CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA · CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for...

30
Unclassified 1 Subject Munition Systems Division CLP – IMI’s Nitramine Propellant Family for LOVA G. Strul, E. Shachar, Y. Cohen, D. Grinstein Insensitive Munitions and Energetic Materials Technology Symposium Oct 07-10, 2013 San Diego

Transcript of CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA · CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for...

Page 1: CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA · CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA G. Strul,E. Shachar, Y. Cohen, ... -Force > 1200 j/gr-Low temperature dependence.

Unclassified 1SubjectMunition Systems Division

CLP – IMI’s Nitramine Propellant Family for LOVA

G. Strul, E. Shachar, Y. Cohen, D. Grinstein

Insensitive Munitions and Energetic Materials Technology SymposiumOct 07-10, 2013 San Diego

Page 2: CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA · CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA G. Strul,E. Shachar, Y. Cohen, ... -Force > 1200 j/gr-Low temperature dependence.

Unclassified 2SubjectMunition Systems Division

Kiryat-Shmona

Tel Aviv

Nazareth – Small-Caliber Ammunition Div.

Haifa Metal ComplexRamat-Hasharon – HQ and:

Ammunition Systems Div.

Advanced Systems

Land Systems

Ramla - Rocket Systems Div.

Ashkelon - Ashot

Beer Sheba

IMI FACILITIESAmmunition

Rocket Systems

Anti-Terror Academy

Test Ranges

Page 3: CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA · CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA G. Strul,E. Shachar, Y. Cohen, ... -Force > 1200 j/gr-Low temperature dependence.

Unclassified 3SubjectMunition Systems Division

New Requirements for Propellants:New Requirements for Propellants:

� Increased performance.

� Reduced sensitivity / LOVA.

� Reduced toxicity / Environmental impact –

Replacement of toxic components. Environmental

regulations.

Page 4: CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA · CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA G. Strul,E. Shachar, Y. Cohen, ... -Force > 1200 j/gr-Low temperature dependence.

Unclassified 4SubjectMunition Systems Division

Toxicity of Propellants ComponentsToxicity of Propellants Components:

� Dinitrotoluene (DNT) has been used for years as energetic plasticizer in many propellants – DNT, however, is extremely toxic.

� Current Stabilizers are either very toxic by themselves or they produce toxic products during ageing.

� Nitroglycerine NG has physiological effects in

cardiovascular system. nitroglycerine has migration

tendency.

� Phthalate-Plasticizers (DBP) is toxic.

Page 5: CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA · CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA G. Strul,E. Shachar, Y. Cohen, ... -Force > 1200 j/gr-Low temperature dependence.

Unclassified 5SubjectMunition Systems Division

The Task:

Development of a high performance LOVA propulsion systems

for gun ammunitions

Desired Features:

• Extended range.

• Raising Energy contents by using high impetus formulations.

• Increase progressivity.

• Low temperature dependency.

• Controllable burning rate regime.

• Improved safety and toxicity properties.

• Green ingredients as much as possible.

Page 6: CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA · CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA G. Strul,E. Shachar, Y. Cohen, ... -Force > 1200 j/gr-Low temperature dependence.

Unclassified 6SubjectMunition Systems Division

Methodology of New Propellant DevelopmentMethodology of New Propellant Development

- Potential energetic materials

- Thermochemical evaluation

Synthesis R&D – Lab scale

Synthesis R&D – Pilot scale

Production Formulation & testing Qual. & Ammunition

Page 7: CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA · CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA G. Strul,E. Shachar, Y. Cohen, ... -Force > 1200 j/gr-Low temperature dependence.

Unclassified 7SubjectMunition Systems Division

MWF= R

TvTo maximize the Impetus

High Energetic materials

Nitramine (RDX)H2C

N N

H2C CH2

N

NO2

NO2

O2N

Novel Energetic plasticizer

Nitroglycerin

+

Energy IncreaseEnergy Increase

Page 8: CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA · CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA G. Strul,E. Shachar, Y. Cohen, ... -Force > 1200 j/gr-Low temperature dependence.

Unclassified 8SubjectMunition Systems Division

24.632311090M-26

22.532591204#3 – (CLP-26)

23.534421218# 2

25.035171169# 1

M [ g/mol ]T [ K ]Impetus [ j/g ]Formulation

Propellant for 105Propellant for 105--mm Gun Ammunitionmm Gun AmmunitionThermoThermo--Chemical evaluationChemical evaluation

APFSDSAPFSDS--T 105 mmT 105 mm

Page 9: CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA · CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA G. Strul,E. Shachar, Y. Cohen, ... -Force > 1200 j/gr-Low temperature dependence.

Unclassified 9SubjectMunition Systems Division

No detonationNo detonationGAP-TEST

65 min100 minStability

186oC193oCDSC ignition temperature

No reactionNo reactionElectrostatic discharge (ESD)

sensitivity

Mild reaction at 360N>360 NFriction sensitivity

3.2 N5.5 NImpact sensitivity

MM--2626CLPCLP--2626

Propellant for 105Propellant for 105--mm Gun Ammunitionmm Gun Ammunition

Safety featuresSafety features

Gap-test

Page 10: CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA · CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA G. Strul,E. Shachar, Y. Cohen, ... -Force > 1200 j/gr-Low temperature dependence.

Unclassified 10SubjectMunition Systems Division

Propellant for 105Propellant for 105--mm Gun Ammunitionmm Gun AmmunitionAccelerated aging programAccelerated aging program

Oven Oven 6565°°°°°°°°C C –– 60 days60 days

ClosedClosed vesselvessel

bombbombInterruptionInterruption

bombbombLab TestLab Test

40 mm firing test40 mm firing test

105105 mm firing testmm firing test

Page 11: CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA · CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA G. Strul,E. Shachar, Y. Cohen, ... -Force > 1200 j/gr-Low temperature dependence.

Unclassified 11SubjectMunition Systems Division

Interruption bombInterruption bomb

Un-aged propellant After 60 days aging

Propellant for 105Propellant for 105--mm Gun Ammunitionmm Gun AmmunitionAccelerated agingAccelerated aging

Page 12: CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA · CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA G. Strul,E. Shachar, Y. Cohen, ... -Force > 1200 j/gr-Low temperature dependence.

Unclassified 12SubjectMunition Systems Division

Firing tests – 105 mm.

Propellant for 105Propellant for 105--mm Gun Ammunitionmm Gun AmmunitionBallistic Stability After AgingBallistic Stability After Aging

Page 13: CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA · CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA G. Strul,E. Shachar, Y. Cohen, ... -Force > 1200 j/gr-Low temperature dependence.

Unclassified 13SubjectMunition Systems Division

Bullet impact testBullet impact test

Packaged / Unpackaged round Packaged / Unpackaged round

Loose propellantLoose propellant

Propellant for 105Propellant for 105--mm Gun Ammunitionmm Gun AmmunitionIM testsIM tests

Reaction Type V:

Rupture of packaging,

ejection of propellant,

partly burning

Page 14: CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA · CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA G. Strul,E. Shachar, Y. Cohen, ... -Force > 1200 j/gr-Low temperature dependence.

Unclassified 14SubjectMunition Systems Division

Propellant for 105Propellant for 105--mm Gun Ammunitionmm Gun AmmunitionIM testsIM tests

FCO – TEST - Stanag 4240

Reaction Type V:

Projectile ejection

followed by ejection of

propellant.

In logistic level test:

Rupture of packaging, Projectile

ejection, partly burning.

Page 15: CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA · CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA G. Strul,E. Shachar, Y. Cohen, ... -Force > 1200 j/gr-Low temperature dependence.

Unclassified 15SubjectMunition Systems Division

Propellant for 105Propellant for 105--mm Gun Ammunitionmm Gun AmmunitionIM testsIM tests

Shaped charge jet attackShaped charge jet attack

Reaction Type III-IV:

Rupture of cartridge, Projectile ejection

followed by ejection of propellant,

partly burning

Page 16: CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA · CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA G. Strul,E. Shachar, Y. Cohen, ... -Force > 1200 j/gr-Low temperature dependence.

Unclassified 16SubjectMunition Systems Division

IR photo after IR photo after

70% of burning time70% of burning timeIR photo after IR photo after

10% of burning time10% of burning time

CLP-26 M-26CLP-26 M-26

CCLP-26 M-26

After 30% of After 30% of

burning timeburning time

Propellant for 105Propellant for 105--mm Gun Ammunitionmm Gun AmmunitionOpen air burningOpen air burning

Page 17: CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA · CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA G. Strul,E. Shachar, Y. Cohen, ... -Force > 1200 j/gr-Low temperature dependence.

Unclassified 17SubjectMunition Systems Division

No detonationNo detonationGAP-TEST

70 min100 minStability

186oC200 & 237oCDSC ignition temperature

No reactionNo reactionElectrostatic discharge (ESD)

sensitivity

Mild reaction at 360N>360 NFriction sensitivity

3.2 N6 NImpact sensitivity

CEPCEP--22CLPCLP--1515

Propellant for 120Propellant for 120--mm Gun Ammunitionmm Gun Ammunition

Safety featuresSafety features

GapGap--testtest

Page 18: CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA · CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA G. Strul,E. Shachar, Y. Cohen, ... -Force > 1200 j/gr-Low temperature dependence.

Unclassified 18SubjectMunition Systems Division

Propellant for 120Propellant for 120--mm Gun Ammunitionmm Gun AmmunitionAccelerated aging programAccelerated aging program

Oven Oven 6565 ooCC –– 120 days 120 days

Closed vesselClosed vessel

bombbombInterruptionInterruption

bombbombLab TestLab Test

120 mm firing test120 mm firing test

Page 19: CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA · CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA G. Strul,E. Shachar, Y. Cohen, ... -Force > 1200 j/gr-Low temperature dependence.

Unclassified 19SubjectMunition Systems Division

Stabilizer depletion & weight loss of Nitramine compared to

DB propellants

Propellant for 120Propellant for 120--mm Gun Ammunitionmm Gun AmmunitionAccelerated agingAccelerated aging

0

1

2

3

4

5

0 30 60 90 120

זמן התיישנות מואצת (ימים)

%ל קשמד בואי

CLP-15

CEP-2

Aging time (d)

%

W

L

Page 20: CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA · CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA G. Strul,E. Shachar, Y. Cohen, ... -Force > 1200 j/gr-Low temperature dependence.

Unclassified 20SubjectMunition Systems Division

InterruptionInterruption bombbomb

Propellant for 120Propellant for 120--mm Gun Ammunitionmm Gun AmmunitionAccelerated agingAccelerated aging

120 d 90d 60 d no aging

Page 21: CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA · CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA G. Strul,E. Shachar, Y. Cohen, ... -Force > 1200 j/gr-Low temperature dependence.

Unclassified 21SubjectMunition Systems Division

Nitramine FTIR distribution

across the web size grain

Nitramine FTIR imaging

along the LOVA grain

Microscope FTIR investigationMicroscope FTIR investigation

Propellant for 120Propellant for 120--mm Gun Ammunitionmm Gun AmmunitionAccelerated agingAccelerated aging

Page 22: CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA · CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA G. Strul,E. Shachar, Y. Cohen, ... -Force > 1200 j/gr-Low temperature dependence.

Unclassified 22SubjectMunition Systems Division

Ballistic Performances after accelerated ageing

Ballistic Shelf LifeBallistic Shelf Life

Propellant for 120Propellant for 120--mm Gun Ammunitionmm Gun AmmunitionAccelerated agingAccelerated aging

Page 23: CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA · CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA G. Strul,E. Shachar, Y. Cohen, ... -Force > 1200 j/gr-Low temperature dependence.

Unclassified 23SubjectMunition Systems Division

FCO – TEST - Stanag 4240

Propellant for 120Propellant for 120--mm Gun Ammunitionmm Gun AmmunitionIM testsIM tests

Reaction Type V:

Burning of propellant

and combustible

cartridge.

Page 24: CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA · CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA G. Strul,E. Shachar, Y. Cohen, ... -Force > 1200 j/gr-Low temperature dependence.

Unclassified 24SubjectMunition Systems Division

Bullet Impact Test - Stanag 4241

Propellant grains

Requirement: No explosion or

detonation.

Result: Type V reaction

rupture of cartridge, ejection of

propellant, partly burning

Same results when tested in logistic level

Propellant for 120Propellant for 120--mm Gun Ammunitionmm Gun AmmunitionIM testsIM tests

Page 25: CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA · CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA G. Strul,E. Shachar, Y. Cohen, ... -Force > 1200 j/gr-Low temperature dependence.

Unclassified 25SubjectMunition Systems Division

Set up beforeAfter burning

Result: Moderate burning (~ 75 sec)

Reference (CEP-2): Faster burning (-10 sec)

Propellant for 120Propellant for 120--mm Gun Ammunitionmm Gun AmmunitionOpen Burning of loose CLP 15 propellantOpen Burning of loose CLP 15 propellant

Page 26: CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA · CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA G. Strul,E. Shachar, Y. Cohen, ... -Force > 1200 j/gr-Low temperature dependence.

Unclassified 26SubjectMunition Systems Division

PropellantPropellant for 120for 120--mm Mortar Ammunitionmm Mortar Ammunition

0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

Base p

ress.[

MP

a]

Travel [m]

C19 prop.

Nitramin prop.

CLPM-15

The new mortar CLPM-15 propellant

shows superior ballistic performance

- Extended range

- Force > 1200 j/gr

- Low temperature dependence

Page 27: CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA · CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA G. Strul,E. Shachar, Y. Cohen, ... -Force > 1200 j/gr-Low temperature dependence.

Unclassified 27SubjectMunition Systems Division

Propellant for 120Propellant for 120--mm Mortar Ammunitionmm Mortar AmmunitionSmallSmall scale erosion bombscale erosion bomb

Page 28: CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA · CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA G. Strul,E. Shachar, Y. Cohen, ... -Force > 1200 j/gr-Low temperature dependence.

Unclassified 28SubjectMunition Systems Division

Improved Ballistic performances

-Higher muzzle velocity

-Low flame temperature (< 3500K)

-High Impetus (>1200 j/g)

- Stable formulation

- Low weight loss during aging

- Low stabilizer degradation

-Enhanced safety properties

- low vulnerability in IM test

- Nitroglycerin free

IMI has introduced a novel LOVA propellant IMI has introduced a novel LOVA propellant

familyfamily

Low Vulnerability Ammunition( LOVA) Propellant

IMI

105 & 120 mm gun propellant are IDF qualified

120 mm mortar propellant is under qualification phase

Page 29: CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA · CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA G. Strul,E. Shachar, Y. Cohen, ... -Force > 1200 j/gr-Low temperature dependence.

Unclassified 29SubjectMunition Systems Division

AcknowledgmentsAcknowledgments

To IMI propellant team : Yael C., Eli S., Idit M., Haim R.

And to the audience for the attention

FutureFuture plansplans

IMI intends to further increase its insensitive nitramine

propellant family and to broaden the range of

applications in actual and future ammunition systems

Page 30: CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA · CLP –IMI’sNitramine Propellant Family for LOVA G. Strul,E. Shachar, Y. Cohen, ... -Force > 1200 j/gr-Low temperature dependence.

Unclassified 30SubjectMunition Systems Division