Design Aspects for Terrorist Resistant Buildings

Click here to load reader

download Design Aspects for Terrorist Resistant Buildings

of 48

Transcript of Design Aspects for Terrorist Resistant Buildings

UL3l0N A3PLC13 l0R 1LRR0Rl31 RL3l31AN1 BulLUlN03lN1R0UuC1l0NOI|c ccsi-: oi civilia: o: couuc:cial |uilci:-s to wit|sta:c t|c ciiccts oi a tc::o:ist |last is u:li|c t|c ccsi-: oi uilita:v i:stallatio:s o: t|c ccsi-: oi cu|assv |uilci:-s.OI|c o|jcctivcs oi t|c t:uctu:al l:-i:cc:i:- Guiccli:cs io: t|c Dcsi-: oi :cw lu|assv luilci:-s a:c to :cvc:t |cavv caua-c to couo:c:ts a:c st:uctu:al collasc. OA:c|itcctu:al a:c st:uctu:al icatu:cs lav a si-:iiica:t :olc i: cctc:ui:i:- |ow t|c |uilci:- will :cso:c to t|c |last loaci:-. I|csc icatu:cs ca: i:clucc acjacc:t o: u:cc:-:ou:c a:|i:-. t:a:sic: -i:cc:s. sla| co:ii-u:atio:s. a:c st:uctu:ali:auc svstcusLXPLC1LU 1LRR0Rl31 BLA313 0N 31RuC1uRL3OIternai car bombOInternai car bombOInternai package Osuicidai car bombsA10R CAu3L3 0l LllL L033 Al1LR 1L BLA31Ollvi:- cc|:is Ol:o|c: -lassOuo|c a:c ii:c Olloc|cc -lassOlowc: lossOouuu:icatio:s |:ca|cow:Ol:o-:cssivc collasc oi st:uctu:c00AL3 0l BLA31 RL3l31AN1 UL3l0NOkccucc t|c scvc:itv oi i:ju:vOlacilitatc :cscucOlxccitc :cai:OAccclc:atc t|c sccc oi :ctu:: to iull oc:atio:s.BA3lC RL0ulRLLN13 10 RL3l31 BLA31 L0AU3I|c ii:st :cqui:cuc:t is to cctc:ui:c t|ct|:cat. I|cuajo:t|:catiscauscc|vtc::o:ist|ou|i:-s. I|c t|:cat io: a co:vc:tio:al |ou| isccii:cc |v two cquallv iuo:ta:t clcuc:ts.OI|c |ou| sizc :o: c|a:-c wci-|t. OI|c sta:coii cista:cct|c ui:iuuu -ua:a:tccc cista:cc |ctwcc: t|c |last sou:cc a:c t|c ta:-ctA:ot|c: :cqui:cuc:t is to |cc t|c |ou| as ia: awav as ossi|lc. |v uaxiuizi:- t|c |ccout cista:cc. :o uattc: w|at sizc t|c |ou|. t|c caua-c will |c lcss scvc:c t|c iu:t|c: t|c ta:-ct is i:ou t|c sou:cc.1RLA1LN13 PR0vlULU 10 vARl0u3 PAR13 0l A 31RuC1uRL 10 lPR0vL BLA31 RL3l31lN0 LCANl3lL00R 3LAB31. \o:c attc:tio: uust |c aic to t|c ccsi-: a:c cctaili:- oi cxtc:io: |avs a:c lowc: iloo:s. w|ic| a:c t|c uost susccti|lc to |last loacs .!. li vc:tical clca:a:cc is a :o|lcu. s|ca: |cacs cu|ccccc i: t|c sla| will iu:ovc t|c s|ca: :csista:cc a:c iu:ovc t|c a|ilitv oi t|c sla| to t:a:sic: uouc:ts to t|c coluu:s !. l: cxtc:io: |avslowc: iloo:s. c:o a:cls a:c coluu: caitols a:c :cqui:cc to s|o:tc: t|c ciicctivc sla| lc:-t| a:c iu:ovc t|c u:c|i:- s|ca: :csista:cc+. I|c sla|coluu: i:tc:iacc s|oulc co:tai: closcc|oo sti::u :ci:io:ccuc:t :oc:lv a:c|o:cc a:ou:c ilcxu:al |a:s wit|i: a :csc:i|cc cista:cc i:ou t|c coluu: iacc .. lottou :ci:io:ccuc:t uust |c :oviccc co:ti:uous t|:ou-| t|c coluu:. I|is :ci:io:ccuc:t sc:vcs to :cvc:t |:ittlc iailu:c at t|c co::cctio: a:c :oviccs a: altc::atc ucc|a:isu io: ccvcloi:- s|ca: t:a:sic: o:cc t|c co:c:ctc |as u:c|cc t|:ou-|. C0LuN31. I|c otc:tial io: ci:cct latc:al loaci:- o: t|c iacc oi t|c coluu:s. :csulti:- i:ou t|c |last :cssu:c a:c iuact oi cxlosivc cc|:is. :cqui:cs t|at t|c lowc: iloo: coluu:s |c ccsi-:cc wit| accquatc cuctilitv a:c st:c:-t| !. I|c c:iuctc: coluu:s suo:ti:- t|c lowc: iloo:s uust also |c ccsi-:cc to :csist t|is cxt:cuc |last ciicct !. l:casi:- t|csc lowc:iloo: coluu:s i: a stccl jac|ct will :ovicc co:ii:cuc:t. i:c:casc s|ca: caacitv. a:c iu:ovc t|c coluu:s' cuctilitv a:c st:c:-t|. A: altc::ativc. w|ic| :oviccs siuila: |c:ciits. is to cu|cc a stccl coluu: wit|i: t|c c:iuctc: co:c:ctc coluu:s o: wall scctio:S1FFl 140KF1+. lo: suallc: c|a:-c wci-|ts. si:al :ci:io:ccuc:t :oviccs a ucasu:c oi co:c co:ii:cuc:t t|at -:catlv iu:ovcs t|c caacitv a:c t|c |c|avio: oi t|c :ci:io:ccc co:c:ctc coluu:s u:cc: cxt:cuc loac. 1RAN3lLR 0lRULR3OI|c |uilci:- :clics o: t:a:sic: -i:cc:s at t|c to oi t|c at:iuu to cist:i|utc t|c loacs oi t|c coluu:s a|ovc t|c at:iuu to t|c acjacc:t coluu:s outsicc t|c at:iuu. I|c t:a:sic: -i:cc: sa:s t|c wict| oi t|c at:iuu. w|ic| i:su:cs a coluu:i:cc a:c|itcctu:al sacc io: t|c c:t:a:cc to t|c |uilci:-.OI:a:sic: -i:cc:s tvicallv co:cc:t:atc t|c loac|ca:i:- svstcu i:to a suallc: :uu|c: oi st:uctu:al clcuc:ts.OI|c coluu: co::cctio:s. w|ic| suo:t t|c t:a:sic: -i:cc:s. a:c to :ovicc sustai:cc st:c:-t| ccsitc i:clastic ccio:uatio:s.OI|c coluu: co::cctio:s. w|ic| suo:t t|c t:a:sic: -i:cc:s. a:c to :ovicc sustai:cc st:c:-t| ccsitc i:clastic ccio:uatio:s.3LAR wALL3usc a wcllcist:i|utcc latc:alloac :csisti:- ucc|a:isui: t|c|o:izo:tal iloo:la:.I|is ca:|caccoulis|cc|vusi:-scvc:als|ca:wallsa:ou:ct|cla:oi t|c|uilci:-t|iswill iu:ovct|covc:all scisuic as wcll as t|c |last |c|avio: oi t|c |uilci:-.li acci:- uo:c s|ca: walls is :ot a:c|itcctu:allv icasi|lc. a cou|i:cc latc:alloac :csisti:- ucc|a:isu ca: also |c uscc. A cc:t:al s|ca: wall a:c a c:iuctc: uouc:t:csisti:- i:auc will :ovicc io: a |ala:ccc solutio:. I|c c:iuctc: uouc:t:csisti:- i:auc will :cqui:c st:c:-t|c:i:- t|c sa:c:cl |caus a:c t|c co::cctio:s to t|c outsicc coluu:s. I|is will also :csult i: |cttc: :otcctio: oi t|c outsicc coluu:s.L0wLR lL00R LX1LRl0ROI|c a:c|itcctu:al ccsi-: oi t|c |uilci:- oi i:tc:cst cu::c:tlv calls io: wi:cow -lass a:ou:c t|c ii:st iloo:. u:lcss t|is a:ca is co:st:uctcc i: :ci:io:ccc co:c:ctc. t|c caua-c to t|c lowc: iloo: st:uctu:al clcuc:ts a:c t|ci: co::cctio:s will |c quitc scvc:c. o:scquc:tlv. t|c i:ju:v to t|c lowc: iloo: i:|a|ita:ts will |c cquallv scvc:c. Iwo sizcs oi c|a:-cs ca: |c ciscusscc.1. Io :otcct a-ai:st a suall c|a:-c wci-|t. a :oui:al !00 uu :1! i:. t|ic| wall wit| 0.! stccl cou|lv :ci:io:ccc i: |ot| ci:cctio:s ui-|t |c :cqui:cc. !.lo: i:tc:ucciatc c|a:-c wci-|t :otcctio:. a +o0 uu :1 i:. t|ic| wall wit| 0.. stcclui-|t |c :ccccc. 31ANU 0ll Ul31ANCLOI|c |cc out cista:cc. wit|i: w|ic| cxlosivcslacc: vc|iclcs uav :ot c:ct:atc. uust |c uaxiuizcc a:c -ua:a:tccc. As wc all |:ow. t|c -:catc: t|c sta:coii cista:cc. t|c uo:c t|c |last io:ccs will cissiatc :csulti:- i: :ccuccc :cssu:cs o: t|c |uilci:-. cvc:al :ccouuc:catio:s ca: |c uacc to uai:tai: a:c iu:ovc t|c sta:coii cista:cc io: t|c |uilci:- u:cc: co:sicc:atio:O usc a:ti:au |olla:cs o: la:-c la:tc:s. laccc a:ou:c t|c c:ti:c c:iuctc:. I|csc |a::ic:s uust |c ccsi-:cc to :csist t|c uaxiuuu vc|icula: iuact loac t|at coulc |c iuoscc. lo: uaxiuuu ciicctivc:css. t|c |a::ic:s|olla:cs o: la:tc:suust |c laccc at t|c cu:|. ,397,2 bo||,7/8OI|c u|lic a:|i:- lot at t|c co::c: oi t|c |uilci:- uust |c sccu:cc to -ua:a:tcc t|c :csc:i|cc |ccout cista:cc i:ou t|c iacc oi t|c st:uctu:c. l:cic:a|lv. t|c a:|i:- lot s|oulc |c cliui:atcc. Ot:cct a:|i:- s|oulc :ot |c c:uittcc o: t|c :ca: sicc oi t|c st:cct. acjacc:t to t|c |uilci:-. c+xL x1UDY -1ORLD 1R+DL cLN1LR cOLL+1xLI|c collasc oi t|c Wo:lc I:acc c:tc: :WI towc:s o: ctcu|c: 11. !001. was as succc: as it was c:auatic. t|c coulctc ccst:uctio: oi suc| uassivc |uilci:-s s|oc|cc :ca:lv cvc:vo:c. luucciatclv aitc:wa:c a:c cvc: tocav. t|c:c is wiccs:cac scculatio: t|at t|c |uilci:-s wc:c st:uctu:allv cciicic:t. t|at t|c stccl coluu:s ucltcc. o: t|at t|c ii:c su:cssio: cquiuc:t iailcc to oc:atc. 1lF lFSlCNI|c towc:s wc:c ccsi-:cc a:c |uilt i: t|c uic19o0s t|:ou-| t|c ca:lv 190scac| towc: was o+ u squa:c. sta:ci:- +11 u a|ovc st:cct lcvcl a:c !1 u |clow -:acc. I|is :ocuccs a |ci-|ttowict| :atio oi o.. I|c total wci-|t oi t|c st:uctu:c was :ou-|lv .00.000 t. I|c |uilci:- is a |u-c sail t|at uust :csist a !!. |u| |u::ica:c. lt was ccsi-:cc to :csist a wi:c loac oi ! |laa total oi latc:al loac oi ..000 t.l: o:cc: to ua|c cac| towc: caa|lc oi wit|sta:ci:- t|is wi:c loac. t|c a:c|itccts sclcctcc a li-|twci-|t c:iuctc: tu|c ccsi-: co:sisti:- oi !++ cxtc:io: coluu:s oi !o cu squa:c stccl |ox scctio: o: 100 cu cc:tc:s.OI|is c:uittcc wi:cows uo:c t|a: o:c|ali uctc: wicc. l:sicc t|is outc: tu|c t|c:c was a ! u +0 u co:c. w|ic| was ccsi-:cc to suo:t I|c wci-|t oi t|c towc:. lt also |ouscc t|c clcvato:s. t|c stai:wclls. a:c t|c ucc|a:ical :isc:s a:c utilitics. Wc| joists 0 cu tall co::cctcc t|c co:c to t|c c:iuctc: at cac| sto:v. o:c:ctc sla|s wc:c ou:cc ovc: t|csc joists to io:u t|c iloo:s. l: cssc:cc. I|c |uilci:- is a: c--c:atc co:st:uctio:. i.c. 9.c:cc:t ai:.I|c c--c:atc co:st:uctio: uacc a :ccu:ca:t st:uctu:c :i.c.. ii o:c o: two coluu:s wc:c lost. t|c loacs woulc s|iit i:to acjacc:t coluu:s a:c t|c |uilci:- woulc :cuai: sta:ci:-. I|c WI was :iua:ilv a li-|twci-|t stccl st:uctu:c. |owcvc:. its !++ c:iuctc: coluu:s uacc it o:c oi t|c uost :ccu:ca:t a:c o:c oi t|c uost :csilic:t s|vsc:ac:s.DL1+ILx OI 1HL cOLL+1xL1HL +IR1L+NL Im1+c1I|c ca:lv :cws :co:ts :otcc |ow wcll t|c towc:s wit|stooc t|c i:itial iuact oi t|c ai:c:ait. |owcvc:. w|c: o:c :cco-:izcs t|at t|c |uilci:-s |ac uo:c t|a: 1.000 tiucs t|c uass oi t|c ai:c:ait a:c |ac |cc: ccsi-:cc to :csist stcacv wi:c loacs oi !0 tiucs t|c wci-|t oi t|c ai:c:ait. t|is a|ilitv to wit|sta:c t|c i:itial iuact is |a:clv su::isi:-. lu:t|c:uo:c. si:cc t|c:c was :o si-:iiica:t wi:c o: ctcu|c: 11. t|c outc: c:iuctc: coluu:s wc:c o:lv st:csscc |cio:c t|c iuact to a:ou:c 1! oi t|ci: !00 \laccsi-: allowa|lc. OW|ilc t|c ai:c:ait iuact u:cou|tcclv ccst:ovcc scvc:al coluu:s i: t|c WI c:iuctc: wall. t|c :uu|c: oi coluu:s lost o: t|c i:itial iuact was :ot la:-c a:c t|c loacs wc:c s|iitcc to :cuai:i:- coluu:s i: t|is |i-|lv :ccu:ca:t st:uctu:c. i cqual o: cvc: -:catc: si-:iiica:cc cu:i:- t|is i:itial iuact was t|c cxlosio: w|c: 90.000 l -allo:s oi jct iucl. cou:isi:- :ca:lv 1! oi t|c ai:c:ait`s wci-|t. i-:itcc. I|c c:sui:- ii:c was clca:lv t|c :i:cial causc oi t|c collasc1L C0LLAP3LOI|c c:iuctc: tu|c ccsi-: oi t|c WI was |i-|lv :ccu:ca:t. lt su:vivcc t|c loss oi scvc:al cxtc:io: coluu:s cuc to ai:c:ait iuact. |ut t|c c:sui:- ii:c lcc to ot|c: stccl iailu:cs. O\a:v st:uctu:al c:-i:cc:s |clicvc t|at t|c wca| oi:tswc:c t|c a:-lc clis t|at |clc t|c iloo: joists |ctwcc: t|c coluu:s o: t|c c:iuctc: wall a:c t|c co:c st:uctu:c .OWit| a 00 la iloo: ccsi-: allowa|lc. cac| iloo: s|oulc |avc |cc: a|lc to suo:t a:oxiuatclv 1.!00 t |cvo:c its ow: wci-|t. I|c total wci-|t oi cac| towc: was a|out .00.000 t.O As t|c joists o: o:c o: two oi t|c uost |cavilv |u::cc iloo:s -avc wav a:c t|c outc: |ox coluu:s |c-a: to |ow outwa:c. t|c iloo:s a|ovc t|cu also icll. I|c iloo: |clow :wit| its 1.!00 t ccsi-: caacitv coulc :ot suo:t t|c :ou-|lv +..000 t oi tc: iloo:s :o: uo:c a|ovc c:as|i:- cow: o: t|csc a:-lc clis. I|is sta:tcc t|c coui:o ciicct t|at causcc t|c |uilci:-s to collasc wit|i: tc: scco:cs. |itti:- |ottou wit| a: cstiuatcc sccc oi !00 |u c: |ou:. BuIIDIs RIsIs1 DIRI1 IRPII HI1sOli t|c ccsi-: tc::o:ist attac| is siuila: to t|at oi ct. 11. ca: |uilci:-s |c -ivc: t|c caacitv to ucct t|is ccua:c Io a:swc: t|is qucstio:. it is iuo:ta:t to u:cc:sta:c t|c |vsics at wo:| w|c: a la:c i: ili-|t is stocc |v a |uilci:-.OIo sto a loci:- o t:avcli:- i: cxccss oi .00 uilcs c: |ou: i: a cista:cc oi a icw icct woulc ta|c a cccclc:atio: io:cc i: cxccss oi +00 uillio: ou:cs. Olac| towc: oi t|c Wo:lc I:acc c:tc: was ccsi-:cc io: a total |o:izo:tal io:cc oi a|out 1. uillio: ou:cs. I|c total ccsi-: wi:c loac io: a uo:c couuo:lv sizcc |i-|:isc. sav. +0 sto:ics tall. woulc |c a|out + uillio: ou:cs.OA:ot|c: a:t oi t|c a:swc: to t|is qucstio: lics i: t|c wav t|at t|c cxtc:io: oi t|c |uilci:- was st:uctu:cc. I|c cxtc:io: coluu:s wc:c 1+i:c| squa:c wclccc stccl |ox coluu:s saccc at +0 i:c|cs o: cc:tc:. I|is uca:s t|at t|c:c was o:lv !o i:c|cs clca: |ctwcc: cac| coluu:. I|c coluu:s wc:c i:tc-:al wit| t|c stccl sa:c:cls |caus a:c io:ucc cssc:tiallv a solic wall oi stccl wit| c:io:atio:s io: wi:cows.O a: |uilci:-s |c ccsi-:cc io: ci:cct ai:la:c |its Ycs a:c :o. Ycs. io: suall ai:c:ait. A ccii:itc :o. io: la:-c couuc:cial ai:c:ait.0w CAN wL lNllLL 1L CANCL 0l PR00RL33lvL C0LLAP3LOlccausc t|c towc:s ultiuatclv collascc wit| o:c iloo: c:as|i:- cow: uo: t|c :cxt. it |as |cc: callcc a :o-:cssivc collasc. Ol: t|c casc oi t|c Wo:lc I:acc c:tc: t|c:c wc:c a|out +0 coluu:s lost o: o:c iacc oi cac| oi t|c towc:s a:c t|c:c was :o :oa-atio: oi collasc i:ou t|is loss.O A :cw Yo:| ii:c c|ici w:otc t|at cxc:ic:ccc ii:cii-|tc:s |:ow t|at t|c |uilci:-s t|at a:c uost susccti|lc to :o-:cssivc collasc a:c |uilci:-s t|at a:c wcllticc to-ct|c: :i.c.. a|lc to t:a:sic: |uilci:- loacs i:ou o:c clcuc:t to a:ot|c:. suc| as a coluu:OYct. vi:tuallv cvc:v st:uctu:al c:-i:cc: will acvisc t|at o:c oi t|c |cst wavs to :cvc:t :o-:cssivc collasc is to tic t|c |uilci:- to-ct|c:.OI|c ciiic:c:cc is t|at t|c c:-i:cc: is t|i:|i:- a|out losi:- a coluu: o: two a:c t|c ii:c c|ici is tal|i:- a|out losi:- a w|olc a:t oi a |uilci:-. O At lcast six saictv svstcus :csc:t i: t|c Wo:lc I:acc c:tc: towc:s wc:c coulctclv a:c iuucciatclv cisa|lcc o: ccst:ovcc uo: iuact. ii:c:ooii:-. autouatic s:i:|lc:s. coua:tuc:talizatio: a:c :cssu:izatio:. li-|ti:-. st:uctu:c a:c cxit stai:s.C0NCLu3l0NOI|c:c a:c st:uctu:al tcc|:iqucs t|at ca: i:c:casc t|c caacitv oi |uilci:- st:uctu:cs to :csist cc:tai: |i:cs oi tc::o:ist attac|s. lowcvc:. t|c:c is a|solutclv :o :clia|lc wav to ccsi-: io: t|c iuact oi a la:-c scalc couuc:cial ai:li:c:.IlA:l u`