Conrad Murray Appeal 04/22/13

7/30/2019 Conrad Murray Appeal 04/22/13

1/253

BF ]DG EKWZ] KC NXXGNA KC ]DG U]N]G ENABCKZFBN

UGEKFM NXXGAAN]G MBU]ZBE]! MBSBUBKF UGSGF

]DG XGKXAG KC ]DG U]N]G KC ENABCKZFBN! Fk& J:5?3??

Xanbftbcc nfm Zgspkfmgft!

v&

EKFZNM ZKJGZ] LWZZNR!

Mgcgfmnft nfm Nppgaanft&

Aks Nfogags Ekufty Uupgrbkr Ekurt Fk& UN8?5>3=

]dg Dkfkrnjag Lbednga Xnstkr! @umog

NXXGAANF]U KXGFBFO JZBGC

Snagrbg O& _nss

Nttkrfgy nt Anw

Utntg Jnr Fk& >88==7

erblnppgnasHolnba&ekl

773 U& Cnbr Knis Nvg&! Uubtg 2

Xnsnmgfn! EN 2>>87

$3:3" ?2?,>822

Ekufsga ckr NppgaanftEKFZNM ZKJGZ] LWZZNR


2/253

b

]NJAG KC EKF]GF]UXnog

]NJAG KC NW]DKZB]BGU & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & xbbb

NXXGAANF]U KXGFBFO JZBGC & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >

U]N]GLGF] KC NXXGNANJBAB]R & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >

U]N]GLGF] KC ]DG ENUG & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & :

U]N]GLGF] KC CNE]U & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 5

Xrksgeutbkf Ensg & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 5

Lbednga @neiskfs Zgsbmgfeg # Utncc & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 5

@neiskfs ]dbs Bs Bt ]kur& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 5

Nppgaanft _ns Dbrgm Ns @neiskfs Xgrskfna

Xdysbebnf & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & =

]kur Zgdgnrsnas # Ekfegrf Njkut @neiskf & & & & & & & & & & & & & 7

]dg Gvgfts kc @ufg :7td & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ?

@ufg :7td Ugnred kc Enrkawkkm & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >=

@ufg :3td Ugnred kc Enrkawkkm & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >?

Nppgaanfts Xkabeg Bftgrvbgw & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >?

@ufg :2td Ugnred kc Enrkawkkm & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & :7

Nppgaanfts Lgmbena Xrnetbegs & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & :?

Nppgaanfts Obracrbgfm , Fbekag Navnrgz & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & :4

Nppgaanfts Mruo # Lgmbena Uuppay Krmgrs bf

:882 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & :4

Nppgaanfts Xdkfg Zgekrms Crkl @ufg :7td & & & & & & & & & & & :2

Nppgaanfts Egaa Xdkfgs _grg Zgekvgrgm & & & & & & & & & & & & & 58


3/253

bb


]dg Lny >8! :882 b]nai Zgekrmbfo & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 58

Ugnredgs kc Nppgaanfts Sgdbeag! Zgsbmgfegs!Kccbegs # Utkrnog Wfbts & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 5:

]dg Nutkpsy & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 5:

]kxbekakoy Zgsuats & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 5=

Cbfogrprbft Gvbmgfeg & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 54

Gxpgrt Lgmbena ]gstblkfy & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 54

Gxpgrt Kpbfbkfs rg Ugac,Nmlbfbstrntbkf kc Mruos

Jy @neiskf & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 7:

Mgcgfsg Ensg & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 7:

Ednrnetgr _btfgssgs & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 7:

Wrbfg # Onstrbe Unlpags _grg ]gstgm ckr Akrnzgpnl & & & & 7:

Mr& Xnua _dbtg & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 75

Mr& Naanf Lgtzogr & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 73

Edgrbayf Agg & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 7?

Jrnfmkf Xdbaabps & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 72

Mr& Zkjgrt _namlnf & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 38

Zgjuttna Ensg & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 35


4/253

bbb


NZOWLGF] & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 3=

B& N XX GA ANF ] U E KF SBE ]B KF CK Z BFSKAWF]NZR LNFUANWOD]GZ SBKAN]GU

DBU U]N]G NFM CGMGZNA EKFU]B]W]BKFNA

ZBOD] ]K MWG XZKEGUU JGENWUG ]DG

GSBMGFEG CNBAU ]K GU]NJABUD ]DG

GAGLGF]U KC ]DG KCCGFUG & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 3=

N& Bftrkmuetbkf & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 3=

J& Utnfmnrm kc Zgvbgw & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 3=

E& ] dg K ccgfsg k c B fvka uf tn ryLnfsanuodtgr & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 37

M& ]dg @ury _ns Bfstruetgm Kf ]wk

Mbccgrgft ]dgkrbgs kc Bfvkauftnry

Lnfsanuodtgr & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 3?

G& ]dg Xrksgeutbkf Cnbagm tk Gstnjabsd ]dnt

Nfy Net kc Nppgaanft kr Dbs Cnbaurg tk

Xgrckrl n Agona Muty _ns n Enusntbvg

Cnetkr bf @neiskfs Mgntd & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 34

>& ]dg Gvbmgfeg Mbm Fkt

G s t n j a b s d N p p g a a n f t

Nmlbfbstgrgm Xrkpkcka tk

@neiskf _btd Erblbfna

Fgoabogfeg nfm+kr ]dnt Unbm

Net Enusgm kr _ns n

Uujstnftbna Cnetkr bf Enusbfo

@neiskfs Mgntd & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 34

n& ]dg Gvbmgfeg

Cnbagm tk Gstnjabsd

@neiskf _ns kf n

Xrkpkcka Mrbp kf

@ufg :7td & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 32


5/253

bv


j& Nppgaanfts Net

kc Nmlbfbstgrbfo

X r k p k c k a t k@neiskf _ns Fkt

N E n u s n t b v g

C n e t k r B f

@neiskfs Mgntd & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 4?

e& Bt _ns Fkt

Z g n s k f n j a y

Ckrgsggnjag ]dnt

@neiskf _kuam

Ugac,NmlbfbstgrXrkpkcka Kutsbmg

tdg Xrgsgfeg kc

Nppgaanft & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 2:

:& ]dg Xrksgeutbkf Mbm Fkt

Gstnjabsd ]dnt Nppgaanft

Cnbagm tk Xgrckrl Dbs Agona

Muty tk ]rgnt nfm Enrg ckr

@neiskf nfm+kr ]dnt Uued

Cnbaurg Enusgm tdg Mgntd kr_ns n Uujstnftbna Cnetkr bf

Enusbfo @neiskfs Mgntd & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 22

C& Ekfeausbkf & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >8>

BB& ]DG ]ZBNA EKWZ] GZZGM JR MGFRBFO ]DG

MGCGFUG XKU],SGZMBE] LK]BKF ]K ]GU]

]DG ZGUBMWG BF ]DG GTDBJB] 58 XZKXKCKA

JK]]AG JGENWUG ]DG ZGUWA]U KC ]DG

XZKXKUGM ]GU]BFO EKWAM ZGCW]G ]DG

XZKUGEW]BKFU CBFNA ]DGKZR KCCGZGM

MWZBFO ZGJW]]NA NFM EKWAM

EKFU]B]W]G FG_AR MBUEKSGZGM

GTEWAXN]KZR GSBMGFEG & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >8:

N& Bftrkmuetbkf & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >8:


6/253

v


J& Zgagvnft Xrkegmurna Dbstkry & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >8:

>& ]dg _rbttgf Lktbkf & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >8:

:& ]dg Dgnrbfo # tdg Ekurts

Zuabfo & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >85

5& ]dg Mgcgfsg Cbagm n Ugekfm

Lktbkf tk ]gst tdg Gxdbjbt 58

Zgsbmug & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >87

E& ]dg Xrksgeutbkf Ekftgfmgm ]dnt

Nppgaanft Nmlbfbstgrgm n XrkpkckaBfcusbkf tk @neiskf Crkl tdg Gxdbjbt 58

Jkttag & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >83

>& Gxdbjbt 58 Bs n Ubofbcbenft

Xbgeg kc Gvbmgfeg & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >83

:& Murbfo Zgjuttna tdg

Xrksgeutbkf Xrgsgftgm n Fgw

]dgkry Zgonrmbfo tdg

Ekftgfts kc Gxdbjbt 58 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >84

5& Murbfo Eaksbfo Nroulgft tdg

Xrksgeutkr Ekftgfmgm tdg

Gvbmgfeg Uuppkrtgm Udncgrs

Xrkpkcka Bfcusbkf ]dgkry & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >82

M& ]dg ]rbna Ekurt Njusgm Bts Mbsergtbkf

Jy Mgfybfo tdg Mgcgfsg Lktbkf tk ]gst

tdg Gxdbjbt 58 Zgsbmug & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >82

G& Nppgaanfts Cgmgrna Ekfstbtutbkfna

Zbodts tk Mug Xrkegss! n Cnbr ]rbna! nfm

tk Xrgsgft n Mgcgfsg _grg Sbkantgm jy

tdg ]rbna Ekurts Mgfbna kc Nppgaanfts

Lktbkf tk ]gst tdg Zgsbmug bf Gxdbjbt

58 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >>:


7/253

vb


C& Nppgaanft _ns Xrg`umbegm Jy ]dg ]rbna

Ekurts Zuabfo # Zgvgrsna bs Zgqubrgm & & & & & & & & & & >>7

BBB& N X XG A A N F ] _ N U M G F B G M D B U

EKFU]B]W]BKFNA ZBOD] ]K ]DG

GCCGE]BSG NUUBU]NFEG KC EKWFUGA JR

]DG CNBAWZG KC DBU ]ZBNA EKWFUGA @&

LBEDNGA CANFNONF ]K NMG^WN]GAR

EZKUU,GTNLBFG UDNCGZ MWZBFO

ZGJW]]NA NFM+KZ JR DBU MGCGFUG

]GNLU CNBAWZG ]K LNIG N ]BLGAR

NFM+KZ NMG^WN]G LK]BKF CKZ CKZGFUBE

]GU]BFO KC ]DG ZGUBMWG BF ]DG GTDBJB]58 XZKXKCKA JK]]AG & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >>?

N& Bftrkmuetbkf & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >>?

J& N Mgcgfmnft bf n Erblbfna Ensg Dns n

Cgmgrna nfm Utntg Ekfstbtutbkfna Zbodt tk

Gccgetbvg Nssbstnfeg kc Ekufsga & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >>4

E& Utnfmnrm kc Zgvbgw & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >:8

M& Zgagvnft Xrkegmurna Dbstkry & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >:8

G& N pp gaa nf t _ ns M gf bg m D bs

Ekfstbtutbkfna Zbodt tk Gccgetbvg

Nssbstnfeg kc Ekufsga Jy Canfnonfs

Bfnmgquntg Erkss,Gxnlbfntbkf kc Udncgr

Murbfo Zgjuttna nfm Jy Dbs Mgcgfsg

]gnls Cnbaurg tk Lnig n ]blgay nfm+kr

Nmgquntg Lktbkf tk ]gst tdg Gxdbjbt 58

Zgsbmug & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >:?

BS& NXXGAANF]U EKFU]B]W]BKFNA ZBOD] ]K

MWG XZKEGUU NFM XZGUGF] N MGCGFUG

_GZG SBKAN]GM JR ]DG ]ZBNA EKWZ]U

GTEAWUBKF KC EZB]BENA MGCGFUG

GSBMGFEG ZGONZMBFO @NEIUKFU

LGMBENA DBU]KZR & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >57


8/253

vbb

]NJAG KC EKF]GF]U

Xnog

N& Bftrkmuetbkf & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >57

J& Zgagvnft Xrkegmurna Dbstkry & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >53

E& Ogfgrna Zuags Zgonrmbfo tdg

Nmlbssbjbabty kc Gvbmgfeg & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >=>


Jy Gxeaumbfo tdg ]gstblkfy kc Iagbf!

Jruff nfm Xcgbccgr! Jgenusg Bt Mbm Fkt

Obvg Zbsg tk n ]dbrm Xnrty Euapnjbabty

Bssug! Bt _ns Zgagvnft tk Mbsputgm

Bssugs! nfm bts Xrkjntbvg Snaug

Uujstnftbnaay Kutwgbodgm Nfy Xktgftbna

Xrg`umbebna Blpnet & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >=:

G& ]dg Grrkfgkus Gxeausbkf kc tdg

]gstblkfy kc Iagbf! Jruff nfm Xcgbccgr

Sbkantgm Nppgaanfts Cgmgrna nfm Utntg

Ekfstbtutbkfna Zbodt tk Xrgsgft n

Mgcgfsg! nfm tk Mug Xrkegss nfm n Cnbr

]rbna & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >78

C& ]dg Grrkr _ns Xrg`umbebna nfm Zgqubrgs

Zgvgrsna kc Nppgaanfts Ekfvbetbkf & & & & & & & & & & & & & >78

S& NXXGAANF]U EKFU]B]W]BKFNA ZBOD] ]K



GTEAWUBKF KC EZB]BENA MGCGFUG

GSBMGFEG ZGONZMBFO @NEIUKFU

CBFNFEBNA EKFMB]BKF & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >77

N& Bftrkmuetbkf & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >77

J& Zgagvnft Xagnmbfos # Xrkeggmbfos & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >77


9/253

vbbb



Nmlbssbjbabty kc Gvbmgfeg & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >74

M& ]dg ]rbna Ekurt Njusgm Bts MbsergtbkfJy Gxeaumbfo Gvbmgfeg Zgonrmbfo

@neiskfs Cbfnfebna Ekfmbtbkf Jgenusg Bt

_ns Zgagvnft tk Mbsputgm Bssugs bf tdg

Ensg! ]dg Ekurt Ekuam Dnvg Fnrrkwgm

tdg Uekpg kc Xgrlbssbjag Gvbmgfeg! nfm

bts Xrkjntbvg Snaug _ns Fkt

Uujstnftbnaay Kutwgbodgm Jy Nfy

Xktgftbna Xrg`umbebna Blpnet & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >72

G& ]dg Grrkfgkus Gxeausbkf kc Naa

Gvbmgfeg kc @neiskfs Cbfnfebna

Ekfmbtbkf Sbkantgm Nppgaanfts Cgmgrna

nfm Utntg Ekfstbtutbkfna Zbodt tk Xrgsgft

n Mgcgfsg! nfm tk Mug Xrkegss nfm n Cnbr

]rbna & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >3=


Zgvgrsna kc Nppgaanfts Ekfvbetbkf & & & & & & & & & & & & & >3=

SB& NXXGAANF]U EKFU]B]W]BKFNA ZBOD] ]K



MGFBNA KC ]DG MGCGFUG LK]BKF ]K

BF]ZKMWEG GSBMGFEG KC ]DG ]DBU BU B]

]KWZ EKF]ZNE] JG]_GGF NGO ABSG NFM

@NEIUKF & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >33

N& Bftrkmuetbkf & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >33

J& Zgagvnft Xrkegmurna Dbstkry & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >33


Nmlbssbjbabty kc Gvbmgfeg & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >?5


Jy Gxeaumbfo Gvbmgfeg kc tdg Ekftrnet

Jgtwggf NGO nfm @neiskf & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >?5


10/253

bx


G& ]dg Grrkfgkus Gxeausbkf kc Gvbmgfeg kc

tdg Ekftrnet Jgtwggf NGO nfm @neiskf

Sbkantgm Nppgaanfts Cgmgrna nfm Utntg

Ekfstbtutbkfna Zbodt tk Xrgsgft nMgcgfsg! nfm tk Mug Xrkegss nfm n Cnbr

]rbna & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >?3


Zgvgrsna kc Nppgaanfts Ekfvbetbkf & & & & & & & & & & & & & >?3

SBB& NXXGAANF]U EKFU]B]W]BKFNA ZBOD]U ]K

MWG XZKEGUU! N CNBZ ]ZBNA! NFM N CNBZ

NFM BLXNZ]BNA @WZR _GZG MGFBGM NU N

ZGUWA] KC ]DG ]ZBNA EKWZ]U MGFBNA KC

]DG MGCGFUG LK]BKF ]K UG^WGU]GZ ]DG

@WZR & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >?2

N& Bftrkmuetbkf & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >?2

J& Nppabenjag Anw & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >?2

>& N ]rbna Ekurt Dns tdg

Utntutkry Nutdkrbty tk Krmgr

Ugqugstrntbkf kc n @ury & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >?2

:& N Mgcgfmnft bf n Erblbfna

X r k e g g m b f o D n s n

Ekfstbtutbkfna Zbodt tk Mug

Xrkegss nfm n Cnbr ]rbna jy nf

Blpnrtbna @ury & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >48

E& Zgagvnft Xrkegmurna Dbstkry & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >4>

M& Lgmbn Ekvgrnog kc tdg ]rbna & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >44

G& ]dg @ury _ns Zgpgntgmay Bfstruetgm Fkt

tk Mbseuss tdg Ensg _btd Nfykfg nfm tk

Nvkbm Ekftnet _btd Bftgrfgt nfm Lgmbn

Ekvgrnog kc tdg Ensg! Jut @urkrs _grg

Naakwgm Neegss tk Egaa Xdkfgs nfm tdg

Bftgrfgt Kutsbmg tdg Ekurtrkkl & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >28


11/253

x


C& ]dg ]rbna Ekurt Njusgm Bts Mbsergtbkf

Jy Mgfybfo tdg Mgcgfsg Lktbkf tk

Ugqugstgr tdg @ury Jgenusg tdgWfprgegmgftgm Cnlg kc tdg Naagogm

S b e t b l Ekl jb fg m _b t d t dg

Xgrvnsbvgfgss kc Lkmgrf Lgmbn

Zgfmgrgm Bt Blpkssbjag ckr Nppgaanft tk

Zgegbvg n Cnbr ]rbna _btd n

Fkfsgqugstgrgm @ury bf n Ensg ]dnt _ns

]gagvbsgm nfm Utrgnlgm Abvg Nrkufm

tdg _kram & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >25

O& ]dg Ekurts Grrkr Bf Mgfybfo tdgMgcgfsg Lktbkf tk Ugqugstgr Bs

Zgvgrsbjag Xgr Ug! Jgenusg Bt Sbkantgm

Nppgaanfts Cgmgrna Ekfstbtutbkfna Zbodt

tk n ]rbna Jy nf Blpnrtbna @ury & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >27

SBBB& NXXGAANF]U EKFU]B]W]BKFNA ZBOD]U ]K

MWG XZKEGUU! N CNBZ ]ZBNA! NFM N CNBZ

NFM BLXNZ]BNA @WZR _GZG SBKAN]GM JR

]DG ]ZBNA EKWZ]U ZGCWUNA ]K GTEAWMG

]GAGSBUBKF ENLGZNU CZKL ]DG

EKWZ]ZKKL NFM JR B]U UWJUG^WGF]

CNBAWZG ]K ]NIG U]GXU ]K GFUWZG ]DN]

NXXGAANF] _KWAM ZGEGBSG N CNBZ

]ZBNA & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >23

N& Bftrkmuetbkf & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >23

J& N Mgcgfmnft bf n Erblbfna Xrkeggmbfo

Dns n Ekfstbtutbkfna Zbodt tk Mug

Xrkegss nfm n Cnbr ]rbna jy nf Blpnrtbna

@ury & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >23

E& Zgagvnft Xrkegmurna Dbstkry & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >23

M& Lgmbn Ekvgrnog kc tdg ]rbna & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >24


12/253

xb


G& Xujabebty kc n ]rbna Enf Zgsuat bf Mgfbna

kc n Erblbfna Mgcgfmnfts Cgmgrna

Ekfstbtutbkfna Zbodt tk Mug Xrkegss nfmn Cnbr ]rbna & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >22

C& ]dg ]rbna Ekurt Ekllbttgm Zgvgrsbjag

Grrkr Jy Mgfybfo tdg Mgcgfsg Lktbkf tk

Gxeaumg ]gagvbsbkf Enlgrns Crkl tdg

Ekurtrkkl nfm Jy ]dgrgnctgr Cnbabfo tk

]nig Utgps tk Ounrnftgg ]dnt Nppgaanft

_kuam Zgegbvg n Cnbr ]rbna & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & :8>

O& ]dg Ekurts Grrkr Bf Mgfybfo tdgMgcgfsg Lktbkf tk Gxeaumg ]gagvbsbkf

Enlgrns Crkl tdg Ekurtrkkl Bs

Zgvgrsbjag Xgr Ug Jgenusg Bt Sbkantgm

Nppgaanfts Cgmgrna Ekfstbtutbkfna Zbodt

tk Mug Xrkegss nfm n Cnbr ]rbna & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & :87

BT& ]DG ]ZBNA EKWZ] NJWUGM B]U MBUEZG]BKF

JR BLXKUBFO NF NOOZNSN]GM UGF]GFEG

JGENWUG B] BU FK] UWXXKZ]GM JR N

EKFUBMGZN]BKF KC NAA ZGAGSNF]

UGF]GFEBFO CNE]KZU! ]DG @WMOG

MBUXANRGM N JBNU NONBFU] NXXGAANF]!

NFM ]DG UGF]GFEG MKGU FK] JGU] UGZSG

]DG BF]GZGU]U KC @WU]BEG & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & :8?

N& Bftrkmuetbkf & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & :8?

J& Nppabenjag Ugftgfebfo Anw & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & :8?

E& ]dg Xrkjntbkf Kccbegrs Zgpkrt & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & :82

M& ] dg X rk sg eu tb kf U gf tg fe bf o

Lglkrnfmul & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & :>>

G& ]dg Mgcgfsg Ugftgfebfo Lglkrnfmul & & & & & & & & & & :>:


13/253

xbb


C& ]dg Xrkjntbkf nfm Ugftgfebfo Dgnrbfo & & & & & & & & & & :>7

O& ]dg ]rbna Ekurt Njusgm Bts Mbsergtbkf jyBlpksbfo nf Wppgr ]grl Ugftgfeg & & & & & & & & & & & & & :>2

T& NXXGAANF]U EKFSBE]BKF LWU] JG

ZGSGZUGM JNUGM KF ]DG EWLWAN]BSG

GZZKZU KC ]DG ]ZBNA EKWZ] _DBED

WFMGZLBFGM ]DG CWFMNLGF]NA

CNBZFGUU KC NXXGAANF]U ]ZBNA BF

SBKAN]BKF KC DBU CBC]D! UBT]D NFM

C K W Z ] G G F ] D N L G F M L G F ]

EKFU]B]W]BKFNA ZBOD]U & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ::2

EKFEAWUBKF & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & :5>

EGZ]BCBEN]G KC NXXGAAN]G EKWFUGA XWZUWNF]

]K ENABCKZFBN ZWAGU KC EKWZ]! ZWAG 4&538 $j" & & & & & & & & & :5:


14/253

xbbb

]NJAG KC NW]DKZB]BGU

Ensgs Xnogs

Nig v& Kiandkln $>247" =?8 W&U& 34 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >>5

Nrbzkfn v& Cualbfnftg $>22>" =22 W&U& :?2 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >27! :83

Jrnmy v& Lnryanfm$>235" 5?5 W&U& 45 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >>5

Enabckrfbn v& Znlks $>245" =35 W&U& 22: & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ::2

Ednljgrs v& Lbssbssbppb $>2?5" =>8 W&U& :4= & & & >>5! >>5! >78! >3=! >?3

Ednplnf v& Enabckrfbn $>23?" 543 W&U& >4 & & & & & & & & & >>7! >7>! >3=! >?3

Ebty kc Aks Nfogags v& Uupgrbkr Et& $:88:" :2 Ena&=td > & & & & & & & & & & & & >>=

Ekaagog Dkspbtna! Bfe& v& Uupgrbkr Et& $>22=" 4 Ena&=td ?8= & & & & >75! >37

Ernfg v& Igftueiy $>243" =?3 W&U& 345 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >>5! >78

Euyagr v& Uuaabvnf $>248" ==3 W&U& 557 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >>4

Mnvbs v& Nansin $>2?=" =>7 W&U& 584 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >>=! >78

Mgrmgf v& LeFgga$7td Ebr& >22:" 2?4 C&:m >=75 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & :58

Mkffgaay v& MgEdrbstkckrk $>2?=" =>3 W&U& 35? & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ::2

Mufenf v& Akubsbnfn $>234" 52> W&U& >=7 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >48

Gstgs v& ]gxns $>237" 54> W&U& 75: & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >22! :85

Cnrrkw v& Wfbtgm Utntgs $2td Ebr& >244" 748 C&:m >552 & & & & & & & & & & & & ::4

Dkalgs v& Ukutd Enrkabfn $:882" 7=? W&U& 5>2 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >3=

Bljagr v& Xnedtlnf $>2?3" =:= W&U& =82 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >>=

Bf rg Ekrmgrk $>244" =3 Ena&5m >3> & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >>2! >:8

Bf rg Lnrqugz$>22:" > Ena&=td 74= & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >>4

Bf rg Lbrnfmn $:884" =5 Ena&=td 7=> & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >>5! >>=

Bf rg Luredbskf $>277" 5=2 W&U& >55 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >4>


15/253

xbv


Ensgs Xnogs

Bf rg Unufmgrs $>2?8" : Ena&5m >855 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >>2

Bf rg Utggag $:88=" 5: Ena&=td 34: & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >>=

Bf rg _baskf $>22:" 5 Ena&=td 2=7 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >5:

Bf rg _bfsdbp $>2?8" 52? W&U& 574 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 37! >8>

@neiskf v& Sbrobfbn $>2?2" ==5 W&U& 58? & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 37! >8>

@kdfskf v& Enabckrfbn $:887" 7=7 W&U& >3: & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >48

@kdfskf v& Pgrjst$>254" 58= W&U& =74 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >>2

Abfekaf v& Uuff $2td Ebr& >24?" 48? C&:m 487 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & :58

Lurpdy v& Cakrbmn $>2?7" =:> W&U& ?2= & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & :87

Fgjrnsin Xrgss Nssf& v& Utunrt$>2?3" =:? W&U& 752 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >4>

Xnttgrskf v& Ekakrnmk $>28?" :87 W&U& =7= & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & :88

Xgkpag v& Nygrs $>2?7" 7> Ena&Npp&5m 5?8 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >48

Xgkpag v& Jgfnvbmgs $:887" 57 Ena&=td 32 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >55

Xgkpag v& Janei$:88?" => Ena&=td ?22 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & :84

Xgkpag v& Jrnmckrm$>22?" >7 Ena&=td >::2 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >=5

Xgkpag v& Jrnmy $:887" >:2 Ena&Npp&=td >5>= & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 33

Xgkpag v& Jufynrm$>244" =7 Ena&5m >>42 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >48

Xgkpag v& Jutagr$:8>8" >4? Ena&Npp&=td 224 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 33

Xgkpag v& Entabf $:88>" :3 Ena&=td 4> & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 33

Xgkpag v& Eg`n $>225" = Ena&=td >>5= & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 37

Xgkpag v& Ekkagy $>23:" :>> Ena&Npp&:m >?5 & & & & & & & & & & & >=?! >72! >?=

Xgkpag v& Ekrkfn $>2?4" 48 Ena&Npp&5m 34= & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >>2


16/253

xv


Ensgs Xnogs

Xgkpag v& Ekygr $>245" >=: Ena&Npp&5m 452 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >>3

Xgkpag v& Ergw $:885" 5> Ena&=td 4:: & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 3?

Xgkpag v& Eum`k $>225" 3 Ena&=td 747 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >=:

Xgkpag v& MgAnrek $>245" >=: Ena&Npp&5m :2= & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >=:

Xgkpag v& Mgaskf $>24=" >3> Ena&Npp&5m 73 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & :>2

Xgkpag v& Gmgajnedgr$>242" =? Ena&5m 245 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >=:

Xgkpag v& Gmwnrms $>22>" 7= Ena&5m ?4? & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >=:

Xgkpag v& Gvgrs $>22:" >8 Ena&Npp&=td 744 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 33

Xgkpag v& Cnlnanrk $:8>:" 7: Ena&=td > & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & :87

Xgkpag v& Onaagok $>228" 7: Ena&5m >>7 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >48

Xgkpag v& Onregnu $>225" 3 Ena&=td >=8 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >=>

Xgkpag v& Dnaa$>243" => Ena&5m 4:3 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >=:

Xgkpag v& Dnlbatkf $:882" =7 Ena&=td 435 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >=:

Xgkpag v& Dgnmagg $>2=>" >4 Ena&:m :33 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 37

Xgkpag v& Dkat$>22?" >7 Ena&=td 3>2 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >>2

Xgkpag v& @gffbfos $:8>8" 78 Ena&=td 3>3 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 33

Xgkpag v& @kfgs $:8>8" >43 Ena&Npp&=td :>3 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >:8

Xgkpag v& @kfgs $>22=" := Ena&Npp&=td >?48 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >5:

Xgkpag v& Igaay $>23?" 33 Ena&:m :5: & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >=>

Xgkpag v& Anfpdgnr$>248" :3 Ena&5m 4>= & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >>2

Xgkpag v& Lnfskf $>2??" ?> Ena&Npp&5m > & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >48

Xgkpag v& Lnrsdnaa$>22?" >7 Ena&=td > & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 37


17/253

xvb


Ensgs Xnogs

Xgkpag v& Lnury $:885" 58 Ena&=td 5=: & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 37

Xgkpag v&LeEnry $>247" >33 Ena&Npp&5m > & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >>2

Xgkpag v& LeMkfnam$>24=" 5? Ena&5m 57> & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >=2! >35

Xgkpag v& Lgfmkzn $:888" :5 Ena&=td 423 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >=2

Xgkpag v& Lgfmkzn]gaak $>22?" >7 Ena&=td :3= & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >5:

Xgkpag v& Lurpdy $>235" 72 Ena&:m 4>4 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >=2

Xgkpag v& Fntbkf $>248" :3 Ena&5m >32 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >>4

Xgkpag v& Ksjnfm$>223" >5 Ena&=td 3:: & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & :84

Xgkpag v& Xkpg $>2?2" :5 Ena&5m =>: & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >>4

Xgkpag v& Znagy $>22:" : Ena&=td 4?8 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 37

Xgkpag v& Znlks $>24:" 58 Ena&5m 775 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ::2

Xgkpag v& Zkmrbougz$>238" >43 Ena&Npp&:m =55 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 33

Xgkpag v& Zueigr$>248" :3 Ena&5m 534 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >55

Xgkpag v& Unfedgz$:88>" :3 Ena&=td 45= & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 33

Xgkpag v& Unfmkvna$:88?" => Ena&=td 4:7 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & :82

Xgkpagv& Ukk`bnf $:8>8" >28 Ena&Npp&=td =2> & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >75

Xgkpag v& Uupgrbkr Ekurt $Navnrgz" $>22?" >= Ena&=td 234 & & & & & & & & & :82

Xgkpag v& Snsqugz$:883" 52 Ena&=td =? & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >27

Xgkpag v& Sbfmbkan $>2?2" 23 Ena&Npp&5m 5?8 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ::2

Xgkpag v& _nrfgr$>2?4" :8 Ena&5m 3?4 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ::8

Xgkpag v& _ntskf $>273" =3 Ena&:m 4>4 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >75! >37

Xgkpag v& _dggagr$>2?4" :: Ena&5m :74 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >48


18/253

xvbb


Ensgs Xnogs

Xgkpag v& _baabnls $>2?>" :: Ena&Npp&5m 5= & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ::2

Xgkpag v& _baabnlskf $>24=" >3> Ena&Npp&5m 553 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 37

Xgkpag v& _kkmnrm$>2?2" :5 Ena&5m 5:2 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >55

Xgkpag v& _rbodt$>247" 52 Ena&5m 7?3 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >=2

Xkwgaa v& Nanjnln $>25:" :4? W&U& =7 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >>4

Zbmgnu v& Akubsbnfn $>235" 5?5 W&U& ?:5 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & :87

Udgppnrm v& Lnxwgaa$>233" 54= W&U& 555& & & & & & >48! >4>! >22! :8>! :85

Utrbeianfm v& _nsdbfotkf $>24=" =33 W&U& 334 & & & >>4! >>2! >:8! >55! >75

]nyakr v& Igffgmy $>2?4" =53 W&U& =?4 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & :58

]nyakr v& Baabfkbs $>244" =4= W&U& =88 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >78

]rnxagr v& ]dklpskf $>2?8" = Ena&Npp&5m :?4 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >=>

Wfbtgm Utntgs v& Jnoagy $>247" =?5 W&U& 33? & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >>5

Wfbtgm Utntgs& v& Uncbrstgbf $2td Ebr&>24?" 4:? C&:m >548 & & & & & & & & & & ::4

_nsdbfotkf v& ]gxns $>23?" 544 W&U& >= & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >>7! >78! >3=

@ury Bfstruetbkfs

ENAEZBL Fk& :8> & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >2:

ENAEZBL Fk& 74> & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 3?

ENAEZBL Fk& 74: & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 3?

Ekfst& Xrkvbsbkfs Xnogs

Ena& Ekfst&! nrt& B! >7 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >>:,>>5! >>4! >78

Ena& Ekfst&! nrt& B! >3 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >>:,>>5! >78! >48


19/253

xvbbb


Ekfst& Xrkvbsbkfs Xnogs

Ena& Ekfst&! nrt& B! >? & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >>:,>>5! >78

W& U& Ekfst&! >st Nlgfm & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >22! :8>

W& U& Ekfst&! 7td Nlgfm& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >>:! >>5! :58

W& U& Ekfst&! 3td Nlgfm & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >>:! >>4! >78! >3=! >48 >22

W& U& Ekfst&! >=td Nlgfm& 37! >8>! >>:! >>5! >>4! >78! >3=! >48! >22! :58

Lbse&

Ena& Ekmg kc @umbebna Gtdbes! Enfkf 5J $?" & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ::7

Zuags kc Ekurt

Ena& Zuags kc Ekurt! ruag =&=>8 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & :84

Ena& Zuags kc Ekurt! ruag =&=>= & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & :>=

Ena& Zuags kc Ekurt! ruag =&=:> & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & :84

Ena& Zuags kc Ekurt! ruag =&=:5 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & :84

Utntutgs

Gvbm& Ekmg :>8 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >=>

Gvbm& Ekmg 57> & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >=>

Gvbm& Ekmg 57: & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >57! >=>

Xgf& Ekmg >2: & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 37

Xgf& Ekmg >2:! sujm& $j" & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & :! 33

Xgf& Ekmg >25! sujm& $j" & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & :8?

Xgf& Ekmg >>:> & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >48

Xgf& Ekmg >>?8! sujm& $j" & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & :84

Xgf& Ekmg >>?8! sujm& $d" & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & :! :84


20/253

xbx


Utntutgs Xnogs

Xgf& Ekmg >:5? & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >

Xgf& Ekmg >:38 & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >>3

_gjsbtgs

dttp0++l&bjtblgs&ekl+lbednga,`neiskf,mr,ekfrnm,lurrny,trbna,cuaa,

ekvgrnog,fnfey,orneg,mr,mrgw,pgrgzdbatkf,ekl,tlz,ekl,::8458&

dtla & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >42

dttp0++tv&yndkk&ekl+fgws+lgmbn,ekvgrbfo,ekfrnm,lurrny,trbna,>?:

:88>458& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >42

dttp0++www&enaanwygr&ekl+eastkry&ecl;pujmt:85#gbm42

dttp0++www&dkaaywkkmrgpkrtgr&ekl+fgws+lbednga,`neiskf,trbna,npp

,lurrny,:=>3?> & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & >28


21/253

>

BF ]DG EKWZ] KC NXXGNA KC ]DG U]N]G KC ENABCKZFBN

UGEKFM NXXGAAN]G MBU]ZBE]! MBSBUBKF UGSGF

]DG XGKXAG KC ]DG U]N]G KC ENABCKZFBN! Fk& J:5?3??

Xanbftbcc nfm Zgspkfmgft!

v&

EKFZNM ZKJGZ] LWZZNR!

Mgcgfmnft nfm Nppgaanft&

NXXGAANF]U KXGFBFO JZBGC

U]N]GLGF] KC NXXGNANJBAB]R

]dbs nppgna bs crkl n cbfna umolgft kc ekfvbetbkf tdnt mbspksgs kc naa

bssugs jgtwggf tdg pnrtbgs nfm bs nutdkrbzgm jy Xgfna Ekmg sgetbkf >:5?&


22/253

:

U]N]GLGF] KC ]DG ENUG

Bf nf bfckrlntbkf cbagm kf @nfunry :7! :8>>! nppgaanft Ekfrnm Zkjgrt

Lurrny wns ednrogm wbtd kfg cgakfy ekuft kc bfvkauftnry lnfsanuodtgr $Xgf&

Ekmg >2:! sujm& $j""! ckr tdg mgntd kc Lbednga @neiskf& $?E],>:2=,>:27&"

Nppgaanft pagm fkt oubaty& $?E],>:2?&"

Nctgr n agfotdy vkbr mbrg bf wdbed pktgftbna `urkrs eklpagtgm n 58,

pnog qugstbkffnbrg $?E],>=24,>7:?"! tdg ury wns glpnfgagm kf Ugptgljgr

:5! :8>>& $>8E],:535&" Murbfo trbna! =2 wbtfgssgs tgstbcbgm& $Ugg >Z]

Lnstgr Bfmgx&" Kf Fkvgljgr ?! :8>>! tdg `ury ckufm nppgaanft oubaty ns

ednrogm& $>>E],:3=8&"

Kf Fkvgljgr :2! :8>>! nppgaanft wns sgftgfegm tk tdg uppgr tgrl kc

ckur ygnrs! tk jg sgrvgm bf tdg Aks Nfogags Ekufty @nba pursunft tk Xgfna Ekmg

sgetbkf >>?8! sujmbvbsbkf $d"& $UE],>4?9 58Z],>>?=4&" Nppgaanft cbagm n

tblgay fktbeg kc nppgna& $>:E],:4:8&"


23/253

5

U]N]GLGF] KC CNE]U

Xrksgeutbkf Ensg

Lbednga @neiskfs Zgsbmgfeg # Utncc

Bf antg :884! Lbednga @neiskf nfm dbs edbamrgf lkvgm tk >88 Fkrtd

Enrkawkkm bf Aks Nfogags $Enrkawkkm"! n ontgm rgsbmgfeg nawnys

lkfbtkrgm jy nt agnst twk sgeurbty ounrms& Lbednga Nlbr _baabnls! @neiskfs

pgrskfna nssbstnft! wns tdg abnbskf jgtwggf @neiskf nfm dbs stncc& Dg wkrigm

prblnrbay kut kc tdg sgeurbty trnbagr& $2Z],:4=5,:4==! :47>! :?32,:??5&"

@neiskfs pgrskfna sgeurbty tgnl bfeaumgm Cndggl Ludnllnm $Edbgc kc

Ugeurbty"! Najgrtk Navnrgz $Mbrgetkr kc Akobstbes"! nfm tdrgg ktdgrs&

$2Z],:44=9 >8Z],5887! 5882&"

@neiskfs ]dbs Bs Bt ]kur

Xnua Okfonwnrg! tdg ek,EGK kc NGO Abvg Ekfegrts _gst $NGO

Abvg"! wns tdg prkmuegr nfm prklktgr kc @neiskfs ]dbs Bs Bt tkur& ]dg

tkur ekftrnetgm tk prgsgft 5> sdkws nt tdg K: Nrgfn bf Akfmkf! jut mug tk

trglgfmkus bftgrgst! tdg fuljgr bfergnsgm tk 78& $4Z],:73>,:737&" N

sedgmuag wns prgpnrgm ckr rgdgnrsnas bf Aks Nfogags nfm Akfmkf! nfm ckr 78

sdkws crkl @uay tdrkuod Ugptgljgr :882! nfm @nfunry tdrkuod Lnred :8>8&

$4Z],:73?,:7?:9 Gxd& 5&"

Bf lbm,Nprba :882! Igffgtd Krtgon jgonf wkribfo ns mbrgetkr nfm ek,


24/253

> Naa mntgs rgcgrrgm tk dgrgbf keeurrgm bf :882 ufagss ktdgrwbsg stntgm&

=

ergntkr wbtd @neiskf&> Krtgon! @neiskf! nfm n edkrgkornpdgr lgt tdrgg tk cbvg

mnys n wggi nt Jurjnfi Egftgr Utnogs ckr ergntbvg nfm ekfegptuna mbseussbkfs&

@neiskfs lnbf lktbvntbkf ckr tdg tkur wns tk sdnrg dbs akvg kc pgrckrlbfo

wbtd dbs edbamrgf nfm cnfs! nfm prgsgft nf gfvbrkflgftna lgssnog&

$4Z],:78>,:785&"

Nppgaanft _ns Dbrgm Ns @neiskfs Xgrskfna Xdysbebnf

Uklgtblg bf Lny! @neiskf tkam Okfonwnrg dg wnftgm tk dbrg

nppgaanft ns dbs pgrskfna pdysbebnf ckr tdg tkur& Okfonwnrg enaagm nppgaanft!

jut wns ufnjag tk lnig n mgna& Uujsgqugftay Okfonwnrg kccgrgm nppgaanft

->78!888 n lkftd! nfm nctgr agnrfbfo tdnt cbourg enlg crkl @neiskf! nppgaanft

neegptgm& $4Z],:7?7,:7489 2Z],:?>3,:?>2&"

Bf @ufg! nt tdg rgqugst kc NGO Abvg! nttkrfgy Intdy @krrbg mrnctgm n

ekftrnet ckr sgrvbegs jgtwggf @neiskf nfm nppgaanft& Kf @ufg >7td! sdg g,

lnbagm n mrnct tk nf NGO Abvg neekuftnft! wdk ckrwnrmgm bt tk nppgaanft&

@krrbg nfm nppgaanft tdgrgnctgr ekllufbentgm jy pdkfg nfm g,lnba! nfm sgvgrna

rgvbsbkfs wgrg lnmg& $2Z],:?5:,:?57! :?=>,:?=7! :?=4,:?789 :=Z],4:=?&"

]dg cbfna ekftrnet wns sbofgm jy nppgaanft nfm rgturfgm tk @krrbg kf @ufg :=td&

$2Z], :?54,:?52! :?7:9 Gxd& =&" Bt wns tk tnig gccget ns skkf ns bt wns sbofgm

jy NGO Abvg! nppgaanft! nppgaanfts eklpnfy O&E&N&! nfm @neiskf& Nppgaanft


25/253

7

wns tk jg pnbm rgtrknetbvgay jgobffbfo Lny >st! nfm gfmbfo Lnred 3! :8>8&

$2Z],:?57,:?53&" Kfay nppgaanft sbofgm tdg ekftrnet! nfm dg wns fgvgr pnbm

ckr dbs sgrvbegs& $2Z],:?73&"

]kur Zgdgnrsnas # Ekfegrf Njkut @neiskf

Bf gnray @ufg! rgdgnrsnas lkvgm tk tdg Ckrul& Nrkufm @ufg >4td! tdgy

lkvgm tk Utnpags Egftgr $Utnpags"& Zgdgnrsnas tkki paneg crkl antg

nctgrfkkf bftk tdg gvgfbfo! wbtd @neiskfs bfvkavglgft typbenaay cbvg tk sgvgf

dkurs n mny& $4Z],:787,:782! :775&"

@neiskf lbssgm njkut n wggi kc rgdgnrsnas prbkr tk @ufg >4td& $4Z],

:7>:,:7>5! :77?,:774&" Krtgon trbgm tk nsegrtnbf tdg prkjagl! nfm dg spkig

tk Okfonwnrg! nfm Jrnfmkf Xdbaabps , tdg Xrgsbmgft+EGK kc NGO Abvg&

$4Z],:7=>,:7=:9 :=Z],4=8>,4=85&" Kf @ufg >2td! @neiskfs jgdnvbkr

trkujagm Krtgon! nfm dg wkfmgrgm bc @neiskf wns kf mruos& @neiskf wns

sabodtay bfekdgrgft! edbaagm! sklgwdnt akst! nfm fkt wgaa gfkuod tk rgdgnrsg&

Dg wntedgm rgdgnrsna ckr njkut nf dkur! tdgf agct gnray& $4Z], :7>5,:7>7!

:778,:77>&" Krtgon gxprgssgm dbs ekfegrfs tk Xdbaabps bf nf g,lnba sgft kf

@ufg :8td nt :08= n&l& Bt stntgm bf pnrt! tdg nrtbst lny jg ufnjag tk rbsg tk tdg

keensbkf mug tk rgna glktbkfna stucc! nfm dg sdkuam jg psyedkakobenaay

gvnauntgm& Krtgon fktgm @neiskf wns senrgm tdg tkur lbodt jg enfegagm nfm

dnm prnetbenaay jgoogm ckr dbs ekfcbmgfeg& $4Z],:7>3,:7>29 Gxd& >&"

Kf @ufg :8td! n lggtbfo dgam nt @neiskfs rgsbmgfeg wns nttgfmgm jy


26/253

: @neiskfs rgdgnrsnas wgrg vbmgktnpgm! nfm ckktnog wns gmbtgm bftk

tdg ]dbs Bs Bt lkvbg& $4Z],:777,:773&" ]dg prksgeutbkf panygm vbmgk kc

@neiskf pgrckrlbfo ]dg _ny Rku Lnig Lg Cgga kf @ufg :5rm! nfm Gnrtd

Ukfo kf @ufg :=td& $4Z],:75:,:7539 Gxd& :&"

3

Krtgon! Xdbaabps! Crnfi Mbagk $@neiskfs lnfnogr"! nppgaanft! nfm @neiskf&

Nppgaanft dnm jggf ergntbfo mnbay sedgmuags tk gfsurg @neiskf wkuam fkt lbss

rgdgnrsnas& $4Z],:7>2,:7::&" Dg wns upsgt Krtgon dnm fkt naakwgm @neiskf

tk rgdgnrsg tdg fbodt jgckrg! nfm snbm tk agnvg @neiskfs dgnatd tk dbl&

@neiskf nfm nppgaanft nssurgm Krtgon tdnt @neiskf wns pdysbenaay nfm

glktbkfnaay enpnjag kc dnfmabfo tdg sdkw& Krtgon gxprgssgm ekfegrf ckr

@neiskfs wgaa jgbfo& @neiskf nfm nppgaanft wgrg rgegptbvg tk gvgrykfgs

ekfegrfs& $4Z],:75=,:757! :7=7,:7=3! :74:,:7459 2Z],:?>=&"

Nt tdg fgxt twk sedgmuagm rgdgnrsnas kf @ufg :5rm nfm :=td! @neiskf

wns cuaa kc gfgroy nfm gftdusbnsl&: $4Z],:7:3! :7779 2Z],:?8?! :428&" Kf

@ufg :=td! nrkufm ?088 p&l&! Ludnllnm mrkvg _baabnls nfm @neiskf tk

Utnpags& @neiskf wns bf okkm spbrbts! nfm nfxbkus tk nrrbvg& Navnrgz dnm okfg

gnrabgr tk prgpnrg ckr @neiskfs nrrbvna& $2Z],:?42! :4449 >8Z],58>:,58>5&"

Nctgr rgdgnrsna @neiskf wns dnppy! dg tkam Krtgon tdgy wgrg neeklpabsdbfo

tdg mrgnl! nfm mbseussgm dbs mgsbrg tk tnig tdg tkur tk ktdgr ebtbgs nctgr

Akfmkf! nfm tdgf lnig lkvbgs nfm cbals& $4Z],:75?&"

Nrkufm >088 n&l& @neiskf nfm dbs gftkurnog rgturfgm tk Enrkawkkm&

Nppgaanfts JL_ wns bf tdg mrbvgwny& Ludnllnm! _baabnls nfm Navnrgz


27/253

?

sujsgqugftay wgft dklg ckr tdg fbodt& $2Z],:?28,:?25! :42:9 >8Z],58>3,

58>29 >?Z],7>32,7>?:&"

]dg Gvgfts kc @ufg :7td

Kf @ufg :7td! jgtwggf >:087 nfm >:0>8 p&l&! nppgaanft pnrtbnaay

mgsegfmgm tdg ibtedgf stnbrs nfm sdkutgm! Ogt dgap! ogt sgeurbty! ogt Xrbfeg&

$>8Z],5:8:! 5::3&" @neiskfs edgc! Inb Ednsg! rnf tk tdg nm`negft mgf tk ogt

Xrbfeg& Ednsg nfm Xrbfeg rnf jnei bftk tdg ibtedgf! nfm Xrbfeg npprknedgm

nppgaanft& $>8Z],5>?2,5>4>! 5>24! 5:8:,5:87&" Ugeurbty pgrskffga gftgrgm

tdg dkusg njkut cbvg lbfutgs antgr& $>8Z],5:5>&"

Nt >:0>5 p&l& _baabnls rgegbvgm n vkbeglnba crkl nppgaanft! nsibfo

dbl tk enaa bllgmbntgay& _baabnls enaagm nppgaanft nt >:0>7 p&l& Nppgaanft

snbm @neiskf dnm n jnm rgnetbkf! tk ogt sklgkfg up dgrg bllgmbntgay! nfm

tdgf dg dufo up& $2Z],:?27! :488! :4859 Gxds& >5,>7&" _baabnls enaagm

Ludnllnm! wdk wns ruffbfo nf grrnfm! nfm tkam dbl tk bllgmbntgay rgturf

nfm edgei kf @neiskf& $2Z],:425,:42?9 Gxd& >4&" ]dgrg wgrg sgvgrna

bfeklpagtg enaas jgtwggf _baabnls nfm Navnrgz nt >:0>? nfm >:0>4 p&l& Nt

>:0>4 _baabnls spkig wbtd Navnrgz! nfm mbrgetgm dbl tk gftgr tdg dkusg nfm

nssgss tdg sbtuntbkf& $2Z],:48=,:4839 >8Z],58:>9 Gxd& :3&"

_dgf Navnrgz rgnedgm tdg crkft mkkr! dg snw nppgaanft agnfbfo kvgr

tdg sgekfm cakkr rnbabfo& $2Z],:48?9 >8Z],58:=! 58:3&" Dg wgft upstnbrs

nfm nppgaanft stntgm! Eklg qubei& Navnrgz ornspgm tdg sgrbkusfgss kc tdg


28/253

4

sbtuntbkf! nfm dg dufo up kf _baabnls& $>8Z],58:2! 585:,5855&" Dg gftgrgm

@neiskfs jgmrkkl nfm kjsgrvgm nppgaanft obvbfo @neiskf edgst eklprgssbkfs

wbtd dbs agct dnfm& @neiskf wns kf dbs jgm! dbs gygs wgrg sabodtay kpgf! nfm

dbs lkutd wns kpgf& Nppgaanft snbm tdgy fggmgm tk ogt @neiskf tk n dkspbtna&

@neiskfs edbamrgf gftgrgm tdg rkkl! nfm Navnrgz usdgrgm tdgl kut tk tdg

anfmbfo& $>8Z],585=,5854&"

Navnrgz rgturfgm tk tdg jgmrkkl! nfm nppgaanft snbm @neiskf dnm n

jnm rgnetbkf& Kxyogf tujbfo wns ekffgetgm tk @neiskfs fksg! nfm tdgrg wns

nf BS,stnfm bf tdg rkkl& Navnrgz mbm fkt kjsgrvg n dgnrt lkfbtkr kr sblbanr

gqubplgft& Nt sklg pkbft dg snw nf nlju jno& $>8Z],5854,58=:&"

Nppgaanft ornjjgm n dnfmcua kc vbnas crkl tdg fbodtstnfm! nfm tkam

Navnrgz tk put tdgl bftk n jno& Navnrgz tkki n panstbe jno! dgam bt kpgf! nfm

nppgaanft panegm vbnas bf tdg jno& Nppgaanft pkbftgm tk n jrkwf jno! nfm

Navnrgz ckaakwgm dbs bfstruetbkfs tk paneg tdg panstbe jno bfsbmg& N snabfg jno

wns dnfobfo kf tdg rbodt sbmg kc tdg BS,stnfm $Gxd& :2"! nfm Navnrgz ckaakwgm

nppgaanfts mbrgetbkfs tk ornj bt nfm paneg bt bf n jaug jno& Navnrgz fktbegm n

jkttag $Gxd& 58" bfsbmg tdg snabfg jno! nfm n lbaiy wdbtg sujstnfeg kf tdg

jkttkl kc tdg jno& ]dg lgtna rbllgm stkppgr kc tdg jkttag wns cnebfo tdg

jkttkl kc tdg jno tkwnrms tdg pkrt! bf n sabodtay mbnokfna pksbtbkf& Nppgaanft

mbm fkt nsi Navnrgz tk rglkvg tdg ktdgr snabfg jno kf tdg BS,stnfm&

$>8Z],58=:,58=7! 587>,587=! 583=,583?! 582?,5824&"


29/253

2

Nt nppgaanfts mbrgetbkf! Navnrgz enaagm 2>> nt >:0:8 p&l&

$>8E],:523,:=889 >8Z],58?8,58?79 Gxds& :3! 5>! 5:&" Ludnllnm rgturfgm

tk Enrkawkkm nrkufm >:0:5 p&l&! nfm wgft tk @neiskfs jgmrkkl&

$2Z],:423,:42?&" @neiskfs gygs wgrg kpgf! dbs lkutd wns sabodtay nonpg!

nfm dg nppgnrgm tk jg mgnm& Nppgaanft nsigm Navnrgz nfm _baabnls bc tdgy

ifgw EXZ& Navnrgz jgonf pgrckrlbfo twk,dnfmgm edgst eklprgssbkfs&

$2Z], :287&" Nppgaanft pgrckrlgm lkutd,tk,lkutd rgsusebtntbkf& Navnrgz

dnm fkt sggf nfy sbofs kc abcg crkl @neiskf& $>8Z],584>,584=&"

Xnrnlgmbe cbrgcbodtgrs Zbednrm Ugffgcc nfm Lnrtbf Jakuft rgspkfmgm

tk Enrkawkkm bf nf nljuanfeg! nakfo wbtd Gfobfg ?>& ]dg rgseug tgnl mrkvg

npprkxblntgay n lbag nfm n dnac! nrrbvgm nt >:0:3 p&l&! nfm wgrg gsekrtgm bftk

@neiskfs jgmrkkl& $2Z],:28?9 >>Z],55?7,55?3! 5543! 5=43,5=44&"

Nppgaanft wns stnfmbfo jgmsbmg! agnfbfo kvgr @neiskf! nfm wbtd nssbstnfeg!

lkvgm @neiskf tk tdg cakkr& Dg bmgftbcbgm dblsgac ns @neiskfs mketkr! nfm

nppgnrgm sklgwdnt crnftbe& $>>Z],5542! 5=42,5=28&" Xnrnlgmbes fktbegm

n snabfg BS,jno dnfobfo kf nf BS,stnfm wbtd nttnedgm tujbfo bf @neiskfs

rbodt enac! nf kxyogf tnfi! n akfo tujg wbtd nf nttnedgm fnsna enffuan kf

@neiskfs cneg! nfm nf nlju jno& ]dgy mbm fkt sgg nfy ktdgr lgmbena

gqubplgft& $>>Z],5=:5! 5=58! 5=57! 5==>,5==:! 5=2?,5=24&" ]drgg kpgf

vbnas kc abmkenbfg wgrg kf tdg cakkr& $>>Z],5783&"

Ugffgcc nsigm nppgaanft qugstbkfs! trybfo tk nsegrtnbf tdg prkjagl&


30/253

>8

Nppgaanft snbm tdg bfebmgft keeurrgm rbodt wdgf dg enaagm! kr tdnt @neiskf dnm

jggf mkwf ckr njkut n lbfutg& Jnsgm tdgrgkf! Ugffgcc cgat tdgrg wns n okkm

ednfeg kc snvbfo @neiskf& $>>Z],552>,5525! 57>5&"

Ugffgcc ekftbfugm qugstbkfbfo nppgaanft ns ktdgrs jgonf tk tnig

netbkf& @neiskf wns lkvgm tk nf nrgn kf tdg enrpgt wbtd lkrg rkkl tk wkri&

EXZ! vgftbantbkf! nfm bftujntbkf prkegmurgs wgrg jgouf& Nf GIO bfmbentgm

@neiskf wns nsystkag $fk dgnrtjgnt"& Xnrnlgmbes nmlbfbstgrgm gpbfgpdrbfg

nfm ntrkpbfg bftrnvgfkusay! jut @neiskfs ekfmbtbkf mbm fkt ednfog&

$>>Z],552=,5522! 5=8>,5=85! 5=2>,5=23! 5=22! 578:&"

Ugffgcc nsigm wdgtdgr @neiskf dnm tnigf nfy lgmbentbkf& Nppgaanft

snbm! Fk! tdgf bfmbentgm dg onvg @neiskf akrnzgpnl ckr saggp& Dg snbm

@neiskf rgdgnrsgm >3 dkurs tdg prgvbkus fbodt! nfm dg wns trgntbfo @neiskf

ckr mgdymrntbkf nfm gxdnustbkf wbtd fkrlna snabfg& Nppgaanft fgvgr

lgftbkfgm obvbfo @neiskf prkpkcka kr abmkenbfg& $>>Z],5=88,5=8>! 5=:7,

5=53! 5==:! 5=22,5788! 5783! 57:3&"

]dg pnrnlgmbes lnmg luatbpag kjsgrvntbkfs tdnt mbm fkt eklpkrt wbtd

@neiskf `ust dnvbfo dnm tdg gpbskmg& _dgf Ugffgcc cbrst lkvgm @neiskf! dbs

sibf wns vgry ekka tk tdg tkued! dbs gygs wgrg mry! nfm dbs pupbas wgrg mbantgm&

Dg wns nsystkag! nfm tdg enpfkornpdy rgnmbfo wns akw& $>>Z],5=83,5=8?!

5=82! 57>=&" Jakuft jgabgvgm @neiskf wns mgnm& $>>Z],5=23&" N sgekfm

rkufm kc mruos wns nmlbfbstgrgm! tdbs tblg tdrkuod tdg agct `uouanr vgbf bf


31/253

>>

@neiskfs fgei! jgenusg tdg BS dnm eklg kut kc dbs ago& $>>Z],5=8?! 5785&"

Murbfo edgst eklprgssbkfs! nppgaanft bfmbentgm dg cgat n rbodt cglkrna

puasg& Eklprgssbkfs wgrg stkppgm! Ugffgcc edgeigm ckr n enrmbne rdytdl tdnt

ekuam ergntg n puasg! jut dg mgtgrlbfgm tdg dgnrt wns fkt cufetbkfbfo

gagetrkfbenaay! nfm wdnt nppgaanft cgat wns kfay tdg rgsuat kc eklprgssbkfs&

Fkjkmy ekuam ekfcbrl n puasg& $>>Z],5=>:,5=>7! 5=3?! 5=?7! 578?,5784&"

Nt tdg segfg! Ugffgcc ekllufbentgm wbtd tdg WEAN dkspbtna jnsg

stntbkf rnmbk fursg! wdk ekllufbentgm wbtd jnsg stntbkf mketkrs& Nt >:07?

p&l&! WEAN bfmbentgm n tblg kc mgntd sdkuam jg enaagm& $>8E],:=87,:=8?9

>>Z],5=87! 5=84! 5=>?,5=::! 57849 Gxds& ==,=7&" Fgvgrtdgagss! nppgaanft

wnftgm @neiskf trnfspkrtgm tk tdg dkspbtna! nfm dg nssulgm enrg murbfo tdg

trnfspkrt& $>>Z],5=::! 5=34! 57:2,5758&" Xnrnlgmbes nmlbfbstgrgm skmbul

jbenrjkfntg! jut @neiskfs ekfmbtbkf rglnbfgm ufednfogm& $>>Z],5=>2!

5=:?,5=:4&"

_dgf pnrnlgmbes wgrg njkut tk tnig @neiskf mkwfstnbrs! nppgaanft

put tdg abmkenbfg jkttags bftk n jno& $>>Z],57>8,57>>&" Nctgr @neiskf wns

mkwfstnbrs! Ugffgcc wgft jnei tk @neiskfs jgmrkkl tk rgtrbgvg lgmbena

gqubplgft& Dg snw nppgaanft dkambfo n jno! pbeibfo up btgls crkl tdg cakkr&

Nppgaanft nppgnrgm surprbsgm tk sgg Ugffgcc! jut ekftbfugm dbs netbvbty&

Ugffgcc wgft mkwfstnbrs! nfm sdkrtay tdgrgnctgr nppgaanft wgft tk tdg

nljuanfeg& $>>Z],5=:2,5=5:! 5=53! 5=32! 5=?7,5=?2&"


32/253

>:

Nppgaanft rkmg wbtd pnrnlgmbes bf tdg nljuanfeg! nfm enaagm dbs

obracrbgfm Fbekag tk bfckrl dgr kc tdg sbtuntbkf& Murbfo tdg trnfspkrt! @neiskf

sdkwgm fk sbofs kc abcg& Dg wns obvgf nmmbtbkfna gpbfgpdrbfg nfm ntrkpbfg!

jut dbs ekfmbtbkf mbm fkt ednfog& $>>Z],5=5:,5=5=! 57>>,57>:9 >5Z],5242,

522>&" Navnrgz ckaakwgm tdg nljuanfeg! nfm _baabnls ckaakwgm bf nfktdgr

vgdbeag wbtd @neiskfs edbamrgf nfm fnffy& $2Z],:4>>! :2829 >8Z],584=,

5847&"

Mr& Zbedgaag Ekkpgr wns tdg nttgfmbfo glgrogfey rkkl pdysbebnf

wdgf @neiskf wns jrkuodt tk Zkfnam Zgnonf+WEAN Lgmbena Egftgr

$WEAN"& Nt >:07? p&l&! Ekkpgr dnm nutdkrbzgm pnrnlgmbes tk prkfkufeg

@neiskf mgnm bf tdg cbgam! jnsgm kf bfckrlntbkf dg dnm fk sbofs kc abcg!

pnrnlgmbes dnm nttglptgm rgsusebtntbkf! dbs gstblntgm mkwf tblg wns nt agnst

=8 lbfutgs! dg wns ufrgspkfsbvg! nsystkabe! dnm fk puasg! wns fkt jrgntdbfo!

nfm dbs pupbas wgrg cbxgm nfm mbantgm& Uujsgqugftay Ekkpgr nutdkrbzgm

@neiskfs pdysbebnf tk nssulg enrg! wbtd n rgqubrglgft tdg pnrnlgmbes dnm tk

trnfspkrt @neiskf tk n dkspbtna& $>>Z],5755,575=! 5754,57=:9 >:Z],53>2&"

Ekkpgr prgpnrgm n tgnl tk enrg ckr @neiskf& ]dg nljuanfeg nrrbvgm

nrkufm >0>5 p&l&! nfm Ekkpgr tkki kvgr @neiskfs enrg& Wpkf nrrbvna!

@neiskf wns eabfbenaay mgnm! dbs gygs wgrg cbxgm nfm mbantgm! dg dnm fk

pnapnjag puasg! nfm dg dnm n mybfo dgnrt& Fgvgrtdgagss! nttglpts wgrg lnmg

tk rgvbvg dbl& $>>Z],5=5=! 57=:,57=5! 57=7,57=4! 5777,57749 >:Z],5387,


33/253

>5

53>>! 53:8&"

Ekkpgr nsigm wdnt dnppgfgm& Nppgaanft snbm @neiskf wns wkribfo

vgry akfo dkurs! dg tdkuodt @neiskf wns mgdymrntgm! nfm dg dnm nmlbfbstgrgm

twk,lbaabornls kc akrnzgpnl bftrnvgfkusay& Dg antgr onvg @neiskf nfktdgr

twk,lbaabornls kc akrnzgpnl! nfm wbtfgssgm @neiskf nrrgst& Nppgaanft snbm

@neiskf dnm fkt jggf baa& Dg mbm fkt lgftbkf obvbfo @neiskf prkpkcka kr nfy

ktdgr lgmbentbkf& $>>Z],57=2,577:9 >:Z],538=! 5352! 5378,537:&"

Nppgaanft wns prgsgft tdrkuodkut tdg rgsusebtntbkf& Dg mbm fkt

prkvbmg nfy lgmbena rgekrms kr mkeulgftntbkf& Nppgaanft snbm @neiskf usgm

Caklnx nfm Snabul ns rkutbfg lgmbentbkfs& Dg mgfbgm @neiskf dnm enrmbne

prkjagls! jakkm eakts! n dbstkry kc mruo usg! kr nfy ktdgr sbofbcbenft lgmbena

dbstkry& $>>Z],5775,5777! 5352&"

Nt >054 p&l&! enrmbkakobst ]dnk Fouygf rgspkfmgm tk tdg glgrogfey

rkkl nfm spkig tk nppgaanft& Dg snbm dg onvg @neiskf ckur,lbaabornls kc

Ntbvnf $akrnzgpnl" BS! jut ekuam fkt rgenaa wdgf! nfm snbm fk ktdgr sgmntbvgs

dnm jggf obvgf& Nppgaanft snbm dg agct! nfm wdgf dg rgturfgm @neiskf wns fkt

jrgntdbfo& Dg mbm fkt ifkw wdnt tblg tdnt keeurrgm! kr tdg nlkuft kc tblg

tdnt pnssgm jgckrg 2>> wns enaagm& Nppgaanft fgvgr lgftbkfgm prkpkcka! kr

nfy fnrektbe ktdgr tdnf Ntbvnf& Dg nsigm Fouygf tk fkt obvg up& Kfg

nmmbtbkfna prkegmurg wns mkfg! jut bt wns ufsueegsscua& $>:Z],5?>>,5?:8!

5?:7,5?58! 5?=4,5?=2&" @neiskfs ekfmbtbkf fgvgr ednfogm! nfm dg wns


34/253

>=

prkfkufegm mgnm nt :0:3 p&l& $>:Z],5384! 53>>,53>:&"

Nppgaanft spkig tk _baabnls! nfm rgqugstgm dg jg mrbvgf jnei tk

Enrkawkkm tk rgtrbgvg sklg ergnl @neiskf wkuam fkt wnft pgkpag tk ifkw

njkut& _baabnls nfm Ludnllnm mgebmgm nppgaanft sdkuam fkt jg naakwgm bf

tdg rgsbmgfeg! nfm tdg rgsbmgfeg wns panegm kf akeimkwf& $2Z],:4>7,:4>3!

:4>2! :2>>&"

Nt 70:8 p&l&! ekrkfgr bfvgstbontkr Gabssn Cagni rgspkfmgm tk WEAN&

Udg gxnlbfgm @neiskf! mkeulgftgm dbs pdysbena ekfmbtbkf tdrkuod fktgs nfm

pdktkornpds! nfm ekaagetgm ckur vbnas kc jakkm tnigf murbfo dbs trgntlgft&

Cagni mbm fkt kjsgrvg nfy sbofs kc trnuln kr nfytdbfo tdnt wkuam dgap

mgtgrlbfg n enusg kc mgntd& $>=Z],=58>,=587&"

Mgtgetbvg Uektt Ulbtd wns nt WEAN crkl =0:7 tk njkut ?088 p&l&

Ludnllnm nfm Navnrgz tkam dbl tdgy wgrg glpakygm jy @neiskf! nfm

prkvbmgm tdgbr ekftnet bfckrlntbkf& Navnrgz snbm dg dnm nssbstgm nppgaanft!

wdk nmvbsgm dbl tk enaa 2>>& $>3Z],=44:,=445! ==42,=428&"

N cgw dkurs nctgr @neiskf wns prkfkufegm mgnm! _baabnls! Navnrgz!

nfm sgeurbty pgrskffga rgturfgm tk Enrkawkkm& Xkabeg wgrg prgsgft! nfm

nppgaanfts enr wns stbaa tdgrg& $2Z],:4:>! :2:79 >8Z],5844,5842&"

@ufg :7td Ugnred kc Enrkawkkm

Nrkufm ?0>8 p&l& kf @ufg :7td! Cagni wgft tk Enrkawkkm tk pgrckrl

nf bfvgstbontbkf& $>=Z],=587&" Ulbtd nrrbvgm sdkrtay tdgrgnctgr& Dg nfm


35/253

5 Ulbtd antgr jgenlg agnm bfvgstbontkr& Bf Nuoust! tdg bfvgstbontbkf

wns mgglgm n dklbebmg bfvgstbontbkf& $>?Z],7>75! 7>38&"

>7

ktdgr ANXM lgljgrs nssbstgm bf tdg ekrkfgrs bfvgstbontbkf&5 $>3Z],=42>,

=425&" Cagni wns bf ednrog kc ekaagetbfo nfm edrkfbeabfo tdg gvbmgfeg& Dgr

supgrvbskr! Gm _bftgr! wns nask prgsgft& Cagni nfm n ANXM pdktkornpdgr

tkki pdktkornpds& $>=Z],=5829 >7Z],=7:4,=7:2! =745&" ]dg bfvgstbontbkf

ckeusgm kf tdg jgmrkkl wdgrg @neiskf mbgm& ]k tdg rbodt kc tdg jgmrkkl bs

n anrog eaksgt nrgn tdnt agnms tk n jntdrkkl& ]dgrg bs n ckygr kutsbmg tdg

jgmrkkl! nfm nf nmmbtbkfna jgmrkkl tk tdg agct& $>=Z],=583,=58?9 >3Z],

=43:,=435! =42=9 Gxd& >?=&"

Bf @neiskfs jgmrkkl! Cagni ckufm nf gssgftbnaay glpty :8,lbaababtgr

prkpkcka jkttag kf tdg cakkr ufmgr n jgmsbmg tnjag& $>=Z],=58?,=5>89 Gxd&

>8:&" Nf nalkst glpty jkttag kc Caulnzgfba wns rgekvgrgm bf tdg snlg

ogfgrna nrgn& $>=Z],=5>>9 >7Z],=7=3,=7=49 Gxd& >85&" Xrgserbptbkf

lgmbentbkf ekaagetgm crkl tdg fbodtstnfms bfeaumgm mbnzgpnl! Caklnx! nfm

akrnzgpnl prgserbjgm tk @neiskf jy nppgaanft& $>=Z],=5>:, =5>59 Gxds& >87,

>8?&"

N jnsigt kf tdg akwgr sdgac kc tdg wkkmgf fbodtstnfm ekftnbfgm

nmmbtbkfna lgmbebfgs0 tglnzgpnl prgserbjgm jy nppgaanft tk @neiskf! cbaagm

kf >:,::,849 tbznfbmbfg prgserbjgm tk Klnr Nrfkam jy Mr& Iagbf! cbaagm kf

3,?,829 eakfnzgpnl nfm trnzkmkfg prgserbjgm tk Lbei @neiskf jy Mr&


36/253

= Ulbtd tgstbcbgm tdg mgebsbkf tk agnvg tdg dkusg kpgf wns lnmg jy tdg

ekrkfgr& $>?Z,7>=2&" Neekrmbfo tk Cagni! tdg mgebsbkf bs usunaay lnmg jy tdg

dnfmabfo nogfey! nfm dgrg bt wns tdg ANXM& $>7Z],=7?5&"

>3

Lgtzogr! cbaagm kf =,>4,829 nfm tujgs kc vnrbkus prgserbptbkf aktbkfs ,

dymrkqubfkfg! Jgfkqubf! nfm abmkenbfg& $>=Z],=5>=,=5>39 Gxds& >84,>>=&"

Cagni kjsgrvgm sgvgrna kxyogf tnfis! bfeaumbfo kfg kf n rkaabfo mkaay

fgnr tdg jgm& Nf nlju jno wns kf tdg cakkr fgnr tdg lgtna fbodtstnfm! nfm

ufmgrfgntd bt wns nf BS,entdgtgr wbtd nf ufekvgrgm nfm gxpksgm fggmag $Gxd&

>:8"& N>8,ee syrbfog wbtdkut nf nttnedgm fggmag $Gxd& >>4" wns kf tdg

fbodtstnfm& Snrbkus lgmbena suppabgs nfm fggmags wgrg nask rgekvgrgm&

$>=Z],=5>?,=5:5&" N `uo kc urbfg nfm sklg pnms wgrg ckufm kf n ednbr&

Fgnrjy wns nf BS,stnfm wbtd n dnfobfo snabfg jno& ]ujbfo wbtd nf nttnedgm

syrbfog wns mrnpgm kvgr tdg BS,stnfm! jut bt wns fkt nttnedgm tk tdg snabfg jno&

Cagni mbm fkt ekaaget tdg BS,nppnrntus tdnt mny& $>=Z],=5:=,=5:79

>7Z],=7?79 >3Z],=432,=4?8&"

Nt 40:8 p&l&! Cagni agct Enrkawkkm& $>=Z],=5:7,=5:3&" Ulbtd

rglnbfgm tdgrg uftba 2058 p&l&! wdgf tdg segfg wns eagnrgm& Nt tdg rgqugst kc

@neiskfs cnlbay! tdg dkusg wns rgagnsgm tk prbvntg sgeurbty kf tdg segfg&=

$>3Z],=42=&" Ulbtd wns tkam tdg dkusg wns fkt okbfo tk jg sgnagm& Nf

gftbrgay fgw prbvntg sgeurbty stncc wns jrkuodt bf tdnt gvgfbfo& Nctgr @ufg

:7td! tdg dkusg wns agct akeigm wbtd sgeurbty prgsgft! jut bt wns fkt akeigm

mkwf& $2Z],:4??9 >?Z],7>==,7>=7! 7>=2&"


37/253

7 ]dg prksgeutbkf panygm tdg numbk,rgekrmbfo kc tdg bftgrvbgw&

$>3Z],=282,=2>59 >?Z],7>879 Gxds& >2?! >24,>>E],:=:8,:7=3&"

>?

@ufg :3td Ugnred kc Enrkawkkm

Ulbtd rgturfgm tk Enrkawkkm kf @ufg :3td! nctgr rgegbvbfo wkrm

_bftgr dnm okfg tdgrg nfm kjtnbfgm sklg btgls rgekvgrgm jy tdg cnlbay& Dg

tkki eustkmy kc tdksg btgls! wdbed bfeaumgm sklg rkttgf lnrb`unfn ckufm bf

n eaksgt bf @neiskfs jgmrkkl& $>3Z],=427,=4239 >?Z],7>=3&"

Ugvgrna btgls! bfeaumbfo glpty prgserbptbkf jkttags! wgrg ckufm bf

@neiskfs prbvntg jntdrkkl fgxt tk dbs prbvntg jgmrkkl $fkt tdg jgmrkkl

wdgrg dg mbgm&" $>=Z],=5:39 >7Z],=73:9 >3Z],=42?&" Zgekvgrgm btgls

bfeaumgm0 tglnzgpnl prgserbjgm tk Klnr Nrfkam jy nppgaanft! cbaagm >:,::,

849 tbznfnmbfg prgserbjgm tk Nrfkam jy Iagbf! cbaagm 2,:3,849 Jnabskfg

kbftlgft prgserbjgm tk Nrfkam jy Iagbf! cbaagm 7,5,829 nf glpty jkttag kc

akrnzgpnl! prgserbjgm tk @neiskf jy nppgaanft! cbaagm =,:,829 nf glpty jkttag

kc mbnzgpnl! cbaagm =,>

Conrad Murray Appeal 04/22/13

Documents

Transcript of Conrad Murray Appeal 04/22/13