COVERS FOR MINE WASTE DISPOSAL FACILITIES By Andy Robertson and Shannon Shaw.

16
COVERS FOR MINE WASTE DISPOSAL FACILITIES By Andy Robertson and Shannon Shaw

Transcript of COVERS FOR MINE WASTE DISPOSAL FACILITIES By Andy Robertson and Shannon Shaw.

Page 1: COVERS FOR MINE WASTE DISPOSAL FACILITIES By Andy Robertson and Shannon Shaw.

COVERS FOR

MINE WASTE DISPOSAL FACILITIES

By

Andy Robertson and Shannon Shaw

Page 2: COVERS FOR MINE WASTE DISPOSAL FACILITIES By Andy Robertson and Shannon Shaw.

Review of Cover Purpose

• Access• Physical Isolation• Erosion Protection• Vegetation Establishment• Oxygen (oxidation) Control• Infiltration (leaching) Control

Page 3: COVERS FOR MINE WASTE DISPOSAL FACILITIES By Andy Robertson and Shannon Shaw.

Soil Covers

• Types of Covers:

• Simple– Permeability depends on grain size– Compaction– Oxygen diffusion depends on moisture content

• Compound

• Complex– Variable– Multi-layered

waste

low density

high density

waste

moisture

Page 4: COVERS FOR MINE WASTE DISPOSAL FACILITIES By Andy Robertson and Shannon Shaw.

Grey Eagle Tailings Cover

Page 5: COVERS FOR MINE WASTE DISPOSAL FACILITIES By Andy Robertson and Shannon Shaw.

Trends in Cover Design

• Infiltration barrier design for wet climates (water barrier)• Evaporation enhancing designs for dry climates (water

balance/store and release)• Thick HDPE geomembrane covers to resist disruption

Page 6: COVERS FOR MINE WASTE DISPOSAL FACILITIES By Andy Robertson and Shannon Shaw.

Typical comparison of alternative covers

A ) N o C o ve r

B ) M od erate Ve g etation C ove r

C ) G oo d Veg etation C o ve r

D ) L ow P erm ea bility Till S o il C o ve r

E ) H ig h P erm ea bility T ill S o il C o ve r

N o te : (“”) N u m b e rs are pe rce n t o f to ta lA n nu al precip ita tion

F a irG rass

G oodG rass

F a irG rass

F a irG rass

1 m

1 m

P rec ip ita tion E vapora tion R un o ff

S eepage

P rec ip ita tion E vapora tion R un o ff

R un o ff

S eepage

S eepage

Ta il ingsk= 6x10 cm /s-5

Ta il ingsk= 6x10 cm /s-5

Ta il ingsk= 6x10 cm /s

-5

P rec ip ita tion E vapora tion R un o ff

S eepage

k= 1x10 cm /s

T ill S o ilH igh P e rm eab ility

-4

Ta il ingsk= 6x10 cm /s

-5

Ta il ingsk= 6x10 cm /s

-5

P rec ip ita tion E vapora tion R un o ff

S eepage

k= 2x10 cm /s

T ill S o ilLow P e rm eab il ity

-6

Page 7: COVERS FOR MINE WASTE DISPOSAL FACILITIES By Andy Robertson and Shannon Shaw.

Typical comparison of alternative covers

I) S o il B a rrier w ith S ynthe tic M em brane L iner,Lace ra l D ra in and S oil C over

H ) S o il B a rrier w ith La cera l D ra in and R ip rap C over

F ) R ip rap E rosion R esis tan t C ove r

G ) S oil B a rrie r w ith Lace ra l D ra in and S o il C ove r

0 .5 m

1 .0 m

0 .3 m

1 .0 m

P rec ip ita tion E vapo ra tion R un o ff

S eepage

P rec ip ita tion E vapo ra tion R un o ff

S eepage

La te ra l D ra inS lope0 .5%

Ta il ingsk= 6x10 cm /s

-5

P rec ip ita tion E vapo ra tion R un o ff

S eepage

k= 1x10 cm /s C ov e r S o il-4

P rec ip ita tion E vapo ra tion R un o ff

S eepage

k= 1x10 cm /s B a rrie r S o il-7L inea r

S lope0 .5%

0 .3 m

0 .6 m

1 .0 m

F a irG rass

S lope0 .5%

0 .3 m

1 .0 m

1 .0 m

F a irG rass

La te ra l D ra in

La te ra l D ra in

k= 5x10 cm /s-3

Ta il ingsk= 6x10 cm /s

-5

k= 1x10 cm /s R oc k/G rave l-2

k= 1x10 cm /s B a rrie r S o il-7

k= 5x10 cm /s-3

k= 1x10 cm /s C ov e r S o il-1

k= 1x10 cm /s B a rrie r S o il-7

k= 5x10 cm /s-3

Ta il ingsk= 6x10 cm /s

-5

Ta il ingsk= 6x10 cm /s

-5

k= 1x10 cm /s R oc k/G rave l-2

N o te : (“”) N um b ers are pe rcen t o f to ta lA nnual precip itat ion

Page 8: COVERS FOR MINE WASTE DISPOSAL FACILITIES By Andy Robertson and Shannon Shaw.

mm

Page 9: COVERS FOR MINE WASTE DISPOSAL FACILITIES By Andy Robertson and Shannon Shaw.

Dry Cover Costs

• Oxygen Control• Migration Control

• Simple Covers– Soil covers

• Complex Covers– Multiple soil– “Cefyl”– Clay layered– Geomembrane*

* Perpetual replacement @ 50 year intervals ~22% of present value hence long term fund $0.40-0.60/tonne

$2 - $6/m2

or $0.03-0.10/tonne waste rock

$20 - $30/m2

Or $0.33-0.50/tonne waste rock

Page 10: COVERS FOR MINE WASTE DISPOSAL FACILITIES By Andy Robertson and Shannon Shaw.
Page 11: COVERS FOR MINE WASTE DISPOSAL FACILITIES By Andy Robertson and Shannon Shaw.
Page 12: COVERS FOR MINE WASTE DISPOSAL FACILITIES By Andy Robertson and Shannon Shaw.

Water Cover Costs

• New Rock Waste– In natural water bodies

• Haulage costs– In man-made impoundments

• $0.25 - $1.50 + haulage costs

• Old Rock Waste– With treatment of storage products– >$2.75 - $4.00/tonne

Page 13: COVERS FOR MINE WASTE DISPOSAL FACILITIES By Andy Robertson and Shannon Shaw.

Suitability of Cover Types

Page 14: COVERS FOR MINE WASTE DISPOSAL FACILITIES By Andy Robertson and Shannon Shaw.

Tailings Waste RockPotential Problems

Risk inDesign

Risk duringConstruction(slimes)

Long-termRisk ofDisruption

Risk inDesign

Risk duringConstruction(slopes)

Long-termRisk ofDisruption

Access

Slumping

Erosion Sheet

Channel

Consolidation

Biota

Infiltration

Oxygen Flux

High Risk Elements of Cover Performance

Page 15: COVERS FOR MINE WASTE DISPOSAL FACILITIES By Andy Robertson and Shannon Shaw.

Minimizing Risk of Cover Failure1. Materials

– Maximize use of natural, durable materials– Minimize use of geosynthetics which deteriorate– Rip-rap control of erosion in dry climates

2. Climate• In dry climates:

– consider evaporative cover designs– increase use of rip-rap for erosion protection– provide for sedimentation control

• In wet climates:– consider infiltration cover designs– consider water covers

Page 16: COVERS FOR MINE WASTE DISPOSAL FACILITIES By Andy Robertson and Shannon Shaw.

Minimizing Risk of Cover Failure

3. Biota– Beaver (beaver control or wide channels)– Burrowing animals (bio-intrusion layers)– Ants & insects (bio-intrusion layers)– Anthropogenic activity (institutional control)– Roots (control vegetation species)

4. Monitoring & Maintenance– Erosion– Settlement– Sedimentation (& Glaciation)– Biotic factors (fauna, flora, man)