�Rear:4m

23LowRise

Ap

artm

ents(3

be

droo

m)

Lawnton

Urban

25m

1000

1/dw

elling

2/dw

elling

1vis/3

dwelling

Code

Assessable

4�6st�

1000

1�3st�22m

4�6st�25

mGF

25m

²Else1B8m

²2B

12m

²3B

16m

²

GF5m

Else1B2.5m

2B3m

3B3m

200

5mT�AO

7.1�M

ax.crossover

widthof4

mor5

m(shared),

�Max.one

driv

ewayper

streetfron

tage;o

rseparatio

nbe

tween

drivew

aysisa

minim

umof

T�A0

8.1�M

inim

um50%

of

fron

tageisplanted

fora

min.w

idthof2

m.

T�A0

8.2�5

%ofthe

site

areawith

deepplaning

zone

swith

am

in.w

idthof

AO5.1��The

lesserof

30%ofstreetfrontage;

or10m

widepe

rstreet

fron

tage;and

setback

behind

mainbu

ilding

T�AO

5.2��P

arkingareasfaceinternal

drivew

aysO

Rlocatedbe

hind

building

line

T�AO

5.3���V

isitorp

arkingprovide

dwith

in

thefron

tsetbackhasaland

scaped

area

with

am

in.W

idthof2

mbetweenthe

�min.9m,

�max.17m

�min.

3storeys,

�max.6

storeys

�Height<

8.5m

�60%

�Height<

12m�50%

�Height

>12.1�4

0%

n/a

n/a

�<10.5m=1.0m�

3.0m

toOMP.

�>10.5m=5mto

wall,3m

toOMP

�<4.5m

�1.5m

to

OMP

�4.5mto

7.5m�2m

toOMP

�>7.5m

�2m

to

OMP,plus0

.5mfo

r

noprovisio

nsfo

rlots

with

afron

tage>18m

15m

�SelfA

ssessableform

inim

umlotfrontages30m

� com

mun

alope

nspacebasedon

20%

ofsite

area.

6m.

4m.

carp

arkareaand

streetfron

tage.

T�AO

25.1�6m

3storage/du

every3m

inheight

above7.5m

�Rear:4m

24LowRise

Ap

artm

ents

Margate

Urban

18m

6001/dw

elling

2/dw

elling

1vis/3

dwelling

Code

Assessable

1�3st�22m

GF25

Else1B8m

²2B

12m

²3B

16m²

GF5m

Else1B2.5m

2B3m

3B3m

120

5mT�AO

7.1�M

ax.crossover

widthof4

mor5

m(shared),

�Max.one

driv

ewayper

street

fron

tage;o

r

T�A0

8.1�M

inim

um50%

of

fron

tageisplanted

fora

min.w

idthof2

m.

TA0

82

5%of

thesite

AO5.1�40%

ofstreet

fron

tage;o

r6.0m

(whicheverisgreater);

Noop

eninggreater

T�AO

5.2��P

arkingareasfaceinternal

drivew

aysO

Rlocatedbe

hind

building

line

TAO

53

Visitor

parkingprovided

with

in

�min.9m,

�max.17m

�min.

3storeys,

�max.6

storeys

�Height<

8.5m

�60%

�Height<

12m�50%

Height

n/a

n/a

�<10.5m=1.0m�

3.0m

toOMP.

�>10.5m=5mto

wall3m

toOMP

�<4.5m

�1.5m

to

OMP

�4.5mto

7.5m�2m

to

OMP

Asin

glebu

iltto

bo

udnarywallm

aybe

provided

whe

reth

ebu

iltto

boun

dary

wall

50%

�SelfA

ssessableform

inim

umlotfrontages30m

�com

mun

alope

nspacebasedon

20%

ofsite

area.

developm

entlim

itedto

3storeysd

ueto

dwelling

3B16m

3B3m

streetfron

tage;o

rseparatio

nbe

tween

drivew

aysisa

minim

umof

6m.

T�A0

8.2�5

%ofthe

site

areawith

deepplaning

zone

swith

am

in.w

idthof

4m.

�Noop

eninggreater

than6mwith

outm

in.

1msp

acebe

tween.

T�AO

5.3���V

isitorp

arkingprovide

dwith

in

thefron

tsetbackhasaland

scaped

area

with

am

in.W

idthof2

mbetweenthe

carp

arkareaand

streetfron

tage.

T�AO

25.1�6m

3storage/du

storeys

�Height

>12.1�4

0%wall,3m

toOMP

toOMP

�>7.5m

�2m

to

OMP,plus0

.5mfo

revery3m

inheight

above7.5m

�Rear:4m

builtto

bou

ndarywall

adjoinsa

nallotm

ent

with

afron

tage<18

m.

�develop

men

tlim

itedto3storeysd

ueto

minim

umsiteareaof100

0m²

Page 216: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Notes

Assumption

Applicab

le�Design�Provisions

T�A0

2.120%ofsite

,5m

mindim

Applicab

le�Site

�Provision

sPrivate�Ope

n�Sp

ace

Commun

al�Ope

n�Sp

ace

Setbacks

Table�1.4

Site�Cover

Z�SO

�Tab

le6.2.6.4.4

Sitin

g�an

d�De

sign

T�A0

1.1Accessedoffliving

space;

Grou

ndlevelPOSlocated

behind

mainbu

ildingline

5mm

indim

Includ

es1area,50%

of

requ

iremen

t,im

indim

10m,rationot>2:1

Additio

naltoDe

ep

Plantin

grequ

iremen

ts

Build

ing�He

ight�

Level�o

f�Assessmen

tPa

rking�Ra

te

Car�P

arking/G

arages

Land

scap

ing

Drivew

ays

Scen

�ario

Lot�S

ize�

(m²)

Fron

�tage

�Stree

t�/�Lot�

Type

Precinct�

Locatio

nTypo

logy

Minim

um�Site

�Area�(m

²)Minim

um�

Fron

tage

Min.�A

rea

Min.�

Dimen

sion

Min.�A

rea

Min.�D

im�

ension

Metres

Storeys

to�Lan

eway

�to�Pub

lic�

Ope

n�Sp

ace

to�Front�Setba

ckto�Side/Re

arBu

ilt�to

�Bou

ndary

BTB�

cond

ition

s

25LowRise

Ap

artm

ents

Margate

Urban

25m

1000

1/dw

elling

2/dw

elling

1vis/3

dwelling

Code

Assessable

4�6st�

1000

1�3st�22m

4�6st�25

mGF

25m

²Else1B8m

²2B

12m

²3B

16m

²

GF5m

Else1B2.5m

2B3m

3B3m

200

5mT�AO

7.1�M

ax.crossover

widthof4

mor5

m(shared),

�Max.one

driv

ewayper

streetfron

tage;o

r

T�A0

8.1�M

inim

um50%

of

fron

tageisplanted

fora

min.w

idthof2

m.

T�A0

8.2�5

%ofthe

site

AO5.1��The

lesserof

30%ofstreetfrontage;

or10m

widepe

rstreet

fron

tage;and

setback

T�AO

5.2��P

arkingareasfaceinternal

drivew

aysO

Rlocatedbe

hind

building

line

T�AO

5.3���V

isitorp

arkingprovide

dwith

in�m

in. 9m,

�max.17m

�min.

3storeys,

�max.6

storeys

�Height<

8.5m

�60%

�Height<

12m�50%

�Height

n/a

n/a

�<10.5m=1.0m�

3.0m

toOMP.

�>10.5m=5mto

wall,3m

toOMP

�<4.5m

�1.5m

to

OMP

�4.5mto

7.5m�2m

toOMP

noprovisio

nsfo

rlots

with

afron

tage>18m

15m(3

.5min

height)

�SelfA

ssessableform

inim

umlotfrontages30m

�com

mun

alope

nspacebasedon

20%

ofsite

area.

separatio

nbe

tween

drivew

aysisa

minim

umof

6m.

areawith

deepplaning

zone

swith

am

in.w

idthof

4m.

behind

mainbu

ilding

thefron

tsetbackhasaland

scaped

area

with

am

in.W

idthof2

mbetweenthe

carp

arkareaand

streetfron

tage.

T�AO

25.1�6m

3storage/du

>12.1�4

0%�>

7.5m

�2m

to

OMP,plus0

.5mfo

revery3m

inheight

above7.5m

�Rear:4m

Page 217: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Notes

Assumption

Applicab

le�Design�Provisions

T�A0

2.120%ofsite

,5m

mindim

Applicab

le�Site

�Provision

sPrivate�Ope

n�Sp

ace

Commun

al�Ope

n�Sp

ace

Setbacks

Table�1.4

Site�Cover

Z�SO

�Tab

le6.2.6.4.4

Sitin

g�an

d�De

sign

T�A0

1.1Accessedoffliving

space;

Grou

ndlevelPOSlocated

behind

mainbu

ildingline

5mm

indim

Includ

es1area,50%

of

requ

iremen

t,im

indim

10m,rationot>2:1

Additio

naltoDe

ep

Plantin

grequ

iremen

ts

Build

ing�He

ight�

Level�o

f�Assessmen

tPa

rking�Ra

te

Car�P

arking/G

arages

Land

scap

ing

Drivew

ays

Scen

�ario

Lot�S

ize�

(m²)

Fron

�tage

�Stree

t�/�Lot�

Type

Precinct�

Locatio

nTypo

logy

Minim

um�Site

�Area�(m

²)Minim

um�

Fron

tage

Min.�A

rea

Min.�

Dimen

sion

Min.�A

rea

Min.�D

im�

ension

Metres

Storeys

to�Lan

eway

�to�Pub

lic�

Ope

n�Sp

ace

to�Front�Setba

ckto�Side/Re

arBu

ilt�to

�Bou

ndary

BTB�

cond

ition

s

26Med

iumRise

Ap

artm

ents

Redcliffe

Urban

20m

8001/dw

elling

2/dw

elling

1vis/3

dwelling

Code

Assessable

4�6st�

1000

7�8�160

0m²

9�12

st�

1�3st�22m

4�6st�25

m7�8st�30m

9�12st�35m

GF25m

²Else1B8m

²2B

12m

²3B

16m

²

GF5m

Else1B2.5m

2B3m

3B3m

160

5mT�AO

7.1�M

ax.crossover

widthof4

mor5

m(shared),

�Max.one

driv

ewayper

streetfron

tage;o

r

T�A0

8.1�M

inim

um50%

of

fron

tageisplanted

fora

min.w

idthof2

m.

T�A0

8.2�5

%ofthe

site

AO5.1�40%

ofstreet

fron

tage;o

r6.0m

(whicheverisgreater);

�Noop

eninggreater

T�AO

5.2��P

arkingareasfaceinternal

drivew

aysO

Rlocatedbe

hind

building

line

T�AO

5.3 ���V

isitorp

arkingprovide

dwith

in�P

odium

<10.5m

�min.9m

�max.17m

�min.

3storeys

�max.6

storeys

�Height<

12m�50%

�Height

>12.1�4

0%

n/a

n/a

�<10.5m=1.0m�

3.0m

toOMP.

�>10.5m=5mto

wall,3m

toOMP

�<4.5m

�1.5m

to

OMP

�4.5mto

7.5m�2m

toOMP

noprovisio

nsfo

rlots

with

afron

tage>18m

15m(3

.5min

height)

�SelfA

ssessableforlessthan5du

onlyand

fron

tagegreaterth

an30m

.�a

lllotsarewith

in400

mofara

ilstation

2400

separatio

nbe

tween

drivew

aysisa

minim

umof

6m.

areawith

deepplaning

zone

swith

am

in.w

idthof

4m.

than6mwith

outm

in.

1msp

acebe

tween.

thefron

tsetbackhasaland

scaped

area

with

am

in.W

idthof2

mbetweenthe

carp

arkareaand

streetfron

tage.

T�AO

25.1�6m

3storage/du

�>7.5m

�2m

to

OMP,plus0

.5mfo

revery3m

inheight

above7.5m

�Rear:4m

27Med

iumRise

A

tt

Redcliffe

Urban

30m

1000

1/dw

elling

2/d

lliCo

deAssessable

4�6st�

1000

²1�3st�22m

46t25

GF25m

²El

1B8

²GF

5m

El1B

25

200

5mT�AO

7.1�M

ax.crossover

idth

f45

(h

d)T�A0

8.1�M

inim

um50%

of

ft

il

tdf

�Ope

ningofn

omore

th30%

ft

tT�AO

5.2��P

arkingareasfaceinternal

di

ORl

tdb

hidb

ildi

�Pod

ium

<105

�min.

3t

�Height<

12m�50%

Hiht

n/a

n/a

�<10.5m=1.0m�

30

tOMP

�<4.5m

�1.5m

to

OMP

noprovisio

nsfo

rlots

ithf

t>18

15m(3

.5min

hiht)

�SelfA

ssessableforlessthan5du

only

�alllotsarewith

in400

mofara

ilstation

Apartm

ents

2/dw

elling

1vis/3

dwelling

1000m²

7�8�160

0m²

9�12

st�

2400

4�6st�25m

7�8st�30m

9�12st�35m

Else1B8m

²2B

12m

²3B

16m

²

Else1B2.5m

2B3m

3B3m

widthof4

mor5

m(shared),

�Max.one

driv

ewayper

streetfron

tage;o

rseparatio

nbe

tween

drivew

aysisa

minim

umof

6m.

fron

tageisplanted

fora

min.w

idthof2

m.

T�A0

8.2�5

%ofthe

site

areawith

deepplaning

zone

swith

am

in.w

idthof

4m.

than30%

ofstreet

fron

tage;o

r10m

wide

perstreetfrontage;and

setbackbe

hind

main

building

drivew

aysO

Rlocatedbe

hind

building

line

T�AO

5.3���V

isitorp

arkingprovide

dwith

in

thefron

tsetbackhasaland

scaped

area

with

am

in.W

idthof2

mbetweenthe

carp

arkareaand

streetfron

tage.

T�AO

25.1�6m

3storage/du

<10.5m

�min.9m

�max.17m

3storeys

�max.6

storeys

� Height

>12.1�4

0%3.0m

toOMP.

�>10.5m=5mto

wall,3m

toOMP

OMP

�4.5mto

7.5m�2m

toOMP

�>7.5m

�2m

to

OMP,plus0

.5mfo

revery3m

inheight

above7.5m

�Rear:4m

with

afron

tage>18m

height)

28Med

iumRise

Ap

artm

ents

Margate

Urban

25m

1000

1/dw

elling

2/dw

elling

1vis/3

dwelling

Code

Assessable

4�6st�

1000

7�8�160

0m²

9�12

st�

2400

1�3st�22m

4�6st�25

m7�8st�30m

9�12st�35m

GF25m

²Else1B8m

²2B

12m

²3B

16m

²

GF5m

Else1B2.5m

2B3m

3B3m

200

5mT�AO

7.1�M

ax.crossover

widthof4

mor5

m(shared),

�Max.one

driv

ewayper

streetfron

tage;o

rseparatio

nbe

tween

drivew

aysisa

minim

umof

6

T�A0

8.1�M

inim

um50%

of

fron

tageisplanted

fora

min.w

idthof2

m.

T�A0

8.2�5

%ofthe

site

areawith

deepplaning

zone

swith

am

in.w

idthof

4

AO5.1��The

lesserof

30%ofstreetfrontage;

or10m

widepe

rstreet

fron

tage;and

setback

behind

mainbu

ilding

T�AO

5.2��P

arkingareasfaceinternal

drivew

aysO

Rlocatedbe

hind

building

line

T�AO

5.3���V

isitorp

arkingprovide

dwith

in

thefron

tsetbackhasaland

scaped

area

with

am

in.W

idthof2

mbetween the

kd

ttf

t

�Pod

ium

<10.5m

�min.9m

�max.17m

�min.

3storeys

�max.6

storeys

�Height<

12m�50%

�Height

>12.1�4

0%

n/a

n/a

�<10.5m=1.0m�

3.0m

toOMP.

�>10.5m=5mto

wall,3m

toOMP

�<4.5m

�1.5m

to

OMP

�4.5mto

7.5m�2m

toOMP

�>7.5m

�2m

to

OMP,plus0

.5mfo

r3

ih

iht

noprovisio

nsfo

rlots

with

afron

tage>18m

15m(3

.5min

height)

�SelfA

ssessableforlessthan5du

onlyand

fron

tagegreaterth

an30m

.�alllotsarewith

in400

mofara

ilstation

6m.

4m.

carp

arkareaand

streetfron

tage.

T�AO

25.1�6m

3storage/du

every3m

inheight

above7.5m

�Rear:4m

29Med

iumRise

Ap

artm

ents

Burpen

gary

Urban

25m

1000

1/dw

elling

2/dw

elling

1vis/3

dwelling

Code

Assessable

4�6st�

1000

7�8�160

0m²

9�12

st�

1�3st�22m

4�6st�25

m7�8st�30m

9�12st�35m

GF25m

²Else1B8m

²2B

12m

²3B

16m

²

GF5m

Else1B2.5m

2B3m

3B3m

200

5mT�AO

7.1�M

ax.crossover

widthof4

mor5

m(shared),

�Max.one

driv

ewayper

streetfron

tage;o

r

T�A0

8.1�M

inim

um50%

of

fron

tageisplanted

fora

min.w

idthof2

m.

T�A0

8.2�5

%ofthe

site

AO5.1��The

lesserof

30%ofstreetfrontage;

or10m

widepe

rstreet

fron

tage;and

setback

T�AO

5.2��P

arkingareasfaceinternal

drivew

aysO

Rlocatedbe

hind

building

line

T�AO

5.3���V

isitor p

arkingprovide

dwith

in�P

odium

<10.5m

�min.9m

�max.17m

�min.

3storeys

�max.6

store ys

�Height<

12m�50%

�Height

>12.1�4

0%

n/a

n/a

�<10.5m=1.0m�

3.0m

toOMP.

�>10.5m=5mto

wall ,3m

toOMP

�<4.5m

�1.5m

to

OMP

�4.5mto

7.5m�2m

toOMP

noprovisio

nsfo

rlots

with

afron

tage>18m

15m(3

.5min

height)

�SelfA

ssessableforlessthan5du

onlyand

fron

tagegreaterth

an30m

.�alllotsarewith

in400

mofara

ilstation

g24

00m²

g;

separatio

nbe

tween

drivew

aysisa

minim

umof

6m.

areawith

deepplaning

zone

swith

am

in.w

idthof

4m.

g;

behind

mainbu

ilding

pgp

thefron

tsetbackhasaland

scaped

area

with

am

in.W

idthof2

mbetweenthe

carp

arkareaand

streetfron

tage.

T�AO

25.1�6m

3storage/du

y,

�>7.5m

�2m

to

OMP,plus0

.5mfo

revery3m

inheight

above7.5m

�Rear:4m

30Med

iumRise

A

Burpen

gary

Centre(C

an

b25

m10

001/dw

elling

2/d

lliCo

deAssessable

4�6st�

1000

²1�3st�22m

46

25GF

25m

²El

1B8

²GF

5m

El1B

25

200

5mT�AO

7.1�M

ax.crossover

idh

f45

(h

d)T�A0

8.1�M

inim

um50%

of

fi

ldf

AO5.1��The

lesserof

30%

ff

T�AO

5.2��P

arkingareasfaceinternal

di

ORl

db

hidb

ildi

�Pod

ium

105

�min.

3�H

eight<

12m�50%

Hih

n/a

n/a

�<10.5m=1.0m�

30

OMP

�<4.5m

�1.5m

to

OMP

noprovisio

nsfo

rlots

ihf

1815m(3

.5min

hih)

�SelfA

ssessableforlessthan5du

onlyand

fh

30�alllotsarewith

in400

mofara

ilstation

Apartm

ents

useurba

nprovision

s)2/dw

elling

1vis/3

dwelling

1000m²

7�8�160

0m²

9�12

st�

2400

4�6st�25m

7�8st�30m

9�12st�35m

Else1B8m

²2B

12m

²3B

16m

²

Else1B2.5m

2B3m

3B3m

widthof4

mor5

m(shared),

�Max.one

driv

ewayper

streetfron

tage;o

rseparatio

nbe

tween

drivew

aysisa

minim

umof

6m.

fron

tageisplanted

fora

min.w

idthof2

m.

T�A0

8.2�5

%ofthe

site

areawith

deepplaning

zone

swith

am

in.w

idthof

4m.

30%ofstreetfrontage;

or10m

widepe

rstreet

fron

tage;and

setback

behind

mainbu

ilding

drivew

aysO

Rlocatedbe

hind

building

line

T�AO

5.3���V

isitorp

arkingprovide

dwith

in

thefron

tsetbackhasaland

scaped

area

with

am

in.W

idthof2

mbetweenthe

carp

arkareaand

streetfron

tage.

T�AO

25.1�6m

3storage/du

< 10.5m

�min.9m

�max.17m

3storeys

�max.6

storeys

� Height

>12.1�4

0%3.0m

toOMP.

�>10.5m=5mto

wall,3m

toOMP

OMP

�4.5mto

7.5m�2m

toOMP

�>7.5m

�2m

to

OMP,plus0

.5mfo

revery3m

inheight

above7.5m

� Rear:4m

with

afron

tage>18m

height)

fron

tagegreaterth

an30m

.

Rear:4m

31Med

iumRise

Ap

artm

ents

AranaHills

Centre(C

an

useurba

nprovision

s)

20m

8001/dw

elling

2/dw

elling

1vis/3

dwelling

Code

Assessable

4�6st�

1000

7�8�160

0m²

9�12

st�

2400

1�3st�22m

4�6st�25

m7�8st�30m

9�12st�35m

GF25m

²Else1B8m

²2B

12m

²3B

16m

²

GF5m

Else1B2.5m

2B3m

3B3m

160

5mT�AO

7.1�M

ax.crossover

widthof4

mor5

m(shared),

�Max.one

driv

ewayper

streetfron

tage;o

rseparatio

nbe

tween

drivew

aysisa

minim

umof

T�A0

8.1�M

inim

um50%

of

fron

tageisplanted

fora

min.w

idthof2

m.

T�A0

8.2�5

%ofthe

site

areawith

deepplaning

zone

swith

am

in.w

idthof

�40%

ofstreet frontage;

or6.0m(w

hicheveris

greater);

�Noop

eninggreater

than6mwith

outm

in.

1msp

acebe

tween.

T�AO

5.2��P

arkingareasfaceinternal

drivew

aysO

Rlocatedbe

hind

building

line

T�AO

5.3���V

isitorp

arkingprovide

dwith

in

thefron

tsetbackhasaland

scaped

area

with

am

in.W

idthof2

mbetweenthe

�Pod

ium

<10.5m

�min. 9m

�max.17m

�min.

3storeys

�max.6

storeys

�Height<

12m�50%

�Height

>12.1�4

0%

n/a

n/a

�<10.5m=1.0m�

3.0m

toOMP.

�>10.5m=5mto

wall,3m

toOMP

�<4.5m

�1.5m

to

OMP

�4.5mto

7.5m�2m

toOMP

�>7.5m

�2m

to

OMP,plus0

.5mfo

r

noprovisio

nsfo

rlots

with

afron

tage>18m

15m(3

.5min

height)

�SelfA

ssessableforlessthan5du

onlyand

fron

tagegreaterth

an30m

.�alllotsarewith

in400

mofara

ilstation

6m.

4m.

carp

arkareaand

streetfron

tage.

T�AO

25.1�6m

3storage/du

every3m

inheight

above7.5m

�Rear:4m

32Med

iumRise

Ap

artm

ents

Cabo

olture

Centre(C

an

useurba

nprovision

s)

25m

1000

1/dw

elling

2/dw

elling

1vis/3

dwelling

Code

Assessable

4�6st�

1000

7�8�160

0m²

9�12

st�

1�3st�22m

4�6st�25

m7�8st�30m

9�12

st�3

5m

GF25m

²Else1B8m

²2B

12m

²3B

16m²

GF5m

Else1B2.5m

2B3m

3B3m

200

5mT�AO

7.1�M

ax.crossover

widthof4

mor5

m(shared),

�Max.one

driv

ewayper

street

fron

tage;o

r

T�A0

8.1�M

inim

um50%

of

fron

tageisplanted

fora

min.w

idthof2

m.

TA0

8.2�5

%of

thesite

�Ope

ningofn

omore

than30%

ofstreet

fron

tage;o

r10m

wide

perstreetfrontage;and

T�AO

5.2��P

arkingareasfaceinternal

drivew

aysO

Rlocatedbe

hind

building

line

TAO

5.3�V

isitorp

arking

provided

with

in

�Pod

ium

<10.5m

�min.9m

� max.17m

�min.

3storeys

�max.6

storeys

�Height<

12m�50%

�Height

>12.1�4

0%

n/a

n/a

�<10.5m=1.0m�

3.0m

toOMP.

�>10.5m=5mto

wall,3m

toOMP

�<4.5m

�1.5m

to

OMP

�4.5mto

7.5m�2m

to

OMP

noprovisio

nsfo

rlots

with

afron

tage>18m

15m(3

.5min

height)

�SelfA

ssessableforlessthan5du

onlyand

fron

tagegreaterth

an30m

.�alllotsarewith

in400

mofara

ilstation

dwelling

912

st

2400

912

st35m

3B16m

3B3m

streetfron

tage;o

rseparatio

nbe

tween

drivew

aysisa

minim

umof

6m.

T�A0

8.2

5%ofthe

site

areawith

deepplaning

zone

swith

am

in.w

idthof

4m.

perstreetfrontage;and

setbackbe

hind

main

building

T�AO

5.3�

�Visitorp

arkingprovide

dwith

in

thefron

tsetbackhasaland

scaped

area

with

am

in.W

idthof2

mbetweenthe

carp

arkareaand

streetfron

tage.

T�AO

25.1�6m

3storage/du

max.17m

storeys

wall,3m

toOMP

toOMP

�>7.5m

�2m

to

OMP,plus0

.5mfo

revery3m

inheight

above7.5m

�Rear:4m

Page 218: Design Review and Feasibility Assessment of Draft MBRC Planning Scheme Residential … · 2019-04-23 · Design Review & Feasibility Assessment - Draft Planning Scheme Residential

Notes

Assumption

Applicab

le�Design�Provisions

T�A0

2.120%ofsite

,5m

mindim

Applicab

le�Site

�Provision

sPrivate�Ope

n�Sp

ace

Commun

al�Ope

n�Sp

ace

Setbacks

Table�1.4

Site�Cover

Z�SO

�Tab

le6.2.6.4.4

Sitin

g�an

d�De

sign

T�A0

1.1Accessedoffliving

space;

Grou

ndlevelPOSlocated

behind

mainbu

ildingline

5mm

indim

Includ

es1area,50%

of

requ

iremen

t,im

indim

10m,rationot>2:1

Additio

naltoDe

ep

Plantin

grequ

iremen

ts

Build

ing�He

ight�

Level�o

f�Assessmen

tPa

rking�Ra

te

Car�P

arking/G

arages

Land

scap

ing

Drivew

ays

Scen

�ario

Lot�S

ize�

(m²)

Fron

�tage

�Stree

t�/�Lot�

Type

Precinct�

Locatio

nTypo

logy

Minim

um�Site

�Area�(m

²)Minim

um�

Fron

tage

Min.�A

rea

Min.�

Dimen

sion

Min.�A

rea

Min.�D

im�

ension

Metres

Storeys

to�Lan

eway

�to�Pub

lic�

Ope

n�Sp

ace

to�Front�Setba

ckto�Side/Re

arBu

ilt�to

�Bou

ndary

BTB�

cond

ition

s

33HighRise

Ap

artm

ents(8

Storey)

Woo

dyPoint

Urban

30m

1600

1/un

it+1/3

units(vis)

2/unit+

1/3

units(vis)

Code

Assessable

4�6st�

1000

7�8�160

0m²

9�12

st�

1�3st�22m

4�6st�25

m7�8st�30m

9�12st�35m

GF25m

²Else1B8m

²2B

12m

²3B

16m

²

GF5m

Else1B2.5m

2B3m

3B3m

320

5m�M

ax.crossoverwidthof 4

m

or5m(shared),

�Max.one

driv

ewayper

streetfron

tage;o

r

T�A0

8.1�M

inim

um50%

of

fron

tageisplanted

fora

min.w

idthof2

m.

T�A0

8.2�5

%ofthe

site

AO5.1��The

lesserof

30%ofstreetfrontage;

or10m

widepe

rstreet

fron

tage;and

setback

T�AO

37.1��Po

dium

doe

snotexceed

10.5m

T�AO

5.2�P

arkingareasfaceinternal

drivew

aysO

Rlocatedbe

hind

building

�min.9m,

�max.17m

�min.

3storeys,

�max.6

storeys

�Height<

8.5m

�60%

�Height<

12m�50%

�Height

n/a

n/a

�<10.5m=1.0m�

3.0m

toOMP.

�>10.5m=5mto

wall,3m

toOMP

�<4.5m

�1.5m

to

OMP

�4.5mto

7.5m�2m

toOMP

noprovisio

nsfo

rlots

with

afron

tage>18m

15m

�SelfA

ssessableforlessthan5du

only

�com

mun

alope

nspacebasedon

20%

ofsite

area.

�alllotsarewith

in400

mofara

ilstation

2400

separatio

nbe

tween

drivew

aysisa

minim

umof

6m.

areawith

deepplaning

zone

swith

am

in.w

idthof

4m.

behind

mainbu

ilding

line

T�AO

5.3�V

isitorp

arkingprovide

dwith

in

thefron

tsetbackhasaland

scaped

area

with

am

in.W

idthof2

mbetweenthe

carp

arkareaand

streetfron

tage.

T�AO

25.1�6m

3storage/du

>12.1�4

0%�>

7.5m

�2m

to

OMP,plus0

.5mfo

revery3m

inheight

above7.5m

�Rear:4m

34Hi

hRi

Rdliff

Ub

201000

1/it+1/3

Cd

Abl

46t

13t

22GF

25²

GF5

200

5TAO

71

MTA0

81

Mii

50%

fAO

51

Thl

fTAO

371

Pdi

dt

di

9i

Hiht

<85

//

<105

10

<45

15

tii

flt

15SlfA

blf

lth

5d

llllt

ithi400

fil

ti34

HighRise

Ap

artm

ents(8

Storey)

Redcliffe

Urban

20m

1000

1/un

it+1/3

units(vis)

2/unit+

1/3

units(vis)

Code

Assessable

4�6st�

1000

7�8�160

0m²

9�12

st�

2400

1�3st�22m

4�6st�25

m7�8st�30m

9�12st�35m

GF25m

²Else1B8m

²2B

12m

²3B

16m

²

GF5m

Else1B2.5m

2B3m

3B3m

200

5mT�AO

7.1�M

ax.crossover

widthof4

mor5

m(shared),

�Max.one

driv

ewayper

streetfron

tage;o

rseparatio

nbe

tween

drivew

aysisa

minim

umof

6m.

T�A0

8.1�M

inim

um50%

of

fron

tageisplanted

fora

min.w

idthof2

m.

T�A0

8.2�5

%ofthe

site

areawith

deepplaning

zone

swith

am

in.w

idthof

4m.

AO5.1��The

lesserof

30%ofstreetfrontage;

or10m

widepe

rstreet

fron

tage;and

setback

behind

mainbu

ilding

T�AO

37.1��Po

dium

doe

snotexceed

10.5m

T�AO

5.2�P

arkingareasfaceinternal

drivew

aysO

Rlocatedbe

hind

building

line

T�AO

5.3�V

isitorp

arkingprovide

dwith

in

thefron

tsetbackhasaland

scaped

area

with

am

in.W

idthof2

mbetweenthe

�min.9m,

�max.17m

�min.

3storeys,

�max.6

storeys

� Height<

8.5m

�60%

�Height<

12m�50%

�Height

>12.1�4

0%

n /a

n/a

�<10.5m=1.0m�

3.0m

toOMP.

�>10.5m=5mto

wall,3m

toOMP

� <4.5m

�1.5m

to

OMP

�4.5mto

7.5m�2m

toOMP

�>7.5m

�2m

to

OMP,plus0

.5mfo

revery3m

inheight

above7.5m

noprov isio

nsfo

rlots

with

afron

tage>18m

15m

�SelfA

ssessableforlesstha

n5du

only

�com

mun

alope

nspacebasedon

20%

ofsite

area.

�alllotsarewith

in400mofara

ilsatio

n

carp

arkareaand

streetfron

tage.

T�AO

25.1�6m

3storage/du

�Rear:4m

35HighRise

Ap

artm

ents(6

Storey)

Lawnton

Urban

30m

1600

1/un

it+1/3

units(vis)

2/unit+

1/3

units(vis)

Code

Assessable

4�6st�

1000

7�8�160

0m²

9�12

st�

2400

²

1�3st�22m

4�6st�25

m7�8st�30m

9�12st�35m

GF25m

²Else1B8m

²2B

12m

²3B

16m

²

GF5m

Else1B2.5m

2B3m

3B3m

320

5mT�AO

7.1�M

ax.crossover

widthof4

mor5

m(shared),

�Max.one

driv

ewayper

streetfron

tage;o

rti

bt

T�A0

8.1�M

inim

um50%

of

fron

tageisplanted

fora

min.w

idthof2

m.

T�A0

8.2�5

%ofthe

site

ithd

li

AO5.1��The

lesserof

30%ofstreetfrontage;

or10m

widepe

rstreet

fron

tage;and

setback

bhi

dib

ildi

T�AO

37.1��Po

dium

doe

snotexceed

10.5m

T�AO

5.2�P

arkingareasfaceinternal

drivew

aysO

Rlocatedbe

hind

building

li

�min.9m,

�max.17m

�min.

3storeys,

�max.6

storeys

�Height<

8.5m

�60%

�Height<

12m�50%

�Height

121

40%

n/a

n/a

�<10.5m=1.0m�

3.0m

toOMP.

�>10.5m=5mto

wall,3m

toOMP

�<4.5m

�1.5m

to

OMP

�4.5mto

7.5m�2m

toOMP

75

2t

noprovisio

nsfo

rlots

with

afron

tage>18m

15m

�SelfA

ssessableforlessthan5du

only

�com

mun

alope

nspacebasedon

20%

ofsite

area.

�alllotsarewith

in400

mofara

ilstation

2400m²

separatio

nbe

tween

drivew

aysisa

minim

umof

6m.

areawith

deepplaning

zone

swith

am

in.w

idthof

4m.

behind

mainbu

ilding

line

T�AO

5.3�V

isitorp

arkingprovide

dwith

in

thefron

tsetbackhasaland

scaped

area

with

am

in.W

idthof2

mbetweenthe

carp

arkareaand

streetfron

tage.

T�AO

25.1�6m

3storage/du

> 12.1�4

0%�>

7.5m

�2m

to

OMP,plus0

.5mfo

revery3m

inheight

above7.5m

�Rear:4m

36HighRise

Re

dcliffe

Centre(C

an

35m

2400

1/un

it+1/3

Code

Assessable

4�6st�

1�3st�22m

GF25

GF5m

480

5mT�AO

7.1�M

ax.crossover

T�A0

8.1�M

inim

um50%

ofAO

5.1��The

lesserof

T�AO

37.1��Po

dium

doe

snotexceed

�min.9m,

�min.

�Height<

8.5m

�n/a

n/a

�<10.5m=1.0m�

�<4.5m

�1.5m

to

noprovisio

nsfo

rlots

15m

�SelfA

ssessableforlessthan5du

only

�alllotsarewith

in400

mofara

ilstation

gAp

artm

ents

(12Storey)

(useurba

nprovision

s)

//

units(vis)

2/unit+

1/3

units(vis)

1000

7�8�160

0m²

9�12

st�

2400

4�6st�25

m7�8st�30m

9�12st�35m

Else1B8m

²2B

12m

²3B

16m

²

Else1B2.5m

2B3m

3B3m

widthof4

mor5

m(shared),

�Max.one

driv

ewayper

streetfron

tage;o

rseparatio

nbe

tween

drivew

aysisa

minim

umof

6m.

fron

tageisplanted

fora

min.w

idthof2

m.

T�A0

8.2�5

%ofthe

site

areawith

deepplaning

zone

swith

am

in.w

idthof

4m.

30%ofstreetfrontage;

or10m

widepe

rstreet

fron

tage;and

setback

behind

mainbu

ilding

10.5m

T�AO

5.2�P

arkingareasfaceinternal

drivew

aysO

Rlocatedbe

hind

building

line

T�AO

5.3�V

isitorp

arkingprovide

dwith

in

thefron

tsetbackhasaland

scaped

area

with

am

in.W

idthof2

mbetweenthe

kd

f

,�m

ax.17m

3storeys,

�max.6

storeys

g60%

�Height<

12m�50%

�Height

>12.1�4

0%

//

3.0m

toOMP.

�>10.5m=5mto

wall,3m

toOMP

OMP

�4.5mto

7.5m�2m

toOMP

�>7.5m

�2m

to

OMP,plus0

.5mfo

revery3m

inheight

above7.5m

R4

pwith

afron

tage>18m

y�com

mun

alope

nspacebasedon

20%

ofsite

area.

carp

arkareaand

streetfron

tage.

T�AO

25.1�6m

3storage/du

�Rear:4m

37HighRise

Ap

artm

ents(8

Storey)

Strathpine

Centre(C

an

useurba

nprovision

s)

35m

2400

1/un

it+1/3

units(vis)

2/unit+

1/3

units(vis)

Code

Assessable

4�6st�

1000

7�8�160

0m²

9�12

st�

2400m²

1�3st�22m

4�6st�25

m7�8st�30m

9�12st�35m

GF25m

²Else1B8m

²2B

12m

²3B

16m

²

GF5m

Else1B2.5m

2B3m

3B3m

480

5mT�AO

7.1�M

ax.crossover

widthof4

mor5

m(shared),

�Max.one

driv

ewayper

streetfron

tage;o

rseparatio

nbe

tween

T�A0

8.1�M

inim

um50%

of

fron

tageisplanted

fora

min.w

idthof2

m.

T�A0

8.2�5

%ofthe

site

area

with

deep

planing

AO5.1��The

lesserof

30%ofstreetfrontage;

or10m

widepe

rstreet

fron

tage;and

setback

behind

mainbu

ilding

T�AO

37.1��Po

dium

doe

snotexceed

10.5m

T�AO

5.2�P

arkingareasfaceinternal

drivew

aysO

Rlocatedbe

hind

building

line

�min.9m,

�max.17m

�min.

3storeys,

�max.6

storeys

�Height<

8.5m

�60%

�Height<

12m�50%

�Height

> 12.1�4

0%

n/a

n/a

�<10.5m=1.0m�

3.0m

toOMP.

�>10.5m=5mto

wall,3m

toOMP

�<4.5m

�1.5m

to

OMP

�4.5mto

7.5m�2m

toOMP

�>7.5m

�2m

to

noprovisio

nsfo

rlots

with

afron

tage>18m

15m

�SelfA

ssessableforlessthan5du

only

�com

mun

alope

nspacebasedon

20%

ofsite

area.

�alllotsarewith

in400

mofara

ilstation

2400m

separatio

nbe

tween

drivew

aysisa

minim

umof

6m.

areawith

deepplan

ing

zone

swith

am

in.w

idthof

4m.

behind

mainbu

ilding

line

T�AO

5.3�V

isitorp

arkingprovide

dwith

in

thefron

tsetbackhasaland

scaped

area

with

am

in.W

idthof2

mbetweenthe

carp

arkareaand

streetfron

tage.

T�AO

25.1�6m

3storage/du

12.140%

7.5m

2m

to

OMP,plus0

.5mfo

revery3m

inheight

above7.5m

�Rear:4m

38HighRise

Strathpine

Centre(C

an

35m

2400

1/un

it+1/3

Code

Assessable

4�6st� ²

1�3st�22m

GF25m

²²

GF5m

480

5mT�AO

7.1�M

ax.crossover

T�A0

8.1�M

inim

um50%

ofAO

5.1��The

lesserof

T�AO

37.1��Po

dium

doe

snotexceed

�min.9m,

�min.

�Height<

8.5m

�n/a

n/a

�<10.5m=1.0m�

�<4.5m

�1.5m

to

noprovisio

nsfo

rlots

15m

�SelfA

ssessableforlessthan5du

only

�alllotsarewith

in400

mofara

ilstation

Apartm

ents(8

Storey)

useurba

nprovision

s)un

its(vis)

2/unit+

1/3

units(vis)

1000m²

7�8�160

0m²

9�12

st�

2400

4�6st�25

m7�8st�30m

9�12st�35m

Else1B8m

²2B

12m

²3B

16m

²

Else1B2.5m

2B3m

3B3m

widthof4

mor5

m(shared),

�Max.one

driv

ewayper

streetfron

tage;o

rseparatio

nbe

tween

drivew

aysisa

minim

umof

6m.

fron

tageisplanted

fora

min.w

idthof2

m.

T�A0

8.2�5

%ofthe

site

areawith

deepplaning

zone

swith

am

in.w

idthof

4m.

30%ofstreetfrontage;

or10m

widepe

rstreet

fron

tage;and

setback

behind

mainbu

ilding

10.5m

T�AO

5.2�P

arkingareasfaceinternal

drivew

aysO

Rlocatedbe

hind

building

line

T�AO

5.3�V

isitorp

arkingprovide

dwith

in

thefron

tsetbackhasaland

scaped

area

with

am

in.W

idthof2

mbetweenthe

carp

arkarea

andstreet

fron

tage.

�max.17m

3storeys,

�max.6

storeys

60%

�Height<

12m�50%

�Height

>12.1�4

0%

3.0m

toOMP.

�>10.5m=5mto

wall,3m

toOMP

OMP

�4.5mto

7.5m�2m

toOMP

�>7.5m

�2m

to

OMP,plus0

.5mfo

revery3m

inheight

above7.5m

� Rear:4m

with

afron

tage>18

m�com

mun

alope

nspacebasedon

20%

ofsite

area.

carp

arkareaand

streetfron

tage.

T�AO

25.1�6m

3storage/du

Rear:4m