Customizing the KAP survey

Target audiences question 1Which of the following statements best describes you [choose only one]: -You are a fisher that fished at least 1 time in the past month near the Tandayag / Bio-os Marine Sanctuary, - You are a fisher that fished at least 1 time in the past month in the Tandayag / Bio-os Marine Sanctuary, - You are a gleaner that gleaned at least 1 time in the past month near the Tandayag / Bio-os Marine Sanctuary, - You are a gleaner that gleaner at least 1 time in the past month in the Tandayag / Bio-os Marine

Section 1 (by enumerator)

• Sampling methodology• [ ] random [ ] selected for target audience

=> Add all the TA in your sampling methodology

Suggestion:After question on profession

If fisherman, what kind of gear do you use?Gill netBobo – Fish trapHook and lineSpear fishing

TV/RADIO questionKEEP IF THERE IS ANY CHANCE THAT YOU WOULD BE ABLE TO

BROADCAST ANYTHING ON TV(13) In the past month, would you say that you usually watch television, never, up to 3 days per week, 4 to 6 days per week, or 7 days per week?KEEP IF THERE IS ANY CHANCE THAT YOU WOULD BE ABLE TO BROADCAST ANYTHING ON TV[ ] Never [ ] Up to 3 days per week [ ] 4 to 6 days per week [ ] 7 days per week (A) Which TV stations do you watch most of the time? Please tell me up to 3 TV stations that you like to watch. KEEP IF THERE IS ANY CHANCE THAT YOU WOULD BE ABLE TO BROADCAST ANYTHING ON TV- [ ] ABS-CBN [ ] GMA [ ] TV5 [ ] ANC [ ] No favorite [ ] Don't know [ ] Don't watch [ ] Other

________________ (B) When you watch TV during the week, Monday to Friday, what are the most likely times for you to watch TV? Please indicate up to 2 times during the day

when you are most likely to watch.KEEP IF THERE IS ANY CHANCE THAT YOU WOULD BE ABLE TO BROADCAST ANYTHING ON TV, OTHERWISE REMOVE QUESTION[ ] Before 6:00 a.m. [ ] 6:01 a.m. to 10:00 a.m. [ ] 10:01 a.m. to 2:00 p.m. [ ] 2:01 p.m. to 6:00 p.m. [ ] 6:01 p.m. to 10:00

p.m. [ ] After 10:00 p.m. [ ] No particular time [ ] Off and on all day [ ] Don't know [ ] Don't watch/listen

(C) When you watch TV during the weekend, Saturday to Sunday, what are the most likely times for you to watch TV? Please indicate up to 2 times during

the day when you are most likely to watch.KEEP IF THERE IS ANY CHANCE THAT YOU WOULD BE ABLE TO BROADCAST ANYTHING ON TV, OTHERWISE REMOVE QUESTION[ ] Before 6:00 a.m. [ ] 6:01 a.m. to 10:00 a.m. [ ] 10:01 a.m. to 2:00 p.m. [ ] 2:01 p.m. to 6:00 p.m. [ ] 6:01 p.m. to 10:00

p.m. [ ] After 10:00 p.m. [ ] No particular time [ ] Off and on all day [ ] Don't know [ ] Don't watch/listen

Preliminary Objectives

Preliminary Obj. => Question => SMART Obj.

TA1: 200 Fishermen from Tandayag MPA stop intrusion into Tandayag MPA

Preliminary objective:People who say they intrude goes downIntrusions into Tandayag MPA go down

=> People who say others intrude goes down

Question(20) I am going to read you a list of 6 statement about following regulations of

the Tandayag / Bio-os Marine Sanctuary. I would like you to listen to all 6 statements, then tell me which one statement best represents you:

[ ] I have never considered following the regulations of Tandayag / Bio-os Marine Sanctuary [ ] I have considered following the regulations of Tandayag / Bio-os Marine Sanctuary but don't want to do so [ ] I intend to follow the regulations of Tandayag / Bio-os Marine Sanctuary in the next 6 months. [ ] I have talked to someone about following the regulations of the Tandayag / Bio-os Marine Sanctuary in the past 6 months. [ ] I often follow the regulations of Tandayag / Bio-os Marine Sanctuary but not at all times. [ ] I have always followed the regulations of Tandayag / Bio-os Marine Sanctuary in the past 12 months. [ ] Behavior not relevant to this respondent


Question(36) I am going to read you a number of statements

about the management of the local no-take area. For each statement, I would like you to tell me if you strongly agree, agree, disagree, or strongly disagree with it.

(COHORT QUESTION)(C) Local people know boundaries of the no-take area[ ] SA [ ] A [ ] D [ ] SD[ ] NS/DK


(41) I am going to read you a list of different types of fishers, and for each one, I would like you to tell me whether you remember seeing someone like that fishing in this area in the past 6 months (show the NTZ on a map of the area but don't mention whether it is NTZ or not)

COHORT QUESTION - SHOW MAP LABELLED A (EACH CF WILL HAVE TO CREATE THEIR OWN MAP)

(A) Subsistence fishers from your village[ ] Seen [ ] Not seen [ ] Not sure / Don't remember



TA1: 200 Fishermen from Tandayag MPA stop intrusion into Tandayag MPA

Preliminary objective:Intrusions into Tandayag MPA go down

SMART:The % of respondents who say they have seen subsistence fishermen in the NTZ (when shown a map of the site) in the least 6 months will go down from 55% to 30 % (a decrease of 15pp)

Result chain

Preliminary Obj.

Survey question SMART Obj.

KAICBRBCTRCR

Removing the Bias

Leading questionsDouble barreled (2 in one)Order of questions

Types of bias

Top tips

Make sure for questions it is clear what the correct answers is

Make sure for every question there is a NATranslation

Instructions for enumerators

• (32) Who should primarily enforce the rules and regulations of Tandayag / Bio-os Marine Sanctuary? Should it be the Coastguard, Fishers/gleaners, the Bantay dagat, the National Police, local village officials, or someone else? (CHOOSE ONE ONLY)

• [ ] Coastguard [ ] Fishers/Gleaners [ ] Bantay Dagat (licensed enforcers) [ ] National Police[ ] Local village officials [ ] Other ________________


• (C) Local Residents know who and when guarding takes place and so are able to enter Tandayag / Bio-os Marine Sanctuary when the guards are not there

• [ ] Strongly Agree [ ] Agree [ ] Disagree[ ] Strongly Disagree

(20) I am going to read you a list of 6 statement about following regulations of the Tandayag / Bio-os Marine Sanctuary. I would like you to listen to all 6 statements, then tell me which one statement best represents you: CHOOSE ONLY ONE

[ ] I have never considered following the regulations of Tandayag / Bio-os Marine Sanctuary [ ] I have considered following the regulations of Tandayag / Bio-os Marine Sanctuary but don't want to do so [ ] I intend to follow the regulations of Tandayag / Bio-os Marine Sanctuary in the next 6 months. [ ] I have talked to someone about following the regulations of the Tandayag / Bio-os Marine Sanctuary in the past 6 months. [ ] I often follow the regulations of Tandayag / Bio-os Marine Sanctuary but not at all times. [ ] I have always followed the regulations of Tandayag / Bio-os Marine Sanctuary in the past 12 months. [ ] Behavior not relevant to this respondent


• (55) Please name 3 creatures that live in the sea that you are particularly fond or proud of. (do not read out options but tick box as appropriate and/or fill in the blank for any additional answers)

• FLAGSHIP SP QUESTION - 1st OPTION• [ ] grouper "lapu-lapu" [ ] giant clam [ ] giant

sea fan [ ] XXX ADD OPTIONS AS APPROPRIATE [ ] XXX ADD OPTIONS AS APPROPRIATE [ ] Other ________________ [ ] N/A


Choosing & Training enumerators

Choosing & Training enumerators

• Enumerators “neutral” in the community• Should be committed to survey so there is not

a high turnover

• Should receive a day training & practice• Have clear instructions in the survey for

enumerators

Training enumerators agenda

• Intro to campaign => Motivation

• Ethos / Neutral approachable attitude

• Process (one on one; don’t share paper but interview)

• Run through questions and instructions one by one (translated version)

• Keep tally of respondents who don’t want to be interviewed

• Record any changes in sampling methodology• Have feedback system

Training enumerators - agenda

• Go over survey plan Make sure enumerators understand sampling methodologyrandom sampling – (map + dice to select street?)stratified sampling – (create simplified version)

• Provide additional materials needed (MAP, dice & photographs)

• Do a practice run & debrief

Training enumerators - agenda

Top Tip

• Laminate survey questionnaire with hole and ring binder

• Create answer sheet

=> Instructions for enumerators in both documents

• Do a pilot survey 3-5 per enumerator(test on people random sample in least important area first)

• Do a debrief from pilot survey

Training enumerators

Training enumerators

• Agree on n of surveys per day and target• Have organizer within group• Safety protocol• At a minimum take part in first 2 days of

surveying• Do data entry of pilot survey with encoders!

Good luck!

Diskarte

Data entry

Data entry

• Bottleneck! Start early• Save every form• System for keeping paper copy

=> BACK UP every day!

Customizing the KAP survey

Documents

Transcript of Customizing the KAP survey