Contempt by publication under the Contempt of Court Act 1981

8/18/2019 Contempt by publication under the Contempt of Court Act 1981

1/104

P 1

C C

C A 1981:

?

A R

U P

S S, H L

S

M 2012

D

BA (H) J M S


2/104

P 2

A

T

, C C A 1981,

. A ,

.

T , ,

,

. O

, ,

. T

.

T ,

,

. T

. T

.


3/104

P 3

A

F I , B

S . H

.

S I W ,

. I I

.


4/104

P 4

C

I..1

C O: L R.5

C T: C R..15

C T: C A27

C.37

A41

R L..68

B84


5/104

P 5

F

(E & S, 2005, .1). H,

,

(C, 2010, .56). O

(E & S, 2005, .303). N,

(S, 2006, .116) ,

, '

(C, 2011, . 9). T C C A 1981

(G, 2012, . 2)

(Q & L, 2008,

.136).

T

C C A 1981,

. T

,

. T

, ,


6/104

P 6

.

C C

(B & H, 2009, .273) , E W,

(C,

A, C & O, 2002, .1). T C C A

1981 L H L.C.

C L J P, J 1971,

(E & S, 2005,

.27). W ,

( ) 1973

(W, 1973, .177). T

(S, 2006, .116).

A , 1974 H L

(E & S, 2005, .28). T P

, ,

(E & S, 2005, .28). T

(Y, 1981, .243) A. T

:


7/104

P 7

R : P

,

.

R : A

( ).

R : S

,

.

(E & S, 2005, .1354)

T A

(Y, 1981, .247). H,

C C A A 1981

(E & S, 2005, .37). B H A

(2009, .274). T

(E & S, 2005, .49)

, A,

(E & S, 2005, .49).

T

. I


8/104

P 8

. T

.

C

. T L B, J F

T D J T. S

, , ,

.

C . T

. I

.

T . T

,

.


9/104

P 9

C

B C C A 1981

(F, 2005, .216). W ,

(R, 2011) ,

, (G,

2003, .1). H,

(G, 2003, .120). T

C C A 1981

, ,

. I

.

T ,

. I (C, A,

L, Q, 2010, .158).

T C C A 1981

(S, 2000, .351), ,

(S, 2006, .121). S A,

, ( ),


10/104

P 10

,

(B & H, 2009, .274). T

(C , 2010, .159). A

(T, 2010, .5). T

L H A

(Y, 1981, .245). T

, (E & S, 2005, .226).

S ;

(S, 2000,

.354). I (E & S, 2005,

.241). S

, ,

(B & H, 2009,

.276). R N

(2002, .349). N,

(S, 2006, .125)

(Y, 1981, .247). A ,

,


11/104

P 11

(B & H, 2009, .276). O

(E

& S, 2005, .278). T ;

(E & S, 2005, .232)

(S, 2006, .124). T

,

(T, 2010, .41).

T A G, D G,

(E & S, 2005, .133). T

E C H R. A

:

I

,

(R & N, 2002, .346).

T

(F, H, M & W, 2006, .141)

. T

(G, 2003, .136). I ,


12/104

P 12

(E & S, 2005, .61). T

(C, 2010, .56).

T

. T

(G, 2003,

.131).

I

(C, 2010, .50). T

(O, 2002, .76).

T

(R & N, 2002, .346).

H ,

(G, 2007, .6)

,

. T

(L, 2002, .98); ,

(M & R, 2011, .3). F ,

,

(MN, 2011, .38)

. O , ,

. A D

G


13/104

P 13

(2012, . 8)

(G: P, 2011, . 12).

A

. G :

T

. S

,

(2003, .137).

B

(Q, 2011, .77). T

S ( ). P

(E & S, 2005, .275). T , L O,

(E & S, 2005,

.275) ,

, (Q, 2011, .78). T

. I 2008, L C

, (Q, 2011, .78). I

(G, S & W, 2009, .143)

. T


14/104

P 14

(E &

S, 2005, .61). T (P, 2010, .1)

(C, 2010, .50).

B

(2012, . 7).

A

M 2011. B

,

. T

(H, 2011, . 2)

(S D, 2011, . 3). L J M

(S D, 2011, . 7). A

,

(P , 2011, . 9)

(E

& S, 2005. P.249). A

, D G (R, 2011). T

. F,

(H, 2011, .

9).


15/104

P 15

T ,

, UK

(C, A, C, & O, 2002, .1). T

, S

,

(2010, .100). S F, T YT

(M &

R, 2011, .9)

, ,

(MN, 2011, .39).

T (L, 2011, . 1)

. T L C J T

, (

). T T

(L, 2011, . 1). I

T

(M, 2011, . 2: L, 2011, . 5). T L C J

(C , 2011, . 21)

(T , 2010, . 2).

F, T (R,

2011, . 9); T

(M, 2011, . 10). D H R


16/104

P 16

, T

(P, 2012, .

1 & 2). A J Y ,

T F

(B, 2011, . 4). T

.

A ,

(P, 2011, . 8).

A T

(R, 2011, . 10). F, G T

(A G, 2011, . 4),

(R, 2011, . 14). T T

. T

. B :

J

. P

(2011, . 9).

M,

. B

(G, 2007, .24)

,

(M & R, 2011, .9). T


17/104

P 17

. I

; ,

(W, 2011, . 20).

D G (G, 2011,

. 7) (W, 2011,

. 23). A ,

(G, 2003, .134). T

(E & S, 2005, .54)

.

Q L

; ,

(2008, .127). T , K C

(P, 2011, . 5 & 6). H

;

,

. F, B :

J , ,

. G ,

G

' (2011, . 14).


18/104

P 18

T, ,

,

. T ,

, (Q & L, 2008, .127). L,

(H, 2011, . 19)

(A G , 2011, . 26). I D G

(G: P, 2011)

(P, 2010,

.1) .

T

. T L B

. T J T

. T T D J F

. C

,

, (R, L & F,

2005, .28),

. T

.


19/104

P 19

C

C

T

(T, 2010, .5). R ,

(E, 2011, . 1). S

(C,

2008, .191). T

. I

, ,

,

. F, L B,

,

. S, J T

. L, J F T

D . T

. O ,

. A

.

T

. I


20/104

P 20

, ? I

(P, 2011, .3 & . 5).

L B F 2008 , M

MD A D K S. H

. T

, , B

M D,

S 2002. I M 2010 B

M D, J 2011 ,

. P .

A , B

. I

,

, 2008. R

(E & S, 2005,

.249). T ,

, . A

.

L B,

( ). T

2008. A

H (MV, 2008)

. B


21/104

P 21

,

(. 1). W A D B

(. 7). A B

(MV, 2008)

(. 4), ,

(. 14). I B

, 14 16 (. 15). D M

D

,

. F B 2008,

; B, 39

(MV, 2008, . 2). T B

. F,

M

2004 (B, 2008, . 7). T

. T

.

L B, 2006 . T

( ). R

, . B

H L? (S, 2008)


22/104

P 22

(. 5) (. 1). W

B (. 9)

. E . C

, , ,

. T B 100 ,

(. 14). T ,

B

.

F, K J H (2008)

B .

C M D ,

20 (. 15) (. 2)

13

(. 12). I B (. 30),

(. 17)

15 (. 25). B

14 P M (P, 2008,

. 3). T M D , B

.

I

L B . H,

(B &


23/104

P 23

H, 2009, .84)

, B

. M

(E & S, 2005, .265). A

, .

A B M D ,

R C

( ) (H, 2011, 6). T

. H,

,

. T

,

. T .

T J T

. D P

L C Q P R 23 O

2011, J T

A F. A , T

1 F 2012

E F A. A

C D A, ' 9 J


24/104


25/104

P 25

(, 2011). M T

. A A F: J T

(J, 2011) T .

C JT ,

(1234, 2011)

(, 2011). O T

(, 2011) , (,

2011).

T .

. W J T

F , J T (GG,

2011) T . T

(W, 2011). A

FA T T (J M, 2012)

? (E,

2012).

O 3 F 2012

. J B, A F

T, J T

. T T

. Q

, , **

? I I


26/104

P 26

(J B, 2012). T

J T T I A (J

B, 2012). B T

(J B, 2012). T

T . A T

.

A, J B 1,220,200 T;

. B

? I

? C , ? (J B, 2012). S

T

. H, . T

YT . T

181,698 . T

YT . T

. T

. T

. I

, ,

. H J B , D G

M


27/104

P 27

B M T (J B,

2012, . 3 & 7). T A G

B

(B, 2012, . 2). T

.

A

. T J F

T D

. F, A

2010, J F J S F

G K

. S F

F S ,

. A

(J , 2011, . 3). W

,

. F F

: (2011) ( )

F , ,

J (. 19) I

[ (. 4), I

(. 54)

(. 28) (. 34). S


28/104

P 28

I , I (.

20) ? (. 14). F

G K

. T D G ,

UK (J , 2011, . 1), F

. T

(J , 2011, .28). L J , :

H

, ,

,

(J , 2011, . 9).

T

. A ,

J F ,

.

T T D

. D L C C J 2011

, D T D

B M (B

, 2012, . 4). T

(B , 2012, . 12).

S D

(J T, 2012, . 27),


29/104

P 29

(R & N, 2002, .351). H,

. N

. A ,

. T

. T ,

(B , 2012, . 14). H,

A G (B, 2012, . 6) H C

T D (J T, 2012, . 4).

T

. O

. F , D D

L

(B , 2012, . 16). B

, L J

,

(J T, 2012, . 22). F, D G :

M D ,

(B,

2012, . 17).

A ,

, . I

(B, 2012, . 3). T L C J


30/104

P 30

(B, 2011, . 1).

T

. I

. T ,

.

I

(A

G, 2011, . 68). T

,

, .


31/104


32/104

P 32

(Y, 1981, .248). A

,

(T, 2010, .44). I ,

(G, 2003, .137).

N, L B M D

;

. C T , A J F?

(2010, .43). T

. I

, (T, 2010,

.41), L B. H,

, (E & S, 2005,

.275). T

.

D G

(J B, 2012, . 4). T C A :

I

:

(R & N, 2002, .347).


33/104

P 33

A

(R, 2011, . 16)

(B, 2011, . 18). T

. A L B ,

,

.

S

(MC, 2011, . 5)

. W

(G, 2012, . 4)

(H, 2012, . 7). T J B T

J T, D G

. A B

(H, 2012, . 3) G

(J B , 2012, . 13)

T . T

. D ,

(E & S, 2005, .260). I

T , . N,

B (B, 2012, .

4) . C


34/104

P 34

(B, 2012, . 7). B

M J A G

(2012, .

3). T

. D G

:

T

. T

. T (G, 2012, . 5).

T,

. A C C A 1981

(B , 2012)

T (B,

2012, . 5). Y, G

(2012, . 8) . B

,

; M J T ,

(2012, . 7). T

. A,


35/104

P 35

L

C 2014. H, 2016,

(B, 2012, . 9). A

J B , .

T

. T

M J (B, 2012, . 5).

W

(G, 2011, . 82). T

J T ,

. A J T ,

. T

. T ;

(E & S, 2005, .77). N,

(O , 2008, .

6) .

T

,

, (G, 2007, .3)

T

. F, , ,


36/104

P 36

(R, 2011, . 12),

(H, 2012, . 7). M

(T , 2008, . 18) . M

. S

. I

(S, 2006, .116)

(G: P, 2011, . 12). A

.

(B, 2011, . 2). T

, (B, 2011, . 5 &

6). T

.

MC

(2011, . 8). I 2010

. T

,


37/104

P 37

(N , 2010, . 6). K P

: W

(N , 2010, . 9). T

(N , 2010, . 7). T

.

I T ,

, (C, 2008, .191). T

,

(R, 2011, . 10). P

.

I

(B, 2011, . 2). W J

F T D

(T, 2010, .6).

F J F , L C J

(D, 2011, . 15),


38/104

P 38

. I

(E & S, 2005, .752).

A, F

(R, 2011, . 7). L C J

,

(C, 2011, . 5),

(C, 2011, . 5). H,

,

(B, 2011, . 4).

T ; T D

. A D

,

(E &

S, 2005, .752). J

(T,

2010, .3)

(B, 2012, . 19). H

D. O I

(R, 2012, . 4). L C

J :

T

. I

(B, 2012, . 10: R, 2012, . 7).


39/104

P 39

D G

(B, 2011, . 11). T

. N,

. P

(T, 2010, .50) . S

(B, 2011, . 19) L MD QC,

(B, 2011, . 10). I

(R, 2011, . 16), ,

(C, 2011, . 6). I

(G, 2011, . 83)

,

. P

(R, 2011, . 13)

(B, 2011, . 12).

I D

G

(P, 2012, . 7). T

,


40/104


41/104

P 41

C

W C C A 1981

(E & S, 2005, .283). T

. A D G

(P, 2012, . 7),

,

. I

.

T C C

A 1981,

. A,

,

(B, 2011, . 8). W ,

, ,

,

(C, 2011, . 10)

T T

. T J B


42/104

P 42

(H, 2012, . 3). U ,

(L, 2011, . 1)

. T (R,

2011, . 14)

.

I , ,

(E & S, 2005, .230)

(C, 2010, .52). W

(E & S, 2005, .275)

(G,

2011, . 68). T

. F

,

(Y, 1981, .246)

(T, 2010, .36).

I , ,

(T, 2010, .50)

(E & S, 2005,

.54). D G

;


43/104

P 43

C C A

(R, 2011).

A,

(H, 2011, . 9 & 10)

. T

,

. L J M

:

T

,

(H,

2011, . 8).

F,

(E & S, 2005, .259)

,

. A

L C 2014,

(B, 2012, . 9).

I

, ,

. D ,

. T

(Y, 1981, .247)


44/104

P 44

, . F

C C

A 1981 . T

.

W C 10,923


45/104

P 45

A

A : A G T N L42

A : T .43

A : HM A B (N.2).44

A : I P G T C.45

A : .48

A : .56

A : A G A N L63

A : T .65


46/104

P 46

A

A

25 1973

C A

[1974 A.C. 273; [1973 3 W.L.R. 298; [1973 3 A E.R. 54; (1973) 117 S.J. 617

: C

: C ; I; P; P

: C; ;

A: T H L S

T

. P L R: A

,

,

. B ,

, : ,

. T D C , .

F ,

, ,

. T S T

. T D

C ,

. T A G D C

,

, . S,

P , D. T C A . T A G

H L.

H, ,

. (D C.A. ; R. H E . D (N.2) [1954

J: L R; L M BG; L D

R F 25, 2012, : W.


47/104

P 47

A

I

(E & S, 2005, 241). T ,

. C C

(C ,

2010, .162). O

(E & S, 2005, .99). T

. H

. T

,

, (B, H, 2000,

.429). A

.

I . T

(E & S, 2005,

.254). I ,

(E & S,

2005, .61).

I , C C A,

(C, 2010, .449). T

. A

(E & S, 2005, .232)


48/104

P 48

A

A B (.2)

C

21 2001

C A

2002 S.L.T. 139; 2001 S.C.C.R. 879; 2001 G.W.D. 341327

: A

: C; C ; P; S; T; W

: ; ; ; ;

S

A: B, S 2001 , ,

""

,

. T C

" " C C A 1981 .2(3)

.

H, , (1) "" .2(1)

, ,

""

.2(1); (2) " "

, (3)

.2(2)

. T D 1999,

B' ,

.

: L O

C: F HM A: T Q.C., AD AA E. F B: D F Q.C.,

VJ Y DAC Y.

: F HM A: AC N CB, C A. F B: K S,

SSC (L).

R M 02, 20120, : W


49/104

P 49

A

ACC AC: BA

CCA (C ) C

A A ACCA

1. T

.

2. T

, , ( T)

.

F

, , , .

3. A ,

. T J,

S S J, A G, D P

P, B C, L S, P C C,

S E

J .

4. P ,

, ,

,

. I

, ,

P D.

5. T ,

, :

. ,

. ( 41 C J A

1925); ,

.

( 9 C C A 1981).

. R 1,

2 4 C C A 1981

.

I .

G P

6. T

,

.


50/104


51/104

P 51

..,

,

, , T

. H, ;

,

, .

15. T :

. , ,

, ; ,

. ,

. T , ,

,

.

16. T

.

C 20 2010

R F 28, 2012, ://.../R/JCO/D/G/

20122010.


52/104

P 52

A

L B R

A

' '

.., 25 2008 15.31

A

A M P L B. P: PA

I L B,

" , ".

S ,

. B' , P J, "

".

B I, L, M 17 1968, B

. H , 2001 2004,

L M4 , M25.

D , B, W D, L, .

H 42, L J D B,

" "

.

B, 11 , "'

" . B ,

, . A ,

.

P F A D

A 19 2004 , , .

S CCTV F C D, ,

T G,

.

G O B , B

,

.


53/104

P 53

H ,

, : "I' , I'

."

T

D A M R T O 15 2001.

W , B ,

. W ,

: "Y' , ."

R, S, ID 2005

. S

.

I , B " O B".

B' I D, 33

S. O D 16 2003,

L V, H. S

.

B S G, B, . H

B :

"W ."

G D,

. H , , . B

, G .

B' ,

.

E.

A

B ''

.., 25 2008 15.32

A

CCTV A D 267 21:39 T

A 19 2004, . P: PA


54/104

P 54

O A 2004, A D

.

A , 22

T G.

T , A, F, L ,

T

. T .

B , A 19,

F C . CCTV ,

.

I , D' ,

, .

W , . S

,

.

T , , L B L 39

W D. I

.

H , ,

, , .

B M MD, 19 ,

D,

, . S

.

A F 2003 A 2004

17 22. A .

T L M4 M25 B ,

.

E M, ,

, T G,

D B' , A M

R, .

T L

, .


55/104

P 55

A ,

, . W B

""

, , .

U , B .U ,

, 14 16, . T , .

P ,

13 M D

M 21 2002.

S Y ,

, .

T E H, 34, T G A 16 2004; D B

H C N 2003; S S,

T G N 3 2002; 17

S H J 2003. A

B .

T , ,

. H ""

, .

D , D, . V

. S

.

V ,

.

N MD H, L, F 4

2003, D.

B V C CCTV 111 MD . T

.

T ""

, 18 K S,

. A M MD, B C

1,500 4,500 .

S,

, P

"", .


56/104

P 56

I ' .

B , , .

T ,

.

O , B .

E.

A

B

, 27 2008

A

L B, ,

" ", .

B, 39, ,

, A

D, 22, M MD, 19, , K

S, 21, .

H

, ,

.

H , W B QC, B

" " " ".

I ,

13 M D, 2002,

,

.

Y, D' , D,

, . I "

" . "I

A ...

S , ,

. S ."

A B O B , M J

R : "Y

."


57/104

P 57

T "!" .

B , S W,

I, .

T D C I C S, , " "

B' .

A , B .

S : "I ."

D' , JF, : "I' . H

,

."

MD' , S, : "F ...

. W

."

E.

A

B

B

.., 25 2008 15.54

A

M M D. P: S /PA

D M D

L B .

T B O B

F A D, 22, M

MD, 19 , K S, 18.

A D, M,

WT, S, M 21 2002.

T 13'

Y H, H, 30 .

S B

M N 2004.


58/104

P 58

D O B

D , O R.

B

. B M'

.

O

.

M M 21. A

, W, S.

W ,

.

F . T

57 L, 2005. I J 52 .

T 36 C,

M' , .

M' B S D

.

"S M

," . "H ? H

?"

"I ,

, . I

, ."

I 2005,

. "W

," .

"N M ,

, , '

.

"W M,

."

D 11,000

, B.

S D N

CCTV WT M .

I B' E M.


59/104

P 59

T D, 500,

M . P .

D , N503 GLT, ,

KLATF68V1SB554108, D .

I M H M .

D B' M .

H . B W

T, M' Y H.

T O B

. T : "W L B'

' .

"W , , . O

.

"W B'

."

T C W S A

CCTV U 4.33. F

,

.

D CCTV FBI ,

. T ,

S "", M

.

B J 2005

M' . B .

D , M'

M .

C M' , , .T

D M MD.

N M' . O

.

P H , N

.

T : "W M. I

." E


60/104

P 60

A

L B R

A

?

A

: 12 2011

LEVI B' EVIL "

".

K S

: "I . T B

I ."

V: B S K G O M

W L B

T , 21, : "I' . T

I I '

."

K, B TWICE,

O B.

S , : "I '

' .

"I ' . E . H

."

K B' "

".

S : "I

."

S B .

T

.

T

N 2004. I

A D' .

O : "L .


61/104

P 61

"H ."

I, B 100

.

M ... M MD

S MD, 19 M,

.

H M " ,

".

S, M' P, : "F ,

. T . I

."

S, 45, MD M' .

H : "N . T

A . I M'

."

M ... F A D

T F A, JF

D, B 22.

H D O B.

T : "I A

. S ,

. S ."

T : "W A

.

"A F ,

A , , .

"H . W ."

W B S W L,

.

T 20 M

F 5 2003, H.

M 14

.


62/104

P 62

S .

T B 18 K

W.

S A. K B' T P

.

W B . T

, ,

.

T B K, A

T.

T T G

.

B K A

. K 12.30 M 28 2004,

CCTV M 27.

D A' B'

T .

A M A, ,

. A .

A F C CCTV T

G A . T . O 129

.

O B' J C,

. D C I C S : "O

C ."

I

.

I I B W

D, H Q .

B, , . A

A' , . A

.

E.


63/104

P 63

A

' '

A

: 25 2008

BUS L B

.

H

20

.

T M D M 2002

WT

W.

I S

.

B B, L, ,

J L

J G P M.

M G H, L 20

1990. A M M, ,

H H L 14.

I L, B

.

T , , J

H

.

B ,

.

H 11 , 18,

13. H

. S, .

W ,

. T .

O B 13 .

O , "" .


64/104

P 64

H ""

.

T 20

. I , .

B , B

.

A

.

B

, " , , ".

"H . H ," B A.

A P R J

2004.

H , B

.

T W D

.

A B .

"H . H ," .

R B B 15 .

O B .

H : "I . S . H '

."

M B B ' ,

14 15.

"S . H I

."

P B

, , ,

.

T T P K S

. T

2004.


65/104

P 65

T N 2004, B

14 16 .

H , : "A ?" .

T 6 L .

H

T .

T

.

W , . I ,

"" .

A , B.

A B

.

B F R .

H : "W ...

18 , , . A

???? ... ."

E.

A

'' 12

A A

: 27 2008

DETECTIVES L B' 28

TWELVE.

C 14

P M, .

P'

.

H H H

F, M, .


66/104

P 66

S .

L P' N, 44, B, 39.

S : "W . I

. F . I . W

.

"P ."

P' G, 72, '

B.

H : "T , 'I' '. I

. I .

"H . I 12 13 ."

A G , : "I

. W ,

.

"W 28 , . I

."

A B, : "I

' , ."

E.


67/104

P 67

A

T, 22 N, 2011

A A ACA A

: LORD JUSTICE MOORE‑BICK MR JUSTICE BEAN

MR PERRY QC MR HALL C

MR J CAPLAN QC A N L

MS K GALLIFANT MGM L

CA

(A )

1. LORD JUSTICE MOOREBICK: T

M' A G

A N L, D M, MGM L,

D M, . T

D M D M 24

J 2011, 23 J 2011 L B

M D.

2. I , M J W, B

, R C. A 23 J ,

.

3. F B C

P S ,

,

. A ,

. T

D M D M, , B' . I D

M D M,

B . A

, M J W

.

4. T 2

D M, 1 D

M. I

. T

A G


68/104

P 68

B,

.

5. P

D C,

. I AG '

.

R F 26, 2012, : LN L.


69/104

P 69

A

:

J J F J S'

,

F

.., T 14 J 2011 15.50 BST

A

F J F ("J S") J S

3 A 2010:

18:31:36: S : S:

18:31:58: S : S:

18:33:35: S : S:

18:34:26: S : S: [

18:34:27: S : S:

18:34:40: S : S: [

18:34:57: S : S: /

18:35:40: S : S:

18:35:53: S : S:

18:36:46: S : S: [

18:36:56: S : S:

18:37:30: S : S:

18:37:52: S : S: [

18:38:11: S : S: ??

18:38:40: S : S:

18:38:52: S : S:


70/104

P 70

18:39:08: S : S: ?

18:39:35: S : S:

18:42:28: S : S:

4 0

18:43:37: S : S:

18:44:43: S : S:

18:45:19: S : S:

18:46:02: S : S:

18:47:05: S : S:

18:48:02: S : S: 2

18:48:54: S : S:

18:49:01: S : S:

18:49:39: S : S:

18:49:50: S : S: 2

18:50:52: S : S:

18:53:10: S : S:

18:53:34: S : S:

18:54:01: S : S:

18:54:31: S : S:

,

18:56:08: S : S: [

1

18:58:16: S : S:

18:59:49: S : S: ......

19:02:01: S : S:


71/104

P 71

19:02:19: S : S:

19:02:41: S : S:

19:02:52: S : S: '

19:03:38: S : S:

19:03:39: S : S:

19:04:03: S : S: (",)

19:04:18: S : S:

!

19:04:58: S : S:

19:06:19: S : S:

19:06:50: S : S:

19:07:05: S : S:

19:07:28: S : S:

E.


72/104

P 72

A G . (2011, J 05).

. R J 04, 2012, ://../

A G . (2011, J 07).

. R D 17, 2012,

://.../.?=47242

B, A. (2011, J 05). C

? . R F 15, 2012,

://...//2011//05/

?INTCMP=ILCNETTXT3487

B, D. (2011, A 10). W ? .

R N 15, 2011,

://...//2011//10/

B, D. (2011, N 11). H

? . R N 12, 2011,

://...//2011//11/

?INTCMP=SRCH

B, D. (2012, F 06). T J B . .

R F 10, 2012,

://...//2012//06/


73/104

P 73

B, D., & H, M. (2009). . O:

O U P.

B, E., & H, L. (2000). : . E: P

E L.

B, J. (2012). E , , 03 F. A :

://./#!/J7B (A 15 F 2012).

B, J. (2012). G , , 03 F. A :

://./#!/J7B (A 15 F 2012).

B, J. (2012). M C, , 03 F. A :

://./#!/J7B (A 15 F 2012).

B, J. (2012). R, , 03 F. A :

://./#!/J7B (A 15 F 2012).

B, J. (2012). T , , 03 F. A :

://./#!/J7B (A 15 F 2012).

B, J. (2012). T I , , 03 F. A :

://./#!/J7B (A 15 F 2012).

B, J. (2012). W , , 03 F. A :

://./#!/J7B (A 15 F 2012).

B [R . (2012, F 07).

. L: BBC R 4. R F 17, 2012,

://...////9693000/9693808.


74/104

P 74

B, D. (2008, F 25). B D .

. R F 16, 2012,

://...//2008//25/2?INTCMP=SRCH

B . (2012, J 19). .

R F 16, 2012, ://...//

16640560

B, S. (2011, N 01). T .

. R J 08, 2012,

://.../2011//

/

B, S. (2011, D 19). N .

. R F 17, 2012,

://.../2011//

/

B, O. (2011, S 26). T

. . R N 02, 2011,

://...//

/2011//26/

B, O. (2011, D 09). T

. . R F 06, 2012,

://...//2011//09/



75/104

P 75

B, O. (2012, J 23). J . .

R F 16, 2012,

://...//2012//23/

B, N. (2012, F 07). C: J B

. . R F 11, 2012,

://...//2012/02/

.

C, P., A, N., L, D., & Q. (2010). (5

.).

L: S & M.

C , . (2011, D 14).

. R J 14, 2012,

://.../2011//

/

C, D. (2011, J 14). J F . .

R J 24, 2012, ://...//13751454

C, L. (2008). B C. , 37 (185). R

D 21, 2011, ://..//37/3/185..+

C, C. (2011, J 16). F

. . R J 14, 2012, ://...//

13792080


76/104

P 76

C, K. (2011, J 09). D

. . R M 02, 2012,

://...//2011//09/

C, T., A, P., C, T., & O, E (E.). (2002). (4

.). O: F P.

C, T. (2010). . O: R.

D, J. (2011, J 16). F . .

R F 02, 2012,

://...//2011//16/

E D., & S, A. T. H. (2005). , (3

.).

L: S M.

E, C. (2011, S). T

. . R J 02, 2012,

://...//2011//11/

E (2012, F 03). J T: FA E [M 2..

M ://..//54951

/%2B+%2B1

F : T . (2011, J 14).

. R F 07, 2012,


77/104

P 77

://...//2011//14/

F, C., H, E., M, G., & W, D. (2006).

. L: SAGE P L.

F, J. C. (2005). : .

A: H H P, I.

G, C. (2011, D 01). G: C C A .

. R M 02, 2012,

://../2011/12/01//

G, S. (2007). :

. N Y: F P.

GG (2011, D 21) J T

F [M 4.. M

://..//53413

/%2B+%2B1

G, D., S, G., & W, I. (2009). . O:

O U P.

G (2011, O 26). C J T [M 22..

M ://...////3894227/C

JT.


78/104

P 78

G, D. (2011, D 01). A G: A B A 'C A

B A:

. . R D 21, 2012,

://.../NC/S/P/CA

.

G: P . (2011, D 02).

. R J 04, 2012,

://.../.?=1&=48382&=1

G, D. (2012, F 12). C .

. R F 19, 2012,

://...//2012//08/

?=239

G, B. (2003). . M: L E P.

H, J. (2011, M 03). S D M

. . R D 30, 2011,

://...//2011//03/

H, N. (2011, M 24). C .

. R J 12, 2012,

://.../2011//

/

H, A. (2011, J 25). L B : R C

' . . R F 18, 2012,


79/104

P 79

://...////8597461/LB

RC.

H, J. (2012, F 08). J B , .

. R F 10, 2012,

://...////

J, P. (2011, O 26). A F: J T . .

R F 05, 2012,

://.../////3894171/AF

JT.

J M (2012, F 04). J T: FA E [M 14..

M ://..//54951

/%2B+%2B1

J B J T . (2012, F 07). . R

F 10, 2012, ://...//16922612

J1234 (2011, O 26). A F: J T [M 2..

M

://.../////3894171/AF

JT.

J T A F . (2011, D 21).

. R F 12, 2012, ://...//

16284813


80/104

P 80

J F . (2011, J 14). .

R F 06, 2012, ://...//13751454

J T D . (2012, J 23). .

R F 16, 2012, ://...//

16676871

K J H. (2008, F 25). . R F 16,

2012, ://...////845069/K

JH.

L, H. (2011, M 14). R .

. R J 07, 2012,

://.../2011//

/

L, P. (2011, M 31). E T.

. R J 08, 2012,

://.../2011///

/

L, J. (2002). B C. I T. C, P. A, T. C & E.

O. (E.), (4

.). (. 89101). O: F P.

M (2011, O 26). A F: J T [M

30.. M

://.../////3894171/AF

JT.


81/104

P 81

MC, J. (2011, J 18). J F: G .

. R J 16, 2012,

://...////8583972/J

FG.

MN, B. (2011). M : UK . I G.

M & G. R. (E.), : (. 38

52). L: P M.

MV, K. (2008, F 25). B

. . R F 16, 2012,

://...//2008//25/.1?INTCMP=SRCH

MV, K. (2008, F 25). H . .

R F 16, 2012,

://...//2008//25/1?INTCMP=SRCH

MV, K. (2008, F 27). B .

. R F 16, 2012,

://...//2008//27/1?INTCMP=SRCH

M, G., & R, G. (E.). (2011). :

. L: P M.

M (2011, O 26). C J T [M 19..

M ://...////3894227/C

JT.


82/104

P 82

M, S. (2011, N 02). H I V T .

. R J 16, 2012,

://...//2011//02/

M7 (2011, O 26). C J T [M 13..

M ://...////3894227/C

JT.

N . (2010, M 24).

. R F 19, 2012,

://.../2010//

/

O (2008, S 23).

. R F 16, 2012,

://.../2008//

/

OS, G. (2011, O 26). C J T . .

R F 05, 2012,

://...////3894227/CJ

T.

O, E. (2002). N M. I T. C, P. A, T. C & E. O. (E.),

(4

.). (. 6579). O: F P.

P, A. (2010). . W S: W B.


83/104

P 83

P (2011, O 26). A F: J T [M 13..

M

://.../////3894171/AF

JT.

P . (2011, M 03). . R

M 04, 2012, ://...////

2231007.?=S

P, A. (2008, F 27). M 12. . R

F 16, 2012,

://...////851615/M

12LB.

P (2011, O 26). A F: J T [M 16..

M

://.../////3894171/AF

JT.

P, J. (2011, M 15). K C .

. R A 01, 2011,

://...//2011//15/

?INTCMP=SRCH

P, P. (2011, J 02). J Y

. . R F 11, 2012,


84/104

P 84

://...//2011//02/

P, A. (2012, J 24). J S .

. R F 12, 2012,

://.../.?=1&=48622&=1

P, A. (2012, J 25). T R .

. R F 12, 2012,

://.../.?=1&=48623&=1

Q, F. (2011). (3

.). E: P E L.

Q, S., & L, S. (2008). :

. O: F P.

R, D., L, S., & F, F. (2005). :

(2

.). M: L E A, I.,

P.

R, G., & N A. (2002). (4

.). L: S M.

R, J. (P). (2011). C C P V [R

. I S, C (P), . L: BBC R 4.

R A 04, 2011, ://...//0061

R, J. (2011, F 09). T T ,

. . R J 15, 2012,

://...//2011//09/


85/104

P 85

R, J. (2011, J 15). F .

. R J 14, 2012,

://...///2011//15/

R, J. (2012, J 24). T D: I .

. R F 17, 2012,

://...//2012//24/

S (2011, O 26). C J T [M 23..

M ://...////3894227/C

JT.

S, U. (2006). . L: SAGE P L.

S, A. (2010). . S:

G P L.

S, S. (2000). . L: C P L.

S, M. (2008, F 26). H L? . R

F 16, 2012,

://...////846156/LBH

BSK.

S D M . (2011, M 03). .

R D 04, 2012, ://...//

12632587


86/104


87/104

P 87

W, D. G. T. (1973, N). C T C

[E . , 32(2), 177181.

W (2011, D 21) J T F

[M 7.. M

://..//53413

/%2B+%2B1

Y, J. (1981). T C C A 1981 [E .

, 8(2), 243255.


88/104

P 88

B

A G . (2011, J 05).

. R J 04, 2012, ://../

A G . (2011, J 07).

. R D 17, 2012,

://.../.?=47242

B, A. (2011, J 05). C

? . R F 15, 2012,

://...//2011//05/


B, D. (2011, A 10). W ? .

R N 15, 2011,

://...//2011//10/

B, D. (2011, N 11). H

? . R N 12, 2011,

://...//2011//11/

?INTCMP=SRCH

B, D. (2012, F 06). T J B . .

R F 10, 2012,

://...//2012//06/


89/104

P 89

B, D., & H, M. (2009). . O:

O U P.

B, E., & H, L. (2000). : . E: P

E L.

B, J. (2012). E , , 03 F. A :

://./#!/J7B (A 15 F 2012).

B, J. (2012). G , , 03 F. A :

://./#!/J7B (A 15 F 2012).

B, J. (2012). M C, , 03 F. A :

://./#!/J7B (A 15 F 2012).

B, J. (2012). R, , 03 F. A :

://./#!/J7B (A 15 F 2012).

B, J. (2012). T , , 03 F. A :

://./#!/J7B (A 15 F 2012).

B, J. (2012). T I , , 03 F. A :

://./#!/J7B (A 15 F 2012).

B, J. (2012). W , , 03 F. A :

://./#!/J7B (A 15 F 2012).

B [R . (2012, F 07).

. L: BBC R 4. R F 17, 2012,

://...////9693000/9693808.


90/104

P 90

B, D. (2008, F 25). B D .

. R F 16, 2012,

://...//2008//25/2?INTCMP=SRCH

B . (2012, J 19). .

R F 16, 2012, ://...//

16640560

B, S. (2011, N 01). T .

. R J 08, 2012,

://.../2011//

/

B, S. (2011, D 19). N .

. R F 17, 2012,

://.../2011//

/

B, O. (2011, S 26). T

. . R N 02, 2011,

://...//

/2011//26/

B, O. (2011, D 09). T

. . R F 06, 2012,

://...//2011//09/



91/104

P 91

B, O. (2012, J 23). J . .

R F 16, 2012,

://...//2012//23/

B, N. (2012, F 07). C: J B

. . R F 11, 2012,

://...//2012/02/

.

C, R., & J, H. (2008). (2

.).

O: O U P.

C, D, (2011, J 26). C

. . R F 24, 2012,

://...//2011//26/

?=239

C, P., A, N., L, D., & Q. (2010). (5

.).

L: S & M.

C , . (2011, D 14).

. R J 14, 2012,

://.../2011//

/

C, D. (2011, J 14). J F . .

R J 24, 2012, ://...//13751454


92/104

P 92

C, L. (2008). B C. , 37 (185). R

D 21, 2011, ://..//37/3/185..+

C, C. (2011, J 16). F

. . R J 14, 2012, ://...//

13792080

C, K. (2011, J 09). D

. . R M 02, 2012,

://...//2011//09/

C, T., A, P., C, T., & O, E (E.). (2002). (4

.). O: F P.

C, T. (2010). . O: R.

D, J. (2011, J 16). F . .

R F 02, 2012,

://...//2011//16/

E D., & S, A. T. H. (2005). , (3

.).

L: S M.

E, C. (2011, S). T

. . R J 02, 2012,

://...//2011//11/


93/104

P 93

E (2012, F 03). J T: FA E [M 2..

M ://..//54951

/%2B+%2B1

F : T . (2011, J 14).

. R F 07, 2012,

://...//2011//14/

F, C., H, E., M, G., & W, D. (2006).

. L: SAGE P L.

F, J. C. (2005). : .

A: H H P, I.

G, C. (2011, D 01). G: C C A .

. R M 02, 2012,

://../2011/12/01//

G, S. (2007). :

. N Y: F P.

GG (2011, D 21) J T

F [M 4.. M

://..//53413

/%2B+%2B1


94/104

P 94

G, D., S, G., & W, I. (2009). . O:

O U P.

G (2011, O 26). C J T [M 22..

M ://...////3894227/C

JT.

G, L. (2010). . O: B P L.

G, D. (2011, D 01). A G: A B A 'C A

B A:

. . R D 21, 2012,

://.../NC/S/P/CA

.

G: P . (2011, D 02).

. R J 04, 2012,

://.../.?=1&=48382&=1

G, D. (2012, F 12). C .

. R F 19, 2012,

://...//2012//08/

?=239

G, B. (2003). . M: L E P.


95/104

P 95

H, J. (2011, M 03). S D M

. . R D 30, 2011,

://...//2011//03/

H, N. (2011, M 24). C .

. R J 12, 2012,

://.../2011//

/

H, D., & R, J. (2006). . E: P E

L.

H, A. (2011, J 25). L B : R C

' . . R F 18, 2012,

://...////8597461/LB

RC.

H, J. (2012, F 08). J B , .

. R F 10, 2012,

://...////

J, P. (2011, O 26). A F: J T . .

R F 05, 2012,

://.../////3894171/AF

JT.


96/104

P 96

J M (2012, F 04). J T: FA E [M 14..

M ://..//54951

/%2B+%2B1

J B J T . (2012, F 07). . R

F 10, 2012, ://...//16922612

J1234 (2011, O 26). A F: J T [M 2..

M

://.../////3894171/AF

JT.

J T A F . (2011, D 21).

. R F 12, 2012, ://...//

16284813

J F . (2011, J 14). .

R F 06, 2012, ://...//13751454

J T D . (2012, J 23). .

R F 16, 2012, ://...//

16676871

K J H. (2008, F 25). . R F 16,

2012, ://...////845069/K

JH.


97/104

P 97

L, H. (2011, M 14). R .

. R J 07, 2012,

://.../2011//

/

L, P. (2011, M 31). E T.

. R J 08, 2012,

://.../2011///

/

L, J. (2002). B C. I T. C, P. A, T. C & E.

O. (E.), (4

.). (. 89101). O: F P.

M (2011, O 26). A F: J T [M

30.. M

://.../////3894171/AF

JT.

MC, J. (2011, J 18). J F: G .

. R J 16, 2012,

://...////8583972/J

FG.

MK, A. (2006). . L: S P L.

MN, B. (2011). M : UK . I G.

M & G. R. (E.), : (. 38

52). L: P M.


98/104

P 98

MV, K. (2008, F 25). B

. . R F 16, 2012,

://...//2008//25/.1?INTCMP=SRCH

MV, K. (2008, F 25). H . .

R F 16, 2012,

://...//2008//25/1?INTCMP=SRCH

MV, K. (2008, F 27). B .

. R F 16, 2012,

://...//2008//27/1?INTCMP=SRCH

M, G., & R, G. (E.). (2011). :

. L: P M.

M (2011, O 26). C J T [M 19..

M ://...////3894227/C

JT.

M, C. J. (2000). (3

.). O: O U P.

M, S. (2011, N 02). H I V T .

. R J 16, 2012,

://...//2011//02/

M7 (2011, O 26). C J T [M 13..

M ://...////3894227/C

JT.


99/104

P 99

N . (2010, M 24).

. R F 19, 2012,

://.../2010//

/

O (2008, S 23).

. R F 16, 2012,

://.../2008//

/

OS, G. (2011, O 26). C J T . .

R F 05, 2012,

://...////3894227/CJ

T.

O, E. (2002). N M. I T. C, P. A, T. C & E. O. (E.),

(4

.). (. 6579). O: F P.

P, A. (2010). . W S: W B.

P (2011, O 26). A F: J T [M 13..

M

://.../////3894171/AF

JT.

P . (2011, M 03). . R

M 04, 2012, ://...////

2231007.?=S


100/104

P 100

P, A. (2008, F 27). M 12. . R

F 16, 2012,

://...////851615/M

12LB.

P (2011, O 26). A F: J T [M 16..

M

://.../////3894171/AF

JT.

P, J. (2011, M 15). K C .

. R A 01, 2011,

://...//2011//15/

?INTCMP=SRCH

P, P. (2011, J 02). J Y

. T O. R F 11, 2012,

://...//2011//02/

P, A. (2012, J 24). J S .

. R F 12, 2012,

://.../.?=1&=48622&=1

P, A. (2012, J 25). T R .

. R F 12, 2012,

://.../.?=1&=48623&=1


101/104

P 101

Q, F. (2011). (3

.). E: P E L.

Q, S., & L, S. (2008). :

. O: F P.

R, D., L, S., & F, F. (2005). :

(2

.). M: L E A, I.,

P.

R, G., & N A. (2002). (4

.). L: S M.

R, J. (P). (2011). C C P V [R

. I S, C (P), . L: BBC R 4.

R A 04, 2011, ://...//0061

R, J. (2011, F 09). T T ,

. . R J 15, 2012,

://...//2011//09/

R, J. (2011, J 15). F .

. R J 14, 2012,

://...///2011//15/

R, J. (2012, J 24). T D: I .

. R F 17, 2012,

://...//2012//24/


102/104

P 102

S (2011, O 26). C J T [M 23..

M ://...////3894227/C

JT.

S, U. (2006). . L: SAGE P L.

S, A. (2010). . S:

G P L.

S, S. (2000). . L: C P L.

S, M. (2008, F 26). H L? . R

F 16, 2012,

://...////846156/LBH

BSK.

S D M . (2011, M 03). .

R D 04, 2012, ://...//

12632587

T L C: W ? (2008,

A 25). . R F 18, 2012,

://.../2008//

/

T, C. (2010, F 17). A J F? ,

1(10). R J 15, 2012,

://...///.


103/104

P 103

T (2011, O 26). C J T [M 7..

M ://...////3894227/C

JT.

T (2011, O 26). C J T [M 2.. M

://...////3894227/C

JT.

T . (2010. N 19). . R

F 19, 2012,

://...///8146678/T

.

W, A. (2011, M 07). A : T

. . R M 01, 2012,

://./2011/03/07/

/

W, D. G. T. (1973, N). C T C

[E . , 32(2), 177181.

W (2011, D 21) J T F

[M 7.. M

://..//53413

/%2B+%2B1

Y, J. (1981). T C C A 1981 [E .

, 8(2), 243255.


104/104

A A

I

.

S..................................................................

Contempt by publication under the Contempt of Court Act 1981

Documents

Transcript of Contempt by publication under the Contempt of Court Act 1981