Cosmic background KM anisotrophy measurement at 10 degrees€¦ · Cosmic background anisotrophy...

2
Cosmic background anisotrophy measurement at 10 degrees TODD GAIER, JEFFREY Sci 1L'T ER,* (flj(] Pi iiiii' M. LLs]x LJuu't'ritiI of Califorii 61 San to Barbara, Cal ifor, ha 93106 The cosmic background radiation is believed to be the rem- nant of the primeval fireball from which the present-day Uni- verse evolved. When observed with a radiometer (radiotelescope), the cosmic background radiation has a tem- perature of about 2.75 kelvin. Measurements of the degree of uniformity (isotropy) of the cosmic background radiation serve to provide information about the early Universe. Numerous measurements of the isotropy of the cosmic back- ground radiation have shown it to be uniform to T/T < 2 x i0 - (where T = 2.75 kelvin on arc-minute scales. Experiments at scales greater than 10 degrees have measured a dipole an- isotropy, believed to be a result of the peculiar motion of our galaxy with respect to very distant objects. The region of 1 to 10 degrees remains a relatively unexplored angular size. Two groups have recently reported anisotropy on this scale at a level approximately equal to 5 x 10 (Mel- chiorri et al. 1981; Davies et al. 1987). This is particularly sig- nificant because it occurs at a level predicted by many theories of galaxy formation. Unfortunately these results are also con- troversial because they were close to experimental sensitivity limits and may be marred by systematic errors in the experi- ment. To test these results we decided to make a measurement at the 10-degree scale at two microwave frequencies. The Amundsen-Scott South Pole Station was chosen as a site for this measurement because the cold high-altitude environment serves to reduce atmospheric interference with the measure- ment. Figure 1 shows the expected atmospheric emission at the South Pole. We chose to make our measurement at 15 and 25 gigahertz where atmospheric emissions, as well as signals from our gal- axy, are low. By using two frequencies, we can determine whether a signal is galactic in origin or truly reflects anisotro- phy in the cosmic background radiation. Because we are trying to make very sensitive measurements, a low-noise receiver is desired. In both systems, we employ low-noise cryogenic high electron-mobility transitor amplifiers. In each system, two an- tennas with 7 degree beams pointed 10 degrees apart feed the signal into a cryogenic microwave switch operating at 100 hertz. Cryogenic requirements for the system are met using a closed cycle helium gas refrigerator needing only electricity to oper- ate. The switched signal is fed into the high electron-mobility transistor amplifier where the signal power is multiplied by 1,000. The signal is further amplified by a low-noise warm amplifier and then converted to a direct-current signal. This direct-current signal is passed to a lock-in amplifier which elec- tronically differences the signal from the two sky positions. * Jeffrey Schuster is also affiliated with the physics department, Uni- versity of California, Berkeley, California 94720. CALCULATED ATMOSPHERIC BRIGHTNESS TEMPERATURE AT 3.6 KM (SOUTH POLE BAROMETRIC ALTITUDE) 102 2 10 IjJ w Ld a- 10' Z Z w 10 - 10' 50 100 150 200 250 300 FREQUENCY (GHz) Figure 1. South Pole Atmospheric Emissions. This is the predicted atmospheric emission as a function of frequency. The calculation is based on theoretical water (H 2 0), oxygen (0 2 ), and ozone (03) line shapes assuming 300 microns precipitable water based on South Pole balloon data included in this article. For comparison, the upper and lower plots are atmospheric emissions at sea level and balloon altitudes, respectively. (K denotes kelvin. KM denotes kilometers. GHz denotes gigahertz.) The total noise of each system was about 4iiiK/ V"H - z including atmospheric noise. Because these are highly sensitive measurements, excess noise due to systematic drifts and atmospheric disturbances must be minimized. A slow second chop on the sky serves this purpose. By moving the whole apparatus back and forth on the sky, 'second" subtracting these signals results in mea- surements on smaller time scales making the system less sus- ceptible to drifts and atmospheric noise. We then let the rotation of the Earth change our field of view. The instrument operated as expected. Atmospheric radio- metric temperatures of 2.7 kelvin at 15 gigahertz and 5.5 kelvin at 25 gigahertz were measured and are close to the theoretically predicted values for the South Pole. To ensure the system was operational, the galactic plane was allowed to drift into the beam. The data including the galactic crossing is in figure 2. The galaxy appears as a bump with amplitude 9 mK, roughly twice the value predicted by scaling galactic maps from low frequencies, but the theories are not well understood at these high frequencies (25 gigahertz). By putting together scans, we can build up integration time, reducing noise signal and increasing our ultimate sensitivity. Figure 3 shows just such data. Data from different scans at close sky positions are binned and averaged together. A rough attempt was made at removing galaxy signal as well as the signal due to the dipole anisotropy. An additional residual linear trend remained; because we are not sensitive to such large angular scales, this trend was removed. This data is slightly oversampled with points displayed at 2.5 degrees apart on the sky or roughly one-third of a beamwidth. The reduced x2 of this set is 0.95 for 19 degrees of freedom and is consistent at the 50-percent level with random noise, i.e., no structure is immediately obvious. These results are preliminary and more analysis must be done. This work was supported by National Science Foundation grant DPP 87-15984, the California Space Institute, and the 1989 REVIEW 249

Transcript of Cosmic background KM anisotrophy measurement at 10 degrees€¦ · Cosmic background anisotrophy...

Page 1: Cosmic background KM anisotrophy measurement at 10 degrees€¦ · Cosmic background anisotrophy measurement at 10 degrees TODD GAIER, JEFFREY Sci 1LT ER, (flj(] Pi iiiii M. LLs]x

Cosmic backgroundanisotrophy measurement

at 10 degrees

TODD GAIER, JEFFREY Sci 1L'T ER,* (flj(]Pi iiiii' M. LLs]x

LJuu't'ritiI of Califorii 61San to Barbara, Cal ifor, ha 93106

The cosmic background radiation is believed to be the rem-nant of the primeval fireball from which the present-day Uni-verse evolved. When observed with a radiometer(radiotelescope), the cosmic background radiation has a tem-perature of about 2.75 kelvin. Measurements of the degree ofuniformity (isotropy) of the cosmic background radiation serveto provide information about the early Universe.

Numerous measurements of the isotropy of the cosmic back-ground radiation have shown it to be uniform to T/T < 2 xi0 - (where T = 2.75 kelvin on arc-minute scales. Experimentsat scales greater than 10 degrees have measured a dipole an-isotropy, believed to be a result of the peculiar motion of ourgalaxy with respect to very distant objects.

The region of 1 to 10 degrees remains a relatively unexploredangular size. Two groups have recently reported anisotropyon this scale at a level approximately equal to 5 x 10 (Mel-chiorri et al. 1981; Davies et al. 1987). This is particularly sig-nificant because it occurs at a level predicted by many theoriesof galaxy formation. Unfortunately these results are also con-troversial because they were close to experimental sensitivitylimits and may be marred by systematic errors in the experi-ment. To test these results we decided to make a measurementat the 10-degree scale at two microwave frequencies. TheAmundsen-Scott South Pole Station was chosen as a site forthis measurement because the cold high-altitude environmentserves to reduce atmospheric interference with the measure-ment. Figure 1 shows the expected atmospheric emission atthe South Pole.

We chose to make our measurement at 15 and 25 gigahertzwhere atmospheric emissions, as well as signals from our gal-axy, are low. By using two frequencies, we can determinewhether a signal is galactic in origin or truly reflects anisotro-phy in the cosmic background radiation. Because we are tryingto make very sensitive measurements, a low-noise receiver isdesired. In both systems, we employ low-noise cryogenic highelectron-mobility transitor amplifiers. In each system, two an-tennas with 7 degree beams pointed 10 degrees apart feed thesignal into a cryogenic microwave switch operating at 100 hertz.Cryogenic requirements for the system are met using a closedcycle helium gas refrigerator needing only electricity to oper-ate. The switched signal is fed into the high electron-mobilitytransistor amplifier where the signal power is multiplied by1,000. The signal is further amplified by a low-noise warmamplifier and then converted to a direct-current signal. Thisdirect-current signal is passed to a lock-in amplifier which elec-tronically differences the signal from the two sky positions.

* Jeffrey Schuster is also affiliated with the physics department, Uni-versity of California, Berkeley, California 94720.

CALCULATED ATMOSPHERIC BRIGHTNESS TEMPERATUREAT 3.6 KM (SOUTH POLE BAROMETRIC ALTITUDE)

102

2 10

IjJ

wLd

a-10'

ZZw 10 -

10'

50100150200250300FREQUENCY (GHz)

Figure 1. South Pole Atmospheric Emissions. This is the predictedatmospheric emission as a function of frequency. The calculationis based on theoretical water (H 20), oxygen (0 2), and ozone (03)line shapes assuming 300 microns precipitable water based onSouth Pole balloon data included in this article. For comparison,the upper and lower plots are atmospheric emissions at sea leveland balloon altitudes, respectively. (K denotes kelvin. KM denoteskilometers. GHz denotes gigahertz.)

The total noise of each system was about 4iiiK/ V"H-z includingatmospheric noise.

Because these are highly sensitive measurements, excessnoise due to systematic drifts and atmospheric disturbancesmust be minimized. A slow second chop on the sky servesthis purpose. By moving the whole apparatus back and forthon the sky, 'second" subtracting these signals results in mea-surements on smaller time scales making the system less sus-ceptible to drifts and atmospheric noise. We then let the rotationof the Earth change our field of view.

The instrument operated as expected. Atmospheric radio-metric temperatures of 2.7 kelvin at 15 gigahertz and 5.5 kelvinat 25 gigahertz were measured and are close to the theoreticallypredicted values for the South Pole. To ensure the system wasoperational, the galactic plane was allowed to drift into thebeam. The data including the galactic crossing is in figure 2.The galaxy appears as a bump with amplitude 9 mK, roughlytwice the value predicted by scaling galactic maps from lowfrequencies, but the theories are not well understood at thesehigh frequencies (25 gigahertz).

By putting together scans, we can build up integration time,reducing noise signal and increasing our ultimate sensitivity.Figure 3 shows just such data. Data from different scans atclose sky positions are binned and averaged together. A roughattempt was made at removing galaxy signal as well as thesignal due to the dipole anisotropy. An additional residuallinear trend remained; because we are not sensitive to suchlarge angular scales, this trend was removed. This data is slightlyoversampled with points displayed at 2.5 degrees apart on thesky or roughly one-third of a beamwidth. The reduced x2 ofthis set is 0.95 for 19 degrees of freedom and is consistent atthe 50-percent level with random noise, i.e., no structure isimmediately obvious. These results are preliminary and moreanalysis must be done.

This work was supported by National Science Foundationgrant DPP 87-15984, the California Space Institute, and the

1989 REVIEW 249

Page 2: Cosmic background KM anisotrophy measurement at 10 degrees€¦ · Cosmic background anisotrophy measurement at 10 degrees TODD GAIER, JEFFREY Sci 1LT ER, (flj(] Pi iiiii M. LLs]x

,f\tI'I

2.00

—2.00

(I)

03

—6.00

T2 sigma—0.44 mK

- 25 GHz Data• - - Predicted Galaxy

0.40

E

Qj 0.00

Cr)

03

—0.40

—0.80

2 ci

JRA (Hr)

Figure 2. Twenty-five gigahertz (GHz) data including galaxy emis-sion. The drift scan data are grouped into 30 second bins anddouble-subtracted. For display purposes the data are filtered andthe average 2-sigma error bar is shown. The expected signal fromthe galaxy based on maps made at low frequencies is included.

University of California. This work would not have been pos-sible without the support and encouragement of John Lynch.We thank Mike Balister, Sandy Weinreb, and Marian Pos-pieszalski at NRAO. We also wish to thank the physics de-partment machine shop and electronics shop and Thea Howardat the University of California at Santa Barbara. Finally, wewould like to thank Amundsen-Scott Station manager BillCoughran and the whole 1988-1989 ANS support staff for theirconstant support at the Pole.

References

Davies, R.D., A.N. Lasenby, R.A. Watson, E.J. Daintree, J. Hopkins,J . Beckman, J. Sanches-Almeida, and R. Rebolo. 1987. A sensitivemeasurement of fluctuations in the cosmic microwave backgroundon scales of 5 degrees to 15 degrees. Nature, 326, 462.

Melchiorri, F., B.O. Melchiorri, C. Ceccarelli, and L. Pietranera. 1981.Fluctuations in the microwave background at intermediate angularscales. Ali. J . , 250, Li.

Figure 3. Twenty-five gigahertz (GHz) data. The data are binned intoone-third beamwidth bins and are slightly oversampled. The gal-actic component as well as a dipole component have been re-moved. A slight linear trend remained in the data and was alsoremoved. A 2-sigma error bar is included.

—10.00

RA (Hr)

25 GHz DATA IN 1/3 BEAMWIDTH BINSGALAXY AND DIPOLE REMOVED. LINEAR FIT

250 ANTARCTIC JOURNAL