Contents · Citations H index USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904 Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142...

50

Transcript of Contents · Citations H index USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904 Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142...

Page 1: Contents · Citations H index USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904 Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142 Israel ... 0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush. Arab nations lagging behind other Middle

Contents

0 Introduction

0 Aims

0 Methods

0 Findings

0 Conclusions and road map

2

Introduction

3

Strengths 0 Resources

0 23 countries distributed on a very wide geographic area Rich in natural resources

0 370989000 (mid 2013 estimations) Rich in human resources

0 Academic institutions

4

Weaknesses

0 Nowadays the Arab countries are counted among the developing countries

0 Most of them are living under conflict

5

Research 0 This may lead to the question what is the situation of

health related research in Arab Countries

0 Even itrsquos Importance why it stay at lower level of Priority

0 Whatrsquos the impact of conflict and brain drain on the situation of research

6

AIMS

Reviewing main issues published in the literature regarding health related

research in Arab countries and paving the way forward

7

Methods

0 Internet Search

0Key words research biomedical health related Arab countries

012 publications

8

Issues derived

0 Visibility of the research to the scientific community

0 Productivity of countries when adjusted to the population size and GDP

0 Comparison with other countries

0 Bibliometric analyses

0 Bellagio meeting

9

Output of Arab institutions

during the period of 1996-2012

0 2000 4000 6000 8000 10000 12000 14000 16000 18000

Saudi arabia

Tunisia

Lebanon

Jordan

Oman

Iraq

Sudan

Libya

Yemen

Mauritania

Somalia

11

1988- 2007

12

2003

0 The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia and Egypt had the highest number of publications together accounting for 584 of the Arab countriesrsquo publications

13

Progress number of publications

88-97 98-07

15868

35211

14

Progress contribution

88-97 98-07

038 06

15

1988-2002

0 Arabs produce less than 1 of the biomedical citations in the world despite the available wealth and human resources

16

Is it a matter of population size

or wealth of the country

18

Population size

19

1988-2002

0 MEDLINE results normalized to population size show that small countries such as Kuwait the United Arab Emirates and Lebanon are more productive than Egypt and Saudi Arabiamdashthe largest publishers in the Arab world

20

2003 per 100000 of the population

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

Kuwait UAE

657

262

21

22

Wealth

23

Normalizing by the GDP

Jordan Lebanon

112

103

Per one billion of GDP

24

Together

25

upper-middle lower-upper upper

11

4

32 33

8

38

Number of publications per million population per year

According to Income groups

88-97 98-07

26

Rank of Arab Medical research Institutions

during the period of 1996-2012

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200

Saudi arabia

Tunisia

Lebanon

Jordan

Oman

Iraq

Sudan

Libya

Yemen

Mauritania

Somalia

28

Medical research output from the USA Turkey Israel Iran and Arab nations (1996mdash2012)

Documents Citable

Documents

Citations H index

USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904

Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142

Israel 59894 54409 953440 255

Iran 38147 35492 131537 82

Arab countries 76417 69753 444281 39

29

Documents

1875195

120954 59894 38147 764170

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

2000000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

30

Citable Documents

0

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

31

Citations

32

H index 904

142

255

82 39

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

1 2 3 4 5

33

Pub Med Publications 2001-2005

34

2001-2005

0 The Arab countries also scored less when the data were normalized to

0 Population

0 GDP

35

Published 2009

0 In Lebanon

0 most of the citations originated from the capital city of Beirut mainly the American University of Beirut

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in Lebanon indicate a focus on internal medicine anesthesiology surgery transplantation medical genetics pediatrics obstetrics neoplasms and pain management

37

Published 2009

0 In the UAE

0 most of the biomedical publications originate from Al-Ain University

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in the UAE indicate developed interest in pediatrics obstetrics clinical dysmorphologies transplantation dermatology diabetes and consanguinity

38

Bellagio

0 A meeting was held in Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013 on lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo

0 to discuss how best to use the current opportunities to strengthen research science and innovation for health in the region

40

Partners 0 The Council on Health Research for Development

(COHRED)

0 the World Health Organisation (WHO) Regional-Office for the Eastern Mediterranean

0 and regional institutions such as the Faculty of Health Sciences of the American University of Beirut (AUB)

0 This event is supported by the International Development Research Centre (IDRC) in line with the Global Health Research Initiative (GHRI) the Middle East and North Africa Health Policy Forum and the Rockefeller Foundation

41

Outputs

0A call for action to strengthen system capacity for research and innovation for health

0A communication strategy to disseminate and keep this alive until the regional conference

0A conference plan for 2014

42

Conclusions

0 Visibility Egypt Saudi Arabia

0 Productivity UAE Lebanon Kuwait Jordan hellip

0 Compared to regional countries far away

0 Bibliometric AUB Al Ain U

0 Future more Partners Leaders and supporters are needed to be involved

44

Contribution concerns

In order to contribute more therersquos a need for

0 Center

0 Researcher and scientific writer

0 funding

0 Local issues hypothesis

0 Language

45

Road map

Arab Countries Health Research Group

(ACHRG)

Coordination networking

Specialized Conferences

46

References 0 Amin Bredan Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Editors Visibility

of Arab countries in the world biomedical literature Libyan J Med 2011 6 103402ljmv6i06325 Published online 2011 March 3 doi 103402ljmv6i06325 PMCID PMC3081872

0 Tadmouri GO Bissar-Tadmouri N Biomedical publications in an unstable region the Arab world 1988-2002 Lancet 2003 Nov 22362(9397)1766

0 Shaban SF Abu-Zidan FM A quantitative analysis of medical publications from Arab countries Saudi Med J 2003 Mar24(3)294-6

0 Deleu D Northway MG Hanssens Y Geographical distribution of biomedical publications from the Gulf Corporation Council countries Saudi Med J 2001 Jan22(1)10-2

47

References 0 Waleed M Sweileh Sarsquoed H Zyoud Ansam F Sawalha Adham Abu-Taha

Ayman Hussein and Samah W Al-Jabi Medical and biomedical research productivity from Palestine 2002 ndash 2011 BMC Res Notes 2013 6 41 Published online 2013 February 2 doi 1011861756-0500-6-41 PMCID PMC3566958

0 Afifi M Egyptian biomedical publications in PubMed 1996-2005

0 Bakoush O Al-Tubuly A Ashammakhi N Elkhammas E PubMed Medical publications from Libya Libyan J Med 2007 Sep 12(3)125-8 doi 104176070625

0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Arab nations lagging behind other Middle Eastern countries in biomedical research a comparative study Published online 2009 April 17 doi 1011861471-2288-9-26 BMC Med Res Methodol 2009 9 26 PMCID PMC2674457

48

References 0 Bissar-Tadmouri N Tadmouri GO Bibliometric analyses of

biomedical research outputs in Lebanon and the United Arab Emirates (1988-2007) Saudi Med J 2009 Jan30(1)130-9

0 Bellagio Meeting lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013

0 Mohammed El-Azami-El-Idrissi Mounia Lakhdar-Idrissi Karim Ouldim Wafaa Bono Afaf Amarti-Riffi Moustapha Hida Chakib Nejjari aImproving medical research in the Arab world The Lancet December 21st 2013

0 S A Ismail A McDonald E Dubois F G Aljohani A P Coutts A Majeed and S Rawaf Assessing the state of health research in the Eastern Mediterranean Region J R Soc Med published online 10 May 2013 DOI 101258jrsm2012120240

49

Page 2: Contents · Citations H index USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904 Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142 Israel ... 0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush. Arab nations lagging behind other Middle

Introduction

3

Strengths 0 Resources

0 23 countries distributed on a very wide geographic area Rich in natural resources

0 370989000 (mid 2013 estimations) Rich in human resources

0 Academic institutions

4

Weaknesses

0 Nowadays the Arab countries are counted among the developing countries

0 Most of them are living under conflict

5

Research 0 This may lead to the question what is the situation of

health related research in Arab Countries

0 Even itrsquos Importance why it stay at lower level of Priority

0 Whatrsquos the impact of conflict and brain drain on the situation of research

6

AIMS

Reviewing main issues published in the literature regarding health related

research in Arab countries and paving the way forward

7

Methods

0 Internet Search

0Key words research biomedical health related Arab countries

012 publications

8

Issues derived

0 Visibility of the research to the scientific community

0 Productivity of countries when adjusted to the population size and GDP

0 Comparison with other countries

0 Bibliometric analyses

0 Bellagio meeting

9

Output of Arab institutions

during the period of 1996-2012

0 2000 4000 6000 8000 10000 12000 14000 16000 18000

Saudi arabia

Tunisia

Lebanon

Jordan

Oman

Iraq

Sudan

Libya

Yemen

Mauritania

Somalia

11

1988- 2007

12

2003

0 The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia and Egypt had the highest number of publications together accounting for 584 of the Arab countriesrsquo publications

13

Progress number of publications

88-97 98-07

15868

35211

14

Progress contribution

88-97 98-07

038 06

15

1988-2002

0 Arabs produce less than 1 of the biomedical citations in the world despite the available wealth and human resources

16

Is it a matter of population size

or wealth of the country

18

Population size

19

1988-2002

0 MEDLINE results normalized to population size show that small countries such as Kuwait the United Arab Emirates and Lebanon are more productive than Egypt and Saudi Arabiamdashthe largest publishers in the Arab world

20

2003 per 100000 of the population

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

Kuwait UAE

657

262

21

22

Wealth

23

Normalizing by the GDP

Jordan Lebanon

112

103

Per one billion of GDP

24

Together

25

upper-middle lower-upper upper

11

4

32 33

8

38

Number of publications per million population per year

According to Income groups

88-97 98-07

26

Rank of Arab Medical research Institutions

during the period of 1996-2012

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200

Saudi arabia

Tunisia

Lebanon

Jordan

Oman

Iraq

Sudan

Libya

Yemen

Mauritania

Somalia

28

Medical research output from the USA Turkey Israel Iran and Arab nations (1996mdash2012)

Documents Citable

Documents

Citations H index

USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904

Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142

Israel 59894 54409 953440 255

Iran 38147 35492 131537 82

Arab countries 76417 69753 444281 39

29

Documents

1875195

120954 59894 38147 764170

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

2000000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

30

Citable Documents

0

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

31

Citations

32

H index 904

142

255

82 39

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

1 2 3 4 5

33

Pub Med Publications 2001-2005

34

2001-2005

0 The Arab countries also scored less when the data were normalized to

0 Population

0 GDP

35

Published 2009

0 In Lebanon

0 most of the citations originated from the capital city of Beirut mainly the American University of Beirut

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in Lebanon indicate a focus on internal medicine anesthesiology surgery transplantation medical genetics pediatrics obstetrics neoplasms and pain management

37

Published 2009

0 In the UAE

0 most of the biomedical publications originate from Al-Ain University

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in the UAE indicate developed interest in pediatrics obstetrics clinical dysmorphologies transplantation dermatology diabetes and consanguinity

38

Bellagio

0 A meeting was held in Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013 on lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo

0 to discuss how best to use the current opportunities to strengthen research science and innovation for health in the region

40

Partners 0 The Council on Health Research for Development

(COHRED)

0 the World Health Organisation (WHO) Regional-Office for the Eastern Mediterranean

0 and regional institutions such as the Faculty of Health Sciences of the American University of Beirut (AUB)

0 This event is supported by the International Development Research Centre (IDRC) in line with the Global Health Research Initiative (GHRI) the Middle East and North Africa Health Policy Forum and the Rockefeller Foundation

41

Outputs

0A call for action to strengthen system capacity for research and innovation for health

0A communication strategy to disseminate and keep this alive until the regional conference

0A conference plan for 2014

42

Conclusions

0 Visibility Egypt Saudi Arabia

0 Productivity UAE Lebanon Kuwait Jordan hellip

0 Compared to regional countries far away

0 Bibliometric AUB Al Ain U

0 Future more Partners Leaders and supporters are needed to be involved

44

Contribution concerns

In order to contribute more therersquos a need for

0 Center

0 Researcher and scientific writer

0 funding

0 Local issues hypothesis

0 Language

45

Road map

Arab Countries Health Research Group

(ACHRG)

Coordination networking

Specialized Conferences

46

References 0 Amin Bredan Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Editors Visibility

of Arab countries in the world biomedical literature Libyan J Med 2011 6 103402ljmv6i06325 Published online 2011 March 3 doi 103402ljmv6i06325 PMCID PMC3081872

0 Tadmouri GO Bissar-Tadmouri N Biomedical publications in an unstable region the Arab world 1988-2002 Lancet 2003 Nov 22362(9397)1766

0 Shaban SF Abu-Zidan FM A quantitative analysis of medical publications from Arab countries Saudi Med J 2003 Mar24(3)294-6

0 Deleu D Northway MG Hanssens Y Geographical distribution of biomedical publications from the Gulf Corporation Council countries Saudi Med J 2001 Jan22(1)10-2

47

References 0 Waleed M Sweileh Sarsquoed H Zyoud Ansam F Sawalha Adham Abu-Taha

Ayman Hussein and Samah W Al-Jabi Medical and biomedical research productivity from Palestine 2002 ndash 2011 BMC Res Notes 2013 6 41 Published online 2013 February 2 doi 1011861756-0500-6-41 PMCID PMC3566958

0 Afifi M Egyptian biomedical publications in PubMed 1996-2005

0 Bakoush O Al-Tubuly A Ashammakhi N Elkhammas E PubMed Medical publications from Libya Libyan J Med 2007 Sep 12(3)125-8 doi 104176070625

0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Arab nations lagging behind other Middle Eastern countries in biomedical research a comparative study Published online 2009 April 17 doi 1011861471-2288-9-26 BMC Med Res Methodol 2009 9 26 PMCID PMC2674457

48

References 0 Bissar-Tadmouri N Tadmouri GO Bibliometric analyses of

biomedical research outputs in Lebanon and the United Arab Emirates (1988-2007) Saudi Med J 2009 Jan30(1)130-9

0 Bellagio Meeting lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013

0 Mohammed El-Azami-El-Idrissi Mounia Lakhdar-Idrissi Karim Ouldim Wafaa Bono Afaf Amarti-Riffi Moustapha Hida Chakib Nejjari aImproving medical research in the Arab world The Lancet December 21st 2013

0 S A Ismail A McDonald E Dubois F G Aljohani A P Coutts A Majeed and S Rawaf Assessing the state of health research in the Eastern Mediterranean Region J R Soc Med published online 10 May 2013 DOI 101258jrsm2012120240

49

Page 3: Contents · Citations H index USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904 Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142 Israel ... 0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush. Arab nations lagging behind other Middle

Strengths 0 Resources

0 23 countries distributed on a very wide geographic area Rich in natural resources

0 370989000 (mid 2013 estimations) Rich in human resources

0 Academic institutions

4

Weaknesses

0 Nowadays the Arab countries are counted among the developing countries

0 Most of them are living under conflict

5

Research 0 This may lead to the question what is the situation of

health related research in Arab Countries

0 Even itrsquos Importance why it stay at lower level of Priority

0 Whatrsquos the impact of conflict and brain drain on the situation of research

6

AIMS

Reviewing main issues published in the literature regarding health related

research in Arab countries and paving the way forward

7

Methods

0 Internet Search

0Key words research biomedical health related Arab countries

012 publications

8

Issues derived

0 Visibility of the research to the scientific community

0 Productivity of countries when adjusted to the population size and GDP

0 Comparison with other countries

0 Bibliometric analyses

0 Bellagio meeting

9

Output of Arab institutions

during the period of 1996-2012

0 2000 4000 6000 8000 10000 12000 14000 16000 18000

Saudi arabia

Tunisia

Lebanon

Jordan

Oman

Iraq

Sudan

Libya

Yemen

Mauritania

Somalia

11

1988- 2007

12

2003

0 The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia and Egypt had the highest number of publications together accounting for 584 of the Arab countriesrsquo publications

13

Progress number of publications

88-97 98-07

15868

35211

14

Progress contribution

88-97 98-07

038 06

15

1988-2002

0 Arabs produce less than 1 of the biomedical citations in the world despite the available wealth and human resources

16

Is it a matter of population size

or wealth of the country

18

Population size

19

1988-2002

0 MEDLINE results normalized to population size show that small countries such as Kuwait the United Arab Emirates and Lebanon are more productive than Egypt and Saudi Arabiamdashthe largest publishers in the Arab world

20

2003 per 100000 of the population

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

Kuwait UAE

657

262

21

22

Wealth

23

Normalizing by the GDP

Jordan Lebanon

112

103

Per one billion of GDP

24

Together

25

upper-middle lower-upper upper

11

4

32 33

8

38

Number of publications per million population per year

According to Income groups

88-97 98-07

26

Rank of Arab Medical research Institutions

during the period of 1996-2012

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200

Saudi arabia

Tunisia

Lebanon

Jordan

Oman

Iraq

Sudan

Libya

Yemen

Mauritania

Somalia

28

Medical research output from the USA Turkey Israel Iran and Arab nations (1996mdash2012)

Documents Citable

Documents

Citations H index

USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904

Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142

Israel 59894 54409 953440 255

Iran 38147 35492 131537 82

Arab countries 76417 69753 444281 39

29

Documents

1875195

120954 59894 38147 764170

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

2000000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

30

Citable Documents

0

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

31

Citations

32

H index 904

142

255

82 39

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

1 2 3 4 5

33

Pub Med Publications 2001-2005

34

2001-2005

0 The Arab countries also scored less when the data were normalized to

0 Population

0 GDP

35

Published 2009

0 In Lebanon

0 most of the citations originated from the capital city of Beirut mainly the American University of Beirut

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in Lebanon indicate a focus on internal medicine anesthesiology surgery transplantation medical genetics pediatrics obstetrics neoplasms and pain management

37

Published 2009

0 In the UAE

0 most of the biomedical publications originate from Al-Ain University

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in the UAE indicate developed interest in pediatrics obstetrics clinical dysmorphologies transplantation dermatology diabetes and consanguinity

38

Bellagio

0 A meeting was held in Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013 on lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo

0 to discuss how best to use the current opportunities to strengthen research science and innovation for health in the region

40

Partners 0 The Council on Health Research for Development

(COHRED)

0 the World Health Organisation (WHO) Regional-Office for the Eastern Mediterranean

0 and regional institutions such as the Faculty of Health Sciences of the American University of Beirut (AUB)

0 This event is supported by the International Development Research Centre (IDRC) in line with the Global Health Research Initiative (GHRI) the Middle East and North Africa Health Policy Forum and the Rockefeller Foundation

41

Outputs

0A call for action to strengthen system capacity for research and innovation for health

0A communication strategy to disseminate and keep this alive until the regional conference

0A conference plan for 2014

42

Conclusions

0 Visibility Egypt Saudi Arabia

0 Productivity UAE Lebanon Kuwait Jordan hellip

0 Compared to regional countries far away

0 Bibliometric AUB Al Ain U

0 Future more Partners Leaders and supporters are needed to be involved

44

Contribution concerns

In order to contribute more therersquos a need for

0 Center

0 Researcher and scientific writer

0 funding

0 Local issues hypothesis

0 Language

45

Road map

Arab Countries Health Research Group

(ACHRG)

Coordination networking

Specialized Conferences

46

References 0 Amin Bredan Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Editors Visibility

of Arab countries in the world biomedical literature Libyan J Med 2011 6 103402ljmv6i06325 Published online 2011 March 3 doi 103402ljmv6i06325 PMCID PMC3081872

0 Tadmouri GO Bissar-Tadmouri N Biomedical publications in an unstable region the Arab world 1988-2002 Lancet 2003 Nov 22362(9397)1766

0 Shaban SF Abu-Zidan FM A quantitative analysis of medical publications from Arab countries Saudi Med J 2003 Mar24(3)294-6

0 Deleu D Northway MG Hanssens Y Geographical distribution of biomedical publications from the Gulf Corporation Council countries Saudi Med J 2001 Jan22(1)10-2

47

References 0 Waleed M Sweileh Sarsquoed H Zyoud Ansam F Sawalha Adham Abu-Taha

Ayman Hussein and Samah W Al-Jabi Medical and biomedical research productivity from Palestine 2002 ndash 2011 BMC Res Notes 2013 6 41 Published online 2013 February 2 doi 1011861756-0500-6-41 PMCID PMC3566958

0 Afifi M Egyptian biomedical publications in PubMed 1996-2005

0 Bakoush O Al-Tubuly A Ashammakhi N Elkhammas E PubMed Medical publications from Libya Libyan J Med 2007 Sep 12(3)125-8 doi 104176070625

0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Arab nations lagging behind other Middle Eastern countries in biomedical research a comparative study Published online 2009 April 17 doi 1011861471-2288-9-26 BMC Med Res Methodol 2009 9 26 PMCID PMC2674457

48

References 0 Bissar-Tadmouri N Tadmouri GO Bibliometric analyses of

biomedical research outputs in Lebanon and the United Arab Emirates (1988-2007) Saudi Med J 2009 Jan30(1)130-9

0 Bellagio Meeting lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013

0 Mohammed El-Azami-El-Idrissi Mounia Lakhdar-Idrissi Karim Ouldim Wafaa Bono Afaf Amarti-Riffi Moustapha Hida Chakib Nejjari aImproving medical research in the Arab world The Lancet December 21st 2013

0 S A Ismail A McDonald E Dubois F G Aljohani A P Coutts A Majeed and S Rawaf Assessing the state of health research in the Eastern Mediterranean Region J R Soc Med published online 10 May 2013 DOI 101258jrsm2012120240

49

Page 4: Contents · Citations H index USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904 Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142 Israel ... 0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush. Arab nations lagging behind other Middle

Weaknesses

0 Nowadays the Arab countries are counted among the developing countries

0 Most of them are living under conflict

5

Research 0 This may lead to the question what is the situation of

health related research in Arab Countries

0 Even itrsquos Importance why it stay at lower level of Priority

0 Whatrsquos the impact of conflict and brain drain on the situation of research

6

AIMS

Reviewing main issues published in the literature regarding health related

research in Arab countries and paving the way forward

7

Methods

0 Internet Search

0Key words research biomedical health related Arab countries

012 publications

8

Issues derived

0 Visibility of the research to the scientific community

0 Productivity of countries when adjusted to the population size and GDP

0 Comparison with other countries

0 Bibliometric analyses

0 Bellagio meeting

9

Output of Arab institutions

during the period of 1996-2012

0 2000 4000 6000 8000 10000 12000 14000 16000 18000

Saudi arabia

Tunisia

Lebanon

Jordan

Oman

Iraq

Sudan

Libya

Yemen

Mauritania

Somalia

11

1988- 2007

12

2003

0 The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia and Egypt had the highest number of publications together accounting for 584 of the Arab countriesrsquo publications

13

Progress number of publications

88-97 98-07

15868

35211

14

Progress contribution

88-97 98-07

038 06

15

1988-2002

0 Arabs produce less than 1 of the biomedical citations in the world despite the available wealth and human resources

16

Is it a matter of population size

or wealth of the country

18

Population size

19

1988-2002

0 MEDLINE results normalized to population size show that small countries such as Kuwait the United Arab Emirates and Lebanon are more productive than Egypt and Saudi Arabiamdashthe largest publishers in the Arab world

20

2003 per 100000 of the population

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

Kuwait UAE

657

262

21

22

Wealth

23

Normalizing by the GDP

Jordan Lebanon

112

103

Per one billion of GDP

24

Together

25

upper-middle lower-upper upper

11

4

32 33

8

38

Number of publications per million population per year

According to Income groups

88-97 98-07

26

Rank of Arab Medical research Institutions

during the period of 1996-2012

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200

Saudi arabia

Tunisia

Lebanon

Jordan

Oman

Iraq

Sudan

Libya

Yemen

Mauritania

Somalia

28

Medical research output from the USA Turkey Israel Iran and Arab nations (1996mdash2012)

Documents Citable

Documents

Citations H index

USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904

Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142

Israel 59894 54409 953440 255

Iran 38147 35492 131537 82

Arab countries 76417 69753 444281 39

29

Documents

1875195

120954 59894 38147 764170

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

2000000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

30

Citable Documents

0

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

31

Citations

32

H index 904

142

255

82 39

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

1 2 3 4 5

33

Pub Med Publications 2001-2005

34

2001-2005

0 The Arab countries also scored less when the data were normalized to

0 Population

0 GDP

35

Published 2009

0 In Lebanon

0 most of the citations originated from the capital city of Beirut mainly the American University of Beirut

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in Lebanon indicate a focus on internal medicine anesthesiology surgery transplantation medical genetics pediatrics obstetrics neoplasms and pain management

37

Published 2009

0 In the UAE

0 most of the biomedical publications originate from Al-Ain University

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in the UAE indicate developed interest in pediatrics obstetrics clinical dysmorphologies transplantation dermatology diabetes and consanguinity

38

Bellagio

0 A meeting was held in Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013 on lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo

0 to discuss how best to use the current opportunities to strengthen research science and innovation for health in the region

40

Partners 0 The Council on Health Research for Development

(COHRED)

0 the World Health Organisation (WHO) Regional-Office for the Eastern Mediterranean

0 and regional institutions such as the Faculty of Health Sciences of the American University of Beirut (AUB)

0 This event is supported by the International Development Research Centre (IDRC) in line with the Global Health Research Initiative (GHRI) the Middle East and North Africa Health Policy Forum and the Rockefeller Foundation

41

Outputs

0A call for action to strengthen system capacity for research and innovation for health

0A communication strategy to disseminate and keep this alive until the regional conference

0A conference plan for 2014

42

Conclusions

0 Visibility Egypt Saudi Arabia

0 Productivity UAE Lebanon Kuwait Jordan hellip

0 Compared to regional countries far away

0 Bibliometric AUB Al Ain U

0 Future more Partners Leaders and supporters are needed to be involved

44

Contribution concerns

In order to contribute more therersquos a need for

0 Center

0 Researcher and scientific writer

0 funding

0 Local issues hypothesis

0 Language

45

Road map

Arab Countries Health Research Group

(ACHRG)

Coordination networking

Specialized Conferences

46

References 0 Amin Bredan Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Editors Visibility

of Arab countries in the world biomedical literature Libyan J Med 2011 6 103402ljmv6i06325 Published online 2011 March 3 doi 103402ljmv6i06325 PMCID PMC3081872

0 Tadmouri GO Bissar-Tadmouri N Biomedical publications in an unstable region the Arab world 1988-2002 Lancet 2003 Nov 22362(9397)1766

0 Shaban SF Abu-Zidan FM A quantitative analysis of medical publications from Arab countries Saudi Med J 2003 Mar24(3)294-6

0 Deleu D Northway MG Hanssens Y Geographical distribution of biomedical publications from the Gulf Corporation Council countries Saudi Med J 2001 Jan22(1)10-2

47

References 0 Waleed M Sweileh Sarsquoed H Zyoud Ansam F Sawalha Adham Abu-Taha

Ayman Hussein and Samah W Al-Jabi Medical and biomedical research productivity from Palestine 2002 ndash 2011 BMC Res Notes 2013 6 41 Published online 2013 February 2 doi 1011861756-0500-6-41 PMCID PMC3566958

0 Afifi M Egyptian biomedical publications in PubMed 1996-2005

0 Bakoush O Al-Tubuly A Ashammakhi N Elkhammas E PubMed Medical publications from Libya Libyan J Med 2007 Sep 12(3)125-8 doi 104176070625

0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Arab nations lagging behind other Middle Eastern countries in biomedical research a comparative study Published online 2009 April 17 doi 1011861471-2288-9-26 BMC Med Res Methodol 2009 9 26 PMCID PMC2674457

48

References 0 Bissar-Tadmouri N Tadmouri GO Bibliometric analyses of

biomedical research outputs in Lebanon and the United Arab Emirates (1988-2007) Saudi Med J 2009 Jan30(1)130-9

0 Bellagio Meeting lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013

0 Mohammed El-Azami-El-Idrissi Mounia Lakhdar-Idrissi Karim Ouldim Wafaa Bono Afaf Amarti-Riffi Moustapha Hida Chakib Nejjari aImproving medical research in the Arab world The Lancet December 21st 2013

0 S A Ismail A McDonald E Dubois F G Aljohani A P Coutts A Majeed and S Rawaf Assessing the state of health research in the Eastern Mediterranean Region J R Soc Med published online 10 May 2013 DOI 101258jrsm2012120240

49

Page 5: Contents · Citations H index USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904 Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142 Israel ... 0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush. Arab nations lagging behind other Middle

Research 0 This may lead to the question what is the situation of

health related research in Arab Countries

0 Even itrsquos Importance why it stay at lower level of Priority

0 Whatrsquos the impact of conflict and brain drain on the situation of research

6

AIMS

Reviewing main issues published in the literature regarding health related

research in Arab countries and paving the way forward

7

Methods

0 Internet Search

0Key words research biomedical health related Arab countries

012 publications

8

Issues derived

0 Visibility of the research to the scientific community

0 Productivity of countries when adjusted to the population size and GDP

0 Comparison with other countries

0 Bibliometric analyses

0 Bellagio meeting

9

Output of Arab institutions

during the period of 1996-2012

0 2000 4000 6000 8000 10000 12000 14000 16000 18000

Saudi arabia

Tunisia

Lebanon

Jordan

Oman

Iraq

Sudan

Libya

Yemen

Mauritania

Somalia

11

1988- 2007

12

2003

0 The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia and Egypt had the highest number of publications together accounting for 584 of the Arab countriesrsquo publications

13

Progress number of publications

88-97 98-07

15868

35211

14

Progress contribution

88-97 98-07

038 06

15

1988-2002

0 Arabs produce less than 1 of the biomedical citations in the world despite the available wealth and human resources

16

Is it a matter of population size

or wealth of the country

18

Population size

19

1988-2002

0 MEDLINE results normalized to population size show that small countries such as Kuwait the United Arab Emirates and Lebanon are more productive than Egypt and Saudi Arabiamdashthe largest publishers in the Arab world

20

2003 per 100000 of the population

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

Kuwait UAE

657

262

21

22

Wealth

23

Normalizing by the GDP

Jordan Lebanon

112

103

Per one billion of GDP

24

Together

25

upper-middle lower-upper upper

11

4

32 33

8

38

Number of publications per million population per year

According to Income groups

88-97 98-07

26

Rank of Arab Medical research Institutions

during the period of 1996-2012

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200

Saudi arabia

Tunisia

Lebanon

Jordan

Oman

Iraq

Sudan

Libya

Yemen

Mauritania

Somalia

28

Medical research output from the USA Turkey Israel Iran and Arab nations (1996mdash2012)

Documents Citable

Documents

Citations H index

USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904

Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142

Israel 59894 54409 953440 255

Iran 38147 35492 131537 82

Arab countries 76417 69753 444281 39

29

Documents

1875195

120954 59894 38147 764170

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

2000000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

30

Citable Documents

0

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

31

Citations

32

H index 904

142

255

82 39

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

1 2 3 4 5

33

Pub Med Publications 2001-2005

34

2001-2005

0 The Arab countries also scored less when the data were normalized to

0 Population

0 GDP

35

Published 2009

0 In Lebanon

0 most of the citations originated from the capital city of Beirut mainly the American University of Beirut

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in Lebanon indicate a focus on internal medicine anesthesiology surgery transplantation medical genetics pediatrics obstetrics neoplasms and pain management

37

Published 2009

0 In the UAE

0 most of the biomedical publications originate from Al-Ain University

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in the UAE indicate developed interest in pediatrics obstetrics clinical dysmorphologies transplantation dermatology diabetes and consanguinity

38

Bellagio

0 A meeting was held in Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013 on lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo

0 to discuss how best to use the current opportunities to strengthen research science and innovation for health in the region

40

Partners 0 The Council on Health Research for Development

(COHRED)

0 the World Health Organisation (WHO) Regional-Office for the Eastern Mediterranean

0 and regional institutions such as the Faculty of Health Sciences of the American University of Beirut (AUB)

0 This event is supported by the International Development Research Centre (IDRC) in line with the Global Health Research Initiative (GHRI) the Middle East and North Africa Health Policy Forum and the Rockefeller Foundation

41

Outputs

0A call for action to strengthen system capacity for research and innovation for health

0A communication strategy to disseminate and keep this alive until the regional conference

0A conference plan for 2014

42

Conclusions

0 Visibility Egypt Saudi Arabia

0 Productivity UAE Lebanon Kuwait Jordan hellip

0 Compared to regional countries far away

0 Bibliometric AUB Al Ain U

0 Future more Partners Leaders and supporters are needed to be involved

44

Contribution concerns

In order to contribute more therersquos a need for

0 Center

0 Researcher and scientific writer

0 funding

0 Local issues hypothesis

0 Language

45

Road map

Arab Countries Health Research Group

(ACHRG)

Coordination networking

Specialized Conferences

46

References 0 Amin Bredan Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Editors Visibility

of Arab countries in the world biomedical literature Libyan J Med 2011 6 103402ljmv6i06325 Published online 2011 March 3 doi 103402ljmv6i06325 PMCID PMC3081872

0 Tadmouri GO Bissar-Tadmouri N Biomedical publications in an unstable region the Arab world 1988-2002 Lancet 2003 Nov 22362(9397)1766

0 Shaban SF Abu-Zidan FM A quantitative analysis of medical publications from Arab countries Saudi Med J 2003 Mar24(3)294-6

0 Deleu D Northway MG Hanssens Y Geographical distribution of biomedical publications from the Gulf Corporation Council countries Saudi Med J 2001 Jan22(1)10-2

47

References 0 Waleed M Sweileh Sarsquoed H Zyoud Ansam F Sawalha Adham Abu-Taha

Ayman Hussein and Samah W Al-Jabi Medical and biomedical research productivity from Palestine 2002 ndash 2011 BMC Res Notes 2013 6 41 Published online 2013 February 2 doi 1011861756-0500-6-41 PMCID PMC3566958

0 Afifi M Egyptian biomedical publications in PubMed 1996-2005

0 Bakoush O Al-Tubuly A Ashammakhi N Elkhammas E PubMed Medical publications from Libya Libyan J Med 2007 Sep 12(3)125-8 doi 104176070625

0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Arab nations lagging behind other Middle Eastern countries in biomedical research a comparative study Published online 2009 April 17 doi 1011861471-2288-9-26 BMC Med Res Methodol 2009 9 26 PMCID PMC2674457

48

References 0 Bissar-Tadmouri N Tadmouri GO Bibliometric analyses of

biomedical research outputs in Lebanon and the United Arab Emirates (1988-2007) Saudi Med J 2009 Jan30(1)130-9

0 Bellagio Meeting lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013

0 Mohammed El-Azami-El-Idrissi Mounia Lakhdar-Idrissi Karim Ouldim Wafaa Bono Afaf Amarti-Riffi Moustapha Hida Chakib Nejjari aImproving medical research in the Arab world The Lancet December 21st 2013

0 S A Ismail A McDonald E Dubois F G Aljohani A P Coutts A Majeed and S Rawaf Assessing the state of health research in the Eastern Mediterranean Region J R Soc Med published online 10 May 2013 DOI 101258jrsm2012120240

49

Page 6: Contents · Citations H index USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904 Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142 Israel ... 0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush. Arab nations lagging behind other Middle

AIMS

Reviewing main issues published in the literature regarding health related

research in Arab countries and paving the way forward

7

Methods

0 Internet Search

0Key words research biomedical health related Arab countries

012 publications

8

Issues derived

0 Visibility of the research to the scientific community

0 Productivity of countries when adjusted to the population size and GDP

0 Comparison with other countries

0 Bibliometric analyses

0 Bellagio meeting

9

Output of Arab institutions

during the period of 1996-2012

0 2000 4000 6000 8000 10000 12000 14000 16000 18000

Saudi arabia

Tunisia

Lebanon

Jordan

Oman

Iraq

Sudan

Libya

Yemen

Mauritania

Somalia

11

1988- 2007

12

2003

0 The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia and Egypt had the highest number of publications together accounting for 584 of the Arab countriesrsquo publications

13

Progress number of publications

88-97 98-07

15868

35211

14

Progress contribution

88-97 98-07

038 06

15

1988-2002

0 Arabs produce less than 1 of the biomedical citations in the world despite the available wealth and human resources

16

Is it a matter of population size

or wealth of the country

18

Population size

19

1988-2002

0 MEDLINE results normalized to population size show that small countries such as Kuwait the United Arab Emirates and Lebanon are more productive than Egypt and Saudi Arabiamdashthe largest publishers in the Arab world

20

2003 per 100000 of the population

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

Kuwait UAE

657

262

21

22

Wealth

23

Normalizing by the GDP

Jordan Lebanon

112

103

Per one billion of GDP

24

Together

25

upper-middle lower-upper upper

11

4

32 33

8

38

Number of publications per million population per year

According to Income groups

88-97 98-07

26

Rank of Arab Medical research Institutions

during the period of 1996-2012

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200

Saudi arabia

Tunisia

Lebanon

Jordan

Oman

Iraq

Sudan

Libya

Yemen

Mauritania

Somalia

28

Medical research output from the USA Turkey Israel Iran and Arab nations (1996mdash2012)

Documents Citable

Documents

Citations H index

USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904

Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142

Israel 59894 54409 953440 255

Iran 38147 35492 131537 82

Arab countries 76417 69753 444281 39

29

Documents

1875195

120954 59894 38147 764170

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

2000000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

30

Citable Documents

0

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

31

Citations

32

H index 904

142

255

82 39

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

1 2 3 4 5

33

Pub Med Publications 2001-2005

34

2001-2005

0 The Arab countries also scored less when the data were normalized to

0 Population

0 GDP

35

Published 2009

0 In Lebanon

0 most of the citations originated from the capital city of Beirut mainly the American University of Beirut

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in Lebanon indicate a focus on internal medicine anesthesiology surgery transplantation medical genetics pediatrics obstetrics neoplasms and pain management

37

Published 2009

0 In the UAE

0 most of the biomedical publications originate from Al-Ain University

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in the UAE indicate developed interest in pediatrics obstetrics clinical dysmorphologies transplantation dermatology diabetes and consanguinity

38

Bellagio

0 A meeting was held in Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013 on lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo

0 to discuss how best to use the current opportunities to strengthen research science and innovation for health in the region

40

Partners 0 The Council on Health Research for Development

(COHRED)

0 the World Health Organisation (WHO) Regional-Office for the Eastern Mediterranean

0 and regional institutions such as the Faculty of Health Sciences of the American University of Beirut (AUB)

0 This event is supported by the International Development Research Centre (IDRC) in line with the Global Health Research Initiative (GHRI) the Middle East and North Africa Health Policy Forum and the Rockefeller Foundation

41

Outputs

0A call for action to strengthen system capacity for research and innovation for health

0A communication strategy to disseminate and keep this alive until the regional conference

0A conference plan for 2014

42

Conclusions

0 Visibility Egypt Saudi Arabia

0 Productivity UAE Lebanon Kuwait Jordan hellip

0 Compared to regional countries far away

0 Bibliometric AUB Al Ain U

0 Future more Partners Leaders and supporters are needed to be involved

44

Contribution concerns

In order to contribute more therersquos a need for

0 Center

0 Researcher and scientific writer

0 funding

0 Local issues hypothesis

0 Language

45

Road map

Arab Countries Health Research Group

(ACHRG)

Coordination networking

Specialized Conferences

46

References 0 Amin Bredan Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Editors Visibility

of Arab countries in the world biomedical literature Libyan J Med 2011 6 103402ljmv6i06325 Published online 2011 March 3 doi 103402ljmv6i06325 PMCID PMC3081872

0 Tadmouri GO Bissar-Tadmouri N Biomedical publications in an unstable region the Arab world 1988-2002 Lancet 2003 Nov 22362(9397)1766

0 Shaban SF Abu-Zidan FM A quantitative analysis of medical publications from Arab countries Saudi Med J 2003 Mar24(3)294-6

0 Deleu D Northway MG Hanssens Y Geographical distribution of biomedical publications from the Gulf Corporation Council countries Saudi Med J 2001 Jan22(1)10-2

47

References 0 Waleed M Sweileh Sarsquoed H Zyoud Ansam F Sawalha Adham Abu-Taha

Ayman Hussein and Samah W Al-Jabi Medical and biomedical research productivity from Palestine 2002 ndash 2011 BMC Res Notes 2013 6 41 Published online 2013 February 2 doi 1011861756-0500-6-41 PMCID PMC3566958

0 Afifi M Egyptian biomedical publications in PubMed 1996-2005

0 Bakoush O Al-Tubuly A Ashammakhi N Elkhammas E PubMed Medical publications from Libya Libyan J Med 2007 Sep 12(3)125-8 doi 104176070625

0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Arab nations lagging behind other Middle Eastern countries in biomedical research a comparative study Published online 2009 April 17 doi 1011861471-2288-9-26 BMC Med Res Methodol 2009 9 26 PMCID PMC2674457

48

References 0 Bissar-Tadmouri N Tadmouri GO Bibliometric analyses of

biomedical research outputs in Lebanon and the United Arab Emirates (1988-2007) Saudi Med J 2009 Jan30(1)130-9

0 Bellagio Meeting lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013

0 Mohammed El-Azami-El-Idrissi Mounia Lakhdar-Idrissi Karim Ouldim Wafaa Bono Afaf Amarti-Riffi Moustapha Hida Chakib Nejjari aImproving medical research in the Arab world The Lancet December 21st 2013

0 S A Ismail A McDonald E Dubois F G Aljohani A P Coutts A Majeed and S Rawaf Assessing the state of health research in the Eastern Mediterranean Region J R Soc Med published online 10 May 2013 DOI 101258jrsm2012120240

49

Page 7: Contents · Citations H index USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904 Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142 Israel ... 0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush. Arab nations lagging behind other Middle

Methods

0 Internet Search

0Key words research biomedical health related Arab countries

012 publications

8

Issues derived

0 Visibility of the research to the scientific community

0 Productivity of countries when adjusted to the population size and GDP

0 Comparison with other countries

0 Bibliometric analyses

0 Bellagio meeting

9

Output of Arab institutions

during the period of 1996-2012

0 2000 4000 6000 8000 10000 12000 14000 16000 18000

Saudi arabia

Tunisia

Lebanon

Jordan

Oman

Iraq

Sudan

Libya

Yemen

Mauritania

Somalia

11

1988- 2007

12

2003

0 The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia and Egypt had the highest number of publications together accounting for 584 of the Arab countriesrsquo publications

13

Progress number of publications

88-97 98-07

15868

35211

14

Progress contribution

88-97 98-07

038 06

15

1988-2002

0 Arabs produce less than 1 of the biomedical citations in the world despite the available wealth and human resources

16

Is it a matter of population size

or wealth of the country

18

Population size

19

1988-2002

0 MEDLINE results normalized to population size show that small countries such as Kuwait the United Arab Emirates and Lebanon are more productive than Egypt and Saudi Arabiamdashthe largest publishers in the Arab world

20

2003 per 100000 of the population

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

Kuwait UAE

657

262

21

22

Wealth

23

Normalizing by the GDP

Jordan Lebanon

112

103

Per one billion of GDP

24

Together

25

upper-middle lower-upper upper

11

4

32 33

8

38

Number of publications per million population per year

According to Income groups

88-97 98-07

26

Rank of Arab Medical research Institutions

during the period of 1996-2012

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200

Saudi arabia

Tunisia

Lebanon

Jordan

Oman

Iraq

Sudan

Libya

Yemen

Mauritania

Somalia

28

Medical research output from the USA Turkey Israel Iran and Arab nations (1996mdash2012)

Documents Citable

Documents

Citations H index

USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904

Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142

Israel 59894 54409 953440 255

Iran 38147 35492 131537 82

Arab countries 76417 69753 444281 39

29

Documents

1875195

120954 59894 38147 764170

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

2000000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

30

Citable Documents

0

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

31

Citations

32

H index 904

142

255

82 39

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

1 2 3 4 5

33

Pub Med Publications 2001-2005

34

2001-2005

0 The Arab countries also scored less when the data were normalized to

0 Population

0 GDP

35

Published 2009

0 In Lebanon

0 most of the citations originated from the capital city of Beirut mainly the American University of Beirut

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in Lebanon indicate a focus on internal medicine anesthesiology surgery transplantation medical genetics pediatrics obstetrics neoplasms and pain management

37

Published 2009

0 In the UAE

0 most of the biomedical publications originate from Al-Ain University

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in the UAE indicate developed interest in pediatrics obstetrics clinical dysmorphologies transplantation dermatology diabetes and consanguinity

38

Bellagio

0 A meeting was held in Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013 on lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo

0 to discuss how best to use the current opportunities to strengthen research science and innovation for health in the region

40

Partners 0 The Council on Health Research for Development

(COHRED)

0 the World Health Organisation (WHO) Regional-Office for the Eastern Mediterranean

0 and regional institutions such as the Faculty of Health Sciences of the American University of Beirut (AUB)

0 This event is supported by the International Development Research Centre (IDRC) in line with the Global Health Research Initiative (GHRI) the Middle East and North Africa Health Policy Forum and the Rockefeller Foundation

41

Outputs

0A call for action to strengthen system capacity for research and innovation for health

0A communication strategy to disseminate and keep this alive until the regional conference

0A conference plan for 2014

42

Conclusions

0 Visibility Egypt Saudi Arabia

0 Productivity UAE Lebanon Kuwait Jordan hellip

0 Compared to regional countries far away

0 Bibliometric AUB Al Ain U

0 Future more Partners Leaders and supporters are needed to be involved

44

Contribution concerns

In order to contribute more therersquos a need for

0 Center

0 Researcher and scientific writer

0 funding

0 Local issues hypothesis

0 Language

45

Road map

Arab Countries Health Research Group

(ACHRG)

Coordination networking

Specialized Conferences

46

References 0 Amin Bredan Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Editors Visibility

of Arab countries in the world biomedical literature Libyan J Med 2011 6 103402ljmv6i06325 Published online 2011 March 3 doi 103402ljmv6i06325 PMCID PMC3081872

0 Tadmouri GO Bissar-Tadmouri N Biomedical publications in an unstable region the Arab world 1988-2002 Lancet 2003 Nov 22362(9397)1766

0 Shaban SF Abu-Zidan FM A quantitative analysis of medical publications from Arab countries Saudi Med J 2003 Mar24(3)294-6

0 Deleu D Northway MG Hanssens Y Geographical distribution of biomedical publications from the Gulf Corporation Council countries Saudi Med J 2001 Jan22(1)10-2

47

References 0 Waleed M Sweileh Sarsquoed H Zyoud Ansam F Sawalha Adham Abu-Taha

Ayman Hussein and Samah W Al-Jabi Medical and biomedical research productivity from Palestine 2002 ndash 2011 BMC Res Notes 2013 6 41 Published online 2013 February 2 doi 1011861756-0500-6-41 PMCID PMC3566958

0 Afifi M Egyptian biomedical publications in PubMed 1996-2005

0 Bakoush O Al-Tubuly A Ashammakhi N Elkhammas E PubMed Medical publications from Libya Libyan J Med 2007 Sep 12(3)125-8 doi 104176070625

0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Arab nations lagging behind other Middle Eastern countries in biomedical research a comparative study Published online 2009 April 17 doi 1011861471-2288-9-26 BMC Med Res Methodol 2009 9 26 PMCID PMC2674457

48

References 0 Bissar-Tadmouri N Tadmouri GO Bibliometric analyses of

biomedical research outputs in Lebanon and the United Arab Emirates (1988-2007) Saudi Med J 2009 Jan30(1)130-9

0 Bellagio Meeting lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013

0 Mohammed El-Azami-El-Idrissi Mounia Lakhdar-Idrissi Karim Ouldim Wafaa Bono Afaf Amarti-Riffi Moustapha Hida Chakib Nejjari aImproving medical research in the Arab world The Lancet December 21st 2013

0 S A Ismail A McDonald E Dubois F G Aljohani A P Coutts A Majeed and S Rawaf Assessing the state of health research in the Eastern Mediterranean Region J R Soc Med published online 10 May 2013 DOI 101258jrsm2012120240

49

Page 8: Contents · Citations H index USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904 Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142 Israel ... 0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush. Arab nations lagging behind other Middle

Issues derived

0 Visibility of the research to the scientific community

0 Productivity of countries when adjusted to the population size and GDP

0 Comparison with other countries

0 Bibliometric analyses

0 Bellagio meeting

9

Output of Arab institutions

during the period of 1996-2012

0 2000 4000 6000 8000 10000 12000 14000 16000 18000

Saudi arabia

Tunisia

Lebanon

Jordan

Oman

Iraq

Sudan

Libya

Yemen

Mauritania

Somalia

11

1988- 2007

12

2003

0 The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia and Egypt had the highest number of publications together accounting for 584 of the Arab countriesrsquo publications

13

Progress number of publications

88-97 98-07

15868

35211

14

Progress contribution

88-97 98-07

038 06

15

1988-2002

0 Arabs produce less than 1 of the biomedical citations in the world despite the available wealth and human resources

16

Is it a matter of population size

or wealth of the country

18

Population size

19

1988-2002

0 MEDLINE results normalized to population size show that small countries such as Kuwait the United Arab Emirates and Lebanon are more productive than Egypt and Saudi Arabiamdashthe largest publishers in the Arab world

20

2003 per 100000 of the population

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

Kuwait UAE

657

262

21

22

Wealth

23

Normalizing by the GDP

Jordan Lebanon

112

103

Per one billion of GDP

24

Together

25

upper-middle lower-upper upper

11

4

32 33

8

38

Number of publications per million population per year

According to Income groups

88-97 98-07

26

Rank of Arab Medical research Institutions

during the period of 1996-2012

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200

Saudi arabia

Tunisia

Lebanon

Jordan

Oman

Iraq

Sudan

Libya

Yemen

Mauritania

Somalia

28

Medical research output from the USA Turkey Israel Iran and Arab nations (1996mdash2012)

Documents Citable

Documents

Citations H index

USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904

Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142

Israel 59894 54409 953440 255

Iran 38147 35492 131537 82

Arab countries 76417 69753 444281 39

29

Documents

1875195

120954 59894 38147 764170

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

2000000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

30

Citable Documents

0

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

31

Citations

32

H index 904

142

255

82 39

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

1 2 3 4 5

33

Pub Med Publications 2001-2005

34

2001-2005

0 The Arab countries also scored less when the data were normalized to

0 Population

0 GDP

35

Published 2009

0 In Lebanon

0 most of the citations originated from the capital city of Beirut mainly the American University of Beirut

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in Lebanon indicate a focus on internal medicine anesthesiology surgery transplantation medical genetics pediatrics obstetrics neoplasms and pain management

37

Published 2009

0 In the UAE

0 most of the biomedical publications originate from Al-Ain University

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in the UAE indicate developed interest in pediatrics obstetrics clinical dysmorphologies transplantation dermatology diabetes and consanguinity

38

Bellagio

0 A meeting was held in Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013 on lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo

0 to discuss how best to use the current opportunities to strengthen research science and innovation for health in the region

40

Partners 0 The Council on Health Research for Development

(COHRED)

0 the World Health Organisation (WHO) Regional-Office for the Eastern Mediterranean

0 and regional institutions such as the Faculty of Health Sciences of the American University of Beirut (AUB)

0 This event is supported by the International Development Research Centre (IDRC) in line with the Global Health Research Initiative (GHRI) the Middle East and North Africa Health Policy Forum and the Rockefeller Foundation

41

Outputs

0A call for action to strengthen system capacity for research and innovation for health

0A communication strategy to disseminate and keep this alive until the regional conference

0A conference plan for 2014

42

Conclusions

0 Visibility Egypt Saudi Arabia

0 Productivity UAE Lebanon Kuwait Jordan hellip

0 Compared to regional countries far away

0 Bibliometric AUB Al Ain U

0 Future more Partners Leaders and supporters are needed to be involved

44

Contribution concerns

In order to contribute more therersquos a need for

0 Center

0 Researcher and scientific writer

0 funding

0 Local issues hypothesis

0 Language

45

Road map

Arab Countries Health Research Group

(ACHRG)

Coordination networking

Specialized Conferences

46

References 0 Amin Bredan Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Editors Visibility

of Arab countries in the world biomedical literature Libyan J Med 2011 6 103402ljmv6i06325 Published online 2011 March 3 doi 103402ljmv6i06325 PMCID PMC3081872

0 Tadmouri GO Bissar-Tadmouri N Biomedical publications in an unstable region the Arab world 1988-2002 Lancet 2003 Nov 22362(9397)1766

0 Shaban SF Abu-Zidan FM A quantitative analysis of medical publications from Arab countries Saudi Med J 2003 Mar24(3)294-6

0 Deleu D Northway MG Hanssens Y Geographical distribution of biomedical publications from the Gulf Corporation Council countries Saudi Med J 2001 Jan22(1)10-2

47

References 0 Waleed M Sweileh Sarsquoed H Zyoud Ansam F Sawalha Adham Abu-Taha

Ayman Hussein and Samah W Al-Jabi Medical and biomedical research productivity from Palestine 2002 ndash 2011 BMC Res Notes 2013 6 41 Published online 2013 February 2 doi 1011861756-0500-6-41 PMCID PMC3566958

0 Afifi M Egyptian biomedical publications in PubMed 1996-2005

0 Bakoush O Al-Tubuly A Ashammakhi N Elkhammas E PubMed Medical publications from Libya Libyan J Med 2007 Sep 12(3)125-8 doi 104176070625

0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Arab nations lagging behind other Middle Eastern countries in biomedical research a comparative study Published online 2009 April 17 doi 1011861471-2288-9-26 BMC Med Res Methodol 2009 9 26 PMCID PMC2674457

48

References 0 Bissar-Tadmouri N Tadmouri GO Bibliometric analyses of

biomedical research outputs in Lebanon and the United Arab Emirates (1988-2007) Saudi Med J 2009 Jan30(1)130-9

0 Bellagio Meeting lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013

0 Mohammed El-Azami-El-Idrissi Mounia Lakhdar-Idrissi Karim Ouldim Wafaa Bono Afaf Amarti-Riffi Moustapha Hida Chakib Nejjari aImproving medical research in the Arab world The Lancet December 21st 2013

0 S A Ismail A McDonald E Dubois F G Aljohani A P Coutts A Majeed and S Rawaf Assessing the state of health research in the Eastern Mediterranean Region J R Soc Med published online 10 May 2013 DOI 101258jrsm2012120240

49

Page 9: Contents · Citations H index USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904 Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142 Israel ... 0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush. Arab nations lagging behind other Middle

Output of Arab institutions

during the period of 1996-2012

0 2000 4000 6000 8000 10000 12000 14000 16000 18000

Saudi arabia

Tunisia

Lebanon

Jordan

Oman

Iraq

Sudan

Libya

Yemen

Mauritania

Somalia

11

1988- 2007

12

2003

0 The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia and Egypt had the highest number of publications together accounting for 584 of the Arab countriesrsquo publications

13

Progress number of publications

88-97 98-07

15868

35211

14

Progress contribution

88-97 98-07

038 06

15

1988-2002

0 Arabs produce less than 1 of the biomedical citations in the world despite the available wealth and human resources

16

Is it a matter of population size

or wealth of the country

18

Population size

19

1988-2002

0 MEDLINE results normalized to population size show that small countries such as Kuwait the United Arab Emirates and Lebanon are more productive than Egypt and Saudi Arabiamdashthe largest publishers in the Arab world

20

2003 per 100000 of the population

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

Kuwait UAE

657

262

21

22

Wealth

23

Normalizing by the GDP

Jordan Lebanon

112

103

Per one billion of GDP

24

Together

25

upper-middle lower-upper upper

11

4

32 33

8

38

Number of publications per million population per year

According to Income groups

88-97 98-07

26

Rank of Arab Medical research Institutions

during the period of 1996-2012

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200

Saudi arabia

Tunisia

Lebanon

Jordan

Oman

Iraq

Sudan

Libya

Yemen

Mauritania

Somalia

28

Medical research output from the USA Turkey Israel Iran and Arab nations (1996mdash2012)

Documents Citable

Documents

Citations H index

USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904

Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142

Israel 59894 54409 953440 255

Iran 38147 35492 131537 82

Arab countries 76417 69753 444281 39

29

Documents

1875195

120954 59894 38147 764170

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

2000000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

30

Citable Documents

0

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

31

Citations

32

H index 904

142

255

82 39

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

1 2 3 4 5

33

Pub Med Publications 2001-2005

34

2001-2005

0 The Arab countries also scored less when the data were normalized to

0 Population

0 GDP

35

Published 2009

0 In Lebanon

0 most of the citations originated from the capital city of Beirut mainly the American University of Beirut

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in Lebanon indicate a focus on internal medicine anesthesiology surgery transplantation medical genetics pediatrics obstetrics neoplasms and pain management

37

Published 2009

0 In the UAE

0 most of the biomedical publications originate from Al-Ain University

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in the UAE indicate developed interest in pediatrics obstetrics clinical dysmorphologies transplantation dermatology diabetes and consanguinity

38

Bellagio

0 A meeting was held in Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013 on lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo

0 to discuss how best to use the current opportunities to strengthen research science and innovation for health in the region

40

Partners 0 The Council on Health Research for Development

(COHRED)

0 the World Health Organisation (WHO) Regional-Office for the Eastern Mediterranean

0 and regional institutions such as the Faculty of Health Sciences of the American University of Beirut (AUB)

0 This event is supported by the International Development Research Centre (IDRC) in line with the Global Health Research Initiative (GHRI) the Middle East and North Africa Health Policy Forum and the Rockefeller Foundation

41

Outputs

0A call for action to strengthen system capacity for research and innovation for health

0A communication strategy to disseminate and keep this alive until the regional conference

0A conference plan for 2014

42

Conclusions

0 Visibility Egypt Saudi Arabia

0 Productivity UAE Lebanon Kuwait Jordan hellip

0 Compared to regional countries far away

0 Bibliometric AUB Al Ain U

0 Future more Partners Leaders and supporters are needed to be involved

44

Contribution concerns

In order to contribute more therersquos a need for

0 Center

0 Researcher and scientific writer

0 funding

0 Local issues hypothesis

0 Language

45

Road map

Arab Countries Health Research Group

(ACHRG)

Coordination networking

Specialized Conferences

46

References 0 Amin Bredan Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Editors Visibility

of Arab countries in the world biomedical literature Libyan J Med 2011 6 103402ljmv6i06325 Published online 2011 March 3 doi 103402ljmv6i06325 PMCID PMC3081872

0 Tadmouri GO Bissar-Tadmouri N Biomedical publications in an unstable region the Arab world 1988-2002 Lancet 2003 Nov 22362(9397)1766

0 Shaban SF Abu-Zidan FM A quantitative analysis of medical publications from Arab countries Saudi Med J 2003 Mar24(3)294-6

0 Deleu D Northway MG Hanssens Y Geographical distribution of biomedical publications from the Gulf Corporation Council countries Saudi Med J 2001 Jan22(1)10-2

47

References 0 Waleed M Sweileh Sarsquoed H Zyoud Ansam F Sawalha Adham Abu-Taha

Ayman Hussein and Samah W Al-Jabi Medical and biomedical research productivity from Palestine 2002 ndash 2011 BMC Res Notes 2013 6 41 Published online 2013 February 2 doi 1011861756-0500-6-41 PMCID PMC3566958

0 Afifi M Egyptian biomedical publications in PubMed 1996-2005

0 Bakoush O Al-Tubuly A Ashammakhi N Elkhammas E PubMed Medical publications from Libya Libyan J Med 2007 Sep 12(3)125-8 doi 104176070625

0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Arab nations lagging behind other Middle Eastern countries in biomedical research a comparative study Published online 2009 April 17 doi 1011861471-2288-9-26 BMC Med Res Methodol 2009 9 26 PMCID PMC2674457

48

References 0 Bissar-Tadmouri N Tadmouri GO Bibliometric analyses of

biomedical research outputs in Lebanon and the United Arab Emirates (1988-2007) Saudi Med J 2009 Jan30(1)130-9

0 Bellagio Meeting lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013

0 Mohammed El-Azami-El-Idrissi Mounia Lakhdar-Idrissi Karim Ouldim Wafaa Bono Afaf Amarti-Riffi Moustapha Hida Chakib Nejjari aImproving medical research in the Arab world The Lancet December 21st 2013

0 S A Ismail A McDonald E Dubois F G Aljohani A P Coutts A Majeed and S Rawaf Assessing the state of health research in the Eastern Mediterranean Region J R Soc Med published online 10 May 2013 DOI 101258jrsm2012120240

49

Page 10: Contents · Citations H index USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904 Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142 Israel ... 0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush. Arab nations lagging behind other Middle

1988- 2007

12

2003

0 The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia and Egypt had the highest number of publications together accounting for 584 of the Arab countriesrsquo publications

13

Progress number of publications

88-97 98-07

15868

35211

14

Progress contribution

88-97 98-07

038 06

15

1988-2002

0 Arabs produce less than 1 of the biomedical citations in the world despite the available wealth and human resources

16

Is it a matter of population size

or wealth of the country

18

Population size

19

1988-2002

0 MEDLINE results normalized to population size show that small countries such as Kuwait the United Arab Emirates and Lebanon are more productive than Egypt and Saudi Arabiamdashthe largest publishers in the Arab world

20

2003 per 100000 of the population

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

Kuwait UAE

657

262

21

22

Wealth

23

Normalizing by the GDP

Jordan Lebanon

112

103

Per one billion of GDP

24

Together

25

upper-middle lower-upper upper

11

4

32 33

8

38

Number of publications per million population per year

According to Income groups

88-97 98-07

26

Rank of Arab Medical research Institutions

during the period of 1996-2012

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200

Saudi arabia

Tunisia

Lebanon

Jordan

Oman

Iraq

Sudan

Libya

Yemen

Mauritania

Somalia

28

Medical research output from the USA Turkey Israel Iran and Arab nations (1996mdash2012)

Documents Citable

Documents

Citations H index

USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904

Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142

Israel 59894 54409 953440 255

Iran 38147 35492 131537 82

Arab countries 76417 69753 444281 39

29

Documents

1875195

120954 59894 38147 764170

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

2000000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

30

Citable Documents

0

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

31

Citations

32

H index 904

142

255

82 39

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

1 2 3 4 5

33

Pub Med Publications 2001-2005

34

2001-2005

0 The Arab countries also scored less when the data were normalized to

0 Population

0 GDP

35

Published 2009

0 In Lebanon

0 most of the citations originated from the capital city of Beirut mainly the American University of Beirut

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in Lebanon indicate a focus on internal medicine anesthesiology surgery transplantation medical genetics pediatrics obstetrics neoplasms and pain management

37

Published 2009

0 In the UAE

0 most of the biomedical publications originate from Al-Ain University

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in the UAE indicate developed interest in pediatrics obstetrics clinical dysmorphologies transplantation dermatology diabetes and consanguinity

38

Bellagio

0 A meeting was held in Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013 on lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo

0 to discuss how best to use the current opportunities to strengthen research science and innovation for health in the region

40

Partners 0 The Council on Health Research for Development

(COHRED)

0 the World Health Organisation (WHO) Regional-Office for the Eastern Mediterranean

0 and regional institutions such as the Faculty of Health Sciences of the American University of Beirut (AUB)

0 This event is supported by the International Development Research Centre (IDRC) in line with the Global Health Research Initiative (GHRI) the Middle East and North Africa Health Policy Forum and the Rockefeller Foundation

41

Outputs

0A call for action to strengthen system capacity for research and innovation for health

0A communication strategy to disseminate and keep this alive until the regional conference

0A conference plan for 2014

42

Conclusions

0 Visibility Egypt Saudi Arabia

0 Productivity UAE Lebanon Kuwait Jordan hellip

0 Compared to regional countries far away

0 Bibliometric AUB Al Ain U

0 Future more Partners Leaders and supporters are needed to be involved

44

Contribution concerns

In order to contribute more therersquos a need for

0 Center

0 Researcher and scientific writer

0 funding

0 Local issues hypothesis

0 Language

45

Road map

Arab Countries Health Research Group

(ACHRG)

Coordination networking

Specialized Conferences

46

References 0 Amin Bredan Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Editors Visibility

of Arab countries in the world biomedical literature Libyan J Med 2011 6 103402ljmv6i06325 Published online 2011 March 3 doi 103402ljmv6i06325 PMCID PMC3081872

0 Tadmouri GO Bissar-Tadmouri N Biomedical publications in an unstable region the Arab world 1988-2002 Lancet 2003 Nov 22362(9397)1766

0 Shaban SF Abu-Zidan FM A quantitative analysis of medical publications from Arab countries Saudi Med J 2003 Mar24(3)294-6

0 Deleu D Northway MG Hanssens Y Geographical distribution of biomedical publications from the Gulf Corporation Council countries Saudi Med J 2001 Jan22(1)10-2

47

References 0 Waleed M Sweileh Sarsquoed H Zyoud Ansam F Sawalha Adham Abu-Taha

Ayman Hussein and Samah W Al-Jabi Medical and biomedical research productivity from Palestine 2002 ndash 2011 BMC Res Notes 2013 6 41 Published online 2013 February 2 doi 1011861756-0500-6-41 PMCID PMC3566958

0 Afifi M Egyptian biomedical publications in PubMed 1996-2005

0 Bakoush O Al-Tubuly A Ashammakhi N Elkhammas E PubMed Medical publications from Libya Libyan J Med 2007 Sep 12(3)125-8 doi 104176070625

0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Arab nations lagging behind other Middle Eastern countries in biomedical research a comparative study Published online 2009 April 17 doi 1011861471-2288-9-26 BMC Med Res Methodol 2009 9 26 PMCID PMC2674457

48

References 0 Bissar-Tadmouri N Tadmouri GO Bibliometric analyses of

biomedical research outputs in Lebanon and the United Arab Emirates (1988-2007) Saudi Med J 2009 Jan30(1)130-9

0 Bellagio Meeting lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013

0 Mohammed El-Azami-El-Idrissi Mounia Lakhdar-Idrissi Karim Ouldim Wafaa Bono Afaf Amarti-Riffi Moustapha Hida Chakib Nejjari aImproving medical research in the Arab world The Lancet December 21st 2013

0 S A Ismail A McDonald E Dubois F G Aljohani A P Coutts A Majeed and S Rawaf Assessing the state of health research in the Eastern Mediterranean Region J R Soc Med published online 10 May 2013 DOI 101258jrsm2012120240

49

Page 11: Contents · Citations H index USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904 Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142 Israel ... 0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush. Arab nations lagging behind other Middle

2003

0 The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia and Egypt had the highest number of publications together accounting for 584 of the Arab countriesrsquo publications

13

Progress number of publications

88-97 98-07

15868

35211

14

Progress contribution

88-97 98-07

038 06

15

1988-2002

0 Arabs produce less than 1 of the biomedical citations in the world despite the available wealth and human resources

16

Is it a matter of population size

or wealth of the country

18

Population size

19

1988-2002

0 MEDLINE results normalized to population size show that small countries such as Kuwait the United Arab Emirates and Lebanon are more productive than Egypt and Saudi Arabiamdashthe largest publishers in the Arab world

20

2003 per 100000 of the population

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

Kuwait UAE

657

262

21

22

Wealth

23

Normalizing by the GDP

Jordan Lebanon

112

103

Per one billion of GDP

24

Together

25

upper-middle lower-upper upper

11

4

32 33

8

38

Number of publications per million population per year

According to Income groups

88-97 98-07

26

Rank of Arab Medical research Institutions

during the period of 1996-2012

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200

Saudi arabia

Tunisia

Lebanon

Jordan

Oman

Iraq

Sudan

Libya

Yemen

Mauritania

Somalia

28

Medical research output from the USA Turkey Israel Iran and Arab nations (1996mdash2012)

Documents Citable

Documents

Citations H index

USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904

Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142

Israel 59894 54409 953440 255

Iran 38147 35492 131537 82

Arab countries 76417 69753 444281 39

29

Documents

1875195

120954 59894 38147 764170

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

2000000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

30

Citable Documents

0

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

31

Citations

32

H index 904

142

255

82 39

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

1 2 3 4 5

33

Pub Med Publications 2001-2005

34

2001-2005

0 The Arab countries also scored less when the data were normalized to

0 Population

0 GDP

35

Published 2009

0 In Lebanon

0 most of the citations originated from the capital city of Beirut mainly the American University of Beirut

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in Lebanon indicate a focus on internal medicine anesthesiology surgery transplantation medical genetics pediatrics obstetrics neoplasms and pain management

37

Published 2009

0 In the UAE

0 most of the biomedical publications originate from Al-Ain University

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in the UAE indicate developed interest in pediatrics obstetrics clinical dysmorphologies transplantation dermatology diabetes and consanguinity

38

Bellagio

0 A meeting was held in Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013 on lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo

0 to discuss how best to use the current opportunities to strengthen research science and innovation for health in the region

40

Partners 0 The Council on Health Research for Development

(COHRED)

0 the World Health Organisation (WHO) Regional-Office for the Eastern Mediterranean

0 and regional institutions such as the Faculty of Health Sciences of the American University of Beirut (AUB)

0 This event is supported by the International Development Research Centre (IDRC) in line with the Global Health Research Initiative (GHRI) the Middle East and North Africa Health Policy Forum and the Rockefeller Foundation

41

Outputs

0A call for action to strengthen system capacity for research and innovation for health

0A communication strategy to disseminate and keep this alive until the regional conference

0A conference plan for 2014

42

Conclusions

0 Visibility Egypt Saudi Arabia

0 Productivity UAE Lebanon Kuwait Jordan hellip

0 Compared to regional countries far away

0 Bibliometric AUB Al Ain U

0 Future more Partners Leaders and supporters are needed to be involved

44

Contribution concerns

In order to contribute more therersquos a need for

0 Center

0 Researcher and scientific writer

0 funding

0 Local issues hypothesis

0 Language

45

Road map

Arab Countries Health Research Group

(ACHRG)

Coordination networking

Specialized Conferences

46

References 0 Amin Bredan Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Editors Visibility

of Arab countries in the world biomedical literature Libyan J Med 2011 6 103402ljmv6i06325 Published online 2011 March 3 doi 103402ljmv6i06325 PMCID PMC3081872

0 Tadmouri GO Bissar-Tadmouri N Biomedical publications in an unstable region the Arab world 1988-2002 Lancet 2003 Nov 22362(9397)1766

0 Shaban SF Abu-Zidan FM A quantitative analysis of medical publications from Arab countries Saudi Med J 2003 Mar24(3)294-6

0 Deleu D Northway MG Hanssens Y Geographical distribution of biomedical publications from the Gulf Corporation Council countries Saudi Med J 2001 Jan22(1)10-2

47

References 0 Waleed M Sweileh Sarsquoed H Zyoud Ansam F Sawalha Adham Abu-Taha

Ayman Hussein and Samah W Al-Jabi Medical and biomedical research productivity from Palestine 2002 ndash 2011 BMC Res Notes 2013 6 41 Published online 2013 February 2 doi 1011861756-0500-6-41 PMCID PMC3566958

0 Afifi M Egyptian biomedical publications in PubMed 1996-2005

0 Bakoush O Al-Tubuly A Ashammakhi N Elkhammas E PubMed Medical publications from Libya Libyan J Med 2007 Sep 12(3)125-8 doi 104176070625

0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Arab nations lagging behind other Middle Eastern countries in biomedical research a comparative study Published online 2009 April 17 doi 1011861471-2288-9-26 BMC Med Res Methodol 2009 9 26 PMCID PMC2674457

48

References 0 Bissar-Tadmouri N Tadmouri GO Bibliometric analyses of

biomedical research outputs in Lebanon and the United Arab Emirates (1988-2007) Saudi Med J 2009 Jan30(1)130-9

0 Bellagio Meeting lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013

0 Mohammed El-Azami-El-Idrissi Mounia Lakhdar-Idrissi Karim Ouldim Wafaa Bono Afaf Amarti-Riffi Moustapha Hida Chakib Nejjari aImproving medical research in the Arab world The Lancet December 21st 2013

0 S A Ismail A McDonald E Dubois F G Aljohani A P Coutts A Majeed and S Rawaf Assessing the state of health research in the Eastern Mediterranean Region J R Soc Med published online 10 May 2013 DOI 101258jrsm2012120240

49

Page 12: Contents · Citations H index USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904 Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142 Israel ... 0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush. Arab nations lagging behind other Middle

Progress number of publications

88-97 98-07

15868

35211

14

Progress contribution

88-97 98-07

038 06

15

1988-2002

0 Arabs produce less than 1 of the biomedical citations in the world despite the available wealth and human resources

16

Is it a matter of population size

or wealth of the country

18

Population size

19

1988-2002

0 MEDLINE results normalized to population size show that small countries such as Kuwait the United Arab Emirates and Lebanon are more productive than Egypt and Saudi Arabiamdashthe largest publishers in the Arab world

20

2003 per 100000 of the population

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

Kuwait UAE

657

262

21

22

Wealth

23

Normalizing by the GDP

Jordan Lebanon

112

103

Per one billion of GDP

24

Together

25

upper-middle lower-upper upper

11

4

32 33

8

38

Number of publications per million population per year

According to Income groups

88-97 98-07

26

Rank of Arab Medical research Institutions

during the period of 1996-2012

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200

Saudi arabia

Tunisia

Lebanon

Jordan

Oman

Iraq

Sudan

Libya

Yemen

Mauritania

Somalia

28

Medical research output from the USA Turkey Israel Iran and Arab nations (1996mdash2012)

Documents Citable

Documents

Citations H index

USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904

Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142

Israel 59894 54409 953440 255

Iran 38147 35492 131537 82

Arab countries 76417 69753 444281 39

29

Documents

1875195

120954 59894 38147 764170

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

2000000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

30

Citable Documents

0

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

31

Citations

32

H index 904

142

255

82 39

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

1 2 3 4 5

33

Pub Med Publications 2001-2005

34

2001-2005

0 The Arab countries also scored less when the data were normalized to

0 Population

0 GDP

35

Published 2009

0 In Lebanon

0 most of the citations originated from the capital city of Beirut mainly the American University of Beirut

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in Lebanon indicate a focus on internal medicine anesthesiology surgery transplantation medical genetics pediatrics obstetrics neoplasms and pain management

37

Published 2009

0 In the UAE

0 most of the biomedical publications originate from Al-Ain University

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in the UAE indicate developed interest in pediatrics obstetrics clinical dysmorphologies transplantation dermatology diabetes and consanguinity

38

Bellagio

0 A meeting was held in Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013 on lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo

0 to discuss how best to use the current opportunities to strengthen research science and innovation for health in the region

40

Partners 0 The Council on Health Research for Development

(COHRED)

0 the World Health Organisation (WHO) Regional-Office for the Eastern Mediterranean

0 and regional institutions such as the Faculty of Health Sciences of the American University of Beirut (AUB)

0 This event is supported by the International Development Research Centre (IDRC) in line with the Global Health Research Initiative (GHRI) the Middle East and North Africa Health Policy Forum and the Rockefeller Foundation

41

Outputs

0A call for action to strengthen system capacity for research and innovation for health

0A communication strategy to disseminate and keep this alive until the regional conference

0A conference plan for 2014

42

Conclusions

0 Visibility Egypt Saudi Arabia

0 Productivity UAE Lebanon Kuwait Jordan hellip

0 Compared to regional countries far away

0 Bibliometric AUB Al Ain U

0 Future more Partners Leaders and supporters are needed to be involved

44

Contribution concerns

In order to contribute more therersquos a need for

0 Center

0 Researcher and scientific writer

0 funding

0 Local issues hypothesis

0 Language

45

Road map

Arab Countries Health Research Group

(ACHRG)

Coordination networking

Specialized Conferences

46

References 0 Amin Bredan Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Editors Visibility

of Arab countries in the world biomedical literature Libyan J Med 2011 6 103402ljmv6i06325 Published online 2011 March 3 doi 103402ljmv6i06325 PMCID PMC3081872

0 Tadmouri GO Bissar-Tadmouri N Biomedical publications in an unstable region the Arab world 1988-2002 Lancet 2003 Nov 22362(9397)1766

0 Shaban SF Abu-Zidan FM A quantitative analysis of medical publications from Arab countries Saudi Med J 2003 Mar24(3)294-6

0 Deleu D Northway MG Hanssens Y Geographical distribution of biomedical publications from the Gulf Corporation Council countries Saudi Med J 2001 Jan22(1)10-2

47

References 0 Waleed M Sweileh Sarsquoed H Zyoud Ansam F Sawalha Adham Abu-Taha

Ayman Hussein and Samah W Al-Jabi Medical and biomedical research productivity from Palestine 2002 ndash 2011 BMC Res Notes 2013 6 41 Published online 2013 February 2 doi 1011861756-0500-6-41 PMCID PMC3566958

0 Afifi M Egyptian biomedical publications in PubMed 1996-2005

0 Bakoush O Al-Tubuly A Ashammakhi N Elkhammas E PubMed Medical publications from Libya Libyan J Med 2007 Sep 12(3)125-8 doi 104176070625

0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Arab nations lagging behind other Middle Eastern countries in biomedical research a comparative study Published online 2009 April 17 doi 1011861471-2288-9-26 BMC Med Res Methodol 2009 9 26 PMCID PMC2674457

48

References 0 Bissar-Tadmouri N Tadmouri GO Bibliometric analyses of

biomedical research outputs in Lebanon and the United Arab Emirates (1988-2007) Saudi Med J 2009 Jan30(1)130-9

0 Bellagio Meeting lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013

0 Mohammed El-Azami-El-Idrissi Mounia Lakhdar-Idrissi Karim Ouldim Wafaa Bono Afaf Amarti-Riffi Moustapha Hida Chakib Nejjari aImproving medical research in the Arab world The Lancet December 21st 2013

0 S A Ismail A McDonald E Dubois F G Aljohani A P Coutts A Majeed and S Rawaf Assessing the state of health research in the Eastern Mediterranean Region J R Soc Med published online 10 May 2013 DOI 101258jrsm2012120240

49

Page 13: Contents · Citations H index USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904 Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142 Israel ... 0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush. Arab nations lagging behind other Middle

Progress contribution

88-97 98-07

038 06

15

1988-2002

0 Arabs produce less than 1 of the biomedical citations in the world despite the available wealth and human resources

16

Is it a matter of population size

or wealth of the country

18

Population size

19

1988-2002

0 MEDLINE results normalized to population size show that small countries such as Kuwait the United Arab Emirates and Lebanon are more productive than Egypt and Saudi Arabiamdashthe largest publishers in the Arab world

20

2003 per 100000 of the population

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

Kuwait UAE

657

262

21

22

Wealth

23

Normalizing by the GDP

Jordan Lebanon

112

103

Per one billion of GDP

24

Together

25

upper-middle lower-upper upper

11

4

32 33

8

38

Number of publications per million population per year

According to Income groups

88-97 98-07

26

Rank of Arab Medical research Institutions

during the period of 1996-2012

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200

Saudi arabia

Tunisia

Lebanon

Jordan

Oman

Iraq

Sudan

Libya

Yemen

Mauritania

Somalia

28

Medical research output from the USA Turkey Israel Iran and Arab nations (1996mdash2012)

Documents Citable

Documents

Citations H index

USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904

Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142

Israel 59894 54409 953440 255

Iran 38147 35492 131537 82

Arab countries 76417 69753 444281 39

29

Documents

1875195

120954 59894 38147 764170

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

2000000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

30

Citable Documents

0

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

31

Citations

32

H index 904

142

255

82 39

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

1 2 3 4 5

33

Pub Med Publications 2001-2005

34

2001-2005

0 The Arab countries also scored less when the data were normalized to

0 Population

0 GDP

35

Published 2009

0 In Lebanon

0 most of the citations originated from the capital city of Beirut mainly the American University of Beirut

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in Lebanon indicate a focus on internal medicine anesthesiology surgery transplantation medical genetics pediatrics obstetrics neoplasms and pain management

37

Published 2009

0 In the UAE

0 most of the biomedical publications originate from Al-Ain University

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in the UAE indicate developed interest in pediatrics obstetrics clinical dysmorphologies transplantation dermatology diabetes and consanguinity

38

Bellagio

0 A meeting was held in Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013 on lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo

0 to discuss how best to use the current opportunities to strengthen research science and innovation for health in the region

40

Partners 0 The Council on Health Research for Development

(COHRED)

0 the World Health Organisation (WHO) Regional-Office for the Eastern Mediterranean

0 and regional institutions such as the Faculty of Health Sciences of the American University of Beirut (AUB)

0 This event is supported by the International Development Research Centre (IDRC) in line with the Global Health Research Initiative (GHRI) the Middle East and North Africa Health Policy Forum and the Rockefeller Foundation

41

Outputs

0A call for action to strengthen system capacity for research and innovation for health

0A communication strategy to disseminate and keep this alive until the regional conference

0A conference plan for 2014

42

Conclusions

0 Visibility Egypt Saudi Arabia

0 Productivity UAE Lebanon Kuwait Jordan hellip

0 Compared to regional countries far away

0 Bibliometric AUB Al Ain U

0 Future more Partners Leaders and supporters are needed to be involved

44

Contribution concerns

In order to contribute more therersquos a need for

0 Center

0 Researcher and scientific writer

0 funding

0 Local issues hypothesis

0 Language

45

Road map

Arab Countries Health Research Group

(ACHRG)

Coordination networking

Specialized Conferences

46

References 0 Amin Bredan Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Editors Visibility

of Arab countries in the world biomedical literature Libyan J Med 2011 6 103402ljmv6i06325 Published online 2011 March 3 doi 103402ljmv6i06325 PMCID PMC3081872

0 Tadmouri GO Bissar-Tadmouri N Biomedical publications in an unstable region the Arab world 1988-2002 Lancet 2003 Nov 22362(9397)1766

0 Shaban SF Abu-Zidan FM A quantitative analysis of medical publications from Arab countries Saudi Med J 2003 Mar24(3)294-6

0 Deleu D Northway MG Hanssens Y Geographical distribution of biomedical publications from the Gulf Corporation Council countries Saudi Med J 2001 Jan22(1)10-2

47

References 0 Waleed M Sweileh Sarsquoed H Zyoud Ansam F Sawalha Adham Abu-Taha

Ayman Hussein and Samah W Al-Jabi Medical and biomedical research productivity from Palestine 2002 ndash 2011 BMC Res Notes 2013 6 41 Published online 2013 February 2 doi 1011861756-0500-6-41 PMCID PMC3566958

0 Afifi M Egyptian biomedical publications in PubMed 1996-2005

0 Bakoush O Al-Tubuly A Ashammakhi N Elkhammas E PubMed Medical publications from Libya Libyan J Med 2007 Sep 12(3)125-8 doi 104176070625

0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Arab nations lagging behind other Middle Eastern countries in biomedical research a comparative study Published online 2009 April 17 doi 1011861471-2288-9-26 BMC Med Res Methodol 2009 9 26 PMCID PMC2674457

48

References 0 Bissar-Tadmouri N Tadmouri GO Bibliometric analyses of

biomedical research outputs in Lebanon and the United Arab Emirates (1988-2007) Saudi Med J 2009 Jan30(1)130-9

0 Bellagio Meeting lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013

0 Mohammed El-Azami-El-Idrissi Mounia Lakhdar-Idrissi Karim Ouldim Wafaa Bono Afaf Amarti-Riffi Moustapha Hida Chakib Nejjari aImproving medical research in the Arab world The Lancet December 21st 2013

0 S A Ismail A McDonald E Dubois F G Aljohani A P Coutts A Majeed and S Rawaf Assessing the state of health research in the Eastern Mediterranean Region J R Soc Med published online 10 May 2013 DOI 101258jrsm2012120240

49

Page 14: Contents · Citations H index USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904 Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142 Israel ... 0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush. Arab nations lagging behind other Middle

1988-2002

0 Arabs produce less than 1 of the biomedical citations in the world despite the available wealth and human resources

16

Is it a matter of population size

or wealth of the country

18

Population size

19

1988-2002

0 MEDLINE results normalized to population size show that small countries such as Kuwait the United Arab Emirates and Lebanon are more productive than Egypt and Saudi Arabiamdashthe largest publishers in the Arab world

20

2003 per 100000 of the population

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

Kuwait UAE

657

262

21

22

Wealth

23

Normalizing by the GDP

Jordan Lebanon

112

103

Per one billion of GDP

24

Together

25

upper-middle lower-upper upper

11

4

32 33

8

38

Number of publications per million population per year

According to Income groups

88-97 98-07

26

Rank of Arab Medical research Institutions

during the period of 1996-2012

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200

Saudi arabia

Tunisia

Lebanon

Jordan

Oman

Iraq

Sudan

Libya

Yemen

Mauritania

Somalia

28

Medical research output from the USA Turkey Israel Iran and Arab nations (1996mdash2012)

Documents Citable

Documents

Citations H index

USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904

Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142

Israel 59894 54409 953440 255

Iran 38147 35492 131537 82

Arab countries 76417 69753 444281 39

29

Documents

1875195

120954 59894 38147 764170

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

2000000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

30

Citable Documents

0

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

31

Citations

32

H index 904

142

255

82 39

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

1 2 3 4 5

33

Pub Med Publications 2001-2005

34

2001-2005

0 The Arab countries also scored less when the data were normalized to

0 Population

0 GDP

35

Published 2009

0 In Lebanon

0 most of the citations originated from the capital city of Beirut mainly the American University of Beirut

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in Lebanon indicate a focus on internal medicine anesthesiology surgery transplantation medical genetics pediatrics obstetrics neoplasms and pain management

37

Published 2009

0 In the UAE

0 most of the biomedical publications originate from Al-Ain University

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in the UAE indicate developed interest in pediatrics obstetrics clinical dysmorphologies transplantation dermatology diabetes and consanguinity

38

Bellagio

0 A meeting was held in Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013 on lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo

0 to discuss how best to use the current opportunities to strengthen research science and innovation for health in the region

40

Partners 0 The Council on Health Research for Development

(COHRED)

0 the World Health Organisation (WHO) Regional-Office for the Eastern Mediterranean

0 and regional institutions such as the Faculty of Health Sciences of the American University of Beirut (AUB)

0 This event is supported by the International Development Research Centre (IDRC) in line with the Global Health Research Initiative (GHRI) the Middle East and North Africa Health Policy Forum and the Rockefeller Foundation

41

Outputs

0A call for action to strengthen system capacity for research and innovation for health

0A communication strategy to disseminate and keep this alive until the regional conference

0A conference plan for 2014

42

Conclusions

0 Visibility Egypt Saudi Arabia

0 Productivity UAE Lebanon Kuwait Jordan hellip

0 Compared to regional countries far away

0 Bibliometric AUB Al Ain U

0 Future more Partners Leaders and supporters are needed to be involved

44

Contribution concerns

In order to contribute more therersquos a need for

0 Center

0 Researcher and scientific writer

0 funding

0 Local issues hypothesis

0 Language

45

Road map

Arab Countries Health Research Group

(ACHRG)

Coordination networking

Specialized Conferences

46

References 0 Amin Bredan Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Editors Visibility

of Arab countries in the world biomedical literature Libyan J Med 2011 6 103402ljmv6i06325 Published online 2011 March 3 doi 103402ljmv6i06325 PMCID PMC3081872

0 Tadmouri GO Bissar-Tadmouri N Biomedical publications in an unstable region the Arab world 1988-2002 Lancet 2003 Nov 22362(9397)1766

0 Shaban SF Abu-Zidan FM A quantitative analysis of medical publications from Arab countries Saudi Med J 2003 Mar24(3)294-6

0 Deleu D Northway MG Hanssens Y Geographical distribution of biomedical publications from the Gulf Corporation Council countries Saudi Med J 2001 Jan22(1)10-2

47

References 0 Waleed M Sweileh Sarsquoed H Zyoud Ansam F Sawalha Adham Abu-Taha

Ayman Hussein and Samah W Al-Jabi Medical and biomedical research productivity from Palestine 2002 ndash 2011 BMC Res Notes 2013 6 41 Published online 2013 February 2 doi 1011861756-0500-6-41 PMCID PMC3566958

0 Afifi M Egyptian biomedical publications in PubMed 1996-2005

0 Bakoush O Al-Tubuly A Ashammakhi N Elkhammas E PubMed Medical publications from Libya Libyan J Med 2007 Sep 12(3)125-8 doi 104176070625

0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Arab nations lagging behind other Middle Eastern countries in biomedical research a comparative study Published online 2009 April 17 doi 1011861471-2288-9-26 BMC Med Res Methodol 2009 9 26 PMCID PMC2674457

48

References 0 Bissar-Tadmouri N Tadmouri GO Bibliometric analyses of

biomedical research outputs in Lebanon and the United Arab Emirates (1988-2007) Saudi Med J 2009 Jan30(1)130-9

0 Bellagio Meeting lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013

0 Mohammed El-Azami-El-Idrissi Mounia Lakhdar-Idrissi Karim Ouldim Wafaa Bono Afaf Amarti-Riffi Moustapha Hida Chakib Nejjari aImproving medical research in the Arab world The Lancet December 21st 2013

0 S A Ismail A McDonald E Dubois F G Aljohani A P Coutts A Majeed and S Rawaf Assessing the state of health research in the Eastern Mediterranean Region J R Soc Med published online 10 May 2013 DOI 101258jrsm2012120240

49

Page 15: Contents · Citations H index USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904 Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142 Israel ... 0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush. Arab nations lagging behind other Middle

Is it a matter of population size

or wealth of the country

18

Population size

19

1988-2002

0 MEDLINE results normalized to population size show that small countries such as Kuwait the United Arab Emirates and Lebanon are more productive than Egypt and Saudi Arabiamdashthe largest publishers in the Arab world

20

2003 per 100000 of the population

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

Kuwait UAE

657

262

21

22

Wealth

23

Normalizing by the GDP

Jordan Lebanon

112

103

Per one billion of GDP

24

Together

25

upper-middle lower-upper upper

11

4

32 33

8

38

Number of publications per million population per year

According to Income groups

88-97 98-07

26

Rank of Arab Medical research Institutions

during the period of 1996-2012

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200

Saudi arabia

Tunisia

Lebanon

Jordan

Oman

Iraq

Sudan

Libya

Yemen

Mauritania

Somalia

28

Medical research output from the USA Turkey Israel Iran and Arab nations (1996mdash2012)

Documents Citable

Documents

Citations H index

USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904

Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142

Israel 59894 54409 953440 255

Iran 38147 35492 131537 82

Arab countries 76417 69753 444281 39

29

Documents

1875195

120954 59894 38147 764170

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

2000000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

30

Citable Documents

0

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

31

Citations

32

H index 904

142

255

82 39

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

1 2 3 4 5

33

Pub Med Publications 2001-2005

34

2001-2005

0 The Arab countries also scored less when the data were normalized to

0 Population

0 GDP

35

Published 2009

0 In Lebanon

0 most of the citations originated from the capital city of Beirut mainly the American University of Beirut

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in Lebanon indicate a focus on internal medicine anesthesiology surgery transplantation medical genetics pediatrics obstetrics neoplasms and pain management

37

Published 2009

0 In the UAE

0 most of the biomedical publications originate from Al-Ain University

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in the UAE indicate developed interest in pediatrics obstetrics clinical dysmorphologies transplantation dermatology diabetes and consanguinity

38

Bellagio

0 A meeting was held in Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013 on lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo

0 to discuss how best to use the current opportunities to strengthen research science and innovation for health in the region

40

Partners 0 The Council on Health Research for Development

(COHRED)

0 the World Health Organisation (WHO) Regional-Office for the Eastern Mediterranean

0 and regional institutions such as the Faculty of Health Sciences of the American University of Beirut (AUB)

0 This event is supported by the International Development Research Centre (IDRC) in line with the Global Health Research Initiative (GHRI) the Middle East and North Africa Health Policy Forum and the Rockefeller Foundation

41

Outputs

0A call for action to strengthen system capacity for research and innovation for health

0A communication strategy to disseminate and keep this alive until the regional conference

0A conference plan for 2014

42

Conclusions

0 Visibility Egypt Saudi Arabia

0 Productivity UAE Lebanon Kuwait Jordan hellip

0 Compared to regional countries far away

0 Bibliometric AUB Al Ain U

0 Future more Partners Leaders and supporters are needed to be involved

44

Contribution concerns

In order to contribute more therersquos a need for

0 Center

0 Researcher and scientific writer

0 funding

0 Local issues hypothesis

0 Language

45

Road map

Arab Countries Health Research Group

(ACHRG)

Coordination networking

Specialized Conferences

46

References 0 Amin Bredan Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Editors Visibility

of Arab countries in the world biomedical literature Libyan J Med 2011 6 103402ljmv6i06325 Published online 2011 March 3 doi 103402ljmv6i06325 PMCID PMC3081872

0 Tadmouri GO Bissar-Tadmouri N Biomedical publications in an unstable region the Arab world 1988-2002 Lancet 2003 Nov 22362(9397)1766

0 Shaban SF Abu-Zidan FM A quantitative analysis of medical publications from Arab countries Saudi Med J 2003 Mar24(3)294-6

0 Deleu D Northway MG Hanssens Y Geographical distribution of biomedical publications from the Gulf Corporation Council countries Saudi Med J 2001 Jan22(1)10-2

47

References 0 Waleed M Sweileh Sarsquoed H Zyoud Ansam F Sawalha Adham Abu-Taha

Ayman Hussein and Samah W Al-Jabi Medical and biomedical research productivity from Palestine 2002 ndash 2011 BMC Res Notes 2013 6 41 Published online 2013 February 2 doi 1011861756-0500-6-41 PMCID PMC3566958

0 Afifi M Egyptian biomedical publications in PubMed 1996-2005

0 Bakoush O Al-Tubuly A Ashammakhi N Elkhammas E PubMed Medical publications from Libya Libyan J Med 2007 Sep 12(3)125-8 doi 104176070625

0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Arab nations lagging behind other Middle Eastern countries in biomedical research a comparative study Published online 2009 April 17 doi 1011861471-2288-9-26 BMC Med Res Methodol 2009 9 26 PMCID PMC2674457

48

References 0 Bissar-Tadmouri N Tadmouri GO Bibliometric analyses of

biomedical research outputs in Lebanon and the United Arab Emirates (1988-2007) Saudi Med J 2009 Jan30(1)130-9

0 Bellagio Meeting lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013

0 Mohammed El-Azami-El-Idrissi Mounia Lakhdar-Idrissi Karim Ouldim Wafaa Bono Afaf Amarti-Riffi Moustapha Hida Chakib Nejjari aImproving medical research in the Arab world The Lancet December 21st 2013

0 S A Ismail A McDonald E Dubois F G Aljohani A P Coutts A Majeed and S Rawaf Assessing the state of health research in the Eastern Mediterranean Region J R Soc Med published online 10 May 2013 DOI 101258jrsm2012120240

49

Page 16: Contents · Citations H index USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904 Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142 Israel ... 0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush. Arab nations lagging behind other Middle

Population size

19

1988-2002

0 MEDLINE results normalized to population size show that small countries such as Kuwait the United Arab Emirates and Lebanon are more productive than Egypt and Saudi Arabiamdashthe largest publishers in the Arab world

20

2003 per 100000 of the population

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

Kuwait UAE

657

262

21

22

Wealth

23

Normalizing by the GDP

Jordan Lebanon

112

103

Per one billion of GDP

24

Together

25

upper-middle lower-upper upper

11

4

32 33

8

38

Number of publications per million population per year

According to Income groups

88-97 98-07

26

Rank of Arab Medical research Institutions

during the period of 1996-2012

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200

Saudi arabia

Tunisia

Lebanon

Jordan

Oman

Iraq

Sudan

Libya

Yemen

Mauritania

Somalia

28

Medical research output from the USA Turkey Israel Iran and Arab nations (1996mdash2012)

Documents Citable

Documents

Citations H index

USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904

Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142

Israel 59894 54409 953440 255

Iran 38147 35492 131537 82

Arab countries 76417 69753 444281 39

29

Documents

1875195

120954 59894 38147 764170

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

2000000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

30

Citable Documents

0

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

31

Citations

32

H index 904

142

255

82 39

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

1 2 3 4 5

33

Pub Med Publications 2001-2005

34

2001-2005

0 The Arab countries also scored less when the data were normalized to

0 Population

0 GDP

35

Published 2009

0 In Lebanon

0 most of the citations originated from the capital city of Beirut mainly the American University of Beirut

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in Lebanon indicate a focus on internal medicine anesthesiology surgery transplantation medical genetics pediatrics obstetrics neoplasms and pain management

37

Published 2009

0 In the UAE

0 most of the biomedical publications originate from Al-Ain University

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in the UAE indicate developed interest in pediatrics obstetrics clinical dysmorphologies transplantation dermatology diabetes and consanguinity

38

Bellagio

0 A meeting was held in Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013 on lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo

0 to discuss how best to use the current opportunities to strengthen research science and innovation for health in the region

40

Partners 0 The Council on Health Research for Development

(COHRED)

0 the World Health Organisation (WHO) Regional-Office for the Eastern Mediterranean

0 and regional institutions such as the Faculty of Health Sciences of the American University of Beirut (AUB)

0 This event is supported by the International Development Research Centre (IDRC) in line with the Global Health Research Initiative (GHRI) the Middle East and North Africa Health Policy Forum and the Rockefeller Foundation

41

Outputs

0A call for action to strengthen system capacity for research and innovation for health

0A communication strategy to disseminate and keep this alive until the regional conference

0A conference plan for 2014

42

Conclusions

0 Visibility Egypt Saudi Arabia

0 Productivity UAE Lebanon Kuwait Jordan hellip

0 Compared to regional countries far away

0 Bibliometric AUB Al Ain U

0 Future more Partners Leaders and supporters are needed to be involved

44

Contribution concerns

In order to contribute more therersquos a need for

0 Center

0 Researcher and scientific writer

0 funding

0 Local issues hypothesis

0 Language

45

Road map

Arab Countries Health Research Group

(ACHRG)

Coordination networking

Specialized Conferences

46

References 0 Amin Bredan Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Editors Visibility

of Arab countries in the world biomedical literature Libyan J Med 2011 6 103402ljmv6i06325 Published online 2011 March 3 doi 103402ljmv6i06325 PMCID PMC3081872

0 Tadmouri GO Bissar-Tadmouri N Biomedical publications in an unstable region the Arab world 1988-2002 Lancet 2003 Nov 22362(9397)1766

0 Shaban SF Abu-Zidan FM A quantitative analysis of medical publications from Arab countries Saudi Med J 2003 Mar24(3)294-6

0 Deleu D Northway MG Hanssens Y Geographical distribution of biomedical publications from the Gulf Corporation Council countries Saudi Med J 2001 Jan22(1)10-2

47

References 0 Waleed M Sweileh Sarsquoed H Zyoud Ansam F Sawalha Adham Abu-Taha

Ayman Hussein and Samah W Al-Jabi Medical and biomedical research productivity from Palestine 2002 ndash 2011 BMC Res Notes 2013 6 41 Published online 2013 February 2 doi 1011861756-0500-6-41 PMCID PMC3566958

0 Afifi M Egyptian biomedical publications in PubMed 1996-2005

0 Bakoush O Al-Tubuly A Ashammakhi N Elkhammas E PubMed Medical publications from Libya Libyan J Med 2007 Sep 12(3)125-8 doi 104176070625

0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Arab nations lagging behind other Middle Eastern countries in biomedical research a comparative study Published online 2009 April 17 doi 1011861471-2288-9-26 BMC Med Res Methodol 2009 9 26 PMCID PMC2674457

48

References 0 Bissar-Tadmouri N Tadmouri GO Bibliometric analyses of

biomedical research outputs in Lebanon and the United Arab Emirates (1988-2007) Saudi Med J 2009 Jan30(1)130-9

0 Bellagio Meeting lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013

0 Mohammed El-Azami-El-Idrissi Mounia Lakhdar-Idrissi Karim Ouldim Wafaa Bono Afaf Amarti-Riffi Moustapha Hida Chakib Nejjari aImproving medical research in the Arab world The Lancet December 21st 2013

0 S A Ismail A McDonald E Dubois F G Aljohani A P Coutts A Majeed and S Rawaf Assessing the state of health research in the Eastern Mediterranean Region J R Soc Med published online 10 May 2013 DOI 101258jrsm2012120240

49

Page 17: Contents · Citations H index USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904 Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142 Israel ... 0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush. Arab nations lagging behind other Middle

1988-2002

0 MEDLINE results normalized to population size show that small countries such as Kuwait the United Arab Emirates and Lebanon are more productive than Egypt and Saudi Arabiamdashthe largest publishers in the Arab world

20

2003 per 100000 of the population

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

Kuwait UAE

657

262

21

22

Wealth

23

Normalizing by the GDP

Jordan Lebanon

112

103

Per one billion of GDP

24

Together

25

upper-middle lower-upper upper

11

4

32 33

8

38

Number of publications per million population per year

According to Income groups

88-97 98-07

26

Rank of Arab Medical research Institutions

during the period of 1996-2012

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200

Saudi arabia

Tunisia

Lebanon

Jordan

Oman

Iraq

Sudan

Libya

Yemen

Mauritania

Somalia

28

Medical research output from the USA Turkey Israel Iran and Arab nations (1996mdash2012)

Documents Citable

Documents

Citations H index

USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904

Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142

Israel 59894 54409 953440 255

Iran 38147 35492 131537 82

Arab countries 76417 69753 444281 39

29

Documents

1875195

120954 59894 38147 764170

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

2000000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

30

Citable Documents

0

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

31

Citations

32

H index 904

142

255

82 39

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

1 2 3 4 5

33

Pub Med Publications 2001-2005

34

2001-2005

0 The Arab countries also scored less when the data were normalized to

0 Population

0 GDP

35

Published 2009

0 In Lebanon

0 most of the citations originated from the capital city of Beirut mainly the American University of Beirut

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in Lebanon indicate a focus on internal medicine anesthesiology surgery transplantation medical genetics pediatrics obstetrics neoplasms and pain management

37

Published 2009

0 In the UAE

0 most of the biomedical publications originate from Al-Ain University

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in the UAE indicate developed interest in pediatrics obstetrics clinical dysmorphologies transplantation dermatology diabetes and consanguinity

38

Bellagio

0 A meeting was held in Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013 on lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo

0 to discuss how best to use the current opportunities to strengthen research science and innovation for health in the region

40

Partners 0 The Council on Health Research for Development

(COHRED)

0 the World Health Organisation (WHO) Regional-Office for the Eastern Mediterranean

0 and regional institutions such as the Faculty of Health Sciences of the American University of Beirut (AUB)

0 This event is supported by the International Development Research Centre (IDRC) in line with the Global Health Research Initiative (GHRI) the Middle East and North Africa Health Policy Forum and the Rockefeller Foundation

41

Outputs

0A call for action to strengthen system capacity for research and innovation for health

0A communication strategy to disseminate and keep this alive until the regional conference

0A conference plan for 2014

42

Conclusions

0 Visibility Egypt Saudi Arabia

0 Productivity UAE Lebanon Kuwait Jordan hellip

0 Compared to regional countries far away

0 Bibliometric AUB Al Ain U

0 Future more Partners Leaders and supporters are needed to be involved

44

Contribution concerns

In order to contribute more therersquos a need for

0 Center

0 Researcher and scientific writer

0 funding

0 Local issues hypothesis

0 Language

45

Road map

Arab Countries Health Research Group

(ACHRG)

Coordination networking

Specialized Conferences

46

References 0 Amin Bredan Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Editors Visibility

of Arab countries in the world biomedical literature Libyan J Med 2011 6 103402ljmv6i06325 Published online 2011 March 3 doi 103402ljmv6i06325 PMCID PMC3081872

0 Tadmouri GO Bissar-Tadmouri N Biomedical publications in an unstable region the Arab world 1988-2002 Lancet 2003 Nov 22362(9397)1766

0 Shaban SF Abu-Zidan FM A quantitative analysis of medical publications from Arab countries Saudi Med J 2003 Mar24(3)294-6

0 Deleu D Northway MG Hanssens Y Geographical distribution of biomedical publications from the Gulf Corporation Council countries Saudi Med J 2001 Jan22(1)10-2

47

References 0 Waleed M Sweileh Sarsquoed H Zyoud Ansam F Sawalha Adham Abu-Taha

Ayman Hussein and Samah W Al-Jabi Medical and biomedical research productivity from Palestine 2002 ndash 2011 BMC Res Notes 2013 6 41 Published online 2013 February 2 doi 1011861756-0500-6-41 PMCID PMC3566958

0 Afifi M Egyptian biomedical publications in PubMed 1996-2005

0 Bakoush O Al-Tubuly A Ashammakhi N Elkhammas E PubMed Medical publications from Libya Libyan J Med 2007 Sep 12(3)125-8 doi 104176070625

0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Arab nations lagging behind other Middle Eastern countries in biomedical research a comparative study Published online 2009 April 17 doi 1011861471-2288-9-26 BMC Med Res Methodol 2009 9 26 PMCID PMC2674457

48

References 0 Bissar-Tadmouri N Tadmouri GO Bibliometric analyses of

biomedical research outputs in Lebanon and the United Arab Emirates (1988-2007) Saudi Med J 2009 Jan30(1)130-9

0 Bellagio Meeting lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013

0 Mohammed El-Azami-El-Idrissi Mounia Lakhdar-Idrissi Karim Ouldim Wafaa Bono Afaf Amarti-Riffi Moustapha Hida Chakib Nejjari aImproving medical research in the Arab world The Lancet December 21st 2013

0 S A Ismail A McDonald E Dubois F G Aljohani A P Coutts A Majeed and S Rawaf Assessing the state of health research in the Eastern Mediterranean Region J R Soc Med published online 10 May 2013 DOI 101258jrsm2012120240

49

Page 18: Contents · Citations H index USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904 Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142 Israel ... 0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush. Arab nations lagging behind other Middle

2003 per 100000 of the population

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

Kuwait UAE

657

262

21

22

Wealth

23

Normalizing by the GDP

Jordan Lebanon

112

103

Per one billion of GDP

24

Together

25

upper-middle lower-upper upper

11

4

32 33

8

38

Number of publications per million population per year

According to Income groups

88-97 98-07

26

Rank of Arab Medical research Institutions

during the period of 1996-2012

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200

Saudi arabia

Tunisia

Lebanon

Jordan

Oman

Iraq

Sudan

Libya

Yemen

Mauritania

Somalia

28

Medical research output from the USA Turkey Israel Iran and Arab nations (1996mdash2012)

Documents Citable

Documents

Citations H index

USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904

Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142

Israel 59894 54409 953440 255

Iran 38147 35492 131537 82

Arab countries 76417 69753 444281 39

29

Documents

1875195

120954 59894 38147 764170

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

2000000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

30

Citable Documents

0

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

31

Citations

32

H index 904

142

255

82 39

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

1 2 3 4 5

33

Pub Med Publications 2001-2005

34

2001-2005

0 The Arab countries also scored less when the data were normalized to

0 Population

0 GDP

35

Published 2009

0 In Lebanon

0 most of the citations originated from the capital city of Beirut mainly the American University of Beirut

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in Lebanon indicate a focus on internal medicine anesthesiology surgery transplantation medical genetics pediatrics obstetrics neoplasms and pain management

37

Published 2009

0 In the UAE

0 most of the biomedical publications originate from Al-Ain University

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in the UAE indicate developed interest in pediatrics obstetrics clinical dysmorphologies transplantation dermatology diabetes and consanguinity

38

Bellagio

0 A meeting was held in Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013 on lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo

0 to discuss how best to use the current opportunities to strengthen research science and innovation for health in the region

40

Partners 0 The Council on Health Research for Development

(COHRED)

0 the World Health Organisation (WHO) Regional-Office for the Eastern Mediterranean

0 and regional institutions such as the Faculty of Health Sciences of the American University of Beirut (AUB)

0 This event is supported by the International Development Research Centre (IDRC) in line with the Global Health Research Initiative (GHRI) the Middle East and North Africa Health Policy Forum and the Rockefeller Foundation

41

Outputs

0A call for action to strengthen system capacity for research and innovation for health

0A communication strategy to disseminate and keep this alive until the regional conference

0A conference plan for 2014

42

Conclusions

0 Visibility Egypt Saudi Arabia

0 Productivity UAE Lebanon Kuwait Jordan hellip

0 Compared to regional countries far away

0 Bibliometric AUB Al Ain U

0 Future more Partners Leaders and supporters are needed to be involved

44

Contribution concerns

In order to contribute more therersquos a need for

0 Center

0 Researcher and scientific writer

0 funding

0 Local issues hypothesis

0 Language

45

Road map

Arab Countries Health Research Group

(ACHRG)

Coordination networking

Specialized Conferences

46

References 0 Amin Bredan Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Editors Visibility

of Arab countries in the world biomedical literature Libyan J Med 2011 6 103402ljmv6i06325 Published online 2011 March 3 doi 103402ljmv6i06325 PMCID PMC3081872

0 Tadmouri GO Bissar-Tadmouri N Biomedical publications in an unstable region the Arab world 1988-2002 Lancet 2003 Nov 22362(9397)1766

0 Shaban SF Abu-Zidan FM A quantitative analysis of medical publications from Arab countries Saudi Med J 2003 Mar24(3)294-6

0 Deleu D Northway MG Hanssens Y Geographical distribution of biomedical publications from the Gulf Corporation Council countries Saudi Med J 2001 Jan22(1)10-2

47

References 0 Waleed M Sweileh Sarsquoed H Zyoud Ansam F Sawalha Adham Abu-Taha

Ayman Hussein and Samah W Al-Jabi Medical and biomedical research productivity from Palestine 2002 ndash 2011 BMC Res Notes 2013 6 41 Published online 2013 February 2 doi 1011861756-0500-6-41 PMCID PMC3566958

0 Afifi M Egyptian biomedical publications in PubMed 1996-2005

0 Bakoush O Al-Tubuly A Ashammakhi N Elkhammas E PubMed Medical publications from Libya Libyan J Med 2007 Sep 12(3)125-8 doi 104176070625

0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Arab nations lagging behind other Middle Eastern countries in biomedical research a comparative study Published online 2009 April 17 doi 1011861471-2288-9-26 BMC Med Res Methodol 2009 9 26 PMCID PMC2674457

48

References 0 Bissar-Tadmouri N Tadmouri GO Bibliometric analyses of

biomedical research outputs in Lebanon and the United Arab Emirates (1988-2007) Saudi Med J 2009 Jan30(1)130-9

0 Bellagio Meeting lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013

0 Mohammed El-Azami-El-Idrissi Mounia Lakhdar-Idrissi Karim Ouldim Wafaa Bono Afaf Amarti-Riffi Moustapha Hida Chakib Nejjari aImproving medical research in the Arab world The Lancet December 21st 2013

0 S A Ismail A McDonald E Dubois F G Aljohani A P Coutts A Majeed and S Rawaf Assessing the state of health research in the Eastern Mediterranean Region J R Soc Med published online 10 May 2013 DOI 101258jrsm2012120240

49

Page 19: Contents · Citations H index USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904 Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142 Israel ... 0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush. Arab nations lagging behind other Middle

22

Wealth

23

Normalizing by the GDP

Jordan Lebanon

112

103

Per one billion of GDP

24

Together

25

upper-middle lower-upper upper

11

4

32 33

8

38

Number of publications per million population per year

According to Income groups

88-97 98-07

26

Rank of Arab Medical research Institutions

during the period of 1996-2012

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200

Saudi arabia

Tunisia

Lebanon

Jordan

Oman

Iraq

Sudan

Libya

Yemen

Mauritania

Somalia

28

Medical research output from the USA Turkey Israel Iran and Arab nations (1996mdash2012)

Documents Citable

Documents

Citations H index

USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904

Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142

Israel 59894 54409 953440 255

Iran 38147 35492 131537 82

Arab countries 76417 69753 444281 39

29

Documents

1875195

120954 59894 38147 764170

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

2000000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

30

Citable Documents

0

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

31

Citations

32

H index 904

142

255

82 39

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

1 2 3 4 5

33

Pub Med Publications 2001-2005

34

2001-2005

0 The Arab countries also scored less when the data were normalized to

0 Population

0 GDP

35

Published 2009

0 In Lebanon

0 most of the citations originated from the capital city of Beirut mainly the American University of Beirut

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in Lebanon indicate a focus on internal medicine anesthesiology surgery transplantation medical genetics pediatrics obstetrics neoplasms and pain management

37

Published 2009

0 In the UAE

0 most of the biomedical publications originate from Al-Ain University

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in the UAE indicate developed interest in pediatrics obstetrics clinical dysmorphologies transplantation dermatology diabetes and consanguinity

38

Bellagio

0 A meeting was held in Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013 on lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo

0 to discuss how best to use the current opportunities to strengthen research science and innovation for health in the region

40

Partners 0 The Council on Health Research for Development

(COHRED)

0 the World Health Organisation (WHO) Regional-Office for the Eastern Mediterranean

0 and regional institutions such as the Faculty of Health Sciences of the American University of Beirut (AUB)

0 This event is supported by the International Development Research Centre (IDRC) in line with the Global Health Research Initiative (GHRI) the Middle East and North Africa Health Policy Forum and the Rockefeller Foundation

41

Outputs

0A call for action to strengthen system capacity for research and innovation for health

0A communication strategy to disseminate and keep this alive until the regional conference

0A conference plan for 2014

42

Conclusions

0 Visibility Egypt Saudi Arabia

0 Productivity UAE Lebanon Kuwait Jordan hellip

0 Compared to regional countries far away

0 Bibliometric AUB Al Ain U

0 Future more Partners Leaders and supporters are needed to be involved

44

Contribution concerns

In order to contribute more therersquos a need for

0 Center

0 Researcher and scientific writer

0 funding

0 Local issues hypothesis

0 Language

45

Road map

Arab Countries Health Research Group

(ACHRG)

Coordination networking

Specialized Conferences

46

References 0 Amin Bredan Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Editors Visibility

of Arab countries in the world biomedical literature Libyan J Med 2011 6 103402ljmv6i06325 Published online 2011 March 3 doi 103402ljmv6i06325 PMCID PMC3081872

0 Tadmouri GO Bissar-Tadmouri N Biomedical publications in an unstable region the Arab world 1988-2002 Lancet 2003 Nov 22362(9397)1766

0 Shaban SF Abu-Zidan FM A quantitative analysis of medical publications from Arab countries Saudi Med J 2003 Mar24(3)294-6

0 Deleu D Northway MG Hanssens Y Geographical distribution of biomedical publications from the Gulf Corporation Council countries Saudi Med J 2001 Jan22(1)10-2

47

References 0 Waleed M Sweileh Sarsquoed H Zyoud Ansam F Sawalha Adham Abu-Taha

Ayman Hussein and Samah W Al-Jabi Medical and biomedical research productivity from Palestine 2002 ndash 2011 BMC Res Notes 2013 6 41 Published online 2013 February 2 doi 1011861756-0500-6-41 PMCID PMC3566958

0 Afifi M Egyptian biomedical publications in PubMed 1996-2005

0 Bakoush O Al-Tubuly A Ashammakhi N Elkhammas E PubMed Medical publications from Libya Libyan J Med 2007 Sep 12(3)125-8 doi 104176070625

0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Arab nations lagging behind other Middle Eastern countries in biomedical research a comparative study Published online 2009 April 17 doi 1011861471-2288-9-26 BMC Med Res Methodol 2009 9 26 PMCID PMC2674457

48

References 0 Bissar-Tadmouri N Tadmouri GO Bibliometric analyses of

biomedical research outputs in Lebanon and the United Arab Emirates (1988-2007) Saudi Med J 2009 Jan30(1)130-9

0 Bellagio Meeting lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013

0 Mohammed El-Azami-El-Idrissi Mounia Lakhdar-Idrissi Karim Ouldim Wafaa Bono Afaf Amarti-Riffi Moustapha Hida Chakib Nejjari aImproving medical research in the Arab world The Lancet December 21st 2013

0 S A Ismail A McDonald E Dubois F G Aljohani A P Coutts A Majeed and S Rawaf Assessing the state of health research in the Eastern Mediterranean Region J R Soc Med published online 10 May 2013 DOI 101258jrsm2012120240

49

Page 20: Contents · Citations H index USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904 Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142 Israel ... 0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush. Arab nations lagging behind other Middle

Wealth

23

Normalizing by the GDP

Jordan Lebanon

112

103

Per one billion of GDP

24

Together

25

upper-middle lower-upper upper

11

4

32 33

8

38

Number of publications per million population per year

According to Income groups

88-97 98-07

26

Rank of Arab Medical research Institutions

during the period of 1996-2012

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200

Saudi arabia

Tunisia

Lebanon

Jordan

Oman

Iraq

Sudan

Libya

Yemen

Mauritania

Somalia

28

Medical research output from the USA Turkey Israel Iran and Arab nations (1996mdash2012)

Documents Citable

Documents

Citations H index

USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904

Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142

Israel 59894 54409 953440 255

Iran 38147 35492 131537 82

Arab countries 76417 69753 444281 39

29

Documents

1875195

120954 59894 38147 764170

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

2000000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

30

Citable Documents

0

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

31

Citations

32

H index 904

142

255

82 39

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

1 2 3 4 5

33

Pub Med Publications 2001-2005

34

2001-2005

0 The Arab countries also scored less when the data were normalized to

0 Population

0 GDP

35

Published 2009

0 In Lebanon

0 most of the citations originated from the capital city of Beirut mainly the American University of Beirut

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in Lebanon indicate a focus on internal medicine anesthesiology surgery transplantation medical genetics pediatrics obstetrics neoplasms and pain management

37

Published 2009

0 In the UAE

0 most of the biomedical publications originate from Al-Ain University

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in the UAE indicate developed interest in pediatrics obstetrics clinical dysmorphologies transplantation dermatology diabetes and consanguinity

38

Bellagio

0 A meeting was held in Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013 on lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo

0 to discuss how best to use the current opportunities to strengthen research science and innovation for health in the region

40

Partners 0 The Council on Health Research for Development

(COHRED)

0 the World Health Organisation (WHO) Regional-Office for the Eastern Mediterranean

0 and regional institutions such as the Faculty of Health Sciences of the American University of Beirut (AUB)

0 This event is supported by the International Development Research Centre (IDRC) in line with the Global Health Research Initiative (GHRI) the Middle East and North Africa Health Policy Forum and the Rockefeller Foundation

41

Outputs

0A call for action to strengthen system capacity for research and innovation for health

0A communication strategy to disseminate and keep this alive until the regional conference

0A conference plan for 2014

42

Conclusions

0 Visibility Egypt Saudi Arabia

0 Productivity UAE Lebanon Kuwait Jordan hellip

0 Compared to regional countries far away

0 Bibliometric AUB Al Ain U

0 Future more Partners Leaders and supporters are needed to be involved

44

Contribution concerns

In order to contribute more therersquos a need for

0 Center

0 Researcher and scientific writer

0 funding

0 Local issues hypothesis

0 Language

45

Road map

Arab Countries Health Research Group

(ACHRG)

Coordination networking

Specialized Conferences

46

References 0 Amin Bredan Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Editors Visibility

of Arab countries in the world biomedical literature Libyan J Med 2011 6 103402ljmv6i06325 Published online 2011 March 3 doi 103402ljmv6i06325 PMCID PMC3081872

0 Tadmouri GO Bissar-Tadmouri N Biomedical publications in an unstable region the Arab world 1988-2002 Lancet 2003 Nov 22362(9397)1766

0 Shaban SF Abu-Zidan FM A quantitative analysis of medical publications from Arab countries Saudi Med J 2003 Mar24(3)294-6

0 Deleu D Northway MG Hanssens Y Geographical distribution of biomedical publications from the Gulf Corporation Council countries Saudi Med J 2001 Jan22(1)10-2

47

References 0 Waleed M Sweileh Sarsquoed H Zyoud Ansam F Sawalha Adham Abu-Taha

Ayman Hussein and Samah W Al-Jabi Medical and biomedical research productivity from Palestine 2002 ndash 2011 BMC Res Notes 2013 6 41 Published online 2013 February 2 doi 1011861756-0500-6-41 PMCID PMC3566958

0 Afifi M Egyptian biomedical publications in PubMed 1996-2005

0 Bakoush O Al-Tubuly A Ashammakhi N Elkhammas E PubMed Medical publications from Libya Libyan J Med 2007 Sep 12(3)125-8 doi 104176070625

0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Arab nations lagging behind other Middle Eastern countries in biomedical research a comparative study Published online 2009 April 17 doi 1011861471-2288-9-26 BMC Med Res Methodol 2009 9 26 PMCID PMC2674457

48

References 0 Bissar-Tadmouri N Tadmouri GO Bibliometric analyses of

biomedical research outputs in Lebanon and the United Arab Emirates (1988-2007) Saudi Med J 2009 Jan30(1)130-9

0 Bellagio Meeting lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013

0 Mohammed El-Azami-El-Idrissi Mounia Lakhdar-Idrissi Karim Ouldim Wafaa Bono Afaf Amarti-Riffi Moustapha Hida Chakib Nejjari aImproving medical research in the Arab world The Lancet December 21st 2013

0 S A Ismail A McDonald E Dubois F G Aljohani A P Coutts A Majeed and S Rawaf Assessing the state of health research in the Eastern Mediterranean Region J R Soc Med published online 10 May 2013 DOI 101258jrsm2012120240

49

Page 21: Contents · Citations H index USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904 Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142 Israel ... 0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush. Arab nations lagging behind other Middle

Normalizing by the GDP

Jordan Lebanon

112

103

Per one billion of GDP

24

Together

25

upper-middle lower-upper upper

11

4

32 33

8

38

Number of publications per million population per year

According to Income groups

88-97 98-07

26

Rank of Arab Medical research Institutions

during the period of 1996-2012

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200

Saudi arabia

Tunisia

Lebanon

Jordan

Oman

Iraq

Sudan

Libya

Yemen

Mauritania

Somalia

28

Medical research output from the USA Turkey Israel Iran and Arab nations (1996mdash2012)

Documents Citable

Documents

Citations H index

USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904

Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142

Israel 59894 54409 953440 255

Iran 38147 35492 131537 82

Arab countries 76417 69753 444281 39

29

Documents

1875195

120954 59894 38147 764170

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

2000000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

30

Citable Documents

0

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

31

Citations

32

H index 904

142

255

82 39

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

1 2 3 4 5

33

Pub Med Publications 2001-2005

34

2001-2005

0 The Arab countries also scored less when the data were normalized to

0 Population

0 GDP

35

Published 2009

0 In Lebanon

0 most of the citations originated from the capital city of Beirut mainly the American University of Beirut

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in Lebanon indicate a focus on internal medicine anesthesiology surgery transplantation medical genetics pediatrics obstetrics neoplasms and pain management

37

Published 2009

0 In the UAE

0 most of the biomedical publications originate from Al-Ain University

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in the UAE indicate developed interest in pediatrics obstetrics clinical dysmorphologies transplantation dermatology diabetes and consanguinity

38

Bellagio

0 A meeting was held in Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013 on lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo

0 to discuss how best to use the current opportunities to strengthen research science and innovation for health in the region

40

Partners 0 The Council on Health Research for Development

(COHRED)

0 the World Health Organisation (WHO) Regional-Office for the Eastern Mediterranean

0 and regional institutions such as the Faculty of Health Sciences of the American University of Beirut (AUB)

0 This event is supported by the International Development Research Centre (IDRC) in line with the Global Health Research Initiative (GHRI) the Middle East and North Africa Health Policy Forum and the Rockefeller Foundation

41

Outputs

0A call for action to strengthen system capacity for research and innovation for health

0A communication strategy to disseminate and keep this alive until the regional conference

0A conference plan for 2014

42

Conclusions

0 Visibility Egypt Saudi Arabia

0 Productivity UAE Lebanon Kuwait Jordan hellip

0 Compared to regional countries far away

0 Bibliometric AUB Al Ain U

0 Future more Partners Leaders and supporters are needed to be involved

44

Contribution concerns

In order to contribute more therersquos a need for

0 Center

0 Researcher and scientific writer

0 funding

0 Local issues hypothesis

0 Language

45

Road map

Arab Countries Health Research Group

(ACHRG)

Coordination networking

Specialized Conferences

46

References 0 Amin Bredan Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Editors Visibility

of Arab countries in the world biomedical literature Libyan J Med 2011 6 103402ljmv6i06325 Published online 2011 March 3 doi 103402ljmv6i06325 PMCID PMC3081872

0 Tadmouri GO Bissar-Tadmouri N Biomedical publications in an unstable region the Arab world 1988-2002 Lancet 2003 Nov 22362(9397)1766

0 Shaban SF Abu-Zidan FM A quantitative analysis of medical publications from Arab countries Saudi Med J 2003 Mar24(3)294-6

0 Deleu D Northway MG Hanssens Y Geographical distribution of biomedical publications from the Gulf Corporation Council countries Saudi Med J 2001 Jan22(1)10-2

47

References 0 Waleed M Sweileh Sarsquoed H Zyoud Ansam F Sawalha Adham Abu-Taha

Ayman Hussein and Samah W Al-Jabi Medical and biomedical research productivity from Palestine 2002 ndash 2011 BMC Res Notes 2013 6 41 Published online 2013 February 2 doi 1011861756-0500-6-41 PMCID PMC3566958

0 Afifi M Egyptian biomedical publications in PubMed 1996-2005

0 Bakoush O Al-Tubuly A Ashammakhi N Elkhammas E PubMed Medical publications from Libya Libyan J Med 2007 Sep 12(3)125-8 doi 104176070625

0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Arab nations lagging behind other Middle Eastern countries in biomedical research a comparative study Published online 2009 April 17 doi 1011861471-2288-9-26 BMC Med Res Methodol 2009 9 26 PMCID PMC2674457

48

References 0 Bissar-Tadmouri N Tadmouri GO Bibliometric analyses of

biomedical research outputs in Lebanon and the United Arab Emirates (1988-2007) Saudi Med J 2009 Jan30(1)130-9

0 Bellagio Meeting lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013

0 Mohammed El-Azami-El-Idrissi Mounia Lakhdar-Idrissi Karim Ouldim Wafaa Bono Afaf Amarti-Riffi Moustapha Hida Chakib Nejjari aImproving medical research in the Arab world The Lancet December 21st 2013

0 S A Ismail A McDonald E Dubois F G Aljohani A P Coutts A Majeed and S Rawaf Assessing the state of health research in the Eastern Mediterranean Region J R Soc Med published online 10 May 2013 DOI 101258jrsm2012120240

49

Page 22: Contents · Citations H index USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904 Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142 Israel ... 0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush. Arab nations lagging behind other Middle

Together

25

upper-middle lower-upper upper

11

4

32 33

8

38

Number of publications per million population per year

According to Income groups

88-97 98-07

26

Rank of Arab Medical research Institutions

during the period of 1996-2012

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200

Saudi arabia

Tunisia

Lebanon

Jordan

Oman

Iraq

Sudan

Libya

Yemen

Mauritania

Somalia

28

Medical research output from the USA Turkey Israel Iran and Arab nations (1996mdash2012)

Documents Citable

Documents

Citations H index

USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904

Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142

Israel 59894 54409 953440 255

Iran 38147 35492 131537 82

Arab countries 76417 69753 444281 39

29

Documents

1875195

120954 59894 38147 764170

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

2000000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

30

Citable Documents

0

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

31

Citations

32

H index 904

142

255

82 39

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

1 2 3 4 5

33

Pub Med Publications 2001-2005

34

2001-2005

0 The Arab countries also scored less when the data were normalized to

0 Population

0 GDP

35

Published 2009

0 In Lebanon

0 most of the citations originated from the capital city of Beirut mainly the American University of Beirut

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in Lebanon indicate a focus on internal medicine anesthesiology surgery transplantation medical genetics pediatrics obstetrics neoplasms and pain management

37

Published 2009

0 In the UAE

0 most of the biomedical publications originate from Al-Ain University

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in the UAE indicate developed interest in pediatrics obstetrics clinical dysmorphologies transplantation dermatology diabetes and consanguinity

38

Bellagio

0 A meeting was held in Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013 on lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo

0 to discuss how best to use the current opportunities to strengthen research science and innovation for health in the region

40

Partners 0 The Council on Health Research for Development

(COHRED)

0 the World Health Organisation (WHO) Regional-Office for the Eastern Mediterranean

0 and regional institutions such as the Faculty of Health Sciences of the American University of Beirut (AUB)

0 This event is supported by the International Development Research Centre (IDRC) in line with the Global Health Research Initiative (GHRI) the Middle East and North Africa Health Policy Forum and the Rockefeller Foundation

41

Outputs

0A call for action to strengthen system capacity for research and innovation for health

0A communication strategy to disseminate and keep this alive until the regional conference

0A conference plan for 2014

42

Conclusions

0 Visibility Egypt Saudi Arabia

0 Productivity UAE Lebanon Kuwait Jordan hellip

0 Compared to regional countries far away

0 Bibliometric AUB Al Ain U

0 Future more Partners Leaders and supporters are needed to be involved

44

Contribution concerns

In order to contribute more therersquos a need for

0 Center

0 Researcher and scientific writer

0 funding

0 Local issues hypothesis

0 Language

45

Road map

Arab Countries Health Research Group

(ACHRG)

Coordination networking

Specialized Conferences

46

References 0 Amin Bredan Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Editors Visibility

of Arab countries in the world biomedical literature Libyan J Med 2011 6 103402ljmv6i06325 Published online 2011 March 3 doi 103402ljmv6i06325 PMCID PMC3081872

0 Tadmouri GO Bissar-Tadmouri N Biomedical publications in an unstable region the Arab world 1988-2002 Lancet 2003 Nov 22362(9397)1766

0 Shaban SF Abu-Zidan FM A quantitative analysis of medical publications from Arab countries Saudi Med J 2003 Mar24(3)294-6

0 Deleu D Northway MG Hanssens Y Geographical distribution of biomedical publications from the Gulf Corporation Council countries Saudi Med J 2001 Jan22(1)10-2

47

References 0 Waleed M Sweileh Sarsquoed H Zyoud Ansam F Sawalha Adham Abu-Taha

Ayman Hussein and Samah W Al-Jabi Medical and biomedical research productivity from Palestine 2002 ndash 2011 BMC Res Notes 2013 6 41 Published online 2013 February 2 doi 1011861756-0500-6-41 PMCID PMC3566958

0 Afifi M Egyptian biomedical publications in PubMed 1996-2005

0 Bakoush O Al-Tubuly A Ashammakhi N Elkhammas E PubMed Medical publications from Libya Libyan J Med 2007 Sep 12(3)125-8 doi 104176070625

0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Arab nations lagging behind other Middle Eastern countries in biomedical research a comparative study Published online 2009 April 17 doi 1011861471-2288-9-26 BMC Med Res Methodol 2009 9 26 PMCID PMC2674457

48

References 0 Bissar-Tadmouri N Tadmouri GO Bibliometric analyses of

biomedical research outputs in Lebanon and the United Arab Emirates (1988-2007) Saudi Med J 2009 Jan30(1)130-9

0 Bellagio Meeting lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013

0 Mohammed El-Azami-El-Idrissi Mounia Lakhdar-Idrissi Karim Ouldim Wafaa Bono Afaf Amarti-Riffi Moustapha Hida Chakib Nejjari aImproving medical research in the Arab world The Lancet December 21st 2013

0 S A Ismail A McDonald E Dubois F G Aljohani A P Coutts A Majeed and S Rawaf Assessing the state of health research in the Eastern Mediterranean Region J R Soc Med published online 10 May 2013 DOI 101258jrsm2012120240

49

Page 23: Contents · Citations H index USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904 Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142 Israel ... 0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush. Arab nations lagging behind other Middle

upper-middle lower-upper upper

11

4

32 33

8

38

Number of publications per million population per year

According to Income groups

88-97 98-07

26

Rank of Arab Medical research Institutions

during the period of 1996-2012

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200

Saudi arabia

Tunisia

Lebanon

Jordan

Oman

Iraq

Sudan

Libya

Yemen

Mauritania

Somalia

28

Medical research output from the USA Turkey Israel Iran and Arab nations (1996mdash2012)

Documents Citable

Documents

Citations H index

USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904

Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142

Israel 59894 54409 953440 255

Iran 38147 35492 131537 82

Arab countries 76417 69753 444281 39

29

Documents

1875195

120954 59894 38147 764170

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

2000000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

30

Citable Documents

0

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

31

Citations

32

H index 904

142

255

82 39

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

1 2 3 4 5

33

Pub Med Publications 2001-2005

34

2001-2005

0 The Arab countries also scored less when the data were normalized to

0 Population

0 GDP

35

Published 2009

0 In Lebanon

0 most of the citations originated from the capital city of Beirut mainly the American University of Beirut

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in Lebanon indicate a focus on internal medicine anesthesiology surgery transplantation medical genetics pediatrics obstetrics neoplasms and pain management

37

Published 2009

0 In the UAE

0 most of the biomedical publications originate from Al-Ain University

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in the UAE indicate developed interest in pediatrics obstetrics clinical dysmorphologies transplantation dermatology diabetes and consanguinity

38

Bellagio

0 A meeting was held in Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013 on lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo

0 to discuss how best to use the current opportunities to strengthen research science and innovation for health in the region

40

Partners 0 The Council on Health Research for Development

(COHRED)

0 the World Health Organisation (WHO) Regional-Office for the Eastern Mediterranean

0 and regional institutions such as the Faculty of Health Sciences of the American University of Beirut (AUB)

0 This event is supported by the International Development Research Centre (IDRC) in line with the Global Health Research Initiative (GHRI) the Middle East and North Africa Health Policy Forum and the Rockefeller Foundation

41

Outputs

0A call for action to strengthen system capacity for research and innovation for health

0A communication strategy to disseminate and keep this alive until the regional conference

0A conference plan for 2014

42

Conclusions

0 Visibility Egypt Saudi Arabia

0 Productivity UAE Lebanon Kuwait Jordan hellip

0 Compared to regional countries far away

0 Bibliometric AUB Al Ain U

0 Future more Partners Leaders and supporters are needed to be involved

44

Contribution concerns

In order to contribute more therersquos a need for

0 Center

0 Researcher and scientific writer

0 funding

0 Local issues hypothesis

0 Language

45

Road map

Arab Countries Health Research Group

(ACHRG)

Coordination networking

Specialized Conferences

46

References 0 Amin Bredan Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Editors Visibility

of Arab countries in the world biomedical literature Libyan J Med 2011 6 103402ljmv6i06325 Published online 2011 March 3 doi 103402ljmv6i06325 PMCID PMC3081872

0 Tadmouri GO Bissar-Tadmouri N Biomedical publications in an unstable region the Arab world 1988-2002 Lancet 2003 Nov 22362(9397)1766

0 Shaban SF Abu-Zidan FM A quantitative analysis of medical publications from Arab countries Saudi Med J 2003 Mar24(3)294-6

0 Deleu D Northway MG Hanssens Y Geographical distribution of biomedical publications from the Gulf Corporation Council countries Saudi Med J 2001 Jan22(1)10-2

47

References 0 Waleed M Sweileh Sarsquoed H Zyoud Ansam F Sawalha Adham Abu-Taha

Ayman Hussein and Samah W Al-Jabi Medical and biomedical research productivity from Palestine 2002 ndash 2011 BMC Res Notes 2013 6 41 Published online 2013 February 2 doi 1011861756-0500-6-41 PMCID PMC3566958

0 Afifi M Egyptian biomedical publications in PubMed 1996-2005

0 Bakoush O Al-Tubuly A Ashammakhi N Elkhammas E PubMed Medical publications from Libya Libyan J Med 2007 Sep 12(3)125-8 doi 104176070625

0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Arab nations lagging behind other Middle Eastern countries in biomedical research a comparative study Published online 2009 April 17 doi 1011861471-2288-9-26 BMC Med Res Methodol 2009 9 26 PMCID PMC2674457

48

References 0 Bissar-Tadmouri N Tadmouri GO Bibliometric analyses of

biomedical research outputs in Lebanon and the United Arab Emirates (1988-2007) Saudi Med J 2009 Jan30(1)130-9

0 Bellagio Meeting lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013

0 Mohammed El-Azami-El-Idrissi Mounia Lakhdar-Idrissi Karim Ouldim Wafaa Bono Afaf Amarti-Riffi Moustapha Hida Chakib Nejjari aImproving medical research in the Arab world The Lancet December 21st 2013

0 S A Ismail A McDonald E Dubois F G Aljohani A P Coutts A Majeed and S Rawaf Assessing the state of health research in the Eastern Mediterranean Region J R Soc Med published online 10 May 2013 DOI 101258jrsm2012120240

49

Page 24: Contents · Citations H index USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904 Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142 Israel ... 0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush. Arab nations lagging behind other Middle

Rank of Arab Medical research Institutions

during the period of 1996-2012

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200

Saudi arabia

Tunisia

Lebanon

Jordan

Oman

Iraq

Sudan

Libya

Yemen

Mauritania

Somalia

28

Medical research output from the USA Turkey Israel Iran and Arab nations (1996mdash2012)

Documents Citable

Documents

Citations H index

USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904

Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142

Israel 59894 54409 953440 255

Iran 38147 35492 131537 82

Arab countries 76417 69753 444281 39

29

Documents

1875195

120954 59894 38147 764170

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

2000000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

30

Citable Documents

0

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

31

Citations

32

H index 904

142

255

82 39

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

1 2 3 4 5

33

Pub Med Publications 2001-2005

34

2001-2005

0 The Arab countries also scored less when the data were normalized to

0 Population

0 GDP

35

Published 2009

0 In Lebanon

0 most of the citations originated from the capital city of Beirut mainly the American University of Beirut

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in Lebanon indicate a focus on internal medicine anesthesiology surgery transplantation medical genetics pediatrics obstetrics neoplasms and pain management

37

Published 2009

0 In the UAE

0 most of the biomedical publications originate from Al-Ain University

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in the UAE indicate developed interest in pediatrics obstetrics clinical dysmorphologies transplantation dermatology diabetes and consanguinity

38

Bellagio

0 A meeting was held in Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013 on lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo

0 to discuss how best to use the current opportunities to strengthen research science and innovation for health in the region

40

Partners 0 The Council on Health Research for Development

(COHRED)

0 the World Health Organisation (WHO) Regional-Office for the Eastern Mediterranean

0 and regional institutions such as the Faculty of Health Sciences of the American University of Beirut (AUB)

0 This event is supported by the International Development Research Centre (IDRC) in line with the Global Health Research Initiative (GHRI) the Middle East and North Africa Health Policy Forum and the Rockefeller Foundation

41

Outputs

0A call for action to strengthen system capacity for research and innovation for health

0A communication strategy to disseminate and keep this alive until the regional conference

0A conference plan for 2014

42

Conclusions

0 Visibility Egypt Saudi Arabia

0 Productivity UAE Lebanon Kuwait Jordan hellip

0 Compared to regional countries far away

0 Bibliometric AUB Al Ain U

0 Future more Partners Leaders and supporters are needed to be involved

44

Contribution concerns

In order to contribute more therersquos a need for

0 Center

0 Researcher and scientific writer

0 funding

0 Local issues hypothesis

0 Language

45

Road map

Arab Countries Health Research Group

(ACHRG)

Coordination networking

Specialized Conferences

46

References 0 Amin Bredan Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Editors Visibility

of Arab countries in the world biomedical literature Libyan J Med 2011 6 103402ljmv6i06325 Published online 2011 March 3 doi 103402ljmv6i06325 PMCID PMC3081872

0 Tadmouri GO Bissar-Tadmouri N Biomedical publications in an unstable region the Arab world 1988-2002 Lancet 2003 Nov 22362(9397)1766

0 Shaban SF Abu-Zidan FM A quantitative analysis of medical publications from Arab countries Saudi Med J 2003 Mar24(3)294-6

0 Deleu D Northway MG Hanssens Y Geographical distribution of biomedical publications from the Gulf Corporation Council countries Saudi Med J 2001 Jan22(1)10-2

47

References 0 Waleed M Sweileh Sarsquoed H Zyoud Ansam F Sawalha Adham Abu-Taha

Ayman Hussein and Samah W Al-Jabi Medical and biomedical research productivity from Palestine 2002 ndash 2011 BMC Res Notes 2013 6 41 Published online 2013 February 2 doi 1011861756-0500-6-41 PMCID PMC3566958

0 Afifi M Egyptian biomedical publications in PubMed 1996-2005

0 Bakoush O Al-Tubuly A Ashammakhi N Elkhammas E PubMed Medical publications from Libya Libyan J Med 2007 Sep 12(3)125-8 doi 104176070625

0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Arab nations lagging behind other Middle Eastern countries in biomedical research a comparative study Published online 2009 April 17 doi 1011861471-2288-9-26 BMC Med Res Methodol 2009 9 26 PMCID PMC2674457

48

References 0 Bissar-Tadmouri N Tadmouri GO Bibliometric analyses of

biomedical research outputs in Lebanon and the United Arab Emirates (1988-2007) Saudi Med J 2009 Jan30(1)130-9

0 Bellagio Meeting lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013

0 Mohammed El-Azami-El-Idrissi Mounia Lakhdar-Idrissi Karim Ouldim Wafaa Bono Afaf Amarti-Riffi Moustapha Hida Chakib Nejjari aImproving medical research in the Arab world The Lancet December 21st 2013

0 S A Ismail A McDonald E Dubois F G Aljohani A P Coutts A Majeed and S Rawaf Assessing the state of health research in the Eastern Mediterranean Region J R Soc Med published online 10 May 2013 DOI 101258jrsm2012120240

49

Page 25: Contents · Citations H index USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904 Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142 Israel ... 0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush. Arab nations lagging behind other Middle

Medical research output from the USA Turkey Israel Iran and Arab nations (1996mdash2012)

Documents Citable

Documents

Citations H index

USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904

Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142

Israel 59894 54409 953440 255

Iran 38147 35492 131537 82

Arab countries 76417 69753 444281 39

29

Documents

1875195

120954 59894 38147 764170

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

2000000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

30

Citable Documents

0

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

31

Citations

32

H index 904

142

255

82 39

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

1 2 3 4 5

33

Pub Med Publications 2001-2005

34

2001-2005

0 The Arab countries also scored less when the data were normalized to

0 Population

0 GDP

35

Published 2009

0 In Lebanon

0 most of the citations originated from the capital city of Beirut mainly the American University of Beirut

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in Lebanon indicate a focus on internal medicine anesthesiology surgery transplantation medical genetics pediatrics obstetrics neoplasms and pain management

37

Published 2009

0 In the UAE

0 most of the biomedical publications originate from Al-Ain University

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in the UAE indicate developed interest in pediatrics obstetrics clinical dysmorphologies transplantation dermatology diabetes and consanguinity

38

Bellagio

0 A meeting was held in Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013 on lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo

0 to discuss how best to use the current opportunities to strengthen research science and innovation for health in the region

40

Partners 0 The Council on Health Research for Development

(COHRED)

0 the World Health Organisation (WHO) Regional-Office for the Eastern Mediterranean

0 and regional institutions such as the Faculty of Health Sciences of the American University of Beirut (AUB)

0 This event is supported by the International Development Research Centre (IDRC) in line with the Global Health Research Initiative (GHRI) the Middle East and North Africa Health Policy Forum and the Rockefeller Foundation

41

Outputs

0A call for action to strengthen system capacity for research and innovation for health

0A communication strategy to disseminate and keep this alive until the regional conference

0A conference plan for 2014

42

Conclusions

0 Visibility Egypt Saudi Arabia

0 Productivity UAE Lebanon Kuwait Jordan hellip

0 Compared to regional countries far away

0 Bibliometric AUB Al Ain U

0 Future more Partners Leaders and supporters are needed to be involved

44

Contribution concerns

In order to contribute more therersquos a need for

0 Center

0 Researcher and scientific writer

0 funding

0 Local issues hypothesis

0 Language

45

Road map

Arab Countries Health Research Group

(ACHRG)

Coordination networking

Specialized Conferences

46

References 0 Amin Bredan Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Editors Visibility

of Arab countries in the world biomedical literature Libyan J Med 2011 6 103402ljmv6i06325 Published online 2011 March 3 doi 103402ljmv6i06325 PMCID PMC3081872

0 Tadmouri GO Bissar-Tadmouri N Biomedical publications in an unstable region the Arab world 1988-2002 Lancet 2003 Nov 22362(9397)1766

0 Shaban SF Abu-Zidan FM A quantitative analysis of medical publications from Arab countries Saudi Med J 2003 Mar24(3)294-6

0 Deleu D Northway MG Hanssens Y Geographical distribution of biomedical publications from the Gulf Corporation Council countries Saudi Med J 2001 Jan22(1)10-2

47

References 0 Waleed M Sweileh Sarsquoed H Zyoud Ansam F Sawalha Adham Abu-Taha

Ayman Hussein and Samah W Al-Jabi Medical and biomedical research productivity from Palestine 2002 ndash 2011 BMC Res Notes 2013 6 41 Published online 2013 February 2 doi 1011861756-0500-6-41 PMCID PMC3566958

0 Afifi M Egyptian biomedical publications in PubMed 1996-2005

0 Bakoush O Al-Tubuly A Ashammakhi N Elkhammas E PubMed Medical publications from Libya Libyan J Med 2007 Sep 12(3)125-8 doi 104176070625

0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Arab nations lagging behind other Middle Eastern countries in biomedical research a comparative study Published online 2009 April 17 doi 1011861471-2288-9-26 BMC Med Res Methodol 2009 9 26 PMCID PMC2674457

48

References 0 Bissar-Tadmouri N Tadmouri GO Bibliometric analyses of

biomedical research outputs in Lebanon and the United Arab Emirates (1988-2007) Saudi Med J 2009 Jan30(1)130-9

0 Bellagio Meeting lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013

0 Mohammed El-Azami-El-Idrissi Mounia Lakhdar-Idrissi Karim Ouldim Wafaa Bono Afaf Amarti-Riffi Moustapha Hida Chakib Nejjari aImproving medical research in the Arab world The Lancet December 21st 2013

0 S A Ismail A McDonald E Dubois F G Aljohani A P Coutts A Majeed and S Rawaf Assessing the state of health research in the Eastern Mediterranean Region J R Soc Med published online 10 May 2013 DOI 101258jrsm2012120240

49

Page 26: Contents · Citations H index USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904 Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142 Israel ... 0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush. Arab nations lagging behind other Middle

Documents

1875195

120954 59894 38147 764170

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

2000000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

30

Citable Documents

0

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

31

Citations

32

H index 904

142

255

82 39

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

1 2 3 4 5

33

Pub Med Publications 2001-2005

34

2001-2005

0 The Arab countries also scored less when the data were normalized to

0 Population

0 GDP

35

Published 2009

0 In Lebanon

0 most of the citations originated from the capital city of Beirut mainly the American University of Beirut

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in Lebanon indicate a focus on internal medicine anesthesiology surgery transplantation medical genetics pediatrics obstetrics neoplasms and pain management

37

Published 2009

0 In the UAE

0 most of the biomedical publications originate from Al-Ain University

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in the UAE indicate developed interest in pediatrics obstetrics clinical dysmorphologies transplantation dermatology diabetes and consanguinity

38

Bellagio

0 A meeting was held in Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013 on lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo

0 to discuss how best to use the current opportunities to strengthen research science and innovation for health in the region

40

Partners 0 The Council on Health Research for Development

(COHRED)

0 the World Health Organisation (WHO) Regional-Office for the Eastern Mediterranean

0 and regional institutions such as the Faculty of Health Sciences of the American University of Beirut (AUB)

0 This event is supported by the International Development Research Centre (IDRC) in line with the Global Health Research Initiative (GHRI) the Middle East and North Africa Health Policy Forum and the Rockefeller Foundation

41

Outputs

0A call for action to strengthen system capacity for research and innovation for health

0A communication strategy to disseminate and keep this alive until the regional conference

0A conference plan for 2014

42

Conclusions

0 Visibility Egypt Saudi Arabia

0 Productivity UAE Lebanon Kuwait Jordan hellip

0 Compared to regional countries far away

0 Bibliometric AUB Al Ain U

0 Future more Partners Leaders and supporters are needed to be involved

44

Contribution concerns

In order to contribute more therersquos a need for

0 Center

0 Researcher and scientific writer

0 funding

0 Local issues hypothesis

0 Language

45

Road map

Arab Countries Health Research Group

(ACHRG)

Coordination networking

Specialized Conferences

46

References 0 Amin Bredan Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Editors Visibility

of Arab countries in the world biomedical literature Libyan J Med 2011 6 103402ljmv6i06325 Published online 2011 March 3 doi 103402ljmv6i06325 PMCID PMC3081872

0 Tadmouri GO Bissar-Tadmouri N Biomedical publications in an unstable region the Arab world 1988-2002 Lancet 2003 Nov 22362(9397)1766

0 Shaban SF Abu-Zidan FM A quantitative analysis of medical publications from Arab countries Saudi Med J 2003 Mar24(3)294-6

0 Deleu D Northway MG Hanssens Y Geographical distribution of biomedical publications from the Gulf Corporation Council countries Saudi Med J 2001 Jan22(1)10-2

47

References 0 Waleed M Sweileh Sarsquoed H Zyoud Ansam F Sawalha Adham Abu-Taha

Ayman Hussein and Samah W Al-Jabi Medical and biomedical research productivity from Palestine 2002 ndash 2011 BMC Res Notes 2013 6 41 Published online 2013 February 2 doi 1011861756-0500-6-41 PMCID PMC3566958

0 Afifi M Egyptian biomedical publications in PubMed 1996-2005

0 Bakoush O Al-Tubuly A Ashammakhi N Elkhammas E PubMed Medical publications from Libya Libyan J Med 2007 Sep 12(3)125-8 doi 104176070625

0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Arab nations lagging behind other Middle Eastern countries in biomedical research a comparative study Published online 2009 April 17 doi 1011861471-2288-9-26 BMC Med Res Methodol 2009 9 26 PMCID PMC2674457

48

References 0 Bissar-Tadmouri N Tadmouri GO Bibliometric analyses of

biomedical research outputs in Lebanon and the United Arab Emirates (1988-2007) Saudi Med J 2009 Jan30(1)130-9

0 Bellagio Meeting lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013

0 Mohammed El-Azami-El-Idrissi Mounia Lakhdar-Idrissi Karim Ouldim Wafaa Bono Afaf Amarti-Riffi Moustapha Hida Chakib Nejjari aImproving medical research in the Arab world The Lancet December 21st 2013

0 S A Ismail A McDonald E Dubois F G Aljohani A P Coutts A Majeed and S Rawaf Assessing the state of health research in the Eastern Mediterranean Region J R Soc Med published online 10 May 2013 DOI 101258jrsm2012120240

49

Page 27: Contents · Citations H index USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904 Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142 Israel ... 0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush. Arab nations lagging behind other Middle

Citable Documents

0

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

USA Turkey Israel Iran Arab Countries

31

Citations

32

H index 904

142

255

82 39

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

1 2 3 4 5

33

Pub Med Publications 2001-2005

34

2001-2005

0 The Arab countries also scored less when the data were normalized to

0 Population

0 GDP

35

Published 2009

0 In Lebanon

0 most of the citations originated from the capital city of Beirut mainly the American University of Beirut

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in Lebanon indicate a focus on internal medicine anesthesiology surgery transplantation medical genetics pediatrics obstetrics neoplasms and pain management

37

Published 2009

0 In the UAE

0 most of the biomedical publications originate from Al-Ain University

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in the UAE indicate developed interest in pediatrics obstetrics clinical dysmorphologies transplantation dermatology diabetes and consanguinity

38

Bellagio

0 A meeting was held in Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013 on lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo

0 to discuss how best to use the current opportunities to strengthen research science and innovation for health in the region

40

Partners 0 The Council on Health Research for Development

(COHRED)

0 the World Health Organisation (WHO) Regional-Office for the Eastern Mediterranean

0 and regional institutions such as the Faculty of Health Sciences of the American University of Beirut (AUB)

0 This event is supported by the International Development Research Centre (IDRC) in line with the Global Health Research Initiative (GHRI) the Middle East and North Africa Health Policy Forum and the Rockefeller Foundation

41

Outputs

0A call for action to strengthen system capacity for research and innovation for health

0A communication strategy to disseminate and keep this alive until the regional conference

0A conference plan for 2014

42

Conclusions

0 Visibility Egypt Saudi Arabia

0 Productivity UAE Lebanon Kuwait Jordan hellip

0 Compared to regional countries far away

0 Bibliometric AUB Al Ain U

0 Future more Partners Leaders and supporters are needed to be involved

44

Contribution concerns

In order to contribute more therersquos a need for

0 Center

0 Researcher and scientific writer

0 funding

0 Local issues hypothesis

0 Language

45

Road map

Arab Countries Health Research Group

(ACHRG)

Coordination networking

Specialized Conferences

46

References 0 Amin Bredan Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Editors Visibility

of Arab countries in the world biomedical literature Libyan J Med 2011 6 103402ljmv6i06325 Published online 2011 March 3 doi 103402ljmv6i06325 PMCID PMC3081872

0 Tadmouri GO Bissar-Tadmouri N Biomedical publications in an unstable region the Arab world 1988-2002 Lancet 2003 Nov 22362(9397)1766

0 Shaban SF Abu-Zidan FM A quantitative analysis of medical publications from Arab countries Saudi Med J 2003 Mar24(3)294-6

0 Deleu D Northway MG Hanssens Y Geographical distribution of biomedical publications from the Gulf Corporation Council countries Saudi Med J 2001 Jan22(1)10-2

47

References 0 Waleed M Sweileh Sarsquoed H Zyoud Ansam F Sawalha Adham Abu-Taha

Ayman Hussein and Samah W Al-Jabi Medical and biomedical research productivity from Palestine 2002 ndash 2011 BMC Res Notes 2013 6 41 Published online 2013 February 2 doi 1011861756-0500-6-41 PMCID PMC3566958

0 Afifi M Egyptian biomedical publications in PubMed 1996-2005

0 Bakoush O Al-Tubuly A Ashammakhi N Elkhammas E PubMed Medical publications from Libya Libyan J Med 2007 Sep 12(3)125-8 doi 104176070625

0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Arab nations lagging behind other Middle Eastern countries in biomedical research a comparative study Published online 2009 April 17 doi 1011861471-2288-9-26 BMC Med Res Methodol 2009 9 26 PMCID PMC2674457

48

References 0 Bissar-Tadmouri N Tadmouri GO Bibliometric analyses of

biomedical research outputs in Lebanon and the United Arab Emirates (1988-2007) Saudi Med J 2009 Jan30(1)130-9

0 Bellagio Meeting lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013

0 Mohammed El-Azami-El-Idrissi Mounia Lakhdar-Idrissi Karim Ouldim Wafaa Bono Afaf Amarti-Riffi Moustapha Hida Chakib Nejjari aImproving medical research in the Arab world The Lancet December 21st 2013

0 S A Ismail A McDonald E Dubois F G Aljohani A P Coutts A Majeed and S Rawaf Assessing the state of health research in the Eastern Mediterranean Region J R Soc Med published online 10 May 2013 DOI 101258jrsm2012120240

49

Page 28: Contents · Citations H index USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904 Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142 Israel ... 0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush. Arab nations lagging behind other Middle

Citations

32

H index 904

142

255

82 39

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

1 2 3 4 5

33

Pub Med Publications 2001-2005

34

2001-2005

0 The Arab countries also scored less when the data were normalized to

0 Population

0 GDP

35

Published 2009

0 In Lebanon

0 most of the citations originated from the capital city of Beirut mainly the American University of Beirut

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in Lebanon indicate a focus on internal medicine anesthesiology surgery transplantation medical genetics pediatrics obstetrics neoplasms and pain management

37

Published 2009

0 In the UAE

0 most of the biomedical publications originate from Al-Ain University

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in the UAE indicate developed interest in pediatrics obstetrics clinical dysmorphologies transplantation dermatology diabetes and consanguinity

38

Bellagio

0 A meeting was held in Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013 on lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo

0 to discuss how best to use the current opportunities to strengthen research science and innovation for health in the region

40

Partners 0 The Council on Health Research for Development

(COHRED)

0 the World Health Organisation (WHO) Regional-Office for the Eastern Mediterranean

0 and regional institutions such as the Faculty of Health Sciences of the American University of Beirut (AUB)

0 This event is supported by the International Development Research Centre (IDRC) in line with the Global Health Research Initiative (GHRI) the Middle East and North Africa Health Policy Forum and the Rockefeller Foundation

41

Outputs

0A call for action to strengthen system capacity for research and innovation for health

0A communication strategy to disseminate and keep this alive until the regional conference

0A conference plan for 2014

42

Conclusions

0 Visibility Egypt Saudi Arabia

0 Productivity UAE Lebanon Kuwait Jordan hellip

0 Compared to regional countries far away

0 Bibliometric AUB Al Ain U

0 Future more Partners Leaders and supporters are needed to be involved

44

Contribution concerns

In order to contribute more therersquos a need for

0 Center

0 Researcher and scientific writer

0 funding

0 Local issues hypothesis

0 Language

45

Road map

Arab Countries Health Research Group

(ACHRG)

Coordination networking

Specialized Conferences

46

References 0 Amin Bredan Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Editors Visibility

of Arab countries in the world biomedical literature Libyan J Med 2011 6 103402ljmv6i06325 Published online 2011 March 3 doi 103402ljmv6i06325 PMCID PMC3081872

0 Tadmouri GO Bissar-Tadmouri N Biomedical publications in an unstable region the Arab world 1988-2002 Lancet 2003 Nov 22362(9397)1766

0 Shaban SF Abu-Zidan FM A quantitative analysis of medical publications from Arab countries Saudi Med J 2003 Mar24(3)294-6

0 Deleu D Northway MG Hanssens Y Geographical distribution of biomedical publications from the Gulf Corporation Council countries Saudi Med J 2001 Jan22(1)10-2

47

References 0 Waleed M Sweileh Sarsquoed H Zyoud Ansam F Sawalha Adham Abu-Taha

Ayman Hussein and Samah W Al-Jabi Medical and biomedical research productivity from Palestine 2002 ndash 2011 BMC Res Notes 2013 6 41 Published online 2013 February 2 doi 1011861756-0500-6-41 PMCID PMC3566958

0 Afifi M Egyptian biomedical publications in PubMed 1996-2005

0 Bakoush O Al-Tubuly A Ashammakhi N Elkhammas E PubMed Medical publications from Libya Libyan J Med 2007 Sep 12(3)125-8 doi 104176070625

0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Arab nations lagging behind other Middle Eastern countries in biomedical research a comparative study Published online 2009 April 17 doi 1011861471-2288-9-26 BMC Med Res Methodol 2009 9 26 PMCID PMC2674457

48

References 0 Bissar-Tadmouri N Tadmouri GO Bibliometric analyses of

biomedical research outputs in Lebanon and the United Arab Emirates (1988-2007) Saudi Med J 2009 Jan30(1)130-9

0 Bellagio Meeting lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013

0 Mohammed El-Azami-El-Idrissi Mounia Lakhdar-Idrissi Karim Ouldim Wafaa Bono Afaf Amarti-Riffi Moustapha Hida Chakib Nejjari aImproving medical research in the Arab world The Lancet December 21st 2013

0 S A Ismail A McDonald E Dubois F G Aljohani A P Coutts A Majeed and S Rawaf Assessing the state of health research in the Eastern Mediterranean Region J R Soc Med published online 10 May 2013 DOI 101258jrsm2012120240

49

Page 29: Contents · Citations H index USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904 Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142 Israel ... 0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush. Arab nations lagging behind other Middle

H index 904

142

255

82 39

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

1 2 3 4 5

33

Pub Med Publications 2001-2005

34

2001-2005

0 The Arab countries also scored less when the data were normalized to

0 Population

0 GDP

35

Published 2009

0 In Lebanon

0 most of the citations originated from the capital city of Beirut mainly the American University of Beirut

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in Lebanon indicate a focus on internal medicine anesthesiology surgery transplantation medical genetics pediatrics obstetrics neoplasms and pain management

37

Published 2009

0 In the UAE

0 most of the biomedical publications originate from Al-Ain University

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in the UAE indicate developed interest in pediatrics obstetrics clinical dysmorphologies transplantation dermatology diabetes and consanguinity

38

Bellagio

0 A meeting was held in Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013 on lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo

0 to discuss how best to use the current opportunities to strengthen research science and innovation for health in the region

40

Partners 0 The Council on Health Research for Development

(COHRED)

0 the World Health Organisation (WHO) Regional-Office for the Eastern Mediterranean

0 and regional institutions such as the Faculty of Health Sciences of the American University of Beirut (AUB)

0 This event is supported by the International Development Research Centre (IDRC) in line with the Global Health Research Initiative (GHRI) the Middle East and North Africa Health Policy Forum and the Rockefeller Foundation

41

Outputs

0A call for action to strengthen system capacity for research and innovation for health

0A communication strategy to disseminate and keep this alive until the regional conference

0A conference plan for 2014

42

Conclusions

0 Visibility Egypt Saudi Arabia

0 Productivity UAE Lebanon Kuwait Jordan hellip

0 Compared to regional countries far away

0 Bibliometric AUB Al Ain U

0 Future more Partners Leaders and supporters are needed to be involved

44

Contribution concerns

In order to contribute more therersquos a need for

0 Center

0 Researcher and scientific writer

0 funding

0 Local issues hypothesis

0 Language

45

Road map

Arab Countries Health Research Group

(ACHRG)

Coordination networking

Specialized Conferences

46

References 0 Amin Bredan Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Editors Visibility

of Arab countries in the world biomedical literature Libyan J Med 2011 6 103402ljmv6i06325 Published online 2011 March 3 doi 103402ljmv6i06325 PMCID PMC3081872

0 Tadmouri GO Bissar-Tadmouri N Biomedical publications in an unstable region the Arab world 1988-2002 Lancet 2003 Nov 22362(9397)1766

0 Shaban SF Abu-Zidan FM A quantitative analysis of medical publications from Arab countries Saudi Med J 2003 Mar24(3)294-6

0 Deleu D Northway MG Hanssens Y Geographical distribution of biomedical publications from the Gulf Corporation Council countries Saudi Med J 2001 Jan22(1)10-2

47

References 0 Waleed M Sweileh Sarsquoed H Zyoud Ansam F Sawalha Adham Abu-Taha

Ayman Hussein and Samah W Al-Jabi Medical and biomedical research productivity from Palestine 2002 ndash 2011 BMC Res Notes 2013 6 41 Published online 2013 February 2 doi 1011861756-0500-6-41 PMCID PMC3566958

0 Afifi M Egyptian biomedical publications in PubMed 1996-2005

0 Bakoush O Al-Tubuly A Ashammakhi N Elkhammas E PubMed Medical publications from Libya Libyan J Med 2007 Sep 12(3)125-8 doi 104176070625

0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Arab nations lagging behind other Middle Eastern countries in biomedical research a comparative study Published online 2009 April 17 doi 1011861471-2288-9-26 BMC Med Res Methodol 2009 9 26 PMCID PMC2674457

48

References 0 Bissar-Tadmouri N Tadmouri GO Bibliometric analyses of

biomedical research outputs in Lebanon and the United Arab Emirates (1988-2007) Saudi Med J 2009 Jan30(1)130-9

0 Bellagio Meeting lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013

0 Mohammed El-Azami-El-Idrissi Mounia Lakhdar-Idrissi Karim Ouldim Wafaa Bono Afaf Amarti-Riffi Moustapha Hida Chakib Nejjari aImproving medical research in the Arab world The Lancet December 21st 2013

0 S A Ismail A McDonald E Dubois F G Aljohani A P Coutts A Majeed and S Rawaf Assessing the state of health research in the Eastern Mediterranean Region J R Soc Med published online 10 May 2013 DOI 101258jrsm2012120240

49

Page 30: Contents · Citations H index USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904 Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142 Israel ... 0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush. Arab nations lagging behind other Middle

Pub Med Publications 2001-2005

34

2001-2005

0 The Arab countries also scored less when the data were normalized to

0 Population

0 GDP

35

Published 2009

0 In Lebanon

0 most of the citations originated from the capital city of Beirut mainly the American University of Beirut

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in Lebanon indicate a focus on internal medicine anesthesiology surgery transplantation medical genetics pediatrics obstetrics neoplasms and pain management

37

Published 2009

0 In the UAE

0 most of the biomedical publications originate from Al-Ain University

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in the UAE indicate developed interest in pediatrics obstetrics clinical dysmorphologies transplantation dermatology diabetes and consanguinity

38

Bellagio

0 A meeting was held in Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013 on lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo

0 to discuss how best to use the current opportunities to strengthen research science and innovation for health in the region

40

Partners 0 The Council on Health Research for Development

(COHRED)

0 the World Health Organisation (WHO) Regional-Office for the Eastern Mediterranean

0 and regional institutions such as the Faculty of Health Sciences of the American University of Beirut (AUB)

0 This event is supported by the International Development Research Centre (IDRC) in line with the Global Health Research Initiative (GHRI) the Middle East and North Africa Health Policy Forum and the Rockefeller Foundation

41

Outputs

0A call for action to strengthen system capacity for research and innovation for health

0A communication strategy to disseminate and keep this alive until the regional conference

0A conference plan for 2014

42

Conclusions

0 Visibility Egypt Saudi Arabia

0 Productivity UAE Lebanon Kuwait Jordan hellip

0 Compared to regional countries far away

0 Bibliometric AUB Al Ain U

0 Future more Partners Leaders and supporters are needed to be involved

44

Contribution concerns

In order to contribute more therersquos a need for

0 Center

0 Researcher and scientific writer

0 funding

0 Local issues hypothesis

0 Language

45

Road map

Arab Countries Health Research Group

(ACHRG)

Coordination networking

Specialized Conferences

46

References 0 Amin Bredan Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Editors Visibility

of Arab countries in the world biomedical literature Libyan J Med 2011 6 103402ljmv6i06325 Published online 2011 March 3 doi 103402ljmv6i06325 PMCID PMC3081872

0 Tadmouri GO Bissar-Tadmouri N Biomedical publications in an unstable region the Arab world 1988-2002 Lancet 2003 Nov 22362(9397)1766

0 Shaban SF Abu-Zidan FM A quantitative analysis of medical publications from Arab countries Saudi Med J 2003 Mar24(3)294-6

0 Deleu D Northway MG Hanssens Y Geographical distribution of biomedical publications from the Gulf Corporation Council countries Saudi Med J 2001 Jan22(1)10-2

47

References 0 Waleed M Sweileh Sarsquoed H Zyoud Ansam F Sawalha Adham Abu-Taha

Ayman Hussein and Samah W Al-Jabi Medical and biomedical research productivity from Palestine 2002 ndash 2011 BMC Res Notes 2013 6 41 Published online 2013 February 2 doi 1011861756-0500-6-41 PMCID PMC3566958

0 Afifi M Egyptian biomedical publications in PubMed 1996-2005

0 Bakoush O Al-Tubuly A Ashammakhi N Elkhammas E PubMed Medical publications from Libya Libyan J Med 2007 Sep 12(3)125-8 doi 104176070625

0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Arab nations lagging behind other Middle Eastern countries in biomedical research a comparative study Published online 2009 April 17 doi 1011861471-2288-9-26 BMC Med Res Methodol 2009 9 26 PMCID PMC2674457

48

References 0 Bissar-Tadmouri N Tadmouri GO Bibliometric analyses of

biomedical research outputs in Lebanon and the United Arab Emirates (1988-2007) Saudi Med J 2009 Jan30(1)130-9

0 Bellagio Meeting lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013

0 Mohammed El-Azami-El-Idrissi Mounia Lakhdar-Idrissi Karim Ouldim Wafaa Bono Afaf Amarti-Riffi Moustapha Hida Chakib Nejjari aImproving medical research in the Arab world The Lancet December 21st 2013

0 S A Ismail A McDonald E Dubois F G Aljohani A P Coutts A Majeed and S Rawaf Assessing the state of health research in the Eastern Mediterranean Region J R Soc Med published online 10 May 2013 DOI 101258jrsm2012120240

49

Page 31: Contents · Citations H index USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904 Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142 Israel ... 0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush. Arab nations lagging behind other Middle

2001-2005

0 The Arab countries also scored less when the data were normalized to

0 Population

0 GDP

35

Published 2009

0 In Lebanon

0 most of the citations originated from the capital city of Beirut mainly the American University of Beirut

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in Lebanon indicate a focus on internal medicine anesthesiology surgery transplantation medical genetics pediatrics obstetrics neoplasms and pain management

37

Published 2009

0 In the UAE

0 most of the biomedical publications originate from Al-Ain University

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in the UAE indicate developed interest in pediatrics obstetrics clinical dysmorphologies transplantation dermatology diabetes and consanguinity

38

Bellagio

0 A meeting was held in Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013 on lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo

0 to discuss how best to use the current opportunities to strengthen research science and innovation for health in the region

40

Partners 0 The Council on Health Research for Development

(COHRED)

0 the World Health Organisation (WHO) Regional-Office for the Eastern Mediterranean

0 and regional institutions such as the Faculty of Health Sciences of the American University of Beirut (AUB)

0 This event is supported by the International Development Research Centre (IDRC) in line with the Global Health Research Initiative (GHRI) the Middle East and North Africa Health Policy Forum and the Rockefeller Foundation

41

Outputs

0A call for action to strengthen system capacity for research and innovation for health

0A communication strategy to disseminate and keep this alive until the regional conference

0A conference plan for 2014

42

Conclusions

0 Visibility Egypt Saudi Arabia

0 Productivity UAE Lebanon Kuwait Jordan hellip

0 Compared to regional countries far away

0 Bibliometric AUB Al Ain U

0 Future more Partners Leaders and supporters are needed to be involved

44

Contribution concerns

In order to contribute more therersquos a need for

0 Center

0 Researcher and scientific writer

0 funding

0 Local issues hypothesis

0 Language

45

Road map

Arab Countries Health Research Group

(ACHRG)

Coordination networking

Specialized Conferences

46

References 0 Amin Bredan Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Editors Visibility

of Arab countries in the world biomedical literature Libyan J Med 2011 6 103402ljmv6i06325 Published online 2011 March 3 doi 103402ljmv6i06325 PMCID PMC3081872

0 Tadmouri GO Bissar-Tadmouri N Biomedical publications in an unstable region the Arab world 1988-2002 Lancet 2003 Nov 22362(9397)1766

0 Shaban SF Abu-Zidan FM A quantitative analysis of medical publications from Arab countries Saudi Med J 2003 Mar24(3)294-6

0 Deleu D Northway MG Hanssens Y Geographical distribution of biomedical publications from the Gulf Corporation Council countries Saudi Med J 2001 Jan22(1)10-2

47

References 0 Waleed M Sweileh Sarsquoed H Zyoud Ansam F Sawalha Adham Abu-Taha

Ayman Hussein and Samah W Al-Jabi Medical and biomedical research productivity from Palestine 2002 ndash 2011 BMC Res Notes 2013 6 41 Published online 2013 February 2 doi 1011861756-0500-6-41 PMCID PMC3566958

0 Afifi M Egyptian biomedical publications in PubMed 1996-2005

0 Bakoush O Al-Tubuly A Ashammakhi N Elkhammas E PubMed Medical publications from Libya Libyan J Med 2007 Sep 12(3)125-8 doi 104176070625

0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Arab nations lagging behind other Middle Eastern countries in biomedical research a comparative study Published online 2009 April 17 doi 1011861471-2288-9-26 BMC Med Res Methodol 2009 9 26 PMCID PMC2674457

48

References 0 Bissar-Tadmouri N Tadmouri GO Bibliometric analyses of

biomedical research outputs in Lebanon and the United Arab Emirates (1988-2007) Saudi Med J 2009 Jan30(1)130-9

0 Bellagio Meeting lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013

0 Mohammed El-Azami-El-Idrissi Mounia Lakhdar-Idrissi Karim Ouldim Wafaa Bono Afaf Amarti-Riffi Moustapha Hida Chakib Nejjari aImproving medical research in the Arab world The Lancet December 21st 2013

0 S A Ismail A McDonald E Dubois F G Aljohani A P Coutts A Majeed and S Rawaf Assessing the state of health research in the Eastern Mediterranean Region J R Soc Med published online 10 May 2013 DOI 101258jrsm2012120240

49

Page 32: Contents · Citations H index USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904 Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142 Israel ... 0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush. Arab nations lagging behind other Middle

Published 2009

0 In Lebanon

0 most of the citations originated from the capital city of Beirut mainly the American University of Beirut

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in Lebanon indicate a focus on internal medicine anesthesiology surgery transplantation medical genetics pediatrics obstetrics neoplasms and pain management

37

Published 2009

0 In the UAE

0 most of the biomedical publications originate from Al-Ain University

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in the UAE indicate developed interest in pediatrics obstetrics clinical dysmorphologies transplantation dermatology diabetes and consanguinity

38

Bellagio

0 A meeting was held in Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013 on lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo

0 to discuss how best to use the current opportunities to strengthen research science and innovation for health in the region

40

Partners 0 The Council on Health Research for Development

(COHRED)

0 the World Health Organisation (WHO) Regional-Office for the Eastern Mediterranean

0 and regional institutions such as the Faculty of Health Sciences of the American University of Beirut (AUB)

0 This event is supported by the International Development Research Centre (IDRC) in line with the Global Health Research Initiative (GHRI) the Middle East and North Africa Health Policy Forum and the Rockefeller Foundation

41

Outputs

0A call for action to strengthen system capacity for research and innovation for health

0A communication strategy to disseminate and keep this alive until the regional conference

0A conference plan for 2014

42

Conclusions

0 Visibility Egypt Saudi Arabia

0 Productivity UAE Lebanon Kuwait Jordan hellip

0 Compared to regional countries far away

0 Bibliometric AUB Al Ain U

0 Future more Partners Leaders and supporters are needed to be involved

44

Contribution concerns

In order to contribute more therersquos a need for

0 Center

0 Researcher and scientific writer

0 funding

0 Local issues hypothesis

0 Language

45

Road map

Arab Countries Health Research Group

(ACHRG)

Coordination networking

Specialized Conferences

46

References 0 Amin Bredan Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Editors Visibility

of Arab countries in the world biomedical literature Libyan J Med 2011 6 103402ljmv6i06325 Published online 2011 March 3 doi 103402ljmv6i06325 PMCID PMC3081872

0 Tadmouri GO Bissar-Tadmouri N Biomedical publications in an unstable region the Arab world 1988-2002 Lancet 2003 Nov 22362(9397)1766

0 Shaban SF Abu-Zidan FM A quantitative analysis of medical publications from Arab countries Saudi Med J 2003 Mar24(3)294-6

0 Deleu D Northway MG Hanssens Y Geographical distribution of biomedical publications from the Gulf Corporation Council countries Saudi Med J 2001 Jan22(1)10-2

47

References 0 Waleed M Sweileh Sarsquoed H Zyoud Ansam F Sawalha Adham Abu-Taha

Ayman Hussein and Samah W Al-Jabi Medical and biomedical research productivity from Palestine 2002 ndash 2011 BMC Res Notes 2013 6 41 Published online 2013 February 2 doi 1011861756-0500-6-41 PMCID PMC3566958

0 Afifi M Egyptian biomedical publications in PubMed 1996-2005

0 Bakoush O Al-Tubuly A Ashammakhi N Elkhammas E PubMed Medical publications from Libya Libyan J Med 2007 Sep 12(3)125-8 doi 104176070625

0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Arab nations lagging behind other Middle Eastern countries in biomedical research a comparative study Published online 2009 April 17 doi 1011861471-2288-9-26 BMC Med Res Methodol 2009 9 26 PMCID PMC2674457

48

References 0 Bissar-Tadmouri N Tadmouri GO Bibliometric analyses of

biomedical research outputs in Lebanon and the United Arab Emirates (1988-2007) Saudi Med J 2009 Jan30(1)130-9

0 Bellagio Meeting lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013

0 Mohammed El-Azami-El-Idrissi Mounia Lakhdar-Idrissi Karim Ouldim Wafaa Bono Afaf Amarti-Riffi Moustapha Hida Chakib Nejjari aImproving medical research in the Arab world The Lancet December 21st 2013

0 S A Ismail A McDonald E Dubois F G Aljohani A P Coutts A Majeed and S Rawaf Assessing the state of health research in the Eastern Mediterranean Region J R Soc Med published online 10 May 2013 DOI 101258jrsm2012120240

49

Page 33: Contents · Citations H index USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904 Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142 Israel ... 0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush. Arab nations lagging behind other Middle

Published 2009

0 In the UAE

0 most of the biomedical publications originate from Al-Ain University

0 Detailed analysis of biomedical research objectives in the UAE indicate developed interest in pediatrics obstetrics clinical dysmorphologies transplantation dermatology diabetes and consanguinity

38

Bellagio

0 A meeting was held in Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013 on lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo

0 to discuss how best to use the current opportunities to strengthen research science and innovation for health in the region

40

Partners 0 The Council on Health Research for Development

(COHRED)

0 the World Health Organisation (WHO) Regional-Office for the Eastern Mediterranean

0 and regional institutions such as the Faculty of Health Sciences of the American University of Beirut (AUB)

0 This event is supported by the International Development Research Centre (IDRC) in line with the Global Health Research Initiative (GHRI) the Middle East and North Africa Health Policy Forum and the Rockefeller Foundation

41

Outputs

0A call for action to strengthen system capacity for research and innovation for health

0A communication strategy to disseminate and keep this alive until the regional conference

0A conference plan for 2014

42

Conclusions

0 Visibility Egypt Saudi Arabia

0 Productivity UAE Lebanon Kuwait Jordan hellip

0 Compared to regional countries far away

0 Bibliometric AUB Al Ain U

0 Future more Partners Leaders and supporters are needed to be involved

44

Contribution concerns

In order to contribute more therersquos a need for

0 Center

0 Researcher and scientific writer

0 funding

0 Local issues hypothesis

0 Language

45

Road map

Arab Countries Health Research Group

(ACHRG)

Coordination networking

Specialized Conferences

46

References 0 Amin Bredan Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Editors Visibility

of Arab countries in the world biomedical literature Libyan J Med 2011 6 103402ljmv6i06325 Published online 2011 March 3 doi 103402ljmv6i06325 PMCID PMC3081872

0 Tadmouri GO Bissar-Tadmouri N Biomedical publications in an unstable region the Arab world 1988-2002 Lancet 2003 Nov 22362(9397)1766

0 Shaban SF Abu-Zidan FM A quantitative analysis of medical publications from Arab countries Saudi Med J 2003 Mar24(3)294-6

0 Deleu D Northway MG Hanssens Y Geographical distribution of biomedical publications from the Gulf Corporation Council countries Saudi Med J 2001 Jan22(1)10-2

47

References 0 Waleed M Sweileh Sarsquoed H Zyoud Ansam F Sawalha Adham Abu-Taha

Ayman Hussein and Samah W Al-Jabi Medical and biomedical research productivity from Palestine 2002 ndash 2011 BMC Res Notes 2013 6 41 Published online 2013 February 2 doi 1011861756-0500-6-41 PMCID PMC3566958

0 Afifi M Egyptian biomedical publications in PubMed 1996-2005

0 Bakoush O Al-Tubuly A Ashammakhi N Elkhammas E PubMed Medical publications from Libya Libyan J Med 2007 Sep 12(3)125-8 doi 104176070625

0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Arab nations lagging behind other Middle Eastern countries in biomedical research a comparative study Published online 2009 April 17 doi 1011861471-2288-9-26 BMC Med Res Methodol 2009 9 26 PMCID PMC2674457

48

References 0 Bissar-Tadmouri N Tadmouri GO Bibliometric analyses of

biomedical research outputs in Lebanon and the United Arab Emirates (1988-2007) Saudi Med J 2009 Jan30(1)130-9

0 Bellagio Meeting lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013

0 Mohammed El-Azami-El-Idrissi Mounia Lakhdar-Idrissi Karim Ouldim Wafaa Bono Afaf Amarti-Riffi Moustapha Hida Chakib Nejjari aImproving medical research in the Arab world The Lancet December 21st 2013

0 S A Ismail A McDonald E Dubois F G Aljohani A P Coutts A Majeed and S Rawaf Assessing the state of health research in the Eastern Mediterranean Region J R Soc Med published online 10 May 2013 DOI 101258jrsm2012120240

49

Page 34: Contents · Citations H index USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904 Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142 Israel ... 0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush. Arab nations lagging behind other Middle

Bellagio

0 A meeting was held in Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013 on lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo

0 to discuss how best to use the current opportunities to strengthen research science and innovation for health in the region

40

Partners 0 The Council on Health Research for Development

(COHRED)

0 the World Health Organisation (WHO) Regional-Office for the Eastern Mediterranean

0 and regional institutions such as the Faculty of Health Sciences of the American University of Beirut (AUB)

0 This event is supported by the International Development Research Centre (IDRC) in line with the Global Health Research Initiative (GHRI) the Middle East and North Africa Health Policy Forum and the Rockefeller Foundation

41

Outputs

0A call for action to strengthen system capacity for research and innovation for health

0A communication strategy to disseminate and keep this alive until the regional conference

0A conference plan for 2014

42

Conclusions

0 Visibility Egypt Saudi Arabia

0 Productivity UAE Lebanon Kuwait Jordan hellip

0 Compared to regional countries far away

0 Bibliometric AUB Al Ain U

0 Future more Partners Leaders and supporters are needed to be involved

44

Contribution concerns

In order to contribute more therersquos a need for

0 Center

0 Researcher and scientific writer

0 funding

0 Local issues hypothesis

0 Language

45

Road map

Arab Countries Health Research Group

(ACHRG)

Coordination networking

Specialized Conferences

46

References 0 Amin Bredan Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Editors Visibility

of Arab countries in the world biomedical literature Libyan J Med 2011 6 103402ljmv6i06325 Published online 2011 March 3 doi 103402ljmv6i06325 PMCID PMC3081872

0 Tadmouri GO Bissar-Tadmouri N Biomedical publications in an unstable region the Arab world 1988-2002 Lancet 2003 Nov 22362(9397)1766

0 Shaban SF Abu-Zidan FM A quantitative analysis of medical publications from Arab countries Saudi Med J 2003 Mar24(3)294-6

0 Deleu D Northway MG Hanssens Y Geographical distribution of biomedical publications from the Gulf Corporation Council countries Saudi Med J 2001 Jan22(1)10-2

47

References 0 Waleed M Sweileh Sarsquoed H Zyoud Ansam F Sawalha Adham Abu-Taha

Ayman Hussein and Samah W Al-Jabi Medical and biomedical research productivity from Palestine 2002 ndash 2011 BMC Res Notes 2013 6 41 Published online 2013 February 2 doi 1011861756-0500-6-41 PMCID PMC3566958

0 Afifi M Egyptian biomedical publications in PubMed 1996-2005

0 Bakoush O Al-Tubuly A Ashammakhi N Elkhammas E PubMed Medical publications from Libya Libyan J Med 2007 Sep 12(3)125-8 doi 104176070625

0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Arab nations lagging behind other Middle Eastern countries in biomedical research a comparative study Published online 2009 April 17 doi 1011861471-2288-9-26 BMC Med Res Methodol 2009 9 26 PMCID PMC2674457

48

References 0 Bissar-Tadmouri N Tadmouri GO Bibliometric analyses of

biomedical research outputs in Lebanon and the United Arab Emirates (1988-2007) Saudi Med J 2009 Jan30(1)130-9

0 Bellagio Meeting lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013

0 Mohammed El-Azami-El-Idrissi Mounia Lakhdar-Idrissi Karim Ouldim Wafaa Bono Afaf Amarti-Riffi Moustapha Hida Chakib Nejjari aImproving medical research in the Arab world The Lancet December 21st 2013

0 S A Ismail A McDonald E Dubois F G Aljohani A P Coutts A Majeed and S Rawaf Assessing the state of health research in the Eastern Mediterranean Region J R Soc Med published online 10 May 2013 DOI 101258jrsm2012120240

49

Page 35: Contents · Citations H index USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904 Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142 Israel ... 0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush. Arab nations lagging behind other Middle

Partners 0 The Council on Health Research for Development

(COHRED)

0 the World Health Organisation (WHO) Regional-Office for the Eastern Mediterranean

0 and regional institutions such as the Faculty of Health Sciences of the American University of Beirut (AUB)

0 This event is supported by the International Development Research Centre (IDRC) in line with the Global Health Research Initiative (GHRI) the Middle East and North Africa Health Policy Forum and the Rockefeller Foundation

41

Outputs

0A call for action to strengthen system capacity for research and innovation for health

0A communication strategy to disseminate and keep this alive until the regional conference

0A conference plan for 2014

42

Conclusions

0 Visibility Egypt Saudi Arabia

0 Productivity UAE Lebanon Kuwait Jordan hellip

0 Compared to regional countries far away

0 Bibliometric AUB Al Ain U

0 Future more Partners Leaders and supporters are needed to be involved

44

Contribution concerns

In order to contribute more therersquos a need for

0 Center

0 Researcher and scientific writer

0 funding

0 Local issues hypothesis

0 Language

45

Road map

Arab Countries Health Research Group

(ACHRG)

Coordination networking

Specialized Conferences

46

References 0 Amin Bredan Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Editors Visibility

of Arab countries in the world biomedical literature Libyan J Med 2011 6 103402ljmv6i06325 Published online 2011 March 3 doi 103402ljmv6i06325 PMCID PMC3081872

0 Tadmouri GO Bissar-Tadmouri N Biomedical publications in an unstable region the Arab world 1988-2002 Lancet 2003 Nov 22362(9397)1766

0 Shaban SF Abu-Zidan FM A quantitative analysis of medical publications from Arab countries Saudi Med J 2003 Mar24(3)294-6

0 Deleu D Northway MG Hanssens Y Geographical distribution of biomedical publications from the Gulf Corporation Council countries Saudi Med J 2001 Jan22(1)10-2

47

References 0 Waleed M Sweileh Sarsquoed H Zyoud Ansam F Sawalha Adham Abu-Taha

Ayman Hussein and Samah W Al-Jabi Medical and biomedical research productivity from Palestine 2002 ndash 2011 BMC Res Notes 2013 6 41 Published online 2013 February 2 doi 1011861756-0500-6-41 PMCID PMC3566958

0 Afifi M Egyptian biomedical publications in PubMed 1996-2005

0 Bakoush O Al-Tubuly A Ashammakhi N Elkhammas E PubMed Medical publications from Libya Libyan J Med 2007 Sep 12(3)125-8 doi 104176070625

0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Arab nations lagging behind other Middle Eastern countries in biomedical research a comparative study Published online 2009 April 17 doi 1011861471-2288-9-26 BMC Med Res Methodol 2009 9 26 PMCID PMC2674457

48

References 0 Bissar-Tadmouri N Tadmouri GO Bibliometric analyses of

biomedical research outputs in Lebanon and the United Arab Emirates (1988-2007) Saudi Med J 2009 Jan30(1)130-9

0 Bellagio Meeting lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013

0 Mohammed El-Azami-El-Idrissi Mounia Lakhdar-Idrissi Karim Ouldim Wafaa Bono Afaf Amarti-Riffi Moustapha Hida Chakib Nejjari aImproving medical research in the Arab world The Lancet December 21st 2013

0 S A Ismail A McDonald E Dubois F G Aljohani A P Coutts A Majeed and S Rawaf Assessing the state of health research in the Eastern Mediterranean Region J R Soc Med published online 10 May 2013 DOI 101258jrsm2012120240

49

Page 36: Contents · Citations H index USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904 Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142 Israel ... 0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush. Arab nations lagging behind other Middle

Outputs

0A call for action to strengthen system capacity for research and innovation for health

0A communication strategy to disseminate and keep this alive until the regional conference

0A conference plan for 2014

42

Conclusions

0 Visibility Egypt Saudi Arabia

0 Productivity UAE Lebanon Kuwait Jordan hellip

0 Compared to regional countries far away

0 Bibliometric AUB Al Ain U

0 Future more Partners Leaders and supporters are needed to be involved

44

Contribution concerns

In order to contribute more therersquos a need for

0 Center

0 Researcher and scientific writer

0 funding

0 Local issues hypothesis

0 Language

45

Road map

Arab Countries Health Research Group

(ACHRG)

Coordination networking

Specialized Conferences

46

References 0 Amin Bredan Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Editors Visibility

of Arab countries in the world biomedical literature Libyan J Med 2011 6 103402ljmv6i06325 Published online 2011 March 3 doi 103402ljmv6i06325 PMCID PMC3081872

0 Tadmouri GO Bissar-Tadmouri N Biomedical publications in an unstable region the Arab world 1988-2002 Lancet 2003 Nov 22362(9397)1766

0 Shaban SF Abu-Zidan FM A quantitative analysis of medical publications from Arab countries Saudi Med J 2003 Mar24(3)294-6

0 Deleu D Northway MG Hanssens Y Geographical distribution of biomedical publications from the Gulf Corporation Council countries Saudi Med J 2001 Jan22(1)10-2

47

References 0 Waleed M Sweileh Sarsquoed H Zyoud Ansam F Sawalha Adham Abu-Taha

Ayman Hussein and Samah W Al-Jabi Medical and biomedical research productivity from Palestine 2002 ndash 2011 BMC Res Notes 2013 6 41 Published online 2013 February 2 doi 1011861756-0500-6-41 PMCID PMC3566958

0 Afifi M Egyptian biomedical publications in PubMed 1996-2005

0 Bakoush O Al-Tubuly A Ashammakhi N Elkhammas E PubMed Medical publications from Libya Libyan J Med 2007 Sep 12(3)125-8 doi 104176070625

0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Arab nations lagging behind other Middle Eastern countries in biomedical research a comparative study Published online 2009 April 17 doi 1011861471-2288-9-26 BMC Med Res Methodol 2009 9 26 PMCID PMC2674457

48

References 0 Bissar-Tadmouri N Tadmouri GO Bibliometric analyses of

biomedical research outputs in Lebanon and the United Arab Emirates (1988-2007) Saudi Med J 2009 Jan30(1)130-9

0 Bellagio Meeting lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013

0 Mohammed El-Azami-El-Idrissi Mounia Lakhdar-Idrissi Karim Ouldim Wafaa Bono Afaf Amarti-Riffi Moustapha Hida Chakib Nejjari aImproving medical research in the Arab world The Lancet December 21st 2013

0 S A Ismail A McDonald E Dubois F G Aljohani A P Coutts A Majeed and S Rawaf Assessing the state of health research in the Eastern Mediterranean Region J R Soc Med published online 10 May 2013 DOI 101258jrsm2012120240

49

Page 37: Contents · Citations H index USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904 Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142 Israel ... 0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush. Arab nations lagging behind other Middle

Conclusions

0 Visibility Egypt Saudi Arabia

0 Productivity UAE Lebanon Kuwait Jordan hellip

0 Compared to regional countries far away

0 Bibliometric AUB Al Ain U

0 Future more Partners Leaders and supporters are needed to be involved

44

Contribution concerns

In order to contribute more therersquos a need for

0 Center

0 Researcher and scientific writer

0 funding

0 Local issues hypothesis

0 Language

45

Road map

Arab Countries Health Research Group

(ACHRG)

Coordination networking

Specialized Conferences

46

References 0 Amin Bredan Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Editors Visibility

of Arab countries in the world biomedical literature Libyan J Med 2011 6 103402ljmv6i06325 Published online 2011 March 3 doi 103402ljmv6i06325 PMCID PMC3081872

0 Tadmouri GO Bissar-Tadmouri N Biomedical publications in an unstable region the Arab world 1988-2002 Lancet 2003 Nov 22362(9397)1766

0 Shaban SF Abu-Zidan FM A quantitative analysis of medical publications from Arab countries Saudi Med J 2003 Mar24(3)294-6

0 Deleu D Northway MG Hanssens Y Geographical distribution of biomedical publications from the Gulf Corporation Council countries Saudi Med J 2001 Jan22(1)10-2

47

References 0 Waleed M Sweileh Sarsquoed H Zyoud Ansam F Sawalha Adham Abu-Taha

Ayman Hussein and Samah W Al-Jabi Medical and biomedical research productivity from Palestine 2002 ndash 2011 BMC Res Notes 2013 6 41 Published online 2013 February 2 doi 1011861756-0500-6-41 PMCID PMC3566958

0 Afifi M Egyptian biomedical publications in PubMed 1996-2005

0 Bakoush O Al-Tubuly A Ashammakhi N Elkhammas E PubMed Medical publications from Libya Libyan J Med 2007 Sep 12(3)125-8 doi 104176070625

0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Arab nations lagging behind other Middle Eastern countries in biomedical research a comparative study Published online 2009 April 17 doi 1011861471-2288-9-26 BMC Med Res Methodol 2009 9 26 PMCID PMC2674457

48

References 0 Bissar-Tadmouri N Tadmouri GO Bibliometric analyses of

biomedical research outputs in Lebanon and the United Arab Emirates (1988-2007) Saudi Med J 2009 Jan30(1)130-9

0 Bellagio Meeting lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013

0 Mohammed El-Azami-El-Idrissi Mounia Lakhdar-Idrissi Karim Ouldim Wafaa Bono Afaf Amarti-Riffi Moustapha Hida Chakib Nejjari aImproving medical research in the Arab world The Lancet December 21st 2013

0 S A Ismail A McDonald E Dubois F G Aljohani A P Coutts A Majeed and S Rawaf Assessing the state of health research in the Eastern Mediterranean Region J R Soc Med published online 10 May 2013 DOI 101258jrsm2012120240

49

Page 38: Contents · Citations H index USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904 Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142 Israel ... 0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush. Arab nations lagging behind other Middle

Contribution concerns

In order to contribute more therersquos a need for

0 Center

0 Researcher and scientific writer

0 funding

0 Local issues hypothesis

0 Language

45

Road map

Arab Countries Health Research Group

(ACHRG)

Coordination networking

Specialized Conferences

46

References 0 Amin Bredan Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Editors Visibility

of Arab countries in the world biomedical literature Libyan J Med 2011 6 103402ljmv6i06325 Published online 2011 March 3 doi 103402ljmv6i06325 PMCID PMC3081872

0 Tadmouri GO Bissar-Tadmouri N Biomedical publications in an unstable region the Arab world 1988-2002 Lancet 2003 Nov 22362(9397)1766

0 Shaban SF Abu-Zidan FM A quantitative analysis of medical publications from Arab countries Saudi Med J 2003 Mar24(3)294-6

0 Deleu D Northway MG Hanssens Y Geographical distribution of biomedical publications from the Gulf Corporation Council countries Saudi Med J 2001 Jan22(1)10-2

47

References 0 Waleed M Sweileh Sarsquoed H Zyoud Ansam F Sawalha Adham Abu-Taha

Ayman Hussein and Samah W Al-Jabi Medical and biomedical research productivity from Palestine 2002 ndash 2011 BMC Res Notes 2013 6 41 Published online 2013 February 2 doi 1011861756-0500-6-41 PMCID PMC3566958

0 Afifi M Egyptian biomedical publications in PubMed 1996-2005

0 Bakoush O Al-Tubuly A Ashammakhi N Elkhammas E PubMed Medical publications from Libya Libyan J Med 2007 Sep 12(3)125-8 doi 104176070625

0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Arab nations lagging behind other Middle Eastern countries in biomedical research a comparative study Published online 2009 April 17 doi 1011861471-2288-9-26 BMC Med Res Methodol 2009 9 26 PMCID PMC2674457

48

References 0 Bissar-Tadmouri N Tadmouri GO Bibliometric analyses of

biomedical research outputs in Lebanon and the United Arab Emirates (1988-2007) Saudi Med J 2009 Jan30(1)130-9

0 Bellagio Meeting lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013

0 Mohammed El-Azami-El-Idrissi Mounia Lakhdar-Idrissi Karim Ouldim Wafaa Bono Afaf Amarti-Riffi Moustapha Hida Chakib Nejjari aImproving medical research in the Arab world The Lancet December 21st 2013

0 S A Ismail A McDonald E Dubois F G Aljohani A P Coutts A Majeed and S Rawaf Assessing the state of health research in the Eastern Mediterranean Region J R Soc Med published online 10 May 2013 DOI 101258jrsm2012120240

49

Page 39: Contents · Citations H index USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904 Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142 Israel ... 0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush. Arab nations lagging behind other Middle

Road map

Arab Countries Health Research Group

(ACHRG)

Coordination networking

Specialized Conferences

46

References 0 Amin Bredan Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Editors Visibility

of Arab countries in the world biomedical literature Libyan J Med 2011 6 103402ljmv6i06325 Published online 2011 March 3 doi 103402ljmv6i06325 PMCID PMC3081872

0 Tadmouri GO Bissar-Tadmouri N Biomedical publications in an unstable region the Arab world 1988-2002 Lancet 2003 Nov 22362(9397)1766

0 Shaban SF Abu-Zidan FM A quantitative analysis of medical publications from Arab countries Saudi Med J 2003 Mar24(3)294-6

0 Deleu D Northway MG Hanssens Y Geographical distribution of biomedical publications from the Gulf Corporation Council countries Saudi Med J 2001 Jan22(1)10-2

47

References 0 Waleed M Sweileh Sarsquoed H Zyoud Ansam F Sawalha Adham Abu-Taha

Ayman Hussein and Samah W Al-Jabi Medical and biomedical research productivity from Palestine 2002 ndash 2011 BMC Res Notes 2013 6 41 Published online 2013 February 2 doi 1011861756-0500-6-41 PMCID PMC3566958

0 Afifi M Egyptian biomedical publications in PubMed 1996-2005

0 Bakoush O Al-Tubuly A Ashammakhi N Elkhammas E PubMed Medical publications from Libya Libyan J Med 2007 Sep 12(3)125-8 doi 104176070625

0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Arab nations lagging behind other Middle Eastern countries in biomedical research a comparative study Published online 2009 April 17 doi 1011861471-2288-9-26 BMC Med Res Methodol 2009 9 26 PMCID PMC2674457

48

References 0 Bissar-Tadmouri N Tadmouri GO Bibliometric analyses of

biomedical research outputs in Lebanon and the United Arab Emirates (1988-2007) Saudi Med J 2009 Jan30(1)130-9

0 Bellagio Meeting lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013

0 Mohammed El-Azami-El-Idrissi Mounia Lakhdar-Idrissi Karim Ouldim Wafaa Bono Afaf Amarti-Riffi Moustapha Hida Chakib Nejjari aImproving medical research in the Arab world The Lancet December 21st 2013

0 S A Ismail A McDonald E Dubois F G Aljohani A P Coutts A Majeed and S Rawaf Assessing the state of health research in the Eastern Mediterranean Region J R Soc Med published online 10 May 2013 DOI 101258jrsm2012120240

49

Page 40: Contents · Citations H index USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904 Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142 Israel ... 0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush. Arab nations lagging behind other Middle

References 0 Amin Bredan Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Editors Visibility

of Arab countries in the world biomedical literature Libyan J Med 2011 6 103402ljmv6i06325 Published online 2011 March 3 doi 103402ljmv6i06325 PMCID PMC3081872

0 Tadmouri GO Bissar-Tadmouri N Biomedical publications in an unstable region the Arab world 1988-2002 Lancet 2003 Nov 22362(9397)1766

0 Shaban SF Abu-Zidan FM A quantitative analysis of medical publications from Arab countries Saudi Med J 2003 Mar24(3)294-6

0 Deleu D Northway MG Hanssens Y Geographical distribution of biomedical publications from the Gulf Corporation Council countries Saudi Med J 2001 Jan22(1)10-2

47

References 0 Waleed M Sweileh Sarsquoed H Zyoud Ansam F Sawalha Adham Abu-Taha

Ayman Hussein and Samah W Al-Jabi Medical and biomedical research productivity from Palestine 2002 ndash 2011 BMC Res Notes 2013 6 41 Published online 2013 February 2 doi 1011861756-0500-6-41 PMCID PMC3566958

0 Afifi M Egyptian biomedical publications in PubMed 1996-2005

0 Bakoush O Al-Tubuly A Ashammakhi N Elkhammas E PubMed Medical publications from Libya Libyan J Med 2007 Sep 12(3)125-8 doi 104176070625

0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Arab nations lagging behind other Middle Eastern countries in biomedical research a comparative study Published online 2009 April 17 doi 1011861471-2288-9-26 BMC Med Res Methodol 2009 9 26 PMCID PMC2674457

48

References 0 Bissar-Tadmouri N Tadmouri GO Bibliometric analyses of

biomedical research outputs in Lebanon and the United Arab Emirates (1988-2007) Saudi Med J 2009 Jan30(1)130-9

0 Bellagio Meeting lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013

0 Mohammed El-Azami-El-Idrissi Mounia Lakhdar-Idrissi Karim Ouldim Wafaa Bono Afaf Amarti-Riffi Moustapha Hida Chakib Nejjari aImproving medical research in the Arab world The Lancet December 21st 2013

0 S A Ismail A McDonald E Dubois F G Aljohani A P Coutts A Majeed and S Rawaf Assessing the state of health research in the Eastern Mediterranean Region J R Soc Med published online 10 May 2013 DOI 101258jrsm2012120240

49

Page 41: Contents · Citations H index USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904 Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142 Israel ... 0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush. Arab nations lagging behind other Middle

References 0 Waleed M Sweileh Sarsquoed H Zyoud Ansam F Sawalha Adham Abu-Taha

Ayman Hussein and Samah W Al-Jabi Medical and biomedical research productivity from Palestine 2002 ndash 2011 BMC Res Notes 2013 6 41 Published online 2013 February 2 doi 1011861756-0500-6-41 PMCID PMC3566958

0 Afifi M Egyptian biomedical publications in PubMed 1996-2005

0 Bakoush O Al-Tubuly A Ashammakhi N Elkhammas E PubMed Medical publications from Libya Libyan J Med 2007 Sep 12(3)125-8 doi 104176070625

0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush Arab nations lagging behind other Middle Eastern countries in biomedical research a comparative study Published online 2009 April 17 doi 1011861471-2288-9-26 BMC Med Res Methodol 2009 9 26 PMCID PMC2674457

48

References 0 Bissar-Tadmouri N Tadmouri GO Bibliometric analyses of

biomedical research outputs in Lebanon and the United Arab Emirates (1988-2007) Saudi Med J 2009 Jan30(1)130-9

0 Bellagio Meeting lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013

0 Mohammed El-Azami-El-Idrissi Mounia Lakhdar-Idrissi Karim Ouldim Wafaa Bono Afaf Amarti-Riffi Moustapha Hida Chakib Nejjari aImproving medical research in the Arab world The Lancet December 21st 2013

0 S A Ismail A McDonald E Dubois F G Aljohani A P Coutts A Majeed and S Rawaf Assessing the state of health research in the Eastern Mediterranean Region J R Soc Med published online 10 May 2013 DOI 101258jrsm2012120240

49

Page 42: Contents · Citations H index USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904 Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142 Israel ... 0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush. Arab nations lagging behind other Middle

References 0 Bissar-Tadmouri N Tadmouri GO Bibliometric analyses of

biomedical research outputs in Lebanon and the United Arab Emirates (1988-2007) Saudi Med J 2009 Jan30(1)130-9

0 Bellagio Meeting lsquoBoosting Research for Health in the New Arab Worldlsquo Bellagio center Italy 26th of Feb to the 1st of March 2013

0 Mohammed El-Azami-El-Idrissi Mounia Lakhdar-Idrissi Karim Ouldim Wafaa Bono Afaf Amarti-Riffi Moustapha Hida Chakib Nejjari aImproving medical research in the Arab world The Lancet December 21st 2013

0 S A Ismail A McDonald E Dubois F G Aljohani A P Coutts A Majeed and S Rawaf Assessing the state of health research in the Eastern Mediterranean Region J R Soc Med published online 10 May 2013 DOI 101258jrsm2012120240

49

Page 43: Contents · Citations H index USA 1875195 1652683 37441209 904 Turkey 120954 109240 648234 142 Israel ... 0 Hani TS Benamer and Omran Bakoush. Arab nations lagging behind other Middle