Deficiency of GPI of Leukocytes in Paroxysmal Nocturnal Hematuria

7
Deficiency of Glycosyl-Phosphatidylinositol-Linked Membrane Glycoproteins of Leukocytes in Paroxysmal Nocturnal Hemoglobinuria, Description of a New Diagnostic Cytofluorometric Assay By C. Ellen van der Schoot, Tom W.J. Huizinga, Elisabeth T. van ‘t Veer-Korth of, Rosemarie Wijmans, Jantina Pinkster, and Albert E.G. Kr. von dem Borne Paroxysmal nocturnal hemoglobinuria (PNH) is a disease tha t affects not only red cel ls, but other blood cel ls as well. The common defect is supposed to be an acquired defi- ciency of glycosyl-p hosphatidy linositol GPII -anchored mem- brane proteins, which may be present already at the hematopoietic stem cell level. Recently, a panel of mono- clonal antibodies (MoAbs) has become available directed against various GPI-linked membrane proteins. This makes it possible to study various cell lineages for the deficiency of such proteins in PNH in more detail. Using cytofluorogra- 20 PNH patients miss not only GPI-linked FcRlll (CD16 anti- gen). but also three other GPI-linked proteins, ie , CD24 antigen, CD67 antigen and a granulocyte-specific 50 t o 80 Kd antigen. The affected granulocytes were not only neutrophils but also eosinophils, as was found in a more detailed analysis of thr ee patients. Moreover , in all 10 PNH patients tested, the monocytes were found to be defici ent for the GPI-l inked CD14 anti gen, and we found with CD24 AROX YSMAL nocturnal hemoglob inur ia (PNH ) is an P cquired hematologic disorder characterized by inter- mittent intravascular PN H patients have abnor- mal erythrocytes, platelets, and granulocyte^^-^ that have an increased sensitivity to complement. Two types of PNH erythrocytes (PNH-E) have been recognized, based on differences in sensitivity to complement-mediated lysis.7 PNH-E type I1 are three to five times more sensitive to complement than normal red cells, PNH- E type I11 15 to 25 times mo re. 7 PNH-E with normal sensitivity are called P NH type-I cells. The increased sensitivity of the erythrocytes to complemen t (and pro bably of the other blo od cells as we ll) is due to the deficiency of cell-membrane-associated comple- ment regulatory proteins.’-” Decay-accelerating factor (DAF = CD55 antigen) is one o f th e missing proteins in PNH.’ In addi tion to DAF, PNH -E type 111 are deficient in the C8-binding protein (C8bp)9.’0 nd the recently described 18-Kd protein termed membrane inhibito r o f reactive lysis (MIRL = CD59 antigen).” Because DAF ,12 C8bp,I3 and MIRL as well as red-cell acetyl-ch~linesterase ’~ nother protein deficient in PN H, ” belong to the class of glycosyl- phosphatidylinositol (GP1)-linked membrane proteins, Davitz et a 1 suggested that the molecular defect i n P NH may lie in the posttranslational attachment of the GPI anchor.12 The demonstration of deficiency of two other GPI-linked cellular membrane proteins in PN H, LFA-3I6 and alkaline phosphat ase,” is in agreemen t with this hypothesis. Ho w- ever, it is not clear whether in PNH all or only a subset of GPI-linked membrane proteins is deficient. That PNH is a clonal disorder has been shown by glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase enzyme polymorphism studies.” The fact that abnormalities exist in red cells, granulocytes, monocytes, and platelets as well as in their precursor^'^-^' suggests tha t the lesi on specific for PN H is, at least in some patients, present in hematopoietic stem cells and CD55 (DAF) antibodies that lymphocytes may be involved as well. However, abnormal 6 and T lymphocytes were detected only in a subset of patients (2 of 1 0 tested). The uniform deficiency of GPI-linked proteins of granulo- cytes allows the introduc tion of a ne w diagnostic cytofluo- rometric assay for PNH with MoAbs against GPI-linked granulocytic antigens. This test was positive in all PNH patients studied and not in a group of 4 ontrol patients or 5 normal donors, with the exception of three of 16 aplastic anemi a AA) patients. In the three AA patients, (10 20 ) detected, whereas these patients had a negative acidified serum (Ham) test. This indicat es that t he n ew tes t is more sensitive than the Ham tes t and allows the early diagnosis of PNH in AA. An advantage of th e ne utrophil assay is that, in contrast t o th e Ham test, it is not influenced by recent red-cell transfusions. Moreover, it is possible to quantify th e number of affected cells by single cell analysis. 1990 by The American Society of Hematology. from which all these cell lines derive. However, it is not known whether all these blood-cell lineages in PNH are affected as well always. Recently, we as well as others demonstrated that the FcRIII of neutrophils (GD16) is GPI-linked.22.23y screen- ing a panel of MoAbs submitted to the Fourth Workshop o f Leucocyte Differenti ation Antigens, we identified three other GPI-linked proteins on granulocytes: the CD24 antigen, the CD67 antigen, and the antigen recognized by cLBgra11/5.~~ In this report, we demonstrate tha t all these GPI-anchored proteins are deficient on PNH granulocytes. In contrast to the supposed heterogeneity in red cell types in PN H, we did not find indications for t he ex istence of diffe rent typ es of affected granulocytes . By using MoAbs against GPI-linked antigens present not only on neutrophils (FcRIII and CLB- gran/5 antigens) but also on eosinophils (CD24 and CD67 From the Department of Immunological Hematology, Central Laboratory o f the Netherlands Red Cross Blood Transfusion Service, Laboratory for Experimental and Clinical Immunology. University o f Amsterdam; Department o f Haematology. Academic Medical Centre, Amsterdam: and Department of Pediatrics. Univer- sity Hospital Leiden. Leiden, The Netherlands. Submitted March 6,19 90; accepted July 9.1990. Supported by a grant from the Queen Wilhelmina Fund/ Netherlands Fou ndation fo r the Fight Against Cancer. Address reprint requests to C. Ellen van der Schoot. MD, c/o Publication Secretariat, Central Laboratory o f the Netherlands Red Cross Blood Transfusion Service, PO Box 9406, 1006 AK Amsterdam, The Netherlands. The publication costs o f this article were defrayed in par t by page charge paym ent. This article must therefore be hereby marked “advertisement” in accordance with 18 U.S.C. ection 1734 solely to indicate this fact. 990 by The American Society o f Hematology. 0006-4971/90/7609-0028 3.00/0 Blood, Vol76, No 9 (November 1 1 , 1990: pp 1853-1859 1853

Transcript of Deficiency of GPI of Leukocytes in Paroxysmal Nocturnal Hematuria

8/12/2019 Deficiency of GPI of Leukocytes in Paroxysmal Nocturnal Hematuria

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/deficiency-of-gpi-of-leukocytes-in-paroxysmal-nocturnal-hematuria 1/7

Deficiency of Glycosyl-Phosphatidylinositol-Linked Membrane Glycoproteins of

Leukocytes in Paroxysm al Nocturnal Hem oglobinuria, Description of a NewDiag nostic C ytofluorometric Assay

By C.Ellen van der Schoot, Tom W.J. Huizinga, ElisabethT. van ‘t Veer-Korthof, Rosemarie Wijmans, Jantina Pinkster,

and Albert E.G. Kr. von dem Borne

Paroxysmal nocturnal hemoglobinuria (PNH) is a disease

that affects not only red cells, but other blood cells as well.

The common defect is supposed to be an acquired defi-

ciency of glycosyl-phosphatidylinositol GPII-anchored mem-

brane proteins, which may be present already at the

hematopoietic stem cell level. Recently, a panel of mono-

clonal antibodies (MoAbs) has become available directed

against various GPI-linked membrane proteins. This makes

it possible to study various cell lineages for the deficiency

of such proteins in PNH in more detail. Using cytofluorogra-

phy, we could show tha t the granulocytes of 20 different

PNH patients miss not only GPI-linked FcRlll (CD16 anti-

gen). but also three other GPI-linked proteins, ie, CD24

antigen, CD67 antigen and a granulocyte-specific 50 to 80

Kd antigen. The affected granulocytes were not only

neutrophils but also eosinophils, as was found in a moredetailed analysis of three patients. Moreover, in all 10 PNH

patients tested, the monocytes were found to be deficient

for the GPI-linkedCD14 antigen, and we found with CD24

AROXYSMAL nocturnal hemoglobinuria (PNH) is anP cquired hematologic disorder characterized by inter-

mittent intravascular PNH patients have abnor-

mal erythrocytes, platelets, and granulocyte^^-^ that have an

increased sensitivity to complement. Two types of PNH

erythrocytes (PNH-E) have been recognized, based on

differences in sensitivity to complement-mediated lysis.7

PNH-E type I1 are three to five times more sensitive to

complement than normal red cells, PNH-E type I1115 to 25times more.7 PNH-E with normal sensitivity are called PNH

type-I cells. The increased sensitivity of the erythrocytes to

complement (and probably of the other blood cells as well) is

due to the deficiency of cell-membrane-associated comple-

ment regulatory proteins.’-” Decay-accelerating factor

(DAF = CD55 antigen) is one of the missing proteins in

PNH.’ In addition to DAF, PNH-E type111are deficient in

the C8-binding protein (C8bp)9.’0 nd the recently described

18-Kd protein termed membrane inhibitor of reactive lysis

(MIRL = CD59 antigen).” Because DAF,12 C8bp,I3 and

MIRL as well as red-cell acetyl-ch~linesterase ’~nother

protein deficient in PNH,” belong to the class of glycosyl-

phosphatidylinositol (GP1)-linked membrane proteins,Davitz et a1 suggested that the molecular defect in PNH may

lie in the posttranslational attachment of the GPI anchor.12

The demonstration of deficiency of two other GPI-linked

cellular membrane proteins in PNH, LFA-3I6 and alkaline

phosphatase,” is in agreement with this hypothesis. How-

ever, it is not clear whether in PNH all or only a subset of

GPI-linked membrane proteins is deficient.

That PNH is a clonal disorder has been shown by

glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase enzyme polymorphism

studies.” The fact that abnormalities exist in red cells,

granulocytes, monocytes, and platelets as well as in their

precursor^'^-^' suggests that the lesion specific for PNH is, at

least in some patients, present in hematopoietic stem cells

and CD55 (DAF) antibodies that lymphocytes may be

involved as well. However, abnormal 6 and T lymphocytes

were detected only in a subset of patients (2 of 10 tested).

The uniform deficiency of GPI-linked proteins of granulo-

cytes allows the introduction of a new diagnostic cytofluo-

rometric assay for PNH with MoAbs against GPI-linked

granulocytic antigens. This test was positive in all PNH

patients studied and not ina group of 4 ontrol patients or

5 normal donors, with the exception of three of 16

aplastic anemia A A ) patients. In the three AA patients,

subpopulations(10 to 20 ) of PNH granulocytes could be

detected, whereas these patients had a negative acidified

serum (Ham) test. This indicates that the new tes t is more

sensitive than the Ham tes t and allows the early diagnosis

of PNH in AA. An advantage of the neutrophil assay is that,

in contrast to the Ham test, it is not influenced by recentred-cell transfusions. Moreover, it is possible to quantify

the number of affected cells by single cell analysis.

1990by The American Society of Hematology.

from which all these cell lines derive. However, it is not

known whether all these blood-cell lineages in PNH are

affected as well always.

Recently, we as well as others demonstrated that the

FcRIII of neutrophils (GD16) is GPI-linked.22.23 y screen-

ing a panel of MoAbs submitted to the Fourth Workshop of

Leucocyte Differentiation Antigens, we identified three other

GPI-linked proteins on granulocytes: the CD24 antigen, the

CD67 antigen, and the antigen recognized by cLBgra11/5.~~In this report, we demonstrate that all these GPI-anchored

proteins are deficient on PNH granulocytes. In contrast to

the supposed heterogeneity in red cell types in PNH, we did

not find indications for the existence of different types of

affected granulocytes. By using MoAbs against GPI-linked

antigens present not only on neutrophils (FcRIII and CLB-

gran/5 antigens) but also on eosinophils (CD24 and CD67

From the Department of Immunological Hematology, Central

Laboratory of the Netherlands Red Cross Blood Transfusion

Service, Laboratory for Experimental and Clinical Immunology.

University of Amsterdam; Department of Haematology. Academic

Medical Centre, Amsterdam: and Department of Pediatrics. Univer-

sity Hospital Leiden. Leiden, The Netherlands.

Submi t ted March 6,19 90; accepted July 9.19 90.

Supported by a grant from the Queen Wilhelmina Fund/

Netherlands Fou ndation fo r the Fight Against Cancer.

Address reprint requests to C. Ellen van der Schoot. MD, c/o

Publication Secretariat, Central Laboratory of the Netherlands

Red Cross Blood Transfusion Service, PO Box 9406, 1006 AK

Amsterdam, The Netherlands.

The publication costs of this article were defrayed in par t by pag e

charge paym ent. This article must therefore be hereby marked

“advertisement” in accordance with 18 U.S.C. ection 1734 solely to

indicate this fac t.

990 by The American Society ofHematology.

0006-4971/90/7609-0028 3.00/0

Blood, Vol76, No 9 (November 11, 1990: pp 1853-1859 1853

8/12/2019 Deficiency of GPI of Leukocytes in Paroxysmal Nocturnal Hematuria

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/deficiency-of-gpi-of-leukocytes-in-paroxysmal-nocturnal-hematuria 2/7

1854 VAN DER SCHOOT ET AL

antigen), B lymphocytes (CD24 antigen and DAF), Tlymphocytes (DAF), and monocytes (CD14 antigen), we

found that the m embrane lesion specific for P N H could be

demonstrated on these cells as well. Because neutrophils,

eosinophils, an d monocytes deficient for GPI-lin ked proteins

could be demonstrated in all PN H patients tested, but only in

some patients affected lymphocytes, we assume tha t in P N Hthe abnormal cells are always derived at least from com-

monly affected progenitors (CF U-G EM M) . Therefore, it is

possible to introduce a new diagnostic test for P N H based on

th e cytofluorographic analysi s of the reactivity of Mo Abs

against G PI-linked proteins o n leukocytes and specifically on

the easily testable granulocytes. In contrast to t he standard

diagnostic red cell assays for PNH, the reliability of this

assay will not be influenced by previous red cell transfusions,

which a re often administered to P N H patients. Moreover, it

is possible to quantify the percentage of affected cells by

single cell analysis.

MATERIALS AND METHODSPeripheral blood was obtained from 12 patients with

previously diagnosed PNH and 8 patients with newly diagnosed

PNH. The latter 8 patients came from a series of 48 patients with

clinical suspicion for PN H, whose blood was sent to our laboratory

for routine screening in the acidified serum (Ham) test. In 17 of

these patients, th e diagnosis was confirmed by a positive H am test,

whereas in 2 patients the H am test (as well as the sucrose lysis test)

were only dubiously positive. In one patient, the Ham test and the

sucrose lysis test were negative. However, in this patient the

acetylcholinesterase content of the erythrocytes was lowered (0.23

pmol DT NB /min /L, normal values 0.25 to 0.40 pmol). Blood from

50 normal donors was analyzed as well. Furthermore, peripheral

blood was obtained from 16 patients (all children) with aplastic

anem ia with no clinical signs of increased hemolysis. None of these

patients had a positive Ham test, but in two patients the sucrose lysis

test was positive. T he cells of two p atients with th e ra re congenital

disorder here ditary eryth rocytic multinuclearity with positive acidi-

fied serum test ( HE M PA S) were also tested.

Cells were isolated from heparin-anticoagu-

lated peripheral blood. By Ficoll-Isopaque (6 = 1.077 g/cm3) centrif-

ugation the m ononuclear cells were separated from the granulocytes.

The red cells were removed by lysis in NH,CI. The granulocytes

were tested directly, th e mononuclear cells were tested either directly

or after cryopreservation in a medium containing 10 DM SO and

20 fetal calf serum (FCS). In the mononuclear cell fraction,

monocytes were recognized by their forward and side scatter in the

FACSCAN, T lymphocytes by CD3 antigen, B lymphocytes by

CD20 antigen, NK cells by C D56 antigen, and eosinophils by

CD9-antigen expression, respectively.Immunofluorescence. The cells were fixed in 1 (wt/vo l)

parafor malde hyde except for erythrocytes, which were tested un-

fixed. They were then incubated with the MoAbs in appropriatedilutions, washed with phosphate buffered saline (PBS) containing

0.2 (wt/vo l) bovine serum albumin (BSA) and subsequently

incubated with FITC-conjugated goat-anti-mouse Ig (GM17-01-FF, CLB) or phycoerythrin (PE)-co njugate d rat-anti-mouse kapp a-

chain (purchased from Becton Dickinson, Mountain View, CA ). In

case of double fluorescence experiments, the free antigen-binding

sites of the second antibody were blocked with irrelevant murine

IgG l and IgG 2a M oAbs. Thereafter, the cells were incubated with a

directly conjugated antibody. Th e fluorescence intensity (FI) was

quantified by flow cytom etry (FAC SC AN ). W hen cells were studied

Patients.

Cell separation.

in double-fluorescence procedures, at least 2,000 cells tha t were

reactive with the MoAb applied to recognize the leukocyte subset

were analyzed. The mean fluorescence intensity for the different

antibodies was expressed in arbitrary units on a linear scale after

subtra ction of t he mean fluorescence of cells incubated with a n

irrelevant isotype-matched antibody. The following MoAbs were

used: Leu4-PE (CD3, IgGl) , CLBthromb/l (CD9, IgGZa), CLB-

mon /l (CD14, IgGZa), CLB-B4.3 (CD15, IgM), CL BFcR gran/l

(CD16-FcRII1 , IgGZa) , Le ul lc -P E (CD 16-FcRII1 , Ig Gl ) ,

Leul6-PE (CD20, IgGl) , C LB-gran/Bly/l (CD24, IgGl) , ESIVC7

(CD36, IgGl) , BRIC llO (CD55-DAF, IgGl) , Leul9-PE (CD56,

IgG l), B13.9 (CD67, IgG l), CLBgran/lO (CD66, IgGl), and the

antibody CLB gran/5 (unclustered, IgG l), directed against a 50 to

80-Kd GPI-linked antigen of neutrophil̂ ^^^^^ The BRIC antibodies

were kindly donated by Dr D. Anstee (Oxford, UK), YTH53 .1 was a

gift of Dr H. Waldmann (Cam bridge, UK). Leu4-PE. L eul lc-PE,

Leul6-P E, and Leu l9-P E were purchased from Becton Dickinson.

The other antibodies were produced in our own laboratory and,

except for CLBgran/5, clustered in the International Workshops on

Leucocyte Differentiation Antigens. The monoclonal antibodies

agains t PI-linked antigens are listed in Table 1.

IgGl), BRIC5 (CD58-LFA-3, IgG), YTH53.1 (CD59-MIRL,

RESULTS

GPI-linked glycoprotein dejciencies of PNH granulo-

cytes neutrophils, eosinophils). The Ficoll-Isopaque gran-

ulocyte fraction from th e blood of all patients w as tested by

cytofluorography for the expression of the GPI-linked CD16

(FcRIII) , CD24, CD67, and CLBgran/5 antigens. This

fraction was not tested routinely with CD 55 (anti-DA F) or

CD58 (anti-LFA-3) antibodies. DA F and L FA-3 a re a lso

GPI-linked membrane proteins. However, their expression

on granulocytes is too low for reliable cytofluorographic

analysis (mean FI, 20 to 40, compared with a mean FI of 200

to 500 for the other antigens) . To make sure that theanalyzed cells (gate d on differences in light scatter ing) were

indeed granulocy tes, they were also tested for t he expression

of the granulocyte-specific nonGPI-linked CD 15 an d CD 66

antigens.

The granulocyte fraction consists mainly of neutrophils

an d contain s only a small num ber of eosinophils (1.5 to

5 ). Thu s, results of the overall cytofluorographic analysis of

this fraction reflect mainly but not entirely the neutrophil

antigen make-up. Fc RIII (C D16 antigen) and CLBg ran/5

antigens are expressed only on neutrophils and not on

eosinophils. Therefo re, also in normal donors a sm all popula-

tion of granulocytes negative for these an tigens exists.

Table 1. PI-Linked Proteins of Blood Cells

CD Antigen MoAb Expression

14 55Kd

16 FcRl l l

24 38/41 Kd

55 DAF

59 MlRL

67 100Kd

58 LFA-3

50-80 Kd

CLBmon/l Monocytes

CLBFcRgran/l Neutrophils

CLEgran/Bly/ 1 Neutrophils eosinophils

BR lC ll O Leukocytes erythrocytes

BRIC5 Leukocytes erythrocytes

YTH53.1 Leukocytes erythrocytes

8 13.9 Neutrophils eosinophils

CLBgran/5 Neutrophils

B lymphocytes

8/12/2019 Deficiency of GPI of Leukocytes in Paroxysmal Nocturnal Hematuria

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/deficiency-of-gpi-of-leukocytes-in-paroxysmal-nocturnal-hematuria 3/7

A FLUORESCENCE TEST FOR THE DIA GNO SIS OF PNH 1855

100

80

60

40

20

0

affected granulocytes

8

8

CONTROLIn-40)

A An.16)

PNHI n - 2 0 )

In all 20 P N H patients granulocytes were found that w ere

deficient for all the G PI-linked antigens. Besides this subset

of affected granulocytes (PNH-G), in all but two PNH

patients granulocytes with normal expression of GPI-linked

antigens were present. The percentage of PNH-G in the

different patients varied from 30 to 100 (Fig 1). These

percentages were similar for the different antibodies. Thereactivity of the antibodies with the PNH-G as measured by

fluorescence intensity, is shown in Fig 2. As expected, the

expression of the CD1 5 and C D66 antigens was normal. Notin all patients the P NH -G were completely deficient for the

GPI-linked CD24, CD67, and CLBgran/5 antigens. Al-though the measured fluorescence was extremely low in all

Fig 2. Mean fluorescence

intensities induced by CLB-

84.3 (CD15). CLBgran/ lO

(CD68). 813.9 (CD67). CLB-

granBly/l (CD24) CLBgran/5,

CLBFrCgranl (CD16I on the

granulocytes of 60 normal do-

nors ( and on the PNH-G of

20 PNH patients 0 ) .

mean FI log scale)

l o o k 8,

1 ° ~

CD15

Fig 1. Percentages of granulocytes deficient in

GPI-linked membrane p rotei ns in 20 PNH patients,

16 aplastic anemia patients, and 4 control pa-

tients. Granulocytes with a mean FI compared with

normal granulocytes of t 5 for CD67 (mean FI

t 1 0 U) and CLBgran/5 (mean FIt2 U) and 4 0

for CD16 (mean 4 0 0 U), were defined as affected

granulocytes.

cases, the P NH -G showed more than background reactivity

(arbitrare ly defined as FI >8 n these patients, notably with

CD24. In all 20 patients, the PNH-G still expressed FcRIII

(CD16) (F I from 15 to 80). Fluorescence intensity induced

by CD16 on the PNH-G showed a log normal distribution.

This means tha t only one subpopulation of similarly deficient

granulocytes existed in every patient tested.

The eosinophils of three PNH patients were studied in

detail. Eosinophils were recognized by the expression of C D9

antigen and their charac teristic light scatter. C D9 antigen

was shown to be expressed on eosinophils and not on

neutrophils.26 In all thr ee patients , subpo pulations of CD 67and CD24 antigen-deficient CD9-positive eosinophils were

CD68

=  -. C

?.. I

. ..

e

CD24

-.= =ad =. z

r -:.

..

go

CLBgranIC CD16

8/12/2019 Deficiency of GPI of Leukocytes in Paroxysmal Nocturnal Hematuria

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/deficiency-of-gpi-of-leukocytes-in-paroxysmal-nocturnal-hematuria 4/7

8/12/2019 Deficiency of GPI of Leukocytes in Paroxysmal Nocturnal Hematuria

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/deficiency-of-gpi-of-leukocytes-in-paroxysmal-nocturnal-hematuria 5/7

A FLUORESCENCE TEST FOR THE DIAGNOSIS OF PNH 1857

neutrophils deficient in GPI-linked proteins were not found.

Thus, the cytofluorometric test is both sensitive and specific

in the diagnosis of PNH. In a group of 16 patients (children)

with aplastic anemia, small subpopulations of affected neutro-

phils were detected in three patients (lo , 12 , and 19 ,

respectively). The Ham test was negative in all these three

cases, the sucrose lysis test was positive in two of the three. In

two of these patients (including the patient with a negative

sucrose lysis test) the erythrocytes were tested in the immuno-

fluorescence test. In both patients PNH-E could be detected

(Table 2). These children did not have clinical signs of

increased hemolysis and were not transfusion-dependent.

These patients will be described in more detail elsewhere.

Two HEMPAS patients were also studied and showed

normal expression of GPI-linked proteins on their neutro-

phils (data not shown).

DISCUSSION

In the present study we show that, in addition to the

previously described deficient GPI-linked membrane struc-

tures alkaline phosphatase,” LFA-3 (CD58),I6DAF (CD55),8

and FcRIII (CD16),22*23he GPI-linked CD24, CD67 anti-

gens and a 50 to 80-Kd protein are deficient on PNH

granulocytes.So far, all granulocyte antigens that have been

identified as GPI-anchored proteins are deficient in PNH.

These data strongly support the hypothesis that the common

defect in PNH is the deficiency of all GPI-anchored mem-

brane proteins.

The FcR-111 (CD16) was not totally absent from the

granulocytes (mean FI 15 to 80 U, Fig 2), whereas the other

three antigens were, in most cases, completely absent. In the

blood, FcRIII is expressed on neutrophils and NK cells. The

FcRIII of NK cells is a transmembranous form (FcRIII-2).

In contrast, the neutrophils have a GPI-linked form of

FcRIII (FcRIII-1).28Therefore, the expression of the FcRIII

on PNH neutrophils is unexpected. Compared with the other

GPI-linked antigens, the fluorescence ntensity obtained with

MoAb CLBFcRgran/ l (CD16) on normal neutrophils is

high due to the presence of 100,000 to 300,000 FcRIIIs per

ne~ t r oph i l . ~~hus, a possible explanation is that the defect in

PNH is never complete and that the remaining expression is

always above the detection limit only for FcRIII. However,

we were not able to reduce the expression of CD16 antigen by

digestion of the PNH neutrophils with glycosylphosphatidyli-

nositol-specific phospholipase (GPI-PLC) (results not shown).

Another explanation is that on neutrophils, besides theGPI-linked forms, other forms exists that are bound to or in

the membrane in yet an unknown way. Recently, such

alternate binding for FcRIII was shown by Kurosaki et a1 in

an experimental system.30 The FcRIII-1 precursor could

associate with the y-chain of FcRt13’ and become expressed

in this way on the surface of COS cells.

It has been hypothesized that the differences in comple-

ment sensitivity in PNH type-I1 and type-111 red cells are

due to qualitative differences between these cell types.

Type-I11 cells would have additional deficiencies for proteins

other than DAF (CD55 antigen), such as C8bp and MIRL

(CD59 antigen). However, recently, it has been shown that

PNH-E type I1 are deficient for MIRL as well,3’ which

suggests that only subtle quantitative differences in mem-

brane complement regulatory proteins underlie the variabil-

ity in complement sensitivity of PNH erythrocytes. Our

results on granulocytes and erythrocytes are in agreement

with this latter explanation. We did not find subsets of

differently affected granulocytes or erythrocytes in any

patient, whereas we did find relatively subtle quantitative

differences in the expression of GPI-linked membrane glyco-

proteins between the different patients (notably on granulo-

cytes). Possibly in some patients the deficiency is not com-

plete and leading to some expression of GPI-linked proteins.

The existence of abnormal granulocytes in PNH have

previously been de~cribed.~-~.”n agreement with this obser-

vations we found that in all our 20 patients deficient

neutrophils were present in the blood, though we cannot

exclude that in rare patients the neutrophils are normal.

Furthermore, we demonstrate for the first time that of the

granulocytes not only the neutrophils but also the eosinophils

are affected in PNH. This finding further supports the

stem-cell origin of this disease, as does the fact that mono-

cytes of all 10 patients tested were also affected, as demon-

strated by the deficiency of CD14 antigen.

Originally, it was thought that lymphocytes do not have

the membrane lesions characteristic of PNH.2.5.3Z owever,

Kinoshita et a16 found that lymphocytes from two of three

PNH patients showed decreased expression of DAF. We

found in two of 10patients low percentages (15 to 25 ) of

T lymphocytes that were deficient for DAF (CD55 antigen).

Furthermore, we demonstrated that B lymphocytes may be

involved in PNH as well. In the same two patients with

abnormal T lymphocytes, we found also B lymphocytes

deficient for the CD24 and DAF antigen.

These findings indicate that, in at least these two patients,

the disease arises in the totipotent stem cell. It was striking

that both patients with abnormal lymphocytes were patients

of whom 100 of the neutrophils were abnormal (Table 2).

The low percentages of abnormal lymphocytes may explain

the negative results in previous studies.

The standard diagnostic assays for PNH are based on the

abnormal sensitivity of the red cells for spontaneously

activating complement, such as in acidified serum33or to

complement activated by the classic pathway.34The diagno-

sis can be confirmed by the detection of a decreased acetylcho-

line-esterase content of the erythrocytes.” All these assays

are based on abnormalities of the red cells. Therefore, the

reliability of these tests is influenced by previous red-celltransfusions. Moreover, a decrease in acetylcholine-esterase

activity has been found in other diseases as well.35 The

cytofluorographic analysis of granulocytes might circumvent

these problems. An additional advantage is that the percent-

age of affected cells can be quantified, because the differ-

ences in expression of the GPI-linked antigens that we

studied between normal and abnormal cells were quite

prominent. To test the specificity of the immunofluorescence

assay, we tested the granulocytes of 60 patients with PNH,orclinical suspicion for PNH, in parallel with the Ham test on

their erythrocytes. In only one patient did we find a discrep-

ancy, eg, a negative Ham test result and PNH-G in the

immunofluorescence assay. However, in this patient, who

8/12/2019 Deficiency of GPI of Leukocytes in Paroxysmal Nocturnal Hematuria

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/deficiency-of-gpi-of-leukocytes-in-paroxysmal-nocturnal-hematuria 6/7

1858 VAN DER SCHOOT ET AL

had 50 abnorm al circulating granulocytes, the diagnosis

P N H could be confirmed by showing that the erythrocytes

had a decreased acetylcholine-esterase content. Further-

more, discrepancies were found in the group of 16 patients

with aplastic anemia (AA). In three of the 16 AA patients,

we found a subpopulation of PN H- G (10 to 20 ), whereas

t he H a m t es t w as n eg ativ e in al l. L ew is an d D a ~ i e ~ ~rigi-nally described t he association of P N H an d AA. Approxi-

mately 15 of the patients with AA develop PNH in the

course of their di~ease.~’ .~’herefore, we assume that our

three patients may develop clinical P N H in due time. The

discrep ancy between th e two tests possibly reflects the higher

sensitivity of th e cytofluorographic analysis.

We also studied two patients with a positive H am test d ue

to hereditary erythrocytic abnormalit ies (HE MP AS ; data

not shown). Both h ad only normal g ranulocytes in the

immunofluorescence assay. Th us, th e neutrophil GP I-linked

membrane protein test also allows an easy discrimination

between two different types of patients with positive Ham

tests, ie, PN H and HE MPA S.

In conclusion, in P N H neutrophils, eosinophils, an d mono-

cytes are deficient for all presently known GPI-linked mem-

brane proteins, as well as in some patients B a nd T lympho-

cytes. Based on these findings, we developed a simple

cytofluorometric assay on granulocytes which appeared to be

diagnostic for PN H an d also made the diagnosis of P N H in

aplastic anem ia possible.

ACKNOWLEDGMENT

We tha nk all the clinicians who have sent blood of P N H patients

to our laboratory , in particular D rs J.J. Michiels, R. G oudsmit, and

M.M.A.C. Langenhuysen, who provided blood of more than one

patient.

REFERENCES

1. Rosse WF, Parker CJ: Paroxysmal nocturnal haemoglobin-uria. Clin Hae matol 14:105, 1985

2. Vellenga E, Mulder NH, The TH: Paroxysmal nocturnal

hemoglobinuria. Neth J Med 26:138, 1983

3. Aster R H, Enright SE: A platelet and granulocyte membrane

defect in paroxysmal no cturnal hem oglobinuria: Usefulness for the

detection of platelet antibodies. J Clin Invest 48:1199, 1969

4. Stern M , Rosse W F Two populations of granulocytes in

paroxysmal noctu rnal hemoglobinuria. Blood 53:928, 1979

5. Nicholson-Weller A, Spice r DB, Austen K F Deficiency of the

complement regulatory protein, “decay-accelerating factor,” on

mem branes of granulocytes, monocy tes, and platelets in paroxysmal

nocturn al hemoglobinuria. N Engl J Med 312:1091, 1985

6. Kinoshita T, Medof M E, Silber R, Nussenzweig V: Distribu-

tion of decay-accelerating factor in the peripheral blood of normalindividuals and patients with paroxysmal nocturnal hemog lobinuria.

J Exp Med 162:75,1985

7. Rosse WF: Variations in the red cells in paroxysmal nocturn al

hemoglobinuria. Br J Haematol24:327, 1973

8. Nicholson-Weller A March JP, Rosenfeld SI , Austen K F

Affected erythrocytes of patients with paroxysmal nocturnal hemo-

globinuria ar e deficient in the com plement protein, decay-accelerat-

ing factor. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 80 :5066,1983

9. Zalman LS, Wood LM, Frank MM , Muller-Eberhard HJ:

Deficiency of the homologous restriction factor in paroxysmal

nocturn al hemoglobinuria. J Exp Med 165:572,1987

IO Hansch GM , SchonermarkS,Roelcke D: Paroxysmal noctur-

nal hemoglobinuria type 111-Lack of an erythroc yte mem brane

protein rest ricting the lysis by C5b -9. J Clin Invest 80:7, 1987

11. Holguin MH, Frederick LR, Bernshaw NJ, Wilcox LA,Parker CJ: Isolation and characterization of a membrane protein

from normal human erythrocytes that inhibits reactive lysis of the

erythrocytes of paroxysmal nocturnal hemoglobinuria. J Clin Invest

84:7, 1989

12. Davitz MA, Low MG, Nussenzweig V: Release of decay-

accelerating factor (DA F) from the cell mem brane by phosphatidyli-

nositol-specific phospholipase C (PIPL C). J Exp Med 163:1150,

1986

13. HBnsch GM , Weller PF, Nicholson-Weller A: Release of C8

binding protein (C8bp ) from the cell membrane by phosphatidylinosi-

tol-specific phosph olipase C. Blood 72:1089, 1988

14. Low MG , Finean JB: No n-lytic release of acetylcholines-

teras e from erythrocytes by a pho sphatidylinositol-specific phosph o-

lipase C. FE BS Lett 71:741, 1977

15. Kunstling TR, Rosse WF: Erythrocyte acetylcholinesterasedeficiency n paroxysmal nocturnal hemoglobinuria (PNH)-a com-

parison of the complement-sensitive and -insensitive populations.

Blood 33:607,1969

16. Selvaraj P, Dustin ML, Silber R, Low MG, Springer TA:

Deficiency of lymphocyte function-associated antigen (LFA-3) in

paroxysmal nocturnal hemoglobinuria. J Exp M ed 166: 1011, 1987

17. Burroughs SF, Devine DV, Browne G, Kaplan ME: The

population of paroxysmal nocturnal hemoglobinuria neutrophils

deficient in decay-accelerating factor is also deficient in alkaline

phosphatase. Blood 71:1086, 1988

18. Oni SB, Osunkoya BO, Luzatto L Paroxysmal nocturnal

hemoglobinuria: Evidence for mono clonal origin of abn ormal red

cells. Blood 36:145, 1970

19. Tumen J, Kline LB, Fay JW , Scullin DC, Reisner EG, RosseWF, Huang AT: Complement sensitivity of paroxysmal nocturnal

hemo globinuria bone-ma rrow cells. Blood 55: 1040, 1980

20. Kanamaru A, Okuda K, Ueda E, Kitani T, Kinoshita T,

Nagai K Different distribution of decay-accelerating factor on

hematopoietic progenitors from normal individuals and patients with

paroxysmal nocturnal hemoglobinuria. Blood 725 07 , 1 988

21. Dessypris EN , Gleaton J H, C lark DA: Increased sensitivity to

complement of megakaryocyte progenitors in paroxysmal noc turnal

haemoglobinuria. Br J Haematol69:305, 1988

22. Huizinga TW J, van der Schoot CE, Jost C, Klaassen R JL,

von dem Borne AEG Kr, Roos D, Tetteroo PAT: The PI-linked

receptor FcRIII is released on stimulation of neutrophils. Nature

333:667, 1988

23. Selveraj P, Rosse WF, Silber R, Springer TA: The major Fc

receptor in blood has a ph osphatidylinositol anch or and is deficient inparoxysmal nocturnal hemoglobinuria. Na tur e 3335 65, 1988

24. van der Schoot CE, Huizinga TWJ, Gadd S, Majdic 0

Wijmans R, Knapp W, von dem Borne AEG Kr: Identification of

three novel PI-linked proteins on granulocytes, in Knapp W (ed):

Leucocyte Typing IV. Oxford, UK , O xford University, 1990, p 887

25. Tetteroo PAT, Bos MJ E, Visser FJ, von dem Borne AEG K r:

Neutrop hil activation detected by m onoclonal antibodies. J Imm u-

no1 136:3427, 1986

26. Ohto H, Hitomi Y, Kambayashi H, Sa to T , Maeda H: CD 9

defined antigen (p24) is expressed on eosinophils but not on normal

monocytes, in McM ichael ed):eukocyte Typing 111.Oxford, UK,

Oxford University, 1987, p 73 1

27. Haziot A, Chen S, Ferrero E, Low M G, Silber R, Goyert SM :

The monocyte differentiation antigen, CD 14, is anchored to the cell

8/12/2019 Deficiency of GPI of Leukocytes in Paroxysmal Nocturnal Hematuria

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/deficiency-of-gpi-of-leukocytes-in-paroxysmal-nocturnal-hematuria 7/7

A FLUORESCENCE TEST FOR THE DIAGNOSIS OF PNH 1859

membrane by a phosphatidylinositol linkage. J Immunol 141547,

1988

28. Ravetch JV, Perussia B: Alternative membrane forms of

FcR III (C D16) on hu man na tural killer cells and neutrophils. J Exp

Med 170:481,1989

29. Huizinga TWJ, Kerst M, Nuyens JH, Vlug A, Von dem

Borne AEGKr, Roos D, Tetteroo P AT: Binding characteristics of

dimeric IgG subclass complexes to human neutrophils. J Immunol

142:2359,1989

30. Kurosaki T, Ravetch JV: A single amino acid in the glycosyl

phosphatidylinositol attachm ent domain determ ined the memb rane

topology of FcyR III. Na tu re 3422305, 1989

31. Holguin MH , Wilcox LA, Bernshaw NJ , Rosse W F, Parker

CJ: Relationship between the membrane inhibitor of reactive lysis

and the erythrocyte phenotypes of paroxysmal nocturnal hemoglo-

binuria. J Clin Invest 84:1387, 1989

32. Cooper MR, Currie MS , Rustagi PK, Logue GL: T lympho-

cytes escape membrane defect on paroxysmal nocturnal haemoglo-

binuria. Br J Haematol55:263, 1983

33. Ha m TH : Chronic hemolytic anemia with paroxysmal noctur-

nal hemoglobinuria: Stud y of the mechanism of hemolysis in relation

to acid-base equilibrium. N Engl J Med 217:915, 1937

34. Rosse WF, Dacie JV: Immune lysis of normal and paroxys-

mal nocturnal hemoglobinuria (PNH) red blood cells. I. The

sensitivity of P N H red cells to lysis by complement a nd specific

antibody. J Clin Invest 45:736, 196635. Lawson AA, B arr RD : Acetylcholinesterase in red blood cells.

Am J Hematol26:101, 1987

36. Lewis SM, Dacie JV: The aplastic anaemia-paroxysmal

nocturnal haemoglobinuria syndrome. Br J Haematol 13:236, 1967

37. de Planque MM, Bacigalupo A, Wursch A, Hows JM,

Devergie A, Frickhoven N , Brand A, Nissen C: Long-term follow-up

of severe aplastic anemia patients treated with antithymocyte

globulin. Br J Haematol73:121, 1989

38. Tichelli A, Gratwohl A, Wursch A, Nissen C, Speck B La te

haematological complications in severe aplastic anaemia. Br J

Haematol69:413, 1988