CIDOC 2014

32
Language of Bindings thesaurus Athanasios Velios Nicholas Pickwoad Aurelie Martin

description

Presentation about the Language of Bindings thesaurus alongside some interesting conceptual problems of bookbinding surveys.

Transcript of CIDOC 2014

Page 1: CIDOC 2014

Language of Bindings thesaurus

Athanasios VeliosNicholas Pickwoad

Aurelie Martin

Page 2: CIDOC 2014

Stitched structures

Page 3: CIDOC 2014
Page 4: CIDOC 2014
Page 5: CIDOC 2014

Multi-cultural developmentavoid language/tradition dominance

1

Page 6: CIDOC 2014

Multi-cultural development

● English bookbinding structures are not dominant

Page 7: CIDOC 2014
Page 8: CIDOC 2014

Equivalence

● Exact match

Page 9: CIDOC 2014

FRENCH ITALIAN

ITALIAN ITALIAN

SPANISH GERMAN

ENGLISH FLEMISH

Page 10: CIDOC 2014

Equivalence

● Partial equivalence– e.g. brochure (french) – pamphlets

● Compound terms– e.g. αιγοπρόβατα (greek) – sheep and/or goats

Page 11: CIDOC 2014

Equivalence

● Partial equivalence– e.g. brochure (french) – pamphlets

● Compound terms– e.g. αιγοπρόβατα (greek) – sheep and/or goats

● Orphan terms– αιγοπρόβατα

● sheep● goats

Page 12: CIDOC 2014

Rapid developmentfunding available for two years

2

Page 13: CIDOC 2014

Thesaurus sprints

● Get experts in one place● Intense 3 day workshops● Good volume of data

– lack of referencing

Page 14: CIDOC 2014
Page 15: CIDOC 2014

Thesaurus sprints

● Experts divided in teams

● Work on tasks for an hour● Team facilitators record discussions

– SKOS understanding important● Team reps meet to report / ask questions

Page 16: CIDOC 2014

Thesaurus sprints

● Experts divided in teams

● Work on tasks for an hour● Team facilitators record discussions

– SKOS understanding important● Team reps meet to report / ask questions

Page 17: CIDOC 2014
Page 18: CIDOC 2014

Progress

● Number of concepts relatively stable (~700)– Bookbinding manual publication

● First level of hierarchies complete– Reviewing others

● Thesaurus website up and running

Page 19: CIDOC 2014
Page 20: CIDOC 2014

scope note(longish)

scope note(longish)

Page 21: CIDOC 2014

hierarchyhierarchy

Page 22: CIDOC 2014

workflow basedon FORTH'sWebTMS

workflow basedon FORTH'sWebTMS

Page 23: CIDOC 2014

users canfollow termsusers can

follow terms

Page 24: CIDOC 2014

Interesting problemsplease help

3

Page 25: CIDOC 2014

Positive negative

● Absence of a characteristic could be meaningful

● Create records of non-existing characteristics

Page 26: CIDOC 2014
Page 27: CIDOC 2014

Survey problems

● Data depends on observation– (Lack of) experience of surveyor– Weak survey method

Page 28: CIDOC 2014

Ioannes Copus, De fructibus libri quatuor, Paris: Christian Wechel, 1535

Page 29: CIDOC 2014

Nature of form

● Materials combined based on a technique● What is the result?

– e.g. thread and longstitch structure

Page 30: CIDOC 2014

"Unraveling ball of string" by Lewis Ronald - Own work.CC Attribution-Share Alike 3.0https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Unraveling_ball_of_string.jpg

Page 31: CIDOC 2014

Gio. Felice Astolfi, Cento Avenimmento Meraviglioso, Venice, 1660

L’Epistole d’Ovidio in Terza Rima del Signor Angelo Rodolfini,

Macerata: Guiseppe Picini, 1682

Page 32: CIDOC 2014

www.ligatus.org.uk