Cic(24)Tdsat Chair Comp

8/10/2019 Cic(24)Tdsat Chair Comp

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/cic24tdsat-chair-comp 1/35

CENTRAL INFORMATION COMMISSIONClub Building (Near Post Office

Old !N" Ca#$us% Ne& 'eli ) **++,-Tel. /0*)**)1,*+*201

File No3 CIC4BS4A41+*54++++154,506+5 'ece#ber 1+*5

Rele7ant Facts e#erging fro# te A$$eal.

A$$ellant : Mr. Subhash Chandra Agrawal1775, Kucha Lattushah,Dariba, Chandni Chowk,Delhi 11!!!"

Res$ondent : C#$%Teleco# 'is$tes Settle#ent 8 A$$ellateTribunal (9o7t3 of India&. no. '7!, 'rd (loor,)otel Sa*rat, Kautil+a Marg,Chanak+auri, -ew Delhi 11!!/1

RTI a$$lication filed on : 1"0!0/!1'PIO re$lied on : 1501!0/!1'First a$$eal filed on : 1201!0/!1'First A$$ellate Autorit: order : 1"01/0/!1'Second A$$eal recei7ed : /'01/0/!1'

Infor#ation sougt.)3he aellant has sought the 4ollowing in4or*ation:

1. Co*lete in4or*ation on rules roiding residential acco**odations to Chairersons and*e*bers o4 3DSA3 *entioning also e6enses allowable on

reairs0renoation04i6tures04urnishing0*aintenance04urniture0airconditioners0co*uters0electric electronic gadgets and other 4i6tures etc 4or suchgoern*entroided residentialacco**odations either b+ Central #ublic 8orksDeart*ent 9C#8D or b+ 3DSA3.

/. $s it true that so*e e6enses on 4urnishing 04urniture0airconditioners0co*uters0electric electronic gadgets and other 4i6tures etc on such goern*entroided residentialacco**odations to 3DSA3 Chairerson Mr. ;ustice A4tab Ala* and0or the other 3DSA3*e*ber0s is done b+ 3DSA3 *entioning also i4 it is er*issible to trans4er so*e such4urniture0airconditioners0co*uters0electric electronic gadgets and other 4i6tures etc 4ro*3DSA3 o44ice to such goern*entroided residentialacco**odations o4 the Chairerson and0or the other *e*ber0s o4 3DSA3<

'. Co*lete in4or*ation on e6enses on 4urnishing04urniture0airconditioners0co*uters0electric electronic gadgets and other 4i6tures etc *ade underdi44erent heads b+ 3DSA3 on such goern*entroided residentialacco**odations o4the Chairerson Mr ;ustice A4tab Ala* and0or the other *e*ber0s o4 3DSA3.

=. Co*lete in4or*ation about goern*entroided residentialacco**odation to 3DSA3Chairerson Mr ;ustice A4tab Ala*.

5. Co*lete in4or*ation together with related 4ilenotings0docu*ents0corresondence onrenoation04urnishing0reair0*aintenance etc on goern*entroided residentialacco**odation to 3DSA3 Chairerson Mr ;ustice A4tab Ala* b+ C#8D *entioning

of 2



e6enses *ade under di44erent heads enclosing also an+ re>uestletters 4ro* 3DSA3and0or its Chairerson in this regard.

". Co*ete in4or*ation on e6enses *ade on goern*entroided residentialacco**odation to 3DSA3 Chairerson Mr ;ustice A4tab Ala* and0or on4urnishing04urniture0airconditioners0co*uters0electric electronic gadgets and other4i6tures etc either b+ 3DSA3 or b+ C#8D or b+ an+ other ublicauthorit+ which are againstrules.

7. Co*lete in4or*ation together with related 4ilenotings0docu*ents0corresondence onrenoation04urnishing0reair0*aintenance etc b+ C#8D on goern*entroided

residentialacco**odation to other 3DSA3 *e*ber?s *entioning e6enses *ade underdi44erent heads enclosing also an+ re>uestletters 4ro* 3DSA3 and0or the concerned3DSA3 *e*ber in this regard.

2. Co*lete in4or*ation as sought under >uer+nu*bers 91 to 9" in resect o4 earlier 3DSA3Chairersons Mr. ;ustice Arun Ku*ar and Mr. ;ustice S@ Sinha *entioning also details o4goern*entbungalows allotted to Mr. ;ustice Arun Ku*ar and Mr. ;ustice S@ Sinha.

. An+ other related in4or*ation.1!.(ilenotings on *oe*ents o4 this &3$ etition.

9rounds for te Second A$$eal.3he C#$% has not roided the desired in4or*ation.

Rele7ant Facts e#erging during ;earing.3he 4ollowing were resentA$$ellant. Mr. Subhash Chandra AgrawalRes$ondent. Mr. Sanee #ande+ C#$%

3he C#$% stated that the &3$ alication dated 1"0!0/!1' was relied ide letter dated1501!0/!1' and ide (AA?s order dated 1"01/0/!1' the aellant was o44ered insection o4 therecords but he did not aail the oortunit+. )e 4urther stated that the aellant did not *ark aco+ o4 his /nd aeal to hi* and he has brought all the releant records to enable the aellant totake whateer in4or*ation0docu*ents he needs. 3he aellant stated that the in4or*ation soughtin his /nd aeal along with related docu*ents should be sulied to hi* 4ree o4 cost. 3he C#$%

agreed.

'ecision notice.As agreed b+ the C#$% the in4or*ation re>uested b+ the aellant in his /nd aeal should

be roided to hi*, 4ree o4 cost, within '! da+s 4ro* the date o4 receit o4 this order.

Te a$$eal is dis$osed of accordingl:3

BASANT SET; Infor#ation Co##issioner

Autenticated true co$:.

(R3 L3 9u$ta':3 Registrar4'esignated Officer

of 2



File

No. CIC/BS/Al2014/000024

CENTRAL INFORMATION COMMISSION

Club building, Opposite Ber Sarai Market,

Old

JNU Campus,

New Delhi- 110 067.

Tel:

+91-11-26160943,

Telefax:

+91-11.26101592

[email protected]

Dated:-19/11/2014

NOTICE OF

HEARING

Respondent:

~ ~

CPIO

Mr. Subhash Chandra Agrawal

Telecom Disptes Settlement & Appellate

1775,Kucha Lattushah,

Tribunal (Govt.

of

India)

Dariba, Chandni Chowk,

R.

no. 370, 3

rd

Floor,

Delhi

-110006

Hotel Samrat, Kautilya Marg,

Chanakyapuri, New Delhi - 110021

The appeal filed

by

the Appellant has been fixed for hearing on 04

th

December,

2014. The parties 'are hereby directed to be present with all

relevant papersl documents before Shri

Basant Seth, -Information

Commissioner,

at

Club Building, Opposite Ber Sarai Market, Near Post

Office, Old JNU Campus, New Delhi - 110 067

on

04

th

December, 2014

at

01:45 pm.

At the time

of

hearing of the appeal you may be present

in

person or

may authorize your representative who should report and mark his attendance

in

Room No.8

of

the Central Information Commission's office.

If information has already been provided by the Public Information

Officer a copy

of

the same should be brought along with the proof

of

dispatch.

Public Information Officer is hereby further directed to communicate the date

- - - - ~ a n d - t i m e - o f h e a r i n g

to any other officers whose assistance-has- been t l g h t - - - ~ - - - - - - -

under Section 5(4) of the

RTI

Act and ask them to appear before the

Commission on the said date and time.

Both the parties are also directed to produce all relevant papers and

documents that they wish to rely upon during the hearing

with

advance copy to

the

opposite

party.

Please note that

no'

adjournments due to absence will be given

in

any

circumstances. '

Given under the order of the Commission.

9 : . Q ~ e d

Officer

\

TI Date:

16 09 2013;

.

Reference

No.

of CPIO's reply:

2 9 / 3 / 2 0 1 3 / R T I - P t . 1 I 4 0 0 1 , ~

ed:

1,

13; j ) ' ; : ~ \

Enclosed: Co

ofsecond

a eal dated:

23 121

'

.. : .:;),:) fq"

l . ~ "

. .: , : : - ~ ; ~

mailto:[email protected]




SENIOR CITIZEN PRIORITY

HE RING REQUESTED

BEFORE HONOURABLE CENTRAL INFORMATION COMMISSION

PETITION UNDER SECTION 19(3) OF RIGHT TO INFORMATION ACT

Petitioner

Subhash Chandra Agrawal

1775 Kucha Lattushah

Dariba, Chandni Chowk

Delhi-ll0006

Respondent

Shri G Venkata Nagaiah CPIO

Telecom Disputes Settlement Appellate Tribunal (TDSAT)

Room # 370,

31 d

floor, Hotel Sam rat

Kautilya Marg, Chanakyapuri, New Delhi-ll0021

Shri DP De Advisor

Appellate Authority


Hotel Samrat, Kautilya Marg

Chanakyapuri, New Delhi-II 0021

Brief Facts Prayer

I vide

my

RTI petition dated 16.09.2013 sought complete information together with relevant

documents/corrospondence/file-notings on under-mentioned aspects:

1.

Complete information on rules providing residential-accommodations to Chairpersons and members

of

TDSAT mentioning also expenses allowable

on

repairs/renovationS/fixtures/furnishing/maintenance/furniture/air-conditioners/computers/electric

electronic gadgets and other fixtures etc for such government-provided residential-accommodations either

by

Central Public Works Department (CPWD) or

by

TDSAT

2. Is it true that some expenses on furnishing/furniture/air-conditioners/computers/electric

&

electronic

gadgets and other fixtures etc on such government-provided residential-accommodations to TDSAT

Chairperson Mr Justice Aftab Alam and/or the other TDSAT memberls is done by TDSAT mentioning also

if it

is

permissible to transfer some such furniture/air-conditioners/computers/electric & electronic gadgets

and other fixtures etc from TDSA T office to such government-provided residential-accommodations of the

Chairperson and/or the other memberls ofTDSAT?



Even in regard to query 8) attached note-sheets provide cost and source of purchase for items numbered from 16)

to 21) for purchases made for the then TDSAT chairperson

Mr

Justice Arun Kumar. But no such details including

cost and source

of

purchase were given in respect

of

item-numbers 1) to 15). t was also not revealed if due

purchase-process was followed for purchases made as detailed in attached note-sheets or not. I appealed CPIO to be

directed to provide cost and source

of

purchase for item-numbers

1)

to 15) listed

in

attached note-sheets. I also

appealed that copies

of

purchase-orders and purchase-bills should be provided

in

respect

of

items listed

in

the

attached note-sheets mentioning also if all or some

of

these items were purchased through discretionary powers o

the then TDSAT chairperson without following usual government-process for purchases.

1 also appealed CPIO to be directed to provide similar information about any new purchases by TDSAT for

residence of earlier TDSAT chairperson Mr Justice SB Sinha. I also appealed CPIO to be directed. to revea

whereabouts

of

listed items purchased for Mr Justice Arun Kumar and later for Mr Justice SB Sinha since after tha

a different residential accomodation

is

provided to present TDSAT chairperson Mr Justice Aftab Alam. In case

items provided at residences

of

earlier TDSAT chairpersons Mr Justice Arun Kumar and Mr Justice S Sinha are

disposed of, then directions were requested for providing complete details about such disposal.

Sought information becomes crucial because the CPIO

in

his response stated an upper limit

of

rupees four lakhs to

be borne by TDSAT in respect

of

furnishings etc at residence

ofTDS T

chairperson while listed items are costing

much higher than the mentioned limit with cost and source

of

purchase not mentioned for majority

of

purchased

items for the then TDSAT chairperson Mr Justice Arun Kumar and totally avoiding details

in

respect

of

presen

TDSAT chairperson Mr Justice Aftab Alam and the earlier chairperson Mr Justice SB Sinha.

t was indeed surprising that an appeal dated 18.10.2013 was placed before the ordering Appellate Authority only

on 27.11.2013 while documents reveal that there was an earlier Appellate Authority who received first appeal

on

21.10.2013. Question arises why there was a wait for some other Appellate Authority to decide the first appeal.

The new Appellate Authority

in

its order dated 16.12.2013 instead

of

directing the CPIO to provide proper

information together with sought and related documents, at this stage offered inspection.

If

CPIO can provide

information for an earlier Chairperson from old files, then there

is

no logic that information relating to present

Chairperson that too from current files may not be provided. Undersigned petitioner has been paying thousands

of

rupees towards copying charges on a single RTI petition

if

demand was made on time. Here in this case also,

petitioner would have paid copying charges

if

demand would have been made

in

time.

In

suspicious manner

of

pro replying and subsequent had ling

of

first appeal, I doubt that inspection offered may be a complete eye-wash

with proabilibity

of

useless files dumped before me so that I may not be practically able to sort out the required

ones like has been bitter

e x p i r i e ~ e

with the undersigned in a solitary case

of

accepted inspection. Otherwise also,

even information-part

is

also incomplete as referred above.



I appeal TDSAT may kindly be directed to provide point-wise proper and complete information to each of the

query of my RTI petition together with sought and related documents but now to be provided free-of-cost under

section 7(6) ofRTI Act. I also appeal for compensation under section 19(8)(b) ofRTI Act. Erring ones may kindly

be penalised under section 20 of RTI Act with departmental proceedings directed against them. It is prayed

accordingly.

Humbly submitted

SUBHASH CHANDRA AGRAWAL

23.12.2013

Verification

I, Subhash Chandra Agrawal

s o

late Shri Om Prakash and resident

of

1775, Kucha Lattushah, Dariba,

e l ~

110006 verify that the facts mentioned above are correct to best of my knowledge.

(\,



Dariba DELHI 110006 (India)

Mobile 9810033711 Fax 23254036

E-mail [email protected]

23.12.2013

Copies enclosed:

RTI petition dated 16.09.2013

CPIO s reply dated 15.10.2013

First appeal dated 18.10.2013

Appeal-order dated 16.12.2013

Copy of passport as proof

of

being senior citizen

Appeal under section 19(3) ofRTI Act





Telecom Disputes Settlement & Appellate Tribunal (TDSAT)

(Government

of

India)

Hotel Sam rat. Chanakyapuri, New Delhi 110021

Room No. 470,

4th

Floor,

Hotel Samrat, Chanakya

Puri,

New Delhi 110 021.

No.

29/11/2013/RTI/tt

16

t

December, 2013

Sub: In the matter of appeal dated 18.10.2013 filed by Shri Subhash Chandra

Agrawal, appellant against the information supplied by the CPIO,

TOSAT

vide

letter

No.

2 9 3 2 0 1 3 R T I ~ P t · 1 4 0 0 1 dated 15.10.2013 in response

to RTI

petition

dated 16.9.2013.

This is regarding the appeal filed by Shri Subhash Chandra Aarawal,

appellant against his RTI petition dated 16.9.2013 which was replied to by the CPIO,

TDSAT vide letter No. 29/3/2013/RTI Pt 1I4001 dated 15.10.2013.

The Appellate Authority in TDSAT has been changed. The appeal was made

available to the undersigned on 27.11.2013 and sent to CPIO, TDSAT

Mr.

Sanjeev

Pandey on 28.11.2013 to furnish information (copy enclosed).

Reply of CPIO dated 9.12.2013 is enclosed herewith. Against pOints 1,2,4,7

and

10

of

the petition, CPIO has furnished information/observations and against

pOints

3,5,6,8 and

9,

CPIO has offered that the appellant may inspect the relevant

files at his convenience. He has stated that information pertains to various files and

is bulky.

appellant.

He has also listed 9 files which are relevant to the queries raised by the



TELECOM DISPUTES SETTLEMENT & APPELLATE TRIBUNAL

NEW

DELHI

28

th

November, 2013

To

Shri Sanjeev Pandey,

Assistant Registrar,

CPIO,

TDSAT,

New Delhi.

Subject:

First Appeal under Section 19(1) of the RT Act.

I

Enclosed herewith

is

the First Appeal under RTI Act filed by Shri Subhash

-

Chandra Agrawal against his RT petition dated 16.09.2013 which was replied to by the

then CPIO vide letter No. 29/3/2013/RTI-Pt.1I4001 dated 15.10.2013.

The applicant is not satisfied with the information provided. You are requested to

go through the contents of the appeal and furnish information in order to reply to the

appeal at the earliest possible.

This appeal apparently was received by the then appellate authority on

21.10.2013 h!'wever; the same has been made available to the undersigned yesterday

only. Keeping in view the date

of

receipt

of

the appeal in TDSAT and provisions of

RT

Act, the case may be handled on top most priority please.

Encl: As above.

Yours faithfully,

k

D.P. De)

Advisor/HoD

Appellate Authority



FIRST APPEAL UNDER SECTION 19(1) OF RIGHT TO INFORMATION ACT

Shri Akash Deep Chakravarti

Appellate Authority & Registrar


3rd

floor, Room # 370 Hotel Samrat

Kautilya Marg, Chanakyapuri, New Delhi-110021

Sir

I vide my RTI petition dated 16.09.2013 sought complete information together with relevant

documents/corrospondence/file-notings on under-mentioned aspects:

1.

Complete information on rules providing residential-accommodations to Chairpersons

and members of TDSAT mentioning also expenses allowable on

repairs/renovations/fixtures/furnishing/maintenance/furniture/air-

conditioners/computers/electric & electronic gadgets and other fixtures etc for such

government-provided residential-accommodations either by Central Public Works

Department (CPWD) or by TDSAT

2. Is it true that some expenses on furnishing/furniture/air-conditioners/computers/electric &

electronic gadgets and other fixtures etc on such government-provided residential-

accommodations to TDSAT Chairperson Mr Justice Aftab Alam and/or the other TDSAT

member/s is done by TDSAT mentioning also if it is permissible to transfer some such

furniture/air-conditioners/computers/electric & electronic gadgets and other fixtures etc

from TDSAT office to such government-provided residential-accommodations of the

Chairperson and/or the other member/s of TDSAT?

3. Complete information on expenses on furnishing/furniture/air-

conditioners/computers/electric & electronic gadgets and other fixtures etc made under

different heads by TDSAT on such government-provided residential-accommodations to

TDSAT Chairperson Mr Justice Aftab Alam and/or the other TDSAT member/s

mentioning also details of transferring some such furniture/air-

conditioners/computers/electric & electronic gadgets and other fixtures etc from TDSAT



office to government-provided residential-accommodations of the Chairperson Mr Justice

Aftab Alam and/or the other member/s of TDSAT

4. Complete information about government-provided residential-accommodation to TDSAT

Chairperson Mr Justice Aftab Alam

5. Complete information together with related file-notings/documents/correspondence on

renovation/furnishing/repair/maintenance etc on government-provided residential-

accommodation to TDSAT Chairperson Mr Justice Aftab Alam by Central Public

Works Department (CPWD) mentioning expenses made under different heads

enclosing also any request-letters from TDSAT and/or its Chairperson in this regard

6. Complete information on expenses made on government-provided residential-

accommodation to TDSAT Chairperson Mr Justice Aftab Alam and/or on

furnishing/furniture/air-conditioners/computers/electric & electronic gadgets and other

fixtures etc either by TDSAT or by CPWD or by any other public-authority which are

against rules

7. Complete information together with related file-notings/documents/correspondence on

renovation/furnishing/repair/maintenance etc by CPWD on government-provided

residential-accommodation to other TDSAT member/s mentioning expenses made under

different heads enclosing also any request-letters from TDSAT and/or the concerned

TDSAT member in this regard

8. Complete information as sought under query-numbers (1) to (6) in respect of earlier

TDSAT Chairpersons Mr Justice Arun Kumar and Mr Justice SB Sinha mentioning also

details of government-bungalows allotted to Mr Justice Arun Kumar and Mr Justice SB

Sinha

9. Any other related information

10. File-notings on movement of this RTI petition

Learned CPIO vide response number 29/3/2013/RTI-Pt.1/4001 dated 15.10.2013 did provide

some (and not complete) information in regards to query-number (8) regarding earlier TDSAT

chairpersons but cleverly avoiding main query-numbers (1) to (7) in regard to present TDSAT

chairperson Mr Justice Aftab Alam. I appeal that learned CPIO may kindly be directed to

provide detailed and complete information in regard to query-numbers (1) to (7) of my RTI



petition with all related and sought documents now to be provided free-of-cost under section 7(6)

of RTI Act. Necessary department action may kindly be initiated against the concerned CPIO for

deliberately obstructing detailed information regarding query-numbers (1) to (7) regarding

present TDSAT chairperson Mr Justice Aftab Alam at a time when my queries were well

understood because query (8) of similar nature regarding earlier TDSAT charirpersons was tried

to be provided though not completely.

Even in regard to query (8) attached note-sheets provide cost and source of purchase for items

numbered from (16) to (21) for purchases made for the then TDSAT chairperson Mr Justice

Arun Kumar. But no such details including cost and source of purchase are given in respect of

item-numbers (1) to (15). It has also not been revealed if due purchase-process was followed for

purchases made as detailed in attached note-sheets or not. I appeal learned CPIO may kindly be

directed to provide cost and source of purchase for item-numbers (1) to (15) listed in attached

note-sheets. I also appeal that copies of purchase-orders and purchase-bills may also be kindly

directed to be provided in respect6 of items listed in the attached note-sheets mentioning also if

all or some of these items were purchased through discretionary powers of the then TDSAT

chairperson without following usual government-process for purchases.

Learned CPIO may also kindly be directed to provide similar information about any new

purchases by TDSAT for residence of earlier TDSAT chairperson Mr Justice SB Sinha. I also

appeal that learned CPIO may kindly be directed to reveal whereabouts of listed items purchased

for Mr Justice Arun Kumar and later for Mr Justice SB Sinha since after that a different

residential accomodation is provided to present TDSAT chairperson Mr Justice Aftab Alam. In

case items provided at residences of earlier TDSAT chairpersons Mr Justice Arun Kumar and Mr

Justice SB Sinha are disposed of, then directions may kindly be given for providing complete

details about such disposal.

Sought information becomes crucial because the CPIO in his response has stated an upper limit

of rupees four lakhs to be borne by TDSAT in respect of furnishings etc at residence of TDSAT

chairperson while listed items are costing much higher than the mentioned limit with cost and

source of purchase not mentioned for majority of purchased items for the then TDSAT



chairperson Mr Justice Arun Kumar and totally avoiding details in respect of present TDSAT

chairperson Mr Justice Aftab Alam and the earlier chairperson Mr Justice SB Sinha. It is prayed

accordingly.

Humbly submitted


(Guinness Record Holder & RTI Activist)



DELHI 110006 (India)Mobile 9810033711 Fax 23254036

E-mail [email protected]

Web www.subhashmadhu.com

18.10.2013



\'(;flf4N taqli:

lf i

Telecom Disputes Settlement

&

3J tfror

Appellate Tribuna

tf ifil<)

(Government of India

Cfi1Rf

o:f

370,

im,

R.

No. 370

3rd

Floor

mer 'mile, ~ ~ i q 1Jf1f,

Hotel

Samrat,

Kautllya

Marg

i : f I O l q q ~ ~ t

o:tl

~ 1 1 21

Chanakya

Purl

New

Delhl-110021

~ / T e l

: +91-11-26882173

E-mail: reglstrar.tdsat@nlc.'n

~ / F a x :

+91-11-24122219

Website: www.tdsat.nlc.ln

NO.29/3n013/RTI Pt.l 1 00

Dated: 15.10.2013

To

Shri. Subhash Chandra Agrawal

(Guinness Record Holder RTI Activist)



DELHI - 1.10006 (India)

Sub: - Information

under

Right to Information Act 2005 - regarding.

Sir,

Please refer to your R.T.I. application datedI6.09.2013 received in this office on

19.09.2013 seeking information under R.T.!. Act 2005. With regard to providing the complete

information together with relevant documents/correspondence / file-notings. Point wise reply is

under:

Point No.

Reply

;

1

Copy

of

terms Conditions is enclosed herewith.

2. Hon'ble Chairperson is entitled for residential office due to which computers, AC

etc. are being provided by TDSAT. Hon ble Chairperson is occupying Residential

accommodation in

No.2,

Tughlak Lane, New Delhi - 110001. Hon'ble Member

TDSA T has been allotted Residential accommodation in No. C-I/6, Tilak Lane,

New Delhi.

3.

Hon'ble Chairperson is entitled for all the benefits as applicable to the sitting

judges of Supreme Court Judge due to which his Lordship is entitled for furnishing

upto Rs. 4.0 lakhs (Copy enclosed). With regard to providing of furniture,

computers etc., it has been made available by TDSAT for his Lordship's residential

office.

4. Residential accommodation No.2, Tughlak Lane, New Delhi 110001 is allotted

by Dte. ofEstate.

5.

At present TDSAT has not paid any amount to CPWD, all the expenses made by

CPWD for the renovation of the said Bungalow.

6.

The expenses incurred on Govt. accommodation made by CPWD. Only an amount

mailto:reglstrar.tdsat@nlc.'n

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/www.tdsat.nlc.ln

mailto:reglstrar.tdsat@nlc.'n

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/www.tdsat.nlc.ln



'' , ...

6

i ~ ~ ,

. _ . ~ ~ _ · f H E G ~ E : m O F I ~ p J ~ ~ ~ R D l N A ~ ' ( _ _ _ 1 ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 1 ~ \

entitled to a monlhly salary, and

to

such allowances and other benefits,

as

arc

admissible

to

a serving Judge

of

the Supreme Conrt

(b)

When

a serving or a retired Chief Justice of a

High Court is

appointed

as

Chairperson,

he shall

be

entitled to a monthly salary

and

to such allO\vances and

olher

b e l l ~ f i t . s as are

admissible

to a

serving

Chief Justice of the High Court of the

Headquarter station

of

the Appellate TribunaL

Provided that in case the retired Judge of

the

Su-preme Court or

the

retired

Chief Justice

of

a High

Court,

is ill

receipt

of,

or

has received

or

has

become

entitled to receive any

retirement

benefits by

way

of pension, gratuity, employers

contribution

to

the Contributory Provident Fund

or

olher forms of

retirement

benefits, the

pay

of such Chairperson

s11ull be

reduced

by

the gross amount of

.1 '\.

pensipn or employers contribution to the Contributory Provident Fund

or

any

other

form of retirement benefits,

if

any (except pension

eCluivalent

of gratuity). drawn

or

to

be drawn

by

him.

4. Leave·

(1) Wben a retired Supreme Court Judge or a Chief Justice of

High

Court

is appointed as

Chairpersoil,

he ~ I l a l l be

entitled

to 30 days of Eamcd

Leave

for

every year of service

and

the

'President of India shall

be (he

authori

y

competent

to

sanction

leave

to the Chairperson.

(2) The payment

of

leave. salary during leave shall be governed

by rule 40 of the Central Civil Services (Leave) Rules, 1972.

(3,) The

Chairperson

::;hall be entitled to encashmenl

of

fifty per

cent of Earned Leave to his credit at any time.

5. Contribution to Contributory Provident Fund

When a retired Supreme

Court Judge/ Chief Justice of High Court appointed

as

Chairperson, he shall be

entitled to

subscribe

to

the

Contributory Provident

Fund

which sh.all

be

governed

by

the Contributory Provident Fund Rules (India), 1962.

6. Other conditions of service: The

conditions of service

of

Chairperson for

which

no provision is

made in these rules shall

be

governed

by

the Supreme Cour1

Judges

(C...onditions

of Service) Act, 1958. Supreme Court Judges (Travelling

Allowance) Hules, 1959 and any other

rule ;

made under the Act

t

or the High

('...ourt

Judges Act, 1954, High Court

Judges

(Travelling Allowance) Rules, 1956

and any other rule made under the

~ 1 ; >

as

the case may be:

-.

Provided that n case Governfl?cnt a < . ~ c o m m o d a t i o J is not available while on

domestic official tour,

the

Chairperson shall be

entilled 10

stay in Iridin Tourism

Development

C ~ n x n a t i o n

IJotels

~ e n

a

r e i m b u c s c r q ~ n t

basis and wherever

IIdia

Tourism Development

C o r p o r ~ t i o . n

hotels are not' available, in other hotels en

"

'-

I- ;\

,



reimbursement hllSis, reimbursement io bOlh cases being limited 10 lodging

charges

only,

and on a

single room

OCCUP,lIlCY b'ISis.

7.

Applieability of

rules· When

a serving Judge of the Supreme

Court

or

the Chief Justice of a High Court is appointed as ,tbe ChairPerson, his terms and

conditions of

service

shall be the

~ l l m e as

were

applicahle to

him prior to his

appointmenl IS the Chairperson:

Provided

I hill

i n ( ~ l S e of superannuation of Chairpt.::rson Judge before the

expiry of his term as Chairperson, his

lerms uno

conditIons oj ~ ( : r v i : ; t : shall be the

same as are applicable to a retired Judge or the Supreme Court or a retired Chief

Justice of a High

COllrt,

.IS the case

may be,

under these Rules, for

r-cmll oder

period of his term.

8.

Terms

and Conditions

of

S( rvicc nf

Memhers

(1) The l\-1emhcrs

of

the

Appella\e Tribunal shall

be

entitled

10-

i) receive a pay of Rs.26,OOO/- per month (fixed) and dearness allowance at

the

fa Ie

admissible to a

Group

A

of

ficer of the Central Govcmfi1cnt drawing an

equivalent

pay:

Provided lhat in ;ase of apfX>inlmcm of a ptrson

a::>

a Member who has

retired from the service under the Central Governllleni or a State Government and

who is

in

receipt

of, or

has received or has h ecomc entitled

o

receive

any

retirement benefits b)' way of pension. gratuity, employers contribution to the

Contributory Provident Fund or other forms of

retirement

benefits, the pay

of

slich

Member

shall

be

reduced

by the

gross

amount of pension or

employers

contribution 10 the Contributory Provident Fund or

811)'

other form of retirement

benefits.

if any (except pension equivalent of gratuity), drawn or

[

be drawn by

•

him:

Provided further that

if

a person who has retired from any service including

~

service under Central Government

or

State Govcmment. Public: Sector

Undertakings or Autonomous Bodies, is appOinted as a

Member,

he shall receive

\

dearness allowance at the same rate as is admissible to a

Group A

officer

of

the

I

Central Government drawing an eq u)valenl

pay,

but he shall not be entitled to

i

receive the Dearness Relief on pensi9P dllri lg the period he holds office as such

Member;

.

.

li)

receive city cOtIlpensatory allmv.aQce at the same rate as is admissible to a

Group A officer

r w i ~ g

an c'luivalcnCpay

under t h ~

Central Government;

" T



N ,

8

- = - - = = = - - = - ~ = _ ] ] ~ ~ G A ? : ¥ . T r ~ ~ F

~ ? J f - . : J ~ X ~ 1 ~ ~ t , ' : , ~ 1 : : : ; : : : : ; = - ~ _

J } ~ ~ I = - ~ C , Mm ··.

(iii) (a) thirty ?ays of earned leave for every year of service and the

paymenr

: - : ~ 1 -

of

leave saJary dUfing leave shall be governed

by

rule

40

of the Central Civil '

Services (Leave) Rules, 1972 and the Chairperson shall be the authority competent

to sanction lea.ve to the Members.

(b)

encashment of fifty per cent of earned leave to his credit

a[

any time.

(iv) subscribe to the Cnntributory Provident Fund which shall be governed by

the Contributory Provident Fund Rules(lndia), 1 962:

(v) travelling allowance and daily allowance

for

franspmtation of personal

effects while on tour or on transfer (including the Journey undertaken

a

join the

Appellale Tribunal or on the expiry

of

his lenn

\vilh

the Appellate Trit;unal to

proceed to h

is

home-town). at the saIne rates ; ~ s arc admissible o Group .

A'

officers of the Central Government draWing equivalent pay;

(vi) the facility of Government accommodation in guest houses or Inspection

bungalOWS

rull

by

the

Ccnrral

Government,

wherever avail able, 011 payment of

normal rent at outstations. whi Ie Oil lour. as is admissible to Group A" Officers of

the Central Government drawing equivalent

pay:

PlOvided that

w h t ~ r e

Government a c c o m m o d a t j O J ~ is nut avaHable wbile on

d o m e ~ { i c official tour, the Mem ber shall be entitled to stay in

India

Tourism

Development Corporation hotels on a reimbUlsement basis and wherever Iudia

Tourism Development Corporation hotels are not aV3ilable, in other

hOIt".ls

on

reimbursement

basis,

re -imbtltscment in

both cases being

I ill1ited

to

lodging

c h a r g e ~ only,

and

on a

single

mom

occupancy

basis:

(vii) leave travel concession at the same rMe tiS admissible to Group'A' officers

of the Central Government dra\ving.an equivalent pay;

/A, 'Ui) medical

t r e a t ~ e n l

and hospital facHiti e s . ~ ~ ~ p : , ( ) ~ ~ , d ~ , 2 , i . t i t h e C e o t r a ~ t·

, , / Governmcl1t Health Scheme and at places where

t,hc'CenttaIQovermnCl'lt

Health

c h ~ m ~ i s n o t

tn

operation, the Member shaH be entitied

to

facilities as provided

n ; t t t i C e ~ t r a ] Services (Medic:al Attendance

R u l e s > , 1 9 4 4 ~

Ix) undertake official visits abroad with the prior approval o the Minister

of

the

Government of

India in c h a ~ ~ . of t.he Department of Telecommunications

and .

after clearance from

Ministry;of

,Extcmal

Affairs on the points relating to political

affairs; the daily allowance

\ n ~ d

provision of hot.el accormnodatlon during the

period

of

tour abroad shall be, [cgulaled in accordance with the Govemment

instructions \s applicablt to

,gff'icers

of equal grade in the GovcfTlmenl of India;

Indian Missions

abroaa

shall take care

0 f

ahangements and extend

f a c i i t i e ~

as

. .

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hOIt%22.ls

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dra/ving.an

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hOIt%22.ls

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dra/ving.an



admissible to

Group

..A officers

of

the Central

Govcrnmenl drawing

.Jll

equivalenl

pay:

(x)

conveyance

facilitie.s

a ;

admissible

to a Group

A

otficer

of

Ihe Central

Governmenl drawing equivalent pay;

f (xi)

resident

lal

accommodation

us

admissible 10

it

Group .

A' officer of

the

~ I

Central Government drawing

equivillent pay,

and

on dCll1illillg

office, the Me-ml,) er

! shall be entitled 10

retention

of, residential accommod:llion for one { nomh,

on

the

same terms and C O n d i t i O n . : ~

(2) E e t ~ m ~ ) L D ~ Q L . 9 o v e r n m c n L S e 0 . : } c c _

-

A

person

in the service

of

the

GQvernmcnI,

on

his sdection

liS a Member,

shall

bave to retire from service bef')re

entering upon his o f n ~ ~ e as a Member.

9.

Oath of O f f j C { ~ and Secr-cey:

.-

Every

person appointed

as

the

Chairperson

or

a Member

shaH,

belore

entering upon his office, make and

subscribe

an

oath of office and

secrecy,

in

Form.I

and

Form

II respectively annexed to

hese

Rules.

10.

Declaration

of financial or other interest - Every person. on his

appointment as the, Chairperson or Member,

as

the

cas : It;lay

be, shell g i V l ~ a

declaration

in

Form

IfI

annexed to these

rules, to Ihe sal

isfaclion of

the Central

Government,

Ihal he does not have any such financial Of other. interest

a:-

is likely

to affect prejudicially his [unctions as such Chairperson or Member, the case

may

be,

11. Residuary provision -

Matters relating 10

the

terms alld c.onditions of service of the

C h a l r t . Y ~ r s o n

or

Member with respect

to

which no express provision has heen made in these rules,

shall be referred by the Appellate Tribunal to

the

C.cntral Government for its

decision.

12. Powers

to relax:· The Central Government shall have power

to

relax

any

provision of these rules with

respect

to any class or

category

of persons.

(F.

No,

11/2000

TeO]

ANIL

KUMAR,

It.

Se.cy.

:27 q, GIJ2000-1.

I



- , fPf

JI- . . :Wq 3--=<N-1I'V'&' (i) ,

, P A R T ~ b 8 a b - s e e t 1 o n ( l )

,

fllft11 fM

~ flEiiI"iri' .

, 1'\ , . , P U B L 1 S I I E D ' ~ Y AtrnlOmrY, ' , .

~ ~ = = = = = = ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ = = ~ = = ~ ~ ~ = = ~

#.

672)

if

W,

: ~

24,

:zoosl1ft'lf

3,

19aO' .

No.

67:il NEW DELHI, WEDNESDAY, DECEMBER24,

lOOIIfAUSA

3, i930 '

]. (1) ~ f . r q q ' f 1 6 t ~ ;qj<4lE1q ;qjqjEftIlI ~ )

f.Iqq'I 2 0 ~ 8 1fiIrI I .

, (2) 1)' l.roiirtt if

lfft

mmr

.

, ~ ' i f t T

j

, i·

~

;qltjlEiq

; q j t U f f t l l l ~ , 1 9 S 6 · ~

f.Iqq' '2-11

,;

if 2 ; o o ~ O O O / -

m

(m l{)'flltI1IJ;J)fl." 1 50 000/-

;. rn

(m·l{Cfi _ lJ'in'Q' in)

'Q t

cfi'

:'.

~ ~ ' I R

lfifm:

4 , o o . O O O ~ · ( ~ f I R ~ ~ ) •

3,oo,oooi

...

, ~ :

(m

-aR

~

1IJ;J)"

~ 11 i •

SlRlttllfqd ~ ,.

[1fil

.q ( l I f - l i o i 6 1 2 1 2 0 0 ~ - ~ 1

. . " *'l !'VT

• • ~

~

:

24 ~ . 1956·

~

li. :q;r. "f.f.

att.

'224

?6'lmf

'1R'« cfi'

. ~ . 19S6·'ct·'11Tr-n, . . . 3,

~

]06

it

' I<fi'If1mf ~

q

writ

1I1't

if ' q ~ f l g t 1 l R T

.', , , ~ ~ 1 N ; -

.

soAl

.

Gm00 8 ,

'

9.

1U.1Qf.f

..'lf.

698 (01') 31-7-1992

10. 'tft1liLf.t li.

72t(OJ)

~ 2 6 - 1 1 - 1 9 9 3

.

11. 1It1fitf.r. ~ i S S 8 ( 3 f ) ~ 2 9 - 6 : 1 9 9 4

12.

1It1!5t.f.f.-a720(30 ft-ricf;

3 ~ 1 l - 1 9 9 S

MINISTRY

OF LAW ANDJUS11cE

(Department

of

Justice)

:it«Jr.lll'lCATION . '

t

New Delhi; the

24th

December,

2008

G.s.R. 819(E);-In

exercise f ~ ~ c O n f e r r e d

" by sub-tection

(3) ofSec:tion

23 read

with b ~ s e c t i o n (2)

,

, of

Section 24

of

the Hlgh Court Judges, (Salaries' and,

.

,ConditiODSj f S e r y i c e ) Act. 1954 (28

of

1954), the

Centtal

Govermndbereby

makes

the following rules further

to

amend the Highcourt Judges Rules,

]

956, a m e l y : ~

,

1. (1) , these tules may

be

called

the

High

Court

.

. Judges (Amendment)

Rules. 2008. ,

, (2), They sliaJ.I come iDto fon:e the dateoftheir

. pub6tatioti in the

Official

Gazette.

(1)



J _

...

?_/ \

THE

GAZETtE

OF INDIA: BXTRAo.RDINARY [PMTII SEc.3(1))'

2.

IntheHiihCourtJudgesRules,

1956,

inrole2B,

forthewords

and

figures 2 00 000/· (Rupeestwolakbs

only)",

and"Rs. 1 50 000/- (Rupeesone

1akh and

fifty

thousand only)", thewordsand figUres "Ks. ;,00,000/-

..(Rupees.four Iakhs only)"

and

c'Rs.3 00 0001· (Rupeesthree

Iakhs

<mly)"shallreSpectivelybe

u b s t i t u t ~ d ,

.", [F.No.L-Il016121200S-]1$.]

SHASm

BHUSHAN, It. Secy.

FootNote: The Princ.ipaI'ruleswerepublished

vide

notificationnuri:lberS.R.O.224,datedthe24th

January,1956,intheGazetteofIndia,1956Part II,

Section3,page'I

Q6.

Subsequentlyamended'

by : -

1. No.S.R.O.

707

dated28-2-1957.

2

No.G.S.R.497dated13-3-1970.

3. No.G.S.R. 366(E)

dated11-7-1972.

r ~

.

4.

No.

G.S.R.562

dated

21.-4-1979.

5.

No.

G.S.R. lOIS

dated21-7;'1979.

6.

'No.G.S.R.117S(E)dated4-11-1986.

7

No.G.S.R.

2 ~ 9 ( E ) d a t e d

lS-3-f987.'.

8.,

.No.G.S.R.718(E)dated4-12·1991.

'

9.

'No.G.S.R.698(E)dated

31-7·1992.

10.

No.G.S.R.721(E)dated2f).11-1993.,

It

No.G.S.R.558(E)dated29-6-1994.

12 No.

G.S.R.

720(E)

dated

3-11-1995.

~ f t 4 \ l t 4 " 1 .

1 f ~ , 4 ~ 2008

In'.'C5r.f.r. 8 8 0 ( 3 I ) . ~

' 4 f ~ l c l 1 4 (<lwT

~ ~ l R f ) ~ 1958 (l9581wT4t)Cfll' ~

24

Cfll'

0 1 f - ~ (.2)

q}lITtf'tffaamti

23 C f l l ' < f i - ~

(3)

r \ ~ CfiT

m

<tmf

l'Q:,

; : q l ~ r c l ~

~ ' - i m ~ , 1959 lf am m'R

-m ig

. - i U 1 r ~ f & 6 ,f.rql:r 'iiPffirr

t :-

'

1.

(1)

l ' i

ctil

: 4 : j 1 ~ l c l l 4 ~ t i m

(-mITtR)f.p.rq, 2008 ttm I

(2)

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ' ~ ~ t I I t m ' c m

. ~ ~ I

t:'

.2.

*illfl('Ilf

~ l l f I E f t ' l 1

f.pp:{,

1959 q}

4 Ai.q "

2

,!iQ,oOO/-

m(m?J

~ ~ "lft)If

.aiP:

2

,o0/JOO/-

m

m ~ 'clm'-qr;r)" ~

~ q }

. m

q ' { . ~ : ' " 5,00,000

. ( ~ ~

~ ~ )

It am:

114,00,000/- (m

,\:'I'TtI

~ ) I t Wi

oPi;

,

f t t ~ l r q d ' ~

I . " ' "

["CfiT, li. ~ - 1 1

0 1 6 1 2 1 2 0 0 8 - ~ ]

lIfW:'rfVI,

I .

. ,

'1Iti : 43T'm'I', 1959 l i ilLlfitf.f.

,: .935

ct

.

'Imf

ct

'It

qpr-II,

3,

. :'f.::':

).

1161

r 'ti

\

,

..

·

'"

~ - l i h ( i ) ~

1 5 . 6 . 5 8 - ~ - I ]

..q 1RI;

e) o ~

~

i t U 1 ~ 1 l I ( I imTmilf\m~ 'Il'<t

.

:-

.

I.

l I T . ~ . f . I . l i 1 I 3 4 n 4 - o ; : q m , ~

IS-12":1974

2

-m.CfiI'.f.f.

'tf. 634

2 2 ~ ¥ ' : : 1 9 7 6

3.

lIT.'1iT.f.f.li

S54 j-8-1980

4.

lR'1iT.f.f.

1176(at) 4-11-1986

'

•,

5.

lR'1iT.f.I.

li.680(at) 12-11....

(991

6.

l I T . C f i T . f . I . ~ . 698(at) ~ 2 5 - 1 1 - 1 9 9 1

7.

lIT.'1iT.f.I. li.559(at) 27-5-1992

18.

lIT:CfiJ.f.I•.~ 179(at) 25-9-1992

9. m . < 6 t f . l . ~ .

381(at) ~ 2 4 - 4 - 1 9 9 3

· m.'1iT.f.f. li.

444(

at)

IO S

I ~ 9 4

11

.•

m.'1iT.f.I.li.

717(at)

3 - 1 1 - 1 9 9 5

.

NOllFICAll0N

'

New Delki,the24thDecember,2008

G.S.a,.880(E).-Inexerciseof thepowersconferred

bysub-section

(3)of

Section

23 read ~ i t h

sub-section

(2)

f of

Section

24

of theSupremeCourtJudges(Salaries

~ n d

ConditionsofService)Act,

1958

(41of

1958).

theCentral

Governmentherebymakesthefollowingrulesfurther to

mrlend

the'supremecOurt

JUcIges

Rules,

1959,namely:-

.

I 1.,(1) TheserolesmaybecalledtheSupreme

Court

,',.. . ' Judges(Amendment)

u l ~ s , 2008.

;' .

2)

, ~ s h a l l

comeinto

forceon

tfiedateoftheir .

, publh,ationintheOfficial

Gazette.

' '

.

.. 2. Inthe'Supreme

CQurt

JudgesRules,

1959,

in'rule.

j

I forthewords

and

figures ru. 2,SO,OOO/- (Rupees

two

takbs

fiftythousandonly)"

and

"Rs. 2 00 000/-

(Rupees','.,

twolakhsonly)",the

words

and figures "Rs.5 00 0001

. ( R ~ s five

lakhs

only)"

and"Rs.4 00 000/- (RUpees

four

' I ~ S , onlyr ~ h a n respectivelybysubstituted.

. [F.No.1,..110161212008-Ju5.J

SHASHI BHUSHAN,

J1.

Secy

.

. FootNote: The Principalrules.were published

vide

notificationnumber

G.S.R..

935.dated the

4thAugust,1959,inthe O a z e t t ~ of India,Pint

II.'Section 3,Sub"section (i) Page 1161

. I

Ministry

of

HomeAffairsNo.

15.6.58-

JudI.-I]

and

slibsequenUyamendedby:-:-

'

I. G.S.R.No.1134n4-J' 8(1) dated18-12-1974.

· G.S.R.No.634

dl!ted

22-4-1976. ,.

·.

G.S.R.

No.

8S4 dated

1-8-1980.

·ja.S.R

No.

1176(E)dated4-11-1986.

5.

' G.S.R

No.680(E)dated).2-

J

1-1991.

6.

G.SA

No.698(E)

dated

25-11-1991.

'

7.

G:&R.No.

5S9 E)

<htted 27-5-1

992.

· G.SA

No.779(E)dated

25-9-1

992.

.::'O.SiNo.381(E)dated24-4-1993.

1•

a.S.R

No.444(E)

dated

10-5-1994.

1•'G.S.R.No.717(E)dated3-11-I99S;

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/lIT.~.f.I.li

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/lIT.'1iT.f.f.li

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/m.'1iT.f.I.li

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/lIT.~.f.I.li

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/lIT.'1iT.f.f.li

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/m.'1iT.f.I.li



.



I

j



~

I

• I

I ;

I

>

101

°

i

I

I

I

\

1



P.No. ~ 9 ) ~ ) ~ O ~ ) )

RT

Telecom Disputes Settlement

&

Appellate Tribunal

Sub:

- Assistance sought

under

Section 5(4)

ofRTI

ACT

2005 from

the

Adminis trative Officer.

Please find enclosed request received from

Shiro

Subhash Chandra Agrawal

' residence of 1775 Kucha Lattushah, Dariba, Chandini Chowk, Delhi 110006 seeking the

i

information under RTI Act, 2005. Please provide the necessary information to the

undersigned under the RTI Act, 2005 with relevant documents/correspondencelfile-notings

on or before 9

th

October, 2013 in order to reply to the RTI query of the RTI Applicant.

Kindly furnish information for the following SI No. 1 to 9 queries.

1.

Complete information on rules providing residential accommodations to

.

Chairpersons and Members of TDSA T mentioning also expenses allowable on

repairs/renovationS/fixtures/furnishing/maintenance/furniture/air-conditioners/

I

,

computers/electric & electronic gadgets and other fixtures etc for such government

I

provided residential accommodations either by Central Public Works Department

.

,

(CPWD) or by TDSA

T.

I

2.

Is it true that some expenses on furnishing/fumiture/air-conditioners/computers/

electric & electronic gadgets and other fixtures etc on such government provided

residential accommodations to TDSA T Chairperson Mr Justice Aftab Alam and/or

the other TDSAT member/s is done by TDSA T mentioning also

if

it

is

permissible

to transfer some such furniture/air-conditioners/computers/electric

&

electronic

gadgets and other fixtures etc

from

TDSAT office to such government provided

residential accommodations of the Chairperson and lor the other member/s of

TDSAT?

Complete i n f ~ r m t i o n on expense's on furnishing/furniture lair

conditioners/computers/electric

&

electronic gadgets and other fixtures etc made

under different. heads by TDSAT on such government provided residential

accommodations to TDSA T Chairperson Mr. Justice Aftab Alam and lor the other

TDSAT l!1ember/s mentioning also details of transferring some such

flJrniture/airconditioners/computers/electric & electronic gadgets and other fixtures

etc from TDSA T office to government provided residential accommodations of the

Chairperson Mr. Justice Aftab Alam and/or the other member/s ofTDSAT

Complete information about government-provided residential-accommodation to

TDSA T Chairperson Mr. Justice Aftab Alam

5.

Complete information together with related file-notings/documents/correspondence

on

renovation/furnishing/repair/maintenance etc on government-provided

residential-accommodation to TDSAT Chairperson Mr Justice Aftab Alam

by



different heads enclosing also any request letters from TDSAT and/or its

Chairperson in thisregard

6. Complete information on expenses made on government-provided residential

accommodation to TDSAT Chairperson

Mr.

Justice Aftab Alam and/or on

fumishinglfurniture/air-conditioners/computers/electric electronic gadgets and

otherfixturesetceither

by

TDSATorbyCPWDorbyany otherpublicauthority

whichareagainstrules

7.

Complete informationtogetherwithrelatedfile-notings/documents/correspondence I

on renovation/furnishing/repair/ maintenance etc by PWD on government

provided residential-accommodation to other TDSAT' member/s mentioning

expenses made under different heads enclosing also any request-letters from

TDSATandlortheconcernedTDSATmemberin thisregard

8.

Completeinformationassoughtunderquery-numbers(1)to(6)inrespecto earlier

31> L ,bl f O

TDSATChairpersonsMrJusticeArunKumarandMrJustice

SB Sinhamentioning

also detailso government-bungalowsallotted toMrJusticeArun KumarandMr

~ \ t b \ l ~

JusticeSBSinha

,

9.

Anyotherrelatedinformation

The requested information be sent within a week as the last date o sending

information

is

18/10/2013totheRTIApplicant.

i

Administrativ officer

,

,

l



~ ~ f t l q I G ~ ~

Telecom

Disputes Settlement &

T q h i ~

Appellate Tribunal

w ~ ff«ll<

(Government)of India)

CfiTffI ;:f 370,

~

R No. ~ 7 0 , ~ r d

~ I o o r .

'IDire, lfflf.

Hotel Samrat,Kautilya 'arg,

ifIUICNl9;fl ~ ~ - 1 1 0 021

Chanakya Purl New Delhl·11

0021

~ / T e l .

:

+91-11-26882173

E·rnall

: [email protected]

~ / F a x :

+91-11-24122219

Website: www.tdsat.hlc.ln

M o ~ t J : r < l r t \ ~ I ~

JZTJ:

M.aJtt:t

No 29/3/20 13/RTI-I/

~

Dated:

15 10 2013

To

EE

coordination

DDG(HQ),CPWD

RoomNo. 114A,

Nirman Bhawan

New

Delhi-

Subject: - Transfer o applications dated 16.09.2013 received n this office on 19.9.2013) o

Shri. Subhash Chandra Agrawal, Seeking information under RTI Act, 2005.

Sir,

We have received

an RTI

application from Shri. Subhash Chandra Agrawal, regarding

residential

accommodation

of

the

Hon'ble Chairpersons

and

Hon'ble

Member

of

Telecom

Disputes Settlement Appellate Tribunal (TDSAT). TDSA T

is

transferred herewith

for

providing information directly

to

the applicant under intimation

to

this office,

as

the information

sought pertains

to

subject matter related

to

you.

TheQuestions

to

be furnish information for SI

No.

1 (is partially) , 5,6,and 7 belongs to

CPWDas

the information hence, the RTI application

has been

transfer

to

CPIO,CPWD.

Encl:

As above.

Yours

f a i t h ~

(0 ~ a i a h \ H13

CPIO

~ p y t o :

1.

ShriSubhash Chandra Agrawal, (Guinness Record Holder

&

RTIActivist)

1775

Kucha Lattushah Dariba,Chandni Chowk Delhi - 110006 (India)


http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/www.tdsat.hlc.ln


http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/www.tdsat.hlc.ln



mail'(

+ l g ~ c l ~ n M a ,

~ ; : f a ala; Ptiffo,

tRi). l2tl!O

Slo

CilRT

114Tl, Pt 1fUf

«A,

;:rf

flfffr

Ph. No. 011-23061911.23063027. Fax No. 011-23061122

0(- )

~

0 (;

7

~

-

Email: [email protected] ;

No. 9/10/201 0/S&D/125

Dated 20.2.2013

Sub: Implementation of the RTI Act 2005- CPIOs and Appellate Authorities in

CPWD.

The undersigned is directed to refer to above mentioned subject and to state that in

continuation to this Directorate

OM

of even No. 35 dated 10.1.2012 and subsequent

corrigendum of even No.

59

dated 7.2.2012 and

OM

of even No. 306 dated

17.5.2012, it has been further decided

to

nominate the CPIOs and Appellate

Authorities in the units attached with the offices of Special DGs

in

the regions as

under:

Office

CPIO

Alternate

CPIO,

when post

of

CPIO

Is

vacant post

Indicated In col.

No.2

does

not exist

Domain

Appellate

Authority

Each

coordination

unit

O.S. coordination

cell

/

EE

coordination

All matters of

unit

DDG(HQ)

HQ Unit

S.O.orO.S.

EE(HQ)

All

matters of

unit

DDG(HQ)

SD

Unit

AE

EE(SD)

All

matters of

unit

DDG(HQ}

2.

Accordingly, list

of

CPIOs and Appellate Authorities as notified vide above

referred OMs has been updated and enclosed

as

Annexure-A

3. Other provisions contained in earlier OMs issued on above mentioned subject

shall remain unchanged.

This issues with the approval of Director General. CPWD.

d -

\1I9qlcl

«ikt i ( m1 eD50 ti).

To

All Special Directors General. CPWD

All

Add .

Directors General. CPWD }

They are requested to Circulate to the ePIOs and

JS & CVO. CPWD

Appellate Authorities working under their

All Chief Engineers/Chief Architects

jurisdiction.

All

Dy.

Directors General. CPWD

CPWD Website





UNDERRIGHTTOINFORMATIONACT

CentralPublicInformationOfficer

TelecomDisputesSettlementAppellateTribunal(TDSAT)

3

rd

floor,HoterSamrat

KautilyaMarg,Chanakyapuri,NewDelhi-II 0021

Sir

Please provide complete information together with relevant documents/corrospondence/file

notingsonunder-mentionedaspects:

1. Complete informationon rules providingresidential-accommodationstoChairpersonsand members

of TOSAT mentioning also expenses allowable on

repairs/renovationslfixtures/furnishing/maintenance/furniture/air-conditionerslcomputers/electric &

electronicgadgetsandotherfixturesetcfor such government-provided residential-accommodations

eitherbyCentralPublicWorksOepartment(CPWO)orbyTOSAT

2.

Is

it

truethatsomeexpenseson fumishing/fumiture/air-conditionersicomputers/eJectric

electronic

gadgetsandotherfixtures etcon suchgovernment-providedresidential-accommodationstoTOSAT

Chairperson Mr Justice Aftab Alam and/or the other TOSAT member/s is done by TOSAT

mentioningalsoif it

is

permissibletotransfersomesuchfumiture/air-conditioners/computers/electric

& electronic gadgets and other fixtures etc from TOSAT office to such government-provided

residential-accommodationsof theChairpersonandlortheothermemberlsofTOSAT?

3. Complete information on expenses on furnishing/fumiture/air-conditionerslcomputers/electric

&

electronicgadgetsandotherfixturesetcmadeunderdifferentheadsbyTOSATonsuchgovernment

providedresidential-accommodationstoTOSATChairpersonMrJusticeAftabAlamand/ortheother

TOSAT member/s mentioning also details

of

transferring some such furniture/air

conditioners/computers/electric& electronic gadgets and other fixtures etc from TOSAT office to

govemment-providedresidential-accommodationsof theChairperson

Mr

JusticeAftab Alamand/or

theothermemberlsof TOSAT

4. Complete information about government-provided residential-accommodation to TDSAT

ChairpersonMrJusticeAftabAlam

5. Complete information together with related file-notings/documents/correspondence

on

renovation/furn

ish

ing/repair/maintenanceetc on government-provided residential-accommodation

to

TOSAT Chairperson Mr Justice Aftab Alam by

entral ublic Works Department

(CPWD)

mentioning expenses made under different heads enclosing also any request-letters from TOSAT

and/oritsChairperson

in

thisregard

Cic(24)Tdsat Chair Comp

Documents

Transcript of Cic(24)Tdsat Chair Comp