Cooperation and Competition, LUCID 2013
Transcript of Cooperation and Competition, LUCID 2013
Last time, we saw how networks can spread ideas and emotions, and how they can be used to examine the behavior o! groups.
And now...
One, two, three, !our,
we declare a LUCID thumb war!
Pair up with someone next to you.
Do as many thumb wars as you can in two minutes.
No talking !or the !irst minute.
Report your scores to your LUCID !aculty member.
A prize will be awarded to each o! the three top-scoring thumb wrestlers.
The LUCID section with the highest collective score will get pizza !or an upcoming small session meeting.
Dealing withCheaters Among Us
The Situation
Tells us your partner did it: - keep your prize and- partner’s prize taken away.
Tell us nothing:- hal! your prize taken away.
B Cooperates
A Cooperates
A deprived o!hal! the prize
B deprived o!hal! the prize
A De!ects
B De!ects
A deprived !ully o! the prize
B deprived !ully o! the prize
B Cooperates
A De!ects
A keeps the entire prize
B deprived !ully o! the prize
A Cooperates
B De!ects
A deprived !ullyo! the prize
B keeps the entire prize
B Cooperates
A Cooperates A De!ects
B De!ects
A deprived o!hal! the prize
B deprived o!hal! the prize
A deprived !ully o! the prize
B deprived !ully o! the prize
A keeps the entire prize
B deprived !ully o! the prize
A deprived !ullyo! the prize
B keeps the entire prize
B Cooperates
A Cooperates A De!ects
B De!ects
A deprived o!hal! the prize
B deprived o!hal! the prize
A deprived !ully o! the prize
B deprived !ully o! the prize
A keeps the entire prize
B deprived !ully o! the prize
A deprived !ullyo! the prize
B keeps the entire prize
B Cooperates
A Cooperates A De!ects
B De!ects
A
B
A
B
A
B
A
B
The Prisoner’sDilemma.
Individual and the Group
Competition and Cooperation
Multiple Levels o!Competition andCooperation
AcademicInstitutions
PI
GradStudent
PI
GradStudent
GradStudent
Post-DocPI
GradStudent
Post-Doc
ResearchLab
ResearchLab
ResearchLab
ResearchLab
ResearchLab
DepartmentDepartment
Department
University
University
Academia
Society
Laura StenzelCollege o! Liberal Arts and Sciences
employee
employee
employeeemployee
employeeemployee
Individuals within a store:
- Compete !or hours, pay, and recognition
- Cooperate to meet store needs, serve products, and raise store pro!it
StarbucksStore
StarbucksStore
StarbucksStore
StarbucksStore
StarbucksStore
Stores within an area:
- Compete with other starbucks stores (and other businesses!) !or quality sta", customers, and sales.
- Cooperate with other stores to increase !oot tra#c, share materials & resources, and spread company in!ormation.
StarbucksStore
StarbucksStore
StarbucksStore
StarbucksStore
District
District
District
District
Districts within the company:
- Compete with other districts !or new store locations, management sta", customers, and sales.
- Cooperate to ensure consistent product standards, uphold legal regulations, and drive company sales.
StarbucksChain
Teavana
The Starbucks Chain:
- Competes with other !ranchises the corporation owns to increase stockholder attention, develop new marketing techniques, & drive sales to increase name growth.
- Cooperates with other chains to ensure growth o! sales !or the corporation, ensure product availability, and to !ollow proper legal regulations.
StarbucksCorporation
Economy
Ideas andCollective Behavior
Thought
Thought
Thought Thought
ThoughtThought
Idea
Idea
Idea
Idea
IdeaIdea
Person
Person
Person
Person
SmallSocialGroups
Social +Ecological Systems
Human-Environment Systems
Shopping Mall Food Courts
employee
employee
employeeemployee
employeeemployee
QSR
QSRQSR
QSR
Food Court
Store Store
Shop
Food Court
ClothingStores
Shopping Mall
Suburban Ecosystem
Regional Landscape
Reality TV Shows
contestant
contestant
contestantcontestant
contestant
contestant
Sub-group
Sub-group
Sub-group
SurvivorShow
FullHouse
TV Station
TV Station
BroadcastTelevision
Media
Apples and Oranges
apple
orangepear
grapes
trees
shrubs
vines
grasses
cacti
Fruit Types
Fruit Types
ReproductiveStrategy
Multicellular Organisms
LivingThings
Humanity’sCon!licted Nature
Courage in light o! this
Networks present us with challenges and opportunities to be individually or collectively oriented.
Rosa Parksand The Montgomery Bus Boycott
Freedom Summer