Committee on the Internal Market and Consumer Protection Lopez... · 2018. 11. 5. · 86 Jasenko...
Transcript of Committee on the Internal Market and Consumer Protection Lopez... · 2018. 11. 5. · 86 Jasenko...
1/20
Committee on the Internal Market and Consumer Protection - Secretariat -
Version 3
30/10/2018
PC/ic
Vu:
FINAL VOTING LIST
on the Draft Opinion
on the proposal for a regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council establishing the European
Defence Fund
2018/0254(COD)
Rapporteur: Antonio López-Istúriz White
Abbreviations:
CA Compromise amendment
OA Oral amendment
cp Corresponding part
WD Withdrawn
2/20
Concerned
text
AM Author Rap
p.
Posi
tion
Remark Result
of the
vote
Note: The adopted text may be subject after the vote to technical adaptations to ensure coherence
– 36 Mylène Troszczynski
_
Rejection of the proposal
Identical, vote together
Adoption => all other AMs
fall, go to final vote
37 Martin Schirdewan,
Sabine Lösing, Dennis
de Jong
Article 5 CA
3
Rapporteur, EPP,
S&D, ECR, ALDE
+
Adoption CA 3 => AMs 106,
107, 38 and 81 fall
Go to AM 86
Title 0 38 Richard Sulík _ Falls if CA 3 is adopted
Articles
Article 2 –
paragraph 1 –
point 5
86 Jasenko Selimovic
+
(Note: If AM 86 adopted, the word
“undertaking” shall be replaced with
the word “entity” for consistency
reasons)
Article 3 CA
1
Rapporteur, EPP,
S&D, ECR, ALDE
+
Adoption CA 1 => AMs 87 to
92 and 12 fall
Go to AM 94
Article 3 –
paragraph 1
87 Edward Czesak + Falls if CA 1 is adopted
88 Maria Grapini
+
Falls if CA 1 is adopted
Compatible with AM 87, vote
to add “through research”
Article 3 –
paragraph 2 –
point a
89 Igor Šoltes _ Falls if CA 1 is adopted
90 Maria Grapini +
Falls if CA 1 or AM 98 is
adopted
91 Virginie Rozière +
Falls if CA 1 or AM 98 is
adopted
3/20
Compatible with AM 90, vote
to add “European”
Article 3 –
paragraph 2 –
point b
92 Igor Šoltes _ Falls if CA 1 is adopted
12 Antonio López-Istúriz
White +
Falls if CA 1 or AM 92 is
adopted
Article 4 –
paragraph 1
94 Igor Šoltes _
93 Virginie Rozière _ Falls if AM 94 is adopted
Article 4 –
paragraph 2 –
point a
96 Igor Šoltes _
95 Virginie Rozière _
Falls if AM 96 is adopted
Article 4 –
paragraph 2 –
point b
98 Igor Šoltes _
97 Virginie Rozière _
Falls if AM 98 is adopted
Article 4,
paragraphs 3,
4, 4a, 5
CA
2
Rapporteur, EPP,
S&D, ECR, ALDE
+
Adoption CA 2 => AMs 13, 99
to 105, 14 and 178 fall
Go to CA 4
Article 4 –
paragraph 3
99 Igor Šoltes
_
Falls if CA 2 is adopted
DELETION
13 Antonio López-Istúriz
White +
Falls if CA 2 or AM 99 is
adopted
100 Virginie Rozière,
Nicola Danti _
Falls if CA 2, AM 99 or 13 is
adopted
Article 4 –
paragraph 4
101 Igor Šoltes
_
Falls if CA 2 is adopted
DELETION
14 Antonio López-Istúriz
White +
Falls if CA 2 or AM 101 is
adopted
4/20
102 Maria Grapini _
Falls if CA 2, AM 101 or 14 is
adopted
Article 4 –
paragraph 4 a
(new)
103 Jasenko Selimovic
_
Falls if CA 2 is adopted
Article 4 –
paragraph 5
104 Edward Czesak
_
Falls if CA 2 is adopted
DELETION
Identical, vote together
105 Igor Šoltes
Article 5 –
paragraph 1
106 Catherine Stihler + Falls if CA 3 is adopted
107 Richard Sulík _ Falls if CA 3 is adopted
Article 7 CA
4
Rapporteur, EPP,
S&D, ECR, ALDE,
Greens/EFA
+
Adoption CA 4 => AMs 15,
16, 108 to 117, 120 and 85 fall
Go to AM 118
Article 7 –
paragraph 1
108 Virginie Rozière _
Falls if CA 4 is adopted
Article 7 –
paragraph 2
109 Igor Šoltes _ Falls if CA 4 is adopted
110 Virginie Rozière +
Falls if CA 4 or AM 109 is
adopted
Article 7 –
paragraph 3 a
(new)
111 Catherine Stihler
+
Falls if CA 4 is adopted
Adoption => AM 85 deemed
adopted
Article 7 –
paragraph 4
15 Antonio López-Istúriz
White +
Falls if CA 4 is adopted
DELETION
112 Virginie Rozière,
Nicola Danti +
Falls if CA 4 or AM 15 is
adopted
Article 7 –
paragraph 5
113 Virginie Rozière,
Nicola Danti +
Falls if CA 4 is adopted
5/20
16 Antonio López-Istúriz
White +
Falls if CA 4 or AM 113 is
adopted
115 Jasenko Selimovic,
Richard Sulík +
Falls if CA 4, AM 113 or 16 is
adopted
114 Jiří Pospíšil +
Falls if CA 4, AM 113, 16 or
115 is adopted
116 Maria Grapini +
Falls if CA 4, AM 113, 16, 115
or 114 is adopted
117 Edward Czesak +
Falls if CA 4, AM 113, 16,
115, 114 or 116 is adopted
Article 8 –
paragraph 2
118 Virginie Rozière +
Article 9 119 Igor Šoltes _
Article 10 –
paragraph 1
120 Virginie Rozière +
Falls if CA 4 is adopted
Article 10 CA
5
Rapporteur, EPP,
S&D, ECR, ALDE
+
Adoption CA 5 => AMs 17 to
21, 121 to 130, 132 to 139, 84
and 60 fall
Go to AM 131
Article 10 –
paragraph 1
121 Lara Comi
+
Falls if CA 5 or AM 120 is
adopted
Adoption => AM 124, 134, 60
and 62 deemed adopted
Article 10 –
paragraph 1 a
(new)
122 Lara Comi
+
Falls if CA 5 is adopted
Adoption => AM 127 deemed
adopted
Article 10 –
paragraph 2 –
introductory
part
124 Lara Comi
+
Falls if CA 5 is adopted
Do not vote
Adopted/rejected with AM 121
---
6/20
17 Antonio López-Istúriz
White +
Falls if CA 5 or AM 124 is
adopted
123 Edward Czesak
_
Falls if CA 5 or AM 124 is
adopted
Compatible with AM 17, vote
to delete “if this is necessary...
of the action”
125 Catherine Stihler
+
Falls if CA 5 or AM 124 is
adopted
Compatible with AM 17 and
123, vote to change “may” into
“shall”
Article 10 –
paragraph 2 –
point a
127 Lara Comi
+
Falls if CA 5 is adopted
Do not vote
Adopted/rejected with AM 122
---
126 Maria Grapini + Falls if CA 5 or AM 127 is
adopted
128 Jasenko Selimovic,
Richard Sulík _
Falls if CA 5, AM 127 or 126
is adopted
Article 10 –
paragraph 2 –
point b
129 Lara Comi
+
Falls if CA 5 is adopted
Article 10 –
paragraph 2 –
point c
130 Lara Comi
+
Falls if CA 5 is adopted
Article 10 –
paragraph 2 –
point c a (new)
131 Virginie Rozière
+
Put to vote: If CA 5 is
adopted, vote to add “(ca) the
non-associated third country...
European entity”
7/20
Article 10 –
paragraph 2 –
point c a (new)
132 Jasenko Selimovic,
Richard Sulík +
Falls if CA 5 is adopted
Article 10 –
paragraph 3
134 Lara Comi
+
Falls if CA 5 is adopted
Do not vote
Adopted/rejected with AM 121
---
18 Antonio López-Istúriz
White +
Falls if CA 5 or AM 134 is
adopted
133 Jasenko Selimovic,
Richard Sulík
+
Falls if CA 5 or AM 134 is
adopted
Compatible with AM 18, vote
to add “exclusively”
Article 10 –
paragraph 4
19 Antonio López-Istúriz
White +
Falls if CA 5 is adopted
135 Virginie Rozière,
Nicola Danti
+
Falls if CA 5, AM 19 or 122 is
adopted
Adoption => AM 84 deemed
adopted
Article 10 –
paragraph 4 a
(new)
136 Jasenko Selimovic,
Richard Sulík +
Falls if CA 5 is adopted
Article 10 –
paragraph 5
20 Antonio López-Istúriz
White +
Falls if CA 5 is adopted
Article 10 –
paragraph 5 a
(new)
21 Antonio López-Istúriz
White +
Falls if CA 5 is adopted
Article 10 –
paragraph 8
137 Maria Grapini +
Falls if CA 5 is adopted
138 Catherine Stihler + Falls if CA 5 is adopted
8/20
Article 10 –
paragraph 9
139 Maria Grapini _
Falls if CA 5 is adopted
Article 11,
paragraphs 1,
2, 3, 4, 5, 6
CA
6
Rapporteur, EPP,
S&D, ECR, ALDE
+
Adoption CA 6 => AMs 22,
140 to 143 and 145 to 153 fall
Go to CA 8
Article 11 –
paragraph 1 a
(new)
140 Igor Šoltes
_
Falls if CA 6 is adopted
Article 11 –
paragraph 3 –
point a
141 Maria Grapini
+
Falls if CA 6 is adopted
Article 11 –
paragraph 3 –
point h
142 Maria Grapini
+
Falls if CA 6 is adopted
Article 11 –
paragraph 3 –
point i
143 Virginie Rozière
+
Falls if CA 6 is adopted
Article 14 CA
8
Rapporteur, EPP,
S&D, ECR, ALDE
+
Adoption CA 8 => AMs 144,
25 to 28, 167 to 170 and 70 fall
Go to AM 154
Article 11 –
paragraph 3 –
point j
144 Maria Grapini
+
Falls if CA 8 is adopted
Article 11 –
paragraph 4
22 Antonio López-Istúriz
White +
Falls if CA 6 is adopted
145 Igor Šoltes _ Falls if CA 6 or 22 is adopted
146 Edward Czesak +
Falls if CA 6, 22 or 145 is
adopted
150 Richard Sulík,
Jasenko Selimovic _
Falls if CA 6, 22, 145 or 146 is
adopted
9/20
147 Lara Comi
+
Fall if CA 6, 22, 145, 146, or
150 is adopted
148 Nicola Danti
149 Virginie Rozière,
Nicola Danti
Article 11 –
paragraph 5
151 Nicola Danti
+
Fall if CA 6 is adopted
DELETION
Identical, vote together
152 Lara Comi
153 Igor Šoltes _
Falls if CA 6 or 151/152 is
adopted
Article 11 –
paragraph 6 a
(new)
154 Igor Šoltes
_
Article 11 –
paragraph 6 a
(new)
155 Virginie Rozière,
Nicola Danti _
Article 11 –
paragraph 6 b
(new)
156 Igor Šoltes
_
Article 12 –
paragraph 1
157 Igor Šoltes _
Article 12 –
paragraph 3
158 Philippe Juvin +
Article 13 CA
7
Rapporteur, EPP,
S&D, ECR, ALDE
+
Adoption CA 7 => AMs 23, 24
and 159 to 166 fall
Go to AM 171
Article 13 –
paragraph 1 –
point c
23 Antonio López-Istúriz
White +
Falls if CA 7 is adopted
159 Virginie Rozière,
Nicola Danti +
Falls if CA 7 or AM 23 is
adopted
10/20
Article 13 –
paragraph 1 –
point c a (new)
160 Virginie Rozière
+
Falls if CA 7 is adopted
Article 13 –
paragraph 1 –
point d
161 Edward Czesak
+
Falls if CA 7 is adopted
Article 13 –
paragraph 1 –
point e
162 Edward Czesak
+
Falls if CA 7 is adopted
Article 13 –
paragraph 1 –
point e a (new)
163 Catherine Stihler
+
Falls if CA 7 is adopted
Article 13 –
paragraph 1 –
point f a (new)
164 Jasenko Selimovic
_
Falls if CA 7 is adopted
Article 13 –
paragraph 1 –
point f a (new)
165 Catherine Stihler
+
Falls if CA 7 is adopted
Article 13 –
paragraph 1 –
point f a (new)
166 Maria Grapini
_
Falls if CA 7 is adopted
Article 13 –
paragraph 1 –
point f a (new)
24 Antonio López-Istúriz
White +
Falls if CA 7 is adopted
Article 14 –
paragraph 1
25 Antonio López-Istúriz
White +
Falls if CA 8 is adopted
Article 14 –
paragraph 2
26 Antonio López-Istúriz
White +
Falls if CA 8 is adopted
11/20
Article 14 –
paragraph 2 –
point b
167 Lara Comi
+
Falls if CA 8 is adopted
Article 14 –
paragraph 3 –
introductory
part
27 Antonio López-Istúriz
White +
Falls if CA 8 is adopted
Article 14 –
paragraph 3 –
point b
168 Edward Czesak
_
Falls if CA 8 is adopted
Article 14 –
paragraph 3 –
point c
169 Maria Grapini _ Falls if CA 8 is adopted
170 Edward Czesak
_
Falls if CA 8 or AM 169 is
adopted
Adoption => AM 71 deemed
adopted
Article 14 –
paragraph 3 –
point d
28 Antonio López-Istúriz
White +
Falls if CA 8 is adopted
Article 16 –
paragraph 1
171 Lara Comi _
Adoption => AM 172 deemed
adopted
29 Antonio López-Istúriz
White +
Falls if AM 171 is adopted
Article 16 –
paragraph 2
172 Lara Comi
--- Do not vote
Adopted/rejected with AM 171
---
30 Antonio López-Istúriz
White +
Falls if AM 172 is adopted
Article 18 –
paragraph 1
31 Antonio López-Istúriz
White +
Vote as a block with AMs 32,
33 and 34
12/20
Article 18 –
paragraph 2 –
point a a (new)
32 Antonio López-Istúriz
White ---
Do not vote
Adopted/rejected with AM 31
---
Article 18 –
paragraph 2 –
point b
33 Antonio López-Istúriz
White ---
Do not vote
Adopted/rejected with AM 31
---
Article 18 –
paragraph 2 –
point c
34 Antonio López-Istúriz
White ---
Do not vote
Adopted/rejected with AM 31
---
Article 22 –
paragraph 3
35 Antonio López-Istúriz
White +
Article 24 –
paragraph 1 –
point a
173 Jiří Pospíšil
+
Article 25 –
paragraph 2
174 Catherine Stihler _
Falls if AM 135 is adopted
Article 25 –
paragraph 3
175 Igor Šoltes _
Article 25 –
paragraph 3 a
(new)
176 Philippe Juvin
+
Article 27 –
paragraph 1 a
(new)
177 Jasenko Selimovic,
Dita Charanzová,
Richard Sulík
+
Adoption => AM 75 cp1
deemed adopted
Article 27 –
paragraph 1 b
(new)
178 Jasenko Selimovic,
Richard Sulík +
Falls if CA 2 is adopted
Article 27 –
paragraph 2
179 Igor Šoltes
_
Falls if AM 177 is adopted
Vote as a block with AMs 199
and 200
13/20
Article 27 –
paragraph 2 a
(new)
180 Philippe Juvin
+
Article 27 –
paragraph 2 b
(new)
181 Philippe Juvin
+
Falls if AM 177 or 179 is
adopted
Article 28 –
paragraph 1
183 Igor Šoltes _
182 Catherine Stihler
+
Compatible with AM 183, vote
to add “The European... the
committee.”
Article 28 –
paragraph 1 a
(new)
184 Igor Šoltes
_
Article 29 CA
9
Rapporteur, EPP,
S&D, ALDE,
Greens/EFA
+
Adoption CA 9 => AMs 185 to
194 fall
Go to AM 195
Article 29 –
paragraph 2
187 Virginie Rozière + Falls if CA 9 is adopted
189 Igor Šoltes +
Falls if CA 9 or AM 187 is
adopted
186 Catherine Stihler +
Falls if CA 9, AM 187 or 189
is adopted
185 Edward Czesak
+
Falls if CA 9, AM 187 or 189
is adopted
Compatible with AM 186, vote
to change “Union’s citizens
identified” into “ EU... as
possible”
188 Jasenko Selimovic,
Dita Charanzová,
Richard Sulík
+
Falls if CA 9, AM 187 or 189
is adopted
14/20
Compatible with AMs 186 and
185 vote to add “open and
transparent”
Article 29 –
paragraph 2 a
(new)
190 Jasenko Selimovic,
Richard Sulík +
Falls if CA 9 is adopted
Article 29 –
paragraph 2 b
(new)
191 Jasenko Selimovic,
Richard Sulík +
Falls if CA 9 or AM 185 is
adopted
Article 29 –
paragraph 3
192 Igor Šoltes
_
DELETION
Falls if CA 9 is adopted
Article 29 –
paragraph 4
193 Igor Šoltes +
Falls if CA 9 is adopted
Article 29 –
paragraph 5
194 Igor Šoltes _
Falls if CA 9 is adopted
Article 32 –
paragraph 2
195 Jasenko Selimovic _
Article 32 –
paragraph 4
196 Jasenko Selimovic,
Dita Charanzová,
Richard Sulík
+
Article 33 –
paragraph 1
197 Richard Sulík,
Jasenko Selimovic +
Article 34 –
paragraph 1 a
(new)
198 Catherine Stihler
+
Article 36 –
paragraph 1
199 Igor Šoltes
--- Do not vote
Adopted/rejected with AM 179
---
Article 36 –
paragraph 5
200 Igor Šoltes
--- Do not vote
Adopted/rejected with AM 179
---
15/20
Recitals
Recital -1
(new)
39 Jasenko Selimovic,
Dita Charanzová +
Recital 1 CA
10
Rapporteur, EPP,
S&D, ECR, ALDE
+
Adoption CA 10 => AMs 1
and 40 to 42 fall
Go to AM 43
Recital 1 40 Jasenko Selimovic,
Richard Sulík +
Falls if CA 10 is adopted
41 Richard Sulík,
Jasenko Selimovic +
Falls if CA 10 or AM 40 is
adopted
1 Antonio López-Istúriz
White +
Falls if CA 10 is adopted
Compatible with AMs 40 and
41, vote as an addition
42 Edward Czesak
+
Falls if CA 10 is adopted
Compatible with all above
AMs, vote to add “throughout
the Union”
Recital 1 a
(new)
43 Jasenko Selimovic,
Dita Charanzová,
Richard Sulík
+
Recital 1 b
(new)
44 Jasenko Selimovic,
Dita Charanzová,
Richard Sulík
+
Recital 1 c
(new)
45 Jasenko Selimovic,
Richard Sulík +
Recital 1 d
(new)
46 Jasenko Selimovic,
Dita Charanzová +
Recital 2 CA
11
Rapporteur, EPP,
S&D, ECR, ALDE
+
Adoption CA 11 => AMs 2
and 47 fall
Go to CA 12
16/20
Recital 2 2 Antonio López-Istúriz
White +
Falls if CA 11 is adopted
47 Virginie Rozière + Falls if CA 11 or 2 is adopted
Recital 3 CA
12
Rapporteur, EPP,
S&D, ECR, ALDE
+
Adoption CA 12 => AMs 3
and 48 to 53 fall
Go to AM 53
Recital 3 3 Antonio López-Istúriz
White +
Falls if CA 12 is adopted
48 Edward Czesak +
Falls if CA 12 or AM 3 is
adopted
49 Jasenko Selimovic,
Dita Charanzová _
Falls if CA 12 or AM 3 or 48 is
adopted
50 Richard Sulík,
Jasenko Selimovic +
Falls if CA 12 or AM 3, 48 or
49 is adopted
51 Virginie Rozière,
Nicola Danti +
Falls if CA 12 or AM 3, 48, 49
or 50 is adopted
52 Maria Grapini +
Falls if CA 12 or AM 3, 48, 49,
50 or 51 is adopted
Recital 3 a
(new)
53 Jasenko Selimovic,
Dita Charanzová +
Recital 8 4 Antonio López-Istúriz
White +
54 Virginie Rozière,
Nicola Danti +
Falls if AM 4 is adopted
55 Richard Sulík,
Jasenko Selimovic +
Compatible with AM 54 or 4,
vote to changes “and” into “,
unnecessary... capabilities”
Recital 9 56 Richard Sulík _
17/20
57 Maria Grapini +
Recital 10 CA
13
Rapporteur, EPP,
S&D, ECR, ALDE
+
Adoption CA 13 => AMs 5, 58
and 59 fall
Go to AM 61
Recital 10 58 Edward Czesak
---
Falls if CA 13 is adopted
Do not vote
Adopted/rejected with AM 146
---
59 Richard Sulík,
Jasenko Selimovic ---
Falls if CA 13 is adopted
Do not vote
Adopted/rejected with AM 150
---
5 Antonio López-Istúriz
White ---
Falls if CA 13 is adopted
Do not vote
Adopted/rejected with AM 22
---
Recital 12 60 Lara Comi
---
Falls if CA 5 is adopted
Do not vote
Adopted/rejected with AM 121
---
61 Maria Grapini _ Falls if AM 60 is adopted
6 Antonio López-Istúriz
White +
Compatible with AM 60 and
61, vote to add “as a rule”
Recital 13 CA
14
Rapporteur, EPP,
S&D, ECR, ALDE
+
Adoption CA 14 => AMs 62 to
66 and 7 fall
Go to AM 67
Recital 13
62 Lara Comi
---
Falls if CA 5 or CA 14 is
adopted
Do not vote
Adopted/rejected with AM 121
---
63 Jasenko Selimovic,
Dita Charanzová +
Falls if CA 14 or AM 62 is
adopted
18/20
64 Virginie Rozière
+
Falls if CA 14 is adopted
Compatible with all above
AMs, vote as an addition
65 Maria Grapini
_
Falls if CA 14 is adopted
Compatible with all above
AMs, vote as an addition
66 Edward Czesak
_
Falls if CA 14 or AMs 62, 63,
64 or 65 is adopted
7 Antonio López-Istúriz
White +
Falls if CA 14 is adopted
Compatible with all above
AMs, vote as an addition
Recital 13 a
(new)
67 Virginie Rozière,
Nicola Danti _
Recital 13 a
(new)
68 Catherine Stihler _
Falls if AM 67 is adopted
Recital 15 69 Maria Grapini _
Recital 17 8 Antonio López-Istúriz
White +
Recital 18 70 Edward Czesak _ Falls if CA 8 is adopted
Recital 21 a
(new)
71 Edward Czesak
---
Falls if CA 8 is adopted
Do not vote
Adopted/rejected with AM 170
---
Recital 22 9 Antonio López-Istúriz
White +
Recital 23 72 Maria Grapini +
73 Richard Sulík,
Jasenko Selimovic _
Compatible with AM 72, vote
as an addition
Recital 24 74 Maria Grapini _
19/20
Recital 31 75
cp1
Jasenko Selimovic,
Dita Charanzová
---
Do not vote
Adopted/rejected with AM 177
Cp1 concerns the addition
“The work programme shall
set... in the Fund.”
---
Recital 33 CA
15
Rapporteur, EPP,
S&D, ECR, ALDE
+
Adoption CA 15 => AMs 75
cp2, 10 and 76 to 78 fall
Go to AM 79
75
cp2
Jasenko Selimovic,
Dita Charanzová +
Falls if CA 15 is adopted
Cp2 concerns the rest of the
AM 75
Recital 33 76 Jasenko Selimovic
---
Falls if CA 15 is adopted
Do not vote
Adopted/rejected with AM 103
---
10 Antonio López-Istúriz
White +
Falls if CA 15 or AM 76 is
adopted
78 Virginie Rozière,
Nicola Danti +
Falls if CA 15 or AM 76 or 10
is adopted
77 Maria Grapini
+
Falls if CA 15 or AM 76, 10 or
78 is adopted
Recital 34 79 Maria Grapini +
Recital 38 a
(new)
80 Richard Sulík,
Jasenko Selimovic +
Recital 39 81 Richard Sulík,
Jasenko Selimovic _
Falls if CA 3 is adopted
20/20
Recital 40 82 Edward Czesak _
Recital 41 83 Catherine Stihler + Compatible with CA 6 or CA 7
Recital 42 84 Virginie Rozière,
Nicola Danti ---
Falls if CA 5 is adopted
Do not vote
Adopted/rejected with AM 135
---
Recital 43 11 Antonio López-Istúriz
White +
Recital 43 a
(new)
85 Catherine Stihler
---
Falls if CA 4 is adopted
Do not vote
Adopted/rejected with AM 111
---
VOTE on the DRAFT OPINION
as amended
for against abstentions