Consideration of a Target Network for Advanced Laser Light ... · Network for TARGET SUPPLY and HRR...

25
Dr. Irene Prencipe| Institute of Radiation Physics| www.hzdr.de Consideration of a Target Network for Advanced Laser Light Sources I. Prencipe, M. Cernaianu, G. Fiquet, J. Fuchs, Z. Konopkova, P. Lutoslawski, D. Margarone, S. Pascarelli, D. Schumacher, B. Schramm, R. Stephens, M. Tolley, T. Tschentscher, T. Cowan This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 654220

Transcript of Consideration of a Target Network for Advanced Laser Light ... · Network for TARGET SUPPLY and HRR...

Page 1: Consideration of a Target Network for Advanced Laser Light ... · Network for TARGET SUPPLY and HRR ISSUES identified as FORESIGHT ACTIVITY by the European Cluster of Advanced Laser

Dr. Irene Prencipe| Institute of Radiation Physics| www.hzdr.de

Consideration of a Target Network for Advanced Laser Light Sources

I. Prencipe, M. Cernaianu, G. Fiquet, J. Fuchs, Z. Konopkova, P. Lutoslawski, D. Margarone, S. Pascarelli, D. Schumacher, B. Schramm, R. Stephens, M. Tolley, T. Tschentscher, T. Cowan

This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 654220

Page 2: Consideration of a Target Network for Advanced Laser Light ... · Network for TARGET SUPPLY and HRR ISSUES identified as FORESIGHT ACTIVITY by the European Cluster of Advanced Laser

Page 2

Dr. Irene Prencipe| Institute of Radiation Physics| www.hzdr.de 2

efficient use of HIGH POWER LASERS

at MAJOR X-RAY USER FACILITIES

HIBEF UC HPLF

realization of the promise of the

EXTREME LIGHT INFRASTRUCTURE

Upcoming Advanced Laser Facilities

Emerging demands for high repetition-rate target delivery

access to national and international

LASER FACILITIES

Page 3: Consideration of a Target Network for Advanced Laser Light ... · Network for TARGET SUPPLY and HRR ISSUES identified as FORESIGHT ACTIVITY by the European Cluster of Advanced Laser

Page 3

Dr. Irene Prencipe| Institute of Radiation Physics| www.hzdr.de 3

LONG TERM DEVELOPMENT OF THE USER COMMUNITY

lower the barriers-to-entry for new users/small groups

exploit synergies between European and national laser facilities

promote innovation, education & training

Upcoming Advanced Laser Facilities

Emerging demands for high repetition-rate target delivery

GOALS

development of a SUSTAINABLE

TARGET SUPPLY mechanism

1 Hz = 3600 targets/hour

enabling operation at

HIGH REPETITION RATE (HRR)

0.1 – 10 Hz

MAIN ISSUES

Page 4: Consideration of a Target Network for Advanced Laser Light ... · Network for TARGET SUPPLY and HRR ISSUES identified as FORESIGHT ACTIVITY by the European Cluster of Advanced Laser

Page 4

Dr. Irene Prencipe| Institute of Radiation Physics| www.hzdr.de 4

Challenge: how do we deal with target supply and HRR issues?

EUCALL SATELLITE WORKSHOP

Dresden, August 29-31, 2016

90 participants

I. Prencipe, M. Cernaianu, T. Cowan, G. Fiquet, Z. Konopkova, P. Lutoslawski, D. Margarone, S. Pascarelli, M. Tolley

ASSESSMENT of

the CURRENT STATUS

DISCUSSION of

a COORDINATED STRATEGY

Page 5: Consideration of a Target Network for Advanced Laser Light ... · Network for TARGET SUPPLY and HRR ISSUES identified as FORESIGHT ACTIVITY by the European Cluster of Advanced Laser

Page 5

Dr. Irene Prencipe| Institute of Radiation Physics| www.hzdr.de 5

Network for TARGET SUPPLY and HRR ISSUES

identified as FORESIGHT ACTIVITY

by the European Cluster of Advanced Laser Light Sources

First consequence

of the workshop

Challenge: how do we deal with target supply and HRR issues?

EUCALL SATELLITE WORKSHOP

Dresden, August 29-31, 2016

90 participants

I. Prencipe, M. Cernaianu, T. Cowan, G. Fiquet, Z. Konopkova, P. Lutoslawski, D. Margarone, S. Pascarelli, M. Tolley

Page 6: Consideration of a Target Network for Advanced Laser Light ... · Network for TARGET SUPPLY and HRR ISSUES identified as FORESIGHT ACTIVITY by the European Cluster of Advanced Laser

Page 6

Dr. Irene Prencipe| Institute of Radiation Physics| www.hzdr.de 6

DISCUSSION of

a COORDINATED STRATEGY

Challenge: how do we deal with target supply and HRR issues?

EUCALL SATELLITE WORKSHOP

Dresden, August 29-31, 2016

90 participants

I. Prencipe, M. Cernaianu, T. Cowan, G. Fiquet, Z. Konopkova, P. Lutoslawski, D. Margarone, S. Pascarelli, M. Tolley

ASSESSMENT of

the CURRENT STATUS

Page 7: Consideration of a Target Network for Advanced Laser Light ... · Network for TARGET SUPPLY and HRR ISSUES identified as FORESIGHT ACTIVITY by the European Cluster of Advanced Laser

Page 7

Dr. Irene Prencipe| Institute of Radiation Physics| www.hzdr.de 7

Target needs

TARGET = CONSUMABLE

UPCOMING FACILITIES

Increased availability/accessibility

high repetition rates

(1 Hz = 3600 targets/hour)

TARGET DESIGN

on the basis of

physical phenomenon

experimental configuration

(laser properties, diagnostics)

TARGET PROPERTIES

affect strongly the laser-matter

interaction process

huge variety

of possible target configurations

(often complex)

production

controllable and reproducible

characterization

density, thickness, crystalline

structure, surface quality

demand for

a large number of targets

mass production or rapid prototyping?

+

issues related to repetitive irradiation

Page 8: Consideration of a Target Network for Advanced Laser Light ... · Network for TARGET SUPPLY and HRR ISSUES identified as FORESIGHT ACTIVITY by the European Cluster of Advanced Laser

Page 8

Dr. Irene Prencipe| Institute of Radiation Physics| www.hzdr.de 8

Target needs

Laser-driven particle and radiation sources

Julien Fuchs

Target needs

Solid targets: multi-layer, structured, controlled/near

critical density, surface patterns, 3D shapes, multiple

targets

Gas jets and cells (need modeling)

Droplets (need stabilization)

Liquid crystals (no high Z)

Cryogenic (thickness, shape)

HRR PRODUCTION of PARTICLE and RADIATION

BEAMS for APPLICATIONS

Page 9: Consideration of a Target Network for Advanced Laser Light ... · Network for TARGET SUPPLY and HRR ISSUES identified as FORESIGHT ACTIVITY by the European Cluster of Advanced Laser

Page 9

Dr. Irene Prencipe| Institute of Radiation Physics| www.hzdr.de 9

Target needs

Shock-compression phyisics

Sakura Pascarelli

Target needs: multilayer targets, layer characterization!

1-200 µm

Ab

lato

r

Pu

she

r

Pu

she

r

Sample Window

HRR MATERIALS WITH POOR SCATTERING PROPERTIES

(low Z; liquids…)

BETTER

MODELING

User-friendly

HIDRODYNAMIC

CODES

EXPERIMENT AND TARGET DESIGN

Page 10: Consideration of a Target Network for Advanced Laser Light ... · Network for TARGET SUPPLY and HRR ISSUES identified as FORESIGHT ACTIVITY by the European Cluster of Advanced Laser

Page 10

Dr. Irene Prencipe| Institute of Radiation Physics| www.hzdr.de 10

Target needs

2D: multilayer, buried structures and wafer based (RMT, gratings...)

3D: cones, spheres (precise geometry constraints)

Multi-target configurations

Target needs

Electron transport and isochoric heating

Richard Stephens

HRR STUDY OF SMALL EFFECTS (large shot to shot variations)

Page 11: Consideration of a Target Network for Advanced Laser Light ... · Network for TARGET SUPPLY and HRR ISSUES identified as FORESIGHT ACTIVITY by the European Cluster of Advanced Laser

Page 11

Dr. Irene Prencipe| Institute of Radiation Physics| www.hzdr.de 11

High repetition rate challenges

Fast target positioning and alignment

Douglass Schumacher

EUCALL HIREP High Repetition Rate Sample Delivery

Prototype of a target positioning and alignent system

INTEGRATED SOFTWARE

Sample identification

and alignment

INTEGRATED SETUP

Holder, stages, UHV microscope

(EMP resistent, low activation,

thermal loads)

This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 654220

D. Margarone, J. Schulz

Page 12: Consideration of a Target Network for Advanced Laser Light ... · Network for TARGET SUPPLY and HRR ISSUES identified as FORESIGHT ACTIVITY by the European Cluster of Advanced Laser

Page 12

Dr. Irene Prencipe| Institute of Radiation Physics| www.hzdr.de 12

High repetition rate challenges

Collateral issues

Douglass Schumacher

DEBRIS

Vaporized material

Shrapnel

Study case

Page 13: Consideration of a Target Network for Advanced Laser Light ... · Network for TARGET SUPPLY and HRR ISSUES identified as FORESIGHT ACTIVITY by the European Cluster of Advanced Laser

Page 13

Dr. Irene Prencipe| Institute of Radiation Physics| www.hzdr.de 13

High repetition rate challenges

Collateral issues

Douglass Schumacher

DEBRIS

Vaporized material

Shrapnel

Membrane

not enough:

shrapnel can break it

Study case

Page 14: Consideration of a Target Network for Advanced Laser Light ... · Network for TARGET SUPPLY and HRR ISSUES identified as FORESIGHT ACTIVITY by the European Cluster of Advanced Laser

Page 14

Dr. Irene Prencipe| Institute of Radiation Physics| www.hzdr.de 14

High repetition rate challenges

Collateral issues

Douglass Schumacher

DEBRIS

Vaporized material

Shrapnel

E-field

guiding

Membrane

Renewable plasma mirrors

(liquid crystals)

Renewable mirrors

(liquid Hg/Ga)

STRONG DEPENDENCE ON THE

EXPERIMENTAL CONFIGURATION

PARTIAL SOLUTIONS AVAILABLE

BUT STRESSED AT HRR

TOOL KIT

better than single solution

Reduced

mass targets

Study case

Page 15: Consideration of a Target Network for Advanced Laser Light ... · Network for TARGET SUPPLY and HRR ISSUES identified as FORESIGHT ACTIVITY by the European Cluster of Advanced Laser

Page 15

Dr. Irene Prencipe| Institute of Radiation Physics| www.hzdr.de 15

High repetition rate challenges

Collateral issues

Douglass Schumacher

ELECTROMAGNETIC

PULSES

DAMAGE OF NEARBY

TARGETS

PLASMA DAMAGE and

ACTIVATION OF THE

HOLDER FRAME

THERMAL LOADS TARGET

BACKREFLECTONS

AND SCATTER

ONLINE CHARACTERIZATION

X-RAY + OPTICAL LASER

ADDITIONAL ISSUES?

DEBRIS

STRONG DEPENDENCE ON THE

EXPERIMENTAL CONFIGURATION

PARTIAL SOLUTIONS AVAILABLE

BUT STRESSED AT HRR

TOOL KIT

better than single solution

Page 16: Consideration of a Target Network for Advanced Laser Light ... · Network for TARGET SUPPLY and HRR ISSUES identified as FORESIGHT ACTIVITY by the European Cluster of Advanced Laser

Page 16

Dr. Irene Prencipe| Institute of Radiation Physics| www.hzdr.de 16

ASSESSMENT of

the CURRENT STATUS

Challenge: how do we deal with target supply and HRR issues?

EUCALL SATELLITE WORKSHOP

Dresden, August 29-31, 2016

90 participants

I. Prencipe, M. Cernaianu, T. Cowan, G. Fiquet, Z. Konopkova, P. Lutoslawski, D. Margarone, S. Pascarelli, M. Tolley

DISCUSSION of

a COORDINATED STRATEGY

Page 17: Consideration of a Target Network for Advanced Laser Light ... · Network for TARGET SUPPLY and HRR ISSUES identified as FORESIGHT ACTIVITY by the European Cluster of Advanced Laser

Page 17

Dr. Irene Prencipe| Institute of Radiation Physics| www.hzdr.de 17

A coordinated strategy for target supply

Possible synergy levels

BILATERAL

COLLABORATIONS In-kind contributions, co-authorship,

know-how sharing

WORKSHOPS

BILATERAL FUNDING SCHEMES

TARGET CATALOGUE

USER CONSORTIUM

CONTRIBUTIONS Target supply = service to users

ESRF Long Term Proposals

HIBEF User Consortium

Page 18: Consideration of a Target Network for Advanced Laser Light ... · Network for TARGET SUPPLY and HRR ISSUES identified as FORESIGHT ACTIVITY by the European Cluster of Advanced Laser

Page 18

Dr. Irene Prencipe| Institute of Radiation Physics| www.hzdr.de 18

A coordinated strategy for target supply

Possible synergy levels

INTEGRATED

NETWORK JOINT RESEARCH ACTIVITIES

USERS

USER

FACILITIES

SUPPLIERS TARGET FAB,

UNIVERSITY,

MATERIAL

SCIENCE

SUPPORT PARTNERS IN GRANT WRITING

SUSTAINABLE TARGET SUPPLY

TRAINING OF TARGET EXPERTS

BUDGET for TARGET DEVELOPMENT

SUPPORT USERS IN TARGET DESIGN

Page 19: Consideration of a Target Network for Advanced Laser Light ... · Network for TARGET SUPPLY and HRR ISSUES identified as FORESIGHT ACTIVITY by the European Cluster of Advanced Laser

Page 19

Dr. Irene Prencipe| Institute of Radiation Physics| www.hzdr.de 19

A Target Network for Advanced Laser Sources

Next steps

EXPERT PANEL NETWORK SCOPE AND STRUCTURE

FUNDING SCHEME

ACCESS MODELS

FUNDING STRATEGY EU LOBBYING for an APPROPRIATE CALL in

H2020 2018-2019 (perfect timing)

INFRASTRUCTURE CALL

Transnational Access to a VIRTUAL TARGET LAB?

FUTURE AND EMERGING TECHNOLOGIES?

FACTORIES OF THE FUTURE?

INNOVATIVE TRAINING NETWORK

Page 20: Consideration of a Target Network for Advanced Laser Light ... · Network for TARGET SUPPLY and HRR ISSUES identified as FORESIGHT ACTIVITY by the European Cluster of Advanced Laser

Page 20

Dr. Irene Prencipe| Institute of Radiation Physics| www.hzdr.de 20

3 PILLARS

Trans-national access to a pool of research infrastructures

Joint research activities to improve the service to users

Networking activities (workshops/trainings...)

Up to 10 M€ which also cover user access costs!

VIRTUAL ACCESS

to TARGET FABRICATION/CHARACTERIZATION LABORATORIES

(instrumentation/manpower/know-how)

if possible free of charge

Lobbying for an appropriate call:

2018-2019 – EUROPEAN RESEARCH INFRASTRUCTURES

A Target Network for Advanced Laser Sources

Transnational/Virtual Access Network

Page 21: Consideration of a Target Network for Advanced Laser Light ... · Network for TARGET SUPPLY and HRR ISSUES identified as FORESIGHT ACTIVITY by the European Cluster of Advanced Laser

Page 21

Dr. Irene Prencipe| Institute of Radiation Physics| www.hzdr.de 21

A Target Network for Advanced Laser Sources

Next steps

EXPERT PANEL NETWORK SCOPE AND STRUCTURE

FUNDING SCHEME

ACCESS MODELS

AWARENESS about target related issues

support partners in GRANT WRITING

support for EU LOBBYING

WHITE BOOK

FUNDING STRATEGY EU LOBBYING for an APPROPRIATE CALL in

H2020 2018-2019

INFRASTRUCTURE CALL

Transnational Access to a VIRTUAL TARGET LAB?

FUTURE AND EMERGING TECHNOLOGIES?

FACTORIES OF THE FUTURE?

INNOVATIVE TRAINING NETWORK

Page 22: Consideration of a Target Network for Advanced Laser Light ... · Network for TARGET SUPPLY and HRR ISSUES identified as FORESIGHT ACTIVITY by the European Cluster of Advanced Laser

Page 22

Dr. Irene Prencipe| Institute of Radiation Physics| www.hzdr.de 22

A Target Network for Advanced Laser Sources

White book contents

Scopes and goals

Research at advanced laser-light sources

Laser-matter physics: research and applications

Advanced laser-light sources

The role of targets

Targets for high-power laser experiments

Target needs

Target fabrication: state of the art

High-repetition rate challenges

Targeting the future: coordinated strategies

Strategies

Investigation of the potential of a target network for advanced laser-light sources

Next actions

List of endorsing partners

Page 23: Consideration of a Target Network for Advanced Laser Light ... · Network for TARGET SUPPLY and HRR ISSUES identified as FORESIGHT ACTIVITY by the European Cluster of Advanced Laser

Page 23

Dr. Irene Prencipe| Institute of Radiation Physics| www.hzdr.de 23

A Target Network for Advanced Laser Sources

Conclusions

MESSAGE

We need to be AWARE of

TARGET RELATED ISSUES

We can WORK TOGETHER to address them

STRATEGY

COORDINATION

Not to duplicate efforts

Better chance of increasing funding

OPEN TO CONTRIBUTIONS!!!

Page 24: Consideration of a Target Network for Advanced Laser Light ... · Network for TARGET SUPPLY and HRR ISSUES identified as FORESIGHT ACTIVITY by the European Cluster of Advanced Laser

Page 24

Dr. Irene Prencipe| Institute of Radiation Physics| www.hzdr.de 24

Acknowledgements

ORGANIZING COMMITTEE

M. Cernaianu, T. Cowan, G. Fiquet, Z. Konopkova, P. Lutoslawski, D. Margarone, S.

Pascarelli, M. Tolley

PANEL LEADERS

J. Fuchs, S. Pascarelli, D. Schumacher, R. Stephens, T. Tschentscher

HZDR

B. Schramm, J. Fassbender, U. Schramm, J von Borany, J. Grenzer, A. Erbe, B. Gross,

D. Kraus, N. Hartley, J. Metzkes, T. Kluge, S. Vellguth, M. Rödel, A. Laso Garcia, M.

Molodtsova, A. Ferrari, A. Pelka…

EUCALL HIREP

D. Margarone, J. Schultz, R. Appio, M. Cernaianu, C. Deiter, J. Dreyer, M. Gugiu, A.

Meents, A. Pelka, T. Ursby, T. Wiste

This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 654220

Page 25: Consideration of a Target Network for Advanced Laser Light ... · Network for TARGET SUPPLY and HRR ISSUES identified as FORESIGHT ACTIVITY by the European Cluster of Advanced Laser

Page 25

Dr. Irene Prencipe| Institute of Radiation Physics| www.hzdr.de 25

for any information, don’t hesitate to contact [email protected]

This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 654220