CO-FIRING BIOMASS IN STOKER BOILERS...2012/12/13  · CO-FIRING BIOMASS IN STOKER BOILERS Arie...

22
“HOT TOPIC HOUR” PRESENTATION CO-FIRING BIOMASS IN STOKER BOILERS Arie Verloop, P.E. John La Fond, P.E. Jansen Combustion and Boiler Technologies, Inc. Kirkland, Washington, USA

Transcript of CO-FIRING BIOMASS IN STOKER BOILERS...2012/12/13  · CO-FIRING BIOMASS IN STOKER BOILERS Arie...

Page 1: CO-FIRING BIOMASS IN STOKER BOILERS...2012/12/13  · CO-FIRING BIOMASS IN STOKER BOILERS Arie Verloop, P.E. John La Fond, P.E. Jansen Combustion and Boiler Technologies, Inc. Kirkland,

“HOT TOPIC HOUR”

PRESENTATION

CO-FIRING BIOMASS IN

STOKER BOILERS

Arie Verloop, P.E.

John La Fond, P.E. Jansen Combustion and Boiler Technologies, Inc.

Kirkland, Washington, USA

Page 2: CO-FIRING BIOMASS IN STOKER BOILERS...2012/12/13  · CO-FIRING BIOMASS IN STOKER BOILERS Arie Verloop, P.E. John La Fond, P.E. Jansen Combustion and Boiler Technologies, Inc. Kirkland,

Presentation Outline

JANSEN Background and Projects

Biomass Combustion and Goals

Biomass Combustion Problems and Challenges

Phased Approach

Modifying/Retrofitting Combustion Systems

Benefits Synopsis

Page 3: CO-FIRING BIOMASS IN STOKER BOILERS...2012/12/13  · CO-FIRING BIOMASS IN STOKER BOILERS Arie Verloop, P.E. John La Fond, P.E. Jansen Combustion and Boiler Technologies, Inc. Kirkland,

Jansen Background

Experience

36 Years of Boiler Experience (“Difficult Fuels”)

Forest Products, W-t-E, IPP’s

Tested/Evaluated > 300 Boilers, Worldwide

>100 Advanced Combustion Systems, Many Coal

Co-Fired

Superheater (Re-)Design/Replacement

New Economizers for Increased Efficiency

Page 4: CO-FIRING BIOMASS IN STOKER BOILERS...2012/12/13  · CO-FIRING BIOMASS IN STOKER BOILERS Arie Verloop, P.E. John La Fond, P.E. Jansen Combustion and Boiler Technologies, Inc. Kirkland,

Types of Projects

Combustion System Upgrades

− Bark/Wood/Biomass/Sludge/TDF Boilers

− Chemical Recovery Boilers

− RDF/MSW Boilers

− Boilers often Co-Fired with Coal

Boiler MACT Compliance

Boiler Fuel Conversions

New/Replacement Superheaters and

Economizers

Complete Boiler Upgrades

Page 5: CO-FIRING BIOMASS IN STOKER BOILERS...2012/12/13  · CO-FIRING BIOMASS IN STOKER BOILERS Arie Verloop, P.E. John La Fond, P.E. Jansen Combustion and Boiler Technologies, Inc. Kirkland,

Introduction – What is Biomass?

Various Types of Solid Waste Wood:

− Bark, Hogged Fuel, Sawdust, Clippings, Chips,

Pellets

− Construction and Demolition (C&D) Material

− Ground Pallets and Old Furniture

− Agricultural Wastes from Harvesting/Processing

Refuse Derived Fuel (RDF)

Tire Derived Fuel (TDF)

Waste Sludge from Water Treatment Plant

Some say: “Any fuel that is not fossil fuel”

Page 6: CO-FIRING BIOMASS IN STOKER BOILERS...2012/12/13  · CO-FIRING BIOMASS IN STOKER BOILERS Arie Verloop, P.E. John La Fond, P.E. Jansen Combustion and Boiler Technologies, Inc. Kirkland,

Introduction – Fuel & Air Supply

Page 7: CO-FIRING BIOMASS IN STOKER BOILERS...2012/12/13  · CO-FIRING BIOMASS IN STOKER BOILERS Arie Verloop, P.E. John La Fond, P.E. Jansen Combustion and Boiler Technologies, Inc. Kirkland,

Tra

velin

g

Vib

rati

ng

Recip

rocati

ng

Pin

ho

le

Introduction - Stoker Grates

Courtesy of

Detroit Stoker

Company

Page 8: CO-FIRING BIOMASS IN STOKER BOILERS...2012/12/13  · CO-FIRING BIOMASS IN STOKER BOILERS Arie Verloop, P.E. John La Fond, P.E. Jansen Combustion and Boiler Technologies, Inc. Kirkland,

Biomass Composition

By mass

Page 9: CO-FIRING BIOMASS IN STOKER BOILERS...2012/12/13  · CO-FIRING BIOMASS IN STOKER BOILERS Arie Verloop, P.E. John La Fond, P.E. Jansen Combustion and Boiler Technologies, Inc. Kirkland,

Combustion Goals

To Achieve Continuous and Reliable Operation, Economically

Uninterrupted, Stable Operation

Meet Regulatory Emissions Limits

Optimize Fuel Economy

Optimize Steam Conditions for Power

Generation

Minimize Erosion/Corrosion Factors

More Difficult to Achieve with Biomass

Page 10: CO-FIRING BIOMASS IN STOKER BOILERS...2012/12/13  · CO-FIRING BIOMASS IN STOKER BOILERS Arie Verloop, P.E. John La Fond, P.E. Jansen Combustion and Boiler Technologies, Inc. Kirkland,

Combustion Problems Symptoms Frequently Seen with Biomass Combustion

High Carryover of Fly Ash; High Unburned Carbon

Delayed Combustion, Flames “Licking” Superheater

High Excess Air/Low Efficiency

Puffing, Uncontrolled Combustion

High CO and VOC Emissions

Limited Waste Fuel Burning Rates

Need for Fossil Fuel Co-firing (oil/gas/coal)

Clinkering and Slagging

Page 11: CO-FIRING BIOMASS IN STOKER BOILERS...2012/12/13  · CO-FIRING BIOMASS IN STOKER BOILERS Arie Verloop, P.E. John La Fond, P.E. Jansen Combustion and Boiler Technologies, Inc. Kirkland,

SUPER-HEATER

GENERATING BANK

HIGH CARRYOVEROF ASH WITH HIGHUNBURNED CARBON

ELEVATED GASTEMPERATURES

ASH AND FINESLIFTED OFF GRATE

PILING OF UNBURNEDFUEL ON GRATE

POOR MIXING AIRWITH FINES ANDVOLATILES

DELAYEDCOMBUSTION

HIGH CO ANDVOC EMISSIONS

Poor

Combustion

Conditions

Page 12: CO-FIRING BIOMASS IN STOKER BOILERS...2012/12/13  · CO-FIRING BIOMASS IN STOKER BOILERS Arie Verloop, P.E. John La Fond, P.E. Jansen Combustion and Boiler Technologies, Inc. Kirkland,

SUPER-HEATER

GENERATING BANK

LITTLE CARRYOVEROF SPARKLERSAND ASH

RELATIVELY COOLTEMPERATURES

INTENSE COMBUSTIONIN LOWER FURNACE

NO PILING OF UNBURNEDFUEL ON GRATE

LOW CO ANDVOC EMISSIONS

Good

Combustion

Conditions

Page 13: CO-FIRING BIOMASS IN STOKER BOILERS...2012/12/13  · CO-FIRING BIOMASS IN STOKER BOILERS Arie Verloop, P.E. John La Fond, P.E. Jansen Combustion and Boiler Technologies, Inc. Kirkland,

Causes of Poor Combustion

Poor Mixing of Combustion Air with Fuel

− Time, Temperature, Turbulence

− Volatiles, Fines Over Grate

High Undergrate Air (UGA) Flows

− Increases Airborne Material/Carryover

− Higher Excess Air - Lower Efficiencies

Page 14: CO-FIRING BIOMASS IN STOKER BOILERS...2012/12/13  · CO-FIRING BIOMASS IN STOKER BOILERS Arie Verloop, P.E. John La Fond, P.E. Jansen Combustion and Boiler Technologies, Inc. Kirkland,

Typical Project

Phased Approach

Initial Feasibility Study

Process Engineering Evaluation

Definition of Conceptual Modifications

Project Implementation

Page 15: CO-FIRING BIOMASS IN STOKER BOILERS...2012/12/13  · CO-FIRING BIOMASS IN STOKER BOILERS Arie Verloop, P.E. John La Fond, P.E. Jansen Combustion and Boiler Technologies, Inc. Kirkland,

Engineering Evaluation

Key Design Factors for Biomass:

Grate Size, Furnace Volume

Fuel and Air Distribution

Material and Heat Flows, Thermal Efficiency, and

Fuel Economy

Conduct CFD Modeling - Simulate Combustion

− Analytical Tool to Characterize Performance

− Evaluate Potential Modification Designs

If Needed, Analyze Steam/Water-side Circulation

Page 16: CO-FIRING BIOMASS IN STOKER BOILERS...2012/12/13  · CO-FIRING BIOMASS IN STOKER BOILERS Arie Verloop, P.E. John La Fond, P.E. Jansen Combustion and Boiler Technologies, Inc. Kirkland,

CFD Modeling Output

Temperature O2 CO NO Particulate

Original

OFA

System

Upgraded

OFA

System

Original

OFA

System

Upgraded

OFA

System

Temperature O2 CO NO Particulate

Page 17: CO-FIRING BIOMASS IN STOKER BOILERS...2012/12/13  · CO-FIRING BIOMASS IN STOKER BOILERS Arie Verloop, P.E. John La Fond, P.E. Jansen Combustion and Boiler Technologies, Inc. Kirkland,

Modifying Combustion Systems

Modification/Upgrade Concepts:

More Uniform Fuel Distribution with Flexibility to

Control Fuel Trajectory

Limited UGA Quantities to Minimize Lift-off of Fine

Fuel Particles Off the Grate

Preheated Combustion Air, Particularly for High

Moisture Content Fuel

Effective OFA Delivery to Promote Mixing of Air with

Volatiles and Fines Coming Off the Grate

Page 18: CO-FIRING BIOMASS IN STOKER BOILERS...2012/12/13  · CO-FIRING BIOMASS IN STOKER BOILERS Arie Verloop, P.E. John La Fond, P.E. Jansen Combustion and Boiler Technologies, Inc. Kirkland,

Modifying Combustion Systems - Fuel Feeders

Page 19: CO-FIRING BIOMASS IN STOKER BOILERS...2012/12/13  · CO-FIRING BIOMASS IN STOKER BOILERS Arie Verloop, P.E. John La Fond, P.E. Jansen Combustion and Boiler Technologies, Inc. Kirkland,

Modifying Combustion Systems - OFA Supply

Page 20: CO-FIRING BIOMASS IN STOKER BOILERS...2012/12/13  · CO-FIRING BIOMASS IN STOKER BOILERS Arie Verloop, P.E. John La Fond, P.E. Jansen Combustion and Boiler Technologies, Inc. Kirkland,

Modifying Combustion Systems - Benefits

Benefits Experienced:

Increase Biomass Capacity Significantly

(5% - 40%)

Reduce/Eliminate Fossil Fuel Usage

Improve Emissions (CO, NOx, PM)

Reduce Carryover, Erosion

Reduce Unburned Carbon Losses (LOI)

Increase Thermal Efficiency

Page 21: CO-FIRING BIOMASS IN STOKER BOILERS...2012/12/13  · CO-FIRING BIOMASS IN STOKER BOILERS Arie Verloop, P.E. John La Fond, P.E. Jansen Combustion and Boiler Technologies, Inc. Kirkland,

Today’s Opportunities and Challenges - Fuel Based

New Types of Biomass Fuels

C&D Wood, Sludge, TDF, OCC, Railroad Ties,

Pallets, Sometimes RDF/MSW

Deviations in Fuel Analysis (water, HHV,

elemental)

Trace Contaminants (chlorides, minerals, silica)

May Affect Deposit Chemistry, Clinker Formation,

Slagging, Accelerated Erosion/Corrosion

Page 22: CO-FIRING BIOMASS IN STOKER BOILERS...2012/12/13  · CO-FIRING BIOMASS IN STOKER BOILERS Arie Verloop, P.E. John La Fond, P.E. Jansen Combustion and Boiler Technologies, Inc. Kirkland,

Questions?

[email protected]

(425) 952-2825

[email protected]

(425) 952-2832

www.jansenboiler.com