CULTURE COUNTS 15 minutes - mforsafety.ro › docs › evenimente › safety... · The Safety...

38
The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts CULTURE COUNTS 15 minutes Dr. Georgios D. Panopoulos, MFG Bucharest 21 June 2018

Transcript of CULTURE COUNTS 15 minutes - mforsafety.ro › docs › evenimente › safety... · The Safety...

Page 1: CULTURE COUNTS 15 minutes - mforsafety.ro › docs › evenimente › safety... · The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts Safety is not first. Safety is

The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts

CULTURE COUNTS15 minutes

Dr. Georgios D. Panopoulos, MFGBucharest 21 June 2018

Page 2: CULTURE COUNTS 15 minutes - mforsafety.ro › docs › evenimente › safety... · The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts Safety is not first. Safety is

The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts

1. Today we know that

Page 3: CULTURE COUNTS 15 minutes - mforsafety.ro › docs › evenimente › safety... · The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts Safety is not first. Safety is

The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts

Safety is not first. Safety is an integrated element of the business.

Our main scope and objective is our Project /plant), our business

Page 4: CULTURE COUNTS 15 minutes - mforsafety.ro › docs › evenimente › safety... · The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts Safety is not first. Safety is

The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts

Cost of

safety

Traditionally/Historically• Moral• Economic• Legal

and Sustainability

HEALTH & SAFETY POLICY

Company recognises the social and economic impact of incidents and as it operates under the TITAN Group Vision & Policy for Occupational Health & Safety, is initiating this Health & Safety Policy aiming to provide safe workplaces and facilities for its Employees, Contractors, Suppliers, Customers as well as any other that may be affected by its business.To fulfil this target, Company developed and implements a Health & Safety Management System and is

committed to make all reasonably practicable effort to ensure that:National legal requirements and provisions for Health and Safety, as well as corporate provisions of TITAN Group or other applicable requirements are met as necessary;Responsibilities are clearly allocated to all Employees, Contractors and Suppliers;Employees, Contractors and Suppliers receive suitable Health and Safety training and develop high appreciation of Health & Safety principles as necessary;A continuous improvement of the safety culture of Company and its Contractors and Suppliers is worked out.Company recognises Health and Safety as a cornerstone in its CSR policy;Processes are in place for continuous identification and control of workplace hazards and prevention of incidents and diseases;The whole organisational structure of Company from Senior Management to the last employee is involved as a whole in the implementation of the Health and Safety Management System;Clear, measurable, realistic and well-timed Health and Safety targets are set;The knowledge, experience and support of Company are continuously available to society at large in order to improve the National Health and Safety standards.The Health and Safety Management System including this current Policy are regularly reviewed and revised as necessary aiming for continuous improvement of Health and Safety; andAll Employees, Contractors and Suppliers are expected to follow safe work practices, comply with health and safety rules and regulations, work in a manner that upholds the high-level health and safety standards endorsed and achieved by Company. and contribute at their best in the implementation of the current Health & Safety Policy.

……………………...Managing Director

THE SAFETY BASIS

Page 5: CULTURE COUNTS 15 minutes - mforsafety.ro › docs › evenimente › safety... · The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts Safety is not first. Safety is

The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts

THE ECONOMICS (HOLISTIC COST) OF SAFETY

5

XNumber of Accidents Safety Performance

Y

CO

ST

AC1

SC1

SP1/IR1

PC1

Prevention Cost (PC)SCmin

Safety Cost (SC)

Accident Cost (AC)

MfwnAC1

Management Failure without Accident (Cost)

(MFwAC)

Returns Cost(RC)

New SCmin

SC = PC + AC + MFwAC - RC

Prevention Cost (PC)

(Holistic) Safety Cost (SC)

Page 6: CULTURE COUNTS 15 minutes - mforsafety.ro › docs › evenimente › safety... · The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts Safety is not first. Safety is

The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts

2. Today we heard

2.1 Creating a safety culture for a sustainable future in Petrobrazi Refinery (OMV)

2.2 Safety Culture: What is missing? (EBRD)

2.3 Mission Zero: Because We Care – PMI’s Corporate program to build Safety culture (PMI)

2.4 Software aided PSM supports sustainability via safety culture (MFG)

Page 7: CULTURE COUNTS 15 minutes - mforsafety.ro › docs › evenimente › safety... · The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts Safety is not first. Safety is

The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts

3. Do we confirm that still a long way to go before demonstrate a good safety culture in many business sectors and areas of the globe?

Page 8: CULTURE COUNTS 15 minutes - mforsafety.ro › docs › evenimente › safety... · The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts Safety is not first. Safety is

The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts

Cultural issue or other?

Why it appears so difficult to get a safe scaffold? Not knowing, incapable to pay, not used to, not willing to pay underestimating benefits/costly.

• www.google.com

• Project Risk Management.

• The tower crane example.

Page 9: CULTURE COUNTS 15 minutes - mforsafety.ro › docs › evenimente › safety... · The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts Safety is not first. Safety is

The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts

9

Page 10: CULTURE COUNTS 15 minutes - mforsafety.ro › docs › evenimente › safety... · The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts Safety is not first. Safety is

The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts

4. Analysing the facts, looking for the path or creating a path

Page 11: CULTURE COUNTS 15 minutes - mforsafety.ro › docs › evenimente › safety... · The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts Safety is not first. Safety is

The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts

SAFETY PERFORMANCE (ENERGY)

(X) Managerial capacity (energy)

(Y) Technical capacity (energy)

(-, +) (M, T) (+, +)

(0, 0)

(-,-)(+,-)

[(Z) Cultural based capacity (energy)]

Page 12: CULTURE COUNTS 15 minutes - mforsafety.ro › docs › evenimente › safety... · The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts Safety is not first. Safety is

The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts

SAFETY PERFORMANCE

BoD

TOP MANAGEMENT

MIDDLE AND LINE MANAGEMENT

WORKFORCE

PolicyResourcesAuthorisationsReviewImplement PolicyOrganise & planningMonitoring and evaluating performanceProposals to BoD/ReportingImplement SuperviseTrain & inform EmployeesInform Managers/reportFollow the instructionsComply with the rulesBe trained Inform supervisors

Page 13: CULTURE COUNTS 15 minutes - mforsafety.ro › docs › evenimente › safety... · The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts Safety is not first. Safety is

The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts

OPTIMISING SAFETY PERFORMANCE

BoD

TOP MANAGEMENT

MIDDLE AND LINE MANAGEMENT

WORKFORCE

PolicyResourcesAuthorisationReview

Implement policyOrganise & planningMonitoring andevaluating performanceProposals to BoD/ReportingImplement SuperviseTrain & inform EmployeesInform managers/report

Follow the instructionsComply with the rulesBe trained Inform supervisors

Page 14: CULTURE COUNTS 15 minutes - mforsafety.ro › docs › evenimente › safety... · The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts Safety is not first. Safety is

The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts

Training, communication, supervision

Training, supervision, meetings, workshops, re

write

On job training, team work, share, supervision.

hardware changes

Special support, coaching, organisational changes

TEAM WORK& COACHING FOR CHANGING IN FOUR STEPS

UNDERSTAND

DIGEST

KNOW

ACCEPT

CHANGE

Routinise improved planning and implementation procedures/practices

Evaluation

Page 15: CULTURE COUNTS 15 minutes - mforsafety.ro › docs › evenimente › safety... · The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts Safety is not first. Safety is

The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts

THE MAIN OBJECTIVE

People to accept to change their routine striving for a continuous improvement of their effectiveness in fulfilling their safety roles and responsibilities.

Benefits from the change: • For the individuals; • Company; and• Society at large

Need to battle though, also the fear to change

Page 16: CULTURE COUNTS 15 minutes - mforsafety.ro › docs › evenimente › safety... · The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts Safety is not first. Safety is

The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts

Example

Cycle 3

0

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

TOTAL MONTH01

MONTH02

MONTH03

MONTH04

MONTH05

MONTH06

Interventions

Completions

Total7790/649483,3%

Page 17: CULTURE COUNTS 15 minutes - mforsafety.ro › docs › evenimente › safety... · The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts Safety is not first. Safety is

The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts

Η ασφάλεια είναι πολιτισμός

Safetyis an element of civilisation

Management Force Group

Siguria eshte civilizim

السالمة عنصر من عناصر الحضارة

Safetyis an element of civilisation

Безопасността е култура

Bezbednostae kultura

La sécuritéest un élément culturel

Guvenlik’ uygarligin bir parcasidir

Sicherheit ist ein Element der Kultur

Siguranta inseamnacultura

Page 18: CULTURE COUNTS 15 minutes - mforsafety.ro › docs › evenimente › safety... · The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts Safety is not first. Safety is

The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts

THE SAFETY CULTURE EVENT

Effective Construction Safety Management

Software aided

Bucharest, June 21 2018D. Eleftheropoulos, MFG

Page 19: CULTURE COUNTS 15 minutes - mforsafety.ro › docs › evenimente › safety... · The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts Safety is not first. Safety is

The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts

Why Safety

Page 20: CULTURE COUNTS 15 minutes - mforsafety.ro › docs › evenimente › safety... · The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts Safety is not first. Safety is

The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts

The Value of Safety

Or

Safety is a Value

Page 21: CULTURE COUNTS 15 minutes - mforsafety.ro › docs › evenimente › safety... · The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts Safety is not first. Safety is

The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts

Common sense, 2500 years now

Protagoras from Abdera, the pre-Socraticphilosopher (stochastic) introducing his workquoted: “Man is the measure of all things, ofthings which are that they are and of thingswhich are not that they are not”.

So in our case the VALUE of safety depends onthe way the man, the societies measure it andcan differ and indeed differs from society tosociety, sector to sector, organisation toorganisation.

Abdera 490 – 420 BC

Page 22: CULTURE COUNTS 15 minutes - mforsafety.ro › docs › evenimente › safety... · The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts Safety is not first. Safety is

The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts

SAFETY CRITERIA

• Moral

• Legal

• Economical

Last decade Organisations focus on Sustainability

Page 23: CULTURE COUNTS 15 minutes - mforsafety.ro › docs › evenimente › safety... · The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts Safety is not first. Safety is

The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts

COMMUNICATING VESSELS PRINCIPLE

Page 24: CULTURE COUNTS 15 minutes - mforsafety.ro › docs › evenimente › safety... · The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts Safety is not first. Safety is

The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts

Page 25: CULTURE COUNTS 15 minutes - mforsafety.ro › docs › evenimente › safety... · The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts Safety is not first. Safety is

The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts

ECONOMICS OF SAFETY

25X

Number of Accidents Safety Performance

YC

OS

T

AC1

SC1

SP1/IR1

PC1

Traditionally, SC =PC + AC

Prevention Cost (PC)

SCmin

Safety Cost (SC)

Accident Cost (AC)

MfwnAC1

Management Failure without Accident Cost (MFwAC) (1)

Returns Cost(RC) (2)

New SCmin

Then, SC =PC + AC + MFwAC (1)

(1) G. D. Panopoulos 2004(2) G. D. Panopoulos 2009

Page 26: CULTURE COUNTS 15 minutes - mforsafety.ro › docs › evenimente › safety... · The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts Safety is not first. Safety is

The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts

Project Health and Safety Management System

1. Practicable

2. Simple

3. Comprehensive

4. Design for purpose – specific

5. No gaps - No overlaps

6. Effective

7. Economic

Page 27: CULTURE COUNTS 15 minutes - mforsafety.ro › docs › evenimente › safety... · The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts Safety is not first. Safety is

The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts

CONTRACTORS POLICY CORNERSTONESThe are four corner tones in managing contractors. The Owner has to demonstrate clearly thathe (the Owner):

1. wants safety;

2. knows safety;

3. can do it; and

4. does do it.

Dr. Georgios D. Panopoulos (2003)

Has in place a clear Safety Policy

Has in place contract specific tender H&S requirements including contractor’s minimum H&S requirements and the

project/scope specific effective HSP/SMS

Has in place a competent and committed organisation dully authorised and possessing an arsenal to manage the

Project’s Safety and battle risk generation from day one.

Regardless initial delays and costs, Owner applies the H&S procedures from day one, including Contractor’s evaluation.

Page 28: CULTURE COUNTS 15 minutes - mforsafety.ro › docs › evenimente › safety... · The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts Safety is not first. Safety is

The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts

SAFETY ENERGY

«Δός μοι πά στω καί τάν γαν κινήσω»

“Give me place to stand and I will move the earth”

Archimedes 3rd century bc

~ ~

Page 29: CULTURE COUNTS 15 minutes - mforsafety.ro › docs › evenimente › safety... · The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts Safety is not first. Safety is

The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts

Key components – key Issues

Safe passEquipment safe ssMSDS – material safe passSite Master PlanSafe Method Statement

MeetingsTrainingInspectionsCorrective actions track registerStatistics – metrics - KPIs

Page 30: CULTURE COUNTS 15 minutes - mforsafety.ro › docs › evenimente › safety... · The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts Safety is not first. Safety is

The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts

Aids to Improve Performance

1. Safety audits

2. SIR

3. SOR

4. Monthly Report

5. Risk Assessment

Page 31: CULTURE COUNTS 15 minutes - mforsafety.ro › docs › evenimente › safety... · The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts Safety is not first. Safety is

The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts

Key Features

• Multilanguage

• Easy to customize

• Build In Databases

• Easy Data Manipulation

• Clear Structure

• Real Time Results

• Multi User Access

• User Action Log

Page 32: CULTURE COUNTS 15 minutes - mforsafety.ro › docs › evenimente › safety... · The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts Safety is not first. Safety is

The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts

Safety Audits

• Use of +2/-2 method for the rating of the performance,

• Workplace and activities Customization,

• Pending actions Monitoring,

• Comprehensive Graphical output.

Page 33: CULTURE COUNTS 15 minutes - mforsafety.ro › docs › evenimente › safety... · The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts Safety is not first. Safety is

The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts

Site Inspection Report

• Reporting Frequency Customization,

• Pending actions Monitoring,

• Actionee Allocation for each Finding,

• Real Time Statistics,

• Findings Photo Attachment

Page 34: CULTURE COUNTS 15 minutes - mforsafety.ro › docs › evenimente › safety... · The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts Safety is not first. Safety is

The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts

Site Organization Registry

• Customized for worksite requirements,

• Fast data monitoring, grouping, sorting & exporting,

• Real time inspections aiding tool,

• Real time statistics.

Page 35: CULTURE COUNTS 15 minutes - mforsafety.ro › docs › evenimente › safety... · The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts Safety is not first. Safety is

The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts

Monthly Report

• High End information oriented,

• Fast and Comprehensive analysis,

• Straight forward structured development

Page 36: CULTURE COUNTS 15 minutes - mforsafety.ro › docs › evenimente › safety... · The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts Safety is not first. Safety is

The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts

Risk Assessment

• Workplace and activities data recording,

• Risk assessment worksheet,

• Risk evaluation of each job position or any other exposed to risk,

• Pending actions monitoring,

• Revisions back up

Page 37: CULTURE COUNTS 15 minutes - mforsafety.ro › docs › evenimente › safety... · The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts Safety is not first. Safety is

The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts

Conclusion

Software aided PSM, characteristics and objectives1. Practicability2. Simplicity – friendly to user3. Built for purpose Focus (Design for purpose)4. No overlaps5. Completeness 6. Effectiveness7. Productivity 8. Support decision making9. Culture change10. Support continuous improvement

Page 38: CULTURE COUNTS 15 minutes - mforsafety.ro › docs › evenimente › safety... · The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts Safety is not first. Safety is

The Safety Culture Event, Bucharest, June 21 2018 Culture Counts

Safetyis an element of civilisation

Η ασφάλεια είναι πολιτισμός

Management Force Group