c.r.,JSJl Tlull rHl · 2021. 4. 7. · ,JS ggy't-;J," 6jlJl ota ep crt+tiiiYl op +;titl rl-..,i3...
Transcript of c.r.,JSJl Tlull rHl · 2021. 4. 7. · ,JS ggy't-;J," 6jlJl ota ep crt+tiiiYl op +;titl rl-..,i3...
arf
$TAII0IIIWAII
IIII CON$IITUIIONAT COUAT
It
\a,i\lr.-
*s.).F,!,{i|D+tc.r.,JSJl -,H"i -r*.rJl .f.Lo f-,,t+
Tlull rHl &rYl ritJi e+&Jl- ' -u' .^ .. -' _-.:
--
ir.$irrrll A.srtl
lY. Yl .1.,r-*i rJ. V (Fildl -l\ ttYOl$ rr,-c Yo &_tE a-S..lt 'Ub;$rj.lt i,*tlt,i-Sr^ll U.,-+J ,r-fU (H f*,b J-{r. / Jt-,in.^ll , l*lt a*,,t i,ri
r *uJ ll 4l*di CL S U - jll ,+ &lr / Ul.rJt in."ll 5.rl-.Jt L-3.:e3
u!-Jl O's;Jlqe fr*a!) J cr-UlJl Ol& o,arJhre. 3
a-,.lrJl p 64.i 0i+."rll l-lti J-es,c / , l"Jl JJE-,irrJ
's$, f.lllrr
l.l. iirl <r> rrl il_rfirrrJl i.Srl,f d# i *ll g-rhll dtt t r Y . lU Lft U*5. Crl+l3iil+ i'.atS, OJrr.b "
'f SCrrll
.f .;liSlt ro.l $.I..p
:rlJ
4li.ai i.fitrtt ;,,U -f 4$.ei rl.pgll !,"1+. u.+-,1 -Y 4ilai t Yl Ud+. U+rjJ - \
. gljtrlt gL" u*" ell .rp r,c.rl .1 41i..i Lyt ,*t+J pbJl ggaYl -o a.ii.+ j.rdl .;! - t
J
\ )
,l',
$IAII0IIIITAII
IIIX COI{$IIIUIIONAT COURI
I4
{ ,\XW
()t
b
,t :\
ffi. *l&jEdl
J..l r,f .taig;r)etlJl Oi - dl=JUYI g}" i)+J L !'.'' . e+tillt di.aLr 0! 'o'J'
dll3j ,(i*l3Jl) 6.J'ilJl o.l Y . t . ,U LYt onl+. st+tiijl a-,a ,re iFL (,fJ$SJt
& eB eP l+ll} c Y . I, l\ 1 lt t g;-tli i-Sr.tt obl;15 6;l.rl cc.r3i iii.- t-rs. .Jni
d:pEJl)l 6JihJl+ ++e-plll Ltr.lt 0$lll el,! eJ^+Is jJ 6.rts! :t'sll aip.-tt
+;ri 6. ,Clriilrl }dl 6.rtcl 4je Ji-.i tJ Gl +#-i !'!..r oi.ll9 0)le!3 ,1i,,-t3Jl;
.-,,tji ,r dlli "J"
( t Y 1 Y ) eJ" cJ.ar r! 4il3 1e,,-titt; 6ihll .JP 'tJJ" gls 4.r! cjt! dllil Uh-l
4iJ"" os otiJl3n c'*33 $ 4.ri3 (6JiilJl+ J& eJEJt }-.,;l.ll 'lii.. drtJr:'1:Yl d3y
u,srjl gr+SJtj i-rL'.-ll gp rl}ii crl3rll ii 4iLe,',,.tJ il ,6J'ilJl dlll qi.-r.l5,ijYi
++::lt ct)ell gr";.ill-9 lill 6.ra! ,,,t3lr; t-ci 6-JrjlJl o.q; igll g)e! gJ" t-ii
lel gL+lJl so Ou.r;ll .t-.:ri" r;fo ljnti O$l pL.,.l-l gi UUi3 ,ir+s,all
Ot+lll gl*,-ll gl uiLili LrS sgttttl ,r9 oljr..aYl l.rs lUll ;e dJvarJl Cr^ ftiiSrii.j.*Xt+ HlijJl 3l pt cSJl lltj!+ *$lU+ ds fert-f! lshi clp t*,ail 0n lJiLli eJ
t.c O.o SiSJt 4. ,js{i s,,,r ptiJl! A!!". }e elJ$Yl dlJ3i Oi Cp );i ,ot.rp,lJ
.-sJJt ritu 4irrr,.r 4jr.b Lt!! d! t lJr €ljl _.FYl ,,-iex ts,l
Y . t . ail (r) d.t '( lt ", ep o+P ..: 6*!tt a.sr"it ob ,.;liS 6-,1lrl oiE q&J
.par.,ir,iy.hell cl! a.Uot cr-,;pJ r'rLYl u,"li.e ciJ.lsiit+ i,otS,33l.htt
Tl* J
r\l
SIAII OI K]flAII
TIII CONSIIIUTIONAT COUII
?
4rf \p#()
\al )
\ill a,*lc+lL $J soL*$Jl J.bl*i of#ll 4+Jll ,J" Cr.Ut i-Sr.lt ol5 ,"'JJil r53 lb
,Jp Oir.iJ"Jl rL,^.,i; d.ai. Ol+# Wlsljn (ot;l.iiiYl 6,rl.rl) llilJl 6Jl-ls cr i-ss.lt
,k;i gg+$.Jl o*iitXl JJe3 e Y . Y . fbl Lyl ,J-ti{ dlLr r.lil d (4,,".ljJ1) 6JrilJl
ep O;c;s.ll ue gl.*ll lia )t"Li ,dl5i3 d,')+-. rJi. 6JljJrll crJ to gil3 gr. ,tll33
JleJ (o*ii,Ull Jle tJ.+. cl" t+.,iJ-l+ l3hi giUl r&l lJj.lt ir^,,illS 66J'ilJl
crl3rYl $eJ 66JiilrJl 6rf t 0. 4i1J ,JS sre Uy ,JS L#!, cj.ar Cl CrlJyayl
C/^1. dl 1+.Ol+ sr+^i$l jJill i.+r3j .ie c,JLi t-3 .,itLgl crljrYl .r.ra si.r;.rr.all
tJ"+. fti. ,JS ggy't-;J," 6jlJl ota ep crt+tiiiYl op +;titl rl-..,i3 60cs*iJ.ll
ef^+ on jJ..4 i-sr.lt 6tll9. 4lSg ,ijh.Jl dtijll tis3 tgte J.ar Cl crlJ,aYl
l! Ul .ri ,+,1 .l++ll JL.i^ll 4#tiiiYl iilJl 0l+l O" ;Jliur,ll t#.ll Cl .rta4Jl
6r,219!l -;ilr- ll 1y cP Les).bll ,q!l-1ji3 erUh cl" 5-,rljsll 0. +L r- i-sr"cJt
altll 3ti':13 ,Lyt url+rJ Lt .lt i.it-yt J- ,J! dliii)J i-sr.lt 04 ;rsb c+J ,hl!gS:',ft Ol+ill J'^:l-r. gl,;ii*Y i..,,"tStt 6JrjlJt+ l,atS.Jt ..lliiiYl drJLila e+ jl-,r
d! O+s:.tl i-sl.Jl Vtb cJiijl rls ,giJJt lln sp 4rlilJl 6tljl +Es 11pt rj d ,r,,,ll
-.;is+ q$ll J*Xl ,,Jc t-oj=ri! o.lsr.tt i{-nll plrY LYt uyJ++ Lt tt fut-yt ,i.g>tlYt o. f3l.^aiJl CE6^i .rq3 ,-;*2li-rrJl o.u ,ril t e+i. ,Or.hjl & e.Cl dliljYl
,rJ" t{+ p.,a g$ 6jr. OeUdl a1c J;Ul eri ,p6ctir rlq13 qll-pYl ef^} ,Je
,j&Lll gp pSrJi .,rlr,.a! LSs.tt &tj ef.rl$i,s o.Eit-g,jr.hll iirs.ai 6JJIJ'!! 4ilrlL
.fCl i..J+i
t*,\VT
/
gt{z
\_ J,t'
$TAII0IIIIAII
TIII COI,I$IITUIIONAI COUII
s{s\w1
\)
( v '01
e,Crtl
.iJ3lroll &J.J ,iriu.ll tL,.,g e dlJUYl ,le g)!Yt u;
.i:ils.iJl a.et i3i LjpJi*l &!ll 0! e+i.
,.!c (i*tiJt) 6JitJt el oe Ct rrt+tiil)l ule 4!! i ilotlll 0! ,',J-J
i+i3l eP ;jJ. !;l-* +-#c clljrYl t{siJ iJill 4il"e '"'''1-.! $ 4ji cJ:oll cl" $*
dJ,asll Ur dj,&d tJeJ CJ'JI!,.,J{. J+r+ Ol.,:}lJ! gr tr,.3r.r.. UL,Jp '''11 i ,i-r.lsljYl
e+ts.aq l3hl gn i.#4r,.1 rJn dirilt * d +.,l t-cs (ol+.lJl ,rs oljrYt ue lt^+! sJe
J+" c,jls gt;ilYt c!l.,,si Oi Clc );i , pt-,jll i+-Aq +ttull 3l pl*sJl futJ+ lJ.dr LJ d 3l
,ijh-oll A++:lt A-r,a sle dLi,ll .ln ilf cD! edr L^. $-, ,pt!,;Yl1 AJ-"L*"
.L+.,.tt ++Silt .t).c!f grpJt3 j-.,;iJl irlsl rr+O]...rr.f
Fttl a+-,+-t blsrl ObII ,-rli'iiyl 4+l- 6-2l.rl-r r6.c ,r.;tisiY! Oil3 0! 'o'J'J
A,4ii^ll Ll.r.s o,l 6'.;ll.rl!;++,Il t+Ut dr.r 4ji Y! ,+)e,.65i.r 4*t,ai Ot+l
pl$ll.r EJihJl 01,+l !i"+ ,-rtiilfl &rUaa j-O gtS er^l rr+ ,tgi r;t3:',)i dlj'r !)le!+
.;JilJl drLlr.'iil sp i#-;rLiJl el-...,i Jle!4#.i$jl i.+Ut .ll! cr+rri;.bU3,4lrJl
sljrYl jj ',1iE Cf.+ ,3c i.sr-lt g).bt g's i, C1;;li isl ,elJ3 6tS t-rl
ir d+ d (glisll .r.or,l 4 .1,a;11 ilc&ll 6i ,.rr=r+s:l jJijl l"br.J 6rlJl JhJJ
oil oqtii:t ./ *:+ Ct"i .t !13 ,crl-1t i',rYl ob .rp jJ.l' /d di+ t. ol3r,aYl
J.ar 3t r,geiLlt t{-Je cj,ar ll ol.grYt se t +*'..c r:rl3r)ll i!. lJ'!U $ ;Jil.r!l
/'Vl $rnr
\* J,L'
$TAII0IruflAII
TIII CONSIIruIIOtrIAI, COUAT
.o
4
{ ,\ffi)
:\e$t
\ ) ,-J" (s+jtrJt g&'r
# ,r k+I,,a p.t; d i-S..lt l.6!.r--,, \n (f . ) $e hl! GU.a" ,ti3,- (t r o o) (,J9
clll auil .(tfAo ) 4J" d.ar,r.lJl "ll-+Yl
ull e+,4J.! ei"+ll o,r {*"IrJt ii+.I!t
i1el}ll t#le cj,ar ":lt
qt itl drljrYl r.re ptran! r; oilii g {p1.t-!t ii+!t ci.iE
.r.lo 6i gir ./ ,ES,.a (t tlY) ,,Jo al3x.ar ctjtci Jt ,V9- (1f) q+ i".iLj3ill 4#liyl 4J di+ y 1.. 93 ,ti3.a (trAo) eA t#!r d.ar Ct a+ill {rljlaYl
t#!i cj..a.r Cl ,+biJl ol3r.aYl rre i1e cji: c,,ls-i oJc 4Jf-l sotJriliYl ota,Jp
,/ *iJp gbi ir"l eA 4*iliYl 6JSi d ,rt ,uj,o (Y 11) tt$+ -dlrJl -Efll lirLa
,6,j1.$l o.rl
oa+,/ 4i+"+ll eGiYl cF+.tjs.-, ir iPGll ! ''!,*ni L e$ 1.. cJt! Y-l
ol3r,aYl j-C 6.,U: efiJ srs rEii tj9g crJl L{r+}.6153,LSr.cJl S.r--,,31 ,6tatt1
i.:Ltt &t+lsiiYl i++31 ir. JJ- 0i l'61i.i 0" (Jr,Jl ptliYl o.ra 6i 31 66Jihll 0l+l &F+l
.*j$ Cl"i Cr1*
UJ#.9gS ,iJ.,,,I^"i.r fti-li+ Lil 'i.1iYl cllli fp;r #e i). iPtlll ! ''1,* i L Li
,r&4.!' ( ,16+ Ci Crs 1ji ,.31-.pYl oia atgi r5JJ u t r+ d +tiiiYt Os.ti Ot+
Oi Cr O$$Ji 4b:.i.l r-nl iilt r ,l\, i.!J Js d aijr...q d.i 1.r- 4+JA 1.1e , i i.<ll sJl
,q5 /i ti),sYq O$l i-r. ti:iYl
t* CxStSt 4ras,,i ir O'+Ul pt-,it.ri.: l'rc i)" iPUdl 4P+ t-oJ ar.3 Y3
.bU $,-rliii)'l Cit-g 6i il ,c,,tra:loll drLigll oJrJ ei"&S3 !#i'. tjll oJr.J ge olatrsJl
7_
,]
I
''{ffi
_WV, V'
J
SIAII0Irul[AII
IIII CONSIIruIIONAI COUII
4
{ ,WW)
\e rll ,
G *\
O*i5,lJl 4i,al"& Oi. d.irltl 4+LiiJTl ll+lJl el-.,-l;
cjil,.rijlJ o*ii.l,iJl ol-jr-'a! qi.eXJl dt.,;r; $ Ui Ji ,lllt p3-cLS d, Jrgu #.r+ r,tl;
ep iPl}Jl 431-., l- 0F,lUtt+l ,dlJ.t cg,."; sl:'iiyf 4*1"" ;I9 -'+i:lt ;, -li ,,.6r9lai,iil
.! J+ Y ,rt*< ijJ le it-l C*& d oLill..,;iil &r,0 ,f,,4,if,.ttt t.ra
J-l+r tj:S Crs GtsJ )9 ,01+Ilt ctn O*r;-xll sdSJr lA cptlll pb.tl 0e t"i
.+ ,Js 4ir.h dir,& a.il+ .sJ+ Yr ,i+j oJatJis Yl j+h 4Jl" f+ et &-* d-ls
.g3rlilt, -*,-d, !u 3;ri.a
,fuitill3 itJt ,r .rl*i ,r1,, dE ;F ai..x 0,*ll CJ+ .tlll ,b-L"j*iiJ.a;i; pl*iriJl O++ t' g.3
$*r8l eiNi
.0".!lj1 t-Cl:irSetl ed.
g[r.1 i
:q+,\.{l1 V"f
arthl
J
$TAII0Irul[AIT
TIIX COI{$IIIUTIOI{AL COUAI
aif ,\XW
t ''l )l)
{l :\
i^-
1F#S'trJIrii|llr *l
+ss!l ;"i j*-,ll +.t- fl+C!r,.aJI *hll .r.qrYl dli e*i{l
ar.J0irrrJl a.srtt
lY . Y 1 ,Jr+i g,c V #b"ll -r\ t t Y Ot+& g,.c Y o eptr A-Sr.J!'Utc iJ.irj^Jt a*"lrJ!
e-Sr.ll U*-ijJ .r+U (H p-..,b .uls.. / .1t-.:,i.."tl , idl LLi.,;;
U -jll ,+ drtr 3 , :Ujtl J-ll3 l!3-i / Cpttfu*nll 6.rt-,.,,1t L-j*io3
s{hll Ol& O-rJl.tp S ' j;"t.ll 4j+'li dbSi-*Slt .-# Cr+"i ,-j+y t-"ti , t.,Ji / , ldl -U-ars
'o$l tll.liu.1.1. il{ 1sy ii1,; iilf.i.rrlli.srtl d+. i.+.llgrhll {
" Y . Y . pL; LVt ,rl+,. Crl+liijl+ i,.atS g3rr.b'
:$e tgrJl
dt+lt Olib €s. r.!r
rJg u: - t Cl<Jt p*txl iig -r "r+L"lt .tlh .r,t - Y rjuil s+ d$.,,- - I
-,rr; -A dJ+.rll -.;.aU -,r.r+ -V 6'rrJl qb .rJl,i -'i ,-c"llrJl .tlli gUJ* -o -;L.Jl
4ii.4r 4rlihjl -rjr -\ \ urjl $ ....i -\ . c;Llu6ll , +* J.r -1 )lrll rrLrJ_J! a _
Ji
/tr,U\\ J
4
Y K$IAII0Irul[AII
TIII CONSIITUIIONAI COUII
)t
er$
i^,- *\
pbJl ggrYl -\ t 41i.a!r crl;l3l)J l+li.!l ejsJJl g*Jt -tf dii/ar cJuJl +jl -t Y
.Aii.+ LYt u"t+.t
FrtiCf
ctt+tc €r." r.l:r)gstJdl Oi - d!-rYl o. g*ri L*",r - e-',l3JJl d-.ls Ol l:.;r
ora l;1j5 glt! cror3i a,iir.4 dll.r3,Y.Y. fLd Lyl o*l+4 crlll3iil C iFL (,ltqlt
C lll eJtij ei.+ 6rtc!:$.ai #.lt t<.ui C Ul! e Y. Y./t v/r 1 etpQ i-sr.ltLJ liis a,.ui.-j r,r,,...r i1ot^hll j-re O)leb,(*+Ut; 4#liijyl ijhJl+ t*"-;iJlJ {J.aYl OhlJl
(irE..e fi irtslr :t+Lt#.b ,-1tii gr ,illl "&
,-,,i. * l. C,l C#.,a:ll 6ltc) ajs +i.+
+L,,':-5,fuis.all+ tg+l! _lli"l Ot+lll cp 5ll..C1 cu3r.aill d[.13i eJ"+ jJiJ ?tiijylJi.+ l.J tii3 olti:lfl C ojlp O)sls r(pl}Jl L#!, J,,ar Cl qdrill c,,!jrlt rocrJJlaill d!.)Ji ei"+ 6+s. 3 .,1-,p 6rts! glsltlti.yl .,.t+ cxs ,e+a?illJ jill 6rlcJ a.ls
.iiJ. "Jo,,,jj-,
L Ca,o1p C)e.b (A.,iEJl) lrlJ! 4iellJ 4jLayl Ol.irll ddrU*a+
.ttii cr| -,c,*i Cl Lll ,J-1'+4 crltilY (e;uBl) i-rll.rll gc 4y 4il ,Jti dlJI Ul*J
ajlr.ll a+n,ull a+iiiJl C 'El..a (rlAl) .rrs ,rJo J[.as riJ sY. Y./t v/o eJl+
Ll,ar qr.!l (...11 il .".i )*.Uft .Fflt+ -,.U1 ip c,rlJ-i (t) .l.ls r.itl+,g1l.li.':'.;tl,-;1,. ls) C*,[ili 5lt, ..,;,rl-iJl cp '43,- 1l ri .r.r q91!er.3
'U3,.e (l \ 10) .- ,*pleyl #l*.,s +iS
^4' t" .ilt! t -rls Us- (YY.,\) r.ro .,jc ,J.ar .rrll (,"rtiu4ll
C iJct 4la.!E n'Uyali gr l.rc .rJl ai3lar (p ojy3ru *Ir*.. laS ,ili,,nl!f 4eJ'{,,.."J1
i-- ;Et Ohile crlrall ei"+.4$- C *9, ct}ii U+J iP e,r++ tr JAJ entrr:.'::!l
el.tJtr lj-l d a* ,lull i:.lt .r+lt 0i l..S ,6Jjlr! 4+Ell a+,,l,ull ilXlJ i='i.ayl Ol;Ib
Y
,g,rlt: J
)
$IAII0IruflAII
TIII CON$IIIUTIONAL OOUIT
r4ffi\W\,
)rll
diLll 4jr.b LE! J! ! llr L..,UtJl d..:,t+is::Yl ejlx e+"rs -i.e ,tSi *:t'.tt.JSJI dilL 4:1.,1L.,
OJ&^JI .Jl diye! rI,1a3 r Y . Y . 4j.J (t ) ** i-Sr.tt ,j+." ,/ g*LJl +g a.,l
fArn
c+b $J ,srl**l+ll -r..1-+ atl+.Jl A+Jll ";c C".Lil i.Sr.tt oil ,-LJi-: $3 lb
C dris,jdl ct -,i; ,tzria OU# t#Gb" (crtrti:ill ;-;h)) e.,fitJl UUr g. a.s.^Jt
c.1,c AJIS ,t3;! oiqi"ll C*iiEll JJe3 c Y . Y . fkl LYI u"l+. g1!li.'ril 4 (++B) a;tSt
ar.,,iJlJ,oJihll C Optii.:l r.rc gl+Jl h^ )Ll*:!,.i!;3i3 cr)l+-, i,. UUJII d.tJ * gbt{+l', ,J.4r Cl crb,4yl .r.ra ,o*ii,iJl rre gJn+l e #lyi+ lrl.i .-,iJl rrrl LJi.Jl
Ll ,il!t+Jl crb!.ayl .r.ra .ip;1i crgr.aYl .r.rs3 rljlJt Ot+l iF a.r1J # # e4:" #C (Jl-ll,ill ,L-,,b ,C*r"d.rjl Cr..Gl "JI
a+-,iji+ t't+.+ll JJill i+jlj Are '-ui.*i
Ul3 tgf ,i.4r ,*j]l crl3,a)l t "- e3i, dS c;* i-&3" glJl oia ,rr crt;liirYl
OH O. UlJll t€fiE dt *t .ll g;.a u. Jlar a.s..lt 6Li'UE d,UrsJ ,iill-nll dEi!c,,Ul* ir" 6JllCl O" +L U aiSrill l! Us Ci .r-.r.l.eill Jt"j".ll #tiijyl 6jlil
Jl dliij)J i.Ss..lt U qsbe €+r, ,LeJ) ;U!Ci -'.a't .ll )t4 (* t6.e)!b ,&sir
UlJl+ i,atitr sii.':iYl (iru* e.tg J.}j pj)Jl il,i:g.Litl u*h-t Ltrjl dt"yl Ji"l.o C ar1.Iitlt -fp +US ds-.; .:-1l d sll a+lsiXt Ol+Jl J$iLu ClAi*.Y ( "iEll)ia(.J! pl.:y Lll o-l++ a.etrll Luyt l. -t: ;g-r:*ril a^s..lt lJr^:e Jniil .ri3 ,gLjJt
olt i^:. d j+. ,o'lall e gur-i diiliyl f- c+8ll J+lt "/e l4$Jl AiSJ.jl
ip,l}ll p.rE ,p6.ol,i.t cl+b .gtJsYi gi.+ .,Jo t)})l rx tsdl O$^: .u.3 ,;riterJl
dS-JsL (-l*Uf)l (yf:ff) Ua&^b oJLh^Jl )t$s e.!t r4jl+rL "&
r-# |.o.a J:riJSL
r
\ ,r/'.(// VP J
STAII0Irul[AII
IIII CONSIITUTIOI,IAI COURT
t.\\l
G
)l)
,\r *lCslll C #l tl.r-) Y. Y\/r/r 4".!il i-Sult gJ-PJ ,drr.hll obeJ L'6rEi i SL
',rlt a*..U'
ar5rtl
.fu3luJl r*.J .irilll gL^ u,&3Yt slc t).byt +
.A+lS.j,Jl a-sV3l upsi*t ri !'-hll C! f+lt
sli..iiyl 4J- ,-.,,L|1 $ 4jf+ J:nll il" ri.. sje 4jr.b .,,r; i,1slJd! O! ,o,i-J
crlr)l ls 6i rl ,;jlr-dl i;;i:lr A-r,. # 6j.rr. L_-,,lr+ eEii (o#UJ,) E-t'lJl ,si.o3..-".lt deYl ,J.rt..t 4eE 4q U *ill+ t€+b 4lJr.4r e+-,.+{Jll i.irtlt c.ltsi CtC+A- 4J- C dS ri etlii iP.J (P eL*.I- SU,ojir.Jr.r.4J!,, tUr,lt,rj.J.J!
r-1"+it Oi t S ,irilJl a+Ulf A++*Ull AlJlb;+Layl Ol+lJb 4+eJoll OHJH c,lrYl
.Ujhll C cit+truYl ejEj e+.+.s ii etii crildl sl.r.ll+ f;i! C e+.4ru1 i+lll
LVf u".t . eWl cr[.rtiijl Ojti il[+.rl.y iplJ.Jl 4+ dl*,.,oii L C! ,o.J-f
il- C!*+ 4-!l U,*l+. e@l-rl3iil i lt,t -LLsi r.! , \ qr I a;J (ro) fsJi*,.U* L6r. ds.'f;ri glrrr q,Sj -ll t#ui ,.1" ,-ll'r.iiyl 4J- Ull!+ rgcs ,&ULr.,iall
Uij-:,14r,u.;*I. j,;rs L+,.+*f t6.h* ji* l+ a-.lr!l A+[iji .3i eL.aiJl jLr";.t-:i
60,*tiiJl 6tUi C,p ilrtog Ci* JS.i,J lr+c.:)++iXl Oy.c! it+-F ruliiiYl Aap
OL1JJI ora $.riii ,rjill ole.fiYl tiK.;s .5la rel; Ot;iJI oia 'y.al;l.o
,irs.J
"t61 ,t+ t ;sr. JA d,,aYl gi9 r.t{i.}-, LgL, (*' totrlt
^/,lllt
t
rt/ J
$IAII OI KII{AII
IIIX CON$TITUIIONAI COURI
4{ ,\W
)
:\" ^ll
[-jJ.ill ,,;.aLrr3 lJjJl Jt:tar sJe AiSr^ll g)-Ll C-9b.t- O*+tt O! ,r,J.,J
C,+ eiy # t"#le ,J,4r gjll crb.,ayl .t.tc e-r1 JtJ (e+Ut; Ltjl$l.,gr+.i$l
ir. OiJ 6crLli.liYl o.n qJ jrrll 4J.ir.i t crbr.aYl i). d+ C iptllt ui ;-S..I
o!*a!l Lc ,Jc r.,,',1g l-o o!r..aYl i). lrU $ Sjhll oia ot;13:it *,t p4!n gJei
.r.r-o ,& (.r.lsJl {t .r.lti)}itrll iSJr.lL -ijijll d.,ar il ,grl}Jl l-#b J,ar gjJl
(Y Y. A) r,r,.c "+ (,/L.d#l , +* r-'i) e*,[il] .El! -iiLilb .'ti3,,a (v r ro;
(r) ss r.Ll+,:1J33 ,'E3r^a (l I lt) .r.rc cr& ,J.,4r r3 uethll Ci Op C ,'Ur-
,(*r$l) jll+ -ijt.ilt gs 'E3*a (r r) uca (-*t tt; 5#Jl+ -i:UJl O, slJ,4i
6L-Jira c,cLi $ i+jiill OJsJ 6.,rihll o.^ C ,jJF Obi a)"1 4#Iill CJs dElt..lr.r.c ,& r4 olrYl LJrr .!re cr& lJsar O- iPtlJl 4it*l U e$ t-. cjt+ Y-l
#t "J a;+ Ul ojl.J& olei LJ tiif .otril.ir)U i+,*J-JJl ;isjll g" Llult ogrlt
eE: ,r la.r.g A+*i{-ll a,irUt 4jhi L Ja Ot"&Jl lil C AJe cJJr.Jt 6i i1 , l).cYl
eLlll pr-c O. ipl.hll ol*+ L. Li ,!gj).o) U,rlte l.SJ-bJi^lr gA t6.li Jl+sl+ 4+JW
r..Ai,6Jjhll *-i o!tS,::yl eitJiJ H^r:. J j.,;o ptjii dlill elrJl.r a+.*lrul eisJJl cr"i--r
r,ai+ qAl}j 4LJ! 3i r4;fs ']r=nr. \Jr ipt.hll ar+ d Ly .Jl*i Ur cirL+
1." g;r-.a ,rl*i * ,+ #i .! O'r.h]l .,,31, i C.g ,ijJr-oJf i;t5ifi J 4r< j'ltl
.a*ia cLaijl 4r4 C+r.:i
5L+"8t ttor ,ai* :irseu €..sr
i
o
N
eSUsjr
\d
irtrrilr
Jt:
$IAII0Irul[AIT
TIII CON$IIIUTIONAI COUBT
4
{
\rt\p#
IIt
\)
,^ll
[-r+<,h.F<J}{itu *l
c.r.,Jsll ;"i 3r*.,t1 ,.+t- fl+Cl.1..aJI -.,11qJl .rsYl dt3i e+-,lt
arJoirrrtt er5rll
lY. Y1 ,lr.ri o,e V d3lr"Jl -t't ttY 6t+* ur Yo 6.r;Q;*Srill+'Ub ar.irj^lf i*f+l!i-S.^ll U*-ijJ .r-fti (H p-..,b J-.!. / -.1l t,'l,r,ill , l,.Jt Lt i,ri
U -jll ,+ qJtl- 3 , .U.,,ll J-lB, l!3-i / irutff* tl 6ll-^,Jt L-3-.aca
s{Jhll Ot& O-rJl.tp I , i:t dl Ai+'ii CLgi-*5lt .-- C-+.i 'Jy
t-..i ,'i.gJ / , l*ll *-arf' s$l fsrll.1u
.1.1. iirl fly ii11 i{Jti..Il i.srtl d+r i *ll 0*ll g" Y . Y . pl,e Llt u*5. c.rt+tiJril+ i,otS Ojr.L '
:tr st JllLiJ$.ll us. .-,1 '-il;Ui alrp
:lJc#i-4ll c!-,,& ipJl,i. -r s+liill ri-or g3s-..,r -Y -,1gl
irli 9=9t r-n iLt*.,i -trJB' dd(r -v€+L4Jl fj atr+. -1 s+iiill Jrr, r.l*tG -c r;lrrsJl aliqc fpSlrp -t
Cl,.aJI r.c,all.rrc pt& -t.ilL';!l Cb.i-r: -l ;l*Jl u.i .Jy! $+. -A d.*aJl
.4:i,4JLlt ,r*t+.1 pldl 4;r"eYl -\r 4in,4J drdl {-,1J -tt +iir1 4.'lihll };l -t I
4\-+Jt
v\4t
\: J
' SIAII OI [iflAII
IIII COI{$IIruIIONAI COUIT
4
{
Yt\p#
)b
)
\l\} -
l&.in$l
tL,$ at+o;gpEll Oi - &-rY! u.. L)#i L t'.- - Eb.rll dr.alr O! e.p
ih) crsr3i i4F,.+ .tlli3 , Y . Y . ,Uf Ltt orl+r crl,,rl3:it d dFL (dJuull !J*J
t+. l i irtc! #l l.6.cEi C t*lt! rY. t ,ltllrv g-.tr+;.Srrll ob ,-rl3
a;1tS::Yt Uhl! Y . Y . lt I lo s.s &.i *:lt LVt u*IuJ r:Ll3ijYl .ilU,a 6cJUj
O)lel ir!;13 4ielb A*'L.!l +BilY! Ol+lll+ -iill Cilij eiS g+f3 ,(4iJEJl)
4li3,t#,Jbyl i-r.rrll ,+ILill .J-d..: il#-l,l r.1.*r 6J-fr.ll qjlrlt+ O+r^&}4ll j3e
.lEj,r dlll uJo +Ji U g.c.Ii4+JltJ -ufll 6rtrr! d[X.trs ,,f-,i' iJ* LJ tiif
', - 3 ---cr,*i Cl Lyl ur"l+.c crtr'rsilY (cl'ilt1 Uhll * *y 4i! Jli ,ilhJ UL"rr3
3a3 c'tj3r,.a (olV) .-.js +J3rr;i-,*d-!l i.i.U diilsi .rI3,l. Y./l Y/o g.rfQ
Oi gg-Jt O. gts il ,6JjlJl dl$ ,i k+b ,J.a 4t agll drle.ayl .r.ro jis Y L
4J." ,-.JLi LoS .alc zrjjrr ;lci gSl r.rill ,Jc r.;g crb.oi r.rc crle J.a+.l..re C+]riEll cf ;*5 r.rs LjO 3e,t':.<ll ls tgi.c crLiJLi.lll Cf +.lrJl grtriiY!
otlf$Yt3 ol.tti;Ytr f]pyl3 .r$iJl p.rca .nLa[.eS.lt ch3-.1] riil{r f#b-ii cYrY!
c,rL$tjlJ ;J..,ilt+ +Uiili .j.i.S {L p.ra ,,-ll+rJl ;* pLr.yY'U e$:itt e-5x3 ,4..r.,.o.!l
+1.aVt C$iJI # j.rrJl 4J"9 JJ$.b.+ iPtlill r'}Sj! gLr,*it l.rsl rcrLriir,cll
.jJtjl 4il^t etr:i Ulrlti cri C;r-:1,lell *1"l.l...ol tf,rEyt .,81.,-li ;1,+E) es-r,LejllJ+v citr prsj rrsLnir.Yl ,j,.aljrJr Flr" "&
qt-a Elsyt 4J- Ir* Di)lJ rr,.rr-., ,jL"ll 4&! Lt3! .r) t, 1.rr g.rll ylt , eL.. ;i.Bll ieiJl fw C t!$yt
JSJi .tijL
JL'
,$TAII0trIIWAII
TIIX CON$TITUIIONAL COIIAI
{ \p#vt )I
, \r-,rl! Aj)le! c{p.J rY. Y. iil (v1 .17 i.s- tl d+-, C ,*I $ l,
. eAJ*a OJl-L.ll
, crL ..htl J.bl-+ 0*+.ll 4-.JJl * .:s!l! i^S..:t ob o,,p: .rij lin
et -,i+ ,),aia 0l{# Sl.i$ (;rqs::)! 6;rr!) ;lStSt 6.rU-l cl" ;-Sr-ll c+L $J
o*ii,t!l JJe3 rY.Y. tirJ Lyl ud+.611;rr.'r',1 ; (tlJli) ,+tSt C Op4.r.tt
rrs gl1;Jl lla ).t*i.,.i!JL c$+-, O" E;UCI dJ * Sb i.IIi3,t4,ri 4,ti. ri
rre &F.+. ur eCb..L iC.i ii:Jl .r.ni LJ,LJI 4+ Ib , {JihJt C 4c2:fu,I!
JJe3 s[rlJl CtC r'1r 4jJ JS C C*+.r" dS L#ts ,j,4.r qJl c.'U.a!l r.ra 6C*5tjlt
qr+.+Jl jJill a;5 a.ir ''U;*i tr3 ,a$t^jt crljr.aYl JJs3 ris.srJl o5r:tLar {rlJl o.a C cil-rti:jYl C it;,5tirl et*,L ,ucr,qJ,.ell Ci^+ ;t 4gtq6Lib. tllJ.rSS ,a:h-oil e.JEiI til3 ta;to d,ar rrill ,:iJr.ayt &n+e f6+r jS ir.J
Jl,Lll asts::lt UilJl CH J" EJlirl '(ril] dt f,..tl 6;.1 u. JJ*+ a-S..lt
.,Js, kr)l!!..ilui.l c.rUt;4 i). UlJll d). +L ta;.Sr,.Jl l! r;: Oi .rql .tet)
Lte.lt +.it yt -g ,)) dtiijX l-sr.ll u. qJp:e c+r, , LgJ! sr.,,!jl ;Etull 5xa
(i3liJl) IilJtJ i.otilt t-,rs'tiYl &ru,o e+ J.j ri)Jt .tsb ,L!t url+il.O[.il] t.n # qiitst 6rfu +tf,S #r r] d i#t aor'*srt *'u]x! ]:ir. 612ii*Y
;-{.Jl elrY LYI ud++ Lrr:t cr-yl -f. .,'il gsr:rali *Sr,.Jl tc,.e ,iiijl $,1
ola e: il d+*r ,Ur.LJl r-ila gr3nJ! J''iiiYl ry d.+Ui 3*ii ,rc '..C! 4lttail
2,b, ,ppl,ir ctqi3 &dr 6;.+ cJc e)I!)l # t -a$ g$.d ** ,-rltslluJLh^Jl i,1c J.AHI e.i,l .;l.hll 4i..,4 Eftbli 4ilJL up e""zg.,p&il rj,tS- S
.-
,(/
\* J
^Il
'$IAI[OtrIIIflAIT
TIII CONSIIIUTIO]IAI COUIT^$
)
\b ,*l
Y. Y \/r/r i,"I! i.Sxll ,-u_ri.l .a"Lll ,;:it k Ei C +b USt (q/13!) o.rn
.$Cl A-J+ C$Jl C #l Jll.a!
ar5rlJ
.aj3!u.Jl .r1.3 .,irilril gL ,u ,dluitt c& t$Il r+
i+lS.j.jl asL,b3i ,,,rgsr*t $ iqhjl C! .:+i.
{Jl:.'i',yl 4J." c5L&.! cl+ d-frl a}. J-, sle 4sL sfl i,p'&11 O! ,o,J-J
,Jc al3,ar C ,ii"l: ,,lrlsijYl 4J- *f d U,i" crtilL;.e (eiIUJl) eflJl *s(crLli.'ii)J e+.*d-JJl a.i.tlt dl. l{& O)e)l e.,r*ll cr5rYl rrs,Jc .rr;r crlri
O*tJii.ll i). J*5 r.rc L.3o u9 r.i,isJl fl; d 4it, . o+Jru oLarl t-j tii3 clll3
c,,hf,fuYl+ ar*r^ilrJlJ CHiiUli *S e.ES .clt-cLeSjl el.t3-1l r*r.,...r +lriill 4jl"e ,U:i
orirLiJl ar.3 I si.:,Sll :.lh OblJl el*..jJ fS areJ ,Lr,all *I-LIFYIS
i.*i,a)'l O[1Jll C 1ijl 4J- JJ"a+ iPtlli e)iSJl gr.r.,Jl ;.reJ cr:rl.riLrJl
6r.r3.rirJ e+l9 ,is4 gpfl .ilui iP O+ll eL*iJ Li.-:,s ile iP );i ,fusrug
&l-fll itr.-Jo gl*Vl &si .-u.-;,-i tS3,jJil;+lre ,$[ ohl! ,"c uF,Udl
ot^hii U+} gg+ L. . eL* a:.Ur a.e';i J+ 31,1.9)'l *rt+ ,*elcJ .rcleirll
J)e! l#+JlJ;;*ll ;.rtr;r 4r.','ihl 3;rir ,e!l ,(.iJliil) oliJl+ eliijYl A+Ll
.;.rir.4ll ;+jiill
\"ttU\
v\,<|
\: J
s{s\p#t
4rI K.$IAII OII(]UAIT
IIII CON$IITUIIONAT COUIIr /r,^
1LYt ,*\. sWl crLrtiijl OyLl ilt+ rg.U-;pLLll tr,'1,.,u* t O) ,o.i-l.,
cl- 6t+4, i-o!'l u*Jr. *Wl gl iiil A+I^elL-li $.,t qrv ij-.,J (rt) #,i*,,U* 1.6i" # r.F.& grtrr q,i]
"ll tglJi ,.l. sli',iyl 4J- 6-'tt! rgss 6c,Ul4all
UL'a e Q+*.,. L3!"1 14.,1-,1 r6Li,irji* L+ Ltrtt 4+'*.rll 3i rlniJl dLiU J-i
6.U! Os drL U e-.,,* ,JS.iJ'1,,-S. i+iiIl O)il ,/t+ "'ir ccrl+ti:ryl 4iliil
o.ra,4j.rii sr ";-;l ;5*uff ;:ilJ;:t *;Jl
jJ.ill ;:.bls3 jJ.iji -.;r.bls.e "-tc
i-S..ll g)-Ll CJb cl- O#t O! ,', i-r.,
o.^ sJ jJijl 4l Lii- u crbeayl cx d+ d cptllt 0i 1lilBt; lil$l+ sr+^+llr.-.)g l-o og!,.olt 0.. lJJu r! i;tsJ oia sl-rtJjl ,rJ *ii Ol"i Cr 6[9 ,ol1l,i:ill
.r-.i .r.tt-i ,J.6J#) J.iU! jjtill dlar 3! ,gcLhll t#le rl/ar Cl crb.all .r.ls ,Jc,U3,- (olV) .*,r& cpt^bll (,!ar L"!1 .,ti3,.a (Y1. t) sc c,l9 (,ta,Jl e*l+
i,1-J A+EYI OJsi dtjJls .'E3,.,a (Y r . v) ..+ llrll jUJl iHJ q iiJL+ gi
431*. L eS 1"" JLrJ t3 ,L;sz dicLl $ e+,iiilt OJSJ lllJl ora d tj.rs i,Aoi
Airu! o. AjhJl cr'19,aU r.r.c ,Js q ol3,.a!l C{ rs "Jc
aJjxar ir ipl}lldJsll cJi t1 l*!p.a[ o- 09.3r*,c ot-.asi L-e 6C 6]'tir #r.ii i,;a dil=,liiiy fu";r1tt
tgri ,rLtcl+ ,iJt6j ei'Lii O- l^ral {i..*iJii q.irUi Aii,s U Ja aLjJ! lia sp 4Je
.$)t! uS'o l,6; hsr t1 ,
\ul, -;
UN\+rl J
4rf K
'STAII0II[IflAIT
IIII CON$IITI]IIONAI COUII
Ib
"$r
O++i'Ull a+.a!r, O-. Ol4.lJI el*,-|1jil pre U-o iPllll 4+e+ t.ej a.r.3 Y3
r.ll .i',Yl O-t,Li gi 31 ,ot+:l tl ol+iliJl oJr-r.J , L'.i(J .#4++J CE o'r-ct4sll U+eJ", L)*.. O,r.l o+riull 41'.ai",r, rF ,.!.irill i+l,iiiyl Cf+lJl el-..,..|.,11 !U r!crb*"i+ qi.oXJl €+ r! dji Ji .llJ.+ X.Lp pr-c -;;g-c #q c.* dl ,or-3,,aiJl
dEl\.l ,dlJjr .,,,, ,j gl i'li)l a-,rLe "J" -.,;$iSl f. fi ,ilC!,ai"& dt-:jb O*ii,UJl
,rtr( i.-U lSrqs: c+! d oL'lr'ri1 &.r,o .rt4 OL}.JI l- ,/ ip'&ll a!t-,, L oli.fu $r.r y
OhlJI C -1ytt 4JJ- lJ,a+ 4*{r$.J CL&.JI de O" iPt}ll alU t- t-l
4J- ct$! g&b ;S^Le g];lf t .ltr.ri iP Ot;lJI eL,-lJ uti.< p"ro3 ri-c- 7iJg a;Uitt
r+ tl;syl +! cilis e ,-cUir!l &l.fll 3rb.,b eltyl .iLJi qtJ,*i lS3 ,-r./ll
U.r CptLll ert C &y ,j1gi un*. h$ rp CJI Y $F e iL..e i:.Ult ielJla-.,.
"& ,,iil!-l +ti::yt i.,5tr ; ,rrl<&tlt r,air i4$lJii ** _li t{+le lrludr. OrriJ t^.,6;r,a,.,"Li
"& dle J+e iFLl! OJ* d cru (sli'iiYl 4J-.zUail cLbijl
qll+rll eirrJi
.Or.Lll u:i* :irSrll Er.sr
aJil;r s+.i
\ ",\)/g J
)
edrU erjrI
.L,
SIATX OI IIWAII
IIII CONSIIruIIONAI COURT
I
\,e il)
i^-
L'
r !'{$'Fi;)illYaa
+JSll ;"i 3,"-,,t1 .r.L- ft+Ct;..aJI -.14Hl .r,crYl d!! e+lt
a{girrr{ a.s.U
pY.Y\ +.,t;i Ut V dslr"ll -a\ttY Ot*r,^:,U,r Yo e;QA-Sr^lt+'U.!e eUr.l"lt i-"lJt+
a-.Sr,cll U*-iiJ ,-f,U (H p-...b J4!. / Jl-,i&..11 , ldt Lt i,rl
U - jll * drL-e 3 , ,uitt t-Jli l!1-.i / .rut t *^tl 6.ll-,..,,11 L-jl.ao3
,a;lJl cOLie O^r.rJlrp s l-,lJnJl 4j+\lr Ctos
: sfll ddllu. Y. Y. ild 1ty pi11 irfirrll i.srtl d+. i {ll grhll g
n Y . Y . lli Lft
"*l+. c,l+tiijl+ i,.ati g-f.b'
:+e So$f
at.+ -;.al.r rLcr -l PJS^ll .uo.i *L,,JH #b -Y g.--lnll OLil ,*.iU -\t-r
ui+,,UJl -r xl+ll Jti *hgj-,,I+ -o ".i*
rjC.{r eJo ;laU -t g!,rll
.i,^i1 eJJe {t f$lX) -A eii^J! J3rr-u, irlllli.e rJt-i -V Clrs J.frjtqc.clUti Ot1l,l r,f rr$l.us - 1
:lii+lihJl ;r;J -r Aii .i' ,!J!l o#l+. o*#J - Y 4ii,4r Lf t
"*5 r.*rit - 1
.4n.+ a+t, U,tt sUli":l)l "S
a!r',.,*tl l+l1l i':,llt .rJ: - t ,oi,.a't
t*, J
r4ffi\W)
STAII0Irul[AII
IIII CONSTITUIIONAT COURI
aY
\rl^l)
\Wtl) ,t
)
\
7l
-Lr
L,D.
!'ilill,
C lrt.L &deEll 0i - d[JYl g" ar++i L+ '' - gruslt dlaLr 0) C.i.
i-S..tt ob r;ES !ll! crc.r3i ;ii..ai dlJi3 , ! . Y . tld Lyl LJpI+I crl,rtsijl
url+'l sl ";r-l gr.i',| 4J- O)LL# #l tglEi C Ij$L cY. Y.1\ Y/Y. e_tQ
ssa a;s ,-ui,*i t- g>lJr,.3 ,i^iJtjJl LlihJl j Y . Y . lt t lo &;tr &.: Cl Lyl
.-,,8j .1. Clll "rro
++i U g.e ,ejEr
p$+ lAri $J (dJBl) [JjlJl ce CLJrtnJl cr lits r#) ICE .llhJ ul#r
Cl aj+..rll crLilli.dl ,-r.s,.r.illi rl+ riS 6cltJli.i',yl oJA C ea.tri iJp C)e!
0*Ji,tjll op.J sJe gn *lrl*S.ll gp +L fJe C Jil gSiJ a;tS::ft 4*Lrll ,-,,,[]1
or+Frr nJ1 olitiJl o3p3 r..i.&S #L ti r,i;ult #$tL# t{iiiE.J Xl_* O" sf:!
hrliu a;.,ti::ff g,rtiturti o*ii'tjJl cJa+ )-3r^dJ .g$!..a$3 g#ti.a iJ" .rSiilJ
sl C.fuljt, CL.o^.Jb ror3,.ail! L_,.4 Jl l..r ,sta:r.:l j-!.fl! g!" *. O-dtil! alsrl 4ilti.il+ A+^"irJl e;Jtr
J! er)[e) (.{)+J rY. Y. ;j-,J (q) fi-),J A.Si.ll J+-, C O-!Jl $ -,.far.i gr*hJl
.r33 . Gl,.IrJl J^aL+ O*dl 4+Jl .,Jc ;r.l*t aXr.lt oia ctJi r!3 lil,L*! Oaia O!# tdlilJ. (*!ts::Yl 6-'t.!) a.iS,trlt irfu U i.S..tt c+L
O+ij,tJl JJe3 e Y,Y. ,Uf Llt u,...l+.c &Lrii',! i (4ll$l) U:tSt C O$;lrllr.rs glJill ttA )Ul*i,.jt,.r'b 3)+.' d)" iJlgl ctJ,l l'. Stf ,y,Jjj!3.t65 UiJJt.ll
tJ.+. u. r#lJ-t, !3J.ri OiJl r.ul LJi.ll i1..illJ ,6jhJl C 4rrc- ;iLlti\.
\t: \
tJ9
t,4l J
$TAII0IruIIAII
IIII CONSIIIUIIONAT COUAT
4
a
\PHe{l
)l) , \
[,
*lJJe3 e 6-JhJl Ot+J Cr 4.,'+l # Cy",",JS t#e J,,ar Cl ob..yl r.ra 6!*ii'till
gr* .r.rjjl jill a;;U a:s ,'Ut,.,,i La3 ,a$t Jt *gr!t JJca si.1p,a!t o1.9rolt
L'U o;r$ oJA C crLtriiJl C it;fliJl et^*! e q;i.{Ji.ll Cd.+ ,JI a*.,,illi
tl.ib. dlltsl ,i:h^ll FiEilJ tA3 g*ts ,J.4r gXl c.'ldl e.f+r p6.re # #J-1Li.cJl +EijY! qihll Otil c,r. 6JUCI t$iil e.lt J^bl,*.Jl gy; U. Jj,,./+ A.Sull
"& l.ee)t!l-r ,.ibrL {,Uli+ i}" i.,UJJl iF +L t i-Sr^lt l! r-U Oi r*..1 .t<+!
Ltr.tt Ct-yt -r.. "ll dlijDl a.Sr.tt e +f^i" c+r.,ht! ;.U!Cl '.;*:ls.cJl -rur..€
(i:Jllll) lilJti i,.atslt sri'i',Yl &ru,o di J-, fi)tlt lts:'u ,LYt o'"b.J
,gt:,lt lb ,/ at$itst 6.'ll +ES Ot U d ,rill ..r#tiijyl Ot;Ilt -.JF:'r.r.. 6]!i*YA.6.lJl elrY LYI urh+ Ltrii Ct-!t l.;! ;,prr'li^l! a.Sr^tt ble,Ji::l $"1
orA f,*: il d+1l ,Ol.hll e t.r^:l JliiiYl J:sr+ +liJl J.Xl "Je
l-#J! 4lSJ.l!
;,As cpgsLir el+,b r!!,,g)t C;,l+ "Js g)}lt cr ef^ll oHS^i rl3 e -,pllsJl
,* kii IJ..,. d.,!.6.r" !r"$s ,ea,.at$re (irtJl)3 1;Blt)s (,byt) OJjetlJl
,6++ st$L *iU! CrLLjl C c,,l+l.iell c;.r*i l*&f .Cr.hll ;i.,.,al 6.r,.1!ill f#tJL.r*51 +,."tr,, tj*.Ljl C #ttt lle! t. Y \/r/f i,."lrr a.Sr.:t -u.,t\v-
L5rtl.al3lr.Jl rr.,J .iiill! gL,,U ,&-rYt s/e g}.bY! r!
.a;.CUr ast;3i jsi*t rs CrHi O! i+F
{
r<-i,C
Y-J/
\"'d J
)
aY
D
$TAII0IMIAII
IIIX CON$IIIUTIONAI COUNI
),
OJ*L qA .#ts::Il O$.hJt Oi ais:.^Il o.rn ,L,il! C ;r,AJl O" .til d+pJ
e-Sr^lt+ klt.ib k*i-rS Wtr!+F,jjrjl U$ y:S:ca,ol- 4r#L c.,li e5ta6
gjll relrdb tlsry! fu*,ralt1 4 cl ,Jl 6r.s.r +yts .ls!.re-, lKt! L-rjl-..St
4r#L A*rlej t-tJ tils #Ul t# otriii Ct ,Or!l :rjl,.ail! Lr3teJl -,lL i{J C,arl
cltL: OtSl , 4l.r Ol,S t.l, k l-i L+"tt *lelp.Y! 4.Sr.oJl o.ra pLi uJr&ll tLilgidlJr3 , t!l$.3; Oi O$ l.€+Ie L&E lt atL*^lt, rrril s+I3:jyl C"!Jl .,.i L-r.ittrr+ 5++ ciblL 6! i.S..i! dJS ,fii a. iru , srrljt ola 4+rL t,lJil i.J Lii-,
dlJ.j !.+ "ll f+ ,;i er* OLi cl" r! JlJryl d)" ijL' €! jJ+ y ll.hll dJ+
.4i"t3! $e 4+le 015 Llc o-Li,b OllJl
crtIB.dl 0" +dl U+J i). $-, sJe #.tr.L !* r! Or-ie< 01 ,o!-J
C*+iUll o3p3 ,b 6,0 oL'r-os3l 31r +L fre C c,!.: r-ririiYi 4J- j aii,"rJl
)L,iei,ng.!,,.ai*i-e f#Ii,. ir .lSiill r:,iJi3 ol+i':r.tl ilitiJi op.t.i*iS,-.lL pre3
.rs,LdrYl &l$l gb,..r!; hli'U +tS::yt otiUa+X C#iUll Lfr+ i!.3 0e
fKtl ,uiltS.tt+ a+."Lll *FJU. sY 6r"ll+ CU-..ttl r€r.9r3Jl L--,;,*; L,)* ti.. O_dlil
Lgri,l il .rL LAlr-li Ol+X r-rislY! UhF rgs O.b , r-iiIYl CjtI rr! ri.|!,
4-aii^Jl h.r-J C UlsJh a*.girl i;lr jir+ 4ji yl . +.p *{iitu +*,f,ai L,,LJ
Ujl$l Ol+l e+"+l .-rr diryl &rti.. i,9 d[I ea+ rr+ , t(# .-rl'i.1iYl eitij O)s!i
crl-rt^iijl gJ +;jllJl el-*i &te) i+..{i}l iitit g+j*}Uj, dtJl clrrJllaa\
r
\*tq.l J
\r$
(
aY
)
$IAT[ OI II1IAII
THI CON$IITUIIONAI COUII
)b
v rll a
-^
1OL1rUI oJn t<JJiil gjill crl*.[Yl a-iE,+ d!.€.ul-,j, CL]XI o.ra -,;.drtre,J"-r.J
.h ,l+ t i-.a $ d,.itt Oir ,Ld")L,, LgL, *' isiftt
c Y . Y , fbJ LYI Url+i crl.rLrijY qj$ll i++nill c.,lSl ,dllr OtS Lol
cy ,€l dJlar ,9 i; d (aiJBl) 4#LiiiYl tilJti e+-*lJ!l ii+lll kijJei silb
C 5-'idl Oi r! ,lilJl ,il$ crt+lsijl C jlo! #Ja-ii olrYl 0. rre sle O*iellll
.4jl4.t e*U: .r ta.r.l ;* ,JiJil L.lt 4jlr: U 3o gLlt tra
C*ii,ljJl a+.a1"& J. OhiJl eV3t dirj #e O. CJ.lellll 4ie+ tl a+l Y-l
O-g.G Oi .! r,g,rl ri'rintl ,:l iitrJl o3;J tq-it.OEtiiLjlt oJ|.l.J 6-s Ot-rlrsJl tj+L)*,+r, C*Ft.ill a+.ai"& cJ'. {.Jiritl i#tifiYl Ct+Ul el*..,,j}}U $ gl.iiylcrb..i+ HeFl r;1;p $ 4ji Ji ell+ f<.S p.r -.fhr #+ c+l pJ3 ccu_3,.ajll e+Le
dBF ,AJr 9rr.,.9 sl .i.iiyl a-rLe "J"
jiJl a. li ,fr6r1+,.i..i ..JLijb C+ii,lill
,rrr< LjJ kii-'r c+ d crLaL;il crri ,rs.,4 oLijl lb C oJiellrll e!l*. t- 6!i.tu $r.' y
A+".iJl orii ix ferl .,Jc ol;liir)tJ C'J.*i,Jlll .r.ri liJ+ e ls.rYl i,re t"i
air,a cr.J+ 3i oJAU+ #. fi i1c l.,,Jflt el+ $i,€lii aJ3.l ary-:r tu1,.i(Y aS-^fll
.a,c Ju,eilyl !F O-l{$
r.rli.i:yl c,rEt.b1j a+is,Uil (J:+ JrJBai 0. OJ]gt^hJl a;s+ t J a+S I l4S
tr,. "Je'l+*l*.
,IlJi3,c{J'.ail! L_-;,.q Jii* l-i rs,fals.Yl J-'CJ! #l,. uJo hn'U
gGt r-,p.o 01$ Oi J+, Y ai gi i1 ..,tr.'rryl A+l^eorE.
ctrul .JSrJl elh ip ltc
J
)
$TAT[ OI IIITAIT
TIII COI{SIIruIIONAI COUIT
)
\l)
e ill a,
i+cill ,# d iru ,Urltl si t-t'U q $+ Y .l;iiijll 4iLe as,. ci dlS.tl
.r3Jr CJ asir.. cr'ri g3ll *ljr)'l j.9 4*r- 4je ,-uf,,.i Ll 4+l!. ;iJrrll
. O3;LiI
iFJ ( O-r.lJJb Clt l 1.x ,rl*,i "J" dG JBC, C&ll OJ+ dlJ. ,rc t^";*f:3
. zU.Ait,;; clr,irill C,i{ d
T*dl cldl. O*.hll #t:*rSell 8r.5.
arS.ll .r+t erlillr I
.g-
J
r
w V
\* J
€{s\p#I
STAII OI KIWAII
IIII CONSIIIUTIONAT COUNI
rgs\ffit \rt
r\l
I )
\,t
i^rrr^
\
,€r.itr,fua;*sSll ;"i j,*"ll ?tL fl+
rl+all ;t+ll .r"..tt Libi t+\.iJl!'--
iilgirrrJl.e.s.ll
pY.Yl {*i ui. V #b"ll -a\ttY Ot+,.tui. Yo eJqeisilll+'Ute;Ut:"lt ;'*t+tt+
A-Sutl ur-=rjJ ,+,U c,1; e*.b J-ci.. / -21 rr,*Jl , Jdt Lt i.li
oJ=r+ll ,+ qj.tl-e 3 , *tt J-Jli l!1-i / ,ryfffr,*.ll 6.rt-,...11 L-j*aca
g'c-tlrll cOL.j,e C*lllg 3 J-,LJ'all 44li CtoSa,....'..t lt # U'+"i ,--jy r--,i , iirJi / , l*ll .p-ar.l
'4Il CrlllrE.1.1. iid ltfl iu i{r*rrll i.Srtl rr+r i r.1ill O.hll d
" Y . Y . pb LVt ,/+. c,\,l3ijl+ a,ati Ojr.h'
:+e Sgrjl
Ct^a i*t+ r-,i='L$lqs ..fui
:l.j
.xL-Jl u.i D.L &dr -r -g',-ir.ll ,:,JJ- r-si LL.,i -Y (grisjl "ilt.+o t:Sl!.ls -l
Ct. Cl--,-i ,Jt -1 Fd,4Jl cLB y.lrJlt+c -o 6JL tl l,f u..allqc tL&a -tJ+e JrJ.r OaJG -1 cr+iidl .q.c .lt-e UJJr-s -A €{L^Jl .ll.,r!f _rrj O.lt+. -V atUitt
plrJl gyll -l Y 4:L!a,' p!,,jdt O*lr.l s'AjJ -t 'l -irir4ll e-,1+ StS ,Y4r - \ . s+Jldl
t s'::Jr'
w
t*, J
$IAT[ OI I(IIIAII
IHI CON$IITIIONAI COURI
4
{ ,\W! )I
u ,,e "$l
4ii-4,r i-f t ,*-l+" cHt{J -l t 4:i-4r LtitSt >jf -'tf aisar r!r.l+Jl OpJ;.ll
; Lrt u*ryr pbjr 6r;.!r -r o
liliCl
-fui) a;cEJt 6i dbyl o. Oi+j L+ '- - #llJll di.atr 0! d.i'A4i*a,, dlJ.l3 , Y . Y . flrl LYI UHI+.. cil..rtiiil j cdr! (C1,. f""t+ u;lLlll.rp
6rls! #.tt t<.Ui C 4t! cY. Y./t v/r. epe i-sr.tt oio .;LiS !l.r! csrgi
i+1ilJl g)e,b e+trtg i+l,.yl (4illJll) qjlJl+ .irLi..all ei.+ CIEIJ &.+b jrijl
dt3iJl 6.lb! ajs j-,i UJ Gl fg! dS -J#-.;lr r#a Cir.tJAJl #,J aai.r,.J1 ;t1r*1,1Jl
.tEl .r 4Je +)r L3 U^*Jb -p*ll +
,riJl Lll #br *lti:iI (4ilt:lt) Ujhll+ i-l..i;r c,jls l.F) nlti dlhJ ijl+J
c,,ji L*3a +-ric-, ctlii LJli.i',yl 4J- ,-,,,[4f1 4j'b ,Y. Y. lltlo g.r;tr -**1
Cl*l LgbA * el.rilL og*alt )j C ji.ii ,;i.!r.lt glri"ri)f bitl a^r.,a ,rj
# e++ dt Ot+Ut O" +dl d +b.l+ # e++ d O+lt t+)tsrr ,1,64j.rr.
k;'r Ois o.,,- J.r;.JI ;+ii, f +Lii.lYl .irti.a ,,iils ,;i,hl+! dluyl p g>t.Ll!
OLlll da+ 3li3 ,l6js diJj."^ll i+Ur o,!3-).rJrr.J sjJ e+.J--Il Ol+lll JI dii
4J- c,tiitsr gc UUiS,idl J*+*J d\Jll s1b+ el*.,j.1 ,JaiJJ 45tJl (/..r$a o.{-iJti: C*S,junll er.+l i;tr.ntr pt!;Yl ;i ip )*bi ,4iJ..Y5 i-:s-/Jl OSI d jllO>le) .ig3'Uf (tt.) .- O.4jtt.hJi 4Je ,'.iga:r l. OIJ Siti;J! u,JeJiiajl rJe
j$i: l{i$L} Ob a*.Li ,iiliidl deYl ,}1,...J d& t riltiH a+-.,.-tl i+iilJl
-rr'*l
\
.t{f1
w:,V
V i-ri..alt .l;
J
$IA1I0IruIAII
TIII CON$IIIUTIONAT COUII
4
{ ,\ffi)
brll
(t{.rjErr d+r.U cue! iJlr.iiYl 4J- ji .rS} t ga,l ,6JJSr^!l 4#lJ!iyl 5ytrll .,F
.OSl iitu l#'qI+ knL LE! "tt
t4; ls tr".
,U)le! 15,1+J cY.y. ii-J (\t) p* ;-Sr.ll j+-, C 0*ll +Je ls.eal; oJ,l-Lalt l)
cdit-r.bJl J,Ab+ oiiJl 4-.Jll cp 0*!ll i-Sr"tt ob *-.1E .ri3 lta
,L*i=, ,laia Oli# l#Eb" (c,rl+ls3jYr !l.rl) arlrrSi ;tll c,r" a-csull +lL riJ
C*ii,UJl JJe3 e Y.Y. ttJ Lyl ud+. {rLr.:il c/ (IiJBI) oytst C gJ#!s.lc gll.rll lit )tru,.i!J't, o)l+s i). irUJJt (,JJ i- gb.y.ilJr3,L6+ a,l,lalt
r.te tJ.+" o. fr#!.al+ Ul.i OjJl r.d i{Ji^ll a+-JJb ,6JilJl C Clre- ji.ell
JJe3 e iihl! Ou ct" 4bl ,JS C€4; JS k+I; J.ar Cl c,'b.aYt .t.tca (0*5tJl
gr+.+ll 1'.;iill i;*':: a:c ,'ui"i tr3 .eJlul i!r.a)l JJc3 ri.r.srll nbhayl
L'un qjhll o.A C crl,rtrijll C +jtitl eL.-,i3.uF&nll e.i.+,JI aJ...iJl+
6l,ib. AlSt ,iih.ll CJL:Xl tis3 gr-lc ,J.,r Cl &b,alt g,9^;. Xi. # ,};g
JL&ll #tiiiyl ijlJl gt+l il" 6J!-rll l6"ril'r elt J,aL"ll gq oa )y.ar i-S."lt
"Je te.oylb,,i!JiJ c,rU\H O. ojjJll ir. +t t a-Sr.lr ,ll Ul;i r.+.t+l!
Lt*lt a.lt yi -rcl "ll dtiii)tl i-S..:r L.,a ql,2r- c+r. , t(+l! Errldl ..lxllsrJl ,ts'^a
(e-il$l) !ihJ! i.agl ul,iii)l &ru.o Ciri J*. d)lJi .Li:b ,Lll u*l+^J
.oLill lln C 4JitJl Ufu +l:s C,9J rJ d ,rrl asli:iYl i$l JF:tr. elAlya-,6.11 chI Llt !yl++ LhJl cr-oyt .b dl, Orir:i.ll iX'.it W ,Ji:jl $.1
ora fl: ,.r l:+t ,gr.Llt e gq'.Jl JtiijYt ,*iii r+lxl J-1Jl ,r& 'wJl a$rdl
*\
t'tg\ '1S
\tt
w
r iri,ait J
4
{ )$IAT[ OI IIilAII
IIII CON$IITUIIONAT COUIT
b
\e rll a)r-;,ai 6#ttir el+.b ,it.,;3ft e-r+ "J,
g)tbIl cr ttdl 0S.: {S .ytuJl6+.r+ L:l,,lL +lUF gllrtt. diiJd a4Fra p$j ccrlilLtl sJe f".al i,:ctllt ,JS-l
,.r:ir el,ieill kie +L i5L (i1.t3l) o.r*} Og.Lell #E teS e r.rA p3:.ai lU ttb
.piJl e-J+ 6*Lll C #l tlr-! Y . Y l/r/r e,"br Lslell .:.r,., ,Or.LJl
ar5r$
.al3luJl r.{J ,irilll gLt,u ,.i!^rlt s& t)}yt rr+
.a+S,ill asL:3i dJi-,| re CrLll Ol .:+t
OJ.L gA 4#sYl OJr.LII r,ri a.s.rJl oia ,ua! "p
riill ir ttj! ,&'J',,
e-Sr.cll+ Ldl,.ilJ !,g*iJ-, l.6.rlrl*F,5Jr,! L+ &ai:,i,.aLr 4r#L oli agt.aE
g]ll rebnlb tlsryl aprl! 4,-,..J1 6lrc a.r:-.pE s!-Pl fKtl L;3l,"*rll
4r#L 4*{.i l-.1 ti.l dul i{+ o,arii ejtt .{All 4:riL.aill c,3leJl JIl.*ll Ld *llclllrj OlSs , 4l.r OtS l.J ., t6.t-i irr:.lt c.leU+)!r a-Sr.ll o.ll pl-i qrJrLll tEsidlJ.t3 , LAhrl Oi Ogl l,#je es,,!^ll iJL*.J! .r.rsi1 ,;l3iiyl O*ll i a.qr..!l
6++ g.l.,lr. flJ A-Sr.ll dJr,s OF t O,cJ , O,f.hjf olA &+L a,4fi L.l tiis
6i AS OL,i.r r! dbrYl ir JLt,fi+ l9+i I ,cJ*.h11 is+ q r+ fJEai qjtir) 3i
.4i"t3) Je 4:de OIS trc 4.Li.b i'lall dtJ.i !,-+ ,'l! f{rJ
jJ.i A+Le 65J et}ii tlSl ir $*,., cr& 'e t*!'-'tJ t3 4ietLJl u! '''J.J
O-o ''' & .e Lg.ri l-eS c gl rlll d+ ,r-i gJtilti. U+J iP ),:i , o!r,.a)l C+-f
t''\1.1
t i-ri.alt
t\.
)
$IAII OI IIflAIT
IIII CONSIITUTIONAI, COURI
4rf
.l't\ffi
r$)I
? \
,;.r-...i.jl i-:rtlt +:ilci 1." Jisi *iJ..i ,rje cJ,ar S t+f+ Pl.oYl cl.t...r., k+.re
"J" gy-byg rlnl iJ- eGi ortrll g. +.r'Jt up +l3.rrl+ k-;S"l en,.+ d dL
uJu e ipJl!! 4+ro,rJ +rs:rYl (irLi.,. rtr+,J4. il.eilb, e.$ul stjt4yl
i). Ot+Ilt ,.p+,-.li l-eS,4+.*JJl OLilJI -J! kjs JJL,,,^ll i-:ritt O,rt- ) a;i5"
jJlill ;+Le r:Ldls.c (p rl3tS,alt ,*+-..i Ol;lJI .tr+ cL+.il o:i"rf r,an,itst c/.Jrro
r.r.c uJlsi Orr.iil.ll H^J i.:ir-tt fLlJYl Ci Cp i*:i ,;+l,.yb e-- t,;,iJl Ola.lJI ,/.l+llUl d+JdJ &r"Uri -rlslYi 4J- Ji .rS-!g L -lag,6rtr.;Jl;,.,t.rc- Jii.Jt
a*.,1'U lal.sl Ol;!l r.lrii',yl UtlF re.c $ OIS u.l-l , +rs::yi OJitl O! ,o,J-g
b.r-J eJ oltrlL;-.+lJll anlJl .t+ dji yJ .. 4-j ,SFb 4J.-i OH 'r.6r+ii
Hi+l Hl .i.iiyl cirtj/a j1r dijJ ef r+ ., Lg;i ui i.'i',yl elUj C)e!+ i-,aii.cJ!
,/,lrtlll cto*,i O)ri a+,*,,l-il ii:lll ;*J*jaU3, cilrli elrriL orl$l gt rt
.jjl oleLp)l a-lU r.fc i!L4 .ut*i u't+Xi or-o -*irlr.c urr+J e 6jl$l ;;rl-11:.'iil
.te ,t+ L as.,a JA jroyl iL ,l€:")L.,d.tc sJe JJPJI O$l o.ra l4j.rril
r Y . Y . pirJ 4..y1 U.Jr,c crLirljY a=r.ibiJt 4+i:.d! {.ilSS , ,l,LJi Ot.S l-ci
a.isujt d.lar gs ,,i,,i d (4-tiEli) is's::f t {ilr! i+.*,iJt i€Jll **i *rt,cJ,ar ri Lgji c+EJl ri , rytSt cllj c,t+tiiil g! lJ.lJletr$ cilJlaYl gr,c t.rs,rJs
L#!, Llr.4i .jll o[r.,af i r.!.c ip i+ +1.c J.lJ ,';j* (t t . ) c.t-l-i tr-c ,r&
(r1\
o 4.ri..all
\..,
$TAT[ OI IIWAII
IIIX COI{$IITIIIIO}IAI COUTI
tgs\p#l){t -
[-,i,-r 6rJ! {llrJl ,'i (Li,il.j! p*..+ .reri rlii ,J*.e) J-thJi 5}lt+ jill.ll e.i,;llll
slKijYl o.A C jJdl Tl ,.ii.i J t $s,Lto (Yl.t) ss.rJc
aiel.Lll 43Ue 4JIj tr Ji +ji1 re p)l-e}l #L*l OJs i.r dLh i). cJL+ y
la.r-l e+,*$l i-:.tlt 4jlri L so OiA! l* ./ 4Je ..b..it ,;i il , Uti. 6.lti: g"
l-#le ,-,1, - ,i b-i +U*L1 fs i). a.ietUlt 4+e.ti L.l oJ Y LrS , tf# 6.lU rl"
Ol;lJI rl.4!, 4+S ./ dirirr ll .f,i: :i .e+i+ll3 i*tl 4+Ls, ry' r'&ii rJ+J 3i ,
..-,rl i.'ijyi i+Le as.,6 crJe L#ir: aieiljl 41il-,.,, lri AlJ.)+ Ji ..reiil.r-r. 3i
j ,'1.,. ii (tr-r.J ., J+iull *#l ip -1Le gt-ir rnr d'i( 4lt 09* Ui 3r+ Y 3J
c,rt -{ tlra) g11+ $ Lii ,:rjii }l 4ii +s )i-.ai , Uytit t*r'U o+ r+ y l('r- .a
f-J 4+8" i-:Urtt a+iiJl ,t# p-r r-*J ,i;,ti::li '€L,i. UH # U Air:-,.
ora ;5.,;i 13 ,c,}t-qll .lgrt.r& a:ir-d c.*j dl *!rYl ,s ;.5 4je *Ji.*i
a.--g ifl A+Le L)".., qJ C.+ t-e .r,u.ail ir.o gJ i-,,s;iurl ,U.USI t^$ iXr.lt. t{.,e O).l)l d Jt a+*i:ii
, s$'Lijl3 e+!J! ;ro *,*i-,..,1 *& #t .;F d.; !*}i!i n*.$jr s,te i.++*tJ
a4# c.Liaili i.It+ f,r iru
h.L+l{*! ctul. Cnlrlt U6q# :d*s.[t sgsr
i;{Sril gIHJ Lrldlp
J
)I
$TAT[OIruilAIT
IIII CON$IIIUTIONAT COUAI
4{
Yt\W
)Ib , \
F#S'trJ!,ii|4 *tcr#Sjl -Jg"i J,"-.Jl .;.Lo fl+C! tl *hll r".ti Liti e$lt
e{JgirrJt i.srll
pY. Y\ +.,;l1i g:c V drb.ll-t\ ttY 6l+.ir 6r Yo e;tra.Sr.ltr Ute;.rir:"tt i*t+lt+
ersr.Jl U*-ijJ cr+U (H p-.,h Jrr. / Jt-ii.".ll J+-Jt Lt i,rr
oJ=+Jl *i cJtlr 3 l-rall t-lls l!3-i / gpt"t,""ll 6ll-,..,11 L-3raca
cr{JlJl g1t& &..UJh!e 3 t-,!}ll 4iili CUo.l
A-^*lrll #C,+.i ,jF, lli ,iUi/, l*ll *f-a+
' otll efl5E.1.1. ill ltAy pr ifirrlliAl' Jfl i *ll grhll g
n Y . Y . pLi LVt .J*l+. r:t+l;rfi! i,otS g3rr.h'
:+e Sltrlf4l-lljll 0*lr fis -L-lll
:lJ
CrJ J..l r^r - t ,-r-p&il A,i5 u.i -,' */l r6s ' iuul - ? ,,r1,* olisP O"-r - \
.u.allrrs r-r-,.,gU.r-c -V gr ui{1 ,J,n!l+ro srJe -1 iSrrl<tl L..i .,-.ge -o UJUI
iriAL&Jl r* Lt,,i -\. li.ireJl et.I+oirlr+c -q q+.,r.Jl ,',riihre.if airl.rrc -A
4fi.4rLlt .,*l+^t ptdl 4,cYl -rt'4iir.ar cJ.lrJl -r.-jg -\ Y 43ir..li5tSt f_jl -t \
I\,, J
$TAIT0II(I1[AIT
TIII COI{$TITUIIOI,IAT COUII
La
Y
Yt\W
Il)
\)
.?^\!
eJI$l
{*,r , trui).ptUt Oi - dbJYl 4" C** U+,- - e-,UJJl J-,.[i} O! .:rp
ilr! ccr3i iii.',a,,.lll.rJ . Y. Y. ,U Llt c1,,\,o sLri.':',1 C ,* (atijt ur.r
3+.* 6.rlsl.r r'!Li .SiJl t€-.tii *i r*JU rY. Y.f r v/r. e-tQ i.S..fr ob r;tiS
oj-ee O)leb ,(rlsyl) 4#ti'ijIi lilJl+ i-- -,,.1r e+Layl Ol+ill C jll elEi 3ii+,Jtij O. ,:lh .,& ,Jr. .jii rr g.o e+^iill Slls) 4Je .A+ llJ GS 4+-J r.;..r
4ieJrll3 a*'f..!f O[+lll c]rU^+ cu-j,.aiJl .9,!3i g; + t+.+r-l iup irlr! :l+Lliitb
-r./ll 6rb! 4je ,,i..r tJ ia3 aag.; r;....s ojJp O>e,b 4#Eiiyl ("!yt) qilJl+
.-,;tii Cf ,1,U. ,,.1" +'>ri U 6.c ,e+.iiJl3
g$ LYI u*l+{ il.riiijY (.rlJ}'l) EJjhJl re 1.4.1,c s\'S a.l! cjlS diJ.rl U',r*
d)i arsi: a+!.Jt, +c.9,....ff plsYl Jt"J -:,iici .rI3 ,Y. Y./t Y/o eJl+ +*1frr+ Air*ull *ltiitYl b;ij C)e! .io 3;p Aii X! .e+BiiYl ;+i"il1 ,J'!" 4its
,J.ar r! rAi. t+ ('l*'"li) ,:.f (.Jfyt) 0" P.r.il ;3*-h^tt i$l ,:l+tiilYl .r3 oi$
al.9rr ojr.J.rre.r-l l! ,glCl @ d+ Y L^ $l u"r (tvoo) .- ,rJe cptlJt
,J.4r j1: C .n$jii)l C iJirr 4trl! t p dii: "Jo *;p *!-r-i rre .,Jc
zUjnar Obi Cl *!rYl Jr* rp !,',FS Je *tj".i l.lo ,rb J^ld! o.r..b gjra.Ldi
C+"+:4i.,- i i-hr tesJ cP ''\&u yl+r t+ Y L+ ecr+i 6-rl! 5!l -Pl .r.#ls
a1 l.s L.,sril$l 4+[ill ir,.*,r:3r ;:gr3 4J.aYl O$lb 4+e]Jl CSt+ o!r,.aYl
.JSJI 4ilL rrjrtfr. diLJ! a:*.b Ltil ;t
q'.tL J
TIIX CONSIIIUTIONAT
c,,Ut# Cf ;-,USlt cr
$TAII0Irul{AIT
sJl dtiiill i.SMtt O.
6-rihlt+ e;BJt r-rli:iY i
!.n C L\ii,hll Ulu +
4{ ,\W
)
:\e r}l ,
,l! d)le! €FJ .Y. Y. iil ( t ,ti ';ud i^sr.ll ,J+*, C i*!ll + e,s
.ear*b OJ*.L.ll
+JL $J r,CrL"lltl d,\*.il 4..J1 s& C*hll i-Sr.tt oia ,-rJn, ti3 ib
Ot+# tdti'rJ. (el,rtilll fi:!) 4*lilJl q;Us s" LsuJiC dli.,jlJ.ll et -,1+
il" dilil ,t6.i gs,li^ll rteJ.Y ^ t. 'i*r
Lrt u,"I+i crglr.iil # (l3ft) i;tlti+JlJ ,Uihtt j r:* ;r+ll lrl )trlj, ,.ibfif cry+-, iJ. {JUJJI 65ld l. Cab
l,#b g.ar ll o!9,a)i
L3.iJ!t4Jt crl3*aYl so3
.dx+r'dll r.te tJF+. ir. f#l-e*L $.i orli uJ L_Jj.Jt
ir;r.ali n'lJl.€Yl ser <gritiji ge.j ir a..r1.J dS .,.i e+r.pc U
C +Itill ,1"*'U ( 3...+ ,.! .lr;l'y sri^+il: jJill 4+$ 4& c,j-,i
G.9 tgtc o,ar il i g.5r.;. f#. Ljs urj L''u, grlt;lll o.u i oqB'::Yl
OlJ O" IJUJI l+:;'': crll -riarr^!! C* u. JJ^.ei li-Sr"tt 6't!lJ. Jjltt ,iilr.,!l CEiljU a-Si^Jl Cl qJs Oi *l .t+rt! rLj,.li a;ti::ft rylSt
d+t ,t65i trrlJri ,*iri-^ll JJ.a cJe ',€*U ,&lif
e-e J*. ,"i>Ul itJ'J iLft u".l+"J Lt .tt Lt Yl Jtr
,lt .r J ,/l 4#lr}]]yl Cb.I!I 2)ai€g glA!"I (.frtt)L e tt cl.rY Llt
"+o.tl r.ir ^i ,',i. .i-a.Lli
lrJi +jtrYl ,g d;rs$rr:! a.SrlJl lJ^be di:il $3 ,gLiJt
g$.ll JliiiYl ,r.!r i{Ull jn:li ";c
t"#l! 4iSCi
s45_ 3 ."ja: ipgslir rl4 ii!^rli Cf"+ srls, e)llYi ..la pg-giji j;r(.: ..u.r-l ,,qbtt-ujt
C +L isr. (crilill) o
0r-hjl qp rSrJl ,,lr-! Y . Y 1 !? lY a** A-Sr^ll c1jS .0qhjl u5_,, k tii."Ldl;r*Ii"\v-
r.ll
w
Jejr.h.l! i,F.,3:ris.il f.If .dil,*lhll crls fi.dJ iPtLll
$IAIT0IIII1TAII
IIII OON$IITIIONAI COUII
t{x!\wt
\)
t
[-
i,.Sru
.fu3luJi ql ,i*illitL*.,.-l ,d]1lY! .P g).!llt ,*
.;+i(.j,Jl asLil3i dJi-l s g*Jl Ol d+*.
uLL':iYl ;+Le ,-',.l-.i "9
dji.r d$rJl Ui. $-l g-te a:r.U c41 i1ltll Ci ,', -.r.J
.t.Lo ,Js .r.prr clb.,.i "to
;.-.4;i 11 ,,-,rtr.'.rYi *.-J.rJ AJL- ot,iJ[i,.c (d3tl) SjlJl *-io-l.sr- oL -i t-J Gl 4!3 .*relrlj)tl 4#.+\5jl i:.lt O" k.to gy.c}l d dl cr!r.a)l
OHll gp ,b*., al'1r.,=Yl Ci"1. cr'-l4e C 4#L.. c[*ii ,-,.3J US .e)teYl #Ll ,U!..1
dUl JrYl ,i+-#JJl ;nlJl ;." iitr,lr 4JkJl io.::lf qr-i l+l.,.,,qli 4J4!t 3i !s3t.i-pelt i+"cx! o)e.b e+.+lu;jjl 6rtc! ..,.dLi.^, llii:Yl 4*I.c Ju+i 4r. q+ej.+
fEJ Lyl U|*-\+4 c'.Jrf-l *!Lr:rl ;,9G J",,;S.ly dPLhJl a; .jl,'n'i.r *..Jj ,0,-.-,,
{.c3 sCrULr,'ll ,1. el+*+ Lff .,pt-" ct.i3ei ;li!i iJ- }lr}i $ ,111Y &J (f o)
3i eliill ,Jt+u s! i*.,Ut ki" d5.tC6 oLJl L{,iI ,,.!! #gi cx *l:.::}l at1.c lfrp
A! "+ .r-rE$!l 4n[:i Uf- a .,l!-r,,, i;i]XS !j,,!-f r6Li,ia ji* L+ LUlr 4+UiJl
sLo OLfIlr o.u ;rjllsr gir.r.3 r,il+ii,rJi i.r.l;j ip dsLaf Ci* ,Jtt+ Ir+r- aa='filt O)ej
d*.yt ul3,t{i.e)l*,,6rr}rr3eC C'r+Jl o.ra l4.r.:-iii ,ojJl citrlp1l *iSrts .!L.a
.h ot+ U a-r.a 3A
s+.+ill L;,il! 2;ts.e3 _ipri .rn!t rts. ;..S.*tt g)t!l gU rx &Jl g) ,',+r,,
t
O. OIJ .cJtJLr,iiyi orA C -i$.1 a.l ,jis+ U r!r..aYl dF j+ d .ptgt ;i 1;3:t) ajhJl+
Le*le d.,ar ,rjll *lrJaYi *s ,Jo +x t *ir5,-:f J.o ,9ri re 6jiJi o* C pr+ Crrci
(Y \ 1v) sr.e "Jt
(C*UltCL..a *1'.r,-.;s o,.t*,i) ;*lr.t Jf"eil urar i! ..iciJail
\T
aY
STAII0IruflAII
IIII COI,I$IIIUTIONAI COURI
tl)
\,rlt
[=rr+ -r&lrJl j,iUll C,iiJ 4rii ri;t+ ,t\ |.Uo (t voo)us
"& ;p&ll J.ar I rti .iij,.ac,rl+ ri i=-iill OJsu,ijlJl ,.a d C+ gloi id 4#ji!t Oss +H$,Lr (il r;Or Jre ,Jc al3-'ar !ft-; .r! ql$" ii ..X iplJei! +!l*.l t-c e&i L .jt+ Yl .iry..e
4+b ..JJr.lt ,;l 11 .sLJl:.'ii>U a+".1'Ull cllt g,- i.h.lt crlrYl rre gJe .rr; ci!,.aYl
i:jtE !# \g i ,ll s+ .l ,iJl# eUi: .x la.r.l ;+-,JiJJl L:.lll 4.i.!d ti Jo gLijr lia i.ld)lel
C+liudl p1...,,i t,'S+ l-rldl crgrYl j-,s JALr. c/ eLhi'i .U+$ C,rctldl cbtl l.i
l.ra rr_.!s'lr=it. )+Jr fr4 0i ,.1.1,' . aI*{J. ,.Jtfsi ln oL+ ri! ,L'iiJ.it c;t tl f.Eu ,J4s C*r:i l-tr r6-s-^a,rl*i
"jo dli Ji,i, al..hJl CJ* d o.J (gli}:.r-iry li r,els.rYi
4,4.14 elrieil!
,rLFrill c*hli
.gr.hll &i,l+ :iAll €r5r
i6tl #jr a-iill ,r Wi
J
It
)
$TAII0IruilAIT
IIII CONSIITUTIOI,IAI COURT
)e r\l ,r *\
-.+S'[3jt"6f =r+JSJI -;"i 3,*.,11 .r.t o fl+
Cl;,aJI -.,11t;Jl r.qrYl dlJi e+^iJl
arJarlJl i.S{tpY. Y't ,!.ri 0. V d-e!r"lla'l t tYOl$ 6re Yo C.;Q;-SrJfi'r.ib fri.L.Jf i,.IJr+
;'-Sr"ll or,--iiJ s+U CH ;-',b J-.s.. / ;L--^i:."J! ,, ,. tl Lt i.rr
. '"J njl 44lli Cl- S oJr-rJl ,+ d.tl-e / irrLi;r,* tl 6.rt-.J1 Lg:eJ
{-.iJr",ll O,sJl.tp e+!h! J s-UlJl cALi,e 0,er,.!l.t.lc. 3
a-,r,trlt ..# cJr+"i & +.".rll J-Jl3 J-crc / , Idl Jj---r:rJ
'JIr.5rl!;.-
t.t. iird (l.)C <lD ro>C <r>flf i{Jti.Il a.s{ldfl {,i cr1iU gC{hll d." Y . Y . lH LVt ,/+. i3l+13:jt+ i,^atS i1..1FL "
,r/. itgiJl.gA:t eg.cL.'^ r;la
:-isi+rjl ltgi at .rp .lltg" -r orjbJl l$lJt .ur s.rlj r* -Y o.ejtrlt dLirti pJU-, gtls - I
c/ilCt itlly .ll-/u JJr.cr - 1 c*,i-Jt #.,3" $ JlJ. - o o4rJl qi+.alt d-,,1+. gi.r.4ll - t
. ;lLl cgJL! .$, -1 crtsrll rf .rr*. .tr.aU -A dJrrL.ll nlrt &l ,.Jt+3 ej',a -V
\*
tgsw'l
SIAII0IIIIIAIT
TIII CONSTIIUIIONAT COURI
t {
Yl\WY
r)z' )I
! \" rll
lJl ;r3 - 1 't ditrlt ge" u,* 4lll JP .to.i - \ .
.41i,..+ LYt ,r*l+.l1 pbJl 4.cYl - t f
!.iliCf
.tc1.,,. r1t-)gP&ll Oi - dlJUYl ar O+i L+,'' - e-tiftt d;-4Lr 0! '''.,'
.,1i.,,*tiJt;6J,ilJl i f . Y . lU LU u*t+.41[-1ri""il 4-ta ,f # (€JS"lt cpg
i* cr+l Y. t./l t/l f g+;t.r1 i-S..tt ob ,-r.IjS 6-;lrl crc.t3i ifur,a.++-}+ d!i-,
ij-J (1){o) d* l+S gl.b rii+r,4 !r3l Y. Y./\ l/t v Gttrl e t ' Y ' ir.,J (Y)
,.,1L ,Y. Y. Au 1\ .) d* e,+ iFL ltjs.a fr3l Y. Y'/\ Y/Y ' e-,tEg e Y ' Y'
4pylfl 4JLaYt Oblll ellj e*.c+:J j-p 6.rbl+ :rtl,ai :t'sll dr..all 4E aui cf
,.pil! 6lrsl 4je Ji-,i L.J 6iS a;,ri-.;,l !i.,a oi$ O)sll ,1l^.*tSltl a;;ti::Vl 6JilJt+
6jilJl+ giurrri!1 i+jll O).h++ pL,.irili :bbt+i.l .-,,8i ,1.cllj oJe +-,1.rr U ge $.iillJ
.6J,jlJl+ i..+. crl.rtiijYl Srlsl t6r.aii ,lLii J" dllS "Je
+* U 6.c 1i,""tXt1
ri3r ( t 1 '\ t) .lr-J,as. $r (1,,-rSll) 'oJilJl 6c 'i-;-.p
Ols a.r! JE Alil Ut*.1
5.,.!l ?rL^a tg vy (f v) ri,,,Q 6JilJl+.,1& .slLrll -FJ"ll 'tii.. OlLrSiYl ,rl
,* d.4s ,f.rltJ (qfir*tf gL.c rr^,, alrl l;r; .r.i) llrJl 5.r,.il OSnhrll JFilrJl
{iL" ,',.,[! il 6iJilJl ,tlE j !rli.'i:Yl 4iL" .j oti]ti" &^lJ .16 Ct3 edi3ra (t 1o t;
cJU+U 4l cJlJr.4i ,-rL,,',-l f.trJ +lLilYl.r oljr..aYr gr.c#l r-r.lo, 1,! etlii crljlaYl !i
i5_li-rl r,^i 6J,ilJl o{d i+iijll Oye! ;s> rji ,#Srjl 1.. aJ irJs,a dFi crljr..ai
,.j+g rl. i.l,a.^tt 4++:lt ,ii jt;i3 ,ir+r..all 4+riill 0)s!l &raiillJ jiJl 6rbl
YJ. V,
Jt
$IAII0IIIflAII
IIII CONSIITUIIONAI COURI
r4X)W{l
)b
:\
J
//
\* J
r
.,Ar,*ri;r!l i+Uf .J+ ,r i.ilr^tr 4+JiXl oe d!3ii p)ls)l c}.t*.,.1 *e fut-lls a;*sri.
rLii 6rtrrl rl*..3..,;J NiiilJn deJ iJ#.rJ.Jl er!, -f 0" iJtJl FLr.. o-+ Jli ctrc )..h1
.jul ritu 4irrlL., o.r.ur L6! ,rl t ls giJt yYt .LLayl 0hJJ d#ti..all dij
(o)t (Y).r*'0t?* sp *rS ar g$Ht i-s..tt ob etis 61l.rl ,iE +ieJ
&Jrr.h.Jl ,J! f#)t"! .r*-, ,r'Lyl u*l*. cil{l-iijq i-B Oy.hrr Y't ' iU 1\')S (1)-l
.pal.;
,',JtL $J ,c,'U4I+Jl J,a&i Oir ll 4+J!l ,je ayt lt i.s*lt o.la cr-./r 163 lb
,l OF,iJ"Jl rr*,,! d.4L Ol+# WLilJ. (d,rl+t.i3jYl i.,;llt; 4ililJl 6tl-l-l cln 4-s-r.lt
.t#i UE.Ui.ll o#3,tjjl JJe3 e f . t. ,frl LYt U#l+. drtrli'iil up (i..,*BJl) iJrjlJl
eP ir+"i*ll sc gl+.rll t.u ).1.i .clllliS cr)+-l !F lJljill 6J t" gl3 t,' d!i3
rteJ ,dx+rtjJl rre tJ"+. aF f,'$ilJr.ai+ U'hi OJUI ruj lJnl iy*ill3 ,6j1.ilt
(:JljrYl Jre3 r6.,,;rilrJl 6rtr J.4.+l # qi U -r,/\s L#!'i d,lar Cl slJt'aYl
ef"+ ,JI i* ,:rq s#.iill jJil! iiiSj 4je crJLi t j ,itLgt ciljrYl rJca r4r;rr.all
tJ"+" it+. # uiy'i-;Jr 6iilJl oll ,Jp clLlrliyl d.*till pL^,"i-l ,O+:^&'r'Jl
ei^+ ..,. JJ,.+ Ls..lr iEr3. dll3: ,4jh.ll ClEj! G3 q;tc J.ar ll ol-lrYl
,,!! t-,,,1 Oi r*r.s .te+l! -lL& ll 4#l3ijYl 6JtilJl OH il. 6'1t-5Jt [+'t"' .,jJl -r*:ls"Jl
6r-,1tjr!l yillsrll ty * Lfp)llll ,.!l,pi3 d.ul+i .r 6tli.d! cl" ','lL L Lsvlt
elul .rrS:t3 ,LYt u*l+.J Ltr.it a.ruYl Jr. dl Jliij)l LS."tt 0. auJ"ae +$ ,+l!
+EiJ)l gl+lJl J^llsr elJii-,Y i,,-tilt 6;lrJ! i,atstt r-rtiiiYl dfrLj/.a eli J-,,
r
$TAII0II[I1{AII
IIII COI{STIIUIIONAT COURT
1
:\,,)
("'ul
$3 ,61i,J.ll l* sp
Jar+ qt3ll J.Xl ,/5) l-++ll e.tsCt 44&.ll plrY L)l ,J-l++ Ltrlt ijt"Xt ;ri"
g$Yt cl" f-ldl 0..64i .u;3 ,-,ptr.dl o.u pil ,-r e+. ,Ol.hll ' iln elCl dliijyl
Y . Y . ij*l (o) dt c*Hq iPU.jl Oe ;ritL.JI p.ri ,pgsG.r pl{r!., sll.pYl Ci.+ ,,Je
g4s3.,1-! 6llcl L6aEi ,/ +L gGr 6;sr.J t. Y \/\/Y. L*Ii+ gJl$j..,.. i-Elt-
oJc L{+ f..a gLi:6-fro (\.)3(r) d,,r C*hlll d d L5,i.,rtr"r:Yl 6tttt1 Lhrl
p.;6r!ll eF aptHt ip'1lilsJl p.r! v. Y \/r/f 4-"hJJ,gl.hll 'i''4 61.;1311 4irrrL
,ii;...aq 6r,;l3Jl 4il.,lL .,b q+ p"o,a 6_.,;5.Lr3 Crl.rj3.rr"c agit- Y.I. iil 1t.;.Ll-.:t)ll Y. Y. ti",l 1I) dJ C*LJI ,,J! ('l .)s(l)s(o) t'",, O-rUl *A-s..ll c,-,r}s
.fJill L"l++ Oj'l'll oJA el fSsjl -;l.u.a! i-Sr^tt c,tJS e 513 #. tt#-,r..ai3
i6u.iJ3lr.ll .tr+s .ir.it7.ll el*..,-l ..!UrYl
"lc g)!Yt u;
.i;S^ lt LgpLilsi c,i-**l OrrLll O! t:+.
4il- j oliJLr. t$jr; ,JStt cr $-,, cr-!e ajr-b ,a $ 6etLJl 0! 'o'i'J
,ol3r,.aYt ef.+J jy,t pUeii U+J J,'.11 1fr.,.*tSJl) 6JiilJl ep o* ll r-r.t3:JYl
ird-,. crl3r,ai du+!l .ilJl J*:ti. oJo O+..l,yJl ,;3$" #i p.le cp )"ZA
e+*lrj. ir de J3 4ji LS ,ct_F.i O,riiJ"l L{dle J,ar dFi ol3r,ai 9t,l,nrl3 OPU!
dii e, ri Ci3 ,iJ...rjJl i+Ur L#iiei 1". JBi crtyai (P cJ,.. ri 4jti f)eYt cj.t*,,g
.a+l$i.4#i et 913,:jYl dirlii.a'4.
ffit\+r \
\: J
SIATI OI K]IIAIT
IIII CONSIIIUTIONAT COURI
.o ,\Wr$#r\lp\
rf
*tlal.sl Ot+Il u.liijYl 4*l- 6-21.r! sP c,r!s Lil3iiyl Oyt! 0! 'o'J'J
i,a:Ltt h.r.J .ra 6;flJ! i+*+Jll i+Ut .Jr+ 4ji y! .4P-P ..seil i+l,,ai ut+l t#. tt'
cl.ril! 6jihll Otst U.+l ?131J\yl diruaa j+ EtS ea+ rr+ ,t(li eLiiltl dtjJ 0)e!+
.iJilJt crt+tiijl ep.#-!$ll ct"^.,i O)e! {#il,,ll i+tlt rtll:.r#-;.hu3,.lhJl
i++.riJl jJJl =;.als3 jlll FL.. ;c A.Sr"tl t).b! it-9 C, i;;Jl 0! 'l"r'J
6dJ+tjijYl ol.t eJ jJiiil d.l dis; t-o drl3i.aYf Cr cI+ aJ Cptllt ,ti ,(i,,-tSll) ;JilJt+
ol3*aYt s.c .i+il l-c drljr-.aYl j,. !J'lU .rI 6yt.rll olra o!r33il d Pi$ Obi r.1. Ci-l
* @ilJl e+la..rr-,, ell +e r^i) y't Jl Jtjll cJ,4r 3l ,6el}ll L#l'r d.ar crill
dJLri V3*(t 1\ t) tJ.^++.1& .erl-rjl -F-;"JI ef iPtHt pl+ L ill ,E3t- (t 1o l;
or cli-hS.i $ 4r",lUlf i:+llt crjls rtll a-i3 .Es,-a (f V) &l# J.it ,ll iil3l iX+l ++
&i!ei lt ,U3,,a (1 \) L4-t. A,.ijj" i.1eilJl L#le d,4s":lt ltrill crl3rYl .t.le pt-.a.rl
,;+ L#!, d-l4r "Sf
!t ill drlj*aYl r.Lo oi 0i- ,/ ,'133r- ( t o Y r) ,;9 al3r-.ar
Ie 4+jijll ctSSSS ,6-j,jlJl orA sp *i-ee Obi i)"1 4#liYl oJS ,flji lr.j ,Ej,.-a ( t 1 \ t )
Lhttj id+.iJJl et-biYl Lhr.t rls.l LCt dL+ Y3 'cldlill r3'rr cA i=i..a csph
i.+Lill ol3r,,aYi .no 6-cr.3 st-^asl qp el.Lii E.SJ rJ! tfr+-*i.Sr"lt L4j.u-,r r,ir;ll1
6i it ,;yt.r.lr Oh:l &r+l cll3xaYl jj et3j e#iJ dJ 6i,t-iJrll &+ L#le d,,ar s:ll
,*jJi O.l"i .r j3,i1i rt-tt srl+tiiiyl 4++ii i). J+r, ji SLi 0- o*! ptliYt ora
dpfLll +!r-,, f^te+S Y Ci f-S e rJetlll k+le d.ar i+s,a ol3..ai tll^! #+ c+l d-l
w\_:
\* J
4
{$IAI[ OI K]I{AII
TIII CON$TITUTIONAT COUNT
l
\,e rll
*\
Jn OiJl l* ef 4ile ..Jr*.lt Oi ii (t)eYl crl*.r r('il,' 5;[ir gu:] a;*,r& el-,anl 6,c
.4JS etii tr b.sJ A+-,iJJll i+Ut 4jhi t-c
4.jp ,4-r.r,.3$" 4++n .,.l {J.Ls'iJ)l ,3plj,a cjii .s-+ r! 4ji ir iP'J.ll t..lcit" Ui
.:J-,,t-! Oi O*+ y 4jle j-1rJl i+l"e pl;r.1.! + Y! aii ) dcrU'all dij 4il^e .3C 0e l.rc
orr-ri 3i i-:rtlt o,,,ui.i ,i*; i::st t-cil3 qfu$.all Jii aiilJr. .,i iF,iJ^ll sdsJ. &r.+
,L{JU+! ,l! grr+ 3i t('r- ,.J+ li r-r.l3,iiYl 4i1"" ,Jc 4.: JJii Y d C," yYls ,ic..;rilt
aJ3 ,J3Yt rLirill ; ijgt Lyri )qtg.,,- qF! LilSXyt d3.$,a,-r!, gtjrJt qlJi"^l
dr;! d tji dl,4lslls ,4+ ,',dl ,l- ++tisJ dl'Ll"E oULr;ll Lr;r!J+9l pj)l,ll 3Lr:t
.ti -l-+ Y .r.ualt lg j c!*, r- OF ,Jf$L.: sr-rtiiiYl cl.rli' i d+Jl Lri+ $ aii LJ*l'l
.! $q Y dlrts^i,3 ,.lirsi 0USJ
,rL*i ,Jc L'l!.;e a3jnUtl oJa fuSi 64+.+ +ii,-c ,& '.,d-iJl+ 4.r! '''J'J
.l+' e* st ,biil "rjJd. ,g3il3l3 it+tt Cr
e*.81 culi
.0$lrll ,;ait :irSrtl 'ir.s.
aSU $4.) qrl
tt/\")(!'r
:/VI
J
)