City Council Agenda - October 29, 2007• Final Inspection of feedstock(s) at the composting...

30
AGENDA GUELPH CITY COUNCIL October 29, 2007 - 7:00 p.m. Please turn off or place on non-audible all cell phones, PDAs, Blackberrys and pagers during the meeting. SPECIAL MEETING Special meeting of Guelph City Council to hear presentations relating to organic technologies from the following: Introductory Remarks: - Chris Rendell, Purchasing Agent Maple Reinders – Proposal #1 Integrated Municipal Services GSI Maple Reinders – Proposal #2 Ellis Don/Kompogas CCI-TBN ATCON Group Melloul Blammey Miller Waste Systems Next Steps and closing remarks – Janet Laird, Director of Environmental Services ADJOURNMENT

Transcript of City Council Agenda - October 29, 2007• Final Inspection of feedstock(s) at the composting...

Page 1: City Council Agenda - October 29, 2007• Final Inspection of feedstock(s) at the composting facility, and ... chimney effect •characterized by long processing times •pipes sometimes

AGENDA

GUELPH CITY COUNCIL

October 29, 2007 - 7:00 p.m. Please turn off or place on non-audible all cell phones, PDAs, Blackberrys and pagers during the meeting.

SPECIAL MEETING

Special meeting of Guelph City Council to hear presentations relating to organic technologies from the following: Introductory Remarks: - Chris Rendell, Purchasing Agent

• Maple Reinders – Proposal #1 • Integrated Municipal Services • GSI

• Maple Reinders – Proposal #2

• Ellis Don/Kompogas

• CCI-TBN

• ATCON Group

• Melloul Blammey

• Miller Waste Systems

Next Steps and closing remarks – Janet Laird, Director of Environmental Services

ADJOURNMENT

Page 2: City Council Agenda - October 29, 2007• Final Inspection of feedstock(s) at the composting facility, and ... chimney effect •characterized by long processing times •pipes sometimes

Composting 101

Page 3: City Council Agenda - October 29, 2007• Final Inspection of feedstock(s) at the composting facility, and ... chimney effect •characterized by long processing times •pipes sometimes

What is Composting?

“managed process of bio-oxidation of a solid heterogeneous organic substrate including a thermophilic phase.” (BNQ, 2004)

Page 4: City Council Agenda - October 29, 2007• Final Inspection of feedstock(s) at the composting facility, and ... chimney effect •characterized by long processing times •pipes sometimes

Compost Biology

• Composting process is carried out by microorganisms and higher level fauna (macroorganisms).

• During composting, there is a succession of microbial species; the environment created by, or the byproducts of, one species invites the activity of another species.

• As a result, no single species persists though the entire range of conditions encountered during the compost process.

Page 5: City Council Agenda - October 29, 2007• Final Inspection of feedstock(s) at the composting facility, and ... chimney effect •characterized by long processing times •pipes sometimes

Compost Biochemistry

• Composting is a controlled process. The goal is to maintain conditions that encourage a healthy community of microbes.

• This is done by monitoring and manipulating six main process parameters.

oxygen Particle Size, Porosity and Structure

Nutrients Moisture

Temperature pH

Page 6: City Council Agenda - October 29, 2007• Final Inspection of feedstock(s) at the composting facility, and ... chimney effect •characterized by long processing times •pipes sometimes

Composting

Thermophilic

Mesophilic

Primary

Secondary

Curing

Page 7: City Council Agenda - October 29, 2007• Final Inspection of feedstock(s) at the composting facility, and ... chimney effect •characterized by long processing times •pipes sometimes

Composting Process Overview

USCC 1st Level Compost Process Model

Page 8: City Council Agenda - October 29, 2007• Final Inspection of feedstock(s) at the composting facility, and ... chimney effect •characterized by long processing times •pipes sometimes

Recovery

• Final Inspection of feedstock(s) at the composting facility, and separation/removal of contaminants and non-desirable materials.

Page 9: City Council Agenda - October 29, 2007• Final Inspection of feedstock(s) at the composting facility, and ... chimney effect •characterized by long processing times •pipes sometimes

Feedstock Preparation• Preparing the feedstocks in a

manner that establishes optimal conditions for composting to proceed. May includes grinding to set particle size, blending bulking agents to establish porosity, blending feedstocks to optimize C/N ratio or pH, adding water, or inoculating the feedstock with microbes by recycling compost.

Page 10: City Council Agenda - October 29, 2007• Final Inspection of feedstock(s) at the composting facility, and ... chimney effect •characterized by long processing times •pipes sometimes

High-Rate Composting

• High temperature stage of composting process involving pathogen treatment (PFRP), feedstock degradation and biological stabilization of the compost.

Page 11: City Council Agenda - October 29, 2007• Final Inspection of feedstock(s) at the composting facility, and ... chimney effect •characterized by long processing times •pipes sometimes

Curing (Maturation)

• Biological finishing step to stabilize and mature the compost materials.

Page 12: City Council Agenda - October 29, 2007• Final Inspection of feedstock(s) at the composting facility, and ... chimney effect •characterized by long processing times •pipes sometimes

Odour Treatment

• Collection or otherwise control and treat odourous off-gases from the composting process.

Page 13: City Council Agenda - October 29, 2007• Final Inspection of feedstock(s) at the composting facility, and ... chimney effect •characterized by long processing times •pipes sometimes

Screening and Refining

• Removal of oversized materials (stones, bulking agents) and physical contaminants (glass, metals, sharps) to create a product suitable for the selected end use.

Page 14: City Council Agenda - October 29, 2007• Final Inspection of feedstock(s) at the composting facility, and ... chimney effect •characterized by long processing times •pipes sometimes

Storage and Packaging

• Storage of the finished product inventory (in a manner that preserves its beneficial properties) to meet seasonal market demand.

• Mixing with other products to produce compost or soil blends. Bagging for the retail market.

Page 15: City Council Agenda - October 29, 2007• Final Inspection of feedstock(s) at the composting facility, and ... chimney effect •characterized by long processing times •pipes sometimes

Composting Technology Overview

Page 16: City Council Agenda - October 29, 2007• Final Inspection of feedstock(s) at the composting facility, and ... chimney effect •characterized by long processing times •pipes sometimes

General Types of Technologies

• Static Piles

• Windrows

• Aerated Static Piles

• In-vessel

Low Cost

High Cost

Page 17: City Council Agenda - October 29, 2007• Final Inspection of feedstock(s) at the composting facility, and ... chimney effect •characterized by long processing times •pipes sometimes

Static Pile Method

• piles in windrows or cones

• passive aeration –chimney effect

• characterized by long processing times

• pipes sometimes added to improve air flow

Page 18: City Council Agenda - October 29, 2007• Final Inspection of feedstock(s) at the composting facility, and ... chimney effect •characterized by long processing times •pipes sometimes

Windrow Method

• aeration achieved by mixing or “turning” with front end loader of specialized equipment

• monitoring done manually

Page 19: City Council Agenda - October 29, 2007• Final Inspection of feedstock(s) at the composting facility, and ... chimney effect •characterized by long processing times •pipes sometimes

Aerated Static Pile

• positively aerated

• negatively aerated

• bunkers

• covered systems

Page 20: City Council Agenda - October 29, 2007• Final Inspection of feedstock(s) at the composting facility, and ... chimney effect •characterized by long processing times •pipes sometimes

In-vessel Systems

• static containers

• agitated containers

• tunnels

• agitated bays

• drums

• channels

Page 21: City Council Agenda - October 29, 2007• Final Inspection of feedstock(s) at the composting facility, and ... chimney effect •characterized by long processing times •pipes sometimes

Static Containerized Systems

• modular

• positive aeration with recirculation

• temperature feedback process control

• floor grate

• end doors with seals

• common scrubber & biofilter for odour control

• PLC control with customized HMI

Page 22: City Council Agenda - October 29, 2007• Final Inspection of feedstock(s) at the composting facility, and ... chimney effect •characterized by long processing times •pipes sometimes

Agitated Container Systems

• mixed material loaded into one end

• moving floor, spinners or augers mover material through container

• positive aeration with exhaust

• 7-14 day thoughput

Page 23: City Council Agenda - October 29, 2007• Final Inspection of feedstock(s) at the composting facility, and ... chimney effect •characterized by long processing times •pipes sometimes

Agitated Bay Systems

• generally for large scale systems

• positive or negative aeration

• highly automated

older newer

Page 24: City Council Agenda - October 29, 2007• Final Inspection of feedstock(s) at the composting facility, and ... chimney effect •characterized by long processing times •pipes sometimes

Tunnel Systems

• positive aeration with recirculation

• temperature feedback process control

• in-floor channels• aluminum doors with seals

• scrubber/biofilter for odour control

• PLC control with customized HMI

Page 25: City Council Agenda - October 29, 2007• Final Inspection of feedstock(s) at the composting facility, and ... chimney effect •characterized by long processing times •pipes sometimes

Drum Systems

• technology borrowed from cement industry

• drums rotate up to 1 rpm• slight incline combined with rotation causes material to move from end to end

• air injected at discharge end

• typically 1-3 day retention.

• combined with other technology for secondary composting

Page 26: City Council Agenda - October 29, 2007• Final Inspection of feedstock(s) at the composting facility, and ... chimney effect •characterized by long processing times •pipes sometimes

Channel Systems

• similar to agitated bays

• typically positively aerated

• material moved down length of channel by turner

Page 27: City Council Agenda - October 29, 2007• Final Inspection of feedstock(s) at the composting facility, and ... chimney effect •characterized by long processing times •pipes sometimes

Submission 1 Submission 2 Submission 3

Team Members

Prime Contractor Miller Waste Systems Integrated Municipal Services Atcon Group

Designer Partner(s) Wheelwright Group Inc. Sandwell Engineering Hatch Engineering

Jackman Engineering (Struc) GICOM Composting Systems

Paul Lim & Associate (Mech/Elec)

Construction Partners(s) Wheelwright Group Inc. Integrated Municipal Services Atcon Construction

Operation Partners(s) Miller Waste Systems Integrated Municipal Services Envirem

Proposed Technology

Ebara agitated bed system with

enclosed windrow curing

GICOM tunnel composting system

with static pile curing

HotRot invessel composting system

Reference Facilities

Dartmouth, NS Niagara Biosolids Facility HRM, NS (New Era)

Pictou County, NS Niagara Enviro-Centre Colchester County, NS

Lunenburg, NS NWP Compost Facility (Ireland) HotRot, Christchurch, NZ

Pickering, ON IVAREM Facility (Belgium) Hot Rot, Selwyn, NZ

Richmond Hill, ON New England Organics (Maine) HotRot, Western Islands, UK

HotRot, Glasgow, Scotland

Hot Rot, Palmerston North City, NZ

Page 28: City Council Agenda - October 29, 2007• Final Inspection of feedstock(s) at the composting facility, and ... chimney effect •characterized by long processing times •pipes sometimes

Team Members

Prime Contractor

Designer Partner(s)

Construction Partners(s)

Operation Partners(s)

Proposed Technology

Reference Facilities

Submission 4 Submission 5 Submission 6 Submission 7

GSI WCI Modern Niagara Inc. Melloul-Blamey Construction Inc. Maple Reinders

GSI Modern Niagara Inc. Engineered Compost Systems Design consultant not selected

Odotech (odours) WCI Christianens Group

Golder (permitting) Ambio Biofiltration Ltd (odour)

Solmers (design, EMS) Engineered Compost Systems

GSI BBS Construction Inc. Melloul-Blamey Construction Inc. Maple Reinders

GSI WCI Gro-bark Aim Environmental

Aerated static pile system with

static pile or windrow curing

ECS tunnel composting system,

ECS covered aerated static pile

composting system, and passive

curing overtop existing air floor.

ECS tunnel composting system,

and ECS covered aerated static

pile composting system

Christianens tunnel composting

system with static pile curing

MRC du Haut-St-Francois, QC Brookfield, PEI Mariposa County, CA Hamilton, ON

St Henri, QC Zabrze, Poland Granby, Colorado Region of Peel, ON

Ottawa Valley WRC, ON West Yellowstone, Montana Cape Breton, NS

Mariposa County, CA Banff, AB

Granby, Colorado Prince Albert, SK

West Yellowstone, Montana Algonquin Power EFW, ON

Page 29: City Council Agenda - October 29, 2007• Final Inspection of feedstock(s) at the composting facility, and ... chimney effect •characterized by long processing times •pipes sometimes

Team Members

Prime Contractor

Designer Partner(s)

Construction Partners(s)

Operation Partners(s)

Proposed Technology

Reference Facilities

Submission 8 Submission 9 Submission 10

Maple Reinders CCI-TBN Toronto Inc Halton Recycling Ltd.

Design consultant not selected Trow Associates EPS International (Permiting)

Christianens Group MTE Consultants (Civil, Struc, Env)

HRL (Process)

Maple Reinders WS Nicholls Construction Halton Recycling Ltd.

Aim Environmental CCI-TBN Toronto Inc Halton Recycling Ltd.

Anaerobic processing using

Christianens tunnel composting

system, followed by static pile

composting/curing

BTA anaerobic digestion system

with composting of "digestate"

residual using GORE covered

aerated static pile composting

system.

Channel composting system followed

by additional composting using aerated

static pile system. Curing to be done in

static piles.

Hamilton, ON Dufferin

Region of Peel, ON

Cape Breton, NS

Banff, AB

Prince Albert, SK

Algonquin Power EFW, ON

No references provided for technology.

Similar facilities known to be operating

in Edmonton and Abbotsford.

Page 30: City Council Agenda - October 29, 2007• Final Inspection of feedstock(s) at the composting facility, and ... chimney effect •characterized by long processing times •pipes sometimes

Team Members

Prime Contractor

Designer Partner(s)

Construction Partners(s)

Operation Partners(s)

Proposed Technology

Reference Facilities

Submission 11 Submission 12 Submission 13

EllisDon Orgaworld Canada Ltd. Orgaworld Canada Ltd.

Earth Tech Conestoga-Rovers Conestoga-Rovers

Sustainable Energy Holdings

EllisDon Orgaworld Orgaworld

Sustainable Energy Holdings Orgaworld Orgaworld

Has identified Kompogas

anaerobic digestion system as

potential technology.

Orgaworld tunnel composting

system followed by outdoor curing

in windrows.

Orgaworld aerated static pile

composting system followed by

outdoor curing in windrows.

Kyoto, Japan London, ON London, ON

Frankfurt, Germany ZAW, Netherlands ZAW, Netherlands

Passau Hellersberg, Germany

Braunschweig, Germany