Comparative Analysis using Gabor Wavelets, SVM and PCA Methods for Face Recognition

5
International Journal of Trend in Scientific Research and Development (IJTSRD) Volume 4 Issue 5, July-August 2020 Available Online: www.ijtsrd.com e-ISSN: 2456 – 6470 @ IJTSRD | Unique Paper ID – IJTSRD31897 | Volume – 4 | Issue – 5 | July-August 2020 Page 570 Comparative Analysis using Gabor Wavelets, SVM and PCA Methods for Face Recognition M. Swapna 1 , Dr. Yogesh Kumar Sharma 2 , Dr. BMG Prasad 3 1 Research Scholar, 2 Associate Professor, 3 Professor, 1,2 Department of CSE, JJT University, Jhunjhunu, Rajasthan, India 3 Department of CSE, Holy Mary Institute, Hyderabad, Telangana, India ABSTRACT Face identification is a fundamental report field of example recognition. Today, it has created decent enthusiasm for researchers in these fields, similar to PC vision and example identification. We will affirm that crafted by the face acknowledgment framework is chosen by the best approach to portion factor vector absolutely and to convey them into a class appropriately. A technique perfection to help features acknowledgment pace by intertwining the part and size of Gabor's delineations of the features as a fresh out of a box new portrayal, inside the spot of the arrangement pictured, however, the physicist portrayals were generally utilized, strikingly inside the calculations on worldwide methodologies, the physicist part was never misused, trailed by a face acknowledgment algorithmic principle, upheld the important part investigating approach and Support Vector Machine is utilized as a shiny advanced classifier as design acknowledgment. The presentation for the anticipated algorithmic principle is to try the overall population. It is generally utilized databases of Face Recognition is Grand Challenge v2 face and ORL databases. The test domino effect on databases shows that the blends to the greatness on the piece of physicist choices can do talented outcomes. KEYWORDS: Face Recognition, Gabor, Support Vector Machine, Principal components analysis How to cite this paper: M. Swapna | Dr. Yogesh Kumar Sharma | Dr. BMG Prasad "Comparative Analysis using Gabor Wavelets, SVM and PCA Methods for Face Recognition" Published in International Journal of Trend in Scientific Research and Development (ijtsrd), ISSN: 2456-6470, Volume-4 | Issue-5, August 2020, pp.570-574, URL: www.ijtsrd.com/papers/ijtsrd31897.pdf Copyright © 2020 by author(s) and International Journal of Trend in Scientific Research and Development Journal. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0) (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by /4.0) 1. INTRODUCTION The key distractions in our social orders nowadays are the well being of people, products, or information. Additionally, the great shortcoming of the present implies that biometric verification is evident here: the character of an individual is legitimately connected with what it possesses (an identification, attractive identification, and so on…). Notwithstanding an identification might be purloined, speculated word or broken by savage quality calculations, this winds up in misrepresentation. Face acknowledgment is considered to be a fundamental piece of the bioscience method, and critical in the exploration venture [12]. It's the adaptability to discover a particular personality to be upheld his/her facial qualities. Programmed facade acknowledgment was broadly considered in recent years because of its fundamental job during the scope of use spaces, similar to get to the executives, visual police work [1]. A few accomplishments are prepared since the issues were arranged. Matthew Turk given close ongoing facade acknowledgment framework by presenting scientist features in the facial picture include taking out the results. Wang, C., Lan, L., Zhang, Y., & Gu, M. [13] arranged a decent acknowledgment strategy abuse Principle part Analysis and Support Vector Machine. The Principle of Face acknowledgment abuse physicist channels was presented by Z Yankun et al. [14], and in the blink of an eye demonstrated to be powerful implies that in human outward appearance extraction. LeCun [11] arranged a face acknowledgment algorithmic program consolidated vector choices comprising of the extent of a physicist, PCA, and grouping SVM. All in all, to beat the issues of face acknowledgment, piles of methodologies are anticipated. A tolerable face acknowledgment system should think about delineation furthermore as characterization issues, and a not too bad demonstration system ought to call for the least guide comments. In this proposal, it will in general venture a face acknowledgment framework that blends extent and the piece of physicist channel, Principal components Analysis and Support Vector Machine are classifiers. This paper is sorted out as pursues. In fragment, it will generally put forth a couple of defensive methods for the location of the face. Segment three we will, in general, portray the physicist wave. Segment four shows the physicist face approach. Section5 presents a Support Vector Machine (SVM). The segment about six gives the test consequences of the anticipated method tried on the overall population and for the most part utilized databases of Face Recognition Grand Challenge v2 face and ORL. Ends and points of view works are given in Section 7. IJTSRD31897

description

Face identification is a fundamental report field of example recognition. Today, it has created decent enthusiasm for researchers in these fields, similar to PC vision and example identification. We will affirm that crafted by the face acknowledgment framework is chosen by the best approach to portion factor vector absolutely and to convey them into a class appropriately. A technique perfection to help features acknowledgment pace by intertwining the part and size of Gabors delineations of the features as a fresh out of a box new portrayal, inside the spot of the arrangement pictured, however, the physicist portrayals were generally utilized, strikingly inside the calculations on worldwide methodologies, the physicist part was never misused, trailed by a face acknowledgment algorithmic principle, upheld the important part investigating approach and Support Vector Machine is utilized as a shiny advanced classifier as design acknowledgment. The presentation for the anticipated algorithmic principle is to try the overall population. It is generally utilized databases of Face Recognition is Grand Challenge v2 face and ORL databases. The test domino effect on databases shows that the blends to the greatness on the piece of physicist choices can do talented outcomes. M. Swapna | Dr. Yogesh Kumar Sharma | Dr. BMG Prasad "Comparative Analysis using Gabor Wavelets, SVM and PCA Methods for Face Recognition" Published in International Journal of Trend in Scientific Research and Development (ijtsrd), ISSN: 2456-6470, Volume-4 | Issue-5 , August 2020, URL: https://www.ijtsrd.com/papers/ijtsrd31897.pdf Paper Url :https://www.ijtsrd.com/computer-science/other/31897/comparative-analysis-using-gabor-wavelets-svm-and-pca-methods-for-face-recognition/m-swapna

Transcript of Comparative Analysis using Gabor Wavelets, SVM and PCA Methods for Face Recognition

Page 1: Comparative Analysis using Gabor Wavelets, SVM and PCA Methods for Face Recognition

International Journal of Trend in Scientific Research and Development (IJTSRD)

Volume 4 Issue 5, July-August 2020 Available Online: www.ijtsrd.com e-ISSN: 2456 – 6470

@ IJTSRD | Unique Paper ID – IJTSRD31897 | Volume – 4 | Issue – 5 | July-August 2020 Page 570

Comparative Analysis using Gabor Wavelets, SVM and PCA Methods for Face Recognition

M. Swapna1, Dr. Yogesh Kumar Sharma2, Dr. BMG Prasad3

1Research Scholar, 2Associate Professor, 3Professor, 1,2Department of CSE, JJT University, Jhunjhunu, Rajasthan, India

3Department of CSE, Holy Mary Institute, Hyderabad, Telangana, India

ABSTRACT Face identification is a fundamental report field of example recognition. Today, it has created decent enthusiasm for researchers in these fields, similar to PC vision and example identification. We will affirm that crafted by the face acknowledgment framework is chosen by the best approach to portion factor vector absolutely and to convey them into a class appropriately. A technique perfection to help features acknowledgment pace by intertwining the part and size of Gabor's delineations of the features as a fresh out of a box new portrayal, inside the spot of the arrangement pictured, however, the physicist portrayals were generally utilized, strikingly inside the calculations on worldwide methodologies, the physicist part was never misused, trailed by a face acknowledgment algorithmic principle, upheld the important part investigating approach and Support Vector Machine is utilized as a shiny advanced classifier as design acknowledgment. The presentation for the anticipated algorithmic principle is to try the overall population. It is generally utilized databases of Face Recognition is Grand Challenge v2 face and ORL databases. The test domino effect on databases shows that the blends to the greatness on the piece of physicist choices can do talented outcomes.

KEYWORDS: Face Recognition, Gabor, Support Vector Machine, Principal components analysis

How to cite this paper: M. Swapna | Dr. Yogesh Kumar Sharma | Dr. BMG Prasad "Comparative Analysis using Gabor Wavelets, SVM and PCA Methods for Face Recognition" Published in International Journal of Trend in Scientific Research and Development (ijtsrd), ISSN: 2456-6470, Volume-4 | Issue-5, August 2020, pp.570-574, URL: www.ijtsrd.com/papers/ijtsrd31897.pdf Copyright © 2020 by author(s) and International Journal of Trend in Scientific Research and Development Journal. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0) (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0)

1. INTRODUCTION The key distractions in our social orders nowadays are the well being of people, products, or information. Additionally, the great shortcoming of the present implies that biometric verification is evident here: the character of an individual is legitimately connected with what it possesses (an identification, attractive identification, and so on…). Notwithstanding an identification might be purloined, speculated word or broken by savage quality calculations, this winds up in misrepresentation. Face acknowledgment is considered to be a fundamental piece of the bioscience method, and critical in the exploration venture [12]. It's the adaptability to discover a particular personality to be upheld his/her facial qualities. Programmed facade acknowledgment was broadly considered in recent years because of its fundamental job during the scope of use spaces, similar to get to the executives, visual police work [1]. A few accomplishments are prepared since the issues were arranged. Matthew Turk given close ongoing facade acknowledgment framework by presenting scientist features in the facial picture include taking out the results. Wang, C., Lan, L., Zhang, Y., & Gu, M. [13] arranged a decent acknowledgment strategy abuse Principle part Analysis and Support Vector Machine. The Principle of Face acknowledgment abuse physicist channels

was presented by Z Yankun et al. [14], and in the blink of an eye demonstrated to be powerful implies that in human outward appearance extraction. LeCun [11] arranged a face acknowledgment algorithmic program consolidated vector choices comprising of the extent of a physicist, PCA, and grouping SVM. All in all, to beat the issues of face acknowledgment, piles of methodologies are anticipated. A tolerable face acknowledgment system should think about delineation furthermore as characterization issues, and a not too bad demonstration system ought to call for the least guide comments. In this proposal, it will in general venture a face acknowledgment framework that blends extent and the piece of physicist channel, Principal components Analysis and Support Vector Machine are classifiers. This paper is sorted out as pursues. In fragment, it will generally put forth a couple of defensive methods for the location of the face. Segment three we will, in general, portray the physicist wave. Segment four shows the physicist face approach. Section5 presents a Support Vector Machine (SVM). The segment about six gives the test consequences of the anticipated method tried on the overall population and for the most part utilized databases of Face Recognition Grand Challenge v2 face and ORL. Ends and points of view works are given in Section 7.

IJTSRD31897

Page 2: Comparative Analysis using Gabor Wavelets, SVM and PCA Methods for Face Recognition

International Journal of Trend in Scientific Research and Development (IJTSRD) @ www.ijtsrd.com eISSN: 2456-6470

@ IJTSRD | Unique Paper ID – IJTSRD31897 | Volume – 4 | Issue – 5 | July-August 2020 Page 571

2. Facial Recognition: Recognizing human countenance from a portrait might be a solution drawback in a range of face-related appliance like face pursue, face acknowledgment, face demeanor acknowledgment, and so on the point of face location to be seen and also to verify is there any appearance in an image and assuming if any circumstance of each face appears. we have utilized OpenCV to discover faces in our data Face Recognition Grand Challenge v2 and ORL. OpenCV is an Associate in Nursing open stockpile Computer Vision Library that is implemented in C and C++ and executed under the UNIX working framework, Windows and waterproof shell OS X[10]. The thing indicator of OpenCV has been stomach muscle in it io anticipated by Paul Viola and improved by Rainer Lienhart.

Fig1. Face Identification through Open CV.

3. Gabor Wavelet: The Gabor wavelet, that catches the properties of direction property, spatial restriction, and ideally limited inside the house and recurrence areas have been broadly and with improvement used in face acknowledgment [3]. Daugman spearheaded the exploitation of the second physicist swell outline in pc vision during the 1980s [2]. Gabor wavelets (channels) attributes for recurrence and direction portrayals are an incredible same as those of the human tactile framework. These are discovered worthy of surface delineation and separation. The technique of Gabor Wavelet is fundamentally based on the extraction of choices, which are legitimately starting with the dim level pictures and those are independent ones. It has been widely applied to the division of the surface, also applied for unique finger impression acknowledgment. The arrangements suggested on each degree of this chain brought about an exceedingly significant improvement of the exhibitions contrasted with the typical methodologies. For the same calculations, we tend to want to interlink the area and the extent of Gabor's delineation to the face acknowledgment as a clean image from the plastic new portrayal in the spot of the development picture even though the gabor portrayals were mostly utilized altogether inside the calculations strengthen the global methodologies and the gabor part was rarely abused. Convolving the picture with these 40 Gaborkernelscanthen generates the Gabor features. The information picture might be facial and it is geometrically standardized and whose size is 64*64 pixels. Along these lines, the elements of our vector are (64*64*40*2) overlarge in determining the drawback, which we are intending to plan for a sample.

(a) Representation Magnitude part.

(b) Representation Phase part.

Fig 2 4. Principal Component Analysis: This is also called Karhunen-Love development, which could be an old-style include extraction and information delineation procedure, and this innovation is broadly utilized in the territories of example acknowledgment and workstation vision [3]. Head part examination is anticipated by Turk and Pentland in 1991, which were regularly utilized in separating alternatives for the improvement of measurement. In this proposal, the PCA face acknowledgment algorithmic standard was utilized to remove the eigenvectors from the face pictures. In scientific terms, we will have a general need to search out the chief pieces for the conveyance of appearances or the eigenvectors of the change network arrangement from face pictures, regarding an image vector elevated dimensional house [5]. all through hereunder we will load the general data. We will generally apply a few changes before stacking. For sure, the sign has information accommodating the ubiquity and the exclusively for important parameters of separates. The framework of C is N2 by N2 and determinant to the N2 eigenvectors and Manfred Eigenvalues are rebellious undertaking enemy run of the mill picture sizes. From M eigenvectors exclusively for cash supply and it can be picked. That has absolute best Manfred Eigenvalues. The upper Manfred Eigenvalue and the extra trademark alternatives of face genuine eigenvector depict. Manfred Eigenfaces having low Eigenvalues are regularly overlooked as those were legitimizing exclusively, a small piece of

Page 3: Comparative Analysis using Gabor Wavelets, SVM and PCA Methods for Face Recognition

International Journal of Trend in Scientific Research and Development (IJTSRD) @ www.ijtsrd.com eISSN: 2456-6470

@ IJTSRD | Unique Paper ID – IJTSRD31897 | Volume – 4 | Issue – 5 | July-August 2020 Page 572

trademark choice of the countenances when cash supply Manfred Eigenfaces are resolved and preparation of some portion to the algorithmic guideline was done. 5. Support Vector Machine: Support vector machines are learning machines that arrange data by molding an assortment of help vectors [8]. SVM will give a conventional instrument to fortify outside the hyper plane to the data. Another beneficial thing about SVM is the low expected probability of speculation mistakes [9]. Besides that when the data is mentioned into 2 classifications, associate substance advancing recipe will be utilized whenever required for include distinguishing the proof figuring on the applying [10]. SVM makes a hyper-plane between 2 arrangements of information for grouping in our work. We will differentiate the data into 2 classes. One is

faced has a place with the trained data and another is face doesn't have a place with the preparation database. PC document X that fall one locale of the hyper-plane, (XT•W–b) > zero, are named as +1 and individuals that fall on the contrary space, (XT•W–b) < zero, are named as - 1. We get the direct classifier that isolates the data with a modest speculation mistake. Naturally, this classifier might be a hyperplane that expands the edge blunder, which will be that the aggregate of the separations between the hyperplane and positive and negative models nighest to the current hyperplane. we will, in general, consider the occurrence in (an) and place a few potential direct classifiers will isolate the data, in any case, just 1 boosts the edge appeared in (b). This classifier is named the best isolating hyper-plane.

Fig 3 l,m,n- Arbitrary Hyper Planes; Optimal Hyper Planes.

6. Experiment and Results: Our framework might be an arrangement of distinguishing proof, that the framework should figure the personality of the individual. The framework thinks about the vector normal for the check picture using different models which are contained inside the data (kind of drawback 1: n) misuse of the geometer separation or the SVM classifier. In distinguishing proof mode we will in general refer to an open drawback since it's expected by a being no model inside the data (impostor) and it may request to perceived. In this way, we are doing an investigation over the data of learning for the adequate edge θ which allows the U.S. to spot whether the individual model is in our database or not. To represent the power of framework we will in general utilize 2 data a shading database Face acknowledgment Grand Challenge face as well as a grayscale database ORL face. The Face acknowledgment Grand Challenge comprised of increasingly have some test issues, each challenge drawback comprised of an information set of facial pictures and also an illustrated set of investigations. One of the hindrances in creating improved face acknowledgment is that of the absence of information. The Face Recognition Grand challenge issues exemplify adequate data to beat this obstacle. The arrangement of laid out tests helps analysts and expensive in building progress on meeting the new presentation objectives [6]. The ORL has 10 various photos of each forty unmistakable subjects for a couple of subjects, the photos were taken at totally on various occasions, fluctuated the lighting, outward appearances (open/shut eyes, grinning/not grinning) and facial details (glasses/no glasses)[7].

Fig 4 Face Recognition Grand Challenge.

The plan of an arrangement of example acknowledgment needs a premise of learning and approval to evaluate the presentation of the strategy. The Face Recognition Grand Challenge dispersion comprises of six analyses. In our work, we will in general utilize 2 analyses one and four. In test one, the display comprises of one controlled still picture of somebody and each test comprises of a solitary controlled still picture. Analysis one is that the experimentation [6]. In analyze four, the display comprises one controlled still picture, and in this way, the test set comprises one uncontrolled still picture [6]. Legendary beast diagrams are two-dimensional charts inside the FRR and many rates are planned on the Y-hub and threshold is plotted on the X-pivot. Figure.5 receiver operating characteristic cure of the ORL Database.

Page 4: Comparative Analysis using Gabor Wavelets, SVM and PCA Methods for Face Recognition

International Journal of Trend in Scientific Research and Development (IJTSRD) @ www.ijtsrd.com eISSN: 2456-6470

@ IJTSRD | Unique Paper ID – IJTSRD31897 | Volume – 4 | Issue – 5 | July-August 2020 Page 573

Fig 5 Receiver Operating Characteristic curve of the

ORL Database. We have noted that each error rate on FRR and much are reciprocally and comparative will increase if FRR increases are decreases, thus we tend to opt for a compromise between FRR. We can conclude from this figure that the edge is a pair of 7*1013. Figure .6 below shows the operating characters tic creature curve applied within the ORL database:

Fig 6 ORL database - Reciever Operating Characteristic

Curve From the above figure, we concluded that the threshold is 2.5*1019 The algorithmic program PCA is used in the initial part of the experiment. The input image may be a face image detected with OpenCV and normalized geometrically with the size of the face is 64*64 pixels. Table one provides the equal error rate when it was the victimization of PCA with the expertise 1 and also the experience of the Face Recognition Grand Challenge info. The first protocol P1 evaluates performance comparison of pictures (reference and tests), happiness to the sessions to the mass of a similar semester. The second protocol P2 evaluates performance checking sessions and happiness to image acquisition with 2 consecutive semesters and last one test P3 performance of image reference and test duly separated by a year. Tables I and II represent the same error rates for the Face Recognition Grand Challenge database and ORL database.

Error Rate Exp1 P1 0.27 Exp1 P2 0.54 Exp1 P3 0.42 Exp2 P1 0.82 Exp2 P2 0.91 Exp2 P3 0.9

Table II shows the error rate of PCA for the ORL database.

Error Rate 30 features 0.3

Table III portrays the error rate for Gabor's fusing magnitude phase, Principal Component Analysis, and Euclidian distance for the Face Recognition Grand Challenge database.

Error Rate Exp1 P1 0.18 Exp1 P2 0.34 Exp1 P3 0.21 Exp2 P1 0.28 Exp2 P2 0.5 Exp2 P3 0.6

Table IV represents the error rate for Gabor's and Principal Component Analysis's fusing magnitude phase and Euclidien Distance for the ORL database.

Error rate

30 features 0.005

Tables V and VI will give an equal error rate after using the magnitude and phase of Gabor to extract the characteristic vector. The algorithm of face recognition is Principal Component Analysis and for classification, we use Support Vector Machine. Table V illustrates the error rate for fusing the magnitude phase of Principal Component Analysis, Gabor, and Support Vector Machine for Face Recognition Grand Challenge database.

Error Rate Exp1 P1 0.10 Exp1 P2 0.19 Exp1 P3 0.13 Exp2 P1 0.15 Exp2 P2 0.17 Exp2 P3 0.22

Table VI outlines the error rate for fusing the magnitude phase of PCA, Support Vector Machine, and Gabor for the ORL database.

Error Rate

30 features 0.002

The above tables show that the error rate has been decreased. It remarks that by using the Support Vector Machine it classifies the faces which have an important influence on the performance of the application and also on the improvement of the error rates. The protocol was used for learning and also to the test varies from one section to another. Therefore, it is difficult to compare the error of classification. 7. Conclusion: The algorithmic guideline Principal Component Analysis might be a world method to abuse fundamentally with the grayscale pixels of an image. The effortlessness of actualizing the algorithmic standard diverges from a well-built affectability to change in lighting postures and outward appearance. That is the reason we will in general increment the measure of stances for each individual with all the PCA needs and from the earlier information on the picture. Our methodology comprises consolidating the size and of the piece of the physicist to remove the trademark vector and

Page 5: Comparative Analysis using Gabor Wavelets, SVM and PCA Methods for Face Recognition

International Journal of Trend in Scientific Research and Development (IJTSRD) @ www.ijtsrd.com eISSN: 2456-6470

@ IJTSRD | Unique Paper ID – IJTSRD31897 | Volume – 4 | Issue – 5 | July-August 2020 Page 574

the algorithmic standard PCA for acknowledgment and Support Vector Machine to characterize faces. The rule that we just developed a sub-vector house retentive exclusively the least complex eigenvectors, while retentive a lot of supportive information which makes the PCA Associate in Nursing algorithmic principle is powerful and ordinarily used in diminishing spatial property in any place and it will at that point be accomplished upstream various calculations to upgrade the consequences of our application. To finish up the same we will say that the prominence of individuals will remain in an extravagant drawback and regardless of the present dynamic investigation. There are a few conditions of the genuine problematic method to show and envision the point of confinement of the exhibitions of the present frameworks as far as responsible and constant. As future work, we will, in general, propose the usage of such Associate in Nursing algorithmic guidelines on an objective innovation to gain from the exhibitions gave by this innovation. 8. REFERENCES: [1] Anil K. Jain, Brendan Klare, and Unsang Park, "Face

Recognition: Some Challenges in Forensics", in IEEE International Conference Automatic Face & Gesture Recognition and Workshops (FG 2011), 2011, pp. 726-733.

[2] Zhao Lihong, Yang Caikun, Pan Fen, Wang Jiahe, "Face Recognition Based on Gabor with 2DPCA and PCA", in Control and Decision Conference (CCDC), 2012 24th Chinese, pp. 2632-2635.

[3] Jian Wang, Jian Cheng, "FACE RECOGNITION BASED ON FUSION OF GABOR AND 2DPCA FEATURES", IN International Symposium on Intelligent Signal Processing and Communication Systems, December 2010, pp. 1-4.

[4] Li, Bo, et al. “Depth and surface normal estimation from monocular images using regression on deep features and hierarchical CRFs.”Proceedings of the IEEE

Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition. 2015.

[5] Nicolas Morizet, Thomas EA, Florence Rossant, Frederic Amiel, Amara Amara, Revue des algorithmes PCA, LDA et EBGM utilises en reconnaissance 2D du visage pour la biometrie Institut Superieur d'electronique de Paris (ISEP), Departement d'electronique, 2007.

[6] https://sites.google.com/a/nd.edu/public-cvrl/data-sets

[7] http://www.face-rec.org/databases/

[8] Feng Jiao, Wen Giao, Lijuan Duan, and Guoqin Cui, "Detecting adult image using multiple features", In IEEE conference Infotech and Info-net, 2001, pp.378 - 383.

[9] Joachims T, Making Large-Scale SVM Learning Practical. LS8-Report, University of Dortmund, LS 1998.

[10] Vladimir VN, the Nature of Statistical Learning Theory. Springer, Berlin Heidelberg New York, 1995.

[11] LeCun, Yann, YoshuaBengio, and Geoffrey Hinton. "Deep learning." nature 521.7553 (2015): 436.

[12] Jiarui Zhou, Zhen Ji, Linlin Shen, Zexuan Zhu, and Siping Chen, "PSO Based Memetic Algorithm for Face Recognition Gabor Filters Selection", IEEE Conference Memetic Computing (MC), 2011, pp.1 - 6.

[13] Wang, C., Lan, L., Zhang, Y., & Gu, M. “Face Recognition Based on Principle Component Analysis and Support Vector Machine.” 2011 3rd International Workshop on Intelligent Systems and Applications. DOI:10.1109/isa.2011.5873309.

[14] Z Yankun, L Chongqing, Martin Lades-Networks for Signal Processing, 2002 - ieeexplore.ieee.org “Face recognition using kernel principal component analysis and genetic algorithms”.