DES441-1 — Taking Wood to the Next Level – CLT as a Floor ...€¦ · Taking Wood to the Next...
Transcript of DES441-1 — Taking Wood to the Next Level – CLT as a Floor ...€¦ · Taking Wood to the Next...
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 1
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 1
TAKING WOOD TO THE NEXT LEVEL –CLT AS A FLOOR OR ROOF ELEMENT
Michelle Kam-Biron, P.E., S.E., S.E.C.BSenior Director, EducationAmerican Wood Council
Photo courtesy of Seagate Structures
Adam Robertson, M.A.Sc., P.Eng.on behalf of Canadian Wood Council
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 2
This presentation is protected by US and International Copyright laws. Reproduction,
distribution, display and use of the presentation without written permission of
AWC is prohibited.
© American Wood Council 2019
COPYRIGHT
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 2
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 3
DESCRIPTION
An overview of 2018 International Building Code (IBC) and 2018 National DesignSpecification® (NDS®) for Wood Construction provisions related to the use of cross-laminated timber (CLT) will be provided that includes a step-by-step structural andfire design example for a roof and floor application. Additionally, the WoodWorks®Design Office’s Sizer program, version 12 (release date: January 2019) which enablesCLT floor and roof design, will be used to demonstrate the structural design.Innovative wood products such as CLT are leading to a resurgence in heavy timber(Type IV) design and construction. These innovations are also making it possible forwood to be designed and built to taller heights and larger areas than what currentcodes permit. This has led to code change proposals for the 2021 IBC, expandingType IV construction for tall “mass timber” buildings. Participants should find thispresentation useful for current and future applications utilizing CLT in horizontalassemblies.
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 4
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
1. Discuss relevant CLT product manufacturing and design standards and identify where these standards are recognized in the IBC.
2. Consider the relevant structural design properties of CLT for floor and roof applications.
3. Discover how to design CLT floors to achieve serviceability goals related to deflection and creep.
4. Identify applications for using CLT and develop solutions using the highlighted resources.
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 3
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 5
POLLING QUESTION
1. What is your profession?
a. Architect
b. Engineer
c. Code Official
d. Fire Service
e. Builder/Manufacturer/Other
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 6
POLLING QUESTION
2. Where are you located given the map below?
a. West (purple)
b. North Central (green)
c. Northeast (brown)
d. Southeast (teal)
e. South Central (yellow)
West (purple)
North Central (green)
Northeast (brown)
Southeast (teal)
South Central (mustard)
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 4
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 7
POLLING QUESTION
3. How familiar are you with CLT?
a) Guru‐design or plan reviewed many CLT projects and can teach this course.
b) Craftsman‐designed or plan reviewed many projects with CLT.
c) Apprentice‐familiar with CLT but no design/review of projects.
d) Novice‐just started learning about CLT
e) CLT whaaat?
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 8
OUTLINE
CLT Building Examples
CLT - IBC, NDS, ANSI/APA PRG-320
CLT Floor & Roof Design Example
WoodWorks® Ex.
Current Code Happenings
Resources
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 5
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 9
CONTEMPORARY STICK FRAMED CONSTRUCTION
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 1 0
STADHAUS, LONDON, UK
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 6
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 1 1
CANADIAN PROJECTS
Brock CommonsVancouver, British Columbia, Canada• 18 Stories (17 over 1)
• Mixed use student housing
• Completed Sept. 2017
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 1 2
CANADIAN PROJECTS
Photo courtesy of Seagate Structures
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 7
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 1 3
CANADIAN PROJECTS
The ArboraQuébec, Canada• (3) 8 Stories• 434 Residential condo, townhouse
and rental units
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 1 4
CANADIAN PROJECTS
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 8
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 1 5
CANADIAN PROJECTS
The Arbora
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 1 6��������� ������
Elementary School, Franklin, West Virginia –completed 2015
US PROJECTS
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 9
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 1 7Four stories 58,000 sq ftArchitect: Lend Lease
Source: LignaTerra
Private Army HotelRedstone Arsenal Huntsville, ALCompleted 2016
US PROJECTS
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 1 8
US PROJECTS
Albina YardPortland, Oregon4 Story (3 over 1)
Office, Retail
16,000SF
Completed Summer 2016
Client/Owner: Albina Yard LLCArchitect Lever ArchitectureGeneral Contractor ReworksStructural Engineer KPFF Consulting Engineers
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 10
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 1 9
US PROJECTS
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 2 0
US PROJECTS
Carbon 12Portland, Oregon8 Story (85 feet)
Condominiums/ commercial
42,000SF
Completed Summer 2018
Developer: Ben KaiserArchitect PATH ArchitectureGeneral Contractor Kaiser Group Inc.Structural Engineer DCI Engineers
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 11
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 2 1
US PROJECTS
����������� ���� �
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 2 2
OUTLINE
CLT Building Examples
CLT - IBC, NDS, ANSI/APA PRG-320CLT Floor & Roof design
Resources
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 12
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 2 3
BUILDING CODE
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 2 4
CROSS-LAMINATED TIMBER (CLT)
Photo provided by FPInnovations
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 13
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 2 5
MASS TIMBER CONCEPT - HISTORY OF CLT
1985 1st CLT patent - France
1993 1st CLT projects - Switzerland and Germany
1995-1996 Improved press technology
1998 1st multi-story res building - Austria
Early 2000’s• CLT use (Europe) increased significantly
• Green building movement driven
• Better efficiencies, product approvals, improved marketing and distribution channels
• Over 500 CLT buildings in England
Recent - US and Canadian use of CLT
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 2 6
CLT VS. GLT
Beam-like member Thick Orthotropic Plate
Graphics provided by WoodWorksGraphics provided by APA
Cross Laminated TimberGlued Laminated Timber
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 14
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 2 7
MANUFACTURING
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 2 8
http://www.awc.org/Code-Officials/2012-IBC-Challenges/#
http://www.awc.org/Code-Officials/2012-IBC-Challenges/Preliminary-CLT-Fire-Test-Report-FINAL-July2012.pdf
FIRE TESTS
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 15
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 2 9
FIRE TEST
American Wood CouncilASTM E119 Fire Endurance Test• 5-Ply CLT (approx. 7” thick)• 5/8” Type X GWB each side• Sought 2 hour rating• RESULTS: 3 hours 6 minutes
Half-lapped – middle of panel
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 3 0
WHERE IS CLT ALLOWED IN IBC 2018?
Type IV Construction
2015 IBC 2018 IBC
NEW: CLT and SCL
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 16
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 3 1
WHERE IS CLT ALLOWED IN IBC 2018?
Relocated from Ch. 6
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 3 2
TYPE IV CONSTRUCTION
All structural elements can be CLTExterior wallsFloorRoofInterior walls
NLT structural elements:FloorRoof
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 17
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 3 3
WHERE IS CLT ALLOWED IN IBC 2018?
Type III Construction –
602.3 Type III. Type III construction is that type ofconstruction in which the exterior walls are ofnoncombustible materials and the interior buildingelements are of any material permitted by this code.Fire-retardant-treated wood framing and sheathingcomplying with Section 2303.2 shall be permittedwithin exterior wall assemblies of a 2-hour rating orless.
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 3 4
• So where could CLT go?• Almost anywhere!
• Exterior Walls need to be non-combustible or FRT Wood (2 hour or less)
• Interior any material permitted by code
• Roof
TYPE III CONSTRUCTION
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 18
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 3 5
WHERE IS CLT ALLOWED IN IBC 2018?
Type V Construction –
602.5 Type V. Type V construction is that type of construction in which the structural elements, exterior walls and interior walls are of any materials permitted by this code.
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 3 6
WHERE IS CLT ALLOWED IN IBC 2018?
All structural elements can be combustible constructionExterior wallsFloorRoofInterior walls
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 19
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 3 7
POLLING QUESTION
4. Which of the following is correct:a) 2015 IBC included CLT for the first timeb) CLT can be used in Type III, IV and V Constructionc) Heavy timber construction includes GLT, CLT and
SCL.d) All of the above e) a) and b)
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 3 8
OUTLINECLT Building Examples
CLT - IBC, NDS, ANSI/APA PRG-320CLT Floor & Roof Design Example
WoodWorks® Ex.
Current Code Happenings
Resources
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 20
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 3 9
GOVERNING CODES FOR WOOD DESIGN
2018 IBC references in 2018 NDS
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 4 0
2018 NDS
Product Chapters
• Ch. 4 Sawn Lumber
• Ch. 5 Structural Glued Laminated Timber
• Ch. 8 Structural Composite Lumber
• Ch. 10 Cross-Laminated Timber (new in 2015 NDS)
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 21
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 4 1
CROSS-LAMINATED TIMBER
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 4 2
CHAPTER 10 – CROSS-LAMINATED TIMBER
New
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 22
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 4 3
MANUFACTURING STANDARDS
CLT- ANSI/APA PRG 320-2017 references ANSI/AITC 405-2013
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 4 4
MANUFACTURING STANDARDS
CLT- ANSI/APA PRG 320-2018 references ANSI/AITC 405-2018
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 23
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 4 5
PRODUCT MARKING
Marks contain the following:
a) CLT grade qualified
b) CLT thickness or identification
c) Mill name or identification number
d) Approved agency name or logo
e) “ANSI/APA PRG 320”
f) Manufacturer’s designation
g) “Top” stamped on top face (only for unbalanced layup)
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 4 6
CHAPTER 10 – CROSS-LAMINATED TIMBERSingle or multiple
surface layers1, 2, 3, 4 transverse layers
Graphics provided by FPInnovations
Laminations: 5/8”-2” sawn lumber or SCL Panel thickness: 20” maxIn-Service MC: 16%
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 24
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 4 7
CHAPTER 10 – CROSS-LAMINATED TIMBER
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 4 8
CLT PRODUCT REPORTS
https://www.apawood.org/cross-laminated-timber
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 25
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 4 9
CLT PRODUCT REPORTS
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 5 0
CHAPTER 10 – CROSS-LAMINATED TIMBER
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 26
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 5 1
POLLING QUESTION
5. Cross-laminated timber has:a) Laminations of 5/8"-2" thickb) Laminations of sawn lumber or SCLc) Laminations all oriented in one direction d) All of the above e) a) and b)
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 5 2
NDS – CHAPTER 12
Include CLTConnections
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 27
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 5 3
SEISMIC DESIGN OPTIONS
ASCE 7 Minimum Design Loads for Buildings and Other StructuresResponse Modification Coefficient, R
CLT not recognized system in ASCE 7 Table 12.2-1Options• Performance-based design procedure per ASCE 7
• Demonstrating equivalence to an existing ASCE 7 system
• ASCE 7-10, FEMA P695, and FEMA P795 Quantification of Building Seismic Performance Factors; Component Equivalency Methodology
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 5 4
…
CHAPTER 16 – FIRE (ASD)
• Fire resistance up to two hours• Columns• Beams • Tension Members• ASD only
• Products• Lumber• GLT• SCL• Decking• CLT
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 28
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 5 5
HEAVY TIMBER FIRE RESISTANCE RATING
Photo by Structure Magazine
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 5 6
FIRE PERFORMANCE GLULAM VS. STEEL
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 29
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 5 7
NDS CHAPTER 16 – CALCULATED RESISTANCE
Fire resistance of exposed wood members may be calculated using the provisions of NDS Chapter 16
Predictable
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 5 8
2018 NDS METHODOLOGY
Chapter 16 – Fire Design of Wood Members
Mechanics Based Model
Supported by empirical data
NLT, GLT & CLT
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 30
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 5 9
FIRE DESIGN OF EXPOSED WOOD MEMBERS
Allowable Stress Design
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 6 0
Technical Report No. 10• Background on NDS provisions• Design examples• CLT provisions
CHAPTER 16 – FIRE (ASD)
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 31
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 6 1
FIRE DESIGN OF EXPOSED WOOD MEMBERS
Cross-laminated Timber-Effective Char Depth
Revised
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 6 2
FIRE DESIGN OF EXPOSED WOOD MEMBERS
CLT manufactured with laminations of equal thickness
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 32
S i g n i f i c a n t W o o d D e s i g n a n d C o n s t r u c t i o n C h a n g e s t o t h e 2 0 1 8 I B C a n d N D S6 3
CHAR DEPTH
Structural Fire
Design
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 6 4
CONNECTIONS
Source: U.S. CLT Handbook
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 33
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 6 5
FIRE-RESISTANCE OF EXPOSED WOOD
16.3 Wood Connections
Where fire endurance is required, connectors and fasteners shall be protected from fire exposure
• Wood
• Fire-rated gypsum board
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 6 6
OUTLINECLT Building Examples
CLT - IBC, NDS, ANSI/APA PRG-320
CLT Floor & Roof Design ExampleWoodWorks® Ex.
Current Code Happenings
Resources
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 34
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 6 7
NDS-CLT DESIGN
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 6 8
4.6 Exposed CL T Floor Example (Allowable Stress Design)
Simply-supported cross-laminated timber (CLT) floor spanning L=18 ft in the strong-axis direction. The design loads are qlive = 80 psf and qdead = 30 psf including estimated self-weight of the CLT panel.
Floor decking, nailed to the unexposed face of CLT panel, is spaced to restrict hot gases from venting through half-lap joints at edges of CLT panel sections. Calculate the required section dimensions for a two-hour fire resistance time when subjected to an ASTM E119 fire exposure.
Use design provisions from 2018 National Design Specification (NDS)
Adhesive in accordance with ANSI/PRG 320-18 requirements.
Panels connected using a half-lapped joint
TR-10 CLT FLOOR DESIGN EXAMPLE
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 35
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 6 9
TR-10 CLT FLOOR DESIGN EXAMPLEGiven (cont.):Adjustment factors:
Load duration factor CD = 1.0
Moisture factor CM = 1.0
Temperature factor Ct = 1.0
Beam stability factory CL = 1.0
For the structural design of the CLT panel, calculate the maximum induced moment.
Calculate panel load (per foot of width):
Wload = (qdead + qlive) = (30 psf + 80 psf)(1ft width) = 110 plf/ft of panel width
Calculate shear due to support reaction (per foot of width):
Vmax = wload L / 2 = (110)(18)/2 = 990 lbs/ft of width
Calculate maximum induced moment (per foot of width):
Mmax = wload L2 / 8 = (110)(182)/8 = 4,455 ft-lb/ft of width
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 7 0
CLT MANUFACTURING STANDARD
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 36
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 7 1
TR-10 CLT FLOOR DESIGN EXAMPLESee CLT manufacturer or ER for design values!Assume for this ex. PRG 320 design values
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 7 2
CLT MANUFACTURING STANDARDCLT Grades:
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 37
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 7 3
TR-10 CLT FLOOR DESIGN EXAMPLE• From PRG 320-18 select 7-ply CLT floor panel made from 13/8 in. x 31/2 in. lumber boards (CLT
thickness of 95/8 in.)
• V2 CLT grade per ANSI/PRG 320-18 of width (Table A2):
(FbS)eff,f,0= 8,275 ft-lb/ft of width
(EI) eff,f,0= 898 x 106 lbf-in.2/ft of width
(GA) eff,f,0= 1.4 x 106 lbf/ft of width
Vs,0 = 2,490 lbf/ft of width
Structural Check:
• Calculate the allowable design shear:
Vs’ = Vs0(CD)(CM)(Ct) = 2,490(1.0)(1.0)(1.0) = 2,490 lbf/ft of width (NDS 10.3.1)
Vs’ > Vmax 2,490 lbf/ft > 990 lbf/ft
18’-0”
9 5/
8” NA
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 7 4
TR-10 CLT FLOOR DESIGN EXAMPLEStructural Check (cont.):• Calculate the allowable design moment:
Ms’ = Fb(Seff)(CD)(CM)(Ct)(CL) = 8,275(1.0)(1.0)(1.0)(1.0) = 8,275 ft-lb/ft of width (NDS 10.3.1)
Ms’ > Mmax 8,275 ft-lb/ft > 4,455 ft-lb/ft
• Deflection and Creep:
Ks = 11.5 (pinned) Shear deformation adjustment factor (NDS Table 10.4.1.1)
Kcr = 2.0 Creep Factor (NDS 3.5.2)
EI898 x 106
1 11.5 898 x 106
1.4 x 106 18 12 2
EIEIeff
1 Ks
EIeffGAeff
L2
Apparent bending stiffness (NDS Eq. 10.4-1)
= 775 x 106 lbs-in.2/ft.
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 38
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 7 5
TR-10 CLT FLOOR DESIGN EXAMPLE
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 7 6
TR-10 CLT FLOOR DESIGN EXAMPLEStructural Check (cont.):
IBC Table 1604.3 Long-Term DL (Creep Deflection) + Short-Term LL (Live Deflection) Deflection criteria L/360 for short term loading, L/240 for creep deflection.
live = Lpanel (12 in/ft)/360 = 18(12)/360 = 0.60 in. Max. allowable live load (short term) deflection
max = Lpanel (12 in/ft)/240 = 18(12)/240 = 0.90 in. Max. allowable total load deflection
Short Term LL (Live Deflection)
∆5
𝑤12 𝐿 12
384 𝐸𝐼𝑎𝑝𝑝
5 80 12 18 x 12
384 775 𝑥 106= 0.244 in. < 0.60 in.
Live load deflection (short term)
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 39
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 7 7
TR-10 CLT FLOOR DESIGN EXAMPLEStructural Check (cont.):Long Term DL for use with 𝐈𝐁𝐂 𝟏𝟔𝟎𝟒. 𝟑
∆5
𝑤12 𝐿 12
384 𝐸𝐼𝑎𝑝𝑝
5 3012 18 𝑥12
384 775 𝑥 106 = 0.092 in.
∆ ∆ ∆
= 0.092” + 0.244” = 0.336” < 0.90 in.
Long term deflection
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 7 8
TR-10 CLT FLOOR DESIGN EXAMPLEStructural Check (cont.):
NDS Deflection per 3.5
Short-Term DL (Dead Deflection) + Long-Term DL (Creep Deflection) + Short-Term LL (Live Deflection)
∆ 𝐾𝑐𝑟∆ ∆
Short Term LL Deflection (Live Deflection)
∆5
𝑤12 𝐿 12
384 𝐸𝐼𝑎𝑝𝑝
5 80 12 18 x 12
384 775.4 𝑥 106= 0.244 in. Live load deflection (short term)
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 40
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 7 9
TR-10 CLT FLOOR DESIGN EXAMPLEStructural Check (cont.):NDS Deflection per 3.5
Short-Term DL (Dead Deflection) + Long-Term DL (Creep Deflection)
∆ ∆5
𝑤12 𝐿 12
384 𝐸𝐼𝑎𝑝𝑝
5 3012 18 𝑥12
384 775.4 𝑥 106 = 0.092 in.
∆ 𝐾𝑐𝑟∆ ∆ 2.0 0.092 0.244 0.428 𝑖𝑛
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 8 0
TR-10 CLT FLOOR DESIGN EXAMPLEFire Check:
For the fire design of the CLT panel, mass loss due to charring is conservatively neglected so the loading is unchanged. Therefore, the maximum induced moment is unchanged. The fire resistance must be calculated.
Determine the effective char depth, aeff
In this example, the effective char depth, aeff
has penetrated through the first face lamination, the second lamination and partially into the third lamination. The contribution of the partially charred lamination is neglected and the fourth cross-ply lamination is neglected. Therefore, the resisting moment is calculated using the tabulated bending moment of a 3-ply CLT
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 41
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 8 1
Net section 3-ply FbSeff,0 = 2030 ft-lb/ft of width.
Mmax = wload L2 / 8 = (110)(182)/8 = 4,455 ft-lb/ft of width
Calculate the resisting moment (assuming CD = N/A: CM = N/A: Ct = N/A: CL = 1.0) .
Mf′ = (2.85) Fb(Seff) (CL) = 2.85(2,030)(1.0) = 5,785 ft-lb/ft of width (NDS 16.2.2)
Fire Check: Mf′ ≥ Mmax 5,785 ft-lb/ft > 4,455 ft-lb/ft
TR-10 CLT FLOOR DESIGN EXAMPLE
Typical one foot section
NA
18’-0”
9 5/
8” NA
Typical one foot section
NA
Fire Check (cont.):
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 8 2
TR-10 CLT FLOOR DESIGN EXAMPLEThermal Separation:
ASTM E119 also requires floor assemblies to be checked for thermal separation wherein transmission of heat through the test specimen during the fire exposure period does not raise the average temperature on the unexposed surface more than 250°F (139°C) above its initial temperature. If the CLT is used as an unbacked fire barrier, the estimated time to burn-through, tbt, is calculated using TR10 Section 4.4.1.1:
From TR10 Section 4.4.1.2, the time assigned for thermal separation, tts, is calculated as: tts =0.85 tbt
tts =0.85 tbt = 0.85 (562) = 478 minutes
Thermal Separation Check: tts > FRR 478 minutes > 120 minutes
𝑡 60 .
.
.+ 17 = 60 . .
.
.+17 = 562 minutes
(estimated time to burn-through)
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 42
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 8 3
POLLING QUESTION
6. Which of the following is true for CLT floor or roof systems:
a) Manufacturer or code ER provide ref. design valuesb) The deflection criteria in the IBC is the same as the
NDSc) Exposed CLT may be designed for 2 hrs. of fire-
resistance d) All of the above e) a) and c)
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 8 4
OUTLINECLT Building Examples
CLT - IBC, NDS, ANSI/APA PRG-320
CLT Floor & Roof Design Example
WoodWorks® Ex.Current Code Happenings
Resources
This portion of the presentation was developed by a 3rd party and is not funded by AWC or Softwood Lumber Board.
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 43
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 8 5
WOODWORKS® DESIGN OFFICE 12 SOFTWARE
SHEARWALLS
CONNECTIONS
SIZERGravity Design
Lateral Design (Wind and Seismic)
Fasteners
Concept mode
Column modeBeam mode
DATABASE EDITORAdd proprietary products
woodworks-software.com
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 8 6
WOODWORKS® SIZER CLT Floor Example – Panel Inputs
Deflection Limits
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 44
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 8 7
WOODWORKS® SIZER CLT Floor Example – Bearing Design
Supports for Bearing Design
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 8 8
WOODWORKS® SIZER CLT Floor Example – Bearing Design
Bearing Design Input
Applies to..
Type of Support
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 45
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 8 9
WOODWORKS® SIZER CLT Floor Example – Bearing Design
Bearing Design Input
Material, Species, Grade
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 9 0
WOODWORKS® SIZER CLT Floor Example – Load Input
DistributionType
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 46
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 9 1
WOODWORKS® SIZER CLT Floor Example – Structural Analysis Diagrams
Reactions
Bending
Total Deflection
Shear
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 9 2
WOODWORKS® SIZER CLT Floor Example – Structural Design Results
Panel Description
Analysis vs . Allowable Stress and Deflection
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 47
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 9 3
WOODWORKS® SIZER CLT Floor Example – Structural Design Results
Panel Description
Modification Factors
Material Properties
Analysis vs . Allowable Stress and Deflection
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 9 4
WOODWORKS® SIZER CLT Floor Example – Bearing Design Results
Bearing Design Summary
Support Description
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 48
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 9 5
WOODWORKS® SIZER CLT Floor Example – Fire Design
Protection
Required Resistance
Fire Exposure
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 9 6
WOODWORKS® SIZER CLT Floor Example – Fire Design
CLT Floor Panel, V2, 244-7 9-5/8” (12” Width) Typical 1’ Cross-Section
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 49
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 9 7
WOODWORKS® SIZER CLT Floor Example – Fire Design
Simplified Method Cross-Sectional Method
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 9 8
WOODWORKS® SIZER CLT Floor Example – Fire Design Results
Fire Design Summary
Critical Load Combination
Analysis vs . Allowable Stress and Deflection
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 50
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 9 9
WOODWORKS® SIZER CLT Floor Example – Vibration Design Procedure (CSA O86-14, Update 1)
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 1 0 0
WOODWORKS® SIZER CLT Floor Example – Vibration Design Results
Vibration Design Summary
Analysis vs . Allowable Stress and Deflection
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 51
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 1 0 1
WOODWORKS® SIZER CLT Floor Example – Maximum Panel Span
Maximum Design SpanDesign Ratios
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 1 0 2
WOODWORKS® SIZER CLT Floor Example – Maximum Loading Conditions
Live Load
Design Ratios
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 52
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 1 0 3
WOODWORKS® SIZER CLT Floor Example – Database Editor
Database Type
Member Type
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 1 0 4
WOODWORKS® SIZER CLT Floor Example – Database Editor
Material Properties
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 53
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 1 0 5
WOODWORKS® SIZER CLT Floor Example – Database Editor
Species Properties
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 1 0 6
WOODWORKS® SIZER CLT Floor Example – Database Editor Grade Properties
Material Properties
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 54
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 1 0 7
WOODWORKS® SIZER CLT Floor Example – Database Editor Section Properties
Panel Dimensions
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 1 0 8
POLLING QUESTION
7. The WoodWorks® Software performs which of the following design
a) Vibration Designb) Structural Designc) Fire Designd) All of the above e) (b) and (c) only
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 55
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 1 0 9
OUTLINECLT Building Examples
CLT - IBC, NDS, ANSI/APA PRG-320
CLT Floor & Roof Design Example
WoodWorks® Ex.
Current Code HappeningsResources
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 1 1 0
OUTCOMES OF ICC TALL WOOD AD HOC COMMITTEE: PROPOSALS AND DISCUSSION
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 56
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 1 1 1
I B C P R I N C I P L E S F O R H E A V Y T I M B E R A N D M A S S T I M B E R
mass timber ≠ conventional frame
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 1 1 2
I B C P R I N C I P L E S F O R H E A V Y T I M B E R A N D M A S S T I M B E R
mass timber ≠ traditional heavy timber
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 57
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 1 1 3
TWB PROJECT & COMMITTEEPROJECT SCOPE
In December/2015, the ICC Board established the ICC Ad Hoc Committee on Tall Wood Buildings noting the purpose of the ad hoc committee is to explore the building science of tall wood buildings and investigate the feasibility of and take action on developing code changes for tall wood buildings.
AD HOC COMMITTEEThe Board has determined that the effort is to be undertaken by the newly formed Ad Hoc
Committee on Tall Wood Buildings (AH-TWB). In making the committee appointments, the Board recognized the need to have a consensus committee comprised of the necessary balance of stakeholders including: • Representatives from building construction material industries
• Building and Fire Officials
• Architects and engineers
• Fire protection experts
• Other construction related stakeholders
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 1 1 4
TWO-STORY FIRE TESTS
• Purpose: Perform tests of realistic fire scenarios applicable to tall wood construction in order to evaluate occupant and firefighter tenability for egress and suppression efforts, and to provide data necessary to guide further development of relevant code and standard provisions
• Conducted at U.S. government facilities (ATF)
• Supervised by U.S. Forest Product Laboratory staff
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 58
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 1 1 5
14 TALL MASS TIMBER CODE CHANGESIBC Section 602.4 Type IV construction (G108-18)
IBC Section 703.8 Tested noncombustible protection contribution (FS5-18)
IBC Section 722.7 Calculated noncombustible protection contribution (FS81-18)
IBC Section 703.9 Sealing of adjacent mass timber elements (FS6-18)
IBC Section 718.2.1 Fireblocking materials (FS73-18)
IBC Section 403.3.2 High rise sprinkler water supply (G28-18)
IFC Section 701.6 Owner’s responsibility (F88-18)
IFC Section 3314.7 Fire safety during construction (F266-18)
IBC Table 504.3 (G75-18)
IBC Table 504.4 (G80-18)
IBC Table 506.2 (G84-18)
IBC Section 3102.3 Special construction (G146-18)
IBC Appendix D Fire Districts (G152-18)
IBC Sections 508.4.4.1 and 509.4.1.1 Fire barriers at separated occupancies and incidental uses (G89-18)
www.awc.org/tallmasstimber
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 1 1 6
TYPE OF CONSTRUCTION IV-C
Building Element
Maximum Height 85’
Number of Stories ≤9
Exposed Mass Timber Fully Exposed
Sprinklers Yes
Primary Frame FRR 2 hours
Floor FRR 2 hours
Stairs Tower Mass Timber
Concealed Spaces Permitted but must have protection
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 59
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 1 1 7
TYPE OF CONSTRUCTION IV-B
Building ElementMaximum Height 180’Number of Stories ≤12Exposed Mass Timber YES - PartiallySprinklers YesPrimary Frame FRR 2 hoursFloor FRR 2 hoursFire Resistance from Non-com
80 minutes
Stairs Tower Mass TimberConcealed Spaces Permitted but must
have protection
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 1 1 8
TYPE OF CONSTRUCTION IV-A
Building Element
Maximum Height 270’
Number of Stories ≤18Exposed Mass Timber NONE - Fully ProtectedSprinklers Yes
Primary Frame FRR 3 hoursFloor FRR 2 hours
Fire Resistance from Non-com
120 minutes
Stairs Tower Non-combustible
Concealed Spaces Permitted but must have protection
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 60
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 1 1 9
TALL MASS TIMBER TYPE OF CONSTRUCTION
https://awc.org/pdf/tmt/TMT-TypeofConstructionComparison-180316.pdf
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 1 2 0
I-CODE DEVELOPMENT
https://www.iccsafe.org/gr/Documents/HSTTP/ICC_CodeDevelopmentProcess.pdf
https://www.iccsafe.org/codes-tech-support/codes/code-development/current-code-development-cycle/
8-Step I-Code Development Cycle 2018
1. January 8 (ext. Jan. 11) - Code Changes Submitted2. February 28 - Code Changes Posted3. April 15-23 - Committee Action Hearing (Public
Hearing)4. May 15 - Committee Action Hearing Results Posted5. June 1-July 16 - Public Comments Sought on
Committee Action Hearing Results6. August 31 - Public Comments Posted7. Oct 24-31 - Public Comment Hearing8. Nov.-Dec.-online voting9. Fall 2020 - New Edition is Published
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 61
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 1 2 1
ICC PUBLIC COMMENT HEARINGS
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 1 2 2
AWC ECOURSE
https://awc.org/education/main/lists/des-design-considerations/des605-outcomes-of-icc-tall-wood-adhoc-committee-proposals-and-discussion
AWC recorded webinar
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 62
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 1 2 3
OREGON APPROVED ICC MASS TIMBER CODE CHANGE
https://www.oregon.gov/bcd/codes-stand/Documents/sam-18-01-tallwoodbldgs.pdf
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 1 2 4
SAMPLE OF MASS TIMBER PROJECTS
Carbon 128 storiesPortland, OR2018
T37 storiesMinneapolis, MN2016
Bullitt Center6 storiesSeattle, WA2013
Hudson3 storiesVancouver, WA2016
Framework5 storiesPortland, OR2015
Design Building4 storiesAmherst, MA2017
Biomass Boiler1 storiesQuincy, CA2018
Duke Lower & Middle Schools1 storyDurham, NC2009
West Virginia ES2 storyFranklin, WV2015
The Long Hall1 StoryWhitefish MT2011
Redstone Arsenal4 storiesHuntsville, AL2016
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 63
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 1 2 5
http://www.woodworks.org/wp-content/uploads/WoodWorks-June-2018-Mass-Timber-Projects-In-Design-and-Constructed-1.png
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 1 2 6
CLT
126
McDonald’s600 N Clark St. Chicago, IL
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 64
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 1 2 7
CLT
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 1 2 8
CLT
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 65
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 1 2 9
CLT
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 1 3 0
TALL WOOD http://awc.org/tallwood
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 66
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 1 3 1
RESOURCES
https://www.rethinkwood.com/node/1114/done?sid=10589
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 1 3 2
RESOURCES
https://www.structurlam.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/10/Structurlam-CrossLam-CLT-White-Paper-on-Diaphragms-SLP-Oct-2015.pdf
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 67
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 1 3 3
RESOURCES
www.awc.org• Print versions
• PDF versions
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 1 3 4
RESOURCES
Structure Magazine2018 NDS
2015 SDPWSJuly 2015
www.awc.org
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 68
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 1 3 5
TR-10 CLT WALL DESIGN EXAMPLE
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 1 3 6
BUILDING CODES AND STANDARDS EDUCATION
https://www.awc.org/education/livepresentations/requestform
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 69
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 1 3 7
AWC FIELD STAFF
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 1 3 8
EDUCATION
John “Buddy” Showalter, P.E.Vice President, Technology Transfer
Michelle Kam-Biron, P.E., SE. SECBSenior Director, Education
Lori Koch, P.E.Manager, Educational Outreach
https://www.awc.org/education/livepresentations/requestform
Live Presentations
1/16/2019
2019 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 70
Ta k i n g Wo o d t o t h e N e x t L e v e l 1 4 0
WOODWORKS® DESIGN OFFICE 12 SOFTWARE
SHEARWALLS
CONNECTIONS
SIZERGravity Design
Lateral Design (Wind and Seismic)
Fasteners
Concept mode
Column modeBeam mode
DATABASE EDITORAdd proprietary products
10% discount for AWC members Promo code: awc
For more information contact: