Complex Analysis Exercise sheet 7 (Avoiding mistakes in Questions 1 & 2)

22
Complex Analysis Exercise sheet 7 (Avoiding mistakes in Questions 1 & 2)

Transcript of Complex Analysis Exercise sheet 7 (Avoiding mistakes in Questions 1 & 2)

Page 1: Complex Analysis Exercise sheet 7 (Avoiding mistakes in Questions 1 & 2)

Complex Analysis

Exercise sheet 7

(Avoiding mistakes in Questions 1 & 2)

Page 2: Complex Analysis Exercise sheet 7 (Avoiding mistakes in Questions 1 & 2)

Just to familiarize ourselves with the clicker:

Which English indie rock band had a 2007 single entitled “Mathematics”?

1 2 3 4

45%41%

9%5%

1. Cherry Ghost

2. The Killers

3. Red Hot Chili Peppers

4. Snow Patrol

Page 3: Complex Analysis Exercise sheet 7 (Avoiding mistakes in Questions 1 & 2)

Just to familiarize ourselves with the clicker:

Prior to the 2008 redesign, on which British coin can you find a German sentence that

translated to English reads “I serve”?

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

11%

7%

0%

4%

29%

11%

14%

7%

18%

1. 1p coin

2. 2p coin

3. 5p coin

4. 10p coin

5. 20p coin

6. 50p coin

7. £1 coin

8. £2 coin

9. None

Page 4: Complex Analysis Exercise sheet 7 (Avoiding mistakes in Questions 1 & 2)

The reverse side of the 2p coin:

Page 5: Complex Analysis Exercise sheet 7 (Avoiding mistakes in Questions 1 & 2)

Now, let’s start with Question 2:

Page 6: Complex Analysis Exercise sheet 7 (Avoiding mistakes in Questions 1 & 2)

We start with

This is

1 2 3

25%

33%

42%

1. true.

2. true, but even more is true.

3. false.

Page 7: Complex Analysis Exercise sheet 7 (Avoiding mistakes in Questions 1 & 2)

Okay, let’s be more specific:

This is

1 2

65%

35%

1. true

2. false

Page 8: Complex Analysis Exercise sheet 7 (Avoiding mistakes in Questions 1 & 2)

Remember: The complex numbers are not ordered!

would mean that something like

holds which however doesn’t make sense!

Page 9: Complex Analysis Exercise sheet 7 (Avoiding mistakes in Questions 1 & 2)

By Cauchy’s formulae for the derivatives we have:

1 2

52%

48%

1. True

2. False

Page 10: Complex Analysis Exercise sheet 7 (Avoiding mistakes in Questions 1 & 2)

If z0=0 then

1 2 3

26%

57%

17%

1. True

2. False

3. True, but we can do more

Page 11: Complex Analysis Exercise sheet 7 (Avoiding mistakes in Questions 1 & 2)

Or:

1 2 3

19%

46%

35%1. True

2. False

3. Not sure what is going on here

Page 12: Complex Analysis Exercise sheet 7 (Avoiding mistakes in Questions 1 & 2)

To finish: Using Cauchy’s formula for the first derivative, we obtain

Page 13: Complex Analysis Exercise sheet 7 (Avoiding mistakes in Questions 1 & 2)

Now, move on toHere, we cannot use the Cauchy formulae for the derivatives since z0 is not in the Interior of the contour. But I think

1 2

46%

54%

1. This thought is correct.

2. Nonsense!

Page 14: Complex Analysis Exercise sheet 7 (Avoiding mistakes in Questions 1 & 2)

That is because we can use Cauchy’s Theorem since there is a

domain D such that

1 2

75%

25%

1. Correct

2. Hold on a minute!

Page 15: Complex Analysis Exercise sheet 7 (Avoiding mistakes in Questions 1 & 2)

Yes, true, but the main point is:

and since z0 is outside the contour we can apply Cauchy’s Theorem to get 0 for the path integral in question.

Page 16: Complex Analysis Exercise sheet 7 (Avoiding mistakes in Questions 1 & 2)

Now, on to Question 1:Gauss’ Fundamental Theorem of

Algebra

Every non-constant polynomial has a zero!

Page 17: Complex Analysis Exercise sheet 7 (Avoiding mistakes in Questions 1 & 2)

Begin of proof?

1 2 3 4

40%

28%24%

8%

1. Correct

2. Mistakes in line 1 and 3

3. Mistakes in line 2 and 3

4. Line 3 is false

Page 18: Complex Analysis Exercise sheet 7 (Avoiding mistakes in Questions 1 & 2)

There are two problems:

• Again, the complex numbers are not ordered, thus do not write(what does infinity mean here anyway?)

• You cannot bound it that way, see the following real example:

Page 19: Complex Analysis Exercise sheet 7 (Avoiding mistakes in Questions 1 & 2)

Now have a look at this calculation:

where R>|z|.

Which of the three inequalities are correct?

Page 20: Complex Analysis Exercise sheet 7 (Avoiding mistakes in Questions 1 & 2)

Which of the three inequalities are correct?

1 2 3 4 5 6 7

12%

15%

4%

19%

8%

35%

8%

1. None

2. Only the first

3. Only the second

4. Only the third

5. The first and second

6. The first and third

7. The second and third

Page 21: Complex Analysis Exercise sheet 7 (Avoiding mistakes in Questions 1 & 2)

Only the first…

• Second inequality:One cannot “iterate” the inverse triangle inequality (at least not in this way)! See

• For the third inequality, compare

Page 22: Complex Analysis Exercise sheet 7 (Avoiding mistakes in Questions 1 & 2)

Let’s thank all the people that contributed their errors in this exercise sheet so that nobody

has to do them in the final exam again!

(Please, at least, come up with new ones!)