7/30/2019 Complex crimes chart

1/1

Nature GR: 2nd crime mustbe consummated.But, what if onlyattempted/frustrated?

Who mustdie?

What happensto extrarape/homicide?

What if 1stcrime wasNOTconsummated?

Rape withHomicide

Specialcomplexcrime

Consider separatecrime or complex(Art 48),depending on thefacts(rape andattempted/frustrated homicide)

Anyone,since byreason oronoccasionof therape

Not consideredaggravating

Attemptedrape withhomicide(266-B)

KidnappingwithHomicide/rape

Specialcomplexcrime

Consider separatecrime or complex(Art 48),depending on thefacts(kidnapping and

attempted/frustrated homicide/rape)

Kidnapped victimmust bethe onewho died

Not consideredaggravating.Excess rapesare absorbed.

Maybe Art48?

Robberywithrape/homicide

Specialcomplexcrime

Consider separatecrime or complex(Art 48),depending on thefacts(robbery and

attempted/frustrated homicide/rape)

Anyone,since byreason oronoccasionof therobbery.

Not consideredaggravating

Attemptedrobbery withhomicide(297)

Carpnappingwithhomicide/rape

Specialcomplexcrime

Crime which wasnot consummatedcounted asqualifying

Victimmust betheowner,driver oroccupant

of the car.

If anotherpersondies or israped,thenconsiderthatseparating.

Not consideredaggravating.Still countedas one crime.

Not sure ifArt 48 willapply sincecarnappingis a SPL

Forcibleabductionwith rape

ComplexCrimeunder

Art 48

Still complex,since under Art 48

Consider extrarapes asseparate

crimes.