Civic journalism A brief overview of a reform movement in transition.

23
Civic journalism A brief overview of a reform movement in transition

Transcript of Civic journalism A brief overview of a reform movement in transition.

Page 1: Civic journalism A brief overview of a reform movement in transition.

Civic journalism

A brief overview of a reform movement in transition

Page 2: Civic journalism A brief overview of a reform movement in transition.

Jay Rosen

• Loss of circulation tied to loss of community

Page 3: Civic journalism A brief overview of a reform movement in transition.

Jay Rosen

• Loss of circulation tied to loss of community

• “What Are Journalists For?” examines civic (public) journalism

Page 4: Civic journalism A brief overview of a reform movement in transition.

Jay Rosen

• Loss of circulation tied to loss of community

• “What Are Journalists For?” examines civic (public) journalism

• John Dewey is his inspiration

Page 5: Civic journalism A brief overview of a reform movement in transition.

“Bowling Alone”

• Robert Putnam traced the decline of “social capital”

Page 6: Civic journalism A brief overview of a reform movement in transition.

“Bowling Alone”

• Robert Putnam traced the decline of “social capital”

• Newspaper readership associated with community involvement

Page 7: Civic journalism A brief overview of a reform movement in transition.

“Bowling Alone”

• Robert Putnam traced the decline of “social capital”

• Newspaper readership associated with community involvement

• Doing good can be good for business

Page 8: Civic journalism A brief overview of a reform movement in transition.

Journalists as social workers

• News orgs can galvanize local agenda and serving as a sounding board

Page 9: Civic journalism A brief overview of a reform movement in transition.

Journalists as social workers

• News orgs can galvanize local agenda and serving as a sounding board

• The Ledger-Enquirer in Columbus, Ga.

Page 10: Civic journalism A brief overview of a reform movement in transition.

Journalists as social workers

• News orgs can galvanize local agenda and serving as a sounding board

• The Ledger-Enquirer in Columbus, Ga.– 1988 series “Columbus: Beyond 2000”

Page 11: Civic journalism A brief overview of a reform movement in transition.

Journalists as social workers

• News orgs can galvanize local agenda and serving as a sounding board

• The Ledger-Enquirer in Columbus, Ga.– 1988 series “Columbus: Beyond 2000”– Followed up with public forum

Page 12: Civic journalism A brief overview of a reform movement in transition.

Journalists as social workers

• News orgs can galvanize local agenda and serving as a sounding board

• The Ledger-Enquirer in Columbus, Ga.– 1988 series “Columbus: Beyond 2000”– Followed up with public forum– Editor Jack Fuller founded civic group

called United Beyond 2000

Page 13: Civic journalism A brief overview of a reform movement in transition.

Journalists as social workers

• News orgs can galvanize local agenda and serving as a sounding board

• The Ledger-Enquirer in Columbus, Ga.– 1988 series “Columbus: Beyond 2000”– Followed up with public forum– Editor Jack Fuller founded civic group

called United Beyond 2000

• “Seeing the public into fuller existence”

Page 14: Civic journalism A brief overview of a reform movement in transition.

What about objectivity?

• Traditional thinking says don’t get involved in community

Page 15: Civic journalism A brief overview of a reform movement in transition.

What about objectivity?

• Traditional thinking says don’t get involved in community

• Len Downie, who doesn’t vote, says it shouldn’t matter to journalists whether others do or not

Page 16: Civic journalism A brief overview of a reform movement in transition.

Notable experiments

• Boston Globe inadvertently predicted Buchanan victory in 1996

Page 17: Civic journalism A brief overview of a reform movement in transition.

Notable experiments

• Boston Globe inadvertently predicted Buchanan victory in 1996

• In Wilmington, Del., town meetings on economic woes

Page 18: Civic journalism A brief overview of a reform movement in transition.

Notable experiments

• Boston Globe inadvertently predicted Buchanan victory in 1996

• In Wilmington, Del., town meetings on economic woes

• In Indianapolis, Mike Tyson and race

Page 19: Civic journalism A brief overview of a reform movement in transition.

The urge to pander

• What would reader surveys have showed in Southern newspapers in the 1950s?

Page 20: Civic journalism A brief overview of a reform movement in transition.

Who owns the agenda?

• Helms-Gantt contest had broad themes of race, generational change and values

Page 21: Civic journalism A brief overview of a reform movement in transition.

Who owns the agenda?

• Helms-Gantt contest had broad themes of race, generational change and values

• Michael Kelly argues that the media reduced it to a dry civics lesson — crime, taxes, health care, education

Page 22: Civic journalism A brief overview of a reform movement in transition.

Where did civic journalism go?

• Jay Rosen moved on, is now a leading apostle of citizen journalism

Page 23: Civic journalism A brief overview of a reform movement in transition.

Where did civic journalism go?

• Jay Rosen moved on, is now a leading apostle of citizen journalism

• Pioneering placeblogger Lisa Williams makes familiar argument about community