Comparisons Matrix

download Comparisons Matrix

of 66

  • date post

    03-Jun-2018
  • Category

    Documents

  • view

    216
  • download

    0

Embed Size (px)

Transcript of Comparisons Matrix

  • 8/12/2019 Comparisons Matrix

    1/66

  • 8/12/2019 Comparisons Matrix

    2/66

    A17.1 2007 A17.1 2010 Oregon Amendment [Ore]

    elevator_code_comparisons_matrix _revised_100311.doc 2

    and th e stop(s) is in the extended position, an additional

    30 stopping device conforming to 2.25.3.1 and 2.25.3.3through 2.25.3.5 sha ll caus e the car to stop before it

    strikes the movable stop(s). This additional sto pping

    device sh all be rendered ineffective when the s top(s) isin the retracted position. Any electrical device(s) used

    to rend er the additional stopping device ineffective shallbe in conformance with 2.26.4.3, 2.26.9.3(a), and

    2.26.9.4.

    and the sto p(s) is in the extended position, an additional

    30 stopping device conforming to 2.25.3.1 and 2.25.3.3through 2.25.3.5 sha ll cause the car to stop before it

    strikes the movable stop(s). This additional sto pping

    device sh all be rendered ineffective when the s top(s) isin the retracted position. Any electrical device(s) used

    to render the additional stopping device ineffective shallbe in conformance with 2.26.4.3, 2.26.9.3.1(a), 2.26.9.3.2

    and 2.26.9.4.2.7.6.5.1The inspection and test panel shall berequired where any of t he following are not accessible

    from outside the hoistway:(a) the CAR DOOR BYPASS and HOISTWAY

    DOOR BYPASS switches required by 2.26.1.5; or

    (b) the devices necessary for the manual reset of the

    detection means for ascending car overspeed protection

    [see 2.19.1.2(a)(4)], and p rotection against unintendedcar movement [see 2.19.2.2(a)(4)], or

    (c) the circuits of t he following devices:

    (1) the car-safety mechanism switch (see 2.26.2.9)

    (2) the car buffer switch, where provided (see

    2.26.2.22)(3) the top and bottom final terminal stopping

    devices (see 2.26.2.11)

    ASME A17.1-2007/CSA B44-07(4) the car and counterweight governor s witches,

    where provided (see 2.26.2.10)

    2.7.6.5.1The inspection and test panel shall berequired where any of t he following are not accessible

    from outside the hoistway:(a) the devices necessary for the manual reset of the

    detection means for ascending car overspeed protection

    [see 2.19.1.2(a)(4)], and p rotection against unintended

    car movement [see 2.19.2.2(a)(4)], or

    (b) the circuits of t he following devices:(1) the car-safety mechanism switch (see 2.26.2.9)

    (2) the car buffer swit ch, where provided (see

    2.26.2.22)

    (3) the top and bottom final terminal stopping

    devices (see 2.26.2.11)ASME A17.1-2007/CSA B44-07(4) the car and counterweight governor switches,

    where provided (see 2.26.2.10)

    N/A

    2.7.5.2 Th e inspec tion and test panel, where

    provided shall(h) where the circuits of the devices in 2.7.6.5.1(c)(1)

    through (4) are not accessible from outs ide the hoistway,

    include landing ins pection operation in conformance

    with 2.26.1.4.4, and tha t shall be permitted to rend erineffective the following electrical protective devices,individually or as a group or groups, in conformance

    with the requirements of 2.26.9.3(a) and 2.26.9.4:

    2.7.5.2The inspection and test panel, where

    provided shall be accessible from outs ide the hoistwayand s hall

    (h) where the circuits of the devices in 2.7.6.5.1(b)(1)

    through (4) are not accessible from outs ide the hoistway,

    include landing ins pection op eration in conformancewith 2.26.1.4.4, and that sh all be permitted to renderineffective the following electrical protective devices,

    individually or as a group o r groups, in conformancewith the requirements of 2.26.9.3.1(a) and 2.26.9.3.2 and

    2.26.9.4.:

    N/A

    2.12.7.3Operating Requirements. The operation ofthe s witch shall permit movement of the car with thehoistway door at this landing unlocked or not in the

    closed position, and with the car door or gate not in the

    closed position, subject to the requirements o f 2.12.7.3.1through 2.12.7.3.8.

    2.12.7.3 Operating Requirements. The operation of thesw itch shall permit movement of the car

    only when the zonespecif ied in 2.12.7.3.6 or 2.12.7.3.7. The operation of thesw itch shall permit movement of the car w ith the hoistw aydoors at this landing unlocked or not in the closed position,and w ith the car door or gate not in the closed position, subjectto the requirements of 2.12.7.3.1 through 2.12.77.3.8.

    N/A

  • 8/12/2019 Comparisons Matrix

    3/66

    A17.1 2007 A17.1 2010 Oregon Amendment [Ore]

    elevator_code_comparisons_matrix _revised_100311.doc 3

    2.12.7.3.8The acces s switch shall only controlthe movement of the car within the zone s pecified in2.12.7.3.6 or 2.12.7.3.7. Control circuits related to, or

    operated

    by, the hoistway access switches shall comply with2.26.9.3(c), (d), and (e) and 2.26.9.4.

    2.12.7.3.8 Control circuits relate to, or operated by, thehoistw ay access switches shall comply w ith 2.26.9.3 ( c) , (d),and (e) and 2.26.9.4.

    N/A

    2.14.1.8.3In jurisdictions en forcing theNBCC,type 3C film reinforced silvered mirror glas s thatconforms to CAN/CGSB-12.5 sha ll be permitted for

    lining walls or ceilings .

    DELETED N/A

    2.14.2.1Material for Car Enclosures, Enclosure Linings,and Floor Coverings. All materials expos ed to thecar interior and the hoistway shall be metal, glass , orshall conform to 2.14.2.1.1 through 2.14.2.1.6.

    2.14.2.1Mater ial for Car Enclosures, Enclosure Linings,and Floor Coverings. All materials expos ed to thecar interior and the hoistway shall be metal, glass , orsha ll conform to 2.14.2.1.1 through

    2.14.2.1.4.

    .

    N/A

    2.14.2.1.1Materials in their end-use configuration,other than those covered by 2.14.2.1.2 th rough2.14.2.1.6 sha ll conform to the following requirements ,

    based on the tests conducted in accordance with therequirements of ASTM E 84, A NSI/UL 723, NFPA 252,

    or CAN/ULC-S102.2, whichever is applicable:(a) flame s pread rating of 0 to 75

    (b) smoke development of 0 to 450

    2.14.2.1.1 In jurisdictions not enforcing NBCC (a) materials intheir end use configuration, other than those covered by2.14.2.1(b) and (c), 2.14.2.1.3, and 2.14.2.1.4, shall conform tothe follow ing requirements, based on tests conducted inaccordance w ith the requirements of ASTM E 84, AMSI/UL723, or CAN/UCL-S102:(1) flame spread rating of 0 to 75(2) smoke development of 0 to 450(b) napped, tuf ted, w oven, looped, and similar materials intheir end use conf iguration on car enclosure walls shall

    conform to 8.3.7. The enclosure w alls to w hich this material isattached shall conform to 2.14.2.1.1(a).( c ) floor covering, underlayment, and its adhesive shall have

    a critical radiant flux of not less than 0.45 W/cm2, as measuredby ASTM E 648.

    N/A

    2.14.2.1.2In jurisdictions enforcing theNBCC,where the building is designated by the building code as

    a h igh building, materials in their end-us e configurationshall have

    (a) a flame spread rating for walls and ceiling of 0 to25 with s moke development of 0 to 100 bas ed on the

    test conducted in accordance with th e requirements of

    CAN/ULC-S102(b) a flame spread rating for floor surfaces of 0 to 300

    with smoke development of 0 to 300, based on the testconducted in accordance with the requirements of

    CAN/ULC-S102.2.

    2.14.2.1.2In jurisdictions en forcing theNBCC,(a) materials in their end us e configuration other than

    those covered by 2.14.2.1.2(b), 2.14.2.1.3, and 2.14.2.1.4,sha ll conform to the following requirements , based on the

    test s co nducted in accordance with th e requirements ofASTM E 84, ANSI/UL 723, or CAN/UL-S102:(1) flame spread rating of 0 to 75(2) smoke development of 0 to 450(b) floor surfaces shall have a flame spread rating of 0 to 300,

    based upon the test conducted in accordance with therequirements of CAN/UL-S102-2.( c) w here the building is designated by the building code as

    a high building(1) Materials in their end use configuration shall have a

    flame spread rating for w alls and ceiling of 0 to 25,

    N/A

  • 8/12/2019 Comparisons Matrix

    4/66

    A17.1 2007 A17.1 2010 Oregon Amendment [Ore]

    elevator_code_comparisons_matrix _revised_100311.doc 4

    w ith smoke development of 0 to 100, based upon thetest conducted in accordance with the requirements ofCAN/ULC-S102.

    (2) Floor surfaces shall have a flame spread rating of 0 to300, w ith smoke development of 0 to 300, based onthe test c onducted in accordance w ith therequirements of CAN/ULC-S102.2

    2.14.2.1.3Napped, tufted, woven, looped, andsimilar materials in their end-use configuration on car

    enclosu re walls sha ll conform to 8.3.7 or theNBCC andNFCC, whichever is applicable. The enclosure walls to

    which this material is attached shall conform to

    2.14.2.1.1.

    2.14.2.1.3

    Padded protective linings, for temporary use inpassenger cars during the handling of freight shall be ofmaterials conforming to either 2.14.2.1.1(a) or (b), or2.14.2.1.2(a), w hichever is applicable. The protective liningshall clear the floor by not less than 100 mm (4 in.).

    N/A

    2.14.2.1.4Padded protective linings, for temporaryuse in pass enger cars during the handling of freight,

    sha ll be of materials conforming to either 2.14.2.1.1 or

    2.14.2.1.3, whichever is applicable. The protective liningsha ll clear the floor by not less than 100 mm (4 in.).

    2.14.2.1.4 Handrails, opening devices, ventilation devices,signal fixtures, audio and visual communication devices, andtheir housings are not required to conform to 2.14.2.1.

    N/A

    2.14.2.1.5Floor covering, underlayment, and itsadhes ive shall have a critical radiant flux of not less than

    0.45 W/cm2, as measured by ASTM E 648 or con formto the requirements o f theNBCC and ULC standard

    CAN/ULC-S102.2, whichever is applicable.54

    DELETED N/A

    2.14.4.5.1 (a) where a swinging-type hoistway door and a

    car gate are used, 100 mm (4 in.)

    2.14.4.5.1 (a) where a swinging-type hoistway door and a

    car gate

    or folding gate are used , 100 mm (4 in.)

    N/A

    2.14.4.5.2 2.14.4.5.2 added(d) w here a folding car door is used, between the hoistway

    door and the c ar door panel the furthest f rom the hoistwaydoor, when closed (see 2.12.2.2. and 2.14.4.11)

    N/A

    2.14.4.6Strength of Doors, Gates, and Their Guides,Guide Shoes, Tracks, and Hangers.Doors and gatesand th eir guides, guide shoes, tracks, and hangers shall

    be so designed, constructed, and installed that when thefully c losed do or or gate is subjected to a force of 335 N

    (75 lbf), app lied on an area 300 mm (12 in.) sq uare atright angles to and approximately at the cen ter of the

    door or gate, it will not deflect beyond the line of thecar sill.

    When su bjected to a force of 1 100N(250 lbf) similarly

    applied, doors and vertically s liding gates shall notbreak or be permanent ly deformed and shall not be

    displaced from their guides or tracks.Where multisect ion doors or gates are used, each

    panel shall withstand the forces s pecified.

    2.14.4.6Strength of Doors, Gates, and Their Guides,Guide Shoes, Tracks, and Hangers.Doors and gatesand their guides, guide shoes, tracks, and hangers shall

    be so designed, constructed, and installed that when thefully clos ed door or gate is subjected to a force of 335 N

    (75 lbf), app lied on an area 300 mm (12 in.) sq uare atright angles to and approximately at the center of the

    doo r or gate, it will not deflect more than 13mm (0.5 in.)toward the hoistway door.

    Where a s wing-type hoistway door and car gate or folding

    door are used, the gate or folding door shall not deflectmore than 13 mm (0.5 in.) when subject to a force of 335

    N (75 lbf) when applied to the hoitway side of the car gateor folding door at the following locations:

    (a)An area 100 mm ( 4 in.) s quare at right angles at theApproximate center of the gate or folding door opening

    (b) An area 100 mm ( 4 in.) squ are at right angles at

    N/A

  • 8/12/2019 Comparisons Matrix

    5/66

    A17.1 2007 A17.1 2010 Oregon Amendment [Ore]

    elevator_code_comparisons_matrix _revised_100311.doc 5

    25% and 75% of the door width at a height of 450 mm

    (18 in.) from the floor level.For individual panels o f folding doors of a width less than

    100 mm (4 in.), the specified forces in (a) and (b) s hall be

    applied over an area 100 mm ( 4 in.) tall by the width ofthe individual panel.

    When subjected to a force of 1 100N(250 lbf) s imilarlyapplied, doors and vertically s liding ga tes shall not

    break or be permanently deformed and shall not bedisplaced from their guides or tracks.

    Where multisect ion doors or gates are used, eachpanel shall withstand the forces s pecified.

    2.14.5.2 Type Required. Horizontally or verticallysliding doors subject to the restrictions of 2.14.5.3 sha ll

    be provided at each car entrance.

    2.14.5.2 Type Required. Horizontally or verticallysliding doors subject to the restrictions of 2.14.5.3 s hall

    be p rovided at each car entrance . Folding car doors arenot permitted..

    N/A

    2.14.5.9 2.14.5.9 Folding Car Doors Added2.14.5.9.1 Folding car doors shall conf orm to 2.14.4 exceptparas. 2.14.4.4, 2.14.4.7, and 2.14.4.9. They shall alsoconform to all of 2.14.5 except paras. 2.14.5.3, 2.14.5.6.2,

    2.14.5.7, and 2.14.5.8.

    2.14.5.9.2 The ef for t needed to prevent a folding car doorfrom closing shall conform to 2.13..4.2.3.

    2.14.5.9.3 Folding car doors shall not be pow er opened to adistance exceeding one-third of the clear opening, and in nocase more than 250 mm (10 in.).

    2.14.5.9.4 Handles of manually operated folding car doorsnearest the car operating device on elevators operated fromthe car only shall be so located that the nearest handle is notmore than 1,220 mm (48 in.) f rom the care operating devicew hen the folding door is c losed, and between 1,220 mm (4 in.)and 380 cm (15 in) above the car floor.

    N/A

    2.14.6.1.1For elevators d esigned for Class Aloading (see 2.16.2.2), car gates shall be either of the

    vertically s liding type (see 2.14.6.2) or the ho rizontallysliding collapsible type (s ee 2.14.6.3).

    2.14.6.1.1For elevators d esigned for Class Aloading (see 2.16.2.2), car gates sh all be either of the

    vertically s liding typ e (see 2.14.6.2) or the horizontallysliding collapsible type (see 2.14.6.3)., or a car door of thefolding type (see 2.14.5.9).

    N/A

    2.14.7.1.1Not less than two lamps shall be provided 2.14.7.1.1Not less than two lamps shall be provided

    the fullw idth of the car entrance opening, and their height shall bedetermined as follows:(a) car doors and gates shall extend from a point not morethan 25 mm (1 in.) above the car floor to a point nor less than1,825 mm (72 in.) above the car floor.(b) w here a vertical sliding car gate w ith a door reopeningdevice is provided, the 25 mm (1 in.) maximum dimensionspecified shall be measured from the car floor to the bottom of

    the leading member.

    N/A

  • 8/12/2019 Comparisons Matrix

    6/66

    A17.1 2007 A17.1 2010 Oregon Amendment [Ore]

    elevator_code_comparisons_matrix _revised_100311.doc 6

    2.14.7.1.3Each elevator shall be provided withauxiliary lighting h aving its po wer source located onthe car. It s hall conform to the following:

    (a) The intensity of auxiliary lighting illumination

    sha ll be not less than 2 lx (0.2 fc), measu red at any pointbetween 1 225 mm (48 in.) and 890 mm (35 in.) above

    the car floor and approximately 300mm(12 in.) centeredhorizontally in front of a car operating pan el containing

    any o f the following:(1) car operating d evice(s)

    (2) door open bu tton(3) rear or side door open button

    (4) door close button

    (5) rear or side door close button(6) HELP b utton and operating ins tructions, or

    (7) ALARM switch(b) Illumination is n ot required in front o f additional

    car op erating panels where the devices listed in2.14.7.1.3(a) are duplicated.

    (c) Auxiliary lights sha ll be aut omatically turned onin all elevators in service after normal car lighting

    power fails.

    (d) The po wer system shall be capable of maintainingthe light intens ity specified in 2.14.7.1.3(a) for a period

    of at least 4 h.(e)Not less than two lamps of approximately equal

    wattage sh all be used.

    (f) Battery-operated units, where provided, shall(1) comply with CSA C22.2 No. 141 (see Section 4)

    (2) have a 4 h rat ing minimum(3)be permanent ly connected to the car light

    branch circuit

    (4) have an output rating that includes the auxiliarylights and if con nected, the emergency signaling device(see 2.27.1.1.3)

    2.14.7.1.3Each elevator shall be provided withauxiliary lighting h aving its po wer source located onthe car. It s hall conform to the following:

    (a) The intensity of auxiliary lighting illumination

    sha ll be not less than 2 lx (0.2 fc), measu red at any pointbetween 1 225 mm (48 in.) and 890 mm (35 in.) above

    the car floor and approximately 300mm(12 in.) centeredhorizontally in front of a car operating pan el containing

    any of the following:(1) car operating device(s)

    (2) door open bu tton(3) rear or side door open button

    (4) door close button

    (5) rear or side door close button(6) PHONE button and operating instructions, or

    (7) ALARM switch(b) Illumination is n ot required in front of add itional

    car operating panels where the devices listed in2.14.7.1.3(a) are duplicated.

    (c) Auxiliary lights sha ll be automatically turned onin all elevators in service after normal car lighting

    power fails.

    (d) The power source shall be located on the car.(e) The power system shall be capable of maintaining

    the light intens ity specified in 2.14.7.1.3(a) for a periodof at least 4 h.

    (f)Not less than two lamps or sets of lamps of

    approximately equ al illumination sha ll be prov ided,Systems us ing only one of the two required lamps o r sets

    of lamps to provide the required illumination s hall bepermitted and shall comply with the following:

    (1) each lamp or s et of lamps shall provide the minimum

    illumination in conformance with 2.14.7.1.3(a)(2) s ystems s hall be arranged to automatically illuminatethe unlit lamp or set of lamps immediately following a

    failure o f the first lamp or lamps .

    (3) sy stems shall be des igned so that an audible or visualsignal not ifies au thorized personnel when one lamp or set

    of lamps is not func tional.(g) Battery-operated units, where provided, shall

    (1) comply with CSA C22.2 No. 141 or UL 624 (seeSection 9)

    (2) have a 4 h rat ing minimum

    N/A

  • 8/12/2019 Comparisons Matrix

    7/66

    A17.1 2007 A17.1 2010 Oregon Amendment [Ore]

    elevator_code_comparisons_matrix _revised_100311.doc 7

    (3)be permanent ly connected to the car light

    branch circuit(1)have an output rating that includes the auxiliary

    lights and if con nected, the emergency signaling device

    (see 2.27.1.1.3)(h) The lamps used for auxiliary lighting a re permitted to

    be the same lamps used for normal illumination inconformance with 2.14.7.1.1.

    2.16.3.2.2Data plates shall indicate(a) the weight of the complete car, including the carsafety and all auxiliary equipment attached to the car

    (b) the rated load and speed

    (c) the wire rope data required by 2.20.2.1(d) the name or trademark of th e manufactu rer and

    year manufactured(e) rail lubrication instructions (see 2.17.16)

    2.16.3.2.2Data plates sh all indicate(a) the weight of the complete car, including the carsafety and all auxiliary equipment attached to the car

    (b) the rated load and speed

    (c) the suspension means data required by 2.20.2.1(d) the name or trademark of the manufacturer and

    year manufactured(e) rail lubrication instructions (see 2.17.16)

    N/A

    2.17.1

    The car of every elevator suspended by wire ropessha ll be provided with one or more car safety devices

    of on e of the types identified in 2.17.5. The safeties s hallbe attached to the car frame, and one safety shall be

    located within or below the car frame.

    All car s afeties shall be mounted on a single car frameand shall operate only on one pair of guide rails be tween

    which the frame is located.

    2.17.1

    The car of every elevator suspended as required by 2.20.1sha ll be provided with one or more car safety devices

    of on e of the types identified in 2.17.5. Safeties s hall beattached to the car frame, and at least on e safety shall be

    located within or below the car frame.

    All car s afeties shall be mounted on a single car frameand shall operate only on one pair of guide rails between

    which the frame is located.

    N/A

    2.18.5.1 M aterial and Factor of Safety.Governorropes s hall be of iron, stee l, monel metal, pho sphor

    bronze, or stainless steel. They shall be of a regular-lay

    const ruction and not less than 9.5 mm (0.375 in.) in

    diameter. The facto r of safety of gov ernor ropes s hall benot less than 5. Tiller-rope cons truction shall not be us ed.

    2.18.5.1 Material and Factor of Safety. Governorropes s hall be of iron, stee l, monel metal, pho sphor

    bronze, or stainless steel. They shall be of a regular-lay

    const ruction and not less than 6 mm (0.25 in.) in

    diameter. The factor of safety o f governor ropes shall benot less than 5. Where provided, ropes of a diameter lessthan 9.5 mm (0.375 in.) shall have a factor of safety o f not

    less than 8 and sha ll be of six eight, or nine strandcons truction. Tiller-rope con struction shall not be used.

    N/A

    N/ATable 2.18.7.4 Multiplier for DeterminingGovernor Sheave Pitch DiameterRated Speed,m/s (f t/min) Number of Strands Multiplier1.00 or less (200 or less) 6 42

    1.00 or less (200 or less) 8 30

    Over 1.00 (over 200) 6 46

    Over 1.00 (over 200) 8 32

    Table 2.18.7.4 Multiplier for DeterminingGovernor Sheave Pitch DiameterRated Speed,m/s (f t/min) Number of Strands Multiplier1.00 or less (200 or less) 8 42

    1.00 or less (200 or less) 8or 9 30

    Over 1.00 (over 200) 6 46

    Over 1.00 (over 200) 8 or 9 32

    N/A

  • 8/12/2019 Comparisons Matrix

    8/66

    A17.1 2007 A17.1 2010 Oregon Amendment [Ore]

    elevator_code_comparisons_matrix _revised_100311.doc 8

    .

    2.18.7.4 The pitch diameter of governor sheavesand governor tension sheaves shall be not less than the

    product of the diameter of the rope and the applicable

    multiplier listed in Table 2.18.7.4, based on the ratedspeed and the number of strands in the rope

    2.18.7.4 Where governor ropes of a diameter of 9.5 mm(0.375 in.) or greater are used, the pitch diameter of governorand governortension sheaves shall be not less than the product of thediameter of the rope and the applicable multiplier listed inTable 2.18.7.4, based upon the rated speed and the number ofstrands in the rope. Where governor ropes of a diameter lessthan 9.5 mm (0.375 in.) are used, the governor sheave shallhave a pitch diameter of not less than the product of thediameter of the rope and a multiplier of 30.

    N/A

    2.20.1 Suspension Means

    Elevator cars sha ll be su spended by s teel wire ropesattached to the car frame or pas sing around sheaves

    attached to the car frame specified in 2.15.1. Ropes that

    have previously been installed and us ed on anotherinstallation shall not be reused.

    Only iron (low-carbon s teel) or steel wire ropes , havingthe commercial classification Elevator Wire Rope,

    or wire rope specifically constructed for elevator use,sha ll be us ed for the suspension of elevator cars and for

    the sus pension of co unterweights. The wire material

    for ropes shall be manufactured by the open-hearth orelectric furnace process or their equivalent.

    2.20.1Elevator cars and counterweights shall be suspended by steelw ire ropes, aramid fiber ropes, or noncircular elastomericcoated steel suspension members attached to the car frame orpassing around sheaves attached to the car frame specif ied in2.15.1. Suspension means that have previously beeninstalled and used on another installation shall not be reused.All suspension members in a set of suspension means shall beof the same material, grade, construction, and dimensions. Asuitable means shall be provided to protect the suspensionmeans during he installation process.Only the f ollowing shall be permitted:(a) Steel wire ropes constructed n accordance with ASME

    A17.6, Part 1(b) Aramid fiber ropes constructed in accordance with

    ASME A17.6, Part 2(c) Noncircular elastomeric-coated steel suspension

    members constructed in accordance with ASME A17.6,Part 3

    N/A

  • 8/12/2019 Comparisons Matrix

    9/66

    A17.1 2007 A17.1 2010 Oregon Amendment [Ore]

    elevator_code_comparisons_matrix _revised_100311.doc 9

    2.20.2 Wire Rope Data

    2.20.2.1 On Crosshead Data Plate.The crossheaddata plate required by 2.16.3 sha ll bear the following

    wire-rope data:(a) the number of ropes

    (b) the diameter in millimeters (mm) or inches (in.)(c) the manufacturers rated breaking strength per

    rope in kilonewton (kN) or po unds (lb)2.20.2.2 On Rope Data Tag.A metal data tag sh all

    be securely attached to one of the wire-rope fastenings.

    This data t ag shall bear the following wire-rope data:(a) the diameter in millimeters (mm) or inches (in.)

    (b) the manufacturers rated breaking st rength(c) the grade of material used

    (d) the month and year the ropes were installed(e) the month and year the ropes were first shortened

    (f) whether the ropes were nonpreformed or preformed

    (g) construction classification(h) name of the person or organization who ins talled

    the ropes(i) name or trademark of th e manufacturer of the

    ropes(j) lubrication information

    A new tag shall be installed at each rope renewal.

    The material and marking of the rope data tag s hallconform to 2.16.3.3, except that the height of the letters

    and figures shall be not less than 1.5 mm (0.06 in.).

    2.20.2 Wire Rope Data2.20.2.1 On Crosshead Data Plate. The crosshead dta platerequired by 2.16.3 shall bear the following suspension meansdata:(a) type of suspension means(b) the number of suspens ion members(c) either the diameter or the w idth and thickness in millimeters(mm) or inches (in.), as applicable

    (d) the elevator manufacturers required minimum breakingforce per suspension member in kilo New tons (kN) or pounds-force (lbf), as applicable.2.20.2.2 Data tag at suspension means fastening2.20.2.2.1 Pertinent data located on the suspension meansshall be provided by one of the follow ing:(a) a data tag securely attached to one of the suspensionmeans fastenings.(b) Permanent marking of the required information on thesuspension means and visible in the vicinity of the suspensionmeans fastening.(c) A combination of (a) and (b) provided that all requiredinformation is furnished.(d) If (a) or (c) applies, the material and markings of the tagshall conform to 2.16.3.3, except that the height of the letters

    and figures shall not be less than 1.5 mm (0.06 in.).(e)If (a) or (c) applies, a new tag shall be installed at eachsuspension means replacement.2.20.2.2.2 The following data shall be provided:(a) type of suspension (steel wire rope, aramid fiber rope, ornoncircular elastomeric-coated steel suspension member)(b) either the diameter or the w idth and thickness in millimetersor inches, as applicable.(c) the suspension means manufacturer s minimum breakingforce in kN or lbf, as applicable.(d) the residual strength determined by the elevatormanufac turer in kN or lbf, as applicable.(e) the grade of material used or the suspension meansmanufac turers designation, as applicable.(f) construction classification, where applicable.

    (g) f or steel w ire rope, non-preformed, if applicable.(h) f or steel w ire rope, finish coating, if applicable.(i) for steel w ire rope, compacted strands, if applicable.(j) name or t rademark if the suspension means manufacturer.(k) name of pers on or organization w ho installed suspensionmeans.(l) the month and year suspension means w as installed(m) the month and year the suspension means first shortened(n) lubrication information, if applicable

    N/A

  • 8/12/2019 Comparisons Matrix

    10/66

    A17.1 2007 A17.1 2010 Oregon Amendment [Ore]

    elevator_code_comparisons_matrix _revised_100311.doc 10

    2.20.3 Factor of SafetyThe factor of safety of the suspension wire ropes shallbe not les s than shown in Table 2.20.3. Figure 8.2.7 givesthe minimum factor of safety for intermediate ropespeeds. The factor of safety shall be based on the actualrope speed corresponding to the rated speed of the car.The factor of safety shall be calculated by the followingformula:

    f p S _ NWwhereN p number of runs of rope under load. For 2:1roping, N shall be two times the number ofrope s used, etc.S p manufacturer s rated breaking strength ofone ropeW p maximum static load imposed on all car ropeswith the car and its rated load at any positionin the hoistway

    2.20.3 Factor of SafetyThe factor of safety of the suspension means shallbe not les s than shown in Table 2.20.3. Figure 8.2.7 givesthe minimum factor of s afety for intermediate speeds. Thefactor of s afety shall be based on the actual speedcorre sponding to the rated speed of the car.Where suspension means are different from traditionalsteel w ire ropes, technical criteria for essential safety

    requirements and parameters, such as minimum factor ofsafety, monitoring, residual strength, replacement, etc.,shall be se lected on the basis of best engineering practicecompatible w ith the product technology, includingperformance testing under elevator operating conditionsfor its range of application.The m inimum factor for safety for any suspension meansshall not be less than the values shown in Table 2.20.3except that the factor of s afety of s teel wire suspensionrope s with diameters equal to or greater than 8 mm (.0315in.) but less than 9.5 mm ( 0.375 in.) shall be not less than12 or the y shall meet the requirements of 2.20.8.2. Seealso Non m andatory Appendix U.

    The factor of safety shall be calculated by the following

    formula:f = S _ NWwhereN = number of runs of suspension means under load. For2:1roping, N shall be tw o times the number ofrope s used, etc.S= manufacturer s r ated breaking s trength ofone ropeW = maximum static load imposed on all suspensionmembers with the car and its rated load at any positionin the hoistway

    N/A

    Table 2.20.3 Minimum Factors of Safety forSuspension Wire Ropes

    Rope Speed, Minimum Factor of Safetym/s (ft/min) Passenger Freight

    Table 2.20.3 Minimum Factors of Safety forSuspension Wire Ropes

    Suspension Means Speed, Minimum Factor of Safetym/s (ft/min) Passenger Freight

    N/A

    Table 2.20.3 Minimum Factors of Safety forSuspension Wire RopesRope Speed, Minimum Factor of Safetym/s (ft/min) Passenger Freight

    Table 2.20.3 Minimum Factors of Safety forSuspension Wire RopesSuspension Means Speed, Minimum Factor of Safetym/s (ft/min) Passenger Freight

    N/A

    Table 2 20 9 4 510 to 12 inclusive 2.5 larger than nominal rope diameter 3/8 to

    716inclusive 332 larger than nominal rope diameter.

    Table 2 20 9 4 58 to 12 inclusive 2.5 larger than nominal rope diameter 5/16to

    716inclusive 332larger than nominal rope diameter.

    N/A

  • 8/12/2019 Comparisons Matrix

    11/66

    A17.1 2007 A17.1 2010 Oregon Amendment [Ore]

    elevator_code_comparisons_matrix _revised_100311.doc 11

    2.24.2.1 Material and Grooving. Sheaves and dr umsused with suspension and compensating ropes shall beof m etal and provided with finished grooves for ropesor s hall be permitted to be lined w ith nonmetallic groovematerial.

    2.24.2.1 Material and Grooving. Sheaves and drumsused with suspension and compensating ropes shall beconstructed of materials conforming to 2.24.2.1.1 or2.24.2.1.2 and provided w ith finished grooves or s hall bepermitted to be lined with nonmetallic groove

    material. Sheaves and drums shall comply with 2.24.3.

    N/A

    N/A 2.24.2.1.1 Sheave s Driving-machine sheaves shall beintegr al with or dir ectly attached to driving machineshafts. Sheaves shall be provided with steel shafts andmetal bearings. Sheaves constructed of p lastic, fiber-reinforced plastic, or combinations thereof shall be non-regroovable. Permanent and legible marking shall beprovided on or adjacent to the nonmetallic sheavesstating, Regrooving of sheave is not permitted.

    N/A

    2.24.2.2 Minimum Pitch Diameter. Sheaves anddrum s used with suspension and compensating ropesshall have a pitch d iameter of not less than(a) 40 tim es the diameter of the rope where used withsuspension ropes

    (b) 32 times the diameter of the ropes where usedwith compensating ropes

    2.24.2.2 Minimum Pitch Diameter. Sheaves anddrum s used with suspension and compensating means(see 2.20.1) shall have a pitch diameter of not less than(a) 40 tim es the diameter of the rope where used withsuspension ropes

    (b) 40 times the cord diameter (see ASME A17.6, 3.3.3.1.1)of noncircular elastomeric-coated steel suspensionmembers w here used for suspension(c)16 times the functional diameter (see ASME A17.6,2.3.3.1.2) of the load carrying fibers of aramid ropes whereused for suspension or compensation(d) 32 times the diameter of the steel wire ropes and corddiameter of noncircular elastomeric-coated steelsus pension members where used for compensatingropes

    N/A

    2.24.2.3 Traction2.24.2.3.1 Where the gr ooves are used to transmitpow er, sufficient traction s hall be provided betweenthe r ope and groove, and in the event of nonmetallic

    2.24.2.3 Traction2.24.2.3.1 For Steel Wire Ropes. Where the grooves areused to provide traction, sufficient traction shall beprovided between the rope and groove, and in the event of

    nonmetallic lining failure, between the rope and therem aining sheave groove, to safely stop and hold the carwith rated load [see 2.16.8(c) from rated speed in the downdirection

    N/A

    2.24.2.3.2 If e ither the car or the counterweightbottoms on its buffers or becomes otherwise immovable(a) the ropes shall slip in the drive sheave groovesand not allow the car or counterweight to be raised; or(b) the driving system shall stall and not allow thecar or counterweight to be raised.

    2.24.2.3.2 For Aramid Fiber Ropes Where grooves areused to provide traction, sufficient traction shall beprovided between the rope cover and the groove, and inthe event of failure of the cover, between the load carryingportion of the r ope and the sheave groove, to s afely stopand hold the car with rated load [see 2.16.8(c)] from ratedspeed in the down direction.

    N/A

  • 8/12/2019 Comparisons Matrix

    12/66

    A17.1 2007 A17.1 2010 Oregon Amendment [Ore]

    elevator_code_comparisons_matrix _revised_100311.doc 12

    N/A 2.24.2.3.3 For Noncircular Elastomeric-CoastedSuspension Where surfaces are used to provide traction,sufficient traction shall be provided between thenoncircular elastomeric-coated steel suspension memberand the sur face, and in the event of failure of theelastomeric coating, between the load carrying cords andthe sheave contact surface, to safely stop and hold the carwith rated load [see 2.16.8(c) from

    Rated s peed in the down direction.

    N/A

    N/A 2.24.2.3.4 If either the car or the counterweight bottoms onits buffers or become otherwise immovable(a) the suspension members shall slip on the dr ive sheaveand not allow the car or counterweight to be raised, or(b) the driving system shall stall and not allow the car orcounterweight to be raised.

    N/A

    2.25.3.3.1 Traction machine elevators shall havefinal te rminal stopping switches located in the hoistwayand oper ated by cams attached to the car.

    2.25.3.3.1 Traction machines elevators shall have finalterminal stopping switches operated by cams. One of theassemblies (i.e., switch or cam) shall be m ounted on thecar and the other in the hoistway. Where the final terminalstopping devices shall prevent movement of the car by thenorm al operating devices in both directions of travel.

    N/A

    2.25.3.4Controller Switches Controlled by Final TerminalStopping Device. The normal and final terminalstopping devices shall not control the same controllersw itches unless two or more separate and independentsw itches are provided, two of which shall be closed tocomplete the driving-machine motor and brake circuitin eithe r direction of travel..Where a two- or three-phase AC dr iving-machinemotor is used, these switches shall be of the multipoletype.The control shall be so designed and installed that asingle ground or short circuit may permit either, but notprevent both, the normal or final s topping device circuitsfrom stopping the car.

    2.25.3.4The normal terminal stopping device and final terminalstopping devices shall not control the same controllersw itches unless two or more separate and independentcontroller devices are provided, two of which shall becomplete both the dr iving machine motor and the drivingmachine brake circuits in e ither direction of travel.Elevators employing a tw o or three phase alternatingcurre nt driving machine motor, which is not driven from adirect current source through a static inverter, shall beprovided with a means to inhibit the flow of alternatingcurre nt in each phase.The control circuits shall be so designed and installed thata s ingle ground or short circuit shall not prevent both thenorm al terminal stopping device and final te rminal

    stopping device control circuits from stopping the car.

    N/A

  • 8/12/2019 Comparisons Matrix

    13/66

    A17.1 2007 A17.1 2010 Oregon Amendment [Ore]

    elevator_code_comparisons_matrix _revised_100311.doc 13

    2.26.1.4.2 Top-of-Car Inspection Operation. Top of-car inspection operation shall conform to 2.26.1.4.1

    and the following:(a) A sto p switch (see 2.26.2.8) sha ll be permanently

    located on th e car top and readily accessible to a person,while s tanding at the h oistway entrance normally used

    for access to the car top.(b) The transfer switch [see 2.26.1.4.1(b)] sh all belocated on the car top and s hall be so designed as to

    prevent accidental transfer from the INSPECTION toNORMAL pos ition.

    (c) A s eparate device of the con tinuous-pressure typelabeled ENABLE sha ll be provided adjacent to the

    inspect ion operating devices.

    (d) The inspection operating devices sh all becomeeffective only when the ENABLE device is activated.

    (e) The insp ection operating devices [see2.26.1.4.1(c)], shall be permitted to be of the portable

    type, provided that(1) the ENABLE device [see 2.26.1.4.2(c)], and a

    stop switch, in addition to the s top switch required in2.26.1.4.2(a) are included in the p ortable unit

    (2) the flexible cord is permanently attached so that

    the po rtable unit cannot be detached from the car top(f) Separate add itional devices of the co ntinuous pressure

    type s hall be permitted to be p rovided on thecar top to make power door opening and closing and

    automatic car leveling operative from the top of the carfor test ing purposes.

    (g) When on top-of-car inspection operation, a separate

    additional device s hall be permitted to render ineffective

    the top final terminal s topping device, and thebuffer switch for gas spring-return counterweight oilbuffers, in conformance with the requirements of

    2.26.4.3, 2.26.9.3(a), and 2.26.9.4, and it s hall allow thecar to be moved to a position in conformance with the

    requirements of 2.7.4.5 and 2.7.5.1.3(c)..

    2.26.1.4.2 Top-of -Car Inspection Operation Top of the carinspection operation shall conform to 2.26.1.4.1 and thefollowing:

    (a) A stop switch (see 2.26.2.8) sha ll be permanently

    located on th e car top and readily accessible to a person,while s tanding at the h oistway entrance normally used

    for access to the car top.(b) The transfer s witch [see 2.26.1.4.1(b)] sh all belocated on the car top and s hall be so designed as to

    prevent accidental transfer from the INSPECTION to NORMAL position.

    (c) A separate device of the con tinuous-pressure typelabeled ENABLE shall be provided adjacent to the

    inspect ion operating devices.

    (d) The ins pection operating devices s hall becomeeffective only when the ENABLE device is activated.

    e) The inspection operating devices [see2.26.1.4.1(c)], shall be permitted to be of the portable

    type, provided that

    (1) the ENABLE device [see 2.26.1.4.2(c)], and a stop switch, in addition to the s top switch required in

    2.26.1.4.2(a) are included in the portable unit(2) the flexible cord is permanently attached so that

    the portable unit cannot be detached from the car top(f) Separate add itional devices of the co ntinuous pressure

    type s hall be permitted to be provided on thecar top to make po wer door opening and closing and

    automatic car leveling operative from the top of the carfor test ing purposes.

    (g) When on top-of-car inspection operation, a sep arate

    additional device s hall be permitted to render ineffectivethe top final terminal s topping device, and the

    buffer switch for gas spring-return counterweight oilbuffers, in conformance with the requirements of

    2.26.4.3, 2.26.9.3(a), 2.26.9.3.2 and 2.26.9.4, and it shallallow the car to be moved to a po sition in conformance

    with the requirements of 2.7.4.5 and 2.7.5.1.3(c).

    (h) The ins pection operating devices s hall be readilyaccessible to a person while standing in one of the

    horizontal areas des cribed in 2.14.1.6.2 on th e careenclosure top.

    N/A

  • 8/12/2019 Comparisons Matrix

    14/66

    A17.1 2007 A17.1 2010 Oregon Amendment [Ore]

    elevator_code_comparisons_matrix _revised_100311.doc 14

    2.26.1.5 Inspection Operation With Open Door Circuits.

    A s ingle set of switches marked CAR DOORBYPASS and HOISTWAY DOOR BYPASS shall be

    provided in the elevator controller enclosure containingthe car doo r and gate e lectric contact circuits and

    hoistway door interlock and hoistway do or electric contactcircuits (see 2.26.2.14 and 2.26.2.15); except where

    the s witches are not accessible from outside thehoistway, they shall be located in the inspection and test

    panel (see 2.7.6.5). The switches shall prepare the co ntrol

    sys tem so that, only when top-of-car or in-car inspec tionoperation is act ivated, the car shall be permitted to be

    moved with open d oor con tacts. The switches shallconform to 2.26.1.5.1 through 2.26.1.5.8.

    2.26.1.5 Inspection Operation With Open Door Circuits.

    A s ingle set of switches marked CAR DOORBYPASS and HOISTWAY DOOR BYPASS shall be

    provided. The switches shall be accessible from outs ideof the hoistway, They shall be located

    (a) In a cont roller enclosure for the elevator locatedouts ide the hoistway in a common roo m, a control space,

    the machine room, a machinery space, or on a motorcontrollers co mplying with 2.7.6.3.2; or

    (b) in the inspection and test panel (see 2.7.6.5)

    The switches s hall prepare the control system so that, onlywhen top-of-the-car or in car inspec tion operation is

    activated, the car shall be permitted to be moved withopen door contacts. The switches shall conform to

    2.26.1.5.1 through 2.26.1.5.8.

    N/A

    2.26.2.26Pit Acces s Door Electric Contact. An e lectriccontact shall be provided on each pit access doorwhere required by 2.2.4.4.

    2.26.2.26Pit Access Door Electric Contact. An e lectriccontact shall be provided on each pit access doorwhere required by 2.2.4.5.

    N/A

    2.26.2.33 Firefighters Stop Switch.A firefighters

    stop switch that conforms to the requirements of2.26.2.5(a), (b), and (c) shall be provided where required

    by 2.27.3.3.1(m).

    2.26.2.33 Firefight ers Stop Switch. Where required by

    2.27.3.3.1 (m), a firefighters stop switch shall(a) be of the manually opened and closed type(b) have red op erating handles or buttons(c) be conspicuously and permanently marked STOP, andshall indicate the STOP and RUN positions.(d) be of a toggle or push-to-stop configuration

    N/A

    2.26.4.4 Control equipment shall be tes ted in

    accordance with th e tes ting requirements of EN 12016by expos ing it to interference levels at the test values

    specified for safety circuits. The interference shall not caus e any of the conditions described in 2.26.9.3(a)

    through (e) and s hall not cause the car to move while

    on insp ection operation.

    If en closure doors or suppression equipment mustremain ins talled to meet the above requ irements, warningsigns to that effect shall be pos ted on the control

    equipment.

    2.26.4.4 Control equipment shall be tes ted in

    accordance with the tes ting requirements of EN 12016by expos ing it to interference levels at the test values

    specified for s afety circuits. The interference shall not cause any of the conditions described in 2.26.9.3.1(a)

    through (e) and s hall not cause the car to move while

    on insp ection operation.

    If enclosure doors or su ppression equipment mustremain ins talled to meet the abo ve requirements, warningsigns to that effect shall be pos ted on the control

    equipment.2.26.7 Installation of Capacitors or Other Devices toMake Electrical Protective Devices IneffectiveThe insta llation of capacitors or other devices, theoperation or failure of which will cause an unsafe

    operation of the elevator, is prohibited.No permanent device that will make any required

    electrical protective device ineffective shall be installedexcept as p rovided in 2.7.6.5.2(h), 2.12.7.1, 2.26.1.4.2(g),

    2.26.1.5, 2.26.1.6, and 2.27.3.1.6(c) (see 8.6.1.6.1).

    2.26.7 Installation of Capacitors or Other Devices toMake Electrical Protective Devices IneffectiveThe insta llation of capac itors or other devices, theoperation or failure of which will cause an unsafe

    operation of the elevator, is prohibited.No permanent device that will make the traction loss

    detection or any required electrical protective deviceineffective s hall be installed except as provided in

    2.7.6.5.2(h), 2.12.7.1, 2.26.1.4.2(g), 2.26.1.5, 2.26.1.6,

    and 2.27.3.1.6(c) (see 8.6.1.6.1).

    N/A

  • 8/12/2019 Comparisons Matrix

    15/66

    A17.1 2007 A17.1 2010 Oregon Amendment [Ore]

    elevator_code_comparisons_matrix _revised_100311.doc 15

    2.26.8.3The brake shall apply automatically when(a) the op erating device of a car switch or continuous

    press ure operation elevator is in the sto p position

    (b) a normal stopping means functions

    (c) any electrical protective device is act ivated(d) there is a loss of power to the driving-machine

    brake.

    2.26.8.3The driving machine brake shall applyautomatically when(a) the operating device of a car switch or cont inuous

    press ure operation elevator is in the stop position

    (b) a normal stopping means functions(c) any electrical protective device is act ivated

    (d) there is a loss of power to the driving-machinebrake.(e) The traction loss detection means is actuated [see2.20.8.1(c)]

    N/A

    2.26.9.3The occurrence of a single ground or thefailure of any s ingle magnetically operated switch,contactor, or relay, or any single device that limits the

    leveling or truck zone, or any single so lid-state device nota part of a software system; or a failure of a software

    sys tem in circuits n ot in con formance with 2.26.9.4(b),shall not

    (a) render any electrical protective device ineffective

    (see 2.26.2)(b)permit the car to move beyond the leveling or

    truck zone if any hoistway-door interlock is unlockedor if an y hoistway door or car door or gate electric

    contact is not in the closed position (see 2.26.1.6)(c)permit speeds in excess of those specified in

    2.12.7.3.2, 2.26.1.4.1(d)(1), and 2.26.1.6.6(d)permit the car to revert to normal operation when

    the electrical contact required by 2.7.5.2.1(b)(3) is in the

    open position, or the electrical device as p ermitted in2.7.5.5(b) is activated, or on hoistway access switch

    operation (see 2.12.7.3), or on insp ection operation (see2.26.1.4), or on bypass operation (see 2.26.1.5)

    (e) continue to make ineffective any h oistway-door

    interlock or car doo r or gate electric contact when eithera hoistway access switch (see 2.12.7.3) or a BYPASS

    switch (see 2.26.1.5) is turned to the OFF position.operated by the locking member, and the contacts shall bemaintained in the open position by the action of gravity, or by arestrained compression spring, or by both, or by means of theopening member.(2) The interlock shall hold the door in the locked position bymeans of gravity, or by a restrained compression spring, or byboth, or by means of a positive linkage.

    2.26.9.3.1 The occurrence of a single ground or the failure ofany single magnetically operated sw itch, contactor, or relay, orany single device that limits the leveling or truck zone, or anysingle solid-state device not a part of a softw are system; orfailure of a sof tware system in circuits not in conformance w ith2.26.9.3.2(b), shall not(a) render any electrical protective device ineffective (see2.26.2).(b) permit the car to move beyond the leveling or truck zone ifany hoistway door interlock is unlocked or if any hoistway dooror car door or gate electric contact is not in the closed position

    (see 2.26.1.6)(c) permit speeds in excess of this specified in 2.12.7.3.2,2.26.1.4.1(d)(1), and 2.26.1.6.6(d) permit car to revert to normal operation w hen the electricalcontact required by2.7.5.2.1(b)(3) is in the open position, orthe electrical device as permitted in 2.7.5.5(b) is activated, oron inspection operation (see 2.26.1.4), or on bypass operation(see 2.26.1.5)(e) render ineffective any hoistway door or car door interlock,or car door or gate electric contact, or hoistway doorcombination mechanical lock and electric contact w hen eithera hoistw ay access switch (see 2.12.7.3) or a BYPASS sw itch(see 2.26.1.5) is in the OFF position.2.26.9.3.2 Methods used to satisfy 2.26.9.3.1using softw aresystems permitted, provided that(a) a non-sof tw are controlled means is also used to removepow er f rom the driving machine motor and brake, or(b) the sof tware system and related circuits are listed/certifiedand labeled/marked f or compliance w ith the applicablerequirements of IEC 61508-2 and IEC 61508-3. This softaresystem and its related circuits shall have a SIL of not less thanthe highest SIL value of the safety function(s) in Table2.26.4.3.2 used in the circuit.

    N/A

    2.26.9.4Methods used to satisfy 2.26.9.3 shall bechecked prior to each s tart of the elevator from a landing,

    when on automatic operation. When a single ground orfailure, as specified in 2.26.9.3 occurs , the car shall not

    be permitted to restart. Methods implemented us ing

    2.26.9.4 Methods used to satisfy 2.26.9.3 shall be checkedprior to each star t of the elevator from a landing, w hen onautomatic operation. When a single ground or failure asspecified in 2.26.9.3 occurs, the car shall not be permitted torestart.

    N/A

  • 8/12/2019 Comparisons Matrix

    16/66

    A17.1 2007 A17.1 2010 Oregon Amendment [Ore]

    elevator_code_comparisons_matrix _revised_100311.doc 16

    software systems are permitted, provided that

    (a) the removal of power from the driving-machinemotor and brake is not s olely dependent on

    software-controlled means, or

    (b) the s oftware system and related circuits arelisted /certified and labeled/marked for compliance

    with the applicable requirements of IEC 61508-2 andIEC 61508-3. This so ftware system and its related circuits

    sha ll have a SIL of n ot less than the highest SIL valueof th e safety fun ction(s) in Table 2.26.4.3.2 used in the

    circuit.

    2.26.9.5.3The electrical protective devicesrequired by 2.26.2 shall control both means, except that

    leveling s hall be permitted to take place with poweropening of doors and gates in conformance with

    2.13.2.1.1 and 2.13.2.2.1.

    2.26.9.5.3 The electrical protective devices

    required by 2.26.2 and the traction los s detection means

    required by 2.20.8.1 sha ll control both means , except thatleveling s hall be permitted to take place with p ower

    opening of doors and gates in conformance with2.13.2.1.1 and 2.13.2.2.1.

    N/A

    2.26.9.6.3The electrical protective devices

    required by 2.26.2 shall control both means that inhibitthe flow of alternating current through the solid-statedevices , except th at leveling s hall be permitted to take

    place with power opening of the doors and gates asrestricted by 2.13.2.1.1 and 2.13.2.2.1.

    22.26.9.6.3The electrical protective devices

    required by 2.26.2 and th e traction loss detection meansrequired by 2.20.8.1 sha ll control both means that inhibitthe flow of alternating current through the solid-state

    devices , except that leveling shall be permitted to takeplace with power opening of the doors and gates as

    restricted by 2.13.2.1.1 and 2.13.2.2.1.

    N/A

    2.26.12.4Identify HELP button [see2.27.1.1.3(b)] and vis ual indication [see 2.27.1.1.3(c)]with the ph one symbol.

    DELETED N/A

    2.27.1.1.3 The two-way communication means

    within the car shall comply with the following

    requirements:(a) In jurisdictions enforcingNBCC, Appendix E of

    CSA B44, or in jurisdictions not enforcingNBCC, ICC/ANSI A117.1.

    (b) A pu sh but ton to actuate the two-way communicationmeans sha ll be provided in or adjacent to a car

    operating panel. The push button shall be visible and

    permanently identified as HELP. The identificationsha ll be on or adjacent to th e HELP butto n. When

    the pu sh button is actu ated, the emergency two-waycommunication means s hall initiate a call for help and

    establish two-way communications.(c) A visua l indication on th e same panel as the

    HELP pus h button shall be provided, that is activated

    by authorized personnel, to acknowledge that two-way

    communications link has been established. The v isual

    2.27.1.1.3 The two-way co mmunication means

    within the car shall comply with the following

    requirements:(a) In jurisdictions en forcingNBCC, Appendix E of

    CSA B44, or in jurisdictions not enforcingNBCC, ICC/ANSI A117.1.

    (b) A pu sh but ton to actuate the two-way communicationmeans s hall be provided in or adjacent to a car

    operating panel. The push button shall be visible and

    permanently identified with the PHONE. Symbol(see2.26.12.1). The identification shall be on or adjacent to

    the PHONEpus h button. When the push button isactuated, the emergency two-way communication means

    sha ll initiate a ca ll for help and es tablish two -waycommunications.

    (c) A visual indication on the same panel as the

    PHONE pus h button shall be provided, that is activated

    by authorized personnel, to acknowledge tha t two-way

    N/A

  • 8/12/2019 Comparisons Matrix

    17/66

    A17.1 2007 A17.1 2010 Oregon Amendment [Ore]

    elevator_code_comparisons_matrix _revised_100311.doc 17

    indication shall be extinguished when the two-way

    communicationlink is terminated.

    (d) The two-way communication means shall provide

    on demand to authorized pe rsonnel, information tha tidentifies the building location and e levator number and

    that ass istance is required.(e) After the ca ll acknowledgement signals are s ent

    [2.27.1.1.3(c)], the two-way voice communications shallbe available between the car and authorized personnel.

    (f) The two-way communications, once established,sha ll be disconnected only when authorized personnel

    outs ide the car terminate the call.

    (g) The two-way co mmunication means shall not us ea h andset in the car.

    (h) The two-way communications shall not be transmittedto an automated an swering system. The call for

    help sh all be answered by authorized pers onnel.(i) Operating instructions shall be incorpo rated with

    or adjacent to the HELP button.

    communications link has been established. The visual

    indication shall be extinguished when the two-waycommunication link is terminated.

    (d) The two-way communication means shall provide

    on demand to authorized pers onnel, information thatidentifies the building location and e levator number and

    that ass istance is required.(e) After the ca ll acknowledgement signals are s ent

    [2.27.1.1.3(c)], the two-way voice communications shallbe available between the car and authorized personnel.

    (f) The two-way communications, once established,sha ll be disconnected only when authorized personnel

    outs ide the car terminate the call.

    (g) The two-way co mmunication means shall not usea handset in the car.

    (h) The two-way communications shall not be transmittedto an automated an swering system. The call for

    help sh all be answered by authorized personnel.(i) Operating instructions shall be incorpo rated with

    or adjacent to the PHONE button.2.27.3.3.1When the FIRE OPERATION s witchis in the ON pos ition, the elevator shall be on PhaseII Emergency In-Car Operation, for use by emergency

    personnel only, and the elevator shall operate as follows:

    (a) The elevator shall be operable only by a personin the car.

    (b) The car s hall not respond to landing calls. Directionallanterns, where provided, shall remain inoperative.

    Car pos ition indicators, where provided, shallremain operative. Landing position indicators, where

    provided, shall remain inoperative, except at thedesignated

    level and th e building fire control st ation, wherethey sha ll remain operative.(c) Door open and close buttons shall be provided

    for power-operated doors and located as required by2.27.3.3.7. Butto ns shall be a minimum of 19mm(0.75 in.)

    in the s mallest dimens ion. The door open and door closebuttons shall be labeled OPEN and CLOSE. The

    door open and close buttons shall be operative when

    the elevator is stopped within an unlocking zone.(d) The opening of po wer-operated doors shall be

    controlled only by a continuous-pressure door openbutton.

    If the button is released prior to the do ors reaching

    the normal open po sition, the doors shall automatically

    2.27.3.3.1When the FIRE OPERATION switch is in th e ON position, the elevator shall be on Phas eII Emergency In-Car Operation, for use by emergency

    personnel only, and the elevator shall operate as follows:

    (a) The elevator shall be operable only by a personin the car.

    (b) Floor selection means, lanterns an d indicators(1) in the car

    (a) floor s election means shall function as requiredin 2.27.3.3.1.(i)

    (b)car call-registered lights, where provided, s hallremain op erative

    (c) car lanterns, where provided, shall remaininoperative

    (d)pos ition indicators and car-directionindicators, where provided, sh all remainoperative

    (2) at the building fire con trol station(a)pos ition indicators and car-direction

    indicators, where provided, shall remain

    operative(3) at the des ignated level

    (a) the car shall not respond to hall calls(b) hall car-registered lights, where provided,

    sha ll remain inoperative, except where

    ass ociated cars of a grou p have been returned

    N/A

  • 8/12/2019 Comparisons Matrix

    18/66

    A17.1 2007 A17.1 2010 Oregon Amendment [Ore]

    elevator_code_comparisons_matrix _revised_100311.doc 18

    reclose. Requirements 2.13.3.3, 2.13.3.4, 2.13.4.2.1(b)(2),

    and 2.13.4.2.1(c) do not app ly.On cars with multiple entrances, if more than one

    entrance can b e opened at the same landing, separate

    door op en buttons shall be provided for each entrance.(e) Open po wer-operated doors shall be closed only

    by continuous pressure on the door close button. If thebutton is released prior to the doors reaching the fully

    closed position, horizontally s liding doors shallautomatically reop en, and vertically s liding doors shall

    automatically stop or stop and reopen.On cars with multiple entrances, if more than one

    entrance can b e opened at the same landing, a separate

    door close button shall be provided for each entrance.(f) Opening and closing of power-operated car doors

    or ga tes that are opposite manual swing or manual slidehoistway doors shall conform to 2.27.3.3.1(d) and (e).

    (g) All door reopening d evices, except the door openbutton, shall be rendered inoperative. Full-speed closing

    sha ll be permitted.Landing door op ening and closing buttons, whereprovided, shall be rendered inoperative.

    (h) Every car shall be provided with a butto n labeledCALLCANCEL, located as required in 2.27.3.3.7, that

    sha ll be effective during Phase II Emergency In-CarOperation. When act ivated, all registered calls shall be

    canceled and a trave ling car shall stop at or before the

    next ava ilable landing. The button shall be a minimumof 19 mm (0.75 in.) in the smallest dimens ion.

    (i) Floor selection means shall be provided in the carto permit travel to all landings served by the car, and

    sha ll be operative at all times, except as in 2.27.3.3.2

    and 8.12.1. Means to prevent the operation of the floorselection means or door-operating bu ttons sh all berendered inoperative. The floor selection means shall be

    operable without th e use of keys , cards, tools, or special

    knowledge. The floor selection means shall be permittedto be located behind the locked cover specified in

    2.27.3.3.7, only if floor selection means for all landingsserved are included behind the locked cover. Where

    buttons not accessible to the public are provided theyshall be a minimum of 19 mm (0.75 in.) in the smallest

    dimension.

    (j) A traveling car sha ll sto p at the n ext available landingfor which a car ca ll was registe red. When a car stops

    at a landing, all registered car calls shall be canceled.

    to group automatic operation

    (c) Position indicators, car-direction indicators,and h all lanterns, where provide, shall remain

    inoperative

    (4) at all landings , except th e designated level(a)the car sha ll not resp ond to hall calls(b)hall-call registered lights, where provided,

    sha ll remain inoperative, except where

    ass ociated cars of a group have been returnedto group automatic operation

    (c)pos ition indicators car-direction indicators, andhall lanterns , where prov ided, shall; remain

    inoperative

    (c) Door open and close buttons shall be providedfor power-operated doors o nly and located as

    required by 2.27.3.3.7. Butto ns s hall be a minimum of19mm(0.75 in.)in the smallest dimens ion. The door

    open and do or close buttons shall be labeled OPENand CLOSE and when applicable REAR OPEN

    and REAR CLOSE or SIDE OPEN an d SIDECLOSE in lettering a minimum of 5 mm (0.25 in.) inheight with a contras ting background. The labeling

    sha ll be on or adjacent to the buttons. Requirement2.26.12 does n ot apply to these buttons. The door

    open and close buttons shall be operative when theelevator is sto pped within an unlocking zone.

    (d) The opening of power-operated doors s hall be

    controlled only by a continuous-pressure door openbutto n. If the button is released prior to the doors

    reaching the normal open position, the doors shallautomatically reclose. Requirements 2.13.3.3, 2.13.3.4,

    2.13.4.2.1(b)(2), and 2.13.4.2.1(c) do not apply. All door

    open b utton(s) in the car shall be op erational.On cars with multiple entrances, if more than oneentrance can b e opened at the same landing, separate

    door open buttons shall be provided for each entrance in

    conformance with 2.27.3.3.7.(e) Open power-operated doors shall be closed o nly

    by continuous pressure on the door close button. If thebutto n is released prior to the doors reaching the fully

    closed position, horizontally s liding d oors shallautomatically reopen, an d vertically s liding doors shall

    automatically stop or stop and reopen.

    On cars with multiple entrances, if more than oneentrance can b e opened at the same landing, a separate

    door close button shall be provided for each entrance.

  • 8/12/2019 Comparisons Matrix

    19/66

    A17.1 2007 A17.1 2010 Oregon Amendment [Ore]

    elevator_code_comparisons_matrix _revised_100311.doc 19

    (k) Means used to remove elevators from normal

    operation shall not prevent Phase II Emergency In-CarOperation, except

    (1) as specified in this Code

    (2) as co ntrolled by elevator personnel(l)No device, that measu res load, shall prevent operation

    of the elevator at or below the capacity and loadingrequired in 2.16.

    (m) Every car shall be provided with a switch, conformingto the requirements o f 2.26.2.33 and located as

    required in 2.27.3.3.7. When the s witch is in the STOPpos ition, all registered calls shall be canceled and power

    sha ll be removed from th e elevator driving-machine

    motor and brake. When the switch is moved to theRUN pos ition from the STOP position, the car sh all

    not move, except for leveling, until a call is entered . Ifthe ty pe of s witch used is a b utton, it sh all be a minimum

    of 19 mm (0.75 in.) in the smallest dimens ion.NOTE [2. 27.3.3.1(m)]: This requirement does not limit the

    firefight ers stop switch to a specific style of switch. Toggle switch es

    and push/pull butt ons are two po ssible styles. A switch, if p rovided,should be op erable to the STOP position by a firefighter

    wearing protec tive gloves (seeNFPA 1971).

    (n) If the n ormal power sup ply, emergency po wersup ply, and s tandby power supply are not available and

    the elevator is equipped with an alternate source ofpower that is insu fficient to move the car to all landings,

    the requirements of 2.27.3.1.6(n)(1) through (5) shall

    apply.

    (f) Opening and closing of power-operated car doors

    or ga tes that are opposite manual swing or manual slidehoistway doors shall conform to 2.27.3.3.1(d) and (e).

    (g) All door reopening devices, except th e door open

    butto n, shall be rendered inoperative. Full-speed closingsha ll be permitted.

    Landing door opening and closing buttons, whereprovided, shall be rendered inoperative.

    (h) Every car shall be provided with a butto n labeledCALL CANCEL, located as required in 2.27.3.3.2 and

    8.12.1. Means to prevent the operation of the floorselection means or door-operating bu ttons shall be

    rendered inop erative. Floor s election means that provide

    access to a ll landings served by the elevator shall belocated below the firefighters operation panel specified

    by 2.27.3.3.7. The floor selection means shall be operablewithout the u se of keys , cards, tools o r special knowledge.

    (i)The floor selection means shall be permitted to belocated behind locked cover specified in 2.27.3.3.7, only

    if floor s election means for all landings served areincluded behind the locked cover. Where buttons notaccessible to th e public are provided th ey shall be a

    minimum of 199 mm (0.75 in.) in the smallest dimens ion(j) A t raveling car shall sto p at the next available landing

    for which a car call was registered . When a car stopsat a landing, all registered car calls sh all be canceled.

    (k) Means used to remove elevators from normal

    operation shall not prevent Phase II Emergency In-CarOperation, except

    (1) as s pecified in this Code(2) as co ntrolled by elevator personnel

    (l)No device, that measures load, shall prevent operation

    of the elevator at or below the capacity and loadingrequired in 2.16.(m) Every car sh all be provided with a switch, conforming

    to the requirements of 2.26.2.33 and located as

    required in 2.27.3.3.7. When the s witch is in the STOPpos ition, all registered calls shall be canceled and power

    sha ll be removed from th e elevator driving-machinemotor and b rake. When the switch is moved to the

    RUN pos ition from the STOP position, the car sh allnot move, except for leveling, unt il a call is entered . If

    the ty pe of s witch used is a b utton, it sh all be a minimum

    of 19 mm (0.75 in.) in the smallest dimens ion.

  • 8/12/2019 Comparisons Matrix

    20/66

    A17.1 2007 A17.1 2010 Oregon Amendment [Ore]

    elevator_code_comparisons_matrix _revised_100311.doc 20

    NOTE [2. 27.3.3.1(m)]: This requirement does not limit the

    firefight ers stop switch to a specific style of switch. Toggle switch esand push/pull butt ons are two po ssible styles. A switch, if p rovided,should be operable t o the STOP position by a firefighterwearing protective gloves (seeNFPA 1971).

    (n) If the n ormal power sup ply, emergency powersup ply, and s tandby power supply are not available and

    the elevator is equipped with an alternate source ofpower that is insu fficient to move the car to all landings ,

    the requirements of 2.27.3.1.6(n)(1) through (5)shallapply.

    2.27.3.3.7The FIRE OPERATION switch(2.27.3.3), the CALL CANCEL button[2.27.3.3.1(h)],

    the STOP switch [2.27.3.3.1(m)], the door open bu tton(s), the do or close button(s), the additional visual

    signal (2.27.3.3.8), and the op erating instructions shownin Fig. 2.27.7.2 shall be group ed together at the top o f

    a main car operating panel behind a locked cover.

    The firefighters operation panel cover shall be open ableby the same key that operates the FIRE OPERATION

    switch. The cover shall be permitted to openautomatically when the car is on Phas e I Emergency

    Recall Operation and at the recall level. When the keyis in the FIRE OPERATION switch, the cover shall

    not be cap able of being closed. When closed, the cover

    sha ll be self-locking.Where rear doors are provided, buttons for both the

    front and rear doors s hall be provided in the firefightersoperation panel. The doo r open and door close buttons

    for th e rear entrance shall be labeled OPEN REARand CLOSE REAR.

    All buttons and switches shall be readily acces sible,

    located not more than 1 800 mm (72 in.) above the floor

    and shall be arranged as shown in Fig. 2.27.3.3.7.Requirement2.26.12 does not apply to these buttons andswitches . The front of the cover shall conta in the words

    FIREFIGHTERS OPERATION in red letters at leas t 10 mm (0.4 in.) high.

    2.27.3.3.7The FIRE OPERATION switch(2.27.3.3), the CALL CANCEL button [2.27.3.3.1(h)],

    the STOP switch [2.27.3.3.1(m)], the door open bu tton(s), the door close button(s), the additional visual

    signal (2.27.3.3.8), and the operating ins tructions shownin Fig. 2.27.7.2 sha ll be grouped together at the top of

    a main car operating panel behind a locked cover.The fire department communication system phone jack shallbe permitted to be installed in the fire fighters operation panel.No other equipment shall be permitted in the fire fightersoperation panel.

    The firefighters operation panel cover shall be openableby the same key that operates the FIRE OPERATION

    switch. The key shall be rotated clockwise to allow thepanel to be opened. When open, the cover shall not

    restrict access to the buttons or switches or the view of theinstructions.

    The cover sh all be permitted to open

    automatically when the car is on Phas e I EmergencyRecall Operation and at the recall level. When the key

    is in the FIRE OPERATION switch, the cover shallnot be cap able of being closed. When closed, the cover

    sha ll be self-locking.Where rear or side doors are provided, buttons for the

    front, rear, and side doo rs shall be provided in the

    firefighters operation panel. The door open and doorclose bu ttons for the rear ent rance (where provided) shall

    be labeled OPEN REAR and CLOSE REAR. Thedoor open and close button s for the side entrance (where

    provided) shall be labeled SIDE OPEN and SIDECLOSE.

    All button s and switches and the lock for the panel shall

    be located more than 1220 mm (48 in.) and less than 1830mm (72 in.) abov e the floor as measured to the centerline

    of the button, switch or lock, and sh all be and s hall be

    arranged as s hown in Fig. 2.27.3.3.7.

    N/A

  • 8/12/2019 Comparisons Matrix

    21/66

    A17.1 2007 A17.1 2010 Oregon Amendment [Ore]

    elevator_code_comparisons_matrix _revised_100311.doc 21

    Requirement 2.26.12 does n ot apply to these buttons and

    switches . The front of the cover shall contain the wordsFIREFIGHTERS OPERATION in red lette rs at least

    10 mm (0.4 in.) high.

    The firefighters operation panel shall be located asfollows:

    (a)the panel sh all be on the s ame vertical clearancecenterline as a floor selection means tha t

    provides access to all floors served by theelevator.

    (b) The panel and the floor selection means shall belocated on the wall of the car containing the door

    that opens to the lobby where theFIRE

    RECALL switch is located or immediatelyadjacent to that wall on a s ide wall.

    2.27.3.4 Inter ruption of Power.Upon the resumptionof po wer (normal, emergency , or standby), the car

    sha ll be permitted to move to reestab lish ab solute carpos ition. Restoration of electrical power following a

    power interruption shall not cause any elevator to be

    removed from Phase I Emergency Recall Operation orPhase II Emergency In-Car Operation.

    The failure and subsequent restoration of electricalpower (normal, emergency, or standby) shall not cause

    any elevato r to be removed from Phase I EmergencyOperation or Phas e II Emergency In-Car Operation.

    (a) Elevators on Phase I Emergency Operation shallbe permitted to move only to the next floor in the

    direction of the recall level to reestablish absolute car

    pos ition prior to conforming to 2.27.3.1 and 2.27.3.2.(b) Elevators on Phase II Emergency In-Car Operation

    with the key in the OFF pos ition shall be permitted to move only to the next floor in the direction of the

    recall level to reestab lish absolute car position prior toconforming to 2.27.3.3.3 and 2.27.3.3.4. If the key is

    moved to the ON or HOLD position before the

    doors are fully closed, 2.27.3.4(c) or (d) shall apply, andautomatic power-operated doors shall open if in a

    level zone.(c) Elevators on Phase II Emergency In-Car Operation

    with the key in the HOLD position shall not move,except for leveling within a leveling zone. Au tomatic

    power-operated doors shall open if the doors are not

    fully c losed and the car is in a level zone.

    (d) Elevators on Phase II Emergency In-Car Operation

    2.27.3.4 Interruption of Power. The failure and subsequentrestoration of electrical power (normal, emergency, or standby)shall not cause any elevator to be removed from Phase IEmergency Operation or Phase II Emergency In-Car

    Operation.(a) Elevators on Phase I Emergency Operation shall

    be permitted to move only to the next floor in thedirection of the recall level to reestab lish absolute car

    pos ition prior to conforming to 2.27.3.1 and 2.27.3.2.(b) Elevators on Pha se II Emergency In-Car Operation

    with the key in the OFF pos ition shall be permitted to move only to the next floor in the direction of the

    recall level to reestablish absolute car position prior to

    conforming to 2.27.3.3.3 and 2.27.3.3.4. If the key ismoved to the ON or HOLD po sition before the

    doors are fully closed, 2.27.3.4(c) or (d) shall apply, andautomatic power-operated doors shall open if in a

    level zone.(c) Elevators on Phase II Emergency In-Car Operation

    with the key in the HOLD pos ition s hall not move,except for leveling within a leveling zone. Au tomatic

    power-operated doors shall open if the doors are not

    fully clos ed and the car is in a level zone(d) Elevators on Phase II Emergency In-Car Operation

    with the key in the ON positionshall not move, exceptfor leveling within a leveling zone, until a car call is

    entered. Automatic power-operated do ors shall notmove un til a door open or close button is pressed; after

    which they s hall conform to 2.27.3.3.1(d) and (e). After

    a car call is entered, the car shall be permitted to move

    N/A

  • 8/12/2019 Comparisons Matrix

    22/66

    A17.1 2007 A17.1 2010 Oregon Amendment [Ore]

    elevator_code_comparisons_matrix _revised_100311.doc 22

    with the key in the ON pos ition s hall not move, except

    for leveling within a leveling zone, u ntil a car call isentered. A utomatic power-operated do ors shall not

    move un til a door open or close button is pres sed; after

    which they s hall conform to 2.27.3.3.1(d) and (e). Aftera car call is entered, the car shall be permitted to move

    only to th e next floor in the d irection of the recall levelto rees tablish absolute car position prior to answeringcar calls.

    only to th e next floor in the direction of the recall level

    to rees tablish absolute car position prior to an sweringcar calls.

    2.27.7.2A s ign cont aining ins tructions for operationof elevators under Phas e II Emergency In-Car Operationshall be incorporated with or adjacent to the switch

    in each car and sh all be visible only when the cover(2.27.3.3.7) is open. The sign shall include only the

    wording and graphics shown in Fig. 2.27.7.2, except(a) for elevators with manually operated doors, the

    instructions for opening and closing the doors shall be

    permitted to be replaced with short phrases such asPUSH DOOR or PULL DOOR UP

    (b) for elevators with vertically sliding doors, theinstructions for returning the car to th e recall floor shall

    be permitted to be expanded to include ins tructions forclosing the door

    2.27.7.2A s ign containing ins tructions for operationof elevators under Phase II Emergency In-Car Operationshall be incorporated with or adjacent to the switch

    in each car and s hall be visible only when the cover(2.27.3.3.7) is open. The sign shall include only the

    wording and graphics shown in Fig. 2.27.7.2, except(a) for elevators with manually operated doors, the

    instructions for opening and closing the doors shall be

    permitted to be replaced with sho rt phrases such asPUSH DOOR or PULL DOOR UP

    (b) for elevators with vertically sliding doors, theinstructions for returning the car to the recall floor shall

    be permitted to be expanded to include inst ructions forclosing the do or

    N/A

    Figure 2.27.9 Revise d dime nsions clarification N/A

    3.26.3.1.5Only the following, when activated,sha ll prevent operation of the anticreep device:

    (a) the electrical protective devices listed in 3.26.4.1(b) recycling operation (see 3.26.7)

    (c) inspection transfer switch(d) hoistway access switch

    (e) low oil protection means(f) oil tan k temperature shutdown devices

    3.26.3.1.5Only the following, when activated,sha ll prevent operation of the anticreep device:

    (a) the electrical protective devices listed in 3.26.4.1(b) recycling operation (see 3.26.7)

    (c) inspection transfer switch(d) hoistway access switch

    (e) low oil protection means(f) oil tank temperature shutdown devices (see 3.26.5 and

    3.26.6.5)

    N/A

    N/A ADDED 2010 3.26.6.5 In the pump motor controller for electrohydraulicelevators, w hen the occurrence of a single ground or failure ofany single magnetically operated sw itch, contactor, or relay; orany single solid0state device, or softw are system failurecauses the liquid in the hydraulic driving machine to rise intemperature above its maximum operating temperature, thefollowing shall occur:(a) pow er shall be removed from the hydraulic driv ing machinemotor.(b) the hydraulic driving machine motor shall not be permittedto restart(c) w hen the doors are closed, the car shall automatically bebrought to the low est landing and then operate in conformancew ith 3.26.9.2 and 3.26.9.3.

    N/A

    N/A

  • 8/12/2019 Comparisons Matrix

    23/66

  • 8/12/2019 Comparisons Matrix

    24/66

    A17.1 2007 A17.1 2010 Oregon Amendment [Ore]

    elevator_code_comparisons_matrix _revised_100311.doc 24

    5.2.1.4.2.1Where a machinery space or controlspace is not located in the pit, a nonremovable meanssha ll be provided to mechanically hold the car above

    the pit floor to provide an area in the pit for maintenance

    and ins pection, conforming to the following:(a) It shall hold the car at a height of not less than

    900 mm (35 in.) n or more than 2 000 mm (79 in.) abo ve

    the pit floor and not less th an 300 mm (12 in.) abovethe bo ttom landing s ill, as measu red from the undersideof the car platform.

    (b) The means shall be so des igned and constructedas to s top and hold the car at governor tripping speed

    with rated load in the car.

    (c) It shall not caus e the s tresses and deflections incar frame an d platform members and their connections

    to exceed the limits specified in 2.15.10 and 2.15.11.(d) If the means do es not automatically activate when

    the lowest hoistway door is opened with the car not atthe landing

    (1) it shall be capable of being op erated withoutcomplete bodily entry into the pit.(2) a sign conforming to ANSI Z35.1, or

    CAN/CSA-Z321, whichever is applicable (see Part 9),sha ll be consp icuously displayed inside the hoistway,

    which shall include awarning that there is an ins ufficientbottom car clearance and instructions for operating the

    device. The letters s hall be not less th an 25 mm (1 in.)

    in height.

    5.2.1.4.2.1Where a machinery space or controlspace is not located in the pit, a nonremovable meanssha ll be provided to mechanically hold the car above

    the pit floor to provide an area in the pit for maintenance

    and ins pection, conforming to th e following:(a) It shall hold the car at a height of not less t han

    900 mm (35 in.) n or more than 2 000 mm (79 in.) abov e

    the pit floor and not less than 300 mm (12 in.) abovethe bottom landing sill, as measured from the undersideof th e car platform.

    (b) The means shall be so des igned and co nstructedas to s top and hold the car at governor tripping speed

    with rated load in the car.

    (c) It shall not caus e the s tresses and deflections incar frame an d platform members and the ir connections

    to exceed the limits specified in 2.15.10 and 2.15.11.(d) If the means do es not automatically activate when

    the lowest hoistway door is opened with the car not atthe landing

    (1) it shall be capable of being operated withoutcomplete bodily entry into the pit.(2) a sign conforming to ANSI Z535.2, or ANSI Z535.4,

    CAN/CSA-Z321, whichever is applicable (see Part 9),sha ll be con spicuously displayed inside the hoistway,

    which shall include a warning that there is an insufficientbotto m car clearance and instructions for operating the

    device. The letters s hall be not less th an 25 mm (1 in.)

    in height. The sign shall be made of durable material andshall be securely fastened.

    N/A

    5.2.1.4.4 Alternative to Top Car Clearance Requirements.

    In existing b uildings where the top car clearanceconforming to 5.2.1.4.3 canno t be provided, the following

    shall apply:(a) When the car has reached its maximum upper

    movement, no part of the car o r any equipment attachedthereto, o ther than as permitted by 5.2.1.4.4(b), sha ll

    strike the overhead structure or any part of the equipment

    located in the hoistway.(b)Nonremovable means shall be provided to

    mechanically an d electrically prevent upward movementof the car to provide an area above th e car for

    maintenance and inspection, conforming to the following:(1) The means s hall prevent upward movement of

    the car to provide a refuge sp ace conforming to 2.4.12.

    (2) The means shall be so des igned and constructed

    as to s top up ward movement of the car at governor

    5.2.1.4.4 Alternative to Top Car Clearance Requirements.

    In existing b uildings where the top car clearanceconforming to 5.2.1.4.3 cannot be p rovided, the following

    shall apply:(a) When the car has reached its maximum upper

    movement, no part of the car or any equipment attachedthereto, o ther than as permitted by 5.2.1.4.4(b), s hall

    strike the overhead structure or any part of the equipment

    located in the hoistway.(b)Nonremovable means shall be provided to

    mechanically and electrically prevent upward movementof the car to provide an area above the car for

    maintenance and inspection, conforming to the following:(1) The means s hall prevent upward movement of

    the car to provide a refuge space conforming to 2.4.12.

    (2) The means shall be so des igned and co nstructed

    as to s top up ward movement of the car at governor

    N/A

  • 8/12/2019 Comparisons Matrix

    25/66

    A17.1 2007 A17.1 2010 Oregon Amendment [Ore]

    elevator_code_comparisons_matrix _revised_100311.doc 25

    tripping speed with and without rated load in the car.

    (3) The means shall not cause the s tresses anddeflections in car frame and p latform members an d their

    connections to exceed the limits specified in 2.15.10 and

    2.15.11.(4) A s ign conforming to ANSI Z35.1, or CAN/

    CSA-Z321, whichever is applicable (see Part 9), shall be

    cons picuously displayed ins ide the hoistway which shallinclude a warning that there is an insufficient top carclearance and ins tructions for operating the means . The

    letters shall be not less than 25 mm (1 in.) in height.

    tripping speed with and without rated load in the car.

    (3) The means shall not cause the s tresses anddeflections in car frame and p latform members and their

    connections to exceed the limits sp ecified in 2.15.10 and

    2.15.11.(4) A s ign conforming to ANSI Z535.2, ANSI Z535.4 or

    CAN/CSA-Z321, whichever is applicable (see Part 9),

    sha ll be cons picuously displayed inside the hoistwaywhich shall include a warning that there is an insufficienttop car clearance and ins tructions for operating the means.

    The letters sh all be not less than 25 mm (1 in.) in height.The sign s hall be made of durable material and s hall be

    securely fastened.5.2.2.14 Emergency Operations and Signaling

    Devices.Requirement 5.2.1.27 does not apply.Emergency operations and signaling devices shall

    conform to 3.27, except firefighters emergencyoperations (2.27.3 through 2.27.8) does n ot apply. When

    firefighters emergency operation is provided, it s hallconform to 3.27.1through 3.27.4.

    5.2.2.14 Emergency Operations and Signaling

    Devices.Requirement 5.2.1.27 does not apply.Emergency operations and s ignaling devices s hall

    conform to 3.27, except as modified 5.2.2.14.1.

    N/A

    ADDED 5.2.2.14.1 Phase II Emergenc y In-Car Operation shall not beprovided.

    N/A

    5.3.1.18.2 Control and Operating Circuit Requirements.

    The des ign and installation of the op erating

    circuits shall conform to the following:

    5.3.1.18.2 Control and Operating Circuit RequirementsThe design and installation of the operating circuits shallconform to 5.3.1.18.2.1 and 5.3.1.18.2.2.

    N/A

    Numer ical designator and title addedText w as under 5.3.1.18.2

    5.3.1.18.2.1 Des ign and Installation

    (a) The completion or maintenance of an electric circuit

    sha ll be used neither to interrupt the power to theelevator driving machine or brake at the t erminal landings,

    nor to stop the car when any electrical protect