Comparison Weigert Stained Sections with Unfixed ... · thin unstained brain sections of freshly...
4
Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. USA Vol. 71, No. 3, pp. 598-601, March 1974 Comparison of Weigert Stained Sections with Unfixed, Unstained Sections for Study of Myelin Sheaths CURT P. RICHTER AND CAROLYN L. WARNER Psychobiological Laboratory; Phipps Psychiatric Clinic; Johns Hopkins Hospital, Baltimore, Maryland 21205 Contributed by Curt P. Richter, October 19, 1973 ABSTRACT Myelinated fibers can be demonstrated in thin unstained brain sections of freshly killed uninjected animals. With this method myelinated fibers stand out as clearly as in stained Weigert sections from formalin- fixed brains. Unstained unfixed sections can be viewed under ordinary light within minutes after death of the animal and immediately photographed for permanent records. Such sections have value for neuroanatomical studies, and for rapid localization of various types of experimental lesions. A variety of methods are used for staining myelin sheaths of central and peripheral axons. These techniques include the Weigert, Woelcke, and Weil methods, all of which depend on the use of fixed stained tissue and necessitate a processing time of several weeks. For many years we have used a simple and rapid method for showing myelin in experimental material-chiefly for quick localization of experimental lesions but also for neuroana- tomical studies. This technique uses frozen sections of brains of freshly killed uninjected rats. The sections are viewed at once under a microscope and photographed. This method depends on use of a very quick embedding medium (Ames OCT Compound), a cryostat, and a combined microscope and camera (Zeiss Ultra Phot II) which makes possible immediate viewing and photographing of the sections. Such sections compare very favorably with those obtained with any of the methods in common use. MATERIAL AND METHODS The brain of a freshly killed rat is cut into blocks of 10 mm or less-the maximum width of tissue that can be cut in the cryostat. Each block is embedded in Ames OCT compound and frozen in the cryostat at -180 for thinner sections (5-6 Am) and at -10° for thicker sections (40 Mm). Thickness of sections can thus range from 2 to 48 Am. The cut sections are mounted on clean (Iry slides that have been kept at room temperature rather than in the cryostat where moisture con- denses on them and interferes with the refractile properties of the sections. Slides with the mounted sections are stored in racks under dry-ice until ready to be viewed under the micro- scope and photographed. A great many sections can thus be prepared within a short time. The slides are defrosted by holding them against fingers or the wrist for a few seconds. The Zeiss Ultra Phot II makes it possible to inspect the section under the microscope at various magnifications, and to project the image onto a screen (8.0 X 11.5 cm) for rapid, accurate focusing. Myelinated fibers can be clearly seen with- out specialized lighting. The optics of the microscope allow for excellent photographs at low and high power. A built-in condenser makes possible the rapid taking of high quality photographs. With the luminar attachment we obtain excel- lent photographs of slides under high magnification. The photographs can be obtained rapidly by inserting a Polaroid film holder over the viewing screen and adjusting the source of light. If the photographs are not satisfactory they can be repeated at once. After defrosting the sections do not deteriorate (dry out) for 10 min or more, giving ample time for thorough micro- scopic inspections and making of a permanent photographic record. Fixed Unstained Sections. For many years we have also used unstained sections of 10% formalin-perfused brains. These also give excellent resolution of myelin sheaths. They last at least 10 min longer than unfixed sections, allowing more time for microscopic inspections. However, they have several disadvantages. There is much more distortion, particularly of ventricles, than is seen in unfixed sections; also they cannot be quickly embedded. Without embedding, the surface frag- ments of tissue may become lost, or delicate areas around lesions may be torn. And finally, they cannot be mounted until the brains have become well-hardened in formalin, for at least 24 hr. RESULTS Fig. 1A shows a photograph of a sagittal section of a rat's brain prepared by the original Weigert method (1). Fig. 1B shows a photograph of an unstained sagittal section of a freshly killed uninjected rat. Both sections are 25 ,m in thickness, and both were photographed with the same lpro- cedures on Polaroid film. Inspection of these sections shows little difference in the demonstration of mvelinated fibers. Fig. 2A shows a photograph of the section adjoining the one shown in Fig. 1B but made with a regular film (Kodak Plus-X Professional Film). The myelinated fibers are shown in greater detail than those seen in Fig. 1B. Fig. 2B shows the area enclosed in the oblong in Fig. 2A magnified 6.4 X (or 105X from the original section). The degree of resolution permits us to visulaize the finest mvelinated fibers. It will be noted that the sections are free from shrinkage and distortion of ventricles produced by the ordinary methods. DISCUSSION In 1843, Benedict Stilling of Cassel, Germany, pioneer in the histological study of the nervous system, cut sections of tartaric-acid-hardeie(l l)ieces of brain tissue by hand with a razor. In a great un(lerstatement he said that it requires 598 Downloaded by guest on March 26, 2020
Transcript of Comparison Weigert Stained Sections with Unfixed ... · thin unstained brain sections of freshly...
Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. USAVol. 71, No. 3, pp. 598-601, March 1974
Comparison of Weigert Stained Sections with Unfixed, UnstainedSections for Study of Myelin Sheaths
CURT P. RICHTER AND CAROLYN L. WARNER
Psychobiological Laboratory; Phipps Psychiatric Clinic; Johns Hopkins Hospital, Baltimore, Maryland 21205
Contributed by Curt P. Richter, October 19, 1973
ABSTRACT Myelinated fibers can be demonstrated inthin unstained brain sections of freshly killed uninjectedanimals. With this method myelinated fibers stand outas clearly as in stained Weigert sections from formalin-fixed brains. Unstained unfixed sections can be viewedunder ordinary light within minutes after death of theanimal and immediately photographed for permanentrecords. Such sections have value for neuroanatomicalstudies, and for rapid localization of various types ofexperimental lesions.
A variety of methods are used for staining myelin sheaths ofcentral and peripheral axons. These techniques include theWeigert, Woelcke, and Weil methods, all of which depend onthe use of fixed stained tissue and necessitate a processingtime of several weeks.For many years we have used a simple and rapid method for
showing myelin in experimental material-chiefly for quicklocalization of experimental lesions but also for neuroana-tomical studies. This technique uses frozen sections of brainsof freshly killed uninjected rats. The sections are viewed atonce under a microscope and photographed. This methoddepends on use of a very quick embedding medium (AmesOCT Compound), a cryostat, and a combined microscope andcamera (Zeiss Ultra Phot II) which makes possible immediateviewing and photographing of the sections. Such sectionscompare very favorably with those obtained with any of themethods in common use.
MATERIAL AND METHODS
The brain of a freshly killed rat is cut into blocks of 10 mm orless-the maximum width of tissue that can be cut in thecryostat. Each block is embedded in Ames OCT compoundand frozen in the cryostat at -180 for thinner sections (5-6Am) and at -10° for thicker sections (40 Mm). Thickness ofsections can thus range from 2 to 48 Am. The cut sections aremounted on clean (Iry slides that have been kept at roomtemperature rather than in the cryostat where moisture con-denses on them and interferes with the refractile properties ofthe sections. Slides with the mounted sections are stored inracks under dry-ice until ready to be viewed under the micro-scope and photographed. A great many sections can thus beprepared within a short time. The slides are defrosted byholding them against fingers or the wrist for a few seconds.The Zeiss Ultra Phot II makes it possible to inspect the
section under the microscope at various magnifications, andto project the image onto a screen (8.0 X 11.5 cm) for rapid,accurate focusing. Myelinated fibers can be clearly seen with-out specialized lighting. The optics of the microscope allowfor excellent photographs at low and high power. A built-in
condenser makes possible the rapid taking of high qualityphotographs. With the luminar attachment we obtain excel-lent photographs of slides under high magnification. Thephotographs can be obtained rapidly by inserting a Polaroidfilm holder over the viewing screen and adjusting the sourceof light. If the photographs are not satisfactory they can berepeated at once.
After defrosting the sections do not deteriorate (dry out)for 10 min or more, giving ample time for thorough micro-scopic inspections and making of a permanent photographicrecord.
Fixed Unstained Sections. For many years we have alsoused unstained sections of 10% formalin-perfused brains.These also give excellent resolution of myelin sheaths. Theylast at least 10 min longer than unfixed sections, allowing moretime for microscopic inspections. However, they have severaldisadvantages. There is much more distortion, particularlyof ventricles, than is seen in unfixed sections; also they cannotbe quickly embedded. Without embedding, the surface frag-ments of tissue may become lost, or delicate areas aroundlesions may be torn. And finally, they cannot be mounteduntil the brains have become well-hardened in formalin, for atleast 24 hr.
RESULTS
Fig. 1A shows a photograph of a sagittal section of a rat'sbrain prepared by the original Weigert method (1). Fig. 1Bshows a photograph of an unstained sagittal section of afreshly killed uninjected rat. Both sections are 25,m inthickness, and both were photographed with the same lpro-cedures on Polaroid film. Inspection of these sections showslittle difference in the demonstration of mvelinated fibers.Fig. 2A shows a photograph of the section adjoining the oneshown in Fig. 1B but made with a regular film (Kodak Plus-XProfessional Film). The myelinated fibers are shown in greaterdetail than those seen in Fig. 1B. Fig. 2B shows the areaenclosed in the oblong in Fig. 2A magnified 6.4 X (or 105Xfrom the original section). The degree of resolution permitsus to visulaize the finest mvelinated fibers. It will be notedthat the sections are free from shrinkage and distortion ofventricles produced by the ordinary methods.
DISCUSSION
In 1843, Benedict Stilling of Cassel, Germany, pioneer in thehistological study of the nervous system, cut sections oftartaric-acid-hardeie(l l)ieces of brain tissue by hand with a
razor. In a great un(lerstatement he said that it requires598
Dow
nloa
ded
by g
uest
on
Mar
ch 2
6, 2
020
Unstained Sections for Study of Myelin Sheaths 599
L
FIG. 1. (A) A Polaroid photograph of a 25-jum sagittal section of a rat's brain prepared by the original Weigert method. X 12. (B)A Polaroid photograph of a 25-un unstained sagittal section of a freshly killed uninjected rat. X 12.
considerable skill to cut fine sections by hand. He viewed hissections under a primitive microscope and without any photo-graphic technique had to make drawings of all of the sections(2).
1Iuch later other workers also used unstained sections butviewed and photographed them with various forms of light-phase contrast, polarization, and x-ray defraction (3, 4).Guzman et al. (5) and Powell (6) both used unstained but
formalin-fixed sections for the quick localization of implantedstimulating electrodes. Such sections gave good resolutionbut had certain disadvantages that were described above.
Hutchinson and Renfrew (7) also used unstained fixedsections for gross localization of electrode tracks and reported
being able to see outlines of nuclear structures in their slides.We have also seen outlines of some of the nuclei, particularlythe suprachiasmatic and supraoptic nuclei, in our fixed sec-tions.
Advantages of Use of the Unstained Unfixed Sections AsCompared to Weigert Stained Fixed Sections. Within minutesunstained unfixed sections can be inspected and photographedfor a permanent record. This method avoids the time-con-suming steps in other staining procedures used in the prepara-tion of permanent sections. The need for technical help isgreatly reduced. Sections may also be examined for myelinatedfibers and then subsequently used in other staining procedures.
Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. USA 71 (1974)
Dow
nloa
ded
by g
uest
on
Mar
ch 2
6, 2
020
600 Zoology: Richter and Warner Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. USA 71 (1974)
Ss, ts. s e ... V
., v^
s j;N
>v;S_ 4;eS <t _
:.y, .rW ;z '1 _ . ; &S * v ^D l
Bi:, *._. . ,>Wt
% C*B b .. v.
..~'t C
v ~~,*^ | ..
..._~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~.'t t_ . . ,~ ....................~.wr_-
:,,,,i,,4'-r,':,,-,.
i~9:>s-;+r ~>4iK.\: i b jL sS r*~p%. *nS* :e x. f.- .xw~-,,-v~~~~.\',S'*..'"t a,¢ 9. S B s~ \F4 -$
\¢¢ w v v s w * -'"4tt 'wnsow,, 'qt
- _
* .r.4:,, H
,>f - wF - -
FIG. 2. (A) A photograph of the section adjoining the one shown in Fig. 1B, but made with a regular film (Kodak Plus-X ProfessionalFilm). X 16.4. (B) The area enclosed in the oblong in (A) magnified X 6.4 from Fig. 2A (X105 from the original section).
Dow
nloa
ded
by g
uest
on
Mar
ch 2
6, 2
020
Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. USA 71 (1974)
Close examination of unfixed unstained sections reveals thatmyelinated fibers show with great clarity, even under highmagnification. There is no fixative-produced distortion oftissue. Excellent Polaroid photographs can be made of thesefibers. Because it is possible to maximize resolution of photo-graphs by varying exposure time, one is not limited by thevisual parameters of lightly or darkly stained areas.
Finally it is obvious that the slides must be viewed bythe experimenter or neuroanatomist himself. In viewingthe slides the experimenter can decide from section to sectionwhich ones he wants to photograph and which ones he wantsto study under high-power magnification. He need select forthe permanent records only those slides that show the lesionsor structures of interest.
This technique permits the experimenter to obtain in-formation rapidly and allows him to actively check, developand pursue his ideas with study of further sections, differentmagnifications, or additional stains.
Unstained Sections for Study of Myelin Sheaths 601
We are grateful to Prof. George T. Nager, Chairman of theDepartment of Otolaryncology at the Johns Hopkins Hospitalfor use of the cryostat, and to Dr. Richard Lindenberg, Lecturerin Ophthalmology at the Wilmer Clinic-Johns Hopkins Hospi-tal, for suggestions and criticisms. This work was carriedout under grants from National Institute of Mental Health(MH00576-21) and National Science Foundation (GB-23367).
1. Weigert, C. (1884) Fortschr. D. Med. 2, 190-191.2. Stilling, B. (1843) Ueber die Textur und Function der Medulla
Oblongata (Verlag von Ferdinand Enke, Erlangen).3. Frey-Wyssling, A. (1953) in Submicroscopic Morphology of
Protoplasm, (Elsevier Publishing Co., Amsterdam), pp. 54-57.
4. Shanklin, W. M., Issidorides, Ml. & Salam, M. (1962) J.Neuropathol. Exp. Neurol. 21, 284-293.
5. Guzman, C., Alcaraz, M. & Fernandez, A. (1958) Bol. Inst.Estud. Med. Biol. 16, 29-31.
6. Powell, E. (1964) Electroencephalogr. Clin. Neurophysiol. 17,432-434.
7. Hutchinson, R. & Renfrew, J. (1967) J. Exp. Anal. Behav.10, 277-280.
Dow
nloa
ded
by g
uest
on
Mar
ch 2
6, 2
020
