Critical Dialogues | Issue 5 | Writing Dancing | August 2015

34
WRITING DANCING 5 Exercises in writing towards, about, around and alongside dancing. AUGUST 2015 1

description

Exercises in writing towards, about, around and alongside writing

Transcript of Critical Dialogues | Issue 5 | Writing Dancing | August 2015

  • WRITING DANCING

    5Exercises in writing towards, about, around and alongside dancing.

    AUGUST 2015

    1

  • Publication Staff

    Guest Editors Erin Brannigan Justine Shih Pearson

    Copy Editor Cleo Mees

    Production Coordinator Yeehwan Yeoh

    Contributors Erin Brannigan Nikki Heywood Julie-Anne Long Cleo Mees Justine Shih Pearson Lizzie Thomson Nalina Wait

    Patricia Wood

    CRITICAL PATH STAFF

    MARGIE MEDLIN DIRECTOR

    YEEHWAN YEOH PROGRAM AND BUSINESS MANAGER

    BIBI SERAFIM PROGRAM AND COMMUNICATIONS MANAGER

    STAFF

    2

  • Critical Dialogues is Critical Paths biannual online publication. The next issue is scheduled for February 2016. Sign up to Critical Paths e-news via our website to stay informed.

    Introduction: Writing Dancing (Sydney)Erin Brannigan and Justine Shih Pearson 6

    Still Held Cleo Mees 12

    What is it that dances something else?Erin Brannigan 14

    Working with the breathNalina Wait 16

    Scores in hindsightCleo Mees, Lizzie Thomson, Patricia Wood 18

    Watching CannibalNikki Heywood 24

    Watching RosJustine Shih Pearson 26

    Collaborative writingJulie-Anne Long 28

    Authentic movement: seatedNalina Wait 32

    CONTENTS

    criticalpath.org.au

    3

  • Dr. Erin Brannigan is Senior Lecturer in Dance at the University of New South Wales and works in the fields of dance and film as an academic and curator. Erin has written on dance for RealTime since 1997, and her recent publications include Moving Across Disciplines: Dance in the Twenty-First Century (Sydney: Currency House, 2010) and Dancefilm: Choreography and the Moving Image (New York: Oxford University Press, 2011) and Bodies of Thought: 12 Australian Choreographers, co-edited with Virginia Baxter (Kent Town: Wakefield Press, 2014).

    Nikki Heywood works in body based practices: devising and directing original work, making performance as a solo performer and in collaboratively devised projects. She teaches and sometimes takes on role of mentor or dramaturg. She has co-curated regular platforms for improvised performance in Sydney for over a decade and frequently engages in research and master classes at Sydneys Critical Path, including Responsive Residencies in 2010 and 2013. Heywood was recipient of the Rex Cramphorn scholarship in 2005 and is currently a Doctoral Candidate at University of Wollongong. Publication of doctoral research includes the 1st edition of Animal Studies Journal; and international Performance Research Journal #18 On Falling, discussing the dance film/animation Recapturing the Vertical which she made with photographer Heidrun Lohr.

    Dr. Julie-Anne Long is Lecturer in Dance and Performance in the Department of Media, Music, Communication and Cultural Studies, Macquarie University. She has worked in a variety of dance contexts as dancer, choreographer, mentor, dramaturg, curator and producer including Associate Director One Extra (1991-96), Director of dance research organisation Critical Path (2006/2007) and Dance Curator at Campbelltown Arts Centre (2009/2010).

    Cleo Mees is a dancer, writer and filmmaker. She trains in BodyWeather and Contact Improvisation, writes essays and performance reviews for publication, and records and edits video for a range of projects. Fascinated by affect and the interdisciplinary, Cleo fosters an ongoing dialogue between her dancing, writing and filmmaking practices. Her current PhD in filmmaking at Macquarie University brings all three practices together. She has made several short dance works combining movement and text, and in 2012 completed the essay film You Laugh With Your Whole Face.

    ABOUT THE CONTRIBUTORS

    4

  • Justine Shih Pearson is a designer, curator and scholar of contemporary performance and dance. Trained originally in theatre design at New York Universitys Tisch School of the Arts, her work has been presented in Australia, the UK, US and in Asia. She was producer of ReelDance (2007-09), acting director of Critical Path (2012-13, 2015), and is currently Lecturer in dance and performance at Macquarie University. Her current research integrates thinking around spatial design and practice in terms of global culture, the embodiment of cultural belonging, travel, and city planning.

    Lizzie Thomson is a choreographer and performer working across dance and visual art contexts. Recent works include a live performance entitled Restaging the Hills of the Dry Grassy Jazz Dance presented at Alaska Projects (2014) and a screendance installation entitled White Record presented at Carriageworks (2015). She is currently participating in a two-year International Exchange between Australia and Finland; researching Choreography and the Gallery with Erin Brannigan and Matthew Day; and developing new work for Sydneys Spring 1883 art fair program 1 Room 13 Times.

    Nalina Wait is a Sydney-based dance artist and current PhD candidate at UNSW, researching the nexus of improvised performance practice and somatic intelligence. She has performed in works by Sue Healey, Rosalind Crisp, Nikki Haywood, DanceWorks (Sandra Parker), Hans Van Den Broeck (SOIT), Sydney Performance Group, Lizzie Thomson, Joan Jonas and Marina Abramovic. She has written for Real Time and has presented her research in symposia: Centre de recherch sur les arts et le language (CRAL) at Ecole des hautes tudes en sciences sociales (EHESS) (2015), ASDA Sydney University (2015), Improvisational Practices Symposium at Critical Path (2014), and Cultures of Change at UNSW (2013).

    Patricia Wood is a collaborator, performer and maker, working in the realms of dance and performance. Patricia has worked with Les Commandos Percu (Fr), Stans Caf (UK),Tasdance, the Fondue Set, Autumnal, the Dirty Feet Collective and Link Dance Company, and with independents Ros Crisp, Clare Dyson, Natalie Cursio, Martin del Amo, Dean Walsh, Solon Ulbrich, Fiona Malone, Jo Pollitt and Paea Leach. Patricia has received support from the Australia Council of the Arts through programs, SCOPE and Artstart, Ausdance NSW and Western Australias Department of Culture and the Arts. In 2011 she was the co-creator of the winning film in the Dance Your PhD competition, presented at TEDx Brussels, which led to her taking on the role of Entertainment Curator for TEDxPerth in 2012. Patricia is currently completing a Masters in Research (Dance) at Macquarie University and was recently in residence at Critical Path.

    5

  • INTRODUCTION:WRITING DANCING (SYDNEY)

    Erin Brannigan and Justine Shih Pearson

    Writing Dancing is a collective of artists, academics, students and writers. We have met once a month since Stephen Muecke and Erin Brannigans Finding the Right Language for Your Practice workshop, which Critical Path held in collaboration with UNSW in 2010.We have a responsive, organic and non-outcome focused approach that is centered on writing exercises brought to the group from elsewhere or devised by group members that encourage writing towards, about, around and alongside dancing. Sometimes this involves us in dancing too. We also respond to particular writing briefs that participants put forward (succinct by-lines, responses to live works, feedback on writing), do some shared reading (for example the Language poets), and also discuss current work, programs, pedagogy and politics associated with dance. Sometimes artists just talk about their current projects. The group is about community as well as work.

    This issue of Critical Dialogues aims at sharing some of the writing strategies we have been deploying, some outcomes from those processes, and some of the ideas that shape our work. However, it is not without a sense of irony that we put forward this issue the well designed, explicitly set-out record in black and white that a publication such as this involves in many ways runs contrary to the non-outcome focused, in-the-moment, generative kinds of writing that we normally pursue. In cataloguing a list of writing exercises we have engaged in since 2010, we found ourselves searching sketchy notes and dimmed memories, asking When was that? Who did that? The examples of writing included here, while true transcriptions, have also gone through a translation process of context, fragments written on scraps of paper and excavated out of old notebooks never originally meant for display or publication.

    6

  • Atlanta Eke. Photo: Gregory Lorenzutti

    The process of assembling this issue in itself demonstrates something important about our Writing Dancing collective we are bound by the processes of doing and being together more than the building of a paper archive. In this, the writing practice is akin to other communal embodied practices (such as dancing).

    Writing and DancingThe productive tension between writing and dancing has notably been tackled by dance theorists such as Andr Lepecki and Susan Leigh Foster in their evaluations of the development of choreo-GRAPHY, engaging history and theory to trace this development through dance manuals, notation, and performance.1 As a system of writing, choreography operates as an apparatus of capture (Lepeckis phrase) against dances inherently ephemeral nature the first emergence of the word occurs in relation to publications of dance notation, Thoinot Arbeaus Orchsographie (1589) and Raoul Auger Feuillets Chorographie (1700).

    Outside of dance proper, the art form has catalysed new modes of thinking and writing. Historically, dance has operated as a productive foil for poets such as Stphane Mallarm who stretched his writing towards the image of the dancer as a poem set free of any scribes apparatus.2

    Mallarm has since become the creative muse of philosophers such as Alain Badiou, so that dance as a practice and image has been generative of experimental writing across literature, theory and philosophy. Our approach is different. We begin with the tools that the discipline of dance chooses; breath, movement, energy, weight, time, space. We then bring writing into dialogue with dance, approaching writing and dancing as poetic fields that we can work across for the benefit of both.

    By poetic we mean activities that engage deeply with the resources that the practice itself has chosen,3

    Nikki Heywood, 4 x 15 mins

    7

  • Hellen Sky. Photo courtesy Hellen Sky

    the medium and its parameters; so in this case, experimental language practices that are not separable from the dancing practices that inspire them. For British poet J.H. Prynne, poetic thought is stretching thought through an experimental approach to language involving the internal energy of language under intense pressure4 and the language produced is then equivalent to the thought and exists independently as its representative in the world. Pressing thought through dance and into language is a good description to contain the broad activities that we undertake.

    That is to say, this is writing itself explored as an embodied practice: how can we listen to the body when writing? What is the sensory experience of writing? of dancing? of watching dancing? But also, how can this embodied experience come up to meet the dancing through language? How can I write this movement in a way that somehow conveys the mechanical, poetic, spatial, imaginary, quizzical, multi-sensory mix of what I think, see, hear or feel? What may the writing give back to the dancing?

    Ever since Wagner dimmed the lights of the theatres auditorium, we have been trained to think of the act of sitting in the audience as a kind of disembodied experience: losing myself in the dark, I project myself into the fantasy of what is on stage (or on the cinema screen).

    But this is a mistake that contemporary dance in fact alerts us to. The all too familiar lament that dance is un-understandable (I dont get it/ What does it mean/ What is it about?) comes from this misrecognition of the embodied experience of watching dancing (and by extension, a misrecognition of what dance is). Watching dance one must have a willingness to explore, with the dancer, where they might go, what they are sensing, what they are working through, what being and doing in their body causes me to experience about my own. This is our contract, of sorts, to undertake a process together, sharing space and time, kinaesthetic and affective experience.

    Most of the writing on dancing printed in the popular press as reviews or in academic tomes, is done from this position of the watcher sitting in the dark. But writing around, alongside, or through dancing what we have called, in naming the group, simply writing dancing functions differently. At the heart of it is a respect for each of the originary media, and a desire to stretch both towards each other. So we have the existing limits of the two mediums being both tested and validated by the pressure of creating something new each time we meet, a pressure driven by the energy of the very tensions between body and page, dancing and writing.

    8

  • How can we listen to the body when writing? What is the sensory experience of writing? of dancing? of watching dancing? But also, how can this embodied experience come up to meet the dancing through language?

    Lizzie Thomson, Circles dont go anywhere

    9

  • Shared memory-makingWhile the emphasis of the group is undoubtedly on exploring the co-implications of writing and dancing, over the last five years our monthly meetings have also been important community touchstones in a much broader way. There are times when the work of the independent dance sector feels lost from view; or worse, at times like the present when the changes to arts funding in the 2015-16 Federal Budget is wreaking havoc in the sector, our work feels disregarded, unimportant and unvalued.

    As a group of independent artists, academics, students and writers engaged with the independent sector, the opportunity to come together to discuss the recent work of our peers and our work in progress is a way to insist, through communal memory, that these things have happened, are happening. Not necessarily or only by writing about it although the printed record is important too but by being there together and bearing witness to each others endeavor. It is a way of enacting shared memory-making, and making persistent the circulation of our cultural production.

    People have come and left the group as touring, relocation and all sorts of other life events intercede there is no official membership. But roughly

    thirty people have been associated with Writing Dancing since 2010.

    In the following pages, we have attempted to catalogue a range of writing exercises we have engaged in since 2010, and have included examples from some of these writing tasks solicited from writers in the group. Here too, it is evident just how far the informal collegiality of the group extends: ideas have been borrowed and lent and adapted in what can only be described as a promiscuous sharing of intellectual property, or a fast and loose kind of creative commons. These ideas are generously offered and exchanged within the group, and inheritances or shared authorship always readily acknowledged; in this spirit, we also share them with you.

    --

    1 For example, see Fosters 2011 book Choreographing Empathy: Kinaesthesia in Performance.2 Stphane Mallarm, Mallarm in Prose, Ed. Mary Ann Caws, (New York: New Directions Publishing, 2001) 109.3 Laurence Louppe, Poetics of Contemporary Dance, Trans. Sally Gardner (Alton: Dance Books, 2010), 12.4 Jeremy Prynne, Poetic Thought, Textual Practice (2010) 24: 4, 598.

    The Writing Dancing group acknowledges the support of Carriageworks where their monthly meetings take place.

    10

  • STILL HELDCleo Mees

    12

  • Years later, Mondays were even better. Because at Monday Bodyweather you were always enough. Told what to do, but also to accept what your body was not going to give tonight.

    After a day spent wilting in the heat of the office, to come to this big and breathing space. To direct thought into the limbs. The eyes suddenly brighter inside the head (as though they had swiveled to survey my interior), flexing to catch the body as graphic.

    Working hard to make the plank, diagonal, up from the floor. Arms pushed up straight over the head, lengthening the plank. Tilted forwards like a ladder. And always the diamond in the hips, still held.

    --

    Written and workshopped during the original Finding a Language For Your Practice workshop. This two-day event in 2010 spawned the Writing Dancing group which, five years later, continues to meet every month.

    13

  • WHAT IS IT THAT DANCES SOMETHING

    ELSE?Erin Brannigan

    14

  • The Mountain Dances the Man

    The rock stands up and supports the nest, providing a perch, a refuge, a home. The rock reaches up, cradles the nest, comes up to meet the birds in their flight.The unlikeliness of this home or habitat is lost on the mountain who gives up a peak for the birds.

    The mountain cannot hide the nest.In fact, it becomes a stairway for feet that defy gravity and pick their way to the peak.The mountain saw him coming, far below, offered no resistance, suggested pathways, brought the man to the nest.Connecting the man from the land to the birds of the sky.

    Fear Dances the Lamb

    What was the grace of the lamb? What was it made of, a grace that spoke back to fear, converted threat to something benign?What is the stuff of fear that can be defused by the curve of a flank, the flick of a hoove, the stretch of a fluffy white neck?

    --

    Response to an exercise set by Stephen Muecke (2012): finding the words for the eloquent resistance of materials e.g. how the mountain speaks to the body that climbs it, the bag to wind, lamb to fear. What is it that dances something else?

    15

  • WORKING WITH THE BREATH

    Nalina Wait

    16

  • Sighing

    No-one is watching as I draincell-by-cell into the weave of the sisal carpet. The Artists, seduced by the latest catalogues, display themselves like designer vases.

    Panting

    Im not here. Im just a head.Im not looking at you.These glasses that you see are not mine. I have nohair. I have no body.I have no I, nor eyes.

    Decide what you like about me, because I do not care about you.Im not strange, Im just positioned that way.

    Holding breath, standing up, sitting down

    What are you looking at?As you shake your head dismissively at the unusually expressive unconventional movements.Dont you realise this is a place for serious Art?

    Expanding the breath and body

    The body is not yours, it belongs to the bourgeoisie. We allowed you to think it was yours because it served our purposes, but you are using it irregularly and so it must be repossessed.

    --

    Response to an exercise set by Nikki Heywood (2013): working with the breath following exercises in Meg Stuart/Damaged Goodss Are We Here Yet?, edited by Jeroen Peeters.

    Actions: Sigh for 5 minutes Pant for a minute Expand your body as you expand

    your breath

    Thoughts: This body is not yours No-one is watching What are you looking at? Im not there

    17

  • SCORES IN HINDSIGHTLizzie Thomson, Patricia Wood, Cleo Mees

    18

  • JazzLizzie Thomson

    Weigh down your body with a large unethical costume Find actions to go with the words:

    Here is my Pelvis Here is my Chest Frame the Face Avert the Gaze Exhibit the Body

    Find a melody to sing the words in silence as you undertake the actions

    Turn up the volume of your outside eye Bring it to the foreground of your attention and all around Get a birds eye view of your dancing self Feel the boldness of your body-as-form draped in heavy cloth

    Stop when the music stops Start when the music starts

    Choose a step, someone elses stepExhaust yourself with its endlessness

    Avert your gaze until your eyes are close to being shut Turn down the volume of your outside eye Swim inside the rhythm and the falling formStay with this for longer than long

    Turn the volume back up to hear the weirdness of it all Fall in and out of step with your bodyKeep dancing and think about how youre not Michael Jackson Continue till your face is flushed and the cloth is wet

    Stop when the music stops Shrug with embarrassment and walk off grinning

    19

  • Songs Not to Dance To (Martin del Amo and Phil Blackman), Opening Night March 2015Patricia Wood

    Mystery Song: Mariah Carey BalladNumber of performers: 6

    Score:Feel the beat.Share the love.Dont split your pants.Have a moment with someone and then everyone.Commit to the dying moth duet.Honour the makers.Join the rhythm to shift the lovers embrace.Be the rotating tube.Shake it out collectively.

    Unsolicited Retrospective Score for Victoria Hunts Responsive Residency ShowingCleo Mees

    Scenography:

    Wait for a rainy night.Prepare several waterproof, battery-powered torches.

    On the night, bring your audience to a dark oval.Park them undercover, keep their foreheads warm.

    Get two people on lights: two torches from different angles.Let the lights gradually wax and wane.Only rarely should both lights shine at the same time.

    Make sure it is raining when you begin.

    Action:

    Begin at the far end of the oval deep into the darkness, back past the lights.Ensure you are invisible.

    Roll on the grass.Roll at the pace of tectonic plates.Roll with an overview of time; of millennia.Edge into the light; play at the boundary of your own visibility.And retreat.

    Splay yourself out flat in the wet.Energise from the torso.Elevated limbs, your torso is your fulcrum.Whip it all around, fast, keep going.Exhaust yourself.

    Meet a figure from a spirit world.

    -- All three of these pieces of writing are various responses to an idea focused on scoring led by Erin Brannigan and Lizzie Thomson (May 2015).

    20

  • Jazz is a score Lizzie wrote in hindsight about her own work, and was the genesis of the idea she brought to the group.

    Patricias score for Songs Not to Dance To is a retrospective reflection on her own performance in the final section of the show, where Martin and Phil invited audience members onstage to dance together to a mystery song.

    Cleos score follows most closely the task as set out in the Writing Dancing session, where we were asked to write hypothetical scores to describe performances we had recently attended. Our task was to prescribe both the scenography and the action of the piece we had seen as though we were directing it (even though we had only ever experienced the piece as audience members). We were also instructed to stage the piece in a different location to the one we had seen it in. Cleo notes that although this exercise was undertaken without any knowledge of the original score and without invitation from the artists whose works we were describing, it produced some exciting material. She says, More abstract scores, in particular, were promising springboards for new interpretations that may or may not at all resemble the original performances.

    21

  • This page: Patricia Wood. Opposite page: Cleo Mees.

    22

  • 23

  • WATCHING CANNIBALNikki Heywood

    A pale man in a white roomA rolling boxing kind of shadow boxing kind of move...He is pale but pink. He moves in the corner his back to us. Its squeaky.Squeak squeak white sandshoes on white floor.

    Now he is down on his side, beating the air, torso rockingArms attendant, affected, affectingCrouching, he genuflects in a lopsided rhythmic rocking shuffling transportI hear his breath. The rhythm is unchanged. He has plugged into a pulse, a toneI feel my own internal pulse, a desire to rock ever so slightly rockMy body understands something of this vibrational field

    24

  • He looks so Nordic, so tomorrow belongs to me Aryan This pink man in a white box who moves as though his battery has been switched on, a battery that runs and runs in its own small self sustaining circuit of perpetual motiona hidden perpetual man eating battery

    He grooves but is he in pain? What is his state?I am curious about his neutrality. His steady state, on-ness.He is plugged in, turned on, switched on and it wont stop and I just keep watching and wondering as his head nods in control out of control... it has its own machine-ic logic

    White on white squeaking pink a runner going nowhere a man unable to contain his compulsion to keep going keep going no matter no where no why no what he is breathing sweating reddening he continues his own pink flesh eating theres no end no end no end to it no end no end to it

    --

    Watching Matthew Days Cannibal on video (October 2013); the exercise, set by Nalina Wait, was to do all or a combination of these instructions:

    Write descriptively, attending to what we are seeing

    Talk about our own embodied response

    Use association, conceptual relationship, meaning... attribution

    25

  • WATCHING ROSJustine Shih Pearson

    26

  • Hellen Sky. Photo courtesy Hellen Sky

    move back to centre stagedont movebut dont commit to standing here.

    Fa la la.

    swallow an exploding flylingering lightbad dancefall downdance to the sound of a tambourine.

    false applause.

    backwards circle big.harrummphh.

    pat the babystrictly speaking(taxi!)fan dancestutter OPtap dance with big skirtspinmove to centre stagesing farewell and sleep.

    --

    A score written while watching Ros Warby perform her adaptation of Deborah Hays No Time to Fly at Critical Paths Improvisation Practices Symposium (December 2014). This was a response to a set of provocations given by Nikki Heywood, based on her memory of working with Deborah Hay:

    notice your noticing refresh your vision keep your head moving whole body at once dont stay fixed sometimes stay for long enough

    for things to change notice what arrives

    no big deal anything is possible dont try to be creative

    27

  • COLLABORATIVE WRITINGJulie-Anne Long (& others)

    ONE

    I am attempting to write publishable journal articles on somatic practice and poetics of the body. I am also interested in writing that moves my ideas, around the body and

    performance, into a new place. Provocations. New conjunctions.

    Where is this new place? Are there any new places on the body? What about the old places? What will happen to them?

    Are they no longer relevant?

    If only words contained the power of the body. Shift.

    to the left. shift again to the right. to write. Whether words contain

    the power of the body; the act of writing is an embodied act. Feel the

    paper, the hardness of the desk beneath the pen scratching in your

    hand. Feel the words.

    28

  • Forget the desk tattoo the writing what is writing when we read it? When we speak it? When we hear it? When we see it?

    Reading writing, performing writing, trying it out in the space, performing reading each others, considering a model like Cages Lecture On Nothing.

    TRANSGRESS. SMASH. DISRUPT.

    ANNIHILATE. ERUPT. SHATTER.

    WHAT WOULD THIS SOUND LIKE,

    LOOK LIKE, FEEL LIKE, TASTE

    LIKE, AND THEN BURY IT.

    Look to onomatopoeia splash, crash,

    etc. these arent real words, we

    just had no other way to say this

    event. Make a new language if need

    be. Taste it, bury it.

    Elaborate a hunch, an intuition is that what they call morphic resonance??

    TWO

    Writing in response to dancing while watching it. Particularly dancing that is improvised, vague and mostly formless.

    Find the clarity, the point of focus.

    Maybe focus is not a point but a

    zone, an attitude an atmosphere?

    Keeping to the point might foreclose

    potential pathways maybe its about

    clearing a ground in which to act?

    (to write)

    The group could write laying on the floor leave the table or write in the dark or

    Write collectively, or move and write, or write on the way here, or write after performances, or write addressed to someone in the group

    Write with elbows, knees, tongue,

    rib, belly button. Write what you

    see. Free up the

    29

  • Speech can be written and so can

    movement, can movement write? It

    needs help, language, an outline, a

    structure.

    Displace the watching of a dance performance pretend you saw it in a dream. Pretend it was underwater. Is this a practice of making the context (rather than the performance) strange?

    When we make our own seeing strange, then ask how can our dancing change the seeing of the viewer?

    SIX

    I would like to experience more choreographic thinking by undertaking writing tasks set by my peers.

    Choreographic notations like dust

    and smoke and stagnant waters,

    obsidian reflections and soaking

    pores. Writing is to dance this

    poetry.

    Articulation of senses, of feelings and reactions.

    Dance on paper, naked and stripped bare of nuances

    and subtitles. The outlined, the model on the page.

    Ok, so the body-mind is a thinking arrangement. Re-arrange it, starting with head to arse.

    Mouth or anus? Is that what you mean? Back to the digestive tract? Back to ground, what makes us? What connects us?

    What unmakes us? What do we hold? What do we let go of?

    Nothing. Spaces between particles. Mere dots in an endless universe empty.

    Space. Freedom.

    I cheated and read ahead on the page emptiness is not freedom what kind of space is?

    Emptiness is nothing, nothing is

    heavy nothing weighs a lot.

    --

    These pieces are excerpted from a collaborative writing task set by Julie-Anne (February 2013): to start the year, she suggested that we write simultaneous threads on the theme Things that Came Up To Think About for this Year. We wrote for two minutes, passed it on, wrote for another two minutes in response to what came immediately before, passed it on

    Despite the often specific, concrete, or even prosaic beginning sentence, the group responses tended to move in all sorts of directions and provide poetic reflections on the act of writing by members of the group.

    30

  • 31

  • AUTHENTIC MOVEMENT: SEATED

    Nalina Wait

    Moving:

    Not performing or not performing the normal gestures of pedestrian existence?

    Winter clothing textures providing the space for boardroom dancing.If only all meetings began this way (maybe they do on the level of the micro-

    gesture?)

    Watching:

    Saliva, digestive juices. Creative juices, viscera. Alimentary canal

    nuzzling opening, to the mouth. The Feeling Sensing open-to-the-air partscommunicating with the inside. Fleshy

    layers of fluid.

    32

  • Comfort. Feeling the weight of parting the air. The spiral upwardsTwisting the insides.Mouth. Saliva. Digestive juices,creative juices. Fingers.Axis and atlas.Weight of the air on fingernails.Nuzzling, nurturing, nourishment of the flesh.

    The textural world/word of movementis inherently there, as we sit andwrite and talk and listen.But it is made visible by the Elimination of all else but the movement that bodySpeaking, this body listening.

    --

    Response to a task set by Nikki Heywood (May 2013): witness frames, either/or:

    What am I watching? What am I seeing? What is happening to me as I

    watch?

    33