Cyber Risk, Profitability & Corporate Resiliency...s Intra-organizational benchmarking to compare...

21
NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION Cyber Risk, Profitability & Corporate Resiliency June 1, 2017 1 NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 19 th Annual Norway Ship & Offshore Finance Forum

Transcript of Cyber Risk, Profitability & Corporate Resiliency...s Intra-organizational benchmarking to compare...

Page 1: Cyber Risk, Profitability & Corporate Resiliency...s Intra-organizational benchmarking to compare cyber risk management capabilities among parallel business units for in-depth analysis

NOT  FOR  DISTRIBUTION  

Cyber Risk, Profitability & Corporate Resiliency June 1, 2017 1  NOT  FOR  DISTRIBUTION  

19th Annual Norway Ship & Offshore Finance Forum

Page 2: Cyber Risk, Profitability & Corporate Resiliency...s Intra-organizational benchmarking to compare cyber risk management capabilities among parallel business units for in-depth analysis

NOT  FOR  DISTRIBUTION  

Who We Are

HudsonAnaly+x,  Inc.  offers  integrated  risk  management  and  technical  advisory  services  to  the  global  mari@me  industry.  Clients  include:  

•  Port  Authori@es  &  Terminal  Operators  •  Na@onal  and  regional  port  systems    •  Integrated  oil/gas  companies  •  Na@onal  oil  companies  •  Global  mari@me  transporta@on  companies  •  Insurance  Companies    •  Governments  

Opera+ng  Divisions:    •  HA  -­‐  Cyber  -­‐  Mari+me  Cybersecurity  &  Risk  Mgmt.  •  HudsonSystems  -­‐  SoLware  Solu@ons  •  HudsonTrident  -­‐  Security  (Physical  &  Opera@onal)  •  HudsonMarine    -­‐  Opera@onal  Marine  Management  •  HudsonTac+x  -­‐  Consequence  Management  

2  

Key  Facts:    

•  Established  in  1986  •  Worldwide  Presence:  

•  Philadelphia  (Global  HQ)  •  Washington,  DC  •  Sea[le,  WA  •  San  Diego,  CA  •  Houston,  TX  •  Copenhagen,  Denmark  •  London,  UK  •  Rome,  Italy  •  Piraeus,  Greece  •  Jakarta,  Indonesia  (JV)  •  Manila,  Philippines  

©  2017  HudsonAnaly@x,  Inc.  

Page 3: Cyber Risk, Profitability & Corporate Resiliency...s Intra-organizational benchmarking to compare cyber risk management capabilities among parallel business units for in-depth analysis

NOT  FOR  DISTRIBUTION  

Cyber Risk Management Practice

3  

•  Technology  agnos@c  

•  Tailored   execu@ve   training   and  exercises  

•  Unique   capabili@es   tailored   to   the  global  mari@me  and  energy  markets  

•  Blended,   standards-­‐based,   maturity-­‐model   assessment   approach   -­‐   the  HACyberLogix  plaform  

•  Tailored   cyber   threat   intelligence   -­‐  informed  by  “a[ack  side”  

•  Facilita@on  of  cyber  risk  transfer  

•  Global  reach  Ship-­‐owners  &    Operators  

 Offshore  

Ports  &  Terminal  Operators  

 

Waterside  Facili+es  

 

©  2017  HudsonAnaly@x,  Inc.  

Page 4: Cyber Risk, Profitability & Corporate Resiliency...s Intra-organizational benchmarking to compare cyber risk management capabilities among parallel business units for in-depth analysis

NOT  FOR  DISTRIBUTION  

Clausewitz and … Cyber Risk?

4  

He  Recognized:  •  War  is  a  poli%cal,  social  and  military  phenomenon.  

•  Asymmetries  can  defeat  the  perceived  superiority  of  the  defense.  

©  2017  HudsonAnaly@x,  Inc.  

Page 5: Cyber Risk, Profitability & Corporate Resiliency...s Intra-organizational benchmarking to compare cyber risk management capabilities among parallel business units for in-depth analysis

NOT  FOR  DISTRIBUTION  

What is Cybersecurity?

Cybersecurity is NOT: •  Information Technology (“IT”) • Compliance (e.g. ISO; ISPS Code) • Solved by a “silver bullet” approach Cybersecurity IS: • A risk management activity delivering a standard of care • About cultural change and business transformation • The mission of protecting the entire business (the Balance Sheet) • A responsibility that starts at the top (you!)

5  ©  2017  HudsonAnaly@x,  Inc.  

Page 6: Cyber Risk, Profitability & Corporate Resiliency...s Intra-organizational benchmarking to compare cyber risk management capabilities among parallel business units for in-depth analysis

NOT  FOR  DISTRIBUTION  

Cyber Risk Begins and Ends with the Human

6  ©  2017  HudsonAnaly@x,  Inc.  

 •  Service-­‐Oriented  Ecosystems  

•  Crime-­‐as-­‐a-­‐Service  •  Targe%ng-­‐as-­‐a-­‐Service  

•  Networking  /  Social  events  •  Tac@cs,  techniques,  procedures  and  strategies  are  shared  

•  Training  /  lessons-­‐learned    •  Broker  ecosystems  •  Na@onal  teams  •  “Trench  @me”  

Page 7: Cyber Risk, Profitability & Corporate Resiliency...s Intra-organizational benchmarking to compare cyber risk management capabilities among parallel business units for in-depth analysis

NOT  FOR  DISTRIBUTION  

–  Involves everyone!

• Home • Work

–  It is asymmetrical – Easily executable – Affects the entire organization –  Is persistent – Financially rewarding – Evolved from a luxury to a necessity

7  

Exploiting Trust Relationships

©  2017  HudsonAnaly@x,  Inc.  

Page 8: Cyber Risk, Profitability & Corporate Resiliency...s Intra-organizational benchmarking to compare cyber risk management capabilities among parallel business units for in-depth analysis

NOT  FOR  DISTRIBUTION  

The IRISL Hack (2011)

8  

•  Servers  were  compromised  •  Logis@cs  systems  crashed  •  En@re  fleet  of  172  vessels  was  

compromised  •  False  informa@on  input  into  systems:  

•  Compromised  manifests  •  Falsifica@on  of  rates  •  Containers  ‘cloaked’  •  Delivery  dates  •  Client  /  Vendor  Data  

•  Major  Business  Interrup@on!  

©  2017  HudsonAnaly@x,  Inc.  

Page 9: Cyber Risk, Profitability & Corporate Resiliency...s Intra-organizational benchmarking to compare cyber risk management capabilities among parallel business units for in-depth analysis

NOT  FOR  DISTRIBUTION  

So What’s Vulnerable? (Hint: Everything)

•  Supervisory  Control  &  Data  Acquisi@on  (SCADA)  equipment  and  Industrial  Control  Systems  (ICS)  for  loading  /  unloading  of  bulk  /  containerized  cargo  

•  Cargo  /  Terminal  Management  Systems  •  Domain  Awareness  /  Naviga@onal  Systems  -­‐  RADAR,  AIS,  VTS/

VTMS,  ECDIS,  VDR,  etc.  •  Any  Business  SoLware  Applica@on  (e.g.  email,  financial,            human  resources,  finance,  logis@cs,  business  opera@ons            Think  “ERP”)  •  Any  Opera@ng  System  (e.g.  MicrosoL,  Linux)  •  Any  Security  System  -­‐  CCTV,  Access  Control  •  Any  Mobility  device  and  plaform  (RFID)  •  Communica@ons  Systems    •  Employees  (insiders)  and  Contractors  

9  ©  2017  HudsonAnaly@x,  Inc.  

Page 10: Cyber Risk, Profitability & Corporate Resiliency...s Intra-organizational benchmarking to compare cyber risk management capabilities among parallel business units for in-depth analysis

NOT  FOR  DISTRIBUTION  

Nor Shipping 2017

Cyber  Risk   10  

Is  this  a  modern  ba[lefield?  

Page 11: Cyber Risk, Profitability & Corporate Resiliency...s Intra-organizational benchmarking to compare cyber risk management capabilities among parallel business units for in-depth analysis

NOT  FOR  DISTRIBUTION  

Business Leaders Are Left with a Range of Unanswered Questions

11  

•  What  do  we  invest  in?    •  How  much  do  we  budget?  •  What  are  our  priori+es?  •  How  do  we  know  what  to  buy?  •  How  can  we  measure  the  effec@veness  of  our  investments?  

•  Are  our  cybersecurity  investments  sustainable?  

©  2017  HudsonAnaly@x,  Inc.  

Page 12: Cyber Risk, Profitability & Corporate Resiliency...s Intra-organizational benchmarking to compare cyber risk management capabilities among parallel business units for in-depth analysis

NOT  FOR  DISTRIBUTION   12  

WHAT CAN YOU DO ABOUT IT?

©  2017  HudsonAnaly@x,  Inc.  

Page 13: Cyber Risk, Profitability & Corporate Resiliency...s Intra-organizational benchmarking to compare cyber risk management capabilities among parallel business units for in-depth analysis

NOT  FOR  DISTRIBUTION  

What is Cybersecurity Capability Maturity?

13  ©  2017  HudsonAnaly@x,  Inc.  

Cybersecurity   Capability Maturity   analysis   defines  an  organiza@on’s  cyber  ecosystem,   iden@fies   the  depth  and  breadth  of  deployed  capabili@es,  establishes  benchmarks  to  support   long-­‐term  measurement,  and  serves  as  the  primary    mechanism   for   sustaining   the   organiza@on’s   cybersecurity  strategy  and  investments.  

Page 14: Cyber Risk, Profitability & Corporate Resiliency...s Intra-organizational benchmarking to compare cyber risk management capabilities among parallel business units for in-depth analysis

NOT  FOR  DISTRIBUTION  

Cybersecurity Capability and the Cyber Risk Reduction Curve

•  Ini@al  investments  should  be  in    cyber  capability  development—  to  protect.  

•  As  risk  curve  fla[ens,  cyber  insurance  becomes  an  efficient  means  to  further  reduce  risk.  

•  Cybersecurity  capability  maturity  informs  risk  transfer.  

•  Harmonizing  investments  in  technological  and  financial  controls  requires  be[er  exposure  and  loss  metrics.  

Axio provides cyber risk engineering services and data an-alytics to support the improved management of cyber risk, including the deployment of cyber insurance. We work with private and public sector organizations to help them better understand and manage their exposure to cyber risk through cybersecurity program evaluations and cyber loss scenario development and analysis.

ABOUT US

Much of our work is performed for or in collaboration with the insurance industry; we are on the forefront of developing and enabling improved cyber insurance products that protect firms in the energy sector and other sectors for which physical damage, environmental damage, and bodily injury from cyber risk are real concerns.

The core of our data analytics work is the Axio knowledge center, which aggregates data from our ser-vices and other sources to provide a basis for cyber program capability benchmarks, modeling, and other data sciences to improve the understanding of cyber risk losses and associated predictive indicators. Our vision is that the rich data provided through our collaboration with the insurance industry will ultimately provide insight into predictive indicators for cyber loss that materially advance cybersecurity knowledge.

AXIO PROCESS Equiatem poreni ut ipienda et et ilic tem quid unt prae sapis samus simusci dessimus as suntota turem. Itatem sus. Equiatem poreni ut ipienda et et ilic tem quid unt prae sapis samus simusci dessimus as suntota turem. Itatem sus.

CYBER INSURANCE AS A CONTROL The Ultimate Value Proposition: Insight and analysis from Axio’s Cyber Risk Knowledge Center enables

clients to deploy risk transfer capacity to lower their overall risk.

SERVICES Equiatem poreni ut ipienda et et ilic tem quid unt prae sapis samus simusci dessimus as suntota turem.

Itatem sus. Equiatem poreni ut ipienda et et ilic.

ABOUT US CYBER INSURANCEAXIO PROCESS OUR SERVICES AXIO KNOWLEDGE CENTER

MORE INFORMATION

CONTACT US

“Et ati as ut eum cus nisim vel in nossi ut rehendunt auditatusa voloriorum sam qui dolupta

verios ant eum qui doluptatio. Et volorrore necum quibus eosam fugitam.”

“Et ati as ut eum cus nisim vel in nossi ut rehendunt auditatusa voloriorum sam qui dolupta

verios ant eum qui doluptatio. Et volorrore necum quibus eosam fugitam.”

“Et ati as ut eum cus nisim vel in nossi ut rehendunt auditatusa voloriorum sam qui dolupta

verios ant eum qui doluptatio. Et volorrore necum quibus eosam fugitam.”

“Et ati as ut eum cus nisim vel in nossi ut rehendunt auditatusa voloriorum sam qui dolupta

verios ant eum qui doluptatio. Et volorrore necum quibus eosam fugitam.”

1 2 3 4 5

Policy AnalysisIdentify gaps in current insurance coverage.

Understand the types of impacts from potential cyber events that are not covered by

your currentinsurance.

Cyber Loss ScenariosDevelop notional and feasible cyber loss scenarios.

Workshop to brainstorm several cyber lossscenarios that could lead to covered and uncovered impacts; estimate total potential cost of each.

ProgramEvaluationEvaluate cyber risk management capability and maturity.

Evaluation based on Cybersecurity

Capability Maturity

Model (C2M2).

Cyber Risk EngineeringDetailed impact analysis, frequency estimation, and loss control.

More in-depth cyber loss scenario development and analysis than in step 2.

Insurance PlacementWith brokers and insurers, secure meaningfulcoverage.

Various new coverage forms and enhanced existing forms are becoming available.

Catastrophic cyber risktranfer capacity lowersthe curve overall.

CYBERSECURITY CAPABILITY

RISK

INVEST IN

TECHNOLOGYINVEST IN

TRANSFER

FOR INSURERS

Scalable cybersecurity program evaluations and benchmarking to

support underwriting, ranging from online self-evaluations to onsite

in-depth evaluations.

Data collection and analysis to monitor systemic and aggregation risk

and to improve cyber loss models.

Technology support for evaluations, data collection, and analysis.

Training and consulting services to better enable insurers and broker

partners to address the full range of cyber risk with clients.

FOR POLICYHOLDERS

Policy analysis to identify and understand cyber exclusions in

existing policies.

Scenario workshops to develop and analyze cyber loss scenarios.

Scalable cybersecurity program evaluations and benchmarking, ranging

from online self-evaluations to onsite in-depth evaluations.

Intra-organizational benchmarking to compare cyber risk management

capabilities among parallel business units for in-depth analysis of

large organizations.

Cyber risk engineering services to in-depth loss scenario analysis,

control, and modeling.

FOR BROKERS

Policy analysis to identify and understand cyber exclusions in existing

policies in support of specific clients or market analysis.

Consulting services for design and placement of bespoke cyber

insurance solutions such as captives to address unique client needs.

Training and consulting services to better enable brokerage teams to

address the full range of cyber risk with clients.

Axio Knowledge Center Equiatem poreni ut ipienda et et ilic tem quid unt prae sapis samus simusci dessimus as suntota turem.

Itatem sus. Equiatem poreni ut ipienda et et ilic.

Sign me up! Email Us

NEWSLETTER Iquem turit iniquideo, consum patus liquamIquem turit iniquideo,

CONTACT US

Address

address

Phone 000.000.0000

ABOUT US

NEWS

ENGAGE WITH US

LEGAL

Benchmarks

Cybersecurityprogram

evaluations

Loss and claims for insurance

partners

Pedictive Models

Aggregation and systemic risk analysis

Publications

Cyber risk and insurance

training and consulting

Loss scenariodevelopment

and engineering

Aggregated data from Risk Engineering services,

open sources, and

insurance industry

DATA SOURCES

KNOWLEDGE CENTER

INVEST IN CYBER CAPABILITIES!

SUSTAIN CAPABILITY & INVEST IN INSURANCE!

Courtesy: Axio

©  2017  HudsonAnaly@x,  Inc.  14  

Compliance  

Page 15: Cyber Risk, Profitability & Corporate Resiliency...s Intra-organizational benchmarking to compare cyber risk management capabilities among parallel business units for in-depth analysis

NOT  FOR  DISTRIBUTION  

Not All Threats Are Created Equal™

Delivering Unique, Maritime-Specific Cybersecurity Insights and Support

©  2017  HudsonAnaly@x,  Inc.  15  

Page 16: Cyber Risk, Profitability & Corporate Resiliency...s Intra-organizational benchmarking to compare cyber risk management capabilities among parallel business units for in-depth analysis

NOT  FOR  DISTRIBUTION  

What is HACyberLogix?

16  

What  is  HACyberLogix?  It’s  an  easy-­‐to-­‐use,  cloud-­‐based  tool  specifically  designed  to  support  

shipping  companies  in  cost-­‐effec@vely  assessing  and  managing  cyber  risk.    

Who  is  HACyberLogix  for?  It  was  designed  for  shipping  company  owners  and  execu@ves  with  profit  

and  loss  responsibili@es.      

What  does  HACyberLogix  do?  It  facilitates  organiza%on-­‐wide  cybersecurity  self-­‐assessments  and  

provides  customized  guidance  for  managing  the  complexi@es  of  cyber  risk.        

 Why  use  HACyberLogix?  

To  drive  con@nuous  improvement  in  cybersecurity  capability  across  the  en@re  company  by  efficiently  alloca@ng  precious  resources:  

 people,  tools  and  funding.    

©  2017  HudsonAnaly@x,  Inc.  

Page 17: Cyber Risk, Profitability & Corporate Resiliency...s Intra-organizational benchmarking to compare cyber risk management capabilities among parallel business units for in-depth analysis

NOT  FOR  DISTRIBUTION  

Getting to the Point: Informing the Decision - Making Process

©  2017  HudsonAnaly@x,  Inc.   17  

Page 18: Cyber Risk, Profitability & Corporate Resiliency...s Intra-organizational benchmarking to compare cyber risk management capabilities among parallel business units for in-depth analysis

NOT  FOR  DISTRIBUTION  

Recommendations are Automated and Prioritized

©  2017  HudsonAnaly@x,  Inc.   18  

Page 19: Cyber Risk, Profitability & Corporate Resiliency...s Intra-organizational benchmarking to compare cyber risk management capabilities among parallel business units for in-depth analysis

NOT  FOR  DISTRIBUTION  

Key Outputs…

©  2017  HudsonAnaly@x,  Inc.  

Mari<me  Transporta<on  Cybersecurity  Capability  Assessment*  cover  page  (date  &  @me  stamped)  

Execu+ve  Summary  includes  dynamic  visualiza@on  of  

assessment  ac@vity  (heat  map  represents  aggregated  results)  

Scoring  is  aggregated,  normalized  and  

dynamically  visualized  by  for  the  overall  assessment  

and  by  DMIL  Survey.    

Recommenda+ons  are  generated  and  priori@zed  based  on  assessment  

inputs.  Related  document  management  supports  

audit  efforts.  

19  

Page 20: Cyber Risk, Profitability & Corporate Resiliency...s Intra-organizational benchmarking to compare cyber risk management capabilities among parallel business units for in-depth analysis

NOT  FOR  DISTRIBUTION  

Managing Cyber Risk Begins at the Top

Managing   Directors,   CEOs   and   Board   Members   are   increasingly   being   held  accountable   for   their   organiza@on’s   cybersecurity.     Cyber   risk   management  must  be    owned  by  leadership.    Cyber  risk  affects  an  organiza@on’s:    

•  Balance  Sheet  /  Profit  &  Loss  •  Legal  Exposure  •  Opera+onal  Effec+veness  •  Customers  (Reputa+on!)  •  Vendors  •  Partners  •  Employees  •  You  

  20  ©  2017  HudsonAnaly@x,  Inc.  

Page 21: Cyber Risk, Profitability & Corporate Resiliency...s Intra-organizational benchmarking to compare cyber risk management capabilities among parallel business units for in-depth analysis

NOT  FOR  DISTRIBUTION  

Thank You!

Ferry  Terminal  Building  Suite  300  2  Aquarium  Drive  Camden,  NJ    08103    Office:    +1.856.342.7500  Mobile:  +1.301.922.5618  Email:  max.bobys@[email protected]  

Max  Bobys  VP,  HA  -­‐  Cyber    

Ferry  Terminal  Building  Suite  300  2  Aquarium  Drive  Camden,  NJ    08103    Office:    +1.856.342.7500  Mobile:  +1.609.505.6878  Email:  cynthia.hudson@[email protected]  

Cynthia  Hudson  CEO  &  Founder  

©  2017  HudsonAnaly@x,  Inc.   21  

Floor:      K  -­‐  2    Room:      “ARIEL”