Competing against scale - poslovni.hr1].pdfAndrej Vizjak, Introduction of the book ‘Competing...
Transcript of Competing against scale - poslovni.hr1].pdfAndrej Vizjak, Introduction of the book ‘Competing...
Competing against scale –
the outlook of Sloveniancompanies competing toward
the global competition
Aim of the book:
Could Slovenian companies survive the global concentration process of industries?
Book summary:
Yes, they can successfully compete if they develop an appropriate strategic growth combination like Top-Performing Niche Players (TPNs).
3Andrej Vizjak, Introduction of the book ‘Competing against scale’
Key concept: The growth cube
Sustain TPNGrowth Profile
Adapt to IndustryConcentration
Change GrowthDirection
LeverageUniqueGrowth
Capabilities
Apply AppropriateGrowth Paths
Transform YourOrganization
4Andrej Vizjak, Introduction of the book ‘Competing against scale’
TPNs adapt according to requirements of the current industry concentration stage
Focus
Phase
Balance
Phase
Opening
Phase
Scale
Phase
5Andrej Vizjak, Introduction of the book ‘Competing against scale’
For the last ten years globally we were facing rapid concentration process of industries
Analysing requirements of individual phases of the industry concentration process
578
1.3992.072
9.259
6.583
10.000
1987-1991 1992-1996 1997-2001 2002-2006 Total in 25 years
1982-1986
The value of transactions (in million US$)
19.891
6Andrej Vizjak, Introduction of the book ‘Competing against scale’
On 31st December 2006, 500 global industry leading companies managed 54% of the total global market capitalisation
100%
3,8%7,3%
35,3%
53,5%
30.500
500
3.800
6.200
20.000
MC= market capitalization on 31.12.2005; 100% of MC represents 40.000 billion US$ and consists of 30.000 companies
Small (over 10 Million)and ‘little’ companies
from 200 million to 1 billion US$ of MC
Middle-size companies
from 1 to 15 billion US$ of MC
Large companies
over 15 billion of MCBig companies
less than 200 million US$ of MC
% of the total MCnumber of companies in
the category
Analysing requirements of individual phases of the industry concentration process
7Andrej Vizjak, Introduction of the book ‘Competing against scale’
Case 1: Market capitalisation of global food companies on 31.12.2006
10%
8%
7%
5%4%3%3%3%
2%
14%
38%
3%
25 %Top 3
23 %Top 4-10
Food and beverage producers
100% = 1.428 billion $(424 companies)
30%
7%
7%
7%
6%
4%3%3%
17%
10%
3%3%
44 %Top 3
Other 21-92
TOP 11-20
29 %Top 4-10
Food retailers100% = 639 billion $
(92 companies)
AmbevAnheuser-Busch
DanoneInbev
DiageoKraft Foods
Unilever
Pepsico
Coca Cola
Nestle
TOP 11-20
Other 21-424
KrogerAhold KoninklijkeWoolworthsMetroTengelmann
Auchan
Carrefour
HutchisonWhampoa
Tesco
Wal Mart Stores
Analysing requirements of individual phases of the industry concentration process
8Andrej Vizjak, Introduction of the book ‘Competing against scale’
Case 2: Market capitalisation of global automotive companies on 31.12.2006
Analysing requirements of individual phases of the industry concentration process
44 %Top 3
27%
9%
8%
8%
7%
6%
5%4%
3%
15%
5%
3%
Toyota
DaimlerChrysler
Honda
Nissan
Volkswagen
BMW
Renault
FiatGeneral Motors
Porsche
TOP 11-20
Other 21-44
36 %Top 4-10
Automotive producers100% = 661 billion $
(44 companies)
16%
11%
6%
6%
5%4%4%3%
11%
32%
3%2%
33 %Top 3
Robert Bosch
Denso
Bridgestone
Continental
MichelinSMCAisin Seiki
Other 21-151
ZF FriedrichshafenGenuine Parts
TOP 11-20Pirelli
24 %Top 4-10
Automotive suppliers100% = 304 billion $
(151 companies)
9Andrej Vizjak, Introduction of the book ‘Competing against scale’
Case 3: Market capitalisation of global banks and insurance companies on 31.12.2006
Analysing requirements of individual phases of the industry concentration process
21%
15%
11%
11%
10%
4%3%2%
7%
12%
2%2%
Investment banks100% = 797 mrd. $(123 companies)
TOP 11-20
Other 21-123
Bear StearnsCredit Suisse First Boston
Charles SchwabNomura
Merrill Lynch
Lehman Brothers
Goldman Sachs
Morgan Stanley
UBS
JP Morgan Chase
5%
5%
4%
3%
3%
2%2%2%
15%
2%2%
55%
Commercial banks100% = 5.223 bn. $(813 companies)
TOP 11-20
Other 21-813
BNP ParibasWachovia
Banco SantanderWells Fargo
Royal Bank of ScotlandChina Construction Bank
Mitsubishi
HSBC
Bank of America
Citigroup9%
8%
4%
4%
2%2%2%2%
13%
2%2%
50%
Insurance companies100% = 2.102 bn. $(253 companies)
TOP 11-20
Other 21-253
AllstatePrudential
MetlifeNippon Life
GeneraliManulifeAllianz
AXA
BerkshireHathaway
AmericanInternational
10Andrej Vizjak, Introduction of the book ‘Competing against scale’
The Endgame theory describes and predicts the concentration of all industries with 2-3 global industry leaders finally dominating more than 70% of the global market, …
… allowing only “Top Performing Niche Players (TPNs)” to compete in the residual 30%of a concentrated market.
The total market share
of three largest
companies on the global
market
Analysing requirements of individual phases of the industry concentration process
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
100%
∅∅∅∅ 45%
-10 -5 0 5 10 15 20 25
CR31)
Years
Opening Scale FocusBalance/Alliance
Paper
Drugs
Natural gas liquids
Semiconductors
Telecom
BrewersRailroad
Insurance
Divers. ChemicalsUtilities
Automotive Supplier Restaurants & Fast Food
Steel Producer integrated Automotive Mfrs.
ConfectionaryTruck & Trailer Mfrs.
Shipbuilding
Distillers
Cigarette
Defense Electr.
Soft drinks
Aluminum Producers
Food Retail
Airlines
Integrated oil & gas
Ore Mining
Banks
Consumer Electronics
Divers. FoodRubber & Tire Mfrs.
11Andrej Vizjak, Introduction of the book ‘Competing against scale’
TPNs optimise continuously their operational capabilities for growth
Simple
Growers
Value
Growers
Profit
Seekers
Under-
performers
12Andrej Vizjak, Introduction of the book ‘Competing against scale’
47% of companies are not capable to balance their growth of revenues with the profit growth; therefore these companies will become an acquisition target
Sustain TPN Growth Profile
Long-term growth of revenues of 10.500 public companies world-wide larger than 200 million US$
of yearly revenues from different industries
Share of companies positioned in individual quadrants of the matrixx%
∅
industry
average
∅
industry average
Value Growers
RevenueGrowth
ValueGrowth
Profit SeekersUnder-performers
Simple GrowersQ3
Q4
Q1
Q2
Revenue Value
Revenue Value Revenue Value
19%47%
14% 20%
Revenue Value
13.8%
-2.7%
3.6%-3.6%
4.1%
12.8%
21.5%18.0%
13Andrej Vizjak, Introduction of the book ‘Competing against scale’
Among 10.000 companies we have selected 600 companies as TPNs which set the growth profile benchmarks to compete against scale
0
Maximaldeviation
of anindustry median
from themedian of
the 600 TPNsacross
industries
Long-termgrowth of sales
17%
Stabileprofitability
10%
High assetturnover
1,1
Healthyfinancialstructure
0,9
+75%
+50%
+25%
- 75%
- 50%
- 25%
Sales CAGR(2005/2000 in % p.a.)
EBIT intotal assets
(av. 2000-2005 in %)
Equity / debt(av. 2000-2005)
Asset Turn(average 2000-2005)
Critical mass1000 mil $
Sales revenuesin million $ 2005
Indicators of operational capabilitiesIndicators of strategic capabilities
Sustain TPN Growth Profile
Energy24%
Energy17%
Retail1,9
Chemicals1,2
Energy 2000 mil $
Electronic 13%Retail7%
Energy0,6
Mechanical engineering 0,7Raw material
suppliers 690 mil $
14Andrej Vizjak, Introduction of the book ‘Competing against scale’
Case 1: Growth analysis of the global food industry
Sustain TPN Growth Profile
Archer-Daniels-Midland
5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% 35%
Nestlé
CocaCola
Pepsi
UnileverKraft
Foods
Diageo
Inbev
Danone
Anheuser-Busch
Sabmiller
Heineken
CadburySchweppes
General MillsRegional food and beverage producers Wal Mart
StoresTesco
Hutchison Whampoa
Auchan
CarrefourTengelmann
Metro
Woolworths
Ahold
Regional retailers
-10%
0%
10%
20%
30%
Ambev
Food retailersFood and beverage producers MC 2006
Long-term
growth
Median ofglobal TPNs
of thisindustry
Long-term ROI
Median ofglobal TPNs
of thisindustry
Ø Slovenianindustry
Median of regional niche players
15Andrej Vizjak, Introduction of the book ‘Competing against scale’
Case 2: Growth analysis of the global automotive industry
Sustain TPN Growth Profile
EU niche suppliers
Asian niche suppliers
Pirelli
Genuine Parts
ZF Friedrichshafen
Aisin Seiki
SMC
Michelin
Continental
Bridgestone
Denso
Bosch
Asian automotive producers
Ford
Peugeot
Hyundai
Porsche
General Motors
Fiat
Renault
BMW
Volkswagen NissanHonda
DaimlerChrysler
Toyota
-10%
0%
5%
10%
15%
20%
5% 10% 20%
ProducersSuppliers
Mitsubishi
-5%
Suzuki
Mazda
Kia
Daihatsu
MC 2006 Ø Slovenian industry Median of regional niche players
Long-term
growth
Median ofglobal TPNs
of thisindustry
Median ofglobal TPNs
of thisindustry
16Andrej Vizjak, Introduction of the book ‘Competing against scale’
Case 3: Growth analysis of the global financial sector
Sustain TPN Growth Profile
Regional nicheplayers: Europeaninvestment banks
Lehman BrothersMerrill Lynch
Goldman Sachs
Morgan Stanley
UBS
JP MorganChase
Generali
Manulife Financial
Allianz
AXA
Berkshire Hathaway
American International
EU niche commercial banks
WellsFargo
Royal Bankof Scotland
ChinaConstruction
Bank
Mitsubishi UFJ Financial
HSBCBank of America
Citigroup
-5%
0%
5%
10%
15%
20%
25%
35%
0%
1% 2% 3% 4% 5% 6%
MC 2006 Ø Slovenianindustry
Insuran-ces
Commercialbanks
Investment banks Median of regional niche players
8%
Long-term
growth
Median ofglobal TPNs
of thisindustry
Long-term ROI
Median ofglobal TPNs
of thisindustry
Regional nicheplayers: European
insurances
17Andrej Vizjak, Introduction of the book ‘Competing against scale’
TPNs follow adequate growth directions
Regional
Multi-
Business
Niches
Global
Market
or
Niches
Regional
Product
Niches
International
Product
Niches
18Andrej Vizjak, Introduction of the book ‘Competing against scale’
Most TPNs compete either in regional niches or ininternational product niches
InternationalProductNiches(50%)
GlobalMarketNiches
(6%)
RegionalMulti-
businessNiches(25%)
RegionalProductNiches(19%)
Apply Appropriate Growth Paths
100% = 600 Top Performing Niche Players
InternationalizationRegion (domestic country)
Globalmarket
Regionalgroup
Product diversification
Product
Product group
IndustryMarket
Marketsegment
Niche
19Andrej Vizjak, Introduction of the book ‘Competing against scale’
Both regional product niches and regional multi-businessniches are not sustainable in concentrating industries
% Top Performing Niche Players (TPN)according to industry concentration phases (n=600)
Apply Appropriate Growth Paths
0%
20%
17%
63%Regional product niche
Regional multi-product niches
International product niches
Sustainable global market niches100% = 30 TPN
Opening phase
(CR3<20%)
6%
49%
20%
25%
100% = 437 TPN
Scale phase
(20%≤CR3<40%)
8%
60%
15%
17%
100% = 119 TPN
Focusphase
(40%≤CR3<70%)
15%
71%
7%
7%
100% = 14 TPN
Balancephase
(70%≤CR3)
20Andrej Vizjak, Introduction of the book ‘Competing against scale’
TPNs leverage their unique growth capabilities
Product
Related
Capabilities
GlobalEconomies
of Scale or
Counter Niches
Product
and/or
Regional
Focus
Market
Related
Capabilities
21Andrej Vizjak, Introduction of the book ‘Competing against scale’
Market split
Innovation
Other product or market capabilities
Counter Niches
Product and/or Regional Focus
100% = 119 TPN
100% = 14TPN
100% = 437 TPN
100% = 30TPN
90%
67%53%
21%
7%
21%
22%
36%
6%
16%
21%
5% 8%
14%
0% 3% 7%0% 1% 2%
For development of international product niches companies need innovativeness and other unique product and/or market related capabilities
% Top Performing Niche Players (TPN)according to industry concentration phases (n=600)
Leverage Unique Growth Capabilities
Opening phase
(CR3<20%)
Scale phase
(20%≤CR3<40%)
Focusphase
(40%≤CR3<70%)
Balancephase
(70%≤CR3)
22Andrej Vizjak, Introduction of the book ‘Competing against scale’
TPNs apply appropriate growth paths
Speed
NichesCooperations
Organic
GrowthAcquisitions
23Andrej Vizjak, Introduction of the book ‘Competing against scale’
100% = 119 TPN
100% = 14TPN
100% = 437 TPN
Organic growth
100% = 30TPN
Speed niches
Acquisition
Cooperations
60%44% 48%
23%
9%9%
21%
40%
23%24%
21%
24% 19%
35%
0%
0%
Cooperations and acquisitions represent an important growth path toward the TPN in a global market niche
% Top Performing Niche Players (TPN)according to industry concentration phases (n=600)
Apply Appropriate Growth Paths
Opening phase
(CR3<20%)
Scale phase
(20%≤CR3<40%)
Focusphase
(40%≤CR3<70%)
Balancephase
(70%≤CR3)
24Andrej Vizjak, Introduction of the book ‘Competing against scale’
TPNs align the organization according to the strategy
Decentralized
Product
Units
Decentralized
Product and
Regional
Units
Centralized
Functional
Units
Decentralized
Regional
Units
25Andrej Vizjak, Introduction of the book ‘Competing against scale’
More than 70% of TPNs reach the critical mass of 0,7 to 1,5 billion US$ revenues and apply the centralised functional organisation structure
71%
27%
2%
87%
13%
39%
61%
All 600 TPNs 70Regional
TPNs
64%
36%
85International
Product TPNs
11Global
Market TPNs
DecentralizedRegional
Units
DecentralizedProduct
Units
Partial Decentralisation
CentralizedFunctional
Units
DecentralizedProduct and
Regional Units
% of TPNs according to organisation and growth direction
Transform Your Organization
26Andrej Vizjak, Introduction of the book ‘Competing against scale’
The industry concentration process will affect the Slovenian companies as well
0 3 6 9 10 50 90 130 200 700450
0
3
6
9
10
50
90
130
200
700
450
Th
e v
alu
e o
f d
om
es
tic
co
mp
an
ies
a
cq
uir
ed
by f
ore
ign
co
mp
an
ies
The value of foreign companies acquired by domestic companies (according to the
country of origin)
The total value of international acquisitions(1.1.2000 – 31.12.2006 in billion US $)
PTBG
GR
GBD
UA
PL
FI
GDP
FI,DK
SLO
GDP
GDP
MK
CRO, RO
SK YU
TR
NO, IE
≥ 360 Billion $
≥120; <360 Billion $
The size of bubble represents GDP of individual countries (in billion US$)
<120 Billion $
D (Germany), GB (Great Britain)F (France), I (Italy), E (Spain)RU (Russia), NL (Netherlands),CH (Suisse), BE (Belgium), TR (Turkey)
S (Sweden), A (Austria), PL (Poland),NO (Norway), DK (Denmark), GR (Greece), IE (Ireland), FI (Finland),PT (Portugal), CZ (Czech Republic)
HU (Hungary), RO (Romania),UA (Ukraine), SK (Slovakia),CRO (Croatia), SLO (Slovenia),LU (Luxemburg), YU (Serbia),BG (Bulgaria), MK (Macedonia)
RU
A LUCZ
HU
BE,E,CHNO,S
NL
27Andrej Vizjak, Introduction of the book ‘Competing against scale’
If the trend of foreign acquisitions in the Eastern European will be ‘mapped’ into SEE the region will be ‘sold out’ in next five years
0 1 10 20 30
0
1
10
20
40
The color of the bubble indicates the time frame of the transaction
Countries of south-eastern Europe (SEE):RO, CRO, SLO, YU, BG, MK, A
1.1.1987 – 31.12.1991
1.1.1992 – 31.12.1996
1.1.1997 – 31.12.2001
1.1.2002 – 31.12.2006
Countries of eastern Europe (EE):CZ, SK, HU, PL
1)
1) Acquisitions ≥ 100 billion US$
30
40 50
50
1.1.2007 – 31.12.2011
?
SEE
EE
EE
EE
EE
SEE
SEE
The total value of international acquisitions(1.1.2000 – 31.12.2006 in billion US $)
Th
e v
alu
e o
f d
om
es
tic
co
mp
an
ies
a
cq
uir
ed
by f
ore
ign
co
mp
an
ies
The value of foreign companies acquired by domestic companies (according to the
country of origin)
28Andrej Vizjak, Introduction of the book ‘Competing against scale’
The growth of revenues of Slovenian companies is at the level of TPNs, however their limited size (in terms of revenues) would require their faster growth and higher profitability
1,021,113%13%82Median value of all companies
2,461,514%18%181Weighted average of all companies
3,211,434%17%63Weighted average of 109 smaller SLO companies (less than 100 million US$ revenues)
1,461,333%14%350Weighted average of 91 largest SLO companies (more than 100 million US$ revenues)
Asset turnover
Healthy financing
Stabile profitability
RevenueCAGR (2000-
2005 in %)
Revenue in mil US$ (2005)
Median value of TPNs from different industries
1000 17% 10% 0,9 1,1
Note: 1) Bank and insurance companies (11of 91 largest companies) are not included in the calculation of median revenues.The total assets median of Slovene banking and insurance companies was 3045 mil $ and the median of TPNs was 8194 mil $.
1)
29Andrej Vizjak, Introduction of the book ‘Competing against scale’
The implementation of the appropriate growth cube combinationrequires a comprehensive transformation program
30Andrej Vizjak, Introduction of the book ‘Competing against scale’
Case 1: TPN strategic growth combination in the food industry
The implementation of the appropriate growth cube combination
International
multi-product
niches
Organic growth with speed and
acquisitions
20122007 2017
CR3
20%
40%Sustainable
global market
niches
Cooperation
Innov-
ation
Innovation
International
brand
names
31Andrej Vizjak, Introduction of the book ‘Competing against scale’
Case 2: TPN strategic growth combination in the automotive industry (as automotive producer)
The implementation of the appropriate growth cube combination
International
product
niches
Organic growth with speed
2012
Target
customer
focus
2007 2017
CR3
40%
70%Sustainable
global market niches
Cooperation
Inno-
vation
32Andrej Vizjak, Introduction of the book ‘Competing against scale’
Case 3: TPN strategic growth combination in the financial sector (banks and insurance companies)
The implementation of the appropriate growth cube combination
Regional
product
niche
Acquisitions
20122007 2017
CR3
20%
40%
Regional
multi-product
niche
Organic growth with speed
Branding
Target
customer
focus