Connected and Automated Vehicles: Modeling and … · • Enhanced mobility for low-mobility...
Transcript of Connected and Automated Vehicles: Modeling and … · • Enhanced mobility for low-mobility...
![Page 1: Connected and Automated Vehicles: Modeling and … · • Enhanced mobility for low-mobility populaon ... - Cyber-physical systems ... – User equilibrium/system opMmum traffic assignment](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022022514/5af344987f8b9a190c8b61b0/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
ConnectedandAutomatedVehicles:ModelingandManagementNeeds
SrinivasPeeta,[email protected]
1
NUTC-FHWAWorkshopJuly23,2017
![Page 2: Connected and Automated Vehicles: Modeling and … · • Enhanced mobility for low-mobility populaon ... - Cyber-physical systems ... – User equilibrium/system opMmum traffic assignment](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022022514/5af344987f8b9a190c8b61b0/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
q VehicularautomaMon,inconjuncMonwithconnecMvity,isprovingtobedisrupMveandtransformaMve§ ARermorethanacentury,thehumanisrelinquishingdrivingcontrol§ Machines(vehicles):controlandarMficialintelligence(learning)
q VehicularcapabiliMes,drivenbytechnology,areadvancingatafargreaterpacethansociety’sabilitytohandlethem§ Gaps(human,builtenvironment,management,models/procedures)§ Consequences(emergent)§ TransiMon(geZngtherefromhere)
ConnectedandAutomatedVehicles(CAVs)
2
![Page 3: Connected and Automated Vehicles: Modeling and … · • Enhanced mobility for low-mobility populaon ... - Cyber-physical systems ... – User equilibrium/system opMmum traffic assignment](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022022514/5af344987f8b9a190c8b61b0/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
q Standards:clarity,uniformity,policy,ethics,legal
q Technology:flux,acceptability,adopMon,long-term
q SystemevoluMon:emergentoutcomes,phenomena
q TransiMon:mixedtraffic,infra.design,regulaMons
q PotenMalforobsolescence:howtohedge?
q Decision-making:planning,investment,recourse
q Traffic/systemmodelingandmanagementneeds
ChallengesarisingfromCAVs
3
![Page 4: Connected and Automated Vehicles: Modeling and … · • Enhanced mobility for low-mobility populaon ... - Cyber-physical systems ... – User equilibrium/system opMmum traffic assignment](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022022514/5af344987f8b9a190c8b61b0/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
4
Infrastructure
Human Vehicle
Why:modeling&managementneeds?
Industry
Government
Academia
SOCIETY
![Page 5: Connected and Automated Vehicles: Modeling and … · • Enhanced mobility for low-mobility populaon ... - Cyber-physical systems ... – User equilibrium/system opMmum traffic assignment](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022022514/5af344987f8b9a190c8b61b0/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
5
Why:modeling&managementneeds?q Itisaboutmorethanjustthevehicleq Howhumansinterfaceneedstobewell-understoodq Infrastructuredesignq Regulatory,legal,policy/ethical,security,standards
Infrastructure
Human Vehicle
![Page 6: Connected and Automated Vehicles: Modeling and … · • Enhanced mobility for low-mobility populaon ... - Cyber-physical systems ... – User equilibrium/system opMmum traffic assignment](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022022514/5af344987f8b9a190c8b61b0/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
6
Emergentphenomena• Ghostridership,carsharing,ridehailing• Datamanagementandsecurity
Safety• Fewerroadaccidents• Eliminatehumanerror
Mobility• Enhancedmobilityforlow-mobilitypopulaMon• Lesser“wasted”Mmeintravel
ImpactsofCAVs
![Page 7: Connected and Automated Vehicles: Modeling and … · • Enhanced mobility for low-mobility populaon ... - Cyber-physical systems ... – User equilibrium/system opMmum traffic assignment](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022022514/5af344987f8b9a190c8b61b0/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
7
ImpactsofCAVs
Environment• Energy-efficientdriving• Vehicle-milestraveledmayincrease
Industry• Disruptsfreight,mobilityservices,etc.• Couldcreatenewjobs
Realestatemarket• Urbansprawl• Redesigninglanduse
ModelsneedtobeabletocaptureCAVimpacts
![Page 8: Connected and Automated Vehicles: Modeling and … · • Enhanced mobility for low-mobility populaon ... - Cyber-physical systems ... – User equilibrium/system opMmum traffic assignment](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022022514/5af344987f8b9a190c8b61b0/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
8
Example:LevelofautomaMon
![Page 9: Connected and Automated Vehicles: Modeling and … · • Enhanced mobility for low-mobility populaon ... - Cyber-physical systems ... – User equilibrium/system opMmum traffic assignment](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022022514/5af344987f8b9a190c8b61b0/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
9
Source:www.jchs.harvard.edu
Example:Americaisaging
![Page 10: Connected and Automated Vehicles: Modeling and … · • Enhanced mobility for low-mobility populaon ... - Cyber-physical systems ... – User equilibrium/system opMmum traffic assignment](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022022514/5af344987f8b9a190c8b61b0/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
10
Source:www.jchs.harvard.edu
Example:Agingandtravel
![Page 11: Connected and Automated Vehicles: Modeling and … · • Enhanced mobility for low-mobility populaon ... - Cyber-physical systems ... – User equilibrium/system opMmum traffic assignment](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022022514/5af344987f8b9a190c8b61b0/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
11
Supply
Demand Technology
What:modeling&managementneeds?
Individuallyinflux,andinteracGonsontopofthat!
![Page 12: Connected and Automated Vehicles: Modeling and … · • Enhanced mobility for low-mobility populaon ... - Cyber-physical systems ... – User equilibrium/system opMmum traffic assignment](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022022514/5af344987f8b9a190c8b61b0/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
q TransportaMoncharacterisMcs§ Demand-sideaspects§ Supply-sideaspects
q SystemmanagementobjecMve§ Planning§ OperaMons
q AnalysisandimplementaMontools§ AnalyMcalmodels/procedures/processes§ SimulaMonmodels/soRware§ Drivingsimulators§ Virtual/augmentedrealityapproaches§ Real-worldtesMngfaciliMes
What:modeling&managementneeds?
12
![Page 13: Connected and Automated Vehicles: Modeling and … · • Enhanced mobility for low-mobility populaon ... - Cyber-physical systems ... – User equilibrium/system opMmum traffic assignment](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022022514/5af344987f8b9a190c8b61b0/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
13
Demand-sideaspects
TravelMode
IntheVehicle
LifestyleChoices
TravelBehavior
- Vehicleownership- Newmodes&adopMon- Mobilityasaservice- TransiMonperiod
- Modechoice- DepartureMmechoice- Routechoice- Parkingchoice- Roleoftechnology
ModelingforCAVs:
Demand-side
- ValueofMme- In-vehicleacMviMes- Human-machineinteracMons
- LocaMonaldecisions- AcMviMes- AcMvityscheduling- Traveldecisions(roleofdemographics)
![Page 14: Connected and Automated Vehicles: Modeling and … · • Enhanced mobility for low-mobility populaon ... - Cyber-physical systems ... – User equilibrium/system opMmum traffic assignment](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022022514/5af344987f8b9a190c8b61b0/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
14
Driver/TravelerBehavior
TrafficFlow
TrafficManagement
NetworkDesign
- Roleofhuman- RoleofinformaMon- Technologyuptake
- Signalcontrol(V2X)- TrafficoperaMons- Publictransit- Roadwaydesign- Parkingsystem
ModelingforCAVs:
Supply-side
- Trafficmeasures- VehicularinteracMons- Platooning- Mixedtraffic- Ghostridership
- UserobjecMve- Roleoftechnology- InnovaMonsinsoluMons- Cyber-physicalsystems
Supply-sideaspects
![Page 15: Connected and Automated Vehicles: Modeling and … · • Enhanced mobility for low-mobility populaon ... - Cyber-physical systems ... – User equilibrium/system opMmum traffic assignment](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022022514/5af344987f8b9a190c8b61b0/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Concludingcommentsq ExisMngmodelsneedtobeupdated/modified/discardedto
accountforchangesduetoCAVs
q NewmodelstoleveragenewtechnologicalcapabiliMes,andcaptureemergentinteracMons
q ModelingforCAVsemphasizesintegraMonofadvancedtechnologies
q ModelingchallengesinthetransiMonperiod
q ModelingneedstofactorsocialandinteracMon/integraMonaspects
q Datawillplayamoreimportantrole
q CooperaMve/synergisMcapplicaMonswillbemorepromising
15
![Page 16: Connected and Automated Vehicles: Modeling and … · • Enhanced mobility for low-mobility populaon ... - Cyber-physical systems ... – User equilibrium/system opMmum traffic assignment](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022022514/5af344987f8b9a190c8b61b0/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
NOTE: To change the image on this slide, select the picture and delete it. Then click the Pictures icon in the placeholder to insert your own image.
Thankyou!
Popular Mechanics, 1950s
ContactInformaGon:SrinivasPeetaEmail:[email protected]:hSp://www.purdue.edu/discoverypark/nextrans/CCAT:hSp://ccat.umtri.umich.edu
![Page 17: Connected and Automated Vehicles: Modeling and … · • Enhanced mobility for low-mobility populaon ... - Cyber-physical systems ... – User equilibrium/system opMmum traffic assignment](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022022514/5af344987f8b9a190c8b61b0/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Roleofhuman
17
q Newphenomena§ Drivingdecisions/acMonswillbereplacedbyautonomouscontrol
systems§ RouMngdecisions/acMonswillbedynamicallyintervenedby
autonomouscontrolsystems
q Currentmodelscando– DepartureMmechoice;routechoice;modechoice;valueoftravel
Mme;valueoftravelMmereliability
q Ques4onsneedtobeaddressed– ChangestovalueoftravelMmeanditsreliability(vehicleasan
extensionofworkplaceorforleisure)
– RouMng/rerouMngunderCAVs– CombinaMonoftravelers’preferencesandautonomoussystem
control
![Page 18: Connected and Automated Vehicles: Modeling and … · • Enhanced mobility for low-mobility populaon ... - Cyber-physical systems ... – User equilibrium/system opMmum traffic assignment](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022022514/5af344987f8b9a190c8b61b0/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
RoleofinformaMon
18
q Newphenomena§ Real-MmeinformaMoncanbeautomaMcallyprocessedand
analyzedbyCAVs
q Currentmodelscando– TravelMmeesMmaMon;travelMmereliabilityesMmaMon;dynamic
shortestpath;V2VinformaMonpropagaMon;V2IcommunicaMons
q Ques4onsneedtobeaddressed– InformaMonprovisionstrategiesforCAVs
– InformaMonfiltering/customizaMon
– MaliciousinformaMonprevenMon
– PrivacyprotecMon– InformaMonintegraMonwithtravelerpreferences
![Page 19: Connected and Automated Vehicles: Modeling and … · • Enhanced mobility for low-mobility populaon ... - Cyber-physical systems ... – User equilibrium/system opMmum traffic assignment](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022022514/5af344987f8b9a190c8b61b0/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
19
Technologyuptakeq Newphenomena
§ TransiMonperiodandtransiencewillexist
q Currentmodelscando– Lifecycleanalysis
q Ques4onsneedtobeaddressed– Howtravelers’behaviorschangegradually– ModelingtrafficflowevoluMontowardapurelyautonomous
drivingenvironment
![Page 20: Connected and Automated Vehicles: Modeling and … · • Enhanced mobility for low-mobility populaon ... - Cyber-physical systems ... – User equilibrium/system opMmum traffic assignment](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022022514/5af344987f8b9a190c8b61b0/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
q CurrenttrafficflowtheorymaynotbeapplicableforCAVsduetohomogeneityindrivingbehavior
q CAVscanmoveinplatoonsatauniformspeed
q Highwaycapacityismoreflexibleandcontrollable
q QueueformaMonanddissipaMonmechanismmaychange
Trafficflowtheory
20
![Page 21: Connected and Automated Vehicles: Modeling and … · • Enhanced mobility for low-mobility populaon ... - Cyber-physical systems ... – User equilibrium/system opMmum traffic assignment](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022022514/5af344987f8b9a190c8b61b0/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
21
Volume,speedanddensityq Currentmodelscando
§ RelaMonoftrafficvolumewithrespect
tospeedanddensity§ MacroscopicFundamentalDiagram
§ Volume,density,andspeedchangesunderinclementweathercondiMons
§ Uncertaintyinthetrafficflows
q Ques4onsneedtobeaddressed– ChangesintherelaMonshipsbetween
volume,speedanddensityunderCAVs
– UncertaintyreducMon– Uniformheadways
𝑞=𝑣∙𝑘
CitedfromFernandes,P.,Nunes,U.PlatooningWithIVC-EnabledAutonomousVehicles:StrategiestoMiMgateCommunicaMonDelays,ImproveSafetyandTrafficFlow.IEEETransacMonsonIntelligentTransportaMonSystems,13(1),2012
![Page 22: Connected and Automated Vehicles: Modeling and … · • Enhanced mobility for low-mobility populaon ... - Cyber-physical systems ... – User equilibrium/system opMmum traffic assignment](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022022514/5af344987f8b9a190c8b61b0/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
22
Trafficwaveq Newphenomena
§ CAVscancommunicatewitheachotherandreacttoinformaMonmoreefficiently
§ DifferentmobilityparernwithouthumanintervenMon
q Currentmodelscando– Homogeneousandheterogeneoustrafficwave(kinemaMcwave
theory)
q Ques4onsneedtobeaddressed– TrafficwavecharacterisMcsduetoV2VandV2IcommunicaMons
– Trafficwavespeedscanincreasesignificantly
![Page 23: Connected and Automated Vehicles: Modeling and … · • Enhanced mobility for low-mobility populaon ... - Cyber-physical systems ... – User equilibrium/system opMmum traffic assignment](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022022514/5af344987f8b9a190c8b61b0/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
23
Mixedtrafficq Newphenomena
§ CAVsbehavemorehomogeneouslyinplatoonstoimprovesystemperformance
§ CAVscancommunicatewitheachotherandinfrastructure
q Currentmodelscando– Heterogeneoustrafficflowmodels(focusmoreonmixtureofcars
andtrucks)
q Ques4onsneedtobeaddressed– ModelingplatoonstreamsforCAVs
– Car-followingmodelformixedtrafficwithautonomousandhuman-operatedvehicles
– “Car-followingmodels”formulM-classCAVtraffic
![Page 24: Connected and Automated Vehicles: Modeling and … · • Enhanced mobility for low-mobility populaon ... - Cyber-physical systems ... – User equilibrium/system opMmum traffic assignment](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022022514/5af344987f8b9a190c8b61b0/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
Signalcontrolq Newphenomena
§ CAVscancommunicatewithsignalcontrolsystemsandautomaMcallydetermineopMmalspeeds
§ CAVscanformplatoonswhenapproachingintersecMon
§ CAVflowsmaybemanagedthroughsignalcontrol
q Currentmodelscando– SignalMmingplans;adapMvetrafficsignalcontrols;signalcoordinaMon;
signalpreempMon
q Ques4onsneedtobeaddressed– Realizenetwork-widesignalcoordinaMonforCAVs– ProvidesignalpreempMontoCAVplatoons
– ManagepurelyautonomousvehiclesatsignalizedintersecMons
24
![Page 25: Connected and Automated Vehicles: Modeling and … · • Enhanced mobility for low-mobility populaon ... - Cyber-physical systems ... – User equilibrium/system opMmum traffic assignment](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022022514/5af344987f8b9a190c8b61b0/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
§ CAVsmovemoreefficientlythanhuman-drivenvehicles
§ SpecialdesigntofacilitatethemobilityofCAVs
q Newphenomena
Highwaydesign
q Ques4onsneedtobeaddressed– Highwaydesignformixedtrafficwith
autonomousandhuman-drivenvehicles
– Highwaydesignforpurelyautonomousvehicles
25
![Page 26: Connected and Automated Vehicles: Modeling and … · • Enhanced mobility for low-mobility populaon ... - Cyber-physical systems ... – User equilibrium/system opMmum traffic assignment](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022022514/5af344987f8b9a190c8b61b0/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
q Newphenomena§ ACAVcanparkitself
§ Parkingdistancecanbeextended
§ Parkingspacecanbeusedmoreefficiently(on-demand)
q Currentmodelscando– Parkingfacilitydesign;parkingdemandsandsupplyanalysis;
park-and-rideplanningandoperaMons;parkingpricingstrategies
q Ques4onsneedtobeaddressed– Facilitydesigntofacilitateauto-parking– Sharedpark-and-ride
Parkingsystem
26
![Page 27: Connected and Automated Vehicles: Modeling and … · • Enhanced mobility for low-mobility populaon ... - Cyber-physical systems ... – User equilibrium/system opMmum traffic assignment](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022022514/5af344987f8b9a190c8b61b0/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
Publictransitq Newphenomena
§ Human-operatedtaxicabcanbereplacedbydriverlessones
§ Publictransitridershipmayincreaseduetoreducedcarownership
q Currentmodelscando– PublictransitinfrastructuresystemmodelingandopMmizaMon
– IntegratedpublictransportaMonplanning– RouteopMmizaMonanddispatchingplanningfortaxicab
– OpMmalMmetablesfortransitsystems
q Ques4onsneedtobeaddressed– Transitdemandanalysis
– PricingstrategiesforCAVtaxis,ride-sharing/ride-hailingservices
27
![Page 28: Connected and Automated Vehicles: Modeling and … · • Enhanced mobility for low-mobility populaon ... - Cyber-physical systems ... – User equilibrium/system opMmum traffic assignment](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022022514/5af344987f8b9a190c8b61b0/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
28
Freightfacilityq Newphenomena
§ Connectedandautonomoustruckscantravelmoreefficiently
§ RoutescanbeopMmizedandupdatedinreal-Mme
§ Connectedandautonomoustruckscanformplatoons
q Ques4onsneedtobeaddressed– LocaMonplanningforfreightfacility– JointopMmizaMonproblemsoffreightoperaMonsandnetworkdesign
Mercedes-BenzFutureTruck
![Page 29: Connected and Automated Vehicles: Modeling and … · • Enhanced mobility for low-mobility populaon ... - Cyber-physical systems ... – User equilibrium/system opMmum traffic assignment](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022022514/5af344987f8b9a190c8b61b0/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
29
UE/SOq Newphenomena
§ UserdecisionswillbemoreinfluencedbysystemlevelobjecMves
q Currentmodelscando– Userequilibrium/systemopMmumtrafficassignment
– AcMvitybasedtrafficassignment
q Ques4onsneedtobeaddressed– UE/SOtrafficassignmentwithnewcostfuncMon
– UE/SOtrafficassignmentformixedtrafficwithautonomousandhuman-operatedvehicles
– UE/SOtrafficassignmentformulM-classCAVs
![Page 30: Connected and Automated Vehicles: Modeling and … · • Enhanced mobility for low-mobility populaon ... - Cyber-physical systems ... – User equilibrium/system opMmum traffic assignment](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022022514/5af344987f8b9a190c8b61b0/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
30
DeterminisMc/StochasMcq Newphenomena
§ Vehiclescanbecontrolledmoreeasilybycentralizedsystem
§ TrafficcondiMon“percepMons”willbemoreaccurate
q Currentmodelscando– DeterminisMc/stochasMctrafficassignment
q Ques4onsneedtobeaddressed– NoMonofstochasMcitymayhaveadifferentperspecMve;not
primarilydrivenbydriverpercepMons/acMons
– StochasMctrafficassignmentforpurelyautonomousvehicles
![Page 31: Connected and Automated Vehicles: Modeling and … · • Enhanced mobility for low-mobility populaon ... - Cyber-physical systems ... – User equilibrium/system opMmum traffic assignment](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022022514/5af344987f8b9a190c8b61b0/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
31
StaMc/Dynamicq Newphenomena
§ CAVscanreceivereal-MmeinformaMonanddynamicallyadjustdecisions
q Currentmodelscando– StaMc/dynamictrafficassignment
q Ques4onsneedtobeaddressed– StaMc/dynamictrafficassignmentformixedtrafficwith
autonomousandhuman-operatedvehicles
– StaMc/dynamictrafficassignmentforCAVswithfullcooperaMonandreal-MmetrafficinformaMon
![Page 32: Connected and Automated Vehicles: Modeling and … · • Enhanced mobility for low-mobility populaon ... - Cyber-physical systems ... – User equilibrium/system opMmum traffic assignment](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022022514/5af344987f8b9a190c8b61b0/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
32
Responsetoincidents
q Newphenomena§ CAVscanreceivetrafficinformaMonmorequickly
§ CAVscanmovecooperaMvely
q Currentmodelscando– EmergencyevacuaMonrouMng
– RerouMngundernon-recurrenttrafficcongesMon
q Ques4onsneedtobeaddressed– Trafficassignmentmodelsunderincidentscenarioswith
cooperaMvevehiclemovement
![Page 33: Connected and Automated Vehicles: Modeling and … · • Enhanced mobility for low-mobility populaon ... - Cyber-physical systems ... – User equilibrium/system opMmum traffic assignment](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022022514/5af344987f8b9a190c8b61b0/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
IntersecMondesignq Newphenomena§ CAVscanmoveathigherspeedswhen
approachingintersecMons
§ CAVscantalktoeachotherandtheinfrastructure
q Currentmodelscando– Clover-leafdesign;roundabout;
intersecMoncapacitymodeling;safetyanalysis
q Ques4onsneedtobeaddressed– Signal-freeintersecMondesignto
facilitateCAVmovement
33
![Page 34: Connected and Automated Vehicles: Modeling and … · • Enhanced mobility for low-mobility populaon ... - Cyber-physical systems ... – User equilibrium/system opMmum traffic assignment](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022022514/5af344987f8b9a190c8b61b0/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
HighwayoperaMonsq Newphenomena
§ CAVplatoonscantravelmoreefficiently
§ InteracMonsbetweenhuman-drivenvehiclesandautonomousvehiclesneedtobefactored
§ CooperaMveoperaMonsarepossible
q Currentmodelscando– CongesMontollingandtradable-credittollingstrategies;rampmetering;
managedlanes;contraflowlanes
q Ques4onsneedtobeaddressed– UsingexisMnghighwayoperaMonstoencourageCAVride-sharing– Demandmanagementstrategiesforpurelyautonomousvehicles
34