Deep Bay Improvement District

30
Deep Bay Improvement District November 20, 2013 1

description

Deep Bay Improvement District. November 20, 2013. BSI Developed Wells (suggested area). Recommendations from hydrologists (Pacific Hydrology and Guiton Environmental Consulting) are that new wells be developed outside the current small well field of the District. - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Transcript of Deep Bay Improvement District

Page 1: Deep Bay Improvement District

1

Deep Bay Improvement District

November 20, 2013

Page 2: Deep Bay Improvement District

2

BSI Developed Wells (suggested area)

Recommendations from hydrologists (Pacific Hydrology and Guiton Environmental Consulting) are that new wells be developed outside the current small well field of the District.

The area suggested could be on BSI lands.

Page 3: Deep Bay Improvement District

Does the water supply need protecting? What would be the cost to replace the entire

infrastructure of DBID? What is the current status of bylaws? What bylaws are needed? Request that DBID servicing standards

bylaw be established for very large developments

Protecting the Water Supply

3

Page 4: Deep Bay Improvement District

4

Does the water supply need protecting?

Page 5: Deep Bay Improvement District

5

The RDN Bylaw 500 provides protection for areas where the RDN provides water.  The RDN provides no protection to improvement districts or other water purveyors.

It is relatively rare for an improvement district to be faced with a development that would more than double demands for water.

Developers are there to make money. Shortcuts will be taken unless explicit rules are required.

Does the water supply need protecting?

Page 6: Deep Bay Improvement District

6

What would be the cost to replace the entire infrastructure of DBID?

$$$

Page 7: Deep Bay Improvement District

7

What Is the Cost of a Water System?

From the Deep Bay Capital Replacement Schedule: Original Cost to Build

Wells built in 1973 cost ~$75,000

Wells built in 1997 cost ~$145,000

Wells brought on line 2013: EPCOR $300,000

Estimated Replacement Value of DBID’s Infrastructure

The estimated cost to build the system uses the costs estimated by the McElhanney Water System Evaluation reported in February 2008 (based on 2007 costs).

These values were brought up to 2014 costs based on a 2% compounded inflation rate/year.

Page 8: Deep Bay Improvement District

8

2014 Estimated Replacement Value of DBID Water Works (adjusted for inflation @2%/yr.)

Description # Units Unit Cost Total CostNew Wells development

7 $300,000 est. from EPCOR 2013

$2,100,000

Pipelines 18,930 meters

$625/m (2007)$732/m (2014)

$13,862,676

Reservoirs 2 $1,296,165 (2007)$1,518,717 (2014)

3,037,433

Office/ Fire hall

Est. ? 2,000,000

$21,000,109This is probably understating the replacement costs. With inflation compounding at 2%/ year, the cost would go up by about $420,000/year.

Page 9: Deep Bay Improvement District

9

How Much Water Is Required By BSI?

Original estimates were 4 times over current usage.

Page 10: Deep Bay Improvement District

10

The original request was for more than 22 L/s or 4 times current usage. Was there a hidden agenda here to obtain twice as much water than was necessary in order to “transfer” what they didn’t need for the current property to other properties they may develop within the DB District?

Lantzville-Nanaimo Agreement included: Restrictions on provision of water (i.e., properties

within the boundaries of the District of Lantzville) and no resale of water.

Was BSI Acting in Good Faith?

There appears to be no protection in current DBID bylaws to prevent “transfer”

of water rights to additional properties owned by the developer

Page 11: Deep Bay Improvement District

11

RDN BYLAW NO. 500 SCHEDULE ‘7D’

COMMUNITY WATER SYSTEM STANDARDS

The RDN determines the requirement of “how much water is required” not the

developer.

Page 12: Deep Bay Improvement District

12

Phased Development Process

Page 13: Deep Bay Improvement District

13

However, Baynes Sound Investments (BSI) has just hired a

new hydrologist…Gilles Windling – GW Consultants GW Consultants are now testing Deep Bay’s water

system-- for “surplus” water This would indicate BSI is going for a “phased

development” pattern to get their foot in the door for a 700 unit proposal

What are the potential ramifications to residents of Deep Bay? BSI will continue with their high density development

application and re-apply in the near future.

Page 14: Deep Bay Improvement District

14

Phased Development ProcessSometimes called “the pay as you go” plan for developers

More than doubling the number of units currently serviced by DBID would also more than double demands for water. This would require a service structure that includes:• 7 wells• Equivalent sized reservoirs to DBID• Pipelines within the strata itself• Pipelines to link to the DBID water system

• The developer will only be required to pay $6,500/unit even if the actual cost to supply water services costs much more. This payment includes infrastructure he builds within the strata.

Current estimated replacement value of the DBID infrastructure:

$21 million Phase I may only be for 10 units. DBID may receive only $65,000RDN has requested a servicing commitment for the full 700 unit development. This would be a legally binding $21 million commitment for the DBID based on doubling the infrastructure for DBID.

There is no timeline given for this commitment in current bylaws. Shouldn’t this commitment only commit the district to maybe 5 years?

Page 15: Deep Bay Improvement District

15

“Surplus” Water

It is not “surplus” water when engineered into a purveyor's water system; the water supplier must plan for sufficient water supplies over average daily requirement to provide for:1) Peak water usage after 150 days without rainfall 2) Expected growth from fill in lots and smaller

subdivision of 2 to 10 lots3) Extended dry periods that last 2 or more years without

sufficient precipitation to fully recharge the aquiferSome developers attempt to call this engineered water supply “surplus”. This is “water piracy” . Without good bylaws requiring large developments to find and develop new water supplies then the district would be vulnerable to this form of piracy. (more on this later)

Page 16: Deep Bay Improvement District

16

What are DBID’s bylaws regarding new developments?

Page 17: Deep Bay Improvement District

17

Who is Responsible For Finding and Developing New Sources Of Water

Current bylaws in Deep Bay Improvement District

Page 18: Deep Bay Improvement District

18

Baynes Village Centre Water Services

Current process for the development of new water Deep Bay Improvement

District finds the water, applies for crown land approval, obtains engineering services, obtains hydrological services for well drilling, hires the well driller… etc.

oops.. No water $$$

Costs to Find Water The management and

administration of the process would likely require additional staff time or possibly additional staff

What would be the result of not being able to find additional water supplies – after committing water service to the development? Legal action by the developer

may result.

It now costs approximately $300,000 to bring a new well into

production. (EPCOR)

Page 19: Deep Bay Improvement District

19

DBID Bylaws Regarding Developments

Bylaw 201: Comprehensive Capital Expenditure Charge “The capital expenditure charges may be fixed for the sole purpose of providing funds to the improvement district to pay the capital cost of providing, constructing, altering, or expanding water facilities in order to service directly or indirectly, the development in respect to which the charges are fixed” (March 2008 – now more than 5 years old)Current charge: $6,500/unit Phased development:

Only 10 units built out of 700 – Charge: $65,000 Full Build out of development- Charge: $4,550,000The application of this bylaw would not provide sufficient funds to develop even one well in a phased development. There are no timelines required regarding completion of the development. The developer will profit when the land is sold with water rights.

Deficient Bylaw

The RDN has stated in Staff reports that all infrastructure must be completed before construction of homes will be allowed to begin. How is this bylaw going to work under this condition?

Page 20: Deep Bay Improvement District

20

DBID Bylaws Regarding Developments

Bylaw 169: Bare-Land Strata Subdivision Water Regulations

6. To assure adequate maintenance of the distribution mains, fire hydrants, and other fittings within the subdivision, the improvement district may enter into legal agreement with the Strata Corporation or strata council respecting maintenance and repair of the works.Problem:

• The distribution mains, etc., must become the property of the district – this would include necessary right-of-ways for access and fire protection.

• The last phased strata development (36 units) utilizing this bylaw resulted in incomplete payment of charges, legal actions and costs. What could happen with a 700 unit strata?

Deficient Bylaw

Page 21: Deep Bay Improvement District

21

What bylaws are needed?

Page 22: Deep Bay Improvement District

22

REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NANAIMO BYLAW NO. 500 SCHEDULE ‘7D’

COMMUNITY WATER SYSTEM STANDARDS

Learning from other water purveyors and their bylaws

Both the RDN and DBID operate under the Local Government Act. We can operate with similar bylaws and standards.

Page 23: Deep Bay Improvement District

23

RDN BYLAW NO. 500 SCHEDULE ‘7D’

COMMUNITY WATER SYSTEM STANDARDS

Features Not Found in DBID Bylaws

The developer is required to build the water system with theses specifications

Explicit requirements for: water demand fire flows Well drilling Professional designs

In addition Explicit requirements for:

Water storage volume Water distribution piping Service connections Fire hydrants Valves & Fittings Trenching and Backfill Water meters

Page 24: Deep Bay Improvement District

24

RDN BYLAW NO. 500 SCHEDULE ‘7D’

COMMUNITY WATER SYSTEM STANDARDS

Who will own the water system on completion?

Transferring the Water System Final Inspection Transfer Agreement by

Developer Maintenance Agreement Letter of Acceptance of the

Works by the RDN Dedications, easements and

right-of-ways

Financial Commitment of the Developer

Completion Date requirement that all work to be carried out and completed by that date.

If project is not completed by the “Completion Date”, the RDN may use the funds secured by the Letter of Credit to complete the work at the expense of the Developer.

The developer makes the financial commitment, not the community.

Page 25: Deep Bay Improvement District

25

RDN BYLAW NO. 500 SCHEDULE ‘7D’

COMMUNITY WATER SYSTEM STANDARDS

Forms included in Bylaw 500

Subdivision Servicing Agreement

Irrevocable Letter of Credit Letter of Assurance Certificate of Design Certification of Installed Works Fire Hydrant Use Permit Hydrant Certification Form

Transfer Agreement System of Works Certification of Installed Works Maintenance Agreement Wellhead Protection Report Standby Irrevocable Letter of

Credit Latecomer Agreement

The Developer pays the costs for development, not the community.

The developer pays for water used during construction

Page 26: Deep Bay Improvement District

26

RDN BYLAW NO. 500 SCHEDULE ‘7D’

COMMUNITY WATER SYSTEM STANDARDS

Developer Commitments

That all works become the property of the RDN

That the Developer shall give all prospective purchasers a copy of this agreement and covenants and bring to their attention that this agreement restricts their ability to apply for a building permits.

Appendix 2 & 3 Standard Drawings (16p) Approved Products List (5p)

Appendix 4-6 Letter of Assurance (commitment of

compliance) Certificate of Design

Appendix 7 & 8 Fire Hydrant Use Permit (charges

$2/cubic meter and damage deposit: water used during project development)

Fire Hydrant CertificationAppendix 9 & 13

Transfer Agreement Maintenance Agreement Various other required Agreements

Appendix 1Subdivision

Servicing Agreement

This would prevent the developer from selling properties until the water supply has been completed.

Page 27: Deep Bay Improvement District

27

RDN BYLAW NO. 500 SCHEDULE ‘7D’

COMMUNITY WATER SYSTEM STANDARDS

Why an equivalent bylaw should be used by DBID.

RDN Bylaw 500 is comprehensive Has been vetted by legal

advisors Has been developed by

professional engineers Has been tested by the

RDN to protect the RDN interests and services

Provides protection from

developers lawsuits Developer assumes all risks

and financial commitments The DBID would maintain

control with much less administration overhead than would be required under current bylaws of the district.

Page 28: Deep Bay Improvement District

28

1. Lakes District 2. Schooner Cove 3. Fairwinds Phased Developments must have a Phased

Development Agreement (PDA) before the property goes to zoning. This would include timeline requirements.

www.rdn.bc.ca/cms/wpattachments/wpID1185atID5792.pdf

RDN BYLAW NO. 500 SCHEDULE ‘7D’

COMMUNITY WATER SYSTEM STANDARDS

This Bylaw has been applied to the following developments:

Page 29: Deep Bay Improvement District

29

Request that DBID servicing standards bylaw be established based on the RDN Bylaw 500 Section ‘7D’

Without a similar bylaw DBID would be vulnerable to Large financial commitments Water commitments it may not be able to

provide Additional costs, including additional staff to

manage the development of new water sources

DBID

Page 30: Deep Bay Improvement District

30

Questions?