COL. RAJYAVARDHAN SINGH RATHORE164.100.47.5/newdebate/245/07022018/11.00amTo12.00Noon.pdf · COL....

Uncorrected Not for Publication-07022018

1

KR-VNK1A1100

The House met at eleven of the clock MR CHAIRMAN in the Chair

-----

MR CHAIRMAN Hon Members now we will take up Papers to be laid

on the Table

PAPERS LAID ON TABLE

DR MAHESH SHARMA Sir I lay on the Table a copy each (in English and Hindi) of the following papersmdash

(a) Annual Report and Accounts of the Centre for Cultural Resources and Training (CCRT) New Delhi for the year 2016-17 together with the Auditors Report on the Accounts

(b) Review by Government on the working of the above Centre

(Ends)

COL RAJYAVARDHAN SINGH RATHORE Sir I lay on the Tablemdash

I A copy (in English and Hindi) of the Ministry of Information and Broadcasting Notification No GSR 43 (E) dated the 19th January 2018 publishing the Press Council (Amendment) Rules 2018 under sub-section (3) of Section 25 of the Press Council Act 1978


2

II A copy each (in English and Hindi) of the following papersmdash

(i) (a) Annual Report and Accounts of the Sports Authority of India (SAI) New Delhi for the year 2015-16 together with the Auditors Report on the Accounts

(b) Review by Government on the working of the above Authority

(c) Statement giving reasons for the delay in laying the papers mentioned at (i) (a) above

(ii) (a) Annual Report and Accounts of the Indian Institute of Mass Communication (IIMC) New Delhi for the year 2016-17 together with the Auditors Report on the Accounts

(b) Review by Government on the working of the above Institute

(c) Statement giving reasons for the delay in laying the papers mentioned at (ii) (a) above

SHRI KIREN RIJIJU Sir I lay on the Tablemdash

I A copy (in English and Hindi) of the Ministry of Home Affairs Notification No GSR 389 dated the November 19 2017- November 25 2017 (weekly Gazette) publishing the Assam Rifles Para Medical Staff Group ―C Combatised Posts Recruitment Rules 2017 under Section 167 of the Assam Rifles Act 2006

II A copy (in English and Hindi) of the Ministry of Home Affairs Notification No GSR 41 dated the 18th January 2018 publishing the National Fire Service College Nagpur Professor Associate Professor


3

and Assistant Professor (Academic Group A Posts) Recruitment (Amendment) Rules 2017 under Article 309 of the Constitution of India

III(1) A copy each (in English and Hindi) of the following papers under sub-section (1) of Section 70 of the Disaster Management Act 2005mdash

(a) Annual Report and Accounts of the National Institute of Disaster Management (NIDM) New Delhi for the years 2003-04 to 2011-12 together with the Auditors Report on the Accounts

(b) Review by the Government on the working of the above Institute

(2) Statement (in English and Hindi) giving reasons for the delay in laying the papers mentioned at (1) (a) above

SHRI ANANTKUMAR HEGDE Sir I lay on the Table under sub-section (3) of Section 37 of the Apprentices Act 1961 a copy (in English and Hindi) of the Ministry of Skill Development and Entrepreneurship Notification No GSR 1525 (E) dated the 20th December 2017 publishing the Apprenticeship (Sixth Amendment) Rules 2017

SHRI CR CHAUDHARY Sir I lay on the Table under sub-section (2) of Section 38 of the Footwear Design and Development Institute Act 2017 a copy (in English and Hindi) of the Ministry of Commerce and Industry (Department of Commerce) Notification No GSR 63 (E) dated the 25th January 2018 publishing the First Statutes of the Footwear Design


4

and Development Institute along with Statement of objects and reasons and explanatory note

(Ends)

REPORTS OF COMMITTEE ON WELFARE OF OTHER BACKWARD CLASSES

शरी राम नारायण डडी (राजसथान) महोदय म अनय पिछड़ वगो क कलयाण सबधी सपमपत क पनमनपिपखत परपतवदनो की एक-एक परपत (अगरजी तथा पहनदी म) सभा िटि िर रखता ह -

(i) Ninth Report on the subject Measures undertaken to secure representation of OBCs in employment and for their welfare in Oil and Natural Gas Corporation pertaining to the Ministry of Petroleum and Natural Gas

(ii) Tenth Report on the subject Need for greater budgetary allocations for various welfare measuresschemes for OBCs pertaining to the Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment and

(iii) Eleventh Report on the subject Measures undertaken to secure representation of OBCs in employment and for their welfare in Food Corporation of India pertaining to the Ministry of Consumer Affairs Food and Public Distribution

(Ends)

These Reports were presented to the Speaker on the 14

th December 2017 under Direction 71A of the

Directions by the Speaker Lok Sabha The Speaker was pleased to order the printing publication and

circulation of the Reports under Rule 280 of the Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business in Lok Sabha

The Reports were also placed before Chairman Rajya Sabha on the 27th

December 2017


5

STATEMENTS OF COMMITTEE ON WELFARE OF OTHER BACKWARD CLASSES

शरी राम नारायण डडी (राजसथान) महोदय म अनय पिछड़ वगो क कलयाण सबधी सपमपत क अपतम की गई काररवाई सबधी पनमनपिपखत पववरणो की एक-एक परपत (अगरजी तथा पहनदी म) सभा िटि िर रखता ह -

(i) Statement showing action taken by the Government on the recommendationsobservations contained in the First Report (Sixteenth Lok Sabha) of the Committee regarding action taken by the Government on the recommendationsobservations contained in the Fourth Report (Fifteenth Lok Sabha) on the subject Reservation in employment and Welfare measures for OBCs in the Reserve Bank of India pertaining to the Ministry of Finance (Department of Financial Services) and

(ii) Statement showing action taken by the Government on the recommendationsobservations contained in the Seventh Report (Sixteenth Lok Sabha) of the Committee regarding action taken by the Government on the recommendationsobservations contained in the Fifth Report (Sixteenth Lok Sabha) on the subject Measures undertaken to secure representation of OBCs in employment and for their Welfare in Indian Oil Corporation Limited pertaining to the Ministry of Petroleum and Natural Gas

(Ends)


6

MR CHAIRMAN Hon Members we will go ahead with Zero Hour

submissions Shri Ghulam Nabi Azadji Shri Naresh Agrawalji Shri

CM Ramesh Shri Dhindsaji and others have given notice under Rule

267 on various issues We discussed the matter I have taken up the

matter on which Shri Naresh Agrawalji has given notice with regard to

the Maldives situation and to discuss about it I contacted the

External Affairs Minister She is abroad for an important function which

is a prestigious one and she told me that the situation is fluid delicate

and sensitive and let us not discuss it immediately in the House wait

for sometime till the situation crystallises

शरी नरश अगरवाल चयरमन साहब मरा आिस एक अनरोध ह पक व फराइड को

कम स कम यहा जवाब द द पक situation खराब हो रही ह यही जाधव क

मामि म कहा गया था पक हम िोग न बोि िपकन जाधव िर और मकदम िगा

पदए गए इसपिए आि इतना ensure कर दीपजए पक हम इसको फराइड की

सबह उठाए

MR CHAIRMAN Please I have taken note of your suggestion मन

आिका सझाव पिया म इस सबध म मतरी जी स बात करक दखगा The

second is about the Kashmir situation I have decided to convert it into


7

a Zero Hour submission and the Leader of the Opposition will be

making that submission

With regard to the notice given by Shri CM Ramesh

(Interruptions)

SHRI CM RAMESH Regarding the implementation of the Andhra

Pradesh Reorganisation Act please give us some time for discussing it

and let the Members know about it

MR CHAIRMAN I do agree that it is an important issue But there are

other ways and means to discuss the same So please take recourse

to other means and we will give you an opportunity to discuss But I

am not allowing it under Rule 267 (Interruptions) Please dont

argue Once I said something please accept it

With regard to Shri Dhindsas notice on anti-Sikh riots and the

revelation that has come I have decided not to accept it under Rule

267 (Interruptions) No Member is supposed to stand in the isle or

in the lobby and speak to other Members

Then I have decided to allow it during Zero Hour It will be given

priority also (Interruptions)


8

DR KPV RAMACHANDRA RAO Sir I have given notice for Calling

Attention or Short Duration Discussion on the implementation of the

Andhra Pradesh Reorganisation Act

MR CHAIRMAN There will be no Calling Attention in this session It

has been decided long back Now Zero Hour issue on deteriorating

security situation in Jammu and Kashmir by Shri Ghulam Nabi Azad

(Followed by 1BRSS)

NKR-RSS1B1105

MATTERS RAISED WITH PERMISSION OF CHAIR

DETERIORATING SECURITY SITUATION IN JampK

नता ववरोधी दल (शरी गलाम नबी आज़ाद) माननीय चयरमन साहब चपक

जीरो-ऑवर म (वयवधान)

رویز چونکہ صاحب نیئرمیچ مانئے ( آزاد ینب غالم جناب )اختالف حزب قائد

(مداخلت) ںیم آوور

MR CHAIRMAN MoS should take note of it The Leader of the House

has come Okay


9

शरी गलाम नबी आज़ाद जीरो-ऑवर म दो-तीन पमनट स जयादा इस पवषय िर

म चचा नही कर सकता कयोपक बहत सार पवषय सदन क सामन ह इसस िहि

पक म कि की घटना िर सदन म अिनी बात रख म माननीय चयरमन साहब

और सरकार स पनवदन करगा पक जमम-कशमीर म पजस तरह हािात खराब

हए ह उन िर पकसी वकत यहा चचा होनी चापहए अगर इस सशन म नही तो

अगि सशन म जरर चचा होनी चापहए और पवसतार स सभी एमिीज उसम

पहससा ि

मन िरसो भी बताया था पक जमम-कशमीर म हािात पिछि कछ सािो म

बहत खराब हए ह जबपक सरकार की तरफ स बताया गया था पक पिछि वषो म

सबस जयादा हािात ठीक हो गए ह जो सतय नही ह कशमीर म भी हािात

खराब ह और अब जमम परोववस म भी हािात खराब होत जा रह ह कि वहा जो

घटना हई ह वह बहत दखद ह एक िापकसतानी एिईटी का कमाडर नवीद

जाट जो जन 2014 म एक जवाइट ऑिरशन म किगाम पडसटसिकट म िकड़ा

गया था और सनिि जि शरीनगर म था कि उस इिाज क पिए महाराजा

हपरवसह असिताि म ि जाया जा रहा था महाराजा हपरवसह असिताि कशमीर

का सबस िराना असिताि ह शहर क अदर ह मपडकि कॉिज भी उसी म ह

िराना ही नही सबस बड़ा असिताि ह उस असिताि म early 90s म ऐसी घटना

हो सकती थी िपकन पिछि 15-20 साि स जबस हािात कछ ठीक हो गए ह

तब स यह िहिी घटना हई ह पक उस असिताि स एक िापकसतानी ओपरपजन


10

क पमपिटट को कछ दसर पमपिटटस छड़ाकर ि जाए - यह घटना सीधी तरह

स गवनरमट या सरकार िर परफिकट ही नही करती िपकन दश क पिए भी

अचछा नही ह (वयवधान) म खािी सरकार की बात नही करता ह दश क

पकसी गाव क असिताि म ऐसा हो सकता ह िपकन इसम कही-न-कही राजय

सरकार की कमी रही ह कयोपक अगर व पकसी इतन बड़ एिईटी आतकवादी

को उस असिताि म ि गए थ तो उसकी सरकषा क पिए िरा-पमपिटरी आमी या

दसर िोग साथ होन चापहए सबस िहि तो उस इिाज क पिए आमी असिताि

म ि जाना चापहए था जहा िशट और कनटोनमट क िोगो क अिावा दसरा

कोई जा नही सकता था उस ऐसी जगह कयो ि गए जहा ओिीडी क पिए

हजारो िोग जात हो वहा कोई उस धकका दकर भी ि जा सकता ह म

समझता ह पक यह दश क पिए राजय क पिए और सरकार क पिए बहत अचछी

बात नही ह सरकार को सतकर रहना चापहए और इस तरह की घटना दोबारा न

हो इसका धयान रखना चापहए

(समापत)

ںیم پر وشئے اس ادہیز سے منٹ نیت دو ںیم آوور رویز آزاد ینب غالم جناب

سے اس ںیہ سامنے کے سدن وشئے سارے بہت کہ وںیک سکتا کر ںینہ چرچا نیئرمیچ مانئے ںیم رکھوں بات یاپن ںیم سدن پر گھٹنا یک کل ںیم کہ پہلے

حاالت طرح جس ںیم ریکشم-جموں کہ گا کروں دنینو سے سرکار اور صاحب

ںینہ ںیم شنیس اس اگر چاہئے یہون چرچا ہاںی وقت یکس پر ان ںیہ ہوئے خراب


11

ںیم اس زیپمیا یسبھ سے وستار اور چاہئے یہون چرچا ضرور ںیم شنیس اگلے تو ںیل حصہ

کچھہ پچھلے حاالت ںیم ریکشم-جموں کہ تھا ایبتا یبھ پرسوں پنے ںیم

پچھلے کہ تھا ایگ ایبتا سے طرف یک سرکار جبکہ ںیہ ہوئے خراب بہت ںیم سالوں ںیم ریکشم ہے ںینہ سچ جو ںیہ گئے ہو کیٹھ حاالت ادہیز سے سب ںیم سالوں

رہے جا ہوتے خراب حاالت یبھ ںیم پروونس جموں اب اور ںیہ خراب حاالت یبھ کا یٹیالیا یپاکستان کیا ہے دکھد بہت وہ ہے یہوئ گھٹنا جو وہاں کل ںیہ

ڈسٹرکٹ کلگام ںیم شنیآپر جوائنٹ کیا ںیم 2014 جون جو جاٹ دینو کمانڈر

لئے کے عالج اسے کل تھا ںیم نگر یسر لیج نٹرلیس اور تھا ایگ پکڑا ںیم اسپتال سنگھہ یہر مہاراجہ تھا رہا جا ایجا لے ںیم اسپتال سنگھہ یہر مہاراجہ

ںیم یاس یبھ کالج کلیڈیم ہے اندر کے شہر ہے اسپتال پرانا سے سب کا ریکشم یسیا ںیم early 90s ںیم اسپتال اس ہے اسپتال بڑا سے سب ںینہ یہ پرانا ہے

کیٹھ کچھہ حاالت سے جب سے سال سیب-پندرہ پچھلے کنیل یتھ یسکت ہو گھٹنا

یپاکستان کیا سے اسپتال اس کہ ہے یہوئ گھٹنا یپہل ہی سے تب ںیہ گئے ہو کیٹھ گھٹنا ہی ndash ںیجائ لے کر چھڑا نٹسیٹیمل دوسرے کچھہ کو نٹیٹیمل کے جنیاور

یاچھ لئے کے شید کنیل یکرت ںینہ کٹیرفل پر سرکار اور نٹیگوورنم سے طرح یکس کے شید ہوں کرتا ںینہ بات یک سرکار یخال ںیم (مداخلت) ہے ںینہ

یک سرکار ہیراج ںیکہ نہ ںیکہ ںیم اس کنیل ہے سکتا ہو سایا ںیم اسپتال کے گاؤں ںیم اسپتال اس کو یواد آتنک یٹیالیا بڑے یکس وہ اگر کہ وںیک ہے یرہ یکم ساتھہ لوگ دوسرے ای یآرم یملٹر-رایپ لئے کے سرکشا یک اس تو تھے گئے لے


12

جانا لے ںیم اسپتال یآرم لئے کے عالج اسے تو پہلے سے سب ںیچاہئ ہونے جا یکوئ دوسرا عالوہ کے والوں رہنے کے نٹیکنٹونم اور نٹیشیپ جہاں تھا چاہئے

ہزاروں لئے کے یڈیپاو جہاں گئے لے وںیک جگہ یسیا اسے تھا سکتا ںینہ سمجھتا ںیم ہے سکتا جا لے یبھ کر دے دھکا اسے یکوئ وہاں ہوں جاتے لوگ ںینہ بات یاچھ بہت لئے کے سرکار اور لئے کے ہیراج لئے کے شید ہی کہ ہوں انیدھ کا اس ہو نہ دوبارہ گھٹنا یک طرح اس اور چاہئے رہنا محتاط کو سرکار ہے

چاہئے رکھنا( شد ختم)

SHRI DEREK OBRIEN (WEST BENGAL) Sir I associate myself with

the matter raised by the hon Member

SHRIMATI AMBIKA SONI (PUNJAB) Sir I also associate myself with


SOME HON MEMBERS Sir we also associate ourselves with the

matter raised by the hon Member

MR CHAIRMAN Shri Vivek K Tankha to associatehellip (Interruptions)hellip

Dr KVP Ramachandra Rao I will not continue the House with such

placards I am telling you very frankly Whatever has happened this is

not the way Ghulam Nabi Azadji take care of your Member Ask him

to go back to his seat


13

SHRI GHULAM NABI AZAD Sir I would like you to use your good

offices (Interruptions) इस घटना म जो दो कासटबलस मार गए ह म

उनक परपत भी शोक वयकत करता ह (वयवधान)

ئکتیو شوک یبھ ںیتئ کے ان ںیم ںیہ گئے مارے کانسٹبل دو جو ںیم گھٹنا اس (مداخلت) ہوں کرتا

MR CHAIRMAN The point is the issue which he wants to raise is an

important issue not because of his Andhra issue but even otherwise

also But at the same time this is not the way and I am not going to

accept this And some of you felt that why the House is being

adjourned I cannot run the House like this शरी रामचनर राव जी आि

अिनी जगह िर जाकर बपठए (वयवधान) आननद शमा जी पिीज अिन

सदसय को समझाइए(वयवधान)

(Followed by 1cKGG)

KGG-DS1C1110

MR CHAIRMAN (contd) I am very clear about this There are only

two ways leftmdasheither name him and take action otherwise adjourn the

House आि िोग पडसाइड कीपजए

SHRI DEREK O BRIEN The House should run Sir


14

THE LEADER OF THE OPPOSITION (SHRI GHULAM NABI AZAD)

Sir let me tell you that my Party does not approve this behaviour of the

hon Member

शरी सभापवत ऐसा ह तो आिन अचछा पकया Dr Ramachandra Rao you

have made your point please go to your seat Dr Ramachandra Rao

please go to your seat I am telling you the second time Dr

Ramachandra Rao we had a discussion yesterday after that we

discussed it today morning All parties have said that the House should

run and the Zero Hour should go on Now if one Member creates a

situation like this tomorrow another Member will do the same thing

SHRI DEREK O BRIEN Sir the House is in order

MR CHAIRMAN The House is not in order

SHRI DEREK O BRIEN Sir with all humility the House is in order and

we should have Zero Hour mentions

MR CHAIRMAN Yes

SHRI DEREK O BRIEN So the House is in order

MR CHAIRMAN How can you say that the House is in order

(Interruptions)

शरी नरश अगरवाल सर इगनोर कर दीपजए (वयवधान)


15

MR CHAIRMAN No I cant I will not ignore it If I ignore the country

is not going to ignore Are we so helpless

शरी सजय ससह सर एक वयसटकत क पिए िर हाउस को (वयवधान)

शरी सभापवत पिीज ऐसा उदाहरण मत दीपजए आि बपठए आि बपठए न

Mr Sanjay Singh please sit down You are a new Member just watch

for some time I am going to allow you on your issues also Why are

you getting involved in this Mr Vivek Tankha has to associate himself

with what has been said A lot of other Members also have raised their

hands and all of their names should be included

SHRI VIVEK K TANKHA Sir can I speak for a minute on this issue

MR CHAIRMAN Not now The House is not in order I have told you

about the two alternatives (Interruptions) Dr Ramachandra Rao

finally I am telling you to go back to your seat please

Rule 255 talks of withdrawal of Member ldquoThe Chairman may

direct any member whose conduct is in his opinion grossly disorderly

to withdraw immediately from the Council and any member so ordered

to withdraw shall do so forthwith and shall absent himself during the

remainder of the days meetingrdquo Dr Ramachandra Rao I am invoking

Rule 255 and also directing you to please conduct yourself by going


16

back to your seat or withdraw from the House immediately

(Interruptions) Dr Ramachandra Rao I had allowed you and now I

cant allow you to speak I can give you an opportunity if you want to

speak go back to your seat and not here You cant speak to me like

this (Interruptions) Go back to your seat सब िोग कह रह ह

Everybody is saying

DR KVP RAMACHANDRA RAO

(At this stage the hon Member left the Chamber)

MR CHAIRMAN No commentary will go on record No discussion on

this No statement made by Dr Ramachandra Rao will go on record

(Interruptions) A Member coming into the well of the House is very

unfortunate Nothing will go on record No camera to be focused on

this because the disorderly conduct will send a wrong message

(Interruptions) We are here to do justice Justice can be arrived at

by debate discussion and decision and not by disruption Now Shri

Vivek Tankha to associate

--------------------------------- Not recorded


17

SHRI VIVEK K TANKHA (MADHYA PRADESH) Sir I am associating

myself with the Leader of the Opposition on the Kashmir issue for three

very good reasons Firstly we must act on Kashmir because it is

demoralising our security forces We cant let this happen indefinitely

Otherwise the security forces will get demoralised Secondly the

people of Kashmir are tired They want peace There has to be a

dialogue I want to see the start of a dialogue Otherwise it will be

unending Thirdly the very important thing is Kashmiri Pandits who

had left Kashmir in the 90s are wanting to go back to Kashmir We

have to create a situation where the Kashmiri Pandits go back

MR CHAIRMAN Normally the associating Member is not allowed to

speak But he raised an important issue That is why I allowed

SHRI VIVEK K TANKHA These were the important three points Sir

Thank you

(Ends)

(Followed by KLS1D)


18

MCM-KLS1D1115

DEMAND FOR RAISING ISSUE OF INVOLVEMENT OF FORMER UNION MINISTER IN 1984 ANTI-SIKH RIOTS IN DELHI AS

REVEALED IN RECENT STING OPERATION BY NEWS CHANNEL

सरदार सखदव ससह सढडसा (पजाब) सभािपत महोदय म आज ऐसा इशय

आिक सामन और हाउस क सामन उठाना चाहता ह जो 34 साि िहि पसखो

क साथ नरसहार हआ genocide साइड हआ इतन समय बाद अभी तक

उनको कोई इसाफ नही पमिा िपकन जो शरी अटि पबहारी वाजियी जी न

नानावती कमीशन बनाया था उनहोन कागरस क कछ िीडसर क बार म कहा

पक इसम इनका हाथ ह उसम दो आदमी ऐस ह जो अभी यहा िर ह व और

(वयवधान)

कछ माननीय सदसय यहा नाम नही ि सकत(वयवधान)

सरदार सखदव ससह सढडसा चिो म नाम नही िता ह िपकन एक

नया(वयवधान)चिो ठीक ह म(वयवधान)

MR CHAIRMAN Name will not go on record (Interruptions) But

we have to follow this rule in all cases (Interruptions)

Expunged as ordered by the Chair


19

सरदार सखदव ससह सढडसा सर एक नया एपवडस आया ह उस एपवडस को

म यहा िश करना चाहता ह पजसकी सी0डी0 भी हमार िास ह हमार परपजडट

पदलिी पसख गरदवारा मनजमट कमटी क चयरमन को दकर गया था वह सभी

चनलस िर भी कि चिा और ििसर म भी आया ह इसको म टबि िर भी रखगा

िपकन उस इसान न जो कहा वह म इस हाउस क सामन रखना चाहता ह वह

कहता ह पक मन सौ पसख मार(वयवधान)


He shall have to authenticate it (Interruptions)

सरदार सखदव ससह सढडसा जी म यह सी0डी0 टबि िर रख रहा ह आि

दख सकत ह यह कि भी सार पदन चिी ह(वयवधान) उसम वह गािी

भी बहत पनकािता ह(वयवधान)

SHRI ANAND SHARMA Sir I am on a point of order

(Interruptions)

सरदार सखदव ससह सढडसा मझ कमपिीट कर िन दीपजए

MR CHAIRMAN I will give you time (Interruptions)

SHRI ANAND SHARMA Dhindsaji can continue but hear me out Sir

the rules of the House do not allow two things (a) when a matter is sub

judice and the matter is actually sub judice and the evidence as such

can only be presented in the court the court has taken cognizance to


20

whatever is being alleged (b) this House cannot convert itself into a

trial court and (c) a person being named individual irrespective of

MR CHAIRMAN Right I understand what you are trying to say

(Interruptions)

SHRI ANAND SHARMA A person who cannot come and clarify the

fact he cannot be included (Interruptions)

MR CHAIRMAN Please stop (Interruptions)

SHRI ANAND SHARMA It is a sub judice matter (Interruptions)

MR CHAIRMAN Please You have made your point now leave it to

the Chair I do agree that we should not name the Member that is why

I suggested that it will not go on record (Interruptions) Any

person who is not a Member of the House and not present in the

House his name will not go on record (Interruptions) That is one

stand taken by them See it in the future also But the point is that the

hon Member and two other Members came to me met me in my

Chamber and showed me the CD-- it is not my duty to see the CD-- I

told them to authenticate it He said it in the floor of the House now

that he is submitting the same CD with authentication to the House

So I dont find any objection to that Please go ahead


21

सरदार सखदव ससह सढडसा सर उसका अिना confession ह यह कस कह

पदया जबपक कि सार टी0वी0 चनलस िर चिा ह ििसर म भी ह और म इसको

यहा िर रख रहा ह यह उसका confession ह तो शमा जी कह रह ह पक

उसस कया होता ह उसम वह गािी भी पनकािता ह और वह कहता ह पक मन

सौ पसखो को मारा िहि तो यह बताए पक एक आदमी तो सौ पसखो को नही

मार सकता उसक साथ कौन-कौन थ दसरा वह कहत ह पक मन चीफ

जसटसटस को टिीफोन पकया और दो जज और िगवाए और मन उनको

बोि पदया ह और उनहोन ही की जमानत की ह जो कभी भी नही हो सकती

थी यहा बड़-बड़ िीगि फीलड क आदमी बठ ह व बताए पक कया इस परकार

पकसी की जमानत हो सकती ह महोदय दसरा यह ह(वयवधान)

MR CHAIRMAN Please no commentary (Interruptions) मटर

गभीर ह Please try to understand Mr Anand Sharmaji I have not

called you please (Interruptions) I have not called you

(Interruptions)

SHRI ANAND SHARMA There are rules(Interruptions)

MR CHAIRMAN I know what is there in Rajya Sabha rules




22

SHRI NARESH GUJRAL Sir for 33 years where were these rules and

regulations (Contd by 1ESSS

SSS-SC1E1120

SHRI NARESH GUJRAL (CONTD) Where were the rules when Sikhs

were massacred Have they forgotten the rules Is it a rule that Sikhs

should be massacred and no justice should be given (Interruptions)

MR CHAIRMAN Shri Anand Sharma please sit down

(Interruptions) No rule is being allowed to be violated as long as I

am here You dont worry on that count (Interruptions) They have

a serious issue They have every right to raise it in the House I have

permitted them Once the Chair permits you cannot object Please sit

down (Interruptions)

SHRI ANAND SHARMA

MR CHAIRMAN What Shri Anand Sharma is saying will not go on

record Whatever Sardar Sukhdev Singh Dhindsa is saying will go on

record Others should sit down (Interruptions) Please sit down

पिीज आि बठ जाइए(वयवधान)

Not recorded


23

सरदार सखदव ससह सढडसा सरकार की परिोटर ह(वयवधान)

MR CHAIRMAN It is an emotional issue

सरदार सखदव ससह सढडसा सरकार की अिनी परिोटर ह पक 2733 पसख ह

पजनका पसफर पदलिी म कति हआ य उनकी figures ह िपकन 5000 स जयादा

पसखो का यहा िर कतिआम हआ तीन पदन तक यह सब होता रहा इनको उस

वकत रलस मािम नही थ तीन पदन तक न िपिस बिवाई गयी(वयवधान)

शरी सभापवत आिको कया कहना ह

सरदार सखदव ससह सढडसा न िपिस बिायी गयी और न फौज को बिाया

गया(वयवधान)

MR CHAIRMAN What do you want to say

शरी आननद शमा कया रलस यह कहत ह(वयवधान)

सरदार बलसवदर ससह भडर यह National TV िर आया ह(वयवधान)

National TV िर सब आया ह(वयवधान)

SHRI PRAMOD TIWARI Sir it cannot be permitted

(Interruptions)You have to expunge it



24

सरदार सखदव ससह सढडसा यह National TV िर आता रहा ह(वयवधान)

National TV िर आता रहा ह(वयवधान)

MR CHAIRMAN This is not the way to behave Please sit down

(Interruptions) Please conclude Sardar Dhindsa

(Interruptions)

शरी शवत मवलक इनको कषमा याचना करनी चापहए(वयवधान)

सरदार सखदव ससह सढडसा सर य िोग मझ बोिन नही द रह

ह(वयवधान)

MR CHAIRMAN Except Sardar Sukhdev Singh Dhindsas speech

nothing else will on record Any reference to persons name and

position who are not here should be avoided It should be removed

from the record

सरदार सखदव ससह सढडसा आि बताए पक कया हम 34 साि म कोई इसाफ

पमिा ह(वयवधान) आि सब िोगो म स कया कोई इसाफ की बात कर रहा

ह कया पसखो को कभी इसाफ पमिगा या नही पमिगा अगर व खद confess

करत ह तो उस भी आि सनन क पिए तयार नही ह(वयवधान)

सरदार बलसवदर ससह भडर य अभी भी कापतिो की पहमायत कर रह

ह(वयवधान) 34 साि हो गए ह अभी भी पहमायत कर रह ह(वयवधान)


25

सरदार सखदव ससह सढडसा य अभी भी उनकी पहमायत कर रह

ह(वयवधान) अभी भी सनन क पिए तयार नही ह अभी भी ऐसा बोि रह


शरी सभापवत आिका टाइम समापत हो गया ह(वयवधान) Let me make it

clear once again The reference to a particular name earlier the

reference to the former Prime Minister will not be part of the record

Other things will go on Thank you Dhindsaji please sit down I have

to give an opportunity to others (Interruptions)

SHRI NARESH GUJRAL Some hon Members were disrupting him

Sir Please allow him to speak

MR CHAIRMAN That is why I gave him time आि एक िाइन म

conclude कपरए (वयवधान) आि िोग बठ जाइए पिीज

(Interruptions) If you want to associate you can associate

afterwards

सरदार सखदव ससह सढडसा एक तो उसक confession की बात

ह(वयवधान)म एक और चीज बताना चाहता ह वह कहता ह पक

(वयवधान) यह कया बात ह(वयवधान)

शरी सभापवत आि conclude कीपजए Please conclude

(Interruptions)


26


Sir are we having a discussion here He has already taken nine

minutes This is not the discussion time (Interruptions)

MR CHAIRMAN I am asking him to conclude Please sit down

(Interruptions)

सरदार सखदव ससह सढडसा मर सार पमनट तो आि िोग खा गए ह आिन

मझ बोिन नही पदया(वयवधान) मरा सारा वकत तो य िोग खा गए


शरी सभापवत आि िोग बपठए(वयवधान)

SHRI ANAND SHARMA Sir I am on a point of order Please allow

me (Interruptions)

SHRI PRAMOD TIWARI Sir how much time can he take

(Interruptions)

सरदार सखदव ससह सढडसा पजस जनरि स बगिादश बनाया था जनरि

अरोड़ा उनह कस अिनी जान बचानी िड़ी वह भी सभी जानत ह(वयवधान)

गजराि साहब बता सकत ह पक उनहोन कस अिनी जान बचायी(वयवधान)

जो पहनदसतान का हीरो था उसको गजराि साहब क घर म जाकर अिनी जान

बचानी िड़ी(वयवधान)

(समापत)


27

शरीमती रपा गागली (नाम वनदवशत) महोदय म माननीय सदसय दवारा उठाए

गए पवषय स सवय को सबदध करती ह

शरी अजय सचती (महाराषटर) महोदय म भी माननीय सदसय दवारा उठाए गए

पवषय स सवय को सबदध करता ह

शरी भपनर यादव (राजसथान) महोदय म भी माननीय सदसय दवारा उठाए गए


शरी नारायण लाल पचावरया (राजसथान ) महोदय म भी माननीय सदसय दवारा

उठाए गए पवषय स सवय को सबदध करता ह

शरी शवत मवलक (पजाब) महोदय म भी माननीय सदसय दवारा उठाए गए पवषय

स सवय को सबदध करता ह

SARDAR BALWINDER SINGH BHUNDER (PUNJAB) Sir I associate

myself with the concern expressed by Sardar Sukhdev Singh Dhindsa

SHRI NARESH GUJRAL (PUNJAB) Sir I also associate myself with

the concern expressed by Sardar Sukhdev Singh Dhindsa

SHRI LA GANESAN (MADHYA PRADESH) Sir I also associate



concern expressed by Sardar Sukhdev Singh Dhindsa


28

MR CHAIRMAN Okay Now Shrimati Vandana Chavan not present

Shri Manish Gupta

(Contd by NBR1F)

-SSSNBR-GS1F1125

MR CHAIRMAN (CONTD) I am not allowing a discussion I have

already given the ruling So please go by that (Interruptions) Shri

Manish Gupta (Interruptions)

SHRI BHUPENDER YADAV Sir I am on a point of order

(Interruptions) Sir I am on a point of order (Interruptions)

MR CHAIRMAN No no We have been discussing in this House

issues which are sub judice for years together It is everybodys

knowledge (Interruptions)


(Interruptions)

MR CHAIRMAN No no I have already called him Mr Bhupender

Yadav please you are from the ruling party Please sit down I have

already told you

SHRI MANISH GUPTA Sir I rise to flag the issue of abhorrent practice

of manual scavenging (Interruptions)


29

SHRI SUKHENDU SEKHAR RAY Sir you should take care of what is

happening (Interruptions)

MR CHAIRMAN I am keeping a watch on what is happening

Sukhendu ji I have taken note of it

DEMAND FOR ELIMINATING MANUAL SCAVENGING IN COUNTRY

SHRI MANISH GUPTA (WEST BENGAL) Sir I rise to flag the issue of

manual scavenging in India

After more than seventy years more than 26 million dry latrines

still exist in this country And more than 7 lakh of those latrines are

manually serviced

Now the problem is the people engaged in this particular

profession are from poor and disadvantaged sections Although there

is legislation in 1993 and 2013 to look after the interests of this particular

section of people action taken by the Government -- whether it is

Central Government or State Governments -- has not been adequate

The two-pronged strategy of the Government to identify manual

scavengers as well as to provide them alternative livelihood is still at a

nascent stage What we need to do at this hour is to find a way to

bring in stricter laws to see that these people are properly identified


30

There was a proposal to set up a survey to identify the manual

scavengers But it has not taken off As a result this particular

practice is still continuing in many parts of the country

MR CHAIRMAN Mr Gupta what is your conclusion

SHRI MANISH GUPTA Also we have noticed cases of death in

manual scavenging are filed More than 400 people have died due to

manual scavenging in the last 3-4 years It is a very serious matter

But when cases are filed we find that FIRs cite negligence and other

acts instead of saying that it is an act of not only negligence but also

violation of law by those people who employ these manual scavengers

Sir not a single person has been punished in the last 10 years It

means the law is very weak We need to amend law and provide a

comprehensive rehabilitation package for these manual scavengers

Thank you

(Ends)

SOME HON MEMBERS Sir we all associate ourselves with the Zero

Hour submission made by Manishji


31

MR CHAIRMAN Names of all the hon Members be recorded as

associations One is raising your hand subsequently you also send a

slip because it may not be humanly possible for Reporters to note

down all the names So you send a slip so that it will go on record

(Ends)

शरी हसन दलवई (महाराषटर) महोदय माननीय सदसय न जो पवषय उठाया ह

म भी अिन आिको इसस समबदध करता ह

SHRI SUKHENDU SEKHAR RAY (WEST BENGAL) Sir I associate

myself with the Zero Hour submission made by Shri Manish Gupta

शरी आलोक वतवारी (उततर परदश) महोदय माननीय सदसय न जो पवषय

उठाया ह म भी अिन आिको इसस समबदध करता ह

SHRI KC RAMAMURTHY (KARNATAKA) Sir I also associate myself

with the Zero Hour submission made by Shri Manish Gupta

शरी पीएल पवनया (उततर परदश) महोदय माननीय सदसय न जो पवषय उठाया

ह म भी अिन आिको इसस समबदध करता ह

शरीमती जया बचचन (उततर परदश) महोदय माननीय सदसय न जो पवषय

उठाया ह म भी अिन आिको इसस समबदध करती ह

शरी रणववजय ससह जदव (छततीसगढ़) महोदय माननीय सदसय न जो पवषय



32

शरीमती ववपलव ठाकर (वहमाचल परदश) महोदय माननीय सदसय न जो पवषय


कमारी शलजा (हवरयाणा) महोदय माननीय सदसय न जो पवषय उठाया ह म

भी अिन आिको इसस समबदध करती ह

SHRI NEERAJ SHEKHAR (UTTAR PRADESH) Sir I also associate


SHRI MAJEED MEMON (MAHARASHTRA) Sir I also associate


SHRI RITABRATA BANERJEE (WEST BENGAL) Sir I also associate


SHRI MD NADIMUL HAQUE (WEST BENGAL) Sir I also associate


SHRI KIRANMAY NANDA (UTTAR PRADESH) Sir I also associate


SHRIMATI RENUKA CHOWDHURY (ANDHRA PRADESH) Sir I also

associate myself with the Zero Hour submission made by Shri Manish

Gupta

SHRI OSCAR FERNANDES (KARNATAKA) Sir I also associate



33

SHRIMATI AMBIKA SONI(PUNJAB) Sir I also associate myself with

the Zero Hour submission made by Shri Manish Gupta

SHRI VIVEK GUPTA (WEST BENGAL) Sir I also associate myself


(Ends)

DETERIORATING CONDITION OF REAL ESTATE SECTOR

शरी नरश अगरवाल (उततर परदश) माननीय सभािपत जी म एक बहत ही

महतविणर मदद िर इस सदन क माधयम स सरकार का धयान आकरषषत करना

चाहता ह शरीमन जब आि अरबन डवििमट पमपनसटर थ उस समय परयि

सटट बम िर था जमीन क दाम बहत अपधक थ आि कानन भी िाए और उस

कानन न बहत कछ पकया भी और जब जमीन क दाम आध हो गए ह उस समय

तो राजय सरकार सटमि डयटी क पिए सरषकि रट को बढ़ा दती थी िोग सरषकि

रट क पहसाब स सटमि डयटी दत थ actual rate क पहसाब स खरीद ित थ

िपकन इनकम टकस का एक ऑडरर िहचा पक सरषकि रट स नीच जमीन को

खरीदा नही जाएगा शरीमन अगर अब सरषकि रट 6000 रिय ह और जमीन का

दाम 3000 रिय ह तो हम कस खरीद हम 6000 रिय का दाम दग तो बिक

मनी बनगी और बिक मनी बनगी तो सरकार क तमाम कानन हम िर िगग

पजिापधकारी हर साि सरषकि रट बढ़ा दत ह इसस पकसानो क सामन सबस


34

बड़ी समसया िदा हो गयी ह आज एक पकसान अिना खत बचना चाह तो उसक

खत को सरषकि रट क कारण कोई खरीदन वािा नही ह अगर हम उसको

माकट रट िर ित ह तो तरत इनकम टकस का नोपटस आ जाता ह और उस

बीच की मनी को इनकम म जोड़कर उस िर टकस िगा दत ह और फाइन िगा

दत ह इसस पकसान को बहत िरशानी हो रही ह अगर पकसान को अिनी

जररत क पिए जमीन बचनी ह अगर उस बचच की शादी करनी ह और उसक

िास िसा नही ह सरकार तो उस बचच की शादी करन क पिए िसा दगी नही

कयोपक

शरी सभापवत आि अिना पवषय बताइए(वयवधान)

शरी नरश अगरवाल सर आि सरकार वाि शबद सना मत कपरए वह समझ

िीपजए बरपकट म ह बाकी सब शबद सन िीपजए

(HMS1G िर जारी)

USY-HMS1G1130

शरी नरश अगरवाल (करमागत) यह एक बहत बड़ी समसया इस दश क सामन

खड़ी हो गयी ह महोदय बहत स पकसानो न इस बात को कहा ह और यह बात

सही भी ह इसपिए म चाहगा पक इस बार म सरकार कोई पनषकषर पनकाि



35

कयोपक Income Tax Deparment का आदश बिक मनी को बढ़ावा दन का ह

अगर सरकार बिक मनी को बढ़ावा दना चाहती ह तो म कछ नही कहना

चाहगा िपकन म चाहगा पक इस समसया क समाधान क सबध म सरकार कोई

सटटमट द तो बहत अचछा होगा (समापत)

शरी शमशर ससह ढलो (पजाब) महोदय म माननीय सदसय दवारा उठाए गए इस

पवशष उलिख स सवय को समबदध करता ह

शरी ववशमभर परसाद वनषाद (उततर परदश) महोदय म भी माननीय सदसय दवारा

उठाए गए इस पवशष उलिख स सवय को समबदध करता ह (समापत)

शरी सभापवत अगर कोई पवषय पववाद की ओर जाता ह तो म उस correct

करगा इसका कारण यह ह पक पफर समसया क परपत नयाय नही होगा और

unnecessary पववाद होगा अनयथा मरा कोई सरोकार नही ह

CONCERN OVER QUALITY OF EDUCATION IN COUNTRY

शरी हवरवश (वबहार) सभािपत जी जञान और पशकषा की मपजि चढ़कर दपनया

और मानव समाज आज यहा तक िहचा ह हमार यहा हजारो वषर कहा गया ह

पक पवदवान की िजा सवरतर होती ह जब पक राजा अिन घर कषतर म ही सममान

िाता ह

आज दपनया एक मानव society बनन म मसटकत की राह दख रही ह

िपकन हम न पिछि 40-50 वषो म पशकषा की जो बपनयाद डािी उसका कया

outcome ह मानव ससाधन पवकास मतरािय का National Achievement


36

Survey आया ह जोपक दश क 700 पजिो म 22 िाख छातरो क बीच 11 िाख

सकिो म हआ ह इसका पनषकषर ह पक जस-जस हमार बचच बड़ होत ह गपणत

और भाषा म उनका जञान घटता ह महोदय 17 जनवरी को दशभर म गरामीण

भारत क बचचो क पशकषा सतर िर Annual Status of Education Report 2017

आयी ह पजस का पनषकषर ह पक 14 स 18 वषर क गरामीण पवदयारषथयो क बीच 14

फीसदी छातर भारत का नकशा नही िहचानत 36 परपतशत बचच दश की राजधानी

का नाम नही जानत 21 परपतशत बचच अिन राजय का नाम नही जानत 58

परपतशत बचच भारत क नकश म अिन राजय को नही िहचानत महोदय ऐस

अनक तथय ह ASER की परिोटर 2004 और 2014 म ऐसी ही सटसथपत थी वषर

2014 की परिोटर म दपनया म पशकषापवद क रि म परपसदध शरी माधव परधान न कहा

ह पक 2004 स 2014 क बीच 10 करोड़ बचच पबना गपणत और बपनयादी िढ़ाई

यानी formal reading क पनकि ह

सर हमारी पशकषा िदधपत बहत बरी सटसथपत म ह Narcotics Bureau क 1

जनवरी क सव क अनसार drugs िन वाि छातरो म 15 साि स कम उमर क

बचचो की पहससदारी 12 परपतशत ह एक सपताह िवर कोटा स आयी सचना जोपक

Times of India म परमखता स छिी ह उसम पजिा परशासन की परिोटर ह पक

वहा दशभर स आए आईआईटीआईआईएम का बहतर सिना दखन वाि छातर

drugs और आतमहतया की ओर बढ़ रह ह म ऐस अनक परामापणक तथय उदधत

कर सकता ह महोदय यह मददा उठान क िीछ दो कारण ह - यह मामिा दिो


37

और राजनीपत स ऊिर दश स जड़ा ह हमन पशकषा को भी वोट बक की राजनीपत

स चिाया यह उस का िपरणाम ह मौजदा कनर की सरकार म िीक स हटकर

साहपसक कदम उठान की कषमता और सकलि ह मरा अनरोध ह पक वह इस

सबध म कदम उठाए सभािपत जी म आिक माधयम स कनर सरकार स िन

आगरह करगा पक वह इस पदशा म ठोस समयबदध कदम उठाए और सदन स

आगरह ह पक हम पमिकर सकलि ि पक पशकषा क कषतर म िरान नािदा और

तकषपशिा की तरह िन भारत जञान का कनर बनगा

महोदय अत म कहना चाहगा पक पिछि 4 पदनो स नोपटस द रहा ह मझ

आज जीरो ऑवर म मौका पमिा मरा सदन स आगरह ह पक सदन तय कर पक

हम ऐस मदद बहस क पिए िाए या नही धनयवाद

(समापत)

शरी सभापवत धनयवाद

शरी हसन दलवई महोदय म माननीय सदसय दवारा उठाए गए इस पवशष

उलिख स सवय को समबदध करता ह

शरी रवव परकाश वमा (उततर परदश) महोदय म भी माननीय सदसया दवारा उठाए

गए इस पवशष उलिख स सवय को समबदध करता ह

शरीमती कहकशा परवीन (वबहार) महोदय म भी माननीय सदसय दवारा उठाए

गए इस पवशष उलिख स सवय को समबदध करती ह

(समापत)


38

PATHETIC CONDITION OF COOKS EMPLOYED IN GOVERNMENT

SCHOOLS

शरीमती समपवतया उइक (मधय परदश) सर म गरामीण कषतर क सदर अचि स

आती ह सर पवदयाियो म िढ़ रह दश क भपवषय पवदयारषथयो क पिए जो रसोई

की वयवसथा करत ह उन और रसोइयो की आरषथक सटसथपत ठीक नही ह म

आिक माधयम स सरकार स माग करना चाहती ह पक बड़ शहरो म एनजीओ क

माधयम स हर पवदयािय म भोजन िरोसा जाता ह वकत गरामीण कषतर म सटसथपत यह

ह पक रसोइया जहा िर मधयानह भोजन सचापित करत ह उनक मानदय म

बढ़ोतरी हो यह बात म आिक माधयम स सरकार तक िहचाना चाहती ह दश क

हर कषतर स िगातार यह आवाज व उठात रहत ह

महोदय पजस तरह दश क परधान मतरी दश म नई-नई योजनाओ की

शरआत कर रह ह म चाहगी पक इन का मानदय बढ़ाया जाए तापक व दश क

नव-पनमाण म अिना अमलय योगदान द धनयवाद

(समापत)

शरीमती छाया वमा (छततीसगढ़) महोदय म माननीय सदसया दवारा उठाए गए

इस पवशष उलिख स सवय को समबदध करती ह


39

शरी महनर ससह माहरा (उततराखड) महोदय म भी माननीय सदसया दवारा उठाए


शरी आलोक वतवारी (उततर परदश) महोदय म भी माननीय सदसय दवारा उठाए

गए इस पवशष उलिख स सवय को समबदध करता ह (समापत)

(1 एचएएससी िर आग)

PK-ASC1H1135

DEMAND FOR DECLARING BIRTHDAYS OF SWAMI VIVEKANANDA AND NETAJI SUBHASH CHANDRA BOSE AS NATIONAL HOLIDAYS

शरी वववक गपता (पशशचमी बगाल) महोदय म सबस िहि तो आिका शपिया

अदा करना चाहगा पक आिन मझ जीरो ऑवर म बोिन का मौका पदया सर म

थोड़ा दखी भी ह और थोड़ा गौरवासटनवत भी ह म दखी इसपिए ह पक हमार

बगाि क दो सितो न न कवि भारत म अपित अनतराषिीय सतर िर भारत का

नाम रौशन पकया ह म आज सवामी पववकाननद और सभाष चनर बोस जी क बार

म बात करना चाहता ह

महोदय मरा नाम पववक मर दादा जी न सवामी पववकाननद जी स परपरत

होकर ही रखा था उनहोन राषि क पिए जो कछ भी पकया हम सब उनक बार म

जानत ह इसपिए मझ इसको दोहरान की जररत नही ह यहा तक पक हमार

सममाननीय परधान मतरी जी भी सवामी पववकाननद का अकसर अिन भाषणो म


40

पजि करत रहत ह जब भी उनकी पशकषा को फिान क बार म कोई बात आती

ह तो मझ इस सरकार का रख थोड़ा मायस सा नजर आता ह

महोदय म नताजी सभाष चनर बोस क बार म कहना चाहगा पक उनकी

इपडयन नशनि आमी न भारत की सवततरता क पिए जो कछ पकया उनक इस

योगदान को इपतहास न कभी भी िरी तरह स नही आका ह महोदय म अिनी

बात को कम शबदो म कहना चाहता ह पक हमारी मखय मतरी ममता बनजी न

थोड़ पदन िहि परधान मतरी को एक ितर भी पिखा ह पक इन दोनो महानभावो क

जनमपदवस िर राषिीय अवकाश घोपषत करना चापहए

महोदय म आिक माधयम स सरकार क सामन दो माग रखना चाहता ह

िहिी माग यह ह पक हमारी मखय मतरी न जो ितर पिखा ह उस िर एकशन पिया

जाए और छटटी पडकियर की जाए इसक साथ ही साथ इन दोनो क बार म

पकताबो म जानकारी दी जाए तापक आन वािी िीपढ़यो को इनक और इनक

कायो क बार म जयादा स जयादा जानकारी पमि (समापत)

शरी नीरज शखर (उततर परदश) महोदय माननीय सदसय न जो पवषय उठाया

ह म अिन आिको इसस समबदध करता ह

MR CHAIRMAN Naturally everybody will associate because not only

that they were from Bengal but they represented the entire country

India


41

शरी आलोक वतवारी (उततर परदश) महोदय माननीय सदसया न जो पवषय


शरी सरनर ससह नागर (उततर परदश) महोदय माननीय सदसय न जो पवषय


SHRI SUKHENDU SEKHAR RAY (WEST BENGAL) Sir I also

ssociate myself with the issue raised by the hon Member


myself with the issue raised by the hon Member

SHRIMATI JAYA BACHCHAN (UTTAR PRADESH) Sir I also

associate myself with the issue raised by the hon Member






issue raised by the hon Member

(Ends)


42

DEMAND FOR WITHDRAWING INCREASED EXCISE DUTIES ON PETROL AND DIESEL

SHRI KK RAGESH (KERALA) Sir we are witnessing an

unprecedented price rise of petrol and diesel In many cities petrol

prices have touched Rs80- and more Sir considering this alarming

price rise I demand from the Central Government to withdraw the

excise duties which have been imposed since 2014 Sir I also demand

from the Central Government to take steps to regulate the prices of

petrol and diesel and withdraw the deregulation regime Sir the

Finance Minister in his Budget has made a cut in the excise duties to

the tune of Rs8- But he made it sure that the cut does not pass on

to the consumer by introducing a new road cess of Rs8- Sir what

was the argument while deregulating the prices of petrol and diesel

It was that the prices of petrol and diesel will be decided on the basis

of international prices The price may increase or decrease vis-agrave-vis

the international prices But what is our experience Sir when the

crude oil price rises we see that petrol and diesel prices also rise At

the same time when the crude oil price falls it is not getting shifted to

consumers In 2014 crude oil price was US $ 110 per barrel Now it


43

is only US $ 70 per barrel It has come down to US $ 30 per barrel

But unfortunately the Government is taking it as an opportunity to

increase the excise duty but the benefit of falling prices is not being

shifted to the consumers At the same time Sir as you can see in

2014 the total excise duty imposed on this sector was Rs100000-

crore in 2016-17 it increased to Rs 267 lakh crore and now it has

crossed Rs300000 crore What about the subsidy In 2014 for

diesel Rs92000- crores were earmarked as subsidy for diesel

Now it has also been cut into zero

MR CHAIRMAN What is your suggestion

SHRI KK RAGESH Sir it was the UPA Government that had

initiated the deregulation of petrol At that time they were opposed to

this And now they have deregulated the price of diesel and taken

away the subsidy of Rs92000- crores Moreover they are not

passing the benefit of falling prices of crude oil to the consumers and

hence putting more and more burden on the people So I demand

from the Government to review this policy and withdraw the

deregulation regime Thank you

(Ends)


44

SHRI ANAND SHARMA (HIMACHAL PRADESH) Sir I associate










शरीमती रजनी पाविल (महाराषटर) महोदय माननीय सदसय न जो पवषय उठाया

ह म भी अिन आिको इसस समबदध करती ह

शरी अहमद पिल (गजरात) महोदय माननीय सदसय न जो पवषय उठाया ह म

भी अिन आिको इसस समबदध करता ह

शरी मोतीलाल वोरा (छततीसगढ़) महोदय माननीय सदसय न जो पवषय उठाया





45

डा चनरपाल ससह यादव (उततर परदश) महोदय माननीय सदसय न जो पवषय



issue raised by the hon Member (Ends)

(Followed by PB1J)

LP-PB11401J

CONCERN OVER DEATHS AND DESTRUCTION DUE TO UNDERGROUND FIRE IN KOYALANCHAL JHARKHAND

शरी सजीव कमार (झारखड) सभािपत महोदय 20 जनवरी 2018 को झारखड

कोयिाचि म बीसीसीएि कषतर क पविबरा मसटसजद िटटी क सामन भपमगत आग

स भयानक भ धसान क कारण आग धधक उठी इसस उठी जहरीिी गस स िरा

इिाका ढक गया िोग जान-माि बचान क पिए इधर-उधर भाग पजसस वहा

अफरा-तफरी मच गई 20 जनवरी 2018 को घटी भ -धसान की यह इकिौती

घटना नही ह कोयिाचि म यह आम बात ह हाि ही म 24 माचर 2017 को

झपरया क इपदरा चौक की भ -धसान की घटना एक बाि-बट को पनगि गई

पजनकी िाश भी बरामद नही की जा सकी इसी परकार 20 अगसत 2017

सढवाडीह एव 6 पसतमबर 2017 क ढवाडीह इिाक म भ-धसान की घटना घटी

महोदय कोयिाचि म बरसो स भ -धसान की घटनाए घट रही ह

सकड़ो िोग मार जा चक ह िाखो िोग पवसथापित हो चक ह िरत बीसीसीएि


46

म वयापत भरषटाचार बीसीसीएि ऑपफससर की अिरापधयो ठकदार मापफया स

साठ-गाठ एव ठोस नीपत क अभाव म यह समसया बद स बदतर हो गई ह और

भपमगत आग कोि इपडया एव कोयिाचि की एक बड़ी समसया बनकर रह गई

ह

महोदय म बीसीसीएि अपधकापरयो क भरषटाचार सीबीआई

इनकम-टकस ऑपफससर क साथ इनक गठजोड़ क पवषय म ससद एव सरकार

का धयान आकरषषत करता रहा ह मरी बातो को इस बात स बि पमिगा पक हाि

ही म बीसीसीएि क एक दो मामिो म कछ सीपनयर अपधकापरयो क पखिाफ

चाजरशीट फाइि हो चकी ह सर हाि ही म भपमगत आग का बहाना बनाकर

सरकार न धनबाद चरिरा रि िाइन जो झारखड की िाइििाइन ह को बद

कर पदया तापक कीमती कोयिा पनकाि सक हजारो िोग आदोिन कर रह ह

उस सरपकषत कर रह ह

MR CHAIRMAN Right Thank you

शरी सजीव कमार महोदय जो िोग डजर जोन म रह रह ह उनह सरपकषत

सथानो िर िहचाया जाना चापहए तापक उनकी जान बचाई जा सक

महोदय म ससद का धयान कोयिाचि की भपमगत आग भ -धसान

िोगो की मौत सिपि की कषपत परदषण की ओर आकरषषत करन क अिावा यह

माग भी करता ह पक पजन िोगो की इस भ-धसान क कारण मौत हई ह उनको

मआवजा पदया जाए एव उनक िपरवारो को नौकपरया दी जाए


47

MR CHAIRMAN Thank you

शरी सजीव कमार जो िोग डजर जोन म रहत ह उनह सरपकषत सथानो िर

िहचाया जाए आिका बहत-बहत धनयवाद

MR CHAIRMAN Thank you Shri Sanjiv Kumar (Interruptions)

Please take note There are more names today because during last

three days we could not have the Zero Hour That is why I am trying

to accommodate as many people as possible Conclude in two

minutes only

शरी सजीव कमार सभािपत जी मर िरह सकड बच ह इसपिए म आिको

धनयवाद दना चाहता ह

(समापत)

MR CHAIRMAN Thank you Shrimati Vijila Sathyananth not present

Shrimati Rajani Patil

DEMAND FOR WOMEN EMPOWERMENT BY PASSING WOMEN RESERVATION BILL

शरीमती रजनी पाविल (महाराषटर) सभािपत जी आिका धनयवाद म एक बहत

महतविणर पवषय को यहा उठाना चाहती ह पजसको िकर साढ़ तीन साि तक


48

इस सरकार न हम मपहिाओ को बहत बनान का काम पकया ह (वयवधान)

शरी सभापवत आि ऐसा कयो बोिती ह

शरीमती रजनी पाविल चनावी घोषणा म उनहोन बताया था(वयवधान)

शरी सभापवत जस शबद परयोग नही करन ह Issue issue please

शरीमती रजनी पाविल बोि सकत ह (वयवधान)

शरी सभापवत नही आि अिन पवषय िर आइए यह इतना महतविणर पवषय ह


शरीमती रजनी पाविल चनावी जमिा ह

शरी सभापवत िपकन यह अभी चनावी नही ह यह पवषय बहत महतिणर ह

इसपिए मन सोचकर आिको यह बताया ह

शरीमती रजनी पाविल सभािपत जी यह पवषय बहत महतविणर ह और म आिको

धनयवाद दना चाहती ह पक आिन मझ इस पवषय को उठान की अनमपत दी ह

इस दश की जो आधी आबादी ह जो वहदसतान का आधा आसमान वयापत करती

ह जो ऐसी मपहिाए ह उनको पवधान सभा और िोक सभा म अिना हक़ िान

का िरा अपधकार ह 33 परपतशत reservation for women यह कागरस का

अिना नारा था और इसको िहि स ही मरी िाटी यानी कागरस िाटी और मर

नताओ न आग बढ़ान की कोपशश की ह

-------------------------------



49

महोदय िहिी िोक सभा म जो परपतपनपध 489 जगहो स चनकर आए

थ उनम स पसफर 13 जगहो िर मपहिाए चनकर आई थी 1950 म पवपध मडि

की 3000 जगहो िर जो चनाव हआ था उनम 216 जगहो िर मपहिाओ न चनाव

िड़ा था पजनम स पसफर 82 मपहिाए चनकर आई थी आज क पदन ससद म

पसफर 11 परपतशत मपहिाओ का परमाण ह

सयकत राषि सघ क अनमान क अनसार मपहिा परपतपनपधयो क बार म

वहदसतान 149 व नबर िर आता ह यह नबर मपहिा परपतपनपधयो क बार म पदया

गया ह जो पक िड़ोसी दशो बगिादश और िापकसतान स भी नीच ह

सभािपत महोदय िाशचातय दशो की तिना म हमारी मपहिाए

हमशा जापत वगर धमर परात िहराब पशकषण गरीबी इन सबस बट गई ह

(1KKLG िर जारी)

KLG-SKC1K1145

शरीमती रजनी पाविल (करमागत) सरोपजनी नायड जी जो उस समय एक बहत

बड़ी नतरी थी उनहोन मपहिाओ का एक परपतपनपध-मडि तयार करक ततकािीन

सपचव माटगय को अिना परपतवदन पदया था िपकन वह माग नही मानी गयी

माटगय की जो पसफापरश थी जो 1919 म कानन बना उसम मतदान क अपधकार

स भी मपहिाओ को दर रखा गया था इस पनणरय का पवरोध तब सव मोतीिाि

जी नहर न पकया था और आशा वयकत कर दी थी पक एक न एक पदन जरर

मपहिाओ को मतदान करन का अिना हक पमिगा घटनाकार डा बाबा साहब


50

अमबडकर जी न सपवधान क तहत हम यह अपधकार द पदया पक मपहिाए भी

मतदान कर सकती ह पफर 1990 म सव राजीव गाधी जी जो इस दश क हमार

जो पवजनरी परधान मतरी थ उनहोन िचायत राज क तहत सपवधान क अनचछद

73व और 74व म घटना दरसती करक अिना अपधकार द पदया और उसक

अनसार हम राजनीपत म भी शापमि कर पदया

महोदय म पसफर यही माग करना चाहती ह पक 8 माचर नजदीक आ रहा

ह और हाि ही म सोपनया गाधी जी न परधान मतरी जी को िटर पिखा पक

मपहिाओ को 33 िरसट परजवशन पदया जाए तो 8 माचर क िहि इसका पनणरय

हो जाए

(समापत)

शरी सभापवत थक य रजनी जी आिका समय हो गया

शरीमती छाया वमा (छततीसगढ़) महोदय म सवय को इस पवषय स सबदध करती

ह

शरी हसन दलवई (महाराषटर) महोदय म भी सवय को इस पवषय स सबदध करता

ह

शरीमती ववपलव ठाकर (वहमाचल परदश) महोदय म भी सवय को इस पवषय स

सबदध करती ह

शरी परदीप िमिा (उततराखड) महोदय म भी सवय को इस पवषय स सबदध करता

ह


51

शरी महनर ससह माहरा (उततराखड) महोदय म भी सवय को इस पवषय स सबदध

करता ह

SHRIMATI RENUKA CHOWDHURY (ANDHRA PRADESH) Sir I too

associate myself with the matter raised by the hon Member

SHRIMATI WANSUK SYIEM (MEGHALAYA) Sir I too associate

myself with the matter raised by the hon Member

SOME HON MEMBERS Sir we too associate ourselves with the


(Ends)

शरी सभापवत ठीक ह ऑि एसोपसएट आि मपहिाए इतना अचछा बोिती ह

जब आिको मौका पमिता ह िपकन आिको बीच म राजनीपत म नही िड़ना ह

अदरवाइज बपढ़या इशय ह This is a challenge before the entire nation

We have all made a commitment We must honour it at the earliest

Now Shri Sanjay Singh (Interruptions) Please dont make a

running commentary

PROBLEMS BEING FACED BY DELHI BUSINESSMEN DUE TO SEALING

शरी सजय ससह (राषटरीय राजधानी कषतर वदलली) धनयवाद सभािपत महोदय म

आिका आभार वयकत करता ह पक आिन मझ सीविग जस गभीर मदद िर अिनी


52

बात कहन का अवसर पदया दश की राजधानी पदलिी म आिात-सटसथपत िदा हो

गई ह पिछि कछ पदनो स सीविग का कहर वयािापरयो िर बरिाया जा रहा ह

पदलिी क सात िाख वयािापरयो िर सीविग का कहर बरिाया जा रहा ह जब म

सात िाख वयािापरयो की बात कर रहा ह तो पसफर सात िाख वयािारी िोग ही

परभापवत नही ह उनकी दकानो िर काम करन वाि कमरचारी भी ह उनकी

दकानो िर मजदरी करन वाि मजदर भी ह उनकी दकानो स सामान उठा कर

दसरी दकानो तक िहचान वाि परकश वाि भी ह और आसिास क दकानदार भी

ह उनकी दकानो को सीविग क जपरए तबाह और बरबाद पकया जा रहा ह एक

अखबार म उसकी परिोपटिग ह पक पदलिी क वयािापरयो न चार हजार करोड़

रिए कनवजरन चाजज जमा पकय ह उसक बावजद उनकी दकानो को सीि

पकया जा रहा ह मनमान ढग स सीविग का कहर पदलिी क अदर बरिाया जा

रहा ह

सर म एक घटना बताऊगा पक पदलिी म एक इिाका कसतरबा नगर

ह उस इिाक म एक वयािारी न डढ़ करोड़ रिए कनवजरन चाजज क जमा पकय

थ उसक बावजद उसकी दकान सीि कर दी गई पदलिी क अदर जो मगिो क

जमान स अगरजो क जमान स बाजार ह चाह वह चादनी चौक का बाजार हो

चाह वह चावड़ी बाजार हो चाह वह गाधी नगर माकट हो चाह वह सदर बाजार

हो उन बाजारो को भी सीि पकया जा रहा ह हम सभी िोग पदलिी म रहत ह

कनर की सरकार पदलिी म रहती ह हमार परधान मतरी जी पदलिी म रहत ह इस


53

सदन क हमार तमाम माननीय सदसय पदलिी म रहत ह हम िोग पदलिी का

नमक खात ह इसपिए म पवनमरतािवरक सरकार स अनरोध करना चाहता ह

आिक माधयम स पनवदन करना चाहता ह पक सीविग क कहर को रोकन का

काम कर अगर यह सरकार जलिीकटटी तयोहार िर सपरीम कोटर क फसि को

बदि सकती ह तो एक महतविणर पबि सदन म िाकर इस सीविग िर भी रोक

िगाई जाए वयािापरयो को राहत िहचाई जाए पदलिी क अदर आज पजस

परकार स वयािापरयो का उतिीड़न पकया जा रहा ह म आिक माधयम स िछना

चाहता ह पक सरकार की इन वयािापरयो स कया दशमनी ह िहि नोटबदी िाती

ह पफर जीएसटी िकर आत ह

MR CHAIRMAN All right Mr Sanjay Singh

Please(Interruptions) अभी वह पवषय नही ह आिन सीविग क बार म

बात करनी ह

शरी सजय ससह आज वयािापरयो का जो वयािार ह उसको चौिट करन क पिए

सीविग की जा रही ह

MR CHAIRMAN Please Shri Vijayasai Reddy (Interruptions) यह

परकॉडर म नही जा रहा ह (वयवधान)

शरी सजय ससह सर मरा समय ह (समापत)

-----------------

Not recorded


54

शरी सभापवत यह परकॉडर म नही जा रहा ह मन दो पमनट पदए ह To

accommodate maximum number of people the time has been

reduced to two minutes I have said so already Please conclude

(Interruptions)

SHRIMATI AMBIKA SONI (PUNJAB) Sir I associate myself with the


शरीमती छाया वमा (छततीसगढ़) महोदय म भी सवय को इस पवषय स सबदध

करती ह



डा सशील गपता (राषटरीय राजधानी कषतर वदलली) महोदय म भी सवय को इस

पवषय स सबदध करता ह

KUMARI SELJA (HARYANA) Sir I too associate myself with the




SHRI BK HARIPRASAD (KARNATAKA) Sir I too associate myself

with the matter raised by the hon Member


55

SHRI BHUBANESWAR KALITA (ASSAM) Sir I too associate myself




(Ends)

MR CHAIRMAN Shri Vijayasai Reddy please (Interruptions) I

have got names of 17 more Members That is my problem

(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150

NEED FOR RECOGNISING DOCTOR OF PHARMACY GRADUATES AS MEDICAL PRACTIONERS

SHRI V VIJAYASAI REDDY (ANDHRA PRADESH) Sir Doctor of

Pharmacy popularly known as PharmD is a six-year doctoral course

It was introduced in India in 2008 by the Pharmacy Council of India

Ten years are over since introducing the course The objective of the

Doctor of Pharmacy is to provide rationalized therapy to the patients

and improve the quality of therapy and patients life Sir this particular


56

course has got three phases The first phase is academic In the

academics they deal with the study of anatomy pathology

pharmacology therapeutics medical chemistry and bio-chemistry of

human body In the second phase it is one-year internship where

students undergo training relating to clinical pharmacy services and

critical evaluation In the third phase the students are trained in the

general medicine for six months These are all the three phases which

they undergo during the six years The objective behind framing of this

kind of syllabus is that PharmD graduates learn to treat framed

therapy for very basic illness Sir in fact after seeing the academics

initially the course should have been recognized by the Medical

Council of India not the Pharmacy Council of India Sir for better

future of about 20000 PharmD graduates and students I request the

hon Minister for Health amp Family Welfare to recognize PharmD

graduates as Clinical Pharmacists In fact a Starred Question came

yesterday but the House could not sit To that Starred Question the

hon Minister has responded and agreed to recognize PharmD

graduates as Clinical Pharmacists But my request to the hon Minister

is -- there is only one request which he has not addressed in the


57

Starred Question -- since many MBBS doctors are not willing to go to

the rural areas and serve the patients these PharmD graduates can

be sent to the rural areas and asked to serve in the rural areas and can

be conferred with the MBBS after completion of the fixed tenure

Thank you (Ends)

MR CHAIRMAN Now Shri Pramod Tiwari not present Dr T

Subbarami Reddy you have two minutes

DR T SUBBARAMI REDDY Sir I want three minutes

MR CHAIRMAN No two minutes only Others also have to be given

time Moreover no Member can raise two issues separately

CONCERN OVER MISSING OF OIL TANKER WITH 22 INDIAN SAILORS AT COAST OF BENIN WEST AFRICA

DR T SUBBARAMI REDDY (ANDHRA PRADESH) Sir even after

five days of the missing of oil tanker with 22 Indian sailors on board

there is no trace of this merchant ship which lost its contact at Benin

West Africa No contact has been established with the vessel so far

and there have been no reports of a ransom call


58

Sir it is suspected that the Marine Express carrying 13500 tonne

of gasoline may have been hijacked by pirates in the pirate-infested

Gulf of Guinea According to the Shipping Ministry all communication

with the vessel has been lost The Ministry of External Affairs said that

the Indian Mission in Abuja is in touch with authorities in Nigeria and

Benin

Worried relatives of these crew members have sought the help of

the Ministry of Shipping This is the second ship to go missing in the

last one month In January another vessel had gone missing off the

coast and later it was released after reportedly paying ransom

I request the Government of India to take up the matter very

seriously with the authorities in Nigeria and Benin and to closely

monitor the situation They should get in touch with their counterparts

in Nigeria

Sir international authorities like International Maritime Bureaus

Anti Piracy Reporting Centre should also be involved to find out the

fate of the vessel and to ensure the safety of Indian crew members I

request the Government to extend all help in this regard and make a

statement on this issue in Parliament at the earliest (Ends)


59

MR CHAIRMAN Now Shri Partap Singh Bajwa not present

SHRI PRAMOD TIWARI Sir I am here

MR CHAIRMAN You are not Partap Singh Bajwa I know you

personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M

MR CHAIRMAN (CONTD) I called you You were not there You

came back I noticed that You will get your turn once the roster is

over Now Shrimati Sasikala Pushpa

DEMAND FOR DECLARING TAMIL AS OFFICIAL LANGUAGE OF MADRAS HIGH COURT

SHRIMATI SASIKALA PUSHPA (TAMIL NADU) Sir I wish to speak

about a very important issue Recently the Central Government

through the Law Ministry rejected the demand of Tamil Nadu for using

our own language Tamil in the Madras High Court proceedings as the

Official Language

We speak more about co-operative federalism but it is very

unfortunate that in true spirit where are we In 1997 1999 and 2006

also the Tamil Nadu State Legislative Assembly passed a Resolution


60

and forwarded it for the approval of the hon President But in 2018

now replying to my Parliament Question the Ministry of Law and

Justice stated that the Supreme Court has decided not to accede to

the proposal

Sir in Article 348 clause (2) it is clearly stated that the

Governor of a State may with the previous consent of the President

authorise the use of Hindi language or any other language used for

any official purposes of the State in proceedings in the High Court

having its principal seat in that State When the Constitution itself

allows this why has my peoples right to know what is happening in

our High Court been denied Sir I would like to ask the Law Ministry

in which way Tamil which is our goddess and the first language of the

world is considered to be inferior to any other language of the world

Sir Thirukkural and many other Tamil literatures shaped the ethical and

moral values of the people of the whole world What is stopping BJP

from promoting my own language in my own State Sir it is an insult

not only to the Tamil people but also to the whole country because

Singapore and Sri Lanka allow their citizens to use Tamil as official

language Therefore I would request the Government to reconsider


61

the Resolution sent by the Tamil Nadu State Legislative Assembly Our

hon Amma also then and there insisted on this issue that is use of

Tamil language in the proceedings of Madras High Court Kindly

reconsider this issue and do justice to the Tamil people Thank you

(Ends)

SHRI TK RANGARAJAN (TAMIL NADU) Sir I associate myself with

the matter raised by Shrimati Sasikala Pushpa

SHRI D RAJA (TAMIL NADU) Sir I also associate myself with the

matter raised by Shrimati Sasikala Pushpa

SHRI K RAHMAN KHAN (KARNATAKA) Sir I also associate myself

with the matter raised by Shrimati Sasikala Pushpa

SHRI BK HARIPRASAD (KARNATAKA) Sir I also associate myself



associate myself with the matter raised by Shrimati Sasikala Pushpa

SHRI KK RAGESH (KERALA) Sir I also associate myself with the


SHRI PRAMOD TIWARI (UTTAR PRADESH) Sir I also associate

myself with the matter raised by Shrimati Sasikala Pushpa


62



शरी सभापवत यह एक आदशर सटसथपत होगी जब हरक हाई कोटर म िोग अिनी

सथानीय भाषा म ही बोि सक ग अिना कस परजट कर सक ग और जजमट भी आ

सकगी यह एक आदशर सटसथपत होगी This will be an ideal situation if the

country moves in that direction For that there has to be broad

consensus and everybody should agree for the same

SHRI BHUBANESWAR KALITA Sir the Guwahati High Court is the

High Court for seven States Which language will be the Official

Language there

MR CHAIRMAN The North-East is a different case but I am saying

that by and large to the extent possible the people should know what

the advocate is arguing

SHRI LA GANESAN This spirit should be supported

(Ends)

MR CHAIRMAN Yes thats right Now Shri PL Punia िपनया जी

आिक िास टाइम कम ह इसपिए थोड़ा जलदी अिनी बात खतम कीपजएगा


63

DEMAND FOR LISTING SCST (RESERVATION IN POSTS AND SERVICES) BILL 2008 IN CURRENT SESSION AND

GETTING IT PASSED

शरी पीएल पवनया (उततर परदश) सभािपत जी म आिका आभारी ह आिन

मझ दपित समाज स जड़ एक महतविणर पवषय िर बोिन का मौका पदया

अनसपचत जापत जनजापत क कलयाण स सबपधत अनक पबि िारषियामट म

िसटमबत ह चार वषर स अपधक समय स the Scheduled Castes and

Scheduled Tribes (Reservation in Posts and Services) Bill 2008 राजय

सभा म िास होन क बाद िोक सभा म िसटमबत ह कछ सशोधनो क साथ यह

पबि िोक सभा म िास होना था िपकन पिछि कई वषो स कनर सरकार न इस

महतविणर पबि िर पवचार करन हत िोक सभा की कायरसची म अभी तक

ससटममपित नही पकया ह इसक अिावा SCST Reservation in Promotion Bill

और मिा ढोन की परथा िर ततकाि रोक िगान वािा पबि एव अनय कई पबि

िारषियामट म िसटमबत ह पजनको राजय सभा क माधयम स ततकाि पिया जाना

चापहए

माननीय सभािपत जी मरा आिस अनरोध ह पक हर महतविणर पबि को

शीघर स शीघर िास करवान हत आवशयक कदम उठाए जाए तथा the

Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Reservation in Posts and

Services) Bill 2008 को वतरमान सतर की कायरसची म ससटममपित करक िास


64

करवाया जाए म माननीय परधान मतरी जी स भी इस महतविणर पवषय िर हसतकषि

करक पबि को िास करवान क पिए पराथपमकता हत अनरोध करता ह

(समापत)

शरी हसन दलवई (महाराषटर) महोदय म माननीय सदसय दवारा उठाए गए पवषय

स सवय को समबदध करता ह

शरी शमशर ससह ढलो (पजाब) महोदय म भी माननीय सदसय दवारा उठाए गए

पवषय स सवय को समबदध करता ह

शरीमती छाया वमा (छततीसगढ़) महोदय म भी माननीय सदसय दवारा उठाए गए

पवषय स सवय को समबदध करती ह

(समापत)

MR CHAIRMAN Now Shri CP Narayanan Narayananji time is

over

(Followed by 1N ndash GSP)


2

II A copy each (in English and Hindi) of the following papersmdash

(i) (a) Annual Report and Accounts of the Sports Authority of India (SAI) New Delhi for the year 2015-16 together with the Auditors Report on the Accounts

(b) Review by Government on the working of the above Authority

(c) Statement giving reasons for the delay in laying the papers mentioned at (i) (a) above

(ii) (a) Annual Report and Accounts of the Indian Institute of Mass Communication (IIMC) New Delhi for the year 2016-17 together with the Auditors Report on the Accounts

(b) Review by Government on the working of the above Institute

(c) Statement giving reasons for the delay in laying the papers mentioned at (ii) (a) above

SHRI KIREN RIJIJU Sir I lay on the Tablemdash

I A copy (in English and Hindi) of the Ministry of Home Affairs Notification No GSR 389 dated the November 19 2017- November 25 2017 (weekly Gazette) publishing the Assam Rifles Para Medical Staff Group ―C Combatised Posts Recruitment Rules 2017 under Section 167 of the Assam Rifles Act 2006

II A copy (in English and Hindi) of the Ministry of Home Affairs Notification No GSR 41 dated the 18th January 2018 publishing the National Fire Service College Nagpur Professor Associate Professor


3









4


(Ends)






(Ends)






December 2017


5





(Ends)


6




















7




(Interruptions)
















8







(Followed by 1BRSS)

NKR-RSS1B1105








has come Okay


9







पहससा ि














10














(समापत)






11













12
















13












(Followed by 1cKGG)

KGG-DS1C1110






14



hon Member












MR CHAIRMAN Yes



(Interruptions)



15





















16






Everybody is saying











--------------------------------- Not recorded


17














Thank you

(Ends)

(Followed by KLS1D)


18

MCM-KLS1D1115

















19













(Interruptions)








20




(Interruptions)

















21














(Interruptions)






22



SSS-SC1E1120










SHRI ANAND SHARMA





Not recorded


23


















24





(Interruptions)







from the record








25














afterwards





(Interruptions)


26





(Interruptions)






me (Interruptions)


(Interruptions)






(समापत)


27




















28


Shri Manish Gupta

(Contd by NBR1F)

-SSSNBR-GS1F1125










(Interruptions)



already told you




29










manually serviced











30














Thank you

(Ends)




31





(Ends)
















32

















Gupta




33





(Ends)















34








कयोपक





USY-HMS1G1130






35
















िाता ह





36





















37











(समापत)








(समापत)


38


SCHOOLS












(समापत)




39






PK-ASC1H1135













40


















India


41

















(Ends)


42




















43



















(Ends)


44




















45





(Followed by PB1J)

LP-PB11401J














46




ह

















47








minutes only



(समापत)







48


















-------------------------------



49












KLG-SKC1K1145









50









हो जाए

(समापत)



ह


ह




ह


51


करता ह







(Ends)






running commentary





52












रहा ह









53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



3









4


(Ends)






(Ends)






December 2017


5





(Ends)


6




















7




(Interruptions)
















8







(Followed by 1BRSS)

NKR-RSS1B1105








has come Okay


9







पहससा ि














10














(समापत)






11













12
















13












(Followed by 1cKGG)

KGG-DS1C1110






14



hon Member












MR CHAIRMAN Yes



(Interruptions)



15





















16






Everybody is saying











--------------------------------- Not recorded


17














Thank you

(Ends)

(Followed by KLS1D)


18

MCM-KLS1D1115

















19













(Interruptions)








20




(Interruptions)

















21














(Interruptions)






22



SSS-SC1E1120










SHRI ANAND SHARMA





Not recorded


23


















24





(Interruptions)







from the record








25














afterwards





(Interruptions)


26





(Interruptions)






me (Interruptions)


(Interruptions)






(समापत)


27




















28


Shri Manish Gupta

(Contd by NBR1F)

-SSSNBR-GS1F1125










(Interruptions)



already told you




29










manually serviced











30














Thank you

(Ends)




31





(Ends)
















32

















Gupta




33





(Ends)















34








कयोपक





USY-HMS1G1130






35
















िाता ह





36





















37











(समापत)








(समापत)


38


SCHOOLS












(समापत)




39






PK-ASC1H1135













40


















India


41

















(Ends)


42




















43



















(Ends)


44




















45





(Followed by PB1J)

LP-PB11401J














46




ह

















47








minutes only



(समापत)







48


















-------------------------------



49












KLG-SKC1K1145









50









हो जाए

(समापत)



ह


ह




ह


51


करता ह







(Ends)






running commentary





52












रहा ह









53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



4


(Ends)






(Ends)






December 2017


5





(Ends)


6




















7




(Interruptions)
















8







(Followed by 1BRSS)

NKR-RSS1B1105








has come Okay


9







पहससा ि














10














(समापत)






11













12
















13












(Followed by 1cKGG)

KGG-DS1C1110






14



hon Member












MR CHAIRMAN Yes



(Interruptions)



15





















16






Everybody is saying











--------------------------------- Not recorded


17














Thank you

(Ends)

(Followed by KLS1D)


18

MCM-KLS1D1115

















19













(Interruptions)








20




(Interruptions)

















21














(Interruptions)






22



SSS-SC1E1120










SHRI ANAND SHARMA





Not recorded


23


















24





(Interruptions)







from the record








25














afterwards





(Interruptions)


26





(Interruptions)






me (Interruptions)


(Interruptions)






(समापत)


27




















28


Shri Manish Gupta

(Contd by NBR1F)

-SSSNBR-GS1F1125










(Interruptions)



already told you




29










manually serviced











30














Thank you

(Ends)




31





(Ends)
















32

















Gupta




33





(Ends)















34








कयोपक





USY-HMS1G1130






35
















िाता ह





36





















37











(समापत)








(समापत)


38


SCHOOLS












(समापत)




39






PK-ASC1H1135













40


















India


41

















(Ends)


42




















43



















(Ends)


44




















45





(Followed by PB1J)

LP-PB11401J














46




ह

















47








minutes only



(समापत)







48


















-------------------------------



49












KLG-SKC1K1145









50









हो जाए

(समापत)



ह


ह




ह


51


करता ह







(Ends)






running commentary





52












रहा ह









53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



5





(Ends)


6




















7




(Interruptions)
















8







(Followed by 1BRSS)

NKR-RSS1B1105








has come Okay


9







पहससा ि














10














(समापत)






11













12
















13












(Followed by 1cKGG)

KGG-DS1C1110






14



hon Member












MR CHAIRMAN Yes



(Interruptions)



15





















16






Everybody is saying











--------------------------------- Not recorded


17














Thank you

(Ends)

(Followed by KLS1D)


18

MCM-KLS1D1115

















19













(Interruptions)








20




(Interruptions)

















21














(Interruptions)






22



SSS-SC1E1120










SHRI ANAND SHARMA





Not recorded


23


















24





(Interruptions)







from the record








25














afterwards





(Interruptions)


26





(Interruptions)






me (Interruptions)


(Interruptions)






(समापत)


27




















28


Shri Manish Gupta

(Contd by NBR1F)

-SSSNBR-GS1F1125










(Interruptions)



already told you




29










manually serviced











30














Thank you

(Ends)




31





(Ends)
















32

















Gupta




33





(Ends)















34








कयोपक





USY-HMS1G1130






35
















िाता ह





36





















37











(समापत)








(समापत)


38


SCHOOLS












(समापत)




39






PK-ASC1H1135













40


















India


41

















(Ends)


42




















43



















(Ends)


44




















45





(Followed by PB1J)

LP-PB11401J














46




ह

















47








minutes only



(समापत)







48


















-------------------------------



49












KLG-SKC1K1145









50









हो जाए

(समापत)



ह


ह




ह


51


करता ह







(Ends)






running commentary





52












रहा ह









53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



6




















7




(Interruptions)
















8







(Followed by 1BRSS)

NKR-RSS1B1105








has come Okay


9







पहससा ि














10














(समापत)






11













12
















13












(Followed by 1cKGG)

KGG-DS1C1110






14



hon Member












MR CHAIRMAN Yes



(Interruptions)



15





















16






Everybody is saying











--------------------------------- Not recorded


17














Thank you

(Ends)

(Followed by KLS1D)


18

MCM-KLS1D1115

















19













(Interruptions)








20




(Interruptions)

















21














(Interruptions)






22



SSS-SC1E1120










SHRI ANAND SHARMA





Not recorded


23


















24





(Interruptions)







from the record








25














afterwards





(Interruptions)


26





(Interruptions)






me (Interruptions)


(Interruptions)






(समापत)


27




















28


Shri Manish Gupta

(Contd by NBR1F)

-SSSNBR-GS1F1125










(Interruptions)



already told you




29










manually serviced











30














Thank you

(Ends)




31





(Ends)
















32

















Gupta




33





(Ends)















34








कयोपक





USY-HMS1G1130






35
















िाता ह





36





















37











(समापत)








(समापत)


38


SCHOOLS












(समापत)




39






PK-ASC1H1135













40


















India


41

















(Ends)


42




















43



















(Ends)


44




















45





(Followed by PB1J)

LP-PB11401J














46




ह

















47








minutes only



(समापत)







48


















-------------------------------



49












KLG-SKC1K1145









50









हो जाए

(समापत)



ह


ह




ह


51


करता ह







(Ends)






running commentary





52












रहा ह









53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



7




(Interruptions)
















8







(Followed by 1BRSS)

NKR-RSS1B1105








has come Okay


9







पहससा ि














10














(समापत)






11













12
















13












(Followed by 1cKGG)

KGG-DS1C1110






14



hon Member












MR CHAIRMAN Yes



(Interruptions)



15





















16






Everybody is saying











--------------------------------- Not recorded


17














Thank you

(Ends)

(Followed by KLS1D)


18

MCM-KLS1D1115

















19













(Interruptions)








20




(Interruptions)

















21














(Interruptions)






22



SSS-SC1E1120










SHRI ANAND SHARMA





Not recorded


23


















24





(Interruptions)







from the record








25














afterwards





(Interruptions)


26





(Interruptions)






me (Interruptions)


(Interruptions)






(समापत)


27




















28


Shri Manish Gupta

(Contd by NBR1F)

-SSSNBR-GS1F1125










(Interruptions)



already told you




29










manually serviced











30














Thank you

(Ends)




31





(Ends)
















32

















Gupta




33





(Ends)















34








कयोपक





USY-HMS1G1130






35
















िाता ह





36





















37











(समापत)








(समापत)


38


SCHOOLS












(समापत)




39






PK-ASC1H1135













40


















India


41

















(Ends)


42




















43



















(Ends)


44




















45





(Followed by PB1J)

LP-PB11401J














46




ह

















47








minutes only



(समापत)







48


















-------------------------------



49












KLG-SKC1K1145









50









हो जाए

(समापत)



ह


ह




ह


51


करता ह







(Ends)






running commentary





52












रहा ह









53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



8







(Followed by 1BRSS)

NKR-RSS1B1105








has come Okay


9







पहससा ि














10














(समापत)






11













12
















13












(Followed by 1cKGG)

KGG-DS1C1110






14



hon Member












MR CHAIRMAN Yes



(Interruptions)



15





















16






Everybody is saying











--------------------------------- Not recorded


17














Thank you

(Ends)

(Followed by KLS1D)


18

MCM-KLS1D1115

















19













(Interruptions)








20




(Interruptions)

















21














(Interruptions)






22



SSS-SC1E1120










SHRI ANAND SHARMA





Not recorded


23


















24





(Interruptions)







from the record








25














afterwards





(Interruptions)


26





(Interruptions)






me (Interruptions)


(Interruptions)






(समापत)


27




















28


Shri Manish Gupta

(Contd by NBR1F)

-SSSNBR-GS1F1125










(Interruptions)



already told you




29










manually serviced











30














Thank you

(Ends)




31





(Ends)
















32

















Gupta




33





(Ends)















34








कयोपक





USY-HMS1G1130






35
















िाता ह





36





















37











(समापत)








(समापत)


38


SCHOOLS












(समापत)




39






PK-ASC1H1135













40


















India


41

















(Ends)


42




















43



















(Ends)


44




















45





(Followed by PB1J)

LP-PB11401J














46




ह

















47








minutes only



(समापत)







48


















-------------------------------



49












KLG-SKC1K1145









50









हो जाए

(समापत)



ह


ह




ह


51


करता ह







(Ends)






running commentary





52












रहा ह









53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



9







पहससा ि














10














(समापत)






11













12
















13












(Followed by 1cKGG)

KGG-DS1C1110






14



hon Member












MR CHAIRMAN Yes



(Interruptions)



15





















16






Everybody is saying











--------------------------------- Not recorded


17














Thank you

(Ends)

(Followed by KLS1D)


18

MCM-KLS1D1115

















19













(Interruptions)








20




(Interruptions)

















21














(Interruptions)






22



SSS-SC1E1120










SHRI ANAND SHARMA





Not recorded


23


















24





(Interruptions)







from the record








25














afterwards





(Interruptions)


26





(Interruptions)






me (Interruptions)


(Interruptions)






(समापत)


27




















28


Shri Manish Gupta

(Contd by NBR1F)

-SSSNBR-GS1F1125










(Interruptions)



already told you




29










manually serviced











30














Thank you

(Ends)




31





(Ends)
















32

















Gupta




33





(Ends)















34








कयोपक





USY-HMS1G1130






35
















िाता ह





36





















37











(समापत)








(समापत)


38


SCHOOLS












(समापत)




39






PK-ASC1H1135













40


















India


41

















(Ends)


42




















43



















(Ends)


44




















45





(Followed by PB1J)

LP-PB11401J














46




ह

















47








minutes only



(समापत)







48


















-------------------------------



49












KLG-SKC1K1145









50









हो जाए

(समापत)



ह


ह




ह


51


करता ह







(Ends)






running commentary





52












रहा ह









53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



10














(समापत)






11













12
















13












(Followed by 1cKGG)

KGG-DS1C1110






14



hon Member












MR CHAIRMAN Yes



(Interruptions)



15





















16






Everybody is saying











--------------------------------- Not recorded


17














Thank you

(Ends)

(Followed by KLS1D)


18

MCM-KLS1D1115

















19













(Interruptions)








20




(Interruptions)

















21














(Interruptions)






22



SSS-SC1E1120










SHRI ANAND SHARMA





Not recorded


23


















24





(Interruptions)







from the record








25














afterwards





(Interruptions)


26





(Interruptions)






me (Interruptions)


(Interruptions)






(समापत)


27




















28


Shri Manish Gupta

(Contd by NBR1F)

-SSSNBR-GS1F1125










(Interruptions)



already told you




29










manually serviced











30














Thank you

(Ends)




31





(Ends)
















32

















Gupta




33





(Ends)















34








कयोपक





USY-HMS1G1130






35
















िाता ह





36





















37











(समापत)








(समापत)


38


SCHOOLS












(समापत)




39






PK-ASC1H1135













40


















India


41

















(Ends)


42




















43



















(Ends)


44




















45





(Followed by PB1J)

LP-PB11401J














46




ह

















47








minutes only



(समापत)







48


















-------------------------------



49












KLG-SKC1K1145









50









हो जाए

(समापत)



ह


ह




ह


51


करता ह







(Ends)






running commentary





52












रहा ह









53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



11













12
















13












(Followed by 1cKGG)

KGG-DS1C1110






14



hon Member












MR CHAIRMAN Yes



(Interruptions)



15





















16






Everybody is saying











--------------------------------- Not recorded


17














Thank you

(Ends)

(Followed by KLS1D)


18

MCM-KLS1D1115

















19













(Interruptions)








20




(Interruptions)

















21














(Interruptions)






22



SSS-SC1E1120










SHRI ANAND SHARMA





Not recorded


23


















24





(Interruptions)







from the record








25














afterwards





(Interruptions)


26





(Interruptions)






me (Interruptions)


(Interruptions)






(समापत)


27




















28


Shri Manish Gupta

(Contd by NBR1F)

-SSSNBR-GS1F1125










(Interruptions)



already told you




29










manually serviced











30














Thank you

(Ends)




31





(Ends)
















32

















Gupta




33





(Ends)















34








कयोपक





USY-HMS1G1130






35
















िाता ह





36





















37











(समापत)








(समापत)


38


SCHOOLS












(समापत)




39






PK-ASC1H1135













40


















India


41

















(Ends)


42




















43



















(Ends)


44




















45





(Followed by PB1J)

LP-PB11401J














46




ह

















47








minutes only



(समापत)







48


















-------------------------------



49












KLG-SKC1K1145









50









हो जाए

(समापत)



ह


ह




ह


51


करता ह







(Ends)






running commentary





52












रहा ह









53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



12
















13












(Followed by 1cKGG)

KGG-DS1C1110






14



hon Member












MR CHAIRMAN Yes



(Interruptions)



15





















16






Everybody is saying











--------------------------------- Not recorded


17














Thank you

(Ends)

(Followed by KLS1D)


18

MCM-KLS1D1115

















19













(Interruptions)








20




(Interruptions)

















21














(Interruptions)






22



SSS-SC1E1120










SHRI ANAND SHARMA





Not recorded


23


















24





(Interruptions)







from the record








25














afterwards





(Interruptions)


26





(Interruptions)






me (Interruptions)


(Interruptions)






(समापत)


27




















28


Shri Manish Gupta

(Contd by NBR1F)

-SSSNBR-GS1F1125










(Interruptions)



already told you




29










manually serviced











30














Thank you

(Ends)




31





(Ends)
















32

















Gupta




33





(Ends)















34








कयोपक





USY-HMS1G1130






35
















िाता ह





36





















37











(समापत)








(समापत)


38


SCHOOLS












(समापत)




39






PK-ASC1H1135













40


















India


41

















(Ends)


42




















43



















(Ends)


44




















45





(Followed by PB1J)

LP-PB11401J














46




ह

















47








minutes only



(समापत)







48


















-------------------------------



49












KLG-SKC1K1145









50









हो जाए

(समापत)



ह


ह




ह


51


करता ह







(Ends)






running commentary





52












रहा ह









53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



13












(Followed by 1cKGG)

KGG-DS1C1110






14



hon Member












MR CHAIRMAN Yes



(Interruptions)



15





















16






Everybody is saying











--------------------------------- Not recorded


17














Thank you

(Ends)

(Followed by KLS1D)


18

MCM-KLS1D1115

















19













(Interruptions)








20




(Interruptions)

















21














(Interruptions)






22



SSS-SC1E1120










SHRI ANAND SHARMA





Not recorded


23


















24





(Interruptions)







from the record








25














afterwards





(Interruptions)


26





(Interruptions)






me (Interruptions)


(Interruptions)






(समापत)


27




















28


Shri Manish Gupta

(Contd by NBR1F)

-SSSNBR-GS1F1125










(Interruptions)



already told you




29










manually serviced











30














Thank you

(Ends)




31





(Ends)
















32

















Gupta




33





(Ends)















34








कयोपक





USY-HMS1G1130






35
















िाता ह





36





















37











(समापत)








(समापत)


38


SCHOOLS












(समापत)




39






PK-ASC1H1135













40


















India


41

















(Ends)


42




















43



















(Ends)


44




















45





(Followed by PB1J)

LP-PB11401J














46




ह

















47








minutes only



(समापत)







48


















-------------------------------



49












KLG-SKC1K1145









50









हो जाए

(समापत)



ह


ह




ह


51


करता ह







(Ends)






running commentary





52












रहा ह









53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



14



hon Member












MR CHAIRMAN Yes



(Interruptions)



15





















16






Everybody is saying











--------------------------------- Not recorded


17














Thank you

(Ends)

(Followed by KLS1D)


18

MCM-KLS1D1115

















19













(Interruptions)








20




(Interruptions)

















21














(Interruptions)






22



SSS-SC1E1120










SHRI ANAND SHARMA





Not recorded


23


















24





(Interruptions)







from the record








25














afterwards





(Interruptions)


26





(Interruptions)






me (Interruptions)


(Interruptions)






(समापत)


27




















28


Shri Manish Gupta

(Contd by NBR1F)

-SSSNBR-GS1F1125










(Interruptions)



already told you




29










manually serviced











30














Thank you

(Ends)




31





(Ends)
















32

















Gupta




33





(Ends)















34








कयोपक





USY-HMS1G1130






35
















िाता ह





36





















37











(समापत)








(समापत)


38


SCHOOLS












(समापत)




39






PK-ASC1H1135













40


















India


41

















(Ends)


42




















43



















(Ends)


44




















45





(Followed by PB1J)

LP-PB11401J














46




ह

















47








minutes only



(समापत)







48


















-------------------------------



49












KLG-SKC1K1145









50









हो जाए

(समापत)



ह


ह




ह


51


करता ह







(Ends)






running commentary





52












रहा ह









53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



15





















16






Everybody is saying











--------------------------------- Not recorded


17














Thank you

(Ends)

(Followed by KLS1D)


18

MCM-KLS1D1115

















19













(Interruptions)








20




(Interruptions)

















21














(Interruptions)






22



SSS-SC1E1120










SHRI ANAND SHARMA





Not recorded


23


















24





(Interruptions)







from the record








25














afterwards





(Interruptions)


26





(Interruptions)






me (Interruptions)


(Interruptions)






(समापत)


27




















28


Shri Manish Gupta

(Contd by NBR1F)

-SSSNBR-GS1F1125










(Interruptions)



already told you




29










manually serviced











30














Thank you

(Ends)




31





(Ends)
















32

















Gupta




33





(Ends)















34








कयोपक





USY-HMS1G1130






35
















िाता ह





36





















37











(समापत)








(समापत)


38


SCHOOLS












(समापत)




39






PK-ASC1H1135













40


















India


41

















(Ends)


42




















43



















(Ends)


44




















45





(Followed by PB1J)

LP-PB11401J














46




ह

















47








minutes only



(समापत)







48


















-------------------------------



49












KLG-SKC1K1145









50









हो जाए

(समापत)



ह


ह




ह


51


करता ह







(Ends)






running commentary





52












रहा ह









53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



16






Everybody is saying











--------------------------------- Not recorded


17














Thank you

(Ends)

(Followed by KLS1D)


18

MCM-KLS1D1115

















19













(Interruptions)








20




(Interruptions)

















21














(Interruptions)






22



SSS-SC1E1120










SHRI ANAND SHARMA





Not recorded


23


















24





(Interruptions)







from the record








25














afterwards





(Interruptions)


26





(Interruptions)






me (Interruptions)


(Interruptions)






(समापत)


27




















28


Shri Manish Gupta

(Contd by NBR1F)

-SSSNBR-GS1F1125










(Interruptions)



already told you




29










manually serviced











30














Thank you

(Ends)




31





(Ends)
















32

















Gupta




33





(Ends)















34








कयोपक





USY-HMS1G1130






35
















िाता ह





36





















37











(समापत)








(समापत)


38


SCHOOLS












(समापत)




39






PK-ASC1H1135













40


















India


41

















(Ends)


42




















43



















(Ends)


44




















45





(Followed by PB1J)

LP-PB11401J














46




ह

















47








minutes only



(समापत)







48


















-------------------------------



49












KLG-SKC1K1145









50









हो जाए

(समापत)



ह


ह




ह


51


करता ह







(Ends)






running commentary





52












रहा ह









53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



17














Thank you

(Ends)

(Followed by KLS1D)


18

MCM-KLS1D1115

















19













(Interruptions)








20




(Interruptions)

















21














(Interruptions)






22



SSS-SC1E1120










SHRI ANAND SHARMA





Not recorded


23


















24





(Interruptions)







from the record








25














afterwards





(Interruptions)


26





(Interruptions)






me (Interruptions)


(Interruptions)






(समापत)


27




















28


Shri Manish Gupta

(Contd by NBR1F)

-SSSNBR-GS1F1125










(Interruptions)



already told you




29










manually serviced











30














Thank you

(Ends)




31





(Ends)
















32

















Gupta




33





(Ends)















34








कयोपक





USY-HMS1G1130






35
















िाता ह





36





















37











(समापत)








(समापत)


38


SCHOOLS












(समापत)




39






PK-ASC1H1135













40


















India


41

















(Ends)


42




















43



















(Ends)


44




















45





(Followed by PB1J)

LP-PB11401J














46




ह

















47








minutes only



(समापत)







48


















-------------------------------



49












KLG-SKC1K1145









50









हो जाए

(समापत)



ह


ह




ह


51


करता ह







(Ends)






running commentary





52












रहा ह









53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



18

MCM-KLS1D1115

















19













(Interruptions)








20




(Interruptions)

















21














(Interruptions)






22



SSS-SC1E1120










SHRI ANAND SHARMA





Not recorded


23


















24





(Interruptions)







from the record








25














afterwards





(Interruptions)


26





(Interruptions)






me (Interruptions)


(Interruptions)






(समापत)


27




















28


Shri Manish Gupta

(Contd by NBR1F)

-SSSNBR-GS1F1125










(Interruptions)



already told you




29










manually serviced











30














Thank you

(Ends)




31





(Ends)
















32

















Gupta




33





(Ends)















34








कयोपक





USY-HMS1G1130






35
















िाता ह





36





















37











(समापत)








(समापत)


38


SCHOOLS












(समापत)




39






PK-ASC1H1135













40


















India


41

















(Ends)


42




















43



















(Ends)


44




















45





(Followed by PB1J)

LP-PB11401J














46




ह

















47








minutes only



(समापत)







48


















-------------------------------



49












KLG-SKC1K1145









50









हो जाए

(समापत)



ह


ह




ह


51


करता ह







(Ends)






running commentary





52












रहा ह









53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



19













(Interruptions)








20




(Interruptions)

















21














(Interruptions)






22



SSS-SC1E1120










SHRI ANAND SHARMA





Not recorded


23


















24





(Interruptions)







from the record








25














afterwards





(Interruptions)


26





(Interruptions)






me (Interruptions)


(Interruptions)






(समापत)


27




















28


Shri Manish Gupta

(Contd by NBR1F)

-SSSNBR-GS1F1125










(Interruptions)



already told you




29










manually serviced











30














Thank you

(Ends)




31





(Ends)
















32

















Gupta




33





(Ends)















34








कयोपक





USY-HMS1G1130






35
















िाता ह





36





















37











(समापत)








(समापत)


38


SCHOOLS












(समापत)




39






PK-ASC1H1135













40


















India


41

















(Ends)


42




















43



















(Ends)


44




















45





(Followed by PB1J)

LP-PB11401J














46




ह

















47








minutes only



(समापत)







48


















-------------------------------



49












KLG-SKC1K1145









50









हो जाए

(समापत)



ह


ह




ह


51


करता ह







(Ends)






running commentary





52












रहा ह









53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



20




(Interruptions)

















21














(Interruptions)






22



SSS-SC1E1120










SHRI ANAND SHARMA





Not recorded


23


















24





(Interruptions)







from the record








25














afterwards





(Interruptions)


26





(Interruptions)






me (Interruptions)


(Interruptions)






(समापत)


27




















28


Shri Manish Gupta

(Contd by NBR1F)

-SSSNBR-GS1F1125










(Interruptions)



already told you




29










manually serviced











30














Thank you

(Ends)




31





(Ends)
















32

















Gupta




33





(Ends)















34








कयोपक





USY-HMS1G1130






35
















िाता ह





36





















37











(समापत)








(समापत)


38


SCHOOLS












(समापत)




39






PK-ASC1H1135













40


















India


41

















(Ends)


42




















43



















(Ends)


44




















45





(Followed by PB1J)

LP-PB11401J














46




ह

















47








minutes only



(समापत)







48


















-------------------------------



49












KLG-SKC1K1145









50









हो जाए

(समापत)



ह


ह




ह


51


करता ह







(Ends)






running commentary





52












रहा ह









53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



21














(Interruptions)






22



SSS-SC1E1120










SHRI ANAND SHARMA





Not recorded


23


















24





(Interruptions)







from the record








25














afterwards





(Interruptions)


26





(Interruptions)






me (Interruptions)


(Interruptions)






(समापत)


27




















28


Shri Manish Gupta

(Contd by NBR1F)

-SSSNBR-GS1F1125










(Interruptions)



already told you




29










manually serviced











30














Thank you

(Ends)




31





(Ends)
















32

















Gupta




33





(Ends)















34








कयोपक





USY-HMS1G1130






35
















िाता ह





36





















37











(समापत)








(समापत)


38


SCHOOLS












(समापत)




39






PK-ASC1H1135













40


















India


41

















(Ends)


42




















43



















(Ends)


44




















45





(Followed by PB1J)

LP-PB11401J














46




ह

















47








minutes only



(समापत)







48


















-------------------------------



49












KLG-SKC1K1145









50









हो जाए

(समापत)



ह


ह




ह


51


करता ह







(Ends)






running commentary





52












रहा ह









53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



22



SSS-SC1E1120










SHRI ANAND SHARMA





Not recorded


23


















24





(Interruptions)







from the record








25














afterwards





(Interruptions)


26





(Interruptions)






me (Interruptions)


(Interruptions)






(समापत)


27




















28


Shri Manish Gupta

(Contd by NBR1F)

-SSSNBR-GS1F1125










(Interruptions)



already told you




29










manually serviced











30














Thank you

(Ends)




31





(Ends)
















32

















Gupta




33





(Ends)















34








कयोपक





USY-HMS1G1130






35
















िाता ह





36





















37











(समापत)








(समापत)


38


SCHOOLS












(समापत)




39






PK-ASC1H1135













40


















India


41

















(Ends)


42




















43



















(Ends)


44




















45





(Followed by PB1J)

LP-PB11401J














46




ह

















47








minutes only



(समापत)







48


















-------------------------------



49












KLG-SKC1K1145









50









हो जाए

(समापत)



ह


ह




ह


51


करता ह







(Ends)






running commentary





52












रहा ह









53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



23


















24





(Interruptions)







from the record








25














afterwards





(Interruptions)


26





(Interruptions)






me (Interruptions)


(Interruptions)






(समापत)


27




















28


Shri Manish Gupta

(Contd by NBR1F)

-SSSNBR-GS1F1125










(Interruptions)



already told you




29










manually serviced











30














Thank you

(Ends)




31





(Ends)
















32

















Gupta




33





(Ends)















34








कयोपक





USY-HMS1G1130






35
















िाता ह





36





















37











(समापत)








(समापत)


38


SCHOOLS












(समापत)




39






PK-ASC1H1135













40


















India


41

















(Ends)


42




















43



















(Ends)


44




















45





(Followed by PB1J)

LP-PB11401J














46




ह

















47








minutes only



(समापत)







48


















-------------------------------



49












KLG-SKC1K1145









50









हो जाए

(समापत)



ह


ह




ह


51


करता ह







(Ends)






running commentary





52












रहा ह









53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



24





(Interruptions)







from the record








25














afterwards





(Interruptions)


26





(Interruptions)






me (Interruptions)


(Interruptions)






(समापत)


27




















28


Shri Manish Gupta

(Contd by NBR1F)

-SSSNBR-GS1F1125










(Interruptions)



already told you




29










manually serviced











30














Thank you

(Ends)




31





(Ends)
















32

















Gupta




33





(Ends)















34








कयोपक





USY-HMS1G1130






35
















िाता ह





36





















37











(समापत)








(समापत)


38


SCHOOLS












(समापत)




39






PK-ASC1H1135













40


















India


41

















(Ends)


42




















43



















(Ends)


44




















45





(Followed by PB1J)

LP-PB11401J














46




ह

















47








minutes only



(समापत)







48


















-------------------------------



49












KLG-SKC1K1145









50









हो जाए

(समापत)



ह


ह




ह


51


करता ह







(Ends)






running commentary





52












रहा ह









53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



25














afterwards





(Interruptions)


26





(Interruptions)






me (Interruptions)


(Interruptions)






(समापत)


27




















28


Shri Manish Gupta

(Contd by NBR1F)

-SSSNBR-GS1F1125










(Interruptions)



already told you




29










manually serviced











30














Thank you

(Ends)




31





(Ends)
















32

















Gupta




33





(Ends)















34








कयोपक





USY-HMS1G1130






35
















िाता ह





36





















37











(समापत)








(समापत)


38


SCHOOLS












(समापत)




39






PK-ASC1H1135













40


















India


41

















(Ends)


42




















43



















(Ends)


44




















45





(Followed by PB1J)

LP-PB11401J














46




ह

















47








minutes only



(समापत)







48


















-------------------------------



49












KLG-SKC1K1145









50









हो जाए

(समापत)



ह


ह




ह


51


करता ह







(Ends)






running commentary





52












रहा ह









53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



26





(Interruptions)






me (Interruptions)


(Interruptions)






(समापत)


27




















28


Shri Manish Gupta

(Contd by NBR1F)

-SSSNBR-GS1F1125










(Interruptions)



already told you




29










manually serviced











30














Thank you

(Ends)




31





(Ends)
















32

















Gupta




33





(Ends)















34








कयोपक





USY-HMS1G1130






35
















िाता ह





36





















37











(समापत)








(समापत)


38


SCHOOLS












(समापत)




39






PK-ASC1H1135













40


















India


41

















(Ends)


42




















43



















(Ends)


44




















45





(Followed by PB1J)

LP-PB11401J














46




ह

















47








minutes only



(समापत)







48


















-------------------------------



49












KLG-SKC1K1145









50









हो जाए

(समापत)



ह


ह




ह


51


करता ह







(Ends)






running commentary





52












रहा ह









53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



27




















28


Shri Manish Gupta

(Contd by NBR1F)

-SSSNBR-GS1F1125










(Interruptions)



already told you




29










manually serviced











30














Thank you

(Ends)




31





(Ends)
















32

















Gupta




33





(Ends)















34








कयोपक





USY-HMS1G1130






35
















िाता ह





36





















37











(समापत)








(समापत)


38


SCHOOLS












(समापत)




39






PK-ASC1H1135













40


















India


41

















(Ends)


42




















43



















(Ends)


44




















45





(Followed by PB1J)

LP-PB11401J














46




ह

















47








minutes only



(समापत)







48


















-------------------------------



49












KLG-SKC1K1145









50









हो जाए

(समापत)



ह


ह




ह


51


करता ह







(Ends)






running commentary





52












रहा ह









53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



28


Shri Manish Gupta

(Contd by NBR1F)

-SSSNBR-GS1F1125










(Interruptions)



already told you




29










manually serviced











30














Thank you

(Ends)




31





(Ends)
















32

















Gupta




33





(Ends)















34








कयोपक





USY-HMS1G1130






35
















िाता ह





36





















37











(समापत)








(समापत)


38


SCHOOLS












(समापत)




39






PK-ASC1H1135













40


















India


41

















(Ends)


42




















43



















(Ends)


44




















45





(Followed by PB1J)

LP-PB11401J














46




ह

















47








minutes only



(समापत)







48


















-------------------------------



49












KLG-SKC1K1145









50









हो जाए

(समापत)



ह


ह




ह


51


करता ह







(Ends)






running commentary





52












रहा ह









53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



29










manually serviced











30














Thank you

(Ends)




31





(Ends)
















32

















Gupta




33





(Ends)















34








कयोपक





USY-HMS1G1130






35
















िाता ह





36





















37











(समापत)








(समापत)


38


SCHOOLS












(समापत)




39






PK-ASC1H1135













40


















India


41

















(Ends)


42




















43



















(Ends)


44




















45





(Followed by PB1J)

LP-PB11401J














46




ह

















47








minutes only



(समापत)







48


















-------------------------------



49












KLG-SKC1K1145









50









हो जाए

(समापत)



ह


ह




ह


51


करता ह







(Ends)






running commentary





52












रहा ह









53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



30














Thank you

(Ends)




31





(Ends)
















32

















Gupta




33





(Ends)















34








कयोपक





USY-HMS1G1130






35
















िाता ह





36





















37











(समापत)








(समापत)


38


SCHOOLS












(समापत)




39






PK-ASC1H1135













40


















India


41

















(Ends)


42




















43



















(Ends)


44




















45





(Followed by PB1J)

LP-PB11401J














46




ह

















47








minutes only



(समापत)







48


















-------------------------------



49












KLG-SKC1K1145









50









हो जाए

(समापत)



ह


ह




ह


51


करता ह







(Ends)






running commentary





52












रहा ह









53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



31





(Ends)
















32

















Gupta




33





(Ends)















34








कयोपक





USY-HMS1G1130






35
















िाता ह





36





















37











(समापत)








(समापत)


38


SCHOOLS












(समापत)




39






PK-ASC1H1135













40


















India


41

















(Ends)


42




















43



















(Ends)


44




















45





(Followed by PB1J)

LP-PB11401J














46




ह

















47








minutes only



(समापत)







48


















-------------------------------



49












KLG-SKC1K1145









50









हो जाए

(समापत)



ह


ह




ह


51


करता ह







(Ends)






running commentary





52












रहा ह









53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



32

















Gupta




33





(Ends)















34








कयोपक





USY-HMS1G1130






35
















िाता ह





36





















37











(समापत)








(समापत)


38


SCHOOLS












(समापत)




39






PK-ASC1H1135













40


















India


41

















(Ends)


42




















43



















(Ends)


44




















45





(Followed by PB1J)

LP-PB11401J














46




ह

















47








minutes only



(समापत)







48


















-------------------------------



49












KLG-SKC1K1145









50









हो जाए

(समापत)



ह


ह




ह


51


करता ह







(Ends)






running commentary





52












रहा ह









53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



33





(Ends)















34








कयोपक





USY-HMS1G1130






35
















िाता ह





36





















37











(समापत)








(समापत)


38


SCHOOLS












(समापत)




39






PK-ASC1H1135













40


















India


41

















(Ends)


42




















43



















(Ends)


44




















45





(Followed by PB1J)

LP-PB11401J














46




ह

















47








minutes only



(समापत)







48


















-------------------------------



49












KLG-SKC1K1145









50









हो जाए

(समापत)



ह


ह




ह


51


करता ह







(Ends)






running commentary





52












रहा ह









53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



34








कयोपक





USY-HMS1G1130






35
















िाता ह





36





















37











(समापत)








(समापत)


38


SCHOOLS












(समापत)




39






PK-ASC1H1135













40


















India


41

















(Ends)


42




















43



















(Ends)


44




















45





(Followed by PB1J)

LP-PB11401J














46




ह

















47








minutes only



(समापत)







48


















-------------------------------



49












KLG-SKC1K1145









50









हो जाए

(समापत)



ह


ह




ह


51


करता ह







(Ends)






running commentary





52












रहा ह









53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



35
















िाता ह





36





















37











(समापत)








(समापत)


38


SCHOOLS












(समापत)




39






PK-ASC1H1135













40


















India


41

















(Ends)


42




















43



















(Ends)


44




















45





(Followed by PB1J)

LP-PB11401J














46




ह

















47








minutes only



(समापत)







48


















-------------------------------



49












KLG-SKC1K1145









50









हो जाए

(समापत)



ह


ह




ह


51


करता ह







(Ends)






running commentary





52












रहा ह









53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



36





















37











(समापत)








(समापत)


38


SCHOOLS












(समापत)




39






PK-ASC1H1135













40


















India


41

















(Ends)


42




















43



















(Ends)


44




















45





(Followed by PB1J)

LP-PB11401J














46




ह

















47








minutes only



(समापत)







48


















-------------------------------



49












KLG-SKC1K1145









50









हो जाए

(समापत)



ह


ह




ह


51


करता ह







(Ends)






running commentary





52












रहा ह









53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



37











(समापत)








(समापत)


38


SCHOOLS












(समापत)




39






PK-ASC1H1135













40


















India


41

















(Ends)


42




















43



















(Ends)


44




















45





(Followed by PB1J)

LP-PB11401J














46




ह

















47








minutes only



(समापत)







48


















-------------------------------



49












KLG-SKC1K1145









50









हो जाए

(समापत)



ह


ह




ह


51


करता ह







(Ends)






running commentary





52












रहा ह









53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



38


SCHOOLS












(समापत)




39






PK-ASC1H1135













40


















India


41

















(Ends)


42




















43



















(Ends)


44




















45





(Followed by PB1J)

LP-PB11401J














46




ह

















47








minutes only



(समापत)







48


















-------------------------------



49












KLG-SKC1K1145









50









हो जाए

(समापत)



ह


ह




ह


51


करता ह







(Ends)






running commentary





52












रहा ह









53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



39






PK-ASC1H1135













40


















India


41

















(Ends)


42




















43



















(Ends)


44




















45





(Followed by PB1J)

LP-PB11401J














46




ह

















47








minutes only



(समापत)







48


















-------------------------------



49












KLG-SKC1K1145









50









हो जाए

(समापत)



ह


ह




ह


51


करता ह







(Ends)






running commentary





52












रहा ह









53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



40


















India


41

















(Ends)


42




















43



















(Ends)


44




















45





(Followed by PB1J)

LP-PB11401J














46




ह

















47








minutes only



(समापत)







48


















-------------------------------



49












KLG-SKC1K1145









50









हो जाए

(समापत)



ह


ह




ह


51


करता ह







(Ends)






running commentary





52












रहा ह









53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



41

















(Ends)


42




















43



















(Ends)


44




















45





(Followed by PB1J)

LP-PB11401J














46




ह

















47








minutes only



(समापत)







48


















-------------------------------



49












KLG-SKC1K1145









50









हो जाए

(समापत)



ह


ह




ह


51


करता ह







(Ends)






running commentary





52












रहा ह









53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



42




















43



















(Ends)


44




















45





(Followed by PB1J)

LP-PB11401J














46




ह

















47








minutes only



(समापत)







48


















-------------------------------



49












KLG-SKC1K1145









50









हो जाए

(समापत)



ह


ह




ह


51


करता ह







(Ends)






running commentary





52












रहा ह









53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



43



















(Ends)


44




















45





(Followed by PB1J)

LP-PB11401J














46




ह

















47








minutes only



(समापत)







48


















-------------------------------



49












KLG-SKC1K1145









50









हो जाए

(समापत)



ह


ह




ह


51


करता ह







(Ends)






running commentary





52












रहा ह









53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



44




















45





(Followed by PB1J)

LP-PB11401J














46




ह

















47








minutes only



(समापत)







48


















-------------------------------



49












KLG-SKC1K1145









50









हो जाए

(समापत)



ह


ह




ह


51


करता ह







(Ends)






running commentary





52












रहा ह









53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



45





(Followed by PB1J)

LP-PB11401J














46




ह

















47








minutes only



(समापत)







48


















-------------------------------



49












KLG-SKC1K1145









50









हो जाए

(समापत)



ह


ह




ह


51


करता ह







(Ends)






running commentary





52












रहा ह









53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



46




ह

















47








minutes only



(समापत)







48


















-------------------------------



49












KLG-SKC1K1145









50









हो जाए

(समापत)



ह


ह




ह


51


करता ह







(Ends)






running commentary





52












रहा ह









53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



47








minutes only



(समापत)







48


















-------------------------------



49












KLG-SKC1K1145









50









हो जाए

(समापत)



ह


ह




ह


51


करता ह







(Ends)






running commentary





52












रहा ह









53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



48


















-------------------------------



49












KLG-SKC1K1145









50









हो जाए

(समापत)



ह


ह




ह


51


करता ह







(Ends)






running commentary





52












रहा ह









53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



49












KLG-SKC1K1145









50









हो जाए

(समापत)



ह


ह




ह


51


करता ह







(Ends)






running commentary





52












रहा ह









53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



50









हो जाए

(समापत)



ह


ह




ह


51


करता ह







(Ends)






running commentary





52












रहा ह









53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



51


करता ह







(Ends)






running commentary





52












रहा ह









53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



52












रहा ह









53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



53


















-----------------

Not recorded


54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



54




(Interruptions)




करती ह












55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



55





(Ends)



(Interruptions)

(FOLLOWED BY HK1L)

HK-AKG1L1150









56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



56





















57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



57





Thank you (Ends)













58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



58






Benin








in Nigeria







59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



59




personally

(Contd by KSK1M)

KSKSCH11551M









Official Language





60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



60




the proposal

















61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



61





(Ends)
















62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



62










Language there





(Ends)




63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



63


GETTING IT PASSED












चापहए






64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over



64



(समापत)







(समापत)


over


COL. RAJYAVARDHAN SINGH RATHORE164.100.47.5/newdebate/245/07022018/11.00amTo12.00Noon.pdf · COL....

Documents

Transcript of COL. RAJYAVARDHAN SINGH RATHORE164.100.47.5/newdebate/245/07022018/11.00amTo12.00Noon.pdf · COL....