David Gill letter

15
FILED 1 ori=1;:E '< US DISTR:CT COURT to.O.N. . ..... ') ··:. * * \ ·,··. .. ·"'1 . ' ... ,,,. ______ - ·---·-· .. ·········-··· ·····--··- .. -····-· ··--···· - . .. -·--·· ..\.-01!::.FFl,(;E ____ .. __ . ________ .. . . ·-··- ____ -----··· ---···· _ ____ . --·-- _ u. s A..._..:il \ __ _.li...l.3 c R 0 - --- --++----------------- -------41-------------· -- ----- -----·--------··-- .. ---------- ------------H- ----------·----- =··------ ---- ····- . ·-···-· -- ··---· --tt--·...He>"Oro\?1,o CarnL .. ,Y . s\...b-1)lili:i•d G>w=+ Vis\...-;, l of "-1e...... i 'la __ _ Ee.&+ ·---·-------·· --- I I ? o I ---------!+---·-------··---·----··----- -----·------·------------·----·-------------·- Pefe,,,,. .. --- - ___ l4Me,,..h.i""' \-6 \.+ie """--· ____ _ ----------H=- yv1 .. i Ahr:>t:J>lf_fub...,;}\e,1, oh• ..m>' be..\.,.,J-£.h -------·-<+- •N h.e _dekrlM.: .,...c..+;o ... _d_ #i.e o.pf'CoFo'.Ak-i>ecite,.,,.. 4'-c --++--\Jo.,, i). .... .< &.± .f:ft+, \oel o•μ .. C.... v..r_L.'01..u...uJ..L _ __ "\e,.,,+&ve . .e. .. .caA.1.LL'OC.>r-y _ _ __ _ CCIN£6€ ot !Mp.Ci l'>Ql-'Me,.,,;_L ___________ ·····-··-· ·--·· Tu,. s,. .... +,. ...... ;.-.. 3 of l.'l..'£:LL1,1.\.e ........ 1L ____ _ C.W.paki€Noive C.ei"rn.e. ac+ _£'_ru."L)_-f2La..'.:.J.e.s_£,,: ... __ _ of i N'i'-5 _liu.L-...U.L;_u__ fY...i::li...<!..<:_..k. .. _ b.<;,..s;c_ __ _ 1>1.<a.Lmf1U.N iSh't>' <I."' t' .. t Q.-k(o...J 1 -------!+-"""'-... !pUNl1>\,.,..er.1t 1 ii h,-l;QN 'i?11rSah1\- b kt-i.e.... __ C.1•i-+ \o<',,'O.j. llJ1'4.;,,,. h"<- I 1\ C. C C <!S. e .. -...o.typi c 4 L .{ea._-bJ.;:--,__41ie__.,_<l__.o.,\ I c:wJ<. __ -i1,.,_ __ _ _gu; Je ii"'"':>.. °'"" A SizJ,J:e,,,..;e __ c&.sl .... 1., fuL_ ____ _ ·--------+r----------------·-------------- ---------------·---------. --------------- ---- ----" ----------- --- Case 1:13-cr-00487-CBA Document 514 Filed 03/25/15 Page 1 of 14 PageID #: 6463

description

David (Plot) Gill, 43, argues for leniency after he and his brothers were found guilty of the June 22, 1994 shooting death of Michael (Nims) Dawson, 23, on Staten Island.

Transcript of David Gill letter

  • . FILED

    1 ~ 1 (.L~ ''\':~ ori=1;:E '< US DISTR:CT COURT to.O.N. .

    ..... ') :. "':~:i- * * \,. .. "'1 . ' ... ,,,. --4-:anM_-__E~( ______ - ---- .. - --- .. -- -- - . .. ---

    -----------~-130001"\.LI.iNL'!.' ..\.-01!::.FFl,(;E ____ .. __ . ________ .. . . -- ____ ----- --- _ ____ .

    ---- _ u. s A..._..:il D,.,"~-..fu.~I \ __ -~------------~-----tt-----=~---------~."Oro\?1,o CarnL \?vi..~l .. ,Y ~ . s\...b-1)lili:id G>w=+

    Vis\...-;, l of "-1e......i 'la r.~---- __ _ ---------+f-~~,__.._(_,.a.._.cl."'-"""""""'ou,....~~ Ee.&+ ---------- ---

    ---------+1---"S.,.,,cooouls..,.b"""\~-Y;i.ck. I I ? o I

    ---------!+----------------------

    -----------------------------------------

    ------~Th~"- Pefe,,,,. ,..IQ.,,_L-~Lkil .. ...r.e&tJee.~--~lo>1.i:l:s --- --------------+1-_tili.6~.\l::,lct:c.C ___ ~--- l4Me,,..h.i""' \-6 \.+ie Se...bc-~ ~_m._.,..J...., """-- ____ _ ----------H=- yv1 .. i Ahr:>t:J>lf_fub...,;}\e,1, oh ..m>' be..\.,.,J-.h Of>Si.L-~UL .\:k~------------ecite,.,,.. 4'-c

    --++--\Jo.,, i). .il~.fi.i.r._h..e...__r-a .... .< &. .f:ft+, \oel o T_hi.~ .. C....v..r_L.'01..u...uJ..L _ __ "\e,.,,+&ve -~--~---~_Ll,__kfi~~-\p.eloo,i ~ . .e. .. .caA.1.LL'OC.>r-y _ _ __ _

    -IJ---'~ti..1.

  • ..

    --------"4-------~-------- --- ------------------ ----- __ ._ __

    ' :beA rtaN~e _Cet,.seQ C. 3ss3 Ca,) (y) ,CcA) (!f); \3.oc,\ce.- 1 5'13 .u._s_ __ g,_L !U.'-1

    Not poy;,,i.L__k 'f'Y ~ (..,.,,;J,fjN"'.S, ' ' . k) tt..te.wi__~ CANs . ..d.ex--L1:_....J

  • .

    ---------- -------- --- - ---- ------------------- -~------------------------------- --------- ---- -

    _Th.,.t __ _\;,lo!)_i.i_ __ ~_o.l! ~ Oi&~N~I ,:t>\.,. ~ le.v9..I s. or homic.i..k ------ I ~.vi. Q...S lk-~- al-a.~ cJl_ ~i~..-\ QnfJ ~~ ~c____a.L __

    -------------- --~Ni"'5 _ _/)L~h.e,,..--~ nff'roprall t.. c ,!,,,. ,,._ ___ ~------'" ' ,, - mul ~-iple deo4.s - - re.1il W I ON,l \.!,..., 'NleN - ~~-~b>_c_;;,_,______ - --------

    .s Sk 2 - j,i ' Cct.-4,.\ucj.. Cai1; c.v Sb{cMcu\=) _LQ__ \11~ M I> -------'rfi fke v i c..,\-i b1 ,.,, (AJCoh5ful Ca+c:l' irk Co N 1;-1 ~ -I-a f>CO\~ j l"'j-t\A e ctr,._,,, s.e h-\., 0 \1\oc

    ' \1...e c_o.,,ct~"e-- e d.4....\c. .... 1- ky-~----- ------------- -- ___ \ll_cli_i\

  • .

    ------- f----------------------------- ------------------------ ----------------------- --- -- - - ---

    (2) Th~-- c\o "'':I_., C r--eo 50 .... ..la\~ pt>ec "e.l \Jed "'/ \.!,,,, dLJ,,"'l,-- __ -- ~-- \ N du .l.i N!l \iie \J ;cl{""' ,., X--.Pf U ha h'oN foe \I'\ o\ etvce ---------

    ----------- ~-------------------- ---- --------------------------------------------

    (3) TL., .-.r.A~~ 1-ke "cJ.t ' (Nd' IC t- Q~~ '-"")' e.ff.,ek_ ____ I \11 $

    -ht 1-ke cie.'...,, d"' I A: 6 11 ~llet>ld: C0~1~~ b:. \-; "" ' -----------------------

    -81-Awt--_$e.- ff! le II c, t.J..\- C 0bJc..\.w r .\- loy ~ Ii; c:.b"" \.ceb h> .1. - -- - --

    -- -------------

    Tr-', c.LL ON; d, j>1.Ce es\-o \,.,li$laeJ, \.he ' !:> ' \)IC """$. t1 Co"''JQ I c.,.~d____:_.__g_-t ____

    ------- - --

    - ---------- --------(,, 1\Ab \J t . ..- I~. - - _ _)'VI.~\._ '\2)a41S.,0N p>lleJ I >p ' ""i.::. Cqc b 1N --.u.b \ .... /_L,.._ ~~ hie de:h-.. dc;...1\-;,_ O+.J.. p' )\ (e.,.\, 0 Mac~

    ""' ' ,.. . 1.l. .['_ ,1_,A_ 4-.-, J l\.)k of' ku'b ('a.< -Hae. .. 'f'O; .-...\-e). Set Me I u

    ' lf'V'.l -._rL.~ - -. ' _, deh:.,.>.c...,t ~~S&~I C--::.1,\ -j-{,.---...u8ki l"!.ia --v r.lrn liQ r .:. ti J'>L o;.,.e Tr 260 - 26l - -- - - - -- --- -- --I

    -- -~) Tue ~;e-h~ VV\i,.ld:ecii ~l!'!l~.dbii f\ C:e d "-'.: ~'5cbin.tt1: ~- ---------

    I """ ......_., '0"1ec

  • -------------- -

    ------------

    -

    - -----------

    -

    -

    ---

    ------------

    -

    --

    -

    ..

    ---------------

    --------------

    ---

    ------~-------- ----- ---

    -----

    -----------

    -

    -

    --------

    ------------

    .. - -------- --------

    -- - - - --------- ~-- --r----- ------ -------

    QNd acme.A ON). doN'l::JC>'>Y::; LA.>:!- ' l0 N I

    iN\.-icA_ ~a_..,,. ___ _

    \ tuao"'ed, MQN i...r-,i k-ie. \,,e::id a,.,,,_,A, Ski a\> l .l.e 'C . -~---~----- \V>.r/" ~~1e J. loy \:1...~-~.,..J,c,,.,1f 1 ~ u:; .a. 0 toQ S..Cl~!::.il)af l 'J -~"e"' N l .&1~1' cj,., ~

  • -

    -

    -

    -----.

    -

    -

    -

    --- --

    --

    --

    --

    ------

    -------

    -----

    -

    --~---------- ---------- --- ---------- ------------- ------------------

    I. ed. Olhl l.l I o\1.,,v iNd-,\J\ ~ l,;(.I,_~~ po.rl __ al_ 4.e ~trcJ.e,-r 1:. .f'~d \., o r-n\,_~~_.... p..zc~a ... 1 _i..o_s.k..

    LJ_ J. ..I - ' '-' .s ... 8 .--,,t= _:\-b..d -r- fLAc....,s.__--UNAbl-ce . ..6 \,.,Ave 't --5e.e......_ .I.' .. CbM(Nj ANJ pc-e..ve,,tk.d _;_i {',.,,.,, bapf'; Ni "'et~ H.,,,u BAJ e-< Ho.~-- l.J.. acn-;;.teJ ON l.'N~\qb,.J. Q.\,.,4 l le k \.-

    __j_ Oiz.+:e,,.Jg IN.\. 1,,; ~ e.s_..hL_

  • ---------------- ------------------------------ -------------- ------------ - ---- -

    be pro+edeJ =_,.,__a.,...-f--~""""---CS-~-~rn~"'--~~. _

    ----~ defu1da,_1~ w:l1 t,v>lo"'-"aef--.M. abie ~--~-""y.-- ____ _

    Cc~Me '$t> :+s. o._ deterr.eAi;c.C ___io __ ('cjY""iNo..l Cei'"""~'c1. . ..,____ili.__e_ __ ----------------------++--~}e.,.cg will r-e?'k:cf ~ Sedo11=ok CP"f'ec.j.- _b:,.r::__.j-l.,.,..,..p,__1.ic:.."""...,""---------- -----------------------------++-- ___ _____ _ __ ____ _f'o.c:_l-we .C.-egoi "5- Cawc. ___________________ _

    ---------- __ ~>\cl. SeNbc:R j-1,i.e. Dpf:.,_ . ..\., ..,,-\-

    ----------+---------------------- ------------------- ---------

    --------++---- -----------------_______ Q,..,,cedfulb- &....io11.1~i-k.!._ ------1+----------------------------------Laar.:d~-- ---

    ----------#-------------------------- ---------- --- ----------- -

    --------j+-------- --------------------------------------

    -----------#------------------------------------------------------

    -------------!+------------------------- --------- -----------:

    ---------Hf-----------------------------------------------------------------------------

    ------------1+-------- --------------- ------------------ ..

    ---------- -++------ - ------------------------------------

    -----------++-------------------------------------------------

    ----------H-------------------------------------------------------

    ----------#---------------------- -- - ----------- ------------ - -----

    ----------++------------------- --------------------- --------------------

    ------fj- -------------------------------------------

    -------------------- --- ---

    ------- ---------------------------- ----- -------- -------------------------------

    ------------ --- -------------------------------------- ----------------

    Case 1:13-cr-00487-CBA Document 514 Filed 03/25/15 Page 7 of 14 PageID #: 6469

  • -~--L--- --- ----- - - ----- --- ----- ---- --------------- -- __ d(~Ji~J/Jj_f) ! ------- --- -- -y ------- -u-----------__ --__ ---- -------- ------- ------

    -----.---. ~ l~ L -n&~~n1L f n\Cm \~ ~q lr ____ _ -~~--~ in 1 -~?;on. f/L--121etUt$__~~h ___ -*9----~---_bJs___,_ _ __ ';o)'l__J)a.l_S_~f\_ __ k~b '-~-- __

    _ *~ Qro..s1J_ __ __s.ho_ s D >ift_ i ' '(\ !,(,( \{ ~

    Case 1:13-cr-00487-CBA Document 514 Filed 03/25/15 Page 8 of 14 PageID #: 6470

  • -- -t--H ---- -- ------ - ---------------- -t- - ------------ - - - ----t-~ ----------------------- --

    -+-----..-.---------- ---- - -- -- - -------- ------ -- --- --- --

    ' --------+------ -i 1 --- - -'

    I --- - --~----------- -- -- ----- ------- -- -------------- ------------~----- ------ -

    Case 1:13-cr-00487-CBA Document 514 Filed 03/25/15 Page 9 of 14 PageID #: 6471

  • ... ----- --------- - -- -- - --_-[

  • ~---POUC.E. LASORAT'ORY

    ., ... -... '' 'IFJli-"' ,I.

    .. l

    .-..

    ANA\ TSU REPORT. PD s;t't-151 (REV.11~.

    -- .... .... ... SIH't

    . ON--------..,..-,,,,.--------- T>NG IJfMS us~ ilao1'f._ .. .... LI ..... , - .............. - ~

    '. - .....

    ~'.-lllS'S

  • J.~!?""' .~"'1/BDCC {NI J: vocm:ncm UJ.:Sptay

    Staten Island Advance (NY)

    December 30, 1993

    100G BAIL IS SET IN SHOOTING CASE INCIDENT OCCURRED ON CHRIS1MAS DAY

    ADVANCE STAFF REPORT Staten Island Advance

    Bail was set at $100,000 yesterday for a Clifton man charged with attempted murder for the Christmas Day shooting of a 30-year-old man. In Stapleton Criminal Court yesterday Judge Michael J. Brennan ordered Michael Dawson, 23, of Vanderbilt Avenue, held in lieu of the high bail pending a court appearance Jan. 3.

    Dawson allegedly shot Niyyi Fayemi in the head and shoulder around 10 p.m. on Christmas night at the corner of Vanderbilt Avenue and Turgee Street, court records show.

    The defendant is additionally charged with assault and criminal possession of a weapon.

    Scoftlaws arraigned

    'IWo scoftlaws arraigned yesterday were released on their own recognizance pending additional court dates.

    Eugene Aquino, 28, of Amber Street Oakwood, was stopped Tuesoay around 8:30 o.m. m uomran iiiiL after he was allegedly speeding down Jefferson Avenue. A computer check showed ne nad 20 susoens1oc:.. on his license.

    At 11:15 p.m. Tuesday, police stopped Thomas McKennan, 30, of Alexander Avenue, Annadale, after he allegedly drove passed a stop sign on Tynan Street in Annadale. He also had 20 suspensions on his license, police records show.

    Aquino and McKennan are expected to return to court Jan. 27 and Feb. 2, respectively.

    Criminal Court

    Copyright, All Rights Reserved.

    Case 1:13-cr-00487-CBA Document 514 Filed 03/25/15 Page 12 of 14 PageID #: 6474

  • r

    PEilP 1

    PERP 2

    s

    """ PERP 2

    PERP 1

    PERP 2

    5-i ~ Home Telephone

    ol;I .DI Perpetrators ~ '""

    ~poo

    UseG C PossesseG

    Position I Relationship '"' Date of Birtti All De111:ribe eapon 1rearm. give c or. ma e. ca re, lype, mode. e c.

    a11ted Arrested Last Name. First, M.t.

    c Address, Include City, State, Zip Apt. No fin. Pel.

    c Date o rth Age Heg 1 Ha1r olor Hair Length Fae! Hair NY 10 No

    Su Race Date of Birth Age Height Weight Eye Colir Hair Color Hair Lengtll Facial kair

    :tl--rl~,,:.,:,:,,:,..::-\[]=rc,c,:.,o.:,,..::'T-~'--~.1...~c"c.1...~--''"cL-~_JL..~~_JL..~~_JL..~~~_1_~~~~~~J_~~~~~---l l-"'-"""""-"""""""-1 Clothing Descrlptkm. Nlc~name. first Nili'llll. A!Jas Scars. Marks, M.0 .. Etc.

    Clltlllnue In o.11111s ..

    AREA WITHIN BOX FOR DETICT!VE/LATEHT FINGERPRIHT OFFICER ONLY. THIS BOX Will BE UTILIZED BY INVESTIGATOR WHENEVER POSSIBLE AND MUST BE FULLY COMPLETED WHEH USING THIS FORM TO CLOSE A CASE "NO RESULTS." Comp. lnterviewi:d D Yes D No

    Witness Interviewed 0 Yes D No

    Canvass Conducted ::J Yes D No

    Complalflant Viewed Photos O Yes D Refused

    Wil118SS Vlel'ffl(I PhotOG W Yes 0 Refused Crime Scae Ousted

    D Vos D No

    In Ptlrson Sy Phone "'" D D In Person ey l'tlone "'" D D II Yes - Make Entry in Body Re: Time,

    Names, Addressas, Rasul!s

    Results: 0 Future

    Results: 0 Future

    By (Enter Results In Oetal!s)

    Tlma

    """ '"

    Results Same as COl!lp. Report - Dlflerant (Ex$llaln In Details) Cl D

    Results: Same as Comp. Rep0l1 - Olflerent (Explain in Details)

    Crime Scl!ne Visited OYes ONO

    Crime scene Photos 8Ves ONo

    D D 11 Yes - Make Enlrtl ln Delaijs Re: Time, Date,

    Evidence Obtained

    By (Enlllr Results in Details)

    If Closing Casa "No Results," Check Appropriate Brue and Stale Justification in Detalls: Oc-1 Improper Referral OC-2 Inaccurate Facts OC-3 No Evidence I C811't ID OC-'I Uncooperative Complainant Oc-5 "Leads" Exhausted

    DETAILS:, Investigation: Homicide Content.a: Note in Body of Report

    7 1. At apprximately 1640hrs on the date above I the undersigned was pre.sen

    PERP1 at the 122pct and received a phone call from one Herman Dawson. He stated at this tim.e that he had the gun that I was looking for and that he was

    PERP~ enroute t:o the 122pct with same. I met the above at the side entrance of th 122 pct were he surrendered a gray p+astic bag. This bag contained two oth

    8 plastic bags gray and white which had a M-11 9mm and a loaded clip with te

    PERPl rounds. See Voucher #F372257. He added that he unloaded the above for safet reasons

    PEP.1'2 2. One Tisha Felder who was also present at the 122pct ID the above 1hnrn

    PERP 2

    "

    " CHOICE '

    CHOICE

    '

    PERP 2

    " PERP 1

    ""''

    as Michaels Dawsons stating that she has seen aame numerious times in his 23 9

    posesion. PEftl'1 PERP13. In reply to questions Herman Dawson stated thBt at about 1600hrs this at

    he received a phone call from. a fem.ale unknow to him who told him that the PERP 2 ~RP package_your looking for is at the phone booth at VanderVilt and Bay stee

    lie then left 491 VAnderbilt av~- his mothers residence and walked to the above location. There he found behind the phone booth on the ground the above package containing the 9 mm.

    "

    I. Case Active

    tASE

    0ACTIVE 0CLOSED REPORTING

    OFFICER:

    REVIEWING/ CLOSING

    SUl'tRVISOR:

    RANK

    ,. Dot

    DATE REVIEWED/CLOSED

    SIGffAT E

    I .J -( EHTEA DESIGNATION

    ORB

    IF ACTIVE. DATE OF NEXT RfVIEW

    NAME PRINTED Flannery

    SIGN.~.TURE.

    000001816

    """ ""

    Case 1:13-cr-00487-CBA Document 514 Filed 03/25/15 Page 13 of 14 PageID #: 6475

  • I . .,, .. .

    '/: .. ,

    Case 1:13-cr-00487-CBA Document 514 Filed 03/25/15 Page 14 of 14 PageID #: 6476

  • . .

    7. 0 [

    ""' j

    -' 0

    j

    ,,

    ~

    "

    \)

    p

    , , .

    Case 1:13-cr-00487-CBA Document 514-1 Filed 03/25/15 Page 1 of 1 PageID #: 6477