Corporate Architects Facility Management

BIM Implications for Facilities Management of 21

Corporate Architects & Facility Management ‐ BIM Implications for Facilities

Management

(Sources: GoToWebinar and Zoomerang)

General Information

Webinar Name Webinar ID

BIM Implications for Facilities Management (CAFM) 203269726

Actual Start Date & Time Actual Duration (minutes)

Nov 04, 2011 12:14 PM EDT 136

Registered (#) Opened Invitation (#)

707 11

Clicked Registration Link (#) Total Attendees (#)

1115 437

Attendance Metrics

Attendance Rate (%) Average Attendee Interest Rating

61.81 54.51

Average Attentiveness

52.06

Question Responses

Q&A Questions Asked (#)

85

Attendance Profile

Time Number of Attendees (#)

Percentage of Total Attended (%)

12:29 PM EDT 16 3.69

12:44 PM EDT 46 10.60

12:59 PM EDT 225 51.84

01:14 PM EDT 385 88.71

01:29 PM EDT 400 92.17

01:44 PM EDT 408 94.01

01:59 PM EDT 409 94.24

02:14 PM EDT 407 93.78

02:29 PM EDT 215 49.54

02:44 PM EDT 0 0.00


Average Attendance Duration (minutes)

86.41

1)

2)


3)

4)


5)

6) What was your overall impression of the event? How did you hear about the webinar? Do you have any additional comments, or suggestions for future topics?

Respondent # Response 1 ktjekljalsk

2 Really benificial to firms thinking of ways to add competative services beyond the usual list of services offered. We use BIM but definitely not to its full potential!!! This webinar opened my eyes from the standpoint that our industry blinders keep us focused on only what we do, rather than looking beyond what we create. Thank you for this opportunity to catch a glimpse of the start of a shift within our field. Renz A Weinmann, AIA, WTW Architects, Pittsburgh


3 I thought the event was good and informative. I have learned about a number of ways I can get more educated about BIM systems, and their use throughout the life of the building. I heard about the seminar through the AIA e‐mail notifications. Continued seminars of this nature would be great!

4 Good information on future of BIM use in facilities management

5 Good presentation, overall. Would like to see more practicable examples. I belong to the AIA Corporate & TAP knowledge communities, so heard via email.

6 Through AIA. Subject / content was very informative, even for someone just starting his BIM education.

7 via email from AIA good presentation, and helpful.

8 Through AIA website

9 email

10 Hear abut via e‐mail contact.

11 The event was very informative,. I heard about it online.

12 email

13 Overall impression was that is was very good overview. Heard about webinar from AIA email. Future topic could be how Contractor's are using BIM and what they see the future from their perspective.

14 Heard about webinar fron AIA website and would like to see a webinar on IPD in future, thank you.

15 read about it via email note from AIA and seminar provider. Overall, spent a lot of time at the beginning doing participant background, etc. that should be quicker/summary. Birgitta provided a lot of good discussion points on the use of the BIM model post construction.

16 Very well done. It would be helpful to get a follow‐up email containing links to the various websites noted in the presentation for easier follow up.


17 Deke Smith was a very accomplished presenter. Overall information, history of BIM and AutoCad standard development, etc. added credibility. I received an email alert from AIA CAFM committee for sign‐up.

18 One of better webinars I've experienced. Overall quality of presenters,graphics, etc was very good. Received email from AIA on event.

19 very informative

20 The content was interesting, however ‐ as an owner rep we would never use the sort of information being presented. Maybe we aren't as sophisticated in technology as a government agency ‐ however we aren't as heavily staffed as a government agency, either.

21 I heard it via email, no additional comments. Thanks,

22 Heard about event via email.

23 Need to stay on the subject more and less on the background of presenters.

24 Was notified of this via email.

25 I liked it. From last Seminar.

26 Great topic

27 Okay, would be nice to have presentation documents in advance to review.

28 .

29 Overall good event...very specialized for complicated projects versus BIM for profession in general. I received an AIA notice.

30 Better understhanding of BIM. Heard from email.

31 Thank you.

32 Good event. Would have been better without the audio/video difficulties. Found the evnt through the AIA.

33 Excellent program.

34 I like the format for ease.

35 Impression was very good. I found out about it via an e‐mail from AIA.

36 Email notified. Thanks for putting this on.

37 Very good presentation. E‐mail was sent by the AIA to my mailbox announcing the seminar. I like virtual seminars.


38 AIA Staff email effectively informed me of this webinar, and I would be intersted in attending future sessions.

39 Received email about the webinar and felt I needed more knowledge of the subject.

40 through aia

41 My awareness of and interest in BIM was stimulated by a recent DoD seminar. I followed that by researching the NIBS website, the AIA website's BIM content, and many related sites. Presentations on BIM all tend to cover very similar material, especially BIM R&D activity, advocacy, roadmaps, etc. But not many case studies are available, unfortunately.

42 It was a bunch of philosophical fluff saying we should all share our models, no practical information of how it will be done.

43 very informative event, form AIA web site

44 I thought the webinar was good. I received an e‐mail.

45 Very good

46 I receive AIA webinar emails via my personal email and shared it with others. Maybe if there was more time to hear and answer questions would've been really good.

47 Same and similar information Ive heard for years. Its not a "this is how" type seminar but more of a "what Ive done type" with not much evedenciary proof". Thrid speaker started to go where the entire seminar should go, showing proof of what BIM can do in facilities management which is what we are talking about. I thinnk all the "curves" youve shown are old hat and most are familiar enough with BIM to know what its all about. How to use it is another thing.

48 The Weinar was very well organized and the graphics were very helpful. I heard about this via email notification.

49 Heard about this one through AIA CAFM. I expected more content about both the benefits of BIM and how it impacts the owner during design, construction and oeprations. The content was a little heavy on the role of NIBS.


50 we use BIM and share it with contractors, so the seminar did not offer us any new information.

51 It is always good to look forward and from my perspective it "will be" a functional system, but at this point BIM is mind numbing in information gathering and appears to be limited to new construction. We would still have a vast archive of information which would not be in the system and would then be maintaining two formats of data for some time to come. Seminar information was forwarded from another employee. To begin a new format such as this does not seem realistic especially in this current economic environment for the average firm. An example of setting up a project as a test bed for a small firm with limited resources might be a good session.

52 Great

53 Drill down into actual case study of applied CMMS and FMS BIM enablers

54 The event was very informative. I heard about it via e‐mail from AIA. A future webinar on a specific case study from planning thru operations would be good.

55 Excellent presentation, especially the "10 Core Principles." NOTE: I have had difficulty submitting the survey through my default browser (Firefox).

56 Very good! Enjoyed it!

57 The webinar was not geared to small architectural firms (of which I own). The BIM process that was discussed relates to larger firms with larger Owners and clients.

58 Good Presentation of important subject matter.

59 Good overview of the industry. Would like to see more examples.

60 Problem with visual presentation but was able to download the handout for participants.

61 a little less biography of the presenters would be better


62 I think it was very informative, well organized, with clear illustrations/ graphics and the presenters were very knowledgeable. I heard about the webinar through the AIA. I would be interested in similar presentations/ topics.

63 There were a few bits of information outside my current knowledge and indication of references which will be useful.

64 Very good overview and the linkage to related initiatives was very usefull.

65 Knowledgenet

66 Quite well done. The speakers deffinitly knew their stuff and are at the top of their field for knowledge of BIM.

67 The event was very helpful in regards to providing a very general view of the BIM technology, and I hope in future events we can see more in depth technical discussion which can be helpful for architects.

68 Interesting information. Would prefer to have heard more examples from Birgitta's presentation for practical application.

69 Contained some very useful information and ideas...

70 Good introduction of context for tools used during project development (from planning to operations). However, we were looking forward to a presentation about CAFM, rather than BIM. There is enormous potential for integration of BIM and IT to provide “intelligent” CAFM, but for now the BIM models are relatively "dumb". In other words, model attributes are not dynamic enough to deliver a significant value to facility operations. How do we justify first‐cost of a BIM tool when the biggest value is during construction, with collision detection and avoidance?

71 Good event. AIA notice. Can we obtain a PDF of the presentation?

72 helpful as am currently working on FM work flows.

73 Very positive AIA

74 Heard about it through an AIA email.


75 I was unable to access by link provided due to computer issues. I had to call in to attend so had audio only. Wanted to hear more actual specifics how the facility manager can manage his facility using the program data.

76 Good. Would like to know more about how facility managers would extract information from the BIM model. Little less info on the introductions would have sufficed.

77 This was my first brush with BIM, it was very good to get an overview of what BIM is, and what it's trying to achieve.

78 VERY WELL ORGANIZED WITH ADEQUATE INFORMATION FOR SELF FOLLOW UP.

79 A little to much front end information.

80 1. We now know we have a lot to learn about BIM. 2. AIA sent an email 3. A download version of the presentation that is not copywrited.

81 Excellent

82 Heard about the event from an AIA mailing. Event moved along at a good pace and did not become stale or drawn out. The speakers were effectively and adhered to the topic.

83 Very good content, but Dana Smith has spent his entire career in a government setting and not in the real world of architecture. Way too many committees, acronyms and time spent thinking and not really doing.

84 Good information and future use. I will continue to follow and implement this important aspect of the profession.

85 Relevant, helpful

86 Took too long to get to the meat of the presentation. Introductions ran 15 minutes which was too long.

87 It was difficult to keep up with the overwhelming number of standards and/or tools described in the seminar. The actual case studies or application examples were of more value to me. The presentation felt like a sales job to join their organization, especially at the end. I heard about this webinar via email.


88 a good topic. a bit heavy on the background, though I appreciate that was perhaps intended to get more people interested in joining / becoming involved. The "design for maintenance" message from Birgitta was very helpful.

89 Great event very informative and presented with enthusiasm.

90 It was a very important update on the use of BIM by the Federal Government, internationally, and as it relates to building O&M and life‐cycle. AIA email.

91 Heard about webinar via AIA announcements. The information was timely and very informative. Further discussions on use of BIM in FM per specific projects would be eagerly anticipated.

92 Very good and informative

93 The title of the webinar was a little misleading. It seemed to be a fraction of the content delivered. I still found the information interesting but the emphasis seemed to be on creating standards for BIM not discussing how an owner may use them in the future

94 Very informative

95 Bim sounds like it would great for a large firm, large projects. As a Midium and now a small size firm it probably will not happen. The cost to implement and to design within Bim would put our fees well above other firms thus losing business and our competitve edge. To bad they do not make something for small firms. The webinar did what I wanted, I learned about Bim and I am able to make an informed descision about its future in my firm.

96 The webinar was very informative and its a shame that we as architects, engineers, managers, owners, etc pull together and use these tools for every project. I received an invite from the AIA. Using a live video feed would really enhance the presentation.

97 Excellent visual graphics; broad exposure maintained interest; good exposure to resources available online & thru professional organizations. Bravo!


98 Very good. I am a researcher in the BIM field and keep track of these events through the various websites. I thought the seminar was very good and very relevant.

99 I received an email invitation from AIA.

100 too much "alphabet soup" (acronyms) without explanation.

101 i would like to see more emphasis on actual BIM examples.

102 Would use to help with business development in facility management.

103 Good

104 Very informative.

105 Presenters need to speak more clearly and "polish" their presentation. There were too many "ums" in their speech which distracted me from understanding the content

106 I am a CAFM committee member

107 It was informative and easy to follow. My associate infomred me of the webinar and I have no future suggestions.

108 From email notification. It was a good way to get an update and overview cof BIM progress.

109 Not to applicable to my current role but it was good to keep up with recent changes in BIM.

110 Informative but came across as a membership soliciation. The future use of BIM is going to be exciting.

111 Heard via email notice. As a facilities architect, I greatly appreciated this topic and the perspective of increasing BIM's use for the Owner's maintenance of their facilities.

112 Good. email.

113 a lot of background on presenters that was not necessary from my point of view

114 Excellent

115 Informative, clear powerpoint

116 I thought it was a very interesting session.

117 Kind of level 1. Would have liked to see more BIM Facilities applications like the second half. Something Architects could sell the value of to Facilities Managers.


118 Exciting topics, interesting to see where this leads. thank you

119 Content was different than we anticipated ‐ thought it would be more geared toward BIM in facility management, when in reality 2/3 was talking about BIM standards development and the organizations involved. Some of the content re: BIM was dated, I had seen in presentations 6 years ago. The implications as a tool for facility management was good. My perspective; registered architect with 30 years experience, manageing an architecture department.

120 Overall the presentation was good. There was a lot of information being presented in a very short period of time. For time management it would have been better if the first 20 minutes weren't spent on presenter's backgrounds and work history. That information as well as all of the AIA disclaimers and could have been made availabe as an attachment to the Webinar e‐mail notification to the participants.

121 BIM was new to me. So I would have appreciated less detail on the big picture and more detail on exactly what it is and how it works, with numerous examples and how‐to's.

122 Overall it was interesting and provided a general overview of BIM as related to end‐user. However, I was anticipating more in‐depth information on how to utilize functionality of BIM capabilities for maintenance.

123 WOuld hjave liked a more in depth look at BIM and facility management. Too much time spent on overview issues for my experience level.

124 Excellanmt

125 Very comprenhensive presentation on a timely topic.

126 FROM EMAIL

127 I was a presentation focusd on BIM for FM. What was delivered was BIM 101. We counted about 15 minutes of content related to BIM for FM in the 90‐minute webinar.


128 From my Sustainable Industries group.

129 Learned of the webinar from an e‐mail.

130 Continue the good work. An area for improvement: coordinate with presenters to assure the content of the webinar is clear and provides GOOD examples to keep AEC members interested.

131 heard about this through an AIA email and found the webinar very helpful.

132 The presenters were very knowledgeable and dynamic. Time control was very good. I heard this webinar thru AIA.

133 good content; heard about via an AIA email

134 A friend emailed me the link \. I would like to hear more on this subject.

135 Preservation and Conservation, Renovation

136 was very good. but it will be better if it is video, not just Audio.

137 Overall impression is fair to good. The presenters took too much in the introduction (15 minutes) before getting to the subject matter. The content also did not exactly fulfill the promise of the main topic, "BIM Implications for FM" ‐ too much time was devoted to the development of standards in BIMUS as opposed to its application to FM. More case studies of successful implementatino of BIM in FM would have been helpful.

138 Well prepared. Via e‐mail. More emphasis on BIM in FM.

139 I'm a member of the sponsoring KC. I felt that the AG made an excellent decision in sponsoring this webinar. BIM is presented from many perspectives but rarely from that of the Owner. I believe that those who participated in today’s webinar will recognize that AIA and CAFM have provided something really useful to the membership.

140 Excellent event. I heard about it through AIA online news letter.


141 THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU!!!! THIS WAS A LOT OF INFORMATION. TOO MUCH TO TAKE COMPLETE NOTES ON. VERY IMPRESSIVE. EXCELLENT BACKGROUNDS AND HELPFUL TO HAVE TWO VIEWPOINTS. MY POSITION IN FACILITIES MANAGEMENT AT THE VA IS EXACTLY WHERE THIS PRESENTATION WAS FOCUSED. SUGGESTIONS: HAVE PRESENTATION SLIDES DOWNLOADABLE PRIOR TO PRESENTATION HAVE PRESENTATION AVAILABLE FOR REPLAY FOR A FEW MONTHS OR SO AFTER SO WE CAN HELP OTHER GET THIS "EDUCATION" MY EXPERIENCE WITH BIM IS ABOUT 10 YEARS. HOWEVER, OUR MEDICAL CAMPUSES AND THE MAJORITY OF OUR LOCAL STAFF DID NOT WHAT "BIM" WAS WHEN I ARRIVED A LITTLE OVER A YEAR AGO (MOST WERE NON USERS OF EVEN 2D INFORMATION HOWEVER WE NEED THE INFORMATION BIM CAN PROVIDE AND HAVE LITTLE DATABASE OF USE ON‐SITE FOR FACILITIES MANAGEMENT, WORK ORDERS CAPITAL ASSET MANAGEMENT, ETC. WE HAVE 3 MAJOR PROJECTS UNDERWAY THAT WILL ALL BE IN BIM AND THE VA IS LOOKING AT IT AS THE FACILITY MANAGEMENT TOOL,, BUT IT APPEARS THEY ALL COULD USE THIS CLASS CLEAR UP TO VA CENTRAL OFFICE (VACO). VACO IS CONSIDERING OUR STATION (V20 687 WALLA WALLA VAMC) FOR A TEST REGARDING INTEGRATING BIM INTO OUR SYSTEM FOR FACILITES MANAGEMENT. THIS WEBINAR FILLED A VOID FOR INFORMATION NEEDED TO MOVE THIS AHEAD. AND HOPEFULLY BEABLE TO HAVE OTHERS VIEW IT. THANKS AGAIN TO THE AIA AND CAFM KNOWLEDGE GROUP FOR YOUR ASSISTANCE YOU MAY HAVE MADE MY YEAR!! SINCERELY, Michael Michael Runyon, AIA Member: 3004887 Interdisciplinary Architect Jonathan M Wainwright Memorial VA Medical Center Walla Walla, WA. (509) 525‐5200 ext 26465AIA & CAFM MEMBER

142 I received an email, for me it was an update on the challenges and benefits of BIM, and that is what I needed.

143 Good

144 I was very impressed and the topics were very relevant. The links were important also. I will sign up. Is there any way to get a copy of the seminar?


145 Energy conservation measures and current stats on what is working vs what is marketing hype

146 A bit over my head; I heard about it through regular AIA e‐mail noticies. I'm on a college campus. It appears that BIM works well with new construction. What applications are there to remodel projects? What are the start‐up costs

147 relevant topic, helpful info

148 The overall presentation was very good and informative. Look forward to more BIM webinars in the near future.

149 Good E‐mail

150 Good summary ‐‐‐maybe a little too much fundraising request.

151 Needed more on BIM and Facilities Management Applications

152 not clear about how to submit questions, far too much content about presenters personal bios, too much about Smart Alliance, not enough content on how the engineers and contractors work with BIM ‐ I know they still have significant issues, engineers and contractors didn't appear to be part of the Smart Alliance submission process, which makes the process lop sided.

153 Overall ‐ Very Good. I recieved an e mail re: the Webinar. Although I've been exposed to BIM for some time, I learned a lot of history that I was not previously exposed too.


154 The event was great, specially in this time of quick changes even though we are in a slow economy. Since i'm a member of AIA received email. I would like to know the result of an analisis made, not the intension, of going green with large fields located in agricultural district full of air turbines as a means of "less expensive" fuel are really successful economically? Cost of implementing, construction and maintaining(federal/government funding since no private company would do it) vs. real savings for the consumer. Samples could be from California, USA or anywhere in the world. Also verifying who are the companies/owners behind each development. What kind of employments, if technical, and how many jobs it creates vs. benefits for communities at the perimeter of this fields of turbines.

155 Good intro to the coordinating efforts of BIM organizations and to the estimated cost savings associated with BIM. I received an email from AIA inviting me to the session. I would be interested in a follow‐up with more technical information‐‐software requirements, more specific examples of using BIM.

156 Very good presentation. perhaps more 'how to' information.

157 At the beginning of the webinar, I could not see the presenters presentation. I said so in the "question" area, and they said they would get it fixed but they did not so I finally left the webinar and came back, and it worked, but I effectively missed about the first 15 minutes.

158 I've recently "retired" from working on large institutional projects that require the whole design team to use BIM, but I really appreciate the overview of how far things have come. Getting owners to understand the value of including the facilities and management staff in the initial planning/design phase including training on BIM and coordination software is critical.

159 email


160 overall it was good heard about it online from the AIA

161 heard about via email notice. i was hoping for a more solutions‐based/application program rather than what seemed to be a program to convince the audience of the value of BIM. Also, as the vast majority of architects are in small firms, the focus on application of BIM to enormous projects has limited value.

162 I learned of it from an AIA e‐mail and got a lot out of it.

163 From the information given at registration I expected more direct infomation about where BIM and facilities management current opportunities and state exist. I also expected more presentation of Owner's expectations (or maybe that was my hope, since that is what my team represented)

164 Webinar was avertized via internet notices from local AIA chapter

165 I learned of the webinar from email sent to me. I wasn't very familiar with BIM and the Webinar helped me understnad more about BIM.

166 It was a little tough getting started but once under way it was a good presentation.

167 The overall topic was good, but it only seemed to scratch the surface. Would have been nice to hear how one would implement this into a large organization from scratch which has been in existance for 30 yrs. To hear what some of the down falls and issues associated with implementation. Also, when this isn't practical to use.

168 More information about how BIM software integrates with CAFM software for those who haven't implemented.

169 This was a great way to get the same information out to a large group of people. Please offer some follow up sessions.

170 My only comment was that the announcement came over as EST and reading it on an i‐phone quickly one lost the EST component and I assumed CST.

171 so so. too basic. I did not learn anything new.


172 It was a good seminar on an emerging topic. I was referred to the webinar by an architect designing our current project. More information is needed on how BIM is being used in Facilities Management at the technician level, how it speeds workflow, what devices are being used (PCs, iPads, bar code scanners, etc...).

173 Good topic ‐ not much new information

174 I received multiple emails from AIA advertising this webinar. As an owner we were particularly interested in this topic however we were actually very disappointed in how little of the 90 minutes was relevant to how owner's will or can use BIM. The first 45 minutes was basic overview and BIM standards creation that could easily be condensed into 15 minutes. The meat of the program was 30‐45 minutes at the end. This program should have been no longer than 60 minutes.

175 AIA email notice. The "real world" examples provided by Birgitta were much more informative than the "sales pitch" presented by Deke Smith who mainly advertised for JBIM subscriptions and Smart Alliance membership.

176 many of the concepts presented along with information was not new...this has been discuseed for the last 10 years and is just begining implement...i was disapointed in the so called experts. they did not present anything new.

177 Well done

178 Heard about it from a co‐worker. Overall impression is that it could have been more engaging.

179 Very good. Heard about it from e‐mail. The pace was fast, which was EXCELLENT!

180 It gave a good sense of the potential for BIM. Received email from AIA.

181 facinating topic! not sure how revolutionary this will become. I see the benefit (as the Owner), but it also locks me into needing to have a longer term relationship with the architect (and engineers team), and this could be a problem if this is not a good one.


182 All thought it was valuable, but felt too much time was expended towards the organizatinal component ‐ "how came to be" and more time should have been devoted to the "vision" and "potential" as Birgitta shared. The visuals of the GPS fire extinguishers slide were very effective as Facility designers we could see in a very simple fashion how this could save lots of time for the owner. Continue to develop slides that show the potential vision. New Resource information provided was very good, I saw are architect researching it this morning. Thank you Julie McGill‐Kopp ‐ Interior designer and member of IFMA PA central chapter. Saw this webinar offering on email. We would like copy of slide show if available?? Is there a hand out pdf format available???

183 Enjoyed it very much. Great presentation!

184 Good information. Heard about this through a colleague and also through an email announcement (through AIA I believe).

185 Effective presentation of the ideas and their potential. I'm curious to see how software developments can further this vision and bring it to a reality

186 This was about establishing standards. I wanted more on what has been established.

187 Very positive, I work in engineering/ operation dealing with post construction turn over and your presentation provide information to change the status quo or two worlds

188 I got an email thru my AIA connection. I would be interested in topic that would reuse of existing structures and any LEED types of topic. I would also be interested in any commercial interiors topics.

189 from an e‐mail invitation (AIA)

190 Good information ‐ introduced to new resources that will benefit future projects.

191 thru email announcement


192 Was emailed information regarding this seminar from a friend that is also an architect, and thought I would be interested.

193 good webinar, very informative

194 Informative tie between BIM and FM. Heard about this through email notifications.

195 ok spent too much time on the value of BIM and not enough of the "life cylec" facilties component

196 AIA email

197 E‐mail invitation...

198 Very informative. Notified of event by email from AIA membership.

199 Excellent. we need more webinars like this one.

200 Received an email from AIA. Great information very efficiently presented.

201 All the information was relevant and speakers did a good job of presenting it. I heard about the seminar through a notice from my knowledge group, [email protected]

202 I thought it was useful, but would have liked to see a bit more detail around the transfer of data from CAD to MMS.

203 my impression was very good. I received an email notification from AIA and followed the link. I liked that it was just an hour and a half so I could fit it in the day. Almost any topic can be delivered this way. there wasn't much time for questions at the end. only 2 questions got answered.

204 While I like the future prespective I could use more hands on expample of the "what and how" things are being accomplished with BIM today.

205 by email

206 Graphics seemed un‐interesting

Corporate Architects Facility Management

Documents

Transcript of Corporate Architects Facility Management