Commentary: Cash Transfers to Indonesia's Poor Don't ... · Indonesia for St. Moritz Makassar...
5
11/2/15 12:43 PM Commentary: Cash Transfers to Indonesia's Poor Don't Discourage Work | Jakarta Globe Page 1 of 5 http://jakartaglobe.beritasatu.com/opinion/commentary-cash-transfers-indonesias-poor-dont-discourage-work/ Top # Jakarta MOST POPUL Around the world, there are often contentious debates on whether or not to provide social safety net programs to the poor. Critics often paint a portrait of the poor as lazy, refusing to work in order to receive government handouts, wasting valuable tax-payer funds on for example alcohol and cigarettes, rather than feeding and clothing children. The debate in Indonesia over cash transfers mirrors the worldwide debate. Impassioned arguments come from both sides about whether social protection programs, from cash transfers like the temporary direct aid program (BLSM) to conditional transfers like 'Family of Hope' (PKH) -- actually help the poor or simply reduce their incentive to work. Putting aside the political rhetoric and ideology, what do we actually know about the impact of cash transfer programs on work? In 2013 we founded the Abdul Latif Jameel Poverty Action Lab’s Southeast Asia (J-PAL SEA) office – based in Jakarta at the University of Indonesia (UI) – to help answer critical policy questions through rigorous randomized evaluations, which are widely considered the “gold standard” for identifying the impact of a program or policy, and to make the results available to and usable by policymakers in Indonesia and throughout the region. This has helped Indonesian policymakers get reliable evidence on the effect of many programs, from how best to identify poor households for government assistance to how to reduce corruption in village road projects. To answer the question regarding the impact of cash transfer programs, we, along with our colleagues Professor Abhijit Banerjee and Gabriel Kreindler, went back and collected datasets from seven randomized evaluations of government-run, cash transfer programs from six countries around the world. The studies include Indonesia’s PKH and the Philippines’s Pantawid Pamilyang Pilipino Program (PPPP). Some of the programs provide direct cash transfers, while others — including PKH — provide cash transfers conditional on recipients engaging in good behaviors (e.g. sending children to school, getting kids vaccinated). All of these programs are targeted to poor households. Our analysis shows that cash transfer programs aimed at the poor help reduce poverty and improve social outcomes, without providing disincentives to work. As such, these programs should be seen as an important policy tool to help alleviate poverty and inequality in Indonesia. Importantly, the reason J-PAL SEA and our analysis focus on randomized evaluations is that other methods that compare #ThePerspect #Haze #JakartaFashion #Indonesianfashio #JokoWidod Commentary: Cash Transfers to Indonesia's Commentary: Cash Transfers to Indonesia's Commentary: Cash Transfers to Indonesia's Commentary: Cash Transfers to Indonesia's Poor Don't Discourage Work Poor Don't Discourage Work Poor Don't Discourage Work Poor Don't Discourage Work i Search... HOME JG.TV NEWS BUSINESS INTERNATIONAL SPORTS LIFE & STYLE OPINION
Transcript of Commentary: Cash Transfers to Indonesia's Poor Don't ... · Indonesia for St. Moritz Makassar...
11/2/15 12:43 PMCommentary: Cash Transfers to Indonesia's Poor Don't Discourage Work | Jakarta Globe
Page 1 of 5http://jakartaglobe.beritasatu.com/opinion/commentary-cash-transfers-indonesias-poor-dont-discourage-work/
Top # Jakarta Globe
MOST POPULAR
Around the world, there are often contentious debates on whether or not to provide social safety net programs to the poor.Critics often paint a portrait of the poor as lazy, refusing to work in order to receive government handouts, wasting valuabletax-payer funds on for example alcohol and cigarettes, rather than feeding and clothing children.
The debate in Indonesia over cash transfers mirrors the worldwide debate. Impassioned arguments come from both sidesabout whether social protection programs, from cash transfers like the temporary direct aid program (BLSM) to conditionaltransfers like 'Family of Hope' (PKH) -- actually help the poor or simply reduce their incentive to work. Putting aside thepolitical rhetoric and ideology, what do we actually know about the impact of cash transfer programs on work?
In 2013 we founded the Abdul Latif Jameel Poverty Action Lab’s Southeast Asia (J-PAL SEA) office – based in Jakarta atthe University of Indonesia (UI) – to help answer critical policy questions through rigorous randomized evaluations, whichare widely considered the “gold standard” for identifying the impact of a program or policy, and to make the resultsavailable to and usable by policymakers in Indonesia and throughout the region. This has helped Indonesian policymakersget reliable evidence on the effect of many programs, from how best to identify poor households for governmentassistance to how to reduce corruption in village road projects.
To answer the question regarding the impact of cash transfer programs, we, along with our colleagues Professor AbhijitBanerjee and Gabriel Kreindler, went back and collected datasets from seven randomized evaluations of government-run,cash transfer programs from six countries around the world. The studies include Indonesia’s PKH and the Philippines’sPantawid Pamilyang Pilipino Program (PPPP). Some of the programs provide direct cash transfers, while others —including PKH — provide cash transfers conditional on recipients engaging in good behaviors (e.g. sending children toschool, getting kids vaccinated). All of these programs are targeted to poor households.
Our analysis shows that cash transfer programs aimed at the poor help reduce poverty and improve social outcomes,without providing disincentives to work. As such, these programs should be seen as an important policy tool to helpalleviate poverty and inequality in Indonesia.
Importantly, the reason J-PAL SEA and our analysis focus on randomized evaluations is that other methods that compare
#ThePerspective
#Haze
#JakartaFashionWeek
#Indonesianfashiondes…
#JokoWidodo
Commentary: Cash Transfers to Indonesia'sCommentary: Cash Transfers to Indonesia'sCommentary: Cash Transfers to Indonesia'sCommentary: Cash Transfers to Indonesia'sPoor Don't Discourage WorkPoor Don't Discourage WorkPoor Don't Discourage WorkPoor Don't Discourage Work i
Search...
HOME JG.TV NEWS BUSINESS INTERNATIONAL SPORTS LIFE & STYLE OPINION
11/2/15 12:43 PMCommentary: Cash Transfers to Indonesia's Poor Don't Discourage Work | Jakarta Globe
Page 2 of 5http://jakartaglobe.beritasatu.com/opinion/commentary-cash-transfers-indonesias-poor-dont-discourage-work/
TODAY'S EDITION
the outcomes of a person who receives a program with a person who does not are likely to produce inaccurate measuresof the program’s impact. For example, recipients of a cash transfer program are by nature poorer than non-recipientsbecause these programs target poor households. As such, recipients are very likely to have worse employment outcomesto begin with and thus comparing them to non-recipients will not tell you if the cash transfers actually caused the programrecipient to work less or if this is simply a reflection of the recipient being poorer.
Randomized evaluations overcome the above issue by testing the program in randomly selected areas and not others.This way, the people who receive the transfers are similar in educational and employment background to those who do notreceive it. In the end, if you observe any differences between these two groups of people, you know that it is caused by thecash transfer program and not other factors, such as an initial difference in wealth.
The cash transfer randomized evaluations we reviewed highlight important findings. The first important fact that comes outis that most men who are eligible for the transfer programs are working. In Indonesia, prior to receiving the program, 82percent of men (between the ages of 16 and 65) from households that are eligible for PKH cash transfers engaged insome form of work the week before survey. But, despite working, their family income levels remain below the poverty line.
Further, we find that cash transfers do not discourage people from working — in any of the six countries, includingIndonesia. Though we do not have data on hours worked for Indonesia, we can look at the other country evidence —including the Philippines — for guidance. In none of these countries do government cash transfers reduce the number ofhours a person worked, either for men or women.
A recent World Bank study did a similar review as ours, but focused on whether cash transfers led to increases inspending on “temptation goods.” Again, the data contradicted the often prevailing stereotypes — spending on alcohol andtobacco did not increase as a result of the cash transfer programs.
Cash transfer programs for the poor can provide crucial money to help the poor feed their families, ensure their kids go toschool, and fulfill other basic needs. And they don’t seem to discourage the people from working. They can be animportant part of the anti-poverty policy toolkit for Indonesia.
Rema Hanna is professor of public policy at the Harvard Kennedy School. Benjamin Olken is professor of economics atthe Massachusetts Institute of Technology. Hanna and Olken together direct the Abdul Latif Jameel Poverty Action Lab’sSoutheast Asia (J-PAL SEA) office, based in Jakarta at the University of Indonesia (UI).
development poverty temporary direct aid package (BLSM) cash assistance PKH
RELATED ARTICLES:
Lippo Karawaci Appoints GroheLippo Karawaci Appoints GroheLippo Karawaci Appoints GroheLippo Karawaci Appoints GroheIndonesia for St. MoritzIndonesia for St. MoritzIndonesia for St. MoritzIndonesia for St. MoritzMakassar DevelopmentMakassar DevelopmentMakassar DevelopmentMakassar Development
'Grand Corruption Big Stumbling'Grand Corruption Big Stumbling'Grand Corruption Big Stumbling'Grand Corruption Big StumblingBlock for New DevelopmentBlock for New DevelopmentBlock for New DevelopmentBlock for New DevelopmentGoals'Goals'Goals'Goals'
MORE NEWS
11:59 am Nov,02,201511:59 am Nov,02,2015
Indonesia Foreign TouristIndonesia Foreign TouristArrivals up 9.84 PercentArrivals up 9.84 Percent
6:00 pm Nov,02,20156:00 pm Nov,02,2015
Govt to Announce 6thGovt to Announce 6thStimulus Package onStimulus Package onThursdayThursday
12:00 am Nov,02,201512:00 am Nov,02,2015
The Fastest Way To AcquireThe Fastest Way To Acquirea U.S. Degree Starting herea U.S. Degree Starting herein Indonesiain Indonesia
7:37 pm Nov,02,20157:37 pm Nov,02,2015
Police Step Up Fight AgainstPolice Step Up Fight AgainstHate SpeechHate Speech
12:57 pm Nov,02,201512:57 pm Nov,02,2015
Lawmakers LaunchLawmakers LaunchCorruption-Free 'Zone ofCorruption-Free 'Zone ofIntegrity'Integrity'
4:39 pm Nov,02,20154:39 pm Nov,02,2015
Aust. PM Turnbull Plans FirstAust. PM Turnbull Plans FirstJakarta Visit After Bali 9Jakarta Visit After Bali 9Executions, Felling of AbbottExecutions, Felling of Abbott
12:04 pm Nov,02,201512:04 pm Nov,02,2015
Minister: Jakarta Not TryingMinister: Jakarta Not Tryingto Curb People's Right toto Curb People's Right toProtestProtest
3:12 pm Nov,02,20153:12 pm Nov,02,2015
Over Hundred Semi-Over Hundred Semi-Permanent Shops Razed inPermanent Shops Razed inE. JakartaE. Jakarta
2:08 pm Nov,02,20152:08 pm Nov,02,2015
Democratic Party PoliticianDemocratic Party PoliticianGot $106k Saudi 'Fee',Got $106k Saudi 'Fee',Court Hears in SuryadharmaCourt Hears in SuryadharmaAli Graft CaseAli Graft Case
12:00 am Nov,02,201512:00 am Nov,02,2015
Indonesia To Shape FutureIndonesia To Shape FutureIndonesia To Shape FutureIndonesia To Shape FutureGeneration With InternationalGeneration With InternationalGeneration With InternationalGeneration With InternationalStandard EducationStandard EducationStandard EducationStandard Education
34
23
2
11/2/15 12:43 PMCommentary: Cash Transfers to Indonesia's Poor Don't Discourage Work | Jakarta Globe
Page 3 of 5http://jakartaglobe.beritasatu.com/opinion/commentary-cash-transfers-indonesias-poor-dont-discourage-work/
EDITOR'S CHOICE
SOCIAL MEDIA CORNER
One Year on: How Joko Tamed theOne Year on: How Joko Tamed theOne Year on: How Joko Tamed theOne Year on: How Joko Tamed theOnce-Hostile Red-White CoalitionOnce-Hostile Red-White CoalitionOnce-Hostile Red-White CoalitionOnce-Hostile Red-White Coalition
Erik Meijaard: Indonesia's FireErik Meijaard: Indonesia's FireErik Meijaard: Indonesia's FireErik Meijaard: Indonesia's FireCrisis — The Biggest EnvironmentalCrisis — The Biggest EnvironmentalCrisis — The Biggest EnvironmentalCrisis — The Biggest EnvironmentalCrime of the 21st CenturyCrime of the 21st CenturyCrime of the 21st CenturyCrime of the 21st Century
Prev
Prev
A devastating earthquake struck the Hindu Kush region of north-east Afghanistan just after lunchtime on Oct. 26, rockingcommunities as far away as Tajikistan, Pakistan and even India. A devastating earthquake struck the Hindu Kush region ofnorth-east Afghanistan just after lunchtime on Oct. 26, rocking communities as far away as Tajikistan, Pakistan and evenIndia.
The strong quake, estimated at magnitude 7.5 by the US Geological Survey (USGS), had its origins more than 200kmdeep beneath Earth’s surface, and was felt as strong shaking across a very wide area. Casualties have been reportedfrom across the region, with widespread landslips causing potential further damage to infrastructure.
Show More
afghanistan earthquake Hindu Kush
RELATED ARTICLES:
Taliban Overrun District inTaliban Overrun District inTaliban Overrun District inTaliban Overrun District inQuake-Hit Northern AfghanistanQuake-Hit Northern AfghanistanQuake-Hit Northern AfghanistanQuake-Hit Northern Afghanistan
Rescuers Race to Reach QuakeRescuers Race to Reach QuakeRescuers Race to Reach QuakeRescuers Race to Reach QuakeZones in Afghanistan, PakistanZones in Afghanistan, PakistanZones in Afghanistan, PakistanZones in Afghanistan, Pakistanas Toll Nears 300as Toll Nears 300as Toll Nears 300as Toll Nears 300
Commentary: Earthquake Rocks AfghanistanCommentary: Earthquake Rocks AfghanistanCommentary: Earthquake Rocks AfghanistanCommentary: Earthquake Rocks Afghanistanand Pakistan – An Area Prone to Magnitudeand Pakistan – An Area Prone to Magnitudeand Pakistan – An Area Prone to Magnitudeand Pakistan – An Area Prone to Magnitude7 Quakes7 Quakes7 Quakes7 Quakes i
0
0
0
11/2/15 12:43 PMCommentary: Cash Transfers to Indonesia's Poor Don't Discourage Work | Jakarta Globe
Page 4 of 5http://jakartaglobe.beritasatu.com/opinion/commentary-cash-transfers-indonesias-poor-dont-discourage-work/
OPINION
Simon Redfern
Alice de Jonge
China’s latest five-year plan, the details of which were endorsed at last week’s fifth plenum, aims to double the nation’sGDP and per capita income by 2020 (from 2010 numbers).
The 2020 deadline is important because it is the final year of the 13th five-year plan, the first plan led by Xi Jinping and LiKeqiang. It would allow the Chinese Communist Party to claim a doubling of the country’s economic size in the decadepreceding the 100th anniversary of the Party’s founding in 1921.
Show More
China one child policy Chinese economy Chinese Communist Party China five-year economic plan
RELATED ARTICLES:
China Says One-Child PolicyChina Says One-Child PolicyChina Says One-Child PolicyChina Says One-Child PolicyStays in Effect for NowStays in Effect for NowStays in Effect for NowStays in Effect for Now
China Shares up After One-ChildChina Shares up After One-ChildChina Shares up After One-ChildChina Shares up After One-ChildPolicy Change, Dairy StocksPolicy Change, Dairy StocksPolicy Change, Dairy StocksPolicy Change, Dairy StocksJumpJumpJumpJump
Commentary: Earthquake RocksCommentary: Earthquake RocksCommentary: Earthquake RocksCommentary: Earthquake RocksAfghanistan and Pakistan – An AreaAfghanistan and Pakistan – An AreaAfghanistan and Pakistan – An AreaAfghanistan and Pakistan – An AreaProne to Magnitude 7 QuakesProne to Magnitude 7 QuakesProne to Magnitude 7 QuakesProne to Magnitude 7 Quakes
Commentary: China’s Five YearCommentary: China’s Five YearCommentary: China’s Five YearCommentary: China’s Five YearEconomic Plan Is Rich WithEconomic Plan Is Rich WithEconomic Plan Is Rich WithEconomic Plan Is Rich WithSymbolismSymbolismSymbolismSymbolism
Commentary: China’s Five Year EconomicCommentary: China’s Five Year EconomicCommentary: China’s Five Year EconomicCommentary: China’s Five Year EconomicPlan Is Rich With SymbolismPlan Is Rich With SymbolismPlan Is Rich With SymbolismPlan Is Rich With Symbolism i
0
0
0
11/2/15 12:43 PMCommentary: Cash Transfers to Indonesia's Poor Don't Discourage Work | Jakarta Globe
Page 5 of 5http://jakartaglobe.beritasatu.com/opinion/commentary-cash-transfers-indonesias-poor-dont-discourage-work/
The Link Between Gout andKidney StonesHyperuricemia not only leads to gout,but can also cause kidney stones.
Unique Brain Tumor SymptomsYou Never KnewNot all brain tumors have the samesymptoms, making it difficult to detect.
5 Sweet Potato Recipes forBabiesHere are different ways you can servesweet potatoes to your infant.
Understanding The Colors ofSnotCan the color of your nasal excretiontruly reveal your current health?
Follow 1Health on socialmedia for more updates:
ABOUT US ADVERTISE
CONNECT
APPS
Copyright©2015The Jakarta Globe, All Rights Reserved
Back to Top
