CoM - EPRs Version 3 mark-up changes

Built environment - To -, Lu1 Develop and implementa ~-a~ii~f'lle~;t mea-;u~f;~nstru~ti~n and operation of 1· All protect and enhance Melbourne Metro that aim-tG-has the purpose of minimisingse impacts to the development the character, form I and/or operation of existing land uses, including:

1

anbdlfunctiol n ofdthe I • Limiting the permanent change of use within existing publ ic open space I pu 1c ream an buildings within and • Minimising footprints of construction sites and permanent infrastructure on public land

adjacent to the project 1 • The location and design of all project works to avoid. to the extent practicable, alignment, and I temporary and permanent loss of public open space and be designed to maximise particularly in the the re-instatement potential. vicinity of project surface structures, j • Minimising impacts to existing public open spaces and recreational facilities and the having regard to the users of these facilities, including (but not limited to): JJ Holland Park, University existing and evolving I Square, the Melbourne City Baths, City Square, Federation Square, the Shrine of urban context Remembrance and the Shrine Reserve, Domain Parklands, Edmund Herring Oval,

Fawkner Park Fawkner Park and Fawkner Park Tennis Facility and the Albert Road Reserve.

• Minimising the impacts to existing residential areas by locating new above ground infrastructure, such as electrical substations in appropriate locations considering away frsm adjoining Fesiaential propertiesy and exploring the co-location of rail infrastructure facilities where practicable,

Based on IAC Version 3

I _ I ---------! Constructi J LU001

' on/ I to Operation LU008

land, I

be

Such measures must be developed in consultation with affected land managers for public I I I ~ ·· - -- - ---- ·- ------- -- - - - - --- - --- - -- - - -- ------·-•·--- - - -·. ---;--- --- - ------,

LU2 Development of the project 1s to be generally in accordance with have Fe§ar8 ts the All ! Design · LU002, Agreed with I relevant Open Space Master Plans (including but not limited to, the Domain Parklands, I [Constructi I LU005, QQM 1 •avv ""' r arl\

j Fawkner Park Fawkner Park and University Square Master Plans) 1n des1gn1ng and onl . LU006 ± 13/09/16 ass me constructing above-ground infrastructure for the tunnels OJ,Jerabon I wor mav be

Consultation must occur with land managers and/or agencies responsible for the I implementation of the relevant Open Space Master Plans. I J 1

I ;:ls,;-;efer to t~e ;oll~~ng Environment;;j·p;rfor~~~ce Requirements--;or 'Land Use Planni;g': 81, SC2, SC4, LV1, LV2, SW2---- -- - - - - -_J·-j · - ------ - ----·---------- -- - - -- - -- --- ---~ --· ---· ---------- --------------- -- -- - - - -- ·- --- -------

~

~ 'i'T:fr.T.o:J.~TTT.;-

Business

Social, community, --i- 81 land u e and I busine s: To manage effects on the social

1 fabric f the comm nity in the area of the roject, includi g with regard I NEW to land use changes, --comm nity cohesion, busine s functionality and ac ss to services and fa ilities, especially during the construction phase

Social and Community

SC7

1-Reduce the disrup~ion to bu~nesses from direct acquisition or-te~pora;o~~up~~j~~-;;f land, and work with business and land owners to endeavour to reach agreement on the terms for possession of the land.

Provide acquired businesses with access to a central point of contact and case management approach. with opportunities to seek priority access to other State Government business support and mentoring services

Work with City of Melbourne to identify suitable alternative sites for a visitor information service that meet City of Melbourne's requirements. to mitigate the potential loss of the existing site of the Melbourne Visitor Centre at Federation Square due to construction works. The identification of these alternative sites should also take into account the unique design. location and service delivery requirements of the service.

--------

--------- -- - --In consultation with key stakeholders (including local Councils) and in accordance with the Melbourne Metro Urban Design Strategy, relevant statutory approvals and other relevant requirements~,

a) improve community access to open or recreational space with in the CBD by identifying potential opportunities to return as much land as possible used for construction to permanent public open space at City Square and Federation Square;

Q}_re-establish sites impacted by construction works te at least pre existiRQ ceRditieRs to be generally in accordance with open space master plans, including (but not limited to):

• I • • • • •

Childers Street, Kensington

JJ Holland Park

Royal Parade and Grattan Street, Parkville

City Square

Federation Square

The south western entrance of the proposed CBD South station

• St Kilda Road boulevard I I

L I -• _ Edmund Herring Oval

• Fawkner Park and Fawkner Park Tennis Facility

_l~ F"av~~~ ~v~e~rk Tennis F"acilit~ __ _

2 -

I All

-i

I I I

I

~. - -II -__ _! __ !_._ I I I

: A- 11- ·-

1

1 Desig~/ I SC~1~. Jpoint a)

I Construcli SC033, I ~ombines on I SC035, I sea ....;th

I I SC039, SC7 as SC040, suggested SC041 bv IAC

NewCoM

I paragraph to be added

I I ' NewCoM

EPR to be added

I :

[ _ - -· ---

I Include ~rds I "(including

local 1 councils)" in

1 first sentence.

I Reinstate Fa\Nkner Park, as some

I works may be required .

• South Yarra Siding Reserve

I I

~t~~~~l~ltura~~i~age __ f-- _ ___ _ ___ _ ___ ____ _ _ _ _ _ ___ _ _ _ _ __ -J _ -_!_ ~=--~--[-= = i---_L ~ ~~ CH4 · Prior to construction of main works or shafts that affect heritage structures or places, ' 1 - I Pnor to HH04, J Aareee with 1 §.

l. • Lovers Walk

• The South African Soldiers Wal=-Memorial.

~~ee i:elateG-Environmental Per~r_manc~ ~quir~ment ~~2 an~ LU2.) _

develop ~etail~d ~ethodolog~ 1n a?cordance with Australia ICOMOS Surra Charter and Tunnels / constructio HH17, , G9M =ch'""a"'-"'=-'-= to the sat1sfast1ornn consultation with et-Heritage Victoria-, land owner and local councils 3 _

1 n,_ HH19, I ~ I

or the responsiele a1,Jthority (as applicable) where heritage fabric is required to be Arden , reinstatem HH23, ="-"-="' dismantled stored and reconstructed. station ent at an HH25, '-'-""'-'!!>!.!.!.»'-"

' 1 appropnat HH27, I practitioner. South I dunng or I

station after the

7 _ main Domain ! constructio

Work is to be documented and overseen by an appropriately qualified conservation 6 - CBD i e time l HH31

,__ __ _,. - . -- !-sta_1_1o_n_1 n works _ -------

CH5 Prior to construction of main works or shafts that affect heritage structures or places, develop and implement appropriate protection measures for heritage places and objects including sculptures, memorials, monuments and associated heritage fabric where retained in proximity to works. This is to be done in consultation withto the satisfaction of Heritage Victoria , land owner and local councilsor the responsiele a1,Jthorit-y (as applicable).

All I Prior to HH04, constructio HH05, n HH18, commenci HH25, ng HH26,

HH29,

I I HH31

Agreed with G9M ~

I CH6 In consultation withTo the satisfaction of Heritage Victoria:

• Develop archaeological management plans to manage disturbance of archaeological sites and va lues affected by the project

rP~e-- - - - -i-- H-H-0-1.-i'~~a-re_e_e ,,_4j;; -constructio HH02 I ~ I v"~' l"v H~v

1 n I~

All

• Undertake investigation in accordance with the Guidelines for Investigating Historical Archaeological Artefacts and Sites, Heritage Victoria 2014 (as amended or updated) and to the satisfaction of the Executive Director, Heritage Victoria.

~ I Develop and implement a protocol for managing previously unidentified historical archaeological sites discovered during project works.

-CH? ---l -,:;ti;;~at~~~ of H-;;a!;Je Visteria an~-th~ ;;;~iel; a~;;.-dQevelop and I Al l implement a heritage interpretation strategy as part of detailed design as a whole which

I seeks to explore historical and Aboriginal cu ltural heritage themes. This must include (but not be limited to) the exploration of opportunities for interpretation at Arden station

_ ~ __ _ J (r~fer~n~n_g_ t!ie USE!_~- thi~ l9nd for rai l~ays ~_s:>r~shgps and _si_9ings),_ aIJ.9 a_!_g_B_p _SQuth _

on

3

CHS

CH9

CH10

CH11

I : CH12

4

station (referencing the Port Phillip Arcade and the early Port Phillip Club Hotel).

I

I I --- --- --- - ·----1 Te the satisfactien ef HeFita9e Victeria ana the resµensible abltherity (as aµµl icable).

YUndertake all underground service works beneath or w ithin heritage places or tree protection zones (TPZs) for trees as part of heri tage places to avoid, minimise and mitigate impacts to the heritage fabric.

I I

- I

I All

I

I

i

I' Te the satisfactie~f Herita9e Victeria ~na the resµensiele ablth;;;ta~ ~µ;iic-;e~)-. - -r pJI

e!;nsure new development is responsive to heritage places in terms of height, massing, form, fa~ade articulation and materials.

Te the satisfactien ef the resµensiele ai,Jtherity, e!;nsure no d irect impact on heritage buildings on the former Glueworks site in Kens ington.

Te the satisfactien ef the resµensiele ai,Jtherity, r.Betain and protect Langford Street pumping station (part of proposed Moonee Ponds Creek and Infrastructure Precinct) as part of the design for the new substation.

j I 2-1 Western

portal

I 3-Arden station

Based on IAC Version 3

HH23 I but the I

opportun

ities I apply

I across

t the I I project.

- --,-- ---- - --- -- --1

Construcli HH33, AareeEI v.411:1 Specific on

1

HH34 G6M change was ~ not agreed by

I CoM.CoM

I • concerns and

I ! I highlighted

I I I MMRA ~ --!-___ ;_ -- __ I amencied EPR

Detailed I HH05, j AareeEI wil l:l j Specific 1 design HH06, G6M change was

I HH08, ~ not agreed by HH18, CoM.CoM HH20, highlighted

I HH21 , concerns and

: HH22, 1 MMRA HH24, I 1 amended EPR HH26, ! HH27,

1 Constructi HH12

1

on AareeEI wil l:l G6M ~

1 I l --- _ I ---- ---Detailed design

HH14 I ;:v.411:1

,---

1

! Specific change was not agreed by CoM. CoM highlighted concerns and

• MMRA i amencied EPR

I Specific change was

I not agreed by CoM. CoM highlighted

- . - . .- - ! - ---

' concerns and MMRA amended EPR

Te the satisfactien ef Herita9e Victeria ana the resµensible ablther-ity, rReplace removed I ~ - J Constructi I HH15, I fgreeEI with

Elm trees in Royal Parade~~~~ of p~oject delivery using appro~r~~~speci~~nd re- __ L arkville J_: ____ ,_ HH16 _ L

-

Specific change was not agreed b

'-' ._.;

CH13

I

Provide suitable soil conditions to facilitate the growth of new trees to reach the size of the existing mature trees in the boulevard.

Te the satisfastien ef Heritage 'listeria, i!n detailed design ensure the eastern Parkvi lle station entry is set no less than 8-10 metres from the original Gatekeeper's Cottage and an appropriate boundary treatment is retained or re-established for the heritage building.

~-- -----' CH14

-·---~ --· Te the satisfastien ef the respensible mitherity, iln consultation with City of Melbourne, in detailed design for the CBD South station, incorporate the Charles Bush sculpture into the design for the new building on the Port Phillip Arcade site, preferably in a prominent position on the Flinders Street fagade.

---~- -- -CH15 I In the event thof temporary or &-permanent relocation of the Burke and Wills Monument

from its current site is required, resolve the final location of the monument tG-tR& satisfastien ef the appropriate respensible a1itherity ans/er in consultation with the City of Melbourne prior to the commencement of construction. (See Environmental Performance Requirement CH4)

1 CH 18 I Te the satisfastien ef Heritage 'listeria, rfieview the siting and design of the eastern Domain station entry in detailed design to ensure it is as recessive as possible in this location and has only a limited presence on the edge of the Shrine of RememberanseRemembrance Reserve.

CH19

The design needs to allow for the maintenance of an appropriate setting to the Macpherson Robertson Memorial Fountain.

Te the satisfastien efln consultation with Heritage Victoria

• Prior to dismantling the South African Soldiers ffiMemorial, in consultation with City of Port Phillip develop interpretive material to display in the precinct until the monument is restored.

• For detailed design, in consultation with City of Port Phillip review the siting and d~sig_!l of the_ vyestern Dom_ai~ ~talion entiy if!_ 9etaile9 9esign to ensure the ~01:1th

I I

f

1

4-Parkville station

6-CBD South station

~·-~

6-CBD South station

Detailed design

1 Detailed design

I I

I ~etailed i design

7 - I Detailed Domain design station

7 -Domain station

,-' Detailed 1

design I

Based on IAC Version 3

HH18

HH23

HH25

HH26

AareeEI with

I ;:o49,16 I

I

--· L _

5

CH20

I

African Soldiers Memorial has an appropriate landscaped setting if relocated on this site. If no appropriate setting can be established, consider options for relocation of the memorial to an alternative site.

To the satisfaction of the City of MeleolJrne, City of Port Phillip and/or the responsiele allthority In consultation with VicRoads. Heritage Victoria and/or the relevant local councils. as applicaele replace removed trees in St Kilda Road to re~stablish the boulevard formation.

I

7 -Domain station

Detailed I design

I

Based on IAC Version 3

__ l ' HH28 I Aareea witl'l

1~ I

--1 I Specific

change was not agreed by CoM. CoM highlighted concerns and

' MMRA

_____ ! ___ ! __ ---- l _ - -1---1 I j anieiided EPR -r--1---- , - -

Arboric ulture

AR3

6

Re-establish trees to replace loss of canopy cover and achieve canopy size equal to (or greater than) healthy, mature examples of the species in Melbourne. Consult with the City of Melbourne, the City of Port Phillip, the City of Stonnington, the Shrine of Remembrance and Shrine Trustees. University of Melbourne and Heritage Victoria as applicable. Policy documents that mlJst be followed should be referenced to re-establish trees and valued landscape character include:

• The City of Melbourne's Tree Retention and Removal Policy and Urban Forest Strategy, South Yarra Urban Forest Precinct Plan, Central City Urban Forest Precinct Plan and Carlton Urban Forest Precinct Plan and Kensington Urban Forest Precinct Plan (ei<cllJclina sections 8.2 and 8.3)

•

•

The City of Port Phillip's Community Amenity Local Law No. 1 and Greening Port Phillip - An Urban Forest Approach

The City of Stonnington's General Local Law 2008 (No 1) and City of Stonnington Street Tree Strategy

I : Any associated precinct plans

Specific policies of the Domain Parklands Conservation Management Plan-tGMPf, for trees within Domain Parklands

• Shrine of Rememeranso: Shrine of Remembrance Conservation Management Plan (Lovell Chen, 2010) or any future review and the Shrine of Remembrance Landscape Improvement Plan (rush Wright Associates, 2010)

I e South African Soldiers Memorial Reserve: Any relevant Conservation Management Plan (in preparation. Context. 2016)for the Sollth African Soldiers Memorial I

I ·-:.awkn" ·· ·----·.- ·- · , - ·-J -· .......................... """, -'O.I~...,,

• The preferred future character of the University of Melbourne, for trees in the grounds of the University of Melbourne.

,._.

i I

All (except Western turn back )

i Constructi

1

on l AR001, ·-1 Agre~d with I Agre-;;-with AR002,

1. CoM changes in

I AR003, 13/09/16 part. 1- 1 AR014· and Exclusion of

I I University of section 8_2 Melbourne and 8_3 was

I Changes I not agreed by • 1 15/9/16 I CoM.

I I

Additional I urban forest

I plan to be I added to list.

I I i i I

I

__ _l _J J_

Landscape and Visual

LV2

-r ----+- · l --1 - I

r De•elop and ;mplem;,;t a pla; ;n oon,,llabon "''" the Offioe of v;cto~a~ Go,.;;ment - ·r All - I De<lgn/ . -i L voo1 ' ;;;----...;;-.... ;; -1 Cho ., onl Architect, local councils and other land managers to comply with the Melbourne Metro I Construct1 I to 1 CoM incl ed art Urban Design Strategy to re-establish and enhance where appropriate public open ont . LV050 1l 13109l16 I of re uested space, recreation reserves and other valued places (including public art and public OperatieR Co chan e. infrastructure) disturbed by temporary works . I

Surface Water

NEW

The plan must include, but not be limited to a methodology and timeframe for storage, I ' reinstatement or replacement of existing public art, monuments and public infrastructure I '

1 such as poles (including banner poles), bins, and other street furniture such as I I wayfindinq signage (including signage hubs) 1

The plan should also include exploring opportunities for renewal of public spaces for the I J I I benefit of communities beyond resident groups, including visitors, business owners and J

1

I commuters. The plan should include a timeframe for re-establishment of public open j I space, recreation reserves and other valued places disturbed by temporary works. I J

In '°"'""a~on w;t: ~;ty o~ Melbo,rne ~akelhe neoe"a,; ~;;;;o~;h; .,;si;:g ~ -i -=- fl ___ _ r, =-_:_ L 1200mm diameter Council drain required to facilitate the construction of the Flinders I : reauf:!u•uu "Un

Street underpass, to allow for the concurrent extension of the drain to the drain's discharge point at the Yarra River

· Also refer to the following Environmental Performance Requirements for 'Surface Water': AES _____ I --- -- - - -- - - - - - - - - -- -

7